News
Page 2
November 7 2005
news@gairrhydd.com
At
a glance November 7 2005 News Geordie Editorial & Opinion Letters Politics Science/Environment Interviews Taf Od Health Grab! Dear Amber Media Jobs & Money Television Five Min Fun Listings Sport
1 7 8 10 11 13 14 15 16 18 19 20 22 25 33 34 36
EDITOR Tom Wellingham DEPUTY EDITOR Will Dean ASSISTANT TO THE EDITOR Elaine Morgan DESIGNER/GURU Graeme Porteous NEWS Charissa Coulthard, Caroline Farwell, Dan Ridler, Perri Lewis POLITICS Andrew Mickel EDITORIAL AND OPINION Sophie Robehmed, James Emtage SPORT Ed Jones, Tim Lewis LISTINGS Will Schmit, Alice Curitz TELEVISION TV Gareth, TV Grace, TV Holly, TV John LETTERS Dave Menon GRAB Megan Connor TAF-OD Lois Dafydd SCIENCE & ENVIRONMENT Ceri Morgan, Chris Brett MEDIA Heather Casey HEALTH Vanessa Roche, Laura Murphy JOBS AND MONEY Nicola Menage PROBLEM PAGE Amber Duval FIVE MIN FUN Colm Loughlin HEADS OF PHOTOGRAPHY Luke Pavey, Adam Gasson SUB-EDITORS Charlotte White, Holly Marshall PROOF READERS Rebecca Hunt, Rachel Cormican, Sarah Crosbie, Chris White CONTRIBUTORS Sarah Russell, Chris Warlow, Jonathan Duggan, Jenna Harris, Helen Roxburgh, Darren Goeghegen, Jon Mackrell, Dan Maton, James Lewis, Xandria Horton, Rosie Powling, Laura Rowe, Tim Hewish, Andrew Rennison, Victoria Sayce, Amira Hashish, Elis Gomer, Charlie Hughes, Lydia James, Kate Warren, Laura Wootton, Adrian Raudaschl, Anna White, Paul Hunt, Jon Berridge, George Pawley, Steve Myerscough, Billy Hemstock, Craig Smith, Amy Williams, Holly Cooke, Samuel Strang, Charis Simpson, James Perou ADDRESS University Union, Park Place Cardiff, CF10 3QN ADVERTISING 02920 781 474 EMAIL gairrhydd@gairrhydd.com WEB www.gairrhydd.com LOCATION 4th Floor Students’ Union
PRINTED: SHARMANS OF PETERBOROUGH
AFTER KNIGHT’S FALL The nominations for the presidency of NUS Wales have been finalised, but who will fill the void left after James Knight’s controversial resignation?
Mike Wallbank AGE: 20 INSTITUTION: Cardiff University COURSE: Third-year law EXPERIENCE: Served as Press Secretary for Conservative Future at Cardiff University. Served as ViceChairman for Conservative Future’ at Cardiff University PLANS: Wallbank is interested in improving communication and relations between the NUS and individual unions around Wales and starting a ‘Student Services Support’ program to help unions compete in today’s economic climate.
By Jonathan Duggan Reporter A BY-ELECTION will be held to elect a new President of NUS Wales on November 12 at the winter conference in Newport. The by-election comes just over a month after James Knight resigned as President citing ill-health and depression as his reasons for leaving. Knight’s resignation had been called for by many after some claimed he was too inactive during the all-important debate on top-up fees. In his resignation speech in early October, Knight stated that he was ‘victimised, bullied and harassed’ and had to prioritise his mental health over his sense of duty. There are now two contenders battling for the Presidency, but some have found it surprising that more people have not stood for the position. It has been suggested that some potential candidates were not able to run because they couldn’t secure an extended break from their university to apply for and perform the duties of the role. So who are the candidates, and more importantly, what do they stand for? Mike Wallbank is a third-year Law student at Cardiff University and a member of the Conservative Party. Joining Conservative Future in
Are they wor thy of graduation? By Sarah Russell Reporter SOUTHAMPTON Solent University is denying accusations that it has inflated the marks of failing pupils in order to retain government funding. Secret filming for the BBC South programme Inside Out revealed that Dr. Karen Randell, Head of the Film Studies degree, operated a ‘positive pass policy’. The allegations arose after a new lecturer felt pressured into passing work that she felt should have failed and agreed to film a marking session. The footage included Dr. Randell saying that 25% of the people on the course should not have been at university. "These people have been failures all their lives,” she said. "That is why we hold back, why we don’t automatically say [their work has] failed." Some of the essays passed were
shown to the former Chief of Schools, Chris Woodhead, who denounced the work as poorly punctuated, badly spelt and written with ‘no understanding of English grammar’. Another lecturer caught on camera said: "If we didn’t care about how many students we had and how many dropped out, we would mark very differently. "If we were really marking according to what we felt, we would drop a grade for everybody." The lecturer at the centre of the controversy maintains that this university was ‘financially driven’. For every pupil that drops out after their first year of university the institution loses £4,500 of government subsidy. This case has raised fears that the practice of inflating marks is not uncommon. The University strongly denies the accusations, saying: "We are certain that the comments of dedicated and conscientious staff have been grossly misrepresented."
