THD OTUITENT Tlse OfficĂal
Publication of tbe Foreign Corcespondents'Club of Hong Kong
HONGKONG'S PRESS FREEDOMS
Just what is going orr at the Post?
UNDER SIEGE FCC
joins the
battle to beat the censofs
Pictures from the Mexican night
THD GORRTSPONIIDNT Àugust 1995
Io THE FOREIGN CORRESP'OI\DENTS'
An în-depth profíle of the toP I
l8 courses ín Asio
Developed wí¡h ¡he ossisfonce
of
o
IowerAlbert
Telephone: 2527
Pe¡e¡ Thomson ond
Gøry Ployer, lhis ollroclive hordbock publícotion conloþs comprehensive course reporls on lhe region's best gol|clubs. From 4,300 courses, ll8 were chosen by
CLI]B 2
ponelof golfíng prokssíonols for theír merít in desígn,
ployobí!íty, club føcili¡ies, internotionol oppeol, Ioumomenh hos¡ed ond accesshility to visitors. Conloining 250 colour photogrophs, this high-quolity publicotion will groce lhe bookshelves of every golhr.
u
l5ll Ftx:286a 4092
Frorn
Presldent-Hans Vriens
Presldent-
Stuart \Folfenda.le
C-orrespondent Member Govemofs Paul Bayfeld, Ma¡cus W. Bnucttli, Mark Clifford, Peter Engardio, Cathy
ttre President
Self-censorship the greatest danger now
Ft st Vlce Presld€nt- NurF Vittachi Second Vlce
I-elfers
Road, Hong Kong
Co\.ef
Stor5r
Battle is joined
llilbom, Robert Macpherson,
Jonathm Mirsþ, Hubert Van Es S e ret øry : Cathy llilb orn Journaltst Memb€r Goverûors
ao-
Corzer Storj'Club gives airing to coritroversiâl China documentary
Fraficis Moriarty, Simon Twiston Davies
Ässoclate Member Goverßors
€
Johtr Corbett, Kevin Egm, Karin Malmstrcm, Dorothy Rym
a-2-
Profsslonal Commttt€e Conuenor Mtk Cï¡frord House C.omÐlttee Corruertor: KevilrBgal
Eoch golf course repod includes informoîíon on:
o o o
The cost of ploying eoch course.
Conaenor: }ItbeftVan Es Ent€f,taiûmert Commlttee
Key people ot eoch club, including nomes of designer
O o
or : Kf ün lvlalmsÎf ofr F & B Commlttee Conue nor : StttîÍf ïlolfendale
ond resident pro. Course loyout, with hole-by-hole illustrotions. Locotion ond occessibility of the club.
Co n u en
Wall Coññltt€e Contertor: Il.tbeftYan
tr
copies
'
Conloct Detoils
Nlcola Nightingale, Assistmt Edltor 2 l,ower Albert Road, Hoflg Kong Telephone: 2521 l57l Fu:2868 4o92 Club ofHong Kong Opiniom expressed bywriters in Ihe Corresþondent are not necesstrily those of The Foreign Corcspondents' Club.
Address. Country:
Tel: I
Fqx:
I
PRODUCTION FST Line Design
ch"qu" enclosed mode poyøble fo: Edinburgh Finonciol Publishing (Asiol
Crdít
cortlAn,"
cqrd No:
Six years of dynastic probing
25_
Ba-rside Bal-rter| Oh, the wonder of it all
26-
lftrerrre
Niglrt
Down Mexico way
2a-
People Cad Goldsrein bids farewell
Ltd
[T-rnrT_rn Expirydote:l-Tn
3().
& Printing
Founh Flmr, I5B Welliogton Street, Central, Hong Kong ^fel25217993Ftx:25 A366 DI?Artlst-Liema Duong
nMastercqrd
l-T-[l
Was tbís wbat dìdfor Líly Wong?
Tbe Cor'resþondent is publlshed monthly by The Foreign CoÍ€Ðondents' Club ofHong Kong.
Poyment Detoils
I
Backbencher
Lrrnct¡Ii-nes
@ 199t :rhe roreign corespondents'
Job Title:
City:
Posf
Peter Cordingley, Editor
(MrlMs) Compony:
says
The real reasons fo¡ the Posf sackings
EDITORIALOFFICB
Firsl Nomes
Fomity Nome
t9-
Fs
The Correspofrdent
Stofjr
editor-in-chief
Cortuenor: Simoî Tq¡iston Davies Freedom ofthe P¡ess Conuenor : I tancis Moriarty
of Leoding Golf Courses of Asio Pocific 1995 @ US$45 per book(including p&p worldwide) @ HK$292.50 per book (locãl HK delivery only)
Co\.ef
'There was no censorship,'
Publlcatlom Coññltte€
ORDER YOUR COPY NOW AND GET 25% OTT THE RETAIT PRICE OF HKS39O pleqse send ]11"
7-5.
Fltraûce C,onmlttee Tre asilrer : Dolotfry Ry aî MembershlP C.oñmltr€€
The club history ond surroundings.
Co\zer Stor5r Who killed Lily Wong?
ifrll>ute Veteran avìator Ken Begg dies
32.
FCC Faces A taste of Mexico
John McDougall
ADVERflSING SAI.ES Sales Manager - David MurÌay Tel:2521 7993Eut 2521 8366
Sîgnature:
Foxor postyourorder
to; l\ \lf
Jocqueline Rotnoviro, TeL
l4/E 75-77 Wyndhom Slreet,
(852) 286? 896? Fqx: (852) 2526 ó130
CenÍrol, Hong Kong.
Cover photograph by Hugh Van Es
FCC_l August 1995 TBE
CORRXSPoII|IIEII|I
To the
that's about 35 days after the bill was sent out - then the member will be posted. A $100 charge will be added to
editor
the account and the total amount of all credit immediately payable. At the very least, being posted is an expensive inconvenience. Thus all mem-
bers are urged to settle their bills promptþ, prior to the end of the month in which they receive their account. Jethro Lee-Mahoney Club manager
Another angle Gremlin at work The MaylJune issue
of
TIce Corye-
sþondent caffied an information note concerningthe effects of the decision at
the EGM to amend the terms of settlement of club accounts. The information note ahnost made sense. However, I regret to report the activity of a gremlinwhich resulted in an incoffect date in subparagraph 3. The gist of the amendment was this: Anymonth's accountis closed and totalled at the end of that month. The
statement is mailed
I don't think it's Tim Street orAllen Tricþ Shot photo. It looks more like John Rittger. And the fellow with glasses in the upper left-hand corneris definitelyKeith Sillett, whowas at the time the general sales manager for Hales in the
to the member
within 10 days, with the account now due for settlement prior to the end of the month of receipt, ie. normally within 20 or so days. If an account is not settled then, it willbe suspended. This means that credit facilities cannot be used, though use of the club may continue with pre-paid
youchers. In the (ropefirlly) unlikely event of an account remaining unpaid by the l5tlt of thLe following month
-
Cathay Pacific.
Stephen Ellis
Hugh's that rrnafl? I am almost - but not quite, as this letter indicates - wordless with wonder at the humility, modesty and general camera-shyness of Hubert ("Hugh") Van Es, as amply evidenced (oxymoron intended) by the number of times his photograPh aPPears in the May,{une issue of Tb e Corre sþondtimes. ent -He 12 has outdone himself this time,
and I would like this letter to be puÞ lished in recognition (for it's easy to recognise him by now) of the feat.
Canon
a few issues have caused me quite a start; he wasn't anywhere to be seen in one or t!vo. But l waited out the month, and not withoLlt reward. He was back.
To make it easier for the people from the Guinness Book of Records,I would like to cite his appearances in the MaylJune issue:
1. Front cover, contemplating beer-can helicopter. 2. Roof of the Rex hotel. 3. In the Saigon Press Cafe. 4. On Saigon River cruise. 5. Conferring original of a pic on two people. 6. Contemplating a VC escape l;,:atclJ'. T . Standing beside a Ho Chi Minh tunnel sign. 8. Beside bust of "Uncle Ho". 9. Shaking mud from self, after bathing in it. 10. Relaxing at Gustav's restalrrant in Hanoi. 1 1. At the now-defunct Hong Kong Hilton hotel. 1 2. I'm guessing here, but the man behind the only woman in the photo on page 9 resembles him enough to be him. So I'm
including it. Ttre Phantom Counter
A comþlimentaty euening 6tt witb Mr Van Es for the person to cor-rectly identify Íirst tlce opera
tbe autbor of tltis letter.
-
Ed..
Where's Kevin? Thank you for t}:le May/lune Tbe
Capturing
I read every page and single mention of Kevin Sinclair. Is this a record? Comesþondent.
couldn't find
a
A. Member
Tbere tuasn't room
I have long counted, from issue to issue, the number of Hugh's
u.tltøt u,títb
appearances. In the last seYeral years,
Van
Es.
-
all
for
Keuin,
tbe þictures of Huglt
Ed.
The thrill and excitenrent of spectator spolt transcends bordels and is an excellent u'a), for people to expfess the Lrnron olclifierent countries. It is
War coffespondents feruriofr set for Octobef 7 About 5O0 correspondents who covered American wars from Víodd War II to the present are expected to attend a reunion in Washington, D.C. on Saturday, OctoberT. Events
include a ceremony at Arlington National Cemetery honouring journalists who died covering armed conflicts, a lunch at Fort Myer, an exhibit of photos made by correspondents who died on both sides in the Vietnam'Wars, and a black tie dinner at the Sheraton National Hotel
in Arlington, followed by a programme of songs and stories from correspondents about their lighter
moments in'W'odd War II, the Korean
War, Vietnam War and America's smaller wars.
