ChicagoMaroon101416

Page 1

OCTOBER 14, 2016

THE INDEPENDENT STUDENT NEWSPAPER OF THE UNIVERSITY OF CHICAGO SINCE 1892

VOL. 128, ISSUE 5

FINANCIAL AID CRISIS LINGERS College Aid Says It Is Understaffed BY GREG ROSS

MADELEINE JOHNSON

NEWS STAFF

MAROON CONTRIBUTOR

process. Committee members clarified aspects of their work so far and gave insight into their probable recommendations, including the creation of a separate disruptive conduct-specific disciplinary system similar to the one for issues of sexual misconduct. The meeting was led by Committee Chair and Law School

Three weeks into the quarter—and well past due dates for tuition bills —many students are experiencing delays and difficulties in receiving their financial aid packages from the Office of College Aid. Nearly 100 students have signed an online complaint form that will be sent to University administrators. The form targets the Office of College A id, which has experienced a reduction in staffing and is now being accused by students of inefficiency and a lack of transparency. T he form, launched last week by second-year Trenton Crawford, seeks to address a “surge” of student complaints about the Office. “I wanted to gather students’ experiences and let the [University] know that low-income students aren’t at the disposal of the University, and that what the financial aid office is

A group of activists campaigning for increased financial benefits for Resident Assistants (RAs) is prepared to protest if the University’s Office of College Aid does not give them a meeting. Students Organizing United with Labor (SOUL) and last year’s campaigners for a change in RA payment methods met on Tuesday to discuss their plans for the year. The meeting focused largely on introducing last year’s call for a more equitable payment for RAs on financial aid, which SOUL has taken up, and establishing the group’s goals for the year. After last year’s petition to the financial aid office which asked for a change in the way RAs on financial assistance are paid garnered over 1,000 signatures, SOUL hoped to build on the broad campus attention the issue had received and pressure financial aid officials into a meeting. Under the current system, the elimination of room and board costs for RAs is factored into the

Continued on page 3

Continued on page 3

Continued on page 3

Eva I

Members of the Committee on University Discipline for Disruptive Conduct (from left to right), Christopher Wild, Michele Rasmussen, Randal Picker, and Daniel Abebe, hold a forum on the issue of disruptive conduct on Oct. 13.

Committee Evaluating Discipline for Protest Takes Student Feedback BY ALEX WARD SENIOR NEWS REPORTER

T he f ac u lt y c om m it t e e tasked with proposing a disciplinary system for disruptive protests and other conduct that interferes with University business took student input yesterday. The committee was created in the wake of protests last year including the occupation of

Levi Hall by a group calling for increased accountability by the University and audience interruptions of speakers including Cook County Attorney General Anita Alvarez. The All-University Discipline System, which the committee is reviewing, was created after a series of protests against the Vietnam war in 1969 that led to the expulsion of 42 students through a drawnout and contentious disciplinary

Activists Demand Meeting for RA Aid

Professor Sued for Allegedly Defaming Medical Devices for Financial Gain BY ALEX WARD SENIOR NEWS REPORTER

Medical technology corporation St. Jude Medical (STJ) has filed a lawsuit against a University of Chicago Medical Center doctor, alleging that he was involved in an attempt to manipulate the company’s stock for financial gain. Dr. Hemal Nayak, a University of Chicago assistant professor and electrophysiologist, is singled out by plaintiff STJ for allegedly conspiring with companies MedSec, where he is a board member, and Muddy Waters Research LLC to falsely suggest critical security issues in STJ’s products. Nayak obtained a number of St. Jude’s Cardiac Rhythm Management (CRM) devices, including pacemakers and implanted defibrillators, for MedSec to use in a research program that claims to have found significant cybersecurity vulnerabilities in the devices. MedSec brought its findings

