ISSUE
6
Purpose Big Thinking on Why Purpose Pays
PUR POSE S Y PA
Purpose
Purpose Mike Hall always said that “everything should start with a clear end in mind”. Without this, he argued, it’s easy to lose yourself and others. In my view, this is what having a clear purpose is all about. It’s about knowing why you exist and what it is you do to create value in the world. Every organisation is dealing with enormous change. Industries are being overhauled as digital transformation takes hold. In a time of continuous upheaval, the certainty of a clear, guiding purpose and set of principles helps keep organisations focused on what matters. What is exciting, is how digital allows us all to take a wider and a higher-order look at what an organisation actually does and how it can contribute more broadly, beyond the products and services it provides. Kraft’s ‘Everyday Delicious’ initiative delivers beyond the food itself to include recipes, books and digital services through publishing and online content. It’s also a call to action to do something more significant for the wellbeing of others. Like every brand, purpose needs to be true to the organisation and to the value it creates. It should make sense of everything the organisation does, the talent it needs and the behaviours it encourages. Purpose is not a desire to do good in the world. This is CSR activity, which often gets confused with the intent involved in having a closely defined purpose. I think if every organisation was more precise about its role in the world, and made this clear to employees and customers, it would be easier to create strong, profitable and engaging brands. Conflict comes when intent and clarity are missing. Purpose Pays is a collection of views on purpose, the word that seems to be on everyone’s lips and every board agenda. There are many different interpretations. However, the growing need to define purpose more clearly can only be good.
Vanella Jackson Global CEO vanella.jackson@hallandpartners.com
4
PURPOSE PAYS » BIG THINKING ON WHY PURPOSE PAYS
E S O P R PU
S Y PA 5
Highlights » 10
20 Dominik Prinz says jumping on the purpose bandwagon shouldn’t be motivated solely by the bottom line
Paul Rees-Jones says people want something to believe in
50 Monica Skipper and Neil Gibson reveal how FedEx lives and breathes its purpose in everything they do
54
Simon McEvoy tells us why purpose is meaningless if it doesn’t engage your consumers or employees
6
PURPOSE PAYS » BIG THINKING ON WHY PURPOSE PAYS
60 Tim Lindsay urges agencies to further the importance of purposeful thinking
Contents »
The emotionally driven profit of purpose
10
Paul Rees-Jones
Why purpose pays
14
Andy Milligan
The purpose of purpose
20
Dominik Prinz
Want to make money? Listen to Pharrell
28
34 38
Harlan Kennedy
On purpose Monica Skipper and Neil Gibson
Simon McEvoy
Why ad agencies need to drive the conversation on sustainability
60
The selfish corporation’s guide to saving the planet
68
Benny Thomas
Fiona Le Brocq
(Re)finding your purpose
54
Tim Lindsay
Elie Khouri
Why purpose?
How shared value turns brand purpose into measurable actions
50
A note from the Millennials
74
Mads Lindegaard
Being fully engaged with an organisation’s purpose is essential for boards
80
Louise McCann
7
Contributors »
Andy Milligan is a founder of
Benny Thomas leads
The Caffeine Partnership which
strategy and a team
works with leaders to deliver brand-led growth.
of COGs (Cultural Anthropologists) for Crispin Porter + Bogusky, having previously served as a global lead planner at TBWA\Chiat\Day and Y&R.
Dominik Prinz is Interbrand’s
Elie Khouri heads the
Head of Strategy in New York
Middle East and North
and San Francisco and is
Africa operations of
passionate about connecting an organisation’s business, brand and purpose.
communication agencies OMD, PHD, Resolution and several specialist units.
Fiona Le Brocq was most
Harlan Kennedy spent
recently Director of Marketing
over 17 years as an
at SEEK Limited and, prior to
account planner on
that, Head of Brand at National
the agency side before
Australia Bank. She also spent 15 years in
founding VBP Orange in 2011. He
advertising working for M&C Saatchi, Spinach,
delights in inspiring clients to develop
JWT and DDB.
organisational empathy.
8
PURPOSE PAYS » BIG THINKING ON WHY PURPOSE PAYS
Louise McCann is a non-
Mads Lindegaard is an Account
executive director with a
Manager at Hall & Partners and
diverse portfolio including technology, media, health, education, accounting and professional
a Millennial with experience of working with purpose-driven marketing in research.
services.
Monica Skipper, a native
Neil Gibson is Vice President
New Orleanian, enjoys
of Corporate Communications
sharing her passion for branding around the world.
for FedEx Services, providing strategic direction for the
As the Vice President of Brand Experience
development and execution of many of the
Marketing she leads the Advertising, Brand
company’s communication strategies.
and Sponsorship teams at FedEx.
Paul Rees-Jones has led
Simon McEvoy is a strategist
Clemenger BBDO Melbourne’s
with over a decade of experience
planning since 2007. He’s
helping blue chip organisations
helped guide the agency to
grow their business. He now runs
being the most awarded agency for creativity
Three Point Zero, which uses ‘Shared Value’
in Australia, and effectiveness across the
methodology to help businesses grow by
APAC region.
tackling social problems.
Tim Lindsay is former Chairman of Publicis UK and, since September 2011, CEO of D&AD, the advertising and design awards and creative education charity. He’s also Non-Executive Chairman of advertising agency network The Gate Worldwide.
9
The
emotionally of
Paul Rees-Jones says people want something to believe in A few years ago I came across Daniel
Happiness seems to be an increasingly
Gilbert’s great book Stumbling
important emotion in a world where
on Happiness. It was in fact a
reaching any level of satisfaction,
recommendation from an unlikely
in whatever we do, feels more
source, my not-especially-happy
challenging. Whether it’s in our
accountant, but one that’s proven
personal or especially our working
to be of great value when working
lives, there never seems to be enough
with Clemenger BBDO clients as
time, resources or attention given to
they navigate the challenges of an
things that truly matter.
emerging century of ever-present change and uncertainty.
10
PURPOSE PAYS » BIG THINKING ON WHY PURPOSE PAYS
driven
purpose
Gilbert, a Harvard psychologist,
The imagination is something that’s
focused his work around a fascinating
anything but tied down by what we
premise: that human beings are the
know. Rather, it has the ability to draw
only animals that have the ability to
on the subconscious to come up with
think about the future. He explains
something completely original. It’s
that, thanks to the uniqueness of
about what could be, or even should
the human brain, we’re fortunate
be, in this values-driven era where
enough to possess a frontal lobe,
accountability has never been more
something that allows us to learn from
pronounced. Do the right thing, and
experiences we’ve never had, opening
the upside can be felt immediately.
up the concept of imagination. This is
Do the wrong thing, and the impact
interesting, especially as we try to get
can be so quickly damning. This is
to grips with such evolving times, and
something in-touch business leaders
the preparedness of so many to retreat
intuitively understand, and where
to the supposed safety of rational and
organisational purpose has come into
expected solutions that only go on to
a life of its own in recent times.
underwhelm.
