SwissSkiGB09_D

?V]gZhWZg^X]i '%%-$%.

HedchdgZchigj`ijg VW &# BV^ '%%.

>C=6AIHK:GO:>8=C>H

%(

>c]VaihkZgoZ^X]c^h EGtH>9>JB

%)

<:H8=t;IHA:>IJC<

%-

A:>HIJC<HHEDGI

&'

à 6ae^c

&'

à CdgY^hX]

&-

à HcdlWdVgY

''

à ;gZZhinaZ

')

à IZaZbVg`

'+

6JH7>A9JC<

'-

7G:>I:CHEDGI

(%

;>C6COL:H:C

()

>begZhhjb =ZgVjh\ZWZg <ZhiVaijc\ jcY EgZEgZhh 7^aYZg I^iZaW^aY

Hl^hh"H`^ ;gj^iXV`Z LZgWjc\ EgZhhZ 6< lll#[gj^iXV`Z#X] Hl^hh"H`^ dYZg kZgbZg`iZ 7Zoj\hfjZaaZc 9Vg^d 8dad\cV b^i YZg \gdhhZc @g^hiVaa`j\Za [ g YZc LZaiXje"<ZhVbih^Z\ ^c YZg 9^ho^ea^c AVc\aVj[# ;did/ CdgY^X ;dXjh 9gjX` :c\ZaWZg\Zg 9gjX` 6<! HiVch 6j[aV\Z &+%% Y $ )*% [ :ghX]Z^cjc\ Bjg^ WZ^ 7Zgc! ?jc^ '%%.

EGtH>9>JB

%)

Hl^hh"H`^ Ã Z^c KZgWVcY Vj[ :g[da\h`jgh :^cbVa bZ]g `Vcc Hl^hh"H`^ Vj[ Z^cZ ~jhhZghi Zg[da\gZ^X]Z hedgia^X]Z HV^hdc ojg X`Wa^X`Zc# 9Vh cZjZ Eg~h^Y^jb jciZg YZg AZ^ijc\ hZ^cZh Eg~h^YZciZc Jgh AZ]bVcc `Vcc ZWZc[Vaah oj[g^ZYZc 7^aVco o^Z]Zc/ Hl^hh"H`^ ^hi VjX] ^c higViZ\^hX]Zg =^ch^X]i Vj[ @jgh# 9^Z Egd[Zhh^dcVa^h^Zgjc\ ^c VaaZc 7ZgZ^X]Zc hX]gZ^iZi \ji kdgVc! ^chWZhdcYZgZ WZ^ YZg :cil^X`ajc\ YZg Va" e^cZc CVi^dcVaZc jcY GZ\^dcVaZc AZ^hijc\hoZcigZc CAO jcY GAO# 9Vc` YZb 7Z^ig^ii ojb :jgde~^hX]Zc H`^kZgWVcY :#H#;# ]Vi Hl^hh"H`^ VjX] Vj[ ^ciZgcVi^dcVaZg :WZcZ bZ]g <Zl^X]i# JcY c^X]i ojaZioi lZ^hi Hl^hh"H`^ YVc` Z^cZg \jiZc jcY `dc" hZfjZciZc @dhiZc`dcigdaaZ VjX] [^cVco^Zaa Z^cZ \ZhjcYZ 7Vh^h Vj[ jcY `Vcc b^i Z^cZb :gigV\h WZghX]jhh kdc WZg 8=; +%% %%% VWhX]a^ZhhZc#

:g[da\gZ^X]Z hedgia^X]Z HV^hdc 9^Z kZg\Vc\ZcZ HV^hdc lVg Z^cZ YZg Zg[da\gZ^X]hiZc ^c YZg <ZhX]^X]iZ kdc Hl^hh"H`^/ CdX] c^Z ljgYZc ^c YZg &%*"_~]g^" \Zc KZgWVcYh\ZhX]^X]iZ YZgVgi k^ZaZ EdYZhiea~ioZ Zgo^Zai à &%( Vc YZg OV]a 9^Z ]ZgVjhgV\ZcYhiZ AZ^hijc\ ^c Y^ZhZb L^ciZg ZgWgVX]iZ 9Vg^d 8dad\cV/ :g \ZlVcc c^X]i cjg Y^Z Idjg YZ H`^! hdcYZgc `g ciZ hZ^cZc `dbZiZc]V[iZc 6j[hi^Z\ Vc Y^Z LZaihe^ioZ b^i YZb <Zl^cc YZh <ZhVbilZaiXjeh# 9Vb^i hdg\iZ YZg '("_~]" g^\Z 7 cYcZg Vjh YZb KVa B hiV^g [ g YZc \g hhiZc :g[da\ ^b HX]lZ^oZg AVc\aVj[hedgi jcY hX]g^ZW HX]lZ^oZg Hedgi\ZhX]^X]iZ# >b IZaZbVg` \^c\ Y^Z \gdhhZ @g^hiVaa`j\Za b^i 6b a^Z GZnbdcY ZWZc[Vaah Vc Z^cZ Hl^hh"H`^ 6i]aZi^c0 ^c hdjkZg~cZg BVc^Zg \Z" lVcc Y^Z ''"_~]g^\Z :I="HijYZci^c ojYZb VjX] Y^Z Wg^\Zc YgZ^ 9^ho^ea^cZclZaiXjeh#

:^c\Zhe^ZaiZh Eg~h^Y^jb 9Vh Eg~h^Y^jb b^i Jgh AZ]bVcc Vc YZg He^ioZ ]Vi h^X] \ji Z^c\Zhe^Zai0 Y^Z OjhVbbZcVgWZ^i ^hi `dchigj`i^k jcY o^Zadg^" Zci^Zgi# 9^Z 6j[\VWZcWZgZ^X]Z h^cY `aVg kZgiZ^ai jcY Y^Z cZjZc Eg~h^Y^jbhb^i\a^ZYZg ]VWZc h^X] VaaZ gVhX] ^c Y^Z kZghX]^ZYZ" cZc I]ZbZc jcY 9dhh^Zgh Z^c\ZVgWZ^iZi/ Jgh L^c`aZg 7 cYcZg H`^kZgWVcY 7HK jcY :ad^ Gdhh^Zg H`^ LVaa^h h^cY hZ^iZch Eg~h^Y^jb ojhi~cY^\ [ g YVh GZhhdgi AZ^hijc\hhedgi# ?ZVc"E]^a^eeZ GdX]Vi H`^ GdbVcY jcY E^gb^c OjgWg^\\Zc Eg~h^YZci H`^ LVaa^h oZ^X]" cZc h^X] [ g YVh GZhhdgi BVg`Zi^c\ kZgVcildgia^X]# Gd\Zg ;Z]g Eg~h^YZci YZh DhihX]lZ^oZg H`^kZgWVcYZh DHHK jciZga^Z\Zc Y^Z ;^cVcoZc jcY Y^Z 6Yb^c^higVi^dc# ; g Y^Z Hedgi HjW`dbb^hh^dc CAO oZ^X]cZc E^gb^c OjgWg^\\Zc! Jgh L^c`aZg! :ad^ Gdhh^Zg jcY ?d]cn Lnhhb aaZg Eg~h^YZci YZh 7ZgcZg DWZga~cY^hX]Zc H`^kZgWVcYZh 7DHK \ZbZ^chVb kZgVcildgia^X]# AZioiZgZg WZgcV]b ojYZb YVh cZjZ GZhhdgi 7gZ^iZchedgi jcY igZ^Wi Y^Z :cil^X`ajc\ ^c Y^ZhZb l^X]i^\Zc 7ZgZ^X] kdgVc#

HigViZ\^ZjbhZiojc\ Vj[ @jgh JcW~cY^\Z ;gZjYZ WZ^ 9Vg^d 8dad\cV cVX] YZb hZchVi^dcZaaZc H^Z\ Vc YZg Idjg YZ H`^# ;did/ CdgY^X ;dXjh

9^Z zWZgeg [jc\ YZg HigViZ\^Z ]Vi Zg\ZWZc! YVhh Hl^hh"H`^ ^c egV`" i^hX] VaaZc 7ZgZ^X]Zc Vj[ @jgh ^hi# >chWZhdcYZgZ Y^Z :cil^X`ajc\ YZg CVi^dcVaZc jcY GZ\^dcVaZc AZ^hijc\hoZcigZc CAO jcY GAO H`^

%*

<ji Z^c\Zhe^ZaiZh IZVb/ 9Vh Eg~h^Y^jb kdc Hl^hh"H`^# Kdc a^c`h/ E^gb^c OjgWg^\\Zc H`^ LVaa^h ! Jgh L^c`aZg 7ย cYcZg H`^kZgWVcY 7HK ! Gd\Zg ;Z]g DhihX]lZ^oZg H`^kZgWVcY DHHK ! Jgh AZ]bVcc Oย gX]Zg H`^kZgWVcY OHK ! :ad^ Gdhh^Zg H`^ LVaa^h ! ?d]cn Lnhhbย aaZg 7ZgcZg DWZga~cY^hX]Zg H`^kZgWVcY 7DHK jcY ?ZVc"E]^a^eeZ GdX]Vi H`^ GdbVcY # ;did/ Hl^hh"H`^

6ae^c hX]gZ^iZi \ji kdgVc# Hd ]Vi Hl^hh"H`^ ^b H^ccZ Z^cZg kZgZ^c" ]Z^ia^X]iZc Kdg\Z]ZchlZ^hZ Z^c AVWZahnhiZb Z^c\Z[ย ]gi! lZaX]Zh ojb O^Za ]Vi! FjVa^i~ihhiVcYVgYh [ZhiojaZ\Zc# 9^Z AVWZah Yd`jbZc" i^ZgZc `aVg! YVhh YVh Vjh\ZoZ^X]cZiZ OZcigjb! hZ^ Zh Z^c CAO dYZg GAO! Y^Z kdg\Z\ZWZcZc @g^iZg^Zc Zg[ย aai jcY hdb^i YZc kdc Hl^hh"H`^ \Z[dgYZgiZc FjVa^i~ihVchegย X]Zc Zciheg^X]i# 9^Z @g^iZg^Zc h^cY Vj[ YVh Hl^hh"H`^"CVX]ljX]h`dcoZei H`^ 6ae^c VW\Zhiย ioi jcY \gZ^[Zc kdc YZg 8ajWVgWZ^i ย WZg Y^Z GZ\^dcVakZgW~cYZ! Y^Z CAO jcY YZc GAO oj YZc \Z[ย ]giZc cVi^dcVaZc @VYZgc ^cZ^cVcYZg ย WZg# 9^Z 6j[aV\Zc WZigZ[[ZcY IgV^c^c\hfjVa^i~i! 6jhW^aYjc\ YZg IgV^cZg hdl^Z Y^Z de" i^bVaZ hX]ja^hX]Z Aย hjc\ h^cY WZljhhi ]dX]#

AVWZakZg\VWZ CAO AVc\aVj[ Vc 9Vkdh 9^Z 6j[lZgijc\ YZg CAO hX]gZ^iZi lZ^iZg kdgVc# Hd ]Vi Hl^hh" H`^ Vca~hha^X] YZh AVc\aVj["LZaiXjeh 9Vkdh CdgY^X '%%- 9Vkdh YVh AVWZa ยบCVi^dcVaZh AZ^hijc\hoZcigjb CAO AVc\aVj[ยป kZg\Z" WZc# 6jX] YZg @Vcidc hiZ]i ]^ciZg YZb CAO AVc\aVj[ ^c 9Vkdh/ 9^Z GZ\^Zgjc\ YZh @Vcidch <gVjWย cYZc jciZghiย ioi YVh CAO AVc\aVj[ 9Vkdh l~]gZcY YZg c~X]hiZc k^Zg ?V]gZ b^i 8=; &%% %%% _~]ga^X]#

JbhZiojc\ ^c YZc GAO hX]gZ^iZi ZWZc[Vaah kdgVc <Zb~hh HigViZ\^Z lZgYZc b^iiZa[g^hi^\ &* W^h '% GAO H`^ 6ae^c Vc\ZhigZWi! Y^Z Hl^hh"H`^ ^c Oj`jc[i YZc :g[da\ h^X]Zgc hda" aZc# 9ZgZc JbhZiojc\ ^hi ZWZc[Vaah Vj[ \jiZb LZ\Z/ @dc`gZi kZg[ย \i Hl^hh"H`^ ย WZg olZ^ YZ[^c^i^kZ GAO GAO H`^ 6ae^c HHL ;ajbhZgWZg\"=Z^Y^aVcY jcY GAO H`^ 6ae^c HK@"H`^IZVb IVaZci`aVhhZ HX]lno hdl^Z k^Zg egdk^hdg^hX]Z GAO GAO H`^ 6ae^c DHHK DWZgid\\ZcWjg\! GAO H`^ 6ae^c OHHK 7Z\VWiZc[ย gYZgjc\ =Zg\^hl^a! GAO H`^ 6ae^c OHHK HX]ย e[]Z^b jcY GAO H`^ 6ae^c 7DHK <hiVVY # 9Vh GAO ยบ6ccd oZgd IZcZgdยป l^gY ZWZc[Vaah ^c @ย goZ ^c YZc egdk^hdg^hX]Zc AVWZahiVijh GAO H`^ 6ae^c ;HH> IZcZgd ย WZg[ย ]gi# <gjcYh~ioa^X] ^hi Y^Z :cil^X`ajc\ YZg AVWZakZg\VWZ edh^i^k# Jb YVh O^Za b^iiZa" jcY a~c\Zg[g^hi^\ oj ZggZ^X]Zc! bย hhZc WZ^ YZc @g^iZg^Zc [ย g Y^Z AVWZakZg\VWZ _ZYdX] \Zl^hhZ 6ceVhhjc\Zc \ZbVX]i lZgYZc# L^X]i^\hiZg EVgicZg YZg GAO ^hi cVX] l^Z kdg Y^Z HX]jaZ/ :cihegZX]ZcYZ 6ceVhhjc\Zc ^c YZg HX]jaZ Zgbย \a^X]Zc ;gZ^g~jbZ [ย g IgV^c^c\! LZii`Vbe[ jcY :g]dajc\! d]cZ YVhh Y^Z hX]ja^hX]Z O^ZaZggZ^X]jc\ kZg" cVX]a~hh^\i l^gY#

EGtH>9>JB

%+

>ciZ\gVi^dc YZh Hl^hh"H`^ Eddah

Edh^i^kZg ?V]gZhVWhX]ajhh

9Zg <ZhX]~[ihh^io YZh Hl^hh"H`^ Eddah ljgYZ eZg &# ?jc^ '%%. kdc Hi# <VaaZc cVX] Bjg^ kZgaZ\i# 6c Y^ZhZg HiZaaZ YVc`i Hl^hh"H`^ YZb H`^ Edda"Eg~h^YZciZc <j^Yd B~ioaZg hdl^Z hZ^cZb 9^gZ`idg EZiZg =j\ [ g Y^Z aVc\_~]g^\Z jcY \jiZ OjhVbbZcVgWZ^i jcY JciZghi iojc\# Igdio l^gihX]V[ia^X] hX]l^Zg^\Zc OZ^iZc jciZg" hi ioi Y^Z >cYjhig^Z Y^Z 6i]aZi^ccZc jcY 6i]aZiZc kdc Hl^hh"H`^ bVhh\ZWa^X] jcY aZ^hiZi hd Z^cZc l^X]i^\Zc 7Z^igV\ [ g Y^Z Zgo^Za" iZc :g[da\Z# 9^Z 6jhg hiZg YZh Hl^hh"H`^ Eddah h^cY Z^cZ WZgVjh l^X]i^\Z Hi ioZ [ g jchZg Ijc# 6jX] ^]cZc \ZW ]gi Z^c \gdhhZg 9Vc`#

6jX] ^c [^cVco^ZaaZg =^ch^X]i `Vcc Hl^hh"H`^ Vj[ Z^c Zg[da\gZ^" X]Zh ?V]g ojg X`Wa^X`Zc# 9Vh <ZhVbiWjY\Zi `dcciZ igdio Z^c" oZacZg zWZghX]gZ^ijc\Zc Z^c\Z]VaiZc lZgYZc jcY lZ^hi Z^cZc :gigV\h WZghX]jhh kdc 8=; +(* -&% Vjh à Y^Zh c^X]i ojaZioi YVc` c^X]i Vjh\ZhX] e[iZg 7jY\Zih hdl^Z c^X]i WjY\Zi^ZgiZg HedchdgZc"! < ccZg" jcY Hi^[ijc\hWZ^ig~\Zc! [ g Y^Z Vc Y^ZhZg HiZaaZ ]Zgoa^X] \ZYVc`i l^gY# 9Vc` YZg hedgia^X]Zc :g[da\Z ]V" WZc Y^Z KZgWVcYhhedchdgZc Eg~b^Zc Vjh\ZhX] iiZi! Y^Z ZWZc" [Vaah c^X]i WjY\Zi^Zgi lVgZc# C^X]i ojaZioi ]Vi VjX] YZg H`^ Edda jcZglVgiZiZ BZ]gZ^ccV]bZc ^b 7ZigV\ kdc gjcY 8=; &*% %%% \ZcZg^Zgi# 7Z^ Z^cZb JbhVio kdc gjcY 8=; (% B^d# kZg[ \i Hl^hh" H`^ b^i 8=; -.* *'- VWZg lZ^iZg]^c WZg kZg\aZ^X]hlZ^hZ lZc^\ :^\Zc`Ve^iVa# 9^Z :^\Zc`Ve^iVaWVh^h bjhh ol^c\ZcY lZ^iZg \Z" hi~g`i lZgYZc! hZaWhikZghi~cYa^X] d]cZ YVhh Y^Z :ggZ^X]jc\ YZg hedgia^X]Zc O^ZaZ YVgjciZg aZ^YZi#

7Z^ig^ii ojb :jgde~^hX]Zc H`^kZgWVcY :#H#;# Hl^hh"H`^ ]Vi hZ^cZ OjhVbbZcVgWZ^i Vj[ ^ciZgcVi^dcVaZg :WZcZ b^i YZc \gdhhZc H`^kZgW~cYZc l^Z yhiZggZ^X]! >iVa^Zc jcY ;gVc`gZ^X] kZghi~g`i jcY ^hi <g cYjc\hb^i\a^ZY YZh :jgde~^hX]Zc H`^kZgWVcYh :#H#;#! YZhhZc O^ZaZ Y^Z ; gYZgjc\ jcY KZgWZhhZgjc\ YZh He^ioZch`^hedgih ^c :jgdeV hdl^Z Y^Z HiZ^\Zgjc\ YZh >ciZgZhhZch Vb H`^hedgi ^c :jgdeV h^cY# @dc`gZi \Z]i Zh YZg :#H#;# YVgjb! Y^Z >ciZgZhhZc YZg cVi^dcVaZc KZgW~cYZ jcY VaaZg >ciZgZhhZch\gjeeZc! Vahd YZg 6i]aZi^ccZc jcY 6i]aZiZc! HedchdgZc ZiX#! Vj[ ^ciZgcVi^d" cVaZg :WZcZ WZhhZg lV]gojcZ]bZc jcY \ZbZ^chVb `dchigj`i^kZ >YZZc jcY `gZVi^kZ A hjc\Zc [ g YVh HX]cZZhedgi\ZhX]Z]Zc ^b ]^Zh^\Zc 6aeZcgVjb oj [^cYZc# 9^Z cZjZ KZgZ^c^\jc\ higZWi Y^Z JbhZiojc\ ^]gZg O^ZaZ ^c Zc\Zg 6Whi^bbjc\ jcY @ddeZgVi^dc b^i YZg ;>H Vc! ^chWZhdcYZgZ ^c ;gV\Zc ojg H^X]Zg]Z^i YZg 6i]aZi^ccZc jcY 6i]aZiZc jcY YZg Dg\Vc^hVi^dc ^ciZgcVi^dcVaZg GZccZc#

6ceVhhjc\ YZg HiVijiZc Hl^hh"H`^ 9^Z Hl^hh"H`^ HiVijiZc b hhZc Vc\ZeVhhi lZgYZc! YV Y^ZhZ ^c \Zl^hhZc Ejc`iZc YZc V`ijZaaZc <Z\ZWZc]Z^iZc c^X]i bZ]g Zci" hegZX]Zc# 6c YZg 9ZaZ\^ZgiZckZghVbbajc\ lZgYZc Y^Z dg\Vc^hVid" g^hX] jcY \ZhZioa^X] cdilZcY^\Zc tcYZgjc\Zc ojg <ZcZ]b^\jc\ eg~hZci^Zgi# >c Z^cZg olZ^iZc E]VhZ hdaaZc Y^Z HiVijiZc `dbeaZii WZgVgWZ^iZi jcY '%&& ojg 6Whi^bbjc\ \ZWgVX]i lZgYZc#

G X`ig^ii YZh 9^gZ`idgh =VchgjZY^ AV^X]! hZ^i Vc[Vc\h '%%+ 9^gZ`idg WZ^ Hl^hh"H`^! ]Vi eZg :cYZ D`idWZg '%%. \Z` cY^\i# 9Vh Z]ZbVa^\Z Eg~h^Y^jbhb^i\a^ZY ljgYZ '%%* ojb 9^gZ`idg \Zl~]ai# =VchgjZY^ AV^X] ig~\i \gdhhZc 6ciZ^a Vc YZc ]Zji^\Zc :g[da\Zc kdc Hl^hh"H`^# >b CVbZc kdc Hl^hh"H`^ YVc`i YVh Eg~h^Y^jb =VchgjZY^ AV^X] [ g hZ^cZc :^chVio jcY Y^Z \ZaZ^hiZiZ 6gWZ^i ]Zgoa^X]# 9^Z V`ijZaaZ H^ijVi^dc l^gY cjc VjX] YVoj kZglZcYZi! Y^Z \Z\Zcl~gi^\Zc KZgWVcYhhigj`ijgZc oj VcVanh^ZgZc jcY Y^Z WZhib \a^X]Zc KVg^VciZc oj ZgVgWZ^iZc! jb Y^Z ]dX]\ZhiZX`iZc jcY aVc\[g^hi^\Zc O^ZaZ oj ZggZ^X]Zc#

%,

Dg\Vc^\gVbb Hl^hh"H`^ HiVcY/ (%# 6eg^a '%%.

Organigramm

Präsidium

(Stand: 01.06.2009) Direktor Hansruedi Laich * Leiterin Kommunikation Diana Fäh

Viviane Barandun

Chef Leistungssport Dierk Beisel *

Chef Herren Alpin Martin Rufener

Chef Damen Alpin Hugues Ansermoz

Chef Ausbildung/Forschung Peter Läuppi * Pia Alchenberger 50% Simone Murer

Chef Breitensport Hans Bigler

Roman Rogenmoser Tanja Uhlmann Regine Stössel 30% Nicole Moning 40%

Chef Marketing Stefan Brütsch

Vakant 50% Raphael Wyss 50% Leiterin Sponsoring & Events Annalisa Gerber

Christian Stahl Sandra Heiniger 50%

Chef Dienste Andreas Chr. Wenger

Leiter Finanzen Christoph Morandi

Stefanie Gerber 3. LJ Urs Schneider

Chef Nachwuchs Alpin & Schulen Franz Hofer

Leiterin Sekretariat Leistungssport Madeleine Erb Roger Hauser

Chef Langlauf Hippolyt Kempf ab 1. August 2009 Chef Skisprung Gary Furrer

Chef Nordische Kombination Hippolyt Kempf

Simone Lüthi Manuel Bucciolini Adrian Schild Chef Wettkampforganisation Peter Bloch

Vakant 50% Chantal Rieder Leiter Projekte Marketing Oliver Balsiger

Manfred Liechti Stefanie Gerber 3. LJ Céline Hauert 2. LJ Sabrina Aebischer 1 LJ

Jürg Klopfenstein Leiterin MitgliederServices Anina Nussbaum Corina Puorger 80% Katharina Imhof 30% Marco Fölmli 25%

Chef Biathlon Markus Regli

Chef Snowboard Franco Giovanoli Geschäftsleitung Chef Freestyle Christoph Perreten Kader Chef Telemark Hans-Peter Birchler

Sportliche Leitung *

<:H8=t;IHA:>IJC<

%-

:g[da\gZ^X] ^c VaaZc 7ZgZ^X]Zc '' LB"BZYV^aaZc! ' <ZhVbilZaiXjeh^Z\Z! (- LZaiXjeh^Z\Z jcY +* lZ^iZgZ EdYZhiea~ioZ Ã Y^Zh Y^Z WZZ^cYgjX`Zc" YZ 7^aVco YZg Hl^hh"H`^ 6i]aZi^ccZc jcY 6i]aZiZc ^b kZg" \Vc\ZcZc L^ciZg# 9^Z oV]agZ^X]Zc :g[da\Z l^g`iZc h^X] Vj[ Y^Z BVg`Zi^c\" jcY Hedchdg^c\V`i^k^i~iZc kdc Hl^hh"H`^ edh^i^k Vjh jcY h^cY bVhh\ZWa^X] YV[ g kZgVcildgia^X]!

