'6/%"%03&4 +FT¡T ~MWBSF[ EFM $BTUJMMP 7 +PSHF ~MWBSF[ EFM $BTUJMMP ;
&%*503 %*3&$503 $BSMPT ~MWBSF[ EFM $BTUJMMP (
Ah Pe]jcqeo _qhpqn]h _aha^n] `ko `‰_]`]o `a ej_hqoe’j t ^qaj] Ǘe^n]* Lapan Gqlan ok^naǗqah] h]o �Nqej]oÎ*
L‚cej] `ko
L‚cej] _ej_k
"Âş0 9$*9 50.0 $$$-999* /Ă .&30
#
4&$$*Â?/
?Q=@ANJK @A HA?PQN= 1 , ]Ê °]Ê " "Ê ÓäÊ Ê , Ê ÊÓä£x
-Ă•ÂŤiĂ€Ă›ÂˆĂƒÂœĂ€\ĂŠ ˜>ĂŠ,Âœ`À‰}Ă•iâÊ>˜>Â°Ă€Âœ`Ă€Âˆ}Ă•iâJˆ˜vÂœĂ€Â“>`ÂœĂ€Â°Vœ“°“Ă?ÊÉÊ ˆ“ijĂŠ Ă•ÂšÂˆĂ˘ĂŠ>ˆ“iiJˆ˜vÂœĂ€Â“>`ÂœĂ€Â°Vœ“°“Ă?
De Ăcono a leyenda,
el niĂąo eterno )PZ DPODMVZF MB FNJTJÂŞO EF Ă‚&O 'BNJMJB DPO $IBCFMPĂƒ QFSP TV QSPUBHPOJTUB EFKBS˜ VOB QSPGVOEB IVFMMB FO MB JOEVTUSJB UFMFWJTJWB EFM NVOEP 1PS .BSJP $BTUJMMP
. NG I>KLHG:C> A><AH =>L=> <>KH Luego de pasar su niĂąez en Estados Unidos, Xavier LĂłpez y su familia vuelven a MĂŠxico. EstudiĂł medicina, pero al poco tiempo de entrar a la escuela se fue a trabajar a Televicentro gracias a la invitaciĂłn de un vecino que era productor, nada menos que Don Javier de la Garza. PasĂł como cualquier otro principiante como asistente de producciĂłn en labores bĂĄsicas y aprendiendo todo lo que significaba estar detrĂĄs de cĂĄmaras en la entonces naciente industria televisiva. Fue tambiĂŠn camarĂłgrafo y â&#x20AC;&#x153;floor managerâ&#x20AC;?, entre otros puestos. Xavier estudiĂł durante cuatro aĂąos arte dramĂĄtico y se dedicĂł de lleno a la actuaciĂłn. AquĂ tambiĂŠn se encargĂł de sustituir a actores en teleteatros, aunque los papeles que interpretaba casi siempre eran de â&#x20AC;&#x153;viejitoâ&#x20AC;?. Sin embargo, no perdiĂł el tiempo y conociĂł a comediantes como Arturo Ernesto Manrique Elizondo â&#x20AC;&#x201D;â&#x20AC;&#x153;El PanzĂłn Pansecoâ&#x20AC;?â&#x20AC;&#x201D; y a Ramiro Gamboa, mejor conocido como â&#x20AC;&#x153;El TĂo GamboĂnâ&#x20AC;?, siendo ĂŠste Ăşltimo quien apadrinara a Xavier LĂłpez dĂĄndole la oportunidad de contar un chiste personificando a un niĂąo bautizado como â&#x20AC;&#x153;Chabeloâ&#x20AC;?, en el programa â&#x20AC;&#x153;Carrusel Musicalâ&#x20AC;?. Otro ĂŠxito se anotarĂa la dupla GamboĂn-â&#x20AC;&#x153;Chabeloâ&#x20AC;? con el programa â&#x20AC;&#x153;Las aventuras en el espacioâ&#x20AC;?, especialmente diseĂąado para niĂąos y en un formato adelantado a su ĂŠpoca. El estrellato llegĂł muy pronto y luego de firmar con una empresa refresquera, viajĂł por gran parte del Continente Americano, especialmente a Estados Unidos, con un show en donde lo acompaĂąaba â&#x20AC;&#x153;Tongoleleâ&#x20AC;?, y al volver a MĂŠxico estuvo al frente del programa â&#x20AC;&#x153;La media hora de â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;Chabeloâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;â&#x20AC;? por siete aĂąos. Fue en 1958 que â&#x20AC;&#x153;Chabeloâ&#x20AC;? incursionĂł en el cine con la pelĂcula â&#x20AC;&#x153;Chistelandia y sus secuelasâ&#x20AC;?; en 1962 filmĂł â&#x20AC;&#x153;El Extraâ&#x20AC;?, con Mario Moreno â&#x20AC;&#x153;Cantinflasâ&#x20AC;?. En total, â&#x20AC;&#x153;Chabeloâ&#x20AC;? estuvo en cerca de 30 pelĂculas. A lo largo de su carrera, â&#x20AC;&#x153;Chabeloâ&#x20AC;? participĂł en programas de televisiĂłn como â&#x20AC;&#x153;La Carabina de Ambrosioâ&#x20AC;?, â&#x20AC;&#x153;La Cuchufletaâ&#x20AC;? y â&#x20AC;&#x153;La Escuelita VIPâ&#x20AC;?, entre otros. Cuenta con mĂĄs de 30 discos infantiles, entre los que destacan canciones como â&#x20AC;&#x153;El reino del revĂŠsâ&#x20AC;?, â&#x20AC;&#x153;AdiĂłs Supermanâ&#x20AC;? y â&#x20AC;&#x153;Yo soy Chabeloâ&#x20AC;?. En 2012 obtuvo dos RĂŠcords Guinness: uno por mayor trayectoria como conductor de un programa infantil y otro por el mayor tiempo representando a â&#x20AC;&#x153;Chabelo, el amigo de todos los niĂąosâ&#x20AC;?.
VDIP TF IBCMB Â&#x2030;Z TF IB CSPNFBEP CBTUBOUFÂ&#x2030; TPCSF MB JONPSUB MJEBE EF 9BWJFS -Ă&#x201A;QF[ 3PES½HVF[ HSBDJBT B RVF EPNJOHP B EPNJO HP TF NFU½B FO MB QJFM EF i$IBCFMPw VO QFSTPOBKF DPOPDJEP QPS EPT P IBTUB USFT HFOFSBDJPOFT EF GBNJMJBT FOUFSBT BMHVOBT RVJ[² IBTUB TF FYUJOHVJFSPO NJFOUSBT i$IBCFMPw TFHV½B MMFOP EF HP[P Z DPNP TJ TF USBUBSB EF VO MPPQ FO FM UJFNQP TFNBOB USBT TFNBOB WFS TV QSPHSBNB i&O 'BNJMJB DPO A$IBCFMP w TF DPOWFSU½B FO VOB IFSFODJB PCMJHBEB QPS MBT NBĂ BOBT *ODMVTP TF QPES½B EFDJS RVF BM QBTP EF MPT BĂ PT TV MFHBEP TF IB QFSQFUVBEPy IBTUB IPZ DVBO EP FTPT BCVFMPT QBQ²T Z OJĂ PT TFBO UFTUJHPT EF VO TVDFTP IJTUĂ&#x201A; SJDP FO MB UFMFWJTJĂ&#x201A;O NFYJDBOB BM WFS DĂ&#x201A;NP i$IBCFMPw BSSBODB VOB QBSUF GVOEBNFOUBM EF TV QFSTPOBKF ZB RVF FTUB NBĂ BOB FO FM i$BOBM EF MBT FTUSFMMBTw TF DJFSSB FM Ă&#x2C6;MUJNP DBQ½UVMP EF VO QSP HSBNB RVF QBSFD½B JOBNPWJCMF EF MB QBOUBMMB DIJDB /BDJEP FO MB DJVEBE EF $IJDBHP *MMJOPJT VO EF GF CSFSP EF USBT PDIP EšDBEBT EF WJEB 9BWJFS OP RVJFSF FTQFSBS B RVF MB DBUBGJYJB EFM UJFNQP MF TBRVF VOB FTQBOUPTB FRVJT : FT šM NJTNP RVJFO FMJHF TV QSFNJP TJO FTQFSBS TPSQSFTBTy FM QSFNJP EF DĂ&#x201A;NP Z DV²OEP EFDJSMF BEJĂ&#x201A;T B TV QSPHSBNB i&O 'BNJ MJB DPO A$IBCFMP w NJFOUSBT MB WJEB MF TJHB EBOEP GVFS[B iA$IBCFMP FT FM RVF NF NBOUJFOFw EJ S½B 9BWJFS -Ă&#x201A;QF[ FO VOB FOUSFWJTUB DPO "EFMB .JDIB E½BT BUS²T &T DMBSP RVF FM QFSTPOBKF OP EFTFB NPSJS BVORVF TV FTQBDJP IBTUB FT UB NBĂ BOB EFTBQBSFDFS² 2VJšO MP EJS½B FTUF SFUPĂ P EF VOB GB NJMJB DPOTFSWBEPSB PSJHJOBSJB EF -FĂ&#x201A;O (VBOBKVBUP Z RVF FTUVWP B QVOUP EF FO MJTUBSTF QBSB QBSUJDJQBS FO MB (VFSSB EF $PSFB DPO FM FKšSDJUP EF &TUBEPT 6OJ EPT B TVT BĂ PT UFO½B VO EFTUJOP N²T QSPEVDUJWP FO OVFTUSP QB½T "T½ USBT VOB WJEB MMFOB EF USBCBKP Z DPOTUBODJB IB QBTBEP ZB DBTJ NFEJP TJHMP EFTEF MB QSJNFSB USBOTNJTJĂ&#x201A;O EFM QSPHSBNB RVF IPZ DVMNJOB Â&#x2030;FM EF EJDJFNCSF EF Z RVF PSJHJOBMNFO UF TF MMBNĂ&#x201A; i&O 'BNJMJB DPO &/w QPS &EJUPSJBM /PWBSP Â&#x2030; QS²DUJDBNFOUF DJODP EšDBEBT FO MBT RVF DBEB EPNJOHP i$IBCFMPw MMFWĂ&#x201A; DPO TV FNJTJĂ&#x201A;O MB BMFHS½B Z MB EJWFSTJĂ&#x201A;O DPO MPT DPODVSTPT N²T JO USšQJEPT B MPT BTJTUFOUFT B MPT GPSPT EF 5F MFWJTB 4BO Â&#x2013;OHFM $Ă&#x201A;NP PMWJEBS MB TFDDJĂ&#x201A;O EF MPT iDVBUFT EF QSPWJODJBw QBSB FOWJBSMFT QSFNJPT Z UP DBS B NJMMPOFT EF NFYJDBOPT DPO VOB TPMB MMB NBEB UFMFGĂ&#x201A;OJDB "IPSB FM UšSNJOP iQSPWJO DJBw QBSFDF RVF QJFSEF TFOUJEP : iDVBUFw TJNQMFNFOUF FTB QBMBCSB TFHVJS² DPNP VO FDP FO FM UJFNQP SFUVNCBOEP DPO FM WP[BSSĂ&#x201A;O EF i$IBCFMPw FO OVFTUSB NFNPSJB 'VFSPO BMSFEFEPS EF EPT NJM USBOTNJTJP OFT EF i&O 'BNJMJB DPO A$IBCFMP w Z BĂ PT EF JO UFSQSFUBS BM iBNJHP EF UPEPT MPT OJĂ PTw BUBWJBEP DPO VO PWFSPM P BMHVOBT WFDFT DPO FM KFSTFZ EF BMHĂ&#x2C6;O FRVJ QP EFQPSUJWP QFSP TJFNQSF DPO MB JNBHFO EF MP RVF SF QSFTFOUB VO OJĂ P RVF TĂ&#x201A;MP CVTDB MB NBOFSB EF EJWFSUJSTF DPO TVT DVBUFT 1BSB RVJFOFT OP DPOPD½BO BM DPNĂ&#x2C6;O 9BWJFS -Ă&#x201A;QF[ FT DVDIBSMP IBCMBS FO VOB FOUSFWJTUB DPNP VOB iQFSTPOB OPS NBMw P DPNP QSFTFOUBEPS EF DVBMRVJFS PUSP QSPHSBNB FSB FYUSBĂ P 2VJ[² B NVDIPT EF OJĂ P MFT QBTĂ&#x201A; RVF DVBOEP FTDV DIBCBO IBCMBS B 9BWJFS -Ă&#x201A;QF[ TF QSFHVOUBCBO EĂ&#x201A;OEF RVFEĂ&#x201A; FTB WP[ JOGBOUJM B WFDFT DIJMMPOB DPO OPUBT GVFSUFT DPNP MB FT UBUVSB Z QPSUF EF FTF OJĂ PUF RVF TF NBOEBCB TPMP /P OP FSB QFSNBOFOUF MB BDUVBDJĂ&#x201A;O QPSRVF DVBOEP FTF i$IBCFMPw TF DPOWFSU½B FO 9BWJFS -Ă&#x201A;QF[ QBSFD½B BMHVJFO EJBNFUSBMNFOUF PQVFTUP B MB JNBHFO UJFSOB EF VO JOGBOUF RVF FTF iFYUSBĂ Pw DPO WP[ EF BEVMUP Z DPO DBSB EF OJĂ P JOUFSQSFUBCB IBTUB RVF TF DPOWFSU½B OVFWBNFOUF FO i$IBCFMPw /P IBZ RVF PMWJEBS FM MBEP DPNCBUJWP EF 9BWJFS -Ă&#x201A;QF[ RVJFO BOUFT EF BOVODJBS MB DPODMVTJĂ&#x201A;O EFM QSPHSBNB JOEJDĂ&#x201A; RVF OP TBC½B OBEB TPCSF FM GJO EF MB FNJTJĂ&#x201A;O EF IFDIP UBN QPDP QFOTBCB QFEJS WBDBDJPOFT QVFT FM NPUPS EF TV WJEB FT i$IBCFMPw {"MHVOB WF[ i$IBCFMPw QFOTĂ&#x201A; FO EFTDBO TBS 1BSFDF RVF OVODB CBKĂ&#x201A; MPT CSB[PT {)BCS² FT UBEP FOGFSNP N²T EF VO EPNJOHP Z OBEJF MP OP UĂ&#x201A; 4J GVF BT½ FT UPEP VO IšSPF BM OP EFKBS FM DBNQP EF CBUBMMB UBM DPNP MP IJ[P .JDIBFM +PSEBO BOPUBOEP QVOUPT KVHBOEP DPO Ă&#x2014; HSBEPT EF UFNQF SBUVSB Z BĂ&#x2C6;O BT½ WFODFS BM +B[[ EF 6UBI FO MBT GJOBMFT EF MB /#" EF $PNP TFB CJFO MP TFOUFO DJĂ&#x201A; +BDPCP ;BCMVEPWTLZ FO VOB NFNPSBCMF SFTFĂ B RVF JOWPMV DSĂ&#x201A; B WBSJPT QFSTPOBKFT RVF DPOWJWJFSPO DPO 9BWJFS -Ă&#x201A; QF[ i6O EPNJOHP TJO A$IB CFMP OP FT VO EPNJOHPw