11
People want something to believe in that helps make sense of things
It was probably almost a decade ago
before ‘how’ or ‘what’. The simple but
that Nikos Mourkogiannis published
effective premise is that the motivation
Purpose – The Starting Point of
for doing the company’s work isn’t
Great Companies. It was one of
about what you do or how you do it;
those business bibles that literally
it’s about why you do it.
appeared overnight, taking pride of place, in plain view, on so many desks. It certainly did in Australia and signalled a leadership ideal founded on a commitment to be authentic and true to company foundations. It became the mantra du jour that was reignited when Simon Sinek took to the TED stage and showcased the oftcited ‘Golden Circle’, and how great leaders inspire action by asking ‘why’,
12
PURPOSE PAYS » BIG THINKING ON WHY PURPOSE PAYS
So why has the ‘why’ taken such
After all, we should understand our
hold?
future selves well enough to shape our
Working closely with culturally focused clients, I’ve come to see there’s a very real idealism alive and well in
lives more positively, and that goes for the people we affect with what we make, sell and serve.
so many corporate cultures. It feels
And this is probably the most
like a new-found enthusiasm and
fascinating thing of all about
sense of possibility. At the heart of it
a galvanizing, purpose-driven
is the observation that people want
organisation; that when you get the
something to believe in that helps
money out of the way and and start
make sense of things; something that
being true to who you are, as in life
we want to be true because that’s the
you’re more likely to reap the rewards.
way it should be. It’s the return of a
Because people are emotional wired,
decency – an old-fashioned concept
and that’s something more companies
maybe, but it is in fact remarkably
need to feel in what they do.
modern in its ability to make people feel connected to something of worth, and the future contribution of the work being done.
Paul Rees-Jones Executive Planning Director Clemenger BBDO www.clemengerbbdo.com.au
13
14
PURPOSE PAYS » BIG THINKING ON WHY PURPOSE PAYS
Does organisational purpose actually matter to people? Andy Milligan explains why it’s important
“We’re guided by a vision to create a better everyday life for the many people. That is what steers us, motivates us – that is our role… We feel almost obliged to grow.”
PURPOSE MATTERS TO CONSUMERS More and more, people want to buy brands which not only deliver them value personally but also address the wider societal challenges we all
IKEA Group CEO Peter Agnefjäll thus
face. Michael Porter identified this
set out the interconnected relationship
development in customer motivation;
between purpose and profitable
it led him to establish the ‘Shared
growth. If you have a purpose you’re
Value Initiative’. “The purpose of the
compelled to grow to fulfil it. In fact,
corporation”, he writes, “must be
showing you have an authentic and
redefined as creating shared value,
credible sense of purpose – a reason
not just profit per se. This will drive
‘why’ you exist beyond the desire to
the next wave of innovation and
make profit – drives commercial value
productivity growth in the global
in an increasingly competitive world.
economy.”
15
The purpose of the corporation must be redefined as
CRE AT ING
SHARED
VA LUE
The global public relations business,
They concluded that with the limitless
Edelman, conducts an annual survey
options open to consumers they, “are
called the ‘Global Trust Barometer’.
choosing to engage only with content
They look at the importance that
that is personally relevant to them,
people say they ascribe to factors such
their purpose and their passions”.
as ‘the values of an organisation’. The
They summed up their research by
2015 survey found that four in five
saying, “their [the consumers’] path
respondents wanted to see companies
to purchase is actually their path to
pursue a higher purpose, not just
purpose”.
profit.
16
That the search for purpose is
Google recently partnered with
becoming a vital factor in the
agencies TNS and Ogilvy to research
consumer’s choice is shown by Havas
how digital platforms and social
Media’s annual survey into ‘Meaningful
media have changed the relationship
Brands’. CEO Paul Frampton
between advertisers and consumers.
introduced the 2013 report by saying,
PURPOSE PAYS » BIG THINKING ON WHY PURPOSE PAYS
Meaningful Brand Index
STOXX 1800 x 120%
FTSE4 Good Index x 175%
“In our survey of 134,000 consumers
and the most consistently profitable
across 23 countries we found real
airline in the world (42 years and
people crying out for brands to have a
counting!), places the recruitment of
purpose, and live that purpose in what
people who share its culture at the
they do”. The report also found that
heart of its business philosophy. As
the meaningful brands outperformed
Herb Kelleher, its CEO and Chairman
the market by 120%. So focusing on
for most of those 42 years, said, “The
purpose makes you more profitable.
business of business is people”. True
PURPOSE MATTERS TO EMPLOYEES
differentiation, he argued, could only come from culture because everything
Employees are, similarly, looking to
else was replicable; as he pointed out
work for companies with which they
in a speech in 2008, “All airlines have
can share a common sense of purpose
planes”.
and derive dignity from their daily work, not just a salary. Southwest Airlines, the largest low-cost carrier
All the companies we feature in our book, On Purpose, have followed the
17
Southwest Airlines’ route to success,
company succeed’. Doing the right
be they new brands like Citizen M
thing for the customer is a universal
or Sugro, long-established brands
motivator.
such as Lego or Ikea, or business-tobusiness brands like Liberty Global or Altro.
Now, of course there’s a danger in reporting compelling statistics such as these. As we saw with the rush to
The business benefits of engaged
CSR some years ago, the short-sighted
employees are highlighted in a study
CEO, motivated by the potential to
by the Temkin Group. Looking across
generate positive PR or profit, will
a number of different industries in the
conclude that, ‘we need a purpose
US, they discovered that employees
statement’ and delegate some poor
who were ‘engaged’ (people who
minion to create one; or, perhaps
understood and shared a sense of
even worse, they’ll ask their ad agency
common purpose with the business
to craft some fine words. To do so
and felt empowered to deliver that
misses the point entirely. It’s about
purpose) were more productive, more
the ‘doing’, not the ‘having’. Or, to
loyal, and delivered greater customer
put it another way, purpose only pays
satisfaction than those who were not.
when you act on purpose.
A staggering 99% of employees who worked for businesses that delivered
Andy Milligan
excellent customer experiences agreed
Founder The Caffeine Partnership www.thecaffeinepartnership.com
they were ‘committed to helping their
18
PURPOSE PAYS » BIG THINKING ON WHY PURPOSE PAYS
THE BU SINES S OF BU SINES S IS PEOPLE 19
20
PURPOSE PAYS » BIG THINKING ON WHY PURPOSE PAYS
Dominik Prinz thinks jumping on the purpose bandwagon shouldn’t be motivated solely by the bottom line
Contrary to the popular belief that
But instead of the bourgeoisie, it’s
it was Spider-Man, it’s generally
now businesses that need to reassess
accepted that Voltaire coined the
their critical role in society. A new and
phrase, “With great power comes great
enlightened generation of consumers
responsibility”.
and employees demands them to take
Why did he carefully select these nowfamous words? Because he was deeply
a stand on issues that are crucial in helping society to progress.
disturbed by the abuse of authority
This growing generation is now
and privilege by those in power, while
increasingly rewarding truly purpose-
a large part of France’s population
driven brands: by choosing them over
lived in poverty.
their (less purpose-oriented) peers, by
About 200 years later this statement still stands – especially in a time of economic uncertainty, political turmoil and social unrest.
paying a premium for their products and services, or simply by coming back as loyal customers, over and over again.
21
By now, most businesses are beginning to understand this financial upside of being purpose-driven. And herein lie both the opportunity and the dilemma. Let’s start with the opportunity, since it’s compellingly clear that the economic benefits to operating as a purpose-driven business are manifold:
A PURPOSE-DRIVEN BUSINESS DRIVES CHOICE...
WITH EMPLOYEES
WITH CUSTOMERS
Attracts strong talent and
Attracts an increasing
lowers recruiting cost
number of customers who make purpose part of their purchase decision
CREATES PREMIUM...
ENGENDERS LOYALTY...
