Dream Homes of Shelter Island

D R E A M H O M ES O F S H E LT E R I S L A N D PART II

danielgale.com

Shelter Island Office • 631.749.1155 • 17 Grand Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965

Each office is independently owned and operated. We are pledged to provide equal opportunity for housing to any prospective customer or client, without regard to race, color, religion, sex, handicap, familial status or national origin.

danielgale.com

Shelter Island, NY Grand 1883 waterfront. Classically Modern, stunning views to Connecticut. The 4-floor turn-key house was fully restored in 2010. Features panoramic views of Shelter Island Sound throughout, elegant formal entertaining rooms, 7 bedrooms, 8 baths (several en suite) chef’s kitchen, covered porch, spectacular 50 ft. St. Barth’s pool, original floors and mantle pieces, mint condition. SD #1. MLS# 2808875. $8,995,000.

Susan C. Cincotta, 631.749.1155, c.631.514.9891, susancincotta@danielgale.com

Shelter Island, NY This exquisite waterfront Estate was a home built in 1888 that had been renovated and expanded in 2007. This home is situated on 1.7 acres on Dering Harbor with a private dock. This grand Estate boasts a 4-car garage, home theatre, wine cellar, 6-bedroom en suites and additional 4 powder rooms, and a teak bar with nautical flair. SD #1. MLS# P1254259. $7,950,000.

Debra Von Brook Binder, 631.749,1155, c.631.872.2889, debrabinder@danielgale.com

Shelter Island Office • 631.749.1155 • 17 Grand Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965

Each office is independently owned and operated. We are pledged to provide equal opportunity for housing to any prospective customer or client, without regard to race, color, religion, sex, handicap, familial status or national origin.

danielgale.com

Shelter Island, NY Masterful elegance is reflected in the Peter Pennoyer designed waterfront property. After a day spent on the water, tie up at your private dock and sip cocktails on the 2-story veranda. SD #1. MLS# 2853950. $5,395,000.

Carol Tintle, 631.749.1155, c.631.335.9003, caroltintle@danielgale.com Wayne Marciano, 631.692.6770, c.516.987.1500, waynemarciano@danielgale.com

Shelter Island, NY Beautiful sunsets from this water view compound. The main 3+ en suite bedroom shingle traditional with pool is landscaped with mature plantings. There is also sandy beachfront property and an adjacent with lot that make up this move in ready bucolic retreat with many high end extras including waterside roof gazebo, den and additional parlor. SD #1. MLS# 2685460. $2,349,000.

Susan C. Cincotta, 631.749.1155, c.631.514.9891, susancincotta@danielgale.com

Shelter Island Office • 631.749.1155 • 17 Grand Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965

Each office is independently owned and operated. We are pledged to provide equal opportunity for housing to any prospective customer or client, without regard to race, color, religion, sex, handicap, familial status or national origin.

danielgale.com

Shelter Island, NY An artists dream. This home is surrounded by 5.5 acres of gardens, pond and nature. Stunningly redone infinity heated pool and hot tub, high on the bluff overlooking it all. SD #1. MLS# 2834976. $1,850,000.

Linda McCarthy, 631.749.1155, c.631.745.2626, lindamccarthy@danielgale.com

Shelter Island, NY Renovated Menantic Creek front home with 180 ft. deep-water dock. This home offers furnished open living space with sprawling water views, 2 bedrooms, situated on 1+ acres with separate studio/office and gunite heated pool. Your perfect island retreat.

SD #1. MLS# 2857104. $1,838,000.

Debra Von Brook Binder, 631.749,1155, c.631.872.2889, debrabinder@danielgale.com

Shelter Island Office • 631.749.1155 • 17 Grand Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965

Each office is independently owned and operated. We are pledged to provide equal opportunity for housing to any prospective customer or client, without regard to race, color, religion, sex, handicap, familial status or national origin.

danielgale.com

Sag Harbor, NY At the water’s edge of Mill Creek, this well-kept waterfront beach house has great sunset water views of the preserved creek and Noyac Bay. Open floor plan with fireplace and wood stove, 3 bedrooms, 2 baths, waterside decks, bulkhead, garage and great location; a stone’s throw from Circle Beach. SD #5. MLS# 2856409. $1,599,000.