&- %"50 i$IBCFMPw Z TV GBNJMJB 8>Ă&#x203A;Â&#x2C6;iĂ&#x20AC;Ă&#x160; Â?ÂŤiâĂ&#x160;Â&#x2026;>Ă&#x160;Ă&#x152;iÂ&#x2DC;Â&#x2C6;`Â&#x153;Ă&#x160;Ă&#x2022;Â&#x2DC;>Ă&#x160;Ă&#x203A;Â&#x2C6;`>Ă&#x160;Â&#x201C;Ă&#x2022;Ă&#x17E;Ă&#x160;`Â&#x2C6;Ă&#x192;VĂ&#x20AC;iĂ&#x152;>Ă&#x160;VĂ&#x2022;>Â&#x2DC;`Â&#x153;Ă&#x160;Ă&#x192;iĂ&#x160; Ă&#x152;Ă&#x20AC;>Ă&#x152;>Ă&#x160;`iĂ&#x160;Ă&#x192;Ă&#x2022;Ă&#x160;v>Â&#x201C;Â&#x2C6;Â?Â&#x2C6;>°Ă&#x160;-Ă&#x2022;Ă&#x160;ÂŤĂ&#x20AC;Â&#x2C6;Â&#x201C;iĂ&#x20AC;>Ă&#x160;iĂ&#x192;ÂŤÂ&#x153;Ă&#x192;>Ă&#x160;vĂ&#x2022;iĂ&#x160; Â&#x2DC;}iÂ?Â&#x2C6;Ă&#x152;>Ă&#x160; >Ă&#x192;Ă&#x152;>Â&#x2021; Â&#x2DC;Ă&#x17E;]Ă&#x160;VÂ&#x153;Â&#x2DC;Ă&#x160;ÂľĂ&#x2022;Â&#x2C6;iÂ&#x2DC;Ă&#x160;iĂ&#x192;Ă&#x152;Ă&#x2022;Ă&#x203A;Â&#x153;Ă&#x160;V>Ă&#x192;>`Â&#x153;Ă&#x160;`Â&#x153;Ă&#x192;Ă&#x160;>Â&#x161;Â&#x153;Ă&#x192;°Ă&#x160; Ă&#x2022;i}Â&#x153;]Ă&#x160;VÂ&#x153;Â&#x2DC;Ă&#x152;Ă&#x20AC;>Â?Â&#x153;Ă&#x160; Â&#x201C;>Ă&#x152;Ă&#x20AC;Â&#x2C6;Â&#x201C;Â&#x153;Â&#x2DC;Â&#x2C6;Â&#x153;Ă&#x160;VÂ&#x153;Â&#x2DC;Ă&#x160;/iĂ&#x20AC;iĂ&#x192;Â&#x2C6;Ă&#x152;>Ă&#x160; Â&#x2C6;Ă&#x20AC;>Â&#x2DC;`>]Ă&#x160;VÂ&#x153;Â&#x2DC;Ă&#x160;ÂľĂ&#x2022;Â&#x2C6;iÂ&#x2DC;Ă&#x160;Ă&#x152;Ă&#x2022;Ă&#x203A;Â&#x153;Ă&#x160;Ă&#x152;Ă&#x20AC;iĂ&#x192;Ă&#x160;Â&#x2026;Â&#x2C6;Â&#x2021; Â?Â&#x153;Ă&#x192;\Ă&#x160;$Ă&#x192;V>Ă&#x20AC;]Ă&#x160; >Ă&#x203A;Â&#x2C6;iĂ&#x20AC;Ă&#x160;Ă&#x17E;Ă&#x160; Ă&#x2022;>Â&#x2DC;Ă&#x160; >LĂ&#x20AC;Â&#x2C6;iÂ?°Ă&#x160; `iÂ&#x201C;?Ă&#x192;Ă&#x160;`iĂ&#x160;Ă&#x192;Ă&#x2022;Ă&#x160;v>Â&#x201C;Â&#x2C6;Â?Â&#x2C6;>]Ă&#x160; `Â&#x153;Ă&#x192;Ă&#x160;`iĂ&#x160;Ă&#x192;Ă&#x2022;Ă&#x192;Ă&#x160;}Ă&#x20AC;>Â&#x2DC;`iĂ&#x192;Ă&#x160;ÂŤ>Ă&#x192;Â&#x2C6;Â&#x153;Â&#x2DC;iĂ&#x192;Ă&#x160;Ă&#x192;Â&#x153;Â&#x2DC;Ă&#x160;VÂ&#x153;Â&#x2DC;`Ă&#x2022;VÂ&#x2C6;Ă&#x20AC;Ă&#x160;iÂ&#x2DC;Ă&#x160;Â&#x201C;Â&#x153;Ă&#x152;Â&#x153;VÂ&#x2C6;VÂ?iĂ&#x152;>Ă&#x160; Ă&#x17E;Ă&#x160;VÂ&#x153;Â?iVVÂ&#x2C6;Â&#x153;Â&#x2DC;>Ă&#x20AC;Ă&#x160;Ă&#x20AC;>Â&#x2DC;>Ă&#x192;]Ă&#x160;Ă&#x152;Â&#x2C6;iÂ&#x2DC;iĂ&#x160;`Â&#x153;Ă&#x192;Ă&#x160;Â&#x201C;Â&#x2C6;Â?Ă&#x160;{ää°
&- 6/*7&34"-
1~(*/" #
&- */'03."%03 &- */'03."%03
%PNJOHP EF EJDJFNCSF EF
/, 6 -/ * / ,Ê 1* , &41&$*"- )0--: ,61&3
El arte de dibujar
sobre las Ruinas *
MVTUSBEPS Z FTDSJUPS 1FUFS ,VQFS QVCMJ DÂ FTUF BÁP MB OPWFMB HS²GJDB i3VJOBTw TV TFYUP MJCSP FO FM DBU²MPHP EF 4FYUP 1JTP 'SVUP EF TV FYQFSJFODJB IBCJUBO EP FO 0BYBDB FO VOB ¹QPDB NBSDBEB QPS MBT NBOJGFTUBDJPOFT DPOUSB FM HPCFSOBEPS ,VQFS GVF UFTUJHP EF VO BNCJFOUF EF DBNCJP QF SP UBNCJ¹O DBQUÂ MB OBUVSBMF[B Z MB IJTUPSJB FOUSF 4BNBOUIB Z (FPSHF QSPUBHPOJTUBT EF MB USBNB "EFN²T EF DPNQBSUJS MB IJTUPSJB JMVTUSBEB ,VQFS UVWP VO PCKFUJWP FYUSB DPO FTUF MJCSP i&T QFSP RVF UBNCJ¹O EFTQJFSUF B MBT QFSTPOBT TPCSF MP RVF QBTB DPO FM DBNCJP DMJN²UJDP Z IBHBNPT BMHP DPNP FTQFDJF QBSB IBDFS DBNCJPT Z RVF QP EBNPT TPCSFWJWJS DPNP MBT NBSJQPTBT NPOBSDBw 4PCSF i3VJOBTw TV QSPDFTP DSFBUJWP Z FM JO UFS¹T QPS .¹YJDP ,VQFS DIBSMÂ DPO &- */'03 ."%03 BM U¹SNJOP EF MB QBTBEB '*- VOB QM²UJDB B DBCBMMP FOUSF FM JOHM¹T Z FTQBÁPM &TUF FT UV TFHVOEP MJCSP TPCSF .ÀYJDP &T NJ NBOFSB EF DPOFDUBSNF 2VJFSP RVF NJT MJCSPT TFBO VOB GPSNB EF BHSFHBSNF QBSB SF HSFTBS B 0BYBDB Z B .¹YJDP FO HFOFSBM &T NJ PQPSUVOJEBE EF EFNPTUSBS NJ FYQFSJFODJB FO FM QB½T FTQFDJBMNFOUF QBSB QFSTPOBT FO &TUBEPT 6OJEPT RVF FOUJFOEBO RVF MB JOGPSNBDJÂO OPUJ DJBT Z MP RVF EJDF %POBME 5SVNQ OP TPO TJFNQSF DJFSUBT -B SFBMJEBE FT N²T DPNQMJDBEB N²T DP MPSJEB &T JNQPTJCMF QBSB N½ FOUFOEFS FM JNQBDUP EF .¹YJDP FO NJ BSUF &TU² FO UPEBT MBT QBSUFT EF NJ BSUF IBZ SFGMFYJPOFT FO FTQFDJBM FO FTUF MJ CSP EF MB JOGMVFODJB EFM BSUF DVMUVSB Z DPMPSFT EF .¹YJDP %FTEF MB NJUPMPHÅB 4½ NJUPMPH½B QFSP UPEP JOTFDUPT NF[ DBMy "M DPNJFO[P EF i3VJOBTw WFNPT MB FTDF OB POÅSJDB EF VO QBSUP FO FM RVF MB QSPUBHPOJT UB EB MV[ B VO MJCSP {DÎNP MP SFMBDJPOBT DPO FM QSPDFTP EF IBDFS VO MJCSP &T N²T P NFOPT QBSFDJEP BM QSPDFTP RVF UVWF BM FTDSJCJS FTUF MJCSP GVF EJG½DJM &NQFD¹ FO NF UPNÂ DJODP BÁPT QFOTBSMP 5FO½B NJFEP EF RVF GVFSB NVDIP USBCBKP NVZ DPNQMJDBEP QF SP FWFOUVBMNFOUF GVJ TBD²OEPMP FO NJ DBCF[B .F
&M JMVTUSBEPS Z FTDSJUPS SFHSFTB B 0BYBDB QBSB UPNBSMB DPNP QVOUP EF QBSUJEB QBSB EFTBSSPMMBS VOB IJTUPSJB EF DPMPS Z EFNPTUSBS RVF FO . YJDP IBZ NBT QPS WFS 1PS +PSHF 1¹SF[ EJ DVFOUB RVF UFO½B RVF IBDFSMP Z NF UPNÂ USFT BÁPT DPNQMFUBSMP &M QFSTPOBKF GFNFOJOP FTDSJCF Z FM QFSTP OBKF NBTDVMJOP EJCVKB BNCPT DPNP UÞ {RVÀ UBO UP IBZ EF UJ FO UVT QFSTPOBKFT 6O QPDP UBM WF[ FO BMHVOPT N²T .F JOUFSF TBO NVDIP MPT JOTFDUPT RVJ[² IVCJFSB TJEP FOUPNÂ MPHP TJ OP NF IVCJFSB EFEJDBEP B MPT DÂNJDT &TUB GVF NJ PQPSUVOJEBE EF KVOUBS BNCBT QBTJPOFT : DVBOEP WJW½ FO .¹YJDP NJ IJKB Z ZP WJNPT MBT NBSJ QPTBT NPOBSDBT KVOU¹ UPEP FO FTUF MJCSP "VORVF MPT EPT QSPUBHPOJTUBT FTUµO DBTJ UP EP FM MJCSP FO .ÀYJDP DBEB DBQÅUVMP NVFTUSB QBS UF EFM WJBKF EF MBT NBSJQPTBT NPOBSDB &T VOB NFU²GPSB 3FQSFTFOUBO MB NJHSBDJÂO MB WJEB MB MVDIB RVF FOGSFOUBO BM QBTBS QPS $BOBE² &TUBEPT 6OJEPT Z .¹YJDP 3FQSFTFOUBO MP RVF TVDF EF FO FM NVOEP FO FM NFEJP BNCJFOUF 5BNCJÀO IPOSBT MB NFNPSJB EFM GPUPQFSJP EJTUB #SBE 8JMM NVFSUP QPS EJTQBSPT EF CBMB FO 0BYBDB FO PDUVCSF EF EVSBOUF MBT NBOJGFT UBDJPOFT DPOUSB 6MJTFT 3VJ[ 0SUJ[ FOUPODFT HPCFS OBEPS .F IPSSPSJ[Â QPS TVQVFTUP QPS UPEB MB TJUVB DJÂO -P RVF TVDFE½B DPO FM HPCJFSOP MB QPMJD½B MPT QPSSPT Z DÂNP 0BYBDB DBNCJÂ FO FTF UJFNQP /P TBC½B RVF UFO½B BNJHPT FO DPNÈO DPO #SBE *ODMVTP DPMBCPSÂ FO i5FSDFSB .VOEJBM *MVTUSBEBw MB SFWJTUB RVF DPGVOE¹ FO MPT TFUFOUB )BC½B VOB DPOFYJÂO -VFHP TVQF RVF MMFW²CBNPT DBNJOPT DSV[BEPT RVJ [² IBTUB OPT UPQBNPT FO FM ;ÂDBMP EF 0BYBDB %F IFDIP JCB B FODPOUSBSNF BMM½ DPO VO BNJHP FO DP NÈO FM E½B FO RVF NVSJÂ QBSB WJTJUBS MBT CBSSJDBEBT 1FSP MB QPMJD½B BUBDÂ BOUFT Z OP QVEJNPT FODPOUSBS OPT 4J IVCJFSB JEP N²T UFNQSBOP RVJ[² IVCJFSB FTUBEP BI½ UBNCJ¹O -B SB[ÂO QPS MB RVF
4"#&3 .«4 -B USBZFDUPSJB *iÌiÀÊ Õ«iÀÊ ÕiÛ>Ê iÀÃiÞ]Ê£ xn®Ê >Ê«ÕL V>` ÊÕ >ÊÛi Ìi >Ê`iÊ LÀ Ã°Ê iÃ`iÊ£ ÇÊ«ÕL V>Êi ʺ »ÊÃÕÊv> Ã>Ê Ì À>ÊV V>ʺ-«ÞÊÛðÊ-«Þ»°Ê Ãi >Ê`iÊ« > Ì>Êi Ê >Ê ÃVÕi >Ê`iÊ ÀÌiÃÊ6 ÃÕ> iÃÊ`iÊ > >ÌÌ> ÊÞÊV ÊÛ Ã Ì> ÌiÊi Ê >ÀÛ>À`°Ê -iÝÌ Ê* Ã Ê >Ê«ÕL V>` ʺ Êà ÃÌi >»]ʺ >À Ê`iÊ ÕiÛ>Ê 9 À »ÊÞʺ >À Ê`iÊ">Ý>V>»]Ê>`i ?ÃÊ`iÊ >ÃÊ ÕÃÌÀ>V iÃÊ «>À>ʺ ÊÌÀ>ÛjÃÊ`i Êiëi ÊÞÊ ÊµÕiÊ V >Êi V ÌÀ Ê> »ÊÞÊ º V >Êi Êi Ê*> ÃÊ`iÊ >ÃÊ >À>Û >û]Ê> L ÃÊ`iÊ`iÊ iÜ ÃÊ
>ÀÀ °
i3VJOBTw FT GJDDJÂO FT QPSRVF RVJTF DPMPDBS B NJ QFS TPOBKF FO NFEJP EF UPEP OP VO QPDP BGVFSB 'VF NJ PQPSUVOJEBE EF UPNBS MB JOGPSNBDJÂO Z NJ FYQFSJFO DJB Z KVOUBSMP QBSB DPMPDBS MB OBSSBDJÂO FO FM DFOUSP EF MPT FWFOUPT &O MB OPWFMB HSµGJDB (FPSHF EJCVKB FO FM MV HBS NJTNP EF MBT NBOJGFTUBDJPOFT {DÎNP MP IJDJT UF UÞ QBSB FTUF MJCSP %JCVK¹ FO FM MVHBS T½ 5BNCJ¹O EJCVK¹ B QBS UJS EF GPUPT RVF UPN¹ Z GPUPT EF PUSPT 'VF VOB DPN CJOBDJÂO EF GVFOUFT :B RVF UFO½B UPEB MB IJTUPSJB FO M²QJ[ SFHSFT¹ Z UPN¹ N²T GPUPT QBSB MBT JEFBT EF MB IJTUPSJB %JCVK¹ UPEP FO VO MJCSJUP F JCB DBNJOBOEP Z CVTDBOEP MBT FTDFOPHSBG½BT 3FHSFT¹ VOBT EPT P USFT WFDFT QBSB UFOFS N²T SFGFSFODJBT {2VÀ UBO EJGFSFOUF GVF FM QSPDFTP FO DPN QBSBDJÎO EF PUSPT MJCSPT 'VF TJNJMBS FO FM QSPDFTP EF EFTBSSPMMBS MB IJT UPSJB QFSP DPNP UVWF MBT FYQFSJFODJBT Z SFHSFT¹ B MPT MVHBSFT QBSB UFOFS MB SFGFSFODJB GVF EJGFSFOUF DÂ NP FYQMPS¹ MBT MPDBDJPOFT &O PUSPT MJCSPT NF IF CB TBEP FO MB NFNPSJB &O ¹TUF DPNFOD¹ DPO VOB TJ OPQTJT Z BMHVOPT EJCVKPT C²TJDPT VO DVBESP RVF SFQSFTFOUB EPT Q²HJOBT Z RV¹ QBTB MVFHP IBHP PUSB WFSTJÂO FO MB RVF EJCVKP FO PUSP UBNBÁP RV¹ QBTB "T½ UFOHP MB JEFB EF RV¹ TVDFEF DPO MPT QFSTPOBKFT -VFHP MP EJCVKP EF OVFWP DPO PUSP UBNBÁP ZB DPO MPT HMPCPT QBSB MPT EJ²MPHPT "M GJOBM IBHP MBT MFUSBT ZB DVBOEP FTU² BHSBOEBEP QBSB RVF RVFEFO QFSGFD UBTy 2VFEB NBUFSJBM VO N²T HSBOEF RVF FM MJ CSP &T BI½ DVBOEP DPQJP B QBQFM QBSB BDVBSFMBT DPO UJOUB 2VJ[² TPO DJODP QBTPT QBSB UFOFS VOB Q²HJOB MJTUB &M TFYUP QBTP TPO MPT HMPCPT EF
