Chesterland News 2-22-17 by Geauga County Maple Leaf

CHESTERLAND NEWS VOLUME 49 No. 23

Wednesday, February 22, 2017

Your Community Newspaper Since 1967

Judge Issues Rebuke of Grendell Orders BY JOHN KARLOVEC EDITOR@GEAUGAMAPLELEAF.COM

A visiting judge has rebuked Geauga County Probate Court Judge Tim Grendell’s actions against two Chester Township trustees over their refusal to give up control and oversight of township park land. Retired Medina County Probate Court Judge John J. Lohn found Grendell violated the separation of powers doctrine when he issued two judgment entries in September 2016 ordering a civil and criminal investigation into whether trustees Ken Radtke and Mike Petruziello broke the law in voting on Aug. 18, 2016, not to enter into a new agreement with the Chester Township Park District Board of Commissioners for management of Parkside Park. Lohn had been assigned to

Two County Food Inspectors Charged with Falsifying Records, Theft in Office

hear and review Master Commissioner Mary Jane Trapp’s investigative report after Radtke filed an affidavit asking Ohio Supreme Court Chief Justice Maureen O’Conner to remove Grendell from the case because of perceived bias, prejudice and partiality. Grendell eventually agreed to step down. “The September 2016 entries violate the separation of powers doctrine and are premised upon an improper judicial investiga-

BY JOHN KARLOVEC EDITOR@GEAUGAMAPLELEAF.COM

tion,” Lohn said in a strongly worded 16-page order, filed Feb. 2. “I will not conduct further proceedings.” He set aside Trapp’s 22-page report containing her interim findings — which he heard during a 90-minute hearing on Jan. 6 — and discharged her from her commission. Lohn said Grendell justified his orders on non-binding judicial language — language that Trapp, a

Kim Laurie, the budget/fiscal director and county liaison for the Geauga County Probate/Juvenile Court, issued a written statement Feb. 9 criticizing visiting Judge John Lohn’s order, referring to him twice as a “retired” judge. A former Medina County Probate Court judge, Lohn was sitting by assignment at the request of Ohio Supreme Court Chief Justice Maureen O’Conner.

See Rebuke w Page 4

See Statement w Page 5

Firefighters Rescue Dog in Pond BY CASSANDRA SHOFAR CASSANDRA@GEAUGAMAPLELEAF.COM

Two former longtime county food inspectors have been accused of violating the public trust. Anthony Zoccali, 45, of Cortland, and Mark Janezic, 42, of Concord Township, were indicted Feb. 8 on charges of tampering with government records and theft in office, felonies of the third and fourth degrees, respectively. Janezic pleaded not guilty at his Feb. 17 arraignment. His case was assigned to Geauga County Court of Common Pleas Judge Forrest Burt. Zoccali has not yet been served with the indictment, according to court records. The charges followed a nearly three-month investigation conduct-

While most family pets were warm, dry and eagerly awaiting food to drop on the floor during Super Bowl Sunday preparations Feb. 5, a beloved female dog was fighting for her life in a half frozen pond. The mixed-breed pit bull named Tonka had gotten out of the yard of her owner, Fiona Pausch, on Shiloh Drive early that morning and wandered onto a pond at 12265 Shiloh Dr. “My husband came and told me there was a puppy in our pond,” Judy Meyer said via phone interview Feb. 13. “It was just a small section of the pond that was open because of the windmill (aerator) was keeping it open. We had kept it open year round because we had ducks here.” Both Judy and her husband, Bob, thought maybe the dog belonged to their neighbor, but when they called him, he confirmed his dog was at home. “So then I thought, who do I call?” Judy said. “I did not want my husband to tr y to do this

See Inspectors w Page 9

See Rescue w Page 11

BY JOHN KARLOVEC EDITOR@GEAUGAMAPLELEAF.COM

Top Probate Staff Criticizes Order, Despite Pending Appellate Case

“I use the word ‘negotiate’ broadly here, to include threats to put people in jail if they do not vote for an agreement.” – Judge John Lohn

Grendell Administor Accused of Improper Communication Story on Page 7

Arabica Gets Its Mojo Back After Remodel Story on Page 8

Classifieds Start on Page 13

Publication Schedule Tthe Chesterland News publishes every other week.

SUBMITTED

Chester Township firefighter and paramedic Ted Shannon crawled out onto the ice of a partially frozen pond on Shiloh Drive Feb. 5 to retrieve a drowning dog named Tonka who had wandered into the yard of Judy and Bob Meyer and fallen in the pond. Lt. Mitch Plunk, the officer in charge, and firefighters Ryan Fowler, Joe Pavilonis and Daniel Lallitto helped drag Shannon and Tonka back to safety.

March 8 March 22 April 5 April 19 May 3 May 17 May 31 June 14 June 28 July 12 July 26

Aug. 9 Aug. 23 Sept. 6 Sept. 20 Oct. 4 Oct. 18 Nov. 1 Nov. 15 Nov. 29 Dec. 13

facebook.com/chesterlandnews @chesterlandnews

Page 2

CHESTERLAND NEWS

Wednesday, February 22, 2017

CHESTERLAND NEWS

TOWN CRIER Bloodmobile Feb. 22, 2-7 p.m. An American Red Cross blood drive will be held at Mayfield Church, 7747 Mayfield Road, Chester Township. Donors must be at least 17 years old, weigh at least 110 pounds and be in good health. For more information, call 1-800-7332767 or visit www.redcrossblood.org.

Geauga Beekeepers Meet Feb. 23, 7 p.m. The Geauga County Beekeepers will meet in the main lobby at the Kent State Campus at 11141 Clairdon Troy Road in Burton. Carl Bizilla will speak on beginning bee keeping and rules for entering honey at the Geauga County Fair in September. Refreshments New members are welcome; refreshments will be served. For more information, call Eleanor Spirka at 440-968-3371 evenings or visit geaugacountybeekeepers.org.

Foundation, a unique staffing agency seeking to enhance workplaces by employing individuals with mild to moderate exceptionalities, and hear about the success they are having. Breakfast and networking begin at 7:30 a.m. Free and open to the public. Registration is required. For information or to register, call 440564-1060 or email info@geaugagrowth.com.

Emerald Ball March 4, 6-10 p.m. Celebrate the community leadership and ser vice of 2017 Emerald Leader Scott Hildenbrand at the Leadership Geauga Emerald Ball being held at Bertram Inn in Aurora. Join in an evening of leadership recognition and philanthropy. Tickets are available by calling Leadership Geauga at 440-286-8115 or visiting leadershipgeauga.org

St. Anselm Handbag Bash Food Pantry Open Feb. 24, 10 a.m. to noon The Food Pantry at Chester Christian Center church will be open to the community. The pantry is open to anyone who is in need of food. One does not need to be a member of the church to come to the pantry. Chester Christian Center is at 11815 Chillicothe Road in Chester Township.

March 4, 6 p.m. The second annual St. Anselm Handbag Bash will be held in Kelly Hall. Tickets are $40 each and include entrance, dinner, non-alcoholic drinks plus 12 chances to win one of nine designer handbags. Space is limited; reserve a seat.

Dining Around Town Food Distribution Feb. 25, 9-11 a.m. Cleveland Food Bank will be distributing food to families in need at Celebration Lutheran Church, 10621 Auburn Road, Chardon.

Audubon Scans The Shoreline Feb. 25, 9 a.m. Join Blackbrook Audubon for a tour of popular birding sites along the Lake Erie shoreline. Participants will search for wintering gulls, waterfowl and other reported sightings in Fairport Harbor. Bring binoculars. Meet at the parking lot at the end of Water Street, just west of Fairport Harbor Lakefront Park. For more information, call Pat Morse at 440-256-1404 ext. 2101.

Chili Cook-off Feb. 26, 4-6 p.m. All are welcome to participate in a chili cook-off at Mayfield Church, 7747 Mayfield Road, Chester Township. Judging begins at 3:30 p.m.; contestants should have their chili to the church no later than 3 p.m. Chili should be in a 5-quart Crockpot. To enter, send an email to kris@mayfieldchurch.org for details. Entry fee is $5 per contestant. Cost to sample and eat is $5 per person, with a maximum $15 per family. Hot dogs, cornbread, crackers and condiments provided.

Family First Council Feb. 27, 2 p.m. Geauga Family First Council will meet at the Geauga County Board of Mental Health and Recovery Services building located on 13244 Ravenna Road in Chardon. Meetings are open to the public. For more information, please contact Nancy Seelbach, Geauga Family First Council coordinator, at 440-285-1201.

G.E.L. Breakfast March 3, 7:30-9 a.m. Shari Hunter, founder of Two Foundation, will be the guest speaker at the next Geauga Economic Leadership (GEL) breakfast taking place at Kent State Geauga, 14111 Claridon-Troy Road in Burton. Learn about the 15 businesses in Northeast Ohio that are utilizing Two

March 8, 6:30 pm Join others from St. Anselm Church to enjoy dinner on the first Wednesday of each month and try out different restaurants in the area. Meet at Firehouse Grille & Pub 2768 Stark Drive in Willoughby Hills. All are welcome. RSVP to Joan Gambrill by email at sdssignup@aol.com or text 440533-5015.