YVhh Hl^hh"H`^ igdio Z^cZh hX]l^Zg^\Zc l^gihX]V[ia^X]Zc Jb[ZaYh lZ^iZg]^c oj Z^cZg YZg ViigV`i^khiZc EaVii[dgbZc Vj[ YZb HX]lZ^oZg Hedchdg^c\bVg`i o~]ai# 9^Z hedgia^" X]Zc :g[da\Z ]VWZc YZb HX]lZ^oZg HX]cZZhedgi l^ZYZg oj bZ]g EdejaVg^i~i kZg]da[Zc! lVh VjX] Y^Z IK"OV]aZc kdc HG< HHG ^Y Z hj^hhZ oZ^\Zc# CVX][da\ZcY Y^Z OjhVbbZc[Vhhjc\ YZg l^X]i^\hiZc hedgia^X]Zc :g[da\Z/

AZ^hijc\hhedgi/ (- L8"H^Z\Z! +* lZ^iZgZ L8"EdYZhiea~ioZ :^cbVa bZ]g a^Z\i Z^cZ ZgZ^\c^hgZ^X]Z HV^hdc ]^ciZg jch b^i LZaibZ^hiZghX]V[iZc ^c VaaZc VX]i 9^ho^ea^cZc# 9^Z hedgia^X]Zc O^ZaZ ljgYZc WZ^ YZg :a^iZ b^i '' LB"BZYV^aaZc ^c [ c[ 9^ho^ea^cZc hdl^Z ^ch\ZhVbi &%( EdYZhiea~ioZc Vc LZaiXjeVca~hhZc à ldkdc (- H^Z\Z à egV`i^hX] WZgVaa ZggZ^X]i lZcc c^X]i hd\Vg WZgigd[[Zc# 7ZhdcYZgh ]Zgkdgoj]ZWZc ^hi YVWZ^ Y^Z ]ZgVjhgV\ZcYZ AZ^hijc\ kdc 9Vg^d 8dad\cV! YZg c^X]i cjg Y^Z Idjg YZ H`^ [ g h^X] Zci" hX]^ZY! hdcYZgc hZ^cZc `dbZiZc]V[iZc 6j[hi^Z\ Vc Y^Z LZaihe^ioZ b^i YZb <Zl^cc YZh <ZhVbilZaiXjeh `g ciZ# 9Zg H]ddi^c\hiVg YZg AVc\aVj[hoZcZ hdg\iZ YVb^i [ g YZc \g hhiZc :g[da\ ^c YZg <ZhX]^X]iZ YZh HX]lZ^oZg AVc\aVj[hedgih# :WZc[Vaah ]Zgkdgoj]ZWZc \^ai Zh Y^Z :g[da\Z YZg Vae^cZc 6i]aZi^ccZc jcY 6i]aZiZc kdc Hl^hh"H`^/ H^Z Zgo^ZaiZc ^c ,) LZaiXjegZccZc ol a[ H^Z\Z jcY &- lZ^iZgZ EdYZhiea~ioZ# JcWZhig^iiZcZg = ]Zejc`i lVgZc Y^Z Vae^cZc H`^lZaibZ^hiZghX]V[iZc ^c KVa YÈ>h gZ! Vc lZaX]Zc Y^Z HX]lZ^o hZX]h BZYV^aaZc \ZlVcc jcY YVb^i ZghibVah hZ^i '% ?V]gZc l^ZYZg Y^Z Zg[da\gZ^X]hiZ CVi^dc lVg# 9Vhh ;gZjY jcY AZ^Y _ZYdX] cV]Z WZ^Z^cVcYZg a^Z\Zc! oZ^\i YZg igV\^hX]Z Jc[Vaa kdc 9Vc^Za 6aWgZX]i ^c @^ioW ]Za! VWZg VjX]

hZ^c 6j[lVX]Zc Vjh YZb ` chia^X]Zc I^Z[hX]aV[ \ZcVj Vc YZb IV\! Vc YZb hZ^c IZVb`daaZ\Z 8Vgad ?Vc`V ^b G^ZhZchaVadb LB" <daY \ZlVcc# <gjcY ojb ?jWZac ]ViiZc VjX] Y^Z H`^heg^c\Zg/ B^i [ c[ H^Z\Zc jcY ol a[ lZ^iZgZc EdYZhiea~ioZc ljgYZ YVh Kdg_V]gZhgZhjaiVi Z^c H^Z\ jcY k^Zg lZ^iZgZ EdYZhiea~ioZ WZ^ LZ^iZb WZgigd[[Zc# 6c YZg cdgY^hX]Zc LB ^b ihX]ZX]^hX]Zc A^WZgZX hegVc\ 6cYgZVh @ iiZa Vj[ YZg <gdhhhX]VcoZ oj hZ^cZb ZghiZc LB"<daY! l~]gZcY H^bdc 6bbVcc Vj[ YZg CdgbVahX]VcoZ 7gdcoZ \ZlVcc jcY Y^Z LZaiXje"<ZhVbilZgijc\ Vj[ GVc\ ' VWhX]adhh# Hl^hh"HcdlWdVgY Wa^X`i ZWZc[Vaah Vj[ Z^cZ Zg[da\gZ^X]Z HV^hdc ojg X`# Oj [Z^Zgc \VW Zh k^Zg LB"BZYV^aaZc! k^Zg LZaiXjeh^Z\Z jcY Za[ lZ^iZgZ EdYZhiea~ioZ# B^i BZaa^Z ;gVcXdc LB"7gdcoZ Da^k^V CdWh LB"H^aWZg HVcYgV ;gZ^! IVc_V ;g^ZYZc jcY H^bdcV BZ^aZg kZg[ \i Y^Z HX]lZ^o ld]a WZg YVh bdbZciVc hi~g`hiZ 7dVgYZgXgdhh"IZVb# 9Vc` olZ^ lZ^iZgZc LB"BZYV^aaZc kdc EVig^o^V @jbbZg LB"7gdcoZ ^b EVgVaaZag^ZhZchaVadb jcY ;g~co^ B~\Zgi"@d]a^ LB"<daY ^b EVgVaaZahaVadb WZZcYZiZ Y^Z HX]lZ^o Y^Z LB Vah olZ^iWZhiZ CVi^dc# 7Z^ YZc ;gZZhinaZgc hdg\iZ ^chWZhdcYZgZ K^g\^c^Z ;V^kgZ [ g Z^cZc Zg[gZja^X]Zc = ]Zejc`i/ h^Z \ZlVcc Vc YZg LB ^c >cVlVh]^gd LB"<daY ^c YZg =Va[e^eZ hdl^Z Y^Z `aZ^cZ LZaiXje" @g^hiVaa`j\Za# >b H`^Xgdhh igjbe[iZc 6cYgZVh HiZ[[Zc jcY HVccV A Y^ Vb =Z^blZaiXje \gdhh Vj[/ >c <g^cYZalVaY ljgYZ HVccV A Y^ 9g^iiZ! l~]gZcY 6cYgZVh HiZ[[Zc ^c BZ^g^c\Zc Y^Z @dc`jggZco Ydb^c^ZgiZ# >b IZaZbVg` igjbe[iZ 6b a^Z GZnbdcY Vj[ jcY \ZlVcc Y^Z \gdh" hZ @g^hiVaa`j\Za hdl^Z Y^Z Wg^\Zc YgZ^ 9^ho^ea^cZclZaiXjeh# :g[gZja^X] ^hi! YVhh VjX] ^c Y^ZhZg HV^hdc jchZgZ _jc\Zc 6i]aZi^ccZc jcY 6i]aZiZc oV]agZ^X]Z Ide`aVhh^Zgjc\Zc jcY Vc YZc ?jc^dgZclZaibZ^hiZghX]V[iZc h^ZWZc BZYV^aaZc \ZlVccZc/ 6c YZg >7J ?jc^dgZc"LB ^b `VcVY^hX]Zc 8VcbdgZ \ZlVcc YZg

%.

7^Vi]adc"CVX]ljX]h olZ^bVa :YZabZiVaa jcY Zgo^ZaiZ hZX]h lZ^iZgZ Ide IZc"@aVhh^Zgjc\Zc# >chWZhdcYZgZ Y^Z H^aWZgbZYV^aaZ kdc 7Zc_Vb^c LZ\Zg ^b &%`b"LB"Heg^ci hiZaai VaaZh ^c YZc HX]ViiZc! lVh HX]lZ^oZg CVX]ljX]h"7^Vi]aZiZc W^h Vc]^c Zg" gZ^X]i ]ViiZc# 6c YZc Vae^cZc ?jc^dgZc"LZaibZ^hiZghX]V[iZc ^c <Vgb^hX]"EVgiZc`^gX]Zc \ZlVcc 9Zc^hZ ;Z^ZgVWZcY HaVadb" <daY! cVX]YZb h^Z WZgZ^ih ^c KVa YÈ>h gZ b^i Z^cZb +# EaVio ^b LB"HaVadb [ g 6j[hZ]Zc \Zhdg\i ]ViiZ# :WZc[Vaah WZggVhX]ZcY LB"<daY ^c YZg @dbW^cVi^dc \ZlVcc YZg CAO"6i]aZi HZee <ZgWZg# JcY b^i ?ja^Z Od\\ <daY jcY H^aWZg Vc YZg ?jc^dgZc LB ^c CV\Vcd kZg[ \i VjX] Hl^hh"HcdlWdVgY WZg kZg]Z^hhjc\h" kdaaZc CVX]ljX]h# 9ZiV^aa^ZgiZ >c[dgbVi^dcZc ojb AZ^hijc\hhedgi [^cYZc H^Z VW HZ^iZ &'#

BVg`Zi^c\$Hedchdg^c\/ Hedgia^X]Z :g[da\Z igdioZc YZg L^gihX]V[ih`g^hZ 9Vhh YVc` YZg :g[da\Z YVh >ciZgZhhZ Vb HX]cZZhedgi \Zhi^Z\Zc ^hi! WZaZ\Zc Y^Z IK"OV]aZc YZg kZg\Vc\ZcZc HV^hdc/ >b KZg" \aZ^X] ojb Kdg_V]g higV]aiZ jchZg =dhiWgdVYXVhiZg HG< HHG ^Y Z hj^hhZ )' LZaiXjekZgVchiVaijc\Zc bZ]g Vjh# OjYZb lVgZc jchZgZ 6i]aZi^ccZc dYZg 6i]aZiZc YZjia^X] [iZg ^c HijY^dhZcYjc\Zc eg~hZci Vah ^c kZg\Vc\ZcZc ?V]gZc# 9^Z IK" @dciV`iZ hdl^Z Y^Z HZcYZYVjZg h^cY ZWZc[Vaah jb [Vhi Z^cZc 9g^iiZa \Zhi^Z\Zc# Igdio Z^cZh hX]l^Zg^\Zc l^gihX]V[ia^X]Zc Jb[ZaYh ^hi Zh Hl^hh" H`^ \Zajc\Zc! b^i YZb [ ]gZcYZc HX]lZ^oZg :cZg\^ZY^ZchiaZ^hiZg 6ae^f Z^cZc hiVg`Zc EVgicZg oj [^cYZc! YZg YZc KZgWVcY jcY hZ^"

7gZ^iZchedgi/ CVX] l^Z kdg hZ]g WZa^ZWiZ :kZcihZg^Zc 9^Z :kZcihZg^Zc ^b 7gZ^iZchedgi Zg[gZjZc h^X] jc\ZWgdX]Z" cZg 7Za^ZWi]Z^i# 9^Z \jiZc IZ^acV]bZoV]aZc oZ^\Zc! YVhh Z^c 7ZYVg[ Vc hdaX]Zc KZgVchiVaijc\Zc WZhiZ]i# 9Vc` YZh \gdh" hZc >ciZgZhhZch hdl^Z Zc\V\^ZgiZg Dg\Vc^hVidgZc! Y^Z h^X] b^i =ZgoWaji Z^chZioZc jcY [ g Z^cZc gZ^Wjc\hadhZc 6WaVj[ hdg\Zc! ^hi igdio YZh hX]l^Zg^\Zc l^gihX]V[ia^X]Zc Jb[ZaYh YVh >ciZgZhhZ YZg HedchdgZc Vc hdaX]Zc 6ca~hhZc lZ^iZg]^c kdg]VcYZc# 9Vhh Zh YZccdX] ^b HedchdgZcWZgZ^X] oj \Zl^hhZc KZg~cYZgjc\Zc \Z`dbbZc ^hi! ^hi Z^c cdgbVaZg EgdoZhh jcY cVX]kdaao^Z]WVg# 9ZiV^aa^ZgiZ >c[dgbVi^dcZc ojb 7gZ^iZchedgi [^cYZc H^Z VW HZ^iZ (%#

Hl^hhXdb hdg\i [ g higV]aZcYZ <Zh^X]iZg/ 7Z^b HV^hdcVWhX]ajhh[Zhi WZg\^Wi YZg =Vjeihedchdg Hl^hh"H`^ c^X]i cjg Z^cZ :g[da\heg~b^Z! hdcYZgc kZg` cYZi kdgoZ^i^\ Y^Z KZga~c\Zgjc\ YZh KZgigV\h jb lZ^iZgZ k^Zg ?V]gZ W^h '%&)# ;did/ Hl^hhXdb

<:H8=t;IHA:>IJC<

&%

cZ 6i]aZi^ccZc jcY 6i]aZiZc VW &# BV^ '%%. ojhVbbZc b^i YZc W^h]Zg^\Zc KZgWVcYhhedchdgZc GV^[[Z^hZc jcY =ZakZi^V jciZg" hi ioi# 6jY^ hiZ]i Hl^hh"H`^ ^c Oj`jc[i Vj[ Z^cZg cZj \ZhX]V[[Z" cZc Hedchdg^c\hij[Z Vah ;V]goZj\eVgicZg ojg HZ^iZ# 9^Z 6B6< jciZghi ioi Hl^hh"H`^ hZ^i WZg )% ?V]gZc jcY ^hi Z^c ~jhhZghi igZj" Zg jcY lZgikdaaZg EVgicZg [ g YZc KZgWVcY# 9Vhh l^g Y^ZhZ \jiZ EVgicZghX]V[i hdb^i lZ^iZg[ ]gZc ` ccZc! ^hi Zg[gZja^X]# OjYZb `dcciZ YZg KZgigV\ b^i Hl^hh"H`^"=Vjeihedchdg Hl^hhXdb kdg" oZ^i^\ jb lZ^iZgZ k^Zg ?V]gZ W^h '%&) kZga~c\Zgi lZgYZc# 7ZgZ^ih hZ^i '%%& jciZghi ioi YVh IZaZ`dbbjc^`Vi^dchjciZgcZ]bZc YZc KZgWVcY l^Z YZc HX]cZZhedgi ^c bVcc^\[Vai^\Zg LZ^hZ jcY ^hi Z^c \gdhho \^\Zg jcY ojkZga~hh^\Zg EVgicZg! WZg YZc Hl^hh"H`^ hZ]g \a X`a^X] ^hi# 6jX] Vj[ YZg EVgicZghij[Z Y g[Zc l^g Vj[ igZjZ jcY hZ]g Zc\V\^ZgiZ JciZgcZ]bZc o~]aZc/ 9Vc` YZg JciZghi iojc\ kdc 8dde `dcciZ Y^Z º8dde H`^Xgdhh Idjg» à Z^cZ :kZcihZg^Z! Y^Z ]^ch^X]ia^X] YZg Danbe^VegZb^ZgZ YZg _jc\Zc HedgiVgi H`^Xgdhh kdc \gdhhZg 7ZYZjijc\ ^hi à ^ch AZWZc \Zgj[Zc lZgYZc# 9^Z B^\gdh! hZ^i `cVee Z^cZg 9Z`VYZ Hi ioe[Z^aZg YZh Vae^cZc 7gZ^iZchedgih! Y^Z D8 DZga^`dc hdl^Z Y^Z BddkZ HnbeVcn Zgb \a^X]iZc VjX] ^c YZg kZg\Vc\ZcZc HV^hdc Y^kZghZ :kZcih ^c YZc Hl^hh"H`^ 9^ho^ea^cZc# <ZbZ^chVb b^i DX]hcZg Hedgi! YZg hZ^c :c\V\ZbZci Vj[ cVi^dcVaZ ?D"GZccZc Vjh\ZlZ^iZi ]Vi! igV\Zc jchZgZ EVgicZg YVb^i bVhh\ZW" a^X] YVoj WZ^! Y^Z hedgia^X]Z 7Vh^h b^iiZa[g^hi^\ oj [Zhi^\Zc# B^i He^g^\ E]VgbV 9Vnadc\ HdccZcXgZbZ jcY @adgVcZ =VVge[aZ\ZegdYj`iZ `dcciZc ojh~ioa^X] olZ^ cZjZ A^Z[ZgVciZc V`fj^g^Zgi lZgYZc# 9^Z [dgil~]gZcYZ \gdhho \^\Z JciZghi iojc\ kZghX]^ZYZcZg Hi^[ijc\Zc jcY < ccZg W^aYZi Z^cZ l^X]i^\Z 7Vh^h! heZo^Zaa ^c YZg CVX]ljX]hVgWZ^i kdc Hl^hh"H`^# Hd Yjg[iZc l^g VjX] kZg\Vc\ZcZ HV^hdc Vj[ Y^Z JciZghi iojc\ Z^cZg K^ZaoV]a kdc B~oZcZc o~]aZc# >chWZhdcYZgZ Y^Z ºHi^[ijc\ ojg ; gYZgjc\ YZh Vae^cZc H`^hedgih»! l^Z VjX] Y^Z B^i\a^ZYZg YZh º8gnhiVa 8ajWh» jcY YZh º8ajW '%&%» hiZaaZc [^cVco^ZaaZ B^iiZa ojg KZg[ \jc\! YVc` YZgZg h^X] _jc\Zc! iVaZci^ZgiZc HedgiaZg^ccZc jcY HedgiaZg oV]agZ^X]Z EZgheZ`i^kZc Zg [[cZc# 6c Y^ZhZg HiZaaZ hZ^ VjX] VaaZc < ccZgkZgZ^c^\jc\Zc ]Zgoa^X] \ZYVc`i! Y^Z jchZgZ 9^ho^ea^cZc _ZlZ^ah Y^gZ`i jciZghi i" oZc! hdl^Z Hl^hh Danbe^X jcY YZg HX]lZ^oZg Hedgi]^a[Z#

L~]gZcY Y^Z 8ajW" jcY 8ajWb^i\a^ZYZgoV]aZc lZ^iZg]^c g X`a~j[^\ h^cY! `dcciZ Hl^hh"H`^ YZb IgZcY YZg h^c`ZcYZc B^i\a^ZYZgoV]aZc lZ^iZg Zci\Z\Zcl^g`Zc à Y^Zh c^X]i ojaZioi YVc` YZg hedgia^" X]Zc :g[da\Z jcY ViigV`i^kZg B^i\a^ZYZgVc\ZWdiZ# >c[da\Z YZg B^i\a^ZYZgV`i^dc! Y^Z l^Z ^b kZg\Vc\ZcZc ?V]g ^c OjhVbbZcVgWZ^i b^i YZb EVgicZg DX]hcZg Hedgi YjgX]\Z[ ]gi ljgYZ! `dcciZc ^c" cZg]VaW Z^cZh BdcVih WZg ( (%% CZjb^i\a^ZYZg \ZldccZc lZg" YZc# :cYZ 6eg^a '%%. WZigj\ Y^Z 6coV]a B^i\a^ZYZg hX]a^Zhha^X] gjcY &%) %%%# Hl^hh"H`^ gZVa^h^ZgiZ Vca~hha^X] YZg ;>H Vae^cZc H`^lZai" bZ^hiZghX]V[iZc ^c KVa YÈ>h gZ \ZbZ^chVb b^i YZg <EH EZg[dgbVcXZ H6 jcY b^i LVaa^h Idjg^hbjh Vah =Vjeihedchdg YVh º=djhZ d[ Hl^ioZgaVcY»# 9Zg ^b OZcigjb kdc KVa YÈ>h gZ \ZaZ\ZcZ IgZ[[ejc`i [ g ;Vch! K>Eh! HedchdgZc! EVgicZg! ?djgcVa^hiZc! ;jc`i^dc~gZ jcY 6i]aZiZc WZ\Z^hiZgiZ b^i Vj" i]Zci^hX]Zg @ X]Z jcY \Zb ia^X]Zb 6bW^ZciZ jcY lVg _ZYZc 6WZcY bZ]g[VX] Vjh\ZWjX]i# >c YZg kZg\Vc\ZcZc HV^hdc `dcciZc ^c YZg HX]lZ^o &+ LZai" XjekZgVchiVaijc\Zc YjgX]\Z[ ]gi lZgYZc# :^cbVa bZ]g ]Vi YZgZc Dg\Vc^hVi^dc jcY 9jgX][ ]gjc\ gZ^Wjc\hadh \Z`aVeei# 6c Y^ZhZg HiZaaZ \ZW ]gi YZc KZgVchiVaiZgc! d]cZ YZgZc jcZg" b Ya^X]Zc :^chVio hdaX]Z ]dX]`aVhh^\Zc GZccZc c^X]i YjgX]" \Z[ ]gi lZgYZc ` cciZc! Z^c \gdhhZh AdW# HG< HHG ^Y Z hj^hhZ lVg l^ZYZgjb [ g Y^Z IK"EgdYj`i^dc kZgVcildgia^X] jcY eg~hZc" i^ZgiZ Y^Z HX]cZZhedgiVgiZc! VWZg VjX] Y^Z 9jgX][ ]gjc\hdgiZ! kdc ^]gZg ViigV`i^khiZc HZ^iZ# :^cZc [ZhiZc 7ZhiVcYiZ^a gjcY jb Y^Z LZaiXjeVca~hhZ W^aYZiZc VjX] Y^Z K>E"6ca~hhZ# OV]agZ^X]Z <~hiZ \ZcdhhZc ^c 6YZaWdYZc! :c\ZaWZg\! <g^cYZalVaY! 9Vkdh!

Hi# Bdg^io jcY LZc\Zc ^c igVjb]V[iZg Jb\ZWjc\ YVh Z^co^\" Vgi^\Z GZccVbW^ZciZ jcY `dcciZc Vb Z^cZc dYZg VcYZgZc Dgi hd\Vg HX]lZ^oZg H^Z\Z b^iZgaZWZc LZc\Zc/ 9^Y^Zg 9 [V\d 6W[V]gi jcY 8Vgad ?Vc`V HjeZg`dbW^cVi^dc0 Hi# Bdg^io/ AVgV <j!i HjeZg"<0 :c\ZaWZg\/ H^bdc 6bbVcc! H`^heg^c\Zc0 6gdhV/ HVcYgV ;gZ^! HcdlWdVgYXgdhh0 BZ^g^c\Zc"=Vha^WZg\/ 6cYgZVh HiZ[[Zc! H`^Xgdhh #

&&

9^ZchiZ/ LZ^iZgZ Egd[Zhh^dcVa^h^Zgjc\ ^c VaaZc 7ZgZ^X]Zc

@dbbjc^`Vi^dc/ <Zajc\ZcZ ZghiZ HV^hdc b^i cZjZb IZVb jcY cZjZg =dbZeV\Z

>b Oj\Z YZg Egd[Zhh^dcVa^h^Zgjc\ VaaZg HZ`idgZc kdc Hl^hh"H`^ hdaaZc ^b >I"7ZgZ^X] Y^Z Y^kZghZc >I"EgdoZhhZ WZ^ Hl^hh"H`^ kZgZ^c]Z^ia^X]i jcY kZgZ^c[VX]i lZgYZc# Eg^dg^i~g l^gY Y^Z OjhVbbZcaZ\jc\ YZg kZghX]^ZYZcZc 9ViZcWVc`Zc Vc\Z" higZWi# 9Vh W^h]Zg^\Z 8jhidbZg GZaVi^dc BVcV\ZbZci 8GB kdc Hl^hh"H`^ hdaa YjgX] Z^cZ dei^bVaZ jcY cjioZg[gZjcYa^X]Z A hjc\ ZghZioi lZgYZc# Hl^hhXdb! =Vjeihedchdg kdc Hl^hh" H`^! jciZghi ioiZ Hl^hh"H`^ ^b :kVajVi^dchegdoZhh! WZ^ YZb Y^Z LV]a hX]a^Zhha^X] Vj[ YVh EgdYj`i ºZk^YZcXZ» kdc <aVjm Hd[i 6< [^Za# O^Za ^hi Zh cjc! YVh cZjZ 8GB W^h :cYZ HdbbZg '%%. oj ^beaZbZci^ZgZc#

CVX] Z^cZg ]VaW_~]g^\Zc Egd_Z`ie]VhZ ljgYZ B^iiZ CdkZbWZg '%%- Y^Z cZj \ZhiVaiZiZ >ciZgcZihZ^iZ lll#hl^hh"h`^#X] Vj[" \ZhX]VaiZi# >c OjhVbbZcVgWZ^i b^i YZg LZWV\Zcijg Jc^X ^hi Zh \Zajc\Zc! edh^i^kZ 6heZ`iZ YZg VaiZc =dbZeV\Z l^Z Y^Z zWZgh^X]ia^X]`Z^i jcY JhZg[gZjcYa^X]`Z^i WZ^ojWZ]VaiZc jcY \aZ^X]oZ^i^\ Y^Z Dei^b^Zgjc\ho^ZaZ à Z^c bdYZgcZh! YncVb^hX]Zh 9Zh^\c! Z^cZ kZgWZhhZgiZ K^h^W^a^i~i jcY Z^cZc ^ciZgV`i^kZgZc >c[dgbVi^dch\Z]Vai à jbojhZioZc# 9Vh <gdhhegd_Z`i ljgYZ ^b CdkZbWZg '%%- ^ccZg]VaW YZh 7jY\Zih VW\ZhX]adhhZc#

Jb YZc >I"KZgVcildgia^X]Zc oj ZciaVhiZc! ljgYZ Y^Z HiZaaZ Z^" cZh 8dciZci"BVcV\Zgh EZchjb *% \ZhX]V[[Zc# 9Vc` Y^ZhZg BVhhcV]bZ `Vcc h^X] YZg >I"KZgVcildgia^X]Z cjc VjhhX]a^Zhha^X] Vj[ Y^Z VchiZ]ZcYZc iZX]c^hX]Zc 6heZ`iZ l^Z YZc 6jhWVj YZg HZgkZg">c[gVhigj`ijg dYZg Y^Z 6ceVhhjc\ YZg :"BV^a"6gX]^k^Zgjc\ `dcoZcig^ZgZc! l~]gZcY YZg 8dciZci"BVcV\Zg h^X] jb YZc >c]Vai YZg LZWh^iZ ` bbZgi# 6j[ YZg EZghdcVahZ^iZ \VW Zh Y^kZghZ 6W\~c\Z kdc iZ^ah aVc\" _~]g^\Zc B^iVgWZ^iZcYZc oj kZgoZ^X]cZc! ^chWZhdcYZgZ ^c YZg @dbbjc^`Vi^dc jcY ^b AZ^hijc\hhedgi# >c VaaZc ;~aaZc `dcciZ Y^Z CVX][da\Z _ZYdX] gVhX] jcY `dbeZiZci \ZgZ\Zai lZgYZc# 9^Z Hl^hh"H`^ 6i]aZi^ccZc jcY 6i]aZiZc lVgZc W^h ^b ;g ]_V]g '%%- WZ^ kZghX]^ZYZcZc 6cW^ZiZgc \Z\Zc Jc[Vaa ojhViokZg" h^X]Zgi# :^c^\Z Y^ZhZg KZgig~\Z a^Z[Zc oZ^i\aZ^X] Vjh# Hl^hh"H`^ cjioiZ Y^Z <ZaZ\Zc]Z^i! hdld]a Y^Z gjcY '*% 6i]aZi^ccZc jcY 6i]aZiZc l^Z VjX] YVh \ZhVbiZ EZghdcVa ^c Z^cZb <ZhVbieV`Zi kZgh^X]Zgc oj aVhhZc# EZg &# ?VcjVg '%%. lZX]hZaiZc h~bi" a^X]Z EZghdcZckZgh^X]Zgjc\Zc ojg K>H6C6# 9Vc` YZg Zc\Zc OjhVbbZcVgWZ^i ^b 7ZgZ^X] 6i]aZiZckZgh^X]Zgjc\ ol^hX]Zc K>H6C6! G:<6 jcY Hl^hh"H`^ ^hi Y^Zh Y^Z dei^bVaZ A hjc\ [ g Y^Z 6i]aZi^ccZc jcY 6i]aZiZc#

:^c l^X]i^\Zg 6heZ`i YZg =dbZeV\Z kdc Hl^hh"H`^ ^hi YZgZc 6`ijVa^i~i# L~]gZcY YZg GZcchV^hdc lZgYZc i~\a^X] W^h oj VX]i CZlh kZg[Vhhi hdl^Z Y^Z oV]agZ^X]Zc GZhjaiViZ Vjh YZb AZ^hijc\h" l^Z VjX] 7gZ^iZchedgi ejWa^o^Zgi# 9Vh h^cY gjcY &(+% CZlh ^c 9ZjihX] jcY ;gVco h^hX]# Kdc B^iiZ CdkZbWZg W^h :cYZ B~go ZghiZaaiZ YVh cZj ojhVbbZc\ZhiZaaiZ @dbbjc^`Vi^dchiZVb gjcY '+* hiVi^hX]Z >ciZgcZihZ^iZc! Y^Z ZWZc[Vaah ^bbZg olZ^hegVX]^\ ejWa^o^Zgi lZg" YZc# Ojh~ioa^X] l^gY l~]gZcY YZg GZcchV^hdc Z^cbVa l X]Zcia^X] YZg Hl^hh"H`^ CZlhaZiiZg kZghX]^X`i# 9^ZhZg Zci]~ai ojh~ioa^X]Z =^ciZg\gjcYWZg^X]iZ ojb V`ijZaaZc <ZhX]Z]Zc ^c YZc Hl^hh"H`^" 9^ho^ea^cZc jcY bVX]i YjgX] YZc V`i^kZc KZghVcY Y^Z kZghX]^Z" YZcZc 7ZgZ^X]Z jcY 9^ho^ea^cZc Z^cZb \g hhZgZc :be[~c\Zg`gZ^h oj\~c\a^X]# 9Vc` YZg >ciZ\gVi^dc YZg B^i\a^ZYZgVYgZhhZc `dcciZ Y^Z :be[~c\ZgoV]a kdc (+%% Vj[ '&'.' \ZhiZ^\Zgi lZgYZc# ?ZYZg Yg^iiZ YVkdc [[cZi YZc CZlhaZiiZg jcY [^cYZi hd YZc LZ\ Vj[ Y^Z Hl^hh"H`^"=dbZeV\Z# 6aaZ^c ^c YZc BdcViZc CdkZbWZg W^h B~go kZgoZ^X]cZiZ lll# hl^hh"h`^#X] )'% %%% 7ZhjX]Zg hdl^Z ' B^aa^dcZc HZ^iZcoj\g^[[Z# O^Za ^hi Zh! Y^Z 6coV]a HZ^iZcoj\g^[[Z Vj[ lll#hl^hh"h`^#X] l~]" gZcY YZg L^ciZghV^hdc l^Z VjX] l~]gZcY YZc HdbbZgbdcViZc `dci^cj^Zga^X] oj hiZ^\Zgc# 9^Zh \Za^c\i cjg! lZcc l^g YVh \VcoZ ?V]g WZg ViigV`i^kZc jcY ^c[dgbVi^kZc 8dciZci VcW^ZiZc jcY jc" hZgZ =dbZeV\Z hi~g`Zg egdbdiZc! hZ^ Zh WZ^ 6i]aZiZc! B^i\a^ZYZgc! H`^XajWh! GZ\^dcVakZgW~cYZc! HedchdgZc jcY EVgicZgc! ;VcXajWh! ZiX#

