NON-PROFIT ORG
Palo Alto Unified School District Henry M. Gunn High School 780 Arastradero Rd Palo Alto, CA 94306
Students, teachers share artwork on online platforms.
U.S. Postage
PA I D
Permit #44 Palo Alto, Calif.
THEORACLE
PG. 9 FEATURES
Henry M. Gunn High School
http://gunnoracle.com/
Friday, March 30, 2018
Volume 55, Issue 7
780 Arastradero Road, Palo Alto, CA 94306
s
t' c a r e t n I CSY s l e c n ca District
Mi na K im
ys a d ty n e w t ure p t i r r t a p e e d c i e r o serv f e b Kaya van der Horst Forum Editor
On the morning of March 14, a group of students woke up to find an email in their inbox stating that the highly anticipated spring break service trip to Tijuana, Mexico had been cancelled. The Youth Community Service-Interact (YCS-I) trip was scheduled to bring 19 students and three staff members to Tijuana for spring break from April 1 to 8. In the email sent by YCS-I advisor David Deggeller, he expressed his disappointment and frustration with the school board’s sudden decision to pull their support during a board meeting on March 13—20 days before the departure date. Although the board had previously voiced their approval back in January, they ultimately voted against the trip due to safety concerns, citing an uptick in violence, according to Deggeller’s email. The U.S. Department of State, however, has not changed their travel advisory assessment for Tijuana since the beginning of the year: out of four levels, Tijuana remains at a risk factor of two, indicating travelers to “exercise increased caution.” For reference, France, Germany and Denmark also have travel advisory levels of two due to terrorism. According to Deggeller, he received an email from Assistant Superintendent Yolanda Conaway on Jan. 16, with approval to proceed with the trip. After this confirmation, Deggeller could use funds from the Student
Activities Office to purchase plane tickets and make a deposit to the organization through which the trip is organized, Esperanza International. “When I was told the assistant superintendent approved my trip, I took it as a formal okay, and at that point I was allowed to use funds,” he said. Deggeller added that the trip was approved with a stipulation: if the travel advisory increased between January and April, the trip would be cancelled. The cautious sentiments of the Board were again echoed in late February when they contacted Deggeller about insurance concerns. “They were concerned whether district insurance was going to cover the trip because of liability issues, but they emailed me back a few days later on March 2, saying it was okay and that they had figured it out,” he said. During a board meeting on March 13, however, Interim Superintendent Karen Hendricks—who did not respond to The Oracle despite repeated inquiries—voiced safety concerns about the trip and ultimately pulled her support. The board agreed with her recommendation and voted in favor of not approving the trip. Board member Melissa Caswell, who is not speaking on behalf of the entire board, understands the importance of the trip for students. “I feel terrible—this is a wonderful trip; I know people had a wonderful experience in the past, and they have felt very safe,” she said. Still, Caswell stresses the importance of student safety as
her main priority. According to Caswell, the superintendent brought the recommendation to the board to vote on. “When the superintendent believes there is a safety risk, it puts me in a position where if anything were to happen and the superintendent had been concerned about safety, I could never forgive myself,” she said. “In the end, if the superintendent isn’t willing to support the safety of the trip that means a board member can’t support it.” Deggeller, who has organized 16 international trips, says the district’s procedure of approval was very sluggish in comparison to previous years. “What typically happens is after all the paperwork is filed and the superintendent approves the trip, it automatically goes to the board at the next meeting and gets rubber-stamped,” he said. “So the two-month’s lag and the fact that the district took their concerns to the board so late was very surprising for me.” According to Deggeller, the two-month gap between the approval and rejection is the most frustrating part of the situation. While he accepts the board’s decision and believes their safety concerns are valid, Deggeller was upset about the proximity to the departure date. “The families and I would have appreciated this news back in January, when we were told the superintendent was going to approve our trip,” he said. “If the board was going to TIJUANA—p.4
Students ask for more Advanced Placement social studies classes Elisa Moraes Liu and Kristen Yee Reporter and Forum Editor
A group of students, led by school board representative senior Advait Arun, have been campaigning since February for an increased number of advanced humanities classes, specifically the implementation of more social studies electives. They currently have multiple goals, one of which has made significant progress. Advanced Placement (AP) Human Geography has been proposed to the Palo Alto Unified School District (PAUSD) Board of Education, and the campaigning students are currently working to ensure the social studies department follows through in offering the course. The other goals include adding AP Comparative Government for the 2019-2020 school year, making sure students sign up for the additional courses, ensuring that PAUSD commits to review-
ing social studies curriculum through a written resolution and pushing for any additional courses students express interest in on a survey they plan on sending out. The students first voiced their discontent at a school board meeting on Feb. 13. After the meeting, they reached out to both Principal Kathie Laurence and PAUSD Chief Academic Officer for Secondary Education Sharon Ofek. The group is also currently speaking with Social Studies Department Instructional Supervisor Lynne Navarro to gain her insight and work with her in understanding the process of creating new courses. The students came up with the idea to campaign for these classes during Model United Nations (MUN) meetings. “We all started ranting about how there weren’t enough humanities classes,” sophomore Claire Cheng said. “Our first idea was we should take this to the board, and after the board, we got more
and more involved and we realized that it wasn’t so simple.” Arun decided to take charge and has been leading the initiative. “He’s the student board [representative] and he knows a lot of ins and outs of how the school administration works,” Cheng said. “He was kind of the person who was like, ‘We should do something about it.’” The students highlight the imbalance in advanced social studies classes when compared to other subject areas as the main problem. “I think there’s a clear discrepancy between what’s offered for science, technology, engineering and math (STEM) and what’s offered for humanities at an honors lane and show [to colleges] you are more passionate in STEM,” junior Ani Banerjee said in a meeting with Laurence on March 13, which The Oracle was invited to attend. These students SOCIAL STUDIES—p.3