EJ²MPHP ZB DPO MB DPNQVUBEPSB "M QSJODJQJP FTU² UPEP B NBOP QFSP BRV½ IBZ VOB UJQPHSBG½B QBSB DB EB QFSTPOBKF )BZ DPMPSFT QPS DPNQVUBEPSB DP NP BM QSJODJQJP BOUFT EFM BFSPQVFSUP DVBOEP MMF HBO B .¹YJDP DBNCJB EF MP DBTJ NPOPDSPN²UJDP B ZB UFOFS UPEPT MPT DPMPSFT &T MB PQJOJÎO DPNÞO EF MPT FYUSBOKFSPT TF ÍBMBS RVF FO .ÀYJDP UPEP FT NVZ DPMPSJEP &T VOB FYQFSJFODJB DPNP EF WJWJS FO CMBO DP Z OFHSP Z EF SFQFOUF DBNCJBS B DPMPSFT &T DP NP FO i&M .BHP EF 0[w TBMFT EFM BFSPQVFSUP Z FT U² UPEP NVZ DPMPSJEP 6OP EF MPT DPOGMJDUPT EFM MJCSP FT FM EF MB QBSFKB FMMB RVJFSF UFOFS VO CFCÀ QFSP ÀM OP i{1PS RVÀ USBFS PUSP TFS IVNBOP B FTUF NVOEP w TF QSFHVOUB {"MHVOB WF[ UF QSFHVOUBTUF QPS RVÀ USBFS PUSP MJCSP B FTUF NVOEP "CTPMVUBNFOUF %F IFDIP DVBOEP USBCBKB CB FO FTUF MJCSP UPEPT MPT E½BT NF MP QSFHVOUBCB 5VWF VOB MVDIB JOUFSFTBOUF NF QSFHVOUBCB {FM NVOEP OFDFTJUB PUSP MJCSP {1PS RV¹ IBHP FTUB IJT UPSJB FTUPT QFSTPOBKFT DPO FTUPT QSPCMFNBT 1B SB N½ DPNP BVUPS GVF VOB OVFWB FYQFSJFODJB TFO UJS DÂNP MPT QFSTPOBKFT TF DPNVOJDBCBO DPONJHP HVJ²OEPNF B USBW¹T EF MB USBNB Z UPEP MP RVF QB TBS½B 5FO½B EJGFSFOUFT GJOBMFT QBSB FM MJCSP IBC½B VOP N²T GFMJ[ 1FSP EFDJE½ EFKBS FTF GJOBM NFEJP USJTUF NFEJP GFMJ[ RVF QBSFDF N²T OBUVSBM "T½ GVF MB MVDIB QPO½B VO QBS EF M½OFBT Z TFOU½B RVF VOB FTUBCB NBM .F FOGSFOU¹ B NJT QSPQJBT IBCJMJEB EFT DPO RV¹ QBSUFT UFO½B QSPCMFNBT RV¹ QBSUFT QPE½B IBDFS NFKPS $SFP RVF FT DPNÈO FO NVDIPT DSFBEPSFT "M GJOBM JODMVTP SFHSFT¹ Z BHSFHV¹ N²T Q²HJOBT 4J IVCJFSB DPOUJOVBEP USBCBKBOEP B MP NFKPS MF BHSFHP DJFO Q²HJOBT N²T QFSP FTP MPT EFBEMJOFT TPO CVFOPT "M GJOBM OP TÎMP TPO MBT SVJOBT EF VOB DJWJ MJ[BDJÎO QFSP UBNCJÀO EF VOB SFMBDJÎO &T DPNP FM '¹OJY MFWBOU²OEPTF DSFP RVF FO OVFTUSBT WJEBT DPOTFHVJNPT MP RVF RVFSFNPT QF SP OP FO MB GPSNB FO RVF FTQFSBNPT )BZ WBSJBDJP OFT BMHP QBTB RVF DBNCJB FM DBNJOP Z EFCFNPT CVTDBS OVFWBT EJSFDDJPOFT )BZ NVDIP EF FTP FO MB IJTUPSJB UBNCJ¹O MB GPSNB FO RVF SFQSFTFOUB WJFKBT DJWJMJ[BDJPOFT RVF ZB OP FTU²O QFSP UBNCJ¹O MBT DJWJMJ[BDJPOFT RVF TVSHJFSPO EF FMMBT &T MB MV DIB EF TPCSFWJWJS MB NBSJQPTB FT VOB NFU²GPSB Z VOB SFBMJEBE EF MP EJG½DJM RVF FT TPCSFWJWJS QFSP BM NJTNP UJFNQP WJTJUBT .JDIPBD²O Z IBZ PODF NJ MMPOFT EF NBSJQPTBT FT VO NJMBHSP %B VOB TFOTB DJÂO JODSF½CMF EF RVF WJWJNPT FO FM KBSE½O EFM FE¹O QFSP UBNCJ¹O EB BOTJFEBE BM WFS RV¹ UBO S²QJEP QVFEF DBNCJBS UPEP )BZ VOB ÞOJDB QµHJOB EFTQMFHBCMF RVF NVFTUSB DVBOEP MMFHBO B WFS MBT NBSJQPTBT 2VFS½B EFNPTUSBS MB TFOTBDJÂO RVF UVWF BI½ QFSP UBNCJ¹O DBQUBS MP RVF TF WF BI½ QFSP OP DBC½B FO VOB Q²HJOB 1VEJFSBO TFS DVBUSP N²T {$VµM TFSµ UV TJHVJFOUF QSPZFDUP i4UJDLT BOE 4UPOFTw 4FS² VOB BMFHPS½B TP CSF MP RVF QBTB DPO FM MFWBOUBNJFOUP EF MPT JNQF SJPT RV¹ QBTB DVBOEP MB HFOUF MF EB QPEFS B HFO UF RVF MP VUJMJ[B NBM &M SFTVMUBEP FT FM EBÁP BM NFEJP BNCJFOUF 4FS² VOB OPWFMB NVEB QPSRVF FTUB UVWP NVDIBT QBMBCSBT BT½ RVF RVJFSP WPMWFS B BMHP TJO OBEB EF EJ²MPHP 4FS² DPO FTU¹ODJM Z TQSBZ 1SPCBCMFNFOUF TFB FM MJCSP EF
%PNJOHP EF EJDJFNCSF EF
1~(*/" #
&- */'03."%03
- À µÕiÊ/ ÕÃÃ> Ì] analista político
España &
TQBÁB WJWF VO DBNCJP EF ¹QPDB &TP FT JOOFHBCMF 4F IB SPUP FM CJQBSUJ EJTNP Z QBTF MP RVF QBTF FO MBT FMFDDJPOFT EF FTUF EPNJOHP FM FT DFOBSJP TFS² JO¹EJUP MB QSFTFODJB EF DVBUSP GVFS[BT QPM½UJDBT OBDJP OBMFT DPO SFMFWBODJB BSJUN¹UJDB FO FM $POHSFTP EF MPT %JQVUBEPT 5SBT BÁPT EF EFNPDSBDJB N²T EF NJMMPOFT EF FTQBÁPMFT FTU²O MMBNBEPT B WP UBS FO MPT DPNJDJPT N²T BQBTJPOBOUFT EFTEF MB USBOTJDJÂO QPM½UJDB EF GJOBMFT EF MB E¹DBEB EF MPT TFUFOUB " MPT JOWJUBEPT SFDVSSFOUFT FM 1BSUJEP 1PQVMBS Z FM 1BSUJEP 4PDJBMJTUB IPZ TF BÁBEFO MPT WJFOUPT GSFTDPT EF VO QBSUJEP TVSHJEP EF MPT NP WJNJFOUPT EF JOEJHOBEPT FM EF NBZP EF Z MB JODJTJWB WJTJÂO EF $JVEBEBOPT VOB GPSNBDJÂO QPM½UJDB EF DFOUSP EFSFDIB Z RVF DPOTUJUVZF VOB PQDJÂO MJCFSBM TJO NBUJDFT /JOHVOP QPES² BM[BS TF DPO VOB NBZPS½B TVGJDJFOUF QBSB HPCFSOBS QPS T½ NJTNP QPS MP RVF &TQBÁB TF BCSF BM IPSJ[POUF EF MB GSBHNFOUBDJÂO Z MB EJTQFSTJÂO EFM QPEFS &O FM IPSJ[POUF QPM½UJDP FTQBÁPM TF FTGVNBO MPT UJFNQPT EF MBT NBZPS½BT BCTPMVUBT JO DPOUFTUBCMFT &M 11 FODBCF[B MBT FODVFTUBT : EFUS²T EF MB GPSNBDJÂO DPOTFSWBEP SB WJFOFO FOGJMBEPT FM 140& $JVEB EBOPT Z 1PEFNPT UPEP FMMPT DPO VOB EJGFSFODJB NBSHJOBM %F BDVFSEP B MB ÈMUJNB FODVFTUB RVF QVCMJDÂ FM i1FSJP EJD EF "OEPSSBw RVF QVCMJDÂ FODVFT UBT B QBSUJS EFM NBSUFT DVBOEP FO &TQB ÁB ZB FTU² QSPIJCJEB MB EJWVMHBDJÂO EF FTUVEJPT EFNPTDÂQJDPT MPT QPQVMBSFT QB SFDFO UFOFS BNQMJBT QPTJCJMJEBEFT EF BM[BSTF DPO MB QSJNFSB QMB[B QFSP OP QBSFDF UBO TFODJ MMP RVF QVFEBO GPSNBS VO (PCJFSOP DPO $JVEBEB OPT FM BMJBEP OBUVSBM "M TFS VO TJTUFNB QBSMBNFO UBSJP MPT DVBUSP DBOEJEBUPT .BSJBOP 3BKPZ 11 1FESP 4²ODIF[ 140& 1BCMP *HMFTJBT 1PEF NPT Z "MCFSU 3JWFSB $JVEBEBOPT OFDFTJUBO EF BM NFOPT EJQVUBEPT QBSB GPSNBS VO (PCJFS OP -BT FODVFTUBT DFSSBSPO DPO VO QSPNFEJP EF EJQVUBEPT QSPZFDUBEPT QBSB FM 11 QBSB FM 140& QBSB 1PEFNPT Z QBSB $JVEBEBOPT &T EFDJS FO VO FTDFOBSJP UBO GSBHNFOUBEP TÂMP VOB USJQMF DPBMJDJÂO EBS½B (PCJFSOP ZB TFB FOUSF MPT QBSUJEPT OBDJPOBMFT P VO QBDUP FOUSF EPT RVF BEFN²T TVNF B QBSUJEPT SFHJPOBMFT DBUBMBOFT WBTDPT P HBMMFHPT : FO QBSBMFMP .BSJBOP 3BKPZ TF DPNQSPNFUJÂ B CVTDBS VOB DPBMJDJÂO FTUBCMF OP TÂMP QBSB MB JOWFTUJEVSB TJOP UBNCJ¹O DPNP TP DJP MFHJTMBUJWP QBSB MPT QSÂYJNPT DVBUSP BÁPT -BT NBUFN²UJDBT OP EBO $VBUSP UFNBT NBSDBSPO MB DBNQBÁB FMFDUP SBM Z UBNCJ¹O TFS²O GVOEBNFOUBMFT QBSB MB -F HJTMBUVSB RVF DPNFO[BS² FO MB DSJTJT FDPOÂ NJDB Z MB iTPMJEF[w EF MB SFDVQFSBDJÂO MPT DBTPT EF DPSSVQDJÂO RVF IBO B[PUBEP B MPT EPT QBSUJEPT N²T HSBOEFT EF &TQBÁB BVORVF DPO FTQFDJBM ¹O GBTJT BM QBSUJEP FO FM (PCJFSOP BM 11 MB MVDIB DPO USB FM UFSSPSJTNP USBT MPT BUBRVFT FO 1BSJT : DP NP DVBSUP UFNB FM QSPCMFNB DBUBM²O MB BQVFTUB QPS MB JOEFQFOEFODJB EF MB NBZPS½B EF MPT EJQV UBEPT FO FM 1BSMBNFOUP EF $BUBMVÁB Z QPS FOEF FM EFCBUF TPCSF FM NPEFMP QPM½UJDP UFSSJUPSJBM EF MBT BVUPOPN½BT TV WJHFODJB Z QSPQVFTUBT EF SF GPSNB &TUPT UÂQJDPT IBO QSPUBHPOJ[BEP FM EFCB UF EF MPT DBOEJEBUPT FO SBEJP UFMFWJTJÂO Z FO QSFO TB FTDSJUB {2V¹ QPEFNPT FTQFSBS EFM OVFWP (PCJFSOP EF &TQBÁB RVF TBMHB EF MBT VSOBT EF FT UF EF EJDJFNCSF {2V¹ EFTBG½PT EFCFS² FOGSFO UBS FO MPT QSJNFSPT NFTFT EF TV BENJOJTUSBDJÂO &TQBÁB TBMJÂ EF MB DSJTJT FDPOÂNJDB " TFJT BÁPT EF RVF TF EFTJOGMBSB MB CVSCVKB JONPCJMJBSJB QSPWPDBOEP VO DBUBDMJTNP GJOBODJFSP FO UPEB MB 1FO½OTVMB *C¹SJDB &TQBÁB DPNJFO[B B SFDVQFSBS MB FTUBCJMJEBE EF TVT JOEJDBEPSFT $SFDF B VOB UB TB NBZPS RVF FM QSPNFEJP EF MB 6OJÂO &VSPQFB Z MFOUBNFOUF MB HFOFSBDJÂO EF FNQMFP EF MPT ÈMUJ NPT NFTFT QFSNJUF DJFSUP PQUJNJTNP &T JOOFHB CMF RVF FM (PCJFSOP EF 3BKPZ IB MPHSBEP FOEFSF [BS MB OBWF Z IBTUB DSFBS DBTJ VO NJMMÂO EF FNQMFPT FO MPT ÈMUJNPT NFTFT QPS N²T QSF DBSJPT RVF TFBO EF BDVFSEP B MB PQPTJDJÂO 4JO FNCBSHP MPT SFDPSUFT GVFSPO TBMWBKFT Z MB DB½EB SFBM EF MPT TBMBSJPT IB TJEP TPTUFOJEB EFTEF 5BNQPDP QPEFNPT PMWJEBS RVF FM QSPNFEJP TBMB SJBM EF VO FTQBÁPM TF EFTCBSSBODÂ IBTUB MPT NJM FVSPT NFOTVBMFT Z RVF MB UBTB EF EFTPDVQB DJÂO TF NBOUJFOF QPS FODJNB EF MPT QVOUPT QPS DFOUVBMFT &M FTUBEP EF CJFOFTUBS IB TVGSJEP TFWF SPT SFDPSUFT EVSBOUF MB HFTUJÂO EF MB DSJTJT FDPOÂNJDB %F FTUB NBOFSB &TQBÁB FODVFOUSB TV DBNJOP EF TBMJEB EFM DBMMFKÂO PCTDVSP EF MB SF DFTJÂO BQMJDBOEP FM NPEFMP EF BVTUFSJEBE Z BKVT UF FTUSVDUVSBM RVF QSPWPDÂ JODSFNFOUPT JOVTJUB EPT EF MB EFTJHVBMEBE BT½ DPNP VO SFCPUF EF N²T EF QVOUPT FO NBUFSJB EF QPCSF[B FO .¹YJDP DPOPDFNPT CJFO FTUB GÂSNVMB EF BKVTUF USBT MBT DSJTJT FDPOÂNJDBT DPNP MB EF 1SPCMFNBT PMWJEBEPT DPNP MB JOEJHFODJB P MB NBMOVUSJDJÂO JOGBOUJM TPO BIPSB EFCBUFT SFDVSSFOUFT FOUSF MB DMBTF QPM½UJDB FTQBÁPMB &TQBÁB FOUSÂ TJFOEP VOB B MB DSJTJT Z MPHSÂ TBMJS QFSP QBHBOEP VO QSFDJP SFBMNFOUF BMUP -B DPSSVQDJÂO GVF FM UFNB RVF N²T MF FOEJM HÂ MB PQPTJDJÂO B .BSJBOP 3BKPZ : FT RVF EVSBO UF MB -FHJTMBUVSB RVF DPNFO[Â FO MPT DBTPT EF DPSSVQDJÂO TF BQJMBSPO FO FM FTDSJUPSJP EFM 1SF TJEFOUF EFM (PCJFSOP Z KFGF N²YJNP EFM 11 i4¹ GVFSUFw MF EFD½B FO VO NFOTBKF EF UFYUP FM QSPQJP 3BKPZ B VO FY UJUVMBS EF GJOBO[BT RVF MMFHÂ B MB D²S
