EMILY A. DAVIS design portfolio
personal & design ethics Ecologically intelligent design offers methods to solve problems, and empower people in their environment while supporting ecological processes. I can work with both individuals and communities to help create a culture of resiliency. Providing meaningful design solutions means understanding the root of the problem. A comprehensive site analysis is crucial in determining an informed solution, and is a key element in my design process. This context is essential, as understanding an element’s place within a system will help identify its functions and the factors that influence it. This whole-system’s perspective is represented in my work, and embodied in ecological design principles. Finally, beauty is a key element in developing successful design solutions. My goal is to create places that inspire and motivate people. I believe that good design can provide a means for people to be their best selves, and our lives change for the better when our environments are designed to inspire us.
E M I LY A . D A V I S emily@edavisdesign.com (203)-470-3205
1339 Bonnyvale Rd, Brattleboro, VT
EDUCATION & TRAINING
MS Ecological Design The Conway School Graduate Program of Sustainable Landscape Planning & Design Conway, MA June 2014 BS Environmental GeoChemistry Magna Cum Laude State University of New York at New Paltz New Paltz, NY May 2011 Certificate, Ecological Design in the Built Environment Certificate, Permaculture Design Yestermorrow Design/Build School Warren, VT Jan 2012 - July 2013
WORK HISTORY
Owner | Emily A. Davis Design Conduct client meetings and consulations, complete designs, and install proposed design. Designs are primarily residential and site-scale, and include grading and drainage improvements, as well as using native plant palettes to function more sustainably. Brattleboro, VT Apr 2014 - current Landscaping & Gardening | Broadleaf Landscape Architecture Implemented and maintained residential landscape designs. Warren, VT Apr 2012 - Nov 2012 Field Research & GIS Staff | NYC Department of Environmental Protection Conducted field research and collected data on stream features. Applied GIS mapping and analyzed stream characteristics and bank erosion. Kingston, NY June 2010 - Dec 2010
ADDITIONAL EXPERIENCE
INTERESTS
SKILLS
Nov 2010 - Jan 2012
Editor’s Assistant | Capitalism Nature Socialism Journal Revised and applied style corrections to academic manuscripts. Promoted journal to eco-socialist groups and organizations. New Paltz, NY
Aug 2010 - May 2011
Teacher’s Assistant | SUNY New Paltz Hydrogeology Lab Student assistant to Dr. Shafiul Chowdhury during the Hydrogeology course Hydrogeology Lab monitoring and project assistance
Jan 2009 - July 2009
Hydrogeology & Water Quality Study | CloudBridge Nature Reserve San Gerardo de Rivas, Costa Rica Completed a study of water systems in an upper montane tropical forest.
Nov 2008 - June 2011
Commissioner | Village of New Paltz Environmental Conservation Commission Coordinated interns on environmental projects and research. Conducted community outreach and facilitated public meetings.
Graphic design Wild foods & foraging Cooking Rock climbing
Adobe Creative Suite Microsoft Office Graphic Design SketchUp Surveying
Photography Drawing & sketching Creative writing
Botanical Illustration ESRI ArcGIS Spanish Language Architectural Drafting AutoCAD
collection of work
AV E
EXISTING 4.3’ DIAMETER BLACK WALNUT
N
COMMUNITY PAVILION
UE
EN
A’ PARKING
MEADOW
STEV
NE
S LA
•
RENOVATED BARN
REINFORCED TURF
Phase 2: Spring •
FOOT TRAIL TO WILDLIFE VIEWING BLIND
a possible emaking ideas the overall em. Each ready underway cts that build g the ecological y existing rmediate stable, but still
MEADOW
•
BOARDWALK OVER WET MEADOW
Studio Apartment
FOOD FOREST PLANTINGS ON CONTOUR
A
The single story garage gains a second floor, and 0 25 50 Feet this studio apartment can be rented long- or short-term for those seeking a peaceful living space. Utilities are easily connected from the Figure 13.1: Aerial perspective of the proposed homestead main house.
•
EXISTING OLD APPLE GROVE
•
Walking paths should be built in early summer once the meadow has begun to establish. If the meadow has grown too high, the paths should be mowed before the tread is dug, lined, and lightly filled with crushed gravel or heavily topped with wood chips from trees chipped on site.
Phase 4: Mid-summer to mid-fall •
Walking paths should be staked out early in the spring and observed throughout the wettest season so adjustments in the design can be made before the paths are made permanent. Bare-root trees and shrubs that were ordered during the winter should be planted after having their roots soaked in an all-natural mycrorhizal dip that helps the plant roots quickly establish with the fungi present in the soil. Heavy mulching is recommended to hold in moisture and suppress weed growth. A light tilling of the soil should be done after seasonal deluges but before the last spring rains, followed by the seeding and
Newly planted trees and shrubs should be watered if rain fall is scarce throughout the summer. End-of-the-season donated plants should be planted in early fall, heavily watered, and thickly mulched to protect against the winter freeze-and-thaw cycle.
EXISTING 4.3’ BLACK WALNUT
area, featuring the community food forest and pavilion.
new projects in hs represented eas could evolve and the distinct
Phase 3: Early summer
EXISTING BLACK WALNUT AND SPRUCE TREES
PARKING LOT
Shaded Deck Plantings Productive vines grow on an existing pergola on the deck to create a shady microclimate during EXISTING CONDITIONS: the hot summer months.
FOOD FOREST PLANTINGS ON CONTOUR, WITH SWALES AND BERMS (PERMITTING REQUIRED)
WET LAWN & GROUNDWATER SEEP
WESTERN AVENUE
NEW REGRADED STAGING AREA, WITH REINFORCED TURF
FOREST EDGE EXTENDED PARKING CONFIGURATION
Upper Terrace Garden
R HOLYOKE’S INNOVATION DISTRICT 0
10
20
40
FEET
Early Successional Management Plan
a of early successional forest is managed to remove invasive exotic plant species, titute native species that will help maintain this area as ecologically beneficial and nt. Fruiting shrubs and young trees provide important forage and habitat for many d species and birds.
2 -7
Guest-Writer’s Cabin
The forest edge undulates in this area to reduce the amount of mowed lawn space, and the arrival experience is improved. Composting bins are built around a fertility bank and bioaccumulating plants to help provide needed nutrients to the soils.
8-13
W
PROPOSED DESIGN:
BOARDWALK OVER WET MEADOW
14-19
31
MEADOW PLANTINGS TO REPLACE LAWN
Figure 13.2: Section A-A’ Existing & Proposed Homestead Area
WESTERN AVENUE
Sheet:
E Feet
(Not for construction. This drawing is part of a student project, and not based on a legal survey.)
20-23
The Conway School, Spring 2014
RN
Emily Davis & Brandon Tennis
TE
Sherborn, MA
•
ES
Town of Sherborn Conservation Commission & The Land Management Task Force
W
EXISTING FOOT TRAIL TO NATIVE MEADOW
ART WORK
Managing the
es in this hese themes: pontaneous onments, ban agriculture,
All excavation and berming should be done in late summer when the water table is low and enough growing season remains to establish a cover crop for the fall and winter. A cover crop will stabilize the newly disturbed soil and limit weed growth. Fill and grading for the staging area and extend the parking lot can also be done at this time while machinery is already on site. Reinforced turf should be dug into place and lightly mulched to prevent erosion. Building the trailhead lean-to during this initial phase may give community members a sense of progress while construction continues into the next season.
matting of native meadow plant species. A polyculture mix of nitrogen-fixing and dynamic-accumulating plant species should be sown throughout the forest garden (see Appendix I for a food forest plant palette).
Listening to the Landscape
•
The forest edge is allowed to enter the area that was once mowed, thereby reducing the overall area that needs to be mowed. Productive, shade tolerant woodland plants are encouraged to grow along beneficial tree species and important wildlife forage. A sitting area in the hemlock forest provides a way to enjoy the forest landscape and the sound of the streams.