Susan C. Cincotta, 631.749.1155, c.631.514.9891, susancincotta@danielgale.com

Shelter Island, NY This lovely new built home offers 3,800 sq. ft. with an open floor plan. This 4-bedroom, 3.5-bath home offers 2 fireplaces, chef’s kitchen with stainless steel appliances and wood floors throughout. The backyard offers a fireplace for ambiance and those cold fall evenings, in addition, a gunite heated pool with waterfall and cabana with expansive patios. Great home for entertaining.

SD #1. MLS# 2857107. $1,590,000.

Debra Von Brook Binder, 631.749,1155, c.631.872.2889, debrabinder@danielgale.com

Shelter Island Office • 631.749.1155 • 17 Grand Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965

Each office is independently owned and operated. We are pledged to provide equal opportunity for housing to any prospective customer or client, without regard to race, color, religion, sex, handicap, familial status or national origin.

danielgale.com

Shelter Island, NY Unique Ralph Kast waterfront home with dock, waterside pool and patio. Close to the heights shops and restaurants. Water view in the master bedroom en suite plus 3 guest bedrooms, 3.5 baths, 9 skylights and varied decks for entertaining. A magnificent creek front setting. SD #1. MLS# 2857365. $1,482,000.

Linda McCarthy, 631.749.1155, c.631.745.2626, lindamccarthy@danielgale.com

Shelter Island, NY Waterfront Modern at water’s edge with dock, waterside wrap around dining deck, pergola and 2nd floor verandas in private bucolic setting. Quiet and across from large waterfront preserve. Spacious, stylish and recently renovated, Italian custom cabinetry, open kitchen, dining room and living room have doors to deck and dining al fresco. 2 roomy dens, gym, man cave/shop, new roof and skylights in 2014. SD #1. MLS# 2845047. $1,475,000.

Susan C. Cincotta, 631.749.1155, c.631.514.9891, susancincotta@danielgale.com

Shelter Island Office • 631.749.1155 • 17 Grand Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965

Each office is independently owned and operated. We are pledged to provide equal opportunity for housing to any prospective customer or client, without regard to race, color, religion, sex, handicap, familial status or national origin.

danielgale.com

Shelter Island, NY Waterfront, protected dock with easy access to open water and gunite pool with surround deck accompanies this spacious 5-bedroom, 3.5-bath island home. In the Silver Beach area of Shelter Island, the open living plan with fireplace, stainless and granite kitchen and finished basement with gym and media room provide comfort and space for summer fun and year-round living. SD #1. MLS# 2867839. $1,299,000.

Linda McCarthy, 631.749.1155, c.631.745.2626, lindamccarthy@danielgale.com

Shelter Island, NY Charming 1866 Shorewood Farmhouse on .72 acres. Facing south and perfectly situated overlooking gracious yard and fenced in garden. Wood shingled roof and painted shingle siding help to maintain the unique and authentic feel of this beauty. Lovely first floor flows nicely with 2 staircases that lead to 5 bedrooms and 2 full baths. SD #1. MLS# 2860446. $1,175,000.

Margaret Colligan, 631.749.1155, c.516.816.6190, margaretcolligan@danielgale.com

Shelter Island Office • 631.749.1155 • 17 Grand Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965

Each office is independently owned and operated. We are pledged to provide equal opportunity for housing to any prospective customer or client, without regard to race, color, religion, sex, handicap, familial status or national origin.

danielgale.com

Shelter Island, NY Stone’s throw from lake, down the street from public beach. Secret garden hideaway on a level hill top acre+ with mature gardens, gazebo, wrap around dining deck, fenced, private, heated, slate surround gunite pool + lawn to play on. The two owner’s suites, sole upstairs and main floor also boats 2 additional guest rooms, finished den on lower level with walk out 2-car garage. SD #1.

MLS# 2770167. $1,075,000.

Susan C. Cincotta, 631.749.1155, c.631.514.9891, susancincotta@danielgale.com

Shelter Island, NY On 1 beautiful rolling acre with pond and creek views, this 3-bedroom, 2-bath home has lovely extras including a new chef’s kitchen with center island, stainless appliances, formal dining room, living room with sliders to a spacious waterside deck, master bedroom with private bath, gas fireplace and hot tub room, custom fenced garden, plus a finished basement and game room with wood stove.

A must see. SD #1. MLS# 2834805. $899,000.

