Downtown Denver Summer 2012 Pedestrian Count Report Funded by the Downtown Denver Business Improvement District
Downtown Denver Partnership, Inc.
Research Department Research Department • 511 16th Street, Suite 200, Denver, CO 80202 • 303-534-6161 • www.DowntownDenver.com
INTRODUCTION Since 1994, the Downtown Denver Business Improvement District (BID) has funded two pedestrian counts in Downtown Denver each year. The BID conducts a comprehensive count in the summer and a partial count in the winter. This report summarizes data collected during the summer of 2012. Pedestrian counts allow Downtown Denver stakeholders to: Measure pedestrian traffic for prospective Downtown Denver retailers, developers and businesses. Determine the impact of new development. Predict or measure success of a Downtown Denver event. Help determine priority areas for streetscape and amenity projects. Locate areas where increased police presence and cleaning services may be needed. METHODOLOGY Timeframe The 2012 summer pedestrian counts took place from June 19 to August 16 . th
th
Process The BID hired individuals to count pedestrians as they passed a specific spot located in the middle of the block on one side of the street. Counters used automatic, handheld tally counters to count pedestrians on both weekdays and weekends during the middle of the day (11:30am-1:30pm) and the evening (5:00pm-7:00pm). BID staff entered and analyzed data collected by counters. From these two hour counts, BID staff used a tool developed by the National Bicycle and Pedestrian Documentation Project to estimate daily, weekly, monthly and annual pedestrian counts. For more information on this extrapolation process, please see appendix B. Weather Weather can have an impact on both pedestrian activity and the ability to conduct pedestrian counts. Occasionally, the BID needs to reschedule counts due to severe weather and counters record weather conditions as they count pedestrians. Weather conditions during the summer 2012 pedestrian counts were favorable, with average temperatures and minimal precipitation. The average mean temperature for the 20 days the counts took place was 75°. The high temperature recorded during the count time period was 89°, a little higher than the historical average of 83°. The low temperature recorded during the count time period was 60°, also higher than the historical average of 54°. During the 20 days counting occurred, only 0.37 inches of precipitation fell in Denver, with only two of these days having more than a trace of precipitation. External Influences and Limitations In addition to weather, a variety of other outside factors can influence pedestrian counts, including special events, conferences and/or construction. Pedestrian counters record any obvious outside influences throughout their shifts that may impact pedestrian activity and the BID takes these notes into account during data analysis. However, it is not possible to control for all external influences and thus year-to-year variation in counts is expected. Additionally, counts are subject to potential human and equipment errors. The BID carefully manages the pedestrian count process in order to minimize potential errors and is confident in the count’s results.
1
Count site selection: Pedestrian counts occur at core sites, zone sites and timely sites. The BID counts pedestrian activity at 12 core sites at least once a year on both weekends and weekdays. Core sites are included in every summer count and are given priority consideration for off-season counts. The Pedestrian Count Program selected the following core sites based on historical counts and the vision set forth by the 2007 Downtown Area Plan: 16th 16th 16th 16th 16th 16th
between Tremont and Glenarm between Glenarm and Welton between Welton and California between California and Stout between Lawrence and Larimer between Blake and Wazee
14th between California and Stout 14th between Arapahoe and Lawrence Wazee between 16th and 17th Larimer between 14th and 15th Arapahoe between 16th and 17th California between 15th and 16th
In addition to these core sites, pedestrian counts take place in a certain zone that covers a quarter of the blocks in the BID. With the goal of measuring pedestrian activity on every block in the BID, the Pedestrian Count Program developed a rotating zone program in 2011. The 120 blocks within the BID’s boundaries belong to one of four zones, with pedestrian counts occurring in one zone every four years. The map on this page shows the four zones within the BID. In the summer of 2012, pedestrian counts occurred throughout Zone B. Zone B includes the Denver Performing Arts Complex, the Convention Center Complex and many of Downtown Denver’s major hotels. In addition to core and zone sites, the BID counts pedestrians at various timely sites based on special requests, proposed investment or development, sporting or other events, or unique conditions.
Pedestrian Count Four Year Zone Plan
2
WEEKDAY MID-DAY ACTIVITY The following map shows the total number of pedestrians counted on weekdays between the hours of 11:30am and 1:30pm. As the color-coded ovals show, the BID recorded high pedestrian activity along the 16th Street Mall, especially between Stout and Tremont.
