October 2015 | The Evergreen, Greenhill School

Page 1

Evergreen the

Volleyball

1996 1997 1999 2000 2001 2002

Soccer

2003 2004 2005 2008 2010 2011

1994 1995 1998 2002 2003

Basketball

2004 2006 2007 2009

Cross Country

1998 1999 2014

2007

october 7, 2015

Everything Greenhill

Debate 1994 2003 1995 1996 1997 1998 2001

volume 51, issue 1

Tennis

Football

2000

2005 2006 2007 2013

1995 1996 2007 2008 2009

2010 2011 2013 2014 2015

Track & Field

Golf

1999 2000

1999 2001 2002 2003 2004

2006 2007 2014 2015

Graphic by Arhum Khan

Debate Debunked

*Dates since Greenhill Debate’s first State Championship with Aaron Timmons

The culture of debate is explored through the eyes of the Greenhill community Varun Gupta

They practice well into the night and drink tons of water before tournaments. But rather than receiving baked sweets from cheerleaders or getting an ovation for winning, the debate team often goes unnoticed, many times missing days of school before trophies display their accomplishments. Debate is an activity so deeply sewn into Greenhill’s historical tapestry that many students forget the roots of a nationally ranked program. For years, Greenhill debaters have gone on to top tier colleges. The athletes play year round, and many debaters call their passion a sport. But being a nationally ranked debate team, like any other elite sport, requires commitment. Upper School students readily admit it requires a type of dedication they are not willing to make. Director of Debate, Aaron Timmons, who has been at the helm of turning out these champions for more than two decades, recognizes all the work it takes to win. Nevertheless, many debaters say they receive far more from his guidance and the activity overall than they might otherwise glean from living an average teenage life. Like a high school basketball team that sends players to University of North Carolina, for students, the lure of national recognition on Greenhill debate makes the intense dedication it requires hard to turn down. The Greenhill debate team won more than a dozen regional and national events last season, capturing second place at the National Debate Coaches

Associations National Tournament and third at the National Speech and Debate Associations National Championship. In the past 20 years, Greenhill’s debate team has placed consistently in the top 5 state-wide, and is close to winning 20 state championships since the start of the program. Debate is typically a full year course. The team competes at two levels –novice and varsity. Freshman typically make up the novice group, and learn the fundamentals of debate. They often do research for the older varsity groups who are bringing back big trophies. As debaters advance, they can increase commitment as well. Mr. Timmons runs after-school practices for juniors and seniors. Varsity debaters travel up to nine times per year, flying all over the country to places such as Chicago, Las Vegas and Kentucky. Mr. Timmons recommends that the more advanced students go to debate camp that can range from two to seven weeks in the summer. In addition to these time commitments, debaters have mental and physical demands too. While they don’t spend hours in the weight room, jaws get a workout. Much like an elbow injury to a tennis player, a jawline fracture can challenge a debater’s ability to give a speech. Then there is mental toughness. A variety of factors, such as the speed of speech and judging style, contribute to their record. A speech must be persuasive, but some judges favor the latest speaking strategies while others value traditional ones. As a result, judging can be

subjective. Debaters may practice endlessly, but still face losses they find unfair. “Having to adapt to different styles of judging makes you a good debater. If you can only debate in front of one kind of judge, you’re going to lose a lot of rounds,” said junior Brooke Bulmash. Understanding how to handle a tough loss is key to moving forward in a tournament. “When you lose a round at the start or middle of the tournament, you can’t fixate over it; you just have to go back in and beat people,” said senior Bennett Eckert. “I can live with this; I can move past this because it was my bad and there was nothing for me to be angry at anyone other than myself.” For successful top-tier competitors, outcomes of local tournaments significantly impact their chance to qualify for the Tournament of Champions (TOC). While the stakes are high, debaters cannot let a dent on the record crack his or her confidence. “You have to learn how to lose graciously, as much as winning graciously,” Brooke said. As the team continues to cement championships, some nondebaters believe the ‘sport’ takes over debaters’ lives. By choice or by force, debaters are debaters, and that’s all, they say. “I think [debaters] are determined and smart people, but I feel they are secluded and isolated from the community because they have to focus of their work, which is really important,” said senior Nitish Jindal, who does not debate. Aware of the sentiment, debaters will say the activity is more of an advantage.

“[The student body] definitely sees it more as a threat than something you get to enjoy participating in,” said freshman debater Chris Eckert. Chris adds that the debate team’s commitment has some negative connotations at Greenhill, a community that puts a high emphasis on being involved in many different parts of the school. Mr. Timmons says the perception is wrong. “I highly encourage people to try out sports, particularly at a younger age because…after a couple of years you may have to modify,” he says. But not every debater makes these sacrifices. Some team members, like Brooke, swim on the club and school team yearround and participates in LincolnDouglas tournaments. “Debate is very stressful. Swimming keeps me leveled and debate gives me a competitive edge. Both of them complement each other,” Brooke said. Andrew Spomer ’13 played varsity soccer and debated on the top Policy team in his senior year. At the end of his senior year, Andrew had to choose between attending his last Southern Preparatory Conference (SPC) tournament in soccer and the Harvard Debate Tournament. Andrew chose debate. “I began to love debate more than I had ever loved soccer,” said Andrew. “It is not a binary choice, but rather a gradient of commitment. Every single day of high school, I shifted my allegiance closer and closer to debate and farther from soccer, not because any teacher or coach forced me to, but because I wanted to.”

Andrew isn’t alone. Many debaters say they don’t mind making trade-offs such as missing school, sports events, and school dances to compete in tournaments. Their absence means more makeup work, but debaters learn time management skills that enhance their academic experience, they say. “That makes it significantly easier to sit down with an essay. I definitely think since my freshman year, my essay writing skills have improved greatly,” Brooke said. In addition, tournaments serve as a mini-reunion place for debate friends from summer camp. “You create tightly-knit friend groups around the nation so you get to socialize with them as well. So you have multiple friend groups,” said senior Varad Agarwala. Still, Mr. Timmons stresses that to be a national champion, competitors in Advanced Debate need to be honest with thier goals. In the same way [a coach] might tell a player that they can’t win SPC by just suiting up on Friday because they have some natural talent, the same would be true for any competitive activity,” Mr. Timmons said. Nevertheless, the idea of success appeals to debaters who want to leave a mark on the Greenhill program. “I find the back and forth intellectual warfare to be very interesting and the research process prior to the tournament as well,” said Varad. “The feeling of winning is incomparable.”

Views

News

Feat.

Arts

Sports

Special Report and Profiles Editor

What makes a student worthy of recognition? p.3

Behind the new health kick in The Buzz p. 5

Serving Greenhill since 1966

Transgender student shares his story. p. 8

Greenhill students take on Shakespeare in the Park p. 14

4141 Spring Valley Road, Addison, TX 75001

Middle School girls start their football career p. 17

evergreengreenhill.wordpress.com


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.