GCBDD Hosts Night to Shine March 22, 6 p.m. Geauga County Board of Developmental Disabilities (GCBDD), known as the Metzenbaum Center, is hosting its third annual Night to Shine event on at the Metzenbaum Center, 8200 Cedar Road in Chester Township. The event is open to all families who are enrolled in the GCBDD’s Early Intervention (EI) program and are actively receiving services. There is no fee to participate and all enrolled families with children ages birth to 3 years are invited to attend. Families interested in participating must RSVP by calling 440-729-5250 ext. 1530 by March 6. There will be refreshments, a DJ and several door prizes. For more information, visit www.geaugadd.org.

Ohio Division of Forestry Class April 8, 9 a.m. to 1 p.m. Join natural resources professionals from Ohio Division of Forestry, Ohio Division of Wildlife, and the UDSA NRCS to learn about options for private woodland management at Hambden Orchard Wildlife Area, parking area off Sisson Road in Chardon. Appropriate footwear and attire is necessary. The event is free, but registration is required by calling 440-564-5883.

Volunteer Tutors Needed Geauga County Job and Family Services is looking for caring, motivated adults to participate in its Volunteer Tutoring program that matches volunteers with local elementary, middle school and high school students who need help in basic reading and math. Volunteers will be required to attend a one-hour training at Geauga County Job and Family Services and complete a fingerprint background check. For information, contact Sara Shininger, community support/volunteer coordinator, at 440-285-9141, ext. 1263.

Page 3

Editorial Office 101 South Street P.O. Box 1166 Chardon, Ohio 44024-5166 ••• Phone 440-285-2013 FAX 440-285-2015 news@kirtlandchronicle.com Office Hours: 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. Monday - Friday

Advertising Office 8389 Mayfield Road, Suite B5 Chesterland, Ohio 44026 ••• Phone 440-729-7667 FAX 440-729-8240 ads@kirtlandchronicle.com Office Hours: 9:30 a.m. to 4 p.m. Monday, Tuesday, Thursday, Friday Closed Wednesday

Jeffrey B. Karlovec John D. Karlovec Publisher Editor Cassandra C. Shofar Rick Briggs Pamela J. Molnar News Editor Sales Representative Production Supervisor Jamie A. Ward Brian Lavrich Sue Geither Sports Editor Sales Representative Graphic Design Ann Wishart Sharon Waite Karen S. Kaplan Staff Reporter In-House Sales Representative Graphic Design Deadlines • Editorial submissions are printed as space is available, at the publisher’s discretion, and may be edited for length, clarity and grammar. All submissions are due by noon on the Friday prior to the Wednesday publication date for consideration for that edition. •Email all editorial submissions to news@chesterlandnews.com. • The space reservation deadline for paid advertisements in that week’s Chesterland News is 4 p.m. on the Thursday prior to publication. Late ads may be accepted at the discreation of mangement. • Email advertising requests and questions to ads@chesterlandnews.com. Circulation • The Chesterland News is distributed for free to homes and businesses in the communities of Chester Township and Russell Township. It is mailed through the U.S. Postal Service. • Copies are also available at more than 10 rack locations within Chester and Russell townships. • Circulation in excess of 5,900.

• Produced by the Chesterland News, LLC. • In case of error, we will re-print that portion of an advertisement that was in error. Notification of error should be made within three days of published date. • The Chesterland News, LLC assumes no responsibility of error contained in any pre-printed material delivered with the paper as an insertion therein. • The Chesterland News, LLC reserves the right to reject or revise any advertisement or news item for publication. Letters to the Editor reflect the opinion of those signing them and not necessarily that of either the Chesterland News, LLC, its affiliates or its advertisers. All letters submitted are subject to editing, and none will be returned. • The opinions and representations contained in advertisements are those of the advertiser. They have not been verified by the Chesterland News, LLC, nor should they be construed to represent the position or viewpoint of this newspaper or its publisher. • Under no circumstances will any record filed in the county be suppressed at any time for anybody, except by order of court.

Page 4

CHESTERLAND NEWS

Wednesday, February 22, 2017

Rebuke from page 1 former appellate court judge on the 11th District Court of Appeals, agreed was nonbinding editorial during the Jan. 6 hearing — from an April 2016 Ohio Supreme Court decision that he flowered into law; namely, that a probate court’s authority vis-à-vis park districts “surely includes the ability to issue orders to enforce the entry creating the park district, including orders that impose duties on those interring with the park district’s purposes.” But the Supreme Court decision did not authorize Grendell to threaten Radtke and Petruziello, and their attorneys, with jail time, fines or civil judgments, Lohn said. “Under Judge Grendell’s view of his jurisdiction, a property owner who has a yard sale that slows traffic to and from a park, or a contractor who improperly installs a swing set or a citizen who sends an email criticizing a park commissioner — each could be brought before the probate court to face contempt charges for ‘interfering with the park district’s purposes,’” he added. From the township trustees’ standpoint, Lohn said, it was important for the 11th District to determine the limits of a probate court’s authority over them “as a board and as persons.” “I am firmly convinced the court’s jurisdiction does not extend to non-parties such as Mr. Radtke and Mr. Petruziello,” he added. “In my view the jurisdiction of the probate court is limited to the express power to appoint and remove park commissioners and to dissolve a park district; and the implied power to investigate park operations to determine if a park commissioner should be removed,” said Lohn.

Separation of Powers Lohn found Grendell’s September 2016 orders were not directed to Chester Township or the board of trustees as a legislative body. The orders also did not mention Trustee Bud Kinney, who voted to approve the new agreement, he noted. “Rather, the September 2016 orders threaten Trustees Radtke and Petruziello personally,” Lohn said. The judge said Grendell targeted the two trustees for rejecting the agreement, yet he never conducted a hearing at which any evidence was presented about their Aug. 18 vote. In fact, there were no court hearings held between Aug. 9 and the dates the September orders were issued, said Lohn, making them the “product of a highly irregular and erroneous process.” “The doctrine of separation of powers protects a legislative body from judicial activism and overreach. This doctrine is fundamental to our tripartite system, where each department of government is independent but each works in comity with the others,” Lohn said. “This doctrine is part of the checks and balances inherent in Ohio’s constitution.” Radtke and Petruziello had done nothing to subject themselves to the jurisdiction of the probate court as individuals, he found. “But when Mr. Radtke and Mr. Petruziello used their legislative prerogative to vote against the new agreement, it triggered (Grendell) to issue the September 2016 orders against them,” said Lohn, noting each trustee was “free to vote for or against the new agreement according to their own discretion and considered judgment.”

He added, “Township trustees answer to their constituents, not the probate court.” The judge concluded the doctrine of the separation of legislative and judicial powers prevented him from enforcing Grendell’s September orders. Grendell’s action likely violated the separation of executive and judicial powers as well, he said. Park commissioners have operational control and oversight of a park district — an executive function, Lohn said. “And as seen here, (Grendell) acted unilaterally — like an executive — without waiting for a motion from the park commissioners, without notice to the parties and without giving Mr. Radtke or Mr. Petruziello or their attorneys an opportunity to be heard,” he said, adding courts cannot dictate how other branches of government perform the work that is their public duty to accomplish. In addition, Lohn found Grendell’s “judicial influence” over the Chester Township Park District began in 2014, when he first appointed Trapp to determine if it was operating legally and if park funds had been mismanaged. As part of her assignment, she was instructed to broker a new management agreement between trustees and park commissioners for Parkside Park, a role she played until last August. “The probate court has oversight over park commissioners. The board of commissioners has oversight over the park district. It does not follow that because the park board has authority to negotiate agreements and because the probate court appoints the members of the park board, the probate court can negotiate agreements for the park board,” Lohn said. “I use the word ‘negotiate’ broadly here, to include threats to put people in jail if they do not vote for an agreement.” In addition, he pointed out every problem mentioned in Trapp’s 220-page report, issued in 2014, should have been “foreseen, prevented or corrected” by the park commissioners and their administrators “through the exercise of due diligence.” Despite his criticism of Grendell’s actions, Lohn reiterated it would be up to the 11th District to identify limits and exceptions to the probate court’s jurisdiction. Yet, he concluded Grendell’s “incursion” into the legislative function was “clearly prohibited,” and his “usurpation of executive authority” probably was prohibited.

Other Findings In addition to finding Grendell’s orders unconstitutional and unlawful, Lohn said Grendell taxed Trapp’s fees as court costs and approved them “prospectively and without limitation; before they were earned, before they were submitted and before the parties could review and challenge them.” He also found Trapp did not follow the mandatory process set forth in the statute under which she was appointed, and should have disqualified herself from undertaking the assignment because the roles of “witness, investigator and adjudicator were impermissibly combined” in the September orders. In addition, Lohn said the question of whether Radtke or Petruziello committed the crime of retaliation should have been referred to the county prosecutor’s office. “A master commissioner’s opinion on this subject is conjectural and of no value to these proceedings,” he said. Also irrelevant to the proceedings is whether the individual park commissioners or Grendell’s civil rights were violated. “Moreover, the judge cannot ethically so instruct the master commissioner because the master commissioner’s legal opinion on this subject would have value only to the judge personally,” Lohn said. “A judge may not use his office for personal gain … If a judge wants to know if his civil rights were violated, he must hire a lawyer on his own expense to get a definitive answer. A master commissioner cannot act as his private counsel.”

