IA
22 ]
M
[P ag e
AC AD E
th eS yll ab us
IN LE D
SS Li so n
SSL BUZZ Thoughts on DC to DC power for LED lighting are becoming tangible as the EMerge Alliance announces 26 products now meet its standard.
SSL Profile An all-white LEDilluminated office, Blue Cross/Blue Shield of Kansas City borrows from the sets of the TV show ‘24’ to great effect.
NUMBER 16 • february 2011 www.architecturalssl.com
building blocks or building walls? When ‘walls’ created by the implementation of standards and metrics in order to improve the caliber of products get too high, innovation can suffer. With no performance requirements, however, predatory marketers can turn the market into a free for all. Somewhere in between a balance must be sought. [ Page 16]
SSL Buzz: The Latest Round of DOE CALiPER Testing Project Profile: Chestnut Hill Star Market, Boston, Mass.
Architectural SSL • 519 Briarcliff Road, Bolingbrook, IL 60440
ARCHITECTURAL SSL • Chronicling the Advancement of LEDs in the Built Environment
LEDs in action The new Chandler City Hall in Arizona employs both colored and white LED for dramatic results on its unique and multifaceted exterior.
White Pages: Tools & Take-Aways for Evaluating SSL Samples
Curve by Finelite
™
There is only ONE
BEST IN CLASS* • Full Range Dimming • Delivers 49 Lumens Per Watt • 363 Total Lumens • LM-79 and LM-80 Data Available • High Performance Cree® XP-E LED Package • ENERGY STAR® label • 5-Year, Worry-Free Warranty
New Features
QuickTouch™ Dimming
Replaceable LED
Cree® Inside
Durable Components
Sustainable Materials
Scan barcode for details
Circle 01
Are You Ready?
Tyco Electronics introduces the new NEVALO SSL system.
The future of lighting is here. The NEVALO system’s integrated electronics, optics and thermal management allow you to go to market faster and with confidence. Prepare for the future at w w w . n e v a l o . c o m / f u t u r e 1
Š 2011 Tyco Electronics Corporation. All Rights Reserved. NEVALO, TE (logo), and Tyco Electronics are trademarks of the Tyco Electronics group of companies and its licensors.
Circle 02
F§B. 11
43
08 Project Brief: The Pasadena Centennial Library keeps it's historic luminaires while upgrading efficiency. 33 Project Profile: Blue Cross/Blue Shield of Kansas City. 37 Project Profile: Chestnut Hill Star Market, Boston, Mass.
23
BUZZ
PERSPECTIVES
07 CALiPER Round 11
05 LED Insights
DOE says things are getting better as far as performance and veracity of performance of SSL products. However, equivalency claims are still misleading.
Architectural SSL has just wrapped up its fourth year of existence. In this time, the SSL industry has grown quickly, but much work remains as we embark on a second “term.” By Jim Crockett
10 GATEWAY Grades DOE announces the results of GATEWAY performance testing on LED track lighting at Chicago's Field Museum.
11 DC-DC Gains Ground The EMerge Alliance announces it has certified 26 products that comply with its low-voltage DCto-DC power standard.
02 • 02.11 • Architectural SSL
28
“LEDs are being used effectively in other industries and markets and I was confident in the technology [for a university lecture hall]."
48 SSL Observed The “best” thing about SSL is not its energy efficiency, long life, maintenance-friendly aspects or even its color quality. The best thing about a good application of SSL is when you can't tell that it's LED. By Kevin Willmorth
www.architecturalssl.com
24
FEATURES
DESIGN & PRODUCTS
16 analysis: Building Blocks or Building Walls?
40 White Pages
Product standards are a double-edge sword: On one hand, they’re critical for establishing “norms” in production and setting the bar for quality performance. Alternatively, if such “metric walls” are too high, they can hinder creativity and product development. by Kevin Willmorth
Tools & Take-Aways for Evaluating SSL Samples.
41 White Pages Creating Fair Life-Cycle Cost and Payback Evaluations.
22 ARCHITECT'S VIEW: LED for Academia SSL for general illumination is becoming more prevalent in educational settings from K-12 classrooms to university lecture halls. First cost, and the value proposition of existing technologies remain barriers that must be offset by other values to those not at the vanguard. by Barbara Horwitz-Bennett
42 Advances The latest solid-state products, including integrated exterior panels, an optically fantastic cove light and cool pendants.
Architectural SSL, Vol. 5, No. 1 (ISSN# 19418388) is published quarterly by Construction Business Media. Publication Office: Construction Business Media, 579 First Bank Drive, Suite 220, Palatine, IL 60067; 847 359 6493; www.architecturalssl.com. (Copyright © 2011 by Construction Business Media) POSTMASTER: Send address changes to Architectural SSL Magazine, 519 East Briarcliff Road, Bolingbrook, IL 60440.
28 FEATURED PROJECT: Chander City Hall, Chandler, Ariz. A showcase for the evolution of solid-state lighting from a novel “demonstration” technology to a problem-solving technology, SSL became an integral part of the project's architecture and nighttime presence. by Jim Crockett
www.architecturalssl.com
Architectural SSL • 02.11 • 03
NOTHING TO HIDE
W W W . M O D A L I G H T. C O M
Circle 03
LEDInsights
Coµµ§∑T±R∞
NUMBER 16 • february 2011 www.architecturalssl.com
Gary Redmond
Managing Partner Director Publishing Operations gary@architecturalssl.com
Tim Shea
Managing Partner Director Business Development tim@architecturalssl.com
Four on the Floor neer these fixtures, Gerwing said they cost about a third of what those original fixtures did.
Dave Pape
Vice President Director, Art & Production dave@architecturalssl.com
EDITORIAL Jim Crockett 847 359 6493
Editorial Director jimc@architecturalssl.com
Kevin Willmorth
Editor kevin@architecturalssl.com
In covering the world of solid-state lighting for the past four years I’ve learned a few things, but mostly it’s kind of like driving a stick shift: It can be difficult to learn, certainly a pain in traffic jams, but faster, and definitely more fun, than driving with an automatic transmission.
Megan Mazzocco 847 359 6493
Associate Editor megan@architecturalssl.com
The period of four years, at least in U.S. culture,
“let’s do a building with LEDs,” it was in carefully
is notable on many levels: It’s the length of term
studying the element and envisioning a night-
our presidents serve; it’s the time teens spend
time concept for the element that LEDs came to
moving in and through high school—theoretically,
bear, particularly for their performance.
college, too—and it happens to be the amount
of time Architectural SSL has been in business.
beyond people like Jeff, and many other lighting
Contributing Editors Craig DiLouie cd@architecturalssl.com Vilma Barr vilma@architecturalssl.com Barbara Horwitz-Bennett barbara@architecturalssl.com Mavis Linnemann
Copy Editor
Gerwing also proffered that LEDs, now, are
beginning to present themselves as legitimate solutions that naturally evolve in the course of satisfying a project’s needs, rather than being a forced demonstration of a cool, but not necessarily necessary technology. For example, on the Chandler project, where the major use of LED came in illuminating a custom scrim designed by artist Ned Kahn: It wasn’t that the team decided
Here’s what else I’ve learned in four years:
Perhaps it’s because I have one son graduating
designers I’ve worked with, there are lots of
DESIGN & PRODUCTION Dave Pape Art Director dave@architecturalssl.com
from college and another to high school that I
good guys and companies in this industry. Color
also feel a need for some kind of matriculation.
Kinetics, the main product supplier at Chandler,
And in an odd sort of way, that’s just happened.
is one of them.
Lauren Lenkowski
The very first issue of the magazine featured a
story I wrote on the Discovery Communications
tional, fixtures on the market that didn’t exist
headquarters outside of Washington, D.C. The
four years ago. There are a lot of exciting new
lead designer on that project was Jeff Gerwing,
players entering the community and it will be
Associate Art Director lauren@architecturalssl.com
Advertising Sales
There are a lot of other cool, and func-
Gary Redmond 847 359 6493 gary@architecturalssl.com
Tim Shea 847 359 6493 tim@architecturalssl.com
a principal with the SmithGroup. In fact, it was
interesting to track the future of these compa-
Jeff, while I worked on another publication, who
nies: controls, controls, controls for dimming
introduced me to the whole world of LEDs. There-
and effect. Scarily, I’ve learned the difference
Trey Higgens 847 577 8980 trey@architecturalssl.com
Jim Oestmann 847 838 0500 jim@architecturalssl.com
fore, it’s only appropriate, four years later, that I
between DMX and RDM.
face this SSL master in a sort of exam—hopefully
not a final one—as we break down Jeff’s latest
sense, but they’re not a be-all, end-all. They’re
David Haggett Ted Rzempoluch 847 934 9123 609 361 1733 davidh@architecturalssl.com ted@architecturalssl.com
project, the Chandler City Hall near Phoenix.
also still expensive and certainly there’s a need
In reality, the gap in coverage has more to do
for creative funding or financing. At the indi-
with both Jeff and I taking on more managerial
vidual level, we are not islands—to be successful
Jim Führer 503 679 5409 jimf@architecturalssl.com
duties that unfortunately take us away from our
there’s a need to reach out and find partners
original loves, be it creating wonderful architec-
who have the expertise to achieve a given goal,
tural lighting or writing about great buildings
whether you’re a writer, lighting designer or
and spaces.
manufacturer, and there’s definitely a need to
touch base with such folks on a regular basis.
subscription Inquiries There is no charge for subscriptions to qualified requestors in the U.S. All other annual subscriptions will be charged $39 for standard delivery or $55 for air mail delivery. For subscriptions, inquiries or address changes, call 630 739 0900. A Publication of Construction Business Media
Member:
In the course of this reunion, it occurred to
me that a lot has changed in this relatively short
time. Foremost is that the cost of LED luminaires
like I’m headed on to grad school.
Type and globe=PMS 485
Circular blend under globe = PMS 3025
Continents, shadow, base = Black
Finally, more education is needed. Looks
is dropping—it’s not just wishful thinking, it’s happening. For example, SmithGroup, on the Chandler project, employed a modified version of the same linear fixture they used at the Detroit Airport, their first major LED job. Despite the fact that the manufacturer had to custom engi-
LEDs are great sources where they make
www.architecturalssl.com
Jim Crockett, editorial director
Architectural SSL • 02.11 • 05
SHINE
Rely on UL to keep you on the leading edge of lighting innovation. As technology evolves, so does UL, advancing safety, lighting performance and energy e≤ciency in new and necessary ways. UL’s century of experience provides thought leadership, R&D expertise and the confidence and peace of mind you deserve. Specify UL to make lighting shine.
VISIT WWW.UL.COM/SHINE
Circle 04
SSL BUZZ & i∑DUSTR∞ BRi§FS
DOE CALiPER Testing, Round 11 CALipER Rd. 11: For replacements The lighting facts Tell the story
Intensity and Beam Characteristics for PAR Lamps Center Beam Intensity vs. Beam Angle 17W SSL PAR38
7000
Round 11 SSL PAR Lamps Earlier SSL PAR & R Lamps 25 W PAR38 Metal Halide 46 W HIR PAR38 75W Halogen PAR38 50W Halogen PAR30
6000 25W Metal Halide PAR38
5000
11W SSL PAR38
4000
18W SSL PAR38
3000 12W SSL PAR30
2000 1000 0 10
20
30
40
Beam Angle (Degrees)
50
60
Source: DOE SSL CALiPER results, October 2010
ABOVE: Intensity and beam characteristics of PAR lamps are improving. In the latest round of CALiPER testing all four products examined surpassed the curve representing minimum requirements for 50-watt equivalent. One also bordered on the limit for the 75-watt halogen and another even surpassed that mark. None, however, achieved the level of the 25-watt metal halide, which is compared, in LED product labeling, to a 90-watt halogen PAR38.
Table: CALiPER Round 11 Summary A review of the veracity of PAR 38 replacement lamp manufacturer claims P§RFoRµ±∑C§ L§v§L & §Quiv±l§∑C§
µ§§ti∑g µ±∑uF±CtuR§R CL±iµS
µ§§ti∑g L±µP FoRµ±t
Lighti∑g F±CtS L±B§L?
09-112 PAR30
Claims: None Meets: ~50W halogen equivalence
Meets or exceeds manufacturer claims
Not standard or diameter length for short or long PAR30
None
10-04 PAR38
Claims: 50-90W halogen equivalence Meets: 50-55W not 90W
Meets or exceeds manufacturer claims
Yes
Yes
10-11 PAR38
Claims: 75W halogen equivalence Meets: 65-70W
Overstates performance by 15-20%
Slightly exceeds max overall length
Meets: CCT, CRI Does not meet: Light output, efficacy
10-29 PAR38
Claims: None Meets: ~85W halogen equivalence
Meets: Light output, efficacy Incorrect: CCT (labeled 2700K, measured 4056K)*
Slightly too short neck & skirt length
Meets: Light output, efficacy Incorrect: CCT*
Compares to 60W HIR and 90W standard halogen
Yes
Yes
Not applicable
S±µPL§
BK09-111 PAR38
ABOVE: None of the lamps tested have overstated performance claims.
However, consumers could be misled by equivalency claims: two of the PAR lamps DOE tested were only partially true or are somewhat exaggerated.
www.architecturalssl.com
*Note that after receiving test results on product 10-29, two additional samples were ordered to determine whether the incorrect CCT was an on-going problem. While these samples were received too late to be LM-79 tested, visual inspection shows that the samples from a more recent batch have the correct CCT (~2700K).
