SPOTLIGHT ON CRITICAL ENERGY ISSUES ISSUE 3 / 2017 www.RMEL.org
POWER INNOVATORS: WORKFORCE STRATEGIES OF THE FUTURE
Electric Utilities: The Power Innovators
The Power of Crowd Based Challenges
Emerging Leaders are Powering the Electric Energy Future
2018 RMEL Events
2017 RMEL Foundation Scholarship Recipients
Complete energy solutions: We have you covered. The electric power market is evolving worldwide. No matter your power needs, we have the capabilities and integrated team to provide a safe, reliable and cost-effective solution — from concept to completion. Learn more at burnsmcd.com/RMEL17.
Delivering Reliable, Economical Power for the Future
As owner’s engineer, Stanley Consultants provided preliminary engineering, detailed design review, and procurement and construction management services for the Matanuska Electric Association’s new 171-megawatt duel-fueled reciprocating gas engine plant in Palmer, Alaska. Designed to cover all of MEA’s power needs, the Eklutna Generation Station provides reliable, economical power for years to come.
Generation • Transmission • Substation • Distribution • Owner’s Engineer, Detailed Design • Construction Management and Inspection
800.878.6806 | stanleyconsultants.com
CONTENTS
10
Electric Utilities: The Power Innovators
14
22 24
29
By Deborah Knudtzon, Sr. Project Coordinator, HDR, & Bryan Cook, Sr. Project Manager,
Plan Your Unique, Diverse and Trusted RMEL Community Experience
Emerging Moving Leaders are the Project Powering the Management Electric Energy Maturity Model Future Forward
The Power of Crowd Based Challenges: NASA’s Practical Toolkit for Open By Steve Rader, Deputy Manager, NASA’s Center of Excellence
2018 Events Provide Comprehensive Best Practices & Solutions
36
RMEL Foundation Awards a Record Number of Scholarships
HDR
for Collaborative Innovation (CoECI)
06 Executive Director's Message
42 2018 Calendar of Events
08 Board of Directors and
43 Foundation Infographic
Foundation Board of Directors
34 Top RMEL Member Training Needs
41
4
RMEL Foundation Silent Auction
ELECTRIC ENERGY | WINTER 2017
44
RMEL Membership Listings
46
Index to Advertisers
OPINIONS EXPRESSED IN ELECTRIC ENERGY MAGAZINE DO NOT NECESSARILY REFLECT THE OPINIONS OF RMEL OR HUNGRY EYE MEDIA.
REVOLUTIONARY ENERGY
FIRST TO 99.5% RELIABILITY WINS. GAME OVER. Our M501JAC leaves the competition in the dust when it comes to reliability. That’s because no other turbine manufacturer comes close to the testing we put our units through. Saying our JAC fleet has been put through the wringer is an understatement. We’re talking more than 14,500 hours of commercial operation with over 800 starts. All in real working power plants. Don’t settle for less. Join the revolution. changeinpower.com
REVOLUTI ENERG
RMEL INFORMATION
Letter From the Executive Director
N
NEW IDEAS, NEW PEOPLE, NEW talent and invention. Lessons learned, best practices, regulations and safety. There’s a formula and a balance to making everything work together to provide safe, reliable and affordable power with operational ingenuity and workforce strategies that are evolving everyday to best serve electric utility customers. Getting the culture to the right place, investing in the needs of customers and employees and examining the journey of how we get from here to there are critical to the electric energy future. The right people and right ideas will move this industry forward. Traditional relationships, new partnerships and technological revelations will determine what it looks like. In this issue of Electric Energy, RMEL members are providing: Collective executive leader insights from RMEL’s Vital Issues Forum at the Fall Convention in September (pages 10-13) NASA’s take on crowdsourcing strategies to find the best ideas in creative new places (pages 14-21) Emerging leader workforce
6
ELECTRIC ENERGY | WINTER 2017
perceptions and trends (pages 22-27) A look at more than 40 RMEL Foundation Scholarship winners from 2017 (pages 36-41) 2018 RMEL events that will showcase the best of RMEL member knowledge and resources (pages 28-32) The inventive spirit of RMEL members is a great sign of what’s to come for our industry in 2018 and beyond. Thank you for engaging in the RMEL member community as we work together toward RMEL’s mission: MISSION: RMEL, through its diverse membership, educational events, and programs, facilitates the discovery of solutions and strategies for vital issues facing the electric utility industry. I look forward to seeing you in 2018! Sincerely,
Richard Putnicki Executive Director, RMEL
THE FUTURE IS A
POWER FORWARD
POWERFUL PLACE. Join over 700 exhibiting companies as Denver plays host to the T&D industry’s most powerful and experiential conference and exposition. This is your opportunity to gain access and expose your
A P R I L 1 6 –1 9 2 0 1 8
business to over 12,000 professionals
D E N V E R C O LO R A D O
the unparalleled chance to grow
and decision-makers. Don’t miss your network, connect globally and discover the latest innovations to power your business forward. FOR MORE INFORMATION AND UPDATES VISIT US AT: POWERFORWARD2018.ORG
RMEL INFORMATION
RMEL Board of Directors OFFICERS. PRESIDENT Tom Kent Nebraska Public Power District VP & COO PRESIDENT ELECT Scott Fry Mycoff, Fry & Prouse LLC Managing Director PAST PRESIDENT Jon Hansen Omaha Public Power District VP, Energy Production & Marketing VICE PRESIDENT, FINANCE Paul Barham CPS Energy Sr. VP, of Engineering, Integrated Planning, Substation & Transmission VICE PRESIDENT, EDUCATION Joel Bladow Tri State Generation and Transmission Assn. Sr. VP, Transmission VICE PRESIDENT, VITAL ISSUES Neal Walker Texas New Mexico Power President, TNMP VICE PRESIDENT, MEMBERSHIP Elaina Ball Austin Energy Deputy General Manager, COO VICE PRESIDENT, MEMBER SERVICES Kelly Harrison Westar Energy VP, Transmission
DIRECTORS.
