Social Welfare Report 01-10 / 2012
1
January 2012
Additional Social welfare that could be gained with no network constraints:
3,7 M€
Social welfare = Producer surplus + Consumer surplus + Congestion rent
Producer surplus
36,3 M€
Consumer surplus
-21,8 M€
Congestion Rent
-10,8 M€
NB: Producer surplus, Consumer surplus and Congestion Rent are calculated as such: Sum of daily ( Value with ATC=∞) - (Historical value) The daily values being a Sum of hourly values. In single hours the producer/consumer surplus can be positive or negative. The highlighted value presents the sum of all hours of the respective month.
2
January 2012 Evolution of social welfare that could be gained with no network constraints
3
February 2012
Additional Social welfare that could be gained with no network constraints:
31,7 M€
Social welfare = Producer surplus + Consumer surplus + Congestion rent
Producer surplus
57,4 M€
Consumer surplus
45,3 M€
Congestion Rent
-71,0 M€
NB: Producer surplus, Consumer surplus and Congestion Rent are calculated as such: Sum of daily ( Value with ATC=∞) - (Historical value) The daily values being a Sum of hourly values. In single hours the producer/consumer surplus can be positive or negative. The highlighted value presents the sum of all hours of the respective month.
4
February 2012 Evolution of social welfare that could be gained with no network constraints
5
March 2012
Additional Social welfare that could be gained with no network constraints:
4,5 M€
Social welfare = Producer surplus + Consumer surplus + Congestion rent
Producer surplus
34,4 M€
Consumer surplus
-15,3 M€
Congestion Rent
-14,6 M€
NB: Producer surplus, Consumer surplus and Congestion Rent are calculated as such: Sum of daily ( Value with ATC=∞) - (Historical value) The daily values being a Sum of hourly values. In single hours the producer/consumer surplus can be positive or negative. The highlighted value presents the sum of all hours of the respective month.
6
March 2012 Evolution of social welfare that could be gained with no network constraints
7
April 2012
Additional Social welfare that could be gained with no network constraints:
2,5 M€
Social welfare = Producer surplus + Consumer surplus + Congestion rent
Producer surplus
17,2 M€
Consumer surplus
-4,9 M€
Congestion Rent
-9,8 M€
NB: Producer surplus, Consumer surplus and Congestion Rent are calculated as such: Sum of daily ( Value with ATC=∞) - (Historical value) The daily values being a Sum of hourly values. In single hours the producer/consumer surplus can be positive or negative. The highlighted value presents the sum of all hours of the respective month.
8
April 2012 Evolution of social welfare that could be gained with no network constraints
9
May 2012
Additional Social welfare that could be gained with no network constraints:
5,2 M€
Social welfare = Producer surplus + Consumer surplus + Congestion rent
Producer surplus
20,3 M€
Consumer surplus
3,8 M€
Congestion Rent
-18,9 M€
NB: Producer surplus, Consumer surplus and Congestion Rent are calculated as such: Sum of daily ( Value with ATC=∞) - (Historical value) The daily values being a Sum of hourly values. In single hours the producer/consumer gain can be positive or negative. The highlighted value presents the sum of all hours of the respective month.
10
May 2012 Evolution of social welfare that could be gained with no network constraints
11
June 2012
Additional Social welfare that could be gained with no network constraints:
3,8 M€
Social welfare = Producer surplus + Consumer surplus + Congestion rent
Producer surplus
Consumer surplus Congestion Rent
21,2 M€
-2,0 M€ -15,4 M€
NB: Producer surplus, Consumer surplus and Congestion Rent are calculated as such: Sum of daily ( Value with ATC=∞) - (Historical value) The daily values being a Sum of hourly values. In single hours the producer/consumer gain can be positive or negative. The highlighted value presents the sum of all hours of the respective month.
12
June 2012 Evolution of social welfare that could be gained with no network constraints
13
July 2012
Additional Social welfare that could be gained with no network constraints:
1,9 M€
Social welfare = Producer surplus + Consumer surplus + Congestion rent
Producer surplus
Consumer surplus Congestion Rent
11,5 M€
-0,1 M€ -9,5 M€
NB: Producer surplus, Consumer surplus and Congestion Rent are calculated as such: Sum of daily ( Value with ATC=∞) - (Historical value) The daily values being a Sum of hourly values. In single hours the producer/consumer gain can be positive or negative. The highlighted value presents the sum of all hours of the respective month.
14
July 2012 Evolution of social welfare that could be gained with no network constraints
15
August 2012
Additional Social welfare that could be gained with no network constraints:
1,9 M€
Social welfare = Producer surplus + Consumer surplus + Congestion rent
Producer surplus
Consumer surplus Congestion Rent
10,3 M€
-1,1 M€ -7,3 M€
NB: Producer surplus, Consumer surplus and Congestion Rent are calculated as such: Sum of daily ( Value with ATC=∞) - (Historical value) The daily values being a Sum of hourly values. In single hours the producer/consumer gain can be positive or negative. The highlighted value presents the sum of all hours of the respective month.
