Central focus 28 32

Page 1

28

voice

Broken English Flawed testing system has done great disservice to art of literature

“W

hat is the tone of answer. Even grammar is formulaic: the author?” There commas have rules, capitalization are four options has rules, grammar has a set of underneath, each of them similar, rules that can be followed and each of them viable, three of tested. This is not the part of English them wrong. Nervously, I circle I have a problem with; I firmly one, then erase it in believe everyone should favor of another. I move know what an Oxford on tentatively, feeling comma is or how to like I’m wrong, feeling tell the difference like there should be between “there,” “their,” no way for me to even and “they’re.” It’s the be wrong on such an interpretation aspect; interpretation-based it’s having teachers Skylar Laird question. With this tell me for years that Feature editor nervous self-doubt, I I’m wrong because move through English I feel like the author class after English class, has a different tone, or always feeling like I’m missing out because I sympathize differently on something. with a character, or because I Since I was three years old, saw a symbol differently. There learning how to read “One Fish are, of course, ways for me to be Two Fish Red Fish Blue Fish,” I’ve wrong; not every analysis can been addicted to literature. As even be correct if it lacks proper I grew older, I would read every reasoning behind it, but as long book I could get my hands on. I as an interpretation makes sense, excel in English; along with my love it should be considered a valid of reading grew a love of analysis option. Literature analysis is as I dove into classics like “Little simply too subjective to be tested Women” at ages as young as 11 or standardly. 12. It seems to follow that I should This issue is already addressed love English classes, and I do, but through the use of essays and they also frustrate me to no end. class discussions, which both Our education is systematicallyallow students to form their own based: an emphasis is placed on opinions and then support them standardized testing, which is without a right or wrong answer. built to accommodate formulaic These also promote creativity and subjects, such as math and science deeper analysis than multiple - anything that can have a set choice questions, letting students

think up their own analysis and delve into it instead of simply doing a process of elimination or being forced to choose one singular option out of a list that has already been created for them. However, as long as a multiple choice section is still used in big tests like the AP exam and ACT, and as long as teachers are still using it in class as a tool to judge students’ analyses, there remains a problem. Literature should be treated as the art it is; analysis should be judged based on essays while grammar remains multiple choice. There is an obvious reason for the current system: essays are much more subjective and difficult to grade than multiple choice, which can merely be fed into a computer and have a score spit out. Essays may be more effort for both parties, but this is what literature deserves: stories are written for the purpose of in-depth analysis, not shallow and debatable questions about tone and metaphors. I have read too many fantastic works that I have been forced to change my thoughts about in order to fit the questions and answers I’m given, and I am honestly sick of it. I feel as though we as an education system could do so much more for the English program and the students who adore it without the inclusion of standardized testing. While math and science thrive

under this system, English is stifled by it; this has then allowed the teaching of maths and sciences to continue to develop while English classes feel stagnant and overdone: instead of continually learning new concepts, we are force fed the same ideas for years upon years with little variation or variety to make it exciting. I want deeper analysis, not the same statements about metaphors and similes that I have been dealing with since the second grade. I am a student who excels in little other than English, so to be provided with the same opportunities as math or scienceoriented kids would be a dream come true. And this can not be done until English is recognized more as an art form and less as a tedious task. Right now, it’s seen as just another core class or another portion of the ACT, while in reality, it should bear more similarities to the music or art programs. English is a non-standard class shoved into a standardized system, and that can make even someone as passionate about it as me hate it. And this can not be remedied until English is no longer tested through multiple choice questions. I will not stop being infuriated by English classes until I can look at a question asking me about a novel and worry more about the analysis itself than whether my answer is right or wrong.


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.