2003, Wallbank has held various positions within the organisation, acting as press-secretary and as vicechairman. Although he has no experience on a national platform, or for the NUS, Wallbank is confident that his ‘fresh perspective’ and enthusiasm outweighs his inexperience. He is primarily interested in improving communication and relations between the NUS and the unions around Wales and introducing a ‘Student Services Support’ program. Running against Mike Wallbank is Swansea University’s Dylan Williams. Williams is currently a full-time student at Swansea, and holds a nonsabbatical position as a Higher Education Officer for NUS Wales. Having already been a member of the National Executive Committee in Wales, Williams feels he has relevant experience to call upon if elected to office. A fluent Welsh speaker, Williams is committed to a Welsh language campaign encouraging universities in Wales to teach courses in Welsh as well as in English. There is still the possibility that neither will become the new President, as both candidates are running against the third option, R.O.N, (Re-Open Nominations). In which case there will be another opportunity for people to run for office.
Dylan Williams AGE: 21 INSTITUTION: University of Wales, Swansea COURSE: N/A EXPERIENCE: Non-sabbatical HE Officer for NUS Wales Served as a member of the National Executive Committee PLANS: Williams wants to work on four key areas if elected; improving membership services by restoring the image of the NUS, campaigning for universities to offer more courses taught in Welsh, lobbying for increased funding for higher education and improving student representation in further education.
Calamity Jayne Tory Councillor’s rebellion prompts expulsion By Chris Warlow Reporter A MAVERICK Conservative from Cardiff North has been expelled from the party’s group on the city council. The Tories made the decision to ditch councillor Jayne Cowan of Rhiwbina following her failure to apologise for her recent 'outrageous' behaviour. The trouble began when Cllr. Cowan, who has always shown great contempt for council spending, applied for a hefty £3,000 leadership course. A statement issued by the Conservative Party says: "She has always been vociferous in her attacks on council expenditure. To then apply for a very expensive course at tax payers' expense as she did, and try to deny it despite a lengthy paper trail was both regrettable and unwise." The then-suspended councillor caused further strife last month when she refused to leave a meeting of Cardiff council's Tory group, which was subsequently abandoned. She then accused her colleagues of attempting to ‘intimidate, humiliate and belittle her and damage her politically’,
while they described her behaviour as 'appalling'. The Conservative's statement argues: "Jayne has close family friends on the Conservative group. To suggest ... that they were in an underhand campaign of bullying was both fictitious and insulting to all concerned." Her lawyer Julius Hermer stated: "She emphatically denies, and it is ludicrous to suggest, that her behaviour was appalling or that she set out to disrupt the meeting. "It is also denied that the meeting ended in total chaos as a result of our client's action." He added: "Her suspension was contrary to the rules for council Conservative groups and Jayne Cowan had every right to be present at the meeting." The Conservative group said: "[We have] at every stage tried to give Jayne the benefit of doubt and supported her in every one of her previous campaigns. We have been meticulous in ensuring that this situation has been dealt with fairly and properly, at every level. Her recent actions were, frankly, a step too far." Councillor Cowan has yet to comment on the groups decision, but has appealed against it.
COWAN: A step too far