Round 11 of CALiPER testing focused primarily on replacement lamps and outdoor roadway and posttop applications. Average overall efficacy of products tested shows steadily increasing performance. While many products continue to carry misleading equivalency claims and inaccurate published performance metrics, a number of products now carry accurate performance claims—in particular those that carry the Lighting Facts label, says DOE. Small replacement lamps, including MR16 lamps, PAR lamps, AR111, and omni-directional lamps, showed progress for each lamp type. Challenges remain with respect to lamp equivalencies, with a number of products not meeting standard lamp geometries for the type of lamp they claim to replace and with a number of products not meeting average light output levels or beam characteristics of the lamps with which they claim to be equivalent. Slight irregularities in lamp geometry—overall length, diameter, neck length, etc.—were observed for about one-half the lamps. Two-thirds of the lamps meet manufacturer numerical performance claims, but out of those that carry equivalency claims, only one-third meet manufacturer claims. Products which carry the Lighting Facts label have a much greater chance of meeting numerical performance claims, but still frequently carry misleading equivalency claims, but significant improvement in light output and efficacy is observed on average. For MR16 lamps, CALiPER testing, to date, shows two products achieve performance levels equivalent to 20-watt halogen MR16s, while using about 70% less power. As of yet, no SSL MR16 lamps tested meet litght output and beam characteristics of 35-watt halogen MR16s. For PAR lamps, a number of SSL products now meet light output and beam characteristics of 50- or 75-watt halogen PAR lamps, while using 70% to 80% less power. None of the SSL PAR lamps achieve the Z
Center Beam Intensity (Candela)
8000
Continued on page 08
Architectural SSL • 02.11 • 07
SSLBuzz:
Continued FROM page 07
Y
light output or efficacy of a 25-watt ceramic metal halide PAR 38. Note that SSL lamps have some qualities not shared by CMH, such as instant start. For A-lamps, a number of SSL lamps now achieve light output levels equivalent to 40-watt incandescent lamps (although with a more directional light distribution), while using about 80% less power. As of yet, no CALiPER tested SSL A-lamps meet light output levels equivalent to an average 60-watt incandescent lamp.
linear Replacements Round 11 testing of linear replacement lamps shows clear progress, with recent SSL lamps achieving respectable efficacy, though not the light levels and distribution of fluorescent lamps. Using two SSL lamps to replace a single-lamp troffer, where lower light levels are needed or where other characteristics of SSL provide an advantage, may now be viable in some cases, says DOE. The SSL lamps, however, will not likely be the most cost effective or reliable option at this time. All SSL linear replacement lamps tested show better performance than in previous testing, but when operated in situ they still do not provide equivalent levels of light output to 2-lamp fluorescent troffers whether considering bare lamps or overall troffer systems. The four cooler (CCT of 4300K-6000K) SSL linear lamps tested achieve bare-lamp efficacy levels of 85-95 lm. per watt. With an average loss of 17% when installed in a louvered troffer, these lamps can result in overall luminaire efficacy comparable to troffers equipped with linear fluorescent lamps. The majority of claims of light output and efficacy for SSL linear lamps were accurate. Equivalency statements, however, were misleading, implying or claiming comparable light output to T8 fluorescent lamps. None of the products tested in a parabolic louvered troffers achieved the spacing criteria and even light distribution achieved Continued on page 10
Y
08 • 02.11 • Architectural SSL
eco update: lighting retrofit
Silence and Lighting Are Golden A significant eco-friendly pendant lighting project at the Pasadena Central Library will save the city of Pasadena thousands of dollars, according to city officials. The retrofit uses LEDtronics’ high-power 95-watt LED cluster product in the actual, historic, pendant lighting fixtures located in the main common areas of the library. The newly installed cluster lights project upwards from the top of the pendant bowl directly into the upper reflector surface, and the library actually achieved higher footcandle measurements than with the use of old metal halide bulbs. A 17-watt LED lamp at the top of the fixtures produce the required uplighting of the ceiling above the pendant fixtures. Finally, the installation has also reduced the man-power and maintenance required of conventional lamping sources. The retrofit came as
an addendum to the successful relamping of the downstairs document room of the library with LEDtronics LED ceiling panels. “Every light at the library that we replaced was using 900 watts of ballasted power consumption and we helped reduce that by nearly 90%,” says Pervaiz Lodhie, CEO of LEDtronics. “Not only does the LED lighting in the pendant fixtures save greatly on power but because of the low heat they generate, the room temperature is dramatically reduced so as to save on the air-conditioning cost.” Visit www.ledtronics.com.•
An optimal retrofit: Lights are brighter, energy consumption lower and HVAC systems are less taxed by the LEDtronics 95-watt LED clusters placed in the historic fixtures at the Pasadena Central Library.
www.architecturalssl.com
© 2011 OSRAM SYLVANIA
www.sylvania.com/LED
We bring architectural lighting to new heights. Inside and out, LED lighting systems deliver sustainable energy-efficient lighting consistent with the principles of modern architecture. With more than a century’s worth of experience in delivering high-quality light, SYLVANIA LED lighting solutions precisely deliver light to where it is intended, creating the desired interplay of light and shadow. Together with our partner Traxon Technologies, we can specify and install the right LED system for your building, including programming software and commissioning services. As a leader in LED system technology, and with the industry’s best warranty, SYLVANIA is your trusted source to meet all of your lighting challenges. To talk to us about your architectural lighting needs, call 1-800-LIGHTBULB or go to www.sylvania.com/LED.
To get the full LED story on your phone, snap a picture of this tag. (Requires a free mobile app from http://gettag.mobi)
Circle 05
SSLBuzz:
Continued FROM page 08
Y
by fluorescent T8 lamps in the same troffer. The majority of linear lamps tested have color qualities which are not within standard tolerances for white light at their respective nominal CCTs. Reliability and life cycle should factor in purchasing decisions surrounding SSL linear lamps, says DOE. An issue DOE points out is the repeated shipping and handling mishaps and perpetual “out-of-stock” status of some products, which they note may shed doubt on the general reliability and long-term availability of product lines and warranties.
exterior For both roadway and post-top luminaires, a wide range of performance was measured showing, on average, significant improvement over earlier testing. Half of the luminaires achieve overall light output and efficacy levels that match or exceed levels of benchmark outdoor luminaires. Most of the SSL outdoor luminaires exhibit wide variations in color characteristics as compared to their rated CCT. Roadway and post-top luminaires exhibit a wide range of distribution characteristics, requiring photometry and close analysis to determine adequacy for a given application. In a sample calculation for a 24ft. wide street, as compared to a benchmark HPS installation, one SSL product was found to provide adequate uniformity and potential energy savings for equivalent initial illuminance levels. DOE notes caution should be exercised when considering claimed equivalencies in outdoor products—the comparative suitability of products depends not only on performance, but also on the installation parameters—mounting height, pole spacing, illuminance requirements. As far as SSL arm-mount roadway luminaires are concerned, five out of six of the products tested meet or come close to meeting manufacturer ratings for expected light output and efficacy—within approximately 10% of manufacturer published efficacy. Only one highly overstated its performance.•
10 • 02.11 • Architectural SSL
DOE’s Latest GATEWAY Test Targets Chicago For those who assumed the place in Chicago to learn about solid state lighting and LEDs was Museum of Science and Industry, they’ll be swiftly redirected to the Field Museum of Natural History, where the Dept. of Energy recently examined the feasibility of replacing halogen lighting with LEDs in an enclosed gallery exhibit. Results of DOE’s GATEWAY demonstration, executed by replacing 32 track-mounted halogen luminaires with an LED track system using 26 track-mounted fixtures, showed that: The LED system resulted in 63% energy savings compared to the halogen system and produced comparable illuminance on the lighted artifacts. The simple payback for the overall LED system compared to the halogen system was roughly three years. Comparing the LED luminaires one-for-one against the halogen luminaires; however, resulted in paybacks ranging from 5 to 11 years, owing to factors unique to this museum application, such as equipment used to filter the light, maintenance costs, and the effect of the lighting system on the air-conditioning system.
Because the LED luminaires used do not emit energy in the infrared or ultraviolet regions of the electromagnetic spectrum, they are expected to be less detrimental to some museum artifacts. A free download of the study is available at www.ssl.energy.gov/gatewaydemos_results.html. This lighting demonstration is one of several that showcase high-performance LED products for general illumination provided by the DOE GATEWAY demonstration program. Visit www.ssl.energy.gov/ gatewaydemos.html.•
ABOVE: A DOE GATEWAY demonstration of LEDs is on display at Chicago’s Field Museum of Natural History.
www.architecturalssl.com
SSLBuzz:
o∑Li∑§: SSL i∑t§R±Ctiv§
EMerge Alliance Sustains Growth; Plans to Educate
Feedback Icon:
Big Product News: a seven-year warranty; Kevin on Caliper If you haven’t visited it recently, be sure to check out www.architecturalssl.com/ sslinteractive for some interesting news on product developments. First, site caretaker and resident SSL guru, Kevin Willmorth, offers some perspective on DOE’s CALiPER program, including the latest Round 11 testing as notes on the opening page of this edition’s installment of Buzz. While he lauds the organization’s efforts, he wonders about its impact, as there are still a number of questionable products being produced. On the other hand, elsewhere, Kevin reports on Lusio’s unheard of seven-year warranty; a cool exterior fixture that literally weaves greenery into the product; and a set of controls and dimmers that are actually helping to simplify the whole SSL process. For more inspirational reading, peruse the Art of SSL section for a video highlighting a very cool project outside of Madison Square Garden—the latest work by engineer-turned video artist Jim Campbell, a past participant of the ArchLED conference. And for a hybrid of art meeting products, be sure to look at Kevin’s culmination of his 52 luminaires in 52Presented by: weeks project. Of course, this section of the site is “interactive,” so please send us comments and opinions of your own.
SSL interactive SSL interactive SSL interactive
Feedback Icon:
SSL interactive
Presented by:
SSL interactive
Launched back at GreenBuild in 2008, the EMerge Alliance continues to gather steam. An entity dedicated to promoting the concept of DC to DC power in order to better take advantage of “green technologies,” including solar and wind power, the organization recently announced that it now has 26 DC-to-DC “registered” products that fulfill the group’s 24-volt DC Occupied Spaces Standard criteria. These products, including items from the likes of Armstrong Ceilings, Cooper Lighting, Finelite and Lunera Lighting, deliver on the alliance’s promise of making DC power safe, Presented flexible andby: easy-to-use in occupied rooms. Each product, according to Kevin A. Schader, APR, executive director of the organization, was carefully evaluated for conformance to standards by the California Lighting Technology Center. A similar effort to evaluate and register products for use Presented by: with the group’s pending 380-volt DC data center standard will start next year after that standard is released. The alliance, once again, exhibited at Greenbuild in Chicago, and continued to draw interest from Presented passersby interested in sustainable solutions. by: According to Brian Patterson EMerge’s chairman, a technology at the forefront of the DC charge is LED lighting, as it’s a natural for operating on low-voltage DC from sources such as solar or wind power. But another aspect of EMerge, is architectural solutions. For example, a pair of products highlighted at the group’s booth was a new, custom ceiling system from Armstrong fitted with LED luminaires from Lunera for a very clean look. While actual solutions definitely help create awareness for possibilities of LEDs, Patterson says there’s still a tremendous need for education, and not just about lighting, but about the nature of electronics. LEDs are the perfect example. Most manufacturers typically only guarantee a product for about 10,000 hours. Why? Patterson posits, when the technology is supposed to last for years? “It’s the power converters and power
Integrated: Lunera, working in conjunction with Armstrong ceilings, co-developed an SSL lighting/ceiling system to meet EMerge Alliance DC-to-DC criteria, while creating a clean, architecturally pleasing look.
supplies—they’re the weakness of the system,” says Patterson. Converting to low-voltage DC to DC systems, however, will avert a lot of these problems because electronics are more reliable in DC-based systems. Even out of context of DC, both manufacturers and specifiers need to be aware that solidstate lighting products are true systems and that the SSL industry must recognize it’s own weaknesses, address these and then educate the end consumer. Flat-screen LED TVs are a good example. Just like lighting fixtures, Patterson says they should last for years and years and years. That said, there are electronics issues, and it comes back to the question of power supplies. If everything is integral to the unit, that means the whole unit must be repaired or replaced. A simple solution that EMerge is promoting, says Patterson, is simply locating power supplies external to the unit. But the more elegant solution here, Patterson argues, is going back to the DC to DC power delivery concept. “AC is just too difficult to work with,” he says. “DC to DC is 99.9% efficient, where as converting DC from AC is only about 60% efficient— People just don’t realize the [power factor] penalty they pay by running AC.” There’s also a huge maintenance issue right now in switching out LED-powered lighting. Unlike just switching out a light bulb, because AC power systems run at 277 volts, Patterson says, the whole branch circuit has to be shut down to change the faulty power supply. And that’s given that the power supply is external or easily accessible. “We must make the power supplies pluggable.” Elsewhere, the organization is doing some interesting research exploring the whole notion of switching from batteries to capacitors. •
Presented by:
www.architecturalssl.com
Architectural SSL • 02.11 • 11
SSLBuzz:
Innovate & Illuminate LED experience: demo
LIGHTING-UP THE FANS:
LEDs Illuminate Invesco Field
Super high efficacy, low maintenance solid-state lighting fixtures for commercial & industrial spaces
• Use in warehouses, laboratories, high ceiling office spaces, and more! • 70,000 to 100,000-hour L70 lifetimes • 80 models, 5 low-glare light distributions • 35-70% energy savings through a direct replacement of HID and fluorescent fixtures • Occupancy sensors • Made in the USA • Mercury free • UL and CE listed • Housings made of 80% recycled aluminum
7-YEAR WARRANTY
(913) 851-3000 www.LusioLighting.com info@LusioLighting.com
As the home of the NFL’s Broncos, Invesco Field rises up on the edge of Denver like a mountain peak, but Invesco’s chief electrician, Chris Hoag, wanted something eye-catching on the west side of the stadium. The east side of the stadium already had fluorescent strip lights and metal halide floods lights, so the intent was to even-out the lighting and add to the aesthetic appeal of the entire building’s façade. Hoag turned to the recommendation of Conserve-A-Watt, the team’s lighting distributor. The organization was interested in trying LEDs as the result of a presentation of the technology they had recently experienced. The distributor worked with Denver-based American Lighting to implement a new lighting scheme using the company’s RGB LED wall washers. Beginning with 12 RGB fixtures, programmed to display the team’s colors of blue and orange, the fixtures were installed behind an opaque glass wall on the west side of the stadium. After viewing the new installation, the team decided to add three more wall washers, making the total 15, to brighten the façade even further. The final result on the west side was so well-received, Mile High decided to implement 15 additional American Lighting LED Wall Washers in the same format on the east side of
the field as well. “The new lighting is aesthetically pleasing, and it gives us a much broader range of flexibility in terms of colors and patterns,” said Hoag. The fixtures can change color with just the touch of a button, allowing the stadium to show support for not only the home team, but other events held in and around the stadium as well. For instance, during the city’s annual Susan G. Komen Race for the Cure, the stadium can be “painted pink” to support participants. The rich blue and orange colors for the Broncos can also assume different effects. For example, during a touchdown, Hoag has the option of producing a firecracker effect to draw attention to the building. “Our main goal was to create a visual draw that would involve not only the fans inside of the stadium, but those outside as well. American Lighting’s high performing LED Wall Washers helped us do just that,” said Conserve-A-Watt Lighting Consultant Bernie Cowsert. In addition to the aesthetic qualities the new lights bring, the newly implemented LEDs contributed to a 72% reduction in energy consumption, with the total wattage being reduced from 5152W to 1440W, as well as more than $5,000 in annual cost savings.•
ABOVE: Not only did the LED lighting produce aesthetic results, the energy-efficient technology was in suit with the Bronco’s recent implementation of Game Plan Green, a program promoting energy efficiency and a clean environment.