16
August 2012 Evolution of social welfare that could be gained with no network constraints
17
September 2012
Additional Social welfare that could be gained with no network constraints:
3,2 M€
Social welfare = Producer surplus + Consumer surplus + Congestion rent
Producer surplus
Consumer surplus Congestion Rent
19,7 M€
-5,2 M€ -11,3 M€
NB: Producer surplus, Consumer surplus and Congestion Rent are calculated as such: Sum of daily ( Value with ATC=∞) - (Historical value) The daily values being a Sum of hourly values. In single hours the producer/consumer gain can be positive or negative. The highlighted value presents the sum of all hours of the respective month.
18
September 2012 Evolution of social welfare that could be gained with no network constraints
19
October 2012
Additional Social welfare that could be gained with no network constraints:
10,6 M€
Social welfare = Producer surplus + Consumer surplus + Congestion rent
Producer surplus
Consumer surplus Congestion Rent
52,2 M€
-16,1 M€ -25,5 M€
NB: Producer surplus, Consumer surplus and Congestion Rent are calculated as such: Sum of daily ( Value with ATC=∞) - (Historical value) The daily values being a Sum of hourly values. In single hours the producer/consumer gain can be positive or negative. The highlighted value presents the sum of all hours of the respective month.
20
October 2012 Evolution of social welfare that could be gained with no network constraints
21
Definitions / explanations
22
Additional Social welfare that could be gained with no network constraints (Definition/explanation) The figure shows the additional social welfare that could be gained with no network constraints inside CWE (borders D-NL, NL-B, B-F, D-F) . This key figure is calculated by hourly simulating/ coupling the CWE-region with ATC= ∞ at the borders D-NL, NL-B, B-F, D-F and comparing to real MC-results: • Producer surplus= Producer surplus (ATC= ∞)- Producer surplus(real ATC) • Consumer surplus=Consumer surplus (ATC= ∞)- Consumer surplus(real ATC) • Congestion rent= Congestion rent (ATC= ∞)- congestion rent(real ATC)
NB: The simulations are made with ITVC flows remaining identical.
23
Additional Social welfare that could be gained with no network constraints (Definition/explanation) The purpose of the welfare reporting is the demonstration of the benefits of CWE ATC Market Coupling and future CWE FB MC. The monthly publishing of this figure was commonly agreed between the CWE Regulators and the CWE Project. It is one part of the welfare reporting.
24
Examples: “In single hours the producer/consumer gain can be positive or negative�
25
Decrease in consumer surplus example 1/2 Two isolated markets (zero capacity) 80
80
70
70
60
60
50
50
consumer surplus (1)
40
producer surplus (2)
40
30
30
20
20
10
10
0
0 0
500
1000 Demand
1500
2000
0
500
Supply
1000 Demand
Area 1
Area 2
MCV: 1000 MW, MCP: € 10
MCV: 500 MW, MCP: € 50
Consumer surplus: € 60K Producer surplus: € 0
Consumer surplus: € 0 Producer surplus: € 10K
1500
2000
Supply
Totals Consumer surplus: € 60K
Congestion revenue: € 0
Producer surplus: € 10K
Social welfare: € 70K
26
Decrease in consumer surplus example 2/2 Two coupled markets (infinite capacity) 80
70
consumer surplus (1)
60 50
producer surplus (2)
40
producer surplus (1)
30 20 10 0 0
500
1000
1500 Demand
2000
2500
3000
Supply
Area 1
Area 2
MCV: 1400 MW, MCP: € 50
MCV: 500 MW, MCP: € 50
Consumer surplus: € 20K Producer surplus: € 56K
Consumer surplus: € 0 Producer surplus: € 10K
Totals Consumer surplus: € 20K (-40K)
Congestion revenue: € 0
Producer surplus: € 66K (+56K)
Social welfare: € 86K (+16K)
27
Decrease in producer surplus example 1/2 Two isolated markets (zero capacity) 80
80
70
70
60
60
50
50
producer surplus (1)
40
consumer surplus (2)
40
30
30
20
20
10
10
0
0 0
500
1000 Demand
1500
2000
0
500
Supply
1000 Demand
Area 1
Area 2
MCV: 1000 MW, MCP: € 70
MCV: 500 MW, MCP: € 30
Consumer surplus: € 0 Producer surplus: € 60K
Consumer surplus: € 10K Producer surplus: € 0
1500
2000
Supply
Totals Consumer surplus: € 10K
Congestion revenue: € 0
Producer surplus: € 60K
Social welfare: € 70K
28
Decrease in producer surplus example 2/2 Two coupled markets (infinite capacity) 80
70 60
consumer surplus (1)
50
consumer surplus (2)
40 30
producer surplus (1)
20 10 0 0
500
1000
1500 Demand
2000
2500
3000
Supply
Area 1
Area 2
MCV: 1400 MW, MCP: € 30
MCV: 500 MW, MCP: € 30
Consumer surplus: € 56K Producer surplus: € 20K
Consumer surplus: € 10K Producer surplus: € 0
Totals Consumer surplus: € 66K (+56K)
Congestion revenue: € 0
Producer surplus: € 20K (-40K)
Social welfare: € 86K (+16K)
29