22
Can allow for lower base
Can allow to charge higher
salaries since purpose
prices since purpose
serves as an additional
serves as an additional
non-monetary incentive
emotional benefit
Fosters retention and, as
Fosters repeat purchase,
a result, lowers cost of
recommendation and
training new employees
overall brand loyalty
PURPOSE PAYS » BIG THINKING ON WHY PURPOSE PAYS
IT’S NOW BUSINESSES THAT NEED TO REASSESS THEIR CRITICAL ROLE IN SOCIETY So where’s the dilemma if purpose
Today, without a doubt, business
is deeply relevant to people and
and societal impact must go hand in
helps to differentiate a brand in the
hand. Consumers are too informed,
marketplace? Simply put, these two
too connected and too skeptical in
benefits are, for the most part, self-
this information age to fall for a brand
serving.
that claims to be pursuing a profound
If the motivation for jumping on the purpose bandwagon is solely
purpose when what it’s really after is a stronger P&L.
motivated by the bottom line, the
We’re at a critical juncture when
effort is doomed to fail. The key
businesses need to make sure that
to becoming a truly credible and
purpose doesn’t turn into just another
successful purpose-driven brand is
buzzword. No one needs ‘purpose-
authenticity.
washing’ to become the new ‘greenwashing’.
23
CONSUMERS KNOW THAT ACTIONS SPEAK LOUDER THAN WORDS The million-dollar question is how do you stay authentic? Three crucial ingredients are needed:
24
1) LEADERSHIP
2) TRANSPARENCY
Embracing an organisational purpose
Businesses need to be open about
starts at the top. Starbucks’ Howard
how the purpose they’ve subscribed
Schultz and Virgin’s Richard Branson
to connects to their business, while
have spearheaded efforts to align
at the same time creating a positive
their organisations around ideas that
impact on society. There’s no shame
stretch far beyond business impact.
in that; in fact, people ‘get it’. A sound
The moment the CEO acts as a public
storytelling approach is essential, one
role model and walks the purpose talk,
that clearly and simply paints a picture
employees – and ultimately customers
to explain why shared value creation is
– will believe.
beneficial to everyone involved.
PURPOSE PAYS » BIG THINKING ON WHY PURPOSE PAYS
TOMS shoes
AT&T’s ‘It Can Wait’ campaign. A simulator mimics the effects of texting while driving.
3) PARTICIPATION Today’s consumers know that actions speak louder than words, and they want their own actions to make a difference. That’s why successful brands invite them in, providing them with opportunities to engage. Warby Parker and TOMS do it with the ‘One for One’ model, where every purchase directly creates impact. AT&T uses
The stakes are high – and so is the responsibility that comes with it. This is the time for businesses to embrace the sphere of influence they have on millions of consumers. By changing their own behaviour they can affect the behaviour of many and mutually create a world that tilts the scale back into balance. Voltaire (and Spider-Man) would like that, for sure.
interactive workshops at colleges to demonstrate the risks of texting while driving in the context of its ‘It Can Wait’ campaign.
Dominik Prinz Head of Strategy Interbrand www.interbrand.com
25
N O I ACT
26
PURPOSE PAYS » BIG THINKING ON WHY PURPOSE PAYS
THIS IS THE TIME FOR BUSINESSES TO EMBRACE THE SPHERE OF INFLUENCE THEY HAVE ON MILLIONS OF CONSUMERS
27
28
PURPOSE PAYS » BIG THINKING ON WHY PURPOSE PAYS
Want to make money? Listen to Pharrell Elie Khouri tells us how Pharrell Williams hits the nail on the head when it comes to purpose
29
“Do everything with intent. Make
their expectations will be at your
sure intention is the number one
peril: a corporate scandal could go
ingredient in your creation.” Speaking
viral at the click of a mouse. Which
at Cannes Lions, the award-winning
is why companies like Unilever and
producer Pharrell Williams touched
PepsiCo have embraced the concept of
on something all businesses should
sustainability as part of their DNA.
always be thinking about.
30
Keen to measure up? We apply the
The social landscape as we know it
‘4 Ps’ to cater to this altruistically
is changing primarily because of an
driven group of people. No, not the
increase in consumer preferences
traditional marketing ‘4 Ps’ of price,
towards morality. Millennials aren’t
product, promotion and place. We’ve
afraid to switch jobs or wait longer
created our own: purpose, people,
to get married until they feel their
product and profit. Having the right
career echoes their strong sense of
purpose should lead to getting the
ethics, idealism and community. Ethos
right people who will develop the
determines not only where Millennials
right product or service, which will
want to work but also what they want
eventually lead to profit. It’s simple,
to buy. The young consumers of
but remember it must begin with
today aren’t easily fooled – neglecting
purpose. Here’s how it works:
PURPOSE PAYS » BIG THINKING ON WHY PURPOSE PAYS
purpose, people, product, profit. THE RIGHT PURPOSE
Is your company sustainable? Are you doing business with companies who share your values? Are you utilising all your resources responsibly and efficiently? Do you promote a culture of innovation and thought leadership? Is every aspect of your business doing the right thing for the right reason? Remember: sustainability isn’t just about a donation to a charity or corporate volunteering. It isn’t something you can fake. It embodies literally every part of your business and takes a lot of effort to maintain.
31
THE RIGHT people The fact that you value sustainability means a lot to the current working generation. Nowhere is this truer than in the Middle East and in our company, Omnicom Media Group MENA, where the average age of our employees is 27. Millennials really do care about our responsibility to our community – apparent by the active participation of our staff in our sustainability and CSR efforts. Being part of something
THE RIGHT product
larger than quarterly targets gives our employees a sense of engagement and
Having an engaged team leads to a
keeps them motivated and fulfilled.
culture of innovation and an improved service offering. Ultimately, this will help establish your company as an indispensable piece of your clients’ winning equation. Additionally, as more clients commit to sustainability, the more they will want to do business with partners who share similar values. All of this will lead to the fourth ‘P’.
32
PURPOSE PAYS » BIG THINKING ON WHY PURPOSE PAYS
PURPOSE isn't something you can fake THE RIGHT profit This needs little explanation: when you
in the region to be GRI certified. The
have employees who are engaged and
certification is a nod to the years of
motivated, the profit follows shortly.
hard work we’ve put into creating a
I’ve often advised people trying to
holistic sustainable environment. In a
make money to focus on anything but
world of rapid change, your greatest
the money: focus on your purpose and
competitive advantage is your own
everything else will fall into place.
core. Pharrell’s advice to focus on
Just remember, being sustainable is no easy task – it’s taken us a lot of trial and error to perfect the winning formula. We’ve recently
‘intent’ or ‘purpose’ echoes what early adopters are doing to lead the game – don’t take it lightly. Millennials certainly don’t.
been accredited by the ‘Global Reporting Initiative’, becoming the first marketing communications group
Elie Khouri Chief Executive Officer Omnicom Media Group MENA www.omnicommediagroup.com
33
why Fiona Le Brocq shows us that finding a purpose isn’t as daunting as it seems
There’s been nothing more heartening
planning sessions for more than ten
as a marketer than to see the
years and witnessed many blank
increasing interest and commitment
expressions when the group are asked
by organisations to being purpose-led.
to consider this question. With senior
Jim Collins is attributed as one of the earliest proponents of purpose with a very clear definition that your purpose is ‘why you exist beyond making money’. Clarifying this has been a hard
34
managers trained to focus on financial goals as a priority, and rewarded for them, there’s been little aperture to expand thinking beyond what we do to get to the why we do it.
nut to crack with many companies – I
I think one of the hurdles for many
know because I’ve facilitated purpose
executives is that purpose seems
PURPOSE PAYS » BIG THINKING ON WHY PURPOSE PAYS
? lofty, soft and even a luxury – it’s
society. We don’t have to imagine what
anything but. I’ve often used Apple
sort of people are attracted to this
as an example to demonstrate how
type of organisation or the thinking
purpose translates to the bottom line.
and concepting this type of purpose
Apple’s purpose set out by Steve Jobs
will drive – we just have to look at
in 1980 was, “To make a contribution
what it’s delivered in the form of the
to the world by making tools for the
iPod, iPhone and, most recently, the
mind that advance humankind”. Yes,
Apple Watch and acknowledge that
it may sound lofty, but in 2000 the
they are indeed delivering to their
brand was valued at US$6.6bn and in
purpose.
