COMPILATION
ARCH 510: reFORM
MISSOURI VALLEY, IA EMELIA THOMPSON
29, 2017
WILLOW CREEK
CHI HEALTH MISSOURI VALLEY
MISSOURI VALLEY SWIMMING POOL HARRISON COUNTY FAIRGROUNDS
HI
GH
W
AY
30
/E
RI
E
ST
RE
ET
MAIN STREET
TO OMAHA / COUNCIL BLUFFS
MISSOURI VALLEY COMMUNITY SCHOOLS
“I’M NOT READY TO GIVE UP ON MISSOURI VALLEY. THERE’S JUST TOO MUCH POTENTIAL HERE FOR US TO JUST QUIT.”
Annette Deakins Executive Director, Missouri Valley Chamber of Commerce
MISSOURI VALLEY COUNCIL BLUFFS OMAHA
MISSOURI VALLEY COUNCIL BLUFFS OMAHA
MISSOURI VALLEY
6
PHASE 1 / RESEARCH
TRAIN TOWN USA MISSOURI VALLEY, IA Missouri Valley was originally established as St. John’s Township in 1853. In 1865, it was sold to a new owner and the entire downtown was moved in order to intersect the Chicago and Northwestern Railroad after the railroad refused to move north. Missouri Valley was originally used as a terminus for three major railroads: The Chicago and Northwestern, the Sioux City and Pacific (where it was the headquarters), and the Fremont Elkhorn and Missouri Valley Railroad. To date, Missouri Valley is recognized as 1 of the 131 communities designated as “Train Town USA,” As the railroad came through and began to employ more men, Missouri Valley experienced a population boon. A classic frontier town, the streets were unpaved and the location in a flood plain made the ground muddy and often impassable. The floodplain still causes major issues
today, and the town has seen over 6 major floods since it was founded. Many of the issues plaguing the town today were established from the start. Missouri Valley has always struggled with it’s identity as a railroad town. Divided into two communities - wealthy Dog Town to the West and lower income Whisky Row to the East - the dividing line has remained with the town to this day. Like many railroad towns placed throughout the country, the population swelled during the height of the railroad. Businesses opened and flourished, and the town had an influx of low paid but employed workers. As the railroad became more obsolete, the population plummeted and never quite recovered. Large businesses supporting the railroad shut down, and much of the downtown fell into disrepair.
7
MISSOURI VALLEY
BIRD’S EYE VIEW / 1909
The population jumped in the early 1900’s to over 4,000. The town lost the race to Logan, IA to become the county seat of Harrison County.
E R I E STREET / 1907 & 1910 Erie Street acts as the main street of Missouri Valley. The railroad is to the South, and the residences extend North.
8
PHASE 1 / RESEARCH
MAIN BUILDINGS / PRE 1960’S
Buildings still in use in this image are the City Hall, the Public Library, and the Post Office.
RIALTO THEATRE / PRESENT DAY
The Rialto Theatre originally opened in 1908. It was closed in 1984 after deteriorating due to disuse, but a community wide effort reopened the theatre in 1990.
MAJOR FLOOD ZONES / 1952 The flood of 1952 displaced thousands of citizens.
9
MISSOURI VALLEY
BRIGHT LIGHTS, BIG CITY THE PROGNOSIS DOES NOT LOOK GOOD FOR MUCH OF SMALL TOWN AMERICA.
10
Missouri Valley’s first, and most striking, indication of a town in decline is the falling population numbers. From 1930 to 2016, the population has decreased 37%. Harrison County as a whole has had a population loss of 43% in the same amount of time. This is on par with the United States’ continuation of rapid urbanization. The United State’s Department of Agriculture estimates that the number of people living in non metro counties declined by nearly 21,000 from July 2015 to July 2016. From 2011 to 2015, that number was almost 43,000 per year.
generations, and while that may be sustainable for a while, what happens when the older generation is gone?
The vast majority of those leaving small towns are millennial. Small towns invest so much time and money into setting their children up for success and sending them packing for college. But, they don’t return. Small towns are bleeding the younger
Small towns have the advantages of a low cost of living, smaller and more individualized schools, and inexpensive housing. What they are failing to offer are job opportunities and the sort of density that an increasingly connected generation wants.
What’s drawing younger generations to the flashing lights of urban landscapes? More opportunities, more amenities, essentially more everything. It isn’t just the physical, either. Moving to the city still has the feeling of “having made it.” Skyrocketing costs of living aren’t dissuading young adults and families who want to set themselves and their children up for success.
PHASE 1 / RESEARCH 4500
4230
4000
3500
3000
2662
2500
2000
1500
1000
500 1930
1940
1950
1960
1970
1980
1990
2000
2010
2016
MISSOURI VALLEY POPULATION DECLINE 11
MISSOURI VALLEY
100%
PERCENTAGE POPULATION BY AGE
75%
50%
25%
0% UNDER 18
18-24
24-44
45-64
65 OR OLDER
2000 CENSUS 2010 CENSUS
MISSOURI VALLEY HAS SEEN SIGNIFICANT DECREASES IN THE YOUNG ADULT AND ADULT POPULATIONS FROM 2000 TO 2010. MILLENNIALS AND YOUNG FAMILIES ARE TRENDING TOWARDS URBAN AND SUBURBAN LOCATIONS FOR BETTER OPPORTUNITIES, HIGHER QUALITY EDUCATION, AND MORE AMENITIES.
12
PHASE 1 / RESEARCH
EDUCATION AND SINGLE PARENTS
HOUSEHOLDS
Since 2010, single parent households in Missouri Valley have increased significantly. America as a whole has seen a large jump in single parent households: in 2010 26% of homes were single parent families, up from 22% in 2001 and 9% in 1960. Households are less likely to have two parents when the parent does not have a college degree.