MASTER PLANNING
Phase 1: Late summer
Barber Reservation
NGretirement, IDEAS and the her ound oasis.
LAND MANAGEMENT
Homestead Phasing
Woodland Garden
HOMESTEAD PHASING
URBAN PLANNING
DESIGN DETAILS
PRIVATE RESIDENCE
13
27
24-27
A guest or writer’s cabin is an appropriate way to share the natural charm and beauty of the site with those who would benefit from the landscape around it. This rustic cabin would have a low-impact on the sensitive aquatic buffer habitat around it, and sit conveniently into a natural amphitheater.
1
private residence CHARLEMONT, MA SEPT - DEC 2013
The site for this design project was steep and ecologically sensitive. The client, a single woman approaching her retirement, wanted to explore ideas for how she can age in place on this rural property, while also making it productive and maintaining it as a serene landscape. The proposed design includes permaculture gardens, a plan for a composting program and plantings for increased soil fertility, low-maintenance woodland gardens, path grading for accessibility, and a management plan for invasive species, while respecting the sensitive nature of the site’s ecology.
2
“
The plan exceeded my expectations—it is thoroughly researched and executed. -project client
”
final proposed design Woodland Garden
The client stays on the property into her retirement, and the site becomes an inviting ecologically sound oasis.
The forest edge is allowed to enter the area that was once mowed, thereby reducing the overall area that needs to be mowed. Productive, shade tolerant woodland plants are encouraged to grow along beneficial tree species and important wildlife forage. A sitting area in the hemlock forest provides a way to enjoy the forest landscape and the sound of the streams.
Conservation Easement This four-acre forest and upland aquatic habitat, including ecologically significant perennial streams, is of high value to the Franklin County Land Trust. A conservation easement on this property ensures that it is protected from human impact or development in the future.
Studio Apartment The single story garage gains a second floor, and this studio apartment can be rented long- or short-term for those seeking a peaceful living space. Utilities are easily connected from the main house.
Gathering Area A once open lawn area becomes a sitting or gathering space that enjoys the sounds of the stream and the stunning views into the forest. Meadow plantings surround the space to make it more intimate and inviting.
Shaded Deck Plantings Productive vines grow on an existing pergola on the deck to create a shady microclimate during the hot summer months.
Productive Meadow Vinca is removed, and existing stumps are used in retaining terraces to create a terraced meadow. Productive food-bearing plants are interplanted with low maintenance native perennials and grasses, bio-accumulators, beneficial insectaries, and plants that provide habitat for songbirds and small mammals. Plants are selected to increase native biodiversity, ecological habitat, human food production, slope stability, and aesthetic views from the home.
Upper Terrace Garden
0
10
20
40
The forest edge undulates in this area to reduce the amount of mowed lawn space, and the arrival experience is improved. Composting bins are built around a fertility bank and bioaccumulating plants to help provide needed nutrients to the soils.
FEET
Early Successional Management Plan This area of early successional forest is managed to remove invasive exotic plant species, and substitute native species that will help maintain this area as ecologically beneficial and significant. Fruiting shrubs and young trees provide important forage and habitat for many woodland species and birds.
Guest-Writer’s Cabin A guest or writer’s cabin is an appropriate way to share the natural charm and beauty of the site with those who would benefit from the landscape around it. This rustic cabin would have a low-impact on the sensitive aquatic buffer habitat around it, and sit conveniently into a natural amphitheater.
3
Steep slopes dominate the site; creating dramatic character, reducing mobility & threatening erosion. OBSERVATIONS Slopes
A
• • •
A' >30% 25-29%
•
A foot path southwest of the house cuts through a mowed lawn at >30% grade. Because of the confining slopes, car access onto to site is limited, except for truck access to the west of the house.
Slow water
20-24% 15-19% 10-14%
Foot path
5-9%
Car access
0-5%
Access and Circulation •
Fast water
A potentially erosive band of >30% grade wraps around the house, dividing the property into an upper and lower terrace. Much of the topographic complexity is anthropogenic—old stone foundations and stone retaining walls occur throughout the property. Many of these stone walls are crumbling, indicating unstable slopes.
Truck access
Drainage 0
10
20
•
40 FEET
• •
The rate at which water drains on the property is a function of topography and vegetation—water moves quickly over the >30% lawn than the forest. The soils are well drained—a Woodbridge very stony loam. The site drains directly into Hartwell and Willis Brooks, which then flow into the Deerfield River.
DESIGN DIRECTIONS g g g g
Incorporate slope stabilizing strategies. Utilize and mimic the terracing pattern addressing the steep lawn. Improve access by reducing percent grade on paths, where possible. Consider impact on streams, and incorporate water infiltration methods for runoff.
SECTION A-A'
Thesite & assessment Conwayanalysis School Raviele Residence Landscape plan for the
Fall 2013
slopes, drainage, circulation Emily A. Davis 4
552 Mountain Road Charlemont, MA 01339
Summary Analysis
Slopes, Access and Drainage
4 19
site analysis & assessment site intimacy, views, and sound; portraying the meaningful relationship between the client and the place The landscape is like artwork; the views are a painting, and the sounds a symphony. OBSERVATIONS Sounds Inherent to the Site: • •
A
Cascading water in the stream, wind blowing through the trees, and singing birds. Dynamic sounds from the streams travel as a function of vegetation and topography—sound is carried easily over the bare west lawn and to the deck.
Desired & Undesired Views: A'
• • •
Exist from the house, but are also layered with undesired views. Some of the desired views (in the forest to the north of the house, in the lower lawn, etc.) are not being utilized well. The one unpleasant view corresponds with other problematic site conditions (a very steep slope, early successional invasive or aggressive plant species).
Loved & Valued Spaces: Undesired/negative view Desired/positive view
•
Relative Decibel Levels Loud television (>60 Db)
•
Normal conversation (50-59 Db)
The deck that overlooks the gardens, the old mill foundation, and the area of forest to the north of the house are highly valued for their natural beauty or peaceful qualities. The stony streams and forest are valued, but not visited very frequently.
Rainfall (40-49 Db) Quiet conversation (30-39 Db)
Loved/valued space
Rustling leaves (20-29 Db) 0
10
20
DESIGN DIRECTIONS
40 FEET
g g g
Capitalize on strategic areas close to the stream that could be used as sitting or gathering areas. Improve views onto the stumpy lawn from the deck. Preserve and highlight valued and loved areas.
SECTION A-A'
The Conway School Fall 2013
Landscape plan for the
Raviele Residence
Summary Analysis
5
6
A shady woodland garden seeks inspiration from the abundant forests that surround it. Transplanted Native & Localized Plant Species
Trail to hemlock stand, with view to streams
Many of the plants used in this area could be sources and transplanted from forested areas of the property. This would make garden installation less expensive, and would ensure that introduced plants are hardy and naturalized to the site conditions.
ge est ed ed for d n e t x E
Gardens Mimic Forest Structure
Existing sugar maple provides canopy for understory species
0
10
20
Extended forest edge
Existing vinca groundcover
Looking to the forest for inspiration, plants could be placed so that all structural niches are filled. Understory, herbaceous, shrub, and canopy plants should be represented in planting schemes. Introducing larger shrub and tree species would compliment a dense vinca patch to the north of the home, which is currently an establish understory.
Bringing Wild Foods Closer to Home Although many of the selected plants are naturalized woodland species, native edible plants can still be introduced into the plant palette, creating a “forage garden.” The client would then be able to browse the garden for wild food sources in her bunny slippers.
PLANT LIST Understory Species & Groundcovers:
FEET
*Wild violet (Viola sororia)
Wild anemone (Anemone canadensis)
*Running sensitive fern (Onoclea sensibilis)
Jacob’s ladder (Polemonium reptans
*Wild ginger (Asarum canadense)
Lady’s slipper (Cypripedium parviflorum)
Herbaceous Perennials:
The forest edge is encouraged to grow into the woodland garden, providing native plants and blurring the boundary between managed and unmanaged spaces.