2013 US$98.3bn. They also pipped Google at the post for pole position in BrandZ’s ‘Most Valuable Global Brands’ in 2015.
The rise of employee engagement has also increased understanding of the role purpose can play. We now accept that acknowledging emotions
Apple’s purpose doesn’t talk to unique
in the workplace will actually enhance
features and benefits, but stakes out a
productivity because people don’t
provocative and valued position in our
want to work only for a salary and
35
benefits. They want to make a
more succinctly, reciprocity. This was
difference by being part of something
critical for the organisation for which
meaningful, contributing to something
differentiation from the ‘big four’ was
important and bigger than themselves.
the only path to growth. This led us to
The role of purpose in this case is to
develop the positioning of ‘More Give,
connect people emotionally with their
Less Take’ and was the genesis for the
work. They’ll love you, they’ll stay with
world-acclaimed ‘Break Up’ campaign.
you, they’ll be more resilient when
The business results were staggering,
times get tough.
moving preference from No. 3 to No. 1,
To bring this a little closer to home, I had the privilege of working at NAB a few years ago, one of Australia’s ‘big
36
and took NAB to No. 1 in customer satisfaction for the first time in ten years.
four’ banks. The business strategy
More recently I was Director of
was ‘Fair Value Exchange’ in which the
Marketing at SEEK Limited, the
purpose was inherent – fair exchange
foremost global online employment
of costs for products and services, or
group. The Exec was committed
PURPOSE PAYS » BIG THINKING ON WHY PURPOSE PAYS
working lives. This resulted in the highest ever brand engagement score and the strongest lead over SEEK’s competitors. The 2014 Deloitte ‘Core Beliefs & Culture’ survey explored this new context for business and found that organisations that focus beyond profits, and instill a sense of purpose among their employees, are more likely to find long-term success. “When it’s understood that purpose brings power and meaning to your employees, driving deeper connection and engagement in their day-toto articulating our purpose as a means of connecting and unifying all employees and having a positive impact on society. SEEK already do this by facilitating matching the right people with the right jobs. But their purpose took this even further: “To help people live more fulfilling and productive working lives and to help organisations succeed”. This led to a
day jobs, then the benefits for most organisations are manifest”, said Punit Renjen, Chairman of the Board at Deloitte. “What companies do for clients, people, communities and society are all interconnected. A culture of purpose ensures that management and employees alike see each as a reason to go to work every day.”
compelling cultural manifesto which
With this greater understanding, do
has increased employee engagement
we really need to keep asking, “Why
to 80%, and to the ‘Change’ campaign,
purpose”?
encouraging people to embrace change in order that they will thrive rather than just cope with their
Fiona Le Brocq General Manager - Brand & Marketing Medibank flebrocq@gmail.com
37
38
PURPOSE PAYS » BIG THINKING ON WHY PURPOSE PAYS
R Y A E Y
I
O P B D A F H
T E T V A T H Y D V L O Y G A P Y P Y N J K L P A H B H U R T Y B G U A F S
I
I
E W I
T A G F L B Y N O
Q C R T A Z X H E W D F T W C Q E D F
I
N D
I
N G E
E O T T Y D P B D A F H S D N Q M A A O Y B A O
I
E
A S Z T Y S F O T D D F N S U D E T
I
D U H V T V S
E M W E P G V R E F E S T R E Y K K U X O R O C U S C R Y R S C R R E N H H Y W P O
I
U H G P F D N D V
C S D A F H D W O G O G T W L R O F W T F D S L Z E Harlan Kennedy believes you can find your purpose in just three steps
E W D
C T G E G
Y B E L K X K O V R Y X Q 39
Y
A
E
Y
I
O
P
B
D
A
F
H
D
N
Y
A
E
T
V
A
T
B
Y
D
V
L
O
Y
A
A
E
T
A
P
Y
P
Y
R
J
K
L
P
A
H
D
N
A
P
H
U
R
T
Y
A
G
U
I
E
S
I
T
C
H
U
F
S
I
T
A
N
Q
M
A
Y
M
O
N
Y
F
S
C
A
G
U
I
D
E
L
I
N
E
S
Y
N
X
S
C
Q
K
O
A
A
S
A
S
A
R
N
T
W
C
Q
O
T
T
Y
D
P
B
D
A
F
S
O
Y
O
Y
N
N
Q
M
A
A
O
N
Q
M
A
S
E
N
D
N
Q
S
Z
T
Y
S
F
D
F
D
D
F
N
B
A
S
Z
U
D
ESo, you’re T newIto yourMcompany. A
Y
N
T
V
S
T
S
U
D
M
E
Sthe HREpaperwork, S been V through P all B
D
E
S
T
E
E
M
E
E
Y
K
R
Y
R
P
O
IIn a quiet U moment H around G dayE18, N
S
D
It’s week three. You’ve filled out
the onboarding, and sat through a
D
V
W
O
R
couple of meetings about the Q3 sales
projections. You’ve probably also been
S
H
U
R
E
to a workshop. Companies do a lot of workshops these days.
as you sip your grande almond
Amachiatto, F a question H Dpops into N yourQ mind:
F
suggest employing all three:
A. Consult the brand guidelines. It’s probably written somewhere on the
O
C
U
S
T
R
E
Y
first few pages. It might be called a ‘Mission’.
N
H
H
Y
E
C
R
Y
D
N
D
V
W W
P
O
M
A
G
T
S
C
S
D
E
D
W
L
R
Y
S
F
B. Ask someone who works at your company. “Hey Nancy, what do you think our purpose is?” Ask three
people across different departments. C. Ask your customers.
L
R
O“What F W T do we do here?”
S
F
GDon’t panic. T This Y is natural. U You I wantO
be prepared to have multiple answers
D
L
E
A
C
H
D
C
and may happen for any or all of these
B
E
L
K
X
K
O
V
40
F
point you have several options. I would
to feel a sense of purpose at your new job. “Why do we exist?” “What’s the
purpose of this organisation?” At this
PURPOSE PAYS » BIG THINKING ON WHY PURPOSE PAYS
G
T
Z
If you take all three of these steps,
N
H
H
Y
F
to your question. It’s quite common,
T
G
E
G
P
U
D
L
R
Y
X
Q
W
Y
B
E
reasons:
A
E
C
U
S
T
O M
E
R
H
D
T
V
A
T
H
Y
D
V
L
O
Y
A
P
Y
P
Y
N
J
K
L
P
A
H
D
U
R
T
Y
B
G
U
I
E
W
I
T
S
I
O
Y
N
Q
M
A
Y
N
O
N
S
E
Y
I
O
O
B
D
A
F
T
Y
Q
K
O
A
A
Y
A
S
A
Y
N
T
N
Q
O
Y
A
P
D
A
F1. YOUR H PURPOSE S E IS DATED
Q
Z
D
E
M T E S
A Y T E
A S I S
O F A Q
U R P O
Y
K
D
V
W
S
Y
R
S
H
V
E
A T E D
M D N D
W O I
N
A brand purpose can be like last
AWednesday’s I quinoa E salad. N At the time it was made it seemed fresh
Dand delicious F and N sustaining B all at once. But now it’s been hiding in its
TTupperware V forStoo long T and seems
not quite right to anyone who bothers
Eto giveSit the sniff T test.EThis isn’t just about being old. Companies change.
CMarketsUchange.SEveryone T loves a
brand that can stick to its guns but, at
Hthe same H time,Ymany great E companies have dramatically evolved their core
O
I
U
H
Y
K
F
D
Nofferings D over V WWrigley used the years.