Lusio Solid-State Lighting is a registered trademark and division of LightWild. Copyright © 2011. All rights reserved.
012111_architectural_SSL_LW.indd 1
Circle 06
www.architecturalssl.com 1/21/2011 9:13:19 AM
SSL MAGAZINE STERNBERG half page vertical ad MARCH 2010.qxp
C±S§ StuDy: LutRo∑ §xP§RI§∑C§ C§∑T§R
Control Freaks Specify LEDs Lutron’s new 3,100-sq.-ft. Experience Center showcases the company’s latest product designs. The Washington, D.C. location features an expandable line of Lutron light control products presented in a commercial office environment. The center includes an open office mock-up with cubicles, a workroom, a private office, a conference room and a training space that can host up to 30 people. The facility provides an exhibit area that showcases a variety of product applications including control of high-efficacy lighting sources, sustainable light control options, and daylight harvesting strategies. Lotus LED Luminaire LED lighting fixtures from Journee lighting are used as exhibit spotlights. The Lotus LED Luminaire installed on 24-ft. of monorail features a 3000k color temperature. Twenty-three units of Monopoints are installed 2-in. from the ceiling and 2-in. from the stem, creating an elegant and impactful lighting design on the walls and highlighting the energy saving items on display. The Washington, D.C. location is the company’s fifth Experience Center; other centers throughout the country include Irvine, Calif. (in the heart of Orange County); New York City (in the D&B Building); and in Coopersburg, Penn. (at the company’s world headquarters). They offer customers, including facilities staff and energy managers, system designers, architects, interior designers, and their clients, the opportunity to experience the energy savings and elegance of Lutron products in commercial and residential settings. Visit www.lutron.com•
E N E R G Y
S A V I N G
L I G H T I N G
The most efficient LED systems in outdoor decorative lighting. Approximately 70,000 hours of lamp life. Designed to last 16 years or longer operating 12 hours per day, 7 days per week. Reduced maintenance costs. Reduced carbon footprint. 4500K color temperature is standard. Choose from a variety of styles. 5 year warranty. Contact us for a FREE full line catalog and start saving energy today! Shown above: UNRIVALED™ installation at Newbury, NH.
A
B
C
D
A Ivalo L’ale sconce feature white LEDs, Ivalo Aliante pendants that hang from the ceiling; QS wall stations control shades and lights. cubicle: B Features 2 × 2 fluorescent fixtures powered by Eco-System 10% ballasts; solar shade and blackout shades; Ivalo Aliante decorative sconce. conference room: C Ivalo Rotare pendant fixtures float above the table; blackout shades in Wheat; daylight sensor is visible on the ceiling. work room: D Showcases eight types of shade fabrics on motorized shades; daylight and occupancy sensors are visible on the ceiling.
office:
P 800-621-3376 • F 847-588-3440 E info@sternberglighting.com • www.sternberglighting.com Circle 07
1/2
SSLBuzz:
Cloudy With a Chance of LEDs An indoor ‘cloud’ installation envisioned and designed by Transsolar and Tetsuo Kondo Architects for the 12th edition of the prestigious Architecture Biennale of Venice is illuminated using Martin architectural luminaires. The artificial cloud in the installation, dubbed Cloudscapes, is produced by the visualization of the nearly 100% humidity in the cloud layer through a series of Martin Professional smoke machines, which create condensation that renders the cloud viable. It is illuminated by Martin Extube linear LED luminaires and Martin Exterior 200 LED projectors. The dynamics of the lighting is controlled via a Martin Maxxyz lighting controller. Together these elements make the stunning, if amorphous, almost intangible design, come to fruition. Visit www.martin.com.•
ABOVE: An artificial cloud created using a series of Martin Professional smoke machines is lit with the company’s LED luminaires and an exterior projector.
We just raised the bar. Again.
LED Gets Rocket Booster GE Global Research, in concert with the University of Maryland, in an effort to improve the reliability and lifetime of LED lighting systems has developed a lamp source that utilizes jet-engine cooling technology, further addressing size and weight of the heat sink and lamp system—key barriers to the general adoption of LED lighting. “The scientists and technology leaders involved in this collaboration are dissolving some major barriers to the commercialization of general lighting LED bulbs,” says John Strainic, global product general manager for GE Lighting. “We’re taking swings at issues such as higher light output options, thermal management, and bulb size and weight. This kicks open the door to the solid-state age that is upon us.” GE touts the patented technology dubbed, “dual cool jets,” as a snapshot into the future of lighting, as it solves a thermal design challenge in half the size and weight of today’s
600-lumen LED downlights. The 1,500-lumen prototype’s novel cooling technologies effectively manage the heat and promote lower system costs by reducing the number of LED chips required, and produces as much light as a 100-watt incandescent, while using ¹/³ of the energy. The solution is based the company’s Aviation and Energy technologies that manage flow and implement innovative ways to control airflow and combustion. The very small micro-fluidic bellows type devices provide high-velocity cooling jets of air to the LED heat sink. Effectively managing heat promotes lower system costs by reducing the number of LED chips required, when compared to conventional LED technologies. “Through further research and improvements, we may be able to increase performance without compromising the efficiency or lifetime of an LED bulb,” says Mehmet Arik, a mechanical engineer at GE Global Research and principal investigator on the project.•
ABOVE: This LED array is cooled with technology similar to what GE’s aviation and energy group developed to manage airflow and combustion in jet engines.
Are you ready to make the leap? Jump™ is the first high performance architectural luminaire to integrate LEDs with innovative optics and advanced controls. Subtle textures and rhythmic patterns combine with revolutionary technology to create a seamless continuum of luminance.
iamreadytojump.com
Circle 08
marketanalysis
16 • 02.11 • Architectural SSL
www.architecturalssl.com
marketanalysis
SOLID-STATE LIGHTING STANDARDS:
By Kevin Willmorth, editor
It's a fine, and sometimes bent, line as to where tougher performance standards for solid-state lighting products cross the threshold of spur for innovation into damper of creativity.
Newton had it right. For every action there is
innovators bring new ideas and magic forward,
an equal and opposite reaction. This law equally
comfortable assumptions, old metrics, and famil-
applies to the dynamics of innovative cycle. For
iarity with established conventions are put at
every positive movement in development of
risk. Some find this inevitable phase of innova-
fixed standards and metrics, there is an oppos-
tion exciting and inspiring—thriving in the free
ing negative effect on freedom of movement. For
space between the unknown and the possible.
solid-state lighting to succeed in general illumi-
Others find the intrusion threatening, pressing
nation a balance between the forces of freedom
for standards to rein in the chaotic intruders and
to create and a demand for restraint must
put them in their place.
be found. On one hand, with no definitions or
standardization, the technology risks free-for-all
for standards as practical need. During the
activity that fails to provide guidance and cred-
deployment of SSL, there has been a fair amount
ibility. However, if walls built of metric bricks
of communication failures, embarrassing miss-
become too tall, innovation can be stopped alto-
statements, unrealistic promises and mutual
gether, made too expensive or troublesome.
disrespect that have created plenty of emotional
During the early phase of any signifi-
backlash. This has been amplified by the intru-
cantly new technology, chaos reigns. While the
sion of PR. The industry, historically, has gener-
Emotions play as much a role in the demand
ally not employed a lot of PR firm-generated noise. With a propensity to spin everything at the highest volume, the increased level of PR currently surrounding SSL has exponentially increased this irritation of intrusion. Lighting The chaos associated with the launch of any disruptive technology inevitably brings about a call for law and order; in the case of SSL, it's standards for performance. But if the construction of standards is not done with balance, it can result in barriers that hinder innovation and development.
www.architecturalssl.com
decision-makers have reacted to this intruding storm with demands for physical proof and verification of seemingly outrageous claims. This uncovered the reality that existing standards were inadequate to the task. SSL presents new
Z
negotiating the maze
Continued on page 18
Architectural SSL • 02.11 • 17
marketanalysis
characteristics that conventional verification procedures failed to quantify accurately. The demand for new standards, and compliance with them, has emerged to fill missing standards gaps, and to reign in the free-for-all that LED marketing was becoming. The composite result has product innovators facing a gauntlet of testing and verification, and an overly cynical customer base.
With the prospect of customer demands
for unrealistic performance based on PR hype, tougher test standards, slow UL standards progress, new interest in EPA Energy Star compliance, demands for extended warranty periods, and constant discussion of even more standards and metrics on the near horizon—coupled with an already harsh IP (Intellectual Property) landscape—SSL is beginning to look less like an exciting new frontier and more like an obstacle course of metrics walls. The opportunities for small self-financed startups—who have brought many of lighting’s past innovations—is shrinking with each additional brick. The impact? At a time when applied product innovation should be exploding, there is a decided sluggishness of
to widespread application of the technology—to
new and unique applied lighting produce design
save energy.
BE Careful what you wish for
activity. Of course, the slow economy compounds
this by restricting available working capital.
greater influence in prior lighting innovations,
Pam Horner, Osram-Sylvania's director of government and industry relations, spoke recently at IALD's annual conference this past fall in Denver, as part of a panel addressing the state of energy codes and standards. Horner presented a chart demonstrating DOE-mandated phase outs of various products over the next 10 years. While theoretically, more efficient, legislatively mandated products will lead to more efficient spaces, Horner warns that further ratcheting of energy requirements will also limit choice and product prices will rise. Image courtesy of IALD
While romantics might feel design was a
the facts don’t support such feelings. Each new
Energy Metrics Bricks
lighting technology, from electric over gas,
The focus on efficacy standards
fluorescent and HID over incandescent, and
establishes the primary use of the
now LEDs over everything, have been founded
SSL technology as an energy-saving replacement
on rationalizations proved in savings of energy
of incumbent lesser-performing products. The
and maintenance cost. Advancement of lighting
re-dress of color rendering metrics, controls inte-
quality followed, as technologies mature. Based
gration, modularity, life ratings and consistency
on this, the demand for SSL product to perform
are all premised on these being necessary for the
well, and to perform as promised are well-
furtherance of the energy-saving agenda, and
founded demands.
not components of a grander scheme to improve
lighting as a whole. Fueled by the massive pres-
tions, where ultimate energy performance is
ence of the DOE for the first time in lighting—with
less important than other factors, standards
a charter to advance solid-state lighting to save
that push the efficiency envelope provide an
energy, specifically—there is hardly a conversa-
indirect benefit. Since LED component provid-
tion about SSL that does not include discussion
ers must focus on the mass market to realize
of lumens per watt. There are now numerous
realistic returns on their considerable invest-
conferences each year focused specifically on
ment, the core technology will deliver enhanced
advancing SSL to save energy, while the majority
performance, even when it is not necessary. The
of topics at SSL and lighting conferences target
benefit to future products' designs is smaller
the issues of standards, metrics and roadblocks
heat sinks and power supplies, regardless of the
18 • 02.11 • Architectural SSL
For those near- and long-term applica-
www.architecturalssl.com
marketanalysis
need to save energy.
to an effective continued deployment of SSL tech-
nology and avoiding some of the failures other
Perhaps the most disturbing imbalance vis-
ible to those looking to SSL to improve lighting as
technologies have suffered from a lack of attend-
a whole are the product categories that now com-
ing to quality details. The eventual replacement
mand the greatest attention—the Edison socket
of the aged CRI metric with a new CQS, or some
replacement lamp, the MR16 and the down-light—
similar standard, is another welcome improve-
bolstered by the threat of advancing energy
ment. The focus on tightening binning variations,
codes, and lamp phase outs. In this, the most
and insistence on improved color uniformity, has
innovative light source ever to reach general illu-
encouraged leading LED technology providers to
mination, is now primarily targeted at replacing
improve performance in positive ways. Standards
tungsten filament, and still screwing into obsolete
that weed out the low-grade products marketed
sockets. Congress and DOE have established this
by predatory marketers are a welcome wall that
game, with a one-for-one light-bulb-replacement
cannot be made too tall or strong.