Wednesday, February 22, 2017

CHESTERLAND NEWS

Statement from page 1 Lohn, 60, was first elected to the bench in 2002 and ran unopposed in 2008. He stepped down from the bench in 2013, citing medical reasons. Last week, the Geauga County Maple Leaf emailed Chester Township Trustees, Chester Township Park District Commissioners Joe Weiss and Clay Lawrence, and Geauga County Probate/Juvenile Court Judge Tim Grendell inviting them to comment on Lohn’s Feb. 2 order. Grendell did not reply with any comment. Instead, Laurie did, despite a pending appeal before the 11th District Court of Appeals on several of the issues addressed in the order, including the jurisdictional limits and authority of a probate court over park districts and township trustees. “Retired Judge Lohn’s ruling directly contradicts the decision rendered by all seven Ohio Supreme Court Justices, as well as the opinion advocated by eighteen of Ohio’s most experienced Probate judges,” Laurie said. “Judge Grendell relied upon and followed the Ohio Supreme Court’s unanimous 2016 ruling, as he is legally and ethically required to do.” In a subsequent email, Laurie provided additional “clarification” to her earlier comments: “And just to provide some more clarification, Judge Grendell has a duty to ensure that prior Judges’ orders are upheld, including that of Judge Lavrich which created the Chester Township Park District in 1984, as explained by the Ohio Supreme Court’s unanimous decision. “The investigations were conducted by an unbiased court appointed Master Commissioner, as specifically provided for by Ohio law, simply to determine if the actions by the township trustees interfered with that order. Such judicial prevention of interference with Judge Lavrich’s order is specifically permitted by Ohio law, again as explained by the Ohio Supreme Court’s unanimous decision. “There was no separation of powers violation. Judge Grendell directed the Master Commissioner to determine whether the township trustees interfered with, or frustrated the purpose of Judge Lavrich’s Probate Court order that created the township park district, and he relied upon notifications from the Master Commissioner as well as statements made in court by an assistant prosecutor. There were no out of court investigations conducted. “Finally, retired Judge Lohn erroneously interpreted Judge Grendell’s view of his jurisdiction regarding actions interfering with the park district’s purposes to include

trivial matters such as a yard sale that slows traffic to and from a park, an improperly installed swing set, or an email critical of a park commissioner. “Judge Grendell’s jurisdiction was very clearly defined in the Ohio Supreme Court’s unanimous decision which, in fact, recognized that actions by Township Trustees which directly interfere with Judge Lavrich’s original order is proper jurisdiction for the Probate Court judge, as these actions would effectually terminate the park district’s operation of the only current park within the district.” Township trustees Ken Radtke, Bud Kinney and Mike Petruziello declined to comment on Lohn’s Feb. 2, citing the pending appellate court case. Weiss and Lawrence issued the following statement: “On Aug. 9, 2016, the parties, the Park Board and the Trustees, appeared before Judge Grendell. At the time, it was represented to the Court by the attorney for the Trustees that there was a pending agreement between the Park Board and the Trustees, which at that time had already been approved by the Park Board (this document was prepared by the Trustees’ attorney and presented to the Park Board for its signature). “On Aug. 18, 2016, the Trustees met and the majority of the Trustees refused to sign their own agreement. “Now we have a decision recently rendered by a newly appointed Judge, appointed due to Judge Grendell having stepped aside to help move the process to a conclusion. “In our opinion, the decision recently handed down is totally contrary to the Supreme Court’s 7-0 decision of April 14, 2016, which defined the power of Judge Grendell as plenary which meant the Court had jurisdiction to act on this case. “It is a shame that after a half day in Court, with no testimony from the parties this matter ended with no explanation for the actions of the Trustees. “What is certain is that the Trustees have expended more than $100,000 of taxpayer money in legal fees and that there is no longer a contract with the Park Board. This is all because of the efforts by the majority of the Trustees to interfere with the activities of the Park Board beginning in 2014. “In our opinion it is a bigger shame that more time was not spent hearing this matter and finding the truth. “The final end to this mess will be at the ballot box in November with the election.” On Monday, Lawrence said he read their letter to fellow park commissioners Ruth Philbrick and Al Parker, and told the Maple Leaf they agreed to sign it. Park Commissioner Lance Yandell was out of town and unavailable, he added.

SCHOOLS College Information Session

CVWC to Offer Scholarships

March 1, 6:30 p.m. The Lake/Geauga Educational Assistance Foundation will hold a free informational session for high school juniors and their parents at the LEAF Resource Center at 8221 Auburn Road. “Junior Jumpstart” will address the senior year timeline and information regarding the college application and financial aid procedures. Register online at www.leaf-ohio.org or call LEAF at 440-358-8045 to reserve a seat. Reservations are required; capacity is limited

The Chagrin Valley Women’s Club, celebrating its 86th year of service to the communities, will be awarding 10 $1,500 scholarships to qualifying high school seniors from five area high schools, including Chagrin Falls, Kenston, Orange, West Geauga and Solon. Applications for scholarships are available on each school’s website or through the high school guidance counselor’s office. Students who wish to apply must submit completed applications to the Counselor’s office no later than noon March 3.

GCRTA Grant-in-Aid Program

Master Gardener Scholarships

The Geauga County Retired Teachers Association has applications available for its grant-in-aid annual financial assistance program to deserving college seniors. Applicants must be enrolled in the college of education and be student teaching in the 2017-18 academic year. In addition, interested persons must have resided in Geauga County or be a graduate of a Geauga County high school. Completed applications for the $1,500 grants must be submitted by May 20. To download the online application, visit www.gcrta.net.

The Master Gardener Volunteers of Geauga County have funds available for Geauga County residents, teachers and community organizations to promote and encourage horticultural projects in Geauga County. In addition, scholarships are available for high school seniors who are committed to attending The Ohio State University main campus or ATI in Wooster and plan to pursue a degree in horticulture, agriculture, environmental science or a closely related field. Application deadline is May 5. Call 440-834-4656 for more information.

Page 5

610 River Road Gates Mills OH 440-423-4845 Bible Study 9:30 am Worship Service 10:45 am www.littlechurchinthevale.org

Pastor Robert Sandham

Page 6

CHESTERLAND NEWS

Wednesday, February 22, 2017

Grendell Administrator Accused of Improper Communication County, Grendell May Be Personally Liable for Fees, Judge Says BY JOHN KARLOVEC EDITOR@GEAUGAMAPLELEAF.COM The visiting judge who issued a strong rebuke of Geauga County Probate Court Judge Tim Grendell’s actions against two Chester Township trustees now has accused his top administrator of improper communication. He also urged Grendell to recuse himself entirely from the case, stating Geauga County and Grendell could be personally liable if two September 2016 orders Grendell issued are found to be void. Retired Medina County Probate Court Judge John J. Lohn said Kim Laurie, Grendell’s budget/fiscal director and county liaison, initiated two improper communications with him after he had issued a Feb. 2 order — which found Grendell violated the separation of powers doctrine — completing his assignment in the Chester Township Park District case. He advised the parties of Laurie’s improper communication in an eight-page notice, which was filed in the probate court on Feb. 15. In the notice, Lohn said Laurie had called him on Feb. 7 to inform him the court had received an invoice — for $7,025 — from Master Commissioner Mary Jane Trapp. Trapp, whom Grendell appointed in 2014 as a master commissioner in the case, had been instructed in September 2016 to conduct a civil and criminal investigation into whether trustees Ken Radtke and Mike Petruziello broke the law in voting not to enter into a new agreement for the management of the township-owned Parkside Park. Ohio Supreme Court Chief Justice Maureen O’Conner assigned Lohn to review

Laurie

Lohn

Trapp’s report and to conduct future hearings, if any, related to her findings. “The Feb. 7 phone call I view as (permitted) communication for the purpose of scheduling a hearing,” Lohn wrote. “When I informed Ms. Laurie no hearing was necessary, that should have ended things.” Instead, on Feb. 9, Laurie sent Lohn two emails concerning Trapp’s invoice. “These communications are improper,” said Lohn, adding he was not allowed to consider them. “The Feb. 9 emails informed me I have not correctly interpreted Judge Grendell’s Sept. 16, 2016, order and that I did not understand and apply R.C. 2101.07,” Lohn explained, referring to the master commissioner statute. “When I got the second email — the third ex parte communication — I felt I should respond on the record.” Lohn noted Grendell had used the word “shall” in his Sept. 16 order, referring to the approval of the master commissioner’s fees. “Judge Grendell used the word ‘shall’ three other times in his entries in exactly the same sense of a formal, resolute, unconditional command,” Lohn said. He also took exception to Grendell captioning his Sept. 16 order as a “judgment entry” and a Sept. 22 order as a “supplemental judgment entry.” “These entries are orders, not judgments,” said Lohn. “I do not know why Judge Grendell chose to use the word ‘judgment’ (implying self-execution and finality)