D
A
F
H
Z
R
I
M
AplayingGcards. HP T moved S from creating
R
F
O L
F E
W L
O E
V I
I O
G N
to make soap. Nintendo used to make test and measurement equipment to
TPCs andZprinting Eequipment. D These are dramatic changes. It’s more likely your
has undergone subtle shifts in Hbrand H Y F its offering that create a disconnect
L
E
A
C
H
D
C
T
GbetweenEits stated G purpose P and its
E
L
K
X
K
O
V
R
Y
actual offering.
X
Q
W 41
Y
A
E
Y
I
O
P
B
D
A
F
H
D
E
T
V
A
T
C
Y
D
V
L
O
Y
A
A
P
Y
P
Y
R
J
K
T
H
R
E
E
H
U
T
T
Y
T
G
U
I
O
S
T
T
F
S
W
T
A
N
Q
M
A
U
O
O
N
C
A
O
F
I
Y
I
X
I
T
F
U
Y
C
Q
M
U
D
D
Y
A
S
A
R
C
T
O
T
T
Y
D
P
B
D
A
F
S
H
U
N
Q
M
A
A
O
N
Q
M
A
S
E
N
S
Z
T
U
D
Egood atTcreatingI singular M thoughts. A Y
M E
E Y
R
Y
P
O
2. YOUR PURPOSE IS MUDDY
Y
S
F
D
F
Most large organisations aren’t much They are good at compromise, and
Snuance,Eand making S sure V everyone P B leaves the meeting feeling slightly
K(but not Dtotally)Vdisappointed. W OThat’sR why your purpose may feel like it has
adjectives, or an ‘and’ Rone tooSmanyH U R E where one shouldn’t be. HarlanCorp
I
U
H
G
E
N
V
S
T
D
E
S
T
E
company does. That said, disregard your customers’ experience at your
O
C
U
S
T
own risk. Many companies think they have an idea of what their customer
N
H
H
Y
E
experience is, but they don’t. My
local grocer may think that I go there
D
N
D
V
W
because he has the best produce, but in reality I go there because I enjoy
AmakesFseamless, H high-powered, D N low- Q
L
R
O
cost, workplace efficiency software
F
W
T
F
that makes employees happy. You laugh. I’ve seen worse.
G
T
Y
U
I
F O
D
L
E
A
C
H
D
C
B
E
L
K
X
K
O
V
42
T
low-cost office furniture. KennedySoft
D F
N
Customers don’t own the purpose. The
makes the world more fun by creating
S S
3. YOUR PURPOSE IS OUT D TOUCH D WITH F YOUR N B OF CUSTOMERS
PURPOSE PAYS » BIG THINKING ON WHY PURPOSE PAYS
M
A
G
T
S
how friendly the staff are and how
pleasant they make grocery shopping.
G
T
Z
E
D
This misunderstanding might be fine, until my grocer is trying to
N
H
H
Y
F
decide where to allocate his precious resources. Does he hire a produce
T
G
E
G
P
R
Y
X
Q
W
consultant who guides me through the
THE BEST BRAND PURPOSE COMMUNICATES A VISION FOR THE WORLD THAT YOU STRIVE EVERYDAY TO MAKE REAL
various options of heirloom tomatoes,
world that you strive everyday to make
or does he hire more generalists in the
real.
store to smile and say, “Hi”? Why his grocery store exists, what role it plays in the world, is his business. But he’d be wise to at least hear what I value about my experience there.
So find one, or rewrite your existing one. Try not to form a committee. And, above all, make it matter. That doesn’t mean that your brand purpose has to be about saving the
Searching for your purpose can
world, but it should solve a user need
sometimes feel like it’s the most
for someone. And one last thing:
important challenge facing your
‘maximising shareholder value’ is
organisation. It can feel like a Holy
indeed a purpose. It’s clear, it’s
Grail, a magical phrase carved into
singular, it’s measurable, and it acts
stone. While your brand purpose is
as a reliable filter for the actions of
certainly important, I would caution
the company. But it’s probably not
that it’s not an end in and of itself.
very motivating to your customers or
Rather, a great brand purpose is just
employees.
a tool you can use to stay clear, stay focused, and feel good about whether what you do matters to the people who matter most. The best brand purpose communicates a vision for the
Harlan Kennedy Founder and Director of Strategy VBP Orange venablesbell.com
43
44
PURPOSE PAYS » BIG THINKING ON WHY PURPOSE PAYS
OUR PERSPECTIVE ON
E S O P R U P 45
WE LIVE IN A FASTEVOLVING WORLD.
Digital disruption and the rise of the purpose-driven brand
continues to change the way people experience brands.
So, at Hall & Partners over the past six years we’ve been looking at how measures of brand integrity can drive brand relationships. We’ve discovered that even in these times of rapid evolution, the longstanding fundamentals of brands ‘meaning’ something and products and services ‘doing’ something still ring true. Instinctive, unconscious, emotional relevance remains core to the heart of any successful brand/customer relationship.
46
PURPOSE PAYS » BIG THINKING ON WHY PURPOSE PAYS
It may come as no surprise to hear that across a lot of our work we find THREE
RECURRING THEMES:
1
BRANDS WHICH DISPLAY INTEGRITY ALSO HAVE HIGH LEVELS OF CONSIDERATION… …and the majority of today’s consumers profess to engaging with brands that act in the interests of others.
47
HOWEVER, WE ALSO FIND THAT…
2 48
PURPOSE PAYS » BIG THINKING ON WHY PURPOSE PAYS
...the number of people that are most driven by a brand’s broader social purpose, and willing to pay a price premium for this, is actually
RELATIVELY SMALL.
3
FOR THE MAJORITY of people, brands have to deliver first on category expectations of product and brand experience. It’s also imperative that consumers feel brands are connecting individually with them on a ‘do right by me’ basis, before they can focus on ‘do right by everyone’.
AND, BE WARNED. We often find that… …there’s no ‘one size fits all’ rule for brands when it comes to defining a purpose strategy that builds both emotionally and commercially rewarding benefits.
49
On
Purpose
It's no accident that our purpose is the heart of the FedEx story
50
PURPOSE PAYS » BIG THINKING ON WHY PURPOSE PAYS
Monica Skipper and Neil Gibson reveal how FedEx lives and breathes its purpose in everything they do FedEx delivers more than nine million
Connecting people with goods,
packages a day on average. But what
services, ideas and technologies
do we really deliver with each of those
generates opportunities that create
packages?
jobs, build prosperity and lift
We deliver love when we ship flowers for Mother’s Day. We delivered hope to the people of Nepal by flying in urgently needed medical supplies following a devastating earthquake. These stories, and more, are why we believe a connected world is a better world. That belief is embodied in our purpose statement, “Fedex: We connect people and possibilities around the world�.
communities to higher standards of living. And, by reducing our environmental footprint, we also connect future generations to a promise of a better tomorrow. Our purpose is essential to our brand and reputation because it puts who we are and what we do in the context of why we matter. As a result, it gives richer meaning to our portfolio of customer services, and it enhances
51
We connect people and possibilities around the world our reputation as a great place to work
which documents our contributions
and as a committed global citizen.
to economic development worldwide,
We developed our purpose statement
support for our people, sustainability
to be:
goals and progress, and community
INCLUSIVE Our purpose unifies our stakeholders
SHARED
(team members, customers,
Our purpose has enriched the stories
communities and shareowners) by
we tell the world. We’re proud of the
addressing shared economic, societal
many ways we help our customers
and environmental issues.
grow, and we’re just as passionate
AUTHENTIC Our purpose is backed up by our
52
investments worldwide.
about how, together, we make the world a better place.