A:>HIJC<HHEDGI 6AE>C

&'

H`^ Vae^c/ 6jh\ZoZ^X]cZiZ 7^aVco 9^Z Vae^cZc 6i]aZiZc igj\Zc ZWZc[Vaah ojg Vjh\ZoZ^X]cZiZc 7^aVco kdc Hl^hh"H`^ WZ^/ H^Z Zgo^ZaiZc ^c ,) LZaiXjegZccZc ol a[ H^Z\Z hdl^Z &- lZ^iZgZ EdYZhiea~ioZ# JcWZhig^iiZcZg = ]Zejc`i lVgZc Y^Z Vae^cZc H`^lZaibZ^hiZghX]V[iZc ^c KVa YÈ>h gZ! Vc lZaX]Zc Y^Z HX]lZ^o hZX]h BZYV^aaZc \ZlVcc jcY YVb^i ZghibVah hZ^i '% ?V]gZc l^ZYZg Y^Z Zg[da\gZ^X]hiZ CVi^dc Vc Z^cZg LZaibZ^hiZghX]V[i lVg# :g[gZja^X] ^hi Y^Z IVihVX]Z oj lZgiZc! YVhh Y^Z H^Z\Z hdld]a kdc _jc\Zc ;V]gZg^ccZc jcY ;V]gZgc l^Z AVgV <ji jcY 8Vgad ?Vc`V Vah VjX] kdc Vgg^k^ZgiZc 6i]aZiZc l^Z 9^Y^Zg 8jX]Z jcY 9^Y^Zg 9 [V\d Zgo^Zai ljgYZc#

=ZggZc Vae^c/ :^cZ hiVg`Z HV^hdc BVgi^c Gj[ZcZgh IZVb lVg [jab^cVci ^c Y^Z cZjZ LZaiXjehV^hdc \ZhiVgiZi/ 9Vc^Za 6aWgZX]i jcY 9^Y^Zg 8jX]Z Zgo^ZaiZc WZ^b igVY^" i^dcZaaZc LZaiXjeVj[iV`i ^c H aYZc Z^cZc 9deeZah^Z\# 8Vgad ?Vc`V WZggVhX]iZ WZ^ YZg LB"=VjeiegdWZ ^c KVa YÈ>h gZ b^i YZb H^Z\ ^b G^ZhZchaVadb# 6jX] ^c LZc\Zc hiVcY Zg ^c YZg HjeZg`dbW^cVi^dc ojdWZghi Vj[ YZb IgZeeX]Zc jcY Zcil^X`ZaiZ h^X] YVb^i oj Z^" cZb ZgchiojcZ]bZcYZc @dc`jggZciZc ^b @Vbe[ jb Y^Z `aZ^cZ @g^hiVaa`j\Za ^c YZg HjeZg`dbW^cVi^dc! Vj[ Y^Z h^X] VjX] H^akVc OjgWg^\\Zc cVX] hZ^cZb H^Z\ ^c YZg HjeZg`dbW^cVi^dc ^c @^ioW ]Za =d[[cjc\ bVX]Zc Yjg[iZ# 9Zg LVaa^hZg ]ViiZ WZ^b HaVadb ^b [^c" c^hX]Zc AZk^ Z^c idaaZh 8dbZWVX` cVX] hZ^cZb hX]lZgZc Jc[Vaa ^b 9ZoZbWZg '%%, ^c KVa <VgYZcV \Z\ZWZc jcY ljgYZ K^ZgiZg# HjeZg"<"LZaibZ^hiZg 9^Y^Zg 8jX]Z oZ^\iZ ^b ZghiZc GZccZc cVX] YZg LB VjX] ^b G^ZhZchaVadb kdc HZhig^ZgZ Z^cZ \gdhhVgi^\Z AZ^hijc\! Zgo^ZaiZ hZ^cZc ZghiZc LZaiXjeh^Z\ ^c Y^ZhZg HV^hdc jcY WgVX]iZ h^X] hdld]a ^b G^ZhZchaVadb"9^ho^ea^cZclZaiXje Vah VjX] ^b <ZhVbilZaiXje l^ZYZg ojg X` ^ch GZccZc jb Y^Z @g^hiVaa`j\Zac# 9Vc` hZ^cZh Yg^iiZc GVc\h ^b L8"G^ZhZchaVadb kdc 6gZ \ZlVcc Zg hX]a^Zhha^X] Y^Z `aZ^cZ @g^hiVaa`j\Za ^b G^ZhZchaVadb# 8Vgad ?Vc`V ]ViiZ YVh 9jZaa b^i H^akVc OjgWg^\\Zc jb YZc 9^ho^ea^cZch^Z\ ^c YZg HjeZg`dbW^cVi^dc hX]dc kdg\~c\^\ [ g h^X] ZcihX]^ZYZc#

9 [V\d hX]gZ^Wi H`^\ZhX]^X]iZ 9^Y^Zg 9 [V\d \ZlVcc ^ccZgi LdX]Zc[g^hi Y^Z WZ^YZc @aVhh^`Zg LZc\Zc jcY @^ioW ]Za# 9Zg H^Z\ Vb aZ\ZcY~gZc AVjWZg]dgc"GZccZc WZYZjiZiZ [ g YZc GdbVcY \aZ^X]oZ^i^\ YZc ZghiZc LZaiXjeh^Z\ ^c YZg 6W[V]gi# B^i Y^ZhZg idaaZc AZ^hijc\ hX]g^ZW 9 [V\d <ZhX]^X]iZ/ C^X]i k^ZaZ 6W[V]gZg ]VWZc ^c YZg KZg\Vc\Zc]Z^i WZ^YZ \gdhhZc @aVhh^`Zg ^b hZaWZc ?V]g \ZldccZc# AZioibVah \ZaVc\ Y^Zh YZb yhiZggZ^X]Zg HiZe]Vc :WZg]VgiZg '%%'# 6ah W^haVc\ aZioiZg HX]lZ^oZg ]ViiZ ;gVco =Z^coZg &..' YVhhZaWZ @jchihi X` [Zgi^\ \ZWgVX]i# 8Vgad ?Vc`V ^hi Z^cZg YZg H]ddi^c\hiVgh YZg kZg\Vc\ZcZc HV^hdc jcY \ZlVcc cZWZc LB"<daY ^b G^ZhZchaVadb hdl^Z LB"7gdcoZ ^c YZg 6W[V]gi VjX] Y^Z `aZ^cZ @g^hiVaa`j\Za ^c YZg HjeZg`dbW^cVi^dc# ;did/ @ZnhidcZ

<jiZ IZVbVgWZ^i Vah 7Vh^h [ g YZc LB":g[da\ OlZ^ <daY"! YgZ^ H^aWZg" jcY Z^cZ 7gdcoZbZYV^aaZ/ Hd aVjiZi Y^Z Zg[gZja^X]Z 7^aVco kdc Hl^hh"H`^ Vc YZc Vae^cZc H`^lZai" bZ^hiZghX]V[iZc '%%. ^c KVa YÈ>h gZ# 9Vb^i lVg Y^Z HX]lZ^o

&(

;gZjY jcY AZ^Y a^Z\Zc ^b Hedgi cV]Z WZ^Z^cVcYZg/ L~]gZcY h^X] 9^Y^Zg 9 [V\d jcY H^akVc OjgWg^\\Zc jcW~cY^\ WZg ^]gZc H^Z\ ^c YZg 6W[V]gi gZhe# ^c YZg HjeZg`dbW^cVi^dc kdc @^ioW ]Za [gZjZc! hi goi 9Vc^Za 6aWgZX]i \aZ^X]Zcdgih hX]lZg jcY kZgWg^c\i [Vhi YgZ^ LdX]Zc ^b ` chia^X]Zc I^Z[hX]aV[#

ZghibVah hZ^i '% ?V]gZc l^ZYZg YVh Zg[da\gZ^X]hiZ IZVb Vc Z^cZg H`^lZaibZ^hiZghX]V[i# 6jh H^X]i YZh HX]lZ^oZg =ZggZc" iZVbh eg~\iZc Z^c ?jc\hiVg jcY Z^c Gdji^c^Zg Y^Z H`^"LB ^b WZcVX]WVgiZc ;gVc`gZ^X]# 8Vgad ?Vc`V \ZlVcc 7gdcoZ ^c YZg 6W[V]gi jcY [Z^ZgiZ hZ^cZc ZghiZc LZaibZ^hiZgi^iZa ^b G^ZhZc" haVadb# 9Zg &' ?V]gZ ~aiZgZ 9^Y^Zg 8jX]Z \ZlVcc <daY ^b HjeZg"< à hZ^cZ ZghiZ <daYbZYV^aaZ Vc Z^cZb <gdhhVcaVhh à jcY H^aWZg ^c YZg @ c^\hY^ho^ea^c! YZg 6W[V]gi# 7Vh^h [ g YZc :g[da\ ^hi Y^Z \jiZ IZVbVgWZ^i! d]cZ Y^Z hdaX]Z AZ^hijc\Zc c^X]i b \a^X] h^cY# 9Vc` 8jX]Z jcY ?Vc`V `Vcc Hl^hh"H`^ Vc YZg LB '%&& ^c <Vgb^hX]" EVgiZc`^gX]Zc ^c olZ^ 9^ho^ea^cZc b^i [ c[ BVcc I^iZakZgiZ^Y^\Zg ]VWZc Z^cZc ;^meaVio VcigZiZc# >c YZg Ol^hX]ZcoZ^i jcY VjX] ^b =^cWa^X` Vj[ Y^Z Danbe^hX]Zc L^ciZghe^ZaZ '%&% ^c KVcXdjkZg hdaa Y^Z BVcchX]V[i lZ^iZg \Z[Zhi^\i lZgYZc#

=dX]h jcY I^Z[h 9Vh Vae^cZ =ZggZciZVb jciZg 8]Z[igV^cZg BVgi^c Gj[ZcZg WZZcYZiZ hZ^cZ HV^hdc Vj[ GVc\ ' YZg CVi^dcZclZgijc\# 9Vh =ZggZciZVb Zgo^Za" iZ ^ch\ZhVbi VX]i LZaiXje"H^Z\Z hdl^Z oZ]c lZ^iZgZ EdYZhiea~ioZ# 9Vh :g\ZWc^h ^hi ]dX] Z^cojhij[Zc! ojbVa BVgi^c Gj[ZcZg Vj[ bZ]" gZgZ ediZco^ZaaZ H^Z\[V]gZg kZgo^X]iZc bjhhiZ! Y^Z kZgaZiojc\h" WZY^c\i Vjh[^ZaZc dYZg Vj[\gjcY \ZhjcY]Z^ia^X]Zg 7ZhX]lZgYZc c^X]i ^]g \VcoZh EdiZco^Va VWgj[Zc `dcciZc# Hdld]a 7ZVi ;Zjo

;didh/ @ZnhidcZ#

Vah VjX] 8dgcZa O \Zg jcY GVa[ @gZjoZg kZgaZioiZc h^X] WZgZ^ih Vc[Vc\h HV^hdc WZ^ YZc GZccZc ^c zWZghZZ jcY [^ZaZc [ g YZc GZhi YZg HV^hdc Vjh# zWZghX]ViiZi ljgYZ Y^Z HV^hdc VjX] kdb hX]lZ" gZc Jc[Vaa kdc 9Vc^Za 6aWgZX]i# 9Zg ;^ZhX]Zg hi goiZ WZ^b 6WhX]ajhhigV^c^c\ ^c @^ioW ]Za hX]lZg! Zga^ii Z^c =^gc"HX]~YZa" IgVjbV jcY [^Za Y^Z \ZhVbiZ gZhia^X]Z HV^hdc Vjh# 6j[\gjcY hZ^cZg G X`ZcWZhX]lZgYZc `dcciZ BVgX 7Zgi]dY ^c YZg kZg\Vc\ZcZc HV^hdc hZ^c EdiZco^Va ZWZc[Vaah c^X]i kdaa VWgj[Zc#

HaVadb lZ^iZg]^c hX]l~X]hiZ 9^ho^ea^c B^i 9^Y^Zg 8jX]Z! 9^Y^Zg 9 [V\d! 8Vgad ?Vc`V jcY H^akVc OjgWg^\\Zc kZg[ \i BVgi^c Gj[ZcZg ZgcZji WZg bZ]gZgZ ediZco^ZaaZ H^Z\[V]gZg ^c egV`i^hX] VaaZc 9^ho^ea^cZc# Cjg \ZgVYZ ^b HaVadb lVgZc Y^Z GZhjaiViZ c^X]i oj[g^ZYZc hiZa" aZcY! dWhX]dc Y^Z IZX]c^`Zg\gjeeZ kdc HZee 7gjccZg b^i Z^" cZb HaVadbigV^cZg kZghi~g`i ldgYZc lVg# Hd [VcY BVgX <^c^ cVX] Z^cZb BViZg^ValZX]hZa YZc Ig^ii c^X]i jcY ]ViiZ k^ZaZ 6jh[~aaZ oj WZ`aV\Zc! ^c[da\Z YZgZg Zg [ g Y^Z c~X]hiZ HV^hdc ^ch 7"@VYZg ojg X`\Zhij[i l^gY# :cYZ HV^hdc \VW EVig^XZ Bdg^hdY hZ^cZc LZX]hZa kdc Hl^hh"H`^ ojb [gVco h^hX]Zc H`^kZgWVcY WZ`Vcci! ld Zg cZj Vah 8]Z[igV^cZg HeZZY =ZggZc VbiZi# HZ^cZ CVX][da\Z ig^ii BVjgd E^c^! Z]ZbVah IgV^cZg ^b Eg^kViiZVb <ji! Vc#

A:>HIJC<HHEDGI 6AE>C

&)

9Vh Vae^cZ 9VbZciZVb jciZg YZg AZ^ijc\ YZh 8]Z[igV^cZgh =j\jZh 6chZgbdo `Vcc ZWZc[Vaah Vj[ Z^cZ Zg[da\gZ^X]Z HV^hdc ojg X`Wa^X`Zc/ AVgV <jiÈh LB"BZYV^aaZc hdl^Z Y^Z k^Zg LZaiXje"H^Z\Z YjgX] AVgV <ji HjeZg"< Hi# Bdg^io ! 9db^c^fjZ <^h^c 6W[V]gi 6aiZcbVg`i"OVjX]ZchZZ jcY 8dgi^cV YÈ6beZood jcY ;VW^ZccZ HjiZg 6W[V]gi 7Vch`d `g ciZc Z^cZc L^ciZg! ^c YZb Vj[ VaaZc Hij[Zc Y^Z \ZhiZX`iZc O^ZaZ ZggZ^X]i! d[i hd\Vg WZgigd[[Zc lZgYZc `dcciZc# 9Vh ZghiZ BVa hZ^i YZg HV^hdc '%%&$%' hiZ]i YVh Vae^cZ 9VbZciZVb l^ZYZg ]^ciZg yhiZggZ^X] Vc olZ^iZg HiZaaZ YZh CVi^dcZc`aVhhZbZcih jcY WZgigV[ YZc Vc\ZhigZWiZc k^ZgiZc GVc\ WZ^ LZ^iZb#

9VbZc Vae^c/ HV^hdco^ZaZ WZgigd[[Zc >ccZg]VaW Z^cZh ?V]gZh `dcciZc Y^Z L8"Ejc`iZ YZg Vae^cZc 9VbZc jb bZ]g Vah &%%% Ejc`iZ Vj[ (++- \ZhiZ^\Zgi lZgYZc0 hZ^i YZg HV^hdc '%%+$%, ]VWZc Y^Z HX]lZ^oZg 9VbZc Y^ZhZc Ejc`iZlZgi hdb^i kZgYdeeZai# =^ciZg Y^ZhZc OV]aZc hiZ]i Z^c ^c Y^Z 7gZ^iZ \ZlVX]hZcZh IZVb! YVh kdc YZc ojcZ]bZcYZc :g[da\Zc YZg _jc\Zc ;V]gZg^ccZc aZWi/ CZWZc YZc k^Zg H^Z\Zc YjgX] AVgV <ji! 9db^c^fjZ <^h^c jcY ;VW^ZccZ HjiZg \VW Zh VX]i lZ^iZgZ EdYZhiea~ioZ oj [Z^Zgc/ ;VW^ZccZ HjiZg! Y^Z hi~g`hiZ HX]lZ^oZg H`^[V]gZg^c YZg kZg\Vc\ZcZc HV^hdc! hiVcY cZWZc ^]gZb H^Z\ ^c 7Vch`d hZX]hbVa Vj[ Z^cZb LZaiXjeedYZhi '# HjeZg"< AV`Z Adj^hZ! (# HjeZg"@dbW^cVi^dc Hi# Bdg^io! '# HjeZg"< Hi# Bdg^io! '# HjeZg"< IVgk^h^d! (# 6W[V]gi 7Vch`d! '# HjeZg"< 7Vch`d jcY ljgYZ hX]ajhhZcYa^X] Vjh\ZoZ^X]cZiZ 9g^iiZ ^c YZg HjeZg"<" 9^ho^ea^cZclZgijc\# ; g lZ^iZgZ EdYZhiea~ioZ hdg\iZc AVgV <ji!

Y^Z b^i YZb (# EaVio ^b G^ZhZchaVadb ^c HZbbZg^c\ Vah Z^co^\Z YZc Hegjc\ Vj[ Z^c EdYZhi Z^cZg iZX]c^hX]Zc 9^ho^ea^c hX]V[[iZ# 6cYgZV 9Ziia^c\ \ZaVc\ ^c ^]gZg ZghiZc LZaiXjehV^hdc ZWZc[Vaah YZg Hegjc\ Vj[ YVh EdYZhi/ H^Z ljgYZ ^b HjeZg"< kdc 8dgi^cV YÈ6beZood 9g^iiZ#

IgV^cZg"GdX]VYZ hdaa ^b HaVadb [ g cZjZ >bejahZ hdg\Zc

9db^c^fjZ <^h^c l^gY cVX] ^]gZb 6W[V]gihh^Z\ ^c 6aiZcbVg`i" OVjX]ZchZZ 6JI kdc ^]gZc IgV^cZgc Vj[ =~cYZc \ZigV\Zc# ;did/ @ZnhidcZ

L~]gZcY Y^Z HX]lZ^oZg^ccZc ^c YZc kZg\Vc\ZcZc ?V]gZc kdg" l^Z\ZcY ^c YZg 6W[V]gi ejc`iZiZc! `dcciZc Y^ZhZh ?V]g &+ 6i]aZi^ccZc ^c VaaZc [ c[ 9^ho^ea^cZc LZaiXjeejc`iZ hVbbZac# DWld]a b^i 6^iV 8VbVhigVa jcY 8 a^cV =Vc\a olZ^ l^X]i^\Z IZVbhi ioZc YZg IZX]c^`Zg^ccZc kZgaZiojc\hWZY^c\i Z^cZc <gdhhiZ^a YZg HV^hdc gZhe# \~coa^X] [Z]aiZc! `dcciZ YVh C^kZVj ^b HaVadb \Z]VaiZc! ^b G^ZhZchaVadb hd\Vg lZ^iZg Vjh\ZWVji lZgYZc# 9^Z HX]lZ^oZg EdYZhiea~ioZ WZaZ\Zc _ZYdX]! YVhh Y^Z Hi~g`Zc YZh Vae^cZc HX]lZ^oZg 9VbZciZVbh cVX] l^Z kdg ^c YZc HeZZY"9^ho^ea^cZc 6W[V]gi jcY HjeZg"< a^Z\Zc# ; g cZjZ >bejahZ ^b HaVadb"IZVb hdaa Z^cZ IgV^cZg"GdX]VYZ hdg\Zc/ 7ZVi IhX]jdg!

IgV^cZg YZg L8"<gjeeZ ( WZ^ YZc 9VbZc Vae^c kdc Hl^hh"H`^! lZX]hZai ^c YVh :jgdeVXje"IZVb jcY ig~\i YVc` YZg LZ^iZg\VWZ hZ^cZg aVc\_~]g^\Zc :g[V]gjc\ YVoj WZ^! YVhh Y^Z _jc\Zc

&*

;V]gZg^ccZc YZc 6chX]ajhh Vc Y^Z LZaiXje\gjeeZ WVaYb \a^X]hi hX]V[[Zc# >b <Z\Zcoj\ WZgc^bbi GZid CnYZ\\Zg! W^h]Zg^\Zg IgV^cZg ^b :jgdeVXje! Y^Z LZaiXje\gjeeZ YZg IZX]c^`Zg^ccZc kdb VjhigZiZcYZc =VchjZa^ 7 hX]! YZg Vb Zg[da\gZ^X]Zc 6j[WVj YZg HaVadb\gjeeZ \gdhhZc KZgY^Zchi ]ViiZ# 9^Z ;V]gZg^ccZc hda" aZc YVc` Y^ZhZg IgV^cZg"GdX]VYZ ^]g EdiZco^Va ^b =^cWa^X` Vj[ Y^Z Danbe^hX]Zc L^ciZghe^ZaZ '%&% ^c KVcXdjkZg cdX] hi~g`Zg Vjhc ioZc ` ccZc#

9jgX]od\ZcZ LB"7^aVco HV^hdc] ]Zejc`i lVgZc Y^Z Vae^cZc H`^lZaibZ^hiZghX]V[iZc ^b [gVco h^hX]Zc KVa YÈ>h gZ! Vc lZaX]Zc Y^Z HX]lZ^oZg^ccZc YVc` AVgV <ji H^aWZg ^c YZg HjeZg`dbW^cVi^dc jcY ^c YZg 6W[V]gi \ZlVc" cZc jcY hdb^i gZ^c gZX]cZg^hX] Y^Z O^Zakdg\VWZc kdc Z^cZg LB" BZYV^aaZ WZgigd[[Zc ]ViiZc# 9^Z Wg^\Zc HX]lZ^oZg ;V]gZg^ccZc! Y^Z Vj[\gjcY ^]gZg \jiZc AZ^hijc\Zc l~]gZcY YZg LZaiXjehV^hdc Vah B^i[Vkdg^i^ccZc \Z]VcYZai ldgYZc lVgZc! `dcciZc _ZYdX]

YZc ]d]Zc :glVgijc\Zc c^X]i \ZgZX]i lZgYZc/ 6jh \Vco kZg" hX]^ZYZcZc <g cYZc `dcciZc h^Z ^]g EdiZci^Va c^X]i VjhhX] e" [Zc jcY ojb \Z\ZWZcZc OZ^iejc`i c^X]i Vc ^]gZ 7ZhiaZ^hijc\Zc Vc`c e[Zc#

;^mea~ioZ ^b LZaiXje YVc` :g[da\Zc ^b :jgdeVXje Igdio YZh 6j[hi^Z\Zh YZg aZioi_~]g^\Zc AZ^hijc\hig~\Zg^ccZc ^c YZc LZaiXje `dcciZc Vj[ YZg Hij[Z :jgdeVXje Y^Z HX]lZ^oZg^ccZc ^]gZ O^ZaZ ZWZc[Vaah Z\Va^h^ZgZc/ (, BVa eaVio^ZgiZ h^X] Z^cZ ;V]gZg^c jciZg YZc WZhiZc OZ]c! &+ BVa Vj[ YZb EdYZhi# HX]ajhhZcYa^X] ZggZ^X]iZc BVg^VccZ 6WYZg]VaYZc jcY 6ccZ"Hde]^Z @dZ]c Vah OlZ^iZ! gZheZ`i^kZ 9g^iiZ YZh 6W[V]gihZjgdeVXjeh! hdl^Z 9Zc^hZ ;Z^ZgVWZcY Vah :ghiZ YZh HaVadbZjgdeVXjeh Z^cZc [^mZc LZaiXjehiVgieaVio#

Dei^bVaZ IgV^c^c\hWZY^c\jc\Zc Vj[ HX]lZ^oZg <aZihX]Zgc jcY ^c CZjhZZaVcY 9^Z <gjcYaV\Z Y^ZhZg oV]agZ^X]Zc :g[da\Z aZ\iZc VaaZ <gjeeZc YZc HdbbZg WZg l~]gZcY YZb HX]cZZigV^c^c\! YVh ]Vjeih~X]a^X] ^c HVVh";ZZ jcY OZgbVii hiVii[VcY# 9Vc` YZc \jiZc LZiiZg" jcY HX]cZZkZg]~aic^hhZc egd[^i^ZgiZc Y^Z IZVbh dei^bVa kdc YZc gZcc" iVj\a^X] eg~eVg^ZgiZc E^hiZc ^c YZc WZ^YZc LVaa^hZg H`^\ZW^ZiZc! lZaX]Z b^i ^]gZb :^chVio jcY ^]gZb KZghi~cYc^h Z^cZc [aZm^WaZc IgV^c^c\heaVc Zgb \a^X]iZc#

;VW^ZccZ HjiZg [gZji h^X] WZg ^]gZc 6W[V]gihh^Z\ ^c 7Vch`d 7JA ! ld ZghibVah LZaiXjegZccZc hiVii[VcYZc# ;did/ @ZnhidcZ

OjYZb gZ^hiZc B^iiZ 6j\jhi ZghibVah VaaZ YgZ^ LZaiXje\gjeeZc b^i WZg (% 6i]aZi^ccZc jcY 7ZigZjZgc cVX] CZjhZZaVcY! jb Ydgi l~]gZcY YgZ^ LdX]Zc WZ^ l^ciZga^X]Zc KZg]~aic^hhZc ^c YgZ^ kZghX]^ZYZcZc H`^\ZW^ZiZc oj igV^c^ZgZc# JciZg VcYZgZb VWhda" k^ZgiZc h^Z ^b GV]bZc YZh º6jhigVa^Vc CZl OZVaVcY 8jeh» olZ^ IgV^c^c\hgZccZc! lZaX]Z kdc ;VW^ZccZ HjiZg jcY GVWZV <gVcY \Z" ldccZc ljgYZc# >c CZjhZZaVcY igV[Zc Y^Z HX]lZ^oZg 6i]aZi^ccZc Vj[ dei^bVaZ IgV^c^c\hkZg]~aic^hhZ! lZaX]Z ^c VaaZc 9^ho^ea^cZc! WZhdcYZgh VWZg ^c YZg 6W[V]gi! ^ciZch^kZh HX]cZZigV^c^c\ oj" a^ZhhZc# AZ^YZg hi goiZ 8 a^cV =Vc\a ^c YZc aZioiZc IV\Zc YZh IgV^c^c\haV\Zgh hX]lZg jcY od\ h^X] Z^cZ HX]^ZcWZ^c[gV`ijg Vb a^c`Zc 7Z^c oj! hd YVhh h^Z Y^Z \VcoZ HV^hdc Vjh[^Za#

A:>HIJC<HHEDGI 6AE>C

&+

9^Z IVaZciZ kdc ]ZjiZ h^cY Y^Z AZ^hijc\hig~\Zg kdc bdg\Zc/ 9Vh CAO Dhi"IZVb#

CVX]ljX]h H`^ Vae^c/ Z^c KZgheZX]Zc [ g Y^Z Oj`jc[i 9Vh CVX]ljX]h`dcoZei! YVh kZg\Vc\ZcZ HV^hdc Y^Z YgZ^ CVi^dcVaZc AZ^hijc\hoZcigZc CAO ^c 7g^\! 9Vkdh jcY :c\ZaWZg\ b^i ^]gZc EVgicZghX]jaZc Vj[lZgiZiZ! ljgYZ VjX] ^b olZ^iZc ?V]g hZ^cZh 7ZhiZ]Zch `dchZfjZci jb\ZhZioi# >c YZc CAO! Y^Z cVX] Z^cZg AZ^hijc\hkZgZ^cWVgjc\ kdc Hl^hh"H`^ \Z[ ]gi lZgYZc! igV^c^ZgZc Y^Z -% WZhiZc 6i]aZi^ccZc jcY 6i]aZiZc YZg GZ\^dcZc LZhi! B^iiZ jcY Dhi# 9^Z olZ^iZ :WZcZ YZh CVX]ljX]h`dcoZeih H`^ Vae^c W^aYZc Y^Z GZ\^dcVaZc AZ^hijc\hoZcigZc GAO ! Y^Z Hl^hh"H`^ ^c OjhVbbZcVgWZ^i b^i YZc GZ\^dcVakZgW~cYZc kZg\Vc\ZcZh ?V]g lZ^iZg Vj[WVjiZ# 7ZgZ^ih `dcciZc hZX]h YZ[^c^i^kZ dYZg egdk^hdg^hX]Z AVWZah kZg\ZWZc lZgYZc# >c Y^Z" hZc IgV^c^c\hoZaaZc igV^c^ZgZc Y^Z WZhiZc ?D"6i]aZi^ccZc jcY "6i]aZiZc YZg GZ\^dcVakZgW~cYZ# >b GV]bZc YZg cVi^dcVaZc ?D"GZccZc! Y^Z Vj[\gjcY YZh :c\V\ZbZcih kdc DX]hcZg Hedgi cZj jciZg YZb CVbZc ºDX]hcZg Hedgi ?D 8je» aVj[Zc! ljgYZ YZg HX]lZgejc`i kZg" bZ]gi Vj[ Y^Z iZX]c^hX]Zc 9^ho^ea^cZc \ZaZ\i# 9Zh]VaW ljgYZc Z^c HaVadb jcY Z^c G^ZhZchaVadb ojh~ioa^X] YjgX]\Z[ ]gi# IdiVa

