8 minute read
Dept. of Labor Proposes New Rule on Employee Classification
By Michael E. Catania
Misclassification of employees as Independent Contractors (IC’s) has long troubled the construction industry, resulting in government audits and expensive litigation.
+At the Federal level, the U.S. Department of Labor’s (DOL) existing rules are seen as favoring employee versus IC classification. The DOL has proposed a new rule dealing with classifications under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) to change this, revising its interpretation of an IC so as to “promote certainty for stakeholders, reduce litigation, and encourage innovation in the economy.”
Under the FLSA, employers must pay nonexempt employees federal minimum wage and overtime. These requirements do not apply to “independent contractors.” Unfortunately, the Act does not define the term “independent contractor.” Instead, the DOL previously established a multifactor test to be used for such determinations. The test centered upon the concept of “economic dependence.” Workers whose income was generated solely from a particular employer would typically be classified as that employer’s employee, and not an IC, under the FLSA.
The DOL has determined that this test lacks “focus and has not always been sufficiently explained by courts or the Department.” It has proposed a new test, one it claims has a “more employer friendly approach” and shifts the focus from “economic dependence” to “economic reality.” It has 5 factors. The first 2 are defined as “core factors,” each of which will be given far more weight than the others. If adopted, this new test would be the DOL’s “sole and authoritative interpretation” of classification under the FLSA. The factors are: • The nature/degree of the worker’s control over the work;
The worker’s opportunity for profit/loss based on initiative or investment;
The amount of skill required for the work;
The degree of permanence of the working relationship; and
Whether the work is part of an integrated unit of production.
Will this help the employer?
Is this proposed rule a “more employer friendly approach?” That remains to be seen. However, the introduction of the 2 “core” factors does give some needed clarity to the analysis and could lead to fewer misclassifications. Regardless, the rule would apply to classifications under the FLSA only. New York laws, such as the Construction Industry Fair Play Act, will not be impacted. NY construction workers will continue to be classified as employees unless they meet Fair Play Act’s strict 3-part test, i.e., that they are 1) free from the employer’s control/direction; 2) perform work that is not part of the usual work performed by the Employer and 3), are an independently established business.
Michael Catania is a Managing Partner with Catania, Mahon & Rider, PLLC and head of the Construction Practice Group. mcatania@cmmrlegal.com
Update on OSHA Reporting For COVID-19 Cases
Employers generally have 24 hours to report work related incidents that result in hospital admissions. With COVID-19 cases, OSHA measured the 24-hours from when the employee was confirmed to have contracted Covid-19. This led to some confusion and OSHA recently updated its regulations to give further guidance. The new regulations address questions such as: Q: If an employee is exposed to Covid-19 on a Monday, but is not admitted to the hospital until a week later, dose the employer still have to report?
A. No. Per 29 CFR 1904.39(b)(6), employers only have to report Covid-19 hospitalizations that occur within 24 hours from the work-related exposure.
Q: If an employee contracts Covid-19 within the 24-hour time frame, how long does the Employer have to report it?
A. 24 hours from when it becomes aware of the employee’s in-patient hospitalization (assuming it is due to a work-related COVID-19 exposure).
The above applies to reporting only and does not change an employer’s OSHA obligations as to recording work-related COVID-19 cases per 29 CFR 1904.4(a).
EST. 1977
LaFarge North America Kartrite Indoor Water Park Butter Hill Water System Ravena, NY Monticello, NY New Windsor, NY
General Construction ● Design Build Concrete Contractors ● Tilt-Up Construction Clean Room Installations
Commercial ● Industrial ● Institutional Health Care ● Municipal
Watchtower World Headquarters Washington Lake Filtration Plant New Paltz Middle School Warwick, NY Newburgh, NY New Paltz, NY
www.darlindassociates.com
1540 Route 55 PO Box 10 LaGrangeville, NY 12540 Phone: (845) 223-5115 Fax: (845) 223-3721
Locals Lend a Hand
By Barry Lewis, Vice President of Communications for CCA
Laborers Provide Warmth and Comfort to Newburgh Families
Laborers’ Local 17 believes that every child deserves the warmth of cozy pajamas and a fresh pillow. Working under the Laborers’ International Union of North America’s (LIUNA) Feel the Care community outreach initiative, they made sure parents in Newburgh were able to provide these comforts for their children. On Nov. 17 Laborers’ Local 17 staff handed out more than 350 pairs of pajamas and 400 pillows to parents who drove up to the Newburgh Armory Unity Center.
Carpenters Local 279 Provide Shelter for Veterans
More than 25 members of the Carpenters Local 279 participated this summer in a volunteer project led by Spearhead Construction, a veteran and woman owned business, to build a pavilion for veterans at American Legion Post 151 in Orange County. The 20’ x 40’ pavilion offers veterans a safe place to meet with plenty of open space to practice social distancing. A number of union carpenters who volunteered are military veterans themselves. The United Brotherhood of Carpenters is a founding member of Helmets to Hardhats, a national program that links separating military service members with training and careers in the building trades. The project took three weekends to complete. Laborers Local 17 donated a Lull and one volunteer from IBEW 363 brought wired lights and fans along with outlets. Materials for the pavilion was donated by Home Depot.
JOIN THE CCA!
For over 60 years the Construction Contractors Association of the Hudson Valley has had a hand in almost every significant construction project across the region. With its strategy of providing quality management coupled with outstanding workmanship by highly skilled local labor, CCA is the right choice to get the job done right, on time and within budget.
Membership to the CCA includes:
Promote your business or company on all CCA social media platforms Contact list of professional contractors, suppliers and service providers Direct networking with our members at golf outings, lobster bake and holiday gathering Availability of PPE supplies
Members can take advantage of our health insurance plans that offer:
Multiple plans to choose from Favorable premium rates not available in the open market Highly rated national insurance companies Extensive lists of preferred providers