100%
75%
50%
25%
0% CHILDREN
MARRIED
SINGLE
SINGLE
UNDER 18
COUPLES
FEMALE
MALE
NON FAMILIES
TOGETHER
2000 CENSUS 2010 CENSUS
MEDIAN AGE KEEPS GOING UP, BUT THE POPULATION GROWS SMALLER
MISSOURI VALLEY MEDIAN AGE MISSOURI VALLEY
IOWA
UNITED STATES 0
38
39
40
41
42
43
National Public Radio studied the decline of small towns, noticing that the majority of people leaving were young, college bound kids. Small towns continue to increase in median age while big cities decrease.
13
MISSOURI VALLEY
2016 HOUSEHOLDS BY INCOME 8.8%
2.7%
1.4%
13.3%
10.1% 16.9%
LESS THAN 1/4 OF MISSOURI VALLEY’S POPULATION IS CONSIDERED UPPER CLASS
8.3%
13.0% 25.4%
14
01
<$15,000
02
04
$35,000 - $49,999
05
07
$100,000 - $149,000
08
03
$25,000 - $34,999
$50,000 - $74,999
06
$75,000 - $99,999
$150,000 - $199,999
09
$200,000 +
$15,000 - $24,999
PHASE 1 / RESEARCH
INCOME DISCREPANCIES $90,000
$80,000
One thing Missouri Valley has going for it is that only 5.6& of the population is unemployed. This is below both the state and the national average, and a bright spot in an otherwise fairly dim picture. The median, average, and per capita income levels of Missouri Valley are all below the United States levels. This largely has to
$70,000
$60,000
EDUCATION, INDUSTRY, AND INCOME A VICIOUS CIRCLE.
$50,000
$40,000
$30,000
$20,000
0 MEDIAN
AVERAGE
PER CAPITA
HOUSEHOLD
HOUSEHOLD
INCOME
INCOME
INCOME
MISSOURI VALLEY UNITED STATES
do with the types of industries citizens of Missouri Valley are employed in. Education, industry, and education are all tightly intertwined, and Missouri Valley has received the shorter end of the stick in this regard. People are less likely to be involved in their community and with community programs if they do not have the expendable cash to do so. 15
MISSOURI VALLEY
22.6
MINUTE COMMUTE COMMUTER TOWN
The average amount of time it takes a Missouri Valley employee to drive to work is 22.6 minutes. This strongly suggests that most of Missouri Valley’s working citizens are working in places other than Missouri Valley.
BLUE COLLAR VS. WHITE COLLAR
49.5% of Missouri Valley’s employed population work in blue collar or service industries. The service industry dominates the employed population with 51.9% of the industry. Depending on the type of service, those employed may still fall under a white collar classification. Farming only makes up 0.6% of Missouri Valley’s industry, echoing the rapid decline of mid-sized family farms in the U.S. 16
SERVICE DOMINATED INDUSTRY
49.5% IN BLUE COLLAR AND/OR SERVICE CLASSIFIED INDUSTRIES
PHASE 1 / RESEARCH
2016 EMPLOYMENT BY INDUSTRY AGRICULTURE/MINING
CONSTRUCTION
MANUFACTURING
WHOLESALE TRADE
RETAIL TRADE
TRANSPORTATION/UTILITIES
INFORMATION
FINANCE/INSURANCE/REAL ESTATE
SERVICES
PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
17
MISSOURI VALLEY
HARRISON COUNTY HIGH SCHOOL RANKINGS TRI-CENTER HIGH SCHOOL
WOODBINE MIDDLE/HIGH SCHOOL
LOGAN-MAGNOLIA ELEMENTARY SCHOOL
WOODBINE ELEMENTARY SCHOOL
LOGAN-MAGNOLIA MIDDLE/HIGH SCHOOL
TRI-CENTER ELEMENTARY SCHOOL
TRI-CENTER MIDDLE SCHOOL
BOYER VALLEY ELEMENTARY SCHOOL
WEST HARRISON ELEMENTARY SCHOOL
WEST HARRISON MIDDLE/HIGH SCHOOL
BOYER VALLEY MIDDLE/HIGH SCHOOL
MISSOURI VALLEY MIDDLE SCHOOL
MISSOURI VALLEY HIGH SCHOOL
MISSOURI VALLEY ELEMENTARY SCHOOL
0
18
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
PHASE 1 / RESEARCH
MISSOURI VALLEY EDUCATIONAL ATTAINMENT
35.6%
23.7%
7.6%
11.9%
5.4%
HIGH SCHOOL GRADUATE
SOME COLLEGE
ASSOCIATE DEGREE
BACHELOR’S DEGREE
GRADUATE DEGREE
MISSOURI VALLEY HAS TO COMPETE AGAINST TOP RANKED AND WELL RESPECTED SCHOOLS LESS THAN 5 MILES AWAY WHEN IT COMES TO ENTICING YOUNG FAMILIES.
Missouri Valley has long battled a reputation as a below average school. In the Iowa Department of Education’s 2016 Report Card of Iowa Schools, the Middle and High School were merely ranked acceptable, while the Elementary School fell further into needs improvement. Missouri Valley has not had the success in extra curriculars like nearby towns, and still struggles with rumors of drug and substance abuse occurring within the school. This negative outlook carries over to the educational attainment of those over 25. Less than 25% of the population has achieved a college degree, with only 16% achieving above a bachelor’s. Less education is strongly correlated with lower income. Lower income often means longer hours and less expendable cash - time and money that could be devoted towards tutors and working through homework with children. Missouri Valley needs to break that cycle in order to succeed and tempt more families to move in.
