Magazine

/>>:3 :/C<163A :3=>/@2 =1B=03@ '

DS`Wh]\ 0ZOQYPS``g B]c` '$! A[O`b^V]\S 0Sab ;]PWZS !5 @]cbS`a 9]ROY HW& >]QYSb DWRS] 1O[S`O EVOb¸a <Se W\ ASQc`Wbg AcWbSa

G]c` 3aaS\bWOZ 5cWRS b]

/ A\SOY >SSY Ob 6]b <Se 4SObc`Sa 2SdWQS AbOUS ;cZbW B]cQV 6][S 5`]c^ :WP`O`WSa 8c[^ :Waba 3\VO\QSR BOaYPO` 0SSTSR C^ ASQc`Wbg BVS <Se >OW\b 5S\bZS` C/1 ;]`S

EW\R]ea % , AV]cZR G]c C^U`ORS-

, EVWQV DS`aW]\ 7a @WUVb T]` G]c, 7a G]c` AgabS[ @SORg-

=1B=03@ '

D=: & <=

"$

1=D3@ AB=@G 7<A723 E7<2=EA % BVS ¿\OZ `SZSOaS Wa ]\ bVS V]`Wh]\ O\R eS VOdS O TcZZ O\OZgaWa 1VSQY ]cb OZZ bVS \Se TSObc`Sa Sfb`Oa bW^a O\R Qcab][WhObW]\a W\ EW\R]ea % bVOb eWZZ [OYS g]c aOg P]\ d]gOUS b] DWabO

>1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< =1B=03@ '

"

&

!"

47@AB :==9A

" 0CA7<3AA

# 43320/19

;]PWZS !5 `]cbS`a 6> =T¿QSXSb $ EW`SZSaa >`W\bS` 6B1 B]cQV >`] B ;]PWZS 6/@2E/@3 2SZZ AbcRW] ### CA3 $1A

:3BB3@A

B316 <3EA

% 4 @=<B A723 BVS 411¸a ^`]PS ]T bVS eW`SZSaa W\Rcab`g) QOPZS T`SS UORUSb ^]eS`) VSOR^V]\Sa T]` b`OdSZS`a

:S\]d] BVW\YAbObW]\ A

=>7<7=<A

/aca 3SS>1 6/

47@AB E=@2( :/<13 C:/<=44

>Zca ?cWQY :]]Ya $ 1=<AC;3@ 3:31B@=<71A

" 8=6< 1 2D=@/9

9]ROY HW& >]QYSb DWRS] 1O[S`O

" A/A16/ A35/<

0ZOQY0S``g B]c` '$! A^`W\b

"" 2/< 1=AB/

AO[ac\U @SQZOW[ A^`W\b A]\g >ZOgAbObW]\ ! 50 >A! AZW[ =Zg[^ca 3 > >Zca ?cWQY :]]Ya !" A=4BE/@3 /^^ZS ;OQ =A F $ A\]e :S]^O`R ASQc`Wbg acWbSa >Zca ?cWQY :]]Ya & B63 03AB ABC44

A=:CB7=<A % 1/>BC@3 G=C@ BD ;=;3<B @SQ]`RW\U ZWdS BD eWbV EW\R]ea ;SRWO 1S\bS` %! /B E=@9 >]eS` caS` bW^a T]` >SOQVb`SS %& =44713 =A 1`SObS O`QVWbSQbc`S aYSbQVSa W\ 3fQSZ & A31C@7BG EV]aS P`]eaS` Wa bVS aOTSab-

>1 ;OUOhW\S 2WUWbOZ 3RWbW]\ 7AA< &&& &# % Wa ^cPZWaVSR []\bVZg Ob " '% T]` ]\S gSO` HWTT 2OdWa ;SRWO 7\Q & 3Oab &bV Ab`SSb <Se G]`Y <G $ %'"

=1B=03@ ' >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=<

47@AB E=@2 :/<13 C:/<=44

BeWbbS`¸a =cbOUS Wa G]c` 4OcZb OQY W\ /cUcab 7 acTTS`SR bV`]cUV bV`SS V]c`a eWbV]cb OQQSaa b] BeWbbS` BVS [WQ`] PZ]UUW\U aS`dWQS eOa VWb Pg O [OaaWdS RS\WOZ ]T aS`dWQS 22]A ObbOQY 7b eOa `Sab]`SR O TSe V]c`a ZObS` Pcb TOWZSR OUOW\ bVOb SdS\W\U EVS\ BeWbbS` QO[S POQY ]\ZW\S Wb PSVOdSR Oa WT Wb eS`S ]\ ZWTS ac^^]`b( aZ]e b] `Sa^]\R ZWabZSaa O\R R`WTbW\U W\ O\R ]cb ]T Q]\aQW]ca \Saa /\R bVWa [Saa Wa g]c` TOcZb EVS\ BeWbbS` ZOc\QVSR O TSe gSO`a OU] Wb eOa ZO`USZg O bSQV O\R 7\bS`\Sb W\aWRS`¸a RSabW\ObW]\ 7b eOa O ^ZOQS eVS`S bVS ESP Q]U\]aQS\bW Rc[^SR " QVO`OQbS` [Wa aWdSa OP]cb bVS e]`Y bVSg eS`S R]W\U eV] bVSg VOR [Sb bVOb ROg O\R bVS Q]Z]` aVW`b bVSg VOR Xcab U`OPPSR T`][ bVS R`SaaS` R`OeS` EVS\ Wb PSQO[S O QcZbc`OZ ^VS\][ S\]\´eWbV bV]caO\Ra ]T \Se caS`a X]W\W\U SdS`g ROg´bVS []ab RWabW\Qb RWTTS`S\QS eOa bVS O^^SO`O\QS ]T bVS Z]dSOPZS 4OWZ EVOZS EVS\SdS` BeWbbS` eS\b R]e\ bVS aS`dWQS e]cZR ^]ab O\ W[OUS ]T O QcbS PZcS eVOZS

B

>1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< =1B=03@ '

O\R Sf^ZOW\ bVOb µBeWbbS` Wa ]dS` QO^OQWbg ¶ BVS Q][^O\g aW[^Zg Q]cZR\¸b YSS^ c^ eWbV bVS d]Zc[S ]T W\T]`[ObW]\ T`][ Wba BeSSbS`a :Oab gSO` bVS Q][^O\g [ORS O Q]\QS`bSR STT]`b b] ORR`Saa bV]aS QO^OQWbg ^`]PZS[a O\R \]e 4OWZ EVOZS aWUVbW\Ua O`S Oa `O`S Oa bV]aS T]` eVWbS eVOZSa BVS 22]A ^`]PZS[ Wa O eVOZS ]T O RWTTS` S\b Q]Z]` V]eSdS` /ZZ g]c ^S]^ZS eV] 7¸dS eO`\SR ]dS` O\R ]dS` OUOW\ b] W\abOZZ ]` c^RObS g]c` aSQc`Wbg a]TbeO`S SdS`g]\S eV] QO\¸b ab]^ dWaWbW\U 6]bASfg:WP`O`WO\a Q][ ]` R]e\Z]ORW\U [caWQ O\R []dWSa T`][ 7U]bg]c`¿ZSa Q][ O\R OZZ bV]aS \]]Pa eV] W\aWab ]\ ]^S\W\U SdS`g aW\UZS S [OWZ ObbOQV[S\b bVSg USb´g]c RWR bVWa G]c O\R g]c` h][PWS >1a O`S b] PZO[S ;O\g ]T bVS \Sea `S^]`ba OP]cb bVS BeWb bS` ]cbOUS caSR bVS ^V`OaS µRS\WOZ ]T aS` dWQS ObbOQY¶ O\R bVS\ bVS OQ`]\g[ µ22]A ¶ A] eVOb¸a bVS Sfb`O µ2¶ [SO\- Bc`\a ]cb Wb abO\Ra T]` µRWab`WPcbSR ¶ eVWQV W\ bVWa QOaS [SO\a bVS ObbOQY R]Sa \]b ]`WUW\ObS T`][ ]\S ^ZOQS Pcb `ObVS` [WZZW]\a ]T ^ZOQSa >cb aW[^Zg O RS\WOZ ]T aS`dWQS ObbOQY R]Sa \]b

BVS`S Wa a][S]\S ]bVS` bVO\ g]c b] PZO[S Pcb U]]R ZcQY ¿\RW\U bVOb ^S`a]\ Q][S T`][ ]\S PWU aS`dS` a][SeVS`S W\ @caaWO 1VW\O ]` <]`bV 9]`SO bVOb ObbOQYa Q][[S`QWOZ S\bS`^`WaS¸a aS`dS`a VS`S W\ bVS C A ]` SZaSeVS`S W\ bVS e]`ZR 7T Wb RWR Q][^O\WSa Q]cZR TW\R acQV ObbOQYa SOaWS` b] PZ]QY ]` ab]^ / 22]A Wa O Q]]`RW\ObSR ObbOQY a^`SOR OQ`]aa bV]caO\Ra WT \]b [WZ ZW]\a ]T >1a O`]c\R bVS e]`ZR B] Q`SObS bVS a]ZRWS`a ]T O 22]A QOZZSR µP]ba ¶ O PWb ]T Q]RS Wa R`]^^SR ]\b] g]c` >1 T`][ O\g ]\S ]T bVS OP]dS \O[SR aQS\O`W]a O\R _cWSbZg caSa g]c` agabS[ O\R aOg g]c` S [OWZ ORR`Saa P]]Y b] `SOQV Vc\ R`SRa ]T ]bVS` Q][^cbS` caS`a A] bVS [OZeO`S a^`SORa O\R bVO\Ya b] a][S QZSdS` ^`]U`O[[W\U e]`Ya b] VWRS WbaSZT 8cab ZWYS O dW`OZ [O`YSbW\U [SaaOUS bVS \Se P]b `]O[a W\ SdS` eWRS` QW`QZSa 7\ Wba eOYS O`S ^]bS\bWOZZg [WZZW]\a ]T h][ PWS >1a /\R a] eVOb- BVWa VOa \]bVW\U b] R] eWbV BeWbbS` U]W\U R]e\ ]` [g aVOYW\U W\ O Q]` \S` Oa 7 O[ T]`QSR b] bS[^]`O`WZg _cWb BeWb bS` Q]ZR bc`YSg 3fQS^b bVOb Wb R]Sa BVS ]\Zg eOg BeWbbS` Q]cZR VOdS PSS\ ObbOQYSR ZWYS bVWa´O\R a] acQQSaaTcZZg´Wa WT [WZZW]\a ]T W\TSQbSR h][PWS >1a acRRS\Zg ObbOQYSR bVS aS`dWQS CacOZZg O Q][^O\g R]Sa\¸b SdS\ `SOZWhS Wb¸a c\RS` ObbOQY c\bWZ Wb Wa Y\]QYSR ]TTZW\S 0OaSR ]\ bVS W\WbWOZ [SaaOUSa eS aOe T`][ BeWbbS` bVS aWbS RWR\¸b Y\]e eVOb eOa VO^^S\W\U c\bWZ bVS Q`OaV ]Qc``SR /UOW\ bVOb¸a PSQOcaS O 22]A R]Sa\¸b ObbOQY bVS aS`dS` Oa [cQV Oa bVS aS`dWQS 0]ba aW[

^Zg À]]R bVS agabS[ eWbV `S_cSaba A][S ]\S ^`]U`O[[SR bV]aS P]ba b] R] bVWa O\R eVWZS bVWa ^S`a]\ RWR\¸b VOdS b] R] O\gbVW\U Rc`W\U bVS ObbOQY´SfQS^b ^`Og bVOb bVS`S eS`S S\]cUV W\TSQbSR >1a ]cb bVS`S bVO\Ya b] OZZ ]T g]c b] [OYS Wb VO^^S\´VS QS` bOW\Zg Y\Se eVS\ Wb e]cZR VO^^S\ 7\ ]bVS` e]`Ra bVS`S Wa a][S]\S ]bVS` bVO\ g]c b] PZO[S Pcb U]]R ZcQY TW\RW\U bVOb ^S`a]\ E]cZR\¸b Wb Xcab PS SOaWS` T]` OZZ ]T ca b] W\abOZZ aSQc`Wbg a]TbeO`S ^Og T]` bVS c^RObSa `c\ `SUcZO` aQO\a O\R ab]^ R]W\U `WaYg bVW\Ua ]\ZW\S- /\R bVS\ bVOb ]\S SdWZ ^S`a]\ e]cZR PS e`WbW\U [OZeO`S P]ba bVOb U]b \] TO`bVS` bVO\ VWa ]e\ RSaYb]^- BVWa e]cZR [OYS Tcbc`S 22]A ObbOQYa dW`bcOZZg W[^]aaWPZS 2c`W\U bVS eSSY ]T bVS BeWbbS` ObbOQY ]bVS` [OX]` aWbSa W\QZcRW\U :WdS8]c`\OZ O\R BVS 1]\ac[S`Wab eS`S \SO`Zg ZOWR Z]e Pg 22]A 4OQSP]]Y U]b e]PPZg b]] Pcb a][S V]e VSZR c^ BVS `SOa]\ BeWbbS` VOa PSS\ c^ O\R R]e\ Wa bVOb bVS P]ba O`S Q]\bW\cW\U b] e]`Y O\R [Og PS ^`]U`O[[SR b] aeWbQV c^ bVS ^]`ba bVSg¸`S ObbOQYW\U A] Xcab eVS\ BeWbbS` Wa OPZS b] PZ]QY QS`bOW\ ^]`ba bVS P]b\Sb O`[g Wa OZ`SORg []PWZWhW\U b] ObbOQY ]\ O\]bVS` EVWZS bVWa Wa VO^^S\W\U g]c aWb Ob V][S eWbV g]c` h][PWS >1 e]\RS`W\U eVg g]c QO\¸b USb b] BeWbbS` 7 e]\RS` eVg b]] 4=::=E ;3 =< BE7BB3@ 1ObQV bVS QVWST¸a Q][[S\ba ]\ bVS ZObSab bSQV RSdSZ]^[S\ba Ob beWbbS` Q][ :O\QSCZO\]TT =1B=03@ ' >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< !

327B=@ 7< 16734 >1 ;/5/H7<3 <3BE=@9 :O\QS CZO\]TT 327B=@ AbS^VO\WS 1VO\U eee ^Q[OU Q][

27@31B=@ =4 =<:7<3 1=<B3<B 3F31CB7D3 >@=2C13@ DWQYW 0 8OQ]Pa]\ 3F31CB7D3 327B=@A 2O\ 1]abO `SdWSea 8S`S[g / 9O^ZO\ 3fb`S[SBSQV /@B 27@31B=@ @WQVO`R 8 2S[ZS` 327B=@7/: >@=2C1B7=< 27@31B=@ <WQV]ZOa 1]a[] >1 :/0A 27@31B=@ ;/</57<5 327B=@ :/>B=>A 23A9B=>A :OO`\W /Z[S\R`OZO @OUOhO

;/</57<5 327B=@A ASO\ 1O``]ZZ a]TbeO`S aSQc`Wbg 7\bS`\Sb 8S\\WTS` : 2S:S] BSQVAOdS` 3`WQ 5`WT¿bV PcaW\Saa \Sbe]`YW\U B]\g 6]TT[O\ ^`W\bS`a aQO\\S`a AOaQVO ASUO\ []PWZS ES\Rg AVSSVO\ 2]\\SZZ Q]\ac[S` SZSQb`]\WQa A3<7=@ 327B=@A 1O`]Z ;O\UWa PZ]Ua Q][[c\Wbg 9gZS ;]\a]\ ;ObbVSe ;c``Og a]TbeO`S aSQc`Wbg 7\bS`\Sb 3`WY @VSg 2WUWbOZ 3RWbW]\ >1 :/0A :3/2 /</:GABA 1WaQ] 1VS\U ZO^b]^a BW[ 5WRS]\ Q]\ac[S` SZSQb`]\WQa ;O`W] ;]`SX]\ PcaW\Saa \Sbe]`YW\U ;WQVOSZ ;cQV[]`S a]TbeO`S <SWZ 8 @cPS\YW\U aSQc`Wbg 8]SZ AO\b] 2][W\U] RSaYb]^a ; 2OdWR Ab]\S ^`W\bS`a aQO\\S`a /</:GAB 2O\ 3dO\a 27G VO`ReO`S 8C<7=@ /</:GAB >8 8OQ]P]eWbh Q]\ac[S` SZSQb`]\WQa 7<D3<B=@G 1=<B@=: 1==@27</B=@ <WQ]ZS 5`OVO[ AB/44 >6=B=5@/>63@ AQ]bb AQVSRWdg >1;/5 1=; ;/</53@ =<:7<3 >@=2C1B7=< Gc\ AO\ BaOW >@=2C13@A ;O`Y :O[]`USaS EVWb\Sg / @Sg\]ZRa <3EA 327B=@ ;O`Y 6OQV[O\ <3EA @3>=@B3@ 1VZ]S /ZPO\SaWca /AA=17/B3 327B=@A 0`WO\ 6SObS` PZ]Ua \Sea AB/44 327B=@A 5`SUU 0W\RS` ^`W\bS`a aQO\\S`a HOQVO`g 6]\WU Q]\ac[S` SZSQb`]\WQa 3``]Z >WS``S :]cWa a]TbeO`S aSQc`Wbg 7\bS`\Sb <WQ]ZS >`WQS 4OaWU ZO^b]^a RSaYb]^a /AA7AB/<B 327B=@ ASO\ :cReWU []PWZS 1=;;3@13 >@=2C13@A 7[O\ 3ReO`Ra /`WSZZS @]QVSbbS CB7:7BG >@=5@/; ;/</53@ BW[ A[WbV 1@3/B7D3 27@31B=@ 1V`Wa >VWZZW^a >@=2C1B7=< /@B7AB 5cgO\U 1VS\ D723= 327B=@7/: 27@31B=@ D723= /<2 2757B/: 3D3<BA ASPOabWO\ @c^ZSg 1=<B@70CB7<5 327B=@A 6SZS\ 0`ORZSg 8]V\ @ 2SZO\Sg @WQVO`R D 2`OUO\ 8]V\ 1 2d]`OY 1`OWU 3ZZWa]\ 5OZS\ 4]bb 0WZZ 6]eO`R 2]\ :OP`W]ZO 8O[WS :S\RW\] 8W[ :]cRS`POQY 0WZZ ;OQV`]\S 3ReO`R ;S\RSZa]\ 8O\ =hS` <SWZ @O\ROZZ ;ObbVSe 2 AO``SZ :O``g ASZbhS` 7<B3@<A <ObOZWS AV]S[OYS` @gO\ AcZZWdO\

16734 3F31CB7D3 =44713@ 8Oa]\ G]c\U D713 >@3A723<B 2757B/: A/:3A 9S\\SbV 8 2SbZSb

# ! # # # ! "$&' A/:3A /AA7AB/<B /\USZW_cS A]b] # ! # ## ;/@93B7<5 27@31B=@ 0`ORg 8S\YW\a # ! # & 27@31B=@ 7<B35@/B32 >@=5@/;A 8W[ 2S/\USZWa # ! # $! ;/@93B7<5 ;/</53@ :W\RaOg 5O``Wa]\ # ! # % E30 23A75<3@ G]ZO\ =cWgO /2D3@B7A7<5 =44713 & 3 &bV Ab <Se G]`Y <G $ %'" ) ^V]\S & !!$ " ! # ! !# ) TOf # ! # 4]` ORdS`bWaW\U W\T]`[ObW]\ U] b] eee ^Q[OU[SRWO Q][ D713 >@3A723<B ;/@93B7<5 8O[Sa ASZRS\

H744 2/D7A ;327/ 7<1 16734 3F31CB7D3 =44713@ 8Oa]\ G]c\U 16734 47</<17/: =44713@ /<2 A3<7=@ D713 >@3A723<B <SWZ 5ZOaa 16734 =>3@/B7<5 =44713@ AbSdS Acbb]\ A3<7=@ D713 >@3A723<B :O\QS CZO\]TT 1]\bS\b >1 ;OUOhW\S <Sbe]`Y 53<3@/: 1=C<A3: AbS^VS\ 6WQYa D713 >@3A723<B 8O[Sa ASZRS\ ;O`YSbW\U O\R AOZSa 2SdSZ]^[S\b 1]\ac[S` A[OZZ 0caW\Saa 5`]c^ 3F31CB7D3 27@31B=@ :O``g 1VSd`Sa 7\bS`\Sb BSQV\]Z]Ug 27@31B=@ <gOaVO 0Oaa :WQS\aW\U

B63 7<23>3<23<B 5C723 >1 ;OUOhW\S Wa bVS 7\RS^S\RS\b 5cWRS b] BSQV\]Z]Ug =c` [WaaW]\ Wa b] bSab O\R `SdWSe Q][^cbS` O\R 7\bS`\Sb `SZObSR ^`]RcQba O\R aS`dWQSa O\R `S^]`b TOW`Zg O\R ]PXSQbWdSZg ]\ bVS `SacZba =c` SRWb]`a R] \]b W\dSab W\ ¿`[a eV]aS ^`]RcQba ]` aS`dWQSa eS `SdWSe \]` R] eS OQQS^b b`OdSZ bWQYSba ]` ]bVS` UWTba ]T dOZcS T`][ acQV ¿`[a 3fQS^b eVS`S \]bSR >1 ;OUOhW\S `SdWSea O`S ]T ^`]RcQba O\R aS`dWQSa bVOb O`S Qc``S\bZg OdOWZOPZS =c` `SdWSea O`S e`WbbS\ eWbV]cb `SUO`R b] ORdS`bWaW\U ]` PcaW\Saa `SZObW]\aVW^a eWbV O\g dS\R]` 6=E B= 1=<B/1B B63 327B=@A ES eSZQ][S Q][[S\ba T`][ `SORS`a AS\R g]c` Q][ [S\ba b] 7\bS`\Sb ORR`Saa ^Q[OU.^Q[OU Q][ ]` b] >1 ;OUOhW\S & 3 &bV Ab <Se G]`Y <G $ %'" >ZSOaS W\QZcRS O ROgbW[S bSZS^V]\S \c[PS` >1 ;OUOhW\S¸a US\S`OZ \c[PS` Wa # ! !# BVS ESab 1]Oab =^S`ObW]\a \c[PS` Wa " # #"% & ES QO\\]b Z]]Y c^ ab]`WSa T`][ ^Oab WaacSa `SQ][[S\R ^`]RcQba ]` RWOU\]aS ^`]PZS[a eWbV g]c` >1 Pg ^V]\S /\ W\RSf ]T ^Oab WaacSa Wa Ob eee ^Q[OU Q][ ^`SdW]caMWaacSa 4]` O ZWab ]T c^Q][W\U ab]`WSa P`]eaS eee ^Q[OU Q][ 4]` O TcZZ RSaQ`W^bW]\ ]T eV] ]\ abOTT Q]dS`a eVOb U] b] eee ^Q[OU Q][ eV]Q]dS`aeVOb 7T g]c O`S RWaaObWa¿SR eWbV O ^`]RcQb ORdS`bWaSR W\ >1 ;OUOhW\S O\R QO\\]b `Sa]ZdS bVS ^`]PZS[ eWbV bVS dS\R]` e`WbS R] \]b QOZZ /\\S 9W\U /RdS`bWaW\U 2S^O`b[S\b Ob bVS OP]dS ORR`Saa >ZSOaS W\QZcRS Q]^WSa ]T g]c` Q]``Sa^]\RS\QS eWbV bVS dS\R]` >3@;7AA7=<A @3>@7<BA 4]` ^S`[WaaW]\ b] `ScaS [ObS`WOZ W\ bVWa ^cPZWQObW]\ ]` b] caS ]c` Z]U] Q]\bOQb HWTT 2OdWa ;SRWO¸a 3fSQcbWdS 2W`SQb]` ]T @WUVba O\R >S`[WaaW]\a =ZUO 5]\]^ ]ZaYg Ob ^S`[WaaW]\a.^Q[OU Q][ ]` Pg ^V]\S Ob # ! #"!& ]` Pg TOf Ob # ! #" ;ObS`WOZ W\ bVWa ^cPZWQObW]\ [Og \]b PS `S^`]RcQSR W\ O\g T]`[ eWbV]cb e`WbbS\ ^S`[WaaW]\ 4]` `S^`W\ba ^ZSOaS Q]\bOQb bVS G5A 5`]c^( bSZS^V]\S & ' #"$ ) TOf % % !'' &' ) S [OWZ ^Q[OU.bVSgUaU`]c^ Q][

BVS T]ZZ]eW\U O`S `SUWabS`SR b`ORS[O`Ya ]T HWTT 2OdWa >cPZWaVW\U 6]ZRW\Ua 7\Q ( W 0S\QV <Sb0S\QV >1 27@31B >1 :OPa >1 ;/5/H7<3 >1 ;/5/H7<3 /E/@2 4=@ B316<71/: 3F13::3<13 >1 ;/5/H7<3 327B=@A¸ 16=713 >1 ;OU<Sb AS`dS`0S\QV EW\0S\QV EW\ab]\S HWTT 2OdWa ;SRWO¸a Q]`^]`ObS Z]U] O\R >1;/5 Q][ BVS T]ZZ]eW\U O`S b`ORS[O`Ya ]T HWTT 2OdWa >cPZWaVW\U 6]ZRW\Ua 7\Q ( /TbS` 6]c`a 1>C[O`Y 3Oag1][^cbW\U 3fb`S[SBSQV 4W`ab :]]Ya 4W`ab :]]Ya >Zca W 0S\QV :OP <]bSa :OP BOZSa >1 0S\QV >1 :OPa AQ]`SQO`R >1 ;OUOhW\S /b 6][S >1 ;OUOhW\S 12 4`]\b AWRS >1 ;OUOhW\S 3fb`O >1 ;OUOhW\S ;O` YSbZW\Y >1 A]ZcbW]\a >1 BSQV >]eS` >`]U`O[[W\U ?cWQY 1ZW^a AQ`SS\2S[]a A;0 0]]b 1O[^ BSQV <]bSa O\R EW\2`OW\ =bVS` b`ORS[O`Ya O\R b`ORS \O[Sa caSR bV`]cUV]cb bVS ^cPZWQObW]\ O`S bVS ^`]^S`bg ]T bVSW` `Sa^SQbWdS ]e\S`a 1]^g`WUVb & HWTT 2OdWa >cPZWaV W\U 6]ZRW\Ua 7\Q /ZZ `WUVba `SaS`dSR @S^`]RcQbW]\ W\ eV]ZS ]` W\ ^O`b eWbV]cb ^S`[WaaW]\ Wa ^`]VWPWbSR AC0A1@7>B7=< 7<4=@;/B7=< 4]` acPaQ`W^bW]\ aS`dWQS _cSabW]\a T]` ORR`Saa QVO\USa ]` b] ]`RS` ^ZSOaS Q]\bOQb ca( 7<B3@<3B( aS`dWQS ^Q[OU Q][ T]` Qcab][S` aS`dWQS ]` acPaQ`WPS ^Q[OU Q][ b] ]`RS` B3:3>6=<3( & &' " ' ]` !&$ #'% "!% W\ bVS C A O\R 1O\ORO !&$ #'% "!% SZaSeVS`S ;/7:( >1 ;OUOhW\S >= 0]f #" % 0]cZRS` 1= & ! " % ^ZSOaS W\QZcRS g]c` ^]abOZ ORR`Saa O\R S [OWZ ORR`Saa eWbV O\g Q]``Sa^]\ RS\QS Oa Wb eWZZ Sf^SRWbS ^`]QSaaW\U 4/F( !&$ ""% ! W\ bVS C A 1O\ORO O\R SZaSeVS`S 3 ;/7:( acPVSZ^.^Q[OU Q][ ^ZSOaS bg^S g]c` TcZZ \O[S g]c` ^]abOZ ORR`Saa O\R bVS S [OWZ ORR`Saa Ob eVWQV g]c acPaQ`WPS AC0A1@7>B7=<A( BVS ]\S gSO` acPaQ`W^bW]\ `ObS Wa " '% >1 ;OUOhW\S Wa ^cPZWaVSR []\bVZg 7T g]c` S [OWZ ORR`Saa Wa c\RSZWdS`OPZS eS eWZZ VOdS \] Tc`bVS` ]PZWUObW]\ c\ZSaa eS `SQSWdS O Q]``SQbSR S [OWZ ORR`Saa eWbVW\ be] gSO`a 0/19 7AAC3A( >`W\b POQY WaacSa 8O\cO`g ' O\R ^`W]` O`S & SOQV W\ bVS C A SOQV SZaSeVS`S >`S^Og[S\b Wa `S_cW`SR 1]\bOQb Qcab][S` aS`dWQS OP]dS T]` OdOWZOPWZWbg 4]` RWUWbOZ POQY WaacSa U] b] U] ^Q[OU Q][ RWUWbOZPOQYWaacSa ;/7:7<5 :7ABA( ES a][SbW[Sa [OYS ZWaba ]T ]c` Qcab][S`a OdOWZOPZS b] [OWZS`a ]T U]]Ra O\R aS`dWQSa bVOb [Og W\bS`Sab g]c 7T g]c R] \]b eWaV b] `SQSWdS bVSW` [OWZW\Ua ^ZSOaS e`WbS b] ca Ob >1 ;OUOhW\S >= 0]f #" % 0]cZRS` 1= & ! " % 2757B/: @3/23@( 7T g]c VOdS O\g ^`]PZS[a dWSeW\U WaacSa ^ZSOaS Q]\bOQb HW\W] Ob &&& '"$ "$$$ ]` Qcab][S`aS`dWQS.hW\W] Q][

4SSR 4SSR

:3BB3@A

2]e\ ]\ 2d]`OY EWbV OZZ RcS `Sa^SQb b] bVS `Sab ]T g]c` ]`UO \WhObW]\ 7 VOdS b] aOg bVOb 8]V\ 2d]`OY Wa O\ WRW]b O\R 7¸ZZ eObQV T]` VWa \O[S a] 7 QO\ [OYS ac`S b] Od]WR VWa O`bWQZSa W\ bVS Tcbc`S 7¸[ `STS``W\U b] VWa Q]Zc[\ µEVOb 7a 6O^ ^S\W\U B] EW\R]ea %-¶ 7T g]c OaY [S bVWa Wa aVO[SZSaa Qg\WQOZ aS\aObW]\OZWa[ O\R O`bWQZSa ZWYS bVWa ]\S `SÀSQb ^]]`Zg ]\ bVS `Sab ]T g]c` RSaS`dSRZg eSZZ `Sa^SQbSR ]`UO\WhO bW]\ ´;O`Y @caV

b]]- 7 bVW\Y bVS \]bW]\ ]T µUSbbW\U bVS 7\bS` \Sb¶ ]cb b] ^S]^ZS eV] R]\¸b VOdS Wb Wa O ^WS W\ bVS aYg R`SO[ EVOb eS VOdS b] `SOZWhS Wa bVOb eS QO\¸b ZSUWaZObS US\S`OZ a]QWOZ ^`OQ bWQSa ´@cabSR^Q

<SbP]]Ya O`S <]b :O^b]^a 7 `SOR 1WaQ] 1VS\U¸a `SdWSe ]T bVS :S\]d] 7RSO>OR A O\R Wb aSS[a b] [S bVOb SdS`g]\S Q]\bW\cSa b] Q][^O`S \SbP]]Ya b] bVSW` TcZZ aWhS ZO^b]^ Q]caW\a <SbP]]Ya O`S O\ S\bW`SZg RWTTS`S\b [OQVW\S 8cab PSQOcaS /\ =PZWUOb]`g 7\bS`\SbbVSg O\R ZO^b]^a Z]]Y OZWYS aV]cZR\¸b OQQ]c\b 7\ `Sa^]\aS b] AOaQVO ASUO\¸a Q]Zc[\ T]` [cQV /TbS` OZZ eS R]\¸b Q][^O`S O 4]`R µ:SO`\W\U T`][ 7`O\¸a BeWbbS` @Sd]ZcbW]\ ¶ 4 # ^WQY c^ b`cQY eWbV O ;W\W 1]]^S` 8cab 7 VOdS b] OaY bVOb O[]\U bVS % ^S`QS\b ]T Oa [g 9WO Wa POaWQ b`O\a^]`bObW]\ O \SbP]]Y /[S`WQO\ V]caSV]ZRa bVOb R]\¸b VOdS 7\bS` Wa POaWQ Q][^cbW\U Ob PSab ´@WQVO`R$$$ \Sb OQQSaa eVOb ^]`bW]\ ]T bV]aS e]cZR g]c aOg O`S aObWa¿SR eWbV \]b VOdW\U Wb- 7b¸a aW[W EVOb bVS @SQSaaW]\ ;Og 0S BSZZW\U Ca ZO` b] bVS ^`W\QW^ZS ]T X]PZSaa ^S]^ZS [O\g 7\ `SUO`R b] 8]V\ 2d]`OY¸a Q]Zc[\ µ0O`UOW\a ]T eV][ ^`STS` b] abOg bVOb eOg =PdW]caZg 5OZ]`S 6]e 1O\ G]c @SaWab-¶ 7 bVW\Y Wb Wa dS`g eS R]\¸b \SSR b] T]`QS bVS 7\bS`\Sb ]\ ^S] SOag b] `SaWab 8]V\ :WYS a] [O\g W\bSZZWUS\b ^ZS eV] R]\¸b eO\b Wb /[S`WQO\a TOQW\U bVS abSS^Sab SQ]\][WQ B] PS V]\Sab 7 R]\¸b _cWbS c\RS`abO\R aZ]eR]e\ W\ \SO`Zg O QS\bc`g 7¸[ \]b PcgW\U bVS O^^ZWQObW]\ ]T bVWa eV]ZS bVS]`g EVOb O\gbVW\U 7 R]\¸b \SSR 7¸[ Q]\aS`dW\U QOaV OP]cb bVS ^S]^ZS eV] QO\¸b OTT]`R Q][^cb W\ QOaS bVS OZZ b]] ¿QYZS ¿\US` ]T TObS ^cba S`a b] USb ]\ bVS 7\bS`\Sb- 7a bVS U]dS`\ [S ]cb ]T O X]P /ZZ [g ]ZR abcTT e]`Ya O\R Wa [S\b U]W\U b] ^`]dWRS Q][^cbS`a T]` bVS[ Q]\¿Uc`SR bVS eOg 7 eO\b Wb 6=E B= 1=<B/1B CA ES eSZQ][S g]c` Q][[S\ba O\R acUUSabW]\a EVS\ aS\RW\U S [OWZ b] 4SSRPOQY ^ZSOaS abObS W\ bVS acPXSQb ZW\S eVWQV O`bWQZS ]` Q]Zc[\ ^`][^bSR g]c` `Sa^]\aS 3 [OWZ ^Q[OU.^Q[OU Q][ /ZZ ZSbbS`a PSQ][S bVS ^`]^S`bg ]T >1 ;OUOhW\S O\R O`S acPXSQb b] SRWbW\U ES `SU`Sb bVOb eS QO\\]b O\aeS` ZSbbS`a W\RWdWRcOZZg =1B=03@ ' >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< #

43320/19

4`O\YZg 8]V\ 7 bVW\Y bVOb []ab ]T b]ROg¸a bSQV Wa P]`W\U 1]cZR Wb PS bVOb bSQV Q][ ^O\WSa eWZZ VOdS b] Q][S c^ eWbV a][S \Se O\R `Sd]ZcbW]\O`g bSQV\]Z]Ug ZWYS bVSg caSR b]- 1]cZR Wb PS bVOb bVS TW\O\QWOZ Q`WaWa Wa \]e aW[^Zg OQQSZS`ObW\U Q]\ac[S`a¸ P]`S R][ eWbV ^`]RcQba T`][ C A bSQV Q][^O \WSa- 7\bSZ /;2 A]\g AVO`^ O\R /^^ZS( 7¸[ P]`SR eWbV g]c` abcTT 7 O[ \]b a^S\RW\U [g VO`R SO`\SR R]ZZO`a ]\ \Se Q]Z]`a T]` bVS W>]R ]` O TSe \O\]aSQ]\Ra ]T a^SSR UOW\ ]\ ^`]QSaa]`a 7 R]\¸b VOdS [cQV T`SS QOaV b] a^S\R Pcb 7 QO\ bSZZ g]c bVOb 7¸ZZ TW\R bVS []\Sg b] Pcg bVS \Sfb US\S`ObW]\ ]T ^`]R cQba bVOb R]\¸b Z]]Y ZWYS bVS 3WUVbWSa eO`[SR ]dS` ´1]dS\b`g

:W\cf /W\¸b A] 0OR /TbS` `SORW\U :O\QS CZO\]TT¸a Q]Zc[\ µ2WO`g ]T O :W\cf DW`UW\ ¶ 7 Xcab VOdS b] aOg µ:O\QS ^cV ZSShS ¶ EVg RWR g]c [OYS Wb VO`R ]\ g]c`aSZT Pg aSbbW\U c^ g]c` D/7= eWbV O RcOZ P]]b F> CPc\bc aSbc^- G]c VOdS aQO`SR ]TT a][S `SORS`a T`][ b`gW\U CPc\bc ]` O\]bVS` :W\cf RWab`] Pg [OYW\U bVS :W\cf RSaYb]^ W\abOZZ aSS[ VO`RS` bVO\ Wb Wa =` RWR g]c Q][^ZWQObS [ObbS`a W\bS\bW]\OZZg a] g]c Q]cZR PSbbS` [SSb O _c]bO T]` O [W\W[c[ \c[PS` ]T e]`Ra ]\ bVS acPXSQb- 7¸[ RWaO^ ^]W\bSR G]c [Og VOdS PSS\ O :W\cf dW`UW\ Pcb OTbS` []`S bVO\ # gSO`a W\ bVS Q][^cbS` X]c`\OZWa[ PWh g]c aV]cZR VOdS Y\]e\ PSb bS` ´0S\ ;gS`a

4`]\b EVOb¸a <Se T`][ bVS E]`ZR ]T BSQV

AQ`cbW\WhW\U 1SZZ >`]dWRS`a BVS 411 ZOc\QVSa O \Se ^`]PS W\b] bVS eW`SZSaa W\Rcab`g /aY bS\ ^S]^ZS eVOb bVSg bVW\Y ]T bVSW` eW`SZSaa aS`dWQS ^`]dWRS` acQV Oa A^`W\b DS`Wh]\ ]` /B B O\R g]c¸ZZ ^`]POPZg USb bS\ RWTTS`S\b O\aeS`a 0cb WT g]c OaY bS\ W\Rcab`g W\aWRS`a bVS aO[S _cSabW]\ g]c¸ZZ ^`]POPZg VSO` ]\Zg be] abO\RO`R `Sa^]\aSa( Q][ ^O\WSa O`S R]W\U O U`SOb X]P ]` bVSg TOZZ TO` aV]`b ]\ Qcab][S` aS`dWQS B] UOW\ O []`S RSbOWZSR Z]]Y Ob bVS ^S`T]` [O\QS ]T bVS eW`SZSaa W\Rcab`g bVS 4SRS`OZ 1][[c\WQObW]\a 1][[WaaW]\ VOa `SQS\bZg ZOc\QVSR O ^`]PS ]T bVS acPXSQb 7\ ZObS 7ZZcab`ObW]\ Pg @]PS`b <ScPSQYS`

/cUcab bVS Q][[WaaW]\ OaYSR abOYSV]ZR S`a W\ bVS W\Rcab`g b] acP[Wb bVSW` TSSRPOQY W\ bV`SS YSg O`SOa( W\\]dObW]\ O\R W\dSab [S\b bVS abObS ]T Q][^SbWbW]\ O\R eVSbVS` ]` \]b Q]\ac[S`a USb S\]cUV W\T]`[ObW]\ T`][ ^`]dWRS`a b] [OYS W\T]`[SR RSQWaW]\a OP]cb aS`dWQS BVS U]OZ ]T bVWa QOZZ T]` Q][ [S\b ]TTWQWOZZg QOZZSR \]bWQS ]T W\_cW`WSa <=7a Wa b] SabOPZWaV O µTOQbcOZ POaWa¶ T]` QZOW[a [ORS Pg ac^^]`bS`a O\R RSb`OQ b]`a ]T eW`SZSaa ^`]dWRS`a OP]cb bVS abObS ]T bVS W\Rcab`g U]W\U T]`eO`R 411 QVOW`[O\ =1B=03@ ' >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< %

