Second horse crisis report final smaller

! !

!

)*+,&-.&,/*&0*12*! ! ! ! ! !

,#!-.*!%/"0!12!'!

!

!"#$%&'#($($! "#!$#%&'#(!'#(!)'&*+&

& ! !

!

! !

&

,#-/1(45-"1#! ,#!65-17*/!3893!-.*!:';1/! *<4"#*!/*+54*!'#(!/*.1:"#%!

1/%'#"+'-"1#+!"#!$#%&'#(!'#(! )'&*+!/*&*'+*(!'!/*01/-! +.1="#%!-.*!"::*#+*!0/*++4/*!

-.*>!'/*!4#(*/!(4*!-1!-.*! "#5/*'+"#%!#4:7*/!12!.1/+*+! '#(!01#"*+!#**("#%!-.*"/!.*&0?! @.*!1/%'#"+'-"1#+!='/#*(!

-.'-A!+.14&(!-.*/*!7*!'#1-.*/! .'/+.!="#-*/A!-.*>!="&&!7*!

0.>+"5'&&>!4#'7&*!-1!510*!="-.!-.*!*+-":'-*(!BA888!! .1/+*+!-.'-!=*/*!'-!-.'-!01"#-!(*2"#*(!'+!7*"#%!'-!/"+C?!! @."+!/*01/-!(*-'"&+!'#(!40('-*+!-.*!5.'&&*#%*+!-.'-!-.*+*!1/%'#"+'-"1#+!2'5*A!+.1="#%!-.'-!-.*>!'/*!"#D*+-"%'-"#%! :1/*!=*&2'/*!51#5*/#+!'#(!-'C"#%!"#!:1/*!.1/+*+!-.'#!*D*/!7*21/*?!,#!'(("-"1#A!-.*!#4:7*/!12!.1/+*+!"#!$#%&'#(!! '#(!)'&*+!-.'-!'/*!'-!/"+C!.'+!"#5/*'+*(!-1!'&:1+-!EA888?!!

,!%&;%<9:#%&'!:#(6(%$&;:56&6"&=:>%&(6&'<%:#?&5";?&6!:6&6!%@&':55"6&$"<A%&6!($&8#"B<%=&:<"5%&:5C&5%%C&& 6!%&$D88"#6&"9&6!%&!"#$%E";5(57&8DB<('?&7"A%#5=%56&:7%5'(%$&:5C&<"':<&:D6!"#(6(%$&6"&!:5C<%&;!:6&& !:$& Ǯ ǯ F& F*51::*#('-"1#+!21/!'5-"1#+!-1!.*&0!:"-"%'-*!-."+!5/"+"+!'/*!14-&"#*(!"#!-."+!/*01/-?! &

G-.,*.,H& I!:6&($&6!%&8#"B<%=J&

& K&

L8$D#7%&(5&;%<9:#%&'"5'%#5$& M& L8$D#7%&(5&8#"$%'D6("5$&

M&

/"#$%&'!:#(6(%$&!:A%&& <(=(6%C&$'"8%&6"&:'6&

N&

H"<D6("5$&

O&

! !

!

3!! !

)*+,&-.&,/*&0*12*3&45&6!%&7#(8&"9&:&!"#$%&'#($($!"#!$#%&'#(!'#(!)'&*+!

!

I!:6&($&6!%&8#"B<%=J& !

@.*!#4:7*/!12!.1/+*+!-.'-!*<4"#*!5.'/"-"*+!'/*!5'/"#%!21/!'#(!-.*!#4:7*/!12!=*&2'/*!5'+*+!"#D*+-"%'-*(! ! .'D*!"#5/*'+*(!+"%#"2"5'#-&>!1D*/!-.*!0'+-!2"D*!>*'/+!'#(!51#-"#4*+!-1!"#5/*'+*!"#-1!389G?!)1/&(!O1/+*! )*&2'/*!.'+!+**#!'!WG!0*/5*#-!/"+*!"#!-.*!#4:7*/!12!.1/+*+!"-!.'+!-'C*#!"#-1!"-+!5*#-/*+!+"#5*!388BX!2/1:!!

93N!"#!388B!/"+"#%!-1!9YM!"#!3893?!,#!-.*!2"/+-!<4'/-*/!12!389G!-.*!1/%'#"+'-"1#!-11C!"#!W8!0*/5*#-!:1/*!.1/+*+!

-.'#!"#!-.*!*<4"D'&*#-!0*/"1(!-.*!0/*D"14+!>*'/?!,#!3893!U&4*!K/1++!'(:"--*(!9ME!.1/+*+!'#(!-.*!FIJKL! '(:"--*(!EB8!.1/+*+A!-.*!."%.*+-!#4:7*/!"#!'#>!>*'/!-1!('-*?!Z*+0"-*!10*/'-"#%!5&1+*!-1!5'0'5"->!="-.!9G88! .1/+*+!"#!"-+!5'/*A!F*(="#%+!O1/+*!I'#5-4'/>!-11C!"#!9B9!.1/+*+!"#!3893!'#(!.'+!'&/*'(>!'(:"--*(!:1/*!

-.'#!988!+"#5*!-.*!+-'/-!12!389G?!! !

-A%#B#%%C(57& @.*!0104&'-"1#!12!.1/+*+!"#!-.*!RS!"+!4#C#1=#!74-!"+! *+-":'-*(!-1!7*!;4+-!2*=*/!-.'#!1#*!:"&&"1#?!@.*!D'+-! :';1/"->!12!-.*+*!'/*!1=#*(!0/"D'-*&>!21/!&*"+4/*!

T'551/("#%!-1!-.*!U/"-"+.!$<4"#*!@/'(*!L++15"'-"1#!I4/D*>!

3899VA!74-!-."+!"+!-.*!:1+-!4#/*%4&'-*(!12!-.*!.1/+*! +*5-1/+A!4#&"C*!-.1+*!7/*(A!21/!"#+-'#5*A!21/!.1/+*!/'5"#%?!!