19
MISSOURI VALLEY
HOUSING UNITS BY OCCUPANCY AND TENURE 1500
TOTAL: 1291
TOTAL: 1300
418
410
742
812
131
78
2010
2000
1200
VACANT
OWNER OCCUPIED
900
600
RENTER OCCUPIED 300
0
Missouri Valley is having what could be called a housing crisis. Too many homes are sitting vacant and slowly deteriorating. Too many homes are being rented out by real estate agents, denying families the chance to purchase a home and establish roots. The majority of rental units are being rented at rock bottom prices, drawing in less than model citizens. Many of the homes for sale are listed as-is, and would be considered substandard housing. This problem is exacerbated by the shortage in assisted living facilities. Homes are falling into disrepair because the elderly donâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;t have anywhere to go. 20
I N C R E A S E D R E N T A L PROPERTIES OFTEN LEADS TO AN INCREASING T R A N S I E N T POPULATION.
PHASE 1 / RESEARCH
PERCENTAGE CHANGE IN HOUSEHOLDS AND HOUSING UNITS 15%
12%
9%
6%
3%
0%
-3%
-6% MISSOURI VALLEY
IOWA
UNITED STATES
HOUSEHOLDS HOUSING UNITS
UNLIKE WHATâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;S HAPPENING IN IOWA AND THE UNITED STATES, THE NUMBER OF HOUSEHOLDS AND HOUSING UNITS IN MISSOURI VALLEY HAVE BEEN AND ARE PROJECTED TO CONTINUE DECREASING IN THE COMING YEARS. 21
MISSOURI VALLEY
COUNTY HEALTH RANKINGS AND ROADMAPS PRODUCES REPORTS EVERY YEAR COMPARING HOW COUNTIES MATCH UP IN HEALTH OUTCOMES AND HEALTH FACTORS. HARRISON COUNTY RANKED IN THE LOWER 1/2 FOR BOTH.
79 / 99
HEALTH OUTCOMES Health outcomes and factors were established by the University of Wisconsin Population Health Institute and used data from Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, the National Center for Health Statistics and National Center for Chronic Disease and Health Promotion, and Dartmouth Institute for Health Policy & Clinical Practice. Health outcomes were established to be length of life and quality of life. Length of Life 1. Premature Death Quality of Life 1. Poor or fair health 2. Poor physical health days 3. Poor mental health days 4. Low birth weight 22
57 / 99 HEALTH FACTORS
Health Behaviors 1. Tobacco Use 2. Diet and Exercise 3. Alcohol and Drug Use 4. Sexual Activity Clinical Care 1. Access to Care 2. Quality of Care Social and Economic Factors 1. Education 2. Employment 3. Income 4. Family and Social Support 5. Community Safety Physical Environment 1. Air and Water Quality 2. Housing and Transit
PHASE 1 / RESEARCH
HARRISON COUNTY PROMOTE HEALTHY LIVING ASSESSMENT 100%
90%
80%
70%
60%
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0% OBESITY
MENTAL
ALCOHOL
HEALTH
ABUSE
DRUG ABUSE
ELDERLY WELLNESS
CANCERS
CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASE
PROMOTING HEALTHY LIVING
The 2016 Health Needs Assessment of Harrison County was completed using both an online and paper-and-pencil survey completed by 359 Harrison County residents and a set of health statistics from the Center for Disease Control. The majority of citizens ranked alcohol and substance abuse as the most serious risky behavior facing Harrison County today. Substance abuse was the most common write in answer. 23
MISSOURI VALLEY
24
PHASE 1 / RESEARCH
IF IT AIN’T (REALLY) BROKE, WHY FIX IT? ON PAPER, MISSOURI VALLEY SEEMS TO CHECK OFF ALL THE BOXES OF A CURRENT, SUCCESSFUL SMALL TOWN. It’s within reasonable driving distance of two major cities with booming economies and job prospects. It has a brand new athletic complex and hospital and a charming downtown with historical buildings. The cost of living is low and affordable, and visitors can have the small town feel while remaining close to big city amenities. On paper, the town should be thriving, or at least holding steady. But the reality of the situation is much more complicated. When the Iowa Downtown Resource Center conducted a Downtown Assessment in 2016, the number one theme of the visit was that Missouri Valley needs an attitude adjustment. Community involvement is at an all time low and buildings stand vacant until they are no longer habitable. Community leaders refuse
to invest in beautifying the town until they know they can get a return on investment, and right now that isn’t guaranteed. When Main Street was first developed in the early 1900’s, it was centrally located directly across from the track tracks. In 2017, the Main Street is a boon to the advancement of Missouri Valley. Highway 30 cuts right through the downtown core, and large agriculture trucks cause the beautiful historic buildings to crumble every time they brake. The downtown is in a major flood zone, and it’s risky to renovate when 6 disastrous floods have occurred in the last 100 years. It’s difficult to recognize Missouri Valley’s strengths when the challenges rule daily life.
25
MISSOURI VALLEY
10%
20%
32%
VACANT HOUSEHOLDS IN MISSOURI VALLEY
VACANT STOREFRONTS ON MAIN STREET
RENTER OCCUPIED HOUSING UNITS
“WE WANT TO SUCCEED, BUT WE’RE SCARED OF THE CHANGE THAT COMES WITH DOING SO.” Missouri Valley has a housing crisis. As the population grows older, the older generations move into assisted living facilities. Rather than sell the home, because they believe they will be able to return to it or they do not have the assistance to sell, the home is left vacant. Currently, 10% of housing units and 20% of Main Street storefronts in Missouri Valley are unoccupied. Vacant homes and storefronts often fall into disrepair, affecting the image of the town and the real estate market. What homes that are available are increasingly being rented. Renting instead of buying makes it tough for newcomers to establish roots, and renters are less likely to participate in the kind of neighborhood associations that can create change. If Missouri Valley wants to draw in young adults and families who are invested in their town, they will need to address these issues. 26
PHASE 1 / RESEARCH
“THAT’S NOT HOW WE DO THINGS AROUND HERE.”