logic that simultaneously demands phase out of the Edison socket—survives for decades into
Testing & Life Prediction Metric bricks
the future. This is a conventional approach to
Ideally, testing of SSL products
certain bulbs, while insuring their foundation—
would not require additional effort
deploying a new lighting technology, and sets
Innovation
Lusio, a division of LightWild, is stirring things up with the introduction of a new high-bay fixture that not only features superior energy efficiency and precise optics, it comes with a seven-year warranty—an industry first—and is a great example of the quality that can result from tough industry standards. Image courtesy of Lusio
SSL on the path of "evolution," opposed to mean-
or expense over conventional lamps. In reality,
ingful "transformation." Based on the current
SSL presents a higher degree of sensitivity to
mandates, in 15 years, the sockets in place today
heat and power flow, producing greater vari-
will still be in place, filled with gadgets that are
ability from product to product. Fortunately,
made, by mandate, to look like a phased-out obso-
LM79 testing does not require enough hardship
lete technology. This approach and its standards
to be considered a negative. LM80, on the other
only encourage innovation within the light bulb,
hand remains a problem. The time to test a
while ignoring any need to innovate away from
source requires months of testing time, result-
obsolete form factors that impart inefficient use
ing in data of value that is not fully understood.
of light energy. This is the failed historic path of
The lack of a uniform acceptable protocol for
the residential market, and will now be expanded
extrapolating LM80 test results into useable
into retail, food service, hospitality and light com-
life ratings, is frustrating. However, not having
mercial structures.
data is equally problematic, as there has been more than a few cases where package devices,
Quality Metric Bricks
assumed to have long service life, have proved to
Beyond the focus of DOE and utilities
perform poorly. Eventually, the need to accu-
on energy use, there is an encourag-
rately predict product and LED life will resolve
ing growth of investment in establishing useable
with continued standards improvements and
quality metrics. This includes continued work on
test protocol development. This will improve
binning consistencies, lifetime color and lumen
technology overall. There is nothing here that
degradation, flicker mitigation, color render-
limits creative application of SSL. However, the
ing and color standardization. For perhaps the
test process does slow deployment of new LEDs
first time, the impact of lighting on humans is a
somewhat.
topic of real discussion. Issues of biologic impact,
and risk assessment of spectral distributions,
is a frustration to luminaire manufacturers,
modulation effects, dimming behavior and source
while the expansion of available test resources
brilliance are now the focus of numerous com-
to gain Energy Star qualification promises to
mittees and organizations. Many of these quality
improve this program and its deployment. While
concerns are being addressed in the development
there remain areas where measurement of LED
of efficiency standards, producing positive com-
products is lacking, these secondary issues are
bined results. While there are a few bricks being
being resolved at an accelerated pace, present-
created here, they are necessary building blocks
ing little long-term impact on innovation.
The slow pace of UL standards development
www.architecturalssl.com Architectural SSL • 02.11 • 19
marketanalysis
Form Factor Metric Bricks
to be in the near future. Further, while there is
There are several aspects to stan-
some interest in the design community to see
dardization of form factors. At the
standard “lamp” modules, there has been little
source level, there has been little
pressure on manufacturers to provide this as
interest in standardizing LED package devices.
a condition of inclusion, so the overall interest
LED manufacturers are showing little inter-
in this approach is lukewarm. As LEDs become
est in creating or complying with a uniform
more mainstream; applied in a broader range
form factor or footprint. The process here is
of products, this is likely to change, creating
one of evolution that will eventually lead to
greater pressure on standards development.
a consensus standard. The proverbial Edison socket emerged originally from a consensus
The Need for Balance
in use, roughly based on the threads used on a
When the standards and metrics walls around a
small kerosene tin, then later established as a
technology are too high innovation is suffo-
standard. Eventually, this will occur at the pack-
cated. With no standards or performance met-
aged LED device level, as competitive forces and
rics, predatory marketers turn the market into a
expired IP positions move producers away from
free-for-all where sorting good from bad is made
forced proprietary marketing to direct market
impossible by the storm of hype. While stan-
share competitive activity.
dards and metrics do have a throttling effect on
creativity, they can also encourage innovation
There are a few simple LED modules
emerging as a de-facto standard at the board
by providing manufacturers and producers clear
level now. An example of this is the star-board,
performance targets to hit. Somewhere between
once a simple marketing and evaluation tool,
the extremes, there is a balance to be sought.
Energy Star
this has become a de-facto standard format.
So for, the combined efforts of the lighting and
Another is a large format LED array first intro-
technology provider community, coupled with
duced by Bridgelux for its high lumen ES pack-
the power of the EPA and DOE, are building
age. In time, there will be many others, including
solid metric and standards foundations for the
soldering connection points, and other features
technology. While not perfect, and sometimes
Anh Marella, a GE lighting product manager, holds the first production version of the 9-watt Energy Smart LED light bulb. It is the first A-line replacement product to earn Energy Star certification. The bulb is expected to last 22 years. Photo: Timothy Jack Ward
that will allow holders to be made, and standard
too slow, the overall effect is positive. There
optics to be applied, eventually these will be
are certainly areas of disagreement, such as
defined as standards. Otherwise, there has been
the lack of movement in SSL to resolve grander
little real progress in formally standardizing
lighting qualities issues, or retrofit lamp focus
LED package devices or connection points. Until
that enables continuance of obsolete socket
the market determines what formats work best,
architectures. There are certainly instances
this lack of solidity allows innovators the room
where the focus on energy, and standards to
they need to explore.
see that agenda advanced as first priority, limit
the emphasis on creative efforts elsewhere.
In regard to sockets and plug-in modules,
the Zahga consortium is engaged in an effort
However, this is, and has been, the dynamic of
to develop standards, while manufacturers
lighting design and application from its very
continue to develop proprietary approaches. At
beginning. Because of this, while SSL has the
this time, there are no socket formats that have
potential to transform how light is generated
been standardized. Further, populating a light
in the products we use, the impact it will have
module with LEDs often requires unique con-
is being formulated through focus on standards
figurations to accommodate the lack of harmony
and applied metrics, as an evolution toward a
at the device level. There will likely be a fair
more efficient industry as a whole. In time, inno-
number of products and solutions entering the
vations in lighting application will emerge, and
market offering a range of connection methods,
perhaps one day cause a revolution in lighting
LED and optical configurations, and industrial
itself. This too will be supported by the founda-
design approaches to consider. There is nothing
tions being laid through standards and metrics
restricting this exploration, nor is there likely
development being completed now.•
20 • 02.11 • Architectural SSL
EdiSon right or wrong?
While energy and color improvements are occurring, an issue in the development of white light SSL products for general illumination is the debate as to whether or not to continue with Edison-based sockets or move on to new connection methods more suited to the solid-state nature of LED technology. Photo courtesy of Sharp
www.architecturalssl.com
Transforming Light LUXEON LEDs are changing the way we light the spaces we live, shop and play in. With unparalleled efficiency, quality, and reliability, LUXEON LEDs are a simple way to transform lighting and improve the well being of our environment. Whether you’re lighting a restaurant, roadway or architectural masterpiece, you can count on LUXEON to deliver long life, high-quality white light while reducing energy consumption. To learn how LUXEON can help you transform lighting, call our partner, Future Lighting Solutions, at +1-888-589-3662, or visit www.philipslumileds.com/assl
sense and simplicity Circle 09
ARCHITECT’S VIEW
LED for Academia Solid-State Lighting—for general illumination—is becoming more prevalent in educational settings. First cost and the value proposition of existing technologies, however, remain barriers to those not at the vanguard.
By Barbara Horwitz-Bennett, contributing writer
Looking to capitalize on the
entering the market, this equa-
Commercial Indoor Products,
Dept. of Energy’s Commercially
energy savings, reduced mainte-
tion is beginning to change. “LED
Atlanta. Lithonia has had success-
Available LED Product Evaluation
nance and controls compatibility
lighting systems and controls have
ful LED installations at a number
and Reporting (CALiPER) pro-
leveraged by LED lighting, more
made continuous improvements
of universities, including San Diego
gram is helping designers identify
and more academic institutions are
and in certain situations, such as
State, the University of Akron and
exaggerated product claims and
taking the SSL plunge. At the same
presentation or low-light level
Babson College in Wellesley, Mass.
ask the right questions to deter-
time, a number of kinks remain,
environments, maintenance, and
“LEDs generally also improve their
mine if a product is truly a good
limiting a fuller scale adoption
now lower cost from both initial
life expectancy when dimmed to
quality option. “Products do exist
by the educational marketplace.
price and energy consumption, are
lower levels for the same reason.
that meet the performance levels
“Initial cost and maintenance con-
making LED systems and controls
These features create significant
of the traditional technologies in
cerns govern as the main criteria
a top choice,” says Steve Neimeis-
value for university settings.”
light output, dimming range, color
for decision making and we still
ter, lighting designer, EwingCole,
rendering and expected lifetime,”
encounter a hesitation to embark
Irvine, Calif.
need to maintain high quality input
notes Amanda Beebe, LED and
in a full replacement of existing
Additionally, universities
power to prevent lamp flicker in
ballast product manager, Lutron
systems or a complete LED specifi-
have started considering LEDs for
the dimming range and this can
Electronics, Coopersburg, Pa.
cation by our clients,” reports Matt
their high-performance dimming
only be achieved with a high qual-
“However, one must be diligent
Alleman, LC, LEED AP, lighting
features. “Unlike conventional
ity driver and light engine, says
in selecting a product that truly
designer, SmithGroup, Detroit.
light sources, LEDs generally
Ranieri. Of course, the process
represents a replacement.”
“Payback analysis makes it hard to
become more efficacious as they
of determining which products
endorse when balancing the initial
are dimmed to lower levels as a
have truly attained this level of
in that luminaires are now being
investment and its associated risk
by-product of reduced operat-
quality is a challenge in itself. For
custom-developed for LED sources.
assessment.”
ing temperature,” explains Dave
example, responding to the need
Traditionally, conventional lumi-
Ranieri, vice president and gen-
for more reliable, unbiased product
naires have been paired up with
eral manager, Lithonia Lighting
performance information, the U.S.
LEDs, but this has compromised
However, with more advanced
and sophisticated SSL products
22 • 02.11 • Architectural SSL
An important caveat is the
Elsewhere, there’s good news
www.architecturalssl.com
San Diego State University, San Diego, Calif.
above & Below:
A total of 110 ambient and downlight LED sources, along with an Acuity controls system, illuminate San Diego State University’s new 215-seat lecture hall. RTLED from Lithonia is a volumetric, recessed luminaire delivering uniform ambient white light with high color rendering and full range dimming. Photos: Lithonia Lighting
www.architecturalssl.com
brightness control, light distribu-
Energy and Environment Division
tion and color. But now that manu-
in Portland, observes that LED is
factures are fine-tuning the optical,
good in her mind for task light-
thermal and mechanical design of
ing, and perhaps for white board
luminaires, this has proven to boost
or chalkboard lighting, but “there
lighting quality, says Ranieri.
are few LED products for general lighting that control light distribu-
Still Needs Work
tion appropriately, use energy more
While the pros for SSL lighting are
efficiently than linear fluorescent
increasing, there are still a number
T5 and T8 lamps and are affordable
of areas which require develop-
for classrooms at this point in time.”
ment. For example, at this point
in time, LEDs have yet to become
ham Mor, IALD, LEED AP, IESNA,
competitive with fluorescent lamp-
Lightswitch Architectural, Chicago,
ing and dimming ballasts in multi-
points out that a number of major
function direct/indirect areas and
lamp manufacturers recently
spaces requiring high light levels
extended the estimated lamp life
for reading and writing, says Ewing
for 4-ft. T5 and T8 fluorescent lamps
Cole’s Neimeister.
to 55,000 hours. In a one-for-one
comparison, at least right now,
Not shy in her criticism of
As a matter of fact, Avra-
SSL’s flaws, lighting designer Naomi
Beebe agrees that LEDs are not yet
Miller, FIES, FIALD, LC, now a senior
competitive with 2 ft. × 2 ft. and 2 ft.
lighting engineer with Pacific
× 4 ft. fluorescent fixtures. “While
Northwest National Laboratory’s
many manufacturers are designing
SSL in San Diego Executing its first major LED lighting project with flair, San Diego State University, which has grown to become a national research entity, recently installed more than 100 LED fixtures and a controls system in its new 215-seat lecture hall. “LEDs are being used effectively in other industries and markets, and I was confident in the technology,” reports SDSU Architect Jeffrey Herr. Similarly, Dr. James Frazee, director of SDSU’s instructional technology services, who gets directly involved in campus construction projects from a facilitated learning perspective, was also an advocate of LED for this project. Frazee was interested in bringing some warmth to the space, in absence of natural light, and also wanted a simplified controls system for user-friendly faculty use. University officials pursued a solution from Lithonia Lighting, employing their RTLED volumetric lighting products. Specifically, 80 RTLEDs were installed for general ambient lighting and 30 of the company’s DOM8 LEDs were installed for downlighting along with the controls for dimming. Frazee was impressed with the elegance of the systems. “The Acuity Brands controls which simplified the complicated light systems that previously had up to 12 switches in some classrooms. The new lighting system only requires four switches,” he explains. So pleased with the quality of lighting, the university has begun collecting data on the energy, maintenance and sustainability benefits of the LED installation. In addition, Herr anticipates strongly considering LED for upcoming projects.
