The Henry Doetsch Collection
1
THE HENRY DOETSCH COLLECTION THE HIGHLY IMPORTANT COLLECTION OF
PICTURES BY OLD MASTERS OF
HENRY DOETSCH, ESQ. (1839-1894) Deceased; late of 7 New Burlington Street, London
Auctioned in London on 22nd, 24th and 25th June 1895 Edited and assembled by:
G. STEPHEN HOLMES Douglas, Isle of Man. August 2018. --------o-------
The Henry Doetsch Collection
2
Note by G. Stephen Holmes I first came across the name “Doetsch” in 2003. In an obscure article written by Gustav Glück in 1928, the German art historian admitted that he had not viewed a painting attributed to Marco d'Oggiono of the Holy Children Embracing, which had been in the Doetsch Collection, but he was very much aware of its existence. In 2004, I first saw the magnificent publication THE MOND COLLECTION: AN APPRECIATION by the great art-historian and Leonardo scholar, John Paul Richter, published by John Murray in 1910. The very same painting that Glück mentioned in 1928 had been in the Mond Collection, and Richter revealed that the work had been acquired by Dr. Ludwig Mond at the Doetsch sale and that its previous ascription was Leonardo da Vinci. In 2008, I was fortunate to find a copy of THE DOETSCH COLLECTION in a bookshop in Galway, Republic of Ireland, which had been acquired from Burren College of Art in County Clare in the West of Ireland. The book was £23. It was also during 2008 that I discovered more and more books on the world-wide-web; books that had been scanned and published as a Portable Document Format (pdf) file; books that were years out of copyright. The more I studied the two collections compiled up to 1894 and 1909 (Henry Doetsch died in 1894 and Ludwig Mond died in 1909 – the latter gave the majority of his collection to the National Gallery in London), the more important they became. There is a “Mond Room” in the National Gallery in Trafalgar Square, and Mond's chemical company survives to this day (Brunner-Mond patented the Solvay Process), but the name Doetsch (both Mond and Doetsch were born in Germany and moved to England in the mid-nineteenth century) has been largely forgotten, except for a provenance name in some galleries in Europe and North America. For example, a painting in the National Gallery of Art in Washington D.C. was bought in the Doetsch Sale in June 1895 – it was lot number 48. Algernon Graves listed many of the sale prices in his three volumes of Art Sales books published in 1918, and some of these are available on the world-wide-web, but the books were re-published in 1970 by Burt Franklin so they are not out of copyright. A handful of paintings sold in June 1895 are listed on the world-wide-web, among them the Marco d'Oggiono Infant Christ and St. John (Lot 88) that sold for £157 10s or 150 guineas. Calculating a price in 2008 for a painting that fetched £157 in 1895 is not easy; but a price of between £500,000 and £700,000 might be acceptable for a quality work by one of the best known Milanese followers of Leonardo. In 2007 I acquired my own copy of the Mond Collection, and now have a history of two of Marco d'Oggiono paintings of the Holy Children Embracing; Richter correctly describes the version in the Royal collection at Hampton Court Palace as “a decidedly inferior painting” to that in the Doetsch Sale. It is coincidental that Richter assembled the catalogue for the Doetsch sale, and in the early years of the twentieth century, Richter appreciated Dr Mond's collection; he comments briefly on Lot 88 in 1895, but makes a thorough critical analysis of the same painting in 1910, and precedes Glück by twenty years. In fact, Richter made the same comment that more than a dozen art-historians and critics made during the twentieth century; “So many repetitions and variations of this image [the Holy Children Embracing] exist by pupils of Leonardo da Vinci that it is reasonable to suppose that it [the image] is founded on a lost painting by his hand”. In 1895, Richter assumed that Marco had copied from a drawing by Leonardo (now in the Royal Library at Windsor Castle), but by 1910 he had decided that Leonardo would have most likely completed an 'original' painting from which the repetitions and variations were copied; and in the early part of the twenty-first century it is certain that there was a painting upon which ALL the versions are based, and that Glück was right when he asserted that Leonardo alone could have created the motif, probably as a culmination of the ideas in the Virgin of the Rocks. That is another project. Having acquired a copy of THE DOETSCH COLLECTION, and scanned the eighty or so images contained therein, I have great pleasure in presenting this web-based presentation of one of the finest collections of art in England in the latter part of the nineteenth century, that assembled by Henry Doetsch Esquire of London.