Resistance to any sort of progress doesn’t just come with housing. Despite the fact that the majority of employed citizens work outside of Missouri Valley, the town has repeatedly turned down big business offers to build in or outside city limits. Both Walmart and Bass Pro Shops approached the same farmer about building on his land. Both times, he turned them down. His reason? “That’s not how we do things around here.” Many city projects and remodeling efforts have been met with opposition, despite the fact that the vast majority of people recognize that the town isn’t attractive. Projects have been sidelined due to wariness of whether or not the project will provide a reasonable return on investment. The mindset needs to be altered if anything is going to change. Otherwise, Missouri Valley will continue to see decline, and will eventually die out. 27
MISSOURI VALLEY
VACANT STOREFRONT VACANT LOT
3 1
2
45 47
46
5
4
44
6
43 42
8
7
41
40
39 38 37
9
36
35
33
32
31
2
34
RAILWAY EASEMENT
28
PHASE 1 / RESEARCH
10
30
11
29
12
13 14
26
25
17
15 16
24
18 23 22
28
1. BANK 2. BAR AND GRILL 3. VACANT SHED 4. CITY HALL + FIRE STATION 5. INSURANCE AGENCY + VACANT STOREFRONT 6. ANTIQUE STORE + ROOFING COMPANY 7. COMMERCIAL FOR RENT 8. BANK 9. SALON, SECONDHAND CLOTHING STORE, RIALTO THEATRE, INSURANCE AGENCY, INSURANCE AGENCY, TANNING SALON. 10. DENTIST, VET. 11. YOGA AND CHIROPRACTIC OFFICE 12. NEWSPAPER 13. VACANT 14. ACE HARDWARE 15. VACANT 16. HAIR SALON, AUTOSHOP, PARKING 17. SENIOR LIVING FACILITY 18. FLOWER SHOP 19. AUTOSHOP 20. INSURANCE AGENCY 21. BAR 22. LAWN AND GARDEN 23. LAWN AND GARDEN 24. CHINESE RESTAURANT 25. HAIR SALON, INSURANCE AGENCY, CHIROPRACTIC OFFICE 26. VACANT 27. FRATERNAL ORDER OF EAGLES 28. TIRE SHOP 29. ANTIQUE STORE, REAL ESTATE 30. FAMILY DOLLAR 31. FLOWER SHOP, METAL SIGNS 32. VACANT 33. CELL CARRIER, LAW FIRM 34. COMMUNITY CENTER 35. VACANT 36. INSURANCE AGENCY 37. DRUG STORE 38. SECONDHAND CLOTHING 39. VACANT 40. ACCOUNTING FIRM 41. TAX AGENCY, EYE CLINIC, TEMPLE, VACANT UPPER FLOORS 42. PRINT LAB, REAL ESTATE 43. COMMUNITY FELLOWSHIP 44. DENTIST 45. VACANT 46. PROPERTY MANAGEMENT 47 ELECTRONIC STORE
19 20
21 27
100 FT.
29
MISSOURI VALLEY
UNDER (WATER) PRESSURE
Missouri Valley was strategically placed directly adjacent to the railroad. Unfortunately, that placement means over 3/4 of the town is in a flood plain. The town is bordered by two rivers: Willow Creek to the West and Boyer River to the East. The floodplain covers the entire downtown, the Harrison County fairgrounds, the swimming pool, and a large sports complex.
BECAUSE OF THE FLOODPLAIN, D O W N T O W N B U I L D I N G S ARE LARGELY INELIGIBLE FOR MOST MAIN STREET BEAUTIFICATION GRANTS AND THE SPACE BETWEEN THE RAILROAD TRACKS AND THE SOUTH SIDE OF ERIE STREET SITS UNDEVELOPED. 30
PHASE 1 / RESEARCH
IT’S WICKED THERE
OUT
When Missouri Valley was first founded, having a major highway cut through downtown made sense. As the first town from Omaha/Council Bluffs, a huge amount of vehicular traffic has the ability to see the downtown. However, the highway today is increasingly used for agricultural transport. Huge semi-trailer trucks fly through the town. Two stoplights exist in the downtown, but trailers are not always able to stop in time. Safety isn’t the only concern. Large agricultural semis bring livestock, and the scent is overpowering on most days.
FROM 2012 TO 2016, HIGHWAY 30 THROUGH MISSOURI VALLEY HAD
120 CRASHES THE CRASH RATE WAS
365
EXCEEDING THE U.S. CRASH RATE OF 250.
HISTORICAL DOWNTOWN BUILDINGS IN MISSOURI VALLEY EXPERIENCE:
SHATTERED LIGHT BULBS VIOLENT SHAKING CRUMBLING MORTAR EVERY TIME A SEMI USES THEIR JAKE BREAKS ON MAIN STREET.
31
MISSOURI VALLEY
IF YOU BUILD IT, WILL THEY COME? MISSOURI VALLEY CAN BE SAVED. IF IT WANTS TO BE. In much of life, the simplest answer is often the right answer. How do we bring young adults and families back to small towns? We give them the opportunities that exist in a big city. But what if a town just can’t compete with a city? How do you save it? Should it even be saved? Missouri Valley has many challenges facing it. It also has many untapped opportunities. The town recognizes that it is likely going to forever remain a commuter town. Omaha and Council Bluffs have far more than it could ever offer. But just because it’s a commuter town doesn’t mean it has to fail. The town already has one major positive going for it: it’s sense of pride. People who live in small towns tend to have a huge amount of pride about it. Pride is
32
often synonymous with being stubborn, and that is a major battle when it comes to implementing change. But once citizens see the outcome of their hard work - once they see the return on investment - small towns can be all in. Missouri Valley has begun the push towards small town revitalization. An eager Chamber of Commerce and the backing of a few community leaders has begun the gradual move towards progress. Three key opportunities currently exist: a Highway 30 bypass is the catalyst for a multi use, revitalized downtown. The downtown can become a hub, linking the already existing amenities. By supporting and recognizing revitalization efforts, the town can alter it’s reputation into the quintessential, community based small town.
