FA L L I S S U E
K E H I LAT H JESH UR UN BULLETIN
VOLUME LXXXIX, NUMBER 1
SEPTEMBER 3, 2019 | ELUL 3 5779
DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES: WE’VE COME A LONG WAY ON A LONGER ROAD BY RABBI CHAIM STEINMETZ
EACH YEAR, OUR CONGREGATION HOSTS A SHABBATON FOR YACHAD, THE NATIONAL JEWISH COUNCIL FOR DISABILITIES 1. OVER 60 PEOPLE WITH DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES COME TO KJ, AND ONE GIVES A SHORT SERMON FROM THE PULPIT ON SHABBAT MORNING. IT IS A HIGHLIGHT OF THE KJ YEAR.
IN TH IS ISSU E RABBI CHAIM STEINMETZ
1
RABBI ELIE WEINSTOCK
4
RABBI MEYER LANIADO
6
RABBI HASKEL LOOKSTEIN
8
RABBI DANIEL AND RACHEL KRAUS 11 SIMCHAT TORAH CHATANIM
12
CLASSES 14 IN THE COMMUNITY
16
HOLIDAY HIGHLIGHTS
20
UPCOMING EVENTS
26
WITHIN OUR FAMILY
28
BNEI MITZVAH
30
SCHEDULE OF SERVICES
32
This yearly sermon represents a revolution. Fifty years ago, a developmentally disabled person would not have spoken from the pulpit, and no congregation would have welcomed a Yachad Shabbaton. The developmentally disabled were invisible, hidden away in attics and institutions. For the most part attitudes have changed in recent years. But one lingering question remains: why was there such discomfort with developmental disabilities in the first place? Why would people discriminate against the children of their friends and family? Thinking seriously about this question will force us to confront our own instinctive biases. In 2014, a controversy erupted over a comment on Twitter by the famed biologist Richard Dawkins. When asked by a follower about the ethical dilemma of aborting a Down’s Syndrome pregnancy, Dawkins wrote:
Abort it and try again. It would be immoral to bring it into the world if you have the choice. Undoubtedly, such a pregnancy presents a serious ethical dilemma, and even in the Jewish tradition, halakhic opinions on this subject are not monolithic. But Dawkins’ blithe response shocked many. How could he coldly pronounce “abort it,” as if the life of a disabled person is worthless? But Dawkins’ point of view is not new or unique. It is tempting to compare his cold attitude towards developmental disabilities with the Nazi T-4 program, which murdered over 70,000 Germans with disabilities and psychiatric disorders. However, this analogy is deceptive; the exceptional evil of the Nazi regime would leave the impression that any policy they adopted is an outlier, the handiwork of immoral barbarians. But in actuality, the idea of murdering the disabled is quite old, and not at all uncommon. continued on page 2
1 The Shabbaton has been sponsored since its inception by Dr. Karin and Joel Katz.