OFFICERS.
DIRECTORS.
Doug Bennion PacifiCorp VP, Engineering Services & Asset Management
PRESIDENT Paul Compton Kiewit Sr. VP, Business Development
Tim Brossart Xcel Energy VP, Enterprise Transformation Office
VICE PRESIDENT, FINANCE Barry Ingold Tri-State Generation and Transmission Assn. Sr. VP, Generation
John Coggins SRP Sr. Director, Power Delivery Susan Gray UNS Energy Corporation VP, T&D Operations/ Engineering Diane Johnson Yampa Valley Electric Association, Inc. President & CEO Mike Kotara Zachry Group VP, Business Development, Power
CHAIR, FUNDRAISING Tom Haensel Burns & McDonnell Project Manager
Bruce Akin Westar Energy Sr. VP, Power Delivery Bob Gresham Zachry Group VP, Engineering Development Kelly Harrison Westar Energy VP, Transmission Gary Hellard Babcock & Wilcox Company Director, Sales & Business Development
CHAIR, MEMBER DEVELOPMENT Mike Jones SRP Director
John Johnson Black & Veatch Corp. VP, Power Generation Services
CHAIR, SCHOLARSHIP Karin Hollohan Platte River Power Authority Chief Administrative Services Officer
Rick Putnicki RMEL Executive Director Hoss Tabrizi Power, Ulteig Engineers, Inc. Sr. Market Director
Anthony Montoya Western Area Power Administration COO Kevin Noblet Kansas City Power & Light VP, Delivery Andy Ramirez El Paso Electric Company VP, Power Generation Dan Schmidt Black & Veatch Corp. Sr. VP, Power Generation Services Stuart Wevik Black Hills Corporation Group VP, Electric Utilities Ken Wilmot Associated Electric Cooperative, Inc. VP, Power Production SECRETARY Rick Putnicki RMEL Executive Director
8
Foundation Board of Directors
ELECTRIC ENERGY | WINTER 2017
www.RMEL.org Published Winter 2017 PUBLISHED FOR: RMEL 6855 S. Havana St, Ste 430 Centennial, CO 80112 P: (303) 865-5544 F: (303) 865-5548 www.RMEL.org
Kathryn Hail EDITOR (303) 865-5544 kathrynhail@rmel.org Electric Energy is the official magazine of RMEL. Published three times a year, the publication discusses critical issues in the electric energy industry. Subscribe to Electric Energy by contacting RMEL. Editorial content and feedback can also be directed to RMEL. Advertising in the magazine supports RMEL education programs and activities. For advertising opportunities, please contact Susan Wist from HungryEye Media, LLC at (303) 378-1626.
P U B L I S H E D BY:
www.hungryeyemedia.com
800.852.0857 Brendan Harrington PRESIDENT
Susan Wist ACCOUNT EXECUTIVE
(303) 378-1626 susanwist@hungryeyemedia.com Lindsay Burke ART DIRECTOR
Shannon Moore DESIGNER
Susan Humphrey MARKETING OPERATIONS MANAGER
more than 70 years of powering innovations Pike professionals are experts in substation, transmission and distribution infrastructure. From asset management and engineering to construction, maintenance and storm restoration, we deliver.
Safety. Integrity. Solutions.
www.pike.com
| 336.789.2171
ELECTRIC UTILITIES:
THE POWER INNOVATORS
INTRODUCTION Introduction by Neal Walker, VP, Vital Issues, RMEL & President, Texas New Mexico Power
There’s nothing like hundreds of electric utilities from across the country joining forces in our country’s time of need. Just before we met for RMEL’s Fall Executive Leadership and Management Convention in September, the southern and southeast regions of our country unfortunately experienced historic hurricane damage. What followed was the largest collaborative effort from the power workforce that we’ve ever seen. I personally witnessed this amazing effort, as many of my Texas New Mexico Power customers were greatly affected by Hurricane Harvey. It was really something…bucket trucks lined up as far as the eye could see ready to deploy and restore power to help Americans resume their way of life. The stunning display of camaraderie and partnership stayed with me as I traveled from Texas to Arizona for the Convention. Then the fantastic speakers sparked ideas with topics like crowdsourcing and electrification. As we began the 2017 Vital Issues Forum, there was a strong sense of optimism, teamwork and invention. I am happy to share with you this summary of our discussion, which touches on Talent, Customers, Resource Mix and the Grid. It’s exciting to see how new ideas have evolved even just over this past year. I am proud to be part of this industry, and I look forward to seeing what we’ll do together as The Power Innovators.
R
RMEL MEMBER EXECUTIVES AGREE that electric utilities are now the power innovators. Incorporating ideas from Fall Convention presentations on topics like crowdsourcing, electrification and the Disney Institute Customer Experience, these industry leaders also touched on areas that are sparking ingenuity at their organizations.