PHASE 1 / RESEARCH
33
HIGHWAY 30 BYPASS
MISSOURI VALLEY
For several years, Missouri Valley has been working with the Iowa Department of Transportation to establish a Highway 30 bypass that would run south of the town. In the report, the DOT found that a bypass would be an effective alternative to address some of the fright, condition, and safetyrelated needs, as well as taking care of flood mitigation. 34
TRAFFIC
A Highway 30 bypass would take a major thoroughfare away from the town. Highway 30 is directly adjacent to the majority of amenities, affecting the safety of residents and visitors. While the town would lose some vehicular traffic, the bypass would decrease almost all safety issues.
DOWNTOWN WALKABILITY
The walkability of a town has a major impact on whether or not young adults will choose to live there. By removing the highway, Missouri Valley has the opportunity to create a pedestrian friendly downtown. Increasing foot traffic also increases the chance that small businesses could survive.
FLOOD MITIGATION
The Army Corp of Engineers has expressed interest in flood mitigation with the bypass. The bypass would act as a dike and remove the floodplain from downtown. This opens up grants, development of the rail yard, and the ability to create viable multi use developments in the historic buildings.
PHASE 1 / RESEARCH
GREEN SPACE OPPORTUNITIES DEVELOPMENT OPPORTUNITIES
RETAIL GAPS
$6,694,090 RETAIL TRADE
$6,384,247 FOOD AND DRINK
$13,078,337 TOTAL
Once the floodplain is removed, the downtown can be looked at as a whole different opportunity. It no longer just has to be one street. Pedestrian malls and green spaces can be mixed in, creating a vibrant and active community. Grant money can be used for the historic buildings, and the community can address the housing crisis by adding in both low income and higher end rentals to mixed use buildings. Small towns need to create density in order to attract younger generations, and focus on small businesses (decreases the brain drain). Another option is big business in unexpected ways, stepping away from the warehouse. The town is already on community engagement projects, but it wonâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;t matter how pretty the downtown is if hog trucks are rattling through at 45 miles per hour. The bypass is vital to Missouri Valleyâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s success. 35
WILLOW CREEK
MISSOURI VALLEY
FARMLAND
CHI HEALTH MISSOURI VALLEY
MISSOURI VALLEY COMMUNITY SCHOOLS
FARMLAND CLINICS DOWNTOWN
1 MILE WALK
MISSOURI VALLEY SWIMMING POOL
ST R
EE T
MAIN STREET
30
/E
RI
E
UNDERDEVELOPED
HW AY HI G
TO OMAHA / COUNCIL BLUFFS
36
DE
ER
HARRISON COUNTY FAIRGROUNDS
FARMLAND
LOCAL FOOD SOURCES?
FARMLAND
D UN
D
PE
O
L VE
PHASE 1 / RESEARCH
01
02
03
04
OLDER GENERATION AND YOUNG ADULTS MOVE IN
PEOPLE ARE MORE INVESTED WHEN THEY CAN SEE THE FRUITS OF THEIR LABOR. IF WE CREATE A NETWORK OF BEAUTIFICATION, IT’S MORE LIKELY TO SPREAD ACROSS THE ENTIRE TOWN, AND PEOPLE ARE MORE LIKELY TO GET INVOLVED IF THEY SEE THEIR NEIGHBORS MAKING THE EFFORT.
FEWER DUMPY STRUCTURES, BETTER TOWN IMAGE
NETWORKING
FAMILIES MOVE INTO FORMERLY VACANT HOUSES/FARMHOUSES
APARTMENT RENTALS CREATED DOWNTOWN
The new school complex and hospital have already begun to turn around Missouri Valley’s image. However, these are not the most often seen amenities in the town. If the downtown can be restored, and the buildings remodeled, this trickle down effect becomes more like a tidal wave. By getting everyone involved, Missouri Valley creates a cycle of investment in the town beautification. Downtown apartments can be catered to elderly adults looking to downsize, young adults looking for that loft life on a more modest budget, and those with low incomes who cannot afford a house payment just yet. Moving the older generations out of homes they cannot take care of opens up those homes to young families looking for a change. The cycle then repeats when those families have children, and the town’s life cycle becomes more viable and sustainable. 37
MISSOURI VALLEY
38
PHASE 2 / EMOTION
PHASE 02
ARCH 510: reFORM
EMOTION EMELIA THOMPSON
39
MISSOURI VALLEY
PROGRAM OPPORTUNITIES
CIVIC
40
• COMMUNITY CENTER (REPLACE RAND) • DOG PARK • RUNNING/BIKE PATH ALONG RAILROAD • CONCERT/ AMPHITHEATER • HIGHLINE STYLE GREENSPACE • EVENT SPACE COORDINATED WITH COMMUNITY CENTER
COMMERICAL
• BREWERY • COFFEE SHOP • GIFT SHOP (W/ HOSPITAL AND TRAIN TOWN, RIALTO) • FLOWER SHOP (MOVE A CURRENT ONE) • LOCAL FOOD RESTAURANT • PET GROOMING/ BOARDING • ICE CREAM SHOP
RESIDENTIAL
• SENIOR LIVING • LOFTS CATERING TO YOUNG ADULTS AND SENIORS. • LOW INCOME • MIXED USE (SENIOR, LOFT, AND LOW INCOME) • BED AND BREAKFAST