† *Ostrich fern (Matteuccia pensylvanica)
Foamflower (Tiarella cordifolia)
Maidenhair fern (Adiantum pedatum)
Coral bells (Heuchera americana)
Small Trees & Shrubs: † Mountain laurel (Kalmia latifolia)
Spruce (Picea pungens)
Paper birch (Betula papyrifera)
Red twig dogwood (Cornus sericea)
* Edible or medicinal plants † Plants that may be harvested from the property or surrounding forest
proposed design The Conway School Fall 2013
Emily A. Davis
Landscape plan for the
Raviele Residence 552 Mountain Road Charlemont, MA 01339
Design Detail
Woodland Garden
a low-maintenance woodland garden and native plant palette that uses productive eco-types 6
13 19
proposed design a management plan for invasive species in a young succession habitat, with improved aesthetics Young forests provide valuable habitat for many species, especially those that generally do not occur in mature forests. Shrublands and young forest communities provide a unique vegetative structure and diversity that provides nesting, brood rearing, feeding, and escape habitats for early successional wildlife. They are forest gaps, with woody plants typically less than 15-ft tall and scattered grasses and wildflowers that provide floristic diversity. Shrubland-preferring pollinators, insects, and birds may find welcome refuge in young forest patches such as this one, as it stands amidst a much broader forest system. Management plans for these areas generally encourage a mixture of early successional grasses, herbs, shrubs, and saplings, since these combinations are the most valuable for wildlife. This management plan recommends preserving the existing young forest as an ecologically significant area, while improving its aesthetic appearance. Invasive plants are removed and replaced with beneficial and productive native species, and periodic removal of woody tree saplings create a stable shrubland habitat. Currently, Staghorn sumac (Rhus typhina) grows in the shrubland and within view from the home. This plant provides an important food source for birds in winter and early spring. When allowed to mature, its fall red canopy is beautiful and dramatic. This management plan leaves the sumac in place, and includes planted shrubs to soften the visual affects of the sumac.
RECOMMENDED MANAGEMENT STEPS:
1.
3.
The first step to managing this area is to identify and remove exotic invasive or other undesired species. These may include: -Multiflora rose (Rosa multiflora) -Autumn olive (Elaeagnus umbellata)
Once native shrubs are planted, monitor for the establishment of tree species such as maples, red oaks, and pines. Over time, larger woody species with trunk diameters of three inches or greater could be removed mechanically. This will keep the system at an early-successional phase.
Once these species are removed, they should be burnt on site to prevent spreading. It is not recommended that all these plants be removed at once. It is better to stage their removal in small, periodic steps so as to minimize site disturbance.
Many tree species will re-sprout from the roots of a cut trunk. Care should be taken to prevent the tree from sprouting in undesired places, such as new garden beds.
2.
A native substitute should be available for transplanting during the removal of an undesired species, so a niche is filled before another aggressive plant moves in. Refer to Appendix II for a full list of productive and native shrubs that could replace the removed plants.
4.
These three steps could be repeated through time until the desired plant community has been achieved. Once a mixed herbaceous and shrubland habitat has been created, selective cutting of mid-successional hardwood tree saplings will be needed every 3-5 years.
Before:
Staghorn sumac
New productive shrubs Forest edge
Before management, invasive species and young trees grow amongst sumac and other shrubs.
Goldenrod & multiflora rose Oak sapling
Young forest habitat 0
Mature forest, with higher canopy
5
Mowed area
10 FEET
Old foundation
After: Raised beds
Extended meadow, with grasses and wildflowers
Planted shrubs Forest edge
Meadow plants
After management, beneficial shrubs are planted, young trees are pruned, and the sumac is allowed to grow. Meadow plantings border the early forest area, increasing its appeal to wildlife.
Staghorn sumac 0
10
20
FEET
0
The Conway School Fall 2013
5
Landscape plan for the
Raviele Residence
10
FEET
Smaller mowed area
Design Detail
16
7
urban planning HOLYOKE, MA JAN - APR 2014
As part of a three-person team, this project aimed at providing Holyoke’s Office of Planning and Economic Development with a Placemaking Ideabook for their new Innovation District. As part of their efforts to foster innovation-based economy, this project provided a vision for what innovation could look like in this economicallydepressed and ethnically-diverse city. Ultimately, the IdeaBook provided a framework for understanding the succession of placemaking efforts in Holyoke using an ecological metaphor, and proposed community-based placemaking strategies to promote the city’s new creative economy. This project was an exercise in whole-systems thinking, and communicating complex concepts in simple ways. Primary duties included collaborative authoring and editing, graphic design, GIS mapping, and design renderings.
8
final deliverable IdeaBook cover and Table of Contents
The Conway School is the only institution of its kind in North America. Its focus is sustainable landscape planning and design, and its graduates are awarded a Master of Science in Ecological Design degree. Each year, through its accredited, ten-month graduate program, students from diverse backgrounds are immersed in a range of real-world design projects, ranging in scale from residents to regions. Graduates go on to play a significant professional roles in various aspects of landscape planning and design.
A P L A C E M A K I N G IDEABOOK FOR H O LYO K E ’ S I N N O V AT I O N DISTRICT
Emily Davis, Jeffrey Dawson, Elizabeth Kelly
Building on successful examples from other cities and on already-existing projects in Holyoke, this Idea Book suggests various strategies, at multiple scales and time-frames, to help create public spaces that foster the social interaction that is critical to innovation. These strategies involve promoting art and creative expression; temporary “pop-ups”; pedestrian- and bike-friendly environments; connections to canals and the Connecticut River; urban agriculture; and urban ecological repair.
A PLACEMAKING IDEABOOK
The City of Holyoke would like to promote an expansion of its innovation-based economy. By focusing placemaking efforts on existing cultural and physical resources and the talents and initiative of its residents, Holyoke could support a culture of home-grown creativity, resilience, and innovation, create a strong sense of place, improve quality of life, and create conditions attractive to visitors and entrepreneurs.
Prepared for the
Pioneer Valley Planning Commission and the
City of Holyoke’s Office of Planning and Economic Development Emily Davis, Jeffrey Dawson & Elizabeth Kelly Conway School of Landscape Design Winter 2014
TABLE OF CONTENTS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
1
CONTEXT: THE BASICS
PLACEMAKING IDEAS
30
Arts & creative expression
32
Envisioning the innovation economy
4
Pop-ups to permanent
50
Defining innovation in Holyoke
6
Mobility & connections
68
Innovation ecosystems
8
Urban agriculture
84
Holyoke’s distinctive qualities
10
Connection to waterways
96
Placemaking 101
24
Ecological repair
114
The city as a forest
28
MOVING FORWARD
132
GLOSSARY
136
REFERENCES
138
9
proposed principles and strategies of placemaking creating and providing site-specific principles and best practices within Holyoke PLACEMAKING 101
PRINCIPLES FOR CREATING AN INNOVATION ECOSYSTEM This document suggests that bottom-up, grass-roots placemaking can contribute significantly to creating an innovation ecosystem. Placemaking is a process that turns physical spaces into meaningful places. The difference between the two is that places are created and shaped by people, and therefore embody their values and talents. Spaces are generic or commonplace locations that don’t necessarily promote expression or inspire those within it. Placemaking is especially relevant for Holyoke right now, since there are many spaces in the city that merit transformation, and available talent that can transform them into places. The conditions for placemaking—the space, the talent, and the need—are all present in Holyoke.
24
Innovative and sustainable urban development can occur by tapping the residents as the source of its innovation. Innovative ideas for Holyoke can capitalize on the existing assets of the city, are inclusive of the existing community, and explore new and creative solutions to problems. The placemaking principles opposite are based on successful efforts elsewhere, and respond to the cultural and physical contexts of Holyoke. The principles can guide placemaking actions, and result in places that are designed for people. These principles can also serve as inspiration in the formation of new ideas that may improve the quality of city life, stimulate the economy, and improve the sustainability of the city.