H1+-!12!-.*!.1/+*+!/*+54*(!7>!*<4"#*!5.'/"-"*+!'/*!-.1+*! +422*/"#%!2/1:!=*&2'/*!0/17&*:+A!'#(!-.*!#4:7*/!12! =*&2'/*!5'+*+!.'+!"#5/*'+*(?!@.*!FIJKL!/*01/-!'#!"#5/*'+*!

12!99E!0*/5*#-!"#!-.*!#4:7*/!12!51#D"5-"1#+!21/!.1/+*+!"#!

3893!51:0'/*(!-1!-.*!0/*D"14+!93!:1#-.+A!'#(!"#!-.*!2"/+-! <4'/-*/!12!389G!"#D*+-"%'-*(!1D*/!EA888!51:0&'"#-+! "#D1&D"#%!.1/+*+!51:0'/*(!-1!3MAN88!21/!-.*!=.1&*!12!

3893?!)1/&(!O1/+*!)*&2'/*!"#D*+-"%'-*(!33!0*/5*#-!:1/*! =*&2'/*!51:0&'"#-+!"#!-.*!2"/+-!<4'/-*/!12!389G!51:0'/*(!!

-1!3893?!@."+!40='/(!-/*#(!"+!'&+1!'00'/*#-!21/!(1%+!'#(!

5'-+!74-!"+!:1/*!*P-/*:*!21/!.1/+*+?!@=1!":01/-'#-!

2'5-1/+!+**:!-1!7*!'-!0&'>?!

,//*+01#+"7&*!(*'&*/+!'/*!'-!-.*!.*'/-!12!-.*!0/17&*:+!! "#!-.*!*<4"#*!:'/C*-?!@.*>!'/*!+-"&&!74>"#%A!7/**("#%!! '#(!":01/-"#%!.1/+*+!74-!'+!-.*!:'/C*-!.'+!7*51:*! +'-4/'-*(!-.*!:'/C*-!0/"5*+!21/!.1/+*+!'#(!01#"*+!.'D*!

5/'+.*(?!L#":'&+!5'#!#1=!7*!214#(!'-!+'&*+!21/!QM!'#(!! +-"&&!/*:'"#!4#+1&(?!

!

*G-.-P4GH!Ȃ!@.*!51#-"#4*(!011/!*51#1:"5!5&":'-*! .'+!:*'#-!-.'-!.1/+*+A!=."5.!5'#!51+-!40!-1!Q988!0*/! =**C!-1!&11C!'2-*/A!'/*!+422*/"#%!'+!0*10&*!54-!7'5C!!

1#!D*-*/"#'/>!51+-+A!/14-"#*!5'/*A!+.*&-*/!'#(!2**(?!!

-0*1Q1**R4.2&Ȃ&(*+0"-*&-.*!%&11:>!*51#1:"5!

0"5-4/*A!.1/+*+!51#-"#4*!-1!7*!7/*(!'+!+1:*!(*'&*/+! '#(!+1:*!.1/+*!1=#*/+!7*&"*D*!-.'-!-.*>!5'#!+-"&&!:'C*! '!0/12"-!2/1:!7/**("#%!.1/+*+?!,#!/*'&"->A!0/"5*+!21/! .1/+*+!.'D*!(/100*(!+"%#"2"5'#-&>!'#(!'!01#>!5'#!7*!

714%.-!21/!QM!'-!+1:*!:'/C*-+?!H*'#=."&*!.1/+*!

1=#*/+!'/*!.'D"#%!("22"54&->!/*.1:"#%!-.*"/!4#='#-*(! .1/+*+!'#(A!"#5/*'+"#%&>A!5'##1-!*D*#!%"D*!-.*:!'='>?!

! )*+,&-.&,/*&0*12*3&45&6!%&7#(8&"9&:&!"#$%&'#($($!"#!$#%&'#(!'#(!)'&*+! !

!G!

! & ! !

6#*!&"C*&>!/*+4&-!"+!'#!'00'/*#-!"#5/*'+*!"#!-.*!#4:7*/!12! .1/+*+!7*"#%!"&&*%'&&>!2&>!%/'[*(!1#!047&"5!'#(!0/"D'-*!&'#(?!

6#*!(*'&*/!'&1#*!"+!*+-":'-*(!-1!.'D*!3A888\GA888!.1/+*+!

2&>!%/'["#%!'5/1++!D'/"14+!&15'-"1#+!"#!)'&*+?!@.*!0/'5-"5*!

12!&*'D"#%!.1/+*+!-1!%/'[*!1#!047&"5!1/!0/"D'-*!&'#(!="-.14-!

0*/:"++"1#!.'+!&1#%!7**#!51::1#!'5/1++!$#%&'#(!'#(! )'&*+A!0'/-"54&'/&>!':1#%!-.*!-/'D*&&"#%!51::4#"->!T74-!

7>!#1!:*'#+!/*+-/"5-*(!-1!-.*:V?!@."+!.'+!5'4+*(!&"--&*!

51#5*/#!1#!'!#'-"1#'&!+5'&*!40!4#-"&!#1=!74-!="-."#!-.*!

0'+-!-=1!>*'/+!:1/*!"#5"(*#-+!12!2&>!%/'["#%!.'D*!7**#! /*01/-*(!'5/1++!'&&!'/*'+!12!U/"-'"#?!,#5/*'+"#%&>A!2&>! %/'["#%!.'+!7*51:*!'!+"%#"2"5'#-!0/17&*:!21/!&'#(1=#*/+A! 2'/:*/+!'#(!&15'&!'4-.1/"-"*+!'#(!"#!+1:*!5'+*+!01+"#%! /"+C+!-1!-.*!047&"5?!,-!"+!'&+1!&*'("#%!-1!"#5/*'+"#%!=*&2'/*!

0/17&*:+!'+!-.*!'#":'&+!'/*!&*2-!-1!2*#(!21/!-.*:+*&D*+?!!

L+!-.*+*!.1/+*+!'/*!C*0-!51::4#'&&>!'#":'&+!51#-"#4*!!

