Gair Rhydd - Issue 1104 - 30th of October 2017

Page 1

gair rhydd

gair rhydd | free word Cardiff’s student weekly newspaper Papur wythnosol myfyrwyr Caerdydd Issue 1104 | Rhifyn 1104 30th October 2017 | 30ain o Hydref 2017

Cardiff Uni’s student paper | est . 1972

Politics and academia clash

Tory MPs wade into university freedom and censorship Is Britain still great, or a failing country? p.8 In depth: Grey ethics, black soil in Ukraine p.14 Stereophonics return to the ‘Diff - at your

Students’ Union

p.28

Marie-Claire Alfonso and Gareth Axenderrie

P

oliticians and academics have clashed this week with university campuses becoming the latest battleground for the freedom of speech versus censorship debate. First, Universities Minister Jo Johnson announced plans that would allow the new Office for Students (OfS) to fine, suspend or deregister universities if they do not commit to uphold freedom of speech. Johnson said: “I want the OfS to work with universities to encourage a culture of openness and debate and ensure that those with different backgrounds or perspectives can flourish in a higher education environment.” This follows a trend of universities using ‘safe spaces’ and ‘no platforming’ in order to shut down public speakers on campus. Analysis by Spiked magazine, supported by the Joseph Rowntree Reform Trust, found that more

than 9 in 10 UK universities are restrictive of free speech. The Free Speech University Rankings (FSUR) surveyed British universities and found that 63.5% of students’ unions were “severely restrictive of free speech.” The FSUR has named Cardiff University as one of the worst offenders for being restrictive of free speech, naming it in the top five most “ban-happy” universities. Cardiff has banned sales of tabloid newspapers and pornographic magazines in the WHSmith located in the Students’ Union, as well as songs with offensive lyrics on SU club nights and on the student radio station Xpress. Cardiff University also made news in 2015, when feminist writer Germaine Greer was almost banned from giving a guest lecture. There was a call for her to be ‘no-platformed’ for her trans-phobic views. Despite the campaign to silence her, Greer was able to speak at the university under high security. Sir Michael Barber, chairman of the OfS, said: “Ensuring freedom of speech and learn-

ing how to disagree with diverse opinions and differing views of the world is a fundamental aspect of learning at university. The OfS will promote it vigorously.” The OfS will be gaining its legal powers in April 2018. Following Johnson’s announcement, Conservative Government whip, Chris HeatonHarris, waded into the academic domain as he wrote to universities asking for a list of professors lecturing on Brexit, and details of what they are teaching. Bizarrely, Heaton-Harris, a stanch Brexiteer, also requested links to online lectures on Britain’s departure from the EU. Heaton-Harris’ letter read: “I was wondering if you would be so kind as to supply me with the names of professors at your establishment who are involved in the teaching of European affairs, with particular reference to Brexit. Furthermore, if I could be provided with a copy of the syllabus and links to the online lectures which relate to this area I would be much obliged.” Academics responded with widespread con-

demnation as many interpreted the move as an attack on academic freedom, whilst Downing Street quickly distanced itself from the comments, claiming they were made in Heaton-Harris’ move as an MP rather than as a government minister. Cardiff University Vice Chancellor Colin Riordan was forthright in his response to HeatonHarris. “Our academics are free to teach topics including Brexit as they see fit. If Mr Heaton-Harris wants to understand their work he should attend some of our classes or consult our website or directory of experts.” Professor Kevin Featherstone of London School of Economics drew a parallel with a historical political witch hunt: “The letter reflects a past of a McCarthyite nature. It smacks of asking, ‘Are you or have you ever been in favour of Remain?’”

Continued on page 4


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.