A PLACEMAKING IDEABOOK FOR HOLYOKE’S INNOVATION DISTRICT
CONTEXT: THE BASICS | PRINCIPLES OF PLACEMAKING
PLACEMAKING IDEAS
25
The six placemaking strategies in this document are organized by these themes: art and creative expression, spontaneous interactions, pedestrian environments, connection to waterways, urban agriculture, and ecological repair. Each of these themes shows a possible succession of individual placemaking ideas and represents one thread of the overall proposed innovation ecosystem. Each theme highlights initiatives already underway in Holyoke, and offers projects that build on existing efforts. Following the ecological metaphor, the themes identify existing pioneer species, explore intermediate strategies, and lead to a more stable, but still dynamic, future. Community initiatives spawn new projects in unpredictable ways. The paths represented here are just one way that ideas could evolve from the people of Holyoke and the distinct assets of the city.
10
30
A PLACEMAKING IDEABOOK FOR HOLYOKE’S INNOVATION DISTRICT
31
THE CITY CITYAS ASAA FOREST FOREST THE
ANECOLOGICAL ECOLOGICALMETAPHOR METAPHORFOR FORHOLYOKE’S HOLYOKE’SPLACEMAKING PLACEMAKING AN
SUCCESSFUL & When planning for innovation in Holyoke, it can help to think of the city as a forest ecosystem, and to see the ways its urban land uses change over time, as similar to the way forest vegetation changes. For example, after a fire burns down trees in a forested area, a different group of plants may grow that are adapted to the newly created open conditions—including more sunshine and exposure to wind. As
these pioneer species grow, they change the area, making conditions hospitable for other plants that couldn’t get established right after the fire. Successive plant communities can be eventually replaced by other groups of plants, and typically through this process increased biological diversity and stability may result. The process of ecological succession has similarities with successful placemaking.
INNOVATIVE PLACEMAKING
DIVERSE IN FORM AND FUNCTION BUILT FROM EXISTING RESOURCES
A PLACEMAKING IDEABOOK FOR HOLYOKE’S INNOVATION DISTRICT
28
A PLACEMAKING IDEABOOK FOR HOLYOKE’S INNOVATION DISTRICT
Being dynamic and allowing for a succession of projects and uses can lead to long-term, successful urban places. Finally, placemaking processes and ecosystems both can start small and slow. Starting small means not investing large amounts of energy or resources too early in the process. For example, a forest disturbance may be followed by the establishment of grasses and wildflowers; along a city street, small, temporary sales carts may be transformed into permanent businesses.
THE CITY IS A FOREST | AN ECOLOGICAL METAPHOR
27
With further development an ecosystem can reach
Transposing ecological terms into the context of Holyoke’s innovation ecosystem can help guide interventions in the complex social and economic systems of the city.
In Holyoke, a disturbance was created when the paper manufacturing industry left the city. A near monoculture of paper factories didn’t make the city resilient enough to withstand the economic implications of this exodus. This was one catalyst for a period of urban blight in the city.
ECOSYSTEMS
START SMALL, GROW SLOW
As systems develop, their success is often dependent on their resilience. Responding to disturbance or change, successful ecosystems and placemaking processes are diverse and adaptable over time.
Natural disturbances are isolated events or longterm patterns that change or alter the conditions of an ecosystem (such as a forest fire).
NATURAL
DYNAMIC THROUGH TIME
Ecosystems develop from the existing resources in their environment (for example, soils, available nutrients, and the amount of sunshine help determine which plant species will grow). Similarly, successful placemaking is an organic process that develops from the existing conditions of the urban environment.
26
HEALTHY
Intermediate species build off of the work Pioneer species take advantage of the condi-
tions left after a disturbance. They are opportunists, and are able to thrive with few resources. Often, pioneer species have numerous individuals, but are relatively short-lived. In Holyoke, social pioneers have been filling some of the vacancies left by economic disruption. These are small, grass-roots organizations and projects that make innovative use of the available resources.
done by the pioneers. They may require more space and resources, and therefore may be slower to appear and grow, but are generally more ecologically productive. In Holyoke, intermediate placemaking strategies can build from a primed innovation ecosystem started by pioneers. These intermediates are larger projects and land uses that may need more resources and time to develop, and can lead to a more robust and self-sustaining system.
a dynamic equilibrium, where biodiversity is maintained and materials for growth are recycled, even with changes in species. A more diverse ecosystem tends to be resilient in the face of some disturbances. As a diverse innovation ecosystem, Holyoke could reach a kind of dynamic equilibrium, where its economic and cultural activities create a robust city that supports a wide range of vibrant places, which in turn help make the city resilient as economic and cultural activities come and go over time.
THE CITY IS A FOREST | SUCCESSIONAL PLACEMAKING
providing a metaphor of ecological succession
29
developing a whole-systems framework for understanding the city’s social and physical complexities
proposed placemaking strategies
using graphics to portray innovative placemaking concepts 3. ART LANDMARKS AND WAYFINDING
ART & CREATIVE EXPRESSION
Merging functional wayfinding tactics with creativity and visual innovation could enhance pedestrian circulation throughout the district. Integrating art into the design of a wayfinding system could bring color and life to the sidewalks and streets. One of Holyoke’s most distinctive qualities is its high concentration of industrial buildings with large brick facades. The city’s large, monolithic building surfaces could be utilized by the artist community as a medium for creative wayfinding projects, creating urban landmarks for local residents and visitors alike.
46
Kevin Lynch, in The Image of the City, identified which features of the built city environment were important to its residents. He identified landmarks as being one of those elements. They are often physical structures such as a building or a sign and are somehow a prominent feature in the landscape. One example of a Holyoke landmark is City Hall, with its distinctive architecture and appearance. The presence of landmarks enables people to better navigate and understand where they are in the urban environment. Visual art displayed on infrastructural facades could become landmarks and create an innovative and artistic wayfinding system for people moving through Holyoke.
Collaborative efforts between public and private property owners, artists, businesses, and community groups for an artistic wayfinding system throughout the Innovation District could highlight art and cultural groups and buildings (such as Gateway City Arts, Open Square, and the like). Many artists in other cities have expanded their canvases to include public infrastructure, including the artists of the Philadelphia mural program described earlier. Creating large-scale works of art through the built environment could open up an opportunity for an “Innovation Walk” that brings residents and visitors around the city, telling them about the art work and the artists, organizations, and businesses that participated in them.
This shows one example of what an artistic wayfinding system could look like in Holyoke. This example doesn’t necessarily propose painting the privately-owned buildings downtown. Rather, it conceptually represents how visuals could guide people through a city. In this example, strips of bright colors line building facades, and color-code different clusters in a “subway map” fashion. Pedestrians could link the specific color to what that building is, helping them know where they are as they navigate through the city.
47
A PLACEMAKING IDEABOOK FOR HOLYOKE’S INNOVATION DISTRICT
4. NEW ENVIRONMENTAL INDUSTRIES
URBAN ECOLOGICAL REPAIR
Bioremediation of contaminated sites in Holyoke could potentially lead to the creation of new environmental industries in the city. Once specific plants and other organisms are identified as being effective in removing Holyoke-specific industrial contaminants, these species could be propagated at bioremediation centers in downtown. Innovative entrepreneurs or non-profits (such as Nuestras Raices, Cover Technologies Inc., or UMass Extension) may be valuable partners, and could help spread ecological awareness throughout communities while greening the city.
12
126
Such a phyto-remediation industry could lead to propagation centers such as plant nurseries or greenhouses that grow and distribute remediating plants. Residents could have access to these plants, either through a CSA model, grant funding, or private dollars. They could then grow them in their own neighborhoods or backyard gardens, creating a city-wide network of small bioremediation projects. This could empower the community by allowing them to participate in improving the environmental conditions and economic value of their neighborhoods. It could also improve the aesthetics and ecological functioning of Holyoke’s properties. These former industrial sites, with their large building footprints and industrial architecture, could provide ideal spaces for plant propagation or incubator spaces for new bioremediating businesses.