The Henry Doetsch Collection
3
PREFACE --------o-------THE Doetsch Collection was the creation of the twenty years from 1874 to 1894. In this comparatively short time, the energy of its deceased owner succeeded in collecting and exhibiting in his house in London a rich collection of pictures, for the most part of great interest and importance. He aimed especially at the acquisition of works belonging to the best period of the various Schools of Italy and the Netherlands, without, however, neglecting the German and Spanish Schools. Most richly represented are the schools of Florence and Venice. They form the bulk of the Italian collection, the variety of which affords an admirable picture of the different directions in which Italian art accomplished its development. It would be difficult to name a second collection of Italian pictures of any extent, in which, compared to the portraits of historical interest, the Madonnas and Saints fall so markedly into the background as is the case here. Those princes, of world-wide celebrity on account of the splendour of their courts and their relations to the first painters of the Renaissance, whose names are familiar to every one, meet us here in numerous portraits, as to which it can be asserted, on good grounds that they were executed under their orders by the painters in their service. The collection is peculiarly rich in portraits of the Medici family and of the Royal House of Spain ; and among the likenesses of princes, we may call special attention to the portrait of King Henry VII., as unique and remarkable from more than one point of view. No trouble has been spared that, by comparison and in other ways, might contribute to the highest possible degree of certainty in the descriptions and attributions. Among the pictures of the German and Flemish Schools there are some that, apart from their value as works of art, have a special archaeological and historical interest ; and in all such cases explanatory notes have been added to the descriptions in the catalogue. It is hardly necessary to point out that the Dutch School is also brilliantly represented by a large number of capital works – chiefly of small size – by the most famous masters, among whom Franz Hals and his School may be mentioned in the first place ; while at the same time there are specimens of masters scarcely to be met with elsewhere, even in the choicest and most famous collections of Dutch art. It could not fail to happen that, in his extraordinary zeal as a collector, and dominated as he was by the determination to see himself surrounded by works of the greatest masters, the founder and owner of the gallery occasionally procured pictures, the attributions of which failed to satisfy the demands of a scrupulous and ruthless scientific criticism. Influenced, therefore, by these considerations, the executors of the late Mr. Henry Doetsch have seen fit to entrust me (Richter) with the task of submitting every single picture in the collection to a process of critical investigation, and at the same time, with regard to the attributions, they have given me full power to alter them in all cases in which a more accurate determination might seem necessary. However, there is no need to lay stress on the assurance that in the great majority of cases these altered titles in no way depreciate the value of the Collection as such, least of all in the eyes of connoisseurs, or of those collectors whose great object it is to possess pictures which owe their names to something more consistent than chance and more solid than fancy. From the fact that the Collection was always accessible to lovers of art and to art critics, it follows that not a few of its rare and important works have long since met with their just appreciation in critical and historical publications, such, for instance, as Mr. Bernard Berensons's 'Venetian Painters,' the official catalogue of the Rijks Museum at Amsterdam, Ch. Yriarte's 'Autour des Borgia,' Dr. Bode's articles in the Jahrbuch der Kgl. Preussischen Kunstammlungen and others. Of a number of pictures it can be proved that they come from the best and most renowned collections, like the Orléans Gallery and the Collection of Charles I. For, with regard to the acquisition of pictures, not only was it important to Mr. Doetsch that they should fully make good their claims in the matter of preservation and authenticity, but also laid special stress upon the securities involved in their provenance and pedigree. He acquired portraits from the Collections of the Marquis of Exeter, the Marquess of Donegal, the Marquis of Hastings, and the Duke of Rixburghe ; from the Markham Collection, from the Pinacoteca Lochis, and through the intermediation of Dr. Gustavo Frizzoni in Milan. In fact there is not doubt that the pictures forming the Doetsch Collection passed from English country seats directly into the owner's hands, and to this circumstance we are also partly indebted for the fact that many of the pictures are still provided with costly frames, such as only the craft of former centuries could design and execute.
J. P. RICHTER, PH. DR. --------o--------
The Henry Doetsch Collection
4
THE PAINTINGS Although 450 paintings were sold on the three days from 22nd to 26th June 1895, only 80 of them are illustrated in the 1895 catalogue; this web-site is limited to eighty-four works (with seven in colour).