THE 21ST CENTURY ELECTRIC UTILITY CULTURE: SAYING YES
Utilities are in varying stages of moving toward a culture change that is more conducive to the younger, emerging leader style of leadership. There’s more feedback, more passion, more flexibility; and there’s less hierarchy and less division of labor. The incoming generation has more IT-driven expertise, and if there isn’t an IT expert or “data scientist” in the top executive team at most electric utilities, there probably will be soon. Companies are connecting employees and customers to electricity as the foundation for the American way of life. More and more utility employees believe in the brand of the power industry and the possibilities, ingenuity and excitement of electricity as it relates to their job. They’re thinking about customer touchpoints
and how they can ensure customers have a great experience with their electric utility. Customers are starting to understand more about their electricity bill and what it takes to keep the lights on – they’re event getting a personal look at the life, family and routine of a lineman, especially through social media. Utilities are building the foundation for a new and innovative culture, and with that comes more ownership, trust and leeway for employees to use their own judgement. One Vital Issues participant mentioned a policy (with parameters, of course) that employees have to ask permission to say no to customers. Think about how that sets the stage when a customer calls in and says, “We’d like a microgrid. How much does it cost? When can we get it?” Utilities are breaking tradition and are positioning themselves as partners to listen to customer requests and business goals, and say, “here’s what we can do. It’s going to be expensive, here are the numbers. It’s going to take x amount of time.” Utilities are strategizing alongside the customer and staying in tune with what customers might want 5-10 years down the road. One participant said, “if we aren’t flexible and don’t give customers what they need – they’ll go find it somewhere else.”
SIGNATURE EVENTS HEADED TO COLORADO AND TEXAS IN 2018 For 114 years, RMEL has offered two signature annual events with unique programming for utility and service company participants. These events move to different locations each year to ensure RMEL members in various locations can attend. In 2018, the Fall Executive Leadership and Management Convention will be held in San Antonio, TX, and the Spring Management, Engineering and Operations Conference will be held in Keystone, CO. FALL EXECUTIVE LEADERSHIP AND MANAGEMENT CONVENTION The RMEL Fall Executive Leadership and Management Convention started in October of 1903. Since that first meeting, the Fall Convention has grown and evolved into one of the industry’s leading events for senior management. The 2018 Fall Executive Leadership and Management Convention will take place September 16-18, at the Grand Hyatt in San Antonio, TX. SPRING MANAGEMENT, ENGINEERING AND OPERATIONS CONFERENCE The Spring Management, Engineering and Operations Conference has been a tradition since RMEL’s early beginnings known for providing outstanding continuing education and networking opportunities. The 2018 Spring Management, Engineering and Operations Conference is slated for May 20-22 at the Keystone Resort & Conference Center in Keystone, CO.
W W W. R M EL .O R G
11
Training for Nontechnical Electric Energy Employees
OPPORTUNITY: INNOVATION, DATA AND ELECTRIFICATION
The entire planning process of the power industry has shifted. Resource mix planning crosses over into distribution, data are being used to improve customer experience, utilities are focusing on capacity studies and finding the right algorithm to establish an appropriate rate structure. Everything is becoming more integrated, including other industries like telecommunications. The old question of “need,” in the integrated resource planning process is focused more now on customers and economics. “We’ve turned it around and said wait a minute, our pledge is to our customers. Our pledge is not to raise rates,” one participant commented. When it comes to keeping up with changing politics, one participant shared how his utility did research, talked to their customers and put regulations aside for just a moment, asking what emissions level they could realistically set. This put the utility on a path moving forward without having to worry about regulatory uncertainty. In the end, the targets they set aligned with the regulator targets. And now electrification is becoming real. EPRI defines electrification as the application of novel, energy-efficient electric technologies as alternatives to fossil-fueled or non-energized
12
ELECTRIC ENERGY | WINTER 2017
processes. This means an integrated grid, lower emissions and of course load growth. It’s reminiscent of a time when electric utilities promoted refrigerators and washers and dryers or any appliance that used electricity. Now it’s about electric cars, solar glass tiles and manufacturing processes.
2018 AND BEYOND
The group specifically requested that RMEL events, content and publications in 2018 provide answers, solutions, best practices and networking opportunities in these areas: Data Analytics and Algorithms Resource Mix Strategies (including at the distribution level) Workforce/Talent Microgrids Electrification Customer Experience/Touchpoints Crowd sourcing Rates Electric Vehicles Plant Cycling Joint/Integrated Planning Between Generation, Transmission and Distribution Renewable Integration And more True power innovation is here. When it comes to any challenge on the horizon, the collective mindset of the electric utility workforce is: We can do it. We will do it. How can we do it? It’s done.
The Introduction to the Electric Utility Workshop is coming up January 18, 2018, at the Denver Marriott South in Lone Tree, CO. This course is designed to acquaint nontechnical utility employees with the basics of their industry from the generation to the distribution of electricity.
A Comprehensive Look at the Power Industry
All non-technical utility employees wishing to acquire a basic understanding of how electricity is generated, transmitted and distributed are encouraged to attend. This course is ideal for executives, new hires, human resources and finance department employees and administrative personnels in this section.
Knowledgeable Instruction by Steve Sax
Steve Sax, President/CEO, Utility Management Partners LLC, brings extensive experience to his courses, having worked in the utility industry for over 30 years as an engineer and General Manager. Mr. Sax has worked with industrial expansion, community development and energy conservation projects. He has also served as General Manager of Murfreesboro Tennessee Electric Department, a large municipal utility that generates, transmits and distributes power to its consumers.