actions, as highlighted in the ‘Global
Our purpose has launched a
Citizenship Report’ (csr.fedex.com),
transformation that will continue to
PURPOSE PAYS » BIG THINKING ON WHY PURPOSE PAYS
strengthen our culture. Today, our
as the world changes and FedEx
purpose not only articulates why we
evolves with it. We’d love to hear your
matter; it’s become a competitive
questions and thoughts about the
advantage. It inspires team members
power of purpose in your organisation.
by showing them how they make the world a better place. It helps recruit the right team members, and it resonates with customers who want to do business with companies that share their values. We’ll continue to look for ways to keep our purpose relevant and engaging
Monica Skipper Vice President Brand Experience Marketing FedEx Services
Neil Gibson Vice President Corporate Communications FedEx Services about.van.fedex.com
53
How
SHARED VALUE turns brand purpose into measurable actions
Simon McEvoy tells us why purpose is meaningless if it doesn’t engage your consumers or employees
54
PURPOSE PAYS » BIG THINKING ON WHY PURPOSE PAYS
I’ve often heard ‘brand purpose’
on consumer trust or employee
touted as the solution to creating
engagement – some of the very
meaningful businesses. Consultants
things it was designed to tackle.
have made million by getting brands
This is because purpose is only
to find their ‘why’ statement, and
worth anything if it’s translated into
brands that engage in this kind of
meaningful actions and programmes.
process proudly claim they’re here
Most brands claim to want to make the
to ‘make the world a better place’ on
world better, but is this really borne
some level.
out by their actions, and do sceptical
However, the trouble with all this
consumers and employees believe it?
‘purpose conceptualising’ is that
Getting brand purpose to live
it hasn’t really shifted the dial
meaningfully across an entire
55
organisation is an ambition that
tough, purpose is often an early
still escapes most. The majority of
casualty of ‘rationalisation’.
brands tend to separate the ‘moneymaking’ parts of their business from the ‘doing-good’ parts – with core functions like sales, R&D, marketing and/or retailing on one side and CSR, sustainability and HR on the other.
56
However, new thinking on turning brand purpose into meaningful actions has caused some of the world’s largest brands to re-think how their businesses work. With consumers increasingly looking for brands to ‘do
The problem here is that these ‘doing-
good’ as well as run good businesses,
good’ functions are usually the first
the commercial world has started
to be cut when the ‘money-making’
innovating around how these things
parts of the business are struggling or
can work in mutually beneficial ways.
business leadership changes. They’re
How can we create commercial value
typically perceived as cost-centres,
whilst delivering significant social
not value-centres, and as such are
value? This is a methodology called
unsustainable. When the going gets
‘Shared Value’.
PURPOSE PAYS » BIG THINKING ON WHY PURPOSE PAYS
Pioneered by Michael Porter and Mark
value initiatives.2 These innovations
Kramer in the US, ‘Shared Value’ is
included creating less waste, using
now practised by a growing number
less energy and working better with
of businesses all over the world,
local communities. Not only has this
including my own, Three Point Zero.
generated a great deal of commercial
Our belief is that some of society’s
value for Carillion, it’s made them
greatest challenges are, indeed,
more investable and created a happier
also some of our biggest market
place in which to work.
1
opportunities. Areas like housing, education, health and the environment contain huge unmet needs, and there are lucrative as well as helpful roles for brands to play.
Another great example is the engineering giant Siemens which has created the ‘Curiosity Project’ in the UK. This programme is enhancing the quality of teaching in STEM
One of my favourite examples of
(Science, Technology, Engineering &
this is the building firm Carillion,
Mathematics) subjects for 5m young
which generated £27m of profit
people to create more engineers,
in 2014 through its global shared
that are badly needed to help the
1. https://hbr.org/2011/01/the-big-idea-creating-shared-value 2. http://sustainability2014.carillionplc.com/index.html
57
Siemens’ ‘Curiosity Project’
58
PURPOSE PAYS » BIG THINKING ON WHY PURPOSE PAYS
HOW CAN WE CREATE COMMERCIAL VALUE WHILST DELIVERING SOCIAL VALUE? UK engineering sector generate a
By building purpose into clear,
projected additional £27bn by 2022.
business-critical, measurable
Both of these are committed programmes. They not only represent tangible, measurable value for the businesses concerned, but are demonstrably good for society. And this is the key – these are measurable programmes. They have clearly set objectives, they have KPIs, they have financial value attached
programmes, and re-thinking the role of business in society, ‘Shared Value’ solves the challenge of the value of brand purpose while making business a much more positive force. And, if your business can do good at the same time as flourishing financially, wouldn’t that be a good thing for all concerned?
to them. They can speak just as compellingly to shareholders and the board as they can to individuals, to regulators, to the media and to society.
Simon McEvoy Founder and CSO Three Point Zero www.threepointzero.org
59
60
PURPOSE PAYS » BIG THINKING ON WHY PURPOSE PAYS
Tim Lindsay urges agencies to further the importance of purposeful thinking
The advertising industry is under
that doing the right thing will drive
pressure. Spare some sympathy for
growth and profit – if the improved
the poor ad people? Probably not.
behaviour is real. In fact, many would
But there’s a serious issue here that
argue that the move to ‘doing well by
goes way beyond an understandable
doing good’ will only become truly
distaste for designer spectacles. I’ll try
mainstream when the corporate social
to explain.
responsibility agenda and the growth
The world pretty much agrees that
agenda become one and the same.
businesses have to behave more
The advertising business – despite its
ethically, more sustainably, with more
reputation for louchness and excess
concern for the social and cultural
– is brilliant at one thing: persuading
outcomes from their activities. And
people to change their behaviour.
it doesn’t really matter what the
Often this comes down to making
motivation for this improved behaviour
consumers want product B instead of
is – a genuine concern for the fate
product A.
of the planet or a cynical hunch
61
But there’s also a fine record of
the new landscape and discover a
charity, NGO, health and public service
purpose beyond profit for their brands
work that’s brought many benefits to
and businesses. We need new metrics
many people. Political advertising too,
and measurement tools – and new
but let’s not go there.
bonus and remuneration systems to
We’re in a place where major behaviour change is required; and
But here’s the problem. The experts
where governments are too inert/
in behaviour change are under the
broke/ill-intentioned/in thrall to vested
cosh. Client company procurement
interests to take effective action.
departments have systematically
Which is why business and the people
ratcheted down agency compensation
who sustain businesses – us – have to
to the point where talent and resource
take up the challenge.
is thin on the ground – too thin,
And in order to take up the challenge the ad business needs to develop new vocabulary, processes and strategy tools to help their clients understand
62
underpin them.
PURPOSE PAYS » BIG THINKING ON WHY PURPOSE PAYS
in fact, for the necessary ‘R&D’ to happen. In the past, agencies habitually took new ideas and initiatives to their clients. Now, not
so much. Doing the day job is hard
and creative firepower of the big ad
enough. If agencies aren’t getting
agencies. In addition, they often lack
CSR briefs from their clients and
the right client relationships. These
being asked to develop purposeful
conversations need to happen in the
thinking for their brands, who are
offices of the CEO and CMO, not the
they to argue? They’d love to do
CSR department.
more, but it doesn’t pay the bills. The urgent always gets in the way of the important.