-1!7/**(!(*+0"-*!-.*/*!7*"#%!#1!:'/C*-!21/!-.*:?!! @."+A!"#!-4/#A!04-+!0/*++4/*!1#!-.*!&15'&!'4-.1/"->!=.1!! :'>!.'D*!#1!5.1"5*!74-!-1!*4-.'#'+*!5*/-'"#!%/140+!!

12!.1/+*+!+.14&(!5.'/"-"*+!7*!4#'7&*!-1!-'C*!-.*:!"#?! ,//*+01#+"7&*!(*'&*/+!'/*!'&+1!":01/-"#%!'#(!*P01/-"#%! .1/+*+!2/1:!]/'#5*!'#(!,/*&'#(!4#(*/!-.*!@/"0'/-"-*!

L%/**:*#-A!=."5.!'&&1=+!2/**!:1D*:*#-!12!.1/+*+! ="-.14-!.*'&-.!5*/-"2"5'-"1#!7*-=**#!-.*+*!514#-/"*+?!

O1=*D*/A!'+!+'&*+!1#!-.*!51#-"#*#-!.'D*!7**#!(*0/*++*(A! (*'&*/+!'/*!&*2-!="-.!:1/*!.1/+*+!7*"#%!+400&"*(!-.'#!!

-.*/*!"+!(*:'#(?!!

O1/+*+!'/*!'&+1!7*"#%!7/*(!7>!0*10&*!=.1!7/**(!+:'&&! #4:7*/+!12!(1:*+-"5!.1/+*+!21/!+'&*!1/!21/!-.*"/!1=#!4+*?! @."+!"#5/*'+*+!71-.!-.*!+400&>!12!.1/+*+!'#(!-.*!&"C*&".11(!

-.'-!1-.*/!.1/+*+!="&&!7*51:*!=*&2'/*!51#5*/#+?!,#! '(("-"1#A!-.*!21'&+!-.*>!0/1(45*!5'#A!"#!+1:*!5'+*+A!7*!

2/1:!011/!+-15C!'#(!-.*/*21/*!.'D*!&"--&*!4+*!1/!+'&*!D'&4*?!

6D*/!-":*!-.*+*!5'#!7*51:*!=*&2'/*!51#5*/#+!"2!-.*"/!

1=#*/+!-/>!-1!+*&&!-.*:!1/!2"#(!-.*:!#*=!.1:*+?!! @.*/*!'/*!'&+1!1=#*/+!=.1!&*-!-.*"/!.1/+*+!7/**(! "#("+5/":"#'-*&>!-.*#!7*51:*!1D*/=.*&:*(!="-.!-.*! #4:7*/+!0/1(45*(A!/*+4&-"#%!"#!=*&2'/*!0/17&*:+?!I1:*!!

12!-.*+*!5'+*+!5'#!"#D1&D*!'/14#(!988!.1/+*+?!

I1!=.*/*!(1!-.*+*!.1/+*+!%1^!I1:*!%1!"#-1!-.*!:*'-!

-/'(*!'#(!'+!-.*!.1/+*:*'-!+5'#('&!12!389G!4#(*/&"#*(A! +1:*!.1/+*+!1#!2/'4(4&*#-!0'++01/-+!=*/*!%1"#%!-1!

'7'--1"/+?!@.*/*!=*/*!2"D*!-1!+*D*#!'7'--1"/+!10*/'-"#%!"#!

-.*!RSA!0'>"#%!'/14#(!Q3G8!21/!'!.1/+*!1/!'/14#(!QY8!21/!! '!01#>!-1!(*'&*/+!21/!:*'-A!=."5.!='+A!'#(!+-"&&!"+A! *P01/-*(!-1!@.*!_*-.*/&'#(+A!U*&%"4:A!]/'#5*!'#(!,-'&>?! @.*!#4:7*/!12!.1/+*+!+*#-!-1!+&'4%.-*/!"#!-.*!RS!21/!.4:'#!

51#+4:0-"1#!.'+!'&:1+-!(147&*(!+"#5*!388Y?!@.*!&'5C!12!

51#-/1&!1#!-."+!74+"#*++!514&(!.'D*!0&'>*(!'!/1&*!"#!(/"D"#%!

40!-.*!"#5*#-"D*!21/!(*'&*/+!-1!7/**(!'#(!-/'(*!"#!.1/+*+?! @.*!/*5*#-!5&1+4/*!12!-=1!12!-.*!'7'--1"/+!:'>!'&+1!7*! /*+4&-"#%!"#!'#!"#5/*'+*!"#!.1/+*+!7*"#%!2&>!%/'[*(!'#(!

'7'#(1#*(?!,#D'/"'7&>A!-.1+*!="-.!=*&2'/*!0/17&*:+!! *#(!40!="-.!*<4"#*!5.'/"-"*+?!!

!

!

!

W!

!

)*+,&-.&,/*&0*12*3&45&6!%&7#(8&"9&:&!"#$%&'#($($!"#!$#%&'#(!'#(!)'&*+!

!

L8$D#7%&(5& ;%<9:#%&'"5'%#5$& & !

L&&!-.*!:';1/!! ! !1/%'#"+'-"1#+!!

&&!

!

.'D*!+**#!'#!! "#5/*'+*!"#!! .1/+*+!7*"#%!! '(:"--*(A!!

-.*!:';1/"->!!

12!=."5.!'/*!! /*&'-*(!-1!=*&2'/*!51:0&'"#-+?!@.*!/"+"#%!51+-+!!

12!211(A!D*-*/"#'/>!5'/*!'#(!+-'7&"#%A!'#(!-.*!011/! =*'-.*/!T*+0*5"'&&>!1D*/!-.*!0'+-!="#-*/V!0/17'7&>!

'5514#-!21/!+1:*!12!-.*!*P-/'!5'&&+!2/1:!-.*!047&"5! /*01/-"#%!=*&2'/*!51#5*/#+?!! ,!%&Q#(6($!&/"#$%&H"'(%6@!.'+!+**#!'!M8!0*/5*#-!"#5/*'+*! "#!=*&2'/*!51#5*/#+!/*01/-*(!-1!"-!"#!-.*!&'+-!+"P!:1#-.+?! !1%C;(57$!.'+!+**#!'#!"#5/*'+*!"#!'7'#(1#*(!.1/+*+!!