;did/ Hl^hh"H`^

VX]i cVi^dcVaZ GZccZc o~]aiZc ^c YZg HV^hdc '%%-$%. oj Y^ZhZg GZcchZg^Z# >b GV]bZc YZh DX]hcZg Hedgi ?D 8je [VcYZc Y^Z ?D"HX]lZ^oZgbZ^hiZghX]V[iZc ^c KZnhdccVo jcY Vj[ YZb Hiddh hiVii# 9^Z Zg[da\gZ^X]hiZc ?D"6i]aZiZc YZh DX]hcZg Hedgi ?D 8je '%%-$%. lVgZc 8dg^ccZ HjiZg jcY :bVcjZa 7ZaalVaY# >ch\ZhVbi [VcYZc ^c YZg HX]lZ^o l~]gZcY YZg HV^hdc '%%-$%. \Z" \Zc &%% DZga^`dc ;>H"GZccZc hiVii# 9^Z KZgVchiVaiZg `dcciZc YVc` YZg cZj Z^c\Z\Vc\ZcZc EVgicZghX]V[i b^i YZg ;^gbV D8 DZga^`dc ^c ^]gZc 7Zb ]jc\Zc! YZb H`^cVX]ljX]h dei^bVaZ GZccWZY^c\jc\Zc oj W^ZiZc! WZhhZg jciZghi ioi lZgYZc# 9^Z 9jgX][ ]gjc\ YZg DZga^`dc ;>H"GZccZc ^c YZg HX]lZ^o lVg Y^ZhZh ?V]g hZ]g hX]l^Zg^\# Hd bjhhiZc [ g Z^cbVa kZghX]^ZYZ" cZ GZccZc c^X]i lZ\Zc HX]cZZbVc\Zah! hdcYZgc Vj[\gjcY oj \gdhhZg HX]cZZbZc\Zc VW\ZhV\i dYZg kZghX]dWZc lZgYZc# 9Vc` YZh jcZci\Zaia^X]Zc :c\V\ZbZcih kdc jco~]a^\Zc H`^XajWh! H`^hX]jaZc jcY 7Zg\WV]cZc `dcciZ h^X] YZg H`^cVX]ljX]h igdioYZb Vc \ji dg\Vc^h^ZgiZc LZii`~be[Zc bZhhZc# O^cVa \^ai Zh WZhdcYZgh ]Zgkdgoj]ZWZc! YZcc Y^Z LVaa^hZg H`^hiVi^dc [ ]giZ \VcoZ &* ;>H"GZccZc 9VbZc jcY =ZggZc YjgX]#

&,

6c YZc ?jc^dgZclZaibZ^hiZghX]V[iZc ^c <Vgb^hX]"EVgiZc`^gX]Zc ZggZ^X]iZ Y^Z HX]lZ^oZg 9ZaZ\Vi^dc YZc Vjh\ZoZ^X]cZiZc olZ^" iZc HX]ajhhgVc\# <gjcYaV\Z Y^ZhZg \jiZc ?LB"7^aVco W^aYZiZ \aZ^X] oj 7Z\^cc YZg <Zl^cc YZg <daYbZYV^aaZ ^b HaVadb YjgX] 9Zc^hZ ;Z^ZgVWZcY# ; g Y^Z \gdhhZ zWZggVhX]jc\ hdg\" iZ HZee <ZgWZg/ CVX]YZb Zg Vah K^ZgiZg ^c YZg 6W[V]gi Z^cZ BZYV^aaZ `cVee kZgeVhhi ]ViiZ! [j]g YZg 7ZgcZg DWZga~cYZg ^c YZg @dbW^cVi^dc jcZglVgiZi Vj[ YZc &# EaVio#

:^cZ higV]aZcYZ 9Zc^hZ ;Z^ZgVWZcY [gZji h^X] WZg ^]gZ <daYbZYV^aaZ Vc YZc ?jc^dgZclZaibZ^hiZghX]V[iZc '%%. ^c <Vgb^hX]"EVgiZc`^gX]Zc#

6c YZc ^ciZgcVi^dcVaZc GZccZc ºIdeda^cd» \ZaVc\ Zh YZg 9ZaZ\Vi^dc kdc Hl^hh"H`^ b^i YZb )# GVc\ ^b CVi^dcZc`aVhhZ" bZci Z^c hZ]g \jiZh GZhjaiVi ]ZgVjhoj[V]gZc# 9^Z Zg[da\gZ^X]hiZ 6i]aZi^c Vjh HX]lZ^oZg H^X]i lVg HiZaaV ;gdcoVgda^! Y^Z b^i YZg H^aWZgbZYV^aaZ ^b 8dbW^"GVXZ hdl^Z YZg 7gdcoZbZYV^aaZ ^b G^ZhZchaVadb cVX] =VjhZ gZ^hiZ# ;did/ D@

9Zg DZga^`dc Hl^hh 8je! YZg WZ^ YZc =ZggZc Vjh h^ZWZc HaVadbh jcY G^ZhZchaVadbh hdl^Z YgZ^ HjeZg"<! WZ^ YZc 9VbZc Vjh [ c[ HaVadbh jcY G^ZhZchaVadbh hdl^Z k^Zg HjeZg"< WZhiZ]i! W^aYZi cVX] l^Z kdg Y^Z 7Vh^h [ g Y^Z HZaZ`i^dcZc [ g Y^Z CVi^dcVaZc AZ^hijc\hoZcigZc dYZg \Vg Y^Z Hl^hh"H`^ 8"@VYZg# CZj ljgYZc ^b GV]bZc YZh DZga^`dc Hl^hh 8je CVi^dcVaZ ?jc^dgZc GZccZc [ g Y^Z =ZggZc YZg ?V]g\~c\Z &..' W^h &..( Z^c\Z[ ]gi# H^Z hdaaZc YZc zWZg\Vc\ kdc YZg Hij[Z ?D oj YZc ?jc^dgZc kZgZ^c[VX]Zc jcY YZc _jc\Zc 6i]aZiZc bZ]g HiVgi\ZaZ\Zc]Z^iZc W^ZiZc# CVY^V Kd\Za jcY <VWg^Za 6ci]VbViiZc \ZlVccZc YZc Y^Zh_~]g^\Zc DZga^`dc Hl^hh 8je# >c EdaZc! \ZcVjZg \ZhV\i ^c HaVh` 7Zh`^Yn! [VcY b^i YZb :jgde~^hX]Zc ?j\ZcY Danbe^hX]Zc ;Zhi^kVa :ND; YZg ZghiZ \gdh" hZ ^ciZgcVi^dcVaZ KZg\aZ^X] ^b ?jc^dgZcWZgZ^X] > YZg HV^hdc hiVii# ?jhi^c Bjg^h^Zg Vjh EgVggZnZg \ZlVcc YZc HaVadb YZg B~ccZg jcY hdg\iZ b^i hZ^cZb Ig^jbe] [ g Y^Z Z^co^\Z BZYV^aaZ YZg Vae^cZc HX]lZ^oZg 9ZaZ\Vi^dc#

AVgV <ji ljgYZ Vj[\gjcY ^]gZg \jiZc AZ^hijc\Zc ^b ?V]g '%%- WZgZ^ih ojb olZ^iZc BVa kdc YZg HX]lZ^oZg Hedgi]^a[Z Vah CVX]ljX]hhedgiaZg^c YZh ?V]gZh Vjh\ZoZ^X]cZi# A^c`h ^]gZ ºHedgi]^a[Z"<diiZ» BVg^V LVaa^hZg ;did/ E]didegZhh

A:>HIJC<HHEDGI CDG9>H8=

&-

H`^ cdgY^hX]/ :g[da\gZ^X]Z hedgia^X]Z HV^hdc 9^Z HX]lZ^o WZgoZj\iZ Ã ^b <ZhVbilZaiXje jcY Vc YZc LZaibZ^hiZghX]V[iZc# :^cZghZ^ih hX]g^ZW 9Vg^d 8dad\cV b^i YZb H^Z\ ^b <ZhVbilZaiXje HX]lZ^oZg Hedgi\ZhX]^X]iZ! Vc" YZgZghZ^ih eg~\iZc HX]lZ^oZg H`^heg^c\Zg Y^Z HV^hdc b^i bZ]" gZgZc LZaiXjeh^Z\Zc jcY Z^cZb LZaibZ^hiZgi^iZa# :^co^\ ^c YZg CdgY^hX]Zc @dbW^cVi^dc `dcciZc Y^Z :glVgijc\Zc c^X]i \Vco Zg[ aai lZgYZc#

AVc\aVj[/ 9Vg^d 8dad\cV \Zl^cci <ZhVbilZaiXje 9^Z HX]lZ^oZg AVc\a~j[Zg hiZ^\ZgiZc h^X] WZgZ^ih ^c YZg KZg" \Vc\Zc]Z^i kdc HV^hdc oj HV^hdc# 9^Z H^Z\Z kdc 9Vg^d 8dad\cV ^b <ZhVbilZaiXje jcY Vc YZg egZhi^\Zig~X]i^\Zc Idjg YZ H`^ h^cY YZg kdga~j[^\Z = ]Zejc`i Y^ZhZg Zg[gZja^X]Zc :cil^X`ajc\ jcY \Z]Zc ^c Y^Z HX]lZ^oZg Hedgi\ZhX]^X]iZ Z^c#

Jb Vj[ Y^Z hidaoZ OV]a kdc ^ch\ZhVbi &.)+ LZaiXjeejc`iZc kdg olZ^ ?V]gZc lVgZc Zh cdX] *+( oj `dbbZc! WgVjX]iZ Zh VWZg cZWZc YZb IZVbaZVYZg 9Vg^d 8dad\cV VjX] Y^Z hZ]g \jiZc AZ^hijc\Zc YZh \VcoZc IZVbh# L~]gZcY Y^Z A~j[Zg YZg hiVg`Zc 9^hiVco\gjeeZ YZg B~ccZg b^i Idc^ A^kZgh! 8jgY^c EZga jcY GZbd ;^hX]Zg l^Z ^c YZc aZioiZc ?V]gZc \j" iZ AZ^hijc\Zc oZ^\iZc! lVgZc kdg VaaZb Y^Z GZhjaiViZ YZg _jc\Zc Heg^ciZg hZ]g Zg[gZja^X]# 6ah GZhjaiVi YZg `dci^cj^Zg" a^X]Zc 6j[WVjVgWZ^i YZg aZioiZc ?V]gZ ]Vi Y^Z HX]lZ^o c~X]h" iZh ?V]g ^b LZaiXje cZj hZX]h HiVgiea~ioZ kdg olZ^ ?V]gZc cdX] olZ^ # >ch\ZhVbi `dcciZc &+ Hl^hh"H`^ 6i]aZi^ccZc jcY "6i]aZiZc LZaiXjeejc`iZ ZgaVj[Zc# 9^Zh ^hi Z^cZ Zg[gZja^X]Z 7gZ^iZ [ g YZc HX]lZ^oZg AVc\aVj[# 6c YZg LB ^c A^WZgZX ljgYZ Z^cZ BZYV^aaZ cjg `cVee kZg[Z]ai# CZWZc 9Vg^d 8dad\cV oZ^\iZc VjX] Y^Z 9^hiVcoa~j[Zg ^c YZg HiV[[Za igdio HX]l^Zg^\`Z^iZc ^c YZg BViZg^ValV]a Z^cZ hda^YZ AZ^hijc\# 9^ZhZ GZhjaiViZ aVhhZc Vj[ Zg[da\gZ^X]Z Danbe^hX]Z He^ZaZ ^b c~X]hiZc ;ZWgjVg ^c KVcXdjkZg ]d[[Zc# 9Vh ;gVjZciZVb `~be[iZ l~]gZcY YZg \VcoZc HV^hdc b^i KZgaZiojc\hhdg\Zc jcY `dcciZ c^X]i bZ]g Vc Y^Z Zg[da\gZ^X]Z HV^hdc '%%,$%- Vc`c e[Zc# = ]Zejc`i YZg YjgX]od\ZcZc HV^hdc b^i &) Ide"(%"GZhjaiViZc lVg YZg H^Z\ kdc HZgV^cV B^hX]da Vb :c\VY^cZg H`^bVgVi]dc#

HZgV^cV B^hX]da \Zl^cci cVX] Z^cZg YjgX]od\ZcZc HV^hdc YZc :c\VY^cZg H`^bVgVi]dc# ;did/ CdgY^X ;dXjh

6Yg^Vcd >hZee^ ]Vi cVX] olZ^_~]g^\Zg I~i^\`Z^i Vah 9^ho^ea^cZcX]Z[ AVc\aVj[ eZg :cYZ ?ja^ '%%. hZ^cZc G X`ig^ii Z^c\ZgZ^X]i# 9^Z CVX][da\Z WZgc^bbi =^eedani @Zbe[! W^h]Zg^\Zg 9^ho^ea^cZcX]Z[ CdgY^hX]Z @dbW^cVi^dc jcY Hedgi `dcdb Vb 7jcYZhVbi [ g Hedgi 76HED ^c BV\\a^c\Zc# =^eedani @Zbe[ ^hi Z^cZ Zg[V]gZcZ ; ]gjc\heZgh ca^X]`Z^i jcY Z^c @ZccZg YZg HoZcZ jcY hdb^i Y^Z ^YZVaZ EZghdc! jb Y^Z 9^ho^ea^c AVc\aVj[ \ji ^c Y^Z Danbe^V" HV^hdc oj [ ]gZc# <ZbZ^chVb b^i YZc KZgVcildgia^X]Zc kdc Hl^hh"H`^ jcY YZc GZ\^dcZc l^gY @Zbe[ Y^Z Higj`ijgZc WZgeg " [Zc jcY Z^cZ ; ]gjc\hXgZl [ g Y^Z E]VhZ cVX] YZc Danbe^hX]Zc He^ZaZc ojhVbbZchiZaaZc#

&.

H^bdc 6bbVcc a^c`h [gZji h^X] b^i 6cYgZVh @ iiZa WZg YZhhZc LB"<daY Vj[ YZg \gdhhZc HX]VcoZ ^c A^WZgZX IhX]ZX]^Zc #

H`^hegjc\/ 6cYgZVh @ iiZa l^gY LZaibZ^hiZg 9Vh H`^hegjc\"IZVb jciZg YZg cZjZc AZ^ijc\ YZh _jc\Zc HX]lZ^oZg 8]Z[igV^cZgh BVgi^c @ coaZ `dcciZ ^c YZg kZg\Vc" \ZcZc HV^hdc \gdhhVgi^\Z :g[da\Z [Z^Zgc/ H^bdc 6bbVcc \Z" lVcc Y^Z 7gdcoZbZYV^aaZ Vj[ YZg CdgbVahX]VcoZ Vc YZc LZaibZ^hiZghX]V[iZc ^c A^WZgZX! [Z^ZgiZ [ c[ LZaiXjeh^Z\Z jcY hiVcY lZ^iZgZ ol a[ BVa Vj[ YZb EdYZhi# OjYZb WZaZ\iZ Zg hd" ld]a Vc YZg K^ZghX]VcoZcidjgcZZ Vah VjX] ^b <ZhVbilZaiXje YZc ]ZgkdggV\ZcYZc olZ^iZc GVc\ jcY WZgoZj\iZ b^i YZc WZ^YZc Yg^iiZc G~c\Zc ^b <ZhVbi`aVhhZbZci WZ^b CdgY^X"IdjgcVbZci jcY ^b H`^[aj\"LZaiXje# 6cYgZVh @ iiZa `g ciZ Y^Z HV^hdc b^i YZb LZaibZ^hiZgi^iZa Vj[ YZg \gdhhZc HX]VcoZ ^c A^WZgZX# 9^Z @dci^cj^i~i ^b IgV^c^c\hhnhiZb ]Vi h^X] igdio YZb IgV^cZglZX]hZa kdc LZgcZg HX]jhiZg oj BVgi^c @ coaZ VjhWZoV]ai# CZWZc YZc WZ^YZc Ide"6i]aZiZc hX]a^Zhhi VjX] Y^Z º_jc\Z <VgYZ» aVc\hVb Vj[# >b IZVbheg^c\Zc kdc AV]i^ lVg ojb ZghiZc BVa ^c

;did/ CdgY^X ;dXjh

Y^ZhZg HV^hdc VjX] Z^c Hl^hh"H`^ IZVb ^b :^chVio# 6cYgZVh @ iiZa! H^bdc 6bbVcc! EVhXVa :\ad[[ jcY 6Yg^Vc HX]jaZg WZaZ\iZc YZc k^Za kZghegZX]ZcYZc &%# GVc\# :h ^hi \ZeaVci! YVhh YVh IZVb VjX] ^c YZg `dbbZcYZc HV^hdc kZgbZ]gi ojb :^chVio `dbbi# 6c YZg ?j\ZcY Danbe^VYZ :ND; ^c EdaZc \ZlVcc 6Yg^Vc HX]jaZg Y^Z 7gdcoZbZYV^aaZ ^b :^coZaheg^c\Zc! jcY VjX] ^b IZVb" lZii`Vbe[ hegVc\Zc Y^Z HX]lZ^oZg Vj[h EdYZhi# 9Vh \gdhhZ EdiZci^Va YZg _jc\Zc <ZcZgVi^dc kdc H`^heg^c\Zgc ^c YZc ?V]g\~c\Zc &..& W^h &..* hi^bbi ojkZgh^X]ia^X] [ g Y^Z Oj`jc[i# 9Vh ;gVjZc"H`^heg^c\Zc ]Vi h^X] ZWZc[Vaah Zg[gZja^X] lZ^iZg" Zcil^X`Zai# Kdga~j[^\Zg = ]Zejc`i lVgZc Y^Z ZghiZc LZaibZ^hiZg" hX]V[iZc ^c A^WZgZX b^i YZb VchegZX]ZcYZc &)# GVc\ kdc 7^\cV L^cYb aaZg# >]gZ IZVb`daaZ\^ccZc HVWg^cV L^cY" b aaZg jcY BVa^`V HX] eWVX] ]ViiZc KZgaZiojc\heZX] jcY bjhhiZc Y^Z HV^hdc kdgoZ^i^\ WZZcYZc#

A:>HIJC<HHEDGI CDG9>H8=

'%

CdgY^hX]Z @dbW^cVi^dc/ :glVgijc\Zc c^X]i \Vco Zg[ aai 9^Z hZ]g \jiZc GZhjaiViZ ^b HdbbZg <gVcY Eg^m! Gdccn =ZZg ljgYZ OlZ^iZg jcY HZee^ =jghX]aZg ZggZ^X]iZ YZc hZX]h" iZc GVc\ ^c YZg <ZhVbilZgijc\! lZX`iZc [ g YZc L^ciZg ]d" ]Z :glVgijc\Zc# 9Vh =ZgWhiigV^c^c\ `dcciZ eaVcb~hh^\ jcY d]cZ KZgaZiojc\Zc YjgX]\Z[ ]gi lZgYZc# 9ZccdX] kZga^Z[ YZg LZaiXjeVj[iV`i c^X]i cVX] LjchX]# 9Vh IZVb hX]V[[iZ Y^Z Vc\ZhigZWiZc gZ\Zab~hh^\Zc Ide IZc GVc\^Zgjc\Zc c^X]i# Cjg Gdccn =ZZg ZggZ^X]iZ Y^ZhZh O^Za à b^i Z^cZb [ c[" iZc GVc\ ^c HZZ[ZaY jcY Z^cZb cZjciZc EaVio ^c DWZg]d[# 9Vh IZVb YZg @dbW^c^ZgZg `dcciZ h^X] YZccdX] WZg ;dgihX]g^iiZ [gZjZc# C^X]i lZc^\Zg Vah hZX]h 6i]aZiZc hX]V[[iZc Zh ^c Y^Z LZaiXjeejc`iZ! jcY Y^Zh dWhX]dc I]dbbn HX]b^Y! YZg 6j[hiZ^\Zg YZh kZg\Vc\Zc L^ciZgh! Vjh \ZhjcY]Z^ia^X]Zc <g cYZc cjg hZ]g lZc^\ Z^c\ZhZioi lZgYZc `dcciZ# >chWZhdcYZgZ Y^Z _jc\Zc 6i]aZiZc I^b =j\ jcY ?dZa 7^Zg^ bVX]iZc ;dgihX]g^iiZ jcY ZiVWa^ZgiZc h^X] ^b LZaiXje# 6c YZc LZaibZ^hiZghX]V[iZc ^c A^WZgZX ljgYZc Y^Z O^ZaZ b^i Z^cZb &)# jcY '%# GVc\ YjgX] Gdccn =ZZg jcY HZee^ =jghX]aZg c^X]i ZggZ^X]i# 7ZhhZg Zg\^c\ Zh ?dZa 7^Zg^! YZg Vc YZc ?jc^dgZclZaibZ^hiZghX]V[iZc \jiZg HZX]hiZg ljgYZ# 9^Z 9^ho^ea^c CdgY^hX]Z @dbW^cVi^dc ]Vi YVh ZghiZ ?V]g b^i YZb kZgZ^c[VX]iZc LZii`Vbe[gZ\aZbZci ]^ciZg h^X]# 9Vh cZjZ ;dgbVi b^i cjg Z^cZb Hegjc\ jcY Z^cZb VchX]a^ZhhZcYZc &% `b LZii`Vbe[ ]Vi h^X] WZl~]gi# 9^Z HX]lZ^o ]Va[ WZ^ Y^ZhZg :cil^X`ajc\ iVi`g~[i^\ b^i# :^ch^ZYZac [ ]giZ ^b HdbbZg cVX] aVc\Zg 6WhZco l^ZYZg Z^cZ :cihX]Z^Yjc\ ^c YZg CdgY^hX]Zc @dbW^cVi^dc Vj[ ^ciZgcVi^dcVaZb Ide C^kZVj YjgX]# 9Zg :g[da\ jchZgZg 6i]aZiZc kdg ]Z^b^hX]Zb EjWa^`jb oZ^\iZ! l^Z k^Za EdiZci^Va ^b HX]lZ^oZg IZVb hiZX`i#

=ZakZi^V CdgY^X Igde]n/ C^X]i bZ]g lZ\ojYZc`Zc Ojb k^ZgoZ]ciZc BVa ljgYZ ^c YZg kZg\Vc\ZcZc HV^hdc Y^Z =ZakZi^V CdgY^X Igde]n YjgX]\Z[ ]gi# >c YZc 9^ho^ea^cZc

Gdccn =ZZg Zga^Z[ jcY ZghegVc\ h^X] Vc YZc LZaibZ^hiZghX]V[iZc ^c A^WZgZX GVc\ &)# ;did/ CdgY^X ;dXjh

H`^hegjc\! CdgY^hX]Z @dbW^cVi^dc jcY AVc\aVj[ ]ViiZc Y^Z _jc\Zc CVX]ljX]hVi]aZiZc Y^Z B \a^X]`Z^i! ZghiZ LZii`Vbe[Zg[V]gjc\Zc oj hVbbZac jcY h^X] b^i <aZ^X]Vaig^\Zc oj bZhhZc# :gb \a^X]i l^gY Y^Z =ZakZi^V CdgY^X Igde]n YjgX] I^iZahedchdg =ZakZi^V KZgh^X]Zgjc\Zc! lZaX]Zg Y^Z HZg^Z WZgZ^ih ^b k^ZgiZc ?V]g jc" iZghi ioi! YZb aVc\_~]g^\Zc 8d"Hedchdg ;^hX]Zg hdl^Z YZb :c\V\ZbZci YZg dg\Vc^h^ZgZcYZc H`^"8ajWh# >ch\ZhVbi [VcYZc k^Zg KZgVchiVaijc\Zc [ g Y^Z AVc\a~j[Zg jcY oZ]c 6ca~hhZ [ g Y^Z Heg^c\Zg jcY @dbW^c^ZgZg hiVii! ldkdc k^Zg HdbbZglZii`~be[Z lVgZc# 9^Z J&+ HB H`^hegjc\ jcY CdgY^hX]Z @dbW^cVi^dc ljgYZ ^c YZg HV^hdc '%%-$%. Vjh YZb L^ciZg`VaZcYZg \Zhig^X]Zc jcY ^c YZc HZeiZbWZg kdgkZgaZ\i# Oj YZc =^\]a^\]ih o~]aiZc Y^Z J&)" jcY J&+"HX]lZ^oZgbZ^hiZg" hX]V[iZc ^b AVc\aVj[# 9^ZhZ ljgYZc ^c YZg @ViZ\dg^Z J&) kdc A^k^V 6bW ]a jcY <^VXdbd 7VhhZii^ jcY ^c YZg @ViZ\dg^Z J&+ kdc B^X]ZaaZ <VgWZan jcY GdbVc HX]VVY \ZldccZc# :^c lZ^iZ" gZg = ]Zejc`i lVgZc Y^Z =ZakZi^V CdgY^X <VbZh ^c OlZ^h^bbZc! Y^Z Z^cZghZ^ih b^i k^Za HeVhh! VcYZgZghZ^ih VWZg VjX] b^i Z^cZb heVccZcYZc LZii`Vbe[ WZg Y^Z 7 ]cZ \^c\Zc# >b H`^hegjc\ jcY ^c YZg CdgY^hX]Zc @dbW^cVi^dc Ydb^c^ZgiZc Da^kZg 6c`Zc jcY HkZc ;VlZg ^c YZg @ViZ\dg^Z J&+# 9^Z HV^hdc ljgYZ B^iiZ B~go b^i YZb \gdhhZc ;^cVaZ ^c 8]Vjm"CZjkZ WZZcYZi#

'&

7^Vi]adc/ <aVcoa^X]iZg ^c hX]l^Zg^\Zg HV^hdc Hl^hh"H`^ 7^Vi]adc Wa^X`i Vj[ Y^Z ld]a Zg[da\gZ^X]hiZ HV^hdc WZg" ]Vjei ojg X`# 7^Vi]adc ^hi ^c YZg 7gZ^iZ \ZlVX]hZc jcY jchZgZ HedgiaZg ]VWZc Y^Z ZghiZc WZVX]ia^X]Zc ^ciZgcVi^dcVaZc :g[da\Z Z^c\Z[V]gZc# BVii]^Vh H^bbZc \ZlVcc 7gdcoZ Vc YZg HdbbZg"LB ^c =VjiZ"BVjg^ZccZ! 7Zc_Vb^c LZ\Zg YZ`dg^ZgiZ h^X] b^i olZ^ H^aWZgbZYV^aaZc ^b HdbbZg jcY Z^cZg H^aWZgbZYV^aaZ Vc YZc ?jc^dgZclZaibZ^hiZghX]V[iZc ^b `VcVY^hX]Zc 8VcbdgZ ^b L^ciZg! BVg^d 9daYZg ]daiZ Vc \aZ^X]Zg HiZaaZ 7gdcoZ! >gZcZ 8VYjg^hX] `Z]g" iZ b^i Z^cZg h^aWZgcZc jcY Z^cZg WgdcoZcZc 6jhoZ^X]cjc\ kdc YZg :ND; ^c EdaZc cVX] =VjhZ# >ch\ZhVbi h^ZWZc BZYV^aaZc jb[Vhhi Y^Z 6jhWZjiZ YZg kZghX]^ZYZcZc I^iZa`~be[Z ^b HdbbZg jcY ^b L^ciZg! olZ^ Ide IZc"Ea~ioZ Vc YZg LB YjgX] H^bdc =VaaZcWVgiZg jcY Y^Z HX]lZ^oZg HiV[[Za! lZ^iZgZ Ide IZc" jcY Ide '%"Ea~ioZ ^b LZaiXje YjgX] :^coZaVi]aZiZc jcY Y^Z BVcchX]V[i! ZghibVa^\Zg Ejc`iZ\Zl^cc YjgX] HZa^cV <VheVg^c ^b ;gVjZc"LZaiXje! H^Z\ jcY He^ioZcg~c\Z ^b >7J 8je jcY WZg )% IZ^acZ]bZcYZ Vc Z^cZg HX]lZ^oZg BZ^hiZghX]V[i#