Bfoadcastef Walter Cronkite
is
scheduled to be master of ceremonies at the dinner. The photo exhibit will be arranged by Horst Faas of Associated press. The reunion is beingheld this Year to mark the 50th anniversary of the end of tùlodd tù?ar II and ttre 20th anniversary of the end of ttre Vietnam War, said Carmella IaSpada, founder and CEO
of
No Greater Love, an organisation for remembering war Yictims. IaSpada and Peter Amett of CNN
are chairing the rer¡nion. Members
iurportant to capture ¡he th¡ill in photographs for the wor'ld to share . Ard pLofessionaì photographers flom all over tlre wotlcl rely on Canon SLR
of
cameras to give them theiL best shots becuase
the organising committee, which includes correspondents from the Ko
rean and Vietnam wars, are Kevin
Canon EOS
Kaiser,GeorgeMcÂrthur,Ike Pappas, Jack Reynolds, Al Spivak and Dick Swanson.Thecommittee'sNewYork representative is Richard Pyle, AP. FCC war correspondents who have not been notified of the reunion may
-
a single
Successlul photograpl.rers use Canon cameras and the EF lenses
Delaney, Joe Galloway, Al Kaff, Bob
contact CarmellalaSpada, No Greater Love, 1750 NewYorkAvenue, N.W., Washington, D.C. 20006. TelePhone (2O2) 7 83 4665, Fax (2o2) 783 I 168 -
fol them not
oppor'tunity can be nrssed
systen
-
not jLrst because ofits wo|ld fastesl aulofocus
func¡ion, not just because ofCanon's renowned leliabiliq', bu¡ also because of the clLralitv of the images they can plocLuce with the Canon
Canon is alivavs thcr"c rvhcle thc cxcitcmcnt is
Thc I]OS Svstcnl : Thc
Enquiry Hotline: 2590 9666
Al Katr
an¡rr,'e r
Canon Hongkong T[ading Co., Ltd. ïsimshatsui East, Kowloon, Hong Kong.
Hï%*"'ïfl ä",
E
recrron ics
sharing unftn'gcttalie rnoJncrìts
to thc profcssional's ncctls
10/F., N4irror Tower, 61 Mody Road,
Þ
-
Tel.:2739 0802
syste m,
=T
Self-censorship the greatest danger nour Tkre ne!\z club president, Elarts \Zriens, calls for Hong l(ong journalists to stand united against self-censorstrip. lFtre club is doing its bit by forrning a- ner\r corrrrrrittee to battle ttre tfrreat-
f t -rrst be refiex. Even after two I months, it still happens six days a week. When I receive my copy of the Soutlt Cbinø Morning Post, I skip the front page and go instantþ to the bottom of page tw-o, even though by now I have somehow accepted that all I will find is a weather map. I still miss the
best the Post had to offer. Of course, the sudden death of The
rtr'odd of Lily'Wong is not the first case
of selfcensorship in the media. For quite some time our two English-language TV stations, TVB andÄTV, have had the stfange habit of buying intefest-
ing documentaries about China, but never being able to find an appropriate
slot in which to broadcast them. To give our members the opportunity to see these documentaries and judge forthemselves, the FCC lastyear started its highly successfrrl series of "Documentaries you will not see on ÄTV andTVB". So farwe have showed the BBC's Cbairman Mao: The Last
Emperor, a documentary by the nowimprisoned American-Chinese human rights activist H:arry'V7u, on the Chinese Gulags and, recentþ,Ihe Dying Rooms, on China's onechild policy and its state orphanages. Because of demand, this was screened twice. Even more serious is the imprisonment of Hong Kong joumalist Xi Yang, who will have to spend 12 years in a Chinese jaiJ,for "stealing state secrets" - this despite the fact that so far nobody has been able to trace aîy potential state secrets in the series ofarticles for which he was arrested. The most blatant, but honest, case
of selfcensorship came from Rupert Murdoch, the owner of STAR-TV, who unceremoniously dumped the BCC Wodd Service news channel from its
northem beam because this w.ould increase his chances ofg€tting afoothold in the China market. These are all examples of what Martin Lee calls "bending before the north v/ind has begun to blow". The
To defend press freedom in Hong Kong, the Board of Govemors has decided to set up a new sul>committee, which is totally devoted to freedom of the press in Hong Kong and elsewhere. Recently the FCC submitted several
Joint Declaration guarantees freedoms of speech and of the press. But what really counts is to what extent correspondents, journalists, newspaper prcprietors and editors are willing to stand up to defend these rights. Our rights and freedoms will not be lost all at once. As shown above, theywill be lost one by one. Or as the German, Martin Niemoeller, described the gradual loss of freedom in Nazi Germany tn 1933: "In Germany, they came first for the Communists and I didn't sPeak uP because I wasn't a Communist. Then they came for the Jews, and I didn't speak up because I wasn't aJew. Then they came for the ffade unions, and I didn't speakup because I wasn' t atr.ade unionist. Thentheycameforthe Catho lics, and I didn't speak up because I was a Protestant. Then they came for me,
letters to the government in which it expressed its disappointment that, despite our repeated pleas, distressingly little has been done by the government to protect freedom of the press and freedom of expression. This subcommittee will, when appropriate, work closelywith the Hong KongJoumalists Association and other media organizations on press freedom. There is more good news. 'W'e are also increasing our own and your flow of information. The FCCis ontheverge
and by that time no one was left to speak up." Hong Kong's free Press, oPen debate and free flow of information are some of the greatest treasures China will be bequeathed in 1997. Let us hope there is still something to inherit, says Martin ke. He is so right. The FCC has sPokenuP everYtime
Intemet from the upgraded FCC/BM -Workcentre and International Press from their own computers. All four IBM and the Apple computers in the workroom have built-in modems and Intemet facilities. You could also use them to see ouf new and rapidly ex-
it was appropriate to defend press freedom and freedom of sPeech. \Øe didn't
show The fuing Rooms because we approve of everything in it' That is not the point. The FCC is of the oPinion that a serious documentary on China's controversial onechild policy is important enough to give our members the opportunity to watch it.
of entering cyberspace. This
will conclude
monthwe
with one of the providers of Intemet in Hong Kong. Our aim is to provide all members with a
a deal
free Internet account, to create a so-
called Home FCC-Page and to have our own dedicated FCC-software. All memberswill also be able to use
panding FCC-CD-Rom hbrary. Anybodywho wants to participate in the activities of the Press Freedom Committee or one of the other committees is most welcome. Just call the relevant convenor. You will find her/ his name in the masthead of this magazine. Other comments or suggestions canbe sent to: hansv.@hk.linkage . You may also call.
-HansYriens
tr!æ
It's a tall order, even for Reuters. Monitor and capture the entire world's financial and business data, second by second , 24 hours a day. Report market-moving news as it breaks, wherever it breaks. Process this information and deliver via an advanced global network to
it
precisely the point it's needed, quickl¡ accurately and reliably, day in day out. Then add value to the information by providing a comprehensive range of systems and applications to make it easier to find, analyse and profit from the facts that count - to you. It's a tall ordet even for Reuters. But that is our promise. To supply the financial world, business, and the media with the best information, the best applications, the best value for money. And to work continually to improve the ways we achieve that. To find out more about how we could be helping you and your business, just contact your local Reuter office. 'Sl'e'll be standing by - no matter how tall your order.
aaaa aaaa a a aaaaa aaaa a a a a a a a aaaa aaaa a a a aaaa aaaaaaaaaa a a aaaa aaa a aaaa
aaaa aaa a aa aaaa aaa a a aaa
Making the best information work harder Hong Rong (852) 2841 5888, Sldney (612) J73 15Oo, Singapore (65) 75 5088, Tole.yo (81Ð 3432 4141
Hong I(ong's f)ress freedorns afe under frorrr nev\zsf)aç et siege frorrr all sides 1>ro1>rietors, T*W station e><ecì-lti\res, tirnid editors an<J frigtrtened journalists aS vzell, of cogfse, as frorrr Eteijing. lftrat's vzkr¡z ttre FCC kras taken ttre r.rrì.pfecedented stef) of setting up aPress Freedorrr Corrrrnittee. Corr¡zen-or Francis Àzloriarty ta'kes a look at ttre d;an::gers arotlnd us arrd vr¡trat the cornrnittee vzill be doing.
WffiilT"#ff:.¿ï"îiffå
himself sitting in a jail cell, doing some first-hand research on ciyil disobedience, hewasvisitedbyhis goodfriend, RalphWaldo Emerson, who inquired: "Henry, whatever are you doing in there?" To which Thoreau replied: "Ralph, the question is not 'what am I doing in here'. The question is, what are you doing out there?" rü(¡hich is a way of getting around to another question: Whyhas the FCC set up a press freedom committee?
When the real question should be: Why hasn't the FCC set one up before? Perhaps the answer has something to dowith complacency. We have taken our liberty a bit for grante d, whingeing about the odd bureaucrat or the colonial mentality, but generally being left alone to get on with our work. How-
ever, the situation has always been different for reporters who correr really local news, particularly in the days
when certain papers had the proverbial ' special relationship' with the government, leaving disfavoured publications scratching for information where they could find it. Reporters covering
Hong Kong, not just working from here, have always known just how closed this government reallywas, alit benefited grc tly by comparison to what was operating across
though
the tlorder. That is why the Hong KongJourCtub presld.ent Hans Vriens
EilI
August 1995
aûtld tbe local med'iø: a.tlmefor a.ction.
nalistsAssociation has long had a press freedom committee, andwhyit has felt the need to produce an annual report August 1995 TED GORRESPoilIIDilT
on the state ofthe free press. Thisyear's
excellent yersion is appropdately titled Broken Promises: Freedorn of Expression in Hong Kong , anditis a catalogue of all the reasons journalists here have to worry. Which gets us neatly around to why club president Hans Vriens as-
be addressed. It is hard to shut up a couple of hundred reporters. But you can make them silent as stones bY g ggtng a single publisher, as in the case ofthe Internationøl Herald Tribune. Singapore, however, does not
gested that we cÍeatr- a press freedom
stop with single publishers (or even single former FCC presidents). It has now extended its logic to entire na-
committee of our own. Over the past two years, certainly
tions, calling upon the Philippine government to apologise in the case of
since China's arrest and jailingof
Flor Contemplacion, the FiJipina do-
sented so quickly when
it
was
sug-
Míng
Pao reporter Xi Yang. the FCC has b..om. inl creasingly active in the fight for the protection of press freedom, but it
has been on an issueby-issue, event-byevent basis. But the times no
longer allow for such
ad hockery. There is legislation we want passed, bills we want
Local TV stations purchase broadcastrights to documentaries, thenrefi.rse
to air them, effectively blocking them from public view (unless the FCC steps in to fill the void, as president Vriens outlines in this issue).