7*"#%!/*01/-*(!-1!-.*"/!=*&2'/*!-*':!2/1:!9B8!"#!388N!!

-1!'#!'+-1#"+."#%!EBY!"#!3893?!U>!-.*!*#(!12!L0/"&!389G!!

-."+!2"%4/*!.'(!'&/*'(>!/*'5.*(!WWE?!

L8$D#7%&(5& 8#"$%'D6("5$! @."+!"#5/*'+*!"#!=*&2'/*!0/17&*:+!.'+!"#*D"-'7&>! &*(!-1!'#!"#5/*'+*!"#!-.*!#4:7*/+!12!5'+*+!! '#(!0/1+*54-"1#+?!!

6D*/!-.*!0'+-!-./**!>*'/+!-.*/*!.'+!7**#!'!9GW!0*/5*#-! "#5/*'+*!"#!-.*!#4:7*/+!12!5.'/%*+!7/14%.-!4#(*/!-.*!

L#":'&!)*&2'/*!L5-!7>!-.*!FIJKL!"#D1&D"#%!.1/+*+!'#(!'#! "#5/*'+*!12!YE!0*/5*#-!"#!-.*!#4:7*/!12!.1/+*+!/*+54*(!

T]"%4/*!9V?!J/1+*54-"1#+!4#(*/-'C*#!21/!.1/+*+!'/*!#1=!-.*!

-."/(!:1+-!51::1#!->0*+!12!5'+*+!'2-*/!-.1+*!51#5*/#"#%!

5'-+!'#(!(1%+?!H'#>!12!-.*+*!5'+*+!'/*!:4&-"0&*!5'+*+! =.*/*!-.*!1=#*/+!.'D*!7**#!-/>"#%!-1!7/**(!.1/+*+?!! )1/&(!O1/+*!)*&2'/*!.'+!+**#!'!%/*'-*/!-.'#!-./**\21&(! /"+*!"#!-.*!#4:7*/!12!0/1+*54-"1#+!"#!=."5.!-.*>!.'D*! '++"+-*(!+"#5*!388B?!62!-.*!YM!.1/+*+!-'C*#!"#-1!-.*"/!!

5'/*!"#!-.*!2"/+-!-./**!:1#-.+!12!389GA!-."/->\*"%.-!'/*!

0/1+*54-"1#!5'+*+?!@."+!"+!'&:1+-!.'&2!-.*!.1/+*+!'#(!"+!!

40!2/1:!G9!"#!3899?!!

K'/"#%!21/!.1/+*+!-.'-!'/*!-.*!+47;*5-!12!0/1+*54-"1#!5'#!

7*!D*/>!/*+14/5*\"#-*#+"D*!21/!=*&2'/*!5.'/"-"*+?!R#&*++!'#!

1=#*/!=.1!"+!7*"#%!0/1+*54-*(!+"%#+!1D*/!-.*!.1/+*+!-1!

-.*!5.'/"->!D1&4#-'/"&>A!-.*!.1/+*!"+!#1-!-.*!0/10*/->!12!-.*!

5.'/"->!'#(!+1!5'##1-!7*!%*&(*(!1/!/*.'7"&"-'-*(!4#-"&!-.*!

5'+*!"+!;4(%*(!'#(!-.*!.1/+*!21/:'&&>!+"%#*(!1D*/!7>!-.*!

514/-?!@."+!:*'#+!-.'-!0/1+*54-"1#!.1/+*+!5'#!+0*#(!:'#>! :1#-.+!&1#%*/!"#!5*#-/*+!-.'#!1-.*/!.1/+*+A!&*'D"#%!&*++! +0'5*!21/!#*=!'(:"++"1#+?!

@.*!1HSGT!.'+!+**#!'#!"#5/*'+*!"#!51:0&'"#-+!'714-! *<4"#*+!2/1:!;4+-!1D*/!9AM88!"#!388B!-1!3MANE3!"#!3893?!! ,#!-.*!2"/+-!<4'/-*/!12!389G!-.*!1/%'#"+'-"1#!"#D*+-"%'-*(!

EA9W8!51:0&'"#-+!/*&'-"#%!-1!.1/+*+?!!

I"#<C&/"#$%&I%<9:#%!.'+!+**#!=*&2'/*!"#D*+-"%'-"1#+!! /"+*!+-*'("&>!2/1:!388B?!,#!-.*!2"/+-!-./**!:1#-.+!12!389G! -.*"/!122"5*/+!"#D*+-"%'-*(!MEE!51:0&'"#-+A!'!33!0*/5*#-! "#5/*'+*!51:0'/*(!-1!-.*!+':*!0*/"1(!"#!3893?!@.*!!

5.'/"->!-11C!"#!:1/*!:4&-"0&*!.1/+*!5'+*+!'#(!.'+!-'C*#!! "#!W8!0*/5*#-!:1/*!.1/+*+!"#!-.*!2"/+-!<4'/-*/!-.'#!"#!-.*! +':*!0*/"1(!"#!3893?!

@.*!51+-+!12!0/1+*54-"#%!.1/+*!5'+*+!'/*!'&+1!/"+"#%A! 0'/-"54&'/&>!21/!:4&-"0&*!.1/+*!5'+*+A!=.*/*!51+-+!5'#!7*!!

40!-1!QM88!0*/!('>?!@."+!.'+!0&'5*(!'!.4%*!74/(*#!1#!

1/%'#"+'-"1#+!'#(!'%*#5"*+?!H'#>!&15'&!'4-.1/"-"*+!#1=!!

(1!#1-!.'D*!-.*!2"#'#5"'&!/*+14/5*+!-1!-'C*!0/1+*54-"1#+!!

1/!+-10!:"(='>!-./14%.!5'+*+!'+!51+-+!.'D*!7*51:*!

0/1."7"-"D*?!O1/+*+!'/*!#1-!(*+"%#'-*(!'+!1#*!12!-.*!