Grendell personally may be liable for the in captioning these orders, but he did.” In addition, Lohn questioned why master commissioner’s fees.” Filed concurrently with Lohn’s Feb. 15 Grendell did not write in his order the fees would be allowed, if they were found to be notice was an eight-page affidavit from Laurie, in which she admitted to calling proper. “Everything written and not written in Lohn on Feb. 7 to notify him about Trapp’s the entries leads to the conclusion the mas- invoice. However, she denied ever requesting in ter commissioner fees were approved,” Lohn said, adding Trapp interpreted the call or in any of her subsequent emails Grendell’s order the same way he did, that Lohn schedule a hearing concerning because she did not file a motion for the fees. “We had a very pleasant conversation approval of her fees. that lasted approxi“She simply sent mately 12 minutes,” an invoice directly to “Judge Grendell recused Laurie said. the court,” he said. “Judge Lohn kind“Right or wrong, himself while the chief ly explained that he my interpretation of justice contemplated had understood the the Sept. 16 entry is a statement in Judge substantive matter. his disqualification. He (Sept. 16) The recused judge has should be mindful of his Grendell’s order . . . to mean no business commentthat Judge Grendell ing on this issue or recusal.” had (approved the any aspect of my deci– Judge John Lohn fees), as stated in sion, publicly or priJudge Lohn’s Feb. 2, vately, directly or by proxy,” Lohn said, citing to the rules of judi- 2017, journal entry,” she said. Laurie said she told Lohn she needed to cial conduct. He added, “Judge Grendell recused him- confirm his interpretation and, if that were self while the chief justice contemplated his not Grendell’s intent, she would email him disqualification. He should be mindful of his Trapp’s invoice for “review and further advisement.” recusal.” She said she asked Lohn for his email Even if Grendell were correct and Lohn had “left an issue on the table,” Lohn said address and he provided it. After conferring with Grendell, Laurie he would be violating two court orders and disrespecting the 11th District Court of said she sent the Feb. 9 emails to Lohn, Appeals jurisdiction if he decided the rea- advising him Grendell did not pre-approve the fee amounts and that he needed to sonableness of Trapp’s fees. “If the judge feels there are matters review them. “Judge Lohn did not advise me that folremaining to be adjudicated, he should issue a second recusal and notify the chief justice. lowing up via email, as we discussed in our phone conversation, would be considered In fact, I urge him to do so,” Lohn said. “The Code of Judicial Conduct requires ‘ex parte’ communication,” said Laurie. She added, “As of today, the invoice has disqualification when a judge has an economic interest in the subject matter in controver- not been approved for payment.” sy,” he added. “If the September orders are found to be void, Geauga County and Judge See Communication w Page 10

Wednesday, February 22, 2017

CHESTERLAND NEWS

Page 7

SUBMITTED

Students Honored at Art Show SUBMITTED SUBMITTED

West Geauga seniors, from left, Austin Maguire, Tori Finnick and Chase Waterman, pose during the final dual meet of their high school careers.

Swimming Fundraiser Benefits Breast Cancer Research SUBMITTED West Geauga and Cleveland Heights continued a tradition on Feb. 3 when for the seventh straight year they combined their dual swim meet with a fundraiser for breast cancer research and Senior Night, honoring each teamâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s seniors in the final dual meet of their high school careers. Cleveland Heights won both ends of the meet, with the boys prevailing by a 99-62 score and the girls narrowly denying the Lady Wolverines their first win of the season in a 78-75 squeaker. The two teams raised more than $500 through candy and bake sales before and at the meet this year, bringing their seven-year total to just over $7,000. The senior celebration recognized three Wolverine seniors and six swimmers from Cleveland Heights. The West Geauga trio honored along with their parents were cocaptains Tori Finnick, Austin Maguire and Chase Waterman. It is the fourth year on the swim team for all three. With everyone in a celebratory mood, the Wolverines got particularly notable performances from two of their athletes. Waterman punctuated his stellar career by swimming his first-ever â&#x20AC;&#x153;perfectâ&#x20AC;? meet, claiming first place in all four of his events.

He won a tight race in the 50-yard freestyle, then blew away the field in the 100-yard breaststroke to win by an 11-second margin. He also teamed with Maguire, Eli Harvey and Julius Kowalski to win the 200-yard medley relay and then anchored the winning 200-yard freestyle relay, following the same trio into the water. Junior Kami Goodrick, the Lady Wolverinesâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; stellar diver, pulled off a rare double, diving to wins off both the board and the starting blocks. She stepped up onto the block and swam to a victory in the 50-yard freestyle then climbed onto the board and won the one-meter diving competition. As the girlsâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; team scores indicate, the two teams split the race victories evenly with each team winning 6 of the 12 events. Fiona Fisher, who led the scoring for the Wolverine girlsâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; team with 15 points, was responsible for two decisive individual victories in the 200-yard individual medley and 100-yard breaststroke and also swam to a relay victory in the 200-yard freestyle relay along with teammates Emma Roth, Tori Finnick, and Lindsey Kulp. Freshman Kristina Preda claimed the other first place for West Geauga with a solid finish in the 100-yard backstroke, winning by half the length of the pool, seven seconds ahead of her competition.

West Geauga High School students Kaitlyn DiBiase, Gabriella Engoglia, Sarah Rowen and Shannon Stanforth are participating in the Beachwood Arts Councilâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s (BAC) 21st annual Juried Regional High School Student Art Show. The students were honored at the art show opening reception and awards program on Feb. 12 from 2-4:30 p.m. at the Beachwood Community Center, 25225

Fairmount Blvd., Beachwood. The exhibition features artworks by students from 22 area high schools and will be on view through March 5 at the Beachwood Community Center. Visit the exhibition to view the talent and creativity of West Geaugaâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s students, among the regionâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s best high school student artists. Gallery hours are Monday through Friday, 10 a.m. to 4 p.m., Saturday, 10 a.m. to 3 p.m. and Sunday, 10 a.m. to 1 p.m., or by appointment; call 216-464-9064.

ChesterlandNews.com

& $&#) (# ""#)" & " # ' #)& '() "( # ( !#"( & ' "*# * " ( &( ) + & ' ' $& ' "( "( & ( " ' ' '# ( $( " # ( ##( & " '%) & & "( , ' " " ! (# ( #"#& &# " + ' ( '( ) #! #! " %) " & ' $ "" " #" (( " " $ ( " * &' (, " ( & $&#) (# & # " - & ' #)& '() "( # ( !#"( " + ' & #"( ") ') '' " ( )()&

"# !$%# !

( & * , (' & & +++ #& "')& " #!

Page 8

CHESTERLAND NEWS

Wednesday, February 22, 2017

, ,

0 '* 00'

%! && ! , ! , , ), %!!

, !+%,# )&, % , - %, ),,+ )) ,, ), /,) , , %!! , &,- & , ), )% , !, !), %/ %&, % , - %,+&

"*((", !) , $ &) % , , 0*(

, ! , !+& , . ! &, , ! &

SUBMITTED

New flooring is one of the major changes at Arabica Coffee House.

Arabica Gets its Mojo Back BY CASSANDRA SHOFAR EDITOR@GEAUGAMAPLELEAF.COM

After more than a decade under the ownership of Kathy and Matthew Fadorsen, Arabica Coffee House is getting a make-over. â&#x20AC;&#x153;We have wanted to remove the carpet for years, but it is a huge undertaking,â&#x20AC;? said Kathy via email. â&#x20AC;&#x153;We also wanted to update the store and make it more appealing to all age groups. We plan to offer some more lunch options and some additional coffee offerings, but felt the remodel should come first.â&#x20AC;? The renovations started Feb.10 at 3 p.m. and the Fadorsens anticipate re-opening around Feb. 22. â&#x20AC;&#x153;The concrete refinishing is the key. We are not able to be in the store for several days while that is going on,â&#x20AC;? Kathy explained. â&#x20AC;&#x153;We will have a sign posted at the front of the store with our updates as soon as we have them.â&#x20AC;? The Fadorsens, who always had an interest in starting their own business, purchased Arabica, at 12626 Chillicothe Road in Chester Township, in September of 2006 after they were brainstorming their respective lists of ideas. â&#x20AC;&#x153;Coffee house was the only idea on both lists, so it was an easy decision,â&#x20AC;? Kathy said. â&#x20AC;&#x153;Matt grew up in Macedonia and (I) grew up in Mentor. We both had family in Geauga County and Chesterland was a perfect choice to live and work.â&#x20AC;? After they purchased the coffee house, they made minor changes that could be done overnight and not affect customers, such as painting, moving equipment to more efficient locations and utility upgrades, Kathy said. â&#x20AC;&#x153;Since then, we have saved money and planned to be able to redo the flooring,â&#x20AC;? she said.

â&#x20AC;&#x153;The expanded window area and a more modern look with open floor plan will make the dining room more appealing to all types of customers.â&#x20AC;? â&#x20AC;&#x201C; Kathy Fadorsen Kathy said there are two â&#x20AC;&#x153;major changesâ&#x20AC;? she and Matthew hope the customers will love â&#x20AC;&#x201D; the new floor finish, which includes moving the Meeting Room to the back of the store and opening up the front of the store and windows to customers, and moving the hand-dipped Ashbyâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s Sterling Premium Ice Cream offerings closer to the entrance to highlight it. â&#x20AC;&#x153;After years of the old carpet, (the new floor) will be a welcome upgrade to all,â&#x20AC;? Kathy added. In addition to the major changes being done while closed, after re-opening, the Fadorsens plan to continue the work overnight and during times it will not negatively impact customers, she added. â&#x20AC;&#x153;Painting, lighting and decorating changes are also planned,â&#x20AC;? Kathy said. She said her hope for the project â&#x20AC;&#x201D; which cost over $13,000 (not including the revenue lost during the period it was closed) â&#x20AC;&#x201D; is it creates a â&#x20AC;&#x153;comfortable, welcoming and pleasant atmosphere to relax and visit with friends, hold a business meeting, grab your morning coffee or catch up on emails.â&#x20AC;? â&#x20AC;&#x153;The expanded window area and a more modern look with open floor plan will make the dining room more appealing to all types of customers,â&#x20AC;? Kathy said

SENIOR NEWS & EVENTS West Geauga Senior Center 12650 West Geauga Plaza, Unit #4, Chester, 440-721-1416. â&#x20AC;˘ Building Your Immune System: Feb. 24, 11 a.m. Presented by Carol from Heinenâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s Wellness, learn to build oneâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s immune system up by what is around the house and by what needs to be taken out of the house. Find out what fruits and vegetables help bodies fight back and how to balance oneâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s PH so viruses and bugs cannot survive. â&#x20AC;˘ New Exercise Class: Fridays, 11 a.m. Join Senior Strength Building with Mary Kay Simone and help bone density, increase stamina, build muscle and more. Suggested donation is $2. â&#x20AC;˘ Book Club: March 13, 1-2 p.m. Join for a discussion of â&#x20AC;&#x153;The Wright Brothersâ&#x20AC;? by David McCullough at Geauga West Library.