NEBRASKA
Southeast Community What people say about the program . . . College Energy Generation “LES appreciates the foresight at SCC that drove investing the time and resources to bring this program online. Having a local program that Nebraska utilities can help mold to fit their specific needs is a valuable Operations program resource that LES is proud to be a part of. The desire to source locallywA.A.S. degree in 18 months (102-104 quarter credit hours) wIn-person at SCC’s Milford, NE campus wGraduates trained to operate Combined Cycle, coal, nuclear, and other electrical and fluid fuel generating plants. wFocuses: Nuclear, Industrial Process Operations and Military. wControl Room Simulator only one of its kind at any college in the U.S. (see below) wNuclear Regulatory Commission scholarships of up to $3,000 over two-year period available. wTransfer agreements with Bismarck (N.D.) State College, Thomas Edison (N.J.) State College and Excelsior (N.Y.) College allow SCC graduates to pursue a bachelor’s degree. Program graduates receive a high level of training in overall electric utility operations and are being sought by utility Operation Control Centers across the Midwest. A number of utilities are reporting great success in hiring these graduates as distribution operators. Utilities hiring SCC program graduates include MidAmerican Energy and ComEd. About SCC’s Control Room Simulator:
wReplicates control room of a power plant, including realistic time delays and equipment responses to prepare our students for real-life experiences. wCan simulate virtually any abnormal or emergency condition that can occur at two types of power plants: Combined Cycle (jet engine) powered and coal-fired electric generating.
educated and skilled operations staff for our generation facilities has been met by SCC.” Brian McReynolds Generation Operations, Lincoln Electric System “SCC’s Energy Generation Operations program continues to provide Omaha Public Power District with a trained pool of talent to draw from for our fossil generation fleet. Twenty percent of our Operations staff at the Nebraska City Station has graduated from this program.” Ryan Gerdts Operations Superintendent OPPD’s Nebraska City Coal Plant “The Energy Generation Operations program at SCC changed my life tremendously. I wouldn’t be where I am today if it wasn’t for instructors John Pierce, Doug Burks and David Madcharo. They have many years of experience, are dedicated and very knowledgeable. The best thing about the degree is having multiple employment options after graduation. With the advancement of energy and technology, there will always be a demand in this field. SCC Milford is a small, friendly community that cares about students and the wellbeing of everyone. To any new student attending the College, get to know the instructors, advisors, administrators, and students and be involved as much as you can.” Renee Peters, June 2014 Graduate Distribution System Dispatch Operator MidAmerican Energy, Des Moines, Iowa Member, Program Advisory Board
www.southeast.edu/energygenerationoperations - 402-761-8394
W W W. R M EL .O R G
13
The Power of the Crowd
NASA’s Practical Open Innovation Tools By Steve Rader, Deputy Manager, NASA's Center of Excellence for Collaborative Innovation CoECI
I
IT IS NO SECRET THAT THE WORLD IS CHANGING. Global connectivity has given rise to a new type of industry that is connecting people with various passions, skills, expertise, and creativity to people and companies that need those resources. These new “open innovation” or “crowdsourcing” platforms are attracting millions of people around various passions like technical problem solving, software development, data science and machine learning, mechanical design, and even film making. These crowds have proved to be extremely effective at solving hard “unsolved” technical problems from industry, developing high quality, innovative designs and products, and developing high performance algorithms. Over the past 10 to 15 years, companies have been learning to use these resources to great effect. Organizations like General Electric, Procter & Gamble, General Motors, NASA, and many others are changing the way they do R&D and even design and production. These companies curate their communities, incentivizing them to use their skills, expertise, or passion towards some product offering. They offer community members the chance to learn, connect with each other, and make money, all at the convenience of the individual user. Bill Joy famously said that “No matter who you are, most of the smartest people work for someone else.” For the NASA workforce, that is a hard message to hear. However, even though NASA has lots of brilliant people within NASA’s 60,000 workforce, within the remaining global population of 7+ billion people, there are many other brilliant people. Imagine the possibilities if an organization is able to access those brilliant people solve problems or work on projects. The graph below conceptually demonstrates the real opportunity of crowd-sourcing.
Potential Value in the Crowd
FIGURE 1: Notional Capability or Expertise Distribution within the Population
This opportunity to access expertise or skills that are as good or better than your in house capabilities is possible through contests or challenges. Crowdsourcing platforms offer incentives to these curated communities to access the high value portion of the crowd since those are the individuals or teams
W W W. R M EL .O R G
15
that win the contests/challenges. These platforms also provide services and mechanisms to evaluate and filter submissions such that they can efficiently find the high value submissions.
FIGURE 2: The NTL Open Innovation Toolkit
NASA’S CENTER OF EXCELLENCE FOR COLLABORATIVE INNOVATION (COECI) At NASA’s Center of Excellence for Collaborative Innovation (CoECI), we are chartered with working across NASA and with other Federal agencies across the US Government to help organizations learn about and leverage open innovations tools. Since it began working with open innovation or crowd-based challenges, NASA has run over 270 different challenges across a number of disciplines and domains and has worked with over 17 different federal agencies using 15 different crowdsourcing communities (see graphic below). CoECI provides these challenges through its NASA Tournament Lab (NTL) which includes contracts with 12 crowdsourcing platforms/ vendors and has designed these contracts to be available to all of NASA as well as any other U.S. federal agency through an inter-agency agreement. CoECI also supports academic research on crowdsourcing with a number of universities including considerable work with the Laboratory for Innovation Science at Harvard (LISH). NASA’s CoECI provides organizations with education, workshops, consulting, procurement/ contractual support, and assistance with challenge execution. During the past 8 years, NASA has learned a great deal about the various types of challenges, crowd curation models, and approaches to infusing open innovation into an organization. For CoECI, open innovation has proved successful for the following areas: Solving difficult problems, enterprise knowledge sharing, data science, software development, technology search, mechanical design, and creative/multi-media design.