0/"1/"->!'#":'&+!21/!&15'&!'4-.1/"-"*+!Ȃ!-."+!+.14&(!5.'#%*?!

Q<D%&G#"$$!/*01/-*(!-.'-A!"#!-.*!+*51#(!.'&2!12!3893A!!

G8!0*/5*#-!12!.1/+*+!(*'&-!="-.!7>!-.*"/!5*#-/*+!=*/*! '(:"--*(!21/!=*&2'/*!/*'+1#+A!51:0'/*(!-1!39!0*/5*#-!! "#!-.*!2"/+-!.'&2?!,#!-.*!2"/+-!-./**!:1#-.+!12!389G!-."+!.'(! "#5/*'+*(!'%'"#!-1!GE!0*/5*#-?!! !

U:5D:#@&6"&P:#'!&VWXK&A$&$:=%&8%#("C&VWXV&

!

!

!

)*&2'/*!51:0&'"#-+!

LS&MWY&

!

K'&&+!1#!'7'#(1#*(!.1/+*+!

LS&OMY&

!

!

)*&2'/*!"#D*+-"%'-"1#+!

LS&XWY&

!

!

O1/+*+!'(:"--*(!-1!5*#-/*+!

LS&ZWY&

!

!

O1/+*+!-'C*#!"#!(4*!-1! =*&2'/*!51#5*/#+!

LS&XNY&

!

!

+(7D#%&X3&.D=B%#&"9&':$%$&:5C&#%$'D%$&D5C%#6:>%5&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&B@&6!%&1HSGT&9"#&!"#$%$&VWWMEVWXV&

!

!

! )*+,&-.&,/*&0*12*3&45&6!%&7#(8&"9&:&!"#$%&'#($($!"#!$#%&'#(!'#(!)'&*+! !

!M!

!

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

W8!='"-"#%!-1!51:*!"#!"-+!5*#-/*+!'/*!24&&?!@.*!FIJKL!.'+!

1D*/!B88!.1/+*+!"#!"-+!5'/*A!12!=."5.!Y8!0*/5*#-!'/*!"#!

0/"D'-*!71'/("#%?!O1/+*)1/&(!.'+!'!5'0'5"->!12!93M!*<4"#*+A! '&-.14%.!'#!'D*/'%*!12!93N!.1/+*+!=*/*!1#!+"-*!1D*/!-.*!

0'+-!93!:1#-.+?!U&4*!K/1++!'#(!F*(="#%+!'/*!5&1+*!-1!

5'0'5"->?!F*(="#%+!5'/*+!21/!:1/*!-.'#!9AG88!.1/+*+!'#(!

01#"*+!'-!"-+!+'#5-4'/>!+"-*+!'#(!.'+!'&/*'(>!*P-*#(*(!"-+!

5'0'5"->!7>!9M8!.1/+*+!"#!-.*!0'+-!>*'/!-1!-/>!-1!:**-! (*:'#(A!"#5&4("#%!10*#"#%!'!#*=!5*#-/*!"#!#1/-.!_1/21&C?! !

J/"1/"->!.'+!7**#!%"D*#!-1!-.*!:1+-!+*D*/*!=*&2'/*!5'+*+?!

H'#>!.1/+*+!'/*!#1=!C*0-!"#!0/"D'-*!71'/("#%A!=."5.!"+!

"-+*&2!'!0/17&*:!'+!"#5/*'+"#%!51+-+!'/*!4#+4+-'"#'7&*A! =."&*!+1:*!.1/+*+!'/*!("/*5-*(!-1!1-.*/!*<4"#*!5.'/"-"*+!!

1/!'/*!C*0-!!"#$!%&!=."&*!2"*&(!+-'22!=1/C!="-.!-.*"/!1=#*/+!

-1!":0/1D*!51#("-"1#+?! ǯ !-1!/*.1:*!.1/+*+!"+!'&+1!51:"#%!4#(*/!

0/*++4/*!"#!389G!"#!51#-/'+-!="-.!'!/"+*!"#!/*.1:"#%!1D*/!

-.*!0'+-!-=1!>*'/+?!)1/&(!O1/+*!)*&2'/*!.'+!+**#!G3!

0*/5*#-!2*=*/!.1/+*+!/*.1:*(!"#!-.*!2"/+-!<4'/-*/!12!389G! -.'#!"#!-.*!+':*!0*/"1(!"#!3893?!F*(="#%+!.'D*!"#5/*'+*(!

-.*!#4:7*/+!-.*>!/*.1:*(!2/1:!WB!"#!388B!-1!98N!"#!3899! '#(!U&4*!K/1++!&1'#*(!14-!9W8!.1/+*+!"#!3893?!@.*!FIJKL! "#5/*'+*(!-.*!#4:7*/+!12!.1/+*+!"-!/*.1:*(!"#!3893!-1!G8M! 51:0'/*(!="-.!3W8!"#!3899!T=."5.!"#!"-+*&2!='+!(147&*!-.*! #4:7*/!/*.1:*(!"#!3898V?!$D*#!-."+!514&(!#1-!0/*D*#-!-.*! #4:7*/+!12!.1/+*+!"-!='+!5'/"#%!21/!51#-"#4"#%!'-!1D*/!B88?! @."+!'00/1'5.!"+!#1-!+4+-'"#'7&*!21/!-.*!24-4/*?!$P"+-"#%! /*+14/5*+!'/*!+-/'"#*(?!@.*!#4:7*/!12!0&'5*+!'D'"&'7&*!

'5/1++!*<4"#*!1/%'#"+'-"1#+!.'+!7**#!/*(45"#%!+-*'("&>!

1D*/!-.*!0'+-!-./**!>*'/+?!@.*!_'-"1#'&!$<4"#*!)*&2'/*!

K14#5"&A!=."5.!.'+!1D*/!W8!:*:7*/+A!*+-":'-*+!-.'-!-.*!

-1-'&!#4:7*/!12!0&'5*+!'D'"&'7&*!"#!-.*+*!1/%'#"+'-"1#+!"+!