PHASE 2 / EMOTION
3 1
2
45 47
5
4
44
6
43 42
46
1
8
7
41
40
39 38 37
10
9
36
35
33
32
31
30
2
11
29
12
13 14
26
25
17
15 16
24
18 23 22
28
19 20
21 34
27
3
RAILWAY EASEMENT
100 FT.
1. SOUTH SIDE OF STREET TO UTILIZE EMPTY SPACE BETWEEN RAILROAD TRACKS AND DOWNTOWN CORE. 2. UTILIZE VIEWS OF THE LOESS HILLS TO BOTH THE NORTH AND SOUTHEAST. 3. ABILITY TO BUILD A FREESTANDING BUILDING (ALL OPTIONS) OR CONNECT WITH CURRENT DOWNTOWN STRUCTURES (OPTIONS 2 AND THREE)
41
MISSOURI VALLEY
OPTION 1 Access to the formerly unusable railroad easement allows for Missouri Valley to embrace it’s heritage as a railroad town. The town can improve on it’s reputation and image by cleaning up the railyard and creating a community center and greenspace. Inserting a gift shop into the vacant corner building on the main street hospital/community center draws people in and provides a place for families of patients to purchase flowers and gifts from local flower shops and small businesses. At the same time, out of town visitors can learn about the rich history of both the railroad and the Rialto theatre across the street.
CAH COMMUNITY CENTER / AMPHITHEATER
CLOSE PROXIMITY TO
SENIOR LIVING FACILITIES
CLOSE PROXIMITY TO
GIFT SHOP HOSTS EVENTS WITH
STOCKS GIFTS FROM
SHOWCASES RIALTO HISTORY
PURCHASES FLOWERS FROM
LOCAL FLOWER SHOPS
RIALTO THEATRE
3 1
2
45 47
46
5
4
44
6
43 42
8
7
41
40
39 38 37
10
9
36
35
33
32
31
30
11
29
12
13 14
26
25
17
15 16
24
18 23 22
28
19 20
21 34
27
RAILWAY EASEMENT
100 FT.
42
LOCAL RETAIL
PHASE 2 / EMOTION
LOW INCOME HOUSING
OPTION 2
ACCESS TO HEALTH CARE
Creating an atmosphere that caters to pet owners provides opportunities rich in networking possibilities. Missouri Valley has an existing veterinarian clinic, but no grooming or boarding capabilities. Instead of driving to an adjacent town, Missouri Valley can become provide all the services needed. A dog park in the unused flood plain creates free amenities found in larger cities, and the hospital can take advantage of the proximity to explore pet therapy treatments. Patients and families required to stay in the hospital for long periods of time can take advantage the boarding facilities as well, taking the stress out of finding a place out of town to keep their pets. A wealth of free amenities like public pedestrian malls and green spaces allow low income housing to fit right in, and creates a healthy environment.
CAH PROXIMITY TO FREE AMENITIES
GREENSPACE / PET THERAPY
COMMUNITY PARK / DOG PARK
NETWORKING WITH LOCAL PROVIDERS
PET GROOMING / BOARDING VET CLINIC
3 1
2
45 47
46
5
4
44
6
43 42
8
7
41
40
39 38 37
10
9
36
35
33
32
31
30
11
29
12
13 14
26
25
17
15 16
24
18 23 22
28
19 20
21 34
27
RAILWAY EASEMENT
100 FT.
43
MISSOURI VALLEY
OPTION 3
CAH GREENSPACE + EVENTS/FUNDRAISING
Inserting a commercial element of a brewery has the ability to connect to local businesses struggling to create a network within the town. Linking the critical access hospital with a multi use park creates opportunities for the hub to host a wide range of events: weddings, corporate events, hospital fundraisers, and community celebrations.
ACCESS TO HEALTH CARE / WELLNESS
COMMUNITY PARK / AMPHITHEATER
LOFTS
PROXIMITY TO FREE AMENITIES
BUILDING A LOCAL NETWORK
YOGA IN THE PARK
BIG CITY AMENITIES
LOCAL BARS / RESTAURANTS
TASTINGS, EVENTS, AND FUNDRAISERS
YOGA STUDIO
“BALANCE AND BREW”
BREWERY
3 1
2
45 47
46
5
4
44
6
43 42
8
7
41
40
39 38 37
10
9
36
35
33
32
31
30
11
29
12
13 14
26
25
17
15 16
24
18 23 22
28
20 21 27
RAILWAY EASEMENT
44
19
PHASE 2 / EMOTION
As evidenced from research gathered during phase 1, the number one challenge Missouri Valley, and most of rural America, faces is an aging population and the loss of young adults to urban cities. These two core demographic groups are largely responsible for disrupting the small town cycle for both housing and commercial growth and/or consistency. Young adults are leaving small towns for the amenities of larger cities. In order to bring millennials back and keep them, small towns should look to commercial opportunities that are typically found in urban centers and provide housing that fits their lifestyle. Surprisingly, or not surprisingly, breweries are one of those commercial opportunities that often mark a thriving community. Breweries become social hubs for all demographics. Rent is cheaper here than in Omaha, and Missouri Valleyâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s main street has a wealth of potential mid income housing in the upper levels of the businesses. By catering to both the millennial and baby boomer generation, Missouri Valley has the opportunity to create a diverse community hub in the middle of their historic main street.
CRITICAL ACCESS HOSPITAL / MEDICAL
COMMUNITY / CIVIC
RESIDENTIAL
COMMERCIAL
GREEN SPACE
45
MISSOURI VALLEY
46
Located in the middle of the existing main street, replacing the current community center.
Notch carved from south facade to create niche of public space between two wings.
Pass through provides a thoroughfare from main street and views to the Loess Hills.
2nd level pulled back to allow the south facade to break down and carves out outdoor spaces.
3rd level added to provide housing and continues the breakdown from a rigid facade.