HZa^cV <VheVg^c `~be[i WZ^b 9VbZc":^coZagZccZc Vc YZg 7^Vi]adc"LB ^c EnZdc\X]Vc\ @dgZV # ;did/ CdgY^X ;dXjh

K^ZaZ 6jh[~aaZ ^c l^X]i^\hiZg E]VhZ 9ZccdX] Wa^X`Zc Y^Z 7^Vi]aZiZc Vj[ Z^cZ hX]l^Zg^\Z HV^hdc ojg X`# 9jgX] `gVc`]Z^ihWZY^c\iZ 6jh[~aaZ egV`i^hX] YZg `dbeaZiiZc :a^iZ"BVcchX]V[i l~]gZcY YZg egZhi^\Zig~X]i^" \Zc olZ^iZc LZaiXjeeZg^dYZ! Zci\^c\Zc l^X]i^\Z Ejc`iZ ^b CVi^dcZc`aVhhZbZci# 9Zg Vc\ZhigZWiZ oZ]ciZ EaVio bjhhiZ ^c YZg ;da\Z hX]dc [g ] Vj[\Z\ZWZc lZgYZc# 9Vc` Z^cZg hZ]g Zg" [da\gZ^X]Zc LZaibZ^hiZghX]V[i ^c EnZdc\X]Vc\ jcY Z^cZh Zg[gZj" a^X]Zc HV^hdcVWhX]ajhhZh hi^Zhh Y^Z HX]lZ^o YdX] cdX] Vj[ EaVio && kdg# 9^Z )*(- Ejc`iZ ,%% bZ]g Vah ^b Kdg_V]g \VgVci^ZgZc Hl^hh"H`^"7^Vi]adc VjX] ^c YZg c~X]hiZc HV^hdc [ c[ HiVgiea~ioZ ^b LZaiXje# HeZZghe^ioZ YZh :g[da\Zh lVg H^bdc =VaaZcWVgiZg# 9Zg DWZg\dbbZg oZ^\iZ Y^Z `dchiVciZhiZ AZ^hijc\ YZh IZVbh! Zgo^ZaiZ Vc YZg LB Y^Z WZhiZc GZhjaiViZ jcY hegZc\iZ WZ^b ;^cVaZ cdX]" bVah Y^Z WZhiZc oZ]c# >b <ZhVbi`aVhhZbZci hX]V[[iZ Zg Zh ZgcZji ^c Y^Z '* WZhiZc Heg^ciZg YZg LZai# 9jgX] Y^Z Zg[da\gZ^X]Z LB

jcY VjX] Y^Z edh^i^kZc GZhjaiViZ kdc HZa^cV <VheVg^c ZggZ^X]Zc Y^Z 7^Vi]aZiZc ojYZb YVh ;Zgco^Za Z^cZg kdaaZc Danbe^V"FjdiZ/ ) eajh & 6i]aZi WZ^ YZc =ZggZc jcY & 6i]aZi^c WZ^ YZc ;gVjZc#

HX]lZ^olZ^i ^b KdgbVghX] 6aa Y^ZhZ @Zcco^[[Zgc WZaZ\Zc Z^cZc hiZiZc 6j[l~gihigZcY YZg HedgiVgi 7^Vi]adc ^c YZg HX]lZ^o# 6j[ cVi^dcVaZg :WZcZ ZggZ^X]" iZ Y^Z GLH @^YoIgde]n ZghibVah WZg &%%% HiVgih Vc YZc &' LZii`~be[Zc jcY YZg GLH Hl^hh"8je ljgYZ aZioiZc L^ciZg ^b 9jgX]hX]c^ii kdc gjcY (% 6i]aZi>ccZc WZhjX]i# @ c[i^\ higZWi Hl^hh"H`^ cjc WZ^ YZc @aZ^chiZc Z^cZ fjVa^iVi^kZ HiZ^\Zgjc\ Vc! ^cYZb Y^Z 6coV]a LZii`~be[Z gZYjo^Zgi! VWZg YZgZc >c]VaiZ kZg" WZhhZgi lZgYZc# OjYZb hdaa Y^Z cVi^dcVaZ HZg^Z GLH Hl^hh 8je lZ^iZg Vc Jb[Vc\ ojcZ]bZc#

A:>HIJC<HHEDGI HCDL7D6G9

''

HcdlWdVgY/ :g[da\Z ^c VaaZc 9^ho^ea^cZc K^Zg LZaiXjeh^Z\Z! Za[ lZ^iZgZ EdYZhiea~ioZ jcY k^Zg LB"BZYV^aaZc ร Y^Zh Y^Z 7^aVco kdc Hl^hh"HcdlWdVgY ^c YZg HV^hdc '%%-$%.# Kdg VaaZb Y^Z 9VbZc igjbe[iZc b^i \jiZc AZ^hijc\Zc Vj[# B^i BZaa^Z ;gVcXdc LB"7gdcoZ !

Da^k^V CdWh LB"H^aWZg ! HVcYgV ;gZ^! IVc_V ;g^ZYZc jcY H^bdcV BZ^aZg kZg[ย \i Y^Z HX]lZ^o ld]a ย WZg YVh bdbZc" iVc hi~g`hiZ 8gdhh"IZVb# 9Vc` olZ^ lZ^iZgZc LB"BZYV^aaZc kdc EVig^o^V @jbbZg LB"7gdcoZ ^b EVgVaaZag^ZhZchaVadb E<H jcY ;g~co^ B~\Zgi"@d]a^ LB"<daY ^b EVgVaaZahaVadb EHA WZ" ZcYZiZ Y^Z HX]lZ^o Y^Z LB ^b hย Y`dgZVc^hX]Zc <Vc\ldc Vj[ GVc\ '#

;gVjZcedlZg ^b HcdlWdVgYXgdhh 9Vh 9VbZc"IZVb HcdlWdVgYXgdhh oZ^\iZ Z^cZ cdX] hi~g`ZgZ HV^hdc Vah ^c YZc Kdg_V]gZc/ Da^k^V CdWh! BZaa^Z ;gVcXdc jcY HVcYgV ;gZ^ hdg\iZc YVc` EdYZhiea~ioZc ^b LZaiXje jcY Vc YZg LB ^c <Vc\ldc [ย g oj[g^ZYZcZ <Zh^X]iZg WZ^ Hl^hh"HcdlWdVgY# 9Vh WZgZ^ih hX]dc hiVg`Z LZaiXje"IZVb! oj YZb VjX] Y^Z K^ZgieaVio^ZgiZ YZh LZaiXjegZccZch ^c 6gdhV! H^bdcV BZ^aZg! \Z" ]ย gi! l^gY c~X]hiZ HV^hdc YjgX] Y^Z :jgdeVXje"<ZhVbih^Z\Zg^c :bZa^Z 6jWgn Zg\~coi# 6jX] Y^Z =ZggZc ]VWZc h^X] ^b KZg\aZ^X] ojb Kdg_V]g \ZhiZ^\Zgi/ B^i ;VW^d 8VYj[[! YZg Vc YZg LB YZc =VaW[^cVaZ^coj\ cjg `cVee kZgeVhhi ]ViiZ! l~X]hi Z^c ;V]gZg ]Z" gVc! YZg b^i YZg LZaihe^ioZ b^i]VaiZc `Vcc#

Kdc Hl^hh"H`^ oj Hl^hh"HcdlWdVgY 9^Z HcdlWdVgYZg kdc Hl^hh"H`^ igZiZc hZ^i Y^ZhZg HV^hdc jc" iZg YZb CVbZc ยบHl^hh"HcdlWdVgYยป Vj[# 9^Z :^c[ย ]gjc\ YZg JciZgbVg`Z ยบHl^hh"HcdlWdVgYยป ^hi Z^c l^X]i^\Zg HX]g^ii [ย g Y^Z HcdlWdVgYZg ^ccZg]VaW kdc Hl^hh"H`^ jcY ย [[cZi Iย gZc [ย g Z^cZ cdX] Zc\ZgZ OjhVbbZcVgWZ^i b^i YZg HcdlWdVgY"HoZcZ# 9^Z JbhZiojc\ kdc Hl^hh"HcdlWdVgY ^hi cdX] c^X]i VW\ZhX]adhhZc0 hd ^hi VjX] Z^cZ cZjZ LZWh^iZ lll#hl^hh"hcdlWdVgY#X] ^b [gZX]Zc! [g^hX]Zc Add` \ZeaVci! YZg Y^Z HcdlWdVgY 8dbbjc^in heZo^Zaa VchegZX]Zc hdaa#

Ojb 6j[iV`i Z^c Gย X`ig^ii 9^Z HV^hdc '%%-$%. WZ\Vcc b^i Z^cZb Gย X`ig^ii/ BVcjZaV EZh`d! k^Zg[VX]Z LZaiXje"9^ho^ea^cZch^Z\Zg^c =Va[e^eZ! \VW ojb 6j[iV`i YZg HcdlWdVgY"HV^hdc ^]gZc Gย X`ig^ii kdb He^ioZchedgi WZ`Vcci# B^i ^]gZb Gย X`ig^ii hdl^Z YZb kZgaZiojc\hWZY^c\iZc 6jh[Vaa kdc IVc_V ;g^ZYZc jcY E]^a^ee HX]dX] bjhhiZ Hl^hh" HcdlWdVgY ^c YZg kZg\Vc\ZcZc HV^hdc \aZ^X] Vj[ YgZ^ ediZco^Za" aZ BZYV^aaZcVcl~giZg kZgo^X]iZc! lVh h^X] ^c YZg ;da\Z VjX] Vj[ Y^Z 7^aVco kdc Hl^hh"HcdlWdVgY Vjhl^g`iZ/ >b KZg\aZ^X] ojg kdg" ]Zg^\Zc HV^hdc ljgYZc lZc^\Zg EdYZhiea~ioZ jcY LZaiXjeh^Z\Z Zgo^Zai# Edh^i^k oj lZgiZc h^cY _ZYdX] ^chWZhdcYZgZ Y^Z k^Zg LB"BZYV^aaZc kdc <Vc\ldc hdl^Z Y^Z IVihVX]Z! YVhh ^c Va" aZc 9^ho^ea^cZc _jc\Z ;V]gZg Y^Z Vgg^k^ZgiZc 6i]aZi^ccZc jcY 6i]aZiZc jciZg 9gjX` hZioiZc#

=dX]h jcY I^Z[h WZ^ YZc 6ae^cZc H^bdc HX]dX] lVg YZg Z^co^\Z HX]lZ^oZg! YZg ^c Y^ZhZb L^ciZg Vj[h EdYZhi hiZ^\Zc `dcciZ# >c @gZ^hX]WZg\ \ZlVcc Zg YZc EVgVaaZahaVadb EHA jcY ljgYZ OlZ^iZg ^b EVgVaaZag^ZhZchaVadb E<H # 6chdchiZc he^ZaiZc HX]dX] jcY hZ^cZ @daaZ\Zc WZ^b @Vbe[ jb He^ioZcea~ioZ `Z^cZ ZcihX]Z^YZcYZ GdaaZ# 6jX] WZ^ YZc Vae^cZc 9VbZc ^hi Y^Z 7^aVco YjgX]od\Zc# 6c YZg LB ljgYZ ;g~co^ B~\Zgi" @d]a^ hZchVi^dcZaa LZaibZ^hiZg^c ^b EHA jcY EVig^o^V @jbbZg ]daiZ 7gdcoZ ^b E<H# >b LZaiXje ]^c\Z\Zc `dcciZc Y^Z WZ^YZc c^X]i Wg^aa^ZgZc# 9V[ย g hdg\iZ YVh CVX]ljX]hiVaZci ?ja^Z Od\\ [ย g ;jgdgZ/ 9^Z &,"?~]g^\Z \ZlVcc Vc YZg ?jc^dgZc"LB Z^cZ <daY" jcY Z^" cZ H^aWZgbZYV^aaZ# JcY VjX] WZ^ YZc =ZggZc ]VWZc olZ^ _jc\Z ;V]gZg [ย g iZVb^ciZgcZc 9gjX` \Zhdg\i/ CZk^c <VabVg^c^ jcY @VheVg ;aย ihX] ZggZ^X]iZc ^]gZ ZghiZc Ide IZc"Ea~ioZ jcY kZgbdX]iZc h^X] YVb^i ZWZc[Vaah [ย g Y^Z LB oj fjVa^[^o^ZgZc#

:g[da\gZ^X]Z ;gZZhinaZg >ch\ZhVbi `Vcc YVh HX]lZ^oZg ;gZZhinaZ"IZVb Vj[ Z^cZ Zg" [da\gZ^X]Z HV^hdc ojgย X`Wa^X`Zc# HZX]h LZaiXje"EdYZhiea~ioZ k^Zg ^c YZg =Va[e^eZ! olZ^ ^b 7^\ 6^g YjgX] [ย c[ kZghX]^ZYZcZ 6i]aZiZc oZj\Zc kdc YZg 7gZ^iZ YZh IZVbh# =^coj `dbbZc Z^" c^\Z :mead^ih Vj[ YZg IIG"Idjg! ZilV 8da^c ;gZ^h Ig^jbe] Vb 6^g HinaZ ^c >cchWgjX` dYZg Y^Z EdYZhiea~ioZ kdc H^cV 8VcYg^Vc jcY >djg^ EdYaVYiX]^`dk Vb :jgdeZVc DeZc ^c AVVm#

'(

CVX]ljX]h ]Z^oi YZc 6gg^k^ZgiZc Z^c B^i ^]gZb H^Z\ Vc YZg HX]lZ^oZgbZ^hiZghX]V[i ^c Hea \Zc! Vah h^Z Y^Z LB"7gdcoZ\Zl^ccZg^c EVig^o^V @jbbZg ^b ;^cVaZ \ZhX]aV\Zc ]ViiZ! hZioiZ ?ja^Z Od\\ YVh ^"I e[X]Zc Vj[ ^]" gZ Zg[da\gZ^X]Z HV^hdc# JcY b^i olZ^ <daYbZYV^aaZc Vc YZc olZ^ l^X]i^\hiZc CVX]ljX]hlZii`~be[Zc oZ^\iZ h^Z! YVhh h^Z c^X]i cjg [V]gZg^hX]Z hdcYZgc VjX] iV`i^hX]Z FjVa^i~iZc ]Vi# :WZc[Vaah Z^c KZghegZX]Zc [ g Y^Z Oj`jc[i ^hi :b^a^Z 6jWgn! YZgZc :g[da\Z ^b :jgdeVXje ^b HX]ViiZc YZg hiVg`Zc HX]lZ^oZg 8gdhh";V]gZg^ccZc WZ^cV]Z jciZg\^c\Zc/ 9^Z [gVco h^hX]hegV" X]^\Z 7ZgcZg^c \ZlVcc hZX]h :jgdeVXje"GZccZc! `aVhh^Zg" iZ h^X] olZ^bVa Vj[ GVc\ olZ^ jcY \ZlVcc WZgaZ\Zc Y^Z <ZhVbilZgijc\# 6c YZg HB ljgYZ h^Z ojYZb cdX] kdg BZaa^Z ;gVcXdc OlZ^iZ# :^c lZ^iZgZg CVbZ! YZc bVc h^X] [ g Y^Z Oj`jc[i bZg`Zc hdaaiZ/ CZk^c <VabVg^c^# 9Zg ''"_~]g^\Z 7 cYcZg ljg" YZ WZ^ hZ^cZb olZ^iZc LZaiXjeZ^chVio ^c A^bdcZ E^ZbdciZ HZX]hiZg jcY fjVa^[^o^ZgiZ h^X] YVb^i [ g Y^Z LB ^c <Vc\ldc# 6jhhZgYZb \ZlVcc Zg Vc YZc HX]lZ^oZgbZ^hiZghX]V[iZc ^c Hea \Zc YZc HB"I^iZa#

HcdlWdVgY kdg ]Z^b^hX]Zg @ja^hhZ Igdio YZg hX]l^Zg^\Zc 7ZY^c\jc\Zc! Y^Z Y^Z 6i]aZi^ccZc jcY 6i]aZiZc Vc YZc ;>H L8 KZgVchiVaijc\Zc ^c HVVh ;ZZ

=Va[e^eZ jcY 6gdhV HcdlWdVgYXgdhh jcY EVgVaaZahaVadb kdg" [VcYZc Vc]VaiZcYZg HX]cZZ[Vaa! L^cYW Zc! ZiX# ! \^c\Zc Y^Z LZii`~be[Z YVc` YZg Vjh\ZoZ^X]cZiZc 6gWZ^i YZg D@h eaVc" b~hh^\ WZg Y^Z 7 ]cZ# B^i YZg ;a^bhZg^c HVcYgV ;gZ^ \ZlVcc ojYZb Z^cZ Hl^hh"HcdlWdVgY"KZgigZiZg^c Y^Z <daYbZYV^aaZ ^b HcdlWdVgYXgdhh#

7gZ^iZchedgi HcdlWdVgY/ 6j[ YZg ?V\Y cVX] CVX]ljX]hiVaZciZc B^i YZg BddkZ HnbeVcn Hcdl HZg^Zh kZg[ \i Hl^hh"HcdlWdVgY WZg Z^cZ hZ]g Zg[da\gZ^X]Z jcY WZa^ZWiZ cVi^dcVaZ Idjg! YZ" gZc @Zgchi X` Y^Z CVX]ljX]h" jcY 7gZ^iZchedgi"GZccZc Vj[ Hij[Z :jgdeVXje! ;>H jcY DeZc h^cY# :ghibVah lVgZc cZWhi YZc HcdlWdVgYZgc VjX] Y^Z ;gZZh`^Zg jcY ^]gZ kZghX]^ZYZ" cZc 9^ho^ea^cZc =Va[e^eZ! 7^\ 6^g! HadeZ HinaZ ^c Y^Z \g hhiZ HX]lZ^oZg HcdlWdVgY" jcY ;gZZh`^"Idjg ^ciZ\g^Zgi! Y^Z hdb^i oZ]c 9^ho^ea^cZc! VX]i @ViZ\dg^Zc jcY WZg )* GZccZc jb" [Vhhi# 9Vc` YZc Vjh\ZoZ^X]cZiZc HX]cZZWZY^c\jc\Zc `dcc" iZc W^h Vj[ olZ^ h~bia^X]Z GZccZc WZ^ eZg[Z`iZc KZg]~aic^hhZc YjgX]\Z[ ]gi lZgYZc! hd k^ZaZ l^Z cdX] c^Z ^c YZg k^Zg_~]g^\Zc <ZhX]^X]iZ YZg Hcdl HZg^Zh# LZ^iZg]^c WZa^ZWi h^cY VjX] Y^Z Vah IVaZcih^X]ijc\h":kZcih `dco^e^ZgiZc =ZVY]jci"9Vnh! Y^Z ^c h^ZWZc GZ\^dcZc YjgX]\Z[ ]gi ljgYZc#

9^Z HcdlWdVgYZg kZgYVc`Zc ^]gZ WjX]hi~Wa^X]Zc = ]Zc[a \Z YZg 7gZ^iZ ^c ^]gZb IZVb#

;did/ @ZnhidcZ

A:>HIJC<HHEDGI ;G::HINA:

')

;gZZhinaZ/ B^i Kdaa\Vh G^X]ijc\ KVcXdjkZg :^c ?V]g kdg KVcXdjkZg '%&% h^cY jchZgZ ;gZZhinaZg Vj[ @jgh/ :kZancZ AZj hegVc\ WZ^ YZg Danbe^V"=VjeiegdWZ ^c 8negZhh BdjciV^c @VcVYV ojdWZghi Vj[h EdYZhi! l~]gZcY VjX] Y^Z H`^XgdhhZg olZ^bVa Z^cZc LZaiXjeh^Z\ gZVa^h^ZgiZc# OjYZb ]daiZ zWZg[a^Z\Zg^c K^g\^c^Z ;V^kgZ ^c YZg =Va[e^eZ LB"<daY#

H`^XgdhhZg h^cY ]Z^hh Vj[ Danbe^V"EgZb^ZgZ Ojb HV^hdc]^\]a^\]i YZg H`^Xgdhh";V]gZg^ccZc jcY "[V]gZg o~]a" iZc Y^Z =Z^b"LZaiXjegZccZc ^b 7ZgcZg DWZgaVcY! ld YZg HVVcZg 6cYgZVh HiZ[[Zc h^Z\iZ jcY HVccV A Y^ 9g^iiZ ljgYZ# LZ^iZgZ EdYZhiea~ioZ ^b LZaiXje Zgo^ZaiZc B^`Z HX]b^Y! YZg Z^cbVa <daY jcY Z^cbVa 7gdcoZ \ZlVcc! hdl^Z :b^a^Z HZgV^c jcY 6gb^c

C^ZYZgZg# C^ZYZgZg \^ai Vah 6j[hiZ^\Zg YZg HV^hdc# 9Zg 7 cYcZg ^hi YZg _ c\hiZ 6i]aZi! YZg ^b LZaiXje _Z Z^cZc EdYZhieaVio Zgo^Zai ]Vi# HZ^cZ Zg[da\gZ^X]Z HV^hdc WZZcYZiZ YZg ''"?~]g^\Z b^i YZb <Zl^cc YZh HX]lZ^oZgbZ^hiZgi^iZah ^c 9^hZci^h# DWld]a Y^Z He^ioZ ^b H`^Xgdhh ^ciZgcVi^dcVa ojcZ]bZcY WgZ^iZg l^gY! Y g[Zc h^X] Y^Z HX]lZ^oZg lZ^iZg]^c WZgZX]i^\iZ =d[[cjc\Zc Vj[ danbe^hX]Z BZYV^aaZc bVX]Zc#

8dde H`^Xgdhh Idjg [ g ;jc[V]gZg jcY 8gVX`h :cYZ ?VcjVg hiVgiZiZ Y^Z 8dde H`^Xgdhh Idjg ^c OlZ^h^bbZc b^i Z^cZb :jgdeVXje"GZccZc# 9Vh GZccZc! lZaX]Zh YjgX] '&, :a^iZ" jcY ;jc[V]gZg WZhZioi ljgYZ! lVg Vjh HX]lZ^oZg H^X]i Z^c kdaaZg :g[da\/ 9^Z :^c]Z^b^hX]Zc I]dbVh Kdc <jciZc jcY G^X]VgY HeVa^c\Zg hdg\iZc ojb 6j[iV`i YZg 8dde H`^Xgdhh Idjg [ g Z^cZc 9deeZah^Z\# JcY VjX] Vb DeZc"GZccZc h^Z\iZ ^c YZg @ViZ\dg^Z YZg a^oZco^ZgiZc ;V]gZg b^i E]^a^e <VhhZg Z^c 7ZgcZg DWZga~cYZg# >ch\ZhVbi ljgYZ Y^Z 8dde H`^Xgdhh Idjg k^Zg BVa Vjh\ZigV\Zc#

HX]lZ^oZgbZ^hiZghX]V[iZc Vj[ VchegjX]hkdaaZg HigZX`Z :WZc[Vaah ^b GV]bZc YZg 8dde H`^Xgdhh Idjg ljgYZc Y^Z HX]lZ^oZgbZ^hiZghX]V[iZc YjgX]\Z[ ]gi# 7Z^ [g ]a^c\h]V[iZc KZg]~aic^hhZc jcY Z^cZg H`^Xgdhh"HigZX`Z! Y^Z YZc 6i]aZiZc VaaZh VWkZgaVc\iZ! ljgYZc ^c 9^hZci^h Y^Z BZ^hiZgi^iZa Vc 6gb^c C^ZYZgZg! :b^a^Z HZgV^c jcY WZ^ YZc ?jc^dgZc Vc EZiZg Hi~]a^ kZg\ZWZc# 7Z^ _ZYZb GZccZc YZg 8dde H`^Xgdhh Idjg! b^i 6jhcV]bZ YZg :jgdeVXje"GZccZc! \ZlVccZc jchZgZ 6i]aZi^ccZc jcY 6i]aZiZc hdb^i Ejc`iZ# 9^Z Idjg ZcYZiZ Vb DhiZgldX]ZcZcYZ b^i olZ^ DeZc"GZccZc ^c AZnh^c# 9^Z \a X`a^X]Zc H^Z\Zg YZg LZii`Vbe[hZg^Z ]Z^hhZc ;g~co^ HiZ[[Zc! I]dbVh Kdc <jciZc jcY EZiZg Hi~]a^ WZ^ YZc ?jc^dgZc#

6Zg^Vah/ Hd hiVg` l^Z cdX] c^Z

:kZancZ AZj! I^iZakZgiZ^Y^\Zg^c Vc YZc Danbe^hX]Zc L^ciZghe^ZaZc '%&% ^c KVcXdjkZg! WZ^ Z^cZb AVn";jaa";jaa# ;did/ @ZnhidcZ

6ah ZghiZg HX]lZ^oZg ^c YZg <ZhX]^X]iZ hegVc\ H`^V`gdWVi 6cYgZVh >hdo Vc YZc LZaibZ^hiZghX]V[iZc ^c >cVlVh]^gd ?VeVc Z^cZc Hegjc\ b^i [ c[ HX]gVjWZc# LZailZ^i ]VWZc W^h ]ZjiZ Zghi k^Zg =ZggZc YZc ;jaa à 9djWaZ ;jaa à 9djWaZ ;jaa YgZ^ HVaidh b^i [ c[ HX]gVjWZc jb\ZhZioi# >hdo g^h`^ZgiZ YVb^i

'*

oj k^Za jcY bjhhiZ h^X] b^i YZb &'# GVc\ oj[g^ZYZc \ZWZc# 9VWZ^ `dcciZ Zg VWZg [ g Y^Z Danbe^hX]Zc He^ZaZ lZgikdaaZ :g[V]gjc\Zc hVbbZac# 6b Zg[da\gZ^X]hiZc WZhig^ii GZcVid Jag^X] Y^Z LZaibZ^hiZghX]V[iZc! Zg ljgYZ ]ZgkdggV\Zc" YZg K^ZgiZg# >b LZaiXje ZggZ^X]iZ I]dbVh AVbWZgi ^c Bdci <VWg^Za hZ^cZc ZghiZc EdYZhieaVio# 7Z^ YZc 9VbZc ]daiZ h^X] Y^Z Danbe^Vh^Z\Zg^c :kZancZ AZj YZc LZaiXje"H^Z\ ^c 8negZhh BdjciV^c# IZVb`daaZ\^c BVcjZaV B aaZg bZaYZiZ h^X] cVX] Z^cZg aVc\Zc KZgaZiojc\heVjhZ Z^cYg X`a^X] ojg X` jcY hegVc\ olZ^ hVjWZgZ 9gZ^[VX]hVaidh# ; g CVY_V AZjZcWZg\Zg lVg Y^Z kZg\Vc\ZcZ HV^hdc Y^Z ZghiZ! ^c lZaX]Zg h^Z h^X] ^b LZaiXje oj WZ]VjeiZc ]ViiZ# JcY Y^Zh c^X]i d]cZ :g[da\/ >c AV`Z EaVX^Y ZggZ^X]iZ h^Z YZc hZ]g \jiZc VX]iZc GVc\#

;gZZh`^/ <daY [ g ;V^kgZ Vc YZg LB jcY ^b LZaiXje ; g Z^cZ \gdhhZ zWZggVhX]jc\ hdg\iZ Vc YZc LZaibZ^hiZghX]V[iZc ^c >cVlVh]^gd Y^Z LZhihX]lZ^oZg^c K^g\^c^Z ;V^kgZ# 6ah Z^co^\Z

