7
Best trade/specialist publication and website – Voyager Media Awards 2019
Vol 18 No 27, July 15, 2019
Loss won’t be repeated
farmersweekly.co.nz
$3.95
Incl GST
Farmers won’t pay Richard Rennie richard.rennie@globalhq.co.nz
F
ONTERRA Shareholders’ Council chairman Duncan Coull is adamant farmers will not be bailing out their co-op despite a sliding share value, high debt and challenging asset sales. And chief financial officer Marc Rivers is equally adamant the co-op will not be retaining money from the milk payout to repay debt, will not change the milk price mechanism and has no immediate plans to reform its capital structure. In the wake of last week’s farmer vote to sell Westland Milk Products to Chinese dairy giant Yili there is a growing chorus of concern over the likelihood of Fonterra being forced down the same path if it cannot reduce its debts quickly. Industry analyst Peter Fraser kicked off those concerns describing the Westland sale as a dress rehearsal for Fonterra’s. He and others have called for Fonterra to pull back on its payout by as much as 50c a kilogram of milksolids for a rapid fix to its debt woes. But Coull is confident the cooperative can turn around under its present structure without retaining a portion of payout from this year’s milk cheque. “Part of the issue as I understand with Westland is they extended on a growth strategy that did not align with their capital strategy, having to fund and
?
Not with our money
Fonterra’s future
borrow for a strategy that was not well executed, which put them behind on the milk price.” Coull said Fonterra’s issues relate to poor allocation of capital in some instances. “I guess that is putting pressure on the balance sheet. But the difference between Westland and Fonterra is Fonterra is engaged around the world with many options and avenues to pursue for revenue and assets.” Fonterra has targeted an $800 million reduction in its $7.2 billion debt this year by selling nonstrategic assets. Massey University senior management lecturer Dr James Lockhart said Fonterra is not a lost cause but must act quicker to cut debt. His solution, like Fraser’s, is to hold back 50c a kilo of milksolids from this year’s cheque. The $800m that would yield would deal to the debt concerns simply and quickly. “If you go this way, yes, there will be some tears but I suspect considerably less if Fonterra is honest and shares with their shareholder farmers the enormity of what they face.” But both Coull and Rivers are adamant there will be no retentions of milk cheque payments to help improve Fonterra’s position. “Despite what Peter Fraser says, milk price is the most important
Hot prices for cool new brand
FARMERS are unlikely to put any of their milk cheque back into their co-operative in the near future, at least until they get a better idea of where their money will be going, Te Aroha farmer Stuart King says. He would be angry if asked to do so before he can see
number to us here in New Zealand,” Coull said. “We have a milk price model in place for good reason and we should not be funding on-going
AUTODRAFTER/ WOW SYSTEM
TT50 6HP NOW
$
$
25,650.00
operations and propping up the business through retentions.” Rivers accepts the co-op is over extended but is confident its balance sheet strength can
giving them the kiss of death in recent years. “Withholding money means we are being asked to pay to fix up everything, but I want to see some evidence the changes needed are being made first. “It puzzles me why we would be throwing more money at it. Fonterra seems to have done that too often in the past.” Photo: Peter Drury
be restored with assets sales and within the co-operative ownership model.
MORE:
We will be changing our brand from Tru-Test Dairy Solutions to DTS – and to celebrate we’ve got some hot prices on our milk cooling and dairy automation products saving you thousands of $$$. To find out more about our hot prices – and our Dependable, Terrific Service (of course) contact us on 0800 500 387
ICE BANK Usually
the co-op turn its financial performance around. “We are all a bit gun shy at the moment. “When we look at the situation the co-operative has got itself into it seems to be $2 billion poorer from investments with our money. “Fonterra seems to have been good at taking quite good performing businesses and
Richard Rennie richard.rennie@globalhq.co.nz
22,750
Usually
.00
NOW
$
$
32,999 .00
29,500.00
P18-19