Rooftop terraces are carved out facing main street, increasing indoor/outdoor living.
PHASE 2 / EMOTION
2
3
1
PROGRAMMATIC ADJACENCIES BETWEEN PROPOSAL AND EXISTING BUSINESSES 47
MISSOURI VALLEY
NORTH FIFTH STREET
3RD STREET
NORTH FOURTH STREET
EAST HURON STREET
PROPOSED SITE PLAN SCALE: 1” = 100’ - 0”
48
SOUTH FIFTH STREET
SOUTH 3RD STREET
ERIE STREET/LINCOLN HIGHWAY
LOFTS
GREEN ROOF
LOFTS
HOSPITAL
HOSPITAL EVENT SPACE
PLAYGROUND
BREWERY
WALK IN CLINICS
COMMUNITY CENTER
WAITING ROOMS
LEVEL ONE
SCALE: 1” = 200’ - 0”
LEVEL TWO
SCALE: 1” = 200’ - 0”
LEVEL THREE
SCALE: 1” = 200’ - 0”
PHASE 2 / EMOTION
49
MISSOURI VALLEY
SOUTH EAST SECTION AXON SCALE: 1”= 30’ - 0”
50
PHASE 2 / EMOTION
NORTH ELEVATION PERSPECTIVE 3
LOOKING SOUTH WEST
1
51
MISSOURI VALLEY 2
PERSPECTIVE 2 LOOKING SOUTH
52
PHASE 2 / EMOTION
53
MISSOURI VALLEY PERSPECTIVE 3:
LOOKING NORTH EAST
54
PHASE 2 / EMOTION
3
55
MISSOURI VALLEY
56
PHASE 3 / PROPOSAL
PHASE 03
ARCH 510: reFORM
PROPOSAL EMELIA THOMPSON
57
MISSOURI VALLEY
PREV
CAH GREENSPACE + EVENTS/FUNDRAISING ACCESS TO HEALTH CARE / WELLNESS
COMMUNITY PARK / AMPHITHEATER
BUILDING A LOCAL NETWORK
YOGA IN THE PARK
YOGA STUDIO
BIG CITY AMENITIES
LOCAL BARS / RESTAURANTS
TASTINGS, EVENTS, AND FUNDRAISERS
“BALANCE AND BREW”
58
CO C
LOFTS
PROXIMITY TO FREE AMENITIES
BREWERY
B
PHASE 3 / PROPOSAL
LOFTS / BOTH MIDDLE INCOME AND SENIOR LIVING 935-1000 SF
BREWERY 1800 SF
KITCHEN EVENT SPACE 4000 SF 800 SF
OFFICES 400 SF
GYM 5400 SF
PHYSICAL THERAPY CLINIC 3600 SF
AUDITORIUM 2400 SF DIETICIAN, COSMETIC DERMATOLOGY, AND PAIN CLINICS, PHARMACY 1800 SF
MEETING ROOMS 600 SF
59
MISSOURI VALLEY SPECIALIZED FITNESS PROGRAM
SENIOR FOCUSED SERVICES
PHARMACY HOSPICE CARE
OBESITY FOCUSED SERVICES
PREVENTATIVE CARE
DIETICIAN PHYSICAL THERAPY GYM
YOUNG ADULT FOCUSED SERVICES
TELEPHONE/ONLINE ACCESS BOUTIQUE COSMETIC SERVICES PAIN CLINIC
TOWN SPECIFIC SERVICES
INSURANCE EDUCATION NARCOTIC ADDICTION SERVICES
KITCHEN
LARGE EVENT SPACE
BAR RESTROOMS OUTDOOR EVENT SPACE
COMMUNITY CENTER
AUDITORIUM
AUDITORIUM/MEETING SPACES
MEETING SPACE 1 MEETING SPACE 2
BUILDING A LOCAL NETWORK
CHAMBER OF COMMERCE
FLEXIBLE OFFICE SPACES
EMPLOYEES RENTABLE OFFICES
CAL BARS / STAURANTS
PATIO
BREWERY
STILLS TAPROOM DINING
SENIOR LIVING
BAR BAR STORAGE SEATING RESTROOMS
ACCESSIBLE COMMUNITY SPACE
LOFTS MID INCOME
60
BALCONY/PATIO COMMUNAL SPACE
PHASE 3 / PROPOSAL
BA
R
IN
SU
PR
IN
EY
EC
AL
SU
FL GA
AN
TIQ
LA
WN
FL
BA
IN
OW
R
SU
RA
NC
EA
GE
ER
AN
D
GA
UE
ST
CH
ER
ST
DE
IR
OW
UD
SH
RA
IO
OP
AB
GR
ILL
NT
NC
EA
IST
GE
NC
Y
LIN
IC
AR
MA
RA
NT
OP
SU
TL
D
RA CY NC TO EA TH GE EA NC TR NC Y E EA GE NC Y RI
IN
YO
IN
PH
DE
RA
AN
IST
CT
OR
OR
E
RD
EN
SH
OP
NC
Y
61
MISSOURI VALLEY
missouri valley zoomed in
ADJACENT BUILDING CONSTRAINTS:
TO CONSTRAIN PROPORTIONS AND PROVIDE A BASIS OF WHERE TO PLACE THE NEW BUILDING, CREATED GUIDELINES OFF ADJACENT BUILDINGS
SINGLE MODULE:
August 29, 2017
0
0.075
TO KEEP THE STRUCTURE FROM APPEARING TOO MASSIVE 0 IN 0.075 A 0.15 RATHER LOW KEY MAIN STREET, BEGAN WITH A 30’ X 75’ FOOT MODULE. THE MODULE WAS SIZED TO ACCOUNT FOR LARGE PROGRAMMING WHILE FITTING IN WITH THE BAR LANGUAGE OF THE CURRENT MISSOURI VALLEY DOWNTOWN.