If the agencies aren’t initiating the CSR conversation, driving the programme, demonstrating that good behaviour
This has created a capabilities gap.
is also good business, illustrating the
There are, of course, many admirable
points with compelling case histories
companies operating in the CSR space,
and coming to their clients with new
helping clients understand the issues
ideas and programmes, then clients
and stumble towards solutions. But
are going to look elsewhere for their
they are, in the main, small operations,
needs – to the world of consultancy,
and they tend to lack the consumer
design (where these issues have been
understanding, brand expertise
thought about more deeply and for
63
longer), media and technology – and to
social enterprise collective Swarm,
their own resources. At the moment,
has recently launched ‘Break the
the client community is further ahead
Silence’ to encourage the ad and
on this than its agency partners.
design industries to start the climate
But the key skills, the necessary skills, still reside in the ad agencies. How, then, to light a fire under the industry, to force it to address the deficiencies and meet the needs of business? There are a number of things happening… The awards and creative education charity D&AD, in association with
64
PURPOSE PAYS » BIG THINKING ON WHY PURPOSE PAYS
change conversation with their clients. And there’s a cross-industry group of interested planners, strategists, creatives and others that’s beginning the process of identifying the skills and tools gaps and trying to fill them. But – and here’s the encouraging bit – the biggest pressure is starting to
WE'RE IN A PLACE WHERE MAJOR BEHAVIOUR CHANGE IS REQUIRED
come from people in the business,
There’s a long way to go and a lot
in particular the Millennials, who
to be done. The ad business, with
are often more conscious of the
strategy tools and processes that
issues and more literate about
were, for the most part, developed in
them than their ‘seniors’. This
the ‘60s to accommodate the advent
generation understands the power of
of commercial TV, is a lot closer to
communication to be a force for good,
where we started the journey than
are born social media adepts, and
where we need to get to. But there’s
want at least part of their professional
movement, and that’s good.
life to be focused on the ‘good’ part of ‘doing well by doing good’ – social enterprise and commercial enterprise coming together in a natural and
Tim Lindsay CEO D&AD www.dandad.org
unforced way.
65
E U L VA
66
PURPOSE PAYS » BIG THINKING ON WHY PURPOSE PAYS
TODAY BRANDS NEED TO CONSIDER HOW THEY CAN CREATE COMMERCIAL VALUE WHILST DELIVERING SIGNIFICANT SOCIAL VALUE
67
The
selfish
S ’ N O I T A CORPORGuide To
Saving the Planet Benny Thomas believes that sustainability focused marketing is the key to making our parents and children proud
68
PURPOSE PAYS » BIG THINKING ON WHY PURPOSE PAYS
Can an anti-tobacco campaign help us
the insight that all the talk about
save the planet?
the dangers of smoking was actually
There can be no greater purpose for every man, woman and child on this
making it more attractive to the most vulnerable audience – teenagers.
earth than the preservation of our
Because, of course, teenagers are
planet as we know it. Yet, why is it that
immortal, and the threat of death
when every scientist agrees humans are
simply makes smoking cooler.
responsible for potentially catastrophic climate change, we humans simply ignore it and continue with spewing carbon? It’s quite simple. Telling people something is bad for them doesn’t mean they’ll stop doing it.
So the ‘Truth’ campaign shifted its focus to a completely different aspect of the teenage psyche: their rebellion against authority. In a brilliant twist, the campaign took on not tobacco but the tobacco companies, and
One of the most successful social
showed that they were giant, quasi-
campaigns of all time, ‘Truth’ by
authority figures bent on manipulating
Crispin Porter + Bogusky, began with
the masses into buying their product.
69
Telling people something is bad for them doesn’t mean they’ll stop doing it
In an instant, an act of bold, James Dean defiance became seen as obeisance to The Man. It’s a great example of replacing one set of incentives with another of equal power. Much of the conversation in culture is about consumers doing their bit, but when it comes to climate change, individual action isn’t enough. We will fail if we don’t act at scale. Large corporations can be our lever to change the world. But large corporations answer to boards, shareholders and hungry analysts every quarter. To get them to change, we have to stop talking about green action as a moral issue and start talking about it as a way to grow business.
70
PURPOSE PAYS » BIG THINKING ON WHY PURPOSE PAYS
Walmart did. Their now-famous demand that suppliers cut their packaging by 5% may have done more than any single action by a brand to reduce waste and lighten their footprint. In turn, it helped lower prices further for shoppers. In recent studies, Millennials listed the retail giant as one of their favourite brands, which is a nice side effect. Sustainable strategies impact the bottom line and motivate consumers. Coca-Cola hit exactly that sweet spot when they went straight to the core of their business and launched an initiative to save water. They’re active in 320 communities in 86 countries, and consumers are noticing – brand scores have never been higher. Best Buy is another great example of a company that mixes immediate gain with the greater good. Not many know that the company is the biggest e-cycler in the US, handling over one billion pounds of motherboards, chips and once-loved smartphones. They can leverage this to offer trade-ins encouraging consumers to upgrade sooner, setting off a cycle of ‘virtuous consumption’.
71
Sustainable strategies impact the bottom line and motivate consumers In each of these cases, the brand
Green loyalty: In the UK, a new
started from selfishness – how do we
programme called ‘Ice’ rewards
cut costs, preserve our raw materials,
shoppers for shopping more
get shoppers to buy more – and
sustainably. If we want to shift the
elevated to a ‘triple bottom line’
way business thinks, let’s think about
strategy of ‘people, plant, profits’
using nature’s principles.
(not necessarily in that order, but who cares?).
Brand it: Lawmakers opposing the extension of cap-and-trade to
There’s no greater challenge for those
transportation fuels in California called
of us in the marketing community than
it a ‘hidden tax’. Why not rebrand it as
finding ways to incentivise consumers,
the ‘Clean Air Vote’ or the ‘Forest Fire
corporations and governments to
Fighter’?
confront climate change. Our efforts thus far have mostly been moralistic finger-wagging that, at best, preaches to Leo DiCaprio and other members of the converted choir. But there are so many levers available to us; here are just a few time-tested ways to get selfishness working for us.
Find your supporters and empower them: There’s a huge army of climate change activists just waiting to be tapped. They’re your children and mine. If we could get their pester power to change mum and dad, not only do we save the planet, we establish connections with a new generation of consumers.
72
PURPOSE PAYS » BIG THINKING ON WHY PURPOSE PAYS
Behaviourally speaking, the dice are loaded against our brains absorbing the impact of climate change and acting to reverse it. The good news is that if we stop moralising and start doing our job as marketers, we can save the planet and – a little bonus – make our mums and kids proud.
Benny Thomas Executive Strategy Director Crispin Porter + Bogusky www.cpbgroup.com
73
74
PURPOSE PAYS » BIG THINKING ON WHY PURPOSE PAYS
‘Don’t try fobbing us off with what you think we want to hear. If you’re not 100% true to what you claim, we’ll catch you out…’ warns Millennial, Mads Lindegaard
As most of today’s marketers
overnight – just ask VW – and this is
will be keenly aware, consumers’
because of the constantly evolving
relationships with brands have
ways in which brands develop
changed dramatically in the past
relationships with their consumers.
15 years. Back in the day, brand relationships were built and maintained mainly through strong marketing and PR strategies, and changes in consumer perceptions had long lead times and space for a response. Today, however, a brand and everything surrounding it is under constant scrutiny, with information being available instantly. Changing consumer perceptions can make or break brands and companies almost
A brand relationship used to be built through TV ads, the products the consumer picked up on shelf, or the branch where the service was provided. Relationships now are less driven by these somewhat static and controllable channels and more by the negative or positive buzz surrounding the brand; this buzz comes from myriad different independent and less controllable channels, in particular online media.