Rupert Murdoch drops the BBC Wodd Service from STAR-TV to avoid upsetting China. Aþple Datly reporters are denied access to eve nts in Be ijing , inapparent
retaliation for publisher Jimmy Iai's printed insults to Prernier Li Peng. And then
there are the thugs throwtngAþþ/e copies intotheMacauharbour,
perhaps part of the China retaliation, or as seems more likely
an act of revenge
for
stories the paper pub-
Committee. The government has received a High Court verdict upholding Section 30 (reversing a lower court fmding that held the section to be in
violation of Article 16 of the Bill of Rights). Ming Pao is considering an appeal to the Privy Council. Anyone who wonders why there is such a fuss over the Court of Final Appeal is invited to answer this: From whom are theMtng Pao Three more likely to get a lallr }lrear:ng - the Law Lords in London or a group of formerAppellate Court judges, vetted by the Beijingappointed transition team and the chief executive-designate of the future Special Administratiye Region, who are likelyto count among them at
ies? Let's hop
W'omisomeasthehoodlums are, it is the nearsilence by members of
written, rep-
the Preliminary'Work-
resentations made, in-
ing Committee that un-
terviews given. The
settles the most. Save for Tsang Yok-sing and his Democratic Alliance
13ra;ît citizeîs a legal right to know what the administration has in its files. Again, the FCC and the HKJA have been fighting very hard for an Access to Information law and much ef-
creases. Moreover, the
for the Bettement of
fast-approaching transi-
HongKong, none of the PWC members openly objected to China's ex-
tionto Chineserule has many implications for journalists and for the
club itself. For example, will joumalists here need some kind of offi-
cial accreditation,
as
they do in China? What
will "foreign" mean after 1997? exactþ
Howwouldweclassif a
correspondent from a
Chinese newspaper headquartered in Bei- Alteffiatìue þress: a newsstand ln Sbangbat. jing? OrinGuangzhou? Will settingup abureau mestic hanged by the Singapore govin Hong Kong be as easy as it is now? errìment. We have never dealt with Or more like setting one up in China? Our concerns also cover the re- anything quite like the Singapore phenomenon and it's going to require gion. Recent events have, sad to say, some carefi:l thought. name than the made Singapore more But one need not Pick on Singaof a proud republic. It is now a metaphor for restrictions on the press, in- pore. Pick a,tlnreat to press freedom andthere is an example close athand: cluding punitive libe I actions launched TVB News executive Leung Kaby senior government ministers who wing excises unflattering references ought to know how to use their power to communists contairied in a documore productively. How to deal with mentary about Cambodia. this threatis amajorissue thatneedsto
clusion of the Aþþle feporters from covering their meetings. Mind you, this is the samegroupthatisready to Yote itself in as the
Preparatory Committee, then probably as the provisional legislature, where among the firstof theireadypromised acts will the passage of laws against trea-
sonandsubversionthat
will take effe ctwhen China takes oyer. The Hong Kong govemment insists upon punishing three Ming Pao journalists under Section 30 of the Prevention of Bribery Ordinance,
which bars disclosure without prior perrnission of information about ICAC investigations. This is a draconian provision that the FCC has consistently opposed, and about which we have voiced our distaste in letters to both
the govemor and the ICAC Review
The bad news is that the government knows perfectþ well what the lâws are that deeply concern journal-
The govemment continues its half-
hearted effort to remove potentially dangerous legislation that dates from as far back as the last century, much of it virtually never invoked. Some small steps are being taken. The govemment has agreed to repeal regulations contained in the Emergency Regulations Ordinance, alaw t}aat gives the gorrernor unfettered power to do anything deemed necessary in the event of an emergency, a condition for which no
eMing Paotakes
the case to London.
amended,lawswewant scrapped. Many letters
as the urgency in-
advisorybodies have on their agendas. We might also ask for the miriutes of their meetings.
ing on Beijing advisory bodThe govemment refrrses to
workload is expanding
is now a far better piece of law. That is the good news.
least two individuals now serv-
lished about triads.
nee d to be
to know what all those govemment
process.'We might start by demanding
fort by joumalists went into preparingone. The restilÍ Govemment Guidelines to Access that haye no teeth. Access is now a
matter of suggested nfes left operi to the interprètation of
'\üt¡i11
journalists irr Hong
I(ong need sorne accreditation,
as trrLe)r
do in Ctrina?'tül.trat qzill "fofeigtr"
firea;î
after A997?
bureaucrats suchas Works SecretaryJarnes Blake, who recently
told legislators that water pollution measurements would be kept secret because the public
might "misinteipret' ttrem, which of coufse means that the citizeffy might rcaßze how bad the poisoning really is and, in its parric, demand that the pollut-
erspay principle be extended to big business and to goYernment. They might evenwant to see all the information contained in environmental impact statements on projects like the airport and container terminals. Blake's action is a perfect example of what bureaucratic discretion means in practice, and
why we have fought for a legislated right to know. But as the guidelines exist, theymust either be made to work, or shown up
ineffectual. Iæss than a handfirl of joumalists have so far sought to make use of the guidelines. I would call upon every member of the FCC to find a reason to seek information from a govemment department and to test the as
definition is provided. But while scrap pingthe subsidiaryregulations, the govemment has retained the ordinance itself, saying "fresh regulations" cotrld be provided if necessary. That is like tossing outthe oldbullets as beingpast the sell-by date , while le aving the pistol hangng on the wall, ready for fresh aÍìmo when the time comes. Also, as this is being written, the legislature is about to pass the Interpretation and General Clauses (Amendment) Bill, which places restrictions upon the ability of law enforcement agencies to engage in the search and seizure of joumalistic materials. The FCC made a subrnission to the bills committee, as did the HKJA, and the government responded favourably on a number of points. Thanks to the effort of the committee headed by Andrew rùØong, the
bill
it steadfastly refuses to consult the profession when it finally ists, yet
gets around to wateririg these provisions down. So we are forced to be vigilant and track legislation, a time-
consuming and sometimes highly technical process. I have not touched on other areas of deep concern, such as the future role of the Communist Party in Hong Kong; the monitoring of joumalists by China; the division of the news media into categories based on the
perception of their political leanings and their vulnerability to persuasion, intimidation andattack; the blacklisting of publications, news organisations and specific individuals; the infiltration of the media by agents who come in under the cover of being mainland journalists, a much-desired group
due to their connections in China and knowledge of affairs there; the buy-out, then closing down of publications viewed as unfriendly to Beijing (eg, the appointment of as a Hong Kong affairs adviser after the shutting down of Contemþorary; or the shifting news sensibilities of publications who view future growth as being on the mainland and who rre ergeÍ, to borrow the word s of the Hongk ong Standard's editot, Terry Cheng, to engage "in the rectifi.cation of past excesses. " And I haven't eYen meritioned Lily \üong. It is to deal with such matters that
Yip Kwok-wah
we need
a Press Freedom Committee,
and I wish to thank the Board for backingtheproposalto startone. I amequally pleased as conyenof to see that so many members have expressed interest in tak-
lngpart. The formation of the commit-
tee is an importânt statement of the FCC's concem about protecting our lit>
erties. Ourfirst meetingwill take place in late summer, a.fter a number of members retum from holiday and extended assigfiments, andllookforwardto keep
ing the club up to date on orrr efforts
throughthesepages. g3 August 1995 T¡E G0na[SPoI{DDIIT
_T
Club gives aring to
Nikon rF90x
l{oweuer Good You fue, You Can D0 Better ,,,
controversial ChiÍra documentary \üçzith :f\rEl and AT*W stro'vrzing no sign of screening
ttre rrlrclr-discussed Britistr docurrerltary TVte l)1uín'g -R<><>rns, ttre FCC stepped in lrzittr not one, t>ut txzo, rrie-vrzings.