1:9,028
0.15
0.3 km
Source: Esri, DigitalGlobe, GeoEye, Earthstar Geographics, DS, USDA, USGS, AeroGRID, IGN, and the GIS User Communi
PEDESTRIAN THOROUGHFARE: PROPOSED PARK IN CURRENT RAILYARD
62
SPLIT INTERVENTION INTO 2 BUILDINGS. CREATES A PEDESTRIAN PATHWAY TO PROPOSED PARK, AND ALLOWS EACH PROGRAM TO OCCUPY IT’S OWN SPACE WHILE STILL CREATING LINKS BETWEEN THEM. MAXIMIZES ADJACENCIES BETWEEN EXISTING BUILDINGS ON MAIN STREET AND PROPOSED PROGRAMS.
Iowa State Unive
PHASE 3 / PROPOSAL
ARRAY ON A CURVE
ARRAYED MODULE ALONG A CURVE TO EMBRACE THE LOESS HILLS TOPOGRAPHY WHILE ALSO CREATING ZONES BETWEEN PROGRAMS AND THE PARK.
PEAKS AND VALLEYS:
VIE
WC
OR
RID
OR
SECOND AND THIRD ADDED TO THE WESTERN BUILDING TO MAXIMIZE THOSE LOESS HILLS VIEWS AND PROVIDE A VIEW CORRIDOR TO THE SOUTHEAST. PULLED BACK ROOFLINES CALL OUT TO THE WESTERN IOWA LANDMARKS, PROVIDING VALLEYS AND PEAKS. RESIDENTIAL UNITS ARE PLACED ON TOP TO PROVIDE PRIVACY WHILE ALSO ALLOWING FOR MAXIMUM PUBLIC INTERACTION TO THE COMMUNITY AND WELLNESS CENTERS BELOW.
63
T
APAR
APARTMENT
TMEN
T
MISSOURI VALLEY
TMEN
APA
RTM
ENT
APAR
SITE PLAN
3RD FLOOR
SCALE: 1” = 120’ - 0”
LOFT
BREWERY
LOFT
SCALE: 1” = 150’ - 0”
MEN’S LOCKER
OFFICE
COMM UN WAITIN AL G AREA
ICE
1ST FLOOR
SCALE: 1” = 120’ - 0”
64
IUM ITOR AUD
WOMEN’S LOCKER
2ND FLOOR
SCALE: 1” = 120’ - 0”
PHARMACY
COSMETIC WELLNESS SPA
IC
MEETING ROOM
COMMUNAL BREAK ROOM
OOM
IO
CLIN
STUD
PAIN
EVENT SPACE
R TING MEE
KITCHEN
IST
ION
RIT
OFFICE
AL YSIC PH RAPY THE
GYM
NUT
OFFICE
OFF
PHASE 3 / PROPOSAL
PERSPECTIVE LOOKING SOUTH
BREWERY IN THE FOREGROUND, COMMUNITY CENTER BEYOND RIGHT, WELLNESS CLINIC BEYOND LEFT
PERSPECTIVE LOOKING NORTHWEST WELLNESS CENTER
65
MISSOURI VALLEY
PERSPECTIVE LOOKING SOUTHEAST PARK PERSPECTIVE
SOUTH ELEVATION 66
PHASE 3 / PROPOSAL
67
MISSOURI VALLEY
PERSPECTIVE LOOKING SOUTH
BREWERY IN THE FOREGROUND, COMMUNITY CENTER BEYOND RIGHT, WELLNESS CLINIC BEYOND LEFT
68
PHASE 3 / PROPOSAL
69
MISSOURI VALLEY
EXISTING NORTH ELEVATION
PROPOSED NORTH ELEVATION 70
PHASE 3 / PROPOSAL
71
MISSOURI VALLEY
SITE PLAN
SCALE: 1” = 75’ - 0”
72
PHASE 3 / PROPOSAL ERIE STREET
BREWERY
EXECUTIVE OFFICE
LOCKER ROOM BATHROOM
BATHROOM
OFFICE
GYM OFFICE
OFFICE
KITCHEN
DIETICIAN CLINIC
EVENT BALLROOM STUDIO
PHYSICAL THERAPY CLINIC
LOCKER ROOM
CONFERENCE ROOM
FIRST FLOOR
SCALE: 1” = 50’ - 0”
73
MISSOURI VALLEY ERIE STREET
UPPER PATIO
OFFICE
COMMUNAL WAITING AREA
STORAGE
CONFERENCE ROOM UPPER EVENT SPACE
AUDITORIUM OFFICE
SECOND FLOOR SCALE: 1” = 50’ - 0”
74
COMMUNAL KITCHEN AND BREAK ROOM
PAIN CLINIC W/ PHARMACY
WELLNESS SPA & CLINIC
PHASE 3 / PROPOSAL ERIE STREET
STORAGE APARTMENT 4
APARTMENT 1
APARTMENT 3 APARTMENT 2
THIRD FLOOR
SCALE: 1” = 50’ - 0”
75
MISSOURI VALLEY SOUTH FACING SECTION PERSPECTIVE
76
PHASE 3 / PROPOSAL
77
MISSOURI VALLEY
PERSPECTIVE LOOKING NORTH WEST UPPER PATIO
78
PHASE 3 / PROPOSAL
79
MISSOURI VALLEY
PERSPECTIVE LOOKING SOUTH EAST UPPER PATIO
80
PHASE 3 / PROPOSAL
81
MISSOURI VALLEY
82
PHASE 3 / PROPOSAL EVENT SPACE PERSPECTIVE
83
MISSOURI VALLEY
PERSPECTIVE LOOKING SOUTHEAST PARK PERSPECTIVE
84
PHASE 3 / PROPOSAL
85