rhydd
gair
free word - EST. 1972
CARDIFF’S STUDENT WEEKLY
GOOD WILL LAUGHING Xandria Horton meets hot new comic Will Adamsdale ahead of his Cardiff gig
ISSUE 783 March 14 2005
FREE
NUS/DAILY MIRROR NEWSPAPER OF THE YEAR 2003/04
GAME, SET AND MATCH Ladies’ tennis join the list of casualties from the BUSA knockout rounds
INTERVIEWS P14
SPORT P40
MASS DE EBATORS Cardiff and NUS go head to head over disaffiliation
By Matt Wilkin News Editor CARDIFF UNIVERSITY Students’ Union and the National Union of Students finally came head to head in the disaffiliation debate in the Great Hall last Thursday. But despite the importance of the issue for the long term future of the Union, the event was marred by a poor turnout from the student population. The majority of students were already wearing promotional material for both campaigns leaving the number of genuine undecided students at barely twenty, rendering much of the debate worthless. Chaired by Professor Nigel Palastianger, Pro ViceChancellor for Language and Teaching, the ‘Yes’ and ‘No’ panel answered questions from the audience about this week’s disaffiliation vote. Representing Cardiff University Students’ Union were Gary Rees, Union President, Tom Gough, Campaigns and PR officer, Bethan Jenkins, President of the University of Wales Aberystwyth Students’ Guild (who are still NUS affil-
iated), and Jon Walsh, from the University of Southampton which is not affiliated to the NUS. The NUS was represented by Kat Fletcher, National President, James Knight, NUS Wales President, Matt Cook, from NUS Services Limited, and Rob Newman, a Cardiff University postgraduate. The major issue for discussion was whether Cardiff receives enough to warrant an annual £50,000 NUS affiliation fee. Defending the NUS affiliation fee, Fletcher was keen to emphasise that Cardiff would risk losing its national voice if it ceased to be a member of the NUS. She said: "Having a national voice means students can collectively fight for what is important. Just because the NUS is not headline news does not soften its power." But Gary Rees countered with CUSU executive committee’s claim that they do not believe the NUS does enough for the students it represents. "The NUS have little voice, the top-up fees were not stopped [in England] despite their best efforts," he said. The Union also attacked plans for an NUS ‘Extra’ card, which would cost students ten pounds.
"We do not believe the students of Cardiff should have to pay for a discount card," Rees said. "We are researching into what shops in Cardiff will give students discounts. There are some logistical hurdles but it is very feasible." But Fletcher said: "The NUS ‘Extra’ card is a very controversial idea, I accept that. But those decisions will be made through democratic structures, and there will be a vote. "If the card goes ahead, it will be optional. It will be down to the Cardiff students to decide whether they wanted to buy into the product or not. I don’t think [Cardiff University Students’ Union] will be able to compete with the discounts we have." Questions were raised about the importance of NUS’ subsiduary company, NUS Services Limited (NUSSL), a purchasing consortium which currently assists the Union in keeping prices in its retail and catering outelts at a minimum. Rees claimed a motion to retain NUSSL’s services would "keep options open" but Fletcher responded with "if it is more beneficial be outside the NUS, why is Cardiff still trying to benefit from NUSSL?" Additional research by Dave Menon and Nicola Menage.