Does your feedback feed forward? Eddy White, Ph.D.
2
Feedback on law student essay -Univ. of Bergen, Norway
“Nonsense, rubbish, disastrous! This leads nowhere. It is only your minimal knowledge that prevents me from giving you an F�.
(Raaheim, 2008)
3
Targets • Feedback background • My feedback research • Your feedback practices
4
Targets Feedback background
5
What is feedback? (Wiggins, 2004)
• Feedback is information about what was and was not accomplished, given a specific goal.
Feedback: summative vs formative • Summative feedback is a summary of students final output or performance, includes a grade or score
Focus --->
• It may help shape the next performance or process, but it is too late to play a part on the task being evaluated
6
• Formative feedback response to student work, while it is in progress • - identifies strong and weak aspects of performance, gives suggestions for improvement • - plays a part in ‘forming’ or shaping student response to the task being worked on • - aims to draw out students’ best possible performance
7
8
Targets
Your feedback practices
Some key feedback questions 1. What do we say to students about their work? 2. How do we say it? 3. Do they take any notice? 4. How much does it help their learning payoff? 5. How well does it relate to students’ evidence of achievement of the intended learning outcomes? 6. How efficient is it for us?
9
10
Assessment methods in your courses?
11
What formative feedback practices do you use in your courses?
12
Targets Feedback background
13
Feedback: student dissatisfaction
14
Feedback: Student dissatisfaction • The literature shows students are dissatisfied with feedback in terms of: 1. Lacking specific advice to improve 2. Being difficult to interpret 3. Having a negative impact on selfperception and confidence (Carless, 2006)
15
Quality feedback
16
Quality feedbacK:4 Criteria • 1. It must be timely • 2. It must be specific • 3. It must be understandable to the receiver • 4. It must allow the student to act on the feedback (refine, revise, practice and retry) (Wiggins, 1998)
• “Feedback is
like fish . . . . . . it goes off after a week.”
18
Sadler (1989) • Sadler identified three conditions necessary for students to benefit from feedback.
19
To benefit from feedback students must: 1. Possess a concept of the goal/standard or reference level being aimed for 2. Compare the actual (or current) level of performance with that goal or standard 3. Engage in appropriate action which leads to some closure of the gap (Sadler, 1989)
20
The power of feedback (Sadler,1989)
It is closing the gap between where the students are and where they are aiming to be that leads to the power of feedback.
21
Feedforward • Providing useful information to both the teacher and the student that will help them recognize where gaps in student learning are . . . and use that data to move forward with the intent of closing the gaps.
22
Feedforward • -feedback that is “forwardlooking so that it can improve students’ learning and enhance their future performance on assessed tasks.” How Assessment Supports Learning, Carless et al. (2006,)
23
24
3 major feedback questions 1. Where am I going? (the goals) = feedup 2. How am I going? = feedback 3. Where to next? = feedforward (Hattie and Timperley, 2007)
25
Focus on Formative Feedback (Shute, 2008), Review of Educational Research
• “The premise underlying most of the research conducted in this area is that good feedback can significantly improve learning processes and outcomes, if delivered correctly”.
Feedback which supports learning 1. 2. 3. 4.
Is sufficient (in frequency; detail) Is provided quickly enough to be useful Focuses on learning rather than on marks Is linked to assessment criteria/expected outcomes 5. Makes sense to students 6. Is received by students and attended to 7. Is acted upon to improve performance
28
Targets
My feedback research
29
Teacher written feedback on student essays
30
31
Junior Composition - third-year Academic Writing class
32
Junior Composition
essay cycle
33
essay topic: slang
34
Feedback end sheet
- attached to the first essay draft - uses same criteria as the summative assessment for the final draft - a writing guide for students - a teaching tool
35
research focus
Does the feedback feed forward? Students’ response to teacher feedback
36
feedback intervention (FI) • Actions taken by an external agent to provide information regarding some aspect of one’s task performance. (Kluger & DeNisi, 1996)
37
First draft
Final draft
38
first draft (thesis statement)
final draft
39
successful revisions (closing gaps)
40
unsuccessful revisions (open gaps)
41
Reasons for unsuccessful revisions? • Studies of second language writing show that ESL students are willing to follow closely the feedback provided by teachers, but such commentary “had the potential of miscommunicating and of being misunderstood.” (Lee & Schallert, 2008)
• “Students need to have both the ‘will’ and the ‘skill’ to be successful in classrooms.” (Pintrich & De Groot, 1990)
42
My research concludes that . . .
43
• Most revisions linked to the feedback provided did lead to text improvement in the final draft, . . . • . . . supporting empirical research that teacher feedback in multipledraft classrooms does lead to improved student writing (for example, Ferris, 1997; Ferris, 2006, Hyland and Hyland, 2006, Lee, 2008 ) .
44
Conclusion
45
We learn faster, and much more effectively, when we have a clear sense of how well we are doing and what we might need to do in order to improve. (Carless, 2006)
46
• Do you have a clear sense of how well you are doing with the feedback you provide to students?
• Does your feedback feed forward?
47
Feedforward
48
Thank you for your time and participation
49
discussion questions 1. What feedback practices do you find to be effective in your courses (i.e. that promote student learning)? 2. What feedback-related problems do you experience in the courses that you teach?