I:.x'#; DYing of club
Tbe
kinds tarv produced fwo very different
å".ni"g' The fìrst night involved
of
a
sober debate about the documentary journalism in general; the iÀãr ""¿ more ofl a sPeci-fic foãused ,..oo¿ FCC members willwhich to piá¡.., rngly gave money'
" 'ñe
DYtng Rooms shows some of
the abuses in China's state-run from
.,-t **at - abuses that range who aãin tã".. towards toddlers roá¿ ,n. entire daY tied inofchairs potti.t to *¡ I neglect baby die' "ião. ,o the Point where they "nitlt one ofthe moreharrowingimages
emaciated was the final one: a httle
Jir, *ittt lo*ut¿t
i"fected eye' head lolling
"n cameta, then crying in a ftre
pititulway. name, died
filmed.TheorP
but denied her existence' this, ----'iebate
in the FCC after the first joumalistic showing focused on the subtextwas ouestioñs raised, although a consequences the of dre broader issue
äicrti""'t onechild policy'
The results
programme of ttre populationcontrol
Whileadramatic slowcreate ing of the birh rate has heþed growth tlie circumsønces for economic *¿ ttu. improved some people's-lives' ttn
r.¡*^-i".d.
loÀp"rtotY aboftions and medrcaJlY U".Ë¿ nianticide have undoubtedly causedmuch suffering' gust 1995
But the debatewas limited. Certatn organisations who work in these fields in China declined to come to the FCC a sign that incuring the displeasure of Beijing is a matter of concem for other professionals than just those whowork
Fergal Keane, the new BBC correspondentinBeijing, who knows athing or two about documentaries, having won several major awards for his about Rwanda, made the point that the Chi-
inthemedia. hrstead, thepanelincluded Jonathan Mirsky, who appeared in the
Not only do they cteatea "snowstofm" for journalists working there, but they have repe atedly refused permission for the BBC each time it has tried to make a film about the one-child policy. On the second occasion the documentarywas shown, there was no for-
documentary columnist Nury Vittachi and field specialist Sheila Purves. Sadly, noneofthe documentaryteamwasthere; instead, theywere represented by pho tographer David Chappell. The consensus view was that the filmwas flawed, but that the FCC was right to show it because it would not have got an uring on either of Hong Kong's TV stations (see comments on this by club president Hans Vriens, on page 4). The major criticisms were its style and what are best described as its excesses. After all, it was called The fuíng Roortts, but the evidence on cameÍa was of one only. Some members felt the documentary had taken fartoo emotional an approach, leaving analysis and even objectivity behind. There were also objections to its traY-
elogue style. Rex Ellis, who declared himself an old joumalistic foge¡ wanted facts, and
got some from David Chappell, who pointed out that the sryle was foisted on the independent makers by Ctønnel4. He added that one reason tlrat locations and people were obscured was to pro tect their identities - an argument that seemed to be accepted.
nese authorities do
notheþ themselves.
mal discussion. Instead, Nina van Toulon and club member Katy le Blanc
answered questions about their own project - the Ing Mei Orphanage Fund. The frrnd helps look after 110 children at the Ing Mei Orphanage rn Thejiang province, ofwhom over 70 per cent are gids and
9O
per cent are handicapped.
This involves collecting some RM810,000 to pay fot one little girl to have an urgently needed heart operation. FCC members did themselves
proud by stumping up a significant part of the cash. On top of this, the two women who live in Hong Kong but do business in that part of China - ate taking a long-termview and are trying to change culture and attitudes towards the orphanage by encouraging local people to become more involved. A total of 712 members attended the first scree r:lng of Th e Dy íng Ro oms and 52 the second.
-MichaelMackey
Nikon tr90X Higher speed, greater accuraey. Every professional photographer knows that it is cr¡tical to get every single frame right. Because even in several rolls, the perfect moment comes only once, and that one
frame must be flawless. Now there's a camera with an autofocus system so fast and accurate, an exposure system so advanced, you can entrust to your camera what once you only entrusted to your keenly developed senses. Even in complex lighting conditions, D-type AF
Nikkor lenses send information on lens focusing distance to the camera's computer for advanced 3D
matrix metering computations. Better still, it forms the core of a powedul system that includes a vedical shooting grip MB-1O and a new speedlight 58-26 with a wireless slave flash. The new Nikon F9OX. With features to make a great photographer greater. For morc ¡ntormal¡on mailback lhts coupon to Shrtro (H K ) Ltd GPO Box 1 81 , Hong Kong
Name: l Addrêss
:
@ ûEA
-
SOLE AGENT : SHß|RO f H.K.l
LTD.
2nd Froor Hurchison House, 1o Harcourr Road, cenrar, Hong
Kong
Ter: 2s24
soo1-B
Fax: 2810 6sB6
China: there must be no "gratuitous"
accusations. Everything must be accompanied by facts. But comic strips are not like that. They hit and run. For that reason, Tbe
World of Lily Wong probably stung the people in Fortress Xinhua more than a thousand Morning Post leaders. Feign, who had worked for the Posl longer than virtually everybody on the editorial staff ,was dismissed by
killed Lily Wong?
Previous Posú editor Phillip Crawley objected to this first panel, but, after discussion with Feign, decided to run the strip anyway.
oça
fax on the night of the "murderous dog" line. Armstrong and new editorJonathan
Fenby say they received only a few letters after the disappearance of Lily, and none from Chinese readers. This is how Fenby worded it in a letter pub-
Was this what did for Lily? Iarry Feign was sacked on the day this appearcd.
lished in Tl¡e Guardiaz newspaper in London: "'SØe have receivedfewer than
YEAí.
Bof Doil,Î 'IEH.IIEH. TEIL ANY.
a dozen letters, half of them merely inquiringwhere the strip nas been a sufiuïer ofupheavals at ttre Soutlt Cbinø Morning Post.
strips it lrad already paid for but not used? And why didn't it consider the
The first was the sudden killing-off of Tbe World, of Lily Wong catoon strip,
cartoonist's offer to continue work-
which had been running in the Post for eight years. Editor-in-chief David Armstrong
'ùØhatever the reason, Lily had certainlybeen scathing about some of the inequities of life in China. In the days before,{rmstrong dropped the stfip, it had been taking a look at the organ transplant business, with a reference,
ft I
says
Lily, andher creator, Larry Feign,
were done away with to cut costs. Nonsense, says Feign. If thatwere the case, why didn't t}l.e Post run the
ing for a reduced fee?
albeit introduced humorously, to Li
Pengbeing a "fascist, murderous dog". These are the kind of throwaway and enrage the lines that baffle
-
-
Chinese authorities. They don't like criticism of any kind, but, for obvious reasons, they have had to learn to live with it, as long as it is supported by reasoning. In this context, the editors of tl:e Soutlt Cbina Morning Post arc thought to have been given essentially one de when it comes to covering
has gone.
We
have had not a single letter from our Hong Kong Chinese readers, who make up more thLanhalf the circulation and write on every subject under the sun."
way,tlrat Tbe Guardian, on the other side of the wodd, pubQ.{ote, bythe
lished Fenby's letter about Iily Wong. Tl:re Post, under the editorship of the same Fenby, has not published one of those it has received.) So what happened to the letter Martin Lee says he wrote for publica-
tion? That never appeared. Armstrong's reply to that question can be found on page 14.
are feattred the organ transplant series, the strips the Posthad paid for but not used, a number of others
An extended version of Lee's letter is to be found in Larry Feign's new book, B ønne d in IIong Kozg in which
banned over the years byvarious Posf editors and many more.
-Psfs1'Cordingley
The Posü had paid for these, but still didn't use them. A strange way to to save money.
Ai'D T.tY FAfIIER 'IE
UERE VERY
croaE.
tre bfi s'de of lhe roodlore noi trob e'n Chlrc, Yel scores of righltud dr;ve (ong, ore æen in Chinêse cllles, ruryútuen by podv, ormvond pollCe ollbbls.
tr
SHE r¡rAS
A
Blf
OF
Ail
lHE \f{Ew c}flNAz. f fritNK slE EVEN HEI'EÞ FOR}á ffE IþCAI VILLAEE PARÍY CELI. IDEAUST. AELISVED IN
Tf,E CORRf,SPONIIf,NT Àugust 1995
Àugust 1995
Ttr[
GORXESPOI|IIDIIT
B33
'There was no cefrsorship' A4<>rnirtg P<>st editor-in-chief Da"rzid Arrnstrong sa;zs the decision to sack calrtoonist Larry Feign szas purely financial- Etut he acknoxrledges tLLat tre censored letters accusing hirn of politica-l celrsorskrip, including one frorn Derrrocrat I{artin LeeHere is the f'Lrll te><t of Affnstfollg's reply to qLrestions put to trirn, f>y fa><, f>y 7l2z e (]<>rresp o rt(Zev, t editor Peter Cordingle>--
Cordingley: If the sackf)..." I ing of Larry Feign was a
budget-cutting exercise, a) why did you notpublishthe stripsyou had already paid for? and b) why did you not entertain his offer to work for a reduced fee?'
full cost of the LilyS7ong strip was part ofan overall savings target. Ifthe saving to be made is $X and the person
David Amstrong: a)'When Larry
jected saving.
Feign's contract was terminated, I decidednotto publish strips alreadypaid for because I believe that once difficult decisions are taken it is best to
implement them swiftly and have a clean break, rather than prolonging
For Hong Kong trade statistics, information and analysis. Fast. Call the Hong Kong Trade Development Counc¡|.
tions: the money had to be paid whether the strips were published or not.
Hong Kong Trode Development Council We CreoIe Opporlunities
38th Floor, Office Tower, Convention Plaza, 1 Harbour Road, Wanchai, Hong
the separation. This is my general approach. In this pafüculat case, it was obvious that ending Mr Feign's contract would be a contentious decision because "Lily Wong" was intensely popular among a section of the readership (although not, I believe, widely popular). Mr Feign cleady had an opportunity to make a marryr of himself; if I had allowed him to continue drawing Lily NØong for the next month (as he suggested), I would have been giving him a chance to make amartyr of himself day after day. The decision not to publish strips already covered by the notice clause of his contract had no financial implica-
BL]C Kong Tel: 2564 4333 Fax:2824
0249
b) I did not entertain his offer to work for a reduced salary because the
affected ofTers to work for, say, $3¡4X,
then you only make
l/4 of the pro-
would be happy to publish a letter from him on this subject. I suggested he might reconsider his original letter and invited him to replyto me. He did not write back.
P.C. \Vhy did you not publish even one of the letters you received?
P.C. Can you con-fi.rm that you have not received aletterfor publi-
cation onthe Feigntopic from any Clrinese readers, including a)D'{:ar
tin Ire a¡d/or b) Christine Loh?
D.A. I did not receive any letters of complaint, or inquiry, from any Chinese people among the general readership ofthe paper. I did not receive a letter from Christine Loh. I did receive a letter from Martin Lee. It was dated
May 22. The second sentence of his letter began with the words "I do not know the genesis of this decision . . ." The letter continued with more than a page of speculation and criticism.
I wrote to
Martin the next day,
suggesting that his admission that he did not know the reason for the deci-
sion rendered the rest of his letter irrelevant. I explained tl:at tlae Post
D.A.