Architectural SSL • 02.11 • 23
Owen Hall at Michigan State University, East Lansing, Mich.
above + below:
Selected for their small size, narrow grazing optic and the fact that they could be concealed within a very minimal architectural reveal, SmithGroup chose Cooper Lighting’s iO Line 2.0 linear LED fixture for the interior design of Michigan State University’s Owen Hall. The consistency of light, fixture to fixture, was critical in this application to reinforce the architectural “path” concept for the space and produce the desired continuous linear character of light on the ceiling plane.
LED tubes to replace the fluores-
“managing the tension, as opposed
within a fixture’s housing, which
cent lamps and others are designing
to solving it.” For instance, for
eliminates the issue of figuring out
entire 2 ft. × 2 ft. tiles to replace the
global video conference videos,
where to bank the remote power
fluorescent fixture, they have yet to
he says glare can be mitigated if
supplies. However, according to
reliably produce the same amount
fixture and camera placement is
Alleman, “the compatibility between
of light at the same efficiency with
carefully coordinated.
driver, LED and fixture housing still
the same lifetime and controllability
needs to be better developed indus-
as the high-performance fluores-
Driver and LED Compatibility
try wide, particularly with regard to
cent systems.”
While the issue of compatibility
providing field replaceable drivers
issues between the power supplies
and LED boards.”
Group’s Alleman, is glare. Skeptical
or drivers and the LED system
as to whether this can ever be fully
continues to improve, it’s still
developments along these lines,
solved, the lighting designer sug-
something to be wary. For example,
and he certainly believes SSL
gests it may be more a matter of
the latest trend is to include drivers
manufacturers have gained trust
Yet another issue, says Smith-
24 • 02.11 • Architectural SSL
Neimeister has seen positive
www.architecturalssl.com
ARCHITECT’S VIEW
University of Akron, Akron, Ohio
in this realm. Still, he sees the need for some form of oversight to ensure that controls, luminaires, power supplies and drivers are not switched out during value engineering processes as these systems are being developed.
To ensure compatibility, Beebe
says specifiers should consider the following:
• The control system and
driver must utilize the same dimming technology including forward phase control, reverse phase control, zero-10 volts, etc.
• The driver must meet the
appropriate control standard if one exists, for example, IEC 60929 for zero-10 volts and DALI control.
• Select drivers and controls
from the same manufacturer to
above:
As part of its green initiatives the University of Akron considered LED lighting as part of a number of energy conservation projects in its Multiplex residence hall. Lighting consultant Jack Duffy & Assocs., selected Lithonia’s RTLED volumetric luminaires due to their architectural look, ability to meet the installation demands of the LED conversion process, quality of light and brand reputation. According to university vice president of capital planning and facilities management, Ted Curtis, the ambient lighting delivers a crisper lighting effect and he’s comforted knowing “he’s spending fewer dollars for better lighting.” Photo: Lithonia
ensure a tested and compatible solution, and to have one point of contact for any problems.
• Look for control recommen-
dations for specific products, such
Babson College, Babson Park, Mass.
Babson College Discouraged by color temperature issues and fixture dimensions, Babson College in Wellesley, Mass never considered SSL lighting until a new LED volumetric lighting product came to the market. “We were immediately pleased with the color temperature and controllability of Lithonia Lighting’s RTLED systems,” reports Shelley Kaplan, associate vice president of the Wellesley, Mass. college. “This was the first system we evaluated that had the ability to replace our T8 fluorescents and truly deliver on the promise of LEDs.” Following suit, two new 2,760-sq.-ft. classrooms were each recently outfitted with 24 RTLED fixtures.
www.architecturalssl.com
Architectural SSL • 02.11 • 25
A Good Fit White LED lighting proved to be a great solution for the operators of the Donald W. Reynolds Education Center at Happy Hands in Broken Arrow, Okla. The school, specifically designed for hearing-impaired children, faced a unique issue when it came to lighting: typical fluorescent sources generated harmonic distortion and interfered with the students’ hearing aids. The project’s architects, Thalden, Boyd, Emery Architects, Tulsa, worked with a local lighting distributor, Broken Arrow Electric Supply, to come up with alternatives. According to Steve Barrett, the company’s quotations manager, they explored a number of options and settled on LEDs, principally three fixtures: the IC 22 white 6-in. recessed downlight from Juno, a 2 x 4 troffer-style LED from Albeo, and mostly, Albeo’s suspended C-Series LED high bay linear fixtures. The Juno fixtures, says Barrett, are fully dimmable, and were used to illuminate the hallways and office areas. In the classrooms, which featured sloping ceilings, height was an issue, and they went with Albeo’s linear solution. “The product was a godsend,” says Barrett. That said, the supplier didn’t just jump at the technology without doing its homework. The team visited the manufacturer to see the facility, their inventory and quality control measures. “These guys are for real. They’ve got a product that offers quality light, sustainable features and a good warranty. We also wanted a single point of contact and someone who would accept responsibility for the job, and they did.”
26 • 02.11 • Architectural SSL
as drivers or lamps, from control
are also a popular feature. “Special
manufacturers or the driver/lamp
effects via controls are becoming
above:
manufacturer.
more practical and cost-effective,”
says Ranieri. “Color changing
Thomas Jefferson Primary School in Peoria, Ill., was in the process of undergoing a major renovation as the result of a fire. With direction from the board of education, the school pursued LED lighting to replace its existing and outdated T12 fluorescent illumination. They chose dimmable linear T8-style fixtures from Albeo Technologies which offered a low-energy, low maintenance solution. According to Brian Snyder, an electrical engineer at St. Louis-based Farnsworth Group, the project’s lighting designer, the product stood up to his investigations. “Albeo had the LM79 testing, the documentation, the warranty and form factor we needed,” says Snyder. “They impressed me with their technical depth and design support.”
Overall, Beebe believes that
manufacturers need to be more
effects and intense saturated color
transparent about compatibility
of LEDs are being used to create
and performance. “‘Dimmable’
dynamic decorative effects [in
doesn’t help anyone, ‘dimmable
university settings].”
on zero-10-volts controls to a 5%
light level,’ does.”
sconces as another niche for SSL
Miller sees attractive wall
since their purpose is decorative, Put the Accent in the Right Place
as opposed to providing useful
Another popular LED application
light, so it’s best if the sconces use
for schools and universities is
as little energy as possible.
decorative and accent lighting. As
small point sources, they can easily
definitely increasing for LED in
be manipulated into more creative
academia spaces, Mor is still skepti-
applications than traditional light-
cal as to how quickly the technology
ing. Coupled with energy efficiency,
will be accepted. “Too many people
LEDs enable universities to display
see lighting as a commodity, so
artwork and to be creative in their
until that changes, the conversion
lighting design, while still staying
to LED is going to be tough. The
within the constraints of energy
whole metric of how these products
codes and reducing their energy
are designed, specified, purchased
bills,” says Beebe. In addition to
and installed has to change in the
coves, displays and backlit applica-
university setting and that’s asking
tions, LED’s color-changing effects
a lot of many people.”•
While opportunities are
Photo: Albeo Technologies
www.architecturalssl.com
Circle 10
F§±TUR§D PRoj§Ct
Chandler City Hall, Chandler, Ariz.
Chandler City Hall Chandler City Hall, Chandler, Ariz.
Owner: City of Chandler Architect: The SmithGroup, Phoenix Lighting Design: The SmithGroup, Detroit LED product manufacturers: Phillips ColorKinetics, Lutron Text: Jim Crockett Photography: Bill Timmerman
The Challenge: The City of Chandler, Ariz., is representative of the new West: Rooted in its 19th-Century ranch history, and certainly geology, it also enjoys its role as being an active part of the 21st-Century. As the host of Intel and other high-tech companies, the city, in envisioning its new city center complex, desired a structure that demonstrated this commitment to the now without abandoning its past. The SmithGroup was brought in for architectural services, including architectural lighting. Much of the multipurpose facility would be clad in stone to reflect the natural terrain, but the architects, in trying to capture this Old West/New West dichotomy particularly wished to distinguish the city council chamber area with a more modern look, perhaps including some kind of luminous element. The team also wanted a nighttime aspect to the building’s signature art piece, a flexible metal scrim at the building’s entrance created by artist Ned Kahn.
The Solution: The team consulted its Detroit-based lighting group, led by Principal Jeff Gerwing, and together, came up with novel solutions for both desires. The fully enclosed, 30-ft.-tall chamber would end up being clad with milky, translucent glass panels that were given that luminous feel by backlighting said panels with a series of carefully placed white
28 • 02.11 • Architectural SSL
4000K LED fixtures. Gerwing also came up with an intriguing notion to illuminate the art element, a series of independent, perforated stainlesssteel screens that undulate in the wind creating various ripples effects along the scrim as the sun reflects off the metal. Rather than just fire up some floodlights, Gerwing was inspired by the old/new undercur-
www.architecturalssl.com
LED outlook Maturing
An example of the evolving maturity of SSL, the new Chandler City Hall, by the SmithGroup, employs LEDs logically, as light sources— both color and white—to provide definitive solutions to highlight the building’s architecture.
rent running throughout the project, as well as the movement Kahn’s sculpture generates during the day. To further execute this dichotomy, he placed powerful and fully saturated linear LED fixtures of blue and amber at the top and bottom of the scrim respectively. Not only do the hues gel visually, they also match metaphorically with the blues drawing
www.architecturalssl.com
Over the past eight years, the SmithGroup has been a fairly aggressive adopter of LED technology in many of its projects across the country, even the globe. Over the course of this period, one of its principle champions, principal Jeff Gerwing, is glad to see the technology begin to come into its own as a legitimate solution rather than a showy spectacle. “Some owners, in the excitement of a new technology, just want LED and it’s a bit scary in making such a decision without really knowing what’s involved,” says Gerwing. At the same time, he says more owners are interested in doing what’s right, rather than just what’s the least expensive. On the Chandler City Hall project, the “easy” out was to simply floodlight the scrim. An advantage of being an integrated firm, according to Gerwing, is that the lighting group had a real opportunity to have input to really accentuate the architecture. After developing the concept and accompanying renderings, Gerwing says the architectural team “got really excited.” And beyond the visual aspect, the use of LED in this case also was in tune with other goals of the project, which included sustainable solutions, including Dark Sky provisions. “LED is a very long life source and was a very energy efficient way to backlight such an expansive wall.” Maintenance and operational issues are also a “huge” area where LEDs are making strides, particularly given there’s not a lot of space in the chamber and the glass shroud. “This was big sell [for LED].”
upon the association of the color with high-tech manufacturing, and the ambers reflecting the desert and the colors of dusk. The colors also engage and enhance the movement of the sculpture, creating natural color changing on the scrim, as the blues and ambers mix. “When I finished aiming the lights, the city project manager was clapping,” says Gerwing.
Architectural SSL • 02.11 • 29
Controls The big idea on the scrim (opposite) was to let nature do her thing in mixing the colors and their intensity. For example, through the mock up the designers discovered that if the wind blew from the back, it tended to highlight the amber more, whereas if the panels tilt forward, the blue is more prominent. A strong gust of wind creates the ripple effect, which also changes the color complexion. Controls were incorporated, but only to dim one side or the other to achieve proper balancing.
Old Trick Bag with a Twist In contemplating color and color mixing, Gerwing returned to his theatrical lighting background, and turned to the idea of specifically mixing pure blues and ambers. In this case blue would emit from the top, and amber from the bottom with the lighting mixing in the middle. Here’s where LED came to bear. Gerwing desired sources that would be both powerful and that could deliver very saturated light as they’d have to throw that light 50 or 60 ft. Furthermore, he wanted that mingling of color in the middle to be distinct. Metal halide was considered, but the fixtures would be too chunky and detract from the sculpture. Also, he wanted a tighter optical pattern—LEDs became the obvious choice, but there was not an obvious product. At the time, most of the linear SSL fixtures available were RGB and simply did not have the punch Gerwing wanted. Having a relationship with ColorKinetics that dated back to his first extensive SSL project at Detroit Airport’s McNamara Terminal tunnel, Gerwing approached the manufacturer about developing a product similar to their eWBlast Powercore floodlight, but just blue or amber. The company was eager to comply, perhaps even “saying yes before they should have,” jokes Gerwing, as it was a complicated adaptation.
30 • 02.11 • Architectural SSL
The Chamber (right) On the opposite end of the spectrum, SmithGroup employed white LED lighting to create a very different, but visually stunning effect. The chamber, really a concrete box, was clad in “glowing” translucent glass panels. It, however, is not a curtain wall, but a standalone architectural element that shrouds the hall to highlight its importance. “How do you make a 30-ft.-wall luminous?” posits Gerwing. “A lot of backlighting, of course.” The key was uniformity. Some 28 eW Blast Powercore fixtures were used to cover the 30-ft. spans with one fixture per glass panel on 5-ft. centers. But complicating matters was the fact that the shroud intersects with the building in the form of a vestibule on the courtyard side of the complex. Here, nearly 100 ew Graze fixtures were employed to get the distribution needed. Deciding factors for LED, according to Gerwing, included its tight beam, long life and size.
www.architecturalssl.com
Prove it
perfect via practice The team created various mock-ups, running the whole process though artist Ned Kahn, to make sure the effect would be appropriate for the unique art piece. The mock-up testing not only included color penetration on the scrim, but also involved angling sections of the panels forward and back to see how the scrim would react to wind, as well as physically rumpling long sheets of the material to see how larger sections of the sculpture would look under moving conditions (above).
www.architecturalssl.com
Beyond getting Color Kinetics to re-engineer the white-light fixture to a single color, the team also had to prove the concept would work. Gerwing noted a particular difficulty was that the scrim’s panels are perforated and stainless steel, so there was concern about the light reflecting or passing through the panels without effectively lighting them. The team created various mockups, running the whole process though artist Kahn, to make sure the effect would be appropriate for the unique art piece. The mock-up testing not only included color penetration on the scrim, but also involved angling sections of the panels forward and back to see how the scrim would react to wind, as well as physically rumpling long sheets of the material to see how larger sections of the sculpture would look under moving conditions (below, left). Satisfied, the team turned to the next challenge: unobtrusively mounting the 12-in. fixtures, 15 each, onto the top and bottom of the scrim. The solution was a 6-in. tray (left) that conceals the fixtures and leaves a clean line during the day. Then there was the wait, as the custom fixtures took longer to produce than expected. “It was a tight time crunch for getting the lights to the site. It came right down to the wire.” Was it worth it? Gerwing relays a story. While back at the site this past December to do some final aiming, he had turned off the lights temporarily. During this process he was approached by a policeman who was concerned. He noted to Gerwing that he had told his family about the sculpture and wanted to bring them down to show them, but was worried the lighting had gone away. “Those are the biggest rewards,” says Gerwing. “That and knowing that your client feels confident in that they did the right thing.”•
Architectural SSL • 02.11 • 31
Circle 11
SSLprofile: ‘24’-inspired office Pulls off austere but dramatic look with LEDs The Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Kansas City Kansas City, Mo.
