The
Collegian Multimedia Photo editor Matt Weir preps for the WAC tourney, Online
Fresno State | Serving the campus since 1922
Sports The women’s lacrosse team falls in their season opener, Page 7 March 12, 2010 | Friday
collegian.csufresno.edu
Faculty underreport cheating
Senate approves replacement
By Mike Boylan The Collegian
By Thaddeus Miller The Collegian Fresno State instructors underreport incidents of cheating and plagiarism, according to university officials. Fresno State’s policy on cheating and plagiarism calls for instructors to report all incidents of cheating or plagiarism to
the office of the vice president for student affairs and the dean of students. During the 2007-2008 academic year, the university recorded 59 reports, compared to 162 during the 2008-2009 academic year. Joyce Ester, the assistant vice president for judicial affairs and division See CHEATING, Page 6 Photo Illustration by Michael Uribes / The Collegian
Athletes must self-report cheating By Thaddeus Miller The Collegian Athletes caught cheating or plagiarizing do not often receive a heavy sentence for first-time of fenses; repeat offenses, however, receive less leniency, according to university officials. The various punishments are academic sanctions, ranging from receiving an F on one assignment to expulsion from school. First-time offenders, almost exclusively, are assigned F’s for their misconduct. Students can appeal and take their case to an academic hearing. Joyce Ester, the assistant vice president for judicial af fairs and division planning, said “99 percent” of the instructor’s reports of cheating or plagiarism that make it to her office are for first-time offenses. Ester said no student under her tenure, two and a half years, has been expelled from Fresno State. “Students have been suspended, which means that they have to stop out for a semester or more,” Ester said. The rules around cheating
and plagiarism apply to every student across the board, Ester said. Students’ extra curricular activities are not directly affected from a firsttime offense. For example, a student-athlete caught cheating for the first time would receive the same academic sanctions as another student. However, the student-athlete’s playing and practice times would not be affected in anyway. The student-athlete’s coach is not infor med after a first-time infraction. “The cheating and plagiarism for ms [from instructors] come to me,” Ester said. “Therefore, the only way the athletic department would know about it is if the student told [the athletic department].” Ester said student-athletes caught cheating often inform their coaches. “I think that they’d probably rather their coaches hear bad news from them than somebody else,” Ester said. “But I don’t know that for sure.” Susan Gutkind, the assistant athletics director for studentathlete services, said she may
never know that a student cheated if the student doesn’t report it to her. All reports of cheating and plagiarism are confidential under the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act (FERPA). Gutkind said her first priority is to support the university and academic integrity. Student-athlete services teaches good study skills, time management and pride in one’s work, she said, in an effort to keep students from cheating because they backed themselves into a corner and “panicked.” “We try to do all those proactive things,” Gutkind said. Gutkind said student-athlete services could become included in the appeals process if infor med of the report of cheating or plagiarism by the student-athlete or professor involved. There is not a finite list of what will happen to studentathletes who admit that they cheated, according to Gutkind. They are handled on a case-bycase basis. Gutkind said when a studentathlete admits to cheating they take the consequence that the
professor gives them. “In that moment, they are acting as students on campus” Gutkind said. “They fall under the campus code of conduct. We help to enforce the campus code of conduct.” Gutkind said, in such a case, she would inform the studentathlete and his or her coach that such behavior is unacceptable. However, a first-time infraction rarely affects a student’s practice or playing time. Gutkind said student-athletes are in the same developmental stage as the other students on campus. So, studentathletes don’t deserve any harsher punishment, such as lost playing time, than the student sitting next to them. “Our 18-year-olds are the same 18-year-olds that are on campus,” Gutkind said. “They’re 18.” Gutkind said first-time offenses are handled from a developmental standpoint, and need to learn that actions have consequences. The studentathlete is expected to figure out what went wrong and how See ATHLETES, Page 6
At Wednesday’s Associated Students, Inc (ASI) meeting there were new and missing faces. The senate affir med Vice President Alex Andreotti’s recommendation of Patrick Simon to be the new senator for the school of social sciences, replacing Jamie San Andres who recently resigned her post. An official statement from ASI president Jessica Sweeten cited scheduling conflicts as the reason for San Andres’ resignation. San Andres was unavailable for comment. Simon is a political science major and an employee at the Henry Madden Library. In the meeting he expressed eagerness to step in and represent his school. Simon said he hopes to increase graduation rates, work with the dean to promote multicultural education and take part in community service as well. “I wanted to join the student senate because this year, I’ve had tremendous drive to become more involved on this campus to make a difference,” Simon said in an e-mail interview. “I am also involved and hold two positions in the brand new frater nity, Phi Delta Theta.” According to ASI bylaws, the vice president has two weeks to appoint senate replacements, and it is then presented to the senate to cast a vote. The motion to appoint Simon was passed and he was immediately placed on the senate with full senate privileges. Only attending briefly as a visitor was Sen. Cesar Sanchez, who was notified 90 minutes before the meeting that he was officially ruled ineligible through a memo he received from Andreotti. The reason was he had too many units. The ASI bylaws states in Article 1V section 1.2 that members must “satisfy the eligibility and qualification requirements established by the Chancellor of the [California State University].” This refers to California State Student Association (CSSA) student gover nment rules, which state: “undergraduates are allowed to earn a maximum of 150 semester units or 125 percent of the units required for a specific baccaSee ASI, Page 6