Ireceivedfewerthan 20 letters concerning the ending of Lily Wong. Some were unpublishable because they were crude and abusive; some were simple letters of inquiry. The re st were attacks on the allegedly political nature of the decision. I should point out here that until recently the Posf had a policy, going back many years, of not publishing letters criticising its performance or decisions. I changed that policy and letters critical of the Posl are now published. I am willing to be criticised for the things I have done. But I did not see why I should wear the hak-shirt of public criticism in my own newspaper for something I had not done - that is, made a political decision to end Lily 'W'ong; to have allegedlybowed to pres-
had been conducting an economy drive
sure when there was no pressure. This
and that Lily \Vong had been a victim
is not a matter of opinion, of letting people put their viewpoint; this was a
of cost-cutting. I told Martin that I
August 1995 Tf,E CORRXSPoilDIIIT
question of fact. I was accused in these letters of making a political decision; I had not. Instead of publishing letters onthe subject, Iwrote to complainants explaining the position.
P.C.
Can you please supply the
fïgures that support the contention that LilyVong cost the equivalent of two journalists' salaries. D.A. I believe I have actually said it
element- editorial- made to carrythe entire load of the discore
rníssals?
D.A.
Tbe Soutb
CltinaMorníngPost
decided to cut editorial salaries by 10
per cent in order to control rapidly rising costs. These were: the price of newsprint; the cost of editorial sala-
was the equivalent of two young jour-
ries @oosted by expansion of the paper and the higher salaries generated by the competition flowing from the launch of the Eastern Exþress); and
nalists' salaries. The matter of Mr
the cost of equipping two new of-
Feign's monthly contributor's payment confidential, unless Mr Feign chooses
fices/plants, atTaiPo andDorsetHouse
is
to disclose it. I can say it amounted to almost half of the total monthly cartoon bill of tlae Soutlt Cbina Morning Post and tlee Sund,ay Morning Post. \Øith a 10 per cent increase scheduled in October, it would have been more
than half. At a time of financial cutbacks, the question of whether it is worth paying almost half the carroon budget on one strip is an obvious one. I decidecl it was not. More generally, I would suggest that you look at the logic of events at the Posf over the last few months. In March, we began an economy drive, implementing a virtual fteeze on the hiring of new staff, cutting back on
in Quarry Bay. Editorial costs were singled out because theywere the only one of the three over which the company harl control and, of the various departmental staff costs, the only one which had blown out. So there were no non€dito rial staffincluded in the lay-offs.
P.C. How
do you respond to ac-
that the editorial layoffs were caused by the realisation that it would have been too costly to let the Sunday papet move to Tai Po, and that room had to be found for everyone in cusati.ons
Dorset House?
D.A.
I have
never heard of the sugges-
stringers and retainers and putting tight controls on travel. In May, we ended Larry Feign's contract and merged tlae Sundøy and Daily edito-
tion that the company "realised" it would be too costþ to move the Sunday PosttoTai Po. This is not so much of an accusation as aninvention. Itwas
rial operations, resulting in the laying off o125 editorial staff and a cut in the editorial salaries bill of more than 10 per cent. InJune, we tightened control over our leave bill. In the same period there has been no change in editorial policy, our columnists who are critical of China contirue to write exactly as they have done in the past, and Paul Best, our political
not, at any time
cartoonist, still has a free hand. No one has been censored. Yet, somehow in the middle of this, the Lily Wong decision is meant to be a political one. The logic of events at the Post supports the facts of the Lily Wong decision - itwas part of an economic cutback.
P.C. On the rnore general question of sackings, can you please say how many non-editorialper-
sonnel were laid off in the costcutting exercise that led to the merging of the Sunday paper with the daily? If none, why was the lHE
CORRXSPOilDENT
Augusr 1995
,a
factor in the compa-
ny's deliberations on cuttingbackcosts.
P.C. Disrnissing 10 per cerìt of editorial is a very deep cut. There is a risk that good people will be lost. IIas this happened? D.A. In any large scale cutback it is inevitable that some good people will be lost, along with the "passengers". of course, manymore goodpeople the 90 per cent still working at the
P.C. Intheeyesofsome,youwill be remembered as an undistinguished editor who lefï tlae M ornúng Post weaker than he found it. Howwouldyoulike to be remembered af ter you return to Au str alia? D.A. This is a real "when-did-youstop-beating-your-wìfe" question. I am pleased to see, however, that you say some might view me as an undistin-
guished editor, for this means that most do not. It has been my experience here that in the eyes of "some" no editor of the Post has ever produced a decent newspaper. "Some" of the "some", of course, had a chance to put hundreds
L249,999
Read
it
and reap Woolwich Guernsey has consistently offered excellent
I want my
hard (as each successive editordoes) to
make it better, as have the many fine joumalists on the paper who have supported me. I hope, together, we have had some success. I cannot i¡fluence
what people say, or thìnk, of me, so how I would hope to be viewed is irrelevant. I can only hope that inyiew-
rates o[ interest in all these tiers.
In a preamble, Armstrong
also
spoke about the question of selfcensorship: "Selfcensorship is often discussed here as though it is a peculiady Hong Kong problem, which, of course, it is not. It is a common observation iust about everywhere that reporters "talk" their stories much harder than they write them. And it is coflrmon all over the wodd for reporters to go easy for fear of offending a friend, or a foe.
The tendency for journalists to self-censor is greater in countdes run byauthoritarian governments. AsHong
section editors, is this: journalists are expected to report as fully, as accurately and as honestly as they can; if that creates a problem, it becomes my
problem."
Peter Cordingley is a former
-head of the magazine divísion of t}reSCMP.
@
money to earn more interest Please
send me details o[ ¡he Woolwich Guernsey Sterling
lnternational Gross Account Last year, in particular, our Ê500-Ê9,999 tier offered 5 75olo interest, the
highest rate of any offshore building society subsidiary. Which, incidentally, made
ing me, people look at the record faidy.
P.C. Why, when the paper
ily cover the layoff o125 people in any other company or industry.
-
of millions of dollars of C.K. Ma's
Kong is about to be handed back to such a government, journalists feel the need to censor themselves. The policy on the Soutb Cbina Morning Post, as spelled out to all
systematically given space to layoffs in other sectofs, did you not coveryorrr own dfurnissals the following morning? D.A. I don'tthinkwewould ordinar-
f,l00,000
money where their mouths are, and failed spectacularþwhere it mattered: in the eyes ofthe readers. Tbe Soutlt Cbinø Morning Postis a diffefent newspapef than it was twG and-a-half yeaß ago. I have worked
Post - have been retained. They understand that maintaining the quality of the Posf requires more hard work from everyone.
has
Current Interest Rates (r,ariable) Gross p.a.
it
the industry best buy for 1994i
Mr/Mrs/Miss/Ms Address
And, had you invested 110,000 over the past 3 years in our 110,000L3g,ggg tier, you'd now'be crying with laughter, because as
it
was also rated
industry best buy in'94..In fact, you can now earn an impressive
6.50olo
in this bracket.
Poslcode
Quite obviously then, you could do yourself a wealth of good by invest-
ing with Woolwich Guernsey. And you can rest assured your investment is secure. All deposits are 100o/o guaranteed by Woolwich Building Society.T
Not only that, the beauty of this Woolwich Guernsey account is that
it
gives you instant access to your money. You're free to withdraw all or part of
your investment at any time you like with no penalties at all.
Country Iel/Fax No
Relurn to Agent for Hong Kong representative o[[ice: And¡ew Eden, Ernest Maude Continental lnveslments Ltd, l2rh Floor, 3l W;ndham Street, Central, Hong Kong Alternatively, relum to] Woolwich Guernsey Limited, PO Box 341, La Tonnelle House, Les Banques, St Peter Port, Guernsey Channel lslands GYI 3UW
For more information simply call Andrew Eden on 2521 9188 during weekly business hours, alternatively fax him on 2526 2993 or return the coupon to Woolwich Guernsey directly
Woolwich Guernsey We wipe away the competition's tiers.
wooLwrcH GUEBNSEY
OI.YMPUS E l+ E,ff
The realr.easofi.s for the
('IJYMPUS
He¡¡Lçe#¡,t"1*fP,,9
4t Etf
#r4+;t$#Ë+f$
l
Post sackings trLising n-e-e\zsprirtt costs. Declining ad sales- lfl:rese T\zere ir.rst a couple of ttre e><planations girzen for the sackings at ttre P<>st. À4a¡rl>e, sa)zs Peter Cordingle¡z-, but the real story is that ttre people disrnissed szere rrrade to pay for l>lunders b¡z ttre fÍ:Lalra.g,errì-ent-
The ultimate portable tape recorder
+ + <> _
Leather crafted body, new case-free desigr. 35mm AF camera, classy and ultra compact. Infrared active type focus system, shoot as close as to 0.35M. Programmed electronic shutter:
Pockettape recorder, 909 (without battery) 73(H)x 52(W) x 20(D) mm
V15 sec. to V500 sec,
Autoreverse Remote Control
Auto-S flash mode reducing redeye effect.
film loading/ advance/rewind, self-timer. LGD display, auto
LCDpanel
Sole agent: Kingstone Development Co. Tel:2730 5663
for (Hong
Kong
ritories
T f
hese wines moy be ordered hom the Club, bllled to your occounl cnd delivered to on oddress of your choiceOnly whole coses, of twelve boffles, moy be ordered under this scheme To ploce on order pleose send
or Fox (28óB 4092) this
onl),)
FCCAUG MCI Medilerrqneon Summer Selection ($990 per cose) úree holion, two Sponish ond one from Greece. The whites ore lwo from Greece Hove fun checking hese wines ond poy specicl otlenlion lo the ì 990 Merlot ond Vi$o s o reol treotwith ùe '93 Lungoroiti Pinot Grigio ond o '94 Sæve Clossico
completed torm to lhe Club
FCCAUG Wl
$AVE
Potros, 1993. $7O. ($84O per cose) Achoio Clquss, Greece.