SOLVING DIFFICULT PROBLEMS One of the most impactful uses of crowds is to solve hard technical problems. These challenges have a fairly high success rate and tap into diversity as a key ingredient for
16
ELECTRIC ENERGY | WINTER 2017
success. NASA has used a number of diverse/multi-discipline crowds including Innocentive, NineSigma, HeroX, Luminary Labs, and NASA’s employee crowd “NASA@work.” These challenges included ideation, conceptual design, and detailed design/prototyping challenges. One academic study of Innocentive’s successful challenges found that 70% of challenge solvers were from a different discipline/domain than the challenge owner. This really points to a key reason that this method is so successful and valuable to industry. Technical teams or even entire disciplines can be blind to ideas or solutions from adjacent or different domains. Diverse solver communities expose the problem to fresh perspectives that are unconstrained and sometimes bring techniques or technologies from other disciplines to bear on the problem. The larger and more diverse the crowd, the higher the chance of finding a truly innovative solution to the problem. One of our NASA challenges to increase our prediction horizon for solar flares demonstrated this well. The winning solution, which increased the prediction horizon by 4x (twice the goal) was submitted by a retired radio-frequency (RF) engineer. However, this engineer also had studied heliophysics years before in college and had applied RF signal processing techniques to the heliophysics problem of solar flare prediction. There are a number of compelling examples and case studies in this area along with lessons learned and techniques for maximizing the effectiveness of a problem solving or “innovation” challenges. CoEI has solved a number of difficult problems including finding an approach to security key exchanges in delay/disruption communication networks, measuring strain in kevlar/vectran materials for inflatable space habitats, and finding scientifically valuable use for Mars entry vehicle ballast.
ENTERPRISE KNOWLEDGE SHARING NASA CoECI curates its own crowd of NASA civil servant and contractor employees called “NASA@work.” This community consists of almost 18,000 employees which includes about half of all NASA civil servants and about a quarter of the NASA contractor workforce. NASA projects can post challenges on the platform at no cost to them and CoECI helps the project to formulate and run the challenge. CoECI also administers the incentive prize program for the winners of challenges. While some of these challenges fit into the “problem solving” category described above, many of the challenges on NASA@work leverage the human network of solvers to find existing work or knowledge within NASA. Given the technical silos within NASA’s 10+ centers around the country, NASA@work has been shown to be a very effective means to discover synergies or complimentary work that, when shared, benefit the agency and reduce redundant work. CoECI has run over 130 NASA@work challenges with an 80% success rate with some cases where the solutions have resulted in significant saving ($1M+ in some cases).
DATA SCIENCE In a time when “big data” and “machine learning” are transforming the world and creating a high demand for data
208.885.6265 | uiuec@uidaho.edu | www.uiuec.org
Utility Executive Course
June 11 - 28, 2018
65 YEARS
June 26 - 28, 2018 Coeur d’Alene, Idaho
of Excellent Utility Education
“The Summit hit it out of the park! The topics, venue, and organization were stellar.” Anne Jones, Vice President, Human Resources, MDU Resources W W W. R M EL .O R G
17
scientists, crowd-based data science challenges are providing some very impressive results. NASA has worked with the Laboratory for Innovation Science at Harvard (LISH) to run a number of these algorithm/data science challenges on data science specialized crowd platforms like TopCoder, Kaggle, as well as more diverse communities like Innocentive. These challenges include satellite dish sub-array optimization, asteroid discovery, satellite imagery machine learning, robotic vision, and toxicity analysis. Algorithm challenges have demonstrated amazing results. One case study by Harvard showed a 120X performance increase in a genetic sequencing algorithm FIGURE 3: Harvard Business School Case Study on Improving the NIH Megablast Algorithm (see graphic below). This challenge resulted in 89 different approaches demonstrated and the top 20+ submiscapability for over 20 projects with impressive results. As just sions all performed at 2-3 orders of magnitude better perone example, the Asteroid Data Hunter project improved our formance than the existing code. NASA has tapped into this capability to detect asteroids from telescope imagery by 15%.
WHERE PEOPLE+PASSION=
POWER AT NPPD, WE GET CHARGED PROVIDING POWER TO AN ESTIMATED 600,000 NEBRASKANS. WE ARE ALWAYS NICK ENGINEER
LOOKING FOR ENERGETIC AND SKILLED ENGINEERS TO JOIN OUR TEAM. ARE YOU READY TO TAKE CHARGE OF YOUR CAREER? IF SO, THEN WE’RE READY FOR YOU!
NPPD — IT’S WHERE YOU WANT TO BE.
nppd.com/careers
18
ELECTRIC ENERGY | WINTER 2017
Share Generation, Transmission and Distribution Best Practices in March Power Supply Planning and Projects Conference and Roundtable
FIGURE 4: The Use of Atomized Contests to Access Focused Expertise for the Software Development Lifecycle
SOFTWARE DEVELOPMENT As with other organizations, NASA struggles to recruit and maintain software development skills as the demand for complex software systems increases and technology constantly shifts and changes. Several crowd communities have been successful in providing flexible access to software development skills through both contest and freelance models. To date, NASA has successfully used Topcoder, cOutsource, and Freelancer for various software projects. Topcoder uses a contest model where they use members of their 1.1 million member community to split projects into component phases and then use contests to perform those development phases. This approach is able to access particular experts within their community and has often times provided innovative user interfaces, feature, or architectures. This highly parallel development process also tends to speed up the development process while providing a complete set of documentation and security measures. The other freelance based models are proving to be cost effective mechanisms to get small software projects quickly for very low cost. CoECI has developed a number of software applications using these methods including the ISS Food Intake Tracker (FIT) iPad application used by the astronauts onboard the International Space Station (ISS) to track their
nutrition intake. Additionally, these methods have been used to develop Disruption/Delay Tolerant Network (DTN) protocols and management tools, image processing software for lunar imagery, and an astronaut smartwatch app.