By Craig DiLouie, contributing writer
Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Kansas City (Blue KC), is one of 39 independent BCBS companies that collectively provide healthcare coverage for nearly 98 million members. The Kansas City plan’s information systems center, designed by architects Bell/Knott & Assocs. and M/E/P firm Gibbens Drake Scott Inc., and built in 1993, became slated for renovation in 2009. When Blue KC requested that the interior space have the feel of the high-tech HQ spaces in the TV series ‘24,’ Bell/Knott engaged Yarnell Assocs., Architectural Lighting Design to help emulate some of the visual effects on the show using architectural lighting design. According to Komal Hatti, architect for Bell/Knott & Assocs., Kevin Sparks and Jeff Shipley with Blue KC were bold in their design decisions. Without their insistence on creating a “masculine, austere and elegant” space, she says the interiors would have resembled most typical office spaces. “Lighting effects and choices were to assist in attaining the goals and help to reinforce this overall simple aesthetic,” says Hatti.
High contrast with dark backgrounds, blue/
white general illumination and bold lighting on wall graphics were recognized as part of the desired feel of the TV show. The solution was LED. In fact, all of the main open office and corridor lighting utilizes solid-state lighting as the light source, from downlights, task lighting and wall
modern: Cooper’s RSA PROfile track lighting provided good CRI and smooth-edged beams of light in the
washing in the office spaces, to track lighting and
corridors to accent wall-mounted artwork. According to lighting designer Bruce Yarnell, the track, which was customized to make the system appear taller, was especially important as the fixture heads are very modern looking and the light source assisted with this aesthetic. Calculate downlights were used over the work areas.
decorative luminous panels in the corridors.
Images: Chris Crum/Mark McDonald Photography
www.architecturalssl.com
“We were trying for an aesthetic where the
lighting was definitely not linear fluorescent,” says Bruce Yarnell, principal lighting designer for Yarnell Assocs. “LED sources were chosen
Architectural SSL • 02.11 • 33
SSLprofile:
Blue Cross and Blue Shield of kansas city
The Challenge: Create a lighting design that would emulate the high-tech feel of the headquarters spaces in the TV show ‘24.’
A
The solution: The lighting design team went high-tech with a variety of SSL sources across the board to deliver an austere, but dramatic space.
B
accent wall LightWild 12-in. × 12-in. LED panels create an interesting accent wall opposite to the conference room. Yarnell finds that LED is a very good source not only for the future, but now. “Except for some first cost issues and with the caution that there are problems with some vendors and products, I would encourage architects to investigate the use of LED products through qualified professionals who have some experience in the use of LEDs,” he says.
proJEct credits:
Project: Blue Cross Blue Shield Plan’s Information Systems Center Renovation Location: Kansas City, Mo. Owner: Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Kansas City. Architect: Bell/Knott & Assocs. Corporate Architects, PC Lighting Designer: Yarnell Assocs. Electrical Engineer: Gibbens Drake Scott Inc. General Contractor: J.E. Dunn Electrical Contractor: Shaw Electric LED Manufacturers: Cooper Lighting, IO Lighting, Lightolier, LightWild
A Cooper Lighting’s Halo/RSA Profile track system was used in the hallway. wwwcooperlighting.com. Circle 290. B LightWild’s Cool White Lumenpower Lites illuminate the glass wall opposite the veneer wall, which also was illuminated with LightWild 12- x 12-in. LED panels. www.lightwild.com. Circle 289.
because they were sympathetic to the spirit of
developed for A-type incandescent lamps, made
to add a false vertical piece to have the track
the project being modern, crisp and efficient, and
the transformation to fluorescent and now LED.
appear larger and stronger.
a bit on the edgy side. They also provide good
But the basic design, he says, has always been an
efficiency, excellent maintenance features and
excellent way to control glare and distribute the
room wall features a regular array of 12-in.
reasonable first cost opportunities.”
light in the desired downward pattern.
× 12-in. internally illuminated LED panels by
LightWild. “This solution was in a square board
The LED technology used on the project,
In the conference room, IO Lighting’s LED
The veneer wall opposite the conference
according to Jon Brolhorst, electrical/lighting
Line 1.5 units provide wall grazing while Light-
pattern with LED lights visible in a 2-in. × 2-in.
designer for Gibbens Drake Scott, was key in
Wild’s Cool White Lumenpower Lite illuminates
grid,” Yarnell explains. “We found that the cor-
creating the cooler, high-contrast “24” feel, but
the glass wall. For the latter application, LED
rect acrylic would allow a hint of vision of this
furthermore, he noted it brought energy effi-
lighting proved especially valuable for its long
grid, which aided in the depth of the effect and
ciency, longevity and low maintenance.
service life, as accessibility to the equipment
indicated that there is something more interest-
would be difficult.
ing than normal fluorescent backlighting.”
from a series of recessed Lightolier Calculite
LED downlights, with LED task lighting used at
track lighting by Cooper Lighting—with the
cient with a power density of 0.78 watts/sq. ft.
the guest office desks. The downlights, specified
track customized to make the system appear
The $1.6 million renovation for the 9,000-sq.-ft.
at a cool 4000K, provide strong contrasts, giving
taller—provide good-color-rendering accent
space, featuring its $150,000 LED lighting sys-
the space a bolder feel and look consistent with
lighting on the walls with smooth-edged beams
tem, was completed this past Fall. Thanks to the
“24.” “We looked at five different manufactur-
of light. “The track lighting was especially
predominant use of directional point sources,
ers for their versions of the LED downlight and
important as the fixture heads are very modern
the lighting is bold and sharp.
made a specification decision based on look,
looking and the light source assisted with this
performance, glare control—40-degree cutoff
aesthetic,” says Yarnell.
employ state-of-the-art light sources,” Yarnell
angle to the source—and cost,” Yarnell recalls.
says. “I think through careful review of options,
had limited track options, which tended to be
calculations and visual mock ups, the job came
solutions using remote phosphor technology
thin in profile. Because they wanted the track to
out in a very positive light. The spaces look very
in the classic parabolic reflector downlight. He
be a bold leading line connecting all of the open
close to the intended design. The renderings
notes that the reflector downlight was originally
area spaces, he worked with the manufacturer
look like photos and vice versa.”•
The main space receives general lighting
Yarnell has been impressed by fixture
34 • 02.11 • Architectural SSL
In the corridors, Halo and RSA PROfile
The selected manufacturer, Yarnell notes,
The lighting is long lasting and energy effi-
“The project was a unique opportunity to
www.architecturalssl.com
PARKING GARAGE LUMINAIRE PERFORMANCE FACTS
10’ MH
50W INPUT 5000 LUMENS 4100K 70CRI
30’ 30’
The distinctive new LED parking garage luminaire; developed by Tersen Lighting to deliver superior uniformity, minimized glare and unparalleled energy savings. Available early spring 2011, the Ratio is ideal for parking garage, corridor and canopy applications; providing an intelligent lighting solution for new construction or renovation. Circle 12
©2011 ACUITY BRANDS, INC.
ONE LITHONIA WAY, CONYERS, GA 30012
WWW.TERSENLIGHTING.COM
By 2013, there will be 120 million iPADS and 50 milllion more iPHONES that can only stream courses from one provider’s website –
1
2
THECONTINUINGARCHITECT Streaming video courses you watch just like a TV show. No more click.click.click.click. The Continuing Architect makes learning much more enjoyable. Plus, we’ve got some of the most interesting courses available today. It’s free, so visit the site and register today.
FEATURED COURSES
iSuppli research
1
2
Piper Jaffray
Compare and contrast the benefits of tensile architecture over traditional building techniques. Identify the process for creating a tensile structure.
Describes the beneficial relationship between humans and the natural world, the general, developmental and health benefits of engagement with nature.
1 LU,1 SD,1 HSW User Course Rating *****
1 LU, 1 SD, 1 HSW; User Course Rating: *****
TheContinuingArchitect.com
SSLprofile: Boston Grocer Pushes the Green Envelope with Smart Lighting Chestnut Hill Star Market Boston, Mass.
By Jim Crockett
The Chestnut Hill Star Market in Newton, Mass., a Boston suburb, is one of the nearly 200 stores in the Shaw’s/Star Market chain and a key member of the more than 2,200 grocery outlets in the Supervalu family. Targeted as a test lab for energy-efficient technologies that Supervalu hopes to use in other stores, the Chestnut Hill operation has become a model of sustainability, thanks in part to high-performance LED systems borrowing techniques from proven ceiling lighting technology.
Until recently Star Market’s Chestnut Hill
store, which comprises about 35,000 sq. ft. of selling space, was illuminated by conventional incandescent and fluorescent lights. Today, it is one of the first grocery stores to be entirely lit with solid-state lighting. In combination with other sustainability actions, including the use of fuel cell electricity and glycol/carbon dioxide refrigeration, the store also became the first to receive the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s GreenChill Partnership platinum award.
Such initiatives shouldn’t be surprising,
according to Jeanne von Zastrow, senior director of industry relations and sustainability at the Food Marketing Institute. She says supermarkets nationwide are incorporating technology to cut costs and save energy, in part, to reduce the risk of more government regulation on energy consumption, but also to satisfy environmentally
top: Star Market, in creating a prototype “green” store, wanted greater energy efficiency, but also quality
conscious customers and employees.
lighting with a high CRI. bottom: The chain implemented Lithonia’s RTLED volumetric luminaires which have a CRI of 85+, have helped create the contrast the store desired, and as much as 50% energy savings over conventional lighting.
Images: Lithonia
www.architecturalssl.com
“Sustainability needs to be embedded in
every single part of a company and in every single part of a person’s job responsibility,’’ von Zastrow said. The challenge, she added, is “how to get the message from the CEO down to the bagger.’’
Architectural SSL • 02.11 • 37
SSLprofile:
chestnut hill star market, Boston
The Challenge: Intelligently meet the store’s goal to be a green operation with lighting that is not only energy efficient, but of high quality that still meets the needs of retail facilities, including high CRI and good contrast to showcase products. The solution: Grocery operator Star Market, turned to Lithonia and it’s new volumetric LED solution to provide the right general ambient background to help support accent and track lighting efforts.
The company turned to Lithonia Lighting
and its RTLEDs. The luminaires, which borrow many of the principles of the company’s popular 2 × 2 RT5 T-5 volumetric fixtures, have a 50,000hour rated system life without having to change lamps or ballasts and are projected to last as long as 10 years, compared to conventional lighting that generally lasts between eight to 18 months.
According to Dave Ranieri, vice president,
general manager Lithonia Lighting, Commercial Indoor, who presented the project as case study
an absence of glare; and finally, good contrast
at the most recent ArchLED conference, the store
on the merchandise, as he said non-uniformity
features four layers of illumination: General
enhances the visual experience.
ambient—volumetric and recessed downlighting;
feature lighting—track; perimeter cove lighting;
Supervalu’s director of engineering, Holly Angell,
and accent lighting. Ambient lighting is dimmed
the store uses half as many sources as they
back to 66%, keeping the layers “in balance.” The
did with conventional lighting, resulting in an
resulting aggregate, he said, is a uniform power
estimated reduction in energy use of 50% to 65%
density of 1.1 watts per sq. ft.—certainly within
due to the efficiency of the LEDs.
the store’s target of 1.4 watts per sq. ft. Other
project goals, according to Ranieri, included the
with Shaw’s/Star Market, is pumped. “We are the
store becoming a model for sustainable design.
only supermarket in the country that has all LED
To that end, he said energy-efficient LED lighting
lighting on the sales floor. That’s all of the cases,
was employed throughout; refrigerant use was
all of the lights on the ceilings, right down to
reduced by at least 50%, and the facility uses a
the fixtures and the soda machines on the sales
400kW fuel cell to power the 54,000 sq. ft. store.
floors. All LED lighting,” said Mahtesian.
