MUSIC
SCREEN
ARTS
Mr. Hudson
A Single Man
Tim Key
Page 18
Page 25
Spotlight On Elections
Monday March 8 2010 Week 20
Free and Impartial. Your paper, your views, your voice.
In this issue
»
Exeposé
Page 27
Students’ Guild celebrate national record turnout of 36.4% in Sabb Elections, while elected AU President faced allegations of misconduct
Adam Walmesley News Editor
Allegations of misconduct have clouded the record-breaking Sabbatical Elections. Exeter University Students’ Guild is the most represented national Student Union, following a 36.4% turn-out at the elections. The Students’ Guild Sabbatical Election 2010 recorded a total of 5,742 votes, a 966 vote increase on last year’s figures. However, controversy has surrounded the election of the Athletic Union President, after it was revealed that accusations of rule breaches were made against the elected Josh Belsher. Three separate allegations of election malpractice were made against Belsher, and an Appeal Tribunal was held to resolve dispute regarding one of the complaints. Belsher went on to win the AU Presidential candidacy by 376 votes, ahead of Sam Tang. The first complaint against Belsher concerned campaigning in a night club on February 18, before the stipulated time period of canvassing. A shoutout was made in Rococos, although Belsher claims he was at home with all his registered canvassers, at the time of the incident. Josh Belsher is the captain of the AU Men’s Tennis Club. Fellow members, who had apparently declined an offer to canvass for him, were apparently held responsible for the first incident. Belsher was handed a penalty of losing an hour of prime time voting. The most serious allegation involved unsubstantiated reports of a first-year tennis club member campaigning in Exeter Halls. A complaint was made by a female student on Thursday February 25. She alleged that a tennis club member was signing up students to a physical sheet. For every 50 signatures the unofficial canvasser obtained, they would be
rewarded with a Timepiece Gold Card, according to the female student. However, the Guild elections team claimed they could not prove that Belsher had any awareness or involvement in the incident, and it went unpunished. Gary McLachlan, Senior Elections Officer, explained: “Since there was absolutely no link other than the club and friendship between Josh and the first-year allegedly canvassing for reward I considered that the allegation could not ever be investigated using Guild resources. “The Guild is neither a detective agency nor a police force. It has neither the forensic ability nor the legal mechanisms to investigate a complaint of this nature to render a just verdict on innocence or guilt. As Senior Elections Officer I invoked privilege and refused to punish rumour and innuendo, imposing no penalty.” McLachlan cited previous examples of first-year students campaigning for AU candidates without their knowledge. He added, “this is apparently quite common and is based entirely on team spirit rather than any devious motive of election fixing or deliberate will to cheat.” Other AU candidates appealed the decision at the Candidates Question Time event on the evening of Thursday February 25. A tribunal was swiftly organised for 9am the following day, seven hours before voting closed. The appeals panel heard from all the AU candidates, incumbent AU President, Tom Murray, and Gary McLachlan. The panel upheld the decision not to punish Belsher. The AU candidates signed off the incident at the Friday morning election meeting. This procedure meant they accepted the decision-making process, and was before they knew the outcome of the appeals panel. Continued on page 2...
Features discusses the lost children of Zimbabwe, interviews Major General Paul Newton
Lifestyle takes a trip to Los Angeles, reviews the latest Porsche and assesses your local Wagamama for some Oriental cuisine
arts looks at International Women’s Day, analyses Tim Key’s poetic career and quizzes Gilbert and Sullivan Society Jonnie Beddall was elected Guild President. Photo: Adam Walmesley