TECHNOLOGY SEARCH Technology development has become very difficult to track as a vast array of disciplines worldwide are rapidly developing technologies across a range of areas including nano-technology, robotics, artificial intelligence, genomics, and others. Traditional methods like technical journals or even internet searches rarely provide a full landscape view of a given technology. NASA’s CoECI uses its contract with Yet2 to access a large world-wide community network to find a given technology across academia, industry, and government. This service acts as a matchmaking service between our scientists and engineers that have a technology need and those around the world that may have a technology or solution that would meet that need. CoECI has done almost 20 of these technology searches using this contract with very strong results including finding technologies to measure intracranial pressure non-invasively, provide radiation tolerant graphics processing, processing imagery obscured with smoke or rain, and others.
Evolving RTO markets, renewables, distributed resources, and calls for increased grid resiliency present power supply planners with significant challenges to ensure flexibility and reliability while remaining cost competitive. This conference will explore current trends, relevant projects and market perspectives to gain insight to this changing industry. The 2018 Power Supply Planning and Projects Conference will be March 7-8, 2018, in Lone Tree, CO.
Transmission Planning and Operations Conference This conference addresses subjects related to planning, permitting, design, construction, technologies, renewable integration and substations. It will also cover regulatory and policy issues. In 2018, this event will take place March 14-15 at the Denver Marriott South at Park Meadows in Lone Tree, CO.
Distribution Overhead and Underground Operations and Maintenance Conference Join us March 21-22 in Lone Tree, CO to discusses both overhead and underground distribution systems and new technologies. The electric utility industry is a rapidly changing industry both on the technology side and from a policy standpoint. To meet this need, the conference will drill down into the key aspects of distribution planning, regulation and environmental policy. Register for 2018 RMEL Events at www.RMEL.org.
W W W. R M EL .O R G
19
OUR
SUPER POWER IS INVISIBILITY.
At Black & Veatch, we help design, build and implement the electric generation, transmission and distribution systems that enable you to provide reliable and sustainable energy services for your customers. When your customer flips a switch, the lights should come on. When devices are plugged in, they should charge. When the transition is seamless, we’ve done our job. Visit bv.com/power to learn more.
FIGURE 5: A Sample of the 492 CAD Designs Submitted for the ISS Handrail Clamp Contest
MECHANICAL DESIGN CoECI has run several mechanical design challenges using platforms like GrabCAD, a community of 2.5M mechanical engineers and designers, and Freelancer, a community of 25M+ freelance workers. These contests have shown that the crowd is very capable of providing innovative and high quality mechanical designs and their associated CAD models. These contests have shown that NASA can get a large number of innovative designs for as little as $3000 and that this can provide an improved method to access optimal or high performing designs. The graphic shown is a sample of the 492 CAD design submissions received as part of the ISS handrail clamp 3D printable design challenge on GrabCAD. Additionally, these challenges engage a portion of the public that is very interested in working on NASA designs in a real and meaningful way.
CREATIVE/MULTI-MEDIA DESIGN NASA has found that video and graphics can be very important to communicating a project’s purpose. CoECI has used a variety of platforms to produce a range of multimedia products like high end videos, short technical videos, and project graphics. Platforms like Freelancer are often used for inexpensive graphics and simple videos while Tongal (a community of 100,000 film-makers) is used for higher end video production. Graphics challenges can be done for less than $300 and have provided a good entry point for projects that are interested in using crowdsourcing, but want to better understand it before investing more funds or making that approach part of their technical project.
CLOSING THOUGHTS Even though these new crowdsourcing approaches or tools have been demonstrated to be quite effective, they
20
ELECTRIC ENERGY | WINTER 2017
also pose a fundamental change to the way most organizations work. In particular, NASA’s technical/engineering organizations have very traditional approaches to working and it can be difficult to introduce new tools and methods into the workforce. CoECI is working across all levels of the NASA organizations on changing the culture to be able to leverage these new tools. As with any organizational change, this process is slow, but NASA is making good progress and reaching a point where this is considered an alternative procurement or acquisition method. The world is changing and NASA is working to keep up with these changes and to leverage new approaches to advance our efforts to explore space.