3AY88!74-!&*++!-.'#!G!0*/5*#-!12!-.*+*!0&'5*+!'/*!2/**!21/!!

I1:*!5.'/"-"*+!.'D*!:1/*!&'#(!74-!#1-!+422"5"*#-!/*+14/5*+!

-1!2**(!'#(!5'/*!21/!'#>!+"%#"2"5'#-!"#5/*'+*!"#!.1/+*! #4:7*/+!0/10*/&>?!Z*+0"-*!*#514/'%"#%!-/*#(+!"#! /*.1:"#%A!-."+!'&1#*!="&&!#1-!5/*'-*!*#14%.!+0'5*!"#!14/!

5*#-/*+!-1!-'C*!"#!'&&!-.*!.1/+*+!-.'-!:'>!#**(!.*&0?!

/";&=:5@&!"#$%$&:#%&:6&#($>J& ,-!"+!*+-":'-*(!-.'-!'&:1+-!EA888!.1/+*+!'/*!'-!/"+C!"#!

U/"-'"#A!:*'#"#%!-.'-!-.*>!'/*!7*"#%!"//*+01#+"7&>!2&>! %/'[*(!1/!-.*"/!=*&2'/*!"+!'-!/"+C!7*5'4+*!-.*"/!1=#*/+!

5'##1-!1/!="&&!#1-!%"D*!-.*:!-.*!5'/*!-.*>!#**(?!@.*! &'/%*+-!#4:7*/A!'#!*+-":'-*(!GA888A!'/*!"#!)'&*+!'#(!-.*! +4//14#("#%!'/*'!74-!-.*!*<4"#*!1/%'#"+'-"1#+!.'D*! #1-"5*(!-.'-!:'#>!.1/+*+!'/*!7*"#%!-/'#+2*//*(!2/1:!

514#->!-1!514#->!(*0*#("#%!1#!*#21/5*:*#-!'5-"1#?!,#! '(("-"1#!-.*!#4:7*/+!12!.1/+*+!"#!I51-&'#(!-.'-!'/*!'-!/"+C! .'+!-/*7&*(!"#!-.*!0'+-!>*'/!-1!G88?!! `15'&!'4-.1/"-"*+!'/*!'&+1!+-/4%%&"#%!-1!510*!="-.!-.*+*! #4:7*/+!12!.1/+*+A!:'#>!12!=."5.!'/*!#1-!&*%'&&>! "(*#-"2"*(?!H'#>!'4-.1/"-"*+!(1!#1-!.'D*!-.*!74(%*-!1/!-.*! +"-*+!-1!51#2"+5'-*!.1/+*+!'#(!4#(*/!-.*!:'"#!&*%"+&'-"1#!

4+*(A!-.*!L#":'&+!L5-!9NE9A!'/*!51:0*&&*(!-1!04-!-.*! .1/+*+!-1!'45-"1#A!21/!=."5.!-.*>!.'D*!-1!7*!0'++01/-*(! '#(!:"5/15."00*(?!62-*#!-.*>!'/*!-.*#!714%.-!7'5C!7>!

-.*"/!0/*D"14+!1=#*/+!-1!7*!2&>!%/'[*(!1#5*!'%'"#?!

! )*+,&-.&,/*&0*12*3&45&6!%&7#(8&"9&:&!"#$%&'#($($!"#!$#%&'#(!'#(!)'&*+! !

!B!

!

I1&4-"1#+!

! ! ! !@.*!*<4"#*!5.'/"-"*+!7*&"*D*!-.'-!"-!="&&!-'C*!-":*!-1!/*D*/+*!-.*+*!-/*#(+?!@.*!+"-4'-"1#!"+!."%.&>!&"C*&>!-1!51#-"#4*! !=1/+*#"#%!?!L!.1&"+-"5!'00/1'5.!"+!#**(*(!-1!-'5C&*!-.*!/11-!5'4+*+!12!.1/+*!1D*/0104&'-"1#A!'#(!-1!5/*'-*!-.*! !

01&"-"5'&!="&&!-1!-'5C&*!+1:*!12!-.*!"++4*+?!@.*!5.'/"-"*+!7*&"*D*!-.*!21&&1="#%!+1&4-"1#+!'/*!#**(*(b!!

! "#$%&'($!)*+"!#%!,$%#(-#!-.#./(&"!*&0!1%$"("!

L:*#(!-.*!L#":'&+!L5-!9NE9!-1!'&&1=!&'#(!1=#*/+!'#(! &15'&!'4-.1/"-"*+!-.*!01=*/+!-1!("+01+*!12!2&>!%/'[*(!1/!

'7'#(1#*(!.1/+*+!1-.*/!-.'#!-./14%.!:'/C*-+!'#(!

'45-"1#+A!=.*/*!-.*>!'/*!-11!12-*#!+":0&>!714%.-!7'5C! 7>!-.*"/!1/"%"#'&!1=#*/+!21/!&*++!-.'#!"-!51+-!-1!:'C*!-.*! .1/+*!+'&*'7&*?!)'&*+!"+!54//*#-&>!4#(*/-'C"#%!'!

51#+4&-'-"1#!1#!='>+!-1!":0/1D*!&'=+!-1!'((/*++!2&>! %/'["#%!'#(!-."+A!"-!"+!.10*(A!="&&!'&&1=!&15'&!'4-.1/"-"*+! :1/*!2&*P"7"&"->!"#!(*'&"#%!="-.!-."+!0/17&*:!"#!-.*!24-4/*?&

R#-"&!-.*!L#":'&+!L5-!9NE9!"+!':*#(*(A!514#5"&+!! +.14&(!0/1D"(*!%4"('#5*!#1-*+!21/!&'#(1=#*/+!-1! *P0&'"#!=.'-!-.*>!5'#!(1!"2!.1/+*+!'/*!&*2-!1#!-.*"/!&'#(?! @."+!%4"('#5*!+.14&(!7*!="(*&>!'D'"&'7&*!'#(!+.14&(! +**C!-1!2'5"&"-'-*!/*+1&4-"1#!12!-.*+*!+"-4'-"1#+!'#(!! .*&0!/*(45*!-.*!#**(!-1!-'C*!51+-&>!&*%'&!'(D"5*?!