Italian Paintings
7. Ippolito Scarsella: Portrait of a Prince
8. Filippo Mazzuola: Virgin and Child
The Henry Doetsch Collection
5
13. Parmigiano (1503-1540): Portrait of a Cardinal
23. Guido Reni (1575-1642): Mary Magdalene and two angel boys
The Henry Doetsch Collection
6
34. Bartolomeo Veneto: Portrait of a Young Man
36. Lorenzo Lotto (1480-1554): Portrait of a Man
The Henry Doetsch Collection
7
37. Lorenzo Lotto (1480-1554): The Virgin with Saints
43. Jacopo Tintoretto (1513-1594) Portrait of a Agostino Barbarigo
The Henry Doetsch Collection
8
48. Licinio da Pordenone Portrait of a Venetian Nobleman Now attributed to Giorgione and Titian.
60. Giovanni Cariani The Adoration of the Shepherds
62. Savoldo (1480-1548) Portrait of a Nobleman
The Henry Doetsch Collection
9
63. Gian Battiste Moroni: Man and Boy
Lot 84. Giovanni Battista Zelotti (1532-1592): Portrait of Antonio Barbaro
The Henry Doetsch Collection
10
86. Bernardino de'Conti (Painted between 1497 and 1522) Portrait of John of Bourgogne
The Henry Doetsch Collection
11
88. Marco d'Oggiono (1470-1540)
The Holy Children Embracing A similar picture, with a different background, is at Hampton Court Palace. Both are by the same hand and appear to be the reproductions of some drawing by Leonardo da Vinci, to whom both these pictures have also been ascribed. The picture at Hampton Court, No 391, is decidedly an inferior painting. This painting was formerly in the collection of the Marquess of Exeter in Burghley House
The Henry Doetsch Collection
The "decidely inferior work" by Marco d'Oggiono in Hampton Court Palace (#391)
89. Giovanni Pedrini: Leda and the Swan Formerly ascribed to Leonardo da Vinci. A similar picture, which is a copy after Sodoma (see Giovanni Morelli pp. 192-196) is in the Borghese Gallery, Rome. The original cartoon appears to have been at Milan, where Pedrini may have seen it and used it for his own composition. Panel: 52Âź in. by 41Âź in. From the Collection of the Marquis of Hastings.
12
The Henry Doetsch Collection
13
90. Bernardino Luini: The Virgin and Child and the Infant St. John This composition has been repeated by Bernardino in a picture at Langton, Berwick Panel: 21ž in. by 15ž in.
93. Tanzio di Varello (1474-1544) St. John the Baptist
The Henry Doetsch Collection
14
99. Rafaelino del Garbo (1466-1524): The Virgin with the Infant Christ
100. Rafaelino del Garbo (1466-1524): Cleopatra
107. An Altar-Piece by Jacopo da Pontormo (1494-1557)
The Henry Doetsch Collection
108. DOMENICO PULIGO (1475-1527): Virgin and Child, with St. Joseph and the Infant St. John. Besides the galleries of Florence and Rome, where there are several pictures by this artist which are properly named, there are few to be met with which are misnamed Andrea del Sarto. He had been influenced by him to some extent. This is a very characteristic work of this artist. Panel: 37¾ in. by 29¾ in. From the Collection of the Marquis of Hastings.
109. FRANCESCO UBERTINI called BACCHIACCA (1494-1557) Virgin and Child, with the Infant St. John ; in the background the view of a village. The group of the Virgin and Child is very much like Raphael's picture in the Naples Museum, known as "Il Divino Amore". The buildings in the background of the picture are copied from Dürer's engraving "The Prodigal Son". Panel: 24½ in. by 19½ in.