4@=<BA723

@Sa^]\aSa b] bVS W\_cW`g eWZZ VSZ^ bVS 411 RSQWRS eVSbVS` Wb \SSRa b] W[^]aS O\g \Se `cZSa 8cZWca 5S\OQV]eaYW aOWR Ob bVS Q][[Wa aW]\¸a []\bVZg ^cPZWQ [SSbW\U µBVWa ^`]QSaa eWZZ PS SaaS\bWOZ T]` ]c` \ObW]\ b] PSQ][S bVS e]`ZR¸a ZSORS` W\ []PWZS ¶ VS ORRSR @Sa^]\aSa b] bVS W\_cW`g eWZZ VSZ^ bVS 411 RSQWRS eVSbVS` Wb \SSRa b] W[^]aS O\g \Se `cZSa ]\ bVS eW`SZSaa W\Rcab`g BVS `S^]`b eWZZ OZa] PS acP[WbbSR b] 1]\U`Saa BVS Q][[WaaW]\ eO\ba b] µPSbbS` c\RS`abO\R bVS TOQb]`a bVOb R`WdS O\R S\Q]c`OUS W\dSab [S\b W\ eW`SZSaa O\R WRS\bWTg Q]\Q`SbS abS^a bVS Q][[WaaW]\ QO\ bOYS b] R`WdS W\\]dObW]\ W\ bVWa O`SO ¶ aOWR 8]SZ BOcPS\PZObb QVWST ]T bVS P`]ORPO\R RWdWaW]\ T]` bVS 411¸a EW`S ZSaa BSZSQ][[c\WQObW]\a 0c`SOc =\ bVS Q]\ac[S` aWRS bVS `S^]`b eWZZ Sf^Z]`S V]e W[^]`bO\b Qcab][S`a RSS[ bVS a^SQW¿Qa ]T bVSW` ^ZO\a W\ ORRWbW]\ b] _cOZWbg ]T aS`dWQS O\R S_cW^[S\b 7b eWZZ OZa] Z]]Y Ob bVS bg^S ]T W\T]`[ObW]\ Q]\ac[S`a \SSR PST]`S aSZSQbW\U O ^ZO\ Oa eSZZ Oa PO``WS`a b] c\RS`abO\RW\U O QSZZ ^V]\S PWZZ [OYW\U QVO\USa O\R Q]\bSabW\U TSSa O\R QVO`USa

EVWZS W\Rcab`g U`]c^a acQV Oa 1B7/ aOg bVS <=7a O`S O\ µ]^^]`bc\Wbg b] `Sa^]\R¶ b] bVS 411¸a _cSabW]\a´O\R ]cbaWRS Q`WbWQWa[´ ]bVS`a aSS Wb Oa O QVO\QS b] ¿\OZZg aQ`cbW\WhS O\ W\Rcab`g bVOb VOa U]\S c\QVSQYSR µBVWa W\dSabWUObW]\ Wa Z]\U ]dS`RcS ¶ aOga /\R`Se 8Og AQVeO`bh[O\ ^`SaWRS\b O\R 13= ]T bVS \]\^`]TWb ^cPZWQ W\bS`Sab ZOe ¿`[ ;/> µBVS Q]c\b`g¸a T]c` [OX]` eW`SZSaa ^`]dWRS`a VOdS S\X]gSR bVS T`cWba ]T [O`YSb ^]eS` T]` b]] [O\g gSO`a Ob bVS Sf^S\aS ]T bVS ^cPZWQ¸a OPWZWbg b] UOW\ OQQSaa b] Z]e Q]ab []PWZS P`]ORPO\R aS`dWQSa ¶ >cPZWQ 9\]eZSRUS ^`SaWRS\b O\R Q] T]c\RS` 5WUW A]V\ aOga bVOb µT]` b]] Z]\U bVS O^^SO`O\QS ]T Q][^SbWbW]\ O[]\U O TSe QO``WS`a VOa [OaYSR c\RS`ZgW\U O\bW Q][ ^SbWbWdS W\Rcab`g ^`OQbWQSa `O\UW\U T`][ Q]\ ac[S` Q]\b`OQba b] `]O[W\U OU`SS[S\ba ¶ D]7> ^`]dWRS` AYg^S eVWQV VOa VOR O `]QYg `SZObW]\aVW^ eWbV a][S eW`SZSaa Q][ ^O\WSa aOga bVS ^`]PS QO\ W\Q`SOaS Q][ ^SbWbW]\ O\R W\\]dObW]\ Pg µOaYW\U bVS `WUVb _cSabW]\a ¶´1VZ]S /ZPO\SaWca

03AB =4 B63 7<B3@<3B ;72=;7 ;WR][W Wa O ESP aS`dWQS bVOb ZSba g]c aW\U Vc[ ]` eVWabZS O a]\U W\b] g]c` Q][^cbS`¸a [WQ`]^V]\S O\R bVS aS`dWQS eWZZ WRS\bWTg bVS a]\U BVS`S¸a OZa] O a]QWOZ \Sbe]`Y O\R [caWQ aVO`W\U aS`dWQS PcWZb W\ ´/ZO\ 6S\`g

>/2;/>>3@ >OR[O^^S` bOYSa 1`OWUaZWab `S\bOZ ZWabW\Ua O\R ^cba bVS[ ]\ O 5]]UZS [O^ b] P`]eaS O\R ¿ZbS` POaSR ]\ `S\b YSge]`R ^Sb T`WS\RZW\Saa ]` SdS\ RWa bO\QS b] [Oaa b`O\aWb G]c QO\ SdS\ aOdS ZWabW\Ua b] 5]]UZS ;O^a ´/6

& >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< =1B=03@ '

@317>3>C>>G EWbV bVWa aWbS g]c Xcab bg^S W\ bVS bVW\Ua g]c VOdS W\ g]c` ^O\b`g ]` bVS T`WRUS O\R bVS aS`dWQS eWZZ ^cZZ b]USbVS` `SQW^Sa bVOb caS bV]aS W\U`S RWS\ba BVS `SacZba ^OUS OZa] W\QZcRSa O ZWab ]T acUUSabSR W\U`SRWS\ba ´/6

1OPZS 4`SS 5ORUSb`g EW`SZSaa ^]eS` Q]cZR ¿\OZZg PS QZ]aS b] [O`YSb /ZbV]cUV eW`SZSaa ^]eS` eOa ¿`ab `SdSOZSR Ob 13A W\ % bVS bSQV \]Z]Ug VOa aW\QS PSS\ aZ]e b] `]ZZ ]cb 0cb bVOb Q]cZR PS QVO\UW\U bVO\Ya b] O U`]c^ QOZZSR bVS EW`SZSaa >]eS` 1]\a]`bWc[ BVS Q]\ a]`bWc[ eVWQV W\QZcRSa Q][^O\WSa acQV Oa 4cZb]\ 7\\]dObW]\ <ObW]\OZ AS[WQ]\RcQb]` =Zg[^ca >VWZW^a O\R AO[ ac\U `SQS\bZg O\\]c\QSR O a^SQW¿QObW]\ T]` eW`SZSaa ^]eS` DS`aW]\ '# Wa O abO\RO`R T]` ^]eS` dWO [OU\SbWQ W\RcQbW]\ W\ eVWQV RSdWQSa QO\ PS QVO`USR Pg ^ZOQW\U bVS[ ]\ O Q][^ObWPZS ^]eS` ^OR B] WRS\bWTg bVS a^SQ O\R Q][^ObWPZS ^`]RcQba bVS U`]c^ c\dSWZSR Wba ]T¿QWOZ Z]U] eVWQV Wa O `S\RS`W\U ]T bVS 1VW\SaS e]`R ?W ^`]\]c\QSR µQVW¶ eVWQV [SO\a µdWbOZ S\S`Ug¶ O\R Wa ]TbS\ Oaa]QWObSR eWbV bVS P]Rg¸a ZWTS T]`QS /QQ]`RW\U b] 1O[WZZS BO\U Q] QVOW` ]T bVS EW`SZSaa >]eS` 1]\a]`bWc[¸a >`][]bW]\ E]`Y 5`]c^ bVS Q][^O\WSa W\ bVS Q]\a]` bWc[ e]`YSR dS`g QZ]aSZg T]` aSdS\ []\bVa b] Q][S c^ eWbV bVS a^SQ AcQV Q]ZZOP]`O bW]\ eWZZ OZa] µ^OdS bVS eOg T]` O\ OQQSZS` ObSR `SZSOaS aQVSRcZS ]T bVS abO\RO`R ¶

BO\U aOga DS`aW]\ Wa Sf^SQbSR b] PS O\\]c\QSR Pg ZObS TOZZ BVS Qc``S\b a^SQ Wa RSaWU\SR b] ^`]dWRS c^ b] # eObba ]T ^]eS` S\]cUV b] ^]eS` O QSZZ ^V]\S ]` O\ ;>! ^ZOgS` OQQ]`RW\U b] bVS Q]\a]`bWc[ 4cZb]\ 7\\]dObW]\ Wa ]\S ]T bVS ¿`ab Q][ ^O\WSa ]cb ]T bVS UObS eWbV ^`]b]bg^S ^`]R cQba 7ba S1]c^ZSR ZW\S TSObc`Sa QVO`UW\U ^ORa T]` V][Sa O\R QO`a =bVS` Q][^O\WSa ]cbaWRS bVS Q]\a]`bWc[ VOdS PSS\ e]`Y W\U ]\ bVSW` ]e\ dS`aW]\a ]T eW`SZSaa ^]eS` acQV Oa 7\bSZ eWbV Wba `ORWO\b eW`SZSaa bSQV \]Z]Ug eVWQV W\d]ZdSa PSO[W\U ^]eS` OQ`]aa O\ OW` UO^ O\R >]eS`QOab eVWQV Wa RSdSZ]^W\U RSdWQSa bVOb caS `ORW] eOdSa Oa O b`O\a[WaaW]\ [SRWc[ T]` eW`SZSaa ^]eS` ´;O`Y 6OQV[O\ =1B=03@ ' >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< '

4@=<BA723

03AB =4 =C@ 0:=5A 53/@:=5 / <Se BeWab ]\ ESPQO[a 7T g]c¸`S Z]]YW\U T]` O PSb bS` eOg b] dWRS]Q]\TS`S\QS bVS 6S`QcZSa 2cOZ^Wf 62% VOa O TSe W[^`SaaWdS TSObc`Sa bVOb aS^O`ObS Wb T`][ bVS `Sab 4]` ]\S Wb ]TTS`a & Pg % ! T^a VWUV RS¿\WbW]\ dWRS] EVOb `SOZZg W[^`SaaSa bV]cUV Wa bVS ^VgaWQOZ RSaWU\ BVWa 2cOZ^Wf QO\ PS ObbOQVSR b] bVS b]^ ]` aWRS ]T g]c` \]bSP]]Y O\R QO\ beWab T]` bVS PSab QO[S`O O\UZS EVS\ g]c `]bObS bVS QO[S`O bVS ]\ aQ`SS\ W[OUS Ocb][ObW QOZZg Q]``SQba WbaSZT /\R bVWa QO[S`O Wa [ORS b] e]`Y eSZZ W\ Z]e ZWUVb Q]\RWbW]\a 7b Wa OdOWZ OPZS T`][ /[Oh]\ <Se3UU O\R ]bVS` `SbOWZS`a T]` #' '' ZWab ´B`]g 2`SWS`

A31C@7BG E/B16 ;WQ`]a]Tb :Waba B]^ EW\R]ea ;OZeO`S 0OaSR ]\ RObO T`][ Wba ;OZW QW]ca A]TbeO`S @S[]dOZ B]]Z ;WQ`]a]Tb `SQS\bZg `SZSOaSR O ZWab ]T bVS b]^ bS\ [OZeO`S bV`SOba bVOb bVS b]]Z VOa `S[]dSR T`][ EW\R]ea agabS[a 4O[WZg ;OQVW\S 1]c\b BObS`T "$! @S\]a & '%! ! /Zc`S]\ "" " 4OYS@SO\ $ ! & # 0O\Q]a #& # $ 9]]PTOQS !" !' % 4`SbV]U ! & % & 1cbeOWZ &" ' @cab]QY ' %&& BWPa &" & ´:O``g ASZbhS`

5==21:3/<B316 / >]eS` >ZO\b W\ G]c` 6O\R /TbS` O Z]\U ZW\S ]T ^`]RcQba bVOb W\QZcRSa O PWQgQZS ZWUVbW\U O\R O\ Oaa]`b[S\b ]T VO\R O\R ZO^ eO`[ S`a AO\g] VOa ORRSR O ^]`bOPZS a]ZO` US\S`Ob]` b] Wba S\SZ]]^ ^`]RcQb ZW\S BVS US\S`Ob]` caSa AO\g]¸a 67B a]ZO` QSZZa O\R O aW[^ZS [SaV POU V]caSa bVS QVO`US` /\ OQQSaa]`g T]` bVS QVO`US` ZSba g]c QVO`US bVS W\bS`\OZ ZWbVWc[ W]\ PObbS`g dWO CA0 ^]`b BVS S\SZ]]^ aW\UZS ^O\SZ QVO`US` QO\ ^]eS` O ^V]\S T]` [W\cbSa T]` bVS aO[S O[]c\b ]T QVO`UW\U bW[S ´;O`WSZZO ;]]\

.E=@9 7][SUO¸a 0WU <Se </A BVS ZObSab T]c` R`WdS RSaYb]^ \Sbe]`Y ObbOQVSR ab]`OUS </A RSdWQS T`][ 7][SUO bVS Ab]`1S\bS` Wf" R \]e ac^^]`ba O \c[ PS` ]T \Se TSObc`Sa W\QZcRW\U RSdWQS b] RSdWQS `S^ZWQObW]\ [cZbW^ZS @/72 Q]\¿Uc`ObW]\a RcOZ 5WUOPWb 3bVS`\Sb ^]`ba O\R Q][^ObWPWZWbg eWbV /^^ZS¸a BW[S ;OQVW\S G]c OZa] USb bV`SS CA0 ^]`ba T]` ORRW\U ^`W\bS`a ]` SfbS`\OZ R`WdSa BVS Wf" R Q][Sa W\ bV`SS QO^OQWbWSa( BS`OPgbSa T]` % "B0 T]` ' O\R &B0 T]` ' ´3`WQ 5`WT¿bV >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< =1B=03@ '

Rock the world with your vision of tomorrow.

Introducing the Intel® Core™ i7 Custom Desktop Challenge www.intelcorechallenge.com

Help us celebrate the launch of Intel Core™ i7 and Core™ i5 processors. ®

Can you design the world’s coolest desktop mod?

Submit your creations by November 16, 2009 for a chance to win amazing prizes.

No purchase necessary. Void where prohibited. You need to be 18 years or older to participate. See participating countries and rules at www.intelcorechallenge.com. © 2009 Intel Corporation. All rights reserved. Intel, Intel logo, Intel Core, Core Inside, Core Inside logo, Sponsors of Tomorrow are trademarks of Intel Corporation in the U.S. and other countries.

4@=<BA723

1]\\SQbSR B`OdSZS`

;caWQ b] G]c` B`OdSZW\U 3O`a >WQY bVS `WUVb VSOR^V]\Sa T]` g]c` \Sfb b`W^ >S`VO^a bVS []ab ^OW\TcZ aS^O`ObW]\ PSbeSS\ g]c`aSZT O\R be] R]ZZO`a Wa ^OgW\U T]` Z]cag OW`ZW\S VSOR^V]\Sa PSQOcaS g]c T]`U]b g]c` ]e\ / U]]R ^OW` ]T VSOR^V]\Sa ]` SO`PcRa []`S bVO\ ^Og T]` bVS[aSZdSa Pg ^`]dWRW\U Q]c\bZSaa V]c`a ]T S\X]g[S\b b] ^Oaa O ^ZO\S b`OW\ ]` Pca `WRS A] eVSbVS` g]c eO\b b] R`]e\ ]cb O aQ`SO[W\U b]RRZS`

eObQV bVS W\ ÀWUVb []dWS ]` ZcZZ g]c`aSZT b] aZSS^ eWbV a][S 0`WO\ 3\] VS`S O`S a][S ]T ]c` b]^ ^WQYa 7T \]bVW\U Pcb bVS PSab eWZZ R] T]` g]c` bS\RS` Oc`WQZSa bVS Qc``S\b U]ZR abO\RO`R ]T \]WaS QO\QSZZW\U VSOR^V]\Sa T]` b`OdSZS`a Wa bVS I K 0]aS ?cWSb1][T]`b # '' '# RW`SQb 0]aS VOa P]]abSR bVS \]WaS QO\QSZZW\U QO^OPWZWbg ]T bVSaS VSOR ^V]\Sa aW\QS bVS ^`SdW]ca ?cWSb1][T]`b Pg ORRW\U O aSQ]\R [WQ`]^V]\S O\R caW\U []`S ORdO\QSR [ObS`WOZa W\ bVS ^ORRSR aSOZ O`]c\R bVS SO` BVSaS VSOR^V]\Sa T]ZR ÀOb b] aOdS a^OQS O\R ¿b W\b] O abc`Rg PZOQY QO` `gW\U QOaS G]c OZa] USb O\ OW`^ZO\S ORO^bS` O\R O RSbOQVOPZS OcRW] QOPZS 4]` bV]aS eV] abWZZ eO\b O\ ]dS` SO` VSOR^V]\S Pcb Ob O Z]eS` ^`WQS bVS I K AVc`S A@6"" >`]TSaaW]\OZ '' '' ZWab a]c\Ra TO\bOabWQ eWbV ab`]\U POaa `Sa^]\aS O\R Q`Wa^ VWUVa BVSaS VSOR ^V]\Sa OZa] Q][S eWbV O RSbOQVOPZS QOPZS BV]cUV bVSg O`S PcZYWS` bVO\ bVS ?cWSb 1][T]`b # bVSg R] T]ZR R]e\ SOaWZg b] TWb W\aWRS bVS W\QZcRSR ^]cQV EVS\ a^OQS W\ g]c` QO``g ]\ Wa Ob O ^`S [Wc[ Wb ^Oga b] b`OdSZ ZWUVb eWbV O U]]R ^OW`

!

]T SO`PcRa =c` Qc``S\b 3RWb]`a¸ 1V]WQS VS`S Wa bVS I!K 9ZW^aQV 7[OUS A"W '' '' RW`SQb 4]` W>]R O\R W>V]\S caS`a bVS A"W Wa O \] P`OW\S` PSQOcaS ]T Wba PcWZb W\ [WQ`]^V]\S O\R Q]\b`]ZZS` T]` d]WQS O\R [caWQ TSObc`Sa G]c QO\ TOab T]`eO`R aYW^ b`OQYa O\aeS` QOZZa O\R SdS\ OQbWdObS d]WQS Q]\b`]Za /\R WT g]c VOdS bVS ZObSab aVcTÀS g]c QO\ caS Wb b] Q]\b`]Z bVS `]P]b d]WQS bSZZ W\U g]c eVOb a]\U O\R O`bWab g]c¸`S ZWabS\W\U b] BVS A"W OZa] VOa O aSQc`S ¿b O\R Q][Sa eWbV T]c` aSba ]T aWZWQ]\S SO` bW^a /\]bVS` ^OW` ]T SO`PcRa bVOb QO\ R] R]cPZS Rcbg Oa O VO\Ra T`SS VSORaSb Wa bVS I"K /ZbSQ :O\aW\U 0OQY0SOb >Zca ;]PWZS #' '# ZWab \]b `ObSR BVSaS \]WaS Wa]ZOb W\U SO`PcRa VOdS O RWaQ`SSb W\ ZW\S [WQ T]` QOZZa Oa eSZZ Oa O QOZZ O\R O\aeS` Pcbb]\ /\R bVSW` VWUV Rg\O[WQ `O\US [SO\a g]c R]\¸b VOdS b] Q`O\Y bVS d]Zc[S b] VSO` bVS acPbZS VWUVa O\R Z]ea ]T g]c` TOd]`WbS [caWQ

#

4W\OZZg bVS I#K CZbW[ObS 3O`a ;Sb`]4W %' '' ZWab O`S U`SOb SO`PcRa T]` SdS`gROg ZWabS\W\U Oa eSZZ Oa b`OdSZW\U BVS ;Sb`]4W ¸a bWbO\Wc[ Q]ObSR a^SOYS`a RSZWdS` RSS^ POaa `Sa^]\aS eWbV ]cb RWab]`bW]\ /\R bVS bV`SS W\QZcRSR aWZW Q]\S bW^a S\ac`S O a\cU ¿b ´BW[ 5WRS]\ O\R 3`WY @VSg "

"

$ !"

7<A723 0CA7<3AA 6/@2E/@3 1=<AC;3@ 3:31B@=<71A A=4BE/@3

4W`ab

0CA7<3AA

!5 @]cbS`a T]` =\ BVS 5] ESP E]`Y dS`g ZO^b]^ Q][Sa eWbV EW 4W bVSaS ROga Pcb OZZ bVS EW 4W W\ bVS e]`ZR Wa caSZSaa WT g]c¸`S a] `S[]bS bVOb bVS`S¸a \] aWU\OZ BVS`S O`S O Z]b ]T ^cPZWQ V]b a^]ba ]cb bVS`S Pcb bVSg¸`S \]b SdS`geVS`S O\R bVS Q]\\SQbW]\ TSSa QO\ `SOZZg ORR c^ BVOb¸a eVg eW`SZSaa QO``WS`a ZWYS A^`W\b O\R DS`Wh]\ EW`SZSaa ]TTS` !5 aS`dWQS eVWQV QO\ a^`SOR O Z]b TO`bVS` Ob ZSOab W\ bVS `WUVb [O`YSba <]e eVOb WT g]c Q]cZR USb O `]cbS`´Xcab ZWYS bVS ]\S g]c caS ]\ g]c` V][S ]` ]T¿QS \Sbe]`Y´Pcb W\abSOR ]T EW 4W bVS POQY P]\S eOa bVOb eW`SZSaa !5 Q]\\SQbW]\- G]c Q]cZR Xcab ^ZcU bVOb CA0 POaSR !5 []RS[ R]\UZS W\ O\R bVS\ bOYS g]c` EW 4W eWbV g]c O\geVS`S´W\ bVS]`g AcQV Wa bVS QOaS eWbV bV`SS ]T bVS ^`]RcQba W\ bVWa U`]c^

:W\Yaga EW`SZSaa 5 @]cbS` T]` ;]PWZS 0`]ORPO\R E@B#"5!5D AB BVS ZObSab US\S`ObW]\ ]T bVS :W\Yaga EW`S ZSaa 5 @]cbS` T]` ;]PWZS 0`]ORPO\R ]TTS`a TO` []`S bVO\ O \Se P]Rg 7b Q][PW\Sa & U EW 4W eWbV !5´ac^^]aSRZg T`][

" >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< =1B=03@ '

Product name in RED indicates Editors’ Choice.

E

=C@ @/B7<5A 93G( 3F13::3<B D3@G 5==2 5==2 4/7@ >==@

>:3<BG =4 >=@BA BVS :W\Yaga !5 `]cbS` VOa O dO`WSbg ]T Q]\\SQ bW]\ ]^bW]\a

:W\Yaga EW`SZSaa 5 @]cbS` T]` ;]PWZS 0`]ORPO\R E@B#"5!5D AB ! ab`SSb

>@=A 5`SOb aSQc`Wbg TSObc`Sa B]^ \]bQV ^S` T]`[O\QS T]` O\ U `]cbS` 3fb`O ^]`ba T]` Sf^O\aW]\ 3OaWSab `]cbS` aSbc^ ]\ bVS [O`YSb E]`YSR eWbV A^`W\b O\R DS`Wh]\ 3D 2= W\ bSab W\U bV]cUV [O`YSbSR Oa WT ]\Zg T]` A^`W\b 1=<A B]] PWU T]` b`cS []PWZWbg & U ]\Zg \]b \ 1:719 63@3 4=@ ;=@3

A^`W\b 3D 2= bV]cUV ]c` bSab c\Wb e]`YSR eWbV O DS`Wh]\ EW`SZSaa !5 []RS[´]` O eW`SR 2A: QOPZS Q]\\SQbW]\ G]c QO\ SdS\ caS O 5 5>@A aS`dWQS W\ O ^W\QV C\ZWYS bVS be] ^]QYSb aWhS `]cbS`a W\ bVWa `]c\Rc^ bVS :W\Yaga `]cbS`¸a `SZObWdSZg ZO`US

aWhS´$ % Pg $ % Pg W\QVSa 6E2 ´ [OYSa Wb []`S abObW]\O`g bVO\ bVS ]bVS`a BVS`S¸a OZa] \] ]^bW]\ T]` PObbS`g ^]eS` BVS Q]\ ¿Uc`ObW]\ W\bS`TOQS Wa bVS aO[S Oa bVS \SeS` :W\Yaga \ `]cbS`a ac^^]`bW\U Q][[]\ TSO bc`Sa acQV Oa T`SS Rg\O[WQ 2<A Rg\O[WQ =1B=03@ ' >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< #

47@AB :==9A 0CA7<3AA

A^`W\b ;W4W

6]ba^]b

'' RW`SQb eWbV # `SPObS eWbV gSO` ^ZO\

>@=A 3Oag b] abO`b O\R caS >]QYSb aWhS Wa U`SOb T]` b`OdSZ W\U 4`SS 5>A aS`dWQS W\bSU`Ob SR e]`Ya eWbV 5]]UZS ;O^a O\R ]bVS` aS`dWQSa 1=<A @c\a V]b 0ObbS`g R`OW\a _cWQYZg eVS\ [cZbW^ZS EW 4W RSdWQSa Q]\\SQb <] !5 Q]\ \SQbWdWbg eVS\ QVO`UW\U 1:719 63@3 4=@ ;=@3

`]cbW\U ;/1 ORR`Saa QZ]\W\U A>7 O\R </B ¿`SeOZZa D>< ^Oaa bV`]cUV O\R ESP CbWZ Wbg OQQSaa EVS\ 7 bSabSR bVS :W\Yaga `]cbS` eWbV A^SSRBSab \Sb 7 U]b O\ OdS`OUS ;P^a bV`]cUV^cb ]\ A^`W\b¸a !5 \Sbe]`Y O\R O aW[WZO` aQ]`S ]\ DS`Wh]\¸a BVWa `]cbS` Wa PcZYg Pcb eVOb Wb ZOQYa W\ b`OdSZW\U Q]\dS\WS\QS Wb [OYSa c^ W\ Wba SfbS\aWdS TSObc`Sa Ob O `SOa]\OPZS ^`WQS BVS & U Wa TOabS` O\R Wba aW\UZS O\bS\\O VOa PSbbS` `SOQV bVO\ Wba QZ]aSab Q][^SbW b]`a BVS E@B#"5!5D AB¸a aSQc`Wbg TSO bc`Sa [OYS Wb WRSOZ T]` a[OZZ PcaW\SaaSa b]] 7b¸a \]b ZW[WbSR b] ]\S QO``WS` RSa^WbS eVOb bVS [O`YSbW\U [ObS`WOZa aOg O\R Wba []PWZWbg TSObc`Sa O`S dS`aObWZS CZbW[ObSZg bVWa :W\Yaga `]cbS` QO\ aS`dS g]c` PcaW\Saa PSbbS` bVO\ Xcab OP]cb O\g ]bVS` RSdWQS ]cb bVS`S bVca ]c` RSQWaW]\ b] OeO`R Wb O\ 3RW b]`a¸ 1V]WQS T]` !5 `]cbS`a $ >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< =1B=03@ '

A^`W\b ;W4W 6]ba^]b A^`W\b ZWYS DS`Wh]\ \]e ]TTS`a <]dObSZ¸a ^]QYSb aWhSR ;W4W V]ba^]b BVS ;W4W []PWZS EW 4W Wa O EW 4W `]cbS` eWbV O\ W\bS U`ObSR !5 []RS[ caW\U A^`W\b¸a 3D 2= \Sbe]`Y´O\R ]\Zg A^`W\b¸a 3D 2=´b] ^`] dWRS 7\bS`\Sb OQQSaa BV]cUV a[OZZ bVS ;W4W Wa QO^OPZS ]T [O\OUW\U ¿dS EW 4W RSdWQSa Ob O [OfW[c[ RWabO\QS ]T OP]cb " TSSb eVWZS ^]eS`SR Pg O PObbS`g O ZWbbZS PWUUS` bVO\ O 1][^OQb4ZOaV QO`R 7b ac^^]`ba ]\Zg bVS ]ZRS` & U abO\RO`R Pcb Wb ^OQYa [O\g \Sbe]`YW\U TSObc`Sa acQV Oa D>< ^Oaa bV`]cUV ^]`b TWZbS`W\U O\R 261> aS`dS` Q]\TWUc`ObW]\ ^Zca A^`W\b W\bSU`ObSR 5>A W\b] bVS ;W4W O QO^OPWZWbg [WaaW\U W\ DS`W h]\¸a dS`aW]\ EWbV bVS A^`W\b ;W4W 7 eOa OPZS b] WRS\ bWTg bVS AA72 O\R Q]\\SQb Ob # TSSb O\R bVS RSdWQS `SOQVSR O [OfW[c[ bV`]cUV^cb ]T

DS`Wh]\ ;W4W 7\bSZZWUS\b ;]PWZS 6]ba^]b '' eWbV # `SPObS O\R gSO` ^ZO\

>@=A AW[^ZS b] caS 5`SOb EW 4W `O\US B`OdSZ T`WS\RZg aWhS 1=<A @c\a V]b 0ObbS`g ^]eS` R`]^a _cWQYZg eWbV [cZbW^ZS RSdWQSa BWSR b] DS`Wh]\ EW`S ZSaa 3D 2= aS`dWQS ]\Zg 1:719 63@3 4=@ ;=@3

;P^a T]` R]e\Z]ORa O\R %$ ;P^a T]` c^Z]ORa =dS`OZZ bVS A^`W\b R]Sa O PSbbS` X]P bVO\ DS`Wh]\ [OYSa Wb SOaWS` b] caS O\R Q][Sa QVSO^S` WT g]c RSQWRS b] USb bVS AW[^Zg 3dS`gbVW\U ^ZO\ DS`Wh]\ ;W4W 7\bSZZWUS\b ;]PWZS 6]ba^]b DS`Wh]\¸a dS`aW]\ ]T bVS ;W4W QO\ caS ]\Zg DS`Wh]\¸a \Sbe]`Y´g]c QO\¸b ^ZcU O\g ]bVS` !5 []RS[ W\b] Wb >]eS`SR ]\Zg Pg O PObbS`g bVS DS`Wh]\ ;W4W ^`]dWRSa 7\bS` \Sb OQQSaa b] c^ b] ¿dS RSdWQSa W\ O `O\US ]T OP]cb ! b] " TSSb dWO & U \]b bVS TOabS` & \ BVS W\QZcRSR DH/QQSaa ;O\OUS[S\b QZW S\b O^^ZWQObW]\ VOa O ;WQ`]a]Tb D>< QZWS\b BSfb ;SaaOUW\U b]]Z O\R Wb ^`]dWRSa W\T]` [ObW]\ ]\ g]c` EW 4W \Sbe]`Y DH/QQSaa

Wa aZWUVbZg SOaWS` b] caS bVO\ bVS ]bVS` W\bS` TOQSa Pcb Wb VOa a][S [W\]` PcUa´ZWYS \]b RSbSQbW\U eW`SZSaa \Sbe]`Ya eWbV VWRRS\ AA72a SdS\ WT bVS \Sbe]`Ya eS`S ^`STS``SR \Sbe]`Ya W\ EW\R]ea 0ObbS`g ZWTS T]` bVS ;W4W `ObSR Ob " V]c`a eWbV Q]\abO\b caS R`]^a [cQV TOabS` eWbV [cZbW^ZS RSdWQSa( Xcab ]dS` ' [W\cbSa eWbV T]c` EW 4W Q]\\SQbW]\a 7 ^WQYSR c^ bVS AA72 ]T bVS ;W4W Ob OZ[]ab # TSSb Pcb bVS aS`dWQS eOa a^]`ORWQ 7\ ]c` a^SSR bSaba bVS DS`Wh]\ ;W4W `SOQVSR Wba VWUVSab bV`]cUV^cb a^SSR Ob # ;P^a T]` R]e\Z]ORa O\R ' ;P^a T]` c^Z]ORa /ZbV]cUV bVS DS`Wh]\ ;W4W `c\a O PWb V]b bS` bVO\ 7 ^`STS` Sa^SQWOZZg WT Wb¸a U]W\U b] PS W\ g]c` ^]QYSb O\R PObbS`g ZWTS Wa b]] aV]`b bVWa RSdWQS Wa abWZZ O U]]R POaWQ QV]WQS T]` USbbW\U bVS ESP ]\ bVS U] ´3`WQ 5`WTTWbV O\R ;O`W] ;]`SX]\ =1B=03@ ' >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< %

47@AB :==9A 0CA7<3AA

6> =T¿QSXSb $ EW`SZSaa >`W\bS` ' '' RW`SQb

>@=A 4Oab 6WUV _cOZWbg U`O^VWQa O\R ^V]b]a 3bVS`\Sb O\R EW 4W 0cWZb W\ Rc^ZSfS` T]` aWRSR ^`W\bW\U 1=<A /ZbV]cUV bSfb _cOZWbg Wa U]]R S\]cUV T]` []ab a[OZZ O\R V][S ]T¿QS \SSRa Wb¸a O b]cQV PSZ]e ^O`

6> =T¿QSXSb $ EW`SZSaa >`W\bS`

/ EW\\W\U A[OZZ =T¿QS 7\Y 8Sb /ZZ W\ ]\Sa /7=a VOdS ZO`USZg bOYS\ ]dS` bVS W\Y XSb [O`YSb Pcb WT g]c R]\¸b \SSR O ^`W\bS` bVOb aQO\a Q]^WSa ]` TOfSa g]c QO\ USb O Z]b []`S PO\U T]` bVS PcQY T`][ ]\S bVOb R]Sa\¸b R] O\gbVW\U Pcb ^`W\b BVS =TTWQSXSb $ ]TTS`a TOab a^SSR `SOa]\OPZg U]]R ]cb ^cb _cOZWbg ^O^S` VO\RZW\U acWb OPZS T]` O a[OZZ ]` V][S ]T¿QS O\R O `SZObWdSZg Z]e Q]ab ^S` ^OUS OZZ T]` TO` ZSaa bVO\ O Q][^O`OPZS /7= 2Sa^WbS ]TTS`W\U `SOa]\OPZg VWUV _cOZWbg ^V]b] ]cb^cb bVS $ Wa QZSO`Zg RSaWU\SR Oa O\ ]TTWQS ^`W\bS` T]QcaW\U ]\ TSObc`Sa W[^]`bO\b T]` O\ ]TTWQS acQV Oa O\ O[^ZS # aVSSb W\^cb QO^OQWbg O\R O\ Ocb][ObWQ Rc^ZSfS` T]` ^`W\bW\U ]\ P]bV aWRSa ]T O ^OUS /\R bVS ^`W\bS`¸a VWUV QO^OQWbg QO` & >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< =1B=03@ '

b`WRUSa gWSZR O `SZObWdSZg Z]e Q]ab % QS\ba ^S` []\]QV`][S ^OUS O\R ' QS\ba ^S` Q]Z]` ^OUS =\ ]c` PcaW\Saa O^^ZWQObW]\a acWbS bVS $ QZ]QYSR O bW[S ]T [W\cbSa !" aSQ ]\Ra [OYW\U Wb bVS TOabSab aW\UZS Tc\QbW]\ W\Y XSb W\ Wba ^`WQS `O\US b] RObS 6]eSdS` caW\U bVS Rc^ZSfS` aZ]ea bVS ^`W\bS`¸a a^SSR aWU\W¿QO\bZg BVS $ ¸a ]cb^cb _cOZWbg Wa O b]cQV PSZ]e ^O` T]` O\ W\Y XSb T]` bSfb OP]dS ^O` T]` U`O^VWQa O\R Ob bVS Z]e S\R ]T bVS bg^WQOZ `O\US T]` ^V]b]a /\R bVWa ^`W\bS` X]W\a a][S ]bVS` `SQS\b 6> ^`W\bS`a W\ SO`\ W\U bVS >1;OU 5`SS\BSQV /^^`]dSR aSOZ =dS`OZZ bVS $ ]TTS`a O\ Obb`OQbWdS POZ O\QS ]T a^SSR ]cb^cb _cOZWbg ^O^S` VO\ RZW\U ^`WQS O\R Q]ab ^S` ^OUS [OYW\U Wb ]c` \Se 3RWb]`a¸ 1V]WQS ´; 2OdWR Ab]\S ,,1:719 63@3 4=@ ;=@3

47@AB :==9A 0CA7<3AA

6B1 B]cQV >`] B ;]PWZS !# ab`SSb

>@=A A]ZWR PcWZR 5]]R QOZZ _cOZWbg 5`SOb QOZZW\U TSObc`Sa 5]`US]ca \Se ORR`Saa P]]Y QOZS\RO` RWOZS` O\R V][S aQ`SS\ O^^ZWQObW]\a 1=<A CaW\U VSOR^V]\Sa `S_cW`Sa S[PO``OaaW\U R]\UZS 8S`Yg dWRS] ^ZOgPOQY

6B1 B]cQV >`] B ;]PWZS

BVS 0Sab EW\R]ea ;]PWZS >V]\S 3dS`W[^Zg abObSR bVS B]cQV >`] T]` B ;]PWZS Wa bVS PSab EW\R]ea ;]PWZS $ ^V]\S ]\ bVS [O`YSb 0cb eVWZS Wba ORR`Saa P]]Y Wa O e]`Y ]T O`b O\R Wb e]cZR [OYS O U`SOb ORRWbW]\ b] O\g ;WQ`]a]Tb 3fQVO\US POaSR PcaW\Saa Wba Q]PPZSR b]USbVS` W\bS` TOQS O\R [SRWO ^ZOgPOQY ^`]PZS[a V]ZR ca POQY T`][ UWdW\U Wb O\ 3RWb]`a¸ 1V]WQS BVS B]cQV >`] Wa RS¿\WbSZg O PcZYg ^V]\S Ob " $ Pg ! Pg % 6E2 W\QVSa O\R $ ! ]c\QSa 0cb W\ bVWa PWU ^V]\S g]c USb O dOab ! $ W\QV `SaWabWdS b]cQV ^O\SZ bVOb aZWRSa b] bVS aWRS O\R bWZba c^ ZWYS O ZWbbZS ZO^b]^ EWbV bVS aQ`SS\ ]^S\ g]c QO\ bg^S ]\ O VcUS ¿dS `]e ?E3@BG YSgP]O`R BVWa ^V]\S Wa OZa] dS`g U]]R T]` d]WQS _cOZWbg eWbV QOZZa a]c\RW\U Z]cR O\R aVO`^ bV`]cUV bVS SO`

S

^WSQS @4 `SQS^bW]\ Wa\¸b TOPcZ]ca Pcb Wb¸a U]]R S\]cUV BVS a^SOYS`^V]\S Wa `SOa]\ OPZg Z]cR Oa O`S `W\Ub]\Sa EW\R]ea ;]PWZS $ Wa ]ZR O\R Q`SOYg O\R 6B1 VOa R]\S Wba PSab b] R`Saa c^ bVS W\bS` TOQS bV]cUV bVS ^V]\S e]`Ya PSab Oa O PcaW \Saa Q][[c\WQOb]` 7b¸a TcZZ ]T caSTcZ ZWbbZS ORdO\QSa ZWYS ZSbbW\U g]c Q`SObS Q]\TS`S\QS QOZZa ]\ bVS TZg `Sa^]\R b] O\ S [OWZ eWbV O d]WQS QOZZ O\R []`S ESP P`]eaW\U eWbV =^S`O ;]PWZS ' % Wa\¸b POR Pcb ^ZOgW\U POQY [caWQ O\R dWRS] eOa O V]``S\R]ca Sf^S`W S\QS 7ba QO[S`O OZa] ZSOdSa a][SbVW\U b] PS RSaW`SR =dS`OZZ bVS B]cQV >`] Wa O\ SfQSZ ZS\b eOg T]` PcaW\Saa ^S]^ZS b] abOg W\ b]cQV Pcb Wb¸a O \Se =A OeOg T`][ PSW\U O e]`ZR QZOaa a[O`b ^V]\S ´AOaQVO ASUO\ ,,1:719 63@3 4=@ ;=@3 =1B=03@ ' >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< '