K/":"#'&!&*%"+&'-"1#!"+!#**(*(!-1!04#"+.!2&>!%/'[*/+!! '#(!'5-!'+!'!(*-*//*#-!-1!0/*D*#-!-.*:!2/1:!4+"#%!! &15'&!'4-.1/"-"*+!'+!'!.1/+*\("+01+'&!+*/D"5*?!

H'#('-1/>!:"5/15."00"#%!12!.1/+*+A!'#(!'!0/*+4:0-"1#!

1#!-.*!0'/-!12!-.*!&'=!-.'-!'!.1/+*!.'+!#1!1=#*/!4#&*++!

"-!"+!71-.!0'++01/-*(!'#(!:"5/15."00*(?!L4-.1/"-"*+A! 5.'/"-"*+!'#(!&'#(1=#*/+!+**C"#%!'#(!-/>"#%!-1!0/1D*! ǯ 5'#!='+-*!51#+"(*/'7&*!':14#-+!12!/*+14/5*+!-/>"#%!-1!

0/1D*!1=#*/+."0?!K4//*#-!&'=!+-'-*+!'&&!.1/+*+!+.14&(!

7*!0'++01/-*(A!'#(!-.1+*!71/#!'2-*/!388N! :"5/15."00*(!'+!=*&&A!74-!-.*+*!&'=+!'/*!#1-!*#21/5*(! '#(!-.*/*!'/*!#1!51#+*<4*#5*+!21/!#1#\51:0&"'#5*?! @."+!:4+-!5.'#%*!"2!'7'#(1#:*#-!'#(!2&>!%/'["#%!'/*!

-1!7*!'((/*++*(X!0&'5"#%!-.*!74/(*#!12!0/112!12!

1=#*/+."0!1#-1!-.*!.1/+*!1=#*/!=14&(!7*!'#!*22*5-"D*! ='>!-1!*#514/'%*!51:0&"'#5*!="-.!-.*!&'=?!

Z*2/'!-1!*P0*("-*!#*%1-"'-"1#+!="-.!,/*&'#(!'#(!]/'#5*!

-1!/*+-/"5-!-.*!@/"0'/-"-*!L%/**:*#-!=."5.!54//*#-&>! '&&1=+!2/**!:1D*:*#-!12!.1/+*+!7*-=**#!-.*!RS!'#(!

-.*+*!514#-/"*+A!5/*'-"#%!=*&2'/*!0/17&*:+A!2'5"&"-'-"#%!

5/":*!=.*/*!.1/+*+!'/*!4+*(!'+!51D*/!'#(!10*#"#%!-.*!

(11/!-1!*<4"#*!("+*'+*?!

.2,$%3(0!(&4%$-(2(&#!

H1/*!'++"+-'#5*!21/!&15'&!'4-.1/"-"*+A!0'/-"54&'/&>!="-.! /*+14/5*+A!-1!'&&1=!21/='/(!0&'##"#%!/*%'/("#%!

'7'#(1#:*#-!1/!2&>!%/'["#%!"#5"(*#-+?!@."+!+.14&(! "#5&4(*!-/'"#"#%!'#":'&!=*&2'/*!122"5*/+!"#!.1/+*! .'#(&"#%!'#(!"(*#-"2"5'-"1#!'#(!-.*!0/1D"+"1#!12!%/**#! >'/(+!1/!+":"&'/!+0'5*+!=.*/*!1=#*/+!5'#!C**0!.1/+*+!

0*#("#%!"#D*+-"%'-"1#!1/!5&'":+?! !

J/10*/!*#21/5*:*#-!12!-.*!0'++01/-!'#(!:"5/15."0! /*%4&'-"1#+A!="-.!2"#'#5"'&!+4001/-!21/!&15'&!'4-.1/"-"*+!

-1!4#(*/-'C*!-'/%*-*(!*#21/5*:*#-!12!+*/"'&!1/!'%%/*++"D*!

2&>!%/'["#%?!).*#!-.*!0'++01/-!/*%4&'-"1#+!=*/*!2"/+-! "#-/1(45*(!"#!388MA!*#21/5*:*#-!='+!%"D*#!'!&1=!0/"1/"->! '#(!-.*/*!'/*!&"--&*!"2!'#>!/*+14/5*+!-1!4#(*/-'C*!-."+! /*+01#+"7"&"->?!$#21/5*:*#-!:4+-!#1=!7*!51#+"(*/*(!'!

0/"1/"->!21/!-.*!0'++01/-!+>+-*:!-1!=1/C!'#(!21/!2&>! %/'[*/+!-1!7*!.*&(!'5514#-'7&*!21/!"//*+01#+"7&*!1=#*/+."0?!

R+*!7*+-!0/'5-"5*!1#!":0/1D"#%!511/("#'-"1#!7*-=**#!

-.*!*#21/5*:*#-!'%*#5"*+A!0'/-"54&'/&>!21/!:4&-"0&*\ .1/+*!5'+*+!"#D1&D"#%!(*'&*/+?!@/'("#%!+-'#('/(+A!-.*!

L#":'&!O*'&-.!'#(!c*-*/"#'/>!`'71/'-1/>!L%*#5"*+!

TLOc`LV!'#(!1-.*/!'%*#5"*+!+.14&(!=1/C!:1/*!5&1+*&>! ="-.!*'5.!1-.*/!'#(!="-.!=*&2'/*!5.'/"-"*+!-1!":0/1D*! *#21/5*:*#-!'#(!=*&2'/*?!@."+!"+!+-'/-"#%!-1!.'00*#A! 0'/-"54&'/&>!"#!)'&*+?!!

L!5*#-/'&!*<4"#*!('-'7'+*!-1!'"(!*#21/5*:*#-!12!

0'++01/-!/*%4&'-"1#+A!*#514/'%*!/*+01#+"7&*!1=#*/+."0! '#(!'++"+-!"#!0/*D*#-"#%!("+*'+*!+0/*'(?!Z*2/'!"+!54//*#-&>!