DO MORE WITH LESS
Reduce time and costs spent ordering, receiving and managing material. Using our VMI service ensures you have the materials you need. Contact your Border States Account Manager to find out more.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Steve Rader currently serves as the deputy manager for NASA’s Center of Excellence for Collaborative Innovation (CoECI) and is one of 20 Challenge Mentors for U.S. Government Services Administration’s (GSA) Prizes and Challenges government-wide community of practice. Steve has worked with various projects and organizations to develop and/or execute over 60 different challenges and has provided consulting for NASA organizations and agencies such as DHS, NIST, and EPA. These challenges have all been executed on commercial curated communities such as NASA@work, InnoCentive, Topcoder, Yet2, NineSigma, Kaggle, Tongal, HeroX, The Common Pool, Luminary Labs, Applause, GrabCAD, and Freelancer. He speaks regularly about NASA’s work in crowd-based challenges both publically (like InnoCentive’s NASA Experiences Webinar or Crowdopolis XV-2015) and internally to the NASA workforce to promote the use of open innovation tools. Mr. Rader has Mechanical Engineering degree from Rice University and has worked at NASA’s Johnson Space Center in Houston, TX for 25 years. He started his career as an environmental control and life support systems flight controller for Space Station Operations. Mr. Rader moved into flight software engineering where he developed delay tolerant communications software for the Space Shuttle and International Space Station as wells as ground and flight command & control systems for the X-38 emergency crew return vehicle. Mr. Rader led the development of NASA’s Constellation Program’s interoperable Command, Control, Communications & Information (C3I) architecture. After the Constellation program, Mr. Rader supported the Mars design reference mission definition and a number of analog missions studying space mission operations and design. Mr. Rader began studying crowdsourcing communities in 2011 and joined the Center of Excellence for Collaborative Innovation as the deputy manager in 2013.
10-061 (2017-09)
“People Do Projects”
EPC for Power Projects Biomass, Waste-to-Energy (WTE), Simple Cycle, Combined Cycle, Reciprocating Engines, CHP & Alternative Energy Our people each possess more than 30 years of experience in the power business; working as Developers, Contractors, and as Owners Tier 1 Financial Strength, with the flexibility and responsiveness of a small firm Diane Giacomozzi | VP of Operations Diane.Giacomozzi@mastec.com | (303) 390-3064 6446 S. Kenton Street, Unit 100 Centennial, CO 80111
WWW.MASTECPOWER.COM W W W. R M EL .O R G
21
EMERGING LEADERS
ARE POWERING THE ELECTRIC ENERGY FUTURE
O
24
rganizational and electric energy industry success begins with important decisions made by individuals every minute of every day. Many of these individuals have been in the industry for a relatively short time, but are already making great strides at their companies. RMEL’s Emerging Leader
Award recipients are recognized for their outstanding and inventive ability to help their organizations thrive in this exciting but uncertain time for the electric energy industry. We asked four past recipients to examine what brought them to the industry and provide some advice for continuing to draw new talent to this industry, along with strategies to develop high potential employees.
TRAVIS ANDERSON
MARY ANN ZEHR
TYSON ARCHIE
HOSS TABRIZI
Travis Anderson was named the Maintenance Engineering Manager at the Western Area Power Administration (Western) Rocky Mountain Region in May 2014. In this role, Anderson leads a group of 20 engineers and specialists in providing technical support to the Rocky Mountain Region Maintenance Department. Areas of technical support include system protection, communications, asset management, and regulatory compliance. Meeting compliance with Critical Infrastructure Protection Version 5 has been one of Anderson’s primary focal points in this position. Previously, Anderson held positions as a Construction Project Manager in the Rocky Mountain Region and as an Electrical Engineer in Western’s Desert Southwest Office. A native of Casper, WY, Anderson graduated from the University of Wyoming in 2005 with a B.S. in Electrical Engineering and in 2007 with an M.S. in Electrical Engineering.
Mary Ann Zehr has over twelve years of experience in the electric utility industry, which includes experience in transmission -system operations, compliance, rates and policy and currently holds the position of Sr. Mgr. Transmission Contracts, Rates, and Policy for Tri-State Generation and Transmission Association, Inc. Mary Ann’ s educational background includes a Master’s of Science Degree in Global Energy Management from the University of Colorado and a Bachelor’s of Science Degree in Business Administration with a specialization in Management from Regis University. Prior to joining Tri-State, Mary Ann graduated from the U.S. Navy Nuclear Power Program and served as a nuclear power plant operator onboard the U.S.S. Carl Vinson (CVN-70)
After graduating from Bismarck State College with an Associate’s Degree in Power Plant Technology, Tyson Archie started in the electric industry working as a Stationary Engineer with Johnson Controls Inc. After a few short years, Tyson began his career with Platte River Power Authority as a Plant Operator at their Rawhide Energy Station. He quickly grasped the intricacies of plant operations and was promoted to the role of Control Room Operator while simultaneously earning his Bachelor’s Degree in Energy Management from Bismarck State College. With a desire to diversify his knowledge in the energy industry, he moved into the role of Compliance Specialist at Platte River where he oversaw their NERC compliance. He enjoys working with his peers throughout the industry as they overcome the challenges of NERC compliance.
As Chief Engineering and Technical Officer at Ulteig, a leading provider of design engineering, program management and technical and field services, Hoss is responsible for delivering highquality engineering solutions to the fiirm's clients. Prior to his current role, he served as Ulteig's Senior Market Director - Power and as Technical Director - Substation. He also previously served as Ulteig’s Technical Director – substation. Hoss is a past recipient of the Rocky Mountain Electrical League’s (RMEL) Emerging Leader award and Ulteig’s “Big Mo” award, which is given in honor of a highly dedicated former employee to the Ulteig team member who has provided the greatest overall contribution to the company during the year. Hoss holds a B.S. and an M.S. in Engineering (Electrical specialty), both from Colorado School of Mines, and is a licensed Professional Engineer in multiple states.