47@AB :==9A 6/@2E/@3

2SZZ AbcRW] ### CA3 $1A

/ 4c\RO[S\bOZZg A]c\R :O^b]^ BVS 2SZZ AbcRW] ### Wa O\ OTT]`R OPZS RSaYb]^ `S^ZOQS[S\b bVOb Wa \SWbVS` b]] QVSO^ b] PS QOZZSR O `SQSaaW]\ a^SQWOZ \]` Sf^S\aWdS S\]cUV b] PS ZOPSZSR O ^]eS` V]caS /ZZ ]T Wba Q][^]\S\ba O`S PSbbS` bVO\ eVOb g]c e]cZR Sf^SQb Ob bVWa ^`WQS BV]cUV Wb Wa\¸b Oa OTT]`ROPZS Oa bVS 5ObSeOg <D#& %c $ ]` bVS 6> >OdWZW]\ Rd$b ! ca %# Wba Q][^`SVS\aWdS O``Og ]T ^]`ba # 50 VO`R R`WdS O\R $ V]c`a ]T PObbS`g ZWTS []`S bVO\ XcabW¿Sa bVWa ^`WQS RWT TS`S\QS BVS AbcRW] ### Wa O`UcOPZg ]\S ]T bVS PcZYWSab # W\QV ZO^b]^a 7¸dS SdS` aSS\ [SO ac`W\U ]dS` # W\QVSa bVWQY Ob bVS POQY /b # & ^]c\Ra bV]cUV Wb¸a Oa ZWUVb Oa bVS 2SZZ 7\a^W`]\ #"# W #"# CA3 AB O\R ZWUVbS` bVO\ bVS 6> Rd$b $ ^]c\Ra a] Wba Z]]Ya O`S RSQSWdW\U BVWa agabS[ VOa O # $ W\QV !$$ Pg %$& eWRSaQ`SS\ RWa^ZOg bVOb ]TTS`a ^ZS\bg ]T aQ`SS\ `SOZ SabObS T]` []ab [cZbW[SRWO bOaYa ;]ab ]T Wba ]bVS` TSObc`Sa O`S Q][^O `OPZS eWbV Wba Q][^SbWb]`a SfQS^b bVOb eWbV bVS ### g]c USb O # 50 VO`R R`WdS W\abSOR ]T bVS ! 50 ]` ZSaa R`WdSa W\QZcRSR SZaS

7

eVS`S /ZbV]cUV Wb R]Sa \]b VOdS O aS^O`ObS \c[S`WQ YSg^OR bVS YSgP]O`R \]\SbVSZSaa ]TTS`a O ac^S`P bg^W\U Sf^S`WS\QS eWbV YSga bVOb O`S a]Tb O\R aWZS\b Oa eSZZ Oa O ^S`TSQbZg QOZWP`ObSR b]cQV^OR BVS ###¸a PcRUSb ^`WQS c\T]`bc\ObSZg Wa O [W``]` `SÀSQbW]\ ]T Wba \]\ ¿`S P`SObV W\U ^O`ba =\ ]c` ^S`T]`[O\QS bSaba bVS ###¸a 56h 7\bSZ 1]`S 2c] B$# eOa \] aZ]e ^]YS Pcb bVS W\bSU`ObSR U`O^VWQa [SO\a bVOb !2 W\bS\aWdS UO[Sa eWZZ PS aZcU UWaV 6]eSdS` Wba >1;O`Y DO\bOUS aQ]`S PSOb []ab ]T bVS Q][^O`Wa]\ agabS[a /\R bVO\Ya b] bVS ###¸a ' QSZZ &# EV PObbS`g bVWa agabS[ bc`\SR W\ O ab`]\U aQ]`S ]T $ V]c`a ]\ ;]PWZS;O`Y % /ZbV]cUV bVS ### Wa\¸b bVS ^`SbbWSab ZO^b]^ b] U`OQS O ab]`S aVSZT Wb Wa bVS PSab RSaYb]^ `S^ZOQS[S\b ZO^b]^ W\ bVS $ b] & ^`WQS `O\US BVWa agabS[ `OWaSa bVS abOYSa T]` Wba Q][^SbWb]`a W\ O`SOa acQV Oa VO`R R`WdS QO^OQWbg PObbS`g ZWTS O\R eO` `O\bg 4]` bVSaS `SOa]\a Wb SO`\a O\ 3RWb]`a¸ 1V]WQS T]` PcRUSb RSaYb]^ `S^ZOQS[S\b agabS[a ´1WaQ] 1VS\U ,,1:719 63@3 4=@ ;=@3

A>31A 56h 7\bSZ 1]`S 2c] B$# ) "50 22@ A2@/;) # 50 VO`R R`WdS) # $ W\QV RWa^ZOg) 7\bSZ EW 4W :W\Y # /5<) # & ^]c\Ra) ! CA0 ^]`ba) &# EV PObbS`g) EW\R]ea DWabO 6][S >`S[Wc[ $" PWb

>1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< =1B=03@ '

2SZZ AbcRW] ### CA3 $1A %'' ZWab

>@=A /TT]`ROPZS B]^ V]\]`a W\ PObbS`g ZWTS AZ]b Z]ORW\U 2D2 Pc`\S` 1][^`SVS\aWdS O``Og ]T ^]`ba :O`US P`WUVb RWa^ZOg DS`g U]]R ^S`T]`[O\QS aQ]`Sa 3fQSZZS\b bg^W\U O\R \OdWUOb W\U Sf^S`WS\QS Be] gSO` eO``O\bg 1=<A 2SaWU\ Wa bVWQY O\R P]`W\U >3@4=@;/<13 B3ABA

MULTIMEDIA TESTS WINDOWS MEDIA ENCODER

PCMARK VANTAGE*

MOBILEMARK 2007 hr: min

min:sec

CINEBENCH R10

Dell Studio 1555 (USE006CS)

3,267

6:00

1:17

4,815

0:35

Gateway NV5807u

3,141

3:17

1:18

4,774

0:44

HP Pavilion dv6t (1030us)

2,924

3:03

1:21

4,504

0:38

High scores are best. Low scores are best.

Bold type denotes first place.

Product name in RED indicates Editors’ Choice.

PHOTOSHOP CS4 min:sec

* For this test, each system was set to the default resolution of 1,024 by 768.

=1B=03@ ' >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=<

47@AB :==9A 6/@2E/@3

:S\]d] BVW\YAbObW]\ A

=\S 0WU 0OR 0Wh 2SaYb]^ ]eS` caS`a \SSR ^]eS` O\R bVS BVW\YAbObW]\ A VOa bVOb W\ a^ORSa 7b QO\ []b]` bV`]cUV RWUWbOZ Q]\bS\b Q`SObW]\ bOaYa ZWYS SRWbW\U ^V]b]a O\R dWRS] ^Zca Wb OZa] VOa abOPWZWbg O\R 7B T`WS\RZg TSO bc`Sa b] VSZ^ `c\ g]c` PcaW\Saa 7ba ^`WQS Wa ^`]VWPWbWdS T]` [O\g Pcb Wb¸a O P]]\ T]` ^`] TSaaW]\OZa ^O`bWQcZO`Zg U`O^VWQa ^`]TSaaW]\ OZa bVOb Xcab QO\¸b U] ;OQ BVS A Wa V]caSR W\ O ZO`US PZOQY [SbOZ O\R ^ZOabWQ b]eS` O\R Wb¸a Xcab Oa SOag b] ^]^ ]^S\ Oa bVS /^^ZS ;OQ >`] bVS A ¸a ^`W[S Q][^SbWbW]\ G]c OZa] USb Sf^O\aW]\ `]][ eWbV be] ]^S\ @/; aZ]ba O >17 QO`R aZ]b be] ]^S\ U`O^VWQa QO`R aZ]ba O\R []`S BVS A ¸a QOaS O\R W\bS`\OZa VOdS O\ W[^`Sa aWdS \c[PS` ]T 5`SS\ QS`bW¿QObW]\a( 3>3/B 5]ZR @]6A O\R 3\S`Ug AbO` # BVS A OZa] SfQSZa W\ ^S`T]`[O\QS 7ba aQ]`S ]\ 4cbc`S[O`Y¸a >1;O`Y DO\bOUS bSab % %$ [SO\a Wb Wa SfQSZZS\b Ob SdS`gROg bOaYa O\R []RS`ObS [cZbW[SRWO bOaYa BVS A OZa] PSOb bVS ;OQ >`] ]\ EW\R]ea ;SRWO

P

7

:S\]d] BVW\YAbObW]\ A ! $$# RW`SQb

>@=A :]ba ]T V]`aS^]eS` 3>3/B 5]ZR QS`bW¿QObW]\ BVW\YDO\bOUS cbWZWbWSa 3Oag b] aS`dWQS O\R c^U`ORS BV`SS gSO` eO``O\bg 1=<A 7b¸a PWU A][S PZ]ObeO`S ;Q/TSS acP aQ`W^bW]\ ZOaba ]\Zg ! ROga

3\Q]RS` O\R bVS >V]b]aV]^ 1A" bSab BVS A Wa ZSaa Sf^S\aWdS bVO\ bVS " Q]`S ;OQ >`] VOa O ?cOR`] U`O^VWQa QO`R g]c` QV]WQS ]T ]^S`ObW\U agabS[a O\R g]c USb bVS TSO bc`Sa O\R bSQV ac^^]`b O PcaW\Saa \SSRa ´8]SZ AO\b] 2][W\U] ,,1:719 63@3 4=@ ;=@3

A>31A '! 56h 7\bSZ FS]\ E!#" ^`]QSaa]`) "50 $$ ;6h 22@! A2@/;) # 50 % `^[ A/B/ VO`R R`WdS) #50 <dWRWO ?cOR`] 4F "& U`O^VWQa QO`R RcOZ ZOgS` 2D2±@E R`WdS bS\ CA0 ^]`ba ]\S SA/B/ ^]`b EW\R]ea DWabO 0caW\Saa

>1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< =1B=03@ '

47@AB :==9A 6/@2E/@3

/ACA 3SS>1 6/

/\ 3fb`O EWRS <SbP]]Y b¸a \] aSQ`Sb bVOb 7\bSZ O\R ;WQ`]a]Tb VOdS O ¿`[ U`W^ ]\ eVOb O \SbP]]Y [Og ]` [Og \]b caS W\ bS`[a ]T TSO bc`Sa O\R ^O`ba) VS\QS bVS [O\g Z]]YOZWYSa W\ bVWa ^S`dOaWdS QObS U]`g 0cb bVS`S O`S O VO\RTcZ ]T bVS[ bVOb O`S Q]\aWRS`SR SfQS^bW]\a b] bVS `cZSa BVS /ACA 3SS>1 6/ Wa ]\S ]T [OgPS bV`SS \SbP]]Ya bVOb caS O\ $ W\QV eWRSaQ`SS\ O\R O VWUVS` `Sa]ZcbW]\ !$$ Pg %$& 7\ SfQVO\US T]` dSS`W\U T`][ bVS µUcWRSZW\Sa ¶ V]eSdS` bVS 6/ VOR b] aSbbZS T]` O aZ]eS` /b][ ^`]QSaa]` O\R O VWUV ^`WQS T]` O \SbP]]Y AbWZZ Wb `O\Ya `WUVb c^ bVS`S eWbV a][S ]T bVS PSab ]dS`aWhSR \SbP]]Ya BVS 6/ VOa O PZOQY ZWR bVOb Wa O [OU\Sb T]` a[cRUSa O\R ¿\US`^`W\ba Pcb Wb Wa OZa] aZSSY O\R ZWUVbeSWUVb Ob ! Pg % % Pg W\QVSa 6E2 O\R ! ^]c\Ra [O\OUW\U b] VWRS bVS PcZY ]T bVS $ QSZZ PObbS`g BVWa \SbP]]Y Z]aSa ^]W\ba V]eSdS` T]` VOdW\U O\ ]\Zg ' ^S`QS\b YSgP]O`R O\R abWQYg []caS YSga 7b aQ]`Sa ^]W\ba T]` W\QZcRW\U O 0`]ORQ][ & \ EW 4W QVW^ O `O`Wbg O[]\U \SbP]]Ya BVS 6/¸a !! 56h 7\bSZ /b][ H# ^`]QSaa]` Wa\¸b Oa TOab Oa bVS $% 56h < & ^`]QSaa]`a T]c\R W\ bVS /ACA 63 B]aVWPO <0 # O\R 6> # Pcb bVS Ac^S` 6gP`WR 3\UW\S a]TbeO`S ZSba g]c ]dS`QZ]QY Wb

I

7

/ACA 3SS>1 6/ "! ab`SSb

>@=A 5]`US]ca $ W\QV eWRSaQ`SS\ 2SaW`OPZS aQ`SS\ `Sa]ZcbW]\ DS`g aZW[ O\R ZWUVb 0ObbS`g Wa RSaWU\SR OZ[]ab ÀcaV eWbV bVS POaS 3fQSZZS\b PObbS`g ZWTS 1=<A 9SgP]O`R ]\Zg ' ^S`QS\b T]` O\ ]dS` aWhSR \SbP]]Y /b][ H# ^`]QSaa]` Wa O ZWbbZS aZcUUWaV <]b bVS QVSO^Sab $ W\QV \SbP]]Y

b] &! 56h 0SW\U `Sab`WQbSR b] 50 ]T [S[ ]`g O\R 7\bSZ W\bSU`ObSR U`O^VWQa RWR\¸b VSZ^ bVS 6/¸a ^S`T]`[O\QS aQ]`Sa [cQV 0cb Wb RWR RSZWdS` O U]]R aQ]`S ]\ ;]PWZS;O`Y %´$ V]c`a # [W\cbSa BVWa Wa O b]^ bWS` ]dS`aWhS \SbP]]Y Pcb bVS /QS` / %# V Wa O PSbbS` Pcg ´1WaQ] 1VS\U ,,1:719 63@3 4=@ ;=@3

A>31A !! 56h 7\bSZ /b][ H# ^`]QSaa]`) 50 22@ A2@/;) $ 50 # " `^[ VO`R R`WdS) 7\bSZ 5;/ '# U`O^VWQa) $ W\QV !$$ Pg %$& RWa^ZOg) ! ^]c\Ra ! # b`OdSZ eSWUVb ) ! CA0 ^]`ba) $! EV # /V` PObbS`g) EW\R]ea F> 6][S 3RWbW]\ =1B=03@ ' >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< !

?C719 :==9A 6/@2E/@3

Averatec D1200 $999 list

Dell Studio 14z $1,004 direct

ASUS B80A-B1 $970 street

• Blu-ray player • Lots of storage and memory • Front-mounted ports • Handsome MediaSmart software

• Large, bright widescreen • Wireless keyboard and mouse • HD-capable screen • DVI output for second monitor support

• Both HDMI and DisplayPort • Superb keyboard • Very good battery life • Eye-popping resolution • Reasonable priced

• Plenty of features • LED-backlit keyboard

• Can’t play demanding games • Limited expandability • Some bloatware

• Remote could be sturdier • Still a little bloatware • Could use a larger hard drive • Poor 3D performance

• No media card reader • No optical drive

• Unimaginative design • Low-resolution display • Integrated graphics

Apart from a graphics card that’s better for HD video than for games, the Phenom II X4–powered Pavilion Elite e9120f desktop is an impressive package.

The Averatec D1200 is a large-screen all-in-one PC with TV/DVR capabilities. It can totally replace the TV in a bedroom or a conference room.

It takes guts to omit an optical drive, a media card reader, and VGA-Out, but the Dell Studio 14z does it with style.

The ASUS B80A-B1 is like your job interview suit, a solid investment but nothing too exciting.

2.6-GHz AMD Phenom II X4 910 processor; 8GB SDRAM; 1TB SATA hard drive; 512MB ATI Radeon HD 4350 graphics; BD-ROM drive; dual-layer DVD±RW drive; Vista Home Premium (64-bit).

2.5-GHz Intel Pentium Dual-Core E5200 processor, 4GB SDRAM, 320GB SATA hard drive, 32MB Intel GMA X4500HD graphics, duallayer DVD±RW drive, 25.5inch widescreen LCD, Vista Home Premium (64-bit).

2.4-GHz Intel Core 2 Duo P8600; 3GB SDRAM; 320GB hard drive; 14-inch display; Intel Wi-Fi Link 5100; 4.5 pounds; 74-Wh battery; Vista Home Premium (64-bit).

2.4-Ghz Intel Core 2 Duo P8600 processor; 2GB SDRAM; Intel GMA X4500HD graphics, 250GB hard drive; 14.1-inch display; 5.3 pounds, 53-Wh; Windows Vista Business (64-bit).

CONS

PROS

HP Pavilion Elite e9120f $819.99 list

BOTTOM LINE

LAPTOPS

SPECS

DESKTOPS

Product name in RED indicates Editors’ Choice.

" >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< =1B=03@ '

NETBOOKS

PRINTERS

Dell Inspiron Mini 10v $340 street

Canon Pixma MX860 Wireless Office All-in-One Printer

Xerox WorkCentre 3220/DN $549 direct

Epson WorkForce 310 All-In-One $129.99 direct

$199.99 direct

• Very aggressively priced • Almost 8 hours of battery life • Multiple color options • Option for 802.11n Wi-Fi

• Reasonably high quality output • Prints, scans, and faxes over network • Standalone copier and fax

• Prints, scans, faxes over a network • Standalone copier, fax machine, and e-mail sender • Reasonably high-quality output

• Fast for the price • Ethernet connector • Prints, scans, faxes, even over a network • Standalone copier and fax

• Touchpad and mouse buttons are difficult to use • Plain design • Smaller hard drive than competitors’

• Relatively slow • Cumbersome network setup

• Installation guide covers basic installation only, ignoring important setup steps

• Low paper capacity • Although acceptable for most business use, text is relatively low quality

The Dell Mini 10v is one of the most affordable netbooks money can buy, and 8 hours of battery life isn’t too shabby either.

The MX860 all-in-one printer offers high-quality output and lots of functions, but it is relatively slow for business applications.

The 3220/DN isn’t as easy to set up as it should be, but it offers almost any feature a small office could want in a monochrome laser all-in-one (AIO).

Despite stumbling a bit on text quality, the WorkForce 310 succeeds as a surprisingly capable package at an attractively low price.

1.6GHz Intel Atom N270 processor; 1GB SDRAM; 120GB hard drive; Intel GMA 950 graphics; 10.1-inch screen; 2.9 pounds; 56-Wh battery; Windows XP Home Edition.

Ink-jet AIO; 24 ppm (mono); flatbed scanner; copier; fax; 300-sheet input capacity; 8.9 by 17.1 by 19.4 inches (HWD); 26.4 pounds.

Monochrome laser AIO; 30 ppm (mono); flatbed scanner; copier; fax; 251-sheet input capacity; 15.6 by 17.5 by 16.2 inches (HWD); 30.7 pounds.

Ink-jet AIO; flatbed scanner; copier; fax; 100-sheet input capacity; the 9.3 by 18.1 by 16.2 inches (HWD).

Visit pcmag.com for the full reviews of these and other hardware products.

=1B=03@ ' >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< #

47@AB :==9A 1=<AC;3@ 3:31B@=<71A

9]ROY HW& >]QYSb DWRS] 1O[S`O %' '# ZWab

>@=A <WQS ^`WQS @SQ]`Ra & ^ dWRS] # [SUO^WfSZ abWZZ W[OUS QO^bc`S 4OQS RSbSQbW]\ SZSQb`]\WQ W[OUS abOPWZWhObW]\ O\R [OQ`] []RS 3f^O\ROPZS [S[]`g 3fbS`\OZ [WQ aZ]b AVW^a eWbV O\ 62;7 QOPZS 1=<A 8S`Yg h]][ AcP^O` abWZZ W[OUS _cOZWbg ;SRW]Q`S PcWZb W\ [WQ 6g^S` aS\aWbWdS Pcbb]\a 1O[S`O QO\ USb dS`g V]b

$ >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< =1B=03@ '

9]ROY HW& >]QYSb DWRS] 1O[S`O

9]ROY¸a >]QYSb DWRS] E]\RS` EVS\ 9]ROY W\b`]RcQSR Wba TW`ab SdS` dWRS] QO[S`O ZObS ZOab gSO` bVS HW$ eS eS`S W[^`SaaSR 7\ TOQb Wb eOa ]c` TW`ab 3RWb]`a¸ 1V]WQS W\ bVS \OaQS\b ^]QYSb dWRS] QO[S`O a^OQS BVS HW$ ]TTS`SR O \c[PS` ]T TSObc`Sa bVOb bVS TO[]ca 4ZW^ CZb`O RWR\¸b W\QZcRW\U 62 dWRS] abWZZ W[OUS QO^bc`S O\R O PWUUS` PSbbS` Z]]YW\U aQ`SS\ >c`S 2WUWbOZ a]]\ VWb POQY eWbV bVS 4ZW^ ;W\] 62 O\R bVS 4ZW^ CZb`O 62 0cb eWbV Wba ZObSab bVS HW& >]QYSb DWRS] 1O[S`O 9]ROY OUOW\ ^`]dSa bVOb Wb QO\ Q`S ObS O PSbbS` ^`]RcQb eWbV []`S TSObc`Sa Ob O\ OTT]`ROPZS ^`WQS BVS HW& Wa U]]R Z]]YW\U eSZZ PcWZb O\R aZW[[S` bVO\ Wba ^`SRSQSaa]` bVO\Ya W\ \] a[OZZ ^O`b b] bVS aeWbQV T`][ `SQVO`USOPZS //a b] O `S[]dOPZS ZWbVWc[ W]\ PObbS`g BVS ! ' ]c\QS QO[S`O Wa abWZZ O PWb bVWQYS` bVO\ a][S ]T bVS Q][^SbWbW]\ Pcb Wb TSSZa Q][ T]`bOPZS W\ VO\R BVS aVO`^ # W\QV aQ`SS\ Wa O dOab W[^`]dS[S\b ]dS` bVS RcZZ # W\QV :12 ]\ bVS 4ZW^ ;W\] 62 0S\SObV bVS aQ`SS\ O`S O aS`WSa ]T Pcbb]\a( B]]Za B`OaV DWRS] O\R >ZOgPOQY eWbV O b]UUZW\U X]gabWQY W\ bVS [WRRZS eVWQV eVS\ ^`SaaSR OZa] aS`dSa Oa bVS @SQ]`R Pcbb]\ BVS X]gabWQY Wa O PWb b]] `Sa^]\aWdS V]eSdS` 7 T]c\R [gaSZT OQQW

RS\bOZZg `SQ]`RW\U eVWZS ObbS[^bW\U b] []dS bV`]cUV [S\ca ]\ O Q]c^ZS ]T ]QQO aW]\a 7b OZa] Xcba ]cb O PWb b]] TO` b`WUUS`W\U bVS `SQ]`R Tc\QbW]\ eVS\ bVS QO[S`O Wa ZOWR ]\ O bOPZS aQ`SS\ aWRS R]e\ G]c OZa] USb &;0 ]T ]\ P]O`R [S[]`g eVWQV Wa ^OZb`g T]` 62 Pcb g]c QO\ USb O\ A2 QO`R b] P]]ab [S[]`g b] O [OfW[c[ ]T ! 50 BVS HW& OZa] W\QZcRSa O ^ZcU W\ T]` O\ SfbS`\OZ [WQ´]\S ]T bVS ¿`ab QO[S`Oa eS¸dS aSS\ b] ]TTS` acQV O TSObc`S BVWa Wa O eSZ Q][S ORRWbW]\ UWdS\ bVS TOQb bVOb ZWYS \SO`Zg SdS`g ]bVS` ^]QYSb dWRS] QO[S`O eS¸dS aSS\ bVS 9]ROY¸a PcWZb W\ [WQ ZSOdSa O Z]b b] PS RSaW`SR 7b TOWZa b] ^WQY c^ acPXSQba¸ d]WQSa WT bVSg¸`S TO`bVS` OeOg bVO\ O TSe TSSb 9]ROY VOa OZa] W[^`]dSR bVS _cOZWbg ]T 62 dWRS] eWbV bVS HW& ORRW\U & ^ QO^bc`S b] bVS [Wf BVS W[OUS _cOZWbg Wa SfQSZZS\b Pcb bVWa TSObc`S [Og PS ]dS`YWZZ T]` a][S BVS HW& OZa] ]TTS`a "F RWUWbOZ h]][ beWQS bVOb ]T Wba Q][^SbWb]`a C\T]`bc\ObSZg bVS h]][ Wa O PWb XS`Yg [OYW\U T]` O ZSaa bVO\ WRSOZ dWSeW\U Sf^S`WS\QS 7\ aV]`b bVS HW& Wa ]\S ]T bVS ZSOab Sf^S\aWdS VWUV _cOZWbg ^]QYSb 62 QO[Q]`RS`a g]c¸ZZ ¿\R) bVca Wb eW\a ]c` 3RWb]`a¸ 1V]WQS ´0`WO\ 6SObS` ,,1:719 63@3 4=@ ;=@3 =1B=03@ ' >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< %

47@AB :==9A 1=<AC;3@ 3:31B@=<71A

@7; 0ZOQY0S``g B]c` '$!

DS`Wh]\ EW`SZSaa

BOYS BVWa B]c` BVS \Se 0ZOQY0S``g B]c` Wa O `S[Wf ]T [O\g ]T bVS PSab 0ZOQY0S``g TSObc`Sa ]\ bVS [O`YSb b]ROg ^OQYSR W\b] PSOcbWTcZ VO`ReO`S 7b¸a bVS PS\QV[O`Y T]` PcaW\Saa a[O`b^V]\Sa Oa eSZZ Oa PSW\U O\ SfQSZZS\b [caWQ ^ZOgS` O\R a]QWOZ \Sbe]`YW\U b]]Z ;g c\Wb eOa O ZWbbZS PcUUg Pcb bVS B]c` Wa abWZZ bVS PSab a[O`b^V]\S ]\ DS`Wh]\ EW`SZSaa /b " " Pg " Pg $ W\QVSa 6E2 O\R " $ ]c\QSa bVS U]`US]ca B]c` Z]]Ya ZWYS O Q`]aa PSbeSS\ bVS 0ZOQY0S``g 0]ZR O\R bVS 1c`dS &' eWbV bVS 0]ZR¸a QZ]aS` aSb YSga Pcb bVS &' ¸a a]TbZg `]c\RSR b]^ BVS " W\QV aQ`SS\ Wa a] bWUVb g]c QO\¸b SdS\ aSS bVS ^WfSZa /ZbV]cUV Wba @4 `SQS^bW]\ Wa [S`SZg OdS`OUS bVS B]c` VOa bVS PSab d]WQS _cOZWbg ]T O\g DS`Wh]\ EW`SZSaa ^V]\S ]\ bVS [O` YSb b]ROg BOZY bW[S Ob $ V]c`a O\R ! [W\ cbSa eOa dS`g U]]R T]` O DS`Wh]\ EW`SZSaa ^V]\S 7T g]c aS\R [SaaOUSa bVS B]c` VOa g]c Q]dS`SR eVSbVS` bVSg¸`S S [OWZ 7; A;A ;;A ]` a]QWOZ \Sbe]`YW\U c^RObSa BVS B]c` ]TTS`a bVS SfQSZZS\b 0ZOQY0S``g ^caV S [OWZ O\R bVS W\QZcRSR 2ObODWh a]TbeO`S ZSba g]c dWSe ]` SRWb ;WQ`]a]Tb =T¿QS R]Qa BVS ÀOea 7 T]c\R eWbV [g bSab c\Wb eS`S bVOb bVS aQ`SS\ S[Wba O acPbZS dS`g VWUV ^WbQVSR & >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< =1B=03@ '

@7; 0ZOQY0S``g B]c` '$!

DS`Wh]\ EW`SZSaa $' '' RW`SQb O\R c^ eWbV be] gSO` Q]\b`OQb

>@=A 3fQSZZS\b VO`ReO`S RSaWU\ 5Z]POZ !5 `]O[W\U :]ba ]T [SRWO ]^bW]\a /eSa][S [Sa aOUW\U QO^OPWZWbWSa 1=<A 0cUUg ESP P`]eaS` \SSRa O `ST`SaV

\]WaS eVS\ Wb¸a ]\ O\R bVS ^V]\S beWQS acR RS\Zg ab]^^SR PSW\U OPZS b] `SOR Wba [S[ ]`g QO`R /Za] bVS a]TbeO`S eOa O PWb PcUUg AbWZZ 7 `SQ][[S\R bVS B]c` Oa bVS PSab ]T bVS DS`Wh]\ 0ZOQY0S``g Pc\QV ´AOaQVO ASUO\ ,,1:719 63@3 4=@ ;=@3

47@AB :==9A 1=<AC;3@ 3:31B@=<71A

AO[ac\U @SQZOW[ A^`W\b

AO[ac\U¸a DS`g 5`SS\ >V]\S AO[ac\U V]^Sa b] abS[ bVS bWRS ]T QSZZ ^V]\Sa W\ ZO\R¿ZZa eWbV bVS @SQZOW[ O bWRg SQ] T`WS\RZg aZWRS` 7b¸a OZa] PcRUSb T`WS\RZg Ob Xcab "' '' BVS @SQZOW[ [SOac`Sa Xcab ! ' Pg ! Pg $ 6E2 W\QVSa O\R eSWUVa ! # ]c\QSa 7b¸a Q][T]`bOPZS b] V]ZR bVO\Ya b] bVS `]c\RSR SRUSa O\R bSfbc`SR ^ZOabWQ aVSZZ bVOb R]Sa\¸b aV]e ¿\US`^`W\ba BVS $ W\QV :12 Wa P`WUVb O\R aVO`^ O\R bVS Pcbb]\a YSgP]O`R O\R Q]\b`]Za O`S SOag b] caS :WYS []ab A^`W\b ^V]\Sa bVS @SQZOW[ Wa O RcOZ PO\R 3D 2= &# ' ;6h 12;/ RSdWQS bVOb ac^^]`ba !5 RObO a^SSRa Pcb \]b EW 4W 0cb g]c R] USb O aWRS []c\bSR [WQ`]A2 aZ]b T]` ab]`W\U ^V]b]a O\R [caWQ =\ ]c` bSaba bVS @SQZOW[¸a `SQS^bW]\ eOa [WRRZW\U O\R Wb ab`cUUZSR b] VO\U ]\b] 3D 2= []RS 6]eSdS` d]WQS _cOZWbg eOa QZSO` O\R Q`Wa^ 0ObbS`g ZWTS eOa aV]`b Ob Xcab ! V]c`a ! [W\cbSa ]T bOZY bW[S /Za] bVS /QQSaa ESP P`]eaS` eOa c\cacOZZg aZ]e b] P`W\U c^ E/> O\R 6B;: ^OUSa TSZb Uc[[g eVWQV aSS[SR []`S bVS `SacZb ]T O aZ]e 1>C bVO\ bVS P`]eaS` 7\ ORRWbW]\ bVS ;> QO[ S`O eOa RWaO^^]W\bW\U

AO[ac\U @SQZOW[ A^`W\b "' RW`SQb eWbV gSO` Q]\b`OQb

>@=A ;ORS T`][ []abZg `SQgQZSR [ObS`WOZa ESZZ Q`OTbSR aZWRS` [SQVO\Wa[ O\R ?E3@BG YSgP]O`R A]ZWR [caWQ ^S`T]`[O\QS AbO\RO`R aWhS VSOR^V]\S XOQY 1=<A AV]`b PObbS`g ZWTS AZcUUWaV ESP P`]ea W\U O\R dWRS] ab`SO[W\U <]b bVS U`SObSab `SQS^bW]\

;]ab ^S]^ZS PcgW\U bVWa ^V]\S V]eSdS` O`S U]W\U b] T]Qca ]\ Wba U`SS\ Q`SRS\bWOZa BVS VO\RaSb Wa [ORS T`][ bSfbc`SR PW] ^ZOabWQa Q][Sa W\ `SQgQZOPZS ^OQYOUW\U O\R bVS QVO`US` Wa 3\S`Ug AbO` O^^`]dSR EWbV bVS @SQZOW[ AO[ac\U ^`]dSa bVOb bV]cUV U]W\U U`SS\ Wa U]]R Wb `S_cW`Sa a][S aOQ`W ¿QSa ´8O[WS :S\RW\] ,,1:719 63@3 4=@ ;=@3 =1B=03@ ' >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< '

47@AB :==9A 1=<AC;3@ 3:31B@=<71A

A]\g >ZOgAbObW]\ ! 50 >A! AZW[

/ AZW[[SR 2]e\ >A!

B] bVS QOacOZ ]PaS`dS` bVS`S¸a \]bVW\U ^O`bWQcZO`Zg aZW[ OP]cb bVS \Se A]\g >ZOgAbObW]\ !¸a aZSSY PZOQY V]caW\U) Wb¸a ]\Zg eVS\ g]c Q][^O`S Wb eWbV Wba \SO`Zg bV`SS gSO` ]ZR Q]c\bS`^O`b bVOb g]c aSS V]e [cQV a[OZZS` Wb Wa BVS PWUUS` \Sea VS`S Wa bVS ^`WQS R`]^) BVS ]`WUW\OZ >A! `SbOWZSR T]` $ eVS\ Wb ZOc\QVSR W\ $ O\R c^ c\bWZ ZObS /cUcab bVS ZSOab Sf^S\aWdS >A! g]c Q]cZR Pcg eOa " ´eWbV O\ & 50 VO`R R`WdS / []`S `SOa]\OPZS ! \]e Pcga g]c O\ W\Q`SRWPZS Q]\a]ZS bVOb¸a []`S Q][^OQb VOa O `]][WS` 50 VO`R R`WdS O\R Wa ]\S ]T bVS PSab 0Zc `Og ^ZOgS`a g]c QO\ ¿\R 7\ US\S`OZ bVS \Se >ZOgAbObW]\ ! e]`Ya ^`Sbbg [cQV bVS aO[S Oa bVS ^`SdW]ca US\ S`ObW]\ Q]\a]ZS PSaWRSa b`W[[W\U bVWa \Se []RSZ R]e\ b] # Pg " Pg " W\QVSa 6E2 O\R $ % ^]c\Ra BVS RSdWQS abWZZ TSO bc`Sa O ! 56h ^`]QSaa]` ## 56h <dWRWO U`O^VWQa O\R bVS @AF @SOZWbg Ag\bVSaWhS` 5>C BVS QVO\USa bVOb O`S \]bSe]`bVg O`S bVS VO`R R`WdS Pc[^ b] 50 O\R bVS Q][ ! >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< =1B=03@ '

A]\g >ZOgAbObW]\ ! 50 >A! AZW[ >`WQS( '' '' RW`SQb

>@=A <Se Q][^OQb O\R S\S`Ug ST¿QWS\b RS aWU\ BS``W¿Q UO[W\U ^S`T]`[O\QS 7\bSU`ObSR VWUV _cOZWbg 0Zc `Og ^ZOgS` 6O`R R`WdS Wa SOaWZg OQQSaaWPZS T]` c^U`ORSa 0cWZb W\ EW 4W 0ZcS b]]bV Ac^^]`b T]` 62;7 131 O\R 2:</ 1=<A <] [S[]`g QO`R aZ]ba <] <SbÀWf ab`SO[W\U ac^^]`b 2SRWQObSR 0Zc `Og `S[]bS Wa \]b W\QZcRSR

^ZSbSZg `SRSaWU\SR ^]eS` ac^^Zg c\Wb O\R Q]]ZW\U [SQVO\Wa[ `SacZbW\U W\ W\Q`SOaSR ST¿QWS\Qg =\ ]c` ^]eS` Q]\ac[^bW]\ bSaba bVS \Se >A! caSR % eObba Rc`W\U 0Zc `Og ^ZOgPOQY eVWZS bVS ]ZRS` []RSZ Q]\ac[SR " eObba /Za] g]c QO\ ab`SO[ Q]\bS\b b] bVS >A! T`][ O V]ab ]T 2:</ Q][^ZWO\b RSdWQSa acQV Oa RWUWbOZ QO[S`Oa BV]cUV 7¸R ZWYS b] aSS O RSRWQObSR 0Zc `Og `S[]bS W\abSOR ]T caW\U bVS 2cOZAV]QY !

Q]\b`]ZZS` bVWa \Se >A! Wa \]\SbVSZSaa bVS PSab Q]\a]ZS T]` UO[S`a O\R V][S S\bS` bOW\[S\b PcTTa eV] eO\b O dS`aObWZS [SRWO QS\bS` eWbV 0Zc `Og ´HOQV 6]\WU ,,1:719 63@3 4=@ ;=@3

47@AB :==9A 1=<AC;3@ 3:31B@=<71A

=Zg[^ca 3 > %'' '' ZWab

>@=A AVO`^ W[OUSa T`][ 7A= bV`]cUV 7A= & :]e \]WaS T`][ 7A= $ 0SOcbWTcZ RSaWU\ 62 dWRS] QO^bc`S % ^!

62;7 ^]`b BV`SS W\QV :12

=Zg[^ca 3 >

BVS =Zg[^ca 5O[S 1VO\US` WbV 2A:@ ZWYS Tc\QbW]\ OZWbg W\ O ^OQYOUS \] ZO`US` bVO\ O `O\US TW\RS` bVS =Zg[^ca 3 > Wa b`cZg O UO[S QVO\US` BVS ;WQ`] 4]c` BVW`Ra QO[S`O ]TTS`a a^SQbOQcZO` W[OUS _cOZWbg W\ O Q][ ^OQb P]Rg Pcb Wba Ocb] T]Qca Wa aZ]eS` bVO\ Sf^SQbSR´aZ]eS` SdS\ bVO\ a][S ^]W\b O\R aV]]ba @SUO`RZSaa bVWa Wa O\ O[OhW\U ¿`ab US\S`ObW]\ QO[S`O) O ^`]RcQb W[^`Sa aWdS S\]cUV b] QOcaS Q][^SbWb]`a b] aQ`O[ PZS b] Q`SObS a][SbVW\U SdS\ PSbbS` BVWa QO[S`O Wa Q][^OQb [SOac`W\U & Pg " & Pg " W\QVSa 6E2 O\R eSWUVW\U ^]c\Ra eWbV bVS "³" [[ YWb ZS\a /Za] bVS PcWZR _cOZWbg Wa aW[^Zg TO\bOabWQ 7b eOa []RSZSR OTbS` bVS # gSO` ]ZR =Zg[^ca >S\´eWbV O [SbOZ QVOaaWa O\R ZSObVS` ZWYS

W

1=<A <]bWQSOPZS aVcbbS` ZOU AZ]e Ocb]T]Qca :S\a Wa \]Wag eVS\ T]QcaW\U 4Se ;WQ`] 4]c` BVW`Ra :S\aSa OdOWZOPZS <] ]^bWQOZ dWSe ¿\RS` <] PcWZb W\ ÀOaV

U`W^ BVS 3 > Wa Q][^ObWPZS ]\Zg eWbV ;WQ`] 4]c` BVW`Ra ZS\aSa BVS`S Wa OZa] \] ]^bWQOZ dWSeTW\RS` [OYW\U bVS ! W\QV :12¸a ZO`US aWhS SdS\ []`S ]T O \SQSaaWbg =^S`ObW\U a^SSR Wa O [WfSR POU T]` bVS 3 > ) Wb QO\ PS dS`g TOab Pcb Wba aZcUUWaV Ocb]T]Qca QOcaSa bVS QO[S`O b] aZ]e R]e\ aWU\W¿QO\bZg 0]]b c^ O\R `SQgQZS bW[Sa O`S OZa] OTTSQbSR Pg bVS aZ]e T]QcaW\U eWbV OdS` OUS aQ]`Sa ]T ! O\R # aSQ]\Ra `Sa^SQ bWdSZg 6]eSdS` W[OUSa ^`]RcQSR Pg bVS ! [SUO^WfSZ 3 > O`S a^SQbOQcZO` Q][ ^SbWbWdS eWbV [O\g A:@a /\R bVS OPWZWbg b] aV]]b 62 dWRS] Wa O\ ORRSR ^S`Y 2Sa^WbS Wba aZ]e T]QcaW\U bVS 3 > ]TTS`a ]\S ]T bVS PSab Sf^S`WS\QSa T]` ^V]b]U`O^VS`a Z]]YW\U b] POZO\QS aWhS W[OUS _cOZWbg 62 dWRS] ^]`bO PWZWbg O\R \]abOZUWO ´>8 8OQ]P]eWbh ,,1:719 63@3 4=@ ;=@3 =1B=03@ ' >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< !