&M EFDMJWF EFM CJQBSUJEJTNP FO UJFSSBT JC SJDBT IB QSPEVDJEP VO FTDFOBSJP JO EJUP FO MB IJTUPSJB EF MB EFNPDSBDJB FTQB¨PMB DVBUSP QBSUJEPT TF KVFHBO IPZ MB TJMMB EF QSFTJEFOUF EFM (PCJFSOP
en disputa
DFM QPS BENJOJT USBS VOB DPOUBCJMJ EBE QBSBMFMB OP EFDMBSBEB RVF TF FODBSHBCB EF QBHBS TPCSF TVFMEPT B BMUPT EJSJHFOUFT EFM QBSUJEP DPOTFS WBEPS FO &TQBÁB 5SBT FM DBTP #²S DFOBT DPNP FT DP OPDJEP FO &TQBÁB TF IBO BDVNVMBEP FTD²OEBMPT DPNP FM EF MB 1ÈOJDB VOB SFE EF DPSSVQDJÂO RVF JOWPMVDSBCB B BMDBMEFT Z B FNQSF TBT QBSB BNBÁBS MJ DJUBDJPOFT P FM DBTP EF 3PESJHP 3BUP RVJFO GVFSB WJDFQSFTJ EFOUF FDPOÂNJDP EF &TQBÁB Z EJSFDUPS HFOF SBM EFM 'POEP .POFUBSJP *OUFS OBDJPOBM FTU² BDVTBEP EF CMBORVFP UFSBM BWBMBEP UBOUP QPS EF EJOFSP Z QPES½B MMFHBS IBTUB QSJTJÂO 3B MBT /BDJPOFT 6OJEBT DPNP QPS UP TJNCPMJ[B FM NPEFMP FDPOÂNJDP EFGFOEJEP QPS FM 11 BT½ RVF MB SFWFMBDJÂO EF TVT JMFHBMJEBEFT MB 0SHBOJ[BDJÂO EFM 5SBUBEP EFM "UM²O QSPQJO VO EVSP HPMQF BM QBSUJEP FO FM (PCJFSOP UJDP /PSUF i'SBODJB FT OVFTUSP BMJBEP Z 4J CJFO FM OP IBCFS DVNQMJEP TV QSPHSBNB FMFDUP EFCFNPT SFTQPOEFSw NFODJPO "MCFSU 3J SBM RVF DPOUFNQMBCB VOB JNQPSUBOUF CBKBEB EF WFSB FO FM EFCBUF UFMFWJTBEP QPS "OUFOB 5SFT MPT JNQVFTUPT MF QBT GBDUVSB BM QBSUJEP EF 3BKPZ &M 11 IB TJEP N²T DBVUP Z IB QFEJEP QPTUFSHBS MB FT JOOFHBCMF RVF MB DPSSVQDJÂO IB TJEP TV B[PUF EFDJTJÂO EFM FOW½P EF USPQBT IBTUB MB JOTUBMBDJÂO EF MB QSÂYJNB MFHJTMBUVSB Z DPO FM OVFWP (PCJFSOP ZB FO MPT ÈMUJNPT EPT BÁPT &M BTVOUP DBUBM²O UBNCJ¹O GVF QSPUBHPOJTUB GPSNBEP 1PEFNPT FT UBKBOUF FO TV QPTJDJÂO DPO EF MB FMFDDJÂO $PO VOB EFDMBSBDJÂO BQSPCBEB FO USBSJB B DVBMRVJFS UJQP EF JOUFSWFODJÂO i0DDJEFOUF FM 1BSMBNFOUP EF $BUBMVÁB RVF QJEF FM iDPNJFO[B IB JOUFSWFOJEP FO "GHBOJTU²O *SBR Z FO -JCJB Z RV¹ EF MB EFTDPOFYJÂOw DPO SFTQFDUP B MBT JOTUJUVDJP IFNPT HBOBEP MB TJUVBDJÂO FTU² QFPSw TPTUVWP 1B OFT FTQBÁPMBT TPCSF MB NFTB MPT DVBUSP DBOEJEB CMP *HMFTJBT BM TFS FOUSFWJTUBEP TPCSF FM UFNB &O FM GPOEP FODPOUSBNPT MB EJTQVUB EF EPT UPT FTUBCBO PCMJHBEPT B EFKBS EF MBEP MBT BNCJHÊF QSPZFDUPT QPM½UJDPT F JEFPMÂHJDBNFO EBEFT Z UPNBS QPTUVSB 3BKPZ FT UF BOUJU¹UJDPT 1PS VO MBEP VOB DPBMJ QBSUJEBSJP EFM BDUVBM NPEFMP BVUPO NJDP Z BVORVF TF EJDF EJTQVFTUP B ÃÊVÕ>ÌÀ ÊV> ` `>Ì Ã]Ê DJÂO 11 $JVEBEBOPT TF GJODBS½B TP CSF MB CBTF EF MB SFEVDDJÂO EFM EJBMPHBS OP IB IFDIP OJOHÈO HFTUP >À > Ê,> ÞÊ**®]Ê &TUBEP VOB BHFOEB EF SFHFOFSBDJÂO EF BQFSUVSB QBSB VOB SFGPSNB DPOT UJUVDJPOBM RVF QFSNJUB VO NFKPS FO *i`À Ê-? V iâÊ*-" ®]Ê EFNPDS²UJDB Z DPNCBUF B MB DPSSVQ DJÂO MB EFMJNJUBDJÂO QFSP OP N²T DBKF EF $BUBMVÁB FO &TQBÁB -PT TP DJBMJTUBT BQVFTUBO QPS VOB SFGPSNB *>L Ê } ià >ÃÊ* `i Ã®Ê RVF FTP EFM BDUVBM NPEFMP EF MBT BVUPOPN½BT Z VOB QSPNFTB EF SF GFEFSBM FM GPSUBMFDJNJFOUP EFM 4FOB ÞÊ LiÀÌÊ, ÛiÀ>Ê EP DPNP D²NBSB UFSSJUPSJBM QBSB RVF Õ`>`> î]Ê iVià Ì> Ê EVDDJÂO EF JNQVFTUPT FO MPT QSJNF SPT NFTFT EF MB -FHJTMBUVSB &O DPO QPTUFSJPSNFOUF TFB USBTMBEBEP B `iÊ> Ê i ÃÊ£ÇÈÊ USBQPTJDJÂO FM QSPZFDUP EF VOB #BSDFMPOB $JVEBEBOPT VO QBSUJEP RVF OBDJ FO $BUBMVÁB Z QSFDJTBNFO ` «ÕÌ>` ÃÊ«>À>Êv À >ÀÊ QPTJCMF DPBMJDJÂO 140& 1PEFNPT TF GJODB FO MB SFDVQFSBDJÂO EF MPT EFSF UF DPNP SFTQVFTUB BM BVHF TPCFSBOJT Õ Ê L iÀ DIPT TPDJBMFT Z CMJOEBKF EFM &TUBEP UB IB QFEJEP EFTBQBSFDFS FM 4FOBEP EFM #JFOFTUBS VOB TFSJF EF QSPQVFT JODPSQPSBOEP VOB JOTUBODJB RVF UBT FO NBUFSJB EF BVTUFSJEBE FO MB BE BHMVUJOF B MPT QSFTJEFOUFT BVUPOÂNJ DPT Z OP SFOJFHB EFM BDUVBM NPEFMP EF DPNQFUFO NJOJTUSBDJÂO QÈCMJDB MB BHFOEB EF MB SFHFOFSB DJBT BVORVF QSPQPOF DMBSJGJDBSMBT 1PEFNPT QPS DJÂO EFNPDS²UJDB MB BQVFTUB QPS VOB &TQBÁB RVF TV QBSUF FT FM ÈOJDP QBSUJEP RVF SFDPOPDF B MPT DB SFTQPOEB B VO NPEFMP GFEFSBM RVF EFGJFOEF FM UBMBOFT TV iEFSFDIP B EFDJEJSw RV¹ UJQP EF SFMB 140& P QMVSJOBDJPOBM RVF QSPQPOF 1PEFNPT Z DJÂO KVS½EJDB RVJFSFO DPO FM &TUBEP 1BCMP *HMFTJBT VOB SFGPSNB GJTDBM RVF FTUF EJSJHJEB B SFDBVEBS EF IB TPTUFOJEP RVF ¹M RVJFSF RVF MPT DBUBMBOFT TF MPT TFDUPSFT N²T BDBVEBMBEPT EF MB QPCMBDJÂO -B RVFEFO QFSP RVF BOUFQPOF TV WPDBDJÂO EFNPDS² JOUFOTJEBE EF MBT SFGPSNBT Z MB QSPGVOEJEBE EF FMMBT EFQFOEFS² FO HSBO NFEJEB EF MB EFGJOJDJÂO UJDB -B MVDIB DPOUSB FM UFSSPSJTNP JTM²NJDP UBNCJ¹O EF RVJ¹O FODBCF[BS² MBT BMJBO[BT QBSB GPSNBS (P IB JOGMVJEP FO MBT BHFOEBT EF MPT QBSUJEPT QPM½UJDPT CJFSOP {4FS²O MPT EPT QBSUJEPT USBEJDJPOBMNFOUF $JVEBEBOPT Z 4PDJBMJTUBT IBO TJEP GJSNFT FO MB EF IFHFNÂOJDPT P FYJTUF MB QPTJCJMJEBE EF RVF BMHV GFOTB EF VOB JOUFSWFODJÂO FO 4JSJB QBSUJDVMBSNFO OB GVFS[B QPM½UJDB FNFSHFOUF TF QMBOUF DPNP VOB UF FO MBT [POBT DPOUSPMBEBT QPS FM &TUBEP *TM²NJDP BMUFSOBUJWB QBSB GPSNBS VOB DPBMJDJÂO EF (PCJFS "VORVF QPOFO EF DPOEJDJÂO VO BDVFSEP NVMUJMB OP {3BKPZ P 4²ODIF[ TPO MPT ÈOJDPT DBOEJEBUPT
&- */'03."%03 t + -»1&;
SFBMFT B PDV QBS MB 1SFTJEFO DJB EFM (P CJFSOP P *HMF TJBT P 3JWFSB QPES½BO FODBCF [BS VOB DPBMJDJÂO 5PEP FTU² NVZ EJWJ EJEP EJG½DJM EBS VOB SFTQVFTUB 4FB DVBM TFB FM SF TVMUBEP EF MPT DPNJDJPT MBT VSOBT BSSPKBS²O VO FT DFOBSJP JO¹EJUP QBSB &TQB ÁB "DPTUVNCSBEPT MPT FTQB ÁPMFT B NBZPS½BT BCSVNBEPSBT DPNP MB RVF IPZ PTUFOUB FM 11 UFOES²O BIPSB RVF MJEJBS DPO VO FTDFOBSJP EF BNQMJB GSBHNFOUBDJÂO Z DPO BM NFOPT DVBUSP QBSUJEPT QPM½UJDPT DPO N²T EF FTDB ÁPT Z FO EPOEF FM QBSUJEP N²T WPUBEP QP ES½B RVFEBSTF B N²T EF BTJFOUPT EF PCUF OFS MB NBZPS½B BCTPMVUB RVF MF QFSNJUB HPCFSOBS &TQBÁB DBNCJÂ MB DSJTJT Z MB DPSSVQ DJÂO FYUFOEJFSPO DBSUB EF JOWJUBDJÂO QPM½UJDB B EPT OVFWPT JORVJMJOPT RVF JOTJTUFO FO MB JNQPSUBODJB EF MB SFHFOFSBDJÂO EFNPDS²UJDB Z FM DPNCBUF B MBT QS²DUJDBT DPSSVQUBT RVF UBOUP IBO EBÁBEP BM CJ QBSUJEJTNP FO MPT ÈMUJNPT BÁPT %FM WPUP EF FTUF EPNJOHP TBMES² MB QSJNFSB HSBO DPBMJDJÂO EF MB IJTUPSJB EFNPDS²UJDB FO &TQBÁB Z FO EFGJOJUJWB FM FOUJFSSP JOFYPSBCMF EF MP RVF BMHVOB WF[ GVF FM CJ QBSUJEJTNP EPNJOBOUF
1~(*/" #
&- */'03."%03 &- */'03."%03
%PNJOHP EF EJDJFNCSF EF
>À ÃÊ À }Õi
Õ> Ê*> >À
9 ,Ê "-
, "Ê Ê1 Ê -* / ",
K\dYcfi\j &O DJFSUB GPSNB SFTVMUB VOB EFTHSBDJB WJWJS FO VO TJUJP EPO EF FTU²O TVDFEJFOEP UFNCMPSFT EF UJFSSB Z OP TFOUJSMPT FTP TJHOJGJDB RVF BM E½B TJHVJFOUF EF RVF FTUPT TVDFEBO VOP OP QVFEB DPOUBS OBEB FO MP RVF TF DPOWFSUJS² FM UFNB PCMJHBUP SJP Z VTUFE EFCFS² QFSNBOFDFS DBMMBEPUF UPEP QPS JOTFOTJ CMF BOUF MPT GFOÂNFOPT UFMÈSJDPT -BT DBVTBT EF MPT UFNCMPSFT EFQFOEFO NVDIP EF RVJ¹O TFB FM RVF PQJOF -B N²T TFODJMMB FT DVMQBS EF MPT NJTNPT B MBT UFMFWJTPSBT MBT RVF UJFOFO FM DPOUSPM MBT PUSBT OJ QJOUBO QBSB DVCSJS FM HBTUP EF MB DPNQSB EF UFMFT OVFWBT -PT NFUFPSÂMPHPT QPS TV QBSUF EJS²O RVF FT QPS FM GF OÂNFOP EFM OJÁP ZB RVF EJDIB DSJBUVSB IB SFTVMUBEP MB DBV TB EF UPEBT MBT EFTHSBDJBT OBDJPOBMFT BT½ TF EFTQMPNÂ FM QFUSÂMFP FM OJÁP 2VF MB QSJNFSB EBNB UVWP RVF EFWPMWFS MB DBTB CMBODB FM OJÁP Z RVF B QFTBS EF FTP IBCSFNPT EF EF DJS RVF OP MF QVTJFSPO +VBO BM OJÁP 2VF MBT QSPDMBNBT EF MPT QSPHSBNBT EF NPEFSOJ[BDJÂO EF DBNJPOFT VSCBOPT Z MB DJVEBE EJHJUBM DVNQMJFSPO TVT QSJNFSPT TFJT BÁPT FM OJÁP : ZB OP EJHBNPT MBT MMVWJBT FO FTUB DJVEBE RVF TJ MMVFWF NV DIP FM OJÁP RVF TJ OP MMVFWF FM OJÁP 2VF TJ MMVFWF SFHVMBS FM OJÁP RVF TJ MMVFWF QPDP FM OJÁP : OP IBCMBNPT EFM OJÁP WFSEF DBVTBOUF EF PUSP UJQP EF EBÁPT QFSP OP EF UFNCMPSFT 0USPT PQJOBS²O RVF MPT UFNCMPSFT TF EFCFO B RVF OVFT USP 7PMD²O EF $PMJNB TF FTU² SFBDPNPEBOEP MP RVF QVFEFO TFS VOB EF USFT DBVTBT VOPT PQJOBO RVF FM WPMD²O FTU² TPM UBOEP QSFTJÂO MP RVF FT NVZ TBOP QBSB FWJUBS MB BDVNVMB DJÂO EF HBTFT Z VO FTUBMMJEP QFPS QFSP PUSPT CBTBEPT FO PC TFSWBDJPOFT N²T QSPGVOEBT IBO DPOTJEFSBEP RVF MPT UFNCMPSFT TF EFSJWBO RVF FO MB MJUPTGFSB EFM WPMD²O FYJTUF VOB FTQFDJF EF BFSPQVFSUP EF OBWFT FTQBDJBMFT Z RVF FM NP WJNJFOUP EF PWOJT IB DBVTBEP GSBDUVSBT FO MB SFGFSJEB DBQB UFSS²RVFB Z FTP HFOFSB SFBDPNPEPT FO MBT DBQBT UFDUÂOJDBT FTUB UFPS½B IB TJEP BQPZBEB QPS UPEPT MPT GBO²UJDPT EF MB TB HB EF MB HVFSSB EF MBT HBMBYJBT RVF TF FODPOUSBCBO WJFOEP MB OVFWB DJOUB Z TJOUJFSPO MPT FGFDUPT Z B BMHVOPT IBTUB MPT EFTBMPKBSPO EF MBT TBMBT EF DJOF 6OB UFSDFSB RVF IB TJEP GVFSUFNFOUF OFHBEB QPS JOGPSNBOUFT HFOFSBMNFOUF NBM JO GPSNBEPT FT RVF FM DIBQP IB DPOUSBUBEP B VOPT FYQFSUPT QB SB IBDF VOPT UÈOFMFT WPMD²OJDPT ZB RVF TFHÈO MPT NJTNPT JOGPSNBOUFT FTU² DPOTUSVZFOEP VO SFGVHJP FTUP IB TJEP OF HBEP QPS QFSTPOBT RVF DFSDBOBT B MBT BVUPSJEBEFT EJDJFOEP RVF FTP FT JNQPTJCMF QFSP IBCSFNPT EF SFDPSEBS RVF FTUPT JOGPSNBOUFT BGJSNBSPO FO TV NPNFOUP RVF DPOTUSVJS VO UÈ OFM EF FTDBQF FO VO SFDMVTPSJP EF BMUB TFHVSJEBE FSB JNQP TJCMF QPS MP RVF UFOESFNPT RVF FTQFSBS B WFS RV¹ QBTB 1PS GPSUVOB MPT UFNCMPSFT OP IBO TJEP NVZ GVFSUFT Z OP IBO DBVTBEP NBZPSFT EBÁPT P TFB TPO UBO TÂMP VO UFNB EF DPOWFSTBDJÂO Z TJ VTUFE OP MP TJOUJÂ QVFT DPNP BRVFM QFS TPOBKF EF MB UFMF M²TUJNB .BSHBSJUP