K^g\^c^Z ;V^kgZ ]dai h^X] b^i Y^ZhZb eZg[Z`iZc AVj[ ¼

`Z]giZ Y^Z ',"_~]g^\Z ;V^kgZ b^i Z^cZg BZYV^aaZ cVX] =VjhZ! jcY YVcc \aZ^X] cdX] b^i YZg <daYZcZc 6jX] ^b LZaiXje ]Vi K^g\^c^Z ;V^kgZ b^i Z^cZb ZghiZc jcY Z^cZb olZ^iZc GVc\ [ g 6j[bZg`hVb`Z^i \Zhdg\i# 9Vb^i VWZg cdX] c^X]i \Zcj\/ 9^Z fj^g" a^\Z ;gZZhinaZg^c ZcihX]^ZY VjX] YZc 9^ho^ea^cZclZaiXje [ g h^X]# :WZc[Vaah Zg[da\gZ^X] lVg YZg 7ZgcZg DWZga~cYZg C^ah AVjeZg# :g aVcYZiZ ^b LZaiXje olZ^bVa Vj[ YZb EdYZhi jcY h^X]ZgiZ h^X] YVb^i YZc (# GVc\ ^c YZg 9^ho^ea^cZclZgijc\#

<gdhhZh :c\V\ZbZci YZg IZhh^cZg >c YZg 9^ho^ea^c 7jX`Zae^hiZ oZ^X]cZi h^X] YVh :c\V\ZbZci YZh IZhh^cZg H`^kZgWVcYZh ^c YZg CVX]ljX]h[ gYZgjc\ YZg 7jX`Zae^hiZc[V]gZg aVc\hVb VW# 6c YZc HX]lZ^oZgbZ^hiZg" hX]V[iZc \ZaVc\ YZb Zghi &("_~]g^\Zc BVgXd IVYZ kdb H8 6^gdad Z^c 9deeZah^Z\ ?jc^dgZc jcY :a^iZ # >b LZaiXje jcY ^b :jgdeVXje Wa^ZWZc Ide"GZhjaiViZ VWZg aZ^YZg Vjh# :^co^\ EVWad AV[gVcX]^ jcY C^XdaZ 7jbVcc gZ^X]iZ Zh ^c Y^Z Ejc`iZg~c\Z#

¼ Vc YZg LB ^c >cVlVh]^gd YZc LZaibZ^hiZgi^iZa ^c YZg =Va[e^eZ# ;didh/ @ZnhidcZ

A:>HIJC<HHEDGI I:A:B6G@

'+

IZaZbVg`/ Edh^i^kZ 7^aVco :^cbVa bZ]g ig~\i Y^Z 9^ho^ea^c IZaZbVg` Z^cZc \gdhhZc 7Z^igV\ ojg edh^i^kZc 7^aVco kdc Hl^hh"H`^ WZ^ jcY Zcil^" X`Zai h^X] ojb kZga~hha^X]Zc <VgVciZc [ g EdYZhiea~ioZ Ã jcY Y^Zh igdio Z^cZh \Z\Zc WZg Kdg_V]gZc kZg`aZ^cZgiZc @VYZgh# Hd ljgYZc ^c YZg kZg\Vc\ZcZc HV^hdc Za[ LZaiXje"H^Z\Z! &* lZ^iZgZ LZaiXje"EdYZhiea~ioZ jcY oZ]c LB"BZYV^aaZc cZjc :a^iZ jcY Z^c ?jc^dg Zgo^Zai# 9^Z W^haVc\ Zg[da\gZ^X]h" iZ HV^hdc hZ^i YZb 7Z^ig^ii oj Hl^hh"H`^ hX]adhh YVh IZVb kdc =Vch"EZiZg 7^gX]aZg 9^ho^ea^cZcX]Z[ jcY B^X]Za 7dccn 8]Z[igV^cZg ojYZb b^i YZb <Zl^cc kdc ^ch\ZhVbi YgZ^ 9^ho^ea^cZclZaiXjeh hdl^Z YZh <ZhVbilZaiXjeh jcY kZgiZ^" Y^\iZ GVc\ ' ^b CVi^dcZcgVc`^c\# 9Vb^i ljgYZ YVh HV^hdc" o^Za YZjia^X] WZgigd[[Zc#

zWZggV\ZcY/ 6b a^Z GZnbdcY :gcZji lVg Y^Z ''"_~]g^\Z :I="HijYZci^c 6b a^Z GZnbdcY Y^Z VaaZh WZggV\ZcYZ 6i]aZi^c ^b IZaZbVg`# H^Z \ZlVcc cZjc kdc &) L8"GZccZc jcY lVg ^c YZc Wg^\Zc [ c[ c^Z hX]aZX]iZg eaVio^Zgi Vah Vj[ YZb olZ^iZc GVc\# OjYZb \ZlVcc h^Z YZc LZaibZ^hiZgi^iZa ^b G^ZhZchaVadb# 7ZgZ^ih YgZ^ GZccZc kdg HX]ajhh `dcciZ h^X] 6b a^Z GZnbdcY ZghibVah YZc <ZhVbilZaiXje h^X]Zgc jcY Zg" o^ZaiZ ojYZb YgZ^ lZ^iZgZ 9^ho^ea^cZch^Z\Z 8aVhh^X! <^Vci! Heg^ci #

Kdaa YjgX]\ZhiVgiZi/ HVcYg^cZ BZnZg 6b a^Z GZnbdcYh IZVb`daaZ\Zc igj\Zc ZWZc[Vaah ojg Vjh\Z" oZ^X]cZiZc 7^aVco WZ^! VaaZc kdgVc HVcYg^cZ BZnZg# H^Z Zgo^ZaiZ ^]gZc ZghiZc L8"H^Z\ jcY VX]i lZ^iZgZ EdYZhiea~ioZ jcY YVg[ Vah Y^Z 6j[hiZ^\Zg^c YZg IZaZbVg`"GZcchoZcZ WZoZ^X]cZi lZg" YZc# 7ZbZg`ZchlZgiZglZ^hZ lVg Y^Z '+"_~]g^\Z <Zc[Zg^c W^h" aVc\ `Z^c d[[^o^ZaaZh B^i\a^ZY YZh HX]lZ^oZg IZaZbVg`"@VYZgh# 9V Y^Z Z]ZbVa^\Z H`^gZcc[V]gZg^c à h^Z ]ViiZ Zh W^h ^ch 8"@VYZg \ZhX]V[[i à kZg\Vc\ZcZc L^ciZg Vjh iZgb^ca^X]Zc <g cYZc Vc YZc HX]lZ^oZgbZ^hiZghX]V[iZc c^X]i iZ^acZ]bZc `dcciZ! [Z]a" iZc ^]g Y^Z c i^\Zc Ejc`iZ [ g Z^cZ @VYZg"HZaZ`i^dc# 6j[\gjcY ^]gZh \gdhhZc EdiZci^Vah Yjg[iZ h^Z igdioYZb YVh HdbbZg" jcY =ZgWhiigV^c^c\ VWhdak^ZgZc# B^i ^ch\ZhVbi k^Zg LB"BZYV^aaZc ]Vi h^Z YVh KZgigVjZc YZg IgV^cZg bZ]g Vah WZhi~i^\i#

HX]lZ^oZg LZaiXjeh^Z\ WZ^ YZc =ZggZc

6b a^Z GZnbdcY ]Vi \ji aVX]Zc/ H^Z Ydb^c^ZgiZ ^c YZg kZg\Vc\ZcZc HV^hdc Y^Z IZaZbVg`"HoZcZ# ;did/ Hl^hh"H`^

:WZc[Vaah Z^cZ edh^i^kZ 7^aVco o^Z]Zc `Vcc 7Vhi^Zc 9VnZg/ YZb Z]ZbVa^\Zc ?jc^dgZclZaibZ^hiZg \ZaVc\ WZ^ YZg :a^iZ YZg ZghiZ LZaiXjeh^Z\# 6c YZg LB ^c @gZ^hX]WZg\ \ZlVcc Zg ojYZb ^c YZg @ c^\hY^ho^ea^c 8aVhh^X LB"H^aWZg# >ch\ZhVbi `aVhh^ZgiZ Zg h^X] ^c`a# LB VX]i BVa Vj[ YZb )# GVc\! lVh VjX] ^b <ZhVbilZaiXje YZc )# GVc\ WZYZjiZiZ# 6jX] Y^Z Wg^\Zc @VYZgVi]aZiZc ` ccZc oj[g^Z" YZc hZ^c/ 9Vc^Za ;dggZg hiVcY ZWZc[Vaah olZ^bVa Vj[ Z^cZb L8" EdYZhi! jcY VjX] YZg ?jc^dg GZid C^ZYZgWZg\Zg `dcciZ ^b LZaiXje jcY Vc YZg LB ZghiZ :g[da\Z Zgo^ZaZc jcY l^X]i^\Z :g[V]gjc\Zc hVbbZac# LZ^iZg]^c kdb EZX] kZg[da\i hX]Z^ci ]^c\Z\Zc BVgi^c :X]hZg/ >b kZg\Vc\ZcZc L^ciZg ]ViiZ Zg h^X] WZgZ^ih ^b ZghiZc AVj[ YZh ZghiZc LZaiXjegZccZch kZgaZioi jcY lVg [ g YZc GZhi YZg HV^hdc

',

7Vhi^Zc 9VnZg ^c kdaaZg ;V]gi#

Vjh\Z[VaaZc# :g `Z]giZ hi~g`Zg Vah _Z ojkdg ojg X` jcY Zgo^ZaiZ Y^Z" hZ HV^hdc oV]agZ^X]Z eZgh ca^X]Z 7ZhiaZ^hijc\Zc! WZkdg Zg h^X] Vb LZaiXje[^cVaZ ^c CdglZ\Zc ZgcZji kZgaZioiZ#

;did/ Hl^hh"H`^

kZgWdg\Zc \ZWa^ZWZc# Hd \ZaiZc Y^Z ]d]Z @dbeZiZco jcY YZg Vjh" \ZoZ^X]cZiZ IZVbhe^g^i YZg HX]lZ^oZg ^ciZgcVi^dcVa Vah BVhhhiVW#

HiZ^\ZcYZ 7ZYZjijc\ YZg 9^ho^ea^c IZaZbVg` BZYV^aaZc[aji Vc YZg IZaZbVg`"LB ^c @gZ^hX]WZg\ CVX] YZg Zg[da\gZ^X]Zc LB kdg olZ^ ?V]gZc ^c I]ndc &( BZYV^aaZc hdg\iZc Y^Z HX]lZ^oZg IZaZbVg`Zg Vc YZg LB ^c @gZ^hX]WZg\ ZgcZji [ g Z^cZc BZYV^aaZcgZ\Zc jcY \ZlVccZc c^X]i lZc^\Zg Vah oZ]c BZYV^aaZc/ &m <daY! *m H^aWZg jcY )m 7gdcoZ# LB"<daY \^c\ YVWZ^ Vc 6b a^Z GZnbdcY! Y^Z ojYZb YgZ^bVa LB"H^aWZg \ZlVcc# :WZc[Vaah LB"H^aWZg \ZlVccZc 7Vhi^Zc 9VnZg jcY HVcYg^cZ BZnZg! Y^Z ojh~ioa^X] cdX] YgZ^ WgdcoZcZ BZYV^aaZc ]daiZ# LB"BZYV^aaZ Cd# &% \^c\ Vc 9Zc^h BZigV^aaZg0 Zg \ZlVcc Vc YZg ?jc^dgZc LB @dbW^cVi^dchWgdcoZ#

6cZg`Zccjc\ YZg HX]lZ^oZg @dbeZiZco B^i YZb cZj Vj[\ZWVjiZc IZVb ^hi Zh \Zajc\Zc! Y^Z HX]lZ^o Vah Z^cZ YZg [ ]gZcYZc CVi^dcZc ^c YZg ^ciZgcVi^dcVaZc IZaZbVg`" LZii`Vbe[hoZcZ oj WZhi~i^\Zc# 6jX] YZc VcYZgZc CVi^dcZc ^hi Y^Z ]ZgkdggV\ZcYZ 6gWZ^i YZg HX]lZ^oZg IgV^cZg jcY 7ZigZjZg c^X]i

>bbZg bZ]g CVi^dcZc WZiZ^a^\Zc h^X] Vc YZc kdc YZg ;>H dg\V" c^h^ZgiZc LZaiXje jcY LB LZii`~be[Zc/ B^iiaZglZ^aZ h^cY Zh WZgZ^ih &- CVi^dcZc Vjh k^Zg @dci^cZciZc# 9^Z BZY^Zceg~hZco b^i IK"zWZgigV\jc\Zc ^chWZhdcYZgZ ^c CdglZ\Zc a^kZ jcY yhiZggZ^X] a~c\ZgZ 6j[oZ^X]cjc\Zc oZ^\Zc! YVhh h^X] Y^Z HedgiVgi ojcZ]" bZcYZg 7Z`Vcci]Z^i jcY 7Za^ZWi]Z^i Zg[gZji#

6jhWa^X` ; g Y^Z `dbbZcYZ HV^hdc h^cY YZgoZ^i `Z^cZ G X`ig^iiZ oj bZa" YZc# 7Z^ YZc HZaZ`i^dcZc h^cY cjg 6j[hiZ^\Zg oj kZgoZ^X]cZc# 9V IZaZbVg` cdX] c^X]i danbe^hX] ^hi! l^gY Zh Z^cZ Ol^hX]ZchV^hdc hZ^c d]cZ BZYV^aaZc# DWld]a Y^Z 6i]aZi^ccZc jcY 6i]aZiZc ^c Ol^hX]ZchV^hdch ^]gZ Eg^dg^i~iZc ol^hX]Zc He^ioZchedgi HijY^jb$6gWZ^i aZ^X]i kZghX]^ZWZc! ^hi Zh YVh O^Za! ^b LZaiXje lZ^iZg]^c b \a^X]hi k^ZaZ EdYZhiea~ioZ oj ZggZ^X]Zc à hX]a^Zhh" a^X] h^cY ^c olZ^ ?V]gZc l^ZYZg LZaibZ^hiZghX]V[iZc#

6JH7>A9JC<

'-

6j[WgjX]hi^bbjc\ ^c YZg 6jhW^aYjc\ <gjcYVjhW^aYjc\

LZ^iZgW^aYjc\

9Vh 7jcYZhVbi [ g Hedgi 76HED Zc\V\^Zgi h^X] b^i ? H"@^Yh [ g Y^Z gZ\Zab~hh^\Z jcY k^ZahZ^i^\Z Hedgi" jcY 7ZlZ\jc\h[ gYZgjc\ YZg *" W^h &%"?~]g^\Zc# 7Z^ Y^ZhZb Egd\gVbb \Z]i Zh YVgjb! Y^Z 6`i^k^i~iZc WZ^ YZc *" W^h &%"?~]g^\Zc oj ^ciZch^k^ZgZc# 6jX] WZ^ Hl^hh"H`^ ^hi ? H @^Yh Z^c l^X]i^\Zh I]ZbV# 9Vh 6jhW^aYjc\hiZVb kdc Hl^hh"H`^ h^Z]i ^b @dcoZei ? H @^Yh Z^cZ \gdhhZ 8]VcXZ [ g YZc 7gZ^iZchedgi jcY Y^Z 8ajWh kdc Hl^hh"H`^ jcY ]Vi YVh Egd_Z`i kdc 6c[Vc\ Vc jciZghi ioi jcY Z^\ZcZ >YZZc Z^c\ZWgVX]i# ? H @^Yh l^gY cjc cVX] YZc cZjhiZc Higj`ijgZc ^c VaaZc HX]cZZhedgiVgiZc jb\ZhZioi#

9^Z 8dVX] Ed^cih h^cY cVX] l^Z kdg Z^c l^X]i^\Zh LZ^iZgW^aYjc\h" Vc\ZWdi kdc Hl^hh"H`^# GjcY &,% IgV^cZg^ccZc jcY IgV^cZg ]VWZc Y^ZhZ IV\Zh`jghZ [ g @dbeZiZcoZglZ^iZgjc\ jcY BZ^cjc\hVjhiVjhX] \Zcjioi# 6ah l^X]i^\Z CZjZgjc\ hdaaZc Y^Z 6jhW^aYjc\h^c]VaiZ hij[Zc\ZgZX]iZg lZgYZc# ;ZgcZg hdaaZc \Z" l^hhZ I]ZbZc i^Z[\g cY^\Zg WZ]VcYZai jcY YZg L^hhZch" jcY BZ^cjc\hVjhiVjhX] [dgX^Zgi lZgYZc# OjYZb \^ai Y^Z 9Zk^hZ FjVa^i~i kdg FjVci^i~i/ Hd lZgYZc ^c jc\ZgVYZc ?V]gZc cjg cdX] YgZ^ 8dVX] Ed^cih Vc\ZWdiZc#

9Vh 7ZY g[c^h! Z^cZ 6jhW^aYjc\ ^b 7ZgZ^X] 8ajW"6hh^hiZcoigV^cZg VcojW^ZiZc! l^gY YjgX] Y^ZhZ Higj`ijg lZ^iZg jciZghig^X]Zc# Hl^hh" H`^ l^gY Y^ZhZ cZjZ 6jhW^aYjc\! Y^Z YZc 6chX]ajhh YZg &+" W^h &,"?~]g^\Zc Vc Z^cZ IgV^cZg`Vgg^ZgZ kZgZ^c[VX]Zc hdaa! ^b HdbbZg ^c]Vaia^X] YZ[^c^ZgZc jcY ^b c~X]hiZc L^ciZg Z^cZc E^adi`jgh hiVgiZc#

9^Z `dggZ`iZ E^hiZceg~eVgVi^dc l^aa \ZaZgci hZ^c/ @VcY^YViZc WZ^ YZg GZ\^dcVaigV^cZgVjhW^aYjc\ ^c 6cYZgbVii# ;did/ Hl^hh"H`^

9^Z W^h]Zg^\Zc I]ZbZc lVgZc YjgX]lZ\h hedgiVgi WZg\gZ^[ZcY VclZcYWVg KZgaZiojc\hegde]naVmZ! @gV[iigV^c^c\ [ g ?j\ZcYa^X]Z! Hedchdg^c\ j#V# ! YZccdX] ljgYZc ojh~ioa^X]Z Y^ho^ea^cZcheZo^[^" hX]Z 6jhW^aYjc\hiV\Z ^c YZc 9^ho^ea^cZc H`^hegjc\ jcY AVc\aVj[ b^i[^cVco^Zgi jcY dg\Vc^h^Zgi# HcdlWdVgY l^gY VjX] Y^ZhZh ?V]g [^m ^c Y^Z 8dVX] Ed^cih ^ciZ\g^Zgi jcY b^i OjhVioi]ZbZc hedgi" VgiheZo^[^hX] Vc\ZeVhhi#

6j[bZg`hVbZ Oj] gZg WZ^b 8dVX] Ed^ci ^c L^aa^hVj#

;did/ Hl^hh"H`^

'.

AZ]gb^iiZa

OjhVbbZcVgWZ^i b^i ? H

:^c l^X]i^\Zg 7ZhiVcYiZ^a YZg IgV^cZgVjhW^aYjc\ h^cY Y^Z W^d" bZX]Vc^hX]Zc <gjcYaV\Zc# 9^Z ºGVX^c\ :hhZci^Vah» jcY Y^Z ºGVX^c\ 7Vh^Xh» h^cY Y^Z ZcihegZX]ZcYZc AZ]gb^iiZa! Y^Z Y^Z <gjcYVjhW^aYjc\ YZh IgV^cZgh lZhZcia^X] eg~\Zc# Cjg b^i Z^cZg hda^YZc W^dbZX]Vc^hX]Zc 6jhW^aYjc\ l^Z VjX] \jiZc AZ]gb^iiZac `Vcc Z^c `dchigj`i^kZg 6jhiVjhX] jciZg YZc IgV^cZgc \Zl~]gaZ^h" iZi lZgYZc# :^c ZcihX]Z^YZcYZg ;V`idg ^hi! YVhh Y^Z AZ]gb^iiZa ^c YZc 6jhW^aYjc\hlZ\ eVhhZc jcY Vj[ Y^Z \gjcYaZ\ZcYZc AZ]gb^iiZa kdc Hl^hh Hcdlhedgih jcY ? H VW\Zhi^bbi h^cY# 9ZgZc 6jhVgWZ^ijc\ l^gY cdX] Z^c^\Z OZ^i ^c 6chegjX] cZ]bZc#

9^Z :meZgiZcVjhW^aYjc\ ZiVWa^Zgi h^X] ^bbZg bZ]g Vah Z^cZh YZg l^X]i^\hiZc :aZbZciZ ^c YZg KZgWVcYhigV^cZgVjhW^aYjc\# 6ah IgV^cZg bjhh bVc [~]^\ hZ^c! Vj[ ] X]hiZg Hij[Z YZc JciZgg^X]ih^c]Vai oj kZgb^iiZac# 9^Z =ZgVjh[dgYZgjc\! [ g YZc AZgcZg[da\ Z^cZg \VcoZc 6jhW^aYjc\hldX]Z kZgVcildgia^X] oj hZ^c! ^hi [ g k^ZaZ IgV^cZg Z^cZ cZjZ :g[V]gjc\ jcY Zg\^Wi cZjZ >bejahZ ^c YZg EZgh ca^X]`Z^ihZcil^X`ajc\! @dbbjc^`Vi^dc! ^b Eg~hZci^ZgZc jcY ^c ; ]gjc\hVj[\VWZc#

KZgWVcYhigV^cZg`jgh '+ IgV^cZg kdc Hl^hh"H`^ hX]a^ZhhZc ^b 6j\jhi '%%. YZc KZgWVcYhigV^cZg`jgh Hij[Z & KI@ & VW# >c Y^ZhZb @jgh ^hi YZg IgV^cZg\gjcY`jgh kdc Hl^hh Danbe^X ^cWZ\g^[[Zc# Ojh~ioa^X] lZgYZc Y^ZhZc HdbbZg &% @VcY^YViZc YZc KZgWVcYhigV^cZg" `jgh Hij[Z ' KI@ ' b^i YZg ] ]ZgZc ;VX]eg [jc\ IgV^cZg He^ioZchedgi VWhX]a^ZhhZc#

<gdhhZh >ciZgZhhZ VjX] Vb E^hiZceg~eVgVi^dch`jgh ^c 9Vkdh# ;did/ Hl^hh"H`^

;dghX]jc\ Hl^hh"H`^ 9^Z ;dghX]jc\h\gjeeZ kdc Hl^hh"H`^ ^hi [ g YVh >c^i^^ZgZc kdc cZj" Zc ;dghX]jc\hegd_Z`iZc hdl^Z [ g YVh ºL^hhZchbVcV\ZbZci» oj" hi~cY^\# 9Zg cZjc` e[^\Zc ;dghX]jc\h\gjeeZ \Z] gZc KZgigZiZg kdc Hl^hh"H`^! YZb 7jcYZhVbi [ g Hedgi 76HED ! YZb >chi^iji [ g AVl^cZc" jcY HX]cZZ[dghX]jc\ HA; ! YZg >ciZgcVi^dcVa 6XVYZbn d[ Hedgih HX^ZcXZ VcY IZX]cdad\n 6>HIH ! YZb >chi^iji [ g 6cVidb^Z YZg Jc^kZgh^i~i 7Zgc hdl^Z kdc Hl^hh Danbe^X Vc# >c Y^ZhZg OjhVbbZchZiojc\ ^hi Y^Z <gjeeZ hZ^i '%%, i~i^\# 9Vc` Y^Z" hZb <gZb^jb `dcciZc Z^c^\Z cZjZ Egd_Z`iZ ^c OjhVbbZcVgWZ^i b^i YZc 9^ho^ea^cZcX]Z[h jcY YZc >chi^iji^dcZc \ZhiVgiZi lZgYZc# 6b ;dghX]jc\h" jcY IgV^cZg[dgjb ljgYZc Y^Z :g`Zccic^hhZ Vjh YZc Egd_Z`iZc YZc IgV^cZgc kdg\ZhiZaai# :h lZgYZc bdbZciVc &* kZghX]^ZYZcZ ;dghX]jc\hegd_Z`iZ ^c [Vhi VaaZc HX]cZZhedgiVgiZc WZ^ Hl^hh"H`^ WZigZji jcY kdgl~gih\Zig^ZWZc#

7G:>I:CHEDGI

(%

7gZ^iZchedgi/ Jc\ZWgdX]ZcZ 7Za^ZWi]Z^i +%% ?j\ZcYa^X]Z ^b ?jh`^aV BZ]g Vah +%% ?j\ZcYa^X]Z jcY &*% B^iVgWZ^iZg^ccZc jcY B^iVgWZ^iZg Vjh VaaZc @VcidcZc YZg HX]lZ^o gZ^hiZc igVY^i^" dch\Zb~hh ^c YZg ZghiZc ?VcjVgldX]Z ^ch ?j\ZcYh`^aV\Zg kdc Hl^hh"H`^! jb Z^cZ \gVi^h HX]cZZhedgildX]Z Vc YZg AZc` oj ZgaZWZc# B^i kdc YZg EVgi^Z lVgZc VjX] Y^ZhZh ?V]g '% ^b 6jhaVcY aZWZcYZ HX]lZ^oZg @^cYZg hdl^Z \Z]" jcY hZ]WZ]^cYZgiZ @^cYZg# :h ZcihiVcY gjcY jbh @jg" jcY HedgioZcigjb @JHED Z^c k^Za" hegVX]^\Zh jcY `jciZgWjciZh IgZ^WZc! YVh ojb KZghi~cYc^h YZg kZghX]^ZYZcZc @jaijgZc jcY YZg 6cYZghVgi^\`Z^i YZg @^cYZg WZ^" ig~\i jcY oj Z^cZb jckZg\Zhha^X]Zc jcY eg~\ZcYZc :gaZWc^h [ g Y^Z &(" W^h &)"?~]g^\Zc l^gY#

9Vh \g hhiZ ?j\ZcYhedgiaV\Zg YZg HX]lZ^o lVg VjX] ^c hZ^cZb +-# 6jhigV\jc\h_V]g Z^c \gdhhZg :g[da\# 7ZYZjiZcYZg 6ciZ^a Vb gZ^Wjc\hadhZc 6WaVj[ YZg 6jh\VWZ '%%. YZh ?jh`^aV ]ViiZc cZ" WZc Z^cZb Zc\V\^ZgiZc D@ jcY 7ZigZjjc\hiZVb! YVh ZgcZji Vjh\ZoZ^X]cZiZ 6gWZ^i aZ^hiZiZ! VjX] YVh hX] cZ! VWZg `VaiZ LZiiZg! hdl^Z Y^Z dei^bVaZc HX]cZZkZg]~aic^hhZ Vj[ YZc E^hiZc Vc YZg AZc`# Ojb ZghiZc BVa ^c YZg [Vhi ,%"_~]g^\Zc <ZhX]^X]iZ YZh ?jh`^aV WZgcV]b YZg @Vcidc HX]V[[]VjhZc YVh AV\ZgeVigdcVi# 9Vc` Z^cZg \Zo^ZaiZc LZgWZV`i^dc YZh H`^XajWh HX]V[[]VjhZc! YZg AVc\aVj[lVcYZg\gjeeZ ALH hdl^Z YZh `VcidcVaZc 6bih [ g ?j\ZcY jcY Hedgi ljgYZ Y^Z IZ^acZ]bZgVjhadhjc\! Y^Z Vc YZg HX]V[[]VjhZg =ZgWhibZhhZ ^c [Z^Zga^X]Zb GV]bZc YjgX]\Z[ ]gi ljgYZ! ojb :g[da\# HX]ajhhZcYa^X] `dcciZc *% HX]V[[]VjhZg @^cYZg à YVh h^cY ^b KZg\aZ^X] b^i YZc Kdg_V]gZc [Vhi oZ]c BVa bZ]g HX]V[[]VjhZg à Z^cZ jckZg\Zhha^X]Z HX]cZZhedgildX]Z b^i <aZ^X]Vaig^\Zc Vc YZg AZc` ZgaZWZc# 6c YZg :g [[cjc\h[Z^Zg WZggZ^X]iZ YZg EViZc`Vcidc HX]V[[]VjhZc! kZgigZiZc YjgX] Y^Z GZ\^Zgjc\hg~i^c GdhbVg^Z L^YbZg <nhZa! YZg AV\ZgaZ^ijc\ Z^cZc ~jhhZghi \gdhho \^\Zc 8]ZX` WZg 8=; &' %%%# HZ^i bZ]g Vah '% ?V]gZc hZioi YZg =Vjeihedchdg B^\gdh Z^cZc h^ZWZchiZaa^\Zc ;gVc`ZcWZigV\ [ g YVh AV\Zg Z^c# 9Vh ?jh`^aV kdc Hl^hh"H`^ l^gY [^cVco^Zaa jciZghi ioi kdb 8d"Hedchdg HX]lZ^oZg ;aZ^hX]! YZc ? H" jcY @VcidchWZ^ig~\Zc hdl^Z YZc gjcY '%%% eg^kViZc < ccZgc! YZc hd\ZcVcciZc ?jh`^aV"EViZc! Y^Z _~]ga^X] 8=; *% dYZg bZ]g heZcYZc# :^cZc VjhhZg\Zl ]ca^X] \gdhho " \^\Zc 7ZigV\! c~ba^X] 8=; '% %%%! WZgl^Zh Y^ZhZh ?V]g >kd GdbZg! 8:D jcY KZglVaijc\hgViheg~h^YZci YZg ;^gbV Ldg` ;^YjhigV H6! YZb ?j\ZcYh`^aV\Zg#

9Vh +-# ?JH@>A6 [VcY WZ^ ^YZVaZc LZiiZg" jcY HX]cZZkZg]~aic^hhZc hiVii#

;did/ Hl^hh"H`^

6ca~hha^X] YZg ;jhhWVaaZjgdeVbZ^hiZghX]V[i '%%- Zc\V\^ZgiZc h^X] bZ]gZgZ ?jh`^aV"AZ^iZg^ccZc jcY "AZ^iZg ^b 8ViZg^c\ YZg ;^gbV 7Zaa ^c YZc J7H"6gZcZc ^c H^dc jcY 7^Za# CVX] YZg :jgd %- heZcYZiZ 7Zaa Y^Z =~a[iZ YZh GZ^c\Zl^ccZh! Vahd 8=; , %%%! oj\jchiZc YZh ?j\ZcYh`^aV\Zgh#

(&

+ +*% ?j\ZcYa^X]Z Vb <gVcY Eg^m B^\gdh

HiVg\Vhi Vb <E";^cVaZ lVg 9^Y^Zg 8jX]Z! YZg l^Z k^ZaZ lZ^iZgZ V`i^kZ jcY Z]ZbVa^\Z H`^hiVgh YZc @^cYZgc b^i GVi jcY IVi ojg HZ^iZ hiVcY jcY \ZYjaY^\ 6jid\gVbbZ kZgiZ^aiZ#

9Zg <gVcY Eg^m B^\gdh! ZjgdeVlZ^i YVh \gย hhiZ ?j\ZcYh`^gZccZc! ^hi hZ^i [Vhi k^Zg ?V]goZ]ciZc IZ^a YZg hX]lZ^oZg^hX]Zc H`^`jaijg jcY adX`i cVX] l^Z kdg IVjhZcYZ kdc ?j\ZcYa^X]Zc Vc YZc HiVgi# 9^ZhZ HV^hdc bZaYZiZc h^X] + +*% ?j\ZcYa^X]Z ^b 6aiZg ol^hX]Zc - jcY &* ?V]gZc [ย g Z^cZh YZg &( 6jhhX]Z^Yjc\hgZccZc YZh \gย hhiZc jcY igVY^i^dchgZ^X]hiZc 7gZ^iZchedgiVcaVhhZh kdc Hl^hh"H`^ Vc# 9Vh ^hi VWhdajiZg IZ^acV]bZgZ`dgY >c CZcYVo `dcciZ ojYZb b^i +,.