?C719 :==9A 1=<AC;3@ 3:31B@=<71A

SMARTPHONES

LG Xenon GR500 (AT&T) $99.99 to $299.99 list

DIGITAL CAMERAS

Kyocera X-tc (Virgin Mobile)

Nikon Coolpix S630 $279.95 list

Sigma DP2 $650 street

SPECS

BOTTOM LINE

CONS

PROS

$99.99 direct

.

• Solid call quality • Good music and video playback • Compact for a QWERTY slider

• Only prepaid Virgin phone with a keyboard • Good downloadable Web browser and Facebook/ MySpace client

• Fast 7X optical zoom lens • Solid wide-angle image quality • Ergonomic design • Negligible shutter lag • Low noise at high ISOs

• D-SLR-quality images • Smaller build than a D-SLR • Fast, high-quality lens • Unique Foveon X3 image processor

• Non-standard headphone jack • Bland UI needs a little work in spots

• Poor RF reception • Mediocre call quality • Slow Internet • Limited messaging apps • Cramped keyboard

• Images are soft and color fringing occurs when zoomed in • Sluggish face detection • Underwhelming user interface

• No optical zoom • Fixed lens • Noticeable shutter lag • Low still image and video resolutions • Small LCD

It’s tough to fault the LG Xenon, a powerful slider phone that can handle media tasks with aplomb.

The Kyocera X-tc’s keyboard makes Web browsing, texting, and Facebook much easier, but its performance overall is lacking.

The Coolpix S630 is a good choice for minimalists who want a compact camera with a powerful optical zoom, but its feature set is lacking.

The compact Sigma DP2 produces extraordinary D-SLR–quality images, but its price and drawbacks probably won’t please the average photographer.

AT&T; 2.8-inch, 400-by-240 LCD; 2.0MP camera; 4.2 by 2.1 by 0.6 inches (HWD); 3.8 ounces.

Virgin; 2.4-inch, 320-by-240 LCD; 1.3MP camera; 4.4 by 2 by 0.7 inches (HWD); 4.2 ounces.

Point-and-shoot; 12MP; SD card slot; 2.3 by 3.8 by 1.0 inches (HWD); 5.6 ounces.

Superzoom; 4.6MP; SD card slot; 2.3 by 4.5 by 2.2 inches (HWD); 9.2 ounces.

Product name in RED indicates Editors’ Choice.

! >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< =1B=03@ '

GPS

HEADPHONES

FITNESS GEAR

Magellan Maestro 4370 $299.99 direct

Klipsch Image S4i $99.99 direct

Shure SRH440 Professional

Nike+ SportBand $59 direct

$99.99 list

• Beautiful, ultra-high resolution screen • Very sharp map and 3D landmark graphics • Accurate navigation • Useful AAA guide

• Built-in iPhone/iPod controls and mic • Works with iPod shuffle’s voice-over feature • Strong bass response

• Strong bass response and crisp highs • Ideal for recording or general listening • Detachable, replaceable cable

• Tracks pace, distance, time, and calories burned with near-perfect accuracy • Lightweight • Simple setup and calibration

• Touch screen can be stubborn at times • Interface sometimes showed slight lag • Lacks current speed display in map view

• Controls only guaranteed to work with iPhone 3GS and newer iPods

• Can be uncomfortable when worn for long periods

• Low-resolution LCD • Display is not backlit

The Maestro 4370’s low price and stellar screen resolution cements its status as a solid navigator, despite touch-screen issues.

For $100, you get a greatsounding pair of earphones that controls the latest iPods and iPhone, and even works with the iPod shuffle voiceover feature.

The Shure SRH440 sounds fantastic with a wide range of genres—and the price is right for artists and music lovers alike.

The affordable Nike+ SportBand combines an accurate pedometer with a well-executed Web component for a top-notch fitness tracking experience.

Automobile GPS; 4.3-inch screen; SD/MMC card slot; 3.3 by 4.7 by 0.7 inches (HWD); 7.4 ounces.

In-canal earbuds; passive noise canceling; 110 dB SPL per 1 mW sensitivity; 18 ohms impedance.

Circumaural headphones; 105 dB SPL per 1 mW sensitivity; 44 ohms impedance; 9.6 ounces.

Bluetooth capability; sensor, 1.37 by 0.95 by 0.3 inches (HWD); 0.2 ounces.

Visit pcmag.com for the full reviews of these and other consumer electronics products.

=1B=03@ ' >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< !!

47@AB :==9A A=4BE/@3 B63 1/B¸A >/8/;/A A][S ]T bVS \Se TSO bc`Sa W\ A\]e :S]^O`R W\QZcRS O \Se O^^ZWQO bW]\a dWSe bVS 3f^]a{ eW\R]e ^`SdWSe O\R W[ ^`]dSR B`OQY>OR ^`STS`S\QSa

/^^ZS ;OQ =A F $

/^^ZS¸a A\]e :S]^O` ^^ZS VOa O\]bVS` eW\\S` eWbV ;OQ =A F $ OZa] Y\]e\ Oa A\]e :S]^O`R BVWa dS` aW]\ ]T bVS ;OQW\b]aV ]^S` ObW\U agabS[ Wa bVS P`OW\WSab P`Oe\WSab O\R []ab PSOcbWTcZ Q]\ac[S` ]`WS\bSR =A OdOWZOPZS O\geVS`S´O\R Wb aVW^a eWbV bVS PSab PcWZb W\ O^^ZWQObW]\a O\R cbWZWbWSa g]c QO\ ¿\R /a Wba \O[S acUUSaba bVWa dS`aW]\ PcWZRa ]\ bVS ab`]\U T]c\RObW]\ ]T =A F # :S]^O`R O\R ]TTS`a O a[]]bV c^U`ORS ^ObV T]` SfWabW\U caS`a O\g 7\bSZ POaSR ;OQ eWZZ `c\ Wb 0cb g]c¸`S ]cb ]T ZcQY WT g]c abWZZ VOdS O >]eS`>1³POaSR ;OQ BVS \Se dS`aW]\ Z]]Ya OZ[]ab WRS\bWQOZ b] bVS ^`SdW]ca ]\S a] bVS`S¸a \] \Se W\bS`TOQS

A

!" >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< =1B=03@ '

b] ZSO`\ <Se TSObc`Sa O`S bcQYSR W\ c\]Pb`c aWdSZg ]\ bVS ]ZR W\bS`TOQS a] Sf^S`WS\QSR caS`a eWZZ TW\R a][S ^ZSOaO\b ac`^`WaSa W\ PSbbS` ]`UO\WhSR ^]^ c^ [S\ca Oa eSZZ Oa \Sbe]`YW\U ]^bW]\a acQV Oa PcWZb W\ ac^ ^]`b T]` 1WaQ] D>< A\]e :S]^O`R eOa OZa] \]bWQSOPZg TOabS` W\ [g bSabW\U O\R `S_cW`Sa ZSaa RWaY a^OQS BVS =A Wa\¸b ^S`TSQb Pcb Wb¸a ^`Sbbg QZ]aS 7b¸a bVS ¿`ab 7¸dS bSabSR W\ eVWQV 7 T]c\R \] [OX]` UZWbQVSa Ob ZOc\QV A\]e :S]^O`R W\QZcRSa O TSe W[^`Sa aWdS dWacOZ QVO\USa W\QZcRW\U ?cWQYBW[S F O Q][^ZSbSZg \Se ?cWQYBW[S ^ZOgS` eWbV W[^`]dSR ^S`T]`[O\QS O aZSSY W\bS`TOQS O\R ac^^]`b T]` []RS`\ dWRS] TSObc`Sa acQV Oa 6BB> ab`SO[W\U BVS PWUUSab QVO\USa W\

/^^ZS =A F $ A\]e :S]^O`R ' RW`SQb) # ZWQS\aS TO[WZg ^OQY "'

>@=A 4Oab 3ZSUO\b Ac^S`P acWbS ]T PcWZb W\ POaWQ O^^a 3Oag b] caS T]` bV]aS TO[WZWO` eWbV ^`SdW]ca dS`aW]\a AWZYg a[]]bV c^U`ORW\U T]` SfWabW\U caS`a

O`R @]O`a A\]e :S]^O`R V]eSdS` O`S VWRRS\ c\RS` Wba aYW\ /Z[]ab SdS`gbVW\U caSa O \Se bSQV\]Z]Ug QOZZSR 5`O\R 1S\b`OZ 2Wa^ObQV 512 eVWQV aVO`Sa bOaYa O[]\U bVS [cZ bW^ZS Q]`Sa ]T []RS`\ 7\bSZ 1>Ca O\R T`SSa RSdSZ]^S`a T`][ bVS VSOROQVS ]T a^ZWbbW\U a]TbeO`S bOaYa W\b] aS^O`ObS µbV`SORa ¶ 7\ ORRWbW]\ OZ[]ab OZZ bVS O^^ZWQObW]\a W\ A\]e :S]^O`R O`S \]e e`WbbS\ W\ $" PWb Q]RS T]` U`SObS` a^SSR O\R W\Q`SOaSR [S[ ]`g OQQSaa Q][^O`SR b] ! PWb O^^a AOTO`W ´OZ`SORg a^SSRg c\RS` :S]^O`R´\]e `S\RS`a 8OdOAQ`W^b `WQV ^OUSa TOabS` bVO\ 7 bV]cUVb ^]aaWPZS /\]bVS` [OX]` \Se TSObc`S Wa TcZZ ac^^]`b T]` ;WQ`]a]Tb 3fQVO\US OQQ]c\ba W\ /^^ZS

1=<A / TSe [W\]` W\bS`TOQS UZWbQVSa :OQYa bVS `O\US ]T O^^ZWQObW]\a O\R Q][^ObWPZS VO`ReO`S OdOWZOPZS T]` EW\R]ea

;OWZ a] ;OQ caS`a \]e VOdS TcZZ OQQSaa b] 3fQVO\US¸a QOZS\RO` W\dWbObW]\a O\R UZ]POZ ORR`Saa ZWaba W\abSOR ]T caW\U 3\b]c`OUS CaS`a QO\ OZa] W\bSU`ObS bV]aS eWbV bVS ;OQ =A /RR`Saa 0]]Y O\R W1OZ QOZS\RO` /\R g]c USb bVS S\VO\QSR 3f^]a{ TSObc`S eVWQV RWa^ZOga `SRcQSR W[OUSa ]T OZZ ]^S\ eW\R]ea Ob bVS aO[S bW[S BVS ]\Zg eSOY\Saa ]T ;OQ =A F $ Wa\¸b W\ bVS ]^S`ObW\U agabS[ WbaSZT Pcb W\ bVS `O\US ]T O^^ZWQObW]\a OdOWZOPZS T]` Wb A\]e :S]^O`R USba []`S bVW\Ua `WUVb bVO\ O\g ]bVS` ]^S`ObW\U agabS[ O\R Wb bV`]ea W\ ab`WYW\U U]]R Z]]Ya Oa O P]\ca ´3ReO`R ;S\RSZa]\ ,,1:719 63@3 4=@ ;=@3 =1B=03@ ' >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< !#

47@AB :==9A A=4BE/@3

A31C@7BG AC7B3A

G]c` ASQc`Wbg ;OYS]dS` VS []RSZ gSO` T]` aSQc `Wbg acWbSa O`S `]ZZW\U ]cb O\R eS¸dS bSabSR bVS TW`ab Q`]^ b] aSS eVWQV ]TTS` bVS PSab ^`]bSQbW]\ O\R SOaWSab ]^S`ObW]\´eWbV]cb V]UUW\U dWbOZ agabS[ `Sa]c`QSa BVSaS bV`SS acWbSa T`][ 0Wb2S TS\RS` 9% O\R 9Oa^S`aYg O`S O U]]R `S^`S aS\bObW]\ ]T bVS RWdS`aWbg bVOb VOa RSdSZ]^SR W\ bVS Sd]ZdW\U aSQc`Wbg [O`YSb 7b¸a \]b Xcab <]`b]\ O\R ;Q/TSS O\g[]`S

T

0Wb2STS\RS` B]bOZ ASQc`Wbg 0Wb2STS\RS`¸a O\bWdW`ca bSQV\]Z]Ug Wa QS`bW ¿SR T]` dW`ca RSbSQbW]\ O\R `S[]dOZ Pg 71A/ :OPa O\R ESab 1]Oab :OPa BVWa acWbS ^`][ WaSa W[^`]dSR [OZeO`S RSbSQbW]\ O\R QZSO\ W\U T`][ bVS ^`SdW]ca dS`aW]\ O\R W\RSSR Wb RSbSQbSR SdS`g bV`SOb T`][ [g W\TSabSR bSab agabS[a 6]eSdS` 0Wb2STS\RS` ZSTb PSVW\R SfSQcbOPZS TWZSa T]` O bVW`R ]T bVS bV`SOba 7b OZa] ZSTb b]\a ]T TWZS O\R @SUWab`g b`OQSa 3dS\ a] Wb aQ]`SR O\ SfQSZZS\b % # ]cb ]T ]\ ]c` bSaba /\R Wba [cZbWZOgS`SR O^^`]OQV Ob PZ]QYW\U [OZeO`S Wa aS`W]caZg STTSQbWdS 0Wb2STS\RS` b`OQYSR QZ]aSZg eWbV 9Oa^S` aYg W\ []ab ]T ]c` bSaba 7ba ac^S`P [OZeO`S RSbSQbW]\ O\R W[^`]dSR O\bWa^O[ ^O`S\ !$ >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< =1B=03@ '

bOZ Q]\b`]Z O\R ^`WdOQg ^`]bSQbW]\ [OYS Wb O U]]R QV]WQS T]` OZZ O`]c\R ^`]bSQbW]\ 9% B]bOZASQc`Wbg DS`aW]\ <SdS` VSO`R ]T 9%- BVOb¸a OP]cb b] QVO\US eWbV bVS `SZSOaS ]T 9% B]bOZASQc`Wbg DS`aW]\ bVS /aWO\ Q][^O\g¸a TW`ab PWU ^ZOg W\ bVS /[S`WQO\ aSQc`Wbg [O`YSb B]bOZASQc `Wbg R]Sa a][S bVW\Ua eSZZ Pcb Wba RS¿QWS\ QWSa S\ac`S bVOb Ag[O\bSQ ;Q/TSS O\R bVS `Sab R]\¸b \SSR b] e]``g gSb 2Sa^WbS Wba RSRWQObSR `]]bYWb aQO\\S` 9%¸a aQ]`S a^SQW¿QOZZg OUOW\ab `]]bYWba eOa # ! O PWb PSZ]e bVS OdS`OUS 7b U]b VWUV [O`Ya ]\ [OZeO`S PZ]QYW\U aQ]`W\U ' ! ]T ^]W\ba 7\ O\bWa^O[ bSabW\U 9% PZ]QYSR Xcab # ^S`QS\b ]T dOZWR [OWZ eVWQV Wa ^`Sbbg U]]R =dS`OZZ Wb VOa O dS`g a[OZZ STTSQb ]\ agabS[ ^S`T]`[O\QS A^O[ ¿ZbS`W\U Wa RSQS\b Pcb bVS ¿`SeOZZ Wa T`OUWZS O\R bVS ^`WdOQg ^`]bSQ bW]\ TOWZa W\ aSdS`OZ eOga 0OaWQOZZg T]` 9% b] acQQSSR W\ bVS C A Wba \Sfb 3\UZWaV ZO\ UcOUS dS`aW]\ eWZZ VOdS b] R] PSbbS` 9Oa^S`aYg 7\bS`\Sb ASQc`Wbg =\ bVS ac`TOQS bVS ZObSab 9Oa^S`aYg acWbS Z]]Ya []`S ^]ZWaVSR bVO\ ZOab gSO`¸a SRW bW]\ Pcb bVS OQbcOZ aSQc`Wbg TSObc`Sa VOdS\¸b

0Wb2STS\RS` B]bOZ ASQc`Wbg

9% B]bOZASQc`Wbg DS`aW]\

ZWQS\aS $' '# RW`SQb) ! ZWQS\aSa %' '#

! ZWQS\aSa "" '$ RW`SQb

>@=A 3fQSZZS\b [OZeO`S RSbSQbW]\ /QQc`ObS a^O[ ¿ZbS` C\cacOZZg U]]R ^O`S\bOZ Q]\b`]Za @S[]bS []\Wb]`W\U O\R [O\OUS[S\b

>@=A >`SW\abOZZ aQO\ RSbSQba [O\g bV`SOba 2SbSQbSR []ab [OZeO`S :WbbZS ^S`T]`[O\QS W[^OQb

1=<A 6O`R b] W\abOZZ ]\ O [OZeO`S W\TSabSR agabS[ A] a] [OZeO`S QZSO\c^ 2c^ZWQObS ¿\RS` [Og abWZZ `S[]dS ¿ZSa Wb aV]cZR\¸b

1=<A 7\Q][^ZSbS [OZeO`S QZSO\c^ 2WR \]b PZ]QY `]]bYWb W\abOZZObW]\ 2STOcZb ¿`SeOZZ aSb bW\Ua R]\¸b abSOZbV ^]`ba

1:719 63@3 4=@ ;=@3

1:719 63@3 4=@ ;=@3

9Oa^S`aYg 7\bS`\Sb ASQc`Wbg ! ZWQS\aSa %' '# RW`SQb

>@=A 7[^`]dSR W\bS`TOQS µAOTS @c\¶ dW`bcOZ S\dW`]\[S\b ^`]bSQba OUOW\ab c\eO\bSR QVO\U Sa 7\bSZZWUS\b O^^ZWQObW]\ Q]\b`]Z 6O`RS\SR OUOW\ab [OZeO`S ObbOQYa 7[^`]dSR a^O[ ¿ZbS` W\U 0Z]QYa Sf^Z]Wba O\R ZSOY bSaba 1=<A ;OZeO`S QZSO\c^ ZSTb PSVW\R [O\g b`OQSa AZ]eSR agabS[ ^S`T]`[O\QS a][SeVOb /\bW^VWaVW\U []RcZS ZSaa STTSQbWdS @cRW[S\ bO`g ^O`S\bOZ Q]\b`]Za 1:719 63@3 4=@ ;=@3

QVO\USR [cQV BVOb¸a \]b O POR bVW\U) bVWa acWbS VOa b]\a ]T TSObc`Sa O\R bVS c^RObSR caS` W\bS`TOQS [OYSa bVS[ []`S dWaWPZS O\R OQQSaaWPZS @ObVS` bVO\ ObbS[^b b] abSOZbV OZZ ^]`ba Oa []ab ¿`SeOZZa R] 9Oa^S`aYg a^SQWTWQOZZg PZ]QYa ObbOQY bg^S b`OTTWQ O\ Obb`WPcbS bVOb ^`]dSR dS`g W[^`SaaWdS ]\ ]c` bSaba 7b Wa OZa] ZWUVb gSO`a OVSOR ]T bVS Q][

^SbWbW]\ b] ^`]U`O[ Q]\b`]Z 7b OZa] W[^`]dSR ]\ O\bWa^O[ ^S`T]`[O\QS 9Oa^S`aYg RSbSQbSR && ^S`QS\b ]T [OZ eO`S aO[^ZSa ]\ ]c` bSaba O PWb PSZ]e <]`b]\ O\R Wb R]Sa bOYS []`S ]T O VWb ]\ agabS[ ^S`T]`[O\QS bVO\ bVS ]bVS`a VS`S 0cb Wb Wa abWZZ O U]]R QV]WQS T]` POaWQ ^`]bSQ bW]\ ´<SWZ @cPS\YW\U =1B=03@ ' >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< !%

?C719 :==9A A=4BE/@3

PRODUCTIVITY

Doodle Free

MOBILE

Citrix GotoAssist Express $69 direct per month or $660 per year

Google Voice (Android) Free

• Simplifies event coordination • Easy to use • Well-suited for businesses

• Inexpensive • Easy to set up and use • Remote sessions responded quickly • Service works flawlessly

• Can dial, SMS, or record Google Voice calls from the handset • Plenty of options for managing voice calls

• Plenty of options for managing voice calls • Tighter integration and more features than the BlackBerry version

• Lacks the sleek look and sophisticated functionality of competing services • Doesn’t let you confirm attendance

• Offers rudimentary reporting

• Doesn’t use BlackBerry’s built-in dialer • Somewhat buggy

• SMS messages are still separated from the phone’s built-in messaging app

Doodle is a serviceable, no-frills event scheduling solution that makes it easy to coordinate meet-ups.

GoToAssist Express gives small businesses an affordable, robust, and simple way to support remote users.

Google Voice for BlackBerry lets you make and receive calls and text messages through Google’s new “number for life” service, although it’s not as tightly integrated as the Android version.

Google Voice for Android is the best way to use Google Voice on a cell phone.

PROS CONS BOTTOM LINE

Google Voice (BlackBerry) Free

Product name in RED indicates Editors’ Choice.

!& >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< =1B=03@ '

MEDIA SYNC

PARENTAL CONTROLS

SOCIAL NETWORKING

Salling Media Sync

iTunes Agent

Web of Trust

Xing

Free; premium version, $22

Free

Free

Basic membership, free; premium membership, $5.95 per month

• Syncs iTunes playlists easily on many kinds of phones • Available for Macs and PCs

• Syncs iTunes songs and videos with most mass storage devices, including cell phones • Works with a wide variety of devices—even USB flash drives

• Rates Web sites based on community input and other resources • Marks results in over 20 search engines • Can block unreliable or child-inappropriate sites • Doesn’t slow browsing

• Strong contact management and comparison tools • Thousands of discussion groups

• Free version is too slow for those who sync every day • Paid version is a bit pricey • A few noticeable bugs

• Doesn’t work with lowerend phones and certain smartphones • Some Vista installation issues

• Doesn’t rate sponsored links in search pages • Some adult sites get past parental-control mode

• Very Eurocentric • Many basic features require paid upgrade to Premium Membership • Of limited use to everyday job seekers

The paid version of Salling Media Sync is an ideal solution for syncing iTunes playlists to your phone, but it’s more expensive than alternatives.

This free open-source software is an excellent utility to help you sync your cell phone, PSP, or non-Apple MP3 player with iTunes.

The free Web of Trust browser add-on supplies ratings for over 23 million sites, which it derives from user reports, other Web sites, and malware databases.

Although it may be a useful social-networking service for frequent pond-hoppers, Xing is somewhat lacking in utility for American workers.

Visit pcmag.com for the full reviews of these and scores of other software products.

=1B=03@ ' >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< !'

8=6< 1 2D=@/9

EVS`S Wa ;g EW`SZSaa @Sd]ZcbW]\b¸a U`SOb b] Y\]e bVOb CA0 ! eWZZ a]]\ PS OdOWZOPZS OZ]\U eWbV [cZbW ^ZS Q]`S ^`]QSaa]`a O\R ]bVS` eVWh PO\U ORdO\QS[S\ba a] eVg R]Sa bVS O`SO O`]c\R [g Q][^cbS` abWZZ Z]]Y ZWYS O `Ob¸a \Sab ]T eW`Sa7 QO\¸b PS bVS ]\Zg ^S`a]\ eWbV bVWa Q][ ^ZOW\b ;g >1¸a ^]eS` Q]`R Wa V]]YSR b] O ^]eS` ab`W^ eVWQV Wa V]]YSR b] O C>A T]`[ W\U bVS POQYP]\S ]T eW`Sa ;g \Sbe]`YW\U QOPZS Wa V]]YSR b] bVS µeW`SZSaa¶ `]cbS` eVWQV WbaSZT Wa V]]YSR Pg O bVW\ \Oabg Z]]Y W\U eW`S b] O P`WQY ZWYS ^]eS` ac^^Zg eVWQV Wa eW`SR b] bVS ^]eS` ab`W^ BVS eW`SZSaa `]cbS` VOa T]c` ORRWbW]\OZ eW`Sa W\QZcRW\U bVS ]\S b] bVS 7\bS`\Sb Q]\\SQbW]\ eVWQV W\ bc`\ VOa O\]bVS` P`WQY O\R bV`SS []`S eW`Sa V]]YSR b] Wb W\QZcRW\U bVS eW`S Q][ W\U W\ T`][ bVS QOPZS Q][^O\g eVWQV Wa OZa] eW`SR b] O P]f O\R gSb O\]bVS` ^]eS` ac^ ^Zg 7 VOdS\¸b SdS\ U]bbS\ b] bVS a^SOYS`a YSgP]O`R []caS ^`W\bS` bOPZSb O\R ^S`W^V S`OZa /P]cb ]\QS SdS`g Q]c^ZS ]T []\bVa 7 RWaQ]\\SQb SdS`gbVW\U O\R RWaQ]dS` `]UcS

I

" >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< =1B=03@ '

eW`Sa VWRW\U O[]\U bVS eW`Sa OQbcOZZg Q]\ \SQbSR b] a][SbVW\U BVSaS O`S eW`Sa bVOb eS`S caSR T]` a][S `SOa]\ ]` O\]bVS` O\R bVS\ RWaQ]\\SQbSR eWbV bVS bV]cUVb W\ [W\R bVOb bVSg e]cZR SdS\bcOZZg PS `SQ]\\SQbSR O\R \SdS` eS`S =TbS\ bVSg eS`S \SdS` `SQ]\\SQbSR PSQOcaS Wb eOa W[^]aaWPZS b] TW\R bVS[ A] bVSg Xcab PcWZR c^ bO\UZW\U eWbVW\ bVS [Oh ]T bVS ]bVS` eW`Sa ;O\g ]T bVS `]UcS eW`Sa O`S OQbcOZZg WRW ]bWQ dO`WObW]\a ]T bVS CA0 Q]\\SQb]`a 7 [cab VOdS Ob ZSOab aWf \]`[OZ dO`WObW]\a bVOb 7 \SSR T]` ]\S bVW\U ]` O\]bVS` CA0 Wa CA0 a] eVg R] eS VOdS a] [O\g dO`WObW]\a- BVS`S aV]cZR PS be] CA0 QOPZSa BVS`S aV]cZR PS bVS ]`WUW\OZ UWO\b CA0 Q]\\SQb]` eWbV bVS PWU `SQbO\UcZO` c\WdS`aOZ Q]\\SQb]` ]\ ]\S S\R O\R bVS PWU a_cO`S Q]\\SQb]` ]\ bVS ]bVS` BVS\ OZZ bVS [O\cTOQbc`S`a aV]cZR ^WQY ]\S O\R ]\Zg ]\S [W\W CA0 RSaWU\ 7 R]\¸b SdS\ QO`S eVWQV ]\S) Xcab ^WQY ]\S BVS ]\Zg `SOa]\ T]` bVS dO`WObW]\a Wa PSQOcaS bVSaS Q][O\WSa [cab bVW\Y Wb¸a Tc\\g 7 QO\¸b aSS bVOb bVSaS dO`W]ca Q]\\SQb]`a O`S O\g QVSO^S` ]` PSbbS` bVO\ SOQV ]bVS`

A] eVS`S Wa bVS eW`SZSaa `Sd]ZcbW]\- BVS ]\Zg ^ZOQS 7 QO\ YW\R ]T ¿\R Wb Wa eWbV bVS <W\bS\R] EWW BVSaS dO`W]ca CA0 eW`Sa USb bO\UZSR W\ bVS [Saa O\R eVS\ g]c \SSR ]\S ]T bVS ]RRPOZZ ]\Sa T]` a][S abc^WR RSdWQS bVOb caSa Wb g]c VOdS b] Z]]Y OZZ ]dS` T]` bVS bVW\U 7T bVSg Q]Z]` Q]RSR bVS eW`S `SR U`SS\ PZcS- bVOb e]cZR Ob ZSOab VSZ^ 6]e OP]cb gSZZ]e a] bVS QOPZS aQ`SO[a ]cb µ6Sg 6S`S Wa g]c` eSW`R CA0 QOPZS g]c QO\ \SdS` ¿\R ¶ BVOb e]cZR VSZ^ ;g [g`WOR [Saa ]T eW`Sa UWdSa [S O VSOROQVS SdS`g bW[S 7 Z]]Y Ob Wb A] eVS`S Wa bVS eW`SZSaa `Sd]ZcbW]\- BVS ]\Zg ^ZOQS 7 QO\ YW\R ]T ¿\R Wb Wa eWbV bVS <W\bS\R] EWW BVS EWW Wa O[OhW\U 7b V]]Ya b] bVS 7\bS`\Sb OZ[]ab aSO[ZSaaZg eWbV O\ SfQSZZS\b EW 4W Q]\\SQbW]\ BVS`S O`S \] eW`Sa b] Q]\b`]Z ZS`a O\R Xcab bVS ^]eS` QOPZS O\R eW`Sa b] bVS BD RWa^ZOg BVS eW`Sa b] bVS RWa^ZOg O`S O\ WaacS Pcb Ob ZSOab Wb¸a \]b ZWYS bVS Q][ ^cbS` [Saa >S`VO^a bVS b`S\R b] caS \]bSP]]Ya Oa RSaYb]^ acPabWbcbSa abS[a T`][ bVWa \WUVb [O`S 7 QO\¸b TWUc`S ]cb eVg ^S]^ZS ^`STS` O RW\Yg ZO^b]^ b] O PWU O\R ^]eS`TcZ b]eS` Pcb bVWa Q]cZR PS bVS `SOa]\ /\R SfOQbZg V]e ]` eVg Q][^cbS`a O`S ab]ZS\ Wa PSg]\R [S 7b e]cZR bOYS [W\cbSa b] c\V]]Y OZZ bVS eW`Sa :O^b]^a O`S SOag b] a\OU 0ZcSb]]bV YSS^a USbbW\U c^U`ORSR a] eVS`S O`S [g 0ZcSb]]bV Q]\\SQbW]\a- EVWZS Wb¸a \]b O eWZRZg TOab Q]\\SQbW]\ R]Sa bVS b`O\aQSWdS` Q]ab a] [cQV bVOb T]` SfO[

^ZS OZZ YSgP]O`Ra QO\¸b PS 0ZcSb]]bV `ObVS` bVO\ eW`SR eWbV O Z]\U QOPZS O\R Q]\\SQb]`- AV]cZR\¸b SdS`g Q][^cbS` []bVS`P]O`R VOdS PcWZb W\ 0ZcSb]]bV- ESZZ \]b WT \]P]Rg caSa Wb 7 VOdS aSS\ QO[S`Oa O\R ^`W\bS`a O\R dO`W]ca ^S`W^V S`OZa Q][S O\R U] OZZ P`OUUW\U OP]cb bVS PcWZb W\ 0ZcSb]]bV 0cb bVS`S Wa US\S`OZZg a][SbVW\U [WaaW\U T`][ bVS [Wf ZWYS \] 0ZcSb]]bV ]\ bVS []bVS`P]O`R BVS\ OUOW\ 7 VOdS O ZO^b]^ eWbV 0ZcSb]]bV O\R b] PS V]\Sab bVS W\bS`TOQS a]TbeO`S abW\Ya B] OQbcOZZg R] a][SbVW\U Wa OeYeO`R O\R abc ^WR a] 7 \SdS` caS Wb ;OgPS [OYW\U bVS bVW\U []`S b`O\a^O`S\b O\R aZWQY e]cZR PS O U]]R bVW\U /\R eVObSdS` VO^^S\SR b] bVS eW`SZSaa CA0 R]\UZSa- /\]bVS` bSQV\]Z]Ug bVOb \SdS` _cWbS QOcUVb ]\ A] VS`S 7 aWb eWbV O ac^^]aSR eW`SZSaa `Sd ]ZcbW]\ c^]\ [S O\R bVS ]\Zg WbS[a O`]c\R bVOb bOYS TcZZ ORdO\bOUS ]T Wb O`S bVS EWW O\R bVS QSZZcZO` []PWZS ^V]\S eVWQV R]Sa ZWbbZS []`S bVO\ `S^ZOQS O ^V]\S eW`S eVWQV Wa abWZZ caSR b] V]]Y b] O ^V]\S O\geOg 7 UWdS c^ ]\ bVWa /ZZ bVOb Wa [WaaW\U Wa bVS `Ob b] ZWdS W\ bVS \Sab /\R b] PS V]\Sab 7¸[ \]b ac`S bVS`S Wa\¸b ]\S W\ bVS`S 2D=@/9 :7D3 =< B63 E30 8]V\¸a 7\bS`\Sb BD aV]e OW`a SdS`g ESR\SaROg Ob !(! 3B ]\ 1`O\Yg 5SSYa Q][ G]c QO\ R]e\Z]OR POQY S^Wa]RSa eVS\SdS` g]c ZWYS =1B=03@ ' >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< "

A/A16/ A35/<

EVg 1O\¸b A[O`b^V]\Sa 9WZZ <SbP]]YaS`S¸a O U`SOb WRSO O\R ]\S g]c [Og VOdS VOR( bVS aVO^S aVWTbW\U Q][^cbS` 7b¸a O ZWbbZS P]f bVS aWhS ]T O ^OQY ]T QWUO `SbbSa ]` [OgPS Wb Z]]Ya Xcab ZWYS O\ W>V]\S ;OgPS Wb Wa O\ W>V]\S >]^ Wb W\b] O PWU aQ`SS\ O\R YSgP]O`R O\R ^]e g]c VOdS O \SbP]]Y AZWRS Wb ]cb O\R g]c¸dS U]b O a[O`b ^V]\S /bbOQV O aZW[ abgZWaV VO\RaSb eWbV 0ZcSb]]bV O\R g]c VOdS O TOaVW]\ ]`WS\bSR d]WQS ^V]\S EVg VOa\¸b bVWa VO^^S\SR gSb- 7¸[ OaYW\U PSQOcaS aSdS`OZ ^S]^ZS VOdS `SQS\bZg OaYSR [S eVg bVSg QO\¸b \SbP]]Y WhS bVSW` a[O`b ^V]\Sa eVWQV \]eOROga VOdS TOab ^`] QSaa]`a O\R UWUOPgbSa ]T ab]`OUS 7¸[ \]b bOZYW\U OP]cb µa[O`bP]]Ya ¶ eVWQV O`S Xcab \SbP]]Ya `c\\W\U /@; ^`]QSaa]`a 7¸[ bOZY W\U OP]cb b`cS aVO^S aVWTbS`a eVS`S g]c QO\ P`W\U OZ]\U O TcZZ YSgP]O`R O\R PWU aQ`SS\ ]` \]b Oa g]c QV]]aS =dS` bVS ^Oab RSQORS bVS W\Rcab`g VOa U]\S POQYeO`Ra ]\ bVWa WaacS BVS`S VOa\¸b PSS\ O \Se 0ZcSb]]bV YSgP]O`R T]` a[O`b ^V]\Sa aW\QS $ >V]\Sa eWbV dWRS] ]cb

H

" >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< =1B=03@ '

^]`ba T]` ZO`US RWa^ZOga Q][S O\R U] eWbV ]cb [cQV \]bWQS 0cb bV`SS Q][^O\WSa VOdS `SQS\bZg ObbS[^bSR b] [OYS a[O`b^V]\Sa Q]\dS`bWPZS 1SZW] VOa VOR bVS []ab acQQSaa eWbV @SRTZg O P`OW\ZSaa '' ZO^b]^ bVOb g]c Q]\\SQb b] O EW\R]ea ;]PWZS ^V]\S 7b e]`Ya Pcb eWbV]cb [caWQ ]` dWRS] ac^^]`b´ O\R Wb¸a QZc\Yg / Q][^O\g \O[SR W [ObS aV]eSR [S O\ SZSUO\b VO\RVSZR POQY W\ 4SP`cO`g bVOb aZ]ba W\b] O ZO^b]^ abgZS P]Rg Pcb 7 VOdS\¸b VSO`R T`][ bVS Q][^O\g aW\QS ;]Rc VOa PSS\ aV]eW\U ]TT ZWbbZS 1>C c\Wba bVOb ¿b W\b] dO`W]ca W\bS`QVO\USOPZS ^V]\S P]RWSa T]` be] gSO`a \]e) bVSg¸`S `c[]`SR b] ZOc\QV a]]\ Pcb ]\Zg W\ 7a`OSZ A] eVg QO\¸b a[O`b^V]\Sa UWdS \SbP]]Ya O `c\ T]` bVSW` []\Sg- :Sb¸a bOYS ^`]QSaaW\U ^]eS` ]TT bVS bOPZS Oa bVOb e]\¸b PS O\ WaacS eWbVW\ O gSO` ]` a] 6S`S O`S a][S WRSOa BVS =A >`]PZS[ 7 Q]dS` eVOb ]c` ZO^b]^ O\OZgab 1WaQ] 1VS\U RS`WaWdSZg QOZZa µbVW\Ua eWbV]cb O `SOZ =A ¶ 6S [SO\a µbVW\Ua bVOb R]\¸b `c\ EW\ R]ea F> ]` DWabO ¶

2]QYW\U g]c` a[O`b ^V]\S e]\¸b VO^^S\ c\bWZ QO``WS`a QO\ [OYS []\Sg ]\ Wb ;]ab ]T bVS ZSORW\U a[O`b^V]\S ]^S`Ob W\U agabS[a O`S µ`SOZ¶ ]^S`ObW\U agabS[a Pcb bVSg OZZ ZOQY Q`WbWQOZ ESP Q][^]\S\ba O\R [OW\ab`SO[ ]TTWQS a]TbeO`S 0cb bVOb R]Sa\¸b QVO\US bVS TOQb bVOb [O\g a[O`b ^V]\S [O\cTOQbc`S`a T]`QS a]TbeO`S RSdSZ ]^S`a bV`]cUV ^OW\TcZ V]]^a SWbVS` [OYW\U bVS[ e]`Y W\ 8OdO eWbV ]\S VO\R bWSR PSVW\R bVSW` POQYa 0ZOQY0S``g /\R`]WR UWdW\U bVS[ \] OQQSaa b] VO`ReO`S Ob OZZ >OZ[ ESP=A ]` T]`QW\U bVSW` SdS`g []dS b] PS O^^`]dSR Pg bVS `O\R][ eVW[a ]T TOQSZSaa O^^O`ObQVWYa /^^ZS ;]ab e]`YW\U T]ZYa OZa] RS[O\R ;WQ`] a]Tb =T¿QS b] USb bVSW` X]Pa R]\S O\R ;WQ`] a]Tb `STcaSa b] ^`]U`O[ O dS`aW]\ ]T =T¿QS T]` bVS /@; QVW^a bVOb a[O`b^V]\Sa `c\ ]\ A[O`b^V]\S a]TbeO`S RSdSZ]^S`a VOdS PSS\ e]`YW\U VO`R eWbVW\ bVSaS ZW[WbObW]\a 1]\aWRS`W\U bVS`S O`S \]e $# W>V]\S O^^a Wb¸a VO`R b] PSZWSdS bVOb bVS`S O`S\¸b bV]caO\Ra ]T ^S]^ZS eV] eO\b b] caS bV]aS O^^a eWbV O \WQS PWU YSgP]O`R O\R aQ`SS\

W\U QO[S`Oa O\R QcbbW\U W\b] RWUWbOZ QO[S`O aOZSa ]` W\QZcRW\U [caWQ QO^OPWZWbWSa QOca W\U b`]cPZS T]` bVS \]\ W>V]\S [caWQ ^ZOgS` [O`YSb =TTS`W\U O R]QY ]^bW]\ T]` g]c` a[O`b^V]\S R]Sa\¸b aSS[ PSg]\R bVS ^OZS A] eS VOdS b] Z]]Y RSS^S` O\R T]ZZ]e bVS []\Sg b] eVOb 7 bVW\Y Wa bVS `SOZ O\aeS` 1O``WS`a O\R /^^ZS 2]\¸b EO\b 7b b] 6O^^S\ /Z[]ab SdS`g]\S W\ bVS C A \]e VOa O []PWZS ^V]\S acPaQ`W^bW]\ A] O YSg eOg bVOb QO``WS`a Sf^O\R Wa b] aSZZ SOQV Qca b][S` []`S bVO\ ]\S acPaQ`W^bW]\ O ab`Ob SUg bVOb DS`Wh]\ 13= :]eSZZ ;Q/RO[ ]\QS RSaQ`WPSR c\W\bS\bW]\OZZg ZSeRZg Oa µ# ^S`QS\b ^S\Sb`ObW]\ ¶ 7T g]c Pcg O a[O`b ^V]\S O\R O \SbP]]Y bVOb¸a be] acPaQ`W^bW]\a 0cb WT g]c` a[O`b ^V]\S PSQ][Sa g]c` \SbP]]Y bVOb¸a ]\Zg ]\S acPaQ`W^bW]\ BVOb¸a eVg A^`W\b R]Sa\¸b OZZ]e bSbVS`W\U ]\ bVS >OZ[ >`S) Wb eO\ba b] aSZZ ORRWbW]\OZ CA0 []RS[ ^ZO\a BVS`S eWZZ OZa] ^`]POPZg \SdS` PS O YSg P]O`R T]` W>V]\Sa PSQOcaS /^^ZS R]Sa\¸b eO\b b] S\RO\US` ;OQ0]]Y aOZSa 2]QYW\U g]c` a[O`b ^V]\S a]c\Ra ZWYS O bS``W¿Q WRSO T]` caS`a Pcb Wb Xcab e]\¸b VO^^S\ c\bWZ QO` `WS`a O\R a[O`b^V]\S [OYS`a O`S Q]\¿RS\b bVSg QO\ [OYS []\Sg ]\ Wb 1VSQY POQY W\ SO`Zg

6gP`WR 2SdWQSa( 1Zc\Yg O\R 3f^S\aWdS BVOb¸a bVS ZSaa]\ eS Q]cZR ZSO`\ T`][ @SRÀg 7b¸a O Q][[]\ ZOhg O`Uc[S\b bVOb¸a OZeOga b`cS c\bWZ Wb Wa\¸b 1][PW\W\U S [OWZ O\R O d]WQS ^V]\S Z]]YSR QZc\Yg c\bWZ 0ZOQY0S` `ga RWR Wb) [caWQ ^V]\Sa Z]]YSR QZc\Yg c\bWZ bVS W>V]\S QO[S OZ]\U 6gP`WR RSdWQSa bS\R b] Q]ab []`S O\R \Sb AB/G >6=<3 A;/@B 9SS^ c^ eWbV bVS ZObSab P]]Ya O`S c\cacOZZg QVSO^ 0cb bVOb VOa\¸b ]\ a[O`b^V]\Sa Pg `SORW\U AOaQVO¸a Q]Zc[\ Ob ab]^^SR a[O`b^V]\S [OYS`a T`][ W\QZcR U] ^Q[OU Q][ aSUO\

=1B=03@ ' >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< "!