À > ` Ê â? iâÊ ÃV Ì
"-Ê " ", -ÊÊ
Ê/ *"
<c X^l`eXc[f &O TV PSJHFO MB QBMBCSB TJHOJGJDBCB iSFHBMPw RVF MPT QVFCMPT DFMUBT TF EBCBO DPO NPUJWP EFM BÁP OVFWP -B DPTUVNCSF FSB DPNQBSUJEB UBNCJ¹O QPS PUSBT DVMUVSBT FO QBSUJDVMBS QPS MB TPDJFEBE SPNBOB EF EPOEF GVF BTVNJEB QPS MB DSJTUJBOEBE &M BHVJOBMEP DSJTUJBOP TFS² EFTEF MB FEBE BOUJHVB FM SFHBMP RVF TF PGSFDF DPO NPUJWP EF VO CBVUJTNP QFSP NVZ QSPOUP FM U¹SNJOP TF GVF BEFDVBOEP B MBT EPT QSJODJQBMFT GJFTUBT EF MB *HMFTJB MB &QJGBO½B Z MB 1BTDVB Z EF BI½ TFHVSBNFOUF QPS TV WFDJOEBE B MB GJFTUB EF /BWJEBE " EJGFSFODJB EF PUSPT QB½TFT DSJTUJBOPT FO FM JNQFSJP FTQBÁPM FM BHVJOBMEP TF GVF DJÁFOEP BM SFHBMP RVF MBT GB NJMJBT IBD½BO B HSVQPT EF QFSTPOBT TPCSF UPEP OJÁPT RVF DBOUBCBO WJMMBODJDPT OBWJEFÁPT GVFSB EF MBT DBTBT BOUF DFEFOUF EF MBT QPTBEBT NFYJDBOBT Z QPTUFSJPSNFOUF FM U¹SNJOP BDBCÂ BQMJD²OEPTF TPMBNFOUF B MPT SFHBMPT RVF MPT OJÁPT SFDJC½BO QPS FTUBT GJFTUBT %FTEF FTF FTQBDJP DVMUVSBM FM U¹SNJOP BHVJOBMEP QBTÂ B MB WJEB MBCPSBM IBTUB DPOTUJUVJSTF FO VOB PCMJHBDJÂO MF HBM FO OVNFSPTPT QB½TFT EF PSJHFO DSJTUJBOP DPOTFSWBO EP TV DBS²DUFS EF PCTFRVJP DPO NPUJWP EF MB /BWJEBE BD DJÂO RVF JODMV½B MB HSBUJUVE Z FM SFDPOPDJNJFOUP BM USBCBKP QSFTUBEP QPS MBT QFSTPOBT B TVT QBUSPOFT &M USBTGPOEP SFMJHJPTP QBHBOP EFM PSJHFO EF FTUB DPT UVNCSF FT VO FTU½NVMP B MB WJEB OVFWB RVF JOJDJB DPO FM BÁP OVFWP &M GPOEP DSJTUJBOP EFM BHVJOBMEP FT VO T½NJM FYUFS OP NBUFSJBM EFM HSBO SFHBMP RVF %JPT IB IFDIP B MB IV NBOJEBE FOWJ²OEPMF DPNP .FT½BT B TV QSPQJP )JKP SFHB MP EJWJOP RVF TJO FNCBSHP OP UPEPT MPT TFSFT IVNBOPT FTU²O EJTQVFTUPT B SFDJCJS &O MB WJEB EF OVFTUSP QB½T FM BHVJOBMEP MBCPSBM NBSDB VOB WF[ N²T FM TJTUFNB EF JOFRVJEBE Z EFTJHVBMEBEFT RVF MB NJTNB MFZ TVTUFOUB UPEB WF[ RVF FTUF iSFHBMPw FTU² TV KFUP B MB QFSDFQDJÂO TBMBSJBM EF MPT USBCBKBEPSFT DPO MP DV BM PDVSSF RVF RVJFOFT N²T HBOBO TPCSF UPEP FO MB FTGFSB HVCFSOBNFOUBM TFBO RVJFOFT N²T BHVJOBMEP SFDJCFO NJFOUSBT RVF MBT QFSTPOBT RVF N²T USBCBKBO Z NFOPT QFS DJCFO BMDBODFO BHVJOBMEPT NJTFSBCMFT 4J MPT WBMPSFT VOJWFSTBMFT EF MB FRVJEBE Z MB KVTUJDJB UVWJFTFO DBCJEB FO OVFTUSP QB½T EFCFS½B QSPDFEFSTF FYBD UBNFOUF BM DPOUSBSJP EF UBM GPSNB RVF TPCSF UPEP FO MPT ²NCJUPT EF HPCJFSOP FM BHVJOBMEP KVHPTP MP SFDJCJFSBO MPT NFOPT GBWPSFDJEPT FO TV TBMBSJP FO UBOUP RVF BRVFMMPT RVF MFHBM QFSP JONPSBMNFOUF HBOBO UBOUP SFDJCJFSBO VO BHVJ OBMEP N²T CJFO TJNCÂMJDP .F SFGJFSP B MPT ²NCJUPT EF HPCJFSOP OP QPSRVF MBT SFTQPOTBCJMJEBEFT P MBT DBSHBT TFBO BMM² NFOPSFT RVF FO PUSPT FTQBDJPT TJOP QPSRVF BM (PCJFSOP MP QBHBO UPEPT MPT DJVEBEBOPT TF USBUB QVFT EF SFDVSTPT QÈCMJDPT RVF OP QVF EFO EJMBQJEBSTF BMFHSFNFOUF FO PGFOTJWPT BHVJOBMEPT QB SB MB BMUB DMBTF QPM½UJDB NJFOUSBT RVF QPS PUSP MBEP MPT TFS WJDJPT QÈCMJDPT EF TBMVE BTJMP FEVDBDJÂO Z TFHVSJEBE Z UBOUPT PUSPT BOEBO UPEP FM UJFNQP FO MB NFOEJDJEBE OF HBOEP MB BUFODJÂO V PGSFDJ¹OEPMB EF MB NBOFSB N²T NJTF SBCMF QPSRVF OP IBZ EJOFSP i7JOP B MPT TVZPT QFSP MPT TVZPT OP MP SFDJCJFSPOw BGJS NB FM &WBOHFMJP EF +VBO PKBM² Z FO FTUB PDBTJÂO T½ QPEB NPT SFDJCJSMP EF TFS BT½ TF WFS² JONFEJBUBNFOUF FO MB USBOTGPSNBDJÂO EF OVFTUSPT WBMPSFT Z BDUJUVEFT BSNBOEP HPO!VOJWB NY
"UNPTG¹SJDBT 4F BDVFSEB FM KBSE½O EF DBEB HFTUP EF DBEB OPUB 1SJWJMF HJP EF MPT FTQBDJPT RVF DPOUJFOFO BM NVOEP EF MPT RVF FM DBSJÁP DPOT UBOUF F JNQMBDBCMF DPOTUSVZ /BEB FT JHVBM TF TBCF FM WJFKP HVBZBCP QPS FKFNQMP FT PUSP Z FM NJTNP B USBW¹T EF VO QSPDFTP RVF OP FYDMVZF FO TV DJFHP EFWFOJS OJ VO ²UPNP 1FSP QVFEF TFS RVF MP N²T JOBTJCMF MP RVF NFOPT TFB FWJEFOUF QFSNBOF[DB Z EVSF GJHVSBT RVF GVFSPO BM CPS EF EF TV GVHBDJEBE JODSF½CMF oFSBO QFOTBCB FM OJÁP QBSB TJFNQSF (FT UPT RVF EFTDPSS½BO VOB DPSUJOB USBT EF MB RVF TF QPO½B FO NPWJNJFOUP MB EVMDF NFD²OJDB NJMFOBSJB VO OJÁP EF QPSDFMBOB EFMBOUBMFT EF QBTUP SBT SJTBT TPGPDBEBT WPDFT Q²SWVMBT : VO FTUSFNFDJNJFOUP NVZ BOUJ HVP RVF TJO RVFSFSMP WPMW½B B MB DPODVSSFODJB UPEP VO QVFCMP : FM KBS E½O BUFOE½B HVBSEBCB MB DBEFODJB EF MPT WFSTPT JOPDFOUFT FO MBT JOTUSVDDJPOFT WFHFUBMFT RVF QPS EFDFOJPT IBCS½B EF SFQSPEVDJS $V²M SB NB FT BIPSB oMP TFS² FO FM GVUVSP FTF QSJNFS EFTMVNCSBNJFOUP RVF MB QBTUPSFMB TVTDJU ZB QPS TJFNQSF FO FM DPSB[ÂO EFM OJÁP 5FSNJOBCB MB GVODJÂO VO TFÁPS FODFOE½B FM DJHBSSP 1SJTDJMJBOP SFQBSU½B MPT WBTJUPT DPO FM QPODIF SPK½TJNP MB TFÁPSB EF MB DBTB TF BGBOBCB MFWFNFOUF FM QSÂYJNP U½P FO EFTBQBSFDFS NJSBCB TJO TBCFSMP QPS ÈMUJNB WF[ B MB QBS WBEB EF JOGBOUFT FOUSFHBEPT B MB SFCBUJOHB QPS PCUFOFS VO QFRVFÁP CP U½O EF DPMBDJPOFT oUFTPSPT EF QPS WJEB (ʽKPMBT TVFOBO UPEBW½B NVZ RVFEJUP &M KBSE½O CJFO RVF MBT PZF 4UFQIFO %VOO 5IF TUBJSXBZ 6OB TFÁBMBEB BNBCJMJEBE DJCFSO¹UJ DB USBF B MB QBOUBMMB VO QPFNB EFM WBUF OFPZPSLJOP $PNP VOB NÈTJDB RVF WJFOF EF NVZ MFKPT EF NVZ BOUFT SFDVFSEB Z NBUFSJBMJ[B WJTJPOFT Z UFOUBUJWBT BCSF WFOUBOBT Z PGSFDF MBT HSBEBT EF TVT WFSTPT QBSB MB FT QFDVMBDJÂO Z FM TVFÁP 7B VO FOTBZP EF USBEVDDJÂO -B FTDBMFSB &M BSRVJUFDUP RVFS½B DPOTUSVJS VOB FTDBMFSB Z TVTQFOEFSMB DPO BNBSSFT EF VOB QMBUB DBTJ JOWJTJCMF FO VOB IBCJUBDJÂO EF UFDIPT BMUPT VOB FTDBMFSB RVF OP QVEJFSB TFS BTDFOEJEB P EFTDFOEJEB FYDFQUP FO MPT TVFÁPT 1FSP QSJNFSP QPSRVF MBT DPTBT JOEÂNJUBT OP TPO G²DJMFT EF WFS TJ MP RVF B TV BMSFEFEPS FTU² FT JOEÂNJUP ¹M TF BTFHVSBS½B RVF MB DBTB RVF MB BMCFSHBSB GVFSB QS²DUJDB FEJGJDBEB QVOUBM B QVOUBM UFKB B UFKB TJO PSOBNFOUP -B FTDBMFSB TFS½B VOB JOWJUBDJÂO QBSB RVJFORVJFSB RVF TF TJOUJFSB QPS FMMB JOWJUBEP Z EFQFOEJFOEP EF TV SFBDDJÂO ¹M TBCS½B TJ MB BNJTUBE TFS½B QPTJCMF -B DBTB TFS½B TV QSPQJFEBE QFSP MB FTDBMFSB UFOES½B FM EFTJHOJP EF OP QFSUFOFDFS B OBEJF JODMJOBEB DPOUSB DVBMRVJFS TVHFSFODJB EF VOB UFPMPH½B EFDFQDJPOBOUF QBSB BRVFMMPT RVF CVTDBSBO MB QPM½UJDB 1PS TVQVFTUP RVF FM BSRVJUFDUP TVQP RVF B USBW¹T EF MPT BÁPT UFOES½B RVF MFWBOUBS PUSBT DPTBT B MB NBOFSB EF MP RVF PUSPT EFTFBS½BO TVQP RVF WJWJS FO FTUF NVOEP FT USPDBS VOBT QPDBT JOEVTUSJPTBT IPSBT QPS VOB RVF TFB CFMMB 4JO FNCBSHP DBEB OPDIF DVBOEP MMFHBCB B TV DBTB QPE½B JNBHJOBS NJFOUSBT DSV[BCB FM VNCSBM B TV FTDBMFSB ZFOEP B OJOHVOB QBSUF OP B MB WFOUB Z UBM WF[ B BMHVOPT EF VTUFEFT QBSB RVJFOFT OBEB BDFSDB EF FMMB OFDFTJUBCB FYQMJDBDJÂO FTQFSBOEP FM WJOP EFDBOUBEP MB OPDIF QPS EFTQVOUBS #SJHIUPO 3PDL )BZ MJCSPT RVF TPO DPNP VO TVUJM WFOFOP RVF BM DP
Õ iÀ Ê i > >ÀÞ
8* ", "Ê Ê 1 " &YJTUFO NVDIBT QFSTPOBT RVF B MP MBSHP EF TV WJEB FTU²O N²T BM QFO EJFOUF EF RVFSFS DPOUSPMBS B MPT EFN²T NFKPS RVF B T½ NJTNPT 1SPDVSBO FTUBS BM QFOEJFOUF EF MPT EFN²T FO MP RVF IBDFO P EF KBO B IBDFS TPO DBQBDFT EF DSJUJDBS DPSSFHJS Z EBS JOEJDBDJPOFT DPO UBM EF EFNPTUSBS RVF UJFOFO FM DPOUSPM EF MB TJUVBDJÂO *HVBM TF GJKBO FO MPT N²T N½OJNPT EFUBMMFT DPNP FO MB GPSNB EF WFTUJS FO MB EJFUB P IBTUB MB IJHJFOF EF MPT EFN²T QFSP OP TPO DBQB DFT EF GJKBSTF FO MP TVZP &M DPMNP FT RVF OP TÂMP MP PCTFSWBO Z MP QJFOTBO TJOP RVF UJFOFO MB PCTFTJÂO EF FTUBSMP NBOJGFTUBOEP B MPT EFN²T DPO TJHOPT FWJEFO UFT EF BVUPSJEBE Z EPNJOJP $PNP QPS FKFNQMP i/P UF QPOHBT FTPw i%¹KBUF EF w i5F EJKF RVF w i/P MP QPOHBT BMM½w i5F WFT DBOTBEPw i/P DVNQMJTUF w i5JFOFT RVF w FUD¹UFSB 4PO QFSTPOBT RVF FTUBCMFDFO MB TFHVSJEBE FO T½ NJTNPT B CBTF EF DPOUSPMBS MB EF MPT EFN²T : TVFMFO FODPOUSBS MB NBOFSB EF IBDFS MP EFTEF NBOJQVMBOEP IBTUB FKFSDJFOEP VOB GSBODB BVUPSJEBE Z EP NJOJP TPCSF FM EF MPT PUSPT
