The Oracle September 2019

Page 1

Students speak about mental wellness

NON-PROFIT ORG

Palo Alto Unified School District Henry M. Gunn High School 780 Arastradero Rd Palo Alto, CA 94306

U.S. Postage

PA I D

Permit #44 Palo Alto, Calif.

PG. 6 FEATURES

THEORACLE Henry M. Gunn High School

http://gunnoracle.com/

Friday, September 13, 2019

Volume 57, Issue 1

780 Arastradero Road, Palo Alto, CA 94306

Proposed Ethnic Studies graduation requirement inspires conversation, debate Annika Bereny Centerfold Editor On August 22, the bill to make Ethnic Studies a graduation requirement was delayed in the state leg islat ure. Citing the

Annika Bereny Centerfold Editor

huge controversy around the bill, its author, California dialogue among all of the interested parties around it, Sate assembly member Jose Medina, has opted to put it not a debate,” she said. “And, the difference between the on the “two year plan,” postponing the vote on the bill two is that, in a debate, there's a winner and a loser, but without killing it. in dialogue, you're seeking to understand.” The bill had been involved in a whirlwind of controSchool Board Representative senior Claire Cheng versy with many different ethnic groups, some protest- also strongly opposes an Ethnic Studies graduation ing the fact that it does not cover the plights of their requirement, and all other graduation requirements the minority group more inclusively and in-depth. Pro- district may try to impose. “Anytime we add a graduaIsrael groups, for example, claim that the plan shows tion requirement, we are taking away the freedom for the Israel-Palestine conflict in a one-sided manner. students to choose to explore what they are passionate Other critics are upset at the bill’s seemingly left-leaning about,” Cheng said. “The [government] is making the nature, with terms like “Hxrstory” and “Cisheteropa- unilateral assumption that the subject will benefit all triarchy” in the curriculum glossary. students more than another class students chose for Medina, the assembly member representing themselves will. I don’t think the` [school district] knows Riverside who authored the bill, released a us better than we know ourselves.” statement on his decision to delay the bill. The course would most likely come as a semester“It is not a question of whether the subject long course in senior year, probably at the expense of itself is necessary, but rather, how do we the psychology classes. “From a logistical scheduling ensure the curriculum is comprehensive, standpoint, it adds to the complexity, and it would make rigorous and inclusive enough?” he wrote. that part of my job harder,” Patrick said. “But, from the “This underscores the importance of ta k ing t he t ime "I think the biggest thing that has to happen is there has to be a good necessar y to en- dialogue among all of the interested parties around it, not a debate." sure we get the cur-Principal Kathleen Laurence ricul u m right.” social studies teacher standpoint, it’s really important O n e i n f i v e C a l i f o r n i a for kids to have experience with this.” schools offer Ethnic Studies Ethnic Studies wouldn’t immediately be a mandatory as a class. At Gunn, the course class, though. There would be a timeline for Gunn to has been offered for a long have the course up and running. “They would also tell time, yet has not run for 12-15 us by when we would have to have it in our schools as a years due to lack of student inter- graduation requirement,” said Laurence. “A lot of times, est. According to the Gunn course what they’ll do is they’ll pass the bill and say it’s for the catalogue, Ethnic Studies operates graduating class four years later.” from the consideration of profound This requirement would also need more teachers impact that race and racism have and continue for Ethnic Studies. “We'd need a staffing increase for to have on culture and society. Ethnic Studies aims to it, which is one of those interesting things about state focus on themes of social justice, social change and mandates, ” said Patrick, “The state can require this, but social responsibility, using California as a microcosm they don't provide any additional funding, so you have of the country. It raises the essential question—what is to hire teachers to teach that course.” Due to the bill’s the role of racism in the American experience? delay, the issue of finding teachers has been postponed. Social Studies Department Instructional Lead Jeff “Like a lot of things that are done at the state level, we Patrick says that, with the lack of students taking Eth- just kind of take a wait-and-see attitude,” said Patrick. nic Studies, the curriculum has been spread throughWhile the bill is currently at a standstill, it will cerout many other classes. The most notable example is tainly be back in the future, and for students passionate Contemporary World History, which sophomores take about the issue, Cheng advises they attend a board meetfor one semester. “If we knew that subjects were being ing. “An opportunity I find very important that not a lot covered in other classes, then that allows us to focus of students know about is open forums.” At open forums, on the first couple things that we had to drop from the held at the beginning of school board meetings, anyone curriculum,” Patrick said, “It would also bring in some in the district—students, teachers and other community other topics that we haven’t covered in the past.” members—is welcome to give a speech for two or three Principal Kathleen Laurence urges interested stu- minutes on an issue they feel strongly about that isn't dents to sign up for the class. “I think that it's good for placed on the agenda. “Student voice matters,” Cheng students to have some flexibility to be able to try things said. “If you are persistent about the change you want that they may not have known about,” Laurence said. to see, have support from a large group of students and “I encourage students to take it. It makes me sad that have good rationale behind your opinion. The board will it doesn’t run because we have a lot of really cool social take it seriously.” studies classes that students don’t choose to take.” Addressing the bill as a whole, she stresses the importance of civility for Ethnic Studies debates. “I think the biggest thing that has to happen is there has to be a good


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.
The Oracle September 2019 by The Oracle - Issuu