The friendship of Travis and Sanchez.
NON-PROFIT ORG
Palo Alto Unified School District Henry M. Gunn High School 780 Arastradero Rd Palo Alto, CA 94306
U.S. Postage
PA I D
Permit #44 Palo Alto, Calif.
PG. 7 FEATURES
THEORACLE Henry M. Gunn High School
http://gunnoracle.com/
Friday, March 29, 2019 Volume 56, Issue 7
780 Arastradero Road, Palo Alto, CA 94306
Gunn Confessions online page serves as outlet for student struggles Grace Williams Changing the Narrative Editor
Mina Kim
Stanford housing expansion proposal to increase PAUSD student enrollment without new funding Vinay Ranganathan and Joshua Yang Reporter and Forum Editor In light of the plans submitted by Stanford University to expand housing units and campus facilities, the Palo Alto Unified School District (PAUSD) is set to face a sharp increase in student enrollment without any expectation of increased funding from housing tax revenue. According to the General Use Permit (GUP) application submitted in 2018 to the Santa Clara Board of Supervisors detailing Stanford’s expansion plans, the university would add 2.275 million square feet of housing and facilities to the existing campus by 2035. With this expansion would come 2,172 new staff and faculty housing units serving as homes for hundreds of families with school-age children attending PAUSD. However, as Stanford’s proposed housing units would be considered educational facilities, they would be exempt from all property taxes, the main source of funding for PAUSD. PAUSD administration and representatives from the Santa Clara Board of Supervisors are currently working to provide a mitigation plan for the expansion, opening negotiations to find a source of funding for the added students. Without a mitigation plan, all students would be affected, according to PAUSD Superintendent Dr. Donald Austin. “Without mitigation, we would have more students without increasing funding,” he said. “Without an increase in funding, we would be challenged to maintain our class size ratios, number of programs [we offer] and depth of [such] programs.” PAUSD Board Member Todd Collins agreed, also citing class size as a factor likely affected. “If one extra kid comes to Gunn, we don’t change the number of people we hired; nothing else changes,” he said. “But if you add 500 kids, then a lot of things have to change, because if the schools are full you’re going to eventually have to build a new school for them, you’re going to have to hire new teachers for their classes and you’re going to have to have additional administrators to manage all that. Ultimately, you’re going to have to expand your
district office staff, so you’re going to have everything scaling up.” Indeed, Stanford’s GUP plan currently already entails the construction of a new PAUSD campus. According to an online page published by the district, an estimated influx of 275 new students living along the Sand Hill Road corridor would warrant the construction of a new elementary school closer to the homes of these added students. Austin has put forth a resolution attempting to address the funding issues, especially those posed by the creation of a new school, which he estimated would cost $40 million. “There are three pieces to our resolution,” he said. “Number one is we’d like to preserve our community schools. [Stanford’s] proposed location has no existing school near it yet, so we’d like a piece of land from Stanford [to build the elementary school]. Number two, we would like some money towards the creation of [this] school. Third, we would like some money going with the students that are generated through the General Use Permit.” Both Austin and Collins strongly advocated for varying annual sums to be paid to PAUSD instead of a one-time lump sum, with the amount paid each year calculated based on the annual number of students entering PAUSD from Stanford’s housing units. “We really want this flexible funding formula that accommodates the range of outcomes that could happen and sustains [PAUSD] over time so that kids will benefit now and in the future,” Collins said. Collins estimated an annual cost of $5.3 million to PAUSD as a result of the expansion, but cautioned against expecting a set number of students. “I’d say [estimating 275 new students] is now in the ditch,” he said. “I don’t think anybody can credibly say it’ll generate as few as 275.” The reason behind the lack of a stable estimate is due to ever-changing negotiation conditions. Earlier this month, the Board strongly advised that Stanford quadruple the current number of proposed housing units in their GUP. Stanford—p.3
The Gunn Confessions Facebook page became the latest sensation to hit the Gunn community last month, prompting not only widespread attention but also controversy. With 808 followers, 643 likes, and 4,491 confessions (and counting), the page has ignited discussion over the benefits and drawbacks of such social media usage. The page’s administrators collect anonymous “confessions”—which consist of secrets, questions and unpopular opinions—and post these confessions on the page for all to see. Because the page could easily become a toxic forum for students to hurt others without consequence, potentially hurtful posts are filtered out. “Inevitably, posts slip through sometimes, and when that happens we do our best to remove them as soon as someone messages the page about it or if mean comments start to appear,” one of the page’s anonymous administrators said. The list of banned content on the Google Form for submitting confessions includes hate speech, cyberbullying and negative accusations. Though the page was created for Gunn students and serves as an outlet for students to share their struggles, parents and administrators, including Principal Kathleen Laurence, have also noticed the page and expressed concerns about the consequences of the page. “I want to support students but the confessions are anonymous so we can’t help [those students] and that is what I am most concerned about,” Laurence said. Similarly, Gunn parent Stacey Ashlund stated her apprehension over students’ mental health upon discovering the confessions page. “The stigma of mental health cannot be fixed overnight but students are hopefully seeking help when coming across certain posts,” she said. Ashlund also hopes there is an area of the Facebook page that lists mental health resources available to students when necessary; this list is now pinned at the top of the page, including the Crisis Text Line and the Suicide Prevention Hotline. Some, however, have had negative experiences with the page. For example, problems arose for chemistry teacher Casey O’Connell when misleading claims were given a platform to be published. “[A post] said I had psychoanalyzed [a student] by diagnosing them with depression and saying that is why they did not complete their homework,” O’Connell said. According to O’Connell, the confession was inaccurate. O’Connell messaged the Facebook page saying, “I never psychoanalyzed a student because I am not a legal psychiatrist and [am] unable to make that diagnosis.” O’Connell requested the post be taken down, and the page administrators obliged. Despite this incident, O’Connell believes the page could be beneficial to the Gunn community. “I think a well-moderated anonymous group like Gunn Confessions should exist at every high school,” O’Connell said. Assistant Principal Harvey Newland echoed O’Connell’s thoughts. “If [the page] stays lighthearted, it is okay,” he said. Some of the posts discuss heavier topics such as mental health or sexual assault, and students have rallied around these submissions and offered positive and uplifting messages in the comment section of these posts. As of now, no student has come forward to Gunn administrators stating they have a problem with the Facebook page. In addition, the Gunn Confessions Facebook page administrators have no intention of taking down the group.