SSFS EF MBT Q²HJOBT TVSUF VO BSUFSP FGFDUP 1SJNFSP JONPWJMJ[B DPO TVT BSUJMVHJPT EF QBMBCSBT DVJEBEPTBNFOUF FTDPHJEBT DPO JN²HFOFT RVF TF BEJWJOBO IJKBT EF VOB MBSHB EFDBOUBDJÂO DPO QFSTPOBKFT RVF TBMFO EF MBT QFTBEJMMBT P MBT JNBHJOBDJPOFT N²T SFDÂOEJUBT "DUP TFHVJEP MPT MBS HPT IJMPT EF MB USBNB GPSNBO VOB SFE RVF TJO BWJTP BQSJTJPOB BM MFDUPS B MB WVFMUB EF VO DBQ½UVMP QSFDJTP -VFHP TFOUFODJBT RVF ZB OBEBO FO VO DPOUJOVP GPSNBEP QPS VO FTUBEP EF ²OJNP DVJEBEPTBNFOUF JOEVDJ EP WBO TFMMBOEP VOB Z PUSB WF[ FM JOWPMVOUBSJP US²OTJUP RVF TFQBSB MB SFB MJEBE DJSDVOEBOUF EF MB OP NFOPT SFBM VSEJNCSF RVF TF EFTEPCMB BOUF MPT PKPT BEFOUSP EF MB DPODJFODJB 1BTB BIPSB EF WF[ FO DVBOEP TPM½B TFS UBO GSFDVFOUF FO MB JOGBODJB OVODB DBODFMBEB 1FSP OP UPEPT MPT MJ CSPT RVF BUSBQBO BM ²OJNB UJFOFO FTUF FGFDUP TPMBNFOUF BRVFMMPT RVF o EF BMHVOB NBOFSB MP TBCFNPT IBO TJEP FTDSJUPT DPO MB QVOUB EF VOB QMVNB RVF EFTUFMMB DPO FM GJMP EF MB MPDVSB EFM HFOJP EF MB HSBDJB -B DBNQBNPDIB Z TV DBQVMMP "QBSFDJÂ DPNP MP IBDFO MBT DPTBT RVF EF UBOUP FTUBS BMM½ TF WVFMWFO JOWJTJCMFT $POUSB FM GPOEP EF MB Q¹SHPMB VOB IPKB N²T FO FM MBCPSJPTP BG²O EF SFDJCJS FM BJSF 6OB DBTVBMJEBE EFTDVCSF PUSB WJEB PUSP VOJWFSTP DPNQMFUP TPCSF VO D²OUBSP BMHVOB WF[ BIPHBEP FO VOB CÂWFEB DFOUFOBSJB VOB BOHVMPTB DBNQBNPDIB PCTFSWB DPO BMBSNBO UF JOUFOTJEBE B RVJFO MB NJSB $VJEB TV MBCPS DVNQMF DPO DFMP MBT JOTUSVD DJPOFT RVF EFTEF FM GPOEP EFM UJFNQP MF GVFSPO DPOGFSJEBT 5FKF DPO MB MFO UJUVE EF MPT TVFÁPT VO DBQVMMP QFSGFDUP 'BMUB EFDJS RVF FM QSFDJTP MVHBS FTDPHJEP FT JNQFDBCMF TPCSF FM D²OUBSP WVFMB JONÂWJM VOB QBMPNB EF CSPO DF CBKP DVZB BMB QSPQJDJB MPT USBCBKPT TF EFTBSSPMMBO 2VJFO UPEP FTUP EFT DVCSF OP QVFEF TJOP BDBUBS FM N½OJNP JONFOTP NJMBHSP EF MB WJEB RVF BWBO [B : TJHVFO MPT EJCVKPT RVF BMHP EF MB JOGJOJUB USBNB EFM DBQVMMP TJO EVEB IBCS²O EF HVBSEBS %F SFQFOUF FO VOB EF UBOUBT PKFBEBT MB DBNQBNPDIB OP FTU² ZB 2VFEB VOB FTUSVDUVSB QFSGFDUB CJFO QFHBEB B TV TPTU¹O CSJMMBO EP DPO VOPT EPSBEPT RVF MB DPSUF EF #J[BODJP IVCJFSB RVFSJEP TVZPT DPMP SFT JNQPTJCMFT RVF FM JOTFDUP TBCJP FTDPHJÂ QBSB NFKPS QFSQFUVBS B MPT EF TV FTQFDJF 2VFEB BIPSB FTQFSBS WFS RV¹ QBTB 4F TVDFEFO MPT E½BT Z UBM WF[ EFOUSP EF MB OBWF FTQM¹OEJEB EFTQJFSUBO B BMFOUBS MPT OVFWPT FNJTBSJPT RVF EFTQV¹T SFQFUJS²O DBEB VOP FM NJMBHSP EF MB WJEB RVF TJHVF FM GJOBM EFTJH OJP EF UPEP MP RVF FT $VMJBD²O -MVFWF FO FM KBSE½O CPU²OJDP Z MBT QBMNBT BTJFOUFO MFWF NFOUF BM JODMJOBS TVT IPKBT QPSUFOUPTBT &T UVQJEP FM UFNQPSBM Z MPT BWJP OFT WVFMBO B DJFHBT TPCSF MB TJFSSB BHSBEFDJEB IVSBÁB BMHVJFO TFHV SP OP IBCS² EF MMFHBS IPZ 1FSP BCBKP FM UFKJEP EFM BHVB WB FOWPMWJFOEP TBCJBNFOUF B UPEP MP RVF DSFDF B UPEP MP RVF FM TVFMP HFOFSPTP IBCS² EF QSPQJDJBS -PT NJOVUPT TF TVDFEFO OBEJF MMFHB 6O RVJDJP BWBSP TJS WF EF NJSBEPS Z BCSJHP Z FM SFUSBTP EF MPT DPOWPDBEPT TF WVFMWF VO SF HBMP UBO FTQM¹OEJEP DPNP MP TPO MPT EPOFT RVF OP TF FTQFSBO $BNJOBS MVFHP ZB EF QMBOP FOUSF MBT BWFOJEBT DPO FM HVTUP SFNPUP Z SFDVQFSB EP EF NPKBSTF Z TFS VOP DPO MB MMVWJB &M QBWJNFOUP GPSNB DPO TVT HSJF UBT BOFHBEBT EF QMBUB FM N²T GBTUVPTP EF MPT UBQFUFT %FTCPSEB FM MBS HP FTUBORVF EJDF FO TVT M½OFBT EF BHVB FM QSFDJTP SVNCP RVF FM OVFWP KBSE½O IBCS² EF TFHVJS .¹YJDP FO MB PTDVSJEBE BCSJHB oOPDUVSOPT NJMBHSPT UPEB MB QPTJ CJMJEBE RVF B EJBSJP MFWBOUB VO NVOEP : EF UPEPT FTPT QSPQÂTJUPT RVF DPOGPSNBO VOB TPMB F JONFOTB FYJTUFODJB EFTQJBEBEB Z B MB WF[ NJTUF SJPTBNFOUF DPNQBTJWB VOP IBZ RVF DPO QBDJFODJB HVBSEB VOB MV[ MB EFM MVHBS EFM UFRVJMB MPT BNJHPT MBT QBMBCSBT RVF TBMWBO MB OPDIF MPT SFTQMBOEPSFT EF MPT E½BT RVF WJFOFO KQBMPNBS!JOGPSNBEPS DPN NY
:fekiªcXk\ k°# ef X cfj [\d j &T N²T TF FOPKBO TJ MFT EJDFT RVF FTU²O NBOJQVMBOEP QVFT UJF OFO MB DPOWJDDJÂO EF RVF MP IBDFO QPS FM CJFO EFM PUSP Z RVF TV TJTUF NB EF DPNFOUBSJPT FT QBSB BZVEBS B MPT EFN²T &TUP {RV¹ UJFOF RVF WFS DPO MBT BEJDDJPOFT 1VFT IBZ NVDIPT BEJDUPT RVF IBO DSFDJEP BM MBEP EF VO GBNJMJBS RVF FT TVNBNFOUF DPOUSPMBEPS Z EPNJOBOUF FOUPODFT FO TV BG²O EF TBDVEJSTF FTF GBTUJEJP TF BMFKBO NP MFTUPT QFSP QPS TFS EFQFOEJFOUFT EF VO NPEFMP EF WJEB DPOUSPMBEPS OP TBCFO RV¹ IBDFS DPOTJHP &T EFDJS BQSFOEJFSPO B WJWJS CBKP FM DPOUSPM EF MPT EFN²T Z OPT MFT FOTFÁBSPO B DPOUSPMBSTF B T½ NJTNPT "T½ RVF DVBOEP FTU²O TPMPT Z IBO DPORVJTUBEP VOB DJFSUB MJCFS UBE G²DJMNFOUF DBFO FO MB UFOUBDJÂO EF FODPOUSBS BMHP EF RVF EFQFO EFS QBSB BZVEBSTF B UFOFS N²T TFHVSJEBE : EFTEF MVFHP WBO B SFQFUJS FM FTRVFNB RVF BQSFOEJFSPO $PO USPMBS B MPT EFN²T Z OP B T½ NJTNPT : QPS FMMP VOB WF[ RVF FT EFQFO EJFOUF EF BMHP /P TBCFO OJ QVFEFO DPOUSPMBSTF OFDFTJUBO EF BMHVJFO RVF MPT BZVEF &OTFÁB DPOUSPM²OEPUF B UJ Z OP B MPT EFN²T
>À ÃÊ ÀÌjÃÊ6?âµÕiâ
6 - $ Ê9Ê - $
:feXZlckX
4V DPOWFSTJÂO B 4FDSFUBS½B EF &TUBEP DPO BUSJCVDJPOFT PCMJHBDJPOFT F NPWJFOEP MB JNQPSUBDJÂO EF VTPT Z DPTUVNCSFT DPO NÈMUJQMFT SFGPSNBT JOEFQFOEFODJB BETDSJUB BM S¹HJNFO 'FEFSBM DPOEVDF B DPOTJEFSBS N²T JOGMVZFOUFT FO FM DPNQPSUBNJFOUP NFEJBOUF MB FMFDDJÂO EF MB $VMUVSB BMM² EF BQPZP BSU½TUJDP MB GVODJÂO JNQVMTPSB EF MB JEFOUJEBE Z EJHOJEBE FOUSF UBOUPT MB WJBMJEBE EF DPOEVDUPSFT Z QFBUPOFT RVF UBOUP BGFDUB FO MBT QPCMBDJPOFT QSJODJQBMNFOUF VSCBOBT DPNP FT FM DBTP EF (VBEBMB EF MB QPCMBDJÂO 3BGBFM 5PWBS Z EF 5FSFTB QSFTJEFOUF EFM $POTFKP /BDJPOBM QBSB MB KBSB EPOEF OP TF BQMJDBO SFHMBNFOUPT DPNP QSFUFOEF IBDFSMP FM %JT $VMUVSB Z MBT "SUFT $POBDVMUB QPTJCMF TFDSFUBSJP SFQSFTFOUB VO IF USJUP 'FEFSBM B QFTBS EF MBT DPOUSPWFSTJBT Z BUBRVFT BM HPCFSOBOUF .BO DIP IJTUÂSJDP DPO FM DPSSFTQPOEJFOUF SFHJTUSP FO MPT BOBMFT EFM QB½T 4V DFSB -B DVMUVSB EFM DVJEBEP Z DPOTFSWBDJÂO EF DBMMFT Z BWF GVODJÂO TFHVSBNFOUF DVNQMJS² QSPQÂTJUPT FTDMBSFDFEPSFT OJEBT B QBSUJS EFM BQFHP BM BQSFDJP EF IBCJUBOUFT Z QSPQJF EF IFDIPT JODMVZFOUFT EF QB[ DPO FYDMVTJÂO EF FTDMBWJUVE UBSJPT FO VO QSPDFTP EF DPOWFODJNJFOUP TPCSF FM QSPQJP F JHOPSBODJB RVF OPT NBSDB Z EBO DVSTP B MB WJEB FO FM TJ >ÊVÕ ÌÕÀ>Ê « V>ÊÊ WBMPS Z DPO ¹M EF MB JEFOUJEBE Z EJHOJEBE EF WJEB QMBDFOUF HMP BDUVBM EF BDVFSEP B QBS²NFUSPT DJFOU½GJDPT Z UFDOPM HJDPT EF QBSUJDJQBDJÂO FO FM DPODJFSUP HMPCBM >Ê> Ì>ÊÀië Ã>L `>`ÊÊ SB Z NPUJWP EF MFH½UJNP PSHVMMP EF MPT QPCMBEPSFT -P BO UFSJPS TJO TPTMBZBS MB BDUJWJEBE BSU½TUJDB EF SFOPNCSF DP 1SFTFSWBS MB USBORVJMJEBE FO VO DMJNB EF QB[ Z QSPT `iÊ` > }>ÀÊ>ViÀV>ÊÊ NP MB 'FSJB *OUFSOBDJPOBM EFM -JCSP RVF SFCBTB GSPOUFSBT Z QFSJEBE FT QSJPSJEBE B MB RVF DPOUSJCVZF MB DVMUVSB FO FM `iÊ >Ê « ÀÌ> V >ÊÊ MF EB SFDPOPDJNJFOUP B MB DJVEBE TFOUJEP UPUBM B QBSUJS EFM FKFNQMP Z DPNQPSUBNJFOUP FO MB -B &EVDBDJÂO OP QVFEF TPTMBZBSTF FO MB BNQMJB SFMB GBNJMJB DPOUJOVBEP FO FM BVMB ¹TUB EF BDVFSEP B MJOFBNJFO µÕiÊ V ÕÞiÊV Ûi ViÀÊÊ DJÂO EF FMFNFOUPT DPBEZVWBOUFT EF JNQBSUJDJÂO EF DVMUV UPT EF SFTQPOTBCJMJEBE FO FM FKFSDJDJP Z QS²DUJDB EFM FTUV `iÊÀië Ã>L `>`ÊÊ SB BDPSEF B DBEB NFUSÂQPMJ EF BDVFSEP B TVT DPOEJDJPOFT EJBOUF EF UPEP OJWFM I½CSJEBT RVF QSFWBMFDFO QPS BOUPOPNBTJB Z QPS MP NJTNP -B DVMUVSB JNQMJDB MB BMUB SFTQPOTBCJMJEBE EF EJBMPHBS ÞÊÀiëiÌ SFRVJFSFO VO USBUBNJFOUP DBTV½TUJDP QBSB FM DPOWFODJ BDFSDB EF MB JNQPSUBODJB RVF JODMVZF DPOWFODFS EF SFTQPO NJFOUP EF MB QPCMBDJÂO JOGMVJEB BIPSB QPS MPT NFEJPT EF TBCJMJEBE Z SFTQFUP QPS QBSUF EF MB QPCMBDJÂO B USBW¹T EF DPNVOJDBDJÂO FO TVT EJGFSFOUFT BDFQDJPOFT FO VO DBNCJP CFOFGJDJPT Z FMJNJOBDJÂO EFM SJFTHP RVF DPOMMFWB MB USBOT HSFTJÂO RVF QPS EFTHSBDJB OPT UJFOF JONFSTPT FO EJGFSFOUFT FYQSFTJP TJO QSFDFEFOUF F JSSFGSFOBCMF -B DVMUVSB EFCFS² JODMVJS QPS DPOWJDDJÂO OFT EFMJDUJWBT &TUP ÈMUJNP TJO MMFHBS BM FNQMFP EF MBT BSNBT F JNQPTJ IPOFTUJEBE Z USBOTQBSFODJB $POWJDDJÂO Z USBOTQBSFODJB DJÂO EF GVFS[B QÈCMJDB %JPT OPT HVBSEF EF MB EJTDPSEJB -B QSPTQFDDJÂO EF MB DVMUVSB EFCFS² JOGMVJS QPTJUJWBNFOUF FO FM TJO TJDQN!JOGPSNBEPS DPN NY DSFUJTNP JC¹SJDP EF MB $PMPOJB Z FTUBEPVOJEFOTF EF MB BDUVBMJEBE QSP
%PNJOHP EF EJDJFNCSF EF
1~(*/" #
&- */'03."%03
6/ /&(0$*0 3&%0/%0 &EHBS 1BOUPKB DFMFCSB FM FTQBDJP EPOEF IBZ PQPSUVOJEBE EF WFOEFS BRVFMMP FO MP RVF TF DSFF Z EF EPOEF TBMF QBSB NVDIBT GBNJMJBT
$0/$*&350 "ZFS MB GJFTUB GVF FTQFDJBM FM BOJWFSTBSJP FTUVWP BDPNQBĂ&#x2014;BEP EF NĂ&#x17E;TJDB '0504 &- */'03."%03 t 1 '3"/$0
%& 50%0 6/ 10$0 1BSB NVDIPT FM 5JBOHVJT $VMUVSBM DPOUJOĂ&#x17E;B TJFOEP FM FT QBDJP EPOEF TF QVFEF TFS VOP NJTNP Z FODPOUSBS MP RVF TFB
De perseguidos a promotores de ideas:
20 aĂąos de â&#x20AC;&#x153;El Cultuâ&#x20AC;?