Downtown Holyoke would benefit from a new environmental industry that could bring muchneeded innovative green jobs. The unemployment rate in the downtown neighborhoods hovers around 35 percent (9 percent citywide) and approximately 28.6 percent of households earn less than $15,000 annually (2010 US Census Bureau).
The proposed new environmental industry could in addition be a powerful placemaking mechanism for Holyoke. A repaired urban environment around the Innovation District would become a healthier, more beautiful, and more ecologically productive downtown area, as properties are transformed from vacant industrial building lots to bioremediating urban greenspaces built through ecological citizenship and a newly skilled workforce.
Data displays could be made visible to the public, and communicate the environmental or restorative processes that occur within the new environmental industries, fostering civic engagement and stewardship.
But remediation efforts could do more than just create those new jobs. They could stimulate the city’s economy as a whole, through providing educational and job training opportunities. There are currently many youth education programs downtown, including YouthBuild Holyoke, the Care Center in Holyoke, Nueva Esperanza, and Girls Inc. Another example is Nuestras Raices’ “Roots Up” Green Job Training Program, which provides training to young people in downtown Holyoke for positions in fields such as solar hot water system installation, energy audits and weatherization, and sustainable agriculture. New industries in environmental remediation could work with programs like these to provide the necessary training for brownfield redevelopment practices, as well as actively improve the ecological conditions and functioning within these environmental justice neighborhoods. Thus, Holyoke could become a leader in bioremediation strategies for industrial contaminants for the region.
A PLACEMAKING IDEABOOK FOR HOLYOKE’S INNOVATION DISTRICT
127
3. A VIBRANT COMMERCIAL DOWNTOWN
FROM POP-UPS TO PERMANENT
The US Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) acknowledges that urban planning strategies and designated places that support temporary activation tends to lead to more permanent commercial areas. HUD’s publication on temporary urbanism points out that: “evidence suggests that the temporary reactivation of underutilized land leads to eventual permanent use, another potential benefit of this planning strategy. Temporary uses, particularly when clustered in a specific locality, can alter existing identities for neighborhoods—or even create entirely new ones— that are attractive to investors” (HUD 2014).
64
A culture supportive of temporary and popup businesses could attract those investors, and contribute to the creation of a vibrant commercial center downtown. Social media networks in particular could be a powerful tool in marketing temporary uses or pop-ups in an area. “Social networking applications such as Facebook and Twitter are being used to rapidly propagate an otherwise ‘exclusive’ pop-up project to a broad or niche audience. In instances where the temporary use activities aim to ameliorate social and cultural inequality, media coverage is also essential for generating wider awareness and garnering political support” (HUD 2014). Social networking applications can also be tracked to reflect the popularity (and possibly even success) of commercial or cultural activity in an area. A map of
Facebook “likes” of the various cultural resources (see pg. 41) in downtown Holyoke (opposite) shows a clustering of Facebook “likes” in the area around Dwight Street in downtown Holyoke and around Veteran’s Park. Of note is Fernandez Family Restaurant with 3,914 “likes,” Paper City Brewery with 2,454, the Holyoke YMCA with 1,449, the Holyoke Public Library with 1,221, and Nuestras Raices with 1,034. The distribution of Facebook “likes” indicates that certain Holyoke businesses have become cultural institutions, such as in the case of Fernandez Family Restaurant, and that groups with a high social networking presence are geographically clustered near each other. This kind of clustering could indicate the start of a small-business center, where Holyoke’s cultural institutions and businesses collaborate, with the common goal to reactivate Holyoke’s derelict spaces and create a vibrant commercial center downtown. HUD sees the importance of this kind of collaboration, suggesting that “capitalizing on social relationships between different groups and individuals—in particular, the sharing of knowledge, strategies, and experience—can be an important tool for fostering clusters of temporary use projects in a certain area. In addition, networking can engender new forms of cooperation; an area might develop a communal sense of identity, or members can benefit from economies of scale when negotiating permits” (HUD 2014).
MOBILITY & CONNECTIONS
the streets could be a powerful way to create positive community places in downtown Holyoke. For example, engaging the community in the creation of infiltrating rain gardens (either in the design or construction phases) along the streets downtown would provide the city with infrastructure that addresses the CSO problem, as well as beautifies the neighborhoods and creates a sense of ownership.
The Green Streets Guidebook notes that in downtown Holyoke “impervious surface covers 63 percent of the landscape and open space covers only 5 percent” (Carlson, Caughey and Ward 2014). This has strong implications for Holyoke’s impact on the Connecticut River, since “water quality becomes degraded when total impervious surface exceeds 10 percent.” Finally, Holyoke is required by the EPA to reduce its combined sewer runoff (CSOs) and treat its polluted stormwater.
In addition, street signs could explain how green infrastructure improves ecosystem functioning (see pg. 122), and inform residents and visitors about the city’s ecological connections to regional systems (such as the Connecticut River watershed), promoting landscape literacy.
Holyoke Children’s Museum
Enchanted Circle Theatre
Holyoke Public Library
Paper City Brewery
Nueva Esperanza
IMPERVIOUS SURFACE COVERAGE IN DOWNTOWN HOLYOKE
A dominant feature of downtown Holyoke is the high concentration of impervious surfaces, a byproduct of urbanization and industrialization. Though these surfaces don’t necessarily degrade the pedestrian experience, the area around the Innovation District could benefit from more open space or green infrastructure so that the built environment is more connected with the natural environment.
The Cake Lady
Smaller pop-ups and temporary uses in Holyoke could lead to this kind of urban center, where clusters of commercial activity foster a sense of cooperation through local small-business development. Accepting pop-ups as a valid and powerful method of economic development lead to a city where experimentation and innovation is embraced in economic development, leading to a city that is dynamic and resilient to future economic challenges.
A PLACEMAKING IDEABOOK FOR HOLYOKE’S INNOVATION DISTRICT
IMPERVIOUS SURFACES
76
Fernandez Family Restaurant
Capri Pizza
Nuestras Raices
65
SOURCE: Office of Geographic Information (MassGIS), Commonwealth of Massachusetts Information Technology Division, February 2014
PERMEABLE SURFACE IMPERVIOUS SURFACE
City officials have an opportunity to incorporate community placemaking in projects that reduce the amount of impervious surface in Holyoke. Community involvement in environmental activism has ecological, economic, and social benefits, and connecting open spaces and installing green infrastructure on
A PLACEMAKING IDEABOOK FOR HOLYOKE’S INNOVATION DISTRICT
77
proposed placemaking strategies
providing an informed vision, supporting ideas with meaningful and creative site analyses
13
land management planning SHERBORN, MA APR - JUNE 2014
As part of a two-person team, this project aimed to provide a vision and strategies for ecologically-sound land management for a 200-acre town-owned forest in Sherborn, MA. Just 20 miles from downtown Boston, this large open space is surrounding by urban development, and has the potential to serve many people in environmental justice communities. This parcel is used for passive recreation on the reservation’s trails by the local residents, especially equestrians and dog-walkers. But more notably, the reservation is also heavily used and impacted by utility companies. Natural gas pipelines, an industrial railroad, and electricity transmission lines all dissect and fragment this landscape. But within these linear and man-made features are dynamic and sensitive natural habitats. A beaver pond in the center of the property is expanding as the beavers continue to pool water, roughly 13-acres of hayfields remain in reminder of the reservation’s historic homestead, and areas of upland forest contain vernal pools and other valuable habitats. This project aimed to address and mitigate the impact of the utility corridors and integrate public access and recreation onto the site, while still maintaining ecological integrity. This management plan provided the Sherborn Conservation Commission with vision alternatives for the Barber Reservation, and identified a plan that would integrate utility corridor maintenance with the needs of the residents and wildlife that use the site. Design features and management recommendations included details for a native meadow establishment, a parking area schematic design, invasive species management, rotational grazing plan and strategies, forestry recommendation, and trail re-design.