Growing up Amish Feb. 27 Lorina Mast, assistant recreation and education coordinator, will talk about what it is like to grow up Amish at the Chagrin Falls

Senior Center, 7060 Woodland Ave. in Bainbridge. Call the center at 440-247-8510 to RSVP.

Matter of Balance Class University Hospitals Geauga Medical Center, Windsor House at Burton Health Care Center, Hospice of the Western Reserve and Geauga Department on Aging are offering Matter of Balance classes to Geauga seniors interested in improving balance, flexibility and strength and in preventing falls. Classes will be held Fridays, March 3 to April 28, from 9:30-11:30 a.m. at Burton Health Care Center, 14095 E. Center St. in Burton. Seniors will learn to manage concerns about falls as well as set realistic goals for staying active, learn how to stay safe at home, complete exercises to increase strength and balance and learn how to identify and control the fear of falling. This class is free for registered seniors. Space is limited. To register, call Dawn Damante at 440214-3180.

Wednesday, February 22, 2017

CHESTERLAND NEWS

Inspectors from page 1 ed by the Geauga County Prosecu-tor’s Office into the state registered sanitarians’ day-to-day activities. “I commend the health department for bringing their suspicions to us right away so that our office could investigate this matter,” Prosecutor Jim Flaiz said. “We take violations of the public trust very seriously.” According to several sources not authorized to speak publicly, investigators found Zoccali and Janezic routinely falsified daily inspection reports, claiming to have completed more inspections than they actually did and to have spent more time inspecting retail food establishments than they actually spent. Instead, they regularly were observed shopping — both in and outside of Geauga County — or sitting in their cars in parking lots and parks during work hours. After both men were confronted with the results of the investigation last month, they quit their jobs. At the time, Zoccali was being paid $24.49 per hour and Janezic $25.40 per hour, according to the county auditor’s office. Last fall, Geauga County Health District Director Bob Weisdack said he became suspicious of Zoccali and Janezic’s activities. Both men were employed in the district’s Food Safety Division and were primarily responsible for performing all food service inspections in the county. Zoccali, hired in 2002, was responsible for inspecting the southern half of the county and Janezic, hired in 2001, the northern half, Weisdack said. “When inspections are being done and you’re looking at the type of inspections, there were some questions in regards by some of the other sanitarians as to the different types of locations that were being inspected,” said Weisdack, adding there were also questions about whether all of the inspections were being done. Weisdack explained inspectors are required to complete daily time sheets. “These jobs are all of public trust, so that means when you tell me you have done an inspection, then we expect that the county’s health is being monitored, so if you eat at a restaurant, we want that restaurant to be acceptable or we don’t want it to be open,” he said. He added, “I tell my staff if you wouldn’t let your mother or your brother, or your wife or any of your relatives eat at that facility, why would you allow that restaurant to be open?” According to the 2015 annual report, the health district is responsible for inspecting more than 575 food service operations and retail food establishments in the county, in addition to mobile or temporary operations that sell food at festivals or other public events.

Inspection frequency is based upon state law and is determined by a facility’s risk classification. Food establishment locations that generally sell all closed, pre-packaged items are inspected annually, explained Weisdack, while food service locations — which range from small businesses with limited menus to full-service restaurants — are inspected more frequently. Inspections generally can take anywhere from 30-45 minutes for food establishment locations to 60-75 minutes for low-item food service restaurants, to 120-180 minutes for larger full-service restaurants, he said. Areas addressed during an inspection include staff hygiene, food handling, physical facilities and general sanitation practices. As a result of his suspicion, Weisdack said he had GPS units placed on Zoccali and Janezic’s county work vehicle. He later met with prosecutor’s office investigators who began to track each inspector’s movements, including surveillance. Over the course of the investigation, Zoccali claimed on his daily reports to have completed dozens of more inspections than he actually performed, sources said. He also claimed to have spent countless hours more at inspection sites than he actual spent. In addition, he was paid for dozens of hours of work that he actually wasted sitting in his car, often times reading the newspaper. A similar pattern was found for Janezic, although he wasted more time than Zoccali, sources said. In addition to sitting in parking lots, he was found shopping at retailers like Dick’s Sporting Goods and Walmart as well as Beachwood Place. Weisdack said he and his staff are busy verifying past inspection reports and reexamining many of the facilities to ensure they were scrutinized properly. “What we’re finding is the inspections that were supposed to be done within the state code were being done adequately,” he said. “However, what was on the time sheets did not reflect what was actually being done.” Of the re-inspections that have been done, Weisdack said no major violations have been found. “We want to make sure that any food that is served in Geauga County is worthy of being eaten,” he added. As for Zoccali and Janezic, Weisdack said he is extremely disappointed with them. “I put full faith and I want everybody to have faith in our inspectors,” he said. “I am more than extremely disappointed in the fact that, when I sit around the table at a staff meeting, I want people in this community to know that they have people of integrity that are looking out for their best safety and their health. So, trying to sit here and put it in words is extremely difficult to me.”

Vote for Your Favorite Food! Win and it’s 1/2 OFF! By now, everyone knows how amazing everything is at Bada Bing Pizza. Owner Bob Piecenski makes sure the pizza, wings and other menu items are all made with the best ingredients. But, what menu item is best? There are so many great choices, it’s almost impossible to say. However, Piecenski wants to try to find out. Come to Bada Bing today through Monday and vote for your favorite menu item. Fans of Bada Bing can also vote on-line via Twitter and Facebook. The menu item that is voted the favorite can be purchased at half off on Wednesday. That’s right, put your vote in for the Buffalo Chicken Pizza or the Dirty Wings or Fried Ravioli and that menu item

will be 50 percent off on Wednesday. What a great deal. To be able to get the Cowboy Pizza or a famous 12-inch calzone or even some scrumptious loaded fries for half off is quite an offer. So go visit Bada Bing this weekend and make your voice be heard. Enjoy some tasty pizza and put in your vote so you can come back on Wednesday for a deliciously great deal. If any nonprofit group is interested in setting up its own donation day, contact Piecenski at 440-729-9300. Bada Bing is located at 12617 Chillicothe Rd. in the Drug Mart plaza and can also be reached at badabingchester.com or followed on Twitter @BadaBingChester.

Paid Advertisement

Page 9

American Roofing & Construction ROOFING SPECIALIST

Richard Mott - Owner

(440) 729-7040 • (216) 276-4001 www.Americanroofingoh.com 1--americanroofing@sbcglobal.net

FINANCING NOW AVAILABLE

MON – THUR 3-10 FRI 3-11 SAT 11:30-11 Bar Open Late

CLOSED SUN

8190 Mayfield Road, Chesterland OH 44026 • 440-729-1817 www.chesterlandtavern.com

MONDAY 3PM - CLOSE BURGER&BUD NIGHT $6.50 8 oz. Burger & Fries BUD LIGHT DRAFT $2.25 16 oz. / $3.75 22 oz.

TUESDAY 3PM - 10PM YUENGS&WINGS $2.50 Yuengling 16 oz. Draft $6.50 Tavern Wings

WEDNESDAY 3PM - 10PM BBQ WEDNESDAYS RIB NIGHT

WINE DOWN 1/2 PRICE Bottle of Wine

THURSDAY 3PM - CLOSE PRIME RIB $5. Specialty Martini Cocktails

FRIDAY 3PM - CLOSE FIREBALL FRIDAYS Fireball Drink Specials

Join us

EVERY SATURDAY

LIVE MUSIC 8:30-11:30

HAPPY HOUR! MON–FRI 3–7PM

225 $ 00 6 $

Beer & Drink Specials

APPS at the Bar

Watch for New Spring Menu...

Page 10

CHESTERLAND NEWS

POLICE BLOTTER The following is a sampling of the calls handled by the Chester Township Police Department Feb. 2-15. In total, the police department handled 205 calls during this 14-day period. AGENCY ASSIST Feb. 7 1:15 a.m., Mayfield Road. Eastbound n 322 from Old Mill, leaving Gates Mills. Silver SUV, Ford. In pursuit. Two felony warrants attached. They believe it may be related to the recent stolen autos. Mayfield Heights is behind the vehicle; not pursuing at this time. They are approaching 306. Going southbound down 306, going down Hideaway Trail. Dead-end street; they crashed and males are bailing out. Russell and Chester PD responding. They are into the woods. One black male and one juvenile arrested. Report to follow. ALARM RESIDENCE Feb. 6 12:13 p.m., Kingsway Drive. Second floor bugs. Sunroom bugs. Cancelled by alarm company. ANIMAL PROBLEM Feb. 5 9:41 a.m., Shiloh Drive. Puppy in the pond that is having trouble getting out. Puppy is out of the pond.