3
WEEKDAY EVENING ACTIVITY While the BID recorded high pedestrian activity between 5:00pm and 7:00pm along the 16th Street Mall, activity was lower than during the middle of the day. However, there was more pedestrian activity around the Theater District, Larimer Square, and various blocks adjacent to the 16th Street Mall during the evening.
4
WEEKEND MID-DAY ACTIVITY During the weekend between 11:30am and 1:30pm, pedestrian activity was highest on the 16th Street Mall and near the Colorado Convention Center.
WEWAT TA ST
T WEWAT TA S DENVER UNION STATION
WYNKOOP ST
Pedestrian Count Weekend, Mid-day
COORS FIELD
BLAKE ST MARKET STREET STATION
18TH ST
WAZEE ST
5000+ 2500-4999 1000-2499 500-999 0-499
15TH ST
LARIMER ST
604
CURTIS ST
20TH ST
LAWRENCE ST SKYLINE PARK ARAPAHOE ST
19TH ST
TH TH MALL STST MALL 1616
17TH ST
13TH ST
2165
DENVER PERFORMING ARTS COMPLEX
22ND ST
MARKET ST
21ST ST
14TH ST
1852
CHAMPA ST
STOUT ST
R BLV
D
COLORADO CONVENTION CENTER
CALIFORNIA ST
2702 W
SPEE
WELTON ST
GO PA
ST
GLENARM PL
GA
3726
EK TR
AIL
RTD LIGHT RAIL
5466
LA
TREMONT PL
B
A RO
AY W D
GLENARM
TREMONT
CLEVELAND PL
E AV
DE
TH
13
LA W AR
W
E
COURT PL
ST
T
TI LA
ES
FO X
ST
RY CR E CHER
CALI
RTD CIVIC CENTER
E
5
CIVIC CENTER
WEEKEND EVENING ACTIVITY The BID recorded higher pedestrian activity on weekend evenings than during the day at all but one of the count sites. Between the hours of 5:00pm and 7:00pm, the highest pedestrian activity was along the 16th Street Mall. WEWAT TA ST
T WEWAT TA S DENVER UNION STATION
WYNKOOP ST
Pedestrian Count Weekday, Evening
COORS FIELD
BLAKE ST MARKET STREET STATION
18TH ST
WAZEE ST
5000+ 2500-4999 1000-2499 500-999 0-499
LARIMER ST
19TH ST
TH TH MALL STST 1616 MALL
17TH ST
13TH ST DENVER PERFORMING ARTS COMPLEX
LAWRENCE ST SKYLINE PARK ARAPAHOE ST CURTIS ST
20TH ST
3463 4466
22ND ST
MARKET ST
21ST ST
1687
15TH ST
14TH ST
2790
CHAMPA ST
STOUT ST
SPEE R BLV D
COLORADO CONVENTION CENTER
CALIFORNIA ST
5586 WELT
WELTON ST O AG P A
ST
GLENARM PL
4685
G
EK TR
AIL
RTD LIGHT RAIL
5422
AL
TREMONT PL
B
A RO
AY DW
GLENARM PL
TREMONT PL
CLEVELAND PL
E AV
DE
0 E2
TH 13
LA W AR
W
E
COURT PL
ST T
TI LA
ES
FO X
ST
RY CR E CHER
CALIFOR
CIVIC
E
RTD CIVIC CENTER
6
ADDITIONAL ANALYSIS 16th Street Mall As the main pedestrian thoroughfare in the BID, measuring pedestrian activity on the 16th Street Mall is a major goal of the Pedestrian Count Program. Count sites along the 16th Street Mall have the highest pedestrian traffic. In fact, the top ten highest counts were all on the 16th Street Mall. Using the NBPD extrapolation model, the BID is able to estimate daily, weekly, monthly and yearly activity on the 16th Street Mall. Our research estimates that the average yearly pedestrian activity for a block on the 16th Street Mall ranges from a low of 6,594,694 pedestrians to a high of 15,625,601 pedestrians. Location 16th between Blake & Wazee 16th between Lawrence & Larimer 16th between Lawrence & Arapahoe 16th between California & Stout 16th between Welton & California 16th between Glenarm & Welton 16th between Tremont & Glenarm 16TH STREET MALL AVERAGE*
Mid-day Count 2,732 3,463 4,466 5,788 5,825 6,276 6,121 4,953
Evening Count 1,877 2,708 3,559 4,073 4,313 4,620 3,773 3,560
Est. Daily Activity* 16,003 21,518 28,000 34,266 35,287 37,918 34,233 29,604
Est. Monthly Activity* 527,576 709,384 1,000,011 1,129,636 1,163,309 1,250,048 1,128,570 986,933
Est. Yearly Activity* 6,594,694 8,867,295 12,500,140 14,120,450 14,541,359 15,625,601 14,107,121 12,336,666
*numbers derived from the average between extrapolation based on mid-day count and extrapolation based on evening count
Special Events The BID counted pedestrian activity on the 16th Street Mall during a special event, Make Music Denver, in June 2012. Make Music Denver resulted in a 23% increase in pedestrian activity on 16th Street between California and Welton between 11:30am and 1:30pm and a 20% increase between 5:00pm and 7:00pm.