IZ^acZ]bZgc YVh \gย hhiZ 6jhhX]Z^Yjc\hgZccZc ^c YZg <ZhX]^X]iZ YZh <gVcY Eg^m YjgX]\Z[ย ]gi lZgYZc# LZ^iZgZ GZ`dgYoV]aZc kZg" oZ^X]cZiZc Y^Z 6jhigV\jc\hdgiZ Aย ihX]ZciVa jcY AZc`/ B^i ))% 6c\ZbZaYZiZc hiVgiZiZc Vj[ YZg AVjX]ZgcVae hd k^ZaZ ?j\ZcYa^X]Z! l^Z cdX] c^Z ojkdg Vc Z^cZb <gVcY Eg^m B^\gdh ^b DWZglVaa^h# JcY Y^Z AZc` igjbe[iZ b^i *.* 6cbZaYjc\Zc Vj[

8Vgad Aย ihX]Zg igVi Y^Z CVX][da\Z kdc 8aVjY^d 8daaZcWZg\ Vah cZjZg GVXZ"9^gZ`idg YZh <gVcY Eg^m B^\gdh Vc# 9Zg LVaa^hZg lVg ^c kZghX]^Z" YZcZc IgV^cZg[jc`i^dcZc WZ^ Hl^hh"H`^ jcY VjX] WZ^b `VcVY^hX]Zc H`^kZgWVcY i~i^\# 9Zg Vjh\ZW^aYZiZ H`^aZ]gZg! IgV^cZg jcY iZX]c^hX]Z 9ZaZ\^ZgiZ YZg ;>H ZgaZY^\iZ hZ^cZ cZjZc 6j[\VWZc b^i k^Za :aVc jcY igj\ hd YVoj WZ^! YVhh VaaZ ++*% IZ^acZ]bZcYZc Vj[ Z^cZg egd[Zhh^d" cZaaZc GZcchigZX`Z hiVgiZc `dcciZc# 9Zg <gVcY Eg^m B^\gdh `Vcc hZ^i ?V]gZc Vj[ YVh :c\V\ZbZci YZg HedchdgZc B^\gdh! CdgY^XV! HX]lZ^oZg ;aZ^hX]! Id`d! ;VgbZg jcY YZg HX]lZ^oZg B^aX]egdYjoZciZc o~]aZc# 9Vc` YZg Zc\Zc jcY WZhiZch [jc`i^dc^ZgZcYZc OjhVbbZcVgWZ^i ol^hX]Zc YZc kZg" hX]^ZYZc AZ^hijc\hig~\Zgc `dcciZ YZg :kZci VjX] Y^ZhZh ?V]g dei^b^Zgi jcY oj Z^cZb ;Zhi Vj[ jcY cZWZc YZg E^hiZ Vjh\Z" WVji lZgYZc# 9Vh WjciZ K^aaV\Z! ^c YZb YZc @^cYZgc jcY ^]gZc 7Z\aZ^iZgc He^Za! HeVhh jcY KZge[aZ\jc\ \ZWdiZc l^gY! \Z]ย gi b^iiaZglZ^aZ ZWZchd oj Z^cZb <gVcY Eg^m B^\gdh l^Z YVh Z^\Zci" a^X]Z H`^gZccZc0 YVh \ZbZ^chVbZ :gaZWc^h hiZ]i ^b B^iiZaejc`i Y^ZhZh 7gZ^iZchedgiVcaVhhZh#

B^i HVkd\c^c jcY Aย ihX]ZciVa h^cY olZ^ cZjZ 6jhigV\jc\hdgiZ ojb GZcc`VaZcYZg YVoj\Z`dbbZc jcY bZ^hiZgiZc ^]gZ EgZb^ZgZ b^i 7gVkdjg# 9Vh \gdhhZ <gVcY Eg^m B^\gdh ;^cVaZ Vb ZghiZc 6eg^a" LdX]ZcZcYZ ^c AZh 9^VWaZgZih W^aYZiZ YZc `gย cZcYZc 6WhX]ajhh Y^ZhZg Zg[da\gZ^X]hiZc VaaZg W^h]Zg^\Zc <E"HV^hdch# 7Z^ [gย ]a^c\h" ]V[iZc IZbeZgVijgZc `dcciZc Y^Z +*% fjVa^[^o^ZgiZc ?j\ZcYa^X]Zc ^]g @ย ccZc c^X]i cjg ^b G^ZhZchaVadb! hdcYZgc ZWZchd ^b Vc" hegjX]hkdaaZc GZcc[dgbVi ยบ8dbW^"GVXZยป jciZg 7ZlZ^h hiZaaZc#

Grand Prix Migros 2009 !# " & %&$ )'(& )# '$&(

@Z^cZg oj `aZ^c! Vb <E B^\gdh Z^cZ `aZ^cZ AVgV <ji oj hZ^c# ;did/ :gl^c Oย \Zg

,#&

' ,& # & !! &' &$' ('

# #

*$'

&$!$

*$ # # ! )'

#

,(' #( ! # + $ &

7G:>I:CHEDGI

('

6b G^kZaaV ;Vb^an 8dciZhi a^Z[ZgiZc h^X] Y^Z ;Vb^a^Zc eVX`ZcYZ 9jZaaZ#

(ร '%% @^cYZg Vc '' kZghX]^ZYZcZc DgiZc Zg[gZjiZc h^X] ^c YZg kZg\Vc\ZcZc HV^hdc Vb 8dde ;jc"EVgXdjgh b^i Y^kZghZc 6c^bVi^dchlZii`~be[Zc jcY =^cYZgc^hhZc ojb he^ZaZg^hX]Zc :gaZgcZc kdc AVc\aVj[iZX]c^`Zc# ;did/ Hl^hh"H`^

;did/ Hl^hh"H`^

&% %%% IZ^acZ]bZg Vb G^kZaaV ;Vb^an 8dciZhi :^c GZccZc jcY W^h oj [ย c[ ;Vb^a^Zcb^i\a^ZYZg! Y^Z Y^ZhZh \Z" bZ^chVb WZhigZ^iZc/ 9Vh ^hi YZg G^kZaaV ;Vb^an 8dciZhi# 6b aZ" \ZcY~gZc ;Vb^a^ZcVcaVhh `Vcc [ย g cjg 8=; -* iZ^a\ZcdbbZc lZgYZc IV\Zh`VgiZc ^c`ajh^kZ ! ojYZb `Z]gZc ;Vb^a^Zc b^i idaaZc <ZhX]Zc`Zc cVX] =VjhZ# >c YZg L^ciZghV^hdc '%%-$%. `VbZc ' *.- ;Vb^a^Zc dYZg gjcY &% %%% EZghdcZc ^c YZc <Zcjhh Z^cZh jckZg\Zhha^X]Zc IV\Zh ^b HX]cZZ# >c L^aY]Vjh lVgZc b^i '(. ;Vb^a^Zc Vb bZ^hiZc GZcc[V]gZg Vb HiVgi# <ZeaVci lVgZc ', 6jhigV\jc\Zc YZh G^kZaaV ;Vb^an 8dciZhi! YjgX]\Z[ย ]gi ljgYZc YZgZc '+! YV YVh GZccZc ^c AZnh^c Vj[\gjcY hiVg`Zc L^cYZh VW\Z" hV\i lZgYZc bjhhiZ# >b KZg\aZ^X] oj VcYZgZc ?V]gZc! ^c lZaX]Zc W^h oj h^ZWZc 6ca~hhZ c^X]i YjgX]\Z[ย ]gi lZgYZc `dcciZc! ^hi Y^Zh Z^cZ hZ]g Zg[gZja^X]Z BZaYjc\#

6ah BZY^ZceVgicZg hi^Zhh GVY^d Hjch]^cZ cZj ojg G^kZaaV ;Vb^an 8dciZhi";Vb^a^Z# 9Vc` Y^ZhZb :c\V\ZbZci `dcciZc h^ZWZc kZg" hX]^ZYZcZ Hedih ย WZg Y^Z ;Vb^a^ZcgZccZc bZ]g[VX] ย WZg YZc ti]Zg kdc GVY^d Hjch]^cZ \ZhigV]ai lZgYZc# CZj Vb G^kZaaV ;Vb^an 8dciZhi ^hi VjX] Y^Z Egd_Z`iaZ^iZg^c# IVc_V J]abVcc! CVX][da\Zg^c kdc C^XdaZ L^c`aZg! bZ^hiZgiZ ^]gZ ZghiZ HV^hdc Zg[da\gZ^X] jcY oZ^\iZ h^X] h^X]ia^X] oj[g^ZYZc/ ยบ9Vh lVg Z^c idaaZg L^ciZg# LdX]ZcZcYZ [ย g LdX]ZcZcYZ ZgaZWiZ ^X] Z^c Z^co^\Vgi^\Zh 6bW^ZciZ gjcY jbh G^kZaaV ;Vb^an 8dciZhi"K^aaV\Z#ยป

22 von 25

25

20

9Zg DeZc^c\":kZci \^c\ Vb &)# 9ZoZbWZg '%%- ^c YZc ;ajbhZgWZg\Zc ย WZg Y^Z 7ย ]cZ# B^i Vb HiVgi lVgZc egdb^cZciZ IZ^acZ]bZg l^Z Hl^hh"H`^ Eg~h^YZci Jgh AZ]bVcc! :m"GVYegd[^ 6aZm Oย aaZ jcY YZg Z]ZbVa^\Z :^h]dX`ZnhiVg GZcVid Idh^d jcY ^]gZ ;Vb^a^Zc# :WZc[Vaah oj YZc =^\]a^\]ih YZg HV^hdc o~]aiZ YVh CVX]igZccZc Vj[ YZg 6mVae jcY YZg G^kZaaV ;Vb^an 8dciZhi b^i Z^cZb @dhiย blZiiWZlZgW Vc YZg AZc`#

26 26 von 29 von 29

30

23 von 23

27 von 28

24 25 von 24 von 25

18 20 20 20 von 20 von 20 von 20 von 20 18 18 von 18 von 18

15

10

5

0 1997

1998

1999

2000

2001

2002

2003

2004

2005

2006

2007

2008

2009

(( 8dde ;jc EVgXdjgh à AVc\aVj[heVhh [ g HX]ja`aVhhZc 9Zg 8dde ;jc EVgXdjgh hdaa YZc ?j\ZcYa^X]Zc YZc AVj\aVj[hedgi c~]Zg Wg^c\Zc# >c YZg kZg\Vc\ZcZc HV^hdc ]VWZc h^X] hd WZg ( %%% ?j\ZcYa^X]Z kdb AVc\aVj[k^gjh VchiZX`Zc aVhhZc# = ]Zejc`i lVg YVh ?j\ZcYaVc\aVj[aV\Zg ol^hX]Zc LZ^]cVX]iZc jcY CZj_V]g ^c AVc\^h dWZg]VaW HVgcZc! YVh b^i ''% IZ^acZ]bZcYZc gZhiadh Vjh\Z" WjX]i lVg# 9^Z =~a[iZ YZg IZ^acZ]bZcYZc hiVcY YVWZ^ ZghibVah Vj[ AVc\aVj[h`^h# >c YZc Wg^\Zc GZ\^dcZc ]VWZc Y^Z HX]cjeeZg`jghZ ZWZc[Vaah cVX]]Vai^\ :^cYgjX` ]^ciZgaVhhZc# Hd egd[^i^ZgiZc ^c :WcVi"@VeeZa jcY LViil^a WZg )*% HX]ja`^cYZg ^b GV]bZc YZh 8dde ;jc EVgXdjgh kdc YZc \jiZc HX]cZZkZg]~aic^hhZc fjVh^ kdg YZg HX]ja]Vjhi gZ# ; g Hl^hh"H`^ ^hi Y^Z >chiVcYhiZaajc\ YZh 8dde ;jc EVgXdjgh Z^cZ \gdhhZ ad\^hi^hX]Z =ZgVjh[dgYZgjc\# D[i h^cY Y^Z IZgb^cZ ol^hX]Zc olZ^ 6ca~hhZc hd `cVee WZbZhhZc! YVhh c~X]ia^X]Z BViZg^VakZghX]^ZWjc\Zc c i^\ h^cY# L chX]ZchlZgi l~gZ Zh! lZcc Y^Z >YZZ Y^ZhZg HX]cjeeZg`jghZ WgZ^iZg VW\Zhi ioi l~gZ# Hl^hh"H`^ l^aa YZh]VaW oj` c[i^\ cdX] bZ]g BViZg^Va WZgZ^ihiZaaZc jcY \Zc \ZcY AZ^iZg VjhW^aYZc! Y^Z ^c ^]gZg DgihX]V[i hZaWhi~cY^\ @^cYZg jcY ?j\ZcYa^X]Z ojb B^ibVX]Zc Vc^b^ZgZc#

Hl^hh CdgY^X 9Vnh AVc\aVj[hX]cjeeZgiV\Z [ g :^chiZ^\Zg jcY YVb^i ?jc\ jcY 6ai ojb AVc\aVj[Zc Vc^b^ZgZc à YVh ^hi Y^Z >YZZ YZg Hl^hh CdgY^X 9Vnh# &+ 6jhigV\jc\Zc ]Vi YZg KZgWVcY HX]lZ^oZg AVc\aVj[hX]jaZc ojhVbbZc b^i Ad^eZc HX]lZ^o jcY Hl^hh"H`^ ^c Y^ZhZb L^ciZg Zg[da\gZ^X] YjgX]\Z[ ]gi# 6c _ZYZb CdgY^X 9Vn `dcciZc h^X] AVc\aVj[^ciZgZhh^ZgiZ [ g Z^cZc olZ^hi cY^\Zc `dhiZcadhZc JciZgg^X]i VcbZaYZc# 9^Z Hl^hh CdgY^X 9Vnh ZgaZWiZc Z^cZc g^X]i^\Zc 7ddb# 9^Z \jiZc HX]cZZkZg]~aic^hhZ VjX] ^c i^Z[Zc AV\Zc jcY Y^Z idaaZc GZhjaiViZ kdc 9Vg^d 8dad\cV ]VWZc ojg \gdhhZc CVX][gV\Z WZ^\ZigV\Zc# >chWZhdcYZgZ WZ^ Z^cZb _jc\Zc EjWa^`jb hdl^Z WZ^ YZc ;gVjZc ^hi YVh >ciZgZhhZ Vb AVc\aVj[hedgi \Zhi^Z\Zc#

HeVhh ^b HX]cZZ 9Vh E^adiegd_Z`i YZg HX]cZZheVhhiV\Z ljgYZ ^b ?V]g '%%( kdc Hl^hh"H`^! Hl^hh Hcdlhedgih! ><"HX]cZZ hdl^Z kdc HZ^aWV]cZc HX]lZ^o ^ch AZWZc \Zgj[Zc# =^ciZg\gjcY YZg HX]cZZheVhhiV\Z ^hi YZg! YVhh k^ZaZ @^cYZg jcY ?j\ZcYa^X]Z `Z^cZ B \a^X]`Z^iZc ]VWZc! HX]cZZhedgi Vjhoj WZc# >c Y^ZhZb ?V]g [VcYZc Y^Z HX]cZZheVhhiV\Z [ g HX] aZg^ccZc jcY HX] aZg Vjh I]jc jcY DaiZc hiVii#

; g Y^Z I]jcZg dg\Vc^h^ZgiZ Hcdlhedgih I]jc Z^cZ \VcoZ LdX]Z HeVhh ^b HX]cZZ Vc YZg AZc`# I~\a^X] [j]gZc &(% @^Yh ^ch 7ZgcZg DWZgaVcY jcY ljgYZc Ydgi kdc HX]cZZhedgiaZ]gZgc YZg H`^" jcY HcdlWdVgYhX]jaZ AZc` egd[Zhh^dcZaa WZigZji# 9^Z Dg\Vc^hVidgZc oZ^\iZc h^X] Vb :cYZ YZg I]jcZg HX]cZZheVhhiV\Z gjcYjb oj[g^ZYZc/ ºL^g ZgaZWiZc Z^cZ hjeZg LdX]Z b^i hZchVi^dcZaaZc KZg]~aic^hhZc#» 9^Z HX] aZg Vjh DaiZc Yjg[iZc ^b ?VcjVg _ZYZc 9^ZchiV\ cVX] H gZcWZg\ [V]gZc! jb Ydgi Z^cZc jckZg\Zhha^X]Zc IV\ ^b HX]cZZ oj ZgaZWZc# :ilV Y^Z =~a[iZ YZg +%% HX] aZg^ccZc jcY HX] aZg hiVcY YVWZ^ ojb ZghiZc BVa Vj[ Z^cZb HX]cZZhedgi\Zg~i# 9^ZhZ OV]aZc WZaZ\Zc! YVhh k^ZaZ ?j\ZcYa^X]Z ^c YZg HX]lZ^o `Z^cZc 7Zoj\ ojb HX]cZZhedgi ]VWZc# Igdio YZh \gdhhZc =VcYajc\hWZYVg[h [Z]aZc jch _ZYdX] ojgoZ^i Y^Z B^iiZa! jb Y^Z 6`i^dc ^c \g hhZgZb Hi^a VcojW^ZiZc#

BVhiZgh Vae^c <gdhhZ :gZ^\c^hhZ lZg[Zc ^]gZ HX]ViiZc kdgVjh# B^i GdWZgi BVii]^Zj Vah Kdgh^ioZcYZb! ?ja^V HX]~gZg Vah BVcc" hX]V[ih[ ]gZg^c jcY GZc =d[Zg! 8]Z[ >G Dhi! ]VWZc \aZ^X] YgZ^ cZjZ B^i\a^ZYZg ^c YZg @dbb^hh^dc BVhiZgh Vae^c :^ch^io \ZcdbbZc# >c YZg HV^hdc '%%-$%. \VW Zh oV]agZ^X]Z = ]Zejc`iZ oj kZgoZ^X]cZc/ 6b BVhiZgh LdgaY 8g^iZg^jb ^c E^VcXVkVaad \ZlVcc Y^Z `aZ^cZ Hl^hh" H`^ 9ZaZ\Vi^dc hZX]h <daY" jcY k^Zg H^aWZgbZYV^aaZc à Zgl~]cZch" lZgi ^hi! YVhh YgZ^ YZg <daYbZYV^aaZc kdb .%"_~]g^\Zc :gchi 7Zg\Zg Vjh 7Zgc \ZldccZc ljgYZc# 6b Hl^hh HZc^dg 8je cV]bZc gjcY '%% BVhiZgh iZ^a0 YZg ;gVjZcVciZ^a ^hi b^i gjcY &% ~jhhZghi hX]lVX] kZg" igZiZc# (& kdc YZc (' Vjh\ZhX]g^ZWZcZc LZii`~be[Zc `dcciZc hiVii" [^cYZc# B^i YZc ;>H BVhiZgh LdgaY 8g^iZg^jb HZc^dgZc H`^"LB Vae^c kdb '&#Ã',# B~go '%&% ^c BZ^g^c\Zc"=Vha^WZg\ ]Vi Y^Z HX]lZ^o cVX] k^ZaZc ?V]gZc YZc OjhX]aV\ Zg]VaiZc! Y^ZhZ <gdhhkZgVchiVaijc\ b^i gjcY +%% IZ^acZ]bZcYZc oj dg\Vc^h^ZgZc#

H`^idjgZc zWZg &%% kZghX]^ZYZchiZ 6`i^k^i~iZc ^b L^ciZg jcY HdbbZg h^cY ^c YZg DjiYddg"7gdhX] gZ '%%. kdc Hl^hh"H`^ Vj[\Z[ ]gi# 9Vh 6c\ZWdi gZ^X]i kdc XajW^ciZgcZc H`^idjgZc W^h oj 6jh" jcY LZ^iZgW^aYjc\h`jghZc YZg GZ\^dcVakZgW~cYZ jcY Hl^hh"H`^ jcY l^gY gZ\Z \Zcjioi# 9^Z \gdhhZ CVX][gV\Z ]Vi YZg cZjZ 6jhW^aYjc\h" X]Z[ I]dbVh <ddY BZah b^i hZ^cZc 7Zg\[ ]gZgZmeZgiZc ^c Y^kZghZc @jghbdYjaZc dei^bVa VW\ZYZX`i# CVX] &%"_~]g^" \Zg I~i^\`Z^i Vah IdjgZcX]Z[ YZh OHHK jcY Vah B^i\a^ZY YZg IdjgZc`dbb^hh^dc ]Vi LZgcZg Ea hh Gdi]g^hi YZb^hh^dc^Zgi# HZ^c CVX][da\Zg ^hi 7Zgc]VgY HX]^ZhhZg Vjh 7 g\aZc$Jg^#

;>C6COL:H:C

()

:g[da\gZ^X]Zg [^cVco^ZaaZg 6WhX]ajhh 6jX] Vjh [^cVco^ZaaZg H^X]i lVg YVh kZg\Vc\ZcZ <ZhX]~[ih_V]g Z^c :g[da\# Hl^hh"H`^ hX]a^Zhhi Y^Z ?V]gZhgZX]cjc\ '%%-$%. b^i Z^cZb :gigV\h WZghX]jhh kdc 8=; +(*È-&% VW# 9Zg <ZhVbi" ZgigV\ Zg] ]iZ h^X] Vj[ 8=; ('È-.+È+&+#)) ^b Kdg_V]g 8=; '.È.*+È%+%#*' 0 YZg <ZhVbiVj[lVcY WZigj\ 8=; ('È'+%È-%+#))# 9^Z 6j[lVcY" jcY :gigV\hZg] ]jc\ \Z\Zc WZg YZb Kdg_V]g ]Vi eg^b~g b^i BlHi"iZX]c^hX]Zc 6heZ`iZc oj ijc! YV cZj Y^Z 9^ZchiaZ^hijc\Zc \Z\Zc WZg HedchdgZc jcY 6i]aZiZc \Z\ZckZg" gZX]cZi lZgYZc b hhZc# 6j[ YVh <ZhVbiZg\ZWc^h kdc Hl^hh"H`^ ]VWZc Y^ZhZ 7jX]jc\Zc _ZYdX] `Z^cZc :^c[ajhh#

7^aVco eZg (%# 6eg^a '%%. :gcZji kZg[ \i Hl^hh"H`^ Vb :cYZ YZh <ZhX]~[ih_V]gZh WZg \Z" c \ZcY [a hh^\Z B^iiZa ^c YZg = ]Z kdc gjcY 8=; '#' B^d# 9^Zh YVc` KdgVjhoV]ajc\Zc kdc HedchdgZcWZ^ig~\Zc! lZaX]Z _ZYdX] igVch^idg^hX] VW\Z\gZcoi h^cY# 9Vh 9Za`gZYZgZ ljgYZ Vj[\gjcY YZg V`ijZaaZc L^gihX]V[ihaV\Z h^X]Zg]Z^ih]VaWZg Zg] ]i# Ojb OZ^iejc`i YZg 7Zg^X]ihkZg[Vhhjc\ ljgYZc _ZYdX] Y^Z bZ^h" iZc YZg VjhhiZ]ZcYZc GZX]cjc\Zc WZ\a^X]Zc# 9^Z V`i^kZc GZX]cjc\hVW\gZcojc\Zc hZioZc h^X] eg^b~g Vjh 7Z^ig~\Zc kdc Hl^hh Danbe^X! ;>H! ? H jcY KZgh^X]Zgjc\Zc ojhVbbZc#

:gigV\ 7Z^ YZc B^i\a^ZYZgWZ^ig~\Zc `dcciZ ZgcZji aZ^X]i oj\ZaZ\i lZg" YZc# 9Vc` YZg B^i\a^ZYZgV`i^dc! Y^Z ^c OjhVbbZcVgWZ^i b^i YZb EVgicZg DX]hcZg Hedgi YjgX]\Z[ ]gi ljgYZ! `dcciZc ^ccZg]VaW Z^cZh BdcVih WZg ( (%% CZjb^i\a^ZYZg \ZldccZc lZgYZc# :cYZ 6eg^a '%%. WZigj\ Y^Z 6coV]a B^i\a^ZYZg gjcY &%) %%%# Ojb edh^" i^kZc :gigV\hZg\ZWc^h igj\Zc [ZgcZg c^X]i Vjh\ZhX] e[iZ 7jY\Zih! c^X]i WjY\Zi^ZgiZ HedchdgZc"! < ccZg" jcY Hi^[ijc\hWZ^ig~\Z hdl^Z :g[da\heg~b^Zc YZg KZgWVcYhhedchdgZc WZ^# OjYZb ]Vi VjX] YZg Hl^hh"H`^ Edda jcZglVgiZiZ BZ]gZ^ccV]bZc \ZcZg^Zgi# C^X]i ojaZioi kZg]Va[ Z^cZ `dchZgkVi^kZ 7jY\Zi^Zgjc\ hdld]a Vj[ :gigV\hhZ^iZ l^Z VjX] Vj[ 6j[lVcYhZ^iZ ojb edh^i^kZc GZhjaiVi#

6j[lVcY 6jX] Y^ZhZh ?V]g ljgYZc Y^kZghZ 7jY\Zih WZghX]g^iiZc# Hd `Vb Zh WZ^he^ZahlZ^hZ ^c Z^coZacZc 9^ho^ea^cZc oj zWZghX]gZ^ijc\Zc! YV oj\Zh^X]ZgiZ < ccZgWZ^ig~\Z c^X]i ^c YZg kZgZ^cWVgiZc = ]Z VjhWZoV]ai ljgYZc# 9^Z iZ^alZ^hZ bVhh^kZc zWZghX]gZ^ijc\Zc `dcciZc _ZYdX] YjgX] :^cheVgjc\Zc gZYjo^Zgi lZgYZc! hd YVhh YZg [^cVco^ZaaZ HX]VYZc ^c <gZcoZc \Z]VaiZc lZgYZc `dcciZ#

:^\Zc`Ve^iVaWVh^h cVX] l^Z kdg hZ]g i^Z[ 7Z^ Z^cZb JbhVio kdc gjcY 8=; (% B^d# kZg[ \i Hl^hh"H`^ b^i 8=; -.*È*',#.& ^b Kdg_V]g 8=; '*.È,&,#.& VWZg lZ^iZg]^c WZg kZg\aZ^X]hlZ^hZ lZc^\ :^\Zc`Ve^iVa# :g[gZja^X] ^hi _ZYdX] Y^Z IVihVX]Z oj lZgiZc! YVhh YVh :^\Zc`Ve^iVa ^ccZgi aZY^\" a^X] YgZ^ ?V]gZc Y^ZhZ = ]Z ZggZ^X]i ]Vi# CZWhi YZg hedgia^X]Zc LZ^iZgZcil^X`ajc\ ^hi Zh jchZg O^Za! YVh :^\Zc`Ve^iVa Vj[ Z^cZ VchegZX]ZcYZ = ]Z oj Wg^c\Zc# Jb Y^ZhZh O^Za oj ZggZ^X]Zc! b h" hZc h~bia^X]Z 7ZiZ^a^\iZ lZ^iZg]^c Y^Z c i^\Z 9^ho^ea^c jcY YVh KZghi~cYc^h Vj[Wg^c\Zc# 9Zg ;d`jh bjhh hdb^i VjX] ^c Oj`jc[i c^X]i VaaZ^c Vj[ hedgia^X]Zc :g[da\Zc! hdcYZgc VjX] Vj[ Z^cZg \Z" hjcYZc [^cVco^ZaaZc 7Vh^h a^Z\Zc#

7^aVco eZg (%# 6eg^a '%%.