Linda McCarthy, 631.749.1155, c.631.745.2626, lindamccarthy@danielgale.com

Shelter Island Office • 631.749.1155 • 17 Grand Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965

Each office is independently owned and operated. We are pledged to provide equal opportunity for housing to any prospective customer or client, without regard to race, color, religion, sex, handicap, familial status or national origin.

danielgale.com

Shelter Island, NY Surprising, Frank Lloyd Wright-inspired Contemporary in private community with deeded beach and mooring rights. Spacious light-filled open living area, well-crafted unique architectural features, living room with fireplace, 3 bedrooms, living room/den, 2.5 baths, master bedroom suite with sliding glass doors to enclosed mahogany patio, in-ground heated pool with landscaped brick poolside deck. SD #1.

MLS# 2866736. $875,000.

Linda McCarthy, 631.749.1155, c.631.745.2626, lindamccarthy@danielgale.com

Shelter Island, NY This is the ideal location near Crescent Beach. Home has finished lower level, 2-car garage, formal dining room, eat-in kitchen, living room with vaulted ceilings, fireplace, central air conditioning, extensive landscaping stonework, covered front porch, outdoor hot tub, and back yard decking. Master has full bath with tub and shower with 2 large closets. There is room for a pool.

SD #1. MLS# 2797432. $840,000.

Linda McCarthy, 631.749.1155, c.631.745.2626, lindamccarthy@danielgale.com

Shelter Island Office • 631.749.1155 • 17 Grand Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965

Each office is independently owned and operated. We are pledged to provide equal opportunity for housing to any prospective customer or client, without regard to race, color, religion, sex, handicap, familial status or national origin.

danielgale.com

Shelter Island, NY This lovely Contemporary-style home is situated on 1.2 acres of rolling wooded property including a reserve. This home offers three levels of living space and brings nature in through the walls of windows. Lovely decks on the 1st and 2nd level expand the living space outdoors. Beautiful cherry floors throughout make this a wonderful home for seasonal or year round. SD #1. MLS# 2814576. $825,000.

Debra Von Brook Binder, 631.749,1155, c.631.872.2889, debrabinder@danielgale.com

Shelter Island, NY This South Ferry Hills beach home is situated on a corner lot on .44 acres. This home offers open plan living with vaulted ceilings, wood burning fireplace and sun filled rooms. This home is wonderful for a summer retreat or year round living. The association includes a beach on smith cove and is available for swimming and picnicking. Boat slips may also be available. SD #1.

MLS# 2866753. $675,000.

Debra Von Brook-Binder, 631.749.1155, c.631.872.2889, debrabinder@danielgale.com

Shelter Island Office • 631.749.1155 • 17 Grand Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965

Each office is independently owned and operated. We are pledged to provide equal opportunity for housing to any prospective customer or client, without regard to race, color, religion, sex, handicap, familial status or national origin.

INTRODUCING THE NEW

DANIELGALE.COM Data Driven with Style You can find out what your home could be worth, and how many real buyers are out there with just a few clicks on the NEW danielgale.com.

All Offices Are Individually Owned And Operated.

Shelter Islands Premier Real Estate Agents

Susan Cincotta, CBR, RSSP Associate Real Estate Broker c.631.514.9891 susancincotta@danielgale.com

Margaret Colligan, CBR Real Estate Salesperson c.516.816.6190 margaretcolligan@danielgale.com

Donald Dunning Real Estate Salesperson c.516.369.5380 donalddunning@danielgale.com

Linda McCarthy Real Estate Salesperson c.631.745.2626 lindamccarthy@danielgale.com

Robert Mullins Real Estate Salesperson c.631.276.2930 robertmullins@danielgale.com

Allison Mehan Real Estate Salesperson c.631.434.5386 allisonmehan@danielgale.com

Carol Szynaka Associate Real Estate Broker c.917.640.2622 Carolszynaka@danielgale.com

Carol Tintle Associate Real Estate Broker c.631.335.9003 caroltintle@danielgale.com

Debra Von Brook-Binder, CBR Real Estate Salesperson c.631.872.2889 debrabinder@danielgale.com

Shelter Island Office • 631.749.1155 • 17 Grand Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965

Shelter Island Office • 631.749.1155 • 17 Grand Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965

Each office is independently owned and operated. We are pledged to provide equal opportunity for housing to any prospective customer or client, without regard to race, color, religion, sex, handicap, familial status or national origin.

Each office is independently owned and operated. We are pledged to provide equal opportunity for housing to any prospective customer or client, without regard to race, color, religion, sex, handicap, familial status or national origin.