FRAUD Feb. 8 11:35 p.m., County Line Road. Scammed on Craigslist. Need a report for credit card company. PHONE HARASSMENT Feb. 6 6:07 p.m., Cassie Lane. Caller’s teenage daughter is receiving harassing, offensive messages via text/social media. Officer to take report. SUSPICIOUS Feb. 14 10 p.m., Cedar Road. Caller states subject took a piece of his gutter and put it in the middle of his yard. Report taken for suspicious activity. THREATENING Feb. 6 5:09 p.m., Sharp Lane. Caller says a male has called residence stating he is a member of Al-Qaeda and is going to blow up caller’s residence. Phone call started as a sales call regarding a lower interest rate and when the caller called back to ask to be removed from the list, the male started threatening the caller. Phone number that called was a (440) area code number. Incident documented.

Wednesday, February 22, 2017

CHESTER GOVERNMENT UPDATE The Chester Township Board of Trustees met on Feb. 2. Geauga County Engineer representatives Nick Gorris and Andy Haupt attended the meeting. Gorris provided a summary of the county engineer’s culvert condition on West Shiloh. The drainage pipes are deteriorating on the ends, but the passage is safe. Trustees thank the engineer’s office for its prompt response to the residents’ concerns. Haupt explained “Force Accounts,” which is a process that if the estimated prejob cost evaluation certain road maintenance and construction activities is more than $45,000 per mile for road maintenance and more than $15,000 per mile for road construction, then the county engineer will prepare a specification and the board can bid out that work. The board also approved a resolution delegating design and permit authority for future drainage work of drive pipes and ditch enclosures to the county engineer. The action reduces some administrative burdens for the township.

Police Department Chief Mark Purchase participated in 2017 budget discussions for the police department. The township is looking at extending the replacement cycle for police cruisers to a 120,000-mileage threshold rather than a replacement every five years, or about 100,000 miles. There was discussion regarding the possible purchase of a side-by-side ATV to assist in search and rescue with power lines and parks and support for special events such as Laurel Live and Chesterfest. No action was taken; evaluation will continue. A new copier and contract with Canon was approved at $3,965 to replace an old machine.

Road Department Monies were approved for Gradall repairs at $4,000, diesel fuel at $14,468.30 and service for the oil/water separator at $1,500, which is needed about every two years.

Communication from page 6 In a Feb. 16 email to the Maple Leaf, Laurie explained her ability to properly administer invoices requires communication with the judge who presides over a case. "It is no different than a clerk having a

Old Business Trustees executed an agreement to increase township bandwidth to 1 gigabit and transfer incoming phone call service through the county IT department. It is expected to save more than $1,000 per month in phone related charges.

New Business Funds of $1,000 were approved to support the West Geauga Kiwanis with the 2017 Summer Concert in the Park series.

Fiscal Officer’s Report Purchase orders were approved and several transactions were voided including payments for vision and dental insurance coverage because the township is now funding the services through its medical insurance provider, OPEC-HC. The payments were previously going to another company.

Discussion Tim Covert, of Electolite, read a statement concerning his opinion on the static versus electronic sign that the board has been evaluating. He was concerned about the cost, which is between $15,000 and $25,000, and the durability of an electronic sign. Covert added that if the township did purchase a static sign for $5,000 or less, he and Don Yert, of Dry Insurance, would pay for and install a new town hall flag pole. After public and board discussion, a motion was approved 2-1 to approve the static sign. Lions Club member Dennis Farmer was present at the meeting and will work with Covert to facilitate the construction of the brick monument around the sign. On Feb. 9, the board held a special meeting to complete unfinished financial items and conduct an executive discussion regarding employee compensation. No action was taken after executive session. Prepared by Ken Radtke Jr., Trustee

question about how a motion should be docketed, a judicial assistant having a question about how an order that she is typing should be worded, or a prosecutor asking a clerk for access to view a file," she said. "It appears that in Judge Lohn’s view, however, such day-to-day administrative actions would constitute ex parte communication and, if that’s the case, such a prohibition could seriously impede on a court’s ability to function." One week earlier, on Feb. 9, Laurie publicly criticized Lohn’s Feb. 2 order, saying it directly contradicted an April 2016 Ohio Supreme Court decision in the case as well as the opinion advocated by “18 of Ohio’s most experienced probate judges.” She also said Lohn was wrong in finding Grendell violated the separation of powers doctrine and “erroneously interpreted” Grendell’s view of his jurisdiction, even referring to examples Lohn gave as “trivial matters.”

Breaking News and More www.geaugamapleleaf.com

Wednesday, February 22, 2017

CHESTERLAND NEWS

Page 11

CAMPUS CHATTER Chloe Martin, daughter of Erin and Matt Martin of Chester Township, has been named to the deanâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s list at Chatham University for the fall 2016 semester. Darryn Nardi was named to the deanâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s list for the fall semester at Kent State University. Darryn is a sophomore at KSU and a past graduate of West Geauga High School. At Grove City College for the fall semester: Sarah Miller, a sophomore psychology major, was named to the deanâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s list with high distinction. Sarah is a 2015 graduate of homeschooled and is the daughter of Duane and Susan Miller, of Chester Township. Emily El Sanadi, a senior economics major, was named to the deanâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s list with high distinction. A 2013 homeschooled graduate, Emily is the daughter of Laurie Geho, of Russell Township. Faith Menefee, a sophomore preK-4 ele-

mentary education major, was named to the deanâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s list with high distinction. Faith is a 2015 homeschooled graduate and is the daughter of M. Terrell and Amy Menefee, of Russell Township. Michael Eiermann, of Chester Township, has graduated from Baldwin Wallace University with a master of business administration in health care. Lillian Grace Alioto, of Chester Township, graduated from Miami University on Dec. 13 with a bachelor of arts in international studies. Madelyn Ann Brown, of Chester Township, graduated from Miami University on Dec. 13 with a degree in geographic information science. Joshua Egan and Miriam McCarty, both of Chester Township, were named to the deanâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s list at Capital University for the fall semester.

RELIGION St. Markâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s Teen Scene Sundays, 6-7:30 p.m. Middle and high school teens are having a great time at St. Mark Lutheran Church in Chester Township. All are welcome. Call 440-729-1668 for information.

Passion Play Returns to St. Anselm Feb. 24-25, 8 p.m. and Feb. 26, 2 p.m. Cleveland Performing Arts Ministries will put on its 40th annual production of Tetelestai at St. Anselm Church, 12969 Chillicothe Road in Chester Township. A dramatic musical portrayal of the trial, execution and resurrection of Jesus the Messiah, Tetelestai shares the message of

Godâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s unconditional love and forgiveness. Performances are free; a good will offering will be taken following each performance. All petitions written in the prayer journal will be offered up by the entire cast and crew before each performance. For more information, call Cleveland Performing Arts Ministries at 440-944-0635.

The CafĂŠ March 3, 9:30 p.m. Join others from St. Anselm Church at Arabica Coffee House, 12626 Chillicothe Road in Chester Township. Buy a cup of coffee and a muffin, share your thoughts on the blessings in your life and talk with others from St. Anselm Church. All are welcome.

$0')&*% ,$% (&./&-*$+%

Rescue from page 1 because heâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s almost 80 years old. So I thought Iâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;ll call the fire department. They came right away.â&#x20AC;? Fire Chief John Wargelin said his department received the call at 9:42 a.m. and arrived by 9:46 a.m. â&#x20AC;&#x153;When the crew got to the pond, the dog was approximately 20 feet out,â&#x20AC;? the chief said. Judy said while she waited for them to arrive, she watched the dog through her binoculars and kept seeing it going under the water. â&#x20AC;&#x153;I canâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;t count the number of times that dog went under and I was worried sick theyâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;re not going to make it,â&#x20AC;? she said. â&#x20AC;&#x153;When they came, one (firefighter) was already in (his wet) suit and went across the ice on his stomach. (The dog) went under and I thought thatâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s the last time.â&#x20AC;? Wargelin said firefighter Ted Shannon was the man who shimmied across the pond to rescue Tonka as four other firefighters â&#x20AC;&#x201D; Lt. Mitch Plunk, the officer in charge, Ryan Fowler, Joe Pavilonis and Daniel Lallitto â&#x20AC;&#x201D; helped drag them back to safety with ropes. â&#x20AC;&#x153;He bear hugged (Tonka) as they dragged him to the edge of the ice,â&#x20AC;? Judy said. â&#x20AC;&#x153;They did a marvelous job, just marvelous job.â&#x20AC;? The chief said Tonka was â&#x20AC;&#x153;very cold and shaking, but other wise seemed ver y healthy.â&#x20AC;? He added firefighters had wrapped her in towels immediately and the Meyers were generous enough to insist they bring Tonka into their home to warm her up. â&#x20AC;&#x153;They worked on him for a while and got him warmed up,â&#x20AC;? Judy said, adding Pausch, who had called in about her dog missing earlier that morning, showed up 20 minutes later after police called her.

www.chesterlandauto.com " ' # & #" $ % " (&'%+ " $& % + '&&! $( $

EXPERT AUTO BODY AS WELL AS MECHANICAL SERVICE. ALL WORK GUARANTEED! + ! " & %'%" % ! $ " $ + ) &% + ' '"%

+ ' & ! + )!$ + $ % %% ! )!$

+ $ !' & + $ $ " $% % % + ! " & $ % $(

COMPLETE MECHANICAL REPAIRS WITH ASE CERTIFIED MECHANICS!