We ore now ìnto lhe second month of this offer ond ol though stocks ore stìll in hond, lhe populority during lhe lirst month meons lhct there is o likelyhood o[ our runningoul. lI this hoppens we will contocl you with o substilule seleclion The mixed cose offer still rofes high in the populority stokes so, beoring in mind the lime o[ yeor, this lime l've picked o dozen which l'll coll my 'Mediterroneon Summer Selec-
tìon"
You probobly olreody know Achoio Clouss cs lhe producer ol Demeslico. This, lhe oldesl wìnery in Greece {lhey didn'l oll survive those lomous wors), produces much, much more ond here's on exomple ll's soft ond fresh with very good lruil flovour mode hom the lighlly tinted Rhodilis grope
FCCAUG RI Pinot Nero, 1991, $100. ($t20O per cose) Hofstotler, South Tyrol, ltoly The Villo Bor¡henou eslote produces lhls unìque Pinol. The [omily hove owned the proper! for neorly ninety yeors ond with thot much procflce lt's no surprise thot they've gol it righi! Try il very slightly chilled wilh some sl¡ced cold Bee[...greol.
CHEERS.
Wines by the case delivered Name
Wine Ref: FCCAUC MCI TCCAUG FCCAUG Rl
Wl
Full order value: $ Full address for delivery:
Tel. No.
No. of Cases
Total Price $ Total Price $ Total Príce $
No. of No. of
Cases Cases
-
Signatu re:
This offer is for July/August only. Deliveries will be durÌng the 4th week of each month.
-
to you
FCC No.
pate a thought for Soutb Cbina
Morning Post editor Jonathan
Fenby. Few people have had their job description changed as radically and rapidly as his.'When he was hired in London eadier this year, he was le d to
believe he was coming out to Hong Kong to run a strong daily newspaper with a long and (mainly) honourable reputation. løith the challenge from the Eøstern Exþress beaten off, the Post was not only set for a Period of growth, but had a crucial role to PlaY in maintaining Hong Kong's confïdence as the change of sovereignty approached. InsteaÇ, Fenbyfinds himself editor of a newspaper in its worst editorial crisis in its 9l-yeat history. It started with the sacking, in suspicious circumstârnces, of cartoonist I¿rry Feign after a particularly acidic attack on China. Despite denials from Fenby and others, itis now suspectedthe paperhas been tumed byproBeijing political
pres
sure. Days later, some of Fenby's best joumalistswere sackedfromundemeath him by the editor-inchief; and many of those who escaped the dismissals are said to be now resentfi¡l and dispirited. Not only ttrat, ttre feisty Sunday paper was swept away (takingwith itmywife, its editor, it should be said), and in its place is asad, charactedess cat-trayliner. Little wonder, then, that FenbY, when asked recently how things were going, is said to have merely shook his head in disbelief. W-ho's to blame? Itwould be easy
but, in fact, incorrect - to blame Armit- all on editor-in-chief David strong. True, he has serious faults as a leader, but tlae Mornlng Post is not in the mess it's in because of him. The
problem lies with the fact that it is a badly run company. Seen from the outside, the Posf looks like a sleek, money-making machine. But on the inside things are rrery different. Its management team, which groups the principal executives, is split, just about along race lines, with several members openly at wat with each other. Much executilre energy at the Morning Posl is wasted on whispering campaigns, blame-passing and blocking. Atthe top levels of thePos/,
Capital expenditure budgets were flrnning wild, and moving the Sunday pa-
one person's problem is another pef-
about costs, and his secretary then handed out envelopes telling the recipient whether helshe was being dis missed or retained. It was shoddy beyond belief. @y the way, did anyone notice that the sackings were at the very end of May? If they had been left a
son's celebfation. Given this, it should have come
as
no suq)fise to anybody that ttre move to
theTaiPoplantwas simplytoo muchfor the company. From day one, the operationwas botched. Plan A, ifyou remember, was for all editorial to move out to Tai Po. But then, in the face of poaching by the Eastern Exþress, it was thought more caring to keep them in town. So we had Plan B: The joumalists wottld go into the Bank of America Tower. But Bank of America was then judged too valuable a piece of real estate to put hacks in. Plan C: They wottld all go to Dorset House, alongside the building the Posf was vacating. That plan held good for months, but then there was anotherproblem. Itwas discoveredthere wasn't enoughroom in the building for both the daily and Sunday papers. Back to Plan A (revised): The Sunday would go to Tai Po, and the dailywottld stay in town. As solutions go, it was the worst possible. It meant costþ duplication of technology and facilities, and it created two classes of editorial staff Meanwhile , the cost of the Tai Po plant was now almost out of control.
pef out there, with the duplications involved, would only make things worse. Quite cleady, the Sunday staff would have to be squeezed into Dotset House. But how? Plan D (final solution): The Sunday paper would be merged with the daily. So side
the infantrywere marched outagalnst a wall and shot. Or,
, put
more exactþ, DavidArmstrongmade a mumbled, incomprehensible speech
little longer, the victims would have qualifled for the annual pay rise inJuly
- which would have increased all the redundancy pay-outs.) The people who made all thewrong calls over the Tai Po move are still in their executive offrces. Does it bother them that perfectly irìnocent people lost their jobs because of their bungling? Knowing who they are, I don't suppose so. They are skilled survivors and they
will put the Tai Po nightmare behind them soon enough. On page 14,David Armstrong dismisses this scenario. But he would, wouldn't he? He was part of the decision-making team on Tai Po. And, anyway, these days he is being asked to do and say a lot of things he is not comfortable with. As forhis future, I stand bymy prediction that he will be gone before verylong. His job is done here.
@
Äugust 1995 TEE
TORRXSPO¡{I¡EIIT
(Yo-Yo)
World-famous classical cellist Yo Yo Ma probably spends more time on the road than at home. While on tour, he might stay in a converted monastry in Florence one
da¡ and a HongKong high rise the next. Although he
can't take his grand piano with him, there are two things he never leaves home without One is his 2SO-yearold
Stradivarius cello. The other is his
IBM ThinlcPad 755C. The cello gets its own seat on the plane. But it's the keys of his ThinkPad that keep his
fingers nimble on those long flights.
. Intel 486 DX4/75 MHz uith in,tegrated. math co-processor expa,ndable to 36 MB ' VESA LocaL Bus and Windows Accelerator technolog, . Remouoble hrrd disk 340M8 to Bl1MB . Utra large 10.4" Thin Fílm Transistor (TFT) Actiue LCD Dßplay ' IBM unique "pop-up" keyboarcl design' IBM Tracl¡Point integrated pressure-sensitiue poin.ting deuice ' Tuo'l'ype Il or One Type III PCMCIA cards ' EPA Energy Star clesignotion. . Integralecl Aurlio support The IBM ThinkPad 755C:
' 4MB stanrlard m.emory
--- - - -- ----
For more inÍormation, fäx your business card to 2537 6601 and quote "ThinkPad 755C", or call 2825 7B7B
I I r
There is a difference' ---t--
IBM is a registered trademark and There ¡s a difference is trademark ol lnlernational Busines Machines Corporation O 1995 IBM Corporation
E-
-
-TI ---
r
-
I -O
PLEAsE
P,ATRO N I5 E
THEsE
SUPPORTERs
FCC
9o RE,ST.,\LJRA.NT The Village (Indian) Restaurant
For Curry Lovers
57
.
Wyndhm Street, Ba*ment, Hong Kons. Tel 2525 7470,2525 4717
\,lr
FRENCH CUISINE
IT]NCH OFFERS
Z
10 Lcss special discount La Carte only) 1-ll0 Tâke-ä\å}
lj
& C¿ttct,ing scr\ ice: 2õ25 +l
il G""dl
A((l-t ".f
COFFEE $I38
*Ë
-DINNER
I 5o/o
l{cscr\'¿rlions: 232õ
COURSE LUNCH PLUS SALAT),{ND TEA OR
-LUNC]H
N,linimuìrì grorìp
t\
PAPILLON -PRì\'ATE ROOÀIS AVAILABLE I/F 8-I I \(/O ON LANE, CENTRAL.
+r
TEL:2526 5965 foodl r."''d[
',
s¡&]rrn
*"I"o-n"
awai.ú you,.
u
1\"O-tlO'U'RS ttl tl U:iSI\
&iSiS 1-
;-7';0 [)]{ I i,\ PP-f I itO'[:itì ['B ti,\ (-' (-'.t -tUS il'J,\R & ]ìfils:|,\ L'lì'\.\-1f ßostmtnt, .\-t t Jlcnnc.s.sv 'Ro¿r/, 'lltLtnt:litti (Íor co11
:-;:,0 -oo;:
f\on"t¿ Ki-rk devoted more than I) rr*years ot nrs llle to w..ng
how to run a company". He was, reported Kirk, "a multi-billionaire
CbungJu-yung and Hyundai, abook about one of Korea's major economic
treated
dynasties. But when he came to address an FCC lunch on the topic, he began with a confession. "I'm not sure how deeply I got beneath the surface," said Kirk, who had origi-
whether the book would help people do business with Korea. "Perhaps," said Kirk, who, after all, has his sales to think about. Mike Morrow wanted to know
nally allotted six months to the project. A key part of the problem
['\t-'t,t S7t)
was the extreme reluctance of Chung Ju-yung and his famlly, who control
('1,
rtstrt,ttiotts, pleasi
Six years of dynastic probing
S<¡uth China
Bttilding,
1-3
the all-powerful Hyundai group, to talk. This despite the fact that the patriarch ran for president of Korea
V],nclham Street
Tel: 2526-5293 Fax 2801-5006
in
"One can't penetrate the family structure," said Kirk. Even when one
Come and.ioin us af one of Centr.alts
favour.ite pu-bs.
of Chung's sons attended
Hearty English Breadfast served till 1 0.30 am Mon. - Sat. + Tradit¡onal Pub Grub, Daily Special
+
-
l\ilidnight.