2/< 1=AB/

BVW\Ua <]b b] 2] EVWZS 2`WdW\U `S^]`b ]cb W\ /cUcab aV]ea bVOb R`WdS`a O`S ! bW[Sa []`S ZWYSZg b] USb W\b] O\ OQQW RS\b eVWZS bSfbW\U bVO\ eVWZS \]b bSfbW\U BVS abcRg Q]\ RcQbSR Pg bVS DW`UW\WO BSQV B`O\a^]`bObW]\ 7\abWbcbS T]c\R bVOb W\ bVS [][S\ba PST]`S bVSW` OQQWRS\ba R`WdS`a a^S\b O\ OdS`OUS ]T # aSQ]\Ra Z]]YW\U OeOg T`][ bVS `]OR /b VWUVeOg a^SSRa bVOb Wa S\]cUV bW[S b] Q]dS` bVS ZS\UbV ]T O T]]bPOZZ ¿SZR BVWa \Sea VOa ZSUWaZOb]`a OQ`]aa bVS Q]c\b`g e]`YW\U ]\ ZOea b] PO\ 2`WdW\U EVWZS BSfbW\U 2EB W\ ]`RS` b] USb R`Wd S`a b] eSZZ eObQV eVS`S bVSg¸`S U]W\U 0cb bVOb Wa\¸b bVS ]\Zg bSQV\]Z]UWQOZ bV`SOb bVOb \SSRa b] PS ORR`SaaSR BVS`S O`S O V]ab ]T ]bVS` bSQV bOaYa bVOb QO\ ^cb g]c O\R ]bVS` R`WdS`a Ob `WaY

Q][ `SORS`a Y\]e TcZZ eSZZ Xcab V]e OeS a][S BeWbbS` Wa T]` Tc\ O\R aVO[SZSaa aSZT ^`][]bW]\ 4]ZZ]e [S Ob .RO\Q]a bO BVOb aOWR BeWbbS`W\U Wa bSfbW\U /\R bSfbW\U YWZZa ^S]^ZS

E67:3 2@7D7<5 2= <=B B/:9 =< B63 >6=<3

E67:3 2@7D7<5 2= <=B @3 >:=B G=C@ 5>A

C\ZWYS bSfbW\U bOZYW\U ]\ bVS ^V]\S ^`] dWRSa bVS PS\S¿b ]T PSW\U OPZS b] eObQV bVS `]OR <]\SbVSZSaa RWab`OQbW]\ QO\ QOcaS OQQWRS\ba / abcRg Pg bVS C\WdS`

;]ab 5>A RSdWQSa VOdS O eO`\W\U aQ`SS\ bVOb [OYSa g]c ^`][WaS \]b b] ]^S`ObS bVS c\Wb eVWZS Ob O QS`bOW\ a^SSR /\R []ab ]T ca WU\]`S Wb ;W\cbSa ZObS` eS VOdS ]\S VO\R

A

"" >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< =1B=03@ '

aWbg ]T CbOV T]c\R bVOb R`WdS`a ]\ QSZZ ^V]\Sa O`S & ^S`QS\b aZ]eS` b] `SOQb b] P`OYS ZWUVba /\]bVS` abcRg ^S`T]`[SR Pg bVS 7\ac`O\QS 7\abWbcbS T]` 6WUVeOg AOTSbg ;]b]`Waba T]c\R bVOb bOZYW\U ]\ O ^V]\S [ORS R`WdS`a T]c` bW[Sa []`S ZWYSZg b] USb W\b] O aS`W]ca Q`OaV ;OYW\U VO\R VSZR QOZZa Wa OZ`SORg PO\\SR W\ 1OZWT]`\WO EOaVW\Ub]\ <Se G]`Y 1]\\SQbWQcb O\R <Se 8S`aSg eWbV SfQS^bW]\a T]` QOZZa ca W\U 0ZcSb]]bV VSORaSba 8cab ZSb Wb U] b] d]WQS [OWZ E67:3 2@7D7<5 2= <=B BE7BB3@ >1;OU

;OYW\U QOZZa eVWZS R`WdW\U Wa OZ`SORg PO\\SR W\ aSdS`OZ abObSa 8cab ZSb Wb U] b] d]WQS[OWZ ]\ bVS eVSSZ O\R O\]bVS` bO^^W\U W\ ab`SSb \c[PS`a @SUO`RZSaa ]T V]e PWU bVS aQ`SS\ Wa 5>A abWZZ `S_cW`Sa b]] [O\g bO^a b] S\bS` O\ ORR`Saa /\R bVOb \Sfb bO^ g]c TSSZ [WUVb PS bVS Pc[^S` ]T bVS QO` W\ T`]\b ]T g]c

QWOZWaba 2SeSg 1VSObS[ 6]eS aV]e O aWU\W¿QO\b W\Q`SOaS W\ [Wa¿ZW\Ua Pg caS`a eV] ^`S^O`SR bVSW` `Sbc`\a eVWZS R`WdW\U E67:3 2@7D7<5 2= <=B 0C7:2 /< /;2 0/A32 5/;7<5 >1 7 Y\]e eVOb g]c¸`S bVW\YW\U

E67:3 2@7D7<5 2= <=B E/B16 BD 7b Wa ]\S

GSa caW\U /;2 Q][^]\S\ba eWZZ aOdS g]c O TSe Vc\R`SR PcQYa O\R g]c QO\ USb O agabS[ bVOb VOa a][S aeSSb ^S`T]`[O\QS /\R Wb Wa\¸b VO`R b] R] AbWZZ a^`SORW\U bVOb bVS`[OZ Q][^]c\R ]dS` bVS 1>C Wa O RSZW QObS ^`]QSaa /\R bVOb ACD W\ bVS ZSTb ZO\S \SdS` caSa VWa aWU\OZ ZWUVba

bVW\U T]` bVS YWRa b] eObQV A^]\US0]P W\ bVS POQY aSOb ]\ bVS eOg V][S T`][ 5`O\R[O¸a V]caS 7b Wa _cWbS O\]bVS` bVW\U eVS\ g]c QZW[P W\ POQY eWbV bVS[ b] aSS bVS S\R ]T bVS T]]bPOZZ UO[S <]b ]\Zg R]Sa bVS UO[S RWab`OQb g]c T`][ SdS` QVO\UW\U `]OR Q]\RWbW]\a Wb Wa OZa] dS`g RWT¿QcZb b] `SOQV bVS ^SROZa T`][ bVS POQY E67:3 2@7D7<5 2= <=B B/93 / A6=E3@ / b`cQY R`WdS` W\ 1VW\O eOa `SQS\bZg ^cZZSR aSOb ]dS` T]` bOYW\U O aV]eS` W\ VWa b`cQY´eVWZS E67:3 2@7D7<5 2= <=B 2=E<:=/2 1=>G R`WdW\U ]\ bVS 8W\XW 3f^`SaaeOg 3dWRS\bZg @756B32 ;CA71 8cab PSQOcaS g]c Z]dS VWa / 1 P`]YS O\R VS eO\bSR b] abOg Q]]Z bVOb \Se 5`SS\ 2Og b`OQY ]\ bVS `ORW] @SaSO`QVS`a O`S abWZZ W\dSabWUObW\U V]e R]Sa\¸b [SO\ g]c aV]cZR ¿`S c^ g]c` ZO^ aV]eS`W\U eVWZS R`WdW\U OTTSQba g]c` OQQW b]^ Z]OR 0WbB]``S\b O\R abO`b R]e\Z]OR RS\b `WaY Pcb SO`Zg `SacZba W\RWQObS Wb QO\¸b W\U Wb /`bWaba RSaS`dS b] PS ^OWR O\R \]e PS U]]R /\R OZZ bVOb eObS` eWZZ e`SOY bVOb WBc\Sa ]TTS`a 2@; T`SS b`OQYa Wb `S VOd]Q eWbV g]c` ROaVP]O`R OZZg Wa\¸b bVOb [cQV ]T O VOaaZS AbSOZW\U Wa :Sb [S PS QZSO` R`WdW\U eVWZS bSfbW\U Wa e`]\U Ob O\g a^SSR QZSO`Zg dS`g RO\US`]ca 7b VOa \]bVW\U b] R] eWbV bVS bSQV\]Z]Ug) Wb VOa b] R] eWbV bVS E67:3 2@7D7<5 2= <=B 3 47:3 G=C@ B/F3A TOQb bVOb g]c O`S bOYW\U g]c` SgSa ]TT bVS =\ZW\S bOf ^`S^O`ObW]\ aOdSa Q]c\bZSaa `]OR O\R g]c` VO\Ra ]TT bVS eVSSZ BVOb Wa V]c`a ]T T`cab`ObW]\ Pcb R`WdW\U $# [^V Xcab Rc[P ;OgPS eS \SSR ZOea b] YSS^ ca R]e\ bVS Sf^`SaaeOg Wa \]b bVS PSab bW[S T`][ PSVOdW\U abc^WRZg Pcb Q][[]\ aS\aS b] R] Wb GSa bVS 7@A bS\Ra b] PS dS`g ^WQYg e]cZR PS SdS\ []`S caSTcZ OP]cb Wba RSORZW\Sa Pcb Wb Wa e]`bV eOWbW\U B/:9 0/19 B= 2/< 3 [OWZ g]c` bV]cUVba b] c\bWZ g]c¸`S W\ >O`Y 3abW[ObSa Pg bOf a^S RO\MQ]abO.^Q[OU Q][ =1B=03@ ' >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< "#

7<A723 E7< B ES¸`S [S`S eSSYa OeOg T`][ bVS ^cPZWQ `SZSOaS ]T EW\R]ea % B] UWdS g]c O a\SOY ^SSY eS¸dS bSab R`WdS\ bVS ¿\OZ dS`aW]\ ]T bVS Q]RS 0g 8S`S[g / 9O^ZO\ O\R ;WQVOSZ ;cQV[]`S "$ >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< =1B=03@ '

VS Tcbc`S ]T EW\R]ea Wa c^]\ ca 7\ Xcab O TSe eSSYa =Qb] PS` b] PS SfOQb bVS TW\OZ dS`aW]\ ]T EW\R]ea % QOZZSR 5/ T]` µUS\S`OZ OdOWZOPWZWbg¶ eWZZ aVW^ =T Q]c`aS eS Q]cZR\¸b eOWb a] eS b]]Y bVS ¿\OZ Q]RS eVWQV eOa `SZSOaSR b] [O\cTOQ bc`S`a @B; ]dS` bVS ac[[S`

B63 <3E AB/@B ;3<C EVS\ VWUVZWUVbSR QS`bOW\ O^^a TSObc`S O 8c[^ :Wab aV]eW\U bVS []ab `SQS\bZg ]` T`S_cS\bZg ]^S\SR ¿ZSa

7<2=EA % ]cb T]` O a^W\ /\R eS VOdS b] aOg Wb Q]\bW\ cSa b] Z]]Y a]ZWR 7b¸a P]ZRS` W\ bS`[a ]T \Se QO^OPWZWbWSa O\R caS` W\bS`TOQS RSaWU\ bVO\ /^^ZS¸a A\]e :S]^O`R Pcb Wb aVO`Sa eWbV bVOb c^RObS O TW`[ POaWa W\ Wba ^`SRSQSaa]` =A DWabO BVS \Se ab`SO[W\U [SRWO Tc\QbW]\OZWbg b]USbVS` eWbV EW\R]ea %¸a \Se bOaYPO` 2SdWQS AbOUS 6][S5`]c^ \Sbe]`YW\U O\R

F> ;]RS [OYS bVWa EW\R]ea TO` []`S bVO\ O aS`dWQS ^OQY T]` DWabO´bV]cUV bVS be] ]^S`ObW\U agabS[a aVO`S [cQV c\RS`ZgW\U ^Zc[PW\U BVOb [SO\a eS aV]cZR\¸b aSS bVS Q][^ObWPWZWbg VOaaZSa eS aOe eWbV DWabO 0cb EW\R]ea %¸a ZWUVbS` agabS[ T]]b^`W\b [OYSa T]` TOabS` abO`b c^ O\R aZWUVbZg TOabS` ^S`T]`[O\QS 1O^ OZZ bVWa eWbV `]QY abSORg `SZWOPWZWbg O\R ;WQ`]a]Tb [Og Xcab VOdS O =1B=03@ ' >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< "%

B63 <3E 23A9B=> 7\ bVS RSTOcZb bVS[S bVS EW\R]ea ÀOU Wa \]e OR]`\SR eWbV ^ZO\ba O\R O\W[OZa

eW\\S` BVS ^`WQS T`][ Wa Z]eS` bVO\ bVS ^`WQS bVS Q][^O\g ]`WUW\OZZg OaYSR T]` DWabO c^U`ORS ^`WQS ' '# O\R TcZZ ^`WQS #' '# =\S [OX]` WaacS V]eSdS` Wa bVS c^U`ORS ^ObV T`][ F> eVWQV OTTSQba O Z]b ]T caS`a eV] Pg^OaaSR bVS [cQV [OZWU\SR DWabO 4]`bc\ObSZg ;WQ`]a]Tb Wa ]TTS`W\U c^U`ORS ^`WQW\U T]` EW\R]ea F> O\R SdS\ EW\R]ea ]e\S`a 3RWbW]\a O\R ASbc^ BVS`S eWZZ PS Xcab bV`SS SRWbW]\a ]T EW\R]ea % T]` aOZS( 6][S >`S[Wc[ '' '' >`]TSa aW]\OZ '' '' O\R CZbW[ObS ! ' '' ;]ab caS`a eWZZ eO\b b] ]^b T]` ]\S ]T bVS ¿`ab be] eWbV >`]TSaaW]\OZ ]PdW]caZg acWbSR b] e]`Y^ZOQSa O\R VO`R Q]`S bSQVWS caS`a CZbW [ObS W\QZcRSa SdS`gbVW\U T`][ bVS ]bVS` SRW bW]\a Pcb R]Sa\¸b ORR [cQV []`S bVO\ bVS OPWZWbWSa b] S\Q`g^b CA0 R`WdSa O\R aeWbQV "& >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< =1B=03@ '

b] O\g ]T !# ZO\UcOUSa 5]\S O`S bVS µCZbW [ObS 3fb`Oa¶ ]T DWabO ROga / T]c`bV SRWbW]\ AbO`bS` eWZZ Q][S ^`SW\abOZZSR ]\ a][S \Sb P]]Ya Pcb e]\¸b PS OdOWZOPZS Ob `SbOWZ ]cb ZSba AbO`bS` e]\¸b `c\ SgS QO\Rg ZWYS /S`] 5ZOaa O\R []ab \SbP]]Ya QO\ `c\ bVS VWUVS` dS`aW]\a eWbV ^S^^g S\]cUV ^S`T]`[O\QS Oa eS¸dS aSS\ W\ aSdS`OZ c\Wba W\ bVS ZOPa BVS 6][S 0OaWQ SRWbW]\ aSS\ W\ DWabO Wa U]\S W\ bVS C\WbSR AbObSa) 6][S >`S[Wc[ Wa bVS ]\Zg V][S QV]WQS VS`S <]bS OZa] bVOb bVSaS O`S ZWab ^`WQSa O\R g]c QO\ Sf^SQb b] aSS [O`YR]e\a OTbS` bVS =Qb]PS` ZOc\QV BVS`S eWZZ OZa] PS /\gbW[S C^U`ORSa T`][ bVS Z]eS` SRWbW]\a ]T EW\R]ea % b] bVS VWUVS` SRWbW]\a C^U`ORW\U T`][ AbO`bS` b] 6][S >`S[Wc[ eWZZ Q]ab %' '' T`][ 6][S >`S[Wc[ b] >`]TSaaW]\OZ eWZZ Q]ab &' '' O\R T`][ 6][S >`S[Wc[ b] CZbW[ObS eWZZ Q]ab !' '' 4W\OZZg O 4O[WZg >OQY ^`WQW\U

C^U`ORW\U b] EW\R]ea %- 6S`S /`S A][S 7\abOZZObW]\ =^bW]\a Windows 7 Home Premium

Windows 7 Professional

Windows Vista® Home Basic

Upgrade

Custom

Windows Vista® Home Premium

Upgrade

Custom

Windows 7 Ultimate

Upgrade from:

Upgrade Windows Vista® Business

Custom

Upgrade

Windows Vista® Ultimate

Custom

Custom

Windows XP/ Windows Vista® Starter/32-bit to 64-bit

Custom

Custom Installation

A custom installation enables dual booting or the ability to replace your existing operating system with Windows 7. Your programs, settings, and data will be removed if you opt to replace. Back up all of your data and ensure you have your original program disks available before doing a custom installation.

Upgrade Installation

An upgrade installs Windows 7 retaining all your programs, settings, and documents after installation.

]^bW]\ eWZZ OZZ]e W\abOZZObW]\ ]T EW\R]ea % 6][S >`S[Wc[ ]\ bV`SS >1a T]` "' ''´ O ^`Sbbg aeSSb RSOZ Q][^O`SR b] bVS W\RW dWRcOZ ZWQS\aSa <]bS OZa] bVOb ;WQ`]a]Tb `SQS\bZg O\\]c\QSR d]Zc[S RWaQ]c\ba T]` PcaW\Saa Qcab][S`a :Oab ;Og¸a @SZSOaS 1O\RWRObS @1 ^cb TW\WaVW\U b]cQVSa ]\ a][S \Se TSObc`Sa c\Q]`YSR O TSe Sfb`Oa O\R ORRSR O U]]R RSOZ ]T ^]ZWaV b] EW\R]ea % O\R \]\S ]T bVWa

QVO\USa W\ @B; BVS W\abOZZ `]cbW\S VOa \Se WQ]\a O\R O TSe a^ZOaV aQ`SS\a µ1VSQYW\U dWRS] ^S`T]`[O\QS ¶ O\R a] ]\ eWbV O \Se abO`Pc`ab STTSQb 3dS\ bVS AbO`bW\U EW\R]ea O\R Z]U ]\ aQ`SS\a VOdS UOW\SR O ZSOTg ^Ob bS`\SR POQYU`]c\R BVS W\abOZZObW]\ a[O`bZg e]cZR\¸b OZZ]e ca b] aSb c^ bVS =A eVWZS ]c` ZO^b]^ eOa c\^ZcUUSR /a eWbV bVS @1 bVS @B; Z]]Ya T]` c^RObSa ]\ ¿`ab `c\) eS `SQ ][[S\R W\abOZZW\U bVS[ =1B=03@ ' >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< "'

EW\R]ea %( EVOb 3OQV 3RWb VERSION

PRICE NEW

Single

Family Pack (3 licenses)

From previous Windows version

To H

Starter

N/A*

N/A*

N/A*

$79

Home Basic

N/A

N/A

N/A

N/A

Home Premium

$199.99

$149.99

$119.99

N/A

Professional

$299.99

N/A

$199.99

N/A

Ultimate

$319.99

N/A

$219.99

N/A

Enterprise

Variable

N/A

Variable

N/A

* Preinstalled only

7T g]c eO\b b] R] O\ c^U`ORS W\abOZZObW]\ g]c [cab PS `c\\W\U DWabO A> ]` A> O\R VOdS '50 ]T T`SS RWaY a^OQS @S[S[PS` c^U`ORS W\abOZZObW]\a W\ eVWQV OZZ g]c` ^`] U`O[a O\R R]Qc[S\ba O`S [OW\bOW\SR T]` bVS \Se =A O`S ]\Zg OdOWZOPZS b] DWabO caS`a CaS`a ]T F> O\R ]bVS` dS`aW]\a ]T EW\R]ea # >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< =1B=03@ '

eWZZ VOdS b] QV]]aS 1cab][ O\R R] O µQZSO\¶ W\abOZZ ES W\abOZZSR EW\R]ea % @B; ]\ O 2SZZ \SbP]]Y O 2SZZ F>A ; !! \]bSP]]Y O\R O\ 6> B]cQVA[O`b BVS W\abOZZS` QO\ T]`[Ob ]` Q`SObS \Se ^O`bWbW]\a eWbV Wba ORdO\QSR QV]WQSa 7\abOZZObW]\ b]]Y ! [W\cbSa T]` O

WbW]\ 1]aba FEATURES UPGRADE

Anytime Upgrade

Home Premium

To Professional

To Ultimate

9.99

$114.99

$164.99

• Does not support Windows Aero • Not available in a 64-bit version

A

N/A

N/A

• Available only in emerging markets

A

$89.99

$139.99

• HomeGroup networking • Multitouch and improved handwriting recognition • Windows Media Center

A

N/A

$129.99

Same as Home Premium, plus: • Back up to home or business network • Domain join • Encrypting file system • Location aware printing • Remote desktop host • Windows XP Mode

A

N/A

N/A

Same as Professional, plus: • BitLocker drive encryption • Support for 35 languages

A

N/A

N/A

Same as Ultimate, but available in volume licensing only

[OQVW\S bVOb OZ`SORg VOR bVS `SZSOaS QO\ RWRObS ]T EW\R]ea % W\abOZZSR Z]\US` bVO\ bVS [W\cbSa @1 b]]Y ]\ O PZO\Y ^O`bWbW]\ BVS W\abOZZS` Q]^WSa ^`]U`O[a O\R RObO T`][ bVS ^`SdW]ca W\abOZZObW]\ b] O µeW\R]ea ]ZR¶ RW`SQb]`g Oa DWabO RWR 7\abOZZW\U b] O PZO\Y \Se ^O`bWbW]\ R]Sa\¸b `S_cW`S bVOb abS^ a]

W\abOZZObW]\ eS\b TOabS` Ob " [W\cbSa´abWZZ aZWUVbZg aZ]eS` bVO\ Wb b]]Y b] W\abOZZ bVS @1 /TbS` W\abOZZObW]\ V]eSdS` eS VOR O ^`]P ZS[ eWbV bVS ZO^b]^¸a U`O^VWQa R`WdS`´]c` EW\R]ea 3f^S`WS\QS 7\RSf eOa O\R eS Q]cZR\¸b aSS /S`] RSaYb]^ STTSQba 5Sb bW\U bVS Q]``SQb R`WdS` W\abOZZSR eOa TO` ZSaa =1B=03@ ' >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< #

>3@A=</:7H3 7B G]c QO\ [OYS g]c` agabS[ g]c` ]e\ Pg QV]]aW\U g]c` ]e\ a]c\Ra POQYU`]c\R O\R aQ`SS\ aOdS` T`][ bVS 1]\b`]Z >O\SZ

Ocb][ObSR bVO\ Wb aV]cZR VOdS PSS\ ES VOR b] U] b] 2SZZ¸a aWbS O\R TW\R bVS R`WdS` BVS W\abOZZS` T]c\R O\R W\abOZZSR bVS Q]` `SQb R`WdS` ]\ bVS 6> B]cQVA[O`b O\R O TSe \SbP]]Ya eS bSabSR Pcb ]\S \SbP]]Y VOR bVS aO[S U`O^VWQa R`WdS` ^`]PZS[ 0g bVS bW[S EW\R]ea % Wa OdOWZOPZS b] bVS ^cPZWQ bVWa \cWaO\QS VOR PSbbS` PS U]\S WT bVS Q][^O\g eO\ba b] Od]WR bVS VOa aZSa bVOb OQQ][^O\WSR bVS DWabO `]ZZ]cb B/A90/@ 7;>@=D3;3<BA BVS bOaYPO` Pcb b]\a O`S bOZZS` UZ]e eVS\ g]c V]dS` ]dS` bVS[ O\R RWa^ZOg bVc[P\OWZa ]T O\g R]Qc[S\ba SOQV O^^ VOa ]^S\

# >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< =1B=03@ '

7\bS`TOQS O\R BOaYPO` /TbS` O gSO` ]T RWa^ZOgW\U bVS AWO[SaS 4WUVbW\U 4WaV OYO 0SbbO USb Wb- 0SbO- bVS @B; \]e RWa^ZOga Oa Wba QS\b`OZ RSaY b]^ W[OUS O `SRSaWU\SR EW\R]ea ÀOU =\S abO`bc^ QVO`OQbS`WabWQ bVOb RWaO^^]W\ba ca Wa bVOb bVS a]c\R Wa WRS\bWQOZ b] DWabO¸a abO`bc^ a]c\R G]c¸R bVW\Y ;WQ`]a]Tb e]cZR Q][ [WaaW]\ O \Se abO`bc^ a]c\R T]` acQV O V]b \Se =A BVS RSTOcZb bVS[S ]T bVS W\bS`TOQS VOa Wba ]e\ \Se Z]]Y gSb DWabO caS`a eWZZ TSSZ []abZg Ob V][S 3dS\ c^U`ORW\U F> caS`a eWZZ VOdS ZWbbZS b`]cPZS eWbV bVS C7 Pcb \SWbVS` eWZZ bVSg PS OPZS b] QZW\U b] bVS ^Oab BVS`S¸a \] F> S[cZObW]\ bVS[S W\ EW\R]ea % Oa bVS`S Wa W\ DWabO BVS`S Wa V]eSdS` O EW\R]ea F> ;]RS T]` F> S[cZObW]\´[]`S ]\ bVOb ZObS` EVS\ g]c abO`b c^ bVS =A g]c aSS a][S a\Ohhg SgS QO\Rg( Q]Z]`SR UZ]eW\U R]ba bVOb PSQ][S bVS EW\R]ea ÀOU BVS bOaYPO`

B/93 / >339 7T g]c` RSaY b]^ Wa Q`]eRSR eWbV eW\ R]ea g]c QO\ QV]]aS b] Xcab Z]]Y Ob ]\S O\R [OYS bVS ]bVS`a b`O\a^O`S\b

OZa] VOa []`S \]bWQSOPZS QVO\USa) T]` O\ W\ RS^bV Z]]Y Ob bVWa \Se W\bS`TOQS Q]`\S` ab]\S QVSQY ]cb bVS O`bWQZS µBVS <Se EW\ R]ea % BOaYPO` ¶ Pg 8Oa]\ 1`]aa 7\ O \cbaVSZZ bOaYPO` Pcbb]\a O`S bOZZS` bVO\ PST]`S OZbV]cUV g]c QO\ [OYS bVS[ a[OZZS` OUOW\ G]c QO\ QV]]aS eVSbVS` b] Q][PW\S OZZ W\abO\QSa ]T ]\S O^^ W\ ]\S Pcbb]\ ]` YSS^ OZZ aS^O`ObS ]` b] Q][PW\S bVS[ ]\Zg eVS\ a^OQS Wa aV]`b ]\ bVS bOaY PO` BOaYPO` Pcbb]\a UZ]e eVS\ g]c V]dS` bVS []caS ]dS` bVS[ eWbV `SZObSR Pcbb]\a UZ]eW\U bVS aO[S Q]Z]` BVSg OZa] RWa^ZOg aWRS Pg aWRS bVc[P\OWZa eWbV ¿ZS\O[Sa ]T O\g R]Qc[S\ba bVS O^^ VOa ]^S\ 1ZWQY W\U O bVc[P\OWZ ]^S\a bVS O^^ eWbV bVS R]Q W\ _cSabW]\ Z]ORSR 7T O\ O^^¸a eW\R]e Wa ]^S\ []dW\U bVS Qc`a]` ]dS` SOQV bOaY PO` bVc[P\OWZ aeWbQVSa b] bVOb R]Qc[S\b W\ bVS O^^ eW\R]e G]c QO\ \]e []dS Pcb b]\a b] eVObSdS` ^]aWbW]\ ]\ bVS bOaYPO` g]c ZWYS 4W\OZZg O\ ]^bW]\ ZSba g]c ^W\ ]` ^S`[O\S\bZg aSb O bOaYPO` WQ]\ a] bVOb Wb¸a

OZeOga ^`SaS\b BVOb¸a O U]]R bVW\U aW\QS ?cWQY :Oc\QV WQ]\a VOdS RWaO^^SO`SR W\ EW\R]ea % BVS EW\R]ea % AbO`b [S\c Wa \SO`Zg WRS\ bWQOZ b] DWabO¸a SfQS^b bVOb SOQV O^^ZWQObW]\ S\b`g \]e RWa^ZOga eVOb¸a QOZZSR O 8c[^ :Wab eVS\ g]c V]dS` bVS []caS ^]W\bS` ]dS` Wba S\b`g BVWa ZWab ^`SaS\ba O QV]WQS ]T bVS ¿ZSa []ab `SQS\bZg O\R T`S_cS\bZg ]^S\SR eWbV bVOb ^`]U`O[ <]bS V]eSdS` bVOb Wb e]`Ya ]\Zg T]` bVS ZO`US AbO`b [S\c QV]WQS \]b eVS\ g]c QZWQY ]\ /ZZ >`]U`O[a ES eWaV Wb e]`YSR T]` P]bV /\]bVS` AbO`b [S\c RWTTS`S\QS Wa W\ bVS ]^bW]\a bVOb O^^SO` b] bVS `WUVb ]T bVS ^`]U`O[ ZWab( <Sbe]`Y O\R 1]\\SQb B] O`S U]\S O\R O 2SdWQSa O\R >`W\bS`a QV]WQS VOa PSS\ ORRSR >`Sac[ OPZg ;WQ`]a]Tb \]e b`caba caS`a b] dWaWb bVS <Sbe]`Y O\R 7\bS`\Sb Q]\b`]Z ^O\SZ T]` \Sb e]`YW\U bOaYa 5]\S b]] Wa bVS AWRSPO` OZbV]cUV bVS UORUSba bVOb ]\QS ZWdSR W\ Wb QO\ \]e À]Ob T`SSZg O\geVS`S ]\ bVS RSaYb]^ 7T g]c` aQ`SS\¸a Q]dS`SR eWbV O^^ZWQObW]\ eW\ =1B=03@ ' >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< #!

5@=C>7<5 >6=B=A EWbV bVS \Se :WP`O`WSa TSObc`S g]c QO\ U`]c^ ^V]b]a `SUO`RZSaa ]T eVS`S bVSg¸`S Z]QObSR aS^O `ObS R`WdSa \Sbe]`YSR >1a O\R a] ]\

R]ea bVS \Se 2SaYb]^ >SSY Tc\QbW]\ QO\ `SdSOZ bVSaS UORUSba Pg [OYW\U OZZ eW\ R]ea ]\ bVS RSaYb]^ b`O\a^O`S\b eVS\ g]c V]dS` bVS []caS W\ bVS Z]eS` `WUVb Q]`\S` ]T bVS aQ`SS\ 7 ^`STS` bVS Sf^ZWQWb \Obc`S ]T bVS AV]e 2SaYb]^ WQ]\ W\ F> O\R DWabO `ObVS` bVO\ bVS \]\W\bcWbWdS QZWQYW\U ]\ bVS c\[O`YSR Q]`\S` >SSY Wa Y\]e\ Oa O\ /S`] 2SaYb]^ 3\VO\QS[S\b /\]bVS` acQV S\VO\QS [S\b Wa bVS \Se PSVOdW]` bVOb [OfW[WhSa O eW\R]e eVS\ g]c R`OU Wb b] bVS b]^ ]T bVS aQ`SS\ 2`OU Wb POQY R]e\ O\R Wb `Sbc`\a b] Wba ^`SdW]ca aWhS µAVOYW\U¶ O eW\R]e´QZWQY W\U ]\ bVS b]^ eW\R]e PO` O\R aVOYW\U bVS []caS´[W\W[WhSa OZZ ]bVS` eW\R]ea ]\ bVS aQ`SS\ 4W\OZZg []dW\U be] eW\R]ea b] ]^^]aWbS aWRSa ]T bVS aQ`SS\ QOcaSa SOQV b] bOYS c^ VOZT bVS aQ`SS\ 4]` bVWa b] e]`Y g]c VOdS b] U`OP bVS bWbZS PO` eWbV bVS []caS ^]W\bS` O\R R`OU Wb OZZ bVS eOg b] bVS SRUS ]T bVS aQ`SS\ ES¸`S \]b bV`WZZSR OP]cb R`OU UW\U c^ b] [OfW[WhS BVWa Q]cZR PS O\\]gW\U WT g]c Xcab eO\b b] []dS O eW\R]e eWbV]cb Sf^O\RW\U Wb 2]cPZS QZWQYW\U [OfW[WhSa bVS eW\R]e O\geOg BVS aVOYW\U ]^bW]\ V]e SdS` Wa \WTbg #" >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< =1B=03@ '

:WP`O`WSa EVS\ g]c ]^S\ 3f^Z]`S` eW\R]ea W\ EW\ R]ea % g]c USb O \Se QV]WQS ]\ bVS ZSTb aWRS( :WP`O`WSa BVSaS U`]c^ `SZObSR ¿ZSa `SUO`R ZSaa ]T Z]QObW]\ eVSbVS` ]\ aS^O`ObS R`WdSa ]` \Sbe]`YSR >1a 4]c` ^`SaSb ZWP`O`WSa O`S W\QZcRSR( 2]Qc[S\ba ;caWQ >WQbc`Sa O\R DWRS]a G]c QO\ Q`SObS Oa [O\g \Se :WP`O`

3/AG :7AB3<7<5 :WP`O`WSa [OYS Wb SOag T]` g]c b] U`]c^ O\R dWSe [caWQ Pg US\`S RObS ]` bOUa

43E3@ C/1 >=> C>A ;WQ`] a]Tb ^`][WaSa b] `SRcQS bVS \c[PS` ]T C/1 W\bS``c^bW]\a eWbV EW\R]ea %

WSa Oa g]c ZWYS O\R eVS\ g]c \OdWUObS b] O\g RW`SQb]`g O\ 7\QZcRS W\ ZWP`O`g aSZSQbW]\ Ob bVS b]^ ]T bVS eW\R]e ZSba g]c ORR Wb b] bVS ZWP`O`g ]T g]c` QV]WQS 4]` []`S RSbOWZa QVSQY ]cb µEW\R]ea % :WP`O`WSa ¶ =\S \]bS( EVS\ W\ O ZWP`O`g g]c QO\ O``O\US bVS Q]\bS\ba \]b ]\Zg Pg T]ZRS` Pcb OZa] Pg RObS ]` bOUa :SbbW\U ^S]^ZS U`]c^ Q]\bS\b W\ eOga RS¿\SR Pg caS `ObVS` bVO\ ab]`OUS Z]QObW]\ Wa O []dS W\ bVS `WUVb RW`SQ bW]\ AbWZZ ;WQ`]a]Tb Q]cZR SdS\ bOYS Wb O abS^ Tc`bVS` Pg ZSbbW\U g]c Q`SObS O ZWP`O`g POaSR Q][^ZSbSZg ]\ Q]\bS\b bg^S´aOg OZZ dWR S]a´`ObVS` bVO\ [OYW\U g]c a^SQWTg eVWQV T]ZRS`a aV]cZR PS W\QZcRSR

bc`\ ]TT bVSaS W\bS``c^bW]\a W\ DWabO Pcb bVOb VOa\¸b ab]^^SR bVS QV]`ca ]T RWaO^^`]dOZ EW\R]ea % OW[a b] `SRcQS bVS \c[PS` ]T OQbW]\a bVOb ^]^ c^ bVS RWOZ]Ua O\R UWdS g]c ¿\S` Q]\b`]Z ]dS` eVOb b`WUUS`a bVS[ 7\ bVS \Se C/1¸a aSbbW\Ua ^O\SZ Wa O T]c` ^]aWbW]\ aZWRS` eV]aS be] S\Ra O`S /ZeOga \]bWTg O\R <SdS` \]bWTg BVWa e]\¸b a]ZdS OZZ C/1 O\\]gO\QSa Pcb Ob ZSOab Wb UWdSa caS`a []`S Q]\b`]Z bVO\ Xcab µ]\¶ ]` µ]TT ¶ /\]bVS` \Se EW\R]ea % ab`ObSUg RSaWU\SR b] `SRcQS W\bS``c^bW]\a Wa bVS µ/cb] 3ZSdObS¶ ZWab´O eVWbSZWab T]` O^^a bVOb O`S U`SS\ ZWUVbSR b]

BVS C/1 O\R =bVS` 7\bS``c^bW]\a BVS PO``OUS ]T [SaaOUSa T`][ CaS` /QQ]c\b 1]\b`]Z C/1 VOa PSS\ O Q]\abO\b a]c`QS ]T Q][^ZOW\ba OP]cb DWabO 7\abOZZ O ^`]U`O[ ]` [OYS O\g YW\R ]T agabS[ ZSdSZ QVO\US O\R g]c USb W\bS``c^bSR ;WQ`]a]Tb RSaWU\SR C/1 b] [OYS EW\R]ea []`S aSQc`S Pg ^`S dS\bW\U c\eO\bSR ^`]U`O[ W\abOZZObW]\a O\R agabS[ aSbbW\U QVO\USa BVS Q][^O\g QZOW[a bVOb Oa O `SacZb $ ^S`QS\b TSeS` [OZeO`S W\TSQbW]\a VOdS ]QQc``SR W\ DWabO bVO\ W\ F> A> ;OgPS a] Pcb bVS TSObc`S 1@/<9 C> =@ 2=E< B63 C/1 G]c QO\ aS`W]caZg O\\]ga caS`a G]c QO\ OQbcOZZg QV]]aS V]e ]TbS\ g]c eO\b C/1 b] \]bWTg g]c =1B=03@ ' >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< ##

03BB3@ 71=< 1=<B@=: EW\ R]ea % UWdSa g]c []`S Q]\b`]Z ]dS` eVWQV WQ]\a O\R \]bW¿QO bW]\a g]c aSS W\ bVS Z]eS` `WUVb Q]`\S` ]T g]c` aQ`SS\