14
CONNECTED MEADOW
The Bay Circuit Trail is reconnected to the Barber Reservation via a route around the northern edge of the beaver pond through the Humphrey’s Conservation Area. This trail alignment has to remain flexible as it is within a potentially dynamic landscape. Rerouting to the north may be necessary in response to changes in the beaver pond.
WILDLIFE BLIND
Bridge to Rail-to-Trail
SEE SHEET 12
Visitors also have the option to view wildlife from a boardwalk. The boardwalk allows people to step away from the woods-edge and out into the edge of the active beaver pond. The boardwalk can be reached from two directions by a footpath that meanders around the interior edge of the pond. Because the boardwalk lies inside of the dynamic landscape buffer, it is movable.
ET RE ST CU RV E
W
HI
TN
EY
ST
RAIL-TO-TRAIL ACCESS POINT
RE
The hayfields are connected by removing the hedgerows and removing the stone walls between them. They are then re-seeded as a native meadow, thereby increasing the site’s biodiversity and providing habitat for fieldnesting birds. The meadow is expanded to include road frontage, allowing views into the reservation and across the fields.
The entrance experience is improved by creating a more engaging environment that also improves ecological functioning and presents cultural values. The old homestead lawn is replanted as a community food forest.
LINES
Beaver Pond Viewing Boardwalk
PROPOSED RAIL-TO-TRAIL
Expanded Native Meadow
The parking area is improved to accommodate more visitors, as well as potential staging operations for timber, biochar, and food production (see Sheets 12-14). A community pavilion sits on the impacted site of the former tennis court. As this is the area with the most invasive plant species, impact is concentrated here to reduce their population and help control their spread.
ET
Figure 11.1: The
The Conway School, Spring 2014
Emily Davis & Brandon Tennis
New Park-like Entrance
TRANSMISSION
A bridge is constructed across the northern branch of the beaver pond to connect to the regional railto-trail path extending from the south, providing another entrance into the Barber Reservation. Using this route, visitors have easy access to the beaver habitat and the chance to view wildlife. This bridge would help establish permanent regional trail connections to the Barber Reservation via the rail-trail and the Bay Circuit Trail by crossing over the beaver pond instead of traversing the wetlands around it.
The trails on the Barber Reservation are designated for different uses, separating mixeduse and hiking-only trails and minimizing site disturbance by following gentle slopes across contours. Areas of pooling water are avoided and the wildlife blind is buffered, reducing conflict between user groups. Turning radii are kept obtuse to reduce erosion from high-impact use (such as with horses) and to eliminate the occurrence of cut-throughs across steeper slopes.
Sherborn, MA
BEAVER POND PIPELINES
Designated Horse Paths
Barber Reservation
, MA ASHLAND
BEE BOXES
Finally, utility corridors are used as points of access onto the reservation and their maintenance is integrated into the overall management plan.
Re-Routed Bay Circuit Trail
WESTERN AVENUE
THE HUMPHREY’S CONSERVATION AREA
Barber Reservation Proposed Plan
(Not for construction. This drawing is part of a student project, and not based on a legal survey.)
PROPOSED PLAN
H YARD
The beaver pond and the hayfields are allowed to expand, therefore increasing their habitat function, value, and ecosystem services, such as water retention.
SHERBORN, MA
This proposed design accommodates the need for public access and recreation and creates more cultural value for residents by providing facilities, trails, and structures across the landscape, including access to unique landscape features.
The meadow is connected to the transmission line corridor to enhance the potential for wildlife migration in and out of the interior of the reservation. This connection could increase the reservation’s wildlife value and biodiversity.
Managing the
Promoting restoration & integrity
Integrating Utility Maintenance with Meadow
Listening to the Landscape
RAILROAD SWITC
Proposed Plan
BAY CIRCUIT TRAIL
Town of Sherborn Conservation Commission & The Land Management Task Force
final proposed plan
Sheet:
11
27
15
A Beaver Meadow Eventually, the old pond drains and plant succession takes over, using the rich soil that was created by the beaver pond. This community of herbaceous plants in a wet meadow is very valuable habitat for birds and woodland species. With time, woodier plants take hold and revert these areas back to woodlands.
RAILROAD TRACKS
HUMPHREY’S CONSERVATION AREA
The Conway School, Spring 2014
Emily Davis & Brandon Tennis
Sherborn, MA
Woodland Stream Channelized woodland streams are good beaver habitat, especially when the forest contains vegetation that beavers like to eat, like red maple.
Barber Reservation
The Barber Reservation is part of a larger beaver habitat area within a regional wetland complex. This larger wetland complex has active beaver populations, and it is possible that beavers present on the Barber Reservation now have migrated from one of these populations. Beaver removal in the Commonwealth is often difficult to execute, as a result of extensive permitting processes and legal restrictions. Additionally, any beaver removal practices on the site would likely be ineffective, since many more beavers live off site in the rest of the wetland complex, and can readily move back into the Barber Reservation. A more productive approach to beaver management on the site would be to allow the beavers space to complete their life cycle, celebrate the diverse ecosystems they create, and enjoy the many ecological functions they provide (see Figure 6.1), which could ultimately benefit the human communities in the area. Because of the topography of the site and its neighboring parcels, it is unlikely that beaver ponds would flood the homes on higher ground just to the south of Barber. Therefore, property damage should not be a strong concern for these residents. However, beaver pond migration may happen in some low-lying areas just to the north of the Barber Reservation, in an area known as the Humphrey’s Conservation Area. Although no property damage is anticipated if such a expansion occurred, there may be implications for land management in the lowland area. Figure 6.2 shows the extent of a “dynamic landscape buffer,” delineated by outlining the topographic low-lying area. This is the area that can collect water, has small channelized woodland streams, and contains beaver habitat and therefore may be prone to flooding or changing hydrological conditions. In regards to a management plan, it would be best to minimize any possible impact, disturbance, or infrastructure in this area, so as to prevent property damage. This buffer also takes into account that beaver habitat is dynamic in nature, as shown in Figure 6.1. Currently, the central area of Barber is a beaver pond. But with time, if and when beavers leave the area, a beaver meadow will form here, changing the landscape and creating new ecological conditions.
A Beaver Pond Once beavers enter a location they begin digging channels, building dams and lodges, and pooling water so they have access to food. But when their ponds no longer provide enough food, or when their dams fail, they leave the site.
Beaver Habitat Cycle
Managing the
Beaver activity in Barber
Figure 6.1:
Listening to the Landscape
The Barber Reservation has abundant beaver habitat, and beaver activity should be accepted and planned for.
Town of Sherborn Conservation Commission & The Land Management Task Force
site analysis providing site-specific and meaningful site analyses that also work to educate the client’s and plan-set audience
BEAVER POND
WETLAND SYSTEM
16
DYNAMIC LANDSCAPE BUFFER
BEAVER ACTIVITY
For the railroad to run across the Barber Reservation, an embankment was built to lift the tracks above the wetland. The embankment essentially became a dam in the wetland. In the Barber Reservation, the railroad dike did not just stop water from draining to the west, it also likely raised the already high water table to above-ground exposure. It is possible that what is now a beaver pond first began as a seep in a wooded area as the water table rose to new heights. With a railroad embankment already serving as a successful dam across the wetland, beavers had to do relatively little to dam water flowing through the embankment culverts, and then dam the resulting peripheral flows. The result has been an expanding pond behind a rising water table. An active wetland landscape is dynamic and ever changing. All low-lying areas in and around the Barber Reservation are susceptible to beaver activity and, subsequently, inundation. However, the dynamic landscape buffer does not solely correlate to beaver activity. Large or prolonged storms can raise the water table, as can a dramatic landscape disturbance (such as clear-cutting or poor agricultural practices) above these low areas. Therefore, low areas may change as a result of several different factors or variables, and it is best to designate them as no-build or low-impact sites to alleviate any more conflict between man-made and natural landscape features and thus prioritizing habitat health and ecosystem functioning.
SITE ANALYSIS
Wetland systems are dynamic and changing
Sheet: FIGURE 6.2: The blue dashed line shows the dynamic landscape buffer for the Barber Reservation, which includes much of the low-lying area of the property, as well as the area which has been separated from the larger wetland system to the west.