-- AAA Garage and Towing - "

Towing to Chesterland Auto Body for mechanical or body work ONLY $60 FROM CHESTERLAND & SURROUNDING COMMUNITIES. SUBMITTED

Chester Township firefighter and paramedic Dan Lallitto holds Tonka, a mixed-breed pit bull, after he and four other firefighters rescued her from drowning in a half frozen pond on Shiloh Drive Feb. 5.

Pausch could not be reached for comment. â&#x20AC;&#x153;She said she would take him straight to the vet. She thanked us, but I said, â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;Donâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;t thank me, thank these guys,â&#x20AC;&#x2122;â&#x20AC;? Judy said, referring to the firefighters. Wargelin said the incident turned out to be â&#x20AC;&#x153;just a good coordinated effort between the guys,â&#x20AC;? the Meyers and the Chester Township Police Department, who was also on scene and assisted. â&#x20AC;&#x153;It went really well, it was pretty textbook. Those can be tough and dangerous situations and the guys did a really good job,â&#x20AC;? the chief said. â&#x20AC;&#x153;You have a limited amount of time to get (the dog) out.â&#x20AC;?

! &'%#

" $% $ 95 !%& & &$' %

%"!% ) & ) ""! & &

" &! #&% !%& $% &$' %

1 2

$ !%& % ) & $ " $% &! !$$ & & ! & %& !& '

$ %& $ '%& &

10% OFF #% " $ %

&% !% %

39 95

*&$ $ !$ !! &

#% "+ ! " % $ % #) % +#( * "' % #% " '# * " " , . -

Page 12

CHESTERLAND NEWS

- -,- -,- -,- - - +.!# - % "!'(!&# $ - -

)' - - / * - - /

Joseph S. Parisi, O.D. E YE CARE FOR ALL AGES

, + * % '# ' "+ ( ' , * &' #"' ' "& ' "# # + , % '! "' # + & & & " " (% & , ' % ' ) ( ' #"& , & % ) & #" #"&( ' ' #" , '(% + $$# "'! "'&

Serving the West Geauga area for over 35 years $ # % ) &' % " , *** % #& $ $ % & #!

Wednesday, February 22, 2017

OBITUARIES John Thomas Poole WAXHAW, NC â&#x20AC;&#x201C; John Thomas Poole, of Waxhaw, N.C., formerly of Painesville, passed away on Jan. 26, 2017, at the age of 75, from an ongoing battle with cancer. He was a beloved husband, father, grandfather, brother and friend. He was a thoughtful, kind, honest and hard-working man who was known for his sense of humor and easy-going nature. John was a 1959 graduate of Wintersville High School and a U.S. Army veteran, who served as a member of the Third Infantry Division stationed at Fort Stewart, Ga. John spent 30 years as the owner of Sport Rack in Chester Township. After his retirement in 2010, he enjoyed working and playing golf at Stonebridge Golf Club in Monroe, N.C. He is survived by his wife of 47 years, Cheryl Poole; son, John Thomas (Erin)

Poole Jr.; daughter, Madison Poole; grandchildren, John, Samuel and Maxwell; and siblings Walter â&#x20AC;&#x153;Sonnyâ&#x20AC;? Poole, Ruth Ann Cummings, Margaret Ksiazek, George Poole, Twila Carpenter, Denzil Jones and Janet Battlochi. He was predeceased by his parents, Walter Harmon Poole and Margaret Poole (nee Wilson); stepmother, Lorrain Poole (nee Sutton); and brother James Poole. Friends called at Gattozzi and Son Funeral Home, 12524 Chillicothe Road, Chester Township, on Feb. 12, from 1-4 p.m., and concluded with a service of celebration at 4 p.m. John also was remembered at a service at 6 p.m. Feb. 18 at Stonebridge Golf Club in Monroe, N.C. In lieu of flowers, the family suggests contributions to Pelotonia, an annual charity cycling event that donates 100 percent of its proceeds to the James Cancer Hospital at The Ohio State University. Donations in Johnâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s honor can be made at www.pelotonia.org/TPoole. Online tributes and condolences at www.gattozziandson.com.

GEAUGA WEST LIBRARY The Geauga West Library is at 13455 Chillicothe Road. For more information or to register, call 440-729-4250 or visit GeaugaLibrary.net.

Friends Establish Scholarship The Friends of the West Geauga Library voted unanimously to set up a three year $6,000 scholarship for candidates seeking a Master of Library and Information Science Degree (MLIS) at Kent State University. Kent State is the only university in Ohio to offer the American Library Association accredited degree. The scholarship will award $2,000 per year for three years to a student who demonstrates financial need. Residents of Geauga County or Northeast Ohio are preferred. Kent State University will be the administrator and award the scholarship.

ia and activities. Enter to win an â&#x20AC;&#x153;all things Seussâ&#x20AC;? prize.

Sunday With Art March 5, 2 p.m. View work from local budding artists at this art show opening. All throughout the librar y, student art will be displayed. Refreshments will be provided.

Magic School Bus Book Party March 16, 7 p.m. â&#x20AC;&#x153; Take chances, make mistakes, get messyâ&#x20AC;? will be the theme in celebration of the magic of Miss Frizzle and her crazy, educational school bus and classroom. Kids in grades K-5 will enjoy books, crafts and snacks.

Bad Art Spring Book Sale

"# !

& $ & # & & ! # &

$ $ $ $

! " " ! "

EXPIRES 3/31/17

! " $

! $ $ !#

March 14, 3:30 p.m. Teens will combine as many art and craft materials as they can to create sculptures, collages and paintings.

The Geauga West Fr iends of t he Library spring book sale begins March 1 with a members-only preview from 4-6 p.m. and is then open to the public from 6-8:30 p.m. Memberships are available at the door. Sale will continue March 2, 9 a.m. to 8:30 p.m.; March 3, 9 a.m. to 4:30 p.m.; and March 4, which is $3 Bag Day, 9 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. The sale includes thousands of new and gently used adult and childrenâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s books, puzzles and games and audio/video items.

Thursdays Volunteers from AARP will help file your 2016 federal and state taxes. Appointments are required; call Geauga West to schedule. Bring a copy of 2015 tax returns, all 2016 tax statements; proof of identity and social security card.

1,000 Books Before Kindergarten

Travel with Joe the Coupon Guy

Visit Geauga West Library or any GCPL branch to register oneâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s child. Children who sign up will be given a free T-shirt featuring the new library mascot.

March 8, 7 p.m. Joe will demonstrate how to save on flights, car rentals, hotels, bus and train transportation, restaurants, international travel, entertainment and cruises.

Tax assistance

Spring Storytime Signups Register now for the spring storytime session, which begins March 13 and runs through April 27. There will be no storytimes March 26 through April 1. Sign up online or call to register.

March on Dinosaurs Dinosaurs will be on display the entire month of March. Experience the fun while enjoying dinosaur books and activity sheets.

All Things Seuss â&#x20AC;&#x153;Hop On Popâ&#x20AC;? to the library in March for a Dr. Seuss display. Enjoy Seuss books, triv-

Introduction to Microsoft Excel March 15, 7 p.m. Plan ahead to learn the basic skills of the Microsoft Office spreadsheet program.

GCPL Offers Rosetta Stone GCPL patrons who want to learn a new language now have access to Rosetta Stone with their library cards. The language learning tool is a fantastic value, saving people about $159 per language if they were to purchase it on their own. The vital resource includes 30 languages to meet a range of cultural interests.

Wednesday, February 22, 2017

CHESTERLAND NEWS

Page 13

HELP WANTED Gardener/Landscaper for elderly gentleman Also light housekeeping Paid Position with room and board included

Small garden design maintenance company looking for full-time help. Experience preferred.

Matt at 440-759-4380

Call 440-667-2849

& $

Find Your Next Employee of the Month in the Chesterland News 440-729-7667

#% # " ! %

CUSTODIAN/CLEANER FULL-TIME East side private school seeks a self-motivated, energetic custodian/cleaner who takes pride in a job well done for the second shift. Must be able to pass a background check. Excellent benefit package. EOE

Please respond to: DOF, P.O. Box 8002 Gates Mills OH 44040

#! $ #!% # % !' # # #!" ! " " ! ! %" % !" " ! ! " "# "' " ! '

To advertise in the Classifieds or Service Directory, contact the advertising department at 440-729-7667 ext. 500 or ads@chesterlandnews.com.

CLASSIFIED DEADLINE: FRIDAY AT NOON Here is my ad. Please call me with the cost to run my ad _____ times. The per week cost is $10 for the first 20 words, plus 25 cents for each additional word. I am a PAID MAPLE LEAF SUBSCRIBER entitled to 20 WORDS* or less FREE each week, if I fax, email, mail or bring in this coupon. (Words over 20 will be billed at 25 cents per word.) Please run my ad _____ weeks. Note: ALL FREE ads must be resubmitted every four weeks. (NO BUSINESS ADS) Subscriber ads can be emailed to: ads@geaugamapleleaf.com Please include subscriber number (found on mailing label)

I would like to be a MAPLE LEAF SUBSCRIBER and advertise for FREE. Enclosed is $40.00 for an in-county 12 month subscription (subscription rate valid through 12/31/17).