15
The Henry Doetsch Collection
16
111. BACCHIACCA (1494-1557): Portrait of a Florentine Lady
120. Alessandro Allori Bronzino: Portrait of a Medici Princess
The Henry Doetsch Collection
17
121. Federigo Zucchero: Portrait of his Son, Taddeo
124. Ludovico Cardi: Adoration of the Magi
The Henry Doetsch Collection
18
130. Carlo Dolci: An Ecce Homo
135. Raphael: Portrait of Andrea Navagero
140. Scipiono Gaetano: Portrait Group of a High Papal official and Secretary
The Henry Doetsch Collection
19
143. Luca Cambioso: Virgin and Child (in repair)
144. Benvenuto di Giovanni of Siena: Virgin and Child
The Henry Doetsch Collection
20
150. Venetian School: Portrait of Madonna Laura
Lot 157. Angelo Bronzino: Portrait of Ludomia de Medici
The Henry Doetsch Collection
21
Flemish Paintings
167. Flemish School Portrait of King Henry VII
169. Flemish School Portrait of Earl of Lennox
The Henry Doetsch Collection
22
184. School of Clouet Portrait of Francis 1st
190. Mabuse Portrait of an Englishman
The Henry Doetsch Collection
23
203. Peter Lely: Portrait of a Lady
204. Gainsborough: Portrait of a Lady
The Henry Doetsch Collection
24
207. Franรงois Clouet: Portrait of King Francis (of France)
211. Franรงois Clouet: Portrait of a Lady
222. H van Blarenberghe: A Landscape in Winter
The Henry Doetsch Collection
25
225. German School: Adoration of the Infant Christ
228. Christopher Amberger Portrait of a Man
The Henry Doetsch Collection
26
229. Bartel Beham: Portrait of Emperor Ferdinand (of Germany)
232. Jan Vermeyen: The Battle of Pavia
The Henry Doetsch Collection
27
233. Albrecht Dürer: The Triumphal Procession of Emperor Maximilian
236. Lucas Kranach the Elder: Virgin and Child
The Henry Doetsch Collection
28
238. Lucas Kranach the Younger: Portrait of Elisabeth Krelerin
241. Unknown German painter: Portrait of Barbara Kressin
The Henry Doetsch Collection
29
243. Hans Holbein: Portrait of Henry 8th
273. Bernard van Orley: A Triptych
273. Bernard van Orley: Holy Family
The Henry Doetsch Collection
30
280. Martin Heemskirk: The Virgin and Child, with the infant St. John and two angel boys
282. Gillip van Coninxlo: Landscape with Figures
The Henry Doetsch Collection
31
287. Jan Breughel: A Seaport
309. Frans Pourbus the Elder: Portrait of a Lady
311. Frans Pourbus: Portrait of a French Princess
The Henry Doetsch Collection
32
312. Frans Pourbus the Younger: Portrait of Henry 4th of France
The Henry Doetsch Collection
33
Lot 339. Portrait of a Gentleman with a 'Pink': Dirck Jacobszoon In the twentieth century, it was discovered that the coat of arms hanging from the tree in the top right corner of the painting was that of the Amsterdam banker, Pompejus Occo, and that Occo had commissioned the painting from Dirck Jacobszoon, so the painting has been re-ascribed. It it is now in the National Netherlands collection - on loan to the Amsterdam Museum from the Rijksmuseum. In 1895 this painting fetched 150 guineas (ÂŁ157 10s 0d) at the auction
The Henry Doetsch Collection
34
345. Joachim Wtewael: Diana and ActĂŚon
351. Joost Drooch Sloot: A Village near a River
368. Casper Netscher: Portrait of King James 2nd when Duke of York
The Henry Doetsch Collection
35
372. Frans Hals: Portrait of a Gentleman
374. Jan Wynants: A Hilly Landscape
376. Jan Miens Molenaer: A Youth Singing and Playing the Guitar
The Henry Doetsch Collection
36
377. Jan Miens Molenaer: Portrait of a Cavalier
379. Jan Miens Molenaer: A Family Group
380. J. van Velsen: "Le Musicien Espagnol"
The Henry Doetsch Collection
37
385. Pieter Wouwerman: The Start of the Hunting Party
390. Pieter Wouwerman: A Lady on Horseback
395. Nicoleas Elias (Pickenoy): Portrait of a Lady
The Henry Doetsch Collection
38
396. Hendrick Dubbels: Fishing Boats off the Coast
406. Govert Flinck: Portrait of a Girl
412. Paulus Potter: The Milkmaid Washing her Milk Pail
The Henry Doetsch Collection
39
421. Meindert Hobbema: A Landscape (no Windmill!)
422. Meindert Hobbema: Landscape with a Windmill
432. Dominicus van Tol: A Violin Player
The Henry Doetsch Collection
40
436. Willem van Mieris: An Officer at the Window
443. Hendrick Avercamp: A Winter Scene
444. Johan van Rossum: Portrait of a Young Dutch Gentleman
The Henry Doetsch Collection
41
445. Jan Olis: A Family Group of Five Figures
448. Jan Dubbels: A Frozen River