We look fonwand to seeing you!
io
Furama Hotel)
Ceniral, Hong Kong Tel:2525 7436
açat'lìfc THE GODOWN
VOTED HONG KONG'S
-WHERE THINGS REATLY TAKE OFT-
$I IO
2 tAN KWA| FONG 804 ó5ó
GO N
Donald Kirk: Blocked by the Íctmíly.
the length of time it did, although in the encl people did talk - awhich Kirk compared to "breaking code of silence". Jnst like Korea itself, the group is undergoing a period of change, both in itself and as the relationship betlveen the two Koreas changes. Not
about the role North Koreaplayed in all this. Interestingly, this, like his failure to become president, has been one of the few obvious failures of Chung Juyung. He "looked as if he was getting somewhere but wasn't," said Kirk of his subject's business involvements in the North, although Hyr-rndai is still very much involyed in rnoves to bring the two states closer.
"Can
I
"Its late arrd had a bite" we havenrt florn lO -
formed tome. Question time began with a sim-
theywill evolve and change
cusations ofsexism are bandied about.
answer, as Chung was apparently irritated by "mandarins telling him
author'
ple but direct one from Patrick O'Reilly, who wanted to know why a man who the lunch had been told probably didn't know the scale of his own wealth should \Ã/ant to run for a grubby political post. Chagrin and resentment were the
Legco member
. . . unless something re ally dr amatic happens on the Korean peninsula." Equally as dramatic, although much
less likely, would be a change in shareholding - a topic raised by the correspondent from Der Spiegel. "No one is going to buy out H¡rndai," said Kirk. "Despite efforts at streamlining, I think family control will endure."
@
to address meeting
The Women in Publishing's
celebratç in style at our birth day pany
meeting on September 6 will play host to legislator Anna'Wu, who will be talking on freedom of expression afcet 1997. This should
in the first week of October. Last
provide a fascinating forum for
12 a'rn. Late night supper Friday, Saturtlay and eve's to public holidays.
members and non-members. IIIPS is five years old this year,
year,theparLy was held in the Ladies' as all those who wefe there will attest, was a gfeat success. There will be a huge anay of
Recreation Club, and,
prizes for this year's party, plus plenty of good food and beverage. Stay tuned for more details.
The cornmittee is still in the procoffine-flrningtheworkshop schedule and will provide a detailed list shortly. But it is akerdy known that thefi¡stsessionwillprovide aninsight into the on-line wodd and how it can benefit users. If you want to find out more about your future, watch this ess
space.
"^å.i1,"åJ#äliåï'ili,]iili..::", FOR RESERVATIONS CALL 524 ZO88 58 62 D' ,Aguilar Streer Lrn
survive?" asked Russ
checking back - "but he never said anything worth checking back." None of the sons seems well informed about the corporation, as the empire is divided up among them, with their view being "only my father knows, only my father decides". The daughters "don't seem to be factor in the situation," admitted Kirk lest ac-
and all members are invited to THE GODOWN, UPPE,R BASEMENT, FURAMA HOTEL, ONE CONNAUCHT PLACE, CENTRAL, HONG I(ONC
it
Arensman. Kirk acknowledged that the group was perhaps too large, but he didn't think it would crumble. "But
SET TUNCH
INCTUDING COFFEE
D
social inferior by all these
that this provided many opportunities, although Kirk has still managed to write what, by all accounts, is an in-
All this explains why the project took
2 COURSE
LUNCH, DINNER & DANCINC -PRTVATE ROOM,
press con-
not be quoted without the
+
Roast Beef Sunday Lunch + Cocktail Night Every Tuesday 2 for 1,5
a
ference given by the group, the problem persisted. The son asked that he
ODcn¡ng IIout's: B aut t¡ll 2atD ìIonrla! - Satilt'd¿t,t, Nooil - ì,1¡dnighl Sunrla,l,: Ilapp,l, I|out' 5 -B ptn
Ground Floor, Hutchinson H0use (next
1992.
as a
bureaucrats". David Lan asked
*;:;T;,ll_4,::]jlal
Hong
Kong rel:
845 i,577
Aùgust
-Robin
Bourer
1995 Ttr[ CoRRDSPoIIDENT
Oh, the wonder of
C¡rnnv Pncrrrc
it all
Club general rÍlrarLa.g,er Jettrro I-ee-llzIafronelz sa)r's rrruch tras cha-nged in ttre quarter of a ceratur:¡r' since he first rzisited Hong I(ong. But one thing has rerrrained <tollstant: kre still lorzes ttre place.
IY/i-t.n i rsr came ro riong nong, W ,n. OceanTerminal had been rr
open about a year, Harbour City didn't exist and there was a great square space at the top of the Peak. It was 1969.In the intervening years, Hong Kong has witnessed much and spread gteat deal, as ,indeed, have L " The passage of time is not necessarily something that one notices on a regular basis. In fact, I suspect that too
much attention to Old Father Time might actually be atad maudlin. And, a recent edition of this magnificent organ, I was extol-
yes, I do realise that in
ling the yirtue of celebrating birthdays. But that's only once a year.
From first sight, Hong Kong has always been a fascinating city, the people more so than the place. Nowa-
days,l think it's more the place than the people. Any comparison of the Hong Kong of the late '60s with the (un)fragrant harbour of the '90s is impractical, pointless, and probably riddled with inaccuracies. Appreciation of the present is likely to yield a
Though when I realise that there are comfortable facilities to appreciate tlre Phantom of tbe
it
reminded me of the one on the Swiss Centre in Leicester Square; which has a cowherd and lots of cows, while the local version has figures in traditional Chinese dress. However, where once I was impressed, I am now filled with wonder - wondering what has happened to it. It has disappeared, gone, it is no more, an
and the underdevelopment of the parklands without. It ceftainly isn't the
the Royal Geographical Societyto tum up here. It has now. Only a couple of weeks ago, a modest chap called Dick
I
do prtzzle. Tf,E GORRf,SP0ilIIDNI August 1995
the FCC, whenl overheard a couple of middle-aged British males murmuring to themselves that, whatwiththe heat,
humidity and crowds, there wasn't much for them to do in Hong Kong and they were bored. Now that is a
wonder!
sff ,t
Snailham lectured a 250-strong audience in the Furama Kempinski on his escape from Sangay; a volcano in Ecuador that erupted just as he was climbing it. We all wondered what he was
doing on a live mountainanyway.
To have more information sent to your
make your summer perfect.
Pacific on 2747-1100.
fax dial CX Fax 1783, enter code 747-
6t, or
call your travel agent or Cathay
mail to: Marketing Communications Dept, 20lF, Swire House, East Wing, Central, Hong Kong. Or Fax to:2525-4353. Please complete coupon and
IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII
FamilyNamel
I
Given Name
reptile house has just opened
dens. tù(/ith one reptile, now that's a wonder. Actually, it's a plthon. There are a couple of dazed crocodiles in a pond opposite, accompanie dby a family of exhibitionist frogs. I wonder why it took so long for
A new
or Amsterdam / London European culture, famous sights and world class theatre and shopping will London / Paris
I recently sat in a Central bar, not
ex-carillon.
Hong Kong Tourist Association slogan of "Wonders Never Cease" Q can't be the only one, apart from Penny Byrne, who thinks it's aneatpromotional line, surely?). It isn't just the development of the parks within the built-up districts
or the 5o-odd McDonald's outlets, but
ìCnrHnv Pnclnc
ens and the International Dragon Boat Races, well, I admit we 're on the right track. I was both visually and aurally impressed when I saw the Dutch-made carillon being installed on the tower of Nine Queen's Road Central. Okay, I admit
in the Zoolog¡cal and Botanical Gar
Hollywood, Kentucþ Fried Chicken
ls
Opera and the Moscow State Circus in the same part of the wodd thathostS the Rugby Sev-
much more satisfactory result. I find it easy to go along with the
creation of Water Wodd, although I'm impressed with parts of Ocean Park. I am not filled with wonder at the presence of the Hard Rock Cafe, Planet
BEAT THE HEAT WITH A STJMMER RETREAT
fill me with wonder is, I suppose, an assignment of unreasonable expectation. To
Off to the races
n Mr D Mrs n Miss n Ms n HK ID / Passport No.o
Correspondence Address
FlatÆloor/Block/Building
Jockey Club. The facility has a seating capaci|y of 16, with each seat available at a charge of only
District
$30 per person. Due to limited seaLing, members should make reseryations as eady as possible. The first race meeting of the season is September 10. Reservations canbe made
Area
!
("Delete if not appropriate)
I
The club has renegotiated the use of a loge at the Shatin racecourse with the Royal Hong Kong
streetl
Other (please specify)
E
Home Address
E
Business Address(tick box)
IIIII|||IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII Hong Kong
n Kowloon E New Territories (if aPPlicable)
Company Name
TelephoneNo
I I I I I I I I I FaxNo
Are you a member of the Marco Polo Club?
If
I
(e.g. Aberdeen, Tai Po)
o o
n Yes n
No
yes, what is your membership number?
through our reception staff.
The Heart of Asia.
É ø É
o (J
Great Mexican Food ú 7¡r
Fantastic Margarita's and Mexican cocktails rt
+
Party atmosphere every night .t¡
Õ
,i s€
Happy Hour 6-9 pm daily rt
+
s
Group Bookings Welcome
ñ
lFtre lMe><ican ttrerrre nigtrt produced orae I of ttre t>est tlrrn-outs for sorne tirrìe proof, if el¡er an)r' !\zere neecled, that it could be ttre ne><t cult cuisine in l-oqznArnong ttre rrrerrrt>ers ancl guests v\zas ttre 1\zle><ican Consr;l General, Agustin Gutierrez. I
Open Monday - Thursday,12 Noon
Friday:12Noon-4am Saturday:6pm-4am G/Floor, 13 Lan Kwai Fong Central
Tel :2525 6132
August
1995
THE CoRRXSPoHDDI{T
lam
Cafl Goldstein bids farewell
Russell on toad
to recovery Longtime club member Russell Spurr has suffered a stroke, but is recovering well. Former president Phlip Bowring, who saw Russell in Sydney, where he now lives, reports that he is alert, cheerf.¡l and talking about his next project. @ussell's most recent venture, a book on the govemors of Hong Kong, is to be published soon.) However, it is tikely that Russell will be in hospital for several more weeks and would welcome news of and from colleagues and friends. For anyone visiting Sydney, he is at the
Mount Wilga Rehabilitation Hospital in Hornsby. Letters and messages should be sent via Rosemary Russell, at 2A, Ballina Avenue , KillarneyHeights, NSrùØ2071. Tel: 452 1256.