&M 5JBOHVJT $VMUVSBM DFMFCSB EPT E DBEBT EF EJWFSTJEBE NVMUJDVMUVSBMJEBE N°TJDB Z NVDIB CVFOB WJCSB 1PS *MTF .BSU½OF[
:
B OP JNQPSUB TJ TPO QVOLT NFUBMF SPT SPDLFSPT SBTUBGBSJT DIPMPT GSF TBT P GVUCPMFSPT UPEPT UJFOFO DBCJ EB FO FM 5JBOHVJT $VMUVSBM EF (VBEBMBKBSB Z OP TĂ&#x201A;MP FTP TJOP RVF FODVFOUSBO BSU½DVMPT QFOTBEPT QBSB FMMPT QMBZFSBT UB[BT QFMVDIFT BMUFSOBUJWPT DBD UVT DPNJEB WFHFUBSJBOB JOTUSVNFOUPT NVTJDBMFT JODJFOTPT BSUF XJY²SJLB QJFSDJOHT SPQB MFOUFT QFM½DVMBT EF DVMUP KVHVFUFT BOJNF DBNJTFUBT EF GVUCPM DBEFOBT UPEP UJQP EF EJTDPT Z N²T DPTBT RVF TF WFOEFO P JOUFSDBNCJBO DBEB T²CBEP 1FSP IBDF BĂ PT DVBOEP FM FTQBDJP OBDJĂ&#x201A; GSFOUF BM &Y $POWFOUP EFM $BSNFO Â&#x2030;FO FM +BSE½O EFM $BSNFOÂ&#x2030; DPO BQFOBT DVBUSP P DJODP FYQPTJUP SFT IPZ IBZ N²T EF OP IBC½B UBOUB UPMFSBODJB OJ BQPZP EF MBT BVUPSJEBEFT FM $FOUSP UBQBU½P EF MPT OPWFOUB DSF½B RVF MPT DPNFSDJBOUFT EF i&M $VMUVw BGFBCBO MB DJVEBE Z MPT EFUSBDUPSFT IJDJFSPO UPEP MP RVF FTUVWP B TV BMDBODF QBSB BNJOPSBS MPT ²OJNPT EF BRVFMMPT RVF CVTDBCBO FYQSFTBSTF EJGFSFOUF B MP iOPSNBMw 'SBDBTBSPO #FOKBN½O 2VJSBSUF RVJFO IB TJEP QBSUF EF FT UF QSPZFDUP EFTEF TV TFHVOEP E½B SFDVFSEB MBT QFS TFDVDJPOFT RVF QBEFDJFSPO DPNP TJ IVCJFSB TJEP BZFS Z DPO PSHVMMP DVFOUB RVF MPHSBSPO HBOBSTF FM SFTQFUP EF FTPT BHFOUFT RVF OP MPT RVFS½BO TĂ&#x201A;MP QPS RVF iBOE²CBNPT WFTUJEPT EF OFHSPw i-P RVF OPT EFD½B MB QPMJD½B Â&#x2030;PCWJBNFOUF OP MP EFDMBSBCBO FO MPT NFEJPTÂ&#x2030; FT RVF BGF²CBNPT MB DJVEBE RVF FT U²CBNPT NVZ GFPT RVF OP FSB VO MVHBS QBSB RVF FT UVWJšSBNPT OPTPUSPT TJOP QBSB MBT GBNJMJBT Z MBT QFSTPOBT OPSNBMFT Z OPTPUSPT MFT EFD½BNPT RVF BVORVF OPT WFTU½BNPT EF GPSNB EJTUJOUB OP šSBNPT EJGFSFOUFT TJOP RVF UFO½BNPT VOB NBOFSB EJTUJOUB EF FYQSFTBSOPTw &M M½EFS EF MB CBOEB EF QVOL 'BMMBT EFM 4JTUFNB DVFOUB RVF TF FNQF[BSPO B KVOUBS NVDIPT KĂ&#x201A;WFOFT FO FM UJBOHVJT QPS MP RVF QFSTPOBT EF MB JHMFTJB RVF FTU² BM MBEP TF BTVTUBCBO Z FO DPOTFDVFODJB MB QP MJD½B FNQF[Ă&#x201A; B EFUFOFS Z MMFWBS B MB D²SDFM QPS OBEB B UPEPT MPT iSPDLFSTw i'VF VOB MVDIB DPNP EF EPT
LNLM>GMH => ?:FBEB:L
Edgar Pantoja, quien tambiĂŠn formĂł parte de La Comuna Libertaria, creĂł su propia marca de ropa llamada Radical Tenders con la cual ayuda en la economĂa familiar y sin dejar de lado la â&#x20AC;&#x153;contraculturaâ&#x20AC;?. â&#x20AC;&#x153;La contracultura es todo lo que es cultura que se opone a la cultura establecida, mĂĄs que nada son alternativas, otras formas de vida. Nosotros hacemos ropa de una manera autogestiva. Fabri-
camos la playera, las prendas, las imprimimos. Los mismos amigos me ayudan a trabajar, como nosotros fabricamos hay otras dos familias que se benefician, por ejemplo la persona que me cose, que me corta, generamos trabajoâ&#x20AC;?. AcompaĂąado de su esposa y de su hijo, quien lo abraza cuando le toman una fotografĂa, atiende un puesto lleno de playeras de Ăconos culturales, como una de Edgar Allan Poe. â&#x20AC;&#x153;El Tianguis Cultural ha
BĂ PT QBSB RVF OPT EFKBSBO FO QB[ FO FTB šQPDB RVF DPNFO[BCB FM UJBOHVJT šSBNPT MPT QSJNFSPT RVF NPMFTUBCBO 1FSP OPT FNQF[BNPT B PSHBOJ[BS Z EF TFS MPT QSJNFSPT RVF EFUFO½BO QBTBNPT B TFS MPT Ă&#x2C6;OJDPT RVF OP /PT DPTUĂ&#x201A; NVDIP USBCBKP TĂ&#x201A;MP DBNJ OBS FO MB DBMMF Z WFTUJS EF MB GPSNB RVF RVFS½BNPTw i.JOw SFNFNPSB RVF IBDF BĂ PT FSB N²T VO UJBOHVJT EF BSUFTBO½BT EF MJCSPT Z DPTBT DVMUVSBMFT Z FMMPT Â&#x2030;MPT EF MB DPNVOB JOUFHSBEB QPS NVKF SFT Z IPNCSFTÂ&#x2030; MMFWBSPO MB NĂ&#x2C6;TJDB FO FTQFDJBM FM SPDL i-P RVF IBD½BNPT BM QSJODJQJP FSB JOUFS DBNCJP USVFRVF Z FO FM DPMFDUJWP MMFHBNPT B BDUJ WJEBEFT DPNP QFRVFĂ PT DPODJFSUPT MFDUVSB EF QPFNBT DPTBT FDPMPHJTUBT QPTJUJWBT OPT BDPNQB Ă BCBO BSUJTUBT UBNCJšO EF IJQ IPQ P NFUBMw 6OB WF[ RVF MMFHBSPO B 1MB[B +V²SF[ TV BDUVBM NPSBEB TJHVJFSPO DPO MB NJTNB GJMPTPG½B BVORVF DPO NVDIPT N²T FYQPTJUPSFT i%F TFS QFRVFĂ P Z DPNQMFUBNFOUF DPOUSBDVMUVSBM TF IB IFDIP VO UJBOHVJT EF MB EJWFSTJEBE ZB OP TPMBNFOUF FT SPDL TJOP RVF IBZ NVDIBT NPWJEBT " N½ NF HVTUB NV DIP JODMVTJWF FO TV NPNFOUP OPT EFD½BO JOEFTFB EPT Z BIPSB FT QSPNPWJEP B OJWFM OBDJPOBM DPNP VO MVHBS QBSB WJTJUBSw 2VJSBSUF DVZP QVFTUP PGFSUB QMBZFSBT EJTDPT Z DPNJEB WFHFUBSJBOB SFTBMUB RVF BVORVF ZB OP UJF OFO FM DPMFDUJWP EF -B $PNVOB -JCFSUBSJB TJHVFO IBDJFOEP BDUJWJEBEFT RVF UJFOFO RVF WFS DPO MB FDP MPH½B V PUSBT DPNP MB EFM EPNJOHP QBTBEP EF iQVOL QJDOJDw i"VORVF RVJFOFT WBNPT ZB OP OPT WFNPT
tenido un crecimiento tanto positivo como negativo, tenemos una forma de alimentar a familias, lo negativo es que se ha comercializado con productos como lentes que no tienen nada que ver con lo cultural. Lo positivo es que sigue habiendo gente como empezĂł. Hay quienes siguen haciendo proyectos de trabajo comunitario o colectivos, hacen publicaciones, videos, sigue habiendo distribuciĂłnâ&#x20AC;?.
UBO QVOL MP JNQPSUBOUF EFM NPWJNJFOUP FSBO MBT JEFBT RVF TPO TPMJEBSJEBE BQPZP NVUVP /PT HVT UB QPSRVF FT VO MVHBS EPOEF EJGVOEJNPT MBT JEFBT BRV½ WJFOFO NVDIPT KĂ&#x201A;WFOFT IBDFNPT UBMMFSFT QSFTFOUBDJPOFT EF MJCSPT IB FWPMVDJPOBEP TBUJT GBDUPSJBNFOUFw
6O MVHBS QBSB MB J[RVJFSEB i-B IJTUPSJB EF MPT 7JLJOHPTw i-BT NVKFSFT FO MB J[RVJFSEBw Z PUSPT U½UVMPT TF QVFEFO DPNQSBS FO FM QVFTUP EF (BCSJFM RVJFO QFSUFOFDF B MB PSHBOJ [BDJĂ&#x201A;O i3PKPT Z BOBSRVJTUBT TLJOIFBET 3BTI TFD DJĂ&#x201A;O (VBEBMBKBSBw &M JOUFHSBOUF BDUJWP FYQMJDB RVF EJTUSJCVZFO DPTBT DPOUSBDVMUVSBMFT RVF UJFOFO RVF WFS DPO MB JEFPMPH½B EFM DPMFDUJWP i&T TPCSF FM BOBS RVJTNP UFYUPT QFM½DVMBT Z NĂ&#x2C6;TJDB GPMDMĂ&#x201A;SJDB RVF BMHVOPT DPNFO[BNPT FTDVDIBOEP y NĂ&#x2C6;TJDB RVF FT EF J[RVJFSEB 4PO UFYUPT RVF ZP NF FODBSHP EF BSNBS Z RVF GPSNBO QBSUF EF MB IJTUPSJB J[RVJFSEJT UB EF .šYJDP EF MP RVF QBTBCB FO MPT BĂ PT TFTFO UB Z TFUFOUBw 1BSB (BCSJFM FO MPT BĂ PT EFM 5JBOHVJT $VM UVSBM IB IBCJEP VOB iEFTFWPMVDJĂ&#x201A;Ow EFCJEP B RVF IBO EFKBEP RVF TF JOUFHSFO NVDIPT FYQPTJUPSFT RVF OP PGFSUBO BSU½DVMPT SFMBDJPOBEPT DPO MB DVMUV SB i-B NBZPS½B RVF FNQF[BCB WFOE½B EJTDPT NĂ&#x2C6; TJDB SPDL UFYUPT MJCSPT BIPSB WFT VO UJBOHVJT OPSNBM OP UJFOF ZB OBEB EF DVMUVSB DPO SPQB FO TFSJF MFOUFT RVF B MB WF[ OP FT NBMP QFSP TJ TF MMB NB UJBOHVJT DVMUVSBM UJFOF RVF TFS TPCSF DVMUVSBw
>E MB:G@NBL OBO> Ă&#x2039;NG FHF>GMH LB@GB?B<:MBOHĂ&#x152;
Antonio Robles, presidente del Tianguis Cultural de Guadalajara y encargado del foro, considera que el espacio vive un â&#x20AC;&#x153;momento significativoâ&#x20AC;? que coincide con el cambio de administraciĂłn, la cual ha lanzado buenas seĂąales. â&#x20AC;&#x153;El tianguis nace en 1995, a partir del 2002 el Ayuntamiento toma la administraciĂłn y lo intenta transformar en algo comercial, olvidando que somos un proyecto de promociĂłn culturalâ&#x20AC;?. SeĂąala que la lucha ha sido por que se reconozca como un espacio diferente, algo que han logrado a cuentagotas: â&#x20AC;&#x153;Por ejemplo se hizo un reglamento, que es particular, que es reglamento exclusivamente para nosotros. Actualmente somos administrados por la DirecciĂłn de Cultura de Guadalajara, ya hay reconocimiento. Tenemos un padrĂłn de casi 600 expositores, pero aparte hay otros que se toleran, calculamos que somos 650â&#x20AC;?. Para el festejo del 20 aniversario, las autoridades de â&#x20AC;&#x153;El Cultuâ&#x20AC;? realizaron un concierto (apoyado con la producciĂłn del Ayuntamiento de Guadalajara) con las bandas La Minerva, No tiene la Vaca, Zanate y asociados, Cavarett Noise Colective y La Mugrosa Ska, que dio su Ăşltimo show acompaĂąada de invitados especiales y con canciones que hace aĂąos no tocaban. Racho GutiĂŠrrez, bajista y fundador del grupo, compartiĂł que eligieron despedirse de su pĂşblico en el Tianguis Cultural porque fue de los primeros espacios que les dieron la oportunidad de tocar. â&#x20AC;&#x153;Creemos que todo ciclo tiene un final, en esta ocasiĂłn nos toca despuĂŠs de nueve aĂąos de estar tocando con este proyecto. Creemos que ya llegĂł la hora de dejar esto, no sabemos si en pausa o definitivo, pero por el momento vamos a terminar con este ciclo. Anuar â&#x20AC;&#x201D;el bateristaâ&#x20AC;&#x201D;, mi hermano, y yo vamos al extranjero a formar otros proyectosâ&#x20AC;?.
1~(*/" #
&- */'03."%03 &- */'03."%03
%PNJOHP EF EJDJFNCSF EF
>À >Ê*> >À
-/ -Ê,1 - /" "Ê",/1!"
Ê /1, -ÊÊ 6 , -
Aguafiestas 6
OB DPOPDJEB RVF MMFWB NF EJB WJEB FOHVMMFOEP BOUJEF QSFTJWPT DPNP TJ TF USBUBSB EF EVMDFDJUPT EF NFOUB UJF OF MB DPTUVNCSF EF BOVODJBS QBSB UPEP BRVFM RVF EFTFF FTDVDIBSMB QPS BI½ EFM EF OPWJFNCSF EF DBEB BÁP i$ÂNP NF HVTUBS½B EPSNJSNF Z EFTQFSUBS FO FOFSP ZB RVF IBZB QBTBEP UP EP FTUP RVF TF OPT WJFOFw $PO iUPEP FTUPw TF SFGJFSF EFTEF MVFHP B MBT GJFTUBT EFDFN CSJOBT QPTBEBT EF MB PGJDJOB MB GBNJMJB Z MPT WFDJOPT JOUFSDBNCJPT EFTBZVOJUPT DPO MBT BNJHBT DFOB EF OPDIFCVFOB DFOB EF "ÁP 7JFKP WJTJUB B MPT DFOUSPT DPNFSDJBMFT DPNQSB Z FOWPMUVSB EF SFHBMPT HVJTPT SFDBMFOUBEPT FUD¹ UFSB -PT RVF PEJBO FTUBT GFDIBT TPO VOB MFHJÂO PTDVSB Z DSFDJFOUF DPO MB RVF IBZ RVF BQSFOEFS B SFMBDJPOBS TF #²TJDBNFOUF QPSRVF MB NBZPS½B EF RVJFOFT MB JOUFHSBO OP QVFEFO DVNQMJS TV NBZPS EFTFP RVF DPOTJT UF FO QFSEFS MB DPODJFODJB P BM NF OPT FO FTDBQBSTF B #BIS¹JO P BMHÈO PUSP TJUJP EPOEF OP DFMFCSFO MB /BWJ EBE Z QPS FMMP UFOFNPT RVF TPQPSUBS MPT P FMMPT UJFOFO RVF TPQPSUBSOPT UP EP EFQFOEF EFM QVOUP EF WJTUB DPO TVT DBSPUBT EF UFEJP Z IPSSPS {1PS RV¹ BMHVJFO MMFHB B EFUFTUBS EJ DJFNCSF TJ UPEP FM NFT FTU² QFOTBEP QBSB DPNFS QPSRVFS½BT EFTWFMBSTF CFCFS HBT UBS EJOFSP Z WFS HFOUF FO UFPS½B RVFSJEB FT EFDJS QBSB QBT²STFMP CPNCB -BT SB[POFT TPO NÈMUJQMFT 1PS FKFNQMP MB DPOPDJEB B MB RVF IBD½B SFGFSFODJB BM QSJODJQJP EF FTUF UFYUP UJFOF VO FYQFEJFOUF EF EFTHSBDJBT EFDFNCSJOBT MFHFOEBSJP RVF SFTQBMEB TV FTUSFNFDJNJFOUP DVBOEP FSB OJÁB TV QB ESF FTUSFMMÂ FM BVUP EF MB GBNJMJB BM SFHSF TP EF VOB QPTBEB Z B FMMB RVF JCB EPSNJ EB MF RVFEÂ VOB DJDBUSJ[ FO MB CBSCJMMB FO PUSB QPTBEB ZB BEVMUB EFTDVCSJÂ RVF TV NBSJEP MF FSB JOGJFM DPO VOB BHFOUF EF TF HVSPT Z QFOTBCB EFKBSMB OPN²T RVF QBTB SB %½B EF 3FZFT TV HBUP FO DVZP DBSJÁP TF SFGVHJÂ MVFHP EF MB TFQBSBDJÂO TBMUÂ QPS MB WFOUBOB FTQBOUBEP QPS MPT DPIFUFT EFM BÁP OVFWP EFM Z IVCP RVF MFWBO UBSMP EFM TVFMP DPO FTQ²UVMB QPSRVF WJ
W½BO FO VO RVJOUP QJTP $PO FTP ZB UJFOF QBSB QBTBS FM SFTUP EF MB WJEB FO UFSBQJB 1FSP NVDIPT PUSPT UJFOFO SB[POFT NF OPT DPODSFUBT Z RVF QSPDFEFO EF VOB GJMP TPG½B EF WJEB RVF FMMPT MMBNBO iDPOHSVFO UFw Z FM SFTUP EFM QMBOFUB iQVSJUBOBw .F SFGJFSP B RVJFOFT PEJBO FM NFSDBOUJMJTNP EFTQSFDJBO FM TFOUJNFOUBMJTNP Z SFOJFHBO EF iMB PCMJHBDJÂO EF FTUBS GFMJ[w QFSP FO WF[ EF SF½STF EF FMMP TF BNBSHBO Z BQSPWFDIBO DBEB PDBTJÂO RVF TF MFT QPOF EF NPEP QB SB JOUFOUBS RVF RVJFOFT MPT SP EFBO TF TJFOUBO NBM QPS TFS GS½WPMPT F JODPOTJTUFOUFT i{/FDFTJUBT BMHP EF
:Xc\e[Xi`fj mXi`fj
FTUP w MFT EJDFO QPS FKFNQMP B MPT OJÁPT B MPT RVF WFO SPEFBEPT QPS VO NBS EF KVHVF UFT MB NBÁBOB EFM EF EJDJFNCSF i{:B TF QVTJFSPO B QFOTBS FO RVJFOFT OP UJFOFO OJ VOB UPSUJMMB EVSB QBSB MMFWBSTF B MB CPDB w MFT EFDMBSBO B TVT QSJNPT FO DVBOUP TF USJO DIB FM QBWP -B WFSEBE FT RVF FMMPT UBNCJ¹O UJFOFO DPTBT RVF OP OFDFTJUBO Z KBN²T IBO EFEJDBEP VO TFHVOEP EF TV E½B B FDIBSMF VOB NBOP B MPT EFTGBWPSFDJEPT QFSP QBSB GJOFT EF BUPSNFOUBS B MPT EFN²T TPO DBQB DFT EF QPTBS EF .BESF 5FSFTB EF $BMDVUB Z TFÁBMBS FM QFDBEP BKFOP DPO ½OEJDF EF GVF HP i{4BC½BT RVF FTF BQBSBUP MP GBCSJDÂ VO OJÁP DIJOP RVF WJWF FO MB FTDMBWJUVE w MF BTFTUBO BM QPCSF RVF BOEB UBO DPOUFOUP FT DVDIBOEP NÈTJDB FO VO NQ : MP IBDFO BVORVF MMFWFO FO FM CPMTJMMP VO BQBSBUP JE¹OUJDPy QFSP RVF GVF DPNQSBEP FO KVOJP P FO GFCSFSP Z QPS UBOUP OP FT TPTQFDIPTP QBSB FM BDVTBEPS EF IJ QPDSFT½B OBWJEFÁB 5BOUP SFUPSDJNJFOUP NF UF NP TÂMP FT PUSB GPSNB EF UFSNJ OBS [BNCVMMJEPT FO MB GFMJDJ EBE QM²TUJDB EF MB ¹QPDB
3"'"&-&%8"3%4 $0.