75
Millennials, in particularly, are likely to
its aspects – and to look beyond the
utilise these new channels, balancing a
agenda a brand is trying to set with its
variety of sources and weighing them
communication strategy.
up against each other, with friends and family indirectly vouching for these through social media sharing. They’re the first generation to grow up in this brave new world, deviating from a past when consumers had just a couple of sources of information as their trusted go-to points. This dynamic media landscape, and the exchange of information within it, enables Millennials to form a granular and nuanced picture of a brand in all
76
PURPOSE PAYS » BIG THINKING ON WHY PURPOSE PAYS
This arena has also helped shape consumer demand for a greater focus on the role brands play in their life, as well as the brand’s wider impact on society; consumers are essentially asking for brands to have a purpose beyond mere profit and shareholder return. It could be said that Millennials have driven this demand for purpose, as they actively seek out all the information that’s available and utilise it, interacting with brands for better
MILLENNIALS ARE THE FIRST GENERATION TO GROW UP IN THIS BRAVE NEW WORLD or worse; this type of participation
But does that mean there’s a trend
is inevitably less prevalent among
to just use old tools to solve new
Generation X, not to mention baby
challenges? Taking a marketing and
boomers.
communication-led approach based on
On the back of this, many organisations are proactively defining their purpose, incorporating it into their company or brand strategy, then specifically aiming their consumer communication to respond to the Millennials’ request. Much of this seems to have been developed with a marketing lens, telling Millennials ‘we understand why we’re here and what we do for you’.
satisfying a group of consumers seems like the wrong way round. And it runs the risk that, from the customer’s point of view, organisations are seen to be doing the same as in the past: that is, creating a perception of what the brand or company is. If this is indeed the case, then they’ve missed the point and don’t stand a chance of giving even Millennials what they want. And, with the way the world operates
77
today, companies will quickly be
and ask: what do consumers really
caught out if they’re not 100% true to
mean by purpose? How should it
what they claim!
manifest itself in a brand? If there’s
So, maybe purpose shouldn’t be seen as something merely to shore up the marketing or communication strategy. Perhaps it’s time to take a step back
78
PURPOSE PAYS » BIG THINKING ON WHY PURPOSE PAYS
one thing Millennials have taught us, it’s that companies can only claim to be something if it’s true, and that something has to permeate their corporate DNA.
First and foremost, purpose needs to
and marketing guys can start shouting
be rooted within an organisation. It
about it! This is a tough task indeed,
should start at the highest level and
but it’s an approach worth trying to
flow through the company culture,
take if consumers are to believe in
values and decision making. It should
your purpose and, ultimately, buy into
help to engage employees at all
your brand.
levels. It should frame the company’s approach to business. Only once this has been achieved will a company’s purpose organically form the way it thinks and behaves. And then your PR
Mads Lindegaard Account Manager and a Millennial Hall & Partners m.lindegaard@hallandpartners.com
79
80
PURPOSE PAYS » BIG THINKING ON WHY PURPOSE PAYS
Being fully engaged with an
is essential for boards
Louise McCann shares a case study on monitoring and measuring purpose
81
PURPOSE IS NOW A
FUNDAMENTAL PART OF
ST RAT EGY
82
“The purpose of a business is to create
Purpose is no longer just about brand
and keep a customer.”
execution; it’s now a fundamental part
– Peter Drucker
of strategy. ‘Anytime, anywhere, any
Drucker’s perspective is one that’s
device’ has seen the balance of power
always resonated with the CMO,
in the marketing relationship with
the traditional custodian of an
purpose shift from the organisation to
organisation’s brand and customers. A
the customer; and this has influenced
more global economy, along with the
the need for boards to become
enablement of digital and its ensuing
absolutely engaged with brand and
disruption, has created a significant
purpose in a more meaningful manner.
shift in the ownership of purpose, with
Purpose has become a definitive
the brand and the customer being
statement about the ‘how’ of what
amplified into the boardroom.
an organisation does, and the
PURPOSE PAYS » BIG THINKING ON WHY PURPOSE PAYS
ANYT IME ANYWHERE ANY DEVICE
‘how’ is intrinsically linked to the
firsthand the backlash of the power of
brand. ‘Belong Anywhere’ is a great
integrity and the consequent impact
expression of Airbnb’s purpose; as
on share price.
is Uber’s ‘Everyone’s Private Driver’. Indeed, an organisation without purpose would see its workforce simply going through the motions, doing whatever task was at hand without any idea of why they’re actually doing it. Purpose enables employees to focus on the reality that ‘a brand is what a brand does’; and that failure to deliver on the promise will significantly impact the brand’s integrity. VW in the US is experiencing
The evolution of purpose as a single unifying theme allows a workforce to know exactly what they’re working for and how their daily effort contributes. Chipotle’s ‘Food with Integrity’ extends to every part of the business, including all the other companies that come into contact with Chipotle. Equally, employees have to deliver consistently on their ‘day after day we’re committed’ promise.
83
BIGSMALL AND
With purpose now a key organisational
Promoter Score (NPS); whilst not new
driver, boards must be absolutely
to marketers, it’s only recently been
engaged with it; they must ensure that
understood and embraced by boards.
it’s measured in a meaningful way and can be leveraged to deliver financial, operational and customer outcomes. Purpose must also form a significant part of the strategic framework so as to ultimately deliver total shareholder return.
An organisation that was an early adopter of NPS, and linked it strategically and operationally to purpose, is Australia’s challenger ISP/Telecom provider iiNet. NPS was used to monitor iiNet’s core purpose of ‘awesome customer service’; with
Big and small data has allowed
every customer interaction being
the measurement of purpose and
measured, NPS was at the heart of the
brand values, once regarded as soft
organisation. Indeed, it became part of
measures, to have metrics that can
iiNet’s cultural DNA.
stand up credibly as well as being correlated to operational outcomes. One such measure is the Net
84
DATA
PURPOSE PAYS » BIG THINKING ON WHY PURPOSE PAYS
When combined with the core service purpose, NPS saw iiNet achieve industry-low churn and significant
HAS ALLOWED T HE
MEASUREMENT
OF PURPOSE customer growth together with a
consistently in the top 20 performing
strong brand and a distinct culture.
companies on the ASX over the last
Their NPS scores in the 60s were
five years. iiNet’s board and CEO
the envy of competitors and other
held a view consistent with Drucker:
service companies. iiNet’s board and
to stand back and watch the power
management drove purpose and NPS
of a collective purpose drive the
through key remuneration drivers,
organisation to realise unmatched
including short- and longer-term
success. The board’s role was to be
incentives, from the CEO through to
engaged and hold management to the
the call centre staff. These featured
core purpose of ‘awesome customer
strongly in the strategic framework
service’ – and, in doing so, create and
and paved the way for continued
keep customers.
operational excellence and innovation. iiNet’s belief in customer service,
Louise McCann
and discipline in deploying NPS as a
Non-Executive Director louise@mccann.net.au
metric of its single unifying ‘awesome customer service’ theme, saw it
85
Follow us /hall-&-partners /hallandpartners
/hallandpartners /hallandpartners
/hallandpartners
Connect with us Wherever you are, we work there too. And we hope to hear from you. We’re ready to start a new conversation and help you build relationships that matter.
Contacts BOSTON » boston@hallandpartners.com CAPE TOWN » capetown@hallandpartners.com CHICAGO » chicago@hallandpartners.com DUBAI » dubai@hallandpartners.com JOHANNESBURG » johannesburg@hallandpartners.com LONDON » london@hallandpartners.com LOS ANGELES » losangeles@hallandpartners.com MELBOURNE » melbourne@hallandpartners.com MUMBAI » mumbai@hallandpartners.com NEW YORK » newyork@hallandpartners.com SALT LAKE CITY » saltlakecity@hallandpartners.com SEATTLE » seattle@hallandpartners.com SHANGHAI » shanghai@hallandpartners.com SINGAPORE » singapore@hallandpartners.com SYDNEY » sydney@hallandpartners.com TOKYO » tokyo@hallandpartners.com
www.hallandpartners.com
Purpose
Copyright Š 2016 Hall & Partners Purpose is published by Hall & Partners