Name this
man splendid turrl-otlt
in
ttre clul> to sa¡z goodbSze to forrrrer president
Cad Goldstein- Cad, vrztro
stepped dorvrzn frorrr ttre presidenc5z
He looks remarkably like Terry Duckham of ,{siapix, but obviouslY it isn't. Terry doesn't have a suit. Butif itis oldTel, then anumberof questions have to be answered. For instance : 1) Did he get the job? 2) Did he hire the suit for iust the evening or fo r 24}rours? 3)Where's his camera bag?
after a ctrange of ernplo¡zer, ttas rrrolzed to l\zlinnesota .wittr International
Strategic Adrzisers Ltd-
On the move Berton'W'oodward, assistant managing editor of Asiøueek and
a
Hong Kong resident for n early 2O y ears, has returned to his nativ e Canada,
where he will be settling in Toronto with wife Phielle and their two children. Among Berton's many farewells was a seafood dinner on Lamma,followed by an extended schnapps-and-beer session in Lan Kwai Fong, followed by an exciting golf-cart ride on the way back to his Discovery Bay home, followed by a gtazed arm arrd a sore backside, followed by a hangover and a sheepish look.
TEE CORRf,SP0I{DDNT August 1995
August
1995
Tf,E
CORRESPONIIEilT
Press R.elations CanOn lIlt.,
YeteraÍr aviator Ken Begg dies
C,qrHnv Pncrnc
Canon Hongkong Trading Co., Ltd.
Mirror Tower, 61 Mody Rd., Kowloon, Hong Kong
7/E Swire House, 9 Connaught Boad, Central, Hong Kong
Services/Products:
Manager Corporate
Canon cameras and video camcorders
Sole Distributor: J0S Consumer Electronics Address:21/F., Cornwall House, Taikoo Place, 979 King's Hd, Quany Bay, Hong Kong
Senior L
¡
lVlanager
Product l\4arketing
l\,4r
Executive
l/s
Kwan
2747 5214
NadiaStoyle
2747 5393
C.F.
Albert
Chan
2565 2008
Wong
2565 2007
Louise
lnternational
rvices/Prod ucts: Hong Kong-based international airline
Se
Hong Kong Trade Development Council
Pnovlst0NAL ArnpoRr AUtH0Rlrr HoHe Koile
Club rrrerrrl>er l(en Elegg, one of the grea;t originals of ttre flying lrzorld, has died at the age. <>f 70-
Communication
Manager Corporate Commun¡cation
Public Relations Manager Phillip Bruce 282477OO Media Relations Manager Norma Fung 28247705 28247152 Media Enquiries (24 hours) Function: Developing Hong Kong's new airport at Chek Lap Kok
SB/F
)ffice
Tower, Clnvent¡on Plaza, 1 Harbour Road, Wanchai, Hong Kong
Local lnternational
Cheung Lilburn
William
2584 4294
Nigel
25844489
Oflices in: Amsterdam, Athens, Bangkok, Barcelona, Buenos Aires, Chicago, Dallas, Dubai, Frankfurl, Guangzhou, Ho Chi Minh City, lstanbul, Jakarta, London, Los Angeles, Vìexico City, Miami, Milan, Moscow, Nagoya, New York, 0saka, Panama City, Paris, Santiago, Seoul, Shanghai, Shenzhen, Singapore, Stockholm, Sydney, Taipei, Tianjin, Tokyo, Toronto, Vancouver, Vienna, Warsaw, Zurich.
Kenneth RoJ, Begg.
f rironl ÍZ -[\
,n Bess was born in
gurrLrtown, New South'SØales, onlanuary 23, t925. At 15, he joined
the ,{ir Cadets, followed by the Air Training Corps, where at 17 he was the youngest pilot officer at the time, graduating in the top five per cent of his class. His classmates were sent to the European theatre, but, because of
his age, Ken had to bide his time. Eventually, he endedup in flight lieutenant, flying reconnaissance missions until the end of the war. New Guinea
as a
His love affair with Hong Kong started at 21,
when he was hired by
flight from Amsterdam to the Belgian
Congo. On thè tong trip out, he handed over the controls of the DC-4 to Ed, so he could take anap, telling him which dials, etc, to watch and
to wake him if anything
unusual
Congo stories. Ken was then managing director for Lloyd International Aidine, based here, and the FCC was
his favourite watering hole. He had joined the club in L957 and his number was 76. Mr Liao, then our bat managet,
used
The fwo met again in l964,when Ed was at some far-flung airfield in the
Begg is a ver-t-ry nice man, but he drinks too much." It usually spurred Ken to greater effort.
After Hong Kong, came stints in Sydney, where he ran his own travel agency, the US (Real Estate), returning to Sydney in1986 after doctors diagnosed him as having emphysema. The crip-
Cathay Pacific Airways.
pling disease finally
(His dreamwas to one day
brought on a latal heart
run his own aidine; he came close a couple of times, but neYer quite made it.) After several years, Ken moved to the
attack.
Ken's
favourite poem, Higb Fligbt, by * ,5* ¡onn Gillespie Magee Jr. 5 was read at his funeral
F service, attended bysome United States, where he of his surviving RÀF budflew for four years with Some of Ken Begg's friends at drx i?nþro,1rþtlt tttake Jor l.tittt ¿tt tlte l;Ca. dies, other pilots and non-scheduled airlines, friends. The casket was draped with Congolese army. Ken, who happened before accepting a job with Korean the RAAF flag as Ken taxied for his to be there in his DC-4, taxied at full National Aidines, mainly to be near last take-off. A small group of his Hong Kong again speed towards our intrepid camerafriends also gathered in Hong Kong One of the many tales of Ken's man, opened the door and dragged pay to tribute to a remarkable man. they managed unusual approach to life dates from him inside, after which Ken is survived by his daughter, the earþ Sixties, when he flew for a to take off, thus saving van Kan from European aidine based in London. It who knows what kind of fate. Next Kerene, and wife lrene, who supplied the information for this obit. theymet in1966, this time in the safe was then that he ran into a young and Hugh Van Es daring Dutch cameraman, Edvan Kan surroundings of the FCC, where many (later a fellow FCC member), on a a glass was hoisted amid the telling of E@ Tf,E cORRXSP0tllHlT Àugust 1995
Bm 1 902-3, Wheelock House, 20 Pedder Street, Central, Hong Kong
2/F Hutchison House, Central, Hong Kong
Poon
Director fi/ìanager
PL. 25245031 N/ìanaging Jimmy 2524 5031 Senior Servi ces/Products: Sole agent of Nikon cameras, Hasselblad cameras, Linhof cameras and
Wan
Epson LCD portable TVs
Head of Corporate
Affairs
Nick
Thompson 2844-2139
Services/Ploducts: Property investment and development in Hong Kong and Chìna; terminals and transport systems, hotels in Asia and North America; Cable Television and Telecommunications.
to tell Ken's wife, Irene: "Mr
happened.
Congo, being pursued by half of the
THE VHARF (HOLDINGS)LIMITED
Shnro (H.K.) Ltd.
For informatiori on booking an insertion, simply fax your name and contact numbers to 252L a366
Classifi-ed
futoÊe Someone
J{oppy!
1996 Atlonto OlYmPics July '19 2BA Bungolow for rent
O We send anywhere in the UK FOR
ALL OCCASIONS freshly cut naturally scented flowers. AIso chocolates
-
3DR'
Aug 4'
neor Convenienf in town neighborhood RC Driggs' venues, nighrlife' Wrile: Levels' Hong Kong 4 Kennedy Tr, 1óA Mid or Fox (852)2881 6215
and champagne with a spec¡al balloon message. Please Tell.2817 5ó98 Fax: 2817
for prices and order form.
7449
Classified advertising in
Ty'¡e
economical and easy
fax your name and
-
Corresþond.ent is
contact details to 252I-8366 for more information.
Arìgrìst
1995
THE C0Rf,.ESPOIì|IIENT
A montbly þortrøùt of FCC ircepløceøbles
John McDougall Member since:
1978.
Age:
Thoroughbred. Same birthday as all horses and horses' asses in the Southern HemisPhere. Hong Kong jackeroo. According to his friends, he is "hard on the outside but soft on the inside". A bit like a durian, in fact. Can you keep the noise down. I'm thinking. Golf this Thursday? I'm a bit busy. Oh, all right.
Profession:
Description Least likely to say
Most likely to say
Pltotograþbed by Røy Crønboutwe Kodak (Far East) Limited Sponsored by
5
i'JìË (iËF)Ê.ßR'¿\A
WUE,N YOU BUTTO FOR THE FUTURE, NTVE,N FORCP YOUR ROOTS.
Established in 1886, the Wharf Group's main business relies on long term core investment projects in Hong Kong and China. We are committed to developing property and infrastructute projects similar to the ones we have successfully completed in Hong Kong orrer the last 100 years. It is this simple philosophy of aiways remembering our roots that we tell investors all around the ltrorld.
\)øHARF Ccrntactnurnbers: 'I'hel{harf (Holdnrgs)
Ltd 27388222. \{harf Cab1c26116868. OmrriFlotelsAsiaPacific2T3Sllll