Improving Mathematics Teaching: A Journey Beyond TIMSS Video Jim Stigler Ann Arbor September 27, 2006
Copyright Š 2006 Jim Stigler | Please do not distribute or use without permission
Today
Nature of teaching –
What we have learned from TIMSS video
Implications for improving teaching
Copyright Š 2006 Jim Stigler | Please do not distribute or use without permission
Background: TIMSS Video
Two large studies, started in 1993 Strategy: video survey Goals: – –
Investigate “average teaching” Compare teaching across countries
Copyright © 2006 Jim Stigler | Please do not distribute or use without permission
Three Things We Have Learned from TIMSS Video
2.
3.
Teaching is a cultural activity; varies more across than within cultures (TIMSS 1995 video study; goals/scripts) – Learned implicitly – Hard to see (e.g., confusion) – Hard to change; culture wins Teaching is contextual; no one “best” way – TIMSS 1999 video study: what differentiates highachieving countries? – Example: organization of classroom Teaching quality is in the details of implementation
Copyright © 2006 Jim Stigler | Please do not distribute or use without permission
Example: Mathematics Problems
Debate: understanding concepts vs. mastering basic skills Type of problems: – – –
Stating concepts Using procedures Making connections
Results…
Copyright © 2006 Jim Stigler | Please do not distribute or use without permission
Types of Problems Presented in Six Countries
Percent of Problems
100 84
77
80
69 61 54
60
57
41 40 24 20
15
16
17
13
0 AU
CZ
HK
Using procedures
JP
NL
US
Making connections
Copyright Š 2006 Jim Stigler | Please do not distribute or use without permission
How Making Connections Problems are Worked on in the Classroom
Percent of MC Problems
80 59
60
52
48
46 40
37 31 16
20
18
20
19
8 0
0 AU
CZ
HK
Using procedures
JP
NL
US
Making connections
Copyright Š 2006 Jim Stigler | Please do not distribute or use without permission
Underlying Problems Why do US teachers apparently fail to engage students with sustained opportunities to think about mathematics concepts? Teachers lack content knowledge Lack of models for how to engage students with concepts Lack of curricular support: too many standards, lacking in coherence; textbooks that do not support conceptual connections
Copyright Š 2006 Jim Stigler | Please do not distribute or use without permission
Teaching Well Requires
Knowledge –
Skill –
Content, pedagogical content, alternative strategies Capacity to implement, to link knowledge into practice
Judgment –
When to use which strategy with which students (requires analysis of cause/effect relations between teaching and learning)
Copyright © 2006 Jim Stigler | Please do not distribute or use without permission
Improving Teaching
Teaching is a cultural activity. Improving teaching involves making sustainable improvements to cultural routine. (Daily routine as the workshop for change.) First step is to make teaching visible – – –
Broaden our conception of teaching (use cycle of teaching as lever for change) Discuss teaching with colleagues Ground discussions in actual practice: e.g., student work, videos
Next, engage teachers in identifying common student needs and crafting solutions (using all available resources) Finally, provide some means to accumulate and share professional knowledge (improving knowledge base)
Copyright © 2006 Jim Stigler | Please do not distribute or use without permission
Importance of Stable Settings
Teaching will not improve unless we provide a time and place to do this work – – –
Regular and ongoing Job-alike groups 100% focus on improving instruction
Copyright © 2006 Jim Stigler | Please do not distribute or use without permission
Lesson Study
Revise
Plan
Student Learning Examine
Implement
Identifying Common Student Needs. Deliberately testing out new strategies to meet those needs.
Copyright Š 2006 Jim Stigler | Please do not distribute or use without permission
Ermeling (2005): Rob’s First Lesson
Copyright Š 2006 Jim Stigler | Please do not distribute or use without permission
Patty’s First Lesson (Ermeling, 2005)
Copyright Š 2006 Jim Stigler | Please do not distribute or use without permission
Lesson Analysis and Revision (Ermeling, 2005)
Patty’s insight
Copyright Š 2006 Jim Stigler | Please do not distribute or use without permission
Patty’s Second Lesson (Ermeling, 2005)
Copyright Š 2006 Jim Stigler | Please do not distribute or use without permission
Lesson Study: Reflections
Demonstrates the power of focused planning and analysis to improve teacher knowledge and teaching in the classroom – a school where everyone does this is a self-improving school But in general, many schools not ready: – Lack sustainable contexts to support the work of improvement – Lack a culture that supports teacher collaboration – Lack tradition, therefore lack skills for, lesson study – Lack knowledge, expertise and images of alternative implementation Copyright © 2006 Jim Stigler | Please do not distribute or use without permission
Pathways to Lesson Study How do we get there? How do we become the “selfimproving school�? Pre-service: prepare teachers with knowledge and skills to participate in learning/improvement process Districts/schools: Start with settings and protocols: building implementation capacity Provide teachers with opportunities to learn knowledge, skills, judgment Recognize that schools are on developmental pathways; learn to see evidence of progress
Copyright Š 2006 Jim Stigler | Please do not distribute or use without permission
Conclusion
Improving teaching is necessary for improving student learning We know what it takes to improve teaching, but it is hard: not enough to just make teachers more knowledgeable Must also have stable settings where teachers can translate knowledge into improved practice in the classroom (incremental improvements in cultural routine) and continuous growth of student achievement Lesson study is culmination of a developmental pathway toward achieving these goals
Copyright Š 2006 Jim Stigler | Please do not distribute or use without permission
Questions/Comments
jims@lessonlab.com
Copyright Š 2006 Jim Stigler | Please do not distribute or use without permission