gair rhydd
CARDIFF’S STUDENT WEEKLY
Investigations look at unscrupulous electricity suppliers as Sport go rowing with Wright’s weird weekends
rhydd free word - EST. 1972
Quench
gair
ISSUE 761. MAY 3 2004
FREE
CARDIFFSTUDENTS.COM
Interviews, Travel,
Sport, Fashion, Music, Books, DC Gates, Film, Blind Date, Going Out...
40 pages packed with reviews, news and features
THE £16m MISTAKE UNIVERSITY OFFICIALS were left red-faced over Easter after a planning application for the illegally erected Optometry building on Maindy Road was rejected. Residents campaigning against the £16m development secured a close victory after councillors voted 4-3 against the proposals, which would see Optometry and Vision Sciences leave their current home in the Redwood building. This comes as an embarrassing blow to the University, which was ordered to halt construction in February after it emerged that full planning permission had not been granted. The University is now appealing against the decision with a planning inspector set to review the case in June. Since construction halted the sitehas lain unoccupied, with the bare structure – which is beginning to rust – a new addition to the Cathays skyline. But Maindy Road residents say this only highlights the scale of the complete building, designed to be almost twice the size of structure currently standing next to Lidl. An army of owner-occupiers have fought strongly against the application since 2002, maintaining the building – planned to stand at 72ft in some places – will tower over their homes.They claim that plans drawn up in May 2002 proposed that roughly 30 percent of the building would be four storeys high with the remaining 70 percent at three storeys. Yet residents are outraged that now an estimated 70 percent will sit four stories high, encroaching on their homes. A spokesperson for the Maindy Road Neighbourhood Watch Residents Group
PHOTO: Ceri Haddon
By Anna Hodgekiss News Editor
REJECT E
D
OPTOM: Building gathers rust as its future hangs in the balance told gair rhydd, "It’s not a fight between us, the university and the planning department. We just can’t live with the scale of the building. We need a compromise." Residents maintain they have never objected to the development and are in favour of an academic as opposed to a residential project. But they fear approval will set a precedent for any future developments that may take place on the Railtrack depot site, impacting on the front of the residential properties. The group is also angry that archi-
tects’ goal to ‘reflect the department’s stature as one of the leading optometry schools in Europe’ is too ambitious for a residential area. "The building would look lovely in the right surroundings, just not here. It’s ridiculous to say that this monumental thing is in harmony with its surroundings." The building visible – which would have included a large glass atrium through the centre - is only phase one of two planned for the sight, with a further four storey building on the cards.
A spokesperson for the university said, "It is particularly disappointing that the application was turned down by the Planning Committee despite the university’s efforts to ensure that the plans for the new world-class teaching and research facilities for students and staff of Optometry were developed after consultation with users and with the local planning authority. “The university is appealing against the decision and hopes for a speedy resolution.” The spokesperson denied the uni-
versity was embarrassed, saying: "We will never be embarrassed by our work to provide the highest quality facilities for our students and the platform to support vital research which plays a major role in improving the eye care of the nation while contributing to putting the city of Cardiff on the world map." And contrary to rumours the building was due to open in September, the university insists this is untrue, the spokesperson stating, "Planning development will determine the timescale."