4#(*/-'C"#%!'!/*D"*=!12!-.*!0'++01/-!+>+-*:?!@.*! $4/10*'#!K1::"++"1#!.'+!/*51::*#(*(!'+!0'/-!12!"-+!

2"D*\0'/-!0&'#!-.*!*+-'7&"+.:*#-!12!'!5*#-/'&!('-'7'+*! '#(!'!/*(45-"1#!"#!-.*!#4:7*/!12!J'++01/-!,++4"#%!

6/%'#"+'-"1#+!T-.*!RS!54//*#-&>!.'+!EMdVA!=."5.!-.*! =*&2'/*!5.'/"-"*+!=14&(!+4001/-?!

(05-*#.%&!

I.'/"#%!7*+-!0/'5-"5*!1#!&"'"+1#!="-.!2/"#%*!%/140+!+45.! '+!-/'D*&&"#%!51::4#"-"*+!-1!+-*:!2&>!%/'["#%!'#(!

'7'#(1#:*#-+A!'#(!-1!*#514/'%*!/*+01#+"7&*!.1/+*!

1=#*/+."0?!)*&2'/*!5.'/"-"*+!'#(!&15'&!'4-.1/"-"*+!.'D*! :'#>!%11(!5'+*!+-4("*+!1#!=1/C"#%!="-.!-/'D*&&"#%!

51::4#"-"*+!-1!0/1:1-*!7*--*/!.1/+*!5'/*!"#5&4("#%! ("+514#-*(!0'++01/-!'#(!:"5/15."00"#%!'#(!%*&("#%!5&"#"5+?!

a4"('#5*!+.14&(!7*!0/1(45*(!%"D"#%!5&*'/A!+-/1#%&>\ =1/(*(!'(D"5*!1#!=.*#!#1-!-1!7/**(!2/1:!'!.1/+*!+45.! '+!"2!"-!.'+!011/!51#21/:'-"1#!1/!%*#*-"5!(*2*5-+?! a1D*/#:*#-!51::4#"5'-"1#+!5.'##*&+!+.14&(!7*!4+*(!

-1!("+514/'%*!:*:7*/+!12!-.*!047&"5!2/1:!7/**("#%! .1/+*+!-1!51:0&*:*#-!-.*!*(45'-"1#'&!"#"-"'-"D*+!12!-.*! =*&2'/*!5.'/"-"*+?!F'"+"#%!'='/*#*++!':1#%!2'/:*/+A! 7/**(*/+!'#(!(*'&*/+!12!-.*!+5'&*!12!-.*!0/17&*:!'#(!

-.*!&'5C!12!2"#'#5"'&!/*='/(!21/!7/**("#%!"#!-."+!:'/C*-!

514&(!.*&0!+-*:!-.*!0/1(45-"1#!12!.1/+*+?!!

H'C*!+4/*!-.*!.1/+*!1=#"#%!047&"5!+.14&(!/*51%#"+*!

-."+!5/"+"+!Ȃ-.*>!5'#!0&'>!'#!":01/-'#-!0'/-!"#! '&&*D"'-"#%!-."+!5/"+"+!7>!/*.1:"#%!.1/+*+!'#(!01#"*+!

2/1:!5.'/"-"*+!'#(!#1-!7/**("#%!2/1:!-.*"/!1=#!.1/+*+?!

!

! )*+,&-.&,/*&0*12*3&45&6!%&7#(8&"9&:&!"#$%&'#($($!"#!$#%&'#(!'#(!)'&*+! ,/*&*[L4.*&G14H4H!,_!$_a`L_Z!L_Z!)L`$I! !!

!E!

! !

@.*!=*&2'/*!5.'/"-"*+!C#1=!-.'-!-.*/*!"+!#1!+0'/*!5'0'5"->!"#!-.*"/!'7"&"->!-1!510*!="-.!-.*!+5'&*!12!!

-.*!0/*+*#-!0/17&*:+?!)."&+-!-.*>!'/*!=1/C"#%!-1%*-.*/!-1!+.'/*!"#-*&&"%*#5*!"#!-.*!:'/C*-+!'#(!-/'(*! '#(!":0/1D*!21+-*/"#%!'#(!/*.1:"#%A!-.*>!="&&!#1-!7*!'7&*!-1!510*!"2!*D*#!'!2/'5-"1#!12!-.1+*!EA888! *<4"#*+!0/*+*#-&>!'-!/"+C!#**(!"::*("'-*!.*&0?!@.*!+"-4'-"1#!"+!#1-!":0/1D"#%?!@.*!="#-*/!12!3893e9G! (*:1#+-/'-*(!-.*!+5'&*!12!-.*!0/17&*:!'+!51:0&'"#-+A!'#":'&+!#**("#%!/*.1:"#%!'#(!0/1+*54-"1#+!! .'D*!'&&!"#5/*'+*(!"#!-.*!2"/+-!-./**!:1#-.+!12!389G?!@.*!.1/+*!:*'-!5/"+"+!'&+1!+.1=*(!-.*!0/17&*:+!! ="-.!"(*#-"2"5'-"1#!12!.1/+*+?!_1=!"+!-.*!7*+-!1001/-4#"->!21/!%1D*/#:*#-!'%*#5"*+A!&15'&!'4-.1/"-"*+!! '#(!-.*!*<4"#*!5.'/"-"*+!-1!=1/C!-1%*-.*/!1#!+1&4-"1#+!'#(!/*D*/+*!-.*!0/*+*#-!-/*#(+?! !

!

!

J.1-1!5/*("-+b!]/1#-!51D*/!U*5C>!H4//'>eFIJKL!J.1-1&"7/'/>X!J'%*!3!)1/&(!O1/+*!)*&2'/*X!J'%*!G!)1/&(!O1/+*!)*&2'/*A!FIJKLX!! !

J'%*!W!)1/&(!O1/+*!)*&2'/*X!0'%*!M!FIJKLX!J'%*!B!!F*(="#%+X!U'5C!0'%*!F*(="#%+?! !