6
27
EXISTING MULTI-USE TRAIL ALONG WESTERN AVENUE TO NATIVE MEADOW
EXISTING LARGE WHITE PINE HEDGEROW
Improved Gravel Parking Lot
The parking lot largely retains its existing footprint, but incorporates an informal truck access path just to the north. A new stone wall separates the edge of the parking lot and Western Avenue. The large 4.3’ black walnut tree remains, shading part of the parking area.
EXISTING MULTIUSE TRAIL TO NATIVE MEADOW NEW NATURAL PLAYGROUND AREA AMONG LARGE BOULDERS
EXISTING TRUCK ACCESS TO REMAIN
Trailhead Lean-to
The original stone foundation is rehabilitated, and covered with an open-air lean-to. This allows visitors a shaded place for gathering, picnicking, or resting before or after a walk.
BOARDWALK OVER WET MEADOW MEADOW PLANTINGS
EXISTING OLD APPLE GROVE TO REMAIN NEW FOREST GARDEN
Barrier-free Path
Most of the paths circulating around the homestead area are placed so they require minimal grading to achieve a 5% slope. The looped trail system in the homestead area is now accessible to many user groups.
EXISTING DECIDUOUS FOREST TO REMAIN
Series of Short Loop Trails
Wet Meadow Boardwalk
A boardwalk is built over the wet area of this lawn, around a groundwater seep. The boardwalk provides water and wetland education opportunities while traversing saturated soils to complete a loop trail. Being inside of the resource area, boardwalk and trail construction will require permitting.
A productive food forest is planted for community use and education. Swales and berms on contour store and infiltrate runoff down the slope, as fruit and nut trees, shrubs, herbaceous plants, and productive ground covers are planted together to mimic natural plant communities. Permitting would be required to build the swales and berms. A forest garden can be established on contour without swales and berms, but plantings would be limited to moisture-loving species primarily. The existing old apple orchard is revived by understory thinning and pruning and incorporated in this forest garden.
Feet *Contour lines represent one-foot contour intervals, and are created from a survey of existing conditions. The proposed plan may require grading changes that are not shown in this plan.
NEW PATH ALONG STREAM
This one-tenth-mile outer trail allows visitors to walk a short loop in the homestead area that takes them past the pond, the food forest, and the woodland stream, and along the historic renovated barn. A series of inner loops allow for shorter walks.
(Not for construction. This drawing is part of a student project, and not based on a legal survey.)
HOMESTEAD PLAN
MEADOW PLANTINGS
Community Food Forest on Contour
DESIGN DETAILS
E
ENU
EXISTING FOOT TRAIL TO NEW WILDLIFE VIEWING BLIND
Managing the
N AV
TER
REINFORCED TURF
The area between the parking lot and the renovated barn is planted with reinforced turf, thereby allowing staging to occur near parked utility vehicles and the barn. This historic barn can be used by community members or coordinators working in the food forest.
Listening to the Landscape
Staging Area and Renovated Barn WES
Community Pavilion
Barber Reservation
EXISTING 4.3’ BLACK WALNUT MEADOW PLANTINGS
This structure is built in the footprint of the former tennis court (in the last construction phases of the homestead area), and provides a space for staging or gathering for public or educational events in Barber while offering the area as a focus for intensive invasive plant species removal.
The Conway School, Spring 2014
Proposed Homestead Area
Emily Davis & Brandon Tennis
The old homestead, which is the main access point onto the site and the center of human activity in Barber, becomes a day-park. The proposed design builds on existing use patterns to create more recreation, educational, and productive spaces in the homestead, as well as increase the reservation’s curb appeal. Visitors now have the option to interact with the landscape immediately upon arrival. Walking paths lead visitors around the homestead to the renovated barn, a lean-to, a forest garden, a wet meadow, a stream, and a staging area for on-site processing of forest products such as timber, biochar, and food.
FIGURE 12.1:
Meadow plants and wildflowers are seeded in this existing homestead lawn, creating an inviting entrance that reflects the large native meadow in the interior of the reservation.
Sherborn, MA
The old homestead becomes a park
Meadow in Original Lawn
Town of Sherborn Conservation Commission & The Land Management Task Force
Homestead Plan
Sheet:
12
27
schematic patch design a proposed plan for the historic homestead, which is converted to a productive and community-based landscape 17
EXISTING 4.3’ DIAMETER BLACK WALNUT
N
COMMUNITY PAVILION
UE
EXISTING FOOT TRAIL TO NATIVE MEADOW
NS
VE
A’ PARKING
MEADOW
STE
NE
LA
•
RENOVATED BARN
REINFORCED TURF
Phase 2: Spring •
FOOT TRAIL TO WILDLIFE VIEWING BLIND
MEADOW
•
BOARDWALK OVER WET MEADOW
FOOD FOREST PLANTINGS ON CONTOUR
A 0
25
50 Feet
•
EXISTING OLD APPLE GROVE
•
Phase 4: Mid-summer to mid-fall •
Walking paths should be staked out early in the spring and observed throughout the wettest season so adjustments in the design can be made before the paths are made permanent. Bare-root trees and shrubs that were ordered during the winter should be planted after having their roots soaked in an all-natural mycrorhizal dip that helps the plant roots quickly establish with the fungi present in the soil. Heavy mulching is recommended to hold in moisture and suppress weed growth. A light tilling of the soil should be done after seasonal deluges but before the last spring rains, followed by the seeding and
Walking paths should be built in early summer once the meadow has begun to establish. If the meadow has grown too high, the paths should be mowed before the tread is dug, lined, and lightly filled with crushed gravel or heavily topped with wood chips from trees chipped on site.
Newly planted trees and shrubs should be watered if rain fall is scarce throughout the summer. End-of-the-season donated plants should be planted in early fall, heavily watered, and thickly mulched to protect against the winter freeze-and-thaw cycle.
EXISTING 4.3’ BLACK WALNUT
Figure 13.1: Aerial perspective of the proposed homestead area, featuring the community food forest and pavilion.
EXISTING BLACK WALNUT AND SPRUCE TREES
PARKING LOT
EXISTING CONDITIONS:
FOOD FOREST PLANTINGS ON CONTOUR, WITH SWALES AND BERMS (PERMITTING REQUIRED)
WET LAWN & GROUNDWATER SEEP
WESTERN AVENUE
NEW REGRADED STAGING AREA, WITH REINFORCED TURF
FOREST EDGE EXTENDED PARKING CONFIGURATION
W
PROPOSED DESIGN:
18
BOARDWALK OVER WET MEADOW
MEADOW PLANTINGS TO REPLACE LAWN
Figure 13.2: Section A-A’ Existing & Proposed Homestead Area
The Conway School, Spring 2014
AV E
Phase 3: Early summer
Emily Davis & Brandon Tennis
RN
Sherborn, MA
TE
Barber Reservation
•
ES
matting of native meadow plant species. A polyculture mix of nitrogen-fixing and dynamic-accumulating plant species should be sown throughout the forest garden (see Appendix I for a food forest plant palette).
WESTERN AVENUE
HOMESTEAD PHASING
W
All excavation and berming should be done in late summer when the water table is low and enough growing season remains to establish a cover crop for the fall and winter. A cover crop will stabilize the newly disturbed soil and limit weed growth. Fill and grading for the staging area and extend the parking lot can also be done at this time while machinery is already on site. Reinforced turf should be dug into place and lightly mulched to prevent erosion. Building the trailhead lean-to during this initial phase may give community members a sense of progress while construction continues into the next season.
Managing the
•
Listening to the Landscape
Phase 1: Late summer
DESIGN DETAILS
Homestead Phasing
Town of Sherborn Conservation Commission & The Land Management Task Force
land management details providing specific strategies for sustainable public lands maintenance and management
Sheet:
E Feet
(Not for construction. This drawing is part of a student project, and not based on a legal survey.)