6@I>K:C

9ZiV^ah

JbaVj[kZgb \Zc ;a hh^\Z B^iiZa LZgihX]g^[iZc ;dgYZgjc\Zc Kdgg~iZ 6`i^kZ GZX]cjc\hVW\gZcojc\

%

&%È'&)È-,.#') .-#%

6caV\ZkZgb \Zc BdW^aZ HVX]VcaV\Zc >bbdW^aZ HVX]VcaV\Zc ;^cVcoVcaV\Zc >bbViZg^ZaaZ 6caV\Zc

eZg (%#)#%.

HVX]VcaV\Zhe^Z\Za

OlZX`\ZWjcYZcZh KZgb \Zc IdiVa 6`i^kZc

eZg (%#)#%-

%

.È''-È.%'#** ..#)

'È'')È+()#%+ Ã +È*&+È-('#&( &#%% &È),(È)&'#%*

'&#( Ã +'#* %#% &)#&

&È*)%È&'(#&. Ã *È-,%È,*-#)& &#%% &È-&-È%&.#.*

&+#+ Ã +(#( %#% &.#+

'%*È+,(#)*

'#%

*&È.*,#'*

%#+

'%*È+,(#)* Ã Ã Ã

'#% Ã Ã Ã

Ã

Ã

*&È.*,#'* Ã Ã Ã

Ã

%#+ Ã Ã Ã

Ã

&%È)'%È**'#+. &%%#%

.È'-%È-*.#-% &%%#%

.È&%)È-'*#,- -,#)

-È+,&È+)-#-. .(#)

E6HH>K:C @jgo[g^hi^\Zh ;gZbY`Ve^iVa

;^cVcokZgW^cYa^X]`Z^iZc Hdchi^\Z KZgW^cYa^X]`Z^iZc EVhh^kZ GZX]cjc\hVW\gZcojc\

à 'È&++È-*%#)( +È.(,È.,*#(*

à '%#- ++#+

à 'È(,&È&..#*. +È(%%È)).#(%

à '*#* +,#.

AVc\[g^hi^\Zh ;gZbY`Ve^iVa

)'%È&..#%%

)#%

().È).(#%%

(#-

;^cVcokZgW^cYa^X]`Z^iZc Hdchi^\Z KZgW^cYa^X]`Z^iZc G X`hiZaajc\Zc

G X`hiZaajc\hhe^Z\Za

à à )'%È&..#%%

à à )#%

;dcYh`Ve^iVa ;dcYh kdc HeZcYZgc ;dcYh \ZW^aYZi YjgX] YZc KZgWVcY

KZgWVcYh`Ve^iVa KZgWVcYh`Ve^iVa ?V]gZhZg\ZWc^h

IdiVa EVhh^kZc

KZgWVcYh`Ve^iVa

à à ().È).(#%%

à à (#-

Ã

Ã

Ã

Ã

à Ã

à Ã

à Ã

à Ã

-.*È*',#.&

-#+

'*.È,&,#.& +(*È-&%#%%

'#* +#&

&%È)'%È**'#+. &%%#%

'*.È,&,#.& *+È''*#'+ '%(È).'#+*

'#- %#+ '#'

.È'-%È-*.#-% &%%#%

(*

;>C6COL:H:C

<ZhVbiZg[da\hgZX]cjc\ &# BV^ '%%- W^h (%# 6eg^a '%%.

9ZiV^ah

7Zig^ZWa^X]Zg :gigV\

9ZiV^a :gigV\

HeVgiZcVj[lVcY He^ioZchedgi HeVgiZcVj[lVcY CVX]ljX]haZ^hijc\hhedgi HeVgiZcVj[lVcY 7gZ^iZchedgi

(+

'%%-$%.

%

('È-.+È+&+#)) &%%#%

'%%,$%-

%

'.È.*+È%+%#*' &%%#%

HeVgiZcgZX]cjc\

"&+È%&(È*)*#&)

")-#,

"&(È)%(È'-'#++

"))#,

HeVgiZcgZX]cjc\ HeVgiZcgZX]cjc\

")È*&(È(.*#'- "&È,+%È*-+#%&

"&(#, "*#)

")È()-È**&#-* "&È)'*È%&+#.+

"&)#* ")#-

Ol^hX]ZcZg\ZWc^h >

&%È+%.È%.%#%& ('#'

&%È,,.È'%.#%* (+#%

EZghdcVaVj[lVcY GZ^hZ"! GZeg~hZciVi^dch" jcY LZgWZVj[lVcY HVX]Vj[lVcY 6WhX]gZ^Wjc\Zc

"'È&((È)+-#&%

"+#*

"'È'))È,,.#&*

",#*

"+È(%,È*'.#,- "&È)'(È%+,#+) "&%%È)+'#(%

"&.#' ")#( "%#(

"+È,.%È,..#+( "&È)+*È-&+#*) "'&È&,.#)%

"''#, ")#. "%#&

:g\ZWc^h Vjh WZig^ZWa^X]Zg I~i^\`Z^i

+))È*+'#&.

'*+È+()#((

%#.

;^cVcoZgigV\ ;^cVcoVj[lVcY 7Zig^ZWh[gZbYZg :gigV\ 7Zig^ZWh[gZbYZg 6j[lVcY

:g\ZWc^h kdg HiZjZgc

HiZjZgc

:g\ZWc^h kdg ;dcYhZg\ZWc^h ;dcYhZg\ZWc^h

?V]gZhZg\ZWc^h 6j[lVcY

*+È,.'#'* "&+È%%(#)) Ã "*%È%%%#%%

+(*È(*&#%% )*.#%%

+(*È-&%#%% Ã

+(*È-&%#%%

'#% %#' "%#% Ã "%#'

&#. %#%

&#. Ã

&#.

"('È'+%È-%+#))

')È.+-#%. "&-È&.-#., Ã "+%È%%%#%%

'%(È)%(#)* -.#'%

'%(È).'#+* Ã

'%(È).'#+*

%#& "%#& Ã "%#'

%#, %#%

%#, Ã

%#,

"'.È,*'È*+,#-,

9ZiV^a WZig^ZWa^X]Zg :gigV\ &# BV^ '%%- W^h (%# 6eg^a '%%.

7Zig^ZWa^X]Zg :gigV\ 7Z^ig~\Z B^i\a^ZYZg 7Z^ig~\Z [[Zcia^X]Zg 7ZgZ^X] 7Z^ig~\Z eg^kVigZX]ia^X]Zg 7ZgZ^X] 7Z^ig~\Z KZgW~cYZ LZgWZZgig~\Z :gig~\Z < ccZg :gig~\Z Vjh KZgVchiVaijc\Zc :gig~\Z 6jh" jcY LZ^iZgW^aYjc\ 9^kZghZ WZig^ZWa^X]Z :gig~\Z

'%%-$%.

%

('È-.+È+&+#)) &%%#% 'È*((È,-%#-' *%%È.%+#'% (È%-'È&*&#%% (--È+--#+% '(È,%*È)%&#%* ,.'È%*%#%% (,-È*%(#*% -&È),-#*% &È)((È+*+#,,

,#, &#* .#) &#' ,'#& '#) &#' %#' )#)

'%%,$%-

%

'.È.*+È%+%#*' &%%#% 'È)).È-.-#)% '.(È.)'#'* 'È-%-È.'&#(* *).È'(,#,% '&È&%-È'+-#+% &È%(-È..*#%% ()-È''(#%% &)%È.&'#*% &È'&,È++&#,'

-#' &#% .#) &#- ,%#* (#* &#' %#* )#&

zWg^\Z 6c\VWZc '%%-$%.

'%%,$%-

7 g\hX]V[iZc

`Z^cZ

`Z^cZ

<VgVci^ZkZge[a^X]ijc\Zc

`Z^cZ

`Z^cZ

`Z^cZ `Z^cZ `Z^cZ `Z^cZ `Z^cZ `Z^cZ

`Z^cZ `Z^cZ `Z^cZ `Z^cZ `Z^cZ `Z^cZ

`Z^cZ `Z^cZ `Z^cZ `Z^cZ `Z^cZ `Z^cZ

`Z^cZ `Z^cZ `Z^cZ `Z^cZ `Z^cZ `Z^cZ

;~aa^\`Z^ihhigj`ijg/

`Z^cZ

`Z^cZ

KZgW^cYa^X]`Z^iZc \Z\Zc WZg Kdghdg\ZZ^cg^X]ijc\Zc 7K<

`Z^cZ

`Z^cZ

LZhZcia^X]Z 7ZiZ^a^\jc\Zc

`Z^cZ

`Z^cZ

LZ^iZgZ! c^X]i oj W^aVco^ZgZcYZ KZge[a^X]ijc\Zc

`Z^cZ

`Z^cZ

E[VcYWZhiZaajc\Zc oj\jchiZc 9g^iiZg/ KZge[~cYZiZ LZgihX]g^[iZc JbaVj[kZgb \Zc 6W\ZigZiZcZ ;dgYZgjc\Zc KZge[~cYZiZ LZgihX]g^[iZc 6caV\ZkZgb \Zc KZge[~cYZiZ 7ZiZ^a^\jc\Zc KZge[~cYZiZ hdchi^\Z ;^cVcoVcaV\Zc KZge[~cYZiZ hdchi^\Z ;^cVcoVcaV\Zc \\ cV]ZhiZ]ZcYZ EZghdcZc

:^\ZcijbhWZhX]g~c`jc\ [ g Z^\ZcZ KZge[a^X]ijc\Zc/ KZge[~cYZiZ LZgihX]g^[iZc JbaVj[kZgb \Zc 6W\ZigZiZcZ ;dgYZgjc\Zc KZge[~cYZiZ LZgihX]g^[iZc 6caV\ZkZgb \Zc KZge[~cYZiZ 7ZiZ^a^\jc\Zc KZge[~cYZiZ hdchi^\Z ;^cVcoVcaV\Zc KZge[~cYZiZ hdchi^\Z ;^cVcoVcaV\Zc \\ cV]ZhiZ]ZcYZ EZghdcZc

AZVh^c\kZgW^cYa^X]`Z^iZc

G^h^`dWZjgiZ^ajc\ 9Vh Eg~h^Y^jb ]Vi h^X] b^i YZc [ g Y^Z ?V]gZhgZX]cjc\ lZhZcia^X]Zc G^h^`Zc VjhZ^cVcYZg\ZhZioi jcY Ã [Vaah cdilZcY^\ Ã Zg[dgYZga^X]Z BVhhcV]bZc WZhX]adhhZc# 9Vh G^h^`d Z^cZg lZhZcia^X]Zc ;VahX]VjhhV\Z ^c YZg ?V]gZhgZX]cjc\ ^hi Vah `aZ^c Z^cojhij[Zc#

(,

à à à à ,)'È+-*#&.

,)'Ç+-*#&.

IdiVa 7gZ^iZchedgi

,)'È+-*#&.

&È),)È-.)#+.

LZii`~be[Z IgV^c^c\ 6jhW^aYjc\ HeVgiZcbVcV\ZbZci Egd_Z`iZ

7gZ^iZchedgi

IdiVa CVX]ljX]haZ^hijc\hhedgi

&%È,&*#-' '&'È+.,#,- &&.È&&*#+. *+'È(,&#&- *+.È..)#'( Ã Ã

&È),)È-.)#+. &È*.+È.(,#),

?LB LZii`~be[Z IgV^c^c\ IgV^cZg$IZX]c^`Zg HeVgiZcbVcV\ZbZci HedgibZY^o^c CVX]ljX]hegd_Z`iZ

CVX]ljX]haZ^hijc\hhedgi

,)'Ç+-*#'%

à à à à ,)'È+-*#'%

,)'È+-*#'%

&È*.+È.(,#),

-È(,-#*. &-+È)+'#&* &.&È.%.#,( +)%È&+(#,- *,%È%'(#'( Ã Ã

)È*))È*)*#-&

(È,*(È+(+#)'

IdiVa He^ioZchedgi

-'È(',#%% '+&È((.#-& )),È)%,#-' &È-)'È.)-#)( &È%'(È*+'#,, (+%È'-*#(( *'+È+,)#+*

+)È&&+#%% '+.È.'-#&& (((È.(.#,% &È(.&È%%(#%% &È%'(È(%(#%, '*.È,-%#-' )&&È*+*#,'

',*Ç'&*#+'

à à à à ',*È'&*#+'

',*È'&*#+'

(,&È'%,#)*

&-È)',#&* &%'È+(+#&% &&*È('-#,% ..È)',#-% (*È(-,#,% Ã Ã

(,&È'%,#)*

&È+(-È%&+#*&

(,È&+.#-* '*(È%+&#)( '(*È*&&#,. *,,È%')#'* (&(È-)*#%' &'%È&()#&% &%&È',%#%,

Ã

à à à à Ã

Ã

',*È,.,#%%

'È()'#%% &(È+-+#%% &%%È'*(#%% &')È,)+#%% ()È,,%#%% Ã Ã

',*È,.,#%%

&È'(%È%''#,&

&%È%&-#+% *+È-(,#&* &*&È.*%#(+ *%)È,,*#)* (&'È.(.#+* &%)È(-&#-% -.È&&.#,%

H`^hegjc\

(È,*(È+(+#)' )È*))È*)*#-& &È+(-È%&+#*& &È'(%È%''#,&

LB LZii`~be[Z IgV^c^c\ IgV^cZg$IZX]c^`Zg HeVgiZcbVcV\ZbZci HedgibZY^o^c Egd_Z`iZ

AVc\aVj[

He^ioZchedgi

=ZggZc 6ae^c

9VbZc 6ae^c

Ã

à à à à Ã

Ã

&&)È,')#(+

,È',.#.. '&È-.'#%- )È+&+#'. )(È..'#%% (+È.))#%% Ã Ã

&&)È,')#(+

-.(È')+#),

,È&.*#-* ).È+&(#(- ''(È*'*#.) '++È.+.#.% (('È*%%#+% &(È))%#-% Ã

-.(È')+#),

CdgY# @dbW#

HcdlWdVgY

Ã

à à à à Ã

Ã

-,È(.+#-*

'(È+&.#-% )È.'%#&* &È')*#.% '-È,*%#%% '-È-+&#%% Ã Ã

-,È(.+#-*

-+*È%()#&'

&%È'**#,% &%*È&%&#%, '(+È(,-#-% &-,È&(,#,* '*.È,).#'* *&È,'-#-* &)È+-'#,%

Ã

à à à à Ã

Ã

')-È*++#&*

*'È(+&#'% +È,,,#+* '&È,(.#)* ,(È)&.#-* .)È'+-#%% Ã Ã

')-È*++#&*

'È'.-È*(+#+%

,.È,%+#+* &*)È-*)#(* ',&È*%(#-- +',È%)&#-% -)-È)&-#)% &&-È+*%#+, &.-È(+%#-*

-+*È%()#&' 'È'.-È*(+#+%

7^Vi]adc

(-

6J;L6C9

HeVgiZcVj[lVcY &# BV^ '%%- W^h (%# 6eg^a '%%.

Ã

à à à à Ã

Ã

()(È-,&#('

à '*)È&,.#.- +,È***#(.

-È--%#%% &'È,'&#'% *()#,* Ã

()(È-,&#('

,+'È(%-#.*

-+È(*%#+% *(È)+(#%( &*)È***#)% &)&È.--#,% &&(È)(+#.' ('È-(.#%% &,.È+,*#(%

,+'È(%-#.*

;gZZhinaZ

IdiVa

(,,È&)%#'* &È'',È+*.#(- 'È%*.È*&%#&. *È*(-È--.#'- )È'',È,**#+- &È%+&È')&#(, &È*'&È()-#..

)È*&(È(.*#'-

&'(È&')#** -%(È'*&#-. +'&È,+)#&) &È*-&È,*%#+% &È(-'È.+.#(* *()#,* Ã

Ã

à à à à Ã

&Ç,+%Ç*-+#%&

à à à à &È,+%È*-+#%&

à &È,+%È*-+#%&

à à à à à à Ã

à )È*&(È(.*#'-

'-È&.,#** &+È%&(È*)*#&)

à '(È)+&#%* )È,(+#*% à à à Ã

'-È&.,#** &+È%&(È*)*#&)

IZaZbVg`

;>C6COL:H:C

GZk^h^dchWZg^X]i 7Zg^X]i YZg GZk^h^dchhiZaaZ ojg ?V]gZhgZX]cjc\ Vc Y^Z 9ZaZ\^ZgiZckZghVbbajc\ YZh HX]lZ^oZg^hX]Zc H`^kZg" WVcYZh Hl^hh"H`^ kdb )# ?ja^ '%%. ^c EdcigZh^cV# 6ah GZk^h^dchhiZaaZ ]VWZc l^g Y^Z ?V]gZhgZX]cjc\ YZh HX]lZ^oZg^hX]Zc H`^kZgWVcYZh Hl^hh"H`^ ! WZhiZ]ZcY Vjh 7^aVco! :g[da\hgZX]cjc\ jcY 6c]Vc\ [ g YVh Vb (%# 6eg^a '%%. VW\ZhX]adhhZcZ <ZhX]~[ih_V]g \Zeg [i#

KZgVcildgijc\ YZh Eg~h^Y^jbh 9Vh Eg~h^Y^jb ^hi [ g Y^Z 6j[hiZaajc\ YZg ?V]gZhgZX]cjc\ ^c zWZgZ^chi^bbjc\ b^i YZc \ZhZioa^X]Zc KdghX]g^[iZc jcY YZc HiVijiZc kZgVcildgia^X]# 9^ZhZ KZgVcildgijc\ WZ^c]VaiZi Y^Z 6jh\ZhiVaijc\! >beaZbZci^Zgjc\ jcY 6j[gZX]iZg]Vaijc\ Z^" cZh ^ciZgcZc @dcigdaahnhiZbh b^i 7Zoj\ Vj[ Y^Z 6j[hiZaajc\ Z^cZg ?V]gZhgZX]cjc\! Y^Z [gZ^ kdc lZhZcia^X]Zc [VahX]Zc 6c\VWZc Vah ;da\Z kdc KZghi hhZc dYZg >ggi bZgc ^hi# 9Vg WZg ]^cVjh ^hi YVh Eg~h^Y^jb [ g Y^Z 6jhlV]a jcY Y^Z 6clZcYjc\ hVX]\Zb~hhZg GZX]cjc\haZ\jc\hbZi]dYZc hdl^Z Y^Z KdgcV]bZ Vc\ZbZhhZcZg HX]~iojc\Zc kZgVci" ldgia^X]#

KZgVcildgijc\ YZg GZk^h^dchhiZaaZ JchZgZ KZgVcildgijc\ ^hi Zh! Vj[\gjcY jchZgZg Eg [jc\ Z^c Eg [jc\hjgiZ^a WZg Y^Z ?V]gZhgZX]cjc\ VWoj\ZWZc# L^g ]V" WZc jchZgZ Eg [jc\ ^c zWZgZ^chi^bbjc\ b^i YZb hX]lZ^" oZg^hX]Zc <ZhZio jcY YZc HX]lZ^oZg Eg [jc\hhiVcYVgYh hdl^Z YZb GZX]cjc\haZ\jc\h]VcYWjX] Hl^hh Hedgi <66E YZg Hl^hh Danbe^X 6hhdX^Vi^dc kdg\ZcdbbZc# CVX] Y^ZhZc HiVcYVgYh ]VWZc l^g Y^Z Eg [jc\ hd oj eaVcZc jcY YjgX]oj" [ ]gZc! YVhh l^g ]^cgZ^X]ZcYZ H^X]Zg]Z^i \Zl^ccZc! dW Y^Z ?V]gZhgZX]cjc\ [gZ^ kdc lZhZcia^X]Zc [VahX]Zc 6c\VWZc ^hi#

Eg [jc\hjgiZ^a CVX] jchZgZg 7ZjgiZ^ajc\ Zciheg^X]i Y^Z ?V]gZhgZX]cjc\ [ g YVh Vb (%# 6eg^a '%%. VW\ZhX]adhhZcZ <ZhX]~[ih_V]g YZb hX]lZ^oZg^hX]Zc <ZhZio jcY YZc HiVijiZc hdl^Z YZb GZX]cjc\haZ\jc\h]VcYWjX] Hl^hh Hedgi <66E YZg Hl^hh Danbe^X 6hhdX^Vi^dc#

7Zg^X]iZghiViijc\ Vj[\gjcY lZ^iZgZg \ZhZioa^X]Zg KdghX]g^[iZc L^g WZhi~i^\Zc! YVhh l^g Y^Z \ZhZioa^X]Zc 6c[dgYZgjc\Zc Vc Y^Z OjaVhhjc\ \Zb~hh GZk^h^dchVj[h^X]ih\ZhZio G6< jcY Y^Z JcVW]~c\^\`Z^i 6gi# ,'- DG Zg[ aaZc jcY `Z^cZ b^i jchZgZg JcVW]~c\^\`Z^i c^X]i kZgZ^cWVgZ HVX]kZg]VaiZ kdga^Z\Zc# >c zWZgZ^chi^bbjc\ b^i 6gi# ,'-V 6Wh# & O^[[# ( DG jcY YZb HX]lZ^oZg Eg [jc\hhiVcYVgY -.% WZhi~i^\Zc l^g! YVhh Z^c \Zb~hh YZc Kdg\VWZc YZh Eg~h^Y^jbh Vjh\ZhiVaiZiZh ^ciZg" cZh @dcigdaahnhiZb [ g Y^Z 6j[hiZaajc\ YZg ?V]gZhgZX]cjc\ Zm^hi^Zgi# ;ZgcZg WZhi~i^\Zc l^g! YVhh YZg 6cigV\ WZg Y^Z KZglZcYjc\ YZh 7^aVco\Zl^ccZh YZb hX]lZ^oZg^hX]Zc <ZhZio jcY YZc HiVijiZc Zciheg^X]i jcY Zbe[Z]aZc! Y^Z kdga^Z\ZcYZ ?V]gZhgZX]cjc\ oj \ZcZ]b^\Zc# (%,) Bjg^ WZ^ 7Zgc! *# ?jc^ '%%.

9^Z GZk^h^dchhiZaaZ/ ;j]gZg EZiZg Oj\ZaVhhZcZg GZk^h^dchZmeZgiZ

=daYZcZg GjZY^ Oj\ZaVhhZcZg GZk^h^dchZmeZgiZ

:^cZ Eg [jc\ WZ^c]VaiZi Y^Z 9jgX][ ]gjc\ kdc Eg [jc\h]VcY" ajc\Zc ojg :gaVc\jc\ kdc Eg [jc\hcVX]lZ^hZc [ g Y^Z ^c YZg ?V]gZhgZX]cjc\ Zci]VaiZcZc LZgiVch~ioZ jcY hdchi^\Zc 6c\VWZc# 9^Z 6jhlV]a YZg Eg [jc\h]VcYajc\Zc a^Z\i ^b e[a^X]i\Zb~hhZc :gbZhhZc YZh Eg [Zgh# 9^Zh hX]a^Zhhi Z^cZ 7ZjgiZ^ajc\ YZg G^h^`Zc lZhZcia^X]Zg [VahX]Zg 6c\VWZc ^c YZg ?V]gZhgZX]cjc\ Vah ;da\Z kdc KZghi hhZc dYZg >ggi bZgc Z^c# 7Z^ YZg 7ZjgiZ^ajc\ Y^ZhZg G^h^`Zc WZg X`h^X]i^\i YZg Eg [Zg YVh ^ciZgcZ @dcigdaahnhiZb! hdlZ^i Zh [ g Y^Z 6j[hiZaajc\ YZg ?V]gZhgZX]cjc\ kdc 7ZYZjijc\ ^hi! jb Y^Z YZc Jbhi~cYZc ZcihegZX]ZcYZc Eg [jc\h]VcYajc\Zc [ZhiojaZ\Zc! c^X]i VWZg jb Z^c Eg [jc\hjgiZ^a WZg Y^Z L^g`hVb`Z^i YZh ^c" iZgcZc @dcigdaahnhiZbh VWoj\ZWZc# 9^Z Eg [jc\ jb[Vhhi ojYZb Y^Z 7ZjgiZ^ajc\ YZg 6c\ZbZhhZc]Z^i YZg Vc\Z" lVcYiZc GZX]cjc\haZ\jc\hbZi]dYZc! YZg EaVjh^W^a^i~i YZg kdg\ZcdbbZcZc HX]~iojc\Zc hdl^Z Z^cZ L gY^\jc\ YZg <ZhVbiYVghiZaajc\ YZg ?V]gZhgZX]cjc\# L^g h^cY YZg 6j[[Vhhjc\! YVhh Y^Z kdc jch ZgaVc\iZc Eg [jc\hcVX]lZ^hZ Z^cZ VjhgZ^X]ZcYZ jcY Vc\ZbZhhZcZ <gjcYaV\Z [ g jchZg Eg [jc\hjgiZ^a W^aYZc#

<ZWZgi Jgh Oj\ZaVhhZcZg GZk^h^dchZmeZgiZ AZ^iZcYZg GZk^hdg

(.

Hl^hh"H`^ =Vjh YZh H`^hedgiZh LdgWhigVhhZ *' Edhi[VX] '*' 8="(%,) Bjg^ WZ^ 7Zgc IZa/ )& (& .*% +& && ;Vm/ )& (& .*% +& &' ^c[d5hl^hh"h`^#X] lll#hl^hh"h`^#X] HX]lZ^oZg^hX]Zg H`^kZgWVcY ; YZgVi^dc hj^hhZ YZ h`^ ;ZYZgVo^dcZ hk^ooZgV hX^ ;ZYZgVo^jc hk^oZgV YV h`^