As far as performance/maintenance objec-
How did the design stack up? According to
Ken Mahtesian, senior project manager
Drusilla Hufford, director of the federal
tives, the design reduced target lighting levels to
Environmental Protection Agency’s strato-
35 avg. mfc horizontal, and 25 avg. mfc vertical.
spheric protection division, pointed to Star
On the quality side, Ranieri noted the goal was
Market as a model business. “This store sets a
superior visual merchandising in an inviting,
new standard for environmental responsibility
comfortable environment. From a performance
for others in the industry to work to match.’’
perspective, the goal was superior system effi-
ciency, reduced maintenance, and a color render-
Market, concurred, “We’re extremely excited and
ing at or over 85 with good color temperature;
we’re proud of this store.”•
38 • 02.11 • Architectural SSL
Mike Witynski, president of Shaw’s and Star
above:
Recognized by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, the store is the first to receive the organization’s GreenChill Partnership platinum award, in part, thanks to 50% to 65% energy savings the store now accrues from its switch from conventional to all-LED lighting. Photos: Lithonia
www.architecturalssl.com
Architectural SSL magazine announces the first annual Product Innovation Awards competition, recognizing outstanding products and product developments relating to solid-state lighting.
Products—both luminaires and components—and products as applied in projects, will be reviewed by the editorial staff and a panel of judges in a two-part process to identify finalists. Products submitted in the main
categories—luminaires; components; and applications—will also be eligible for a number of special citations issued by the magazine. Turn to the pages of Architectural SSL for the award winners as they’re unveiled.
PRODUCT INNOVATION AWARDS • 2011
Introducing the 2011 Product Innovation Awards
Turn Here as We Unveil the Winners Award winners and finalists will be honored in a special report published in a new annual Spring edition of Architectural SSL magazine. Learn about the SSL products that are distinguishing themselves from the rest.
Publishing in March 2011
Award Categories Luminaire Awards Including categories for downlights, linear, floodlights, landscape, bollards, wall packs and rail, track lighting, street, area lighting, parking, and decorative and pendant Component Awards Categories include: best new light source in SSL—LED; best new light source in SSL—OLED; best new component, driver, or power supply; and best new OEM component. Application Awards Categories include: most innovative use of SSL; most beautiful use of color in SSL; most beautiful use of white light SSL; best renovation project using SSL; most impactful application; and most energy efficient application. Plus several special ‘Market Leadership’ awards honoring some of the industry’s top brands.
Presented by:
the White pages
By Kevin Willmorth
Tools & Take-Aways for Evaluating SSL Samples Invest in a Multi-Meter, Light Meter and a Spectroradiometer The introduction of SSL technology creates some intriguing prob-
Chart such as the 24 color product from GretagMacbeth, available from
lems. First, many of the quick appraisals that have become the main
photographic suppliers for under $50. This simple tool can be used
stay of conventional comparison, simply don’t apply well to LED
for viewing a range of standard colors under a sample light source.
products. LED products take a few hours to reach actual operating
This will not provide exact CCT information, but it does provide some
temperature, while the color of LED light is different in character
insight into how well a source is rendering color.
from conventional sources.
There are three key tools necessary for evaluating SSL products.
Simple Methods
The first is a multi-meter with an ammeter and a temperature probe.
The first step in testing an LED product sample is to get it up to tem-
These can be found for under $100, with the surface temperature
perature. Using the multi-meter with the temperature probe attached,
probe for roughly $40. On-line test instrument resources like www.
measure a point on the heat sink nearest the LED array cold, then again
tequipment.net carry a wide range of products. Look for a meter that
periodically (every 15 minutes or so) as the fixture warms up. At the
measures true RMS power (watts), temperature in both Fahrenheit
same time, set up a point to take a light measurement from that can
and Celcius, as well as standard DC and AC voltage. With a little prac-
be accurately repeated and take a light meter reading. Ideally, leave
tice, simple meters can read power used, and the temperature of the
the product running at room temperature for a minimum of 2 hours,
surface of heat sinks. Further, a multi-meter is a great device for sort-
periodically checking both light output and temperature at the previous
ing out positive from negative, and checking power supply voltage
points. Don’t be surprised if it takes some fixtures more than 3 hours to
before it is plugged into a product. For power measurement alone,
reach their stabile temperature and light output. In this process, take
there are also simple plug-in devices that will deliver watt, volt, KWh,
notes on light output and temperature, noting the change in both. If
amp, and power factor readings. A popular range is offered by Kill A
the light output continues to drop after the temperature has stabilized,
Watt, in single to multi-outlet configurations, available from $30 to
continue to observe its operation until light output stops moving.
$90 from many retail and on-line sources.
stabilize, the fixture has reached its operating equilibrium. At this time
The second important tool is a quality light meter. Due to differ-
When the meter readings for both light level and temperature
ences in the spectral power distribution of LEDs, typical economy light
appraisal of color and general light output can be made with some
meters will produce erroneous results, fluctuating readings, or incon-
degree of accuracy and measuring the amount of power consumed can
sistency from reading to reading. To solve this, Amprobe now offers an
be tested using the multi-meter.
affordable (under $100) #LM-200LED meter that is designed to produce
accurate meter readings of LED light sources—also available from
erence source for comparison. For example, a halogen lamp provides
Tequipment. For those looking for a more fully featured meter, the
a good 3000K reference, while a high CRI fluorescent might be used for
Minolta T-10 series of meters work very well with LED sources.
4100K and 5000K. Moving the color card between the two sources, or
setting up a viewing box with two cards, one under the reference and
Measurement of color information (CCT) or CRI data, requires
The best approach for using a color card is to have a desirable ref-
a third tool, a color meter, or spectroradiometer. While it’s tempting
one under the subject product, will provide a reasonable idea of how
to use photographers equipment, which can be acquired on eBay for
well a source is performing. Use of a spectroradiometer, or color meter,
less than $400, these devices are balanced for film and digital imaging,
can be used to replace or supplement the color chart evaluation.
and not CIE luminous spectral efficiency, so results are not accurate for general illumination. To capture CCT requires a meter designed
Measurement Errors
for the purpose, such as the Milolta CL200, costing roughly $2,700. To
One thing to be careful of is the fact that light sources that modulate,
capture CRI information, one of the most versatile meters is the Orb
such as DC LEDs operated from simple switching power supplies, or
Optronix SP-100, which connects to a PC using proprietary software,
PWM dimmed, AC line voltage—and AC low voltage LED products—gen-
which measures/calculates CCT, chromaticity, spectral distribution,
erate several errors in measuring power and light output. Modulation
luminance, illuminance, irradiance, radiance, and CRI. These tools
confuses light meter processors, resulting in wildly fluctuating read-
cost around $9,000, but for anyone doing a lot of testing where color
ings. Further, power measurements may also show results that are
information is critical, it's worth the cost.
obviously not correct. When this occurs, there is little that can be done
to correct the error, without involving the purchase of more sophisti-
For those who are unable to rationalize the cost of a full color
meter, there is a subjective test method that employs a Color Rendition
40 • 02.11 • Architectural SSL
cated equipment.•
www.architecturalssl.com
the White pages
By Kevin Willmorth, contributing writer
Creating Fair Life-Cycle Cost and Payback Evaluations Many Factors Must be Calculated Including Maintenance In an effort to evaluate ROI for energy saving expenses, simple
energy saving calculations are often used to evaluate the savings
However, the cost is never “$0.00.” In addition to the cost of replace-
of a new system vs. an incumbent product. As is the case with most
ment lamps are the time and effort behind acquiring the lamp, and
overly-simplistic approaches, the results are inaccurate and mislead-
receiving it, in addition to inventory costs, then installation labor.
ing. Operation of lighting systems includes maintenance, and eventual
Further, replacing a lamp may require the use of tools and/or ladders,
replacement of luminaires. Further, lighting creates heat, which must
which must be found and moved to the fixture being serviced.
be accounted for by air conditioning systems.
performance between systems. Attempting to compare a premium LED
While the concept of demanding a replacement system to pay for
• The cost of re-lamping varies widely from customer to customer.
• Comparisons often fail to recognize the difference in quality and
itself within a predetermined period of time to justify investment is
product to a commodity white goods incandescent product is unfair
sound, comparing the continued operation of an existing system to
and will produce unrealistic results. Either discount the value of the
the replacement cost and operation of a new system requires care-
new product to reflect this, use a higher-end product as the base com-
ful evaluation of more than simple energy consumption, and care in
parison, or select another replacement product of equitable quality.
what factors are included. For example, assuming an existing system has a value of “$0.00” while attributing total costs of new systems is
Example:
an unfair comparison. Further, when considering solid-state lighting
For purposes of illustrating the difference between very simple energy
products that are to be replaced at the end of their service life, without
calculation vs. a more equitable methodology, the following is a hypo-
also considering end of life costs of an existing product, comparisons
thetical comparison of 100, 75-watt halogen fixtures (such as a small
are further skewed. Accurate representation and comparison of the
track head or downlight), to 100 new 12-watt LED products of equiva-
cost of operating lighting systems requires inclusion of equitable fac-
lent quality and performance.
tors to produce realistic results. The following points will lead to fairer
comparisons that produce more accurate evaluations.
placing the two systems on equal terms, the resulting apparent sav-
ings is considerably greater than the simple comparison indicates. The
• The act of evaluation indicates a need or desire to realize an
By considering operating costs beyond simple energy reduction,
improvement in either lighting performance or energy use. Existing
results will vary by project, including instances where the additional
systems are rarely performing at 100%, while a new system will. As
considerations extend payback periods, rather than shorten them as it
a minimum, the assumption should include a cleaning and group re-
has in this example. In any case, the accuracy and fairness is improved
lamping of the existing system as a baseline.
by looking beyond simple energy use. However, even this example
fails to consider the additional benefits of rebates or tax credits, or
• All lighting systems require periodic maintenance, upkeep, and
eventual replacement. Evaluations should include the amortized cost
the costs of lost productive days, liability exposure, costs for scaffold-
of eventual replacement of both existing and new proposed products.
ing, or other project specific expenses that can significantly change
TABLEnew 1. ALUMINUM COST IN ENERGY TO PRODUCE For SSL systems, service life may be used. For existing lighting
results. Increasing the number of factors included will add fidelity to
systems, assigning both a remaining life in hours and future replace100% Virgin 25% Recycled 50% Recycled 75% Recycled 100% Recycled ment value is essential in creating a fair comparison. 7.5 5.7 kWh/lb 4 kWh/lb 2.2 kWh/lb 0.44 kWh/lb kWh/lb • Consideration of lighting load on AC systems is of greater
the results, improving both fairness and accuracy.• Based on 100 fixtures, operated 3,200 hrs. per year, at an energy rate of $0.10/KWh, and 30 air conditioning weeks per year. Base fixture replacement cost amortized over 64,000 hrs. (20 years) is $85 + 1 hour installation at $65.00/hr. New LED fixture cost includes $115 per fixture + 1 hour installation at $65.00/hr. Re-lamping cost is calculated at $3.00/lamp + 0.5 hrs. at a rate of $35.00/hr.
impact in some regions than others. In climates demanding long cooling cycles, this should be included for any interior lighting system.
EXAMPLE. TOTAL ENERGY USE OVER 25,000 HRS OF OPERATION – INCLUDING MANUFACTURING COST
Initial $
Watts Load
Lamp Cost
Lamp Life
Fixture Life
Fixture Amount
Re-lamp $/Year
AC Load
Energy Cost
Total Cost
Simple Comparision
Existing
$0
7500
—
—
—
—
—
—
$2,400
$2,400
New
$18,000
1200
n/a
n/a
—
—
n/a
—
$384
$384
Equitable Comparision
Existing
$2,025*
7500
$20.5
2000
64000
$750
$3,280
950W
$2,400
$6,430
New
$18,000
1200
n/a
n/a
50000
$1,152
n/a
228W
$384
$1,536
Savings
Payback Years
$2,016
10.7
$4,894
3.3
*Assumes group re-lamp to restore system performance to 100%
TABLE 3. MERCURY INVOLVED OVER 25,000 HOURS OPERATION
www.architecturalssl.com Architectural SSL • 02.11 • 41
Incandescent
CFL Fluorescent
LED
ADVANCES
Product Introductions
Sleek and Sneaky LEDs integrated with the built environment come in the form of the Lumenatrix Backlighting System from Duo-Gard. A single, structural source provides architectural illumination. Each panel consists of a structural power rail grid system that provides low voltage to the LED lights; a unique heat sink design keeps the lights at 81 degrees. Visit www.duo-gard.com or Circle 306.
“I would encourage architects to investigate the use of LED products through qualified professionals who have some experience in the use of LEDs.”
1 Interior Options Creative Systems Lighting Eco-Downlight LED IC/ AT Adjustable Lamp allows light to be focused and positioned throughout any setting. Compliant with Energy Star and state of California high-efficiency regulations, its performance equals a 50-watt lamp using only 16 watts. Available finishes include black, white, satin aluminum and bronze. Visit www.csllighting.com or Circle 305.
2 Smooth Operator All the cheering is for Illumra’s dimmer product, named “Best Dimming or Control” at The LED Show in Las Vegas. The wireless or wired dimming device uses 65,000 dimming steps to provide ultra smooth LED dimming at all light levels. Visit www.illumra. com or Circle 304.
3 At The Track Designed for high-performance accent lighting, the MB-Led track luminaire from Intense Lighting is capable of delivering up-to 51 lumens per watt. The MB-LED is available in 650lm or 900lm. Fixtures are available in a variety of finishes. Visit www.intenselighting.com or Circle 303.
42 • 02.11 • Architectural SSL
www.architecturalssl.com
Product Introductions
ADVANCES
Get Me to the Greek The renovated Galaxy Bar at the Hilton Hotel, Athens features a fresh, innovative appearance thanks to 35 Martin Professional smartMAC gobo and color-changing moving heads. The smartMACs are controlled via LightJockey system with the DMX line. A Fingers controller allows hands-on access to LightJockey functions. Visit www.martin.com or Circle 302.
“Some owners, in the excitement of a new technology, just want LED, and it's a bit scary in making such a decision without really knowing what's involved.”