The Muddy Waters report notes any living tissue, but was otherwise to financial research firm Muddy Waters Research LLC, which that Nayak has an “immaterial eq- functioning normally. Within two weeks of the publipublished a report on August 25 uity interest” in MedSec, indicating describing the vulnerabilities. The his partial ownership of the compa- cation of the Muddy Waters report, report predicted that “There is a ny as a board member. The report STJ filed a legal complaint requeststrong possibility that close to half was also updated from its original ing a jury trial in the U.S. District of STJ’s revenue is about to disap- version to include a statement that Court for the state of Minnesota. pear for approximately two years.” “Nayak speaks for himself, and not The lawsuit alleges that, rather As a result, Muddy Waters revealed his employers,” referring to the Uni- than expressing genuine concern for the safety of St. Jude’s patients, that it would be short selling STJ versity. After the report’s publication, Muddy Waters, MedSec, and Naystock, through which they would profit off of a decrease in the value STJ published a response defend- ak intended primarily to manipuof the company’s stock. STJ’s stock ing its products and pointing out late financial markets for financial dropped more than four points in a that the vulnerabilities addressed gain. According to the complaint, in the report are largely exagger- “Defendants undertook their careday after the report’s publication. To accompany the report, Nay- ated or speculative. STJ’s response fully orchestrated scheme with the ak published a letter on University noted that an attacker would need express intent to interfere with effiof Chicago letterhead warning his to be continuously within seven feet cient public markets by intentionalpatients and fellow doctors about of a targeted implant once it was ly disseminating false information the vulnerabilities MedSec appar- actually within an individual in in order to depress the value of St. ently uncovered. The letter advises order to drain its battery as demon- Jude’s stock and profit from such depatients with STJ implants to un- strated, and that the device would pression in value by implementing plug their home monitoring systems, give a vibratory warning before a short-selling scheme.” The case is which send information recorded the battery was fully drained. The currently ongoing. by their CRM device to their physi- response also notes that the signs St. Jude’s lawsuit charges Naycians, and states that Nayak no lon- of a supposed crash documented by ak and the other defendants with ger plans to implant STJ devices un- MedSec researchers indicate only four counts, including defamation, til the vulnerabilities are addressed. that the device was not connected to violating state and federal business

practices law, and civil conspiracy. The list of defendants also include Muddy Waters founder Carson. Block and MedSec CEO Justine Bone. Multiple independent entities, including the FDA and a team of researchers at the University of Michigan, have since released their own analyses of the Muddy Waters report. Both the FDA and the University of Michigan researchers concluded that the danger to patients from the possible vulnerabilities described in the report does not outweigh the advantages of the affected devices and reporting systems, according to STJ’s legal complaint. As cited in the complaint, “the FDA advised that at this time ‘patients should continue to use their devices as instructed and not change any implanted device.’” STJ and the lawyers representing both the plaintiff and defendants did not respond to requests for comment, and Nayak declined to comment.

On Race and Culture, Jeff Chang Promises We Gon’ Be Alright

Maroons Hanging on to Homecoming Hopes

Contributing to The Maroon

Page 7

Page 12

“Protecting our home turf is a big deal for us. We take pride in protecting Stagg Field.”

Art is not just an outlet for negative frustration, but an elevated inlet of positive change.

Not Born This Way Page 6

Trigger’d: The Revival a Safe Space for Comedy Page 8

Identity sometimes means rejecting what you were born into.

“[Trigger] hearkens to a very different conflict plaguing neighborhoods only a stone’s throw away.”

If you want to get involved in THE M AROON in any way, please email apply@chicagomaroon.com or visit chicagomaroon.com/ pages/apply.

Excerpts from articles and comments published in T he Chicago Maroon may be duplicated and redistributed in other media and non-commercial publications without the prior consent of The Chicago Maroon so long as the redistributed article is not altered from the original without the consent of the Editorial Team. Commercial republication of material in The Chicago Maroon is prohibited without the consent of the Editorial Team or, in the case of reader comments, the author. All rights reserved. © The Chicago Maroon 2016


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.