13
27
, MA ASHLAND
SHERBORN, MA
Asiatic bittersweet and multiflora rose in this central hedgerow may potentially expand into the fields without proper management.
HAYFIELDS
Shade-tolerant buckthorn in this early succession old field may spread into the surrounding forest. BEAVER POND SMALL SATELLITE FIELD
RAILROAD
INVASIVE “HOT SPOTS” AREAS OF POTENTIAL SPREAD
TRANSMISSION LINE
HOMESTEAD AREA
Multi-flora rose, Asiatic bittersweet, and black locust dominate the historically disturbed homestead area.
Buckthorns beneath the transmission lines provide an abundant seed source on the property, and may spread into the beaver pond area and/or the native meadow.
Phase 2: Following through
After large-scale removal in the first phase, annual cutting or removal will be required for long-term management. This would remove the species that are migrating into areas of forest, wetland, or meadow, thereby concentrating their populations in the highly impacted or managed areas (such as the homestead area). This phase can be done with targeted rotational grazing and/or mechanical removal. Goat browsing can target undesired plant species while improving soil fertility. Once the large woody plants are removed with their attached seeds, livestock grazing or browsing in managed areas will continue to keep the young plants cut, therefore reducing their growing capacity. Letting the animals browse in the late spring (or during the flowering phase, before the plants fruit) will ensure that they do not consume (and therefore spread) the plant’s seeds. Additionally, this stage of the plant’s lifecycle is when energy in the form of plant carbohydrates is sent from the roots and into the new growth. A plant is greatly weakened when it is cut or eaten at this time.
Phase 3: Monitoring & continued management Finally, a continued monitoring program is recommended for invasive species management. The Land Management Task Force should decide on the extent of invasive species management for the Barber Reservation (i.e., a monitoring program or attempted small-scale eradication). But with any management plan, care should be taken to ensure that base-line species data is created, a more detailed and specific management plan is developed, and a monitoring program is established. More information and study would be needed to develop a detailed and comprehensive invasive species management plan. FIGURE 21.2: (A) Sumac seeds grow in conical clusters and are favored by birds and insects. (B) Sumac hedges grow and spread readily by lateral root systems which can be established to compete with aggressive invasive vegetation such as glossy buckthorn.
The Conway School, Spring 2014
Emily Davis & Brandon Tennis
Sherborn, MA
Mechanical (hand) removal is recommended in the first phase, since it would be more effective in removing the large woody masses of the plants (especially large bittersweet vines), and would properly remove any fruit or seeds on the plants. When these larger plants are removed, their biomass can be used in the creation of biochar on site. This is an effective method for recycling the plant’s nutrients and reducing the costs of compost or fertilizer (see Sheet 14 for more details).
Barber Reservation
Japanese knotweed grows along the edge of the beaver pond, which is a naturally dynamic landscape that will likely change in the future. If the beaver pond drains, and the land transitions to a beaver meadow, it may be vulnerable to invasive species migration.
Figure 21.1: Proposed priority management areas for invasive plant species
These plants in the proposed priority areas are chosen for focused attention because of their proximity to sensitive or vulnerable habitats, their aggressive spreading mechanisms, and the feasibility of effective management on Barber.
INVASIVE PLANT MANAGEMENT
Buckthorns beneath the transmission line corridor, Asiatic bittersweet in the meadow, and Japanese knotweed along the railroad adjacent to the beaver pond all threaten to migrate into ecologically valuable areas. By examining those plant species’ ecologies, prevalence on the Barber Reservation, and proximity to vulnerable areas on the property, priority management has been identified for Barber (Figure 21.1). See Appendix III for a table of more information on invasive plant species’ ecologies, and their priority ranking on the Barber Reservation.
The invasive plants that require focused attention are: • Buckthorn in the small old field and beneath the transmission lines. • Asiatic bittersweet in the old hedgerow in the center of the proposed native meadow. • Asiatic bittersweet and multi-flora rose in the homestead area, and especially around the proposed community pavilion area. • Japanese knotweed adjacent to the beaver pond, which should be monitored closely if beaver pond water levels change.
Managing the
To begin to identify focus areas, ecologically sensitive, vulnerable, or valuable areas are identified. In this case, the wetlands, beaver pond, and meadows have the most ecological integrity on the site, due to their size and habitat value. Therefore, it would be appropriate to focus efforts on maintaining these habitats. Next, invasive area “hot spots,” or disturbed areas with high invasive plant concentrations, should be located. The hot spots are mapped in relationship to the ecologically sensitive areas, to determine if the invasive plants threaten to migrate into those places. It would be best if efforts were focused on invasive plant management in these areas.
Listening to the Landscape
Because of the persistent nature of many invasive plant species, it is often impractical to expend energy in efforts to fully eradicate them. Instead, it may be more effective to identify areas where focused attention should be directed, and where management is likely to be successful.
The proposed invasive management plan is integrated with other proposed management solutions, such as a developed and concentrated homestead redesign, the meadow establishment, and rotational livestock grazing. These activities will concentrate human energy in a given area, and therefore make land management more efficient and effective. Management strategies in the homestead area (see Sheet 14) and native meadow (see Sheet 16) are proposed so that they can be integrated with a holistic invasive species management program, and reduce the growing capacity of the identified invasive plant species of concern within them.
Town of Sherborn Conservation Commission & The Land Management Task Force
Phase 1: Focusing efforts
DESIGN DETAILS
Invasive Plant Management
Sheet:
21
27
land management techniques acknowledging the presence of invasive species, but recommending realistic management strategies 19
master planning FLETCHER, VT JAN - SEPT 2013
As part of a two-person team, this master plan project hoped to stream-line the efforts of Camp DREAM, a nonprofit organization that provides a free summer camp experience for under-privileged youths in the northeast. The organization lacked a long-term vision for the site, and needed to organize their improvement efforts so that the limited funding and volunteer resources that they periodically receive could be used efficiently and work towards their long-term goal. This comprehensive plan categorized the individually projects as tweaks, quick fixes, or larger construction projects, and proposed a sequence of improvements that made sense for the camp’s growth. The master plan project’s key themes were designing for outdoor experiences and education, improving the “curb appeal” and entrance experience, working within a densely forested and ecologically sensitive environment, and designing for site sustainability.
“ 20
With limited funds and limited resources, projects at Camp DREAM often happen in phases as materials and volunteer time are made available. Taking this and other factors into consideration,
including local community involvement, ecological landscape, and areas of highest use, Emily and Shane approached the task with fresh eyes and a genuine interest in the future of Camp DREAM. We are so grateful for their
beautifully crafted and committed work.
-Camp DREAM, project client
”
final proposed design
21
site assessment and analysis:
providing meaningful site analyses to meet client’s specific needs and the camp’s programming
22
BOAT RACK & LAUNCH SOLAR SHOWER & GREY WATER GARDENS
COMPOSTING TOILET
TAYLOR ROAD
STAGING TOOLSHED
“FERN GULLY ” WETLAND BOARDWALK
PARKING TURNAROUND
TREEHOUSE IMPROVED ENTRANCE SIGNAGE
SWIMMING DOCK
MP DREAM
CAMP DREAM
PROPOSED SITE PLAN DETAIL: CAMP ENTRANCE
POSED SITE PLAN DETAIL: LEAN-TO AREA
proposed patch design:
proposing low-cost design ideas and arranging spaces for improved efficiency of camp staff
(other work)
sketches, drawings, and photography Field studies, botanical drawing, and free-hand sketching are all important aspects of my practice. Recreating the physical landscape (either small-scale botanical studies to large-scale landscapes) helps me to communicate ideas through drawing and graphics, and improves the visual quality of the final deliverables. I continue to practice botanical illustrations, architectural freehand drawing, and figure study to refine this skill, as well as creating compositions through photography, especially outdoor and nature photography.
24
25
26
27
E M I LY A . D A V I S
emily@edavisdesign.com (203)-470-3205
1339 Bonnyvale Rd Brattleboro, VT