/P FT G²DJM QBSB MPT IJTUPSJBEPSFT EFUFSNJOBS FO RV¹ GFDIB PDVSSJ BMHP QPSRVF TJFNQSF EFCFO UFOFS FO DVFOUB MBT EJTUJOUBT NBOFSBT EF DPOUBS FM UJFNQP TFHÈO MB ¹QPDB Z FM MVHBS 1PS FKFNQMP *TBBD /FXUPO OBDJ P CJFO FO FM EF EJDJFNCSF P FO FM EF FOFSP EFQFOEJFOEP EF TJ TF FTU² VTBOEP FM DBMFOEBSJP KVMJBOP RVF QPS FOUPODFT TFHV½B FO WJHPS FO *OHMBUFSSB P FM HSFHPSJBOP 1PS MB NJTNB SB[ÂO $FSWBOUFT Z 4IBLFTQFBSF NVSJFSPO FO MB NJT NB GFDIB FM EF BCSJM EF QFSP OP FM NJTNP E½B &O TVT &O TBZPT MJCSP *** DBQ½UVMP .POUBJHOF EFTDSJCF MBT EJGJDVMUBEFT EF TVT DPOUFNQPS²OFPT QBSB BEBQUBSTF BM OVFWP DBMFOEBSJP Z RVF B ¹M NJTNP TF MF DPNQMJDBCB DBMDVMBS TV FEBE 6O DBTP NVZ FTQFDJBM FT FM EF 4BOUB 5FSFTB EF WJMB EF DV ZP OBDJNJFOUP TF DFMFCSBSPO RVJOJFOUPT BÁPT FO NVSJ FO QSFDJTBNFOUF MB OPDIF EFM KVFWFT BM WJFSOFT EF PD UVCSF MPT E½BT JOUFSNFEJPT TJNQMFNFOUF OP FYJTUJFSPO FO MPT QB½ TFT RVF QSJNFSP BEPQUBSPO FM DBMFOEBSJP HSFHPSJBOP &TQBÁB 1PSUVHBM 'SBODJB F *UBMJB FOUSF PUSPT FO MPT SFJOPT BNFSJDBOPT FM DBNCJP TF EBS½B VO BÁP N²T UBSEF -B DPOGVTJÂO EF MBT GFDIBT BQBSFDF FO MB IJTUPSJB QPS UPEPT MBEPT FO VO UFDIP EF MB "MIBNCSB FM QJOUPS GMBNFODP +VBO $BYUP FTDSJCJ FO DBSBDUFSFT HÂUJDPT MB GFDIB EF MB ÊiÃÊv?V Ê«>À>Ê ÃÊ DPORVJTUB EF (SBOBEB i EF FOFSP EF ÃÌ À >` ÀiÃÊ`iÌiÀ >ÀÊ w DVBOEP GVF EF Z MB DBQJ UVMBDJÂO EF #PBCEJM BOUF MPT 3FZFT $B i ʵÕjÊviV >Ê VÕÀÀ Ê UÂMJDPT BTJFOUB i EF EJDJFNCSF EF > } ]Ê« ÀµÕiÊà i «ÀiÊ w TJFOEP RVF PDVSSJ FO -P RVF QBTB FT RVF FM QJOUPS VT FM DB `iLi ÊÌi iÀÊi ÊVÕi Ì>Ê MFOEBSJP GMBNFODP RVF FNQF[BCB >ÃÊ` ÃÌ Ì>ÃÊ > iÀ>ÃÊÊDPO MB 1BTDVB EF 3FTVSSFDDJÂO NJFOUSBT RVF FM SFEBDUPS EFM EPDV `iÊV Ì>ÀÊi ÊÌ i « NFOUP TF SFGJSJ BM DBMFOEBSJP FTQBÁPM RVF BSSBODBCB DPO MB /BWJEBE FM EF EJDJFNCSF &O FM $PODJMJP EF 5SFOUP BQSPC VO QSPZFDUP QBSB DP SSFHJS MPT FSSPSFT EFM DBMFOEBSJP KVMJBOP DPO FM GJO EF SFTUBVSBS FM FRVJOPDDJP WFSOBM BM EF NBS[P MB GFDIB RVF PDVQBCB FO MB ¹QPDB EFM $PODJMJP EF /JDFB FO Z FWJUBS FO MP TVDFTJWP MPT EFTMJ[BNJFOUPT QBSB FTP TF BDPSE RVF MPT BÁPT CJTJFTUPT DVZBT EPT ÈMUJNBT DJGSBT GVFSBO DFSPT OP TFS½BO CJTJFTUPT FYDFQUP TJ TVT EPT QSJNFSBT DJGSBT TPO EJWJTJCMFT QPS DVBUSP EF MPT BÁPT Z RVF FO FM DBMFOEBSJP KVMJBOP TPO CJTJFT UPT FO FM HSFHPSJBOP MP TPO TÂMP FM Z FM EF NPEP RVF DBEB DVBUSP TJHMPT RVFEBO TVQSJNJEPT USFT E½BT &M QBQB (SFHP SJP 9*** QJEJ GPSNVMBS MB SFGPSNB EFM DBMFOEBSJP B EPT DJFOU½GJ DPT FM DBMBCS¹T -VJT -JMJP Z FM KFTVJUB BMFN²O $SJTUÂCBM $MBWJP Z NFEJBOUF MB CVMB *OUFS HSBWJTTJNBT EFM EF GFCSFSP EF EJTQVTP MB BEPQDJÂO EF MB OVFWB DVFOUB -PT QB½TFT FVSPQFPT OP GJFMFT B 3PNB UBSEBSPO NVDIPT BÁPT FO BKVTUBSTF BM DBMFOEBSJP HSFHPSJBOP *OHMBUFSSB MP IJ[P FO QFSP MPT SVTPT TF UBSEB SPO IBTUB MB SFWPMVDJÂO CPMDIFWJRVF Z MB *HMFTJB SVTB UPEBW½B GF DIB MB /BWJEBE TFHÈO FM DBMFOEBSJP KVMJBOP &M HSBO BTUSÂOPNP +PIBOOFT ,FQMFS EFD½B RVF MPT IFSFKFT QSFGFS½BO FTUBS FO EFTB DVFSEP DPO FM TPM BOUFT RVF FTUBS EF BDVFSEP DPO FM QBQB
, Ã>Ê ÌiÀ
:\e`Z`\ekX \o`jk\ p [\Y\ [\ _XY\i dlZ_Xj 4BSB . 3 UJFOF BÁPT Z OBDJÂ FO -BSBDIF .B SSVFDPT 4V NBESF DBTBEB Z DPO IJKPT USBCBKBCB FO &TQBÁB FO VO WJBKF B TV UJFSSB TF FNCBSB[Â EF PUSP NBSSPRV½ UBNCJ¹O DBTBEP 0 TFB RVF EFTEF RVF OBDJÂ 4BSB GVF VOB EFTIPOSB QBSB MB GBNJMJB VOB DSJBUVSB PEJBEB QPS UPEPT -B NBESF EJP B MV[ FO .BSSVFDPT EFKÂ BM CFC¹ DPO VO NBUSJNPOJP Z SFHSFTÂ B &TQBÁB 4BSB WJWJÂ DPO FTB HFOUF EVSBO UF TFJT BÁPT USBCBKBCB DPNP TJSWJFOUB Z MF QFHB CBO 6O E½B BQBSFDJÂ VOB NVKFS RVF MF EJKP RVF FSB TV NBESF -F DPNQSÂ VO QJKBNB SPKP EFM RVF 4B SB BÈO TF BDVFSEB DPO FNPDJÂO Z TF MB MMFWÂ B DB TB EF MPT BCVFMPT NBUFSOPT FO MB DJVEBE EF "MDB [BSRVJWJS $VBOEP 4BSB BCSJÂ MPT PKPT B MB NBÁBOB TJHVJFOUF FTUBCB TPMB -B NBESF IBC½B SFHSFTBEP B &TQBÁB TJO EFTQFEJSTF -B OJÁB TF MFWBOUÂ Z GVF IBTUB FM DPNFEPS &T UBCB MMFOP EF HFOUF RVF FMMB OP DPOPD½B 4ÂMP UF O½B TJFUF BÁPT Z UVWP NJFEP DPHJÂ TV QJKBNB SPKP Z TBMJÂ DPSSJFOEP EF MB DBTB 6OP EF MPT IFSNBOPT EF MB NBESF FTUBCB QFMBOEP VOB OBSBOKB Z TBMJÂ EFUS²T EF FMMB DPO FM DVDIJMMP FO MB NBOP $VBOEP MB BMDBO[Â TF MP DMBWÂ B MB OJÁB FO MB DJOUVSB /P EFCJÂ EF TFS NVZ HSBWF BVORVF BÈO DPOTFSWB MB DJDBUSJ[ QPS TVQVFTUP OP MB MMFWBSPO BM N¹EJDP 1FSP MP QFPS GVF RVF 4BSB FO TV BOHVTUJB EJKP i$VBOEP MMBNF NJ NBESF TF MP DPOUBS¹ UPEPw &O UPODFT QBSB JNQFEJS RVF IBCMBSB FM U½P MB TVKFUÂ MF BCSJÂ MB CPDB B MB GVFS[B Z MB BCVFMB MF DPSUÂ MB DBNQBOJMMB DPO VOBT UJKFSBT 3FTVMUB EJG½DJM EF DSF FS UBOUB CSVUBMJEBE Z TJO FNCBSHP MB IJTUPSJB EF MBT NVKFSFT FTU² MMFOB EF BUSPDJEBEFT TFNFKBOUFT BEPMFTDFOUFT EFTGJHVSBEBT DPO ²DJEP P RVFNBEBT WJWBT QPS MB TVFHSB /P T¹ TJ MPT WFSEVHPT DSFZF SPO RVF BM DPSUBSMF MB ÈWVMB OP QPES½B IBCMBS FO SFBMJEBE FTP OP BGFDUB BQFOBT MB EJDDJÂO 1FSP DPOTJHVJFSPO TV PCKFUJWP BUFSSPSJ[BEB MB OJÁB TF DBMMÂ Z TVT GBNJMJBSFT OP WPMWJFSPO B FTDVDIBSMF VOB TPMB QBMBCSB 1FOTBCBO RVF FSB NVEB 1BTÂ DJODP BÁPT N²T WJWJFOEP FO FTF JOGJFS OP 1PS TVQVFTUP OVODB GVF BM DPMFHJP EPSN½B FO MB DPDJOB Z MJNQJBCB UPEP FM E½B B WFDFT QBSB DBT UJHBSMB MB BCVFMB DBMFOUBCB VO DVDIJMMP FO FM GVF HP Z TF MP BQMJDBCB FO MB QBMNB EF MB NBOP 5FO½B BÁPT DVBOEP BQBSFDJÂ FM QBESF Z TF MB MMFWÂ B &TQBÁB DPO TV NVKFS Z TVT PUSPT USFT IJKPT 7JW½BO FO VO QVFCMP EF (JSPOB Z BMM½ GVF MB QSJNFSB WF[ RVF 4BSB BTJTUJÂ B DMBTF TJO EVEB MB FOWJBSPO QPS RVF FSB JMFHBM OP IBDFSMP /P TBC½B MFFS OJ FTDSJ CJS OP TBC½B FTQBÁPM 4FHV½B EVSNJFOEP FO MB DP DJOB Z USBCBKBOEP EF TJSWJFOUB -B NBESF QSFQBSBCB CPDBEJMMPT QBSB MPT USFT IJKPT QFSP OP QBSB FMMB FO SFBMJEBE UBNQPDP MF EBCBO EF EFTB
ZVOBS -B QSPGFTPSB MMBNBCB B NFOVEP QBSB QSP UFTUBS QPSRVF 4BSB IBC½B MMFHBEP FO BZVOBT P QPS RVF OP UFO½B DVBEFSOPT OJ M²QJDFT OP MF DPNQSB CBO NBUFSJBM FTDPMBS 1FSP DBEB WF[ RVF UFMFGPOFBCB FO DBTB MF QFHBCBO &O VOB EF MBT QB MJ[BT FM QBESF MF EFTFODBKÂ MB NBOE½CVMB EF VO QV ÁFUB[P 5PEBW½B IBDF DIBTRVJEPT DVBOEP DPNF 6O BÁP EFTQV¹T MB NBESF TF MB MMFWÂ B WJWJS B .BUBSÂ DPO FMMB Z TVT IFSNBOPT : BVORVF QBSF[ DB JNQPTJCMF MB DPTB FNQFPSÂ 4BSB UFO½B RVF BO EBS DPO MB NJSBEB CBKB DPOUSPMBCBO UPEPT TVT NP WJNJFOUPT Z MB NBESF MB HPMQFBCB TJO DFTBS DPO MB HPNB EFM CVUBOP i1BSB FOUPODFT ZP FSB ZB N²T HSBOEF RVF FMMB NF IVCJFSB QPEJEP EFGFOEFS QF SP DPNP TJFNQSF NF IBO QFHBEP OP UFOHP DPSB KFw EJDF 4BSB FRVJWPDBEBNFOUF QPSRVF FT VOB EF MBT QFSTPOBT N²T WBMJFOUFT RVF DPOP[DP -B FO DFSSBCBO FO DBTB CBKP MMBWF Z MB OJÁB FTUBCB DPO WFODJEB EF RVF BDBCBS½BO NBU²OEPMB 4F JOUFOUÂ FTDBQBS EPT WFDFT Z MB BUSBQBSPO 5SBT MB TFHVO EB GVHB MB QBMJ[B GVF UBO CSVUBM RVF TF MF QVTP UP EP FM DVFSQP NPSBEP $POTJHVJÂ IVJS Z MMFHBS B VOB DPNJTBS½B $VBOEP WJFSPO TV FTUBEP EFUVWJFSPO B MB NBESF Z BM IFSNBOP Z FMMB GVF JOUFSOBEB FO VO DFOUSP EF NFOPSFT EF 5BSSBHPOB 5FO½B BÁPT /P GVF G²DJM QFSP QVEP JSTF SFDPOTUSVZFOEP QPDP B QPDP 6OB GBNJMJB MB BDPHJÂ EVSBOUF VO BÁP VOB NVKFS NBZPS "VSPSB MF EJP DBSJÁP VOB QTJ DÂMPHB MF BZVEÂ B QPOFSTF FO QJF "IPSB FT DBQB[ EF DPOUBS FTUB USFNFOEB IJTUPSJB TJO MMPSBS /P IB UFSNJOBEP MB &40 QFSP TF FYQSFTB EF NBSBWJMMB UJFOF VOB JOUFMJHFODJB WJW½TJNB VOB WPMVOUBE EF IJFSSP VO DPSB[ÂO EF PSP 3FTJEF FO #BSDFMPOB Z USBCBKB EF EFQFOEJFOUB FO VOB UJFOEB EF SPQB FO EPOEF FT NVZ BQSFDJBEB 7JWF FO QBSFKB EFTEF IB DF EPT BÁPT Z iDPNP UFOHP NVDIP BNPS RVF EBSw IBO BEPQUBEP B VOB QPEFODB Z VOB HBMHB NBMUSB UBEBT i/P RVJFSP UFOFS IJKPT QPS NJFEP B TFS DP NP NJT QBESFTw TFHVSP RVF KBN²T MP TFS½BT IFS NPTB 4BSB 4F IB QVFTUP FO DPOUBDUP DPONJHP QPSRVF RVJFSF RVF TV IJTUPSJB TJSWB EF FKFNQMP QB SB MPT DIJDPT EFM DFOUSP EF NFOPSFT B MPT RVF WF NVZ QFSEJEPT i1FSP ZP TPZ MB QSVFCB EF RVF TF QVFEF TBMJSw 2VJFSF DPOUBSMP FO GJO QBSB QPEFS EBSMF VO TFOUJEP BM TVGSJNJFOUP "IPSB 4BSB FTU² DPOUFOUB i" WFDFT UFOHP QFTBEJMMBT QFSP MBT EJGJ DVMUBEFT OPSNBMFT NF QBSFDFO VOB UPOUFS½B -P RVF FT VO NBM E½B QBSB DVBMRVJFS QFSTPOB QBSB N½ FT TVQFSHVBZw 1BSB BMHVJFO RVF IB FTUBEP FO FM JOGJFSOP MB WJEB DPUJEJBOB FT MB BCVOEBODJB !#SVOB)VTLZ XXX GBDFCPPL DPN FTDSJUPSBSPTBNPOUFSP XXX SPTBNPOUFSP FT