4 On the Spot Yamagiwa’s X-series High Quality LED luminaires incorporate the Xicato Spot Module, resulting in a unique combination of elegance and robustness in luminaire design. Visit www.xicato.com or Circle 301.
5 Long Division The Lighting Quotient’s concealed cove fixture developed with the company’s fraqtir optical technology, throws a clean, even and warm wash of white light in an asymmetric pattern. The luminaires feature the latest Philips Lumileds LUXEON Rebel emitters with advanced Lumiramic phosphor technology to provide crisp warm white light with greater color consistency and higher efficacy. Visit www.thelightingquotient.com or Circle 300.
6 Down in the Light enLux DL6-TC Down Light provides vivid color renderings of illuminated objects. Hues include red, amber, green and blue with custom colors within CIE 1931 chromaticity. DL6-TC Down Light is offered in superior white light in warm 2700°K, neutral 3500K or cool 4500K or any custom CCT. Visit www.enLuxLED.com or Circle 299.
www.architecturalssl.com
Architectural SSL • 02.11 • 43
ADVANCES
Product Introductions
Parking Break An LED upgrade at Tampa General Hospital employs LSI Crossover XAM 137-watt LED luminaires; the project included a 1-to-1 retrofitting of the existing metal halide site, garage, wall and canopy fixtures with LED. The retrofit provided a lower acceptable average light level while producing very uniform lighting with no shadowing or unlit parking spaces. The LED installation has reduced energy and maintenance requirements and the well-lit space will result in a 50%-plus annual savings in energy and maintenance costs, with a payback of less than three years. Visit www.lsi-industries.com or Circle 298.
“All lighting systems require periodic maintenance, upkeep and eventual replacement. For new SSL systems, service life may be used. For existing lighting systems, assigning both a remaining life in hours and future replacement value is essential in creating a fair comparison.”
1 Light Therapy Lighting designs can augment the affects of healthcare and lessen patient stress and anxiety. For that reason, Medical Lighting Systems MedFilter16 LED light source offers a unique solution to provide EMI/RF filtered power to areas where it needs to be passed though an RF-shielded wall. Visit www.medicallightingsystems.com or Circle 297.
2 The Replacements LEDtronics LED replacements for recessed T-bar fluorescent ceiling luminaires CLL2x2-400-TPW001W replace 2-ft. × 2-ft. standard fluorescent 64W units. The fixtures deliver a Color Rendering Index of 75 and a clear prismatic acrylic lens. Visit www.ledtronics.com or Circle 296.
3 Unlocked The next generation of the Lightvault (LTV71LED) from Kim Lighting are ideal for in-grade applications. The LTV71 includes a wall wash distribution option an the LTV72 is an eyeball design available in spot and narrow distributions, and a directional marker option—the LTV73, is available in 360° and 180° distribution. Visit www.kimlighting.com or Circle 295.
44 • 02.11 • Architectural SSL
www.architecturalssl.com
Product Introductions
ADVANCES
Besame Mucho A new linear pendant fixture from Besa brings a transitional style to a modern lamp source. The Besa multi-light linear cable-suspended luminaires is available with 7 different Besa glass families: Mia, Brella, Sabrina, Kani, Nico 4, Palla 5 and Tay Tay. These fixtures utilize 40W max G9 Halogen 120V lamping, and are fully dimmable with standard incandescent dimmers. Visit www.besalighting.com or Circle 294.
“In testing LED products, be aware that they take a few hours to reach actual operating temperature, while the color of LED light is different in character from conventional sources.”
4 Lunch Box An elegant but simplistic Japanese box surrounding a bottle of sake became inspiration for the Bento Sconce from Boyd Lighting. The alabaster box provides even, glare-free illumination. Visit www.boydlighting.com or Circle 293.
5 Interior Interchange Interior architectural downlights dubbed, Essentia, from BetaLED offer a variety of warm interior correlated color temperatures (CCT), a wide range of LED counts, a great lumen package and wide, medium and narrow optics including adjustable and wall-wash. Modular light engine and optics keep fixtures up to date with LED technology advances. Visit www.betaled.com or Circle 292.
6 Great Outdoors The Emco LED outdoor luminaire from Philips was designed around the LED lightsource to ensure longevity of performance. The simple, modular and sleek fixture is composed of a one-piece, die-cast aluminum and mounts to a pole with an extruded arm. The optical systems provide IES types II, III, IV and V distributions. Visit www.philips.com or Circle 291.
www.architecturalssl.com
Architectural SSL • 02.11 • 45
Ad Index
±DV§RTiS§R
∆§BSiT§
CiRCL§ ∑UµB§R
P±g§ ∑UµB§R
Beta Lighting
www.betaled.com
Circle 11
32
finelite
www.fineliteled.com
Circle 01
IFC
IALD
www.iald.org
47
Kim Lighting
www.kimlighting.com
BC
ledalite
www.ledalite.com
Circle 08
Ledtronics
www.ledtronics.com
Circle 10
lightsearch
www.lightsearch.com
lusio lighting
www.lusiolighting.com
Circle 06
12
moda lIGHT
www.modalight.com
Circle 03
04
Nora Lighting
www.noralighting.com
Circle 13
IBC
Osram Sylvania
www.sylvania.com/LED
Circle 05
09
PIA ’11 (SSL Product Innovation Awards)
www.architecturalssl.com/pia
Philips/LumiLeds
www.philipslumileds.com
Circle 09
Sternberg Vintage Lighting
www.sternberglighting.com
Circle 07
The continuing architect
www.thecontinuingarchitect.com
Tersen
www.tersenlighting.com
tyco electronics UL
14-15 27 47
39 21 13 36 Circle 12
35
www.nevalo.com/future1
Circle 02
01
www.ul.com/shine
Circle 04
06
A Closing Thought
editorial preview IN THE MAY ISSUE: We’ll take a look at SSL’s role as both an artistic and functional element of cultural facilities such as theaters and museums. Specifically, we’ll profile the dramatic use of LEDs in the new Alice Tully Hall at Lincoln Center in New York. In the Market Setting Feature Kevin Willmorth will break out his crystal ball and proffer some predictions as to the growth potential of the SSL industry on the building side. He’ll also ID major issues which need addressing for real growth to occur. Elsewhere, in our White Pages section, we’ll examine self-testing of SSL products and common errors in doing so.
46 • 02.11 • Architectural SSL
I began this issue noting that the history of Architectural SSL has been a journey, and really an ongoing education. In fact, I noted my next step was to move on to SSL “grad school.” But I wanted to add that all of you can join me in this process. Coming this Fall, we’ll conduct our fourth annual ArchLED Conference. Along with my chief advisor, Kevin Willmorth, we’ve identified the bones of the event. This year we want the sessions to provide true “take-back” information that’s going to allow attendees to directly take content from the sessions and apply it back at the office. We’ve come up with a “quadrant” of themes: color-quality, electronics, performance/metrics and standards, and we plan to address the “pain points” of each of these over-arching categories, such as flicker, CCT deviation, etc. We’ll also present case studies and bring forth other members of the team—the architect, the owner and the installers—
to talk about the issues they encountered and how they were solved. In the meantime, this Spring, we’ll be publishing our first “Products Annual” in advance of Lightfair. The special issue will feature the winners of our inaugural Product Innovations Awards and it’s our hope the publication will help shine light on products that are worth investigating. Stay tuned. Jim Crockett, Editorial Director
Feedback: questions? comments? We hope you found this edition of Architectural SSL insightful. We would love to hear from you about the features included in this installment and we welcome your suggestions for changes, improvements or additions. What would you like to see in future issues and how can we best help you do your job? Email your thoughts to: jimc@architecturalssl.com
www.architecturalssl.com
ANOTHER PERSON’S DARK SPACE IS OUR BLANK CANVAS. AN IALD PROFESSIONAL LIGHTING DESIGNER SEES THE POSSIBILITIES IN EVERY ENVIRONMENT. LEARN HOW AN IALD LIGHTING DESIGNER CAN TURN YOUR VISION INTO REALITY. VISIT IALD.ORG AND CLICK ON "FIND A LIGHTING DESIGNER" TO REFINE YOUR SEARCH.
PUBLIC PASSAGE | MUNICH, GERMANY | LIGHTING DESIGN, PFARRÉ LIGHTING DESIGN | © ANDREAS J. FOCKE
Search at the Speed of Light
Imagine having access to a database with over 5,500 Lighting Manufacturers and 11,000 Product Categories at your fingertips! Lightsearch is a FREE online resource with query options designed by professional specifiers.
It works the way you think
SSL_4_2007_Ver1.indd 1
4/16/07 9:25:12 PM
SSLObserved:
By Kevin Willmorth
The Best Thing About SSL:
Good Light Sources Go Unnoticed The worst comment I can get is “Ooh, that’s LED lighting, isn’t it?” Good lighting is good lighting. The technology should not be a topic of discussion, except between us SSL nerds. I’d rather hear nothing at all.
is just painful. So, as long as I hear about the
blown around the room where it’s wasted. In
results of this circus act, I’ll share them.
other words, my stubborn insistence on applying
SSL from a qualitative perspective has resulted
This is not a good thing, but what is good,
at least in my opinion, is when SSL is virtually
in significant energy savings. This is the magic
invisible. In other words, when properly applied,
of this technology I often rant on about in this
the fact that it’s a semi-conductor technology
publication, on the web and when trapping
is completely irrelevant. To me, the worst com-
people in corners of conference snack breaks.
ment I can get is “Ooh, that’s LED lighting, isn’t
it?” Good lighting is good lighting. The technol-
was invisible has not been easy, or cheap. My
Getting to the point where the technology
ogy should not be a topic of discussion, except
first experiences with retrofit lamps support
I’ve heard more than a few disparaging remarks
between us SSL nerds. I’d rather hear nothing at
the negative impressions we have all heard. The
about LED products by end users and end-use
all, or maybe “This is a pretty space, I really like
first round of LED MR16s were a complete joke,
customers. Color and light harshness are two
the lighting.”
even though they came from a highly respected
of the most common, with bad dimmer behav-
brand. They kind of dribbled a weak impression
ior, and, of course, cost, frequent comments. In
dominated by LEDs. Yes, I do have some retrofit
of light into the room, then faded as time passed.
virtually every instance, the products producing
lamps—a couple of aging PAR20 and PAR30
Three rounds later, I can say the lamps I now
the most negative remarks are retrofit lamps
lamps, a half dozen MR16 lamps, and few down-
have in place produce light that is near enough to
purchased at a discount store from an off brand.
light retrofits. These have all been modified to
the original 20-watt NFL MR16s in light pattern,
I have several of the offending products in a box,
correct their shortcomings, primarily to control
brightness and color—so much so that I no longer
sent or handed to me after being removed from
glare. Otherwise, the majority of LED products
wish to return to the old resister lamps. I have
service. These comments include confrontation
around me are of my own creation, using AC and
a powder room that has been through a couple
at a recent American Council for an Energy-Effi-
DC LED products from all over the SSL roadmap.
rounds of fixture designs, evolving from wimpy
cient Economy conference, where an industry
After five years under LEDs, the best single
grey light to what is now a very nice reading
expert, I will call her “The Heckler,” stated that
thing I can say about SSL is that I can’t tell
environment. Room by room, work surface by
she had several LED lamps in her own home,
anymore they are what they are. They just work
work surface, the evolution has been remarkable.
and hated them. As if to prove her super-human
really well, and I find the light very easy to work
Today, I can truly say that with a little care, one
insanity, she followed by stating she preferred
under and live with.
can actually realize an improvement in lighting
CFLs to the LEDs, because the LEDs were too
quality, with a significant reduction in energy con-
harsh, too blue and too glary in comparison.
constant focus on lumens per watt comedic.
sumption, using a light source that works without
With virtually every light around me, I have no
being the center of conversation and comment.
ments aside as the ranting of individuals so
clue how efficient the fixtures or light sources
That is what I like best about SSL. Not having to
focused on low-low prices, they got what they
are. What I do know is I replaced products
reveal how much this trek has cost is what I like
paid for. In fact I still struggle with a reason
that housed 20- to 150-watt sources with 4- to
about word limits to articles, so that will have to
why anyone would want something still in an
24-watt sources. Adding it all up, I calculate a cut
Edison socket—the concept of screwing the
in energy connected by at least 70%, even when
be the topic of another...•
coolest technology to hit lighting into sockets
I include the addition of portable accents for
fashioned after the neck of a kerosene tin is
effect. My focus in every application, has been on
beyond me. Yet, watching customers get bilked
using SSL to create nicer lighting, more comfort,
by marketing clowns passing off geek product
good color, greater task visibility and less light
I could chose to set most of these com-
48 • 02.11 • Architectural SSL
My home and work environment are
Looking around, I can’t help but find the
about the author:
Kevin Willmorth, a lighting expert and fixture designer, has been instrumental in helping create a vision and mission statement for Architectural SSL.
www.architecturalssl.com
7 YEAR
LIMITED WARRANTY
Diamond Ser ies
LED Retrofit
OutShining thE cOmpEtitiOn Convert medium based incandescent sources to energy efficient LED and save up to 75% energy. Nora Lighting’s LED Retrofit Diamond Series for new construction, remodel and existing 5” and 6” housings produces 650 lumens while utilizing a mere 11.8W and offers smooth dimming down to 5%. Available in baffle and reflector styles in seven finishes. Best of all, this cULus and Energy Star listed unit is backed by a 7-year
TEL. 800.686.6672
NORALIGHTING.COM Circle 13
limited warranty.
20 YEARS
OF EXCELLENCE ILLUMINATING THE FUTURE
THE ARCHETYPE 速 LED this is leD site lighting Perfection. this is Kim lighting.
Glare, no. Brilliant, yes.
www.kimlighting.com