VIPASSANA

Page 1

NEW WEBSITE: www.ephesians-511.net

V I P A S S A N A T I O N

SEPTEMBER 2004, UPDATED AUGUST 2009

M E D I T A

CAN VIPASANA BECOME A SUBSTITUTE FOR PRAYER?*

is the caption given by The New Leader [NL] of February 1-15, 2004 to a Letter to the Editor from a Rev. Sr. Philippa. The same letter captioned ‘VIPASSANA AND PRAYER’ was simultaneously published in The Examiner [TE] of January 24, 2004. The letter underlines some facts, and raises some questions, the chief of which is “CAN VIPASANA BE CALLED PRAYER AT ALL?” asked by Sr. Philippa herself. She admits that “more and more people, including priests and nuns, are participating in (Buddhist) Vipasyana meditation.” [Vipasyana or Vipashyana is the Sanskrit term]. Though the letter seems to not conclusively support vipassana meditation at one point, and in fact raises questions as to its suitability as a form of Christian prayer, the nun does not definitively reject the possibility of some benefit in it, especially in [her recommendation of] a combination of Vipassana with certain other suspect meditations [which will be dealt with in a subsequent write-up], and has left many readers confused on her final message. “I am not averse to the idea of practising Vipasana. Let us freely use the techniques of Vipasna in order to collect together our wandering thoughts and wayward imaginations and focus us on the in-dwelling Spirit,” she says. This, after substantial Christian arguments and a question “Can Vipasna be in any way called ‘Christian prayer’?” Christ, of course, is never mentioned in the meditations.” Thoroughly confused herself, she winds up: “I write, perhaps, as one less wise. I’m sure others could add, or subtract from my views, for further enlightenment.” This writer resisted the temptation to respond with a ‘Letter to the Editor’ in the hope that some enlightened Catholic reader would set the record straight. No one did. Or at least, no response, if there was any, was published. Expressing the correct Catholic position on several important current issues for the benefit of readers, this writer has, over the last eight months, sent to the editors of both magazines a number of letters, most of which have been consigned to the trash bin, while a bit of real trash finds its way into the magazines [see my recent write-up of New Age and other errors that I found in the issues of The Examiner and The New leader over a six-month period]. Both publications of the nun’s letter were not properly edited, sporting errors in spelling the meditation technique variously as Vipasana and Vipasna. [It is also often misspelled as Vippasana]. This despite the news briefs or advertisements that they regularly carry:

*A week-long ‘Centering Prayer (Vipassana Retreat)’ directed by Jesuit priest Fr. Joe Pithekar at Vinayalaya

Retreat House [Bombay Archdiocese] is announced in the October 11, 2003 issue of The Examiner under News- Local. Such courses that came to my notice earlier were in TE of Oct. 16, 1999 (under “Diocesan News”) and April 15, 2000. Also, the NL of January 1-15, 2002. *The NL of December 1-31, 1999 carried an advertisement by the Society of the Divine Word Fathers [SVD Congregation] for retreats in Vipassana meditation, Enneagrams and Dream Therapy at the Atma Darshan Centre for Spirituality and Counselling, Archdiocese of Bombay. They advertised for the same in TE of December 11, 1999 adding on ‘Yoga and Meditation for healing and Godexperience’. *The NL of December 1-31, 2003 carries a full page advertisement by the National Vocation Service Centre [NVSC], Diocese of Pune for a one-year diploma programme in pastoral counselling and religious formation that groups subjects like Christology and Biblical Spirituality with Vipassana to be taught by the Pune Vipassana Samithi. The same centre advertised in that issue for M.A in Psychology again with Vipassana as a subject. The instructors of the other courses at NVSC are over 15 nuns and priests with qualifications in Clinical and Holistic Psychology [see separate article], and Archbishop Oswald Gracias [now a Cardinal]. Apparently these nuns, priests and the Cardinal see no difficulty with the inclusion of Vipassana in the syllabus.


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.