collegian.csufresno.edu
Monday, May 7, 2018
VICTOR E. STAGE TO BE REVEALED PAGE 6
Fresno State’s Award-Winning Newspaper
FORUMS
Castro takes heat for Jarrar tweets Some say ‘the world is watching.’
Ramuel Reyes • The Collegian
Fresno State President Joseph Castro listens to an audience member during a community forum about the recent Fresno State Twitter controversy by English professor Randa Jarrar. The forum was held in the Save Mart Center on May 3, 2018.
By Cresencio Rodriguez-Delgado @cres_guez
T
hey came one by one. Fresno State students, faculty, staff, alumni, community members and parents lined up to finally face President Dr. Joseph Castro about an online controversy that, two weeks in, was still fresh in their minds. In the span of two forums held last week there were tears, fear, obscene language, cries for tougher discipline and many, many questions. But final answers, it appeared, were in short supply. It was the first time Castro met face-toface with campus and community members after the chaos brought on by English professor Randa Jarrar, who tweeted inflammatory messages about former U.S. First Lady Barbara Bush after she died on April 17. Jarrar called Bush a “racist” who “raised a war criminal” along with other messages against the Bush family, which angered people on and offline. Those words on social media spurred national headlines and public calls for donors to drop their support of the university. Nearly three weeks in, the outrage has not appeared to have ended. Despite some heated comments hurled at the university and insults tossed at Castro in the span of more than two weeks, the first group Castro met with showed a calmer response to the events that had transpired in the days following Jarrar’s comments. As he spoke to more than 500 students, staff and faculty at a forum held on campus last Wednesday, Castro said the university had gotten “tens of thousands” of calls about the polemic tweets.
Ramuel Reyes • The Collegian
Keith Freitas calls Fresno State President a “pompous ass” regarding his actions towards English professor Randa Jarrar during a community forum held at the Save Mart Center on May 3, 2018.
Amy Luna, manager for emergency operations and business continuity, said police are investigating an email that was sent to the university regarding Jarrar. University police reported that incident as a “criminal threat.” Students, staff and faculty lined up to share their thoughts on precisely that backlash. From students fearing that the value in their degrees would lessen with employers, to faculty asking that the campus community remain resilient in the face of mounting pressure and threats, Castro assured all that he was listening. Up to that point, it appeared Castro’s handling of the situation had earned him more praise than judgement by the cam-
pus audience. On the same Wednesday, the Fresno State College Republicans organized a peaceful vigil for Bush in the Free Speech Area. Castro faced a much different, angrier group during an evening forum the following day. More than 250 Fresno area residents turned out for a two-hour public forum held at the Save Mart Center. The frustration was obvious among those who spoke out. By the end of the night, those who attended got a clearer picture of the toll that Jarrar’s comments had on the university. A woman, who identified herself as a wife of a farmer and Fresno State alum, told Castro that her family had provided
“thousands and thousands” of dollars in athletic scholarships but the support would likely end there. “We also have to put our heart and soul with our purses, our pocket books, our wallets and we can’t spend money where our values don’t align,” she told Castro. Castro responded to her. “I was offended as well, I’m the first Valley native to be president here, so I felt the some way. I get it,” he told the woman. “But are we going to let her determine whether we support the next generation of leaders?” There was also a tense moment when a man hurled obscenities at Castro, calling him a “pompous ass” and said it was “bull****” that the university could not fire or sue Jarrar. That man, who said he is a farmer, accused Castro of making excuses for Jarrar’s actions and defied requests to wrap up his public comments. He was removed from the arena floor by Fresno State police after a short confrontation with a student. There was concern among other parents who spoke that their children’s education at the university would be affected if the university kept Jarrar. Parents demanded that Castro fire her. “What you’re asking me to do is break the law,” Castro responded to one man with that demand. That same man later retreated and told Castro he understood Castro’s inability to impose further penalties on Jarrar. But the sentiment to have Jarrar removed didn’t go away. In contrast to calls to further penalize Jarrar, one man who took the microphone said that, if fired, Jarrar would have legal grounds to sue Fresno State. Some agreed that those events would only benefit Jarrar.
See FORUMS, Page 3