ELECTRIC ENERGY | WINTER 2017
did you choose to work Q: Why in the power industry? Travis: I greatly appreciate the criticality of WAPA’s mission. Power utilities impact public safety, recreation and the entire economy. It’s important to me to be part of an industry that allows me to make a positive contribution to a mission that I feel strongly about. I also enjoy trying to solve all of the challenges and opportunities we face.
utility industry is very high-tech, with our grid commonly recognized as one of modern man’s greatest inventions.
impact has this Q: What industry had on your career path? Mary Ann:
I started my career life working in a power plant in the Navy. Working in that environment I became curious about power generation in general beyond the ship environment -where does the power go, how does it get there, and what are the purposes it is used for? In a sense tying it back to how as a producer of energy, I was contributing to the larger picture. I think that understanding the nexus of where and how you fit in to the larger picture is of critical importance. It creates a sense of purpose, an understanding of how others depend on you, and where you have the ability to drive change when necessary.
The energy industry has always intrigued me. While many may complain that electric utilities are not dynamic enough, they obviously aren’t actively involved in the day to day business of what we do. I find our industry consistently being faced with new challenges that require us to think outside the box. That is one of my favorite things about working for a utility and in particular, Tri-State G&T. New technologies, federal and state policies, and varying business drivers keep us very busy. Most electric utilities do respond to these, but in a controlled fashion vs. being on the bleeding edge of change. This is important for our customers and for employees as it ensures we endeavor to manage risk appropriately and focus on our core mission-responsibly providing affordable, reliable power.
Tyson:
Travis: The power utility business has
Mary Ann:
I grew up in a rural area that was served by a local cooperative. Jobs at that company always seemed to be stable, high-paying and provided excellent benefits. I had several friends whose parents worked at one of the local power plants, so i was able to gain an understanding of the industry from an early age.
Hoss: I think the electric utility industry sort of found me – and I consider myself very fortunate that it did. I first crossed paths with engineering managers for a local utility at a career fair back when I was just a freshman in college. Quite honestly, I remember thinking that there might be more glamour in the “high-tech” industry. As my electric power systems coursework at Colorado School of Mines, my practical experience through the internship, and my academic and professional networks all came together, it all started to click, and I developed a strong interest and passion for the industry. As it turns out, the electric
allowed me to advance more quickly than I would have anticipated. Our industry is at a unique point in time. The rapidly approaching retirement of many extremely knowledgeable and experienced workers presents a whole host of challenges. It also provides an opportunity for individuals to advance into positions that might have taken them much longer to reach a decade ago.
Hoss:
Early exposure to the electric utility industry led me to a career in consulting engineering. I started out in a rotational engineering program, getting exposure to substation, transmission, distribution, and power generation engineering, and I believe that broad foundation helped me in my professional consulting engineering career, which has been nothing but diverse assignments and exciting challenges. While attrition of senior talent in the industry is a significant challenge, I believe that it also spells
W W W. R M EL .O R G
25
opportunity. By 2023 in the electric utility industry, an estimated 50% of the skilled workforce may need to be replaced due to retirement or attrition. So, there are plenty of opportunities for those of us active in the industry to step up in the coming years.
Tyson: The industry has been great for me from a developmental standpoint. I have had the opportunity to work in multiple areas within generation and transmission. This has allowed me to gain a strong understanding of what drives our industry. While we are in a period of rapid change and relative uncertainty, I feel the future is still positive for the utility industry. The industry provides essential services that our customers can’t live without. If we continue to adapt and evolve we should maintain a positive outlook. I also see an abundance of opportunity for growth and development as a large percentage of the workforce will be retiring soon.
Mary Ann:
development Q: What opportunities are available
Over the last few years, Tri-State has stood up two programs specifically geared at leadership development- Emerging Leaders for future potential leaders; and Leadership Development for new managers. They also provide staff access to executive insights by providing Leaders as Teachers lunch meetings, where staff brings in their lunch and listens to executive staff describe what they do, the challenges they face, and the methods they use to overcome those challenges.
Hoss: I’m very fortunate to work for an
has your organizaQ: What tion done well to help you
at your company?
employee-owned company in Ulteig that takes development seriously. We subscribe to the “70/20/10%” philosophy, which relies on approximately 70% of development taking place on-thejob, 20% through coaching and mentoring, and the remaining 10% through formal learning/training opportunities. My company supports formal mentoring relationships and we make use of Career Development Plans as a coaching/development tool. We encourage our employees to craft these plans in conjunction with their managers.
Tyson:
Currently, most opportunities are provided by external resources. It’s worth noting that after attending the RMEL Developing Leaders workshop, a small group of employees at my company have created a Leadership Discussion group to help brainstorm and promote developmental opportunities within our entity.
Travis:
WAPA has several internal and external leadership development
26
programs targeted toward all levels of our organization. Two specific programs I’ll highlight are the Executive Leadership Development Program and the Craft Leadership Development Program. The ELDP is an 18-month program aimed at developing WAPA’s leaders to drive mission results, evoke change, inspire and lead a diverse workforce throughout WAPA. The CLDP is a 24-month program that provides journeyman craft employees the opportunity to strengthen their leadership skills and competencies.
ELECTRIC ENERGY | WINTER 2017
develop that you’d recommend to other organizations? Mary Ann:
They gave me a chance! They let me swim in the pool and develop my own practices to keep from drowning. To be clear though, they gave me the tools to work with. I would also note that my experience at TriState has been one of not only management, but staff, co-workers, and peers teaching each other. When I joined TriState in System Operations, it was a few of the well-seasoned dispatchers that really gave me my first “chance.” They believed in me. They made me work for it, which was critical and for which I am very grateful, but they believed in me and in turn spent some time developing me. Over my career I have had a few of these interactions. They were CRITICAL in getting me to where I am today. As a result I have developed