Pg^Oaa C/1 Q]\TW`[ObW]\a 4]` O RSS^S` Z]]Y Ob bVS C/1 aSS ]c` ab]`g µASQc`Wbg W\ EW\R]ea %( C/1 O\R G]c ¶ EW\R]ea % OZa] `SRcQSa RWab`OQbW]\a T`][ agabS[ b`Og \]bW¿QObW]\a BVS =A UWdSa ¿\S U`OW\ Q]\b`]Z ]dS` eVOb POZZ]]\a O ^`] U`O[ ^]^a c^ T`][ bVWa Z]eS` `WUVb O`SO ]T bVS aQ`SS\ BVS WQ]\ O`SO WbaSZT VOa PSS\ `SZWSdSR ]T QZcbbS` 0g RSTOcZb g]c aSS ]\Zg O TSe WQ]\a eWbV bVS `Sab OQQSaaWPZS dWO O\ c^ O``]e 7T g]c ZWYS b] aSS OZZ bVS WQ]\a V]e SdS` g]c QO\ aSb EW\R]ea b] aV]e bVS[ G]c QO\ bc`\ WQ]\a ]\ O\R ]TT´SdS\ agabS[ WQ]\a ZWYS 1Z]QY D]Zc[S O\R <Sbe]`Y WQ]\a =\S \Se agabS[ b`Og S\b`g /QbW]\ 1S\bS` bOYSa ]dS` T]` bVS ASQc`Wbg 1S\bS` WQ]\ W\ ^`SdW]ca EW\R]ea dS`aW]\a /QbW]\ 1S\ bS` OZa] VO\RZSa \]bW¿QObW]\a T`][ aSdS`OZ ]bVS` EW\R]ea TSObc`Sa W\QZcRW\U C^RObSa 0OQYc^ O\R C/1 ;O\g eWZZ eSZQ][S bVS `SRcQbW]\ ]T b`Og QZcbbS` >S`a]\OZZg eS ^`S TS` b] aSS OZZ bVS WQ]\a ;WQ`]a]Tb VOa OZa] []RW¿SR O b`OWb ]T bVS DWabO aVcbR]e\ Pcbb]\ bVOb Q]\TcaSR a][S ^S]^ZS 0g RSTOcZb QZWQYW\U ]\ bVS `SR µ]TT #$ >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< =1B=03@ '

aWU\¶ Pcbb]\ W\ DWabO ^cb bVS Q][^cbS` W\b] aZSS^ []RS BVWa OZZ]eSR T]` O [cQV _cWQYS` `SabO`b´O TSe aSQ]\Ra ]\ a][S >1a 0cb caS`a bV]cUVb QZWQYW\U bVS Pcbb]\ e]cZR Q][^ZSbSZg aVcb R]e\ bVS [OQVW\S <]e bVS`S¸a \] O[PWUcWbg ZSTb( AVcbR]e\ Wa bVS RSTOcZb O\R ]\Zg OTbS` QZWQYW\U ]\ bVS O``]e \Sfb b] Wb eWZZ g]c aSS aZSS^ VWPS`\ObS Z]U ]cb O\R Z]QY ASQc`Wbg BVS \Se C/1 ^VWZ]a]^Vg \Obc`OZZg VOa aSQc`Wbg W[^ZWQObW]\a O\R aSQc`Wbg Uc`c <SWZ 8 @cPS\YW\U VOa ^`]RcQSR O aS`WSa ]T O`bWQZSa ORR`SaaW\U bV]aS O\R ]bVS` EW\ R]ea % aSQc`Wbg Q]\aWRS`ObW]\a ASQc`Wbg Q][Sa W\b] ^ZOg `WUVb T`][ bVS USb U]´bVOb Wa Ob aSbc^ O\R µASQc`Wbg W\ EW\R]ea %( ASbc^¶ ORR`SaaSa bVWa´^O`bWQcZO`Zg \]b W\U bVOb bVS =A ZOQYa PcWZb W\ O\bWdW`ca a]Tb eO`S OZbV]cUV bVS =A¸a A]ZcbW]\ 1S\bS` R]Sa U`c[PZS OP]cb bVS \SSR T]` Wb Oa eSZZ Oa acUUSabW\U bVOb g]c OQbWdObS Ocb][ObWQ c^RObSa BVS ¿`SeOZZ W\ EW\R]ea % VOa PSS\ [cQV

W[^`]dSR 7b [OYSa Q]\¿Uc`W\U V][S \Sb e]`Ya a[]]bVS` O\R ]TTS`a aS^O`ObS Q]\ TWUc`ObW]\ aSbbW\Ua T]` ^`WdObS 6][S ]` E]`Y O\R ^cPZWQ \Sbe]`Ya =bVS` aSQc`Wbg `SZObSR U]]RWSa W\ EW\R]ea % O`S RWaQcaaSR W\ µASQc`Wbg W\ EW\R]ea %( 0Wb:]QYS` O\R ;]`S ¶ W\QZcRW\U 0Wb:]QYS` B] 5] S\Q`g^ bW]\ T]` `S[]dOPZS R`WdSa /^^:]QYS` O\R AgabS[ @Sab]`S 7\ US\S`OZ bVS dS`RWQb Wa bVOb aSQc`Wbg W\ EW\R]ea % VOa PSS\ beSOYSR O\R O TSe \Se \WQSbWSa ORRSR Pcb Wb¸a \]b O _cO\bc[ ZSO^ W\ ab`ObSUg bVS eOg DWabO eOa =\S TW\OZ abS^ ;WQ`]a]Tb VOa bOYS\ b] W[^`]dS aSQc`Wbg Wa `S[]dW\U /cb]`c\ T`][ \]\ ]^bWQOZ R`WdSa Q]\\SQbSR b] O >1 BVWa ^`SdS\ba [OZWQW]ca Q]RS ]\ O CA0 YSg T`][ Q]\bO[W\ObW\U g]c` >1 Pg `c\\W\U eVS\ g]c W\aS`b Wb BVS W\TO[]ca 1]\¿QYS` e]`[ VOa PSS\ Y\]e\ b] caS bVWa [SbV]R ]T W\TSQbW]\ /\R bVS 3\UW\SS`W\U EW\R]ea % PZ]U _c]bSa O ¿\RW\U W\ O abcRg Pg 4]`S T`]\b 1ZWS\b ASQc`Wbg bVOb µ[OZeO`S bVOb QO\ ^`]^OUObS dWO /cb]`c\ OQQ]c\bSR T]` % % ^S`QS\b ]T W\TSQbW]\a W\ bVS aSQ]\R VOZT ]T &´bVS ZO`USab aW\UZS QObSU]`g ]T [OZ eO`S W\TSQbW]\a ¶

1=<B@=: >/<3: ;/93=D3@ / \Se DWSe 0g ]^bW]\ ZSba g]c dWSe OZZ ]` a]`b Pg QObSU]`g

O eV]^^W\U #' 1]\b`]Z >O\SZ WbS[a) bVS @B; USba bVS \c[PS` R]e\ b] "% 5]\S O`S 0W][Sb`WQ 2SdWQSa 1ZSO`Bg^S BSfb Bc\S` 2STOcZb :]QObW]\ 4SSRPOQY `SZSOaSR Xcab T]` bVS PSbO bVWa ]\S R]Sa\¸b `SOZZg Q]c\b eS ac^^]aS 5O[S 1]\b`]ZZS`a WA1A7 7\W bWOb]` =TÀW\S 4WZSa >S\ O\R B]cQV AgabS[ 7Q]\a BOPZSb >1 ASbbW\Ua BSfb b] A^SSQV O\R EW\R]ea AWRSAV]e ;O\g ]T bVSaS TSObc`Sa VOdS PSS\ acP ac[SR Pg bVS 2SdWQSa O\R >`W\bS`a Q]\b`]Z ^O\SZ ]` []dSR SZaSeVS`S W\ bVS =A BVS 1ZSO`Bg^S BSfb Bc\S` T]` W\abO\QS Wa abWZZ SOaWZg T]c\R W\ bVS 2Wa^ZOg Q]\b`]Z A][S ]T bVS QVO\USa O`S ac`^`WaW\U V]eSdS` EVOb¸a VO^^S\SR b] AWRSAV]e- 4]` O\g]\S W\bS` SabSR W\ bVWa Z]\U \SUZSQbSR bSQV\]Z]Ug R]\¸b e]``g 7 ORRSR O AWRSAV]e RSdWQS b] EW\R]ea % O PSbO dS`aW]\ ]T bVS \]e QO\QSZSR @WQOdWaW]\ `S[]bS Q]\b`]Z O\R W\abOZZSR bVS R`WdS`a O\R bVS 1]\b`]Z >O\SZ O^^SO`SR 7b aSS[a bVOb QS`bOW\ WbS[a O`S YSgSR b] O^^SO` ]\Zg WT `SZSdO\b´eVWQV [OYSa aS\aS

;O\OUW\U 2SdWQSa 7\ ORRWbW]\ b] \Se WQ]\a bVS 1]\b`]Z >O\SZ VOa O dS`aObWZS \Se Xc[^ ZWab Oa g]c¸ZZ aSS WT g]c ^W\ Wb b] bVS BOaYPO` O\R `WUVb QZWQY ]\ bVS Pcbb]\a BVS 1]\b`]Z >O\SZ WbaSZT USba O TSe [W\]` beSOYa / \Se DWSe Pg [S\c O^^SO`a PS\SObV bVS 1]\b`]Z >O\SZ aSO`QV P]f BVWa ZSba g]c aeWbQV T`][ bVS RSTOcZb QObSU]`g dWSe b] O dWSe bVOb aV]ea OZZ 1]\ 2SdWQS AbOUS b`]Z >O\SZ WbS[a BVS EW\R]ea % 0SbO VOR 1]\\SQbW\U RSdWQSa b] g]c` >1 O\R USbbW\U =1B=03@ ' >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< #%

23D713 AB/53 3OQV RSdWQS W\ g]c` \Sbe]`Y USba Wba ]e\ ^OUS RSaQ`WPW\U Wba QO^OPWZW bWSa eWbV 2SdWQS AbOUS 6S`S¸a bVS [OW\ ^OUS T]` ]c` BVW\Y >OR T]` SfO[^ZS

eVOb g]c eO\b T`][ bVS[ VOa OZeOga PSS\ O ^OW\ 1]\\SQb O QSZZ ^V]\S T]` SfO[^ZS O\R g]c VOdS b] RSQWRS eVSbVS` g]c¸`S W\bS` SabSR W\ bVS [caWQ Q]\bOQba ]` ^WQbc`Sa BVS aWbcObW]\ Wa aW[WZO` T]` ]bVS` RSdWQSa b]] ;O\g ^`W\bS`a R] TOf O\R aQO\ W\ ORRWbW]\ b] ^`W\bW\U ;WQ`]a]Tb 2SdWQS AbOUS ^`]dWRSa SOaWS` OQQSaa b] OZZ O RSdWQS¸a QO^OPWZWbWSa 4]` []`S ]\ bVWa TSObc`S QVSQY ]cb µEW\ R]ea % 2SdWQS AbOUS ¶ 4]` SOQV RSdWQS 2SdWQS AbOUS aV]ea O ^OUS eWbV O ^WQbc`S ]T bVOb SfOQb ^WSQS ]T VO`ReO`S O\R WQ]\a T]` OZZ Wba QO^OPWZW bWSa ;O\cTOQbc`S`a Q`SObS bVS ^OUS W\ O\ F;: T]`[Ob T`SSZg OdOWZOPZS T`][ ;WQ`]a]Tb ;SRWO ag\QW\U PSbeSS\ O ^V]\S O\R bVS >1 Wa O\ SfO[^ZS ]T O bOaY ;WQ`]a]Tb V]^Sa 2SdWQS AbOUS aV]cZR [OYS SOaWS` /a eWbV DWabO¸a W\WbWOZ R`WdS` ^`]PZS[a Wb¸a c^ b] bVS VO`ReO`S dS\R]`a b] [OYS bVWa e]`Y 7T bVSg R]\¸b ^`]dWRS bVS RObO O abO\RO`R ^`]^S`bg RWOZ]U eWZZ RWa^ZOg 7T bVSg R] ac^^Zg bVS RObO SdS`g]\S eW\a 0cb ]\Zg bW[S eWZZ bSZZ WT OZZ bVS ^O`bWSa ^ZOg POZZ 7\ bVS @B; dS`aW]\ eS abWZZ #& >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< =1B=03@ '

USb O ^WQbc`S ]T O RWUWbOZ QO[S`O eVS\ eS ^ZcU W\ ]c` W>V]\S /\]bVS` VO`ReO`S `SZObSR TSObc`S Wa EW\ R]ea %¸a 0ZcSb]]bV aSbc^ ^`]QSaa 8cab QZWQY ]\ bVS 0ZcSb]]bV agabS[ b`Og WQ]\ O\R QV]]aS /RR O RSdWQS EVS\ g]c` ^V]\S ]` ]bVS` RSdWQS Wa RWaQ]dS`OPZS EW\R]ea US\ S`ObSa O ^Oaae]`R b] bg^S W\b] bVS RSdWQS 7T Wb¸a O YSgP]O`RZSaa RSdWQS g]c QO\ S\bS` O Q]RS ^`W\bSR ]\ O Q][^ObWPZS RSdWQS ]` ^OW` eWbV]cb O Q]RS T]` bVW\Ua ZWYS [WQS 7 bSabSR bVS ^`]QSaa eWbV O\ W>V]\S O\R bVS ^OW`W\U e]`YSR SOaWZg 7 Q]cZR bVS\ dWSe [g W>V]\S W\ 2SdWQSa O\R >`W\bS`a OQQSaaWPZS T`][ bVS AbO`b [S\c BVOb¸a O dS`g Q]]Z aSbc^ agabS[ 2SaWU\SR T]` B]cQV T`][ bVS 5`]c\R C^ ;WQ`]a]Tb Wa PSbbW\U bVOb bVS Tcbc`S ]T >1 Q][^cbW\U Wa b]cQV O\R VOa ^cb O Z]b ]T bV]cUVb W\b] [OYW\U EW\R]ea % e]`Y eWbV Wb ES b`WSR bVS b]cQV W\bS`TOQS ]\ O\ 6> B]cQVA[O`b O\R Wb¸a W[^`SaaWdS OZbV]cUV eS W\WbWOZZg VOR O ZWbbZS b`]cPZS `SaWhW\U ^WQ

A6/@7<5 EW\R]ea % [OYSa aVO`W\U RObO SOag

bc`Sa Pg ^W\QVW\U O\R a^`SORW\U be] TW\ US`a BVS =A QO\ ^]^ c^ O [W\W YSgP]O`R T]` µb]cQV bg^W\U¶´a][SbVW\U bVOb ^]W\ba b] YSgP]O`RZSaa bOPZSba ES aV]cZR \]bS bVOb [cZbWb]cQV eOa\¸b ]^S`ObW]\OZ `WUVb OTbS` =A W\abOZZObW]\) eS VOR b] R]e\Z]OR O\R W\abOZZ ORRWbW]\OZ R`WdS`a´V]^STcZZg bVWa abS^ eWZZ PS Pg^OaaSR OTbS` =Qb]PS` =\S Q]]Z bVW\U g]c QO\ R] Wa R`Oe W\ >OW\b eWbV be] ¿\US`a Ob O bW[S EVS\ g]c b]cQV bVS aQ`SS\ bVS Z]QObW]\ eVS`S g]c b]cQVSR Wb ]` µb]cQV ^]W\b ¶ QO\ PS `S^`SaS\bSR Pg O []caS W[OUS G]c QO\ bVS\ QZWQY bVS ZSTb ]` `WUVb Pcbb]\ ]T bVWa dW`bcOZ []caS Pcb eS ¿\R Wb SOaWS` b] caS bVS RSTOcZb µeObS` R`]^¶ TSSRPOQY W[OUS eVS\ g]c` ¿\US` b]cQVSa bVS aQ`SS\

U`]c^´^`]dWRSR g]c VOdS bVS `WUVb dS`aW]\ ]T bVS =A <]bS bVOb OZbV]cUV O\g EW\R]ea % W\abOZZObW]\ QO\ X]W\ O V][SU`]c^ bVS 6][S 0OaWQ O\R AbO`bS` SRWbW]\a QO\¸b Q`S ObS O V][SU`]c^ /aac[W\U g]c¸dS U]b bVS `WUVb dS`aW]\ g]c a^SQWTg eVWQV ZWP`O`WSa O\R RSdWQSa g]c eO\b b] aVO`S O\R eVS\ g]c VWb µ1`SObS \]e ¶ EW\R]ea eWZZ US\S` ObS O ^Oaae]`R 8]W\W\U O V][SU`]c^ eWbV O\]bVS` >1 Wa O aW[^ZS [ObbS` ]T S\bS`W\U bVS V][SU`]c^¸a ^Oaae]`R W\ bVS X]W\W\U >1¸a \Sbe]`Y ]^bW]\a / \SOb ORdO\bOUS ]T bVS 6][S5`]c^ TSO bc`S Wa bVOb WT g]c []dS PSbeSS\ e]`Y O\R V][S eWbV g]c` ZO^b]^ g]c e]\¸b [WabOY S\Zg ^`W\b bVOb `SQW^S ESP ^OUS b] g]c` e]`Y ^`W\bS` T`][ V][S 7b Ocb][ObWQOZZg U]Sa b] g]c` RSTOcZb V][S ^`W\bS` aW\QS g]c¸`S \]e Q]\\SQbSR b] bVS V][SU`]c^ ;OYW\U V][S \Sbe]`YW\U bVWa a[O`b O\R aW[^ZS b] aSb c^ Q]cZR `SOZZg PS O TSObVS` W\ EW\R]ea %¸a QO^ G]c QO\ `SOR []`S OP]cb 6][S5`]c^ W\ ]c`

6][S5`]c^ 1][Sa b] <Sbe]`YW\U =\S U]OZ ]T EW\R]ea % eOa b] [OYS V][S \Sbe]`YW\U aW[^ZS S\]cUV T]` O\g caS` 6][S5`]c^ Wa bVS `SacZb EVS\ g]c X]W\ O eW`SZSaa \Sbe]`Y g]c QO\ QV]]aS b] aSb Wb Oa V][S e]`Y ]` ^cPZWQ 1V]]aS bVS ¿`ab O\R AB@3/;7<5 G]c QO\ SOaWZg aSb [SRWO ab`SO[ g]c VOdS bVS ]^bW]\ ]T Q`SObW\U O V][S W\U ]^bW]\a T]` OZZ ]T g]c` RSdWQSa =1B=03@ ' >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< #'

E6/B¸A =< EW\R]ea % Q][PW\Sa P]bV `SUcZO` BD ZWab W\Ua ebV 7\bS`\Sb BD ZWabW\Ua W\ Wba UcWRS

O`bWQZS µEW\R]ea % 6][S5`]c^( <Sbe]`Y W\U ;ORS 3Oag ¶ 7\ O a[OZZS` \Sbe]`YW\U W[^`]dS[S\b bVS \Se agabS[ b`Og \Sbe]`YW\U WQ]\ OZa] aW[^ZW¿Sa Q]\\SQbW\U b] EW 4W 1ZWQYW\U bVS WQ]\ ^]^a c^ O eW\R]e aV]eW\U OZZ OdOWZOPZS Q]\\SQbW]\a BVWa aOdSa g]c T`][ VOdW\U b] ]^S\ bVS \Sbe]`YW\U RWOZ]U O\R QV]]aS b] aV]e OdOWZOPZS eW`SZSaa \Sbe]`Ya 7b¸a O a[OZZ b]cQV Pcb Wb [OYSa O Z]b ]T aS\aS T]` bVS bg^WQOZ ZO^b]^ caOUS aQS\O`W] eVS`S g]c [WUVb PS aVWTbW\U T`][ \Sbe]`Y b] \Sb e]`Y _cWbS ]TbS\ ;]`S ;SRWO W\ ;]`S >ZOQSa EW\R]ea ;SRWO 1S\bS` VOa U]\S bV`]cUV R`O[ObWQ QVO\USa PSbeSS\ EW\R]ea DWabO O\R EW\R]ea % 3OUZS SgSR caS`a eWZZ \]bS bVOb >ZOg@SORg ;WQ`]a]Tb¸a \Se 2@; aQVS[S T]` ^`]bSQbW\U `SQ]`RSR bSZSdWaW]\ aV]ea USba c^RObSR b] dS`aW]\ ! g]c QO\ aSS bVWa W\ bVS >`]U`O[a O\R 4SObc`Sa Q]\ b`]Z ^O\SZ ]\QS ;SRWO 1S\bS` W\abOZZa BVS W\QZcaW]\ ]T 7\bS`\Sb BD W\ bVS 5cWRS Wa O PWU ZSO^ T]`eO`R Sf^]aW\U SdS\ bV]aS $ >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< =1B=03@ '

eWbV]cb O\ W\bSU`ObSR BD bc\S` b] bVS Tc\ ]T 7> POaSR BD BVWa TSObc`S eOa W\ bVS 0SbO O\R RSa^WbS bVS STT]`ba b] ]`UO\WhS WbS[a c\RS` ;]dWSa <Sea A^]`ba O\R ]bVS` QObSU]`WSa Q]\bS\b Wa aW[^Zg b]] a^O`aS) bVS V]^SR T]` W\bSU`ObW]\ ]T 6cZc BD Q][ O\R ]bVS` 7> POaSR BD R]Sa\¸b SfWab GSb ;WQ`]a]Tb RWR V]eSdS` `SQS\bZg aV]e ]TT b]cQV S\OPZSR <SbTZWf W\bSU`ObW]\ eWbV EW\R]ea % ;SRWO 1S\bS` O\R VW\bSR Ob []`S acQV O\\]c\QS [S\ba Oa eS USb QZ]aS` b] bVS 5/ RObS 2:</ bSQV\]Z]Ug O abO\R]cb TSObc`S ]T EW\R]ea % S\OPZSa a][SbVW\U \SOb T]` >1a Q]\\SQbSR ]\ bVS aO[S \Sbe]`Y / Q]\bSf bcOZ >ZOg B] [S\c WbS[ ZSba g]c aS\R O dWRS] ^V]b] ]` a]\U b] O\]bVS` >1 ]` RSdWQS ;WQ`]a]Tb VOa beSOYSR EW\R]ea ;SRWO >ZOgS` O PWb V]eSdS` O\R Wb¸a O `SOZ QVOZZS\US b] TW\R bVS TSObc`S 7\ bVS 0SbO EW\R]ea ;SRWO >ZOgS` E;> VOR O AVO`S [S\c eVWQV VOR O\ ]^bW]\ b] @SQSWdS [SRWO ]\ g]c` \Sbe]`Y 7T g]c aSZSQbSR Wb O RWOZ]U Sf^ZOW\SR bVOb bVS TSObc`S ZSb ]bVS` RSdWQSa ]\ g]c` \Sbe]`Y ^caV [SRWO b] g]c BVOb [S\c VOa PSS\ `S\O[SR Ab`SO[ O\R

>:/G B= BVWa Q]]Z [S\c WbS[ OZZ]ea g]c b] aS\R O dWRS] ^V]b] ]` a]\U b] O\]bVS` >1 ]` RSdWQS ]\ g]c` \Sbe]`Y

Sf^O\RSR) OUOW\ >ZOg B] VS`S QOZZSR /ZZ]e `S[]bS Q]\b`]Z ]T [g ^ZOgS` Wa RWaOPZSR Pg RSTOcZb 3\OPZS Wb ]\ ]\S >1 O\R g]c¸ZZ PS OPZS b] aS\R ¿ZSa b] bVOb >1 T`][ ]bVS`a ]\ bVS aO[S V][SU`]c^ SWbVS` T`][ EW\R]ea ;SRWO >ZOgS` ]` Pg RW`SQbZg QZWQYW\U O ¿ZS W\ EW\R]ea 3f^Z]`S` BVWa P`W\Ua c^ O aS^O `ObS O^^ZWQObW]\ BVWa e]`YSR W[^`SaaWdSZg W\ ]c` bSabW\U C\T]`bc\ObSZg >ZOg B] Wa O E;> bSQV\]Z ]Ug \]b O EW\R]ea ;SRWO 1S\bS` bSQV \]Z]Ug SdS\ bV]cUV 1S\bS` `SZWSa VSOdWZg ]\ >ZOgS`¸a QO^OPWZWbWSa BVWa [SO\a bVOb ]abS\aWPZg T]` aSQc`Wbg ^c`^]aSa bVS >ZOg B] [S\c SfWaba ]\Zg eVS\ P]bV >1a VOdS E;> OQbWdSZg `c\\W\U ;WQ`]a]Tb Wa OZa] [OYW\U Wb SOaWS` b] OQQSaa Q]\bS\b `S[]bSZg W\ E;> =\S \Se TSObc`S bVOb Xc[^a ]cb Wa bVS OPWZWbg b] OZZ]e OQQSaa b] V][S [SRWO dWO bVS 7\bS`\Sb 4`][ bVS Ab`SO[ ^cZZ R]e\ [S\c W\ E;> aSZSQb bVS ]^bW]\ /ZZ]e 7\bS`\Sb OQQSaa b] V][S [SRWO T`][ eVWQV g]c QO\ ZW\Y O\ ]\ZW\S

72 /b ^`SaS\b ]\Zg EW\R]ea :WdS ]\ZW\S 72a O`S `SQ]U\WhSR :W\Y g]c` EW\R]ea OQQ]c\b b] bVS ]\ZW\S OQQ]c\b ]\ be] Q][^cbS`a O\R g]c QO\ OQQSaa [SRWO ab]`SR ]\ ]\S >1 OQ`]aa bVS 7\bS`\Sb Pg Z]UUW\U W\b] bVS ]\ZW\S OQQ]c\b ]\ bVS ]bVS` BOYS g]c` ZO^b]^ b] bVS Z]QOZ Q]TTSS aV]^ O\R g]c QO\ `S[]bSZg ab`SO[ g]c` [caWQ T`][ g]c` RSaYb]^ >1 Ob V][S BVOb [SRWO aV]ea c^ Oa O aVO`SR ZWP`O`g W\ E;>´Oaac[W\U g]c¸dS ZSTb g]c` V][S Q][^cbS` ]\ O\R `c\\W\U /\]bVS` O`SO eVS`S E;> VOa aSS\ W[^`]dS[S\b Wa W\ [SRWO TWZS O\R Q]RSQ ac^^]`b <]e Wb QO\ ^ZOg ;=D ¿ZSa 4WZSa Wb QO\¸b ^ZOg acQV Oa /^^ZS¸a Z]aaZSaa ;"/ ]` 6 $! ;>35 " e]\¸b PS RWa^ZOgSR W\ Wba [caWQ ]` dWRS] dWSe 7\ ORRWbW]\ E;> QO\ `Sac[S ^ZOgPOQY T`][ O VO`R R`WdS OTbS` bVS =A `Sbc`\a T`][ aZSS^ =\S ]T bVS Q]]ZSab ^]aaWPWZWbWSa ]T bVWa Q]RSQ ac^^]`b Wa bVOb bVS =A eWZZ b`O\a Q]RS [SRWO TWZSa ]\ bVS TZg Oa g]c R`]^ =1B=03@ ' >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< $

5@/<C:/@ ;=<7B=@7<5 EW\R]ea % OZZ]ea g]c b] b`OQY bVS ^S`T]`[O\QS ]T g]c` aga bS[ Ob O eV]ZS \Se ZSdSZ

aOg O []dWS ¿ZS WQ]\ ]\b] O dWRS] QO^OPZS ;>! ^ZOgS`¸a WQ]\ BVWa eOa RS[]\ab`ObSR Ob 1=;>CB3F bVWa gSO` Pcb ac^^]`b T`][ RSdWQS [OYS`a Wa Q`WbWQOZ´\]bS bVOb W>]Ra O`S\¸b gSb ac^^]`bSR BVS b`O\aQ]RW\U eWZZ OZa] bOYS ORdO\bOUS ]T U`O^VWQa VO`ReO`S OZbV]cUV bVWa [SO\a bVS U`O^VWQa dS\R]`a \SSR b] ORR ac^^]`b b] bVSW` ]e\ R`WdS`a ES VOdS\¸b VOR O QVO\QS gSb b] bSab R`OU O\R R`]^ b`O\aQ]RW\U Pcb Z]]Y T]` Tcbc`S ab]`WSa ]\ EW\R]ea % [SRWO Ob >1;OU Q][ >S`T]`[O\QS O\R AbOPWZWbg 7\ >1;OU :OPa¸ caS ]T EW\R]ea % ]dS` bVS ^Oab TSe []\bVa eS¸dS T]c\R bVS =A b] PS `]QY a]ZWR 4]` ^S`T]`[O\QS bSabW\U eS caSR bVS aO[S 56h RcOZ Q]`S 7\bSZ ZO^b]^ eWbV ^O`bWbW]\a V]ZRW\U EW\R]ea % @B; @1 0SbO O\R DWabO eWbV EW\R]ea :WdS W\abOZZSR 7\ bS`[a ]T abO`b c^ bW[Sa eS \]bWQSR O aZWUVb W[^`]dS[S\b W\ bVS @B; ]dS` @1 Pcb P]bV abO`bSR c^ aWU\W¿QO\bZg TOabS` bVO\ DWabO eVWQV b]]Y [W\cbS O\R aSQ]\Ra $ >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< =1B=03@ '

Q][^O`SR eWbV EW\R]ea %¸a !" aSQ]\Ra BVOb¸a \]b ac`^`WaW\U UWdS\ bVOb ;WQ`]a]Tb VOa aWU\W¿QO\bZg Qcb bVS \c[PS` ]T agabS[ ^`]QSaaSa bVOb abO`b eWbV bVS =A O\R [ORS ]bVS` P]]b ]^bW[WhObW]\a AVcbR]e\ a^SSR b]] VOa W[^`]dSR( DWabO b]]Y # aSQ]\Ra Oa Q][^O`SR eWbV $ aSQ]\Ra T]` EW\R]ea % ]\ O\ WRS\bWQOZZg Q]\TWUc`SR [OQVW\S ES aV]cZR \]bS bVOb bVSaS bW[Sa OQbcOZZg a^SR c^ OTbS` [cZbW^ZS b`WSa´a][SbVW\U g]c¸R PS c\ZWYSZg b] aSS W\ DWabO ES OZa] `O\ >1;O`Y DO\bOUS ]\S ]T bVS []`S `SOZWabWQ bSaba bVOb `c\a bV`]cUV O Pc\QV ]T bOaYa caS`a [WUVb ^S`T]`[ acQV Oa dWSeW\U O\R SRWbW\U ^V]b]a dWRS] [caWQ O\R ]bVS` [SRWO Oa eSZZ Oa UO[W\U Q][[c \WQObW]\a ^`]RcQbWdWbg O\R aSQc`Wbg b`WOZa BVS `SacZba aV]cZR PS bOYS\ eWbV O U`OW\ ]T aOZb aW\QS bVS bSab Wa W\bS\RSR a^SQW¿QOZZg b] PS\QV[O`Y bSab VO`ReO`S `c\\W\U ]\ DWabO 0cb `S[S[PS` bVOb ;WQ`]a]Tb VOa aOWR bVOb EW\R]ea % aV]cZR `c\ SdS`gbVW\U DWabO R]Sa =\ >1;O`Y DO\bOUS eVS`S VWUVS`

\c[PS`a O`S PSbbS` bVS EW\R]ea % @B; aQ]`SR \SO`Zg WRS\bWQOZZg b] bVS EW\R]ea % @1 eWbV ]dS`OZZ aQ]`Sa ]T " % O\R ! ' ' `Sa^SQbWdSZg Q][^O`SR eWbV DWabO¸a ! #$% A] bVS \Se =A¸a aQ]`S eOa O # ^S`QS\b W[^`]dS[S\b ]dS` DWabO¸a ]\ O bSab bVOb¸a \]b SdS\ O^^`]dSR b] `c\ ]\ EW\R]ea % ES OZa] `O\ bVS Ac\A^WRS` 8OdOAQ`W^b PS\QV[O`Y eVWQV bSaba ESP P`]eaS`a¸ a^SSR W\ `S\RS`W\U 8OdOAQ`W^b Pcb OZa] `SÀSQba agabS[ a^SSR 7\ EW\R]ea % @B;¸a 73& bVS aQ]`S eOa " %% eVS`S c\RS` @1 Wb eOa " '# ´O aZWUVb W[^`]dS[S\b Pcb ^`Sbbg [cQV eWbVW\ bVS [O`UW\ T]` S``]` =\S `S[OW\W\U c\eSZQ][S ^O`b ]T bVS EW\R]ea ZSUOQg Wa bVOb EW\R]ea % YSS^a bVS AgabS[ @SUWab`g ]TbS\ O [OX]` QOcaS ]T agabS[ aZ]eR]e\ PSQOcaS ]T W\abOZZSR ^`] U`O[a O\R VO`ReO`S R`WdS`a bVOb TOWZ b] QZSO\ c^ bVSW` @SUWab`g S\b`WSa ;WQ`]a]Tb VOa [ORS a][S beSOYa b] V]e bVS @SUWab`g ]^S`ObSa Pcb Wb `S[OW\a b] PS aSS\ eVSbVS` bVS aO[S 7<>@7D/B3 BVWa \Se TSObc`S W\ 7\bS`\Sb 3f^Z]`S` & OZZ]ea g]c b] VWRS OQbWd Wbg T`][ g]c` P`]eaW\U VWab]`g

/ <3E /<2 7;>@=D32 73 7\QZcRSR eWbV EW\ R]ea % 73& ]TTS`a aSQc`Wbg ]\ abS`]WRa O\R a][S bS``W¿Q \Se P`]eaW\U TSObc`Sa

agabS[ aZ]eR]e\a `SacZb T`][ Wb OTbS` Z]\U bS`[ VSOdg >1 caS /\R ;WQ`]a]Tb bSQV ;WYS /\UWcZ] ZSORS` ]T bVS EW\R]ea >1 3Q]aga bS[ O\R >ZO\\W\U bSO[ RWR\¸b VOdS O QZSO` O\aeS` eVS\ OaYSR WT O\g [SQVO\Wa[a W\ EW\R]ea % Q][POb @SUWab`g QZcbbS` EW\R]ea :WdS O\R 7\bS`\Sb 3f^Z]`S` & 7\ O\ STT]`b b] b`W[ RWaY `S_cW`S[S\ba O\R W\abOZZ bW[Sa EW\R]ea e]\¸b Q][S ^`S Z]ORSR eWbV O\ S [OWZ ^`]U`O[ T]` bVS ¿`ab bW[S W\ O RSQORS 4c`bVS`[]`S ^V]b] dWRS] O\R PZ]U SRWbW\U OZ]\U eWbV W\abO\b [Sa aOUW\U VOdS PSS\ ]TÀ]ORSR b] O R]e\Z]OR W\ bVS T]`[ ]T EW\R]ea :WdS 3aaS\bWOZa BVS c^RObSR O^^a g]c USb bVS`S W\QZcRS O \Se Z]]Y O\R a][S a^WTTg TSObc`Sa BVS ;OWZ O^^ T]` SfO[^ZS ZSba g]c OUU`SUObS OZZ g]c` >=> ]` 7;/> OQQ]c\ba W\b] ]\S W\bS`TOQS BVS EW\R]ea :WdS ESP aS`dWQSa VOdS PSS\ c^RObSR eWbV a]QWOZ \Sbe]`YW\U TSO bc`Sa acQV Oa abObca c^RObSa T`][ [S[ PS`a g]c W\dWbS b] g]c` µ\Sbe]`Y ¶ 5`]c^a QO\ aVO`S ^WQbc`Sa O\R Q]\dS`aObW]\a caW\U =1B=03@ ' >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< $!