7
High Traffic Locations in Zone B During mid-day, almost all of the locations with the highest pedestrian traffic in Zone B were along the 16th Street Mall on both weekdays and Saturdays. During the evening, traffic was also high on the 16th Street Mall, but counts showed high evening traffic on Larimer between 14th and 15th on both the weekdays and Saturdays. Mid-Day - Highest Traffic Locations in Zone B Location
Day
Evening - Highest Traffic Locations in Zone B
Count
Location
Day
Count
16th btw. Glenarm and Welton
Weekday 6,276
16th btw. Glenarm and Welton
Saturday 5,422
16th btw. Tremont and Glenarm
Weekday 6,121
16th btw. Tremont and Glenarm
Saturday 4,685
16th btw. Welton and California
Weekday 5,825
16th btw. Glenarm and Welton
Weekday 4,620
16th btw. California and Stout
Weekday 5,788
16th btw. Welton and California
Weekday 4,313
16th btw. Glenarm and Welton
Saturday 5,466
16th btw. California and Stout
Weekday 4,073
16th btw. Lawrence and Arapahoe Weekday 4,466
16th btw. Tremont and Glenarm
Weekday 3,773
16th btw. Tremont and Glenarm
Saturday 3,726
16th btw. Lawrence and Arapahoe Weekday 3,559
16th btw. Lawrence and Larimer
Weekday 3,463
16th btw. Lawrence and Larimer
Weekday 2,708
14th btw. Welton and California
Saturday 2,702
Larimer btw. 14th and 15th
Weekday 1,991
16th btw. Lawrence and Larimer
Saturday 2,165
Larimer btw. 14th and 15th
Saturday 1,687
CONCLUSION Outlook for 2013 In 2013, the BID will count pedestrians throughout the LoDo and Union Station areas of Zone C. This count will provide important baseline data for the Union Station area before the renovated transit hub reopens in 2014. Acknowledgments The Downtown Denver Business Improvement District thanks the Summer 2012 pedestrian counters who spent hours counting pedestrians around Downtown Denver. The BID also thanks the National Bicycle and Pedestrian Documentation Project and Alta Planning and Design for providing a model for pedestrian extrapolations. About this Report The Summer Pedestrian Count report is created by the Downtown Denver Research Department. Staff contributors and editors include: Emily Brett, Aylene McCallum and John Desmond. Please direct any questions about this report to Emily Brett at ebrett@downtowndenver.com or 303-571-8216. Pedestrian count sheets and counter instructions are available upon request.
8
APPENDIX A: FULL RESULTS Graph of All Full Counts (does not include counts on only one side of the street)
9
Table of Full Results from Summer 2012 BID Pedestrian Count (WEEKDAY COUNTS) Location
Mid-Day Count
Evening Count
Location
Mid-Day Count
Evening Count
12th bet Welton & Glenarm
67*
36*
16th between Welton & California 5,825
4,313
13th between Arapahoe & Lawrence
168*
133*
Arapahoe between 13th & 14th
269
121
13th between Glenarm & Tremont
102
64
Arapahoe between 14th & 15th
544
583
13th between Welton & Glenarm
306
163
Arapahoe between 15th & 16th
108*
312
14th between Arapahoe & Curtis
567
784
Arapahoe between 16th & 17th
873
653
14th between Arapahoe & Lawrence
517
644
California between 14th & 15th
368
531
14th between California & Stout
513
927
California between 15th & 16th
1,489
1,592
14th between Champa & Stout
774
656
Champa between 12th & 13th
83*
103
14th between Curtis & Champa
545
826
Champa between 14th & 15th
374
272
14th between Glenarm & Tremont
442
239
Champa between 15th & 16th
1,538
635
14th between Larimer & Lawrence
838
514
Court between 14th & 15th
221*
165*
14th between Tremont & Court
158
308
Court between 15th & 16th
817*
757
14th between Welton & California
262
370
Curtis between 14th & 15th
620
1,092
14th between Welton & Glenarm
546
474
Curtis between 15th & 16th