Dedicated DSPs

Full-time Positions Available

BRI is looking for dedicated DSPs to care for people with developmental disabilities in their own home. Seeking; dedicated, responsible, team players who promote sustainable living skills. Direct care of people with developmental disabilities. Applicant must have a VALID driver's license, Diploma/GED and CPR/First Aid. 5+ years experience with behavioral I/DD population preferred. We are willing to train qualified candidates who learn quickly and follow instruction. BRI benefits include- Employee healthcare coverage, 401k, Paid time off Please Call: 440-428-6648 Email or Fax a Resume to: Brittany Residential, Inc. Attn: Residential Coordinator info@brittanyresidential.com / Fax #: 440-428-4696

'',5,10$. 813'4 $3( < 2(3 813' 145 1)),&( %19 06/%(34 &1605 $4 581 813'4 5(.(2+10( 06/%(34 $%%3(7,$5,104 $0' ;,2 &1'(4 &1605 $4 10( 813'

brittanyresidential.com !

+(&- /$'( 2$:$%.( 51

$45(3&$3' /(3,&$0 923(44

,4$ ,4&17(3

$/( 10 &$3' #################################################################### ,..,0* $''3(44 #################################################################### $3' #########################################

#########

1'( #########

,*0$563( #######################################################################

Drop off in person or mail to: Chesterland News 8389 Mayfield Road, B-5 Chesterland, OH 44026 Fax: 440-729-8240

Page 14

CHESTERLAND NEWS

Wednesday, February 22, 2017

SERVICE DIRECTORY Residential Cleaning Service We Get The Job Done Right The First Time! â&#x20AC;¢ Fully Insured â&#x20AC;¢ Quality Service â&#x20AC;¢ Reference Available â&#x20AC;¢ Flat Rate Cleaning Cleaning May be Scheduled Weekly, Bi-Weekly or Monthly

Call Today 440-226-9740 or 440-415-3571 Great Service â&#x20AC;¢ Reliable â&#x20AC;¢ Experienced

MASTER PAINTERS

Install any type of tiles -Kitchen, Bathroom, Backsplash, etc.

( '% ! ( &"# ! " ( $ ( " " !

%%% !" " ! ! !" " !

Interior & Exterior Painting Pressure Washing Remodeling

Place your classified ad today by calling 440-729-7667

" ! " " gas, water and electric lines " culverts, post hole drilling " concrete tear outs "

" !

" " " " "

440-465-8795 â&#x20AC;¢ 440-254-4281

"# # "

"#!$ #

! !

â&#x20AC;¢ Classified Deadline is Friday at Noon â&#x20AC;¢ 440-729-7667 â&#x20AC;¢

Wednesday, February 22, 2017

CHESTERLAND NEWS

Page 15

CLASSIFIEDS AUTOS & AUTO PARTS 2007 Black Yukon Denali. Fully Loaded, Pioneer Navigation, Corsa Performance Exhaust, Heated Seats, AWD. Serviced at Junction Auto. Great Condition. 100,200 Miles. $15,000 OBO. Call 216-509-6600 and Leave A Message.

BUSINESS OPPORTUNITY Kirtland

Party Center/Restaurant for Lease 9270 Chillicothe Road. Fully equipped and furnished, turn-key operation, low cost entry. 440-256-6339.

FOR RENT

Antique & Treasure Sale: Every Sunday beginning Jan 8, 10am-2pm, and FREE Pancake Breakfast 11a-1p every Sunday! Rent a space to sell your antiques and treasures for only $25 or just join us to see what others have to offer. Space is limited, sign up today (all fees go to advertising), Lowe's Greenhouse, 16540 Chillicothe Rd, Chagrin Falls, 440-543-5123, www.lowesgreenhouse.com.

GRANDMAâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;S Costume Jewelry Compacts â&#x20AC;˘ Perfume Linens â&#x20AC;˘ Knickknacks

GRANDPAâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;S Toys â&#x20AC;˘ Trains Coins â&#x20AC;˘ Bottles Fishing Lures

ALSO BUYING:

Misc. Collections and Estates

MISCELLANEOUS

Middlefield: 2 bedroom duplex, NON-smoking, NO pets, laundry hook-up, $600/month, security deposit required, call 440-636-5747.

+ ' '% (("%$ # *"# "$!

+ " # % , (& )

* &(% ( & ( - $& # , )* & *

( * " +"* &( $ ) ' %!"% ( &%)+$* %* *

FOR SALE 1991 Indy 500 snowmobile, $750, call 440-2144429. 2000+ guns in stock, big variety of ammo, Ohio Supply & Tool, 125 State St., Wadsworth OH, 330-335-1506.

Old wooden fishing lures, wooden duck decoys, old steel traps (mouse to bear). Call Lee, 440-313-8331.

Joe Eicher: doing roofing, siding, remodeling, cleanout houses. We do most anything. Call between 8 a.m. and 4 p.m. 440813-4272. No answer, leave message. Offering special discounts for interior and exterior painting and staining this season. 17 years experience. Professional and insured. Call Dan, 440-342-4552. Landscaper (semi-retired) will cut your lawn and other small jobs using my equipment, call 440-338-6464, 30 yrs experience. Educational: SAT/ACT individualized tutoring. 20-years of experience and success. Also Algebra 1 through Calculus tutoring. Tutoring for enrichment, advancement or credit. 440-338-3563.

Chautauqua Lake: Prime Summer 2017 dates available. Lakefront, 3br/2ba, sleeps 8, furnished, sunroom, boat dock, all amenities, 440-953-8687 www.maplebaygetaway.com.

CHARDON - Condo 2bdr. updated in Colonial Park. $850 month. NO SMOKING, NO PETS. Credit & references. SALE at $79,900, call 440-278-0130.

Educational: Reading, tutoring, all ages. Can help students with dyslexia (Wilson trained). Call 440-321-9485.

VACATION RENTALS

Huntsburg: one bed, 2-car garage, $650 plus electric, no pets, Amish welcomed, 440-6321016.

COMMERCIAL RENTALS

WANTED TO BUY

Johnâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s Plumbing: Affordable and reliable. Water heaters, toilets, faucets, drain cleaning, gas lines, sump pumps, well tanks. 440-285-0800.

Claridon: Rt 322/Rt 608, 2-Bedroom, 1-Bath, stove, refrigerator, washer/dryer hook-up, No dogs, $645 + electric, call 440-478-2408.

CHESTERLAND: 3 bedroom Ranch, one bath, fam room, fireplace, basement, lg. 2car garage, $1000/month, no pets 440-289-0708.

SERVICES

Classifieds 440-729-7667, ext. 3 Exercise Classes at the West Geauga Senior Center, too many to list! New in February: Strength Building, Fridays 11 a.m. Taught by a Certified PersonalTrainer, $2 donation. Call Mary Kay 440-533-5287. Infused within an original (musically-dramatic) audiovisual production, the goal is to become your new trusted platform for quality melodic story-song discovery. Catch scenes from the pilot season during the next northeast Ohio rehearsal walkthrough...02-27-2017, 3-3:30pm, acts 2/3...Experience the first access (regional beta) and embrace the emotive journey: EmotionSnapshot (dot)com/begin

PETS & ANIMALS FARM HELP WANTED: A few hours a morning to do chores, must be hard worker and self-starter. References. Call 440-564-7363.

REAL ESTATE

GARAGE/ESTATE SALES

LOT FOR SALE, NEWBURY. 3 wooded, buildable acre lot. Very scenic! $44,900 Call 440-289-0708.

If you need to have a moving sale, estate sale or garage sale, call Kathy Willis at 440729-2790 for assistance. Experienced. References available. We are now doing partial estate buyouts.

Troy Twp farmette: 28+ acres with 18.6 tillable, 40'x100' Quonset bank barn, 32'x80' pole barn. Completely renovated 4bed/1bath century home, $360,000 firm. Call 440-5488087 or 740-361-3564.

SOLD ONE DAY OVER ASKING 7945 Arlington Dr., Chesterland $409,900

12535 Heath Road, Chesterland $374,000

Beautiful brick colonial on cul-de-sac lot. Four spacious bedrooms 3 and a half baths. Finished bmt. Large updated eat-in kitchen with stainless steel appliances. Resort style living with inground pool and hot tub! Priced to sell!

â&#x20AC;&#x153;I Sell Homes Other Realtors Canâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;t!â&#x20AC;?

Angelo Marrali HOMES OF DISTINCTION SPECIALIST Sales Partner to John DeSantis, 10 Million Dollar Plus Producer

11455 Rust Dr., Chesterland $414,900

Secluded mini estate on over six private acres situated on cul-de-sac. Large gourmet eatin kitchen with granite counters and loads of cabinet space! Four large bedrooms and four full baths! Office/den on first floor! Sunroom overlooking private backyard. Trex deck, new roof and load of many updates throughout! Finished walkout lower level!

440-525-3718 / 440-974-7846 angelomarrali@howardhanna.com

Page 16

CHESTERLAND NEWS

Wednesday, February 22, 2017