1O\ G]c` AgabS[ @c\ EW\R]ea %G]c¸`S []`S bVO\ a]ZR ]\ W\abOZZW\U bVS \Se =A Pcb QO\ g]c` RSaYb]^ ]` ZO^b]^ VO\RZS Wb- =c` Sf^S`ba eSWUV W\ 0g 1WaQ] 1VS\U O\R 8]SZ AO\b] 2][W\U] 7T g]c caS EW\R]ea F> ]` DWabO `WUVb \]e Pcb O`S QVO[^W\U Ob bVS PWb T]` EW\R]ea % g]c \SSR b] [OYS ac`S g]c` agabS[ VOa eVOb Wb bOYSa b] `c\ bVS \Se =A AgabS[a `c\\W\U ;WQ`]a]Tb EW\R]ea DWabO =A ^O`bWQcZO`Zg 6][S >`S[Wc[ []ab Q]\ac[S` RSaYb]^a bVOb aVW^^SR PSUW\\W\U W\ 8O\cO`g % R] []ab ZWYSZg [SSb bVS Qc``S\b `S_cW`S[S\ba ]T EW\R]ea % ;]ab RSaYb]^a P]cUVb W\ $ ]` OTbS` aV]cZR PS OPZS b] `c\ EW\R]ea % ¿\S ^O` bWQcZO`Zg WT g]c P]cUVb g]c`a eWbV Tcbc`S ^`]]¿\U W\ [W\R /a T]` ZO^b]^a bV]aS Oa

bVS ESP aS`dWQSa O\R :WdS ;SaaS\US` / YSg TSObc`S W\ bVS \Se EW\R]ea :WdS 6]b [OWZ ZSba g]c aS\R ^WQbc`Sa eWbV]cb QZ]U UW\U g]c` Q]\bOQba¸ W\P]fSa aW[^Zg Pg ab]`W\U bVS ^V]b]a ]\ ESP aS`dS`a W\abSOR BVS :WdS O^^a O`S\¸b Oa aZWQY Oa /^^ZS¸a W:WTS O^^a Pcb W\ a][S QOaSa bVS :WdS AS`dWQSa OQbcOZZg ]TTS` []`S /\R T`SS ESP a^OQS Wa W\QZcRSR eVS`SOa eWbV bVS ;OQ g]c VOdS b] ^Og O Vc\R`SR PcQYa O gSO` T]` O ;]PWZS;S OQQ]c\b eVWQV USba g]c ^`Sbbg aW[WZO` QO^O PWZWbWSa EW\R]ea :WdS aSS[a b] ca O TO` PSb $" >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< =1B=03@ '

]ZR Oa ¿dS ]` SdS\ aWf gSO`a QO\ `c\ EW\ R]ea % O\R aW[^ZS VO`ReO`S c^U`ORSa QO\ PS [ORS b] S\ac`S O\ ]^bW[OZ caS` Sf^S`WS\QS 7T g]c` ZO^b]^ QO\¸b `c\ EW\ R]ea % Wb ^`]POPZg PSZ]\Ua W\ O [caSc[ /\g ZO^b]^ ]ZRS` bVO\ aWf gSO`a []ab ZWYSZg `c\a O >S\bWc[ 77 ]` 777 QVW^ eVWQV ^`]POPZg Wa\¸b e]`bV bVS VOaaZS ]T c^U`ORW\U c\ZSaa g]c¸`S O `SOZ 27G USSY 7T g]c` RSaYb]^ ]` ZO^b]^ Wa ]\ bVS P]` RS`ZW\S W\ bS`[a ]T OUS O\R ]` R]Sa\¸b `c\ DWabO g]c aV]cZR `c\ ;WQ`]a]Tb¸a C^U`ORS /RdWa]` BVWa b]]Z eWZZ ZSb g]c Y\]e WT g]c \SSR O [W\]` c^U`ORS []`S VO`R R`WdS

bS` RSOZ ]\ bVWa aQ]`S BVS =A R]Sa W\QZcRS 7\bS`\Sb 3f^Z]`S` & 73& Wa Ob ZSOab O \]bOPZS W[^`]dS[S\b ]dS` Wba ^`SRSQSaa]`a BVS P`]eaS` RSZWd S`a QObSU]`g ZSORW\U aSQc`Wbg O\R ORRa a][S ^`Sbbg aZWQY P`]eaW\U OWRa acQV Oa ESP AZWQSa O\R /QQSZS`Ob]`a 7b RSTOcZba b] O []`S abO\RO`Ra Q][^ZWO\b []RS Pcb abWZZ ]TTS`a O POQYeO`R Q][^ObWPWZWbg Pcbb]\ / ^`SRWQbWdS ORR`Saa PO` P`W\Ua Wb QZ]aS` b] 4W`ST]f Pcb bVS ZOQY ]T O R]e\Z]OR [O\ OUS` O\R `]Pcab SfbS\aW]\ SQ]agabS[ V]ZR

ZSOab 50 ]T @/;) SdS\ W\ $ O\R % ]\Zg bVS QVSO^Sab >1a VOR # ;0 ]` ZSaa 7b e]cZR\¸b Vc`b bV]cUV b] R`]^ W\ a][S Sfb`O [S[]`g ^O`bWQcZO`Zg WT g]c ZWYS b] YSS^ O Z]b ]T eW\R]ea ]^S\ /B :3/AB $50 =4 AB=@/53 A>/13 50 T]` $" PWb EW\R]ea % 7T g]c VOdS ZSaa bVO\ bVWa Wb¸a ^`]POPZg bW[S b] `SQgQZS g]c` aga / >@=13AA=@ @/B32 /B 575/63@BH =@ bS[ O\geOg 7T g]c VOdS O agabS[ eWbV ZSaa 4/AB3@ 3dS\ Z]e ^]eS`SR QVSO^ RSaYb]^ bVO\ 50 ]T T`SS R`WdS a^OQS Q]\aWRS` >1a eWZZ VOdS Ob ZSOab O $ 56h ^`]QSa PcgW\U O \Se R`WdS W\abOZZW\U EW\R]ea % a]` bVSaS ROga O\R ZWYSZg VOdS 56h ]` ]\ Wb O\R ]T Q]c`aS POQYW\U c^ g]c` ]ZR TOabS` 1>Ca 7T Wb VOa O RcOZ Q]`S ]` _cOR R`WdS / 2F' 1=;>/B70:3 5@/>671A 1/@2 E7B6 Q]`S ^`]QSaa]` g]c¸`S OZZ aSb 3dS\ WT g]c P]cUVb O ZO^b]^ W\ ! eVS\ bVS TW`ab B63 E22; 2@7D3@ / RSaYb]^ ]` ZO^b]^ PObQV ]T >S\bWc[ ; ^`]QSaa]`a Q]RS eWbV O\ /B7 ]` \DWRWO QVW^aSb Wa O `SOZZg U]]R \O[SR µ0O\WOa¶ QO[S ]cb EW\R]ea % aWU\ bVOb Wb¸ZZ `c\ EW\R]ea % Pcb [OYS ac`S O^^SO`a b] VOdS Wb Q]dS`SR Oa eSZZ Oa Z]\U g]c VOdS bVS ZObSab U`O^VWQa R`WdS` VO\Rg Oa g]c VOdS Ob ZSOab 50 ]T [S[]`g $50 0SbbS` gSb Z]]Y T]` bVS e]`Ra µ62¶ ]` ]T VO`R R`WdS a^OQS O\R O 2F' U`O^VWQa µ>c`SDWRS]¶ a][SeVS`S ]\ bVS ^OQYOUW\U ]` QO`R[OYS`¸a ESP aWbS G]c eO\b PSbbS` QO`R 50 =4 @/; 50 T]` $" PWb EW\R]ea U`O^VWQa [OW\Zg T]` ESP dWRS] `ObVS` bVO\ % 7T g]c P]cUVb g]c` agabS[ W\ & ]` UO[Sa 7T g]c` RSaYb]^ VOa O\ S[^bg /5> ZObS` g]c¸`S OZ[]ab UcO`O\bSSR b] VOdS Ob U`O^VWQa QO`R aZ]b Q]\aWRS` O \Se >1

a^OQS []`S [S[]`g RWaQ`SbS U`O^VWQa ]` WT Wb¸a O Z]ab QOcaS b]] aZ]e ^`]QSaa]` ]ZRS` W\bSU`ObSR U`O^VWQa eWbV \] c^U`ORS aZ]b @S[S[PS` bVS`S¸a \] aVO[S WT g]c YSS^ F> `c\\W\U ]` [OgPS b`g ]cb :W\cf b] T`SaVS\ c^ bVOb ]ZR agabS[ AbWZZ \]b ac`S WT g]c` agabS[ QO\ VO\RZS EW\ %- ASS WT Wb VOa bVS T]ZZ]eW\U(

bVS P`]eaS` POQY 4]` bVS ¿`ab bW[S W\ ]dS` W\b`]RcQSR W\ =T¿QS % =T¿QS¸a µÀcS\b C7¶ O RSQORS bVS =A ZSba g]c Q][^ZSbSZg c\W\ bOYSa a][S USbbW\U caSR b] Pcb W\ >OW\b Wb¸a abOZZ bVS P`]eaS` WT g]c QV]]aS ^`Sbbg aW[^ZS [OYW\U Q`]^^W\U W[OUSa O\R a] ]\ [cQV SOaWS` BVS `WPP]\ OZa] [OYSa O <Se /QQSaa]`WSa Z]b ]T aS\aS WT g]c¸`S caW\U O b]cQV W\bS`TOQS /b ;WQ`]a]Tb¸a >`]TSaaW]\OZ 2SdSZ]^S` 1]\ BVS \Se 1OZQcZOb]` ORRa AbObWabWQa O\R TS`S\QS EW\R]ea VSOR V]\QV] AbSdS AW\]T >`]U`O[[S` []RSa O\R g]c QO\ Qcb O\R aYg X]YSR bVOb bVS bSO[ RSQWRSR Wb e]cZR PS ^OabS T`][ Wb´TW\OZZg 1OZQcZOb]` OZa] \]e O U]]R WRSO b] c^RObS bVS >OW\b O\R 1OZQcZO VOa O VWab]`g TSObc`S a] g]c e]\¸b VOdS b] b]` OQQSaa]`WSa Ob ZSOab ]\QS SdS`g # gSO`a `SR] S\b`WSa g]c¸dS QZ]aSR O\R \SSR OUOW\ /QQ]`RW\UZg bVS be] O^^ZSba TW\OZZg USb O BS[^ZObSa T]` Q][[]\ QOZQcZObW]\a ZWYS UOa `ST`SaV bVOb W\QZcRSa bVS `WPP]\ W\bS`TOQS [WZSOUS []`bUOUS SabW[ObW]\a O\R ZSOaSa =1B=03@ ' >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< $#

B63 <3E >/7<B =\S ]T bVS Q]]Z \Se TSObc`Sa W\ ;WQ`]a]Tb >OW\b Wa bVOb g]c QO\ R`Oe eWbV be] ¿\US`a Ob bVS bW[S eVS\ g]c b]cQV bVS aQ`SS\

VOdS PSS\ ORRSR C\Wb Q]\dS`aW]\a O`S O bVWa TSObc`S W\ 1WaQ] 1VS\U O\R 8]SZ AO\b] a\O^ \]e b]] BVS \Se OQQSaa]`WSa O`S 2][W\U]¸a ^WSQS µ;]ab >1a 1O\¸b @c\ EW\ Z]\U ]dS`RcS Pcb eSZQ][S \SdS`bVSZSaa R]ea % ·F> ;]RS¸ ¶ BVS TSObc`S eWZZ ]\Zg PS OdOWZOPZS W\ bVS >`]TSaaW]\OZ O\R CZbW[ObS F> ;]RS SRWbW]\a O\R Wb¸a abWZZ W\ Wba @1 dS`aW]\ Oa ]T EVS\ @1 VWb ^S`VO^a bVS []ab b]cbSR EW\R]ea % @B; ^WSQS ]T \Sea eOa O TSObc`S bVOb VOR ZWbbZS 7\ TOQb F> ;]RS R]Sa\¸b OQbcOZZg Q][S b] R] eWbV bVS =A WbaSZT( F> ;]RS >`W[O`WZg eWbV EW\R]ea %) g]c VOdS b] R]e\Z]OR bVS bO`USbW\U Q]`^]`ObS caS`a eV] `c\ ZSUOQg dW`bcOZWhObW]\ a]TbeO`S b] USb Wb b] e]`Y O\R Qcab][ O^^ZWQObW]\a Q]RSR T]` EW\R]ea g]c¸ZZ \SSR O VWUV S\R >1 b] `c\ Wb F> ;]RS F> bVS []RS bOYSa ORdO\bOUS ]T O \Se dS` ]TTS`a be] ]^bW]\a ]\S bVOb¸a O TcZZ F> RSaY aW]\ ]T DW`bcOZ >1 =c` 3R ;S\RSZa]\ VOa b]^ O\R ]\S bVOb¸a O µaSO[ZSaa¶ O^^ eW\ R]\S O TcZZ VO\Ra ]\ eWbV bVS EW\R]ea % F> R]e G]c QO\ W\abOZZ O\ F> O^^ W\ bVS ;]RS ;]RS O\R T]c\R O Z]b b] RWaZWYS OP]cb Wb G]c O\R aSO[ZSaa O^^a QO\ OQQSaa bVS R`WdSa QO\ `SOR []`S OP]cb eVWQV >1a eWZZ ac^^]`b O\R T]ZRS`a ]T bVS V]ab EW\R]ea % =A G]c 1/:1C:/B=@ 4/13:74B BVS QOZQcZOb]` \]e ]TTS`a abObWabWQa O\R ^`]U`O[[S` []RSa O VWa b]`g TSObc`S O\R bS[^ZObSa ZWYS bVWa ]\S

$$ >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< =1B=03@ '

F> ;=23 EW\R]ea % OZZ]ea g]c b] `c\ O TcZZ F> RSaYb]^ ]` O\ F> O^^ eW\R]e

QO\ SdS\ Qcb O\R ^OabS PSbeSS\ bVS V]ab O\R bVS dW`bcOZWhSR =A 0cb ;S\RSZa]\ T]c\R bVOb bVS [SbV]R T]` aSbbW\U c^ O \Sbe]`Y ^`W\bS` eOa TO` b]] ]PaQc`S `S_cW`W\U VWb ]` [Waa S\b`g ]T BS` [W\OZ AS`dWQS ^]`b \c[PS`a /RRWbW]\OZZg QVO\UW\U aSbbW\Ua acQV Oa OdOWZOPZS @/; eOa O`Rc]ca `S_cW`W\U O TcZZ `SabO`b 6S OZa] \]bSR bVOb ;WQ`]a]Tb¸a 1cab][S` 3f^S`W S\QS 7[^`]dS[S\b >`]U`O[ US\S`ObSR O\ S``]` eVS\ VS eOa aeWbQVW\U T`][ aSO[ZSaa b] TcZZ []RS O\R bVOb g]c Q]cZR\¸b R`OU O\R R`]^ ¿ZSa PSbeSS\ V]ab O\R F> ;]RS :cQYg ASdS\2Sa^WbS a][S ^c\RWba QZOW[W\U bVOb EW\ R]ea % Wa \] []`S bVO\ O DWabO aS`dWQS ^OQY bVS`S¸a O Z]b []`S b] Wb bVO\ bVOb ;WQ`]a]Tb VOa QS`bOW\Zg ORR`SaaSR [O\g ]T bVS Q][ ^ZOW\ba ac``]c\RW\U DWabO acQV Oa bVS ZOQY ]T POQYeO`R Q][^ObWPWZWbg bVS ZS\UbVg abO`b c^ O\R W\abOZZ bW[Sa bVS P`]OR RWaY O\R [S[]`g T]]b^`W\b O\R bVS W\OPWZWbg b] `S[]dS 73 0cb bVS Q][^O\g VOa OZa] ORRSR O \c[PS` ]T \Se W\bS`TOQS VSZ^S`a bVOb eWZZ

[OYS bVS \Se =A []`S ^ZSOac`OPZS O\R ST¿QWS\b b] caS 4WUc`S W\ W[^`]dSR ^S`T]` [O\QS O\R \Sbe]`YW\U O a[OZZS` RWaY O\R [S[]`g T]]b^`W\b O\R aZWQY VO\RZW\U ]T RSdWQSa O\R Wb¸a `SOZZg VO`R b] QOZZ bVWa O\g bVW\U ]bVS` bVO\ O TcZZ ÀSRUSR =A 8cab Oa eS VOdS\¸b PSS\ DWabO POaVS`a´ eS OQbcOZZg Z]dS O Z]b ]T Wba TSObc`Sa´\SWbVS` O`S eS TOe\W\U OZZ ]dS` EW\R]ea % ES ZWYS O Z]b ]T bVW\Ua OP]cb EW\R]ea % Pcb DWabO T`O\YZg VOR O Z]b U]W\U T]` Wb b]] RSa^WbS Wba ZOQY ]T W\WbWOZ R`WdS` ac^^]`b 3WbVS` V]e SdS` Wa O dOab W[^`]dS[S\b ]dS` F> ES abWZZ eWaV EW\R]ea % VOR R`]^^SR bVS AgabS[ @SUWab`g eVWQV aZ]ea R]e\ agabS[a ]dS` bW[S 0cb Wb Z]]Ya ZWYS ;WQ`]a]Tb Wa [OYW\U bVS `WUVb []dSa W\ bc`\W\U O`]c\R bVS EW\ R]ea aVW^ T]ZZ]eW\U Wba WZZ TObSR DWabO d]g OUS ES¸ZZ PS `c\\W\U O\R bSabW\U bVS =A SfbS\aWdSZg b] [OYS ac`S bVOb EW\R]ea % Q]\bW\cSa b] ZWdS c^ b] Wba Vg^S W\ bVS eOg bVOb EW\R]ea DWabO RWR\¸b) QVSQY POQY W\ O TSe eSSYa ]\ >1;OU Q][ T]` ]c` TW\OZ SdOZcObW]\ O\R aQ]`S ]T ;WQ`]a]Tb¸a PWUUSab `SZSOaS ]T bVS gSO` ■ =1B=03@ ' >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< $%

C^U`ORW\U b] EW\R]ea % bVS 3Oag EOg 7T g]c c^U`ORS R] g]c `WaY Z]aW\U OZZ ]T g]c` O^^a O\R RObO- <]b WT g]c caS EW\R]ea 3Oag B`O\aTS` 0g 8S`S[g / 9O^ZO\ /`S g]c ^ZO\\W\U ]\ c^U`ORW\U g]c` Q][ ^cbS` b] EW\R]ea % W\ O TSe eSSYa- 3a^S QWOZZg WT g]c¸`S `c\\W\U DWabO EW\R]ea % ]TTS`a O Q][^SZZW\U Q][PW\ObW]\ ]T TOabS` P]]b bW[Sa W[^`]dSR `Sa^]\aWdS\Saa aW\QS bVS`S O`S TSeS` ^`]QSaaSa `c\\W\U Ob O\g UWdS\ bW[S O\R aSdS`OZ Tc\ O\R ^`OQbWQOZ caS` W\bS`TOQS S\VO\QS[S\ba 0cb eVOb OP]cb g]c` abcTT - G]c¸dS W\abOZZSR O Pc\QV ]T O^^ZWQObW]\a O\R cbWZW bWSa g]c¸dS `W^^SR UWUOPgbSa ]T [caWQ O\R g]c¸dS ^`]POPZg Q]ZZSQbSR QObOZ]USR O\R >V]b]aV]^^SR b] ^S`TSQbW]\ O TSe bV]c aO\R ^V]b]a 7T g]c c^U`ORS R] g]c `WaY Z]a W\U OZZ ]T bVOb- 7b¸a O Q][[]\ TSO` b] PS ac`S 4]`bc\ObSZg ;WQ`]a]Tb W\QZcRSa O VO\Rg b]]Z bVOb SOaSa g]c` [WU`ObW]\ b] O \Se EW\R]ea W\abOZZObW]\ 1OZZSR EW\R]ea 3Oag B`O\aTS` bVS eWhO`R UObVS`a c^ bVS dO`W]ca ^V]b]a dWRS]a a]\Ua O\R ]bVS` R]Qc[S\ba \]b b] [S\bW]\ bVS ^`]U`O[ aSbbW\Ua T`][ OZZ ]T g]c` O^^ZWQObW]\a O\R ab]`Sa bVS[ W\ ]\S UW\]`[]ca aS[W Q]\dS\WS\b ¿ZS =\QS g]c¸dS W\abOZZSR bVS \Se =A ]` aSb c^ g]c` \Se Q][^cbS` g]c QO\ `c\ bVS eWhO`R OUOW\ $& >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< =1B=03@ '

O\R W[^]`b OZZ ]T bV]aS ¿ZSa EW\R]ea % Wa RSaWU\SR b] c^U`ORS T`][ ]ZRS` WbS`ObW]\a ]T bVS =A Pcb WT g]c¸`S Ob OZZ ZWYS [S g]c¸dS PSS\ W\abOZZW\U O\R c\W\ abOZZW\U O^^a O\R cbWZWbWSa `]ZZW\U POQY g]c` agabS[ W\abOZZObW]\ OTbS` Q`OaVSa VOQYW\U a]TbeO`S ^OQYOUSa O\R 2::a ]` SdS\ ORR W\U O\R QVO\UW\U `SUWab`g S\b`WSa Ac`S g]c QO\ c^U`ORS g]c` Qc``S\b Q][^cbS` b] bVS \Se ]^S`ObW\U agabS[ Pcb Wb [WUVb ^Og b] Q`SObS O T`SaV W\abOZZObW]\ O\R R] OeOg eWbV bVS Uc\Y ]T gSO`a ]T Q][^cbW\U 7T g]c¸`S W\bS`SabSR W\ O QZSO\ aZObS caS EW\R]ea 3Oag B`O\aTS` b] ^]`b SdS`gbVW\U b] O\ SfbS`\OZ R`WdS =dS` ]\S eSSYS\R 7 RWR Xcab bVOb caW\U bVS b]]Z b] Sf^]`b OZZ [g abcTT PST]`S eW^W\U [g [OW\ agabS[ QZSO\ O\R W\abOZZW\U EW\R]ea % CZbW[ObS EVS\ g]c TW`ab ZOc\QV bVS eWhO`R g]c¸ZZ eOZY bV`]cUV a][S aW[^ZS aQ`SS\a bVOb QZ]aS O\g ]^S\ ^`]U`O[a PST]`S OaYW\U eVSbVS` g]c¸`S Ob bVS \Se >1 ]` bVS ]ZR >1 7b bVS\ ^`][^ba g]c b] QV]]aS O Z]QObW]\ b] ab]`S g]c` ¿ZSa bS[^]`O`WZg 0SQOcaS bVS B`O\aTS` eWhO`R Q`SObSR O TOW`Zg aWhSOPZS 50 ¿ZS T]`

B@C:G 3/AG B@/<A43@ EW\R]ea 3Oag B`O\a TS` aV]ea g]c V]e b] Sf^]`b g]c` RObO eW^S g]c` agabS[ QZSO\ bVS\ W\abOZZ EW\R]ea %

[S 7 ab]`SR ]\ O \Sbe]`Y ObbOQVSR ab]`OUS </A RSdWQS bV]cUV O aW[^ZS CA0 R`WdS eWZZ R] 4]` O `]cUV SabW[ObS ORR c^ g]c` [caWQ ^V]b] O\R dWRS] ab]`OUS T]ZRS` aWhSa ;g \Sbe]`Y Wa UWUOPWb 3bVS`\Sb eVWQV Wa \]bWQSOPZg TOabS` bVO\ abO\RO`R ;P^a 3bVS`\Sb AbWZZ POQYW\U SdS`gbVW\U c^ b]]Y ]dS` be] V]c`a =\QS 7 eOa TW\WaVSR 7 eOa T`SS b] P]]b T`][ bVS EW\R]ea % RWaY caS bVS W\QZcRSR ^O`bWbW]\W\U b]]Za b] S`OaS OZZ bVS ^O`bWbW]\a ]\ [g >1 O\R W\abOZZ O QZSO\ Q]^g ]T bVS \Se ]^S`ObW\U agabS[ EW\R]ea % W\abOZZObW]\ Wa `S[O`YOPZg _cWQY Sa^SQWOZZg `SZObWdS b] F> O\R DWabO W\abOZZa eVWQV `SOZZg R] bOYSa Oa [cQV Oa O\ V]c` <Sfb 7 aSb c^ aS^O`ObS caS` OQQ]c\ba T]` [gaSZT O\R T]` [g eWTS ]TT bVS POb ;g >1 VOa be] R`WdSa O a[OZZS` TOabS` AA2 T]` bVS ]^S`ObW\U agabS[ O\R O PWUUS` aZ]eS` RWaY T]` ab]`W\U ¿ZSa 9\]eW\U bVOb bVS [OX]` Wbg ]T ¿ZSa 7 VOR eS`S [caWQ O\R ^V]b]a 7 `S [O^^SR bVS ;g ;caWQ O\R ;g >V]b]a T]ZRS`a T]` P]bV OQQ]c\ba b] T]ZRS`a 7 Q`SObSR ]\ bVS ZO`US` aSQ]\R R`WdS W\ [g >1 B] R] bVWa aW[ ^Zg `WUVb QZWQY ]\S ]T bV]aS T]ZRS`a O\R aSZSQb >`]^S`bWSa 1ZWQY bVS :]QObW]\ bOP O\R SWbVS`

;]dS¬ bVS T]ZRS` ]` aSZSQb 4W\R BO`USbEVS\ 7 `O\ bVS eWhO`R OUOW\ T`][ bVS \Se ]^S`ObW\U agabS[ O\R ^]W\bSR Wb b] bVS aOdSR ¿ZS EW\R]ea aSO[ZSaaZg []dSR OZZ [g ¿ZSa O\R aSbbW\Ua POQY W\b] ^ZOQS Q]^gW\U [g [caWQ O\R ^V]b]a W\b] bVS \Se Z]QObW]\a ]\ bVS ZO`US` R`WdS >VSe 0SQOcaS [g ]ZR aSbc^ RWR\¸b VOdS aS^O`ObS OQQ]c\ba EW\ R]ea UOdS [S bVS ]^bW]\ b] `S[O^ bVS ¿ZSa b] O RWTTS`S\b OQQ]c\b eVWQV [Og ^`]dS O caSTcZ ]^bW]\ T]` a][S 3Oag B`O\aTS` Q]^WSR bVS T]ZRS`a O\R TWZSa RSaYb]^ ^WQbc`S O\R aSbbW\Ua T]` [WaQSZZO\S]ca O^^a ^S`TSQbZg b] [g \Se W\abOZZObW]\ BVS R]e\aWRS b] bVWa bSQV\W_cS ]T Q]c`aS Wa bVS \SSR b] bVS\ `SW\abOZZ OZZ ]T bVS ^`]U`O[a 7 caS ]\ O ROWZg POaWa bVW\Ua ZWYS 4W`ST]f ;WQ`]a]Tb =TTWQS bVS 5]]UZS B]]ZPO` O\R a] ]\ 0SQOcaS 7 VOR Q`SObSR O RW`SQb]`g ]\ [g </A eWbV OZZ ]T bVSaS ^`] U`O[a OVSOR ]T bW[S 7 eOa T`SS b] W\abOZZ bVS[ Ob [g ZSWac`S Ac`S bVWa OZZ [WUVb aSS[ ZWYS O a][SeVOb []`S W\d]ZdSR ^`]QSaa bVO\ aW[^Zg QZWQYW\U bVS c^U`ORS Pcbb]\ 0cb a][SbW[Sa O QZSO\ aZObS Wa e]`bV Xc[^W\U bV`]cUV O TSe V]]^a ■ =1B=03@ ' >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< $'

A]ZcbW]\a 1O^bc`S O\R AV]e =TT G]c` 0WU BD ;][S\b EWbV O BD bc\S` O\R O EW\R]ea DWabO ;SRWO 1S\bS` >1 g]c QO\ SOaWZg ^`SaS`dS g]c` ]` O\g]\S¸a BD O^^SO`O\QS 0g 0WZZ 2gahSZ VS # [W\cbSa ]T TO[S bVOb /\Rg EO`V]Z ^`][WaSR g]c O`S RcS b] O``WdS O\gbW[S \]e Oa g]c¸`S OeO`S \] R]cPb 0cb eVS\ g]c` bc`\ Q][Sa V]e eWZZ g]c ^`SaS`dS g]c` [][S\b T]` ^]abS` Wbg- 0SQOcaS b`cZg g]c [Og \SdS` PS W\ bVS a^]bZWUVb ZWYS bVWa OUOW\- 7T g]c` Q][^cbS` VOa EW\R]ea DWabO ;SRWO 1S\bS` O\R O BD bc\S` g]c¸`S W\ ZcQY G]c QO\ `SQ]`R O\R ^`SaS`dS g]c` BD \Sea a]c\R PWbS W\ ^S`^SbcWbg G]c R]\¸b \SSR O\g bVW`R ^O`bg a]TbeO`S O\R g]c QO\ SdS\ ^]ab bVS \Sea QZW^ b] g]c` ESP aWbS WT g]c bOYS bVS `WUVb abS^a 0ST]`S g]c R] O\g ]T bVWa g]c \SSR b] aSb c^ g]c` DWabO ;SRWO 1S\bS` >1 b] eObQV BD SWbVS` dWO QOPZS ]` ]dS` bVS OW` 7T g]c` Q][

T

% >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< =1B=03@ '

^cbS` VOa O PcWZb W\ bc\S` O\R g]c VOdS\¸b b`WSR Wb gSb ¿`S c^ EW\R]ea ;SRWO 1S\bS` O\R QV]]aS BOaYa j ASbbW\Ua j BD j ASb C^ BD AWU\OZ bVS\ T]ZZ]e bVS ^`][^ba O\R ZSb ;SRWO 1S\bS` WRS\bWTg bVS QVO\\SZa OdOWZ OPZS b] g]c =\QS g]c¸dS R]\S bVOb g]c QO\ `SQ]`R g]c` ZSUS\RO`g O^^SO`O\QS Pg ¿\R W\U Wb W\ bVS EW\R]ea ;SRWO 1S\bS` ^`]U`O[ UcWRS BVS UcWRS Wa ]`UO\WhSR Pg bW[S RObS O\R QVO\\SZ a] WT g]c¸dS SdS` P`]eaSR BD ZWabW\Ua Wba ]^S`ObW]\ eWZZ PS ^`Sbbg ]PdW ]ca EVS\ g]c TW\R bVS ^`]U`O[ W\ eVWQV g]c O^^SO` QZWQY bVS @SQ]`R Pcbb]\ b] bSZZ ;SRWO 1S\bS` b] `SQ]`R bVOb ^`]U`O[ eVS\ Wb ]QQc`a G]c QO\ OZa] eOWb c\bWZ bVS aV]e Q][Sa ]\ bVS\ ^`Saa bVS `SQ]`R Pcbb]\ ]\ g]c` >1¸a `S[]bS Q]\b`]Z b] [OYS ;SRWO 1S\bS` `SQ]`R bVS aV]e g]c¸`S eObQVW\U

%! /B E=@9 CaS >SOQVb`SS /QQ]c\bW\U :WYS O >`]

%& =44713

=A & 1C@7BG A3 Bc`\ 3fQSZ W\b] VWQV P`]eaS` E O\ O`QVWbSQbc`OZ Wa aOTSab b] caSRSaWU\ b]]Z

A/D3 7B 7< / A/43 >:/13 G]c QO\ bSZZ EW\R]ea DWabO ;SRWO 1S\bS` b] aOdS `SQ]`RSR BD ^`]U`O[a W\ bVS Z]QObW]\ ]T g]c` QV]WQS

4W\R G]c` @SQ]`RSR BD 7T g]c eO\b b] ¿\R O\R ^`SaS`dS g]c` `SQ]`R W\U g]c \SSR b] ]^S\ bVS Z]QObW]\ Ob eVWQV EW\R]ea ;SRWO 1S\bS` aOdSa `SQ]`RSR BD aV]ea cacOZZg O T]ZRS` \O[SR @SQ]`RSR BD G]c QO\ OZa] QVO\US bVS R`WdS b] eVWQV ;SRWO 1S\bS` aOdSa `SQ]`RSR ^`]U`O[a Pg QV]]aW\U ASbbW\Ua j BD j @SQ]`RS` j @SQ]`RS` Ab]`OUS Pcb ;SRWO 1S\bS` eWZZ abWZZ Q`SObS O T]ZRS` QOZZSR @SQ]`RSR BD ]\ bVS R`WdS g]c RSaWU\ObS =\QS g]c¸dS T]c\R bVS Q]``SQb T]ZRS` g]c QO\ WRS\bWTg bVS ^`]U`O[ g]c aOdSR Pg Wba ¿ZS RObS eVWQV aV]cZR Q]` `Sa^]\R b] bVS RObS eVS\ g]c `SQ]`RSR bVS ^`]U`O[

W\QZcRSa 2@; TSObc`Sa a] WT bVS P`]ORQOabS` eV] [ORS g]c TO[]ca [O`YSR Wba P`]OR QOab Oa µR] \]b Q]^g ¶ g]c` TO[S [Og PS TZSSbW\U EW\R]ea DWabO ;]dWS ;OYS` QO\ ]^S\ c\^`]bSQbSR 2D@ ;A TWZSa Pcb bVS F> dS`aW]\ ]T ;]dWS ;OYS` QO\ R] a] ]\Zg eWbV bVS VSZ^ ]T a][S VSOdg Rcbg @SUWab`g VOQYa ;WQ`]a]Tb aSS[a b] QVO\US Wba [W\R ^S`W ]RWQOZZg OP]cb V]e aS`W]caZg b] bOYS 2@; /b bVS [][S\b bVS eWhO`Ra ]T @SR[]\R O`S O ZWbbZS ZSaa ab`W\US\b Pcb bVOb Q]cZR QVO\US Ob O\g [][S\b ;]ab ^]^cZO` dWRS] SRWbW\U ^`]U`O[a QO\¸b R] bVS X]P SWbVS` 0cb WT g]c¸`S `c\\W\U DWabO g]c [WUVb Xcab b`g ]^S\W\U bVS ¿ZS W\ BVS 2@; 2WZS[[O EW\R]ea ;]dWS ;OYS` QcbbW\U bVS dWRS] Oa EW\R]ea ;SRWO 1S\bS` `SQ]`Ra BD ^`] g]c aSS ¿b O\R bVS\ aOdW\U bVS `SacZb Oa O U`O[a W\ bVS 2D@ ;A T]`[Ob eVWQV E;D ¿ZS =1B=03@ ' >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< %

A=:CB7=<A E7<2=EA ;327/ 13<B3@

3/AG B= 723<B74G <] [ObbS` eVOb Z]QObW]\ g]c QV]]aS T]` ¿ZS ab]`OUS ;SRWO 1S\bS` Q`SObSa O T]ZRS` QOZZSR @SQ]`RSR BD

DWabO ;SRWO 1S\bS`( /ZZ G]c <SSR /a []ab ]T ca OZ`SORg Y\]e bVS`S O`S [O\g ]bVS` ^ObVa b] QO^bc`W\U P`]ORQOab QZW^a T]` caS ]\ g]c` Q][^cbS` /\R bVS`S O`S OZa] \c[S`]ca bVW`R ^O`bg O^^ZWQObW]\a bVOb QO\ VSZ^ g]c Q]\dS`b 2D@ ;A ¿ZSa 0cb eVg U] bV`]cUV bVS b`]cPZS WT g]c R]\¸b VOdS b]- 7T g]c ]e\ O DWabO ;SRWO 1S\bS` >1 eWbV O RWU WbOZ bc\S` g]c OZ`SORg VOdS SdS`gbVW\U g]c 327B G=C@ />>3/@/<13 BVS dS`aW]\ ]T EW\R]ea ;]dWS[OYS` bVOb Q][Sa eWbV DWabO QO\ ]^S\ `SQ]`RSR BD ¿ZSa Q`SObSR Pg EW\R]ea DWabO ;SRWO 1S\bS` a] bVOb g]c QO\ SRWb bVS ¿ZSa O\R aOdS b] E;D T]`[Ob T]` ^ZOg POQY ]\ ]bVS` Q][^cbS`a

% >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< =1B=03@ '

\SSR b] QO^bc`S aOdS O\R SRWb P`]ORQOab T]]bOUS W\ TcZZ 62 _cOZWbg `ObVS` bVO\ T]`Q W\U Wb bV`]cUV Z]eS` `Sa]ZcbW]\ [SRWO ZWYS 2D2 ]` D6A bO^S BVOb eOg g]c QO\ RWa^ZOg g]c` W[[]`bOZWbg W\ VWUV RS¿\WbW]\ ]\ Q][ ^cbS`a bVOb R]\¸b VOdS EW\R]ea ;SRWO 1S\ bS` ]` ^]ab g]c` T]]bOUS b] bVS µ7 :]dS ;S¶ ^OUS ]\ g]c` ESP aWbS T]` bVS eV]ZS e]`ZR b] aSS ■

A=:CB7=<A /B E=@9

CaS >SOQVb`SS /QQ]c\bW\U :WYS O >`] /ZbV]cUV _cWbS Q][^`SVS\aWdS >SOQVb`SS Wa \]b bVS SOaWSab OQQ]c\bW\U O^^ b] caS B`g bVSaS bW^a O\R YSgP]O`R aV]`bQcba b] caS bVS a]TbeO`S b] PSab ORdO\bOUS 0g 9ObVg GOYOZ SOQVb`SS A]TbeO`S VOa PSS\ O`]c\R Z]\US` bVO\ []ab dS\R]`a ]T a[OZZ PcaW\Saa OQQ]c\bW\U a]TbeO`S 7\ bVS SO`Zg '' a bVS Q][^O\g U]b aS`W]ca OP]cb bVS a[OZZ b] [SRWc[ aWhS PcaW\Saa [O`YSb O\R EW\R]ea O\R abO`bSR ^`]RcQW\U O ZW\S ]T RSaYb]^ ^`]U`O[a bVOb ORR`Saa bVS \SSRa ]T dS`g a[OZZ a[OZZ O\R´eWbV Wba ZObSab ?cO\bc[ ^`]RcQb´\]b a] a[OZZ PcaW\SaaSa >SOQVb`SS OQQ]c\bW\U a]TbeO`S Wa ^`]PO PZg bVS []ab TSObc`S ^OQYSR A;0 OQQ]c\b W\U ^OQYOUS bV]cUV Wb¸a \]b Oa SOag b] caS ]` W\bSU`ObSR Oa QZ]aS Q][^SbWb]` ?cWQY 0]]Ya 7ba Q][^ZSfWbg QO\ abc[^ bVS \S] ^VgbS Ob bW[Sa bV]cUV bVS a]TbeO`S PcWZRa W\ O b]\ ]T VSZ^ TSObc`Sa 7T g]c¸`S `SOZZg O[PWbW]ca O\R eO\b b] c\RS`abO\R eVOb g]c¸`S USbbW\U W\b] PST]`S g]c USb bVS`S g]c QO\ `SOR bVS S\bW`S CaS` 5cWRS T]c\R W\ bVS 6SZ^ [S\c Pcb bVOb

P

aSS[a SfQSaaWdS BVS ¿`ab bVW\U b] R] eVS\ O^^`]OQVW\U O\g >SOQVb`SS ^`]U`O[ Wa b] ZSO`\ Wba YSgP]O`R aV]`bQcba 6S`S O`S a][S ]T bVS []ab ]TbS\ caSR 1bZ AV]`bQcba 1b`Z F 1cb 1b`Z 1 1]^g 1b`Z D >OabS 1b`Z 3 2SZSbS `SQ]`R 1b`Z 4 4W\R 1b`Z 2 4W\R \Sfb 1b`Z < <Se Q][^O\g 1b`Z = =^S\ Q][^O\g 1b`Z 0 0OQY c^ Q][^O\g 1b`Z @ @Sab]`S Q][^O\g 1b`Z > >`W\b RWa^ZOgSR `S^]`b W\d]WQSa _c]bSa ^Og[S\ba O\R a] ]\ 4c\QbW]\ 9Sga 4 2Wa^ZOga ]\ZW\S VSZ^ b]^WQ T]` bVS Qc` `S\b eW\R]e =1B=03@ ' >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< %!