980
1,147
15th between Arapahoe & Curtis
511
524
Glenarm between 12th & 13th
237
118
15th between California & Welton
598
577
Glenarm between 13th & 14th
500
282
15th between Champa & Curtis
630
667
Glenarm between 14th & 15th
619
475
15th between Champa & Stout
558
553
Glenarm between 15th & 16th
833
1,270
15th between Glenarm & Tremont
381
308
Larimer between 14th & 15th
1,592
1,991
15th between Larimer & Lawrence
584
554
Larimer between 14th & 15th
604
1,687
15th between Lawrence & Arapahoe
513
543
Lawrence between 13th & 14th
241*
140*
15th between Stout & California
472
556
Lawrence between 14th & 15th
371
299
15th between Tremont & Court
381
268
Lawrence between 15th & 16th
719
559
15th between Welton & Glenarm
413
408
Market between 14th & 15th
822*
728*
16th between Arapahoe & Curtis
2,149*
1,432*
Stout between 14th & 15th
432
433
16th between Blake & Wazee
2,732
1,877
Stout between 15th & 16th
978
947
16th between California & Stout
5,788
4,073
Tremont between 13th & 14th
292
103
16th between Champa & Stout
2,255*
1,585*
Tremont between 14th & 15th
499
391
16th between Curtis & Champa
1,482*
1,992*
Tremont between 15th & 16th
311*
1,135
16th between Glenarm & Welton
6,276
4,620
Wazee between 16th & 17th
218*
829
16th between Lawrence & Arapahoe
4,466
3,559
Welton between 12th & 13th
224
180
16th between Lawrence & Larimer
3,463
2,708
Welton between 13th & 14th
223
201
16th between Tremont & Court
2,257*
1,762*
Welton between 14th & 15th
292
348
16th between Tremont & Glenarm
6,121
3,773
Welton between 15th & 16th
770
757
*Denotes partial count (only reflects count from one side of the street instead of both sides of the street)
10
Table of Full Results from Summer 2012 BID Pedestrian Count (SATURDAY COUNTS) Location
Mid-Day Count
Evening Count
14th between Curtis & Champa
311*
236*
14th between Welton & California
2,702
205*
16th between California & Stout
3,184*
3,009*
16th between Glenarm & Welton
5,466
5,422
16th between Lawrence & Larimer
2,165
1520*
16th between Market & Blake
1,852
2,790
16th between Tremont & Glenarm
3,726
4,685
16th between Welton & California
2,746*
5,568
Arapahoe between 16th & 17th
294
345
Larimer between 15th & 16th
691
853
*Denotes partial count (only reflects count from one side of the street instead of both sides of the street)
11
APPENDIX B: EXPLANATION OF NBPD EXTRAPOLATION PROCESS The National Bicycle and Pedestrian Documentation Project, along with Alta Planning and Design and the Institute of Transportation Engineers, developed a tool to estimate daily, weekly, monthly, and annual pedestrian activity from 2-hour pedestrian counts. This model takes into account the time of day, day of the week, climate, and type of pedestrian environment. Extrapolated numbers are based on the following adjustments. Contact DDP or visit bikepeddocumentation.org for more information. Table 1: Hourly Adjustments Model assumes 95% of pedestrian traffic occurs between 6am and 10pm; Downtown is considered a “PED District” APR-SEP OCT-MAR PED District PED District wkdy wkend wkdy wkend Hour % of ped traffic % of ped traffic
Table 2: Daily Adjustments Day % of weekly ped traffic SUN
18%
MON
14%
TUES
13%
WED
12%
600
1%
1%
1%
0%
THURS
12%
700
2%
1%
2%
1%
FRI
14%
800
4%
3%
3%
2%
SAT
18%
900
5%
3%
5%
4%
1000
6%
5%
6%
5%
1100
7%
6%
8%
8%
1200
9%
7%
9%
10%
Table 3: Monthly Adjustments (based on climate) % of yearly ped month traffic JAN 7%
1300
9%
7%
10%
13%
FEB
7%
1400
8%
9%
9%
11%
MAR
8%
1500
8%
9%
8%
8%
APR
8%
1600
7%
9%
7%
7%
MAY
8%
1700
7%
8%
6%
6%
JUN
8%
1800
7%
8%
7%
6%
JUL
12%
1900
7%
8%
7%
6%
AUG
16%
2000
7%
8%
6%
6%
SEP
8%
2100
6%
8%
5%
5%
OCT
6%
NOV
6%
DEC
6%
12