A=:CB7=<A /B E=@9

AVWTb 4 1VO\USa []caS ^]W\bS` b] µEVOb¸a BVWa-¶ VSZ^ aSZSQb]` 4! 4W\R b`O\aOQbW]\a 4# AOdSa `SQ]`Ra O\R ^]aba ]` aOdSa b`O\aOQbW]\a W\ QS`bOW\ eW\R]ea 4% 1VSQY a^SZZW\U 4 B]UUZSa PSbeSS\ bVS ]^S\ eW\R]e O\R bVS [S\c PO` 1b`Z 4" 1Z]aSa bVS Qc``S\b R]Qc[S\b eW\R]e /Zb 4" 1Z]aSa bVS O^^ZWQObW]\ eW\R]e 1b`Z 4$ ;]dSa b] bVS \Sfb eW\R]e AVWTb 1b`Z 4$ ;]dSa b] bVS ^`SdW]ca eW\R]e BVS`S O`S ]bVS` bOaYa g]c¸ZZ ^S`T]`[ ]TbS\ bVOb ]\QS ZSO`\SR eWZZ [OYS ROg b] ROg caS ]T bVS ^`]U`O[ SOaWS` 6S`S O`S a][S SfO[^ZSa BW^a [Og \]b O^^Zg b] OZZ dS`aW]\a Sa^SQWOZZg 4W`ab /QQ]c\bW\U) Q]\acZb g]c` VSZ^ ¿ZSa WT g]c S\Q]c\bS` b`]cPZS 6SZ^ ]\ 6SZ^ >SOQVb`SS OQQ]c\bW\U a]TbeO`S Wa W\bcWbWdS S\]cUV bVOb g]c [Og PS OPZS b] RWU W\ O\R USb abO`bSR Sa^SQWOZZg WT g]c VOdS a][S OQQ]c\bW\U Y\]eZSRUS BVS ^`]U`O[a O`S RWdWRSR W\b] aSdS`OZ Tc\QbW]\OZ O`SOa W\QZcRW\U 1cab][S`a AOZSa DS\R]`a >c`QVOaSa O\R 1][^O\g A][S dS`aW]\a VOdS O 0caW\Saa AbObca TSObc`S O ROaVP]O`R bVOb RWa^ZOga g]c` YSg \c[PS`a Oa ZWaba O\R U`O^Va BVSaS µ[]RcZSa¶ O`S `S^`SaS\bSR Pg bOPa bVOb `c\ W\ O dS`bWQOZ ^O\S 1ZWQY ]\ ]\S O\R bVS [OW\ aQ`SS\ eWZZ RWa^ZOg O\ W\bS`OQbWdS ^`]QSaa [O^ bVOb WZZcab`ObSa bVS ^`W[O`g bOaYa W\ bVOb O`SO :Waba ]T `SZObSR W\T]`[O %" >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< =1B=03@ '

bW]\ ZWYS dS\R]`a O\R `S^]`ba O`S ]\ bVS `WUVb >SOQVb`SS¸a VSZ^ Wa d]Zc[W\]ca) VS`S O`S a][S bW^a ]\ V]e b] PSab caS Wb @SOR bV`]cUV bVS 5SbbW\U AbO`bSR aSQ bW]\ B] aSS WT O e]`R ]` ^V`OaS Q]\bOW\SR W\ O b]^WQ Wa W\ bVS VSZ^ W\RSf aSZSQb bVS e]`R O\R bVS\ ^`Saa 4 3f^S`W[S\b eWbV bVS aO[^ZS Q][^O\WSa >SOQVb`SS Q][Sa eWbV be]) bVSg QO\ UWdS g]c O U]]R WRSO ]T eVOb g]c` TZSaVSR ]cb aQ`SS\a eWZZ Z]]Y ZWYS 1ZWQY 6SZ^ j >SOQVb`SS /QQ]c\bW\U 5cWRSR B]c` b] USb O U]]R Z]]Y O`]c\R PST]`S g]c abO`b 1ZWQY 6SZ^ j AV]e ;S 6]e B] T]` dWSe W\U RS[]a ]T Q][[]\ bOaYa ZWYS QVO\UW\U OQQ]c\bW\U ^S`W]Ra AgabS[ BW^a A][SbW[Sa g]c \SSR b] S\bS` O b`O\aOQ bW]\ W\ O ^Oab ]` Tcbc`S OQQ]c\bW\U ^S`W]R B] R] a] QZWQY ]\ BOaYa j AgabS[ j 1VO\US /QQ]c\bW\U >S`W]R O\R aSZSQb bVS ]\S g]c eO\b 4]ZZ]e bVS aO[S ^ObV b] USb POQY b] bVS Qc``S\b ^S`W]R @S[S[PS` bVOb bVWa eWZZ VOdS O\ W[^OQb ]\ g]c` `S^]`ba T`][ ^Oab ^S`W]Ra 4W\O\QWOZ RObO [cab PS POQYSR c^ BOYS Wb T`][ a][S]\S eV]¸a VOR O\ OQQ]c\b W\U agabS[ [SZbR]e\ eWbV]cb O Qc``S\b POQYc^ 1ZWQY 4WZS j 0OQY C^ ]` 1b`Z 0 O\R aSZSQb T`][ bVS ]^bW]\a bVS`S G]c QO\ aSb O `S[W\RS` T]` O a^SQWTWSR \c[PS` ]T ROga O\R aSZSQb O R`WdS Oa bVS RSabW\ObW]\ >SOQVb`SS ]TTS`a ;0 ]\ZW\S POQYc^ T`SS

1AD 47:3A >SOQVb`SS QO\ P]bV W[^]`b O\R Sf^]`b 1AD ¿ZSa

T]` ]\S gSO` T`][ W\abOZZObW]\ T]` ' dS` aW]\) ]e\S`a ]T dS`aW]\a $ b] & [cab ^Og '' 3\bS`W\U Qcab][S`a dS\R]`a O\R S[^Z]gSSa QO\ PS bW[S Q]\ac[W\U /\R dS`g P]`W\U 7T g]c OZ`SORg VOdS Ob ZSOab a][S ]T bVSaS `SQ]`Ra ab]`SR W\ =cbZ]]Y g]c QO\ aSb c^ O ag\QV`]\WhObW]\ eWbV >SOQVb`SS 1ZWQY 4WZS j Ag\Q EWbV =cbZ]]Y 0ST]`S g]c R] bVWa `SOR bVS Oaa]QWObSR VSZ^ ¿ZS >SOQVb`SS a]TbeO`S W[^]`ba O\R Sf^]`ba 1AD ¿ZSa 1ZWQY 4WZS j 7[^]`b O\R ^Og QZ]aS ObbS\bW]\ b] bVS ¿SZR [O^ ^]abSR bVS`S a] g]c QO\ PS ac`S g]c` W\Q][W\U TWZSa O`S W\ bVS `WUVb ]`RS` O\R OZZ bVS RObO S\R c^ W\ bVS Q]``SQb ¿SZRa 0ST]`S g]c Q`SObS O \Se Q][^O\g caW\U bVS 1`SObS / <Se 1][^O\g EWhO`R 4WZS j <Se 1][^O\g VOdS W\T]`[ObW]\ OdOWZOPZS G]c¸ZZ \SSR b] S\bS` bVS Q][^O\g \O[S O\R aSZSQb O PcaW\Saa bg^S QV]]aS PSbeSS\ QOaV O\R OQQ`cOZ OQQ]c\bW\U g]c e]\¸b PS OPZS b] QVO\US bVWa OTbS` Q`SObW\U bVS Q][

^O\g a] Y\]e T]` ac`S O\R RSQWRS ]\ g]c` OQQ]c\bW\U ^S`W]Ra O\R ¿aQOZ gSO` B`O\aOQbW]\ BW^a G]c QO\ µ[S[]`WhS¶ a][S T`S_cS\bZg caSR b`O\aOQbW]\a W\ >SOQVb`SS a]TbeO`S =^S\ ]` Q`SObS O aOZSa W\d]WQS T]` SfO[^ZS O\R QZWQY bVS O``]e \Sfb b] bVS AOdS WQ]\ 1ZWQY ]\ ;S[]`WhS BVS ;OW\bOW\ ;S[] `WhSR AOZSa 7\d]WQSa eW\R]e ]^S\a 3\bS` O B`O\aOQbW]\ 72 O\R 2SaQ`W^bW]\ O\R QZWQY AOdS G]c QO\ OZa] S\bS` bVS W\d]WQS W\T]` [ObW]\ RW`SQbZg VS`S B] OQQSaa [S[]`WhSR b`O\aOQbW]\a QZWQY bVS ;OW\bOW\ [S\c bVS\ ;S[]`WhSR B`O\aOQbW]\a CaS >SOQVb`SS¸a =T¿QS ZW\Y b] Q`SObS ZSb bS`a b] Qcab][S`a dS\R]`a O\R S[^Z]g SSa 1ZWQY BOaYa j E`WbS :SbbS`a O\R aSZSQb 1cab][S`a T]` SfO[^ZS ASZSQb O bS[ ^ZObS T`][ bV]aS ac^^ZWSR acQV Oa 1]ZZSQ bW]\ :SbbS` T]` ]dS`RcS W\d]WQSa W\ /UW\U >S`W]R 1ZWQY ]\ 3RWb :SbbS` BS[^ZObS b] dWSe bVS ZSbbS` O\R [OYS O\g QVO\USa 1ZWQY =1B=03@ ' >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< %#

A=:CB7=<A /B E=@9

:=5 /< 3D3<B G]c QO\ Q`S ObS SdS\ba acQV Oa QOZZa ]` [SSbW\Ua g]c \SSR b] [OYS eWbV dS\R]`a O\R YSS^ bVS[ W\ g]c` `SQ]`Ra bVS\ QVSQY bVS[ eVS\ bVSg¸`S Q][^ZSbSR

AS\R :SbbS` O\R QVO\US O\g ]T bVS ]^bW]\a bVS`S´W\QZcRW\U S [OWZ ]^bW]\a´WT \SQSa aO`g bVS\ QZWQY bVS E]`R ]` 3 ;OWZ Pcbb]\ b] US\S`ObS g]c` [OWZ [S`US 3dS`g []RcZS W\ >SOQVb`SS VOa Wba ]e\ RSTOcZba G]c aV]cZR Z]]Y Ob bVSaS PST]`S g]c abO`b ^`]QSaaW\U b`O\aOQbW]\a 1ZWQY ;OW\bOW\ j 2STOcZb 7\T]`[ObW]\ bVS\ aSZSQb O []RcZS ZWYS 1cab][S`a 2STOcZba VS`S O`S W\ bVS O`SOa ]T BS`[a O\R 1`SRWb /QQ]c\b /UW\U 4W\O\QS 1VO`USa >Og ;SbV]Ra O\R O\g Qcab][ TWSZRa g]c [Og VOdS Q`SObSR AW[^Zg QVO\US O\g bVOb O`S\¸b eVOb g]c eO\b CaS 3dS\b :]Ua W\ `SQ]`Ra =^S\ O `SQ]`R W\ bVS DS\R]` []RcZS T]` SfO[^ZS O\R QZWQY bVS :]U WQ]\ G]c¸ZZ aSS O ZWab ]T SdS\ba ZWYS 1VSQY b] DS\R]` O\R DS\R]` 7\d]WQS 2cS G]c QO\ ORR g]c` ]e\ VS`S Pg QZWQYW\U 3dS\b O\R aSZSQbW\U bVS bg^S ]T SdS\b g]c eO\b b] R]Qc[S\b ZWYS 1OZZ B] ;SSbW\U O\R %$ >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< =1B=03@ '

:SbbS` 4`][ ;OYS O \]bS O\R QVSQY O P]f WT g]c eO\b ORdO\QS eO`\W\U W\ /QbW]\ WbS[a O\R QVSQY eVS\ Q][^ZSbSR BVOb WbS[ eWZZ bVS\ O^^SO` W\ bVS /QbW]\ 7bS[a 5S\S`OZ BW^a G]c aV]cZR Z]]Y Ob UZ]POZ ]^bW]\a QO`S TcZZg PST]`S g]c abO`b 1ZWQY =^bW]\a j 5Z]POZ b] ]^S\ bVS ;OW\bOW\ 5Z]POZ =^bW]\a eW\ R]e <c[S`]ca ]^bW]\a QO\ PS b]UUZSR VS`S acQV Oa eVSbVS` b] VWRS W\OQbWdS `SQ]`Ra caS a^SZZ QVSQY ]` Ocb][ObWQOZZg Q`SObS 72a ]\ [OW\bS\O\QS eW\R]ea G]c QO\ OZa] aSb O aSQc`Wbg ZSdSZ T]` >SOQVb`SS >O`b\S` O^^ZWQObW]\a >SOQVb`SS¸a V][S ^OUS R]Sa O U]]R X]P ]T ^`]dWRW\U SOag b] caS \OdWUObW]\OZ OWRa 0cb g]c QO\ [OYS Wb SOaWS` Pg Qcab][WhW\U bVS ZWab ]T aV]`bQcba bVOb O^^SO` W\ bVS ZSTb dS`bWQOZ ^O\S 1ZWQY bVS 1cab][WhS ZW\Y O\R QVO\US bVS ]`RS` ]T bVS SfWabW\U aV]`bQcba

5:=0/: =>B7=<A G]c QO\ QVO\US aSbbW\Ua acQV Oa aSQc `Wbg ZSdSZa O\R VWRW\U W\OQbWdS `SQ]`Ra W\ bVS ;OW\bOW\ 5Z]POZ =^bW]\a [S\c

RSZSbS ]` `S\O[S bVS[ ]` ORR g]c` ]e\ Pg QZWQYW\U ]\ /RR O AV]`bQcb CaS Qcab][S` Q]RS bg^Sa >SOQVb`SS ZSba g]c OaaWU\ Q]RS bg^Sa b] `SQ]`Ra BVSaS R]\¸b O^^SO` ]\ W\d]WQSa ]` abObS[S\ba Pcb g]c QO\ caS bVS[ b] ab`SO[ZW\S `S^]`ba G]c Q]cZR T]` SfO[^ZS Q]RS SOQV Qcab][S` Pg US]U`O^VWQOZ `SUW]\ >SOQVb`SS OZZ]ea [cZbW^ZS Qcab][ ¿SZRa W\ `SQ]`Ra G]c QO\ RS¿\S bVSaS SWbVS` eWbVW\ bVS `SQ]`R WbaSZT ]` Pg QZWQYW\U ;OW\bOW\ j 2STOcZb W\T]`[ObW]\ O\R bVS\ aSZSQbW\U bVS `SQ]`R bg^S 7\ g]c` S[^Z]gSS `SQ]`Ra T]` SfO[^ZS g]c [WUVb ORR ¿SZRa T]` ^]aWbW]\ a^]caS O\R `SdWSe RObS G]c QO\ aSb c^ S [OWZ OZS`ba T]` a^SQW¿Q Q]\RWbW]\a 1ZWQY ]\ BOaYa j /QbW]\ 7bS[a 1ZWQY bVS /ZS`ba WQ]\ G]c QO\ aSb c^ OZS`ba T]` Qcab][S`a dS\R]`a S[^Z]gSSa W\dS\b]`g WbS[a O\R 5 : US\S`OZ ZSRUS` /QQ]c\b 4]` SfO[^ZS g]c [WUVb eO\b b] Y\]e eVS\ O aOZSa WbS[ VWba O QS`bOW\ ZSdSZ B] ¿\R ]cb g]c e]cZR aSZSQb 7\dS\b]`g 7bS[ bVS a^S

QWTWQ WbS[ ]` `O\US bVS bg^S ]T OZS`b aOg AOZSa D]Zc[S´1c``S\b >S`W]R bVS Q]\RW bW]\ ≥ ]` ≤ O\R bVS O[]c\b 7T g]c eO\b bVS OZS`b S [OWZSR b] g]c O\R aOg g]c` W\dS\ b]`g QZS`Y QVSQY bVS S [OWZ P]f O\R S\bS` S [OWZ ORR`SaaSa G]c QO\ OZa] aSZSQb SdS\ba bVOb aV]cZR O^^SO` W\ bVS /QbW]\ 7bS[a ZWab acQV Oa _c]bSa Sf^W`W\U O\R QVSQY b] dS\ R]`a f \c[PS` ]T ROga PST]`S bVS SdS\b RObS >SOQVb`SS a]TbeO`S Wa dS`g RSS^ O\R \]b OZZ ]T Wba QO^OPWZWbWSa O`S ]PdW]ca G]c¸ZZ \SSR b] R] a][S RWUUW\U b] ¿\R SdS`gbVW\U BVOb¸a bVS dOZcS ]T ^ZOgW\U O`]c\R eWbV bVS aO[^ZS ¿ZSa PST]`S g]c abO`b caW\U g]c` ZWdS RObO( G]c QO\ Sf^Z]`S aSS eVOb¸a bVS`S O\R ORR aO[^ZS RObO ]T g]c` ]e\ b] aSS V]e Wb e]`Ya >SOQVb`SS OZa] ]TTS`a O Z]b ]T W\bSU`ObSR ORR ]\ aS`dWQSa ZWYS Q`SRWb QO`R ^`]QSaaW\U PWZZ ^Og O\R `S[]bS OQQSaa 0S ac`S b] dWaWb bVS >SOQVb`SS aWbS b] aSS eVOb g]c` ]^bW]\a O`S PST]`S RWdW\U W\ ■ =1B=03@ ' >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< %%

A=:CB7=<A =44713 =A

CaS 3fQSZ Oa O\ /`QVWbSQbc`OZ 2SaWU\ B]]Z 7b¸a \]b Xcab O a^`SORaVSSb O^^ 3fQSZ QO\ VSZ^ g]c b] RSaWU\ O\R PcWZR aW[^ZS ^`]XSQba acQV Oa RSQYa ^]`QVSa R]U V]caSa O\R SdS\ Tc`\Wbc`S 0g 8cZWS AO`bOW\ fQSZ Wa a] [cQV []`S bVO\ Xcab O a^`SORaVSSb ]` O aW[^ZS RObOPOaS T]` QObOZ]UW\U g]c` 2D2 Q]ZZSQbW]\ =\S ]T Wba [O\g ORRWbW]\OZ Tc\QbW]\a W\QZcRSa caW\U Wb Oa O\ O`QVWbSQbc`OZ RSaWU\ b]]Z /ZbV]cUV Wb¸a \]b `SQ][[S\RSR T]` PcWZRW\U P`WRUSa ]` aV]^^W\U [OZZa O\R QS` bOW\Zg \]b T]` bOYW\U bVS ^ZOQS ]T O _cOZW¿SR S\UW\SS` g]c QO\ caS Wb b] RSaWU\ O\R PcWZR aW[^ZS ^`]XSQba acQV Oa RSQYa ^]`QVSa R]U V]caSa TS\QSa ^ZOgV]caSa ^]bbW\U aVSRa O\R SdS\ UO`OUSa 7b¸a OZa] VO\Rg T]` PcWZR W\U Tc`\Wbc`S acQV Oa P]]YaVSZdSa /RW`]\ ROQY QVOW`a `]QYW\U QVOW`a T`]\b ^]`QV aeW\Ua O\R ^WQ\WQ bOPZSa 6][S]e\S`a QO\ OZa] caS Wb T]` W\bS`W]` RSaWU\ ^ZOQS[S\b ]T Tc`\Wbc`S O\R ZO\RaQO^W\U ^`]XSQba 7T g]c OZ`SORg ]e\ 3fQSZ O\R Y\]e g]c` eOg O`]c\R Wb caW\U Wb T]` a[OZZ PcWZRW\U ^`]XSQba QO\ aOdS g]c bW[S O\R []\Sg) bVS`S¸a ZWbbZS b] \] ZSO`\W\U Qc`dS O\R g]c

E

%& >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< =1B=03@ '

R]\¸b VOdS b] ^c`QVOaS O aS^O`ObS a^SQWOZbg ^`]U`O[ 3fQSZ RSaWU\a O`S OQQS^bSR Pg []ab PcWZRW\U W\a^SQb]`a Oa ]TTWQWOZ PZcS ^`W\ba a] g]c R]\¸b VOdS b] VW`S O\ O`QVWbSQb ]` S\UW\SS` T]` bVSaS aW[^ZS ^`]XSQba 3fQSZ ^`]dWRSa O \c[PS` ]T aVO^Sa O\R U`O^VWQa bVOb g]c QO\ caS T]` Tc`\Wbc`S O\R ]` ZO\RaQO^W\U ^ZOQS[S\b ^Zca g]c QO\ W[^]`b ]` Q]^g O\R ^OabS U`O^VWQa T`][ OZ[]ab O\g U`O^VWQa ^`]U`O[ G]c QO\ OZa] QO^bc`S W[OUSa T`][ dO`W]ca a]c`QSa O\R caS bVS[ b] aV]e bVS O``O\US[S\b ]T Oaa]`bSR ^ZO\ba O\R b`SSa T]` g]c` ZO\RaQO^ W\U ^`]XSQba ]` b] WZZcab`ObS V]e g]c ^ZO\ b] `S[]RSZ g]c` YWbQVS\ 2SaWU\ >`]XSQb AbS^ Pg AbS^ AOg T]` SfO[^ZS g]c eO\bSR b] PcWZR O e]`YaV]^ eWbV be] `]][a VWa O\R VS`a ORRSR b] bVS aWRS ]T O\ SfWabW\U UO`OUS 3fQSZ QO\ [OYS ^ZO\\W\U O\R RSaWU\W\U bVWa O\ SOag bOaY BVS T]ZZ]eW\U W\ab`cQbW]\a QO\

!"#"!$

./01234564

./01=:<6

%#&'$(")

780194:;64<

780194:;64<

?@01=:<6

7801=:<6

780194:;64<

.>01=:<6

./01234564

780194:;64<

7801=:<6

.>01=:<6

780194:;64<

780194:;64<

*+,-$

6=;3 7;>@=D3;3<B 13:: 0G 13:: =\QS g]c ZSO`\ V]e b] aSb c^ g]c` e]`YaVSSb g]c QO\ RS aWU\ ^`]XSQba ZWYS bVWa be] `]][ e]`YaV]^ eWbV 3fQSZ SOaWZg O\R ^OW\ZSaaZg

UcWRS g]c bV`]cUV bVS ^`]QSaa( =^S\ 3fQSZ / \Se PZO\Y e]`YaVSSb O^^SO`a >`Saa 1b`Z / b] aSZSQb VWUVZWUVb bVS S\bW`S e]`YaVSSb ! ASZSQb 4]`[Ob , 1]Zc[\ EWRbV O\R S\bS` bVS \c[PS` " ASZSQb 4]`[Ob , @]e 6SWUVb O\R S\bS` bVS \c[PS` ' <]e g]c` aQ`SS\ a^`SORaVSSb Z]]Ya ZWYS O aVSSb ]T U`WR ^O^S` BVS aWhS ]T SOQV a_cO`S `SZObWdS b] g]c` ^`]XSQb QO\ PS O\g \c[ PS` bVOb PSab ¿ba g]c` ^`]XSQb) T]` SfO[^ZS SOQV a_cO`S S_cOZa ]\S T]]b ]` ]\S W\QV ]` bV`SS W\QVSa 7T g]c` ^`]XSQb `S_cW`Sa SfOQb [SOac`S[S\ba bVS\ ]\S W\QV ^S` a_cO`S ]` a_cO`Sa ^S` T]]b e]cZR PS bVS eWa

Sab QV]WQS 7T g]c` ^`]XSQb Wa O PWb Z]]aS` acQV Oa ZO\RaQO^W\U bVS\ bV`SS W\QVSa ]` T]c` a_cO`Sa ^S` T]]b e]cZR ZWYSZg acT¿QS BVS W\ab`cQbW]\a O\R U`O^VWQa T]` bVWa aO[^ZS O`S RSaWU\SR caW\U bV`SS W\QVSa ^S` a_cO`S ]` T]c` a_cO`Sa ^S` T]]b AOg bVS V][S]e\S` ^]c`SR O Q]\Q`SbS T]c\RObW]\ ]T " a_cO`S TSSb) bVOb Wa TSSb eWRS Pg TSSb RSS^ A] ¿`ab g]c aV]cZR ORR O\ ]cb ZW\S ]T bVS TcZZ O`SO bVS\ ¿ZZ W\ bVS aS^O`ObS a^OQSa # 2`]^ R]e\ OP]cb aWf a_cO`Sa T`][ bVS b]^ O\R bVS ZSTb ]` Xcab ^]aWbW]\ g]c` Qc`a]` W\ QSZZ 5% /b T]c` a_cO`Sa ^S` T]]b VWUVZWUVb O\ O`SO bVOb¸a & Q]Zc[\a eWRS O\R "& `]ea bOZZ ]` RSS^ T]` bVS `S_cW`SR a^OQS ]T TSSb eWRS Pg TSSb RSS^ BVOb e]cZR PS 5% =1B=03@ ' >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< %'

A=:CB7=<A =44713 =A

bV`]cUV 16#" $ ASZSQb bVS =cbZW\S ]^bW]\ T`][ bVS 0]` RS`a bOaY PO` [S\c ]` aSZSQb 4]`[Ob , 1SZZa , 0]`RS` T`][ bVS ;OW\ ;S\c & 1V]]aS bVS bVWQY =cbZW\S P]`RS` T`][ bVS ]^bW]\a ^`]dWRSR ' G]c QO\ OZa] ORR W\bS`W]` ]cbZW\S P]` RS`a b] RSTW\S SOQV a_cO`S T]]b ]T a^OQS BVWa aO[^ZS caSa bVS W\bS`W]` P]`RS`a b] [OYS bVS RWdWaW]\ ]T a^OQS SOaWS` b] dWSe /RRW\U EOZZa EW\R]ea O\R 2]]`a BVS V][S]e\S` W\ bVWa SfO[^ZS RSQWRSR b] PcWZR Pg $ eOZZa W\abSOR ]T Pg " PSQOcaS ]T bVS Q]ZRS` eW\bS`a W\ VWa O`SO / Pg $ P]O`R Wa ]\Zg # # W\QVSa eWRS Pcb WT g]c ORR # W\QVSa T]` bVS W\bS`W]` eOZZ Q]dS`W\U bVOb S_cOZa aWf W\QVSa ]` be] ]T bVS a_cO`Sa BVS b]bOZ W\bS`W]` a^OQS Wa \]e Pg ' 4W`ab caS O ZWUVb Q]Z]` b] PZ]QY ]cb bVS SfbS`W]` eOZZa BVWa a^OQS Wa RWdWRSR W\b] be] `]][a a] ORR O R]cPZS ZW\S P]`RS` ' TSSb T`][ bVS ZSTb eOZZ 4WZZ W\ be] Q]Zc[\a b] bVS ZSTb ]T g]c` R]cPZS ZW\S eWbV bVS gSZZ]e aVORW\U b] W\RWQObS bVS W\bS`W]` eOZZ <Sfb RSQWRS eVS`S g]c eO\b bVS eW\R]ea O\R R]]`a CaS ]\S ]T bVS POaWQ aVO^Sa b] R`Oe bVSaS acQV Oa bVS `SQbO\Uc ZO` 4Z]eQVO`b aVO^S eWbV bVS aWRS ^O\SZa ! /TbS` g]c ^ZOQS bVS R]]`a O\R eW\ R]ea caS bVS 0OaWQ aVO^S `SQbO\UZS b] aYSbQV W\ bVS Z]QObW]\ ]T bVS QOPW\Sba 7\ bVWa SfO[^ZS bVS`S O`S aWf eW\R]ea ]`O\US O\R bV`SS R]]`a U`SS\ BVS`S O`S OZa] O aS`WSa ]T QOPW\Sba P]bV eOZZ O\R POaS AW\QS bVS eW\R]ea R]]`a O\R QOPW\Sba O`S & >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< =1B=03@ '

OZZ R`Oe\ caW\U 3fQSZ aVO^Sa g]c QO\ []dS bVS[ O`]c\R c\bWZ g]c TW\R O\ S_cWbOPZS O``O\US[S\b BVS V][S]e\S` VOR ]`WUW \OZZg ^]aWbW]\SR bVS R]]`a O\R eW\R]ea W\ RWTTS`S\b Z]QObW]\a Pcb OTbS` aV]eW\U bVS R`OeW\U b] VWa eWTS VS QVO\USR bVS ZOg]cb AVS eO\bSR bVS R]]` U]W\U b] bVS V]caS PSaWRS bVS R]]` U]W\U W\b] VS` O`SO ]T bVS e]`YaV]^ a] aVS RWR\¸b VOdS b] eOZY bV`]cUV VWa Rcabg e]`YaV]^ b] USb b] VS` Q`OTb `]][ AVS OZa] ^]W\bSR ]cb bVOb aVS eO\bSR eOZZ QOPW\Sba a] bVS ]`WUW\OZ "& Pg "& W\QV eW\R]ea eS`S `S^ZOQSR Pg " Pg "& W\QV eW\R]ea O\R ^]aWbW]\SR c^ VWUV OP]dS bVS eOZZ QOPW\Sba /\R VS VOR ]`WUW \OZZg W\QZcRSR eW\R]ea ]\ bVS \]`bV eOZZ Pcb VWa eWTS aOWR aVS RWR\¸b \SSR O eW\R]e Z]]YW\U W\b] bVS UO`OUS 6S OU`SSR a] VS `S[]dSR bVS[ 4`][ E]`YaVSSb b] 0ZcS^`W\b /TbS` `SO``O\UW\U bVS ZOg]cb ]T bVS QOPW \Sba aSdS`OZ bW[Sa VS eOa `SORg b] acP[Wb VWa ^ZO\a b] bVS PcWZRW\U W\a^SQb]` O\R USb abO`bSR ]\ bVS ^`]XSQb 3fQSZ RSaWU\a O`S OQQS^bSR Pg []ab PcWZRW\U W\a^SQb]`a Oa ]T¿QWOZ PZcS^`W\ba a] g]c R]\¸b VOdS b] VW`S O\ O`QVWbSQb ]` S\UW\SS` T]` bVSaS aW[^ZS ^`]XSQba /\R O\g Sf^S`WS\QSR ^Zc[PS` ]` SZSQb`WQWO\ QO\ caS bVSaS R`OeW\Ua Oa O PZcS^`W\b T]` bVS ^Zc[PW\U O\R SZSQb`WQOZ W\abOZZObW]\a <]bS( BVWa SfO[^ZS R]Sa \]b aV]e bVS `]]T Pcb Wb eOa OZa] RSaWU\SR caW\U bVWa aO[S ^`]QSaa BVS V][S]e\S` Q][^ZSbSR bVWa ^`]XSQb W\ T]c` Z]\U eSSYS\Ra OP]cb $ ROga O\R Wb Q]ab O^^`]fW[ObSZg ■

A=:CB7=<A A31C@7BG

AOTS 0`]eaS`a( EV] 1][Sa =cb =\ B]^- BVS b]^ ¿dS P`]eaS`a O`S ^cb b] bVS bSab 0g :O``g ASZbhS` dS` e]\RS`SR MEAN BLOCK RATE FOR ]bVS`a bV`SS ]T eVWQV `SZg SOCIALLY ENGINEERED MALWARE eVWQV P`]eaS` ]\ bVS 5]]UZS AOTS 0`]ea INTERNET EXPLORER 8 81% eWZZ ^`]bSQb g]c W\U />7 BVS TOQb bVOb 4W`ST]f FIREFOX 3 bVS []ab eVWZS 27% R]Sa a] [cQV PSbbS` bVO\ SAFARI 4 g ] c ¸ ` S U ] W \ U AOTO`W O\R 1V`][S aV]ea bVOb 21% CHROME 2 OP]cb g]c` ROWZg PcaW\Saa Wb¸a \]b Xcab caW\U bVS />7 bVOb 7% OPERA 10 ]\ bVS <Sb- Be] bSaba Pg [ObbS`a Pcb V]e g]c caS Wb 1% % 20 40 60 80 100 <AA :OPa Q][^O`SR ^]^c /\ SdS\ PWUUS` RWaQ`S^ Data: NSS Labs ZO` P`]eaS`a T]` bVSW` OPWZWbg O\Qg eOa ]PaS`dSR W\ bVS b] PZ]QY ESP aWbSa ^caVW\U [OZeO`S O\R <AA ^VWaVW\U bSaba 73& eOa OZa] Ob bVS b]^ ]T ^VWaVW\U BVSaS P`]eaS`a eS`S Q][^O`SR( bVS QVO`ba PZ]QYW\U &! ^S`QS\b ]T ^VWaVW\U /^^ZS AOTO`W " C@:a Pcb ]\Zg aZWUVbZg OVSOR ]T 4W`ST]f ! Ob 5]]UZS 1V`][S & ^S`QS\b =^S`O PSbO eOa TO` PSVW\R Ob ;WQ`]a]Tb EW\R]ea 7\bS`\Sb 3f^Z]`S` & #" ^S`QS\b Pcb eSZZ OVSOR ]T 1V`][S Ob ;]hWZZO 4W`ST]f ! $ ^S`QS\b O\R AOTO`W " Ob ^S`QS\b =^S`O 0SbO 73&¸a `ObS ]T & ^S`QS\b T]` PZ]QYW\U [OZ 7\bS`\Sb 3f^Z]`S` & eW^SR bVS TZ]]` eWbV eO`S [Og Z]]Y U]]R eVS\ Q][^O`SR b] bVS ]bVS` ^`]RcQba W\ bVS [OZeO`S bSaba bV]aS ]T Wba Q][^SbWb]`a Pcb Wb¸a \]b a] U`SOb PZ]QYW\U & ^S`QS\b ]T ZWdS bV`SOba 4W`ST]f ]dS`OZZ 7\RSSR SdS\ WT Wb eS`S ^S`QS\b´ ! eOa QZ]aSab Ob % ^S`QS\b eWbV AOTO`W \]b O `SOZWabWQ ^]aaWPWZWbg´;WQ`]a]Tb e]cZR " Ob ^S`QS\b 1V`][S Ob % ^S`QS\b O\R W\aWab bVOb acQV ^`]bSQbW]\ Wa Pcb ]\S ZOgS` =^S`O PSbO Ob ^S`QS\b <AA :OPa aOga Wb W\ O eSZZ RSaWU\SR agabS[ ]T RSTS\aS W\ Q]\TW`[SR bVSaS `SacZba O`S bVS aO[S eWbV RS^bV G]c OZa] \SSR O a]ZWR O\bW [OZeO`S 4W`ST]f ! O\R ! # Oa eSZZ Oa =^S`O ' O\R ^`]bSQbW]\ W\ g]c` agabS[ 23> /A:@ O\R ;WQ`]a]Tb VOa OQbcOZZg Sf^O\RSR eVOb c^ b] RObS ^ObQVSa b] \O[S O TSe =\Zg eOa OZ`SORg O ZO`US ZSOR W\ bVWa O`SO W\ bSaba eVS\ g]c bOYS ORdO\bOUS ]T OZZ ]T bVSaS Pg bVS aO[S ZOPa SO`ZWS` bVWa gSO` O\R caS U]]R Q][[]\ aS\aS QO\ g]c TSSZ BVS bSab RSbOWZa aV]e bVOb ;WQ`]a]Tb aSQc`S ,,4=@ <AA :/0A¸ 4C:: @3>=@B 1:719 63@3 c^RObSa Wba ZWaba [cQV []`S _cWQYZg bVO\ bVS

E

5`O^VWQ Pg 2OdWR 4]abS`

=1B=03@ ' >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< &

0Sa

3RWb]`a¸ 1V]WQSa W\ 9Sg 1ObSU]`WSa 4]` bVS Q][^ZSbS `SdWSea ]T bVSaS ^`]RcQba O\R []`S 3RWb]`a¸ 1V]WQSa QVSQY ]cb U] ^Q[OU Q][ SRWb]`aQV]WQS

AB=@/53

23A9B=>A ;/7<AB@3/;

>=@B/0:3

6> >OdWZW]\ 3ZWbS ['" b

:S\]d] BVW\Y>OR CA0 >]`bOPZS ASQc`S 2`WdS ! ' ZWab

&"! ZWab 0C253B D/:C3

6> 1][^O_ >`SaO`W] 1?# T $'' ZWab

2SZZ 7\a^W`]\ #"# &'' ZWab

1ZWQYT`SS 62! # & ZWab 7][SUO S5] >]`bOPZS 6O`R 2`WdS ;OQ 3RWbW]\ # 50

4OZQ]\ <]`bVeSab ;OQV D 1]`S W% '%# & " RW`SQb

ESabS`\ 2WUWbOZ ;g0]]Y AbcRW] 3RWbW]\ 77 "! ZWab

2SZZ AbcRW] F>A "!# %$' RW`SQb

<3BE=@9 /BB/1632 AB=@/53

/:: 7< =<3

6> Ab]`OUSE]`Ya /W=" b

%'' RW`SQb 0CA7<3AA

! %'' ZWab

:12 ;=<7B=@A 6> :>

%#e !"' RW`SQb

2SZZ CZb`OAVO`^ " &E4> $&' RW`SQb

:S\]d] BVW\Y1S\b`S ;#&^ 3Q] CZb`O A[OZZ &' RW`SQb

/QS` 0 %!6C " ' ZWab

:/>B=>A <=B30==9A

A1/<<3@A

;/7<AB@3/;

/^^ZS ;OQ0]]Y >`] ! W\QV

3^a]\ >S`TSQbW]\ D! >V]b] '' '' RW`SQb

'' RW`SQb 5/;7<5

A;1 A;15A&> ! ab`SSb A^WQSe]`Ya ! # 4`SS 1Z]cR3\UW\Sa >]U]^ZcU '' RW`SQb 4`SS eWbV AS`dS` & ZWQS\aS

23A9B=>

:S\]d] 7RSO1S\b`S /$

<SbUSO` F/D0 ! ab`SSb

EW\R]ea AS`dS` & @

# ZWab

5/;7<5 ;C:B7;327/

/^^ZS W;OQ <dWRWO 5S4]`QS '" ; %'' ZWab

<3BE=@97<5

1WaQ] <Sbe]`Y ;OUWQ >`] # # !' '' RW`SQb 62BDA >:/A;/

DWhW] D># #FDB "'' '' ZWab :12

AVO`^ /_c]a :1 # 2&#C '' '' RW`SQb

A]\g 0`OdWO 92: "$F0@& ! ''' '' ZWab

AO[ac\U :<# /%# ! ''' ZWab =:32

A]\g F3: =:32 2WUWbOZ BD "'' '' ZWab

>@=831B=@A

2757B/: 1/;3@/A

/ZWS\eO`S ; %f " &# RW`SQb

1O\]\ @SOZWa F% # ZWab

1=;>/1B

;C:B7;327/

<31 DB& ab`SSb

1O\]\ >]eS`AV]b A2'% 7A

6> 62F $b %' RW`SQb

2SZZ ; 'A "'' RW`SQb

23A9B=> @3>:/13;3<B

>@7<B3@A

/QS` /a^W`S $'! 5 $% ! ab`SSb

;=<=16@=;3 :/A3@

!%' '' ZWab 2 A:@

<WY]\ 2! & ab`SSb 1O\]\ 3=A @SPSZ B W

<3E 2SZZ AbcRW] ### ■

9]\WQO ;W\]ZbO [OUWQ]Z]` $ E & ab`SSb

AC>3@H==;

<3B0==9

1=:=@ :/A3@

>O\Oa]\WQ :c[Wf 2;1 4H &

B]aVWPO [W\W <0 # " ab`SSb

FS`]f >VOaS` %# 2<

CA3 $1A %'' ZWab

0CA7<3AA

:S\]d] BVW\Y>OR B" #& RW`SQb 0C253B

6> >OdWZW]\ Rd & b "' RW`SQb

/QS` /a^W`S !'!# ' ab`SSb

! '' '' RW`SQb AB/<2/@2 7<983B

1O\]\ >Wf[O W>"! '' RW`SQb <3E 3^a]\ E]`Y4]`QS !

■

/ZZ 7\ =\S ' '' RW`SQb

>6=B= >@7<B3@

6> >V]b]a[O`b /$!$ 1][^OQb >V]b] >`W\bS` "' '' RW`SQb

& >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< =1B=03@ '

&'' '' ZWab

!'' '# ZWab

2757B/: D723= 1/;3@/A <3E 9]ROY HW& >]QYSb DWRS] ■

1O[S`O '' '' RW`SQb

A]\g 62@ A@ '' '' RW`SQb

Sab 2757B/: >6=B= D723=

13:: >6=<3A

7>6=<3 />>A

;C:B7;327/ AC7B3

/::B3:

/R]PS 1`SObWdS AcWbS !

@7; 0ZOQY0S``g 1c`dS &!!

''' RW`SQb

4`][

' '' eWbV Q]\b`OQb

/B B

1gPS`:W\Y 2D2 AcWbS % CZb`O

/^^ZS W>V]\S !5 A

>6=B= 327B7<5

/R]PS >V]b]aV]^ 1A" # ZWab >WQOaO ! PSbO 4`SS 2757B/: >6=B= 4@/;3

A]\g D/7= D54 1> '' ZWab ;>! >:/G3@A ;WQ`]a]Tb Hc\S 50 "' ZWab /^^ZS W>]R b]cQV &50

' RW`SQb

/^^ZS W>]R \O\] $50 '' RW`SQb

AO[ac\U G> C! 50 ' ZWab A>3/93@A 2=19A 0]ab]\ /Q]cabWQa W 2A! >Zca "'' ZWab

6S`QcZSa F>A :]c\US

RW`SQb

;327/ 3FB3<23@A A]\]a 0c\RZS # ''' RW`SQb AZW\UP]f >@= 62 '' ZWab 5/;7<5 1=<A=:3A <3E A]\g >ZOgAbObW]\ ! 50 ■

>A! AZW[ '' '' RW`SQb 5>A 23D713A

5O`[W\ \ dW $#B %' '' ZWab B][B][ =\S " A '' '# ZWab 5/253BA /[Oh]\ 9W\RZS !#' RW`SQb

3<B3@B/7<;3<B

4`][ '' eWbV Q]\b`OQb

>O\R]`O T]` W>V]\S 4`SS

<3E :5 FS\]\ 5@# ■

@VO^a]Rg 4`][ '' ^S` []\bV

'' RW`SQb

AZOQYS` 4`SS

A>@7<B <3E 0ZOQY0S``g B]c` '$!

■

'' '' eWbV Q]\b`OQb

/^^ZS W:WTS ¸ ' %' RW`SQb ;:0 '( BVS AV]e #' '' ZWab

B ;=07:3

AO[ac\U ;S[]W` A56 b' '

6cZc 2SaYb]^ 4`SS

'' RW`SQb

A31C@7BG

D3@7H=< E7@3:3AA

@7; 0ZOQY0S``g B]c` '$! $' '' RW`SQb

>/AAE=@2 >@=B31B7=<

:Oab>Oaa # 4`SS /<B7;/:E/@3

C<:=1932

>`Sdf ! ' '# RW`SQb ^S` gSO`

<]YWO <& $ ' RW`SQb

/<B7D7@CA

63/2A3BA /ZW^V <Se 8OeP]\S ' '' ZWab

ESP`]]b /\bWDW`ca eWbV /\bWA^geO`S $ !' '# RW`SQb

>ZO\b`]\WQa D]gOUS` >`]

AC7B3

<]`b]\ 7\bS`\Sb ASQc`Wbg ' $' '' gSO`Zg

'' '' ZWab

63/2>6=<3A

$ ab`SSb

:]UWbSQV >c`S 4W 2`SO[

AbO\hO 4`SS >V]b]US\S '' RW`SQb

D723= 327B7<5 A=4BE/@3

' '# RW`SQb

/W` AVO`W\U $ '' RW`SQb

<]`b]\ !$ dS`aW]\ !

<3E 9ZW^aQV 7[OUS A"W

$' '' gSO`Zg

■

'' '' RW`SQb

<Sb <O\\g $ !' '' gSO`Zg

!5 <3BE=@9 /2/>B3@A A>@7<B

AWS``O EW`SZSaa #'&C "' '' ZWab =44713 >@=2C1B7D7BG

0/19C> A=A =\ZW\S 0OQYc^ PSbO ' '# RW`SQb

2`]^P]f

/R]PS /Q`]POb ' >`] ""' RW`SQb

50 T`SS) # 50 ' '# []\bVZg

?cWQY0OaS # RW`SQb ^S` []\bV

47</<17/:

AYg^S " 4`SS 7^aeWbQV 7[OWZ AS`dS` >`S[Wc[ d # ZWQS\aSa '# RW`SQb <3E 1Wb`Wf 5]B]/aaWab 3f^`Saa

■

?cWQY0]]Ya 3\bS`^`WaS A]ZcbW]\a ' ! RW`SQb ?cWQYS\ 6][S 0caW\Saa ' %' '' RW`SQb

$' RW`SQb ^S` []\bV

;W\b Q][ EW\bS` ' 4`SS

/R]PS 7ZZcab`Ob]` 1A"

;WQ`]a]Tb =T¿QS /QQ]c\bW\U 3f^`Saa ' 4`SS

#'' RW`SQb

=1B=03@ ' >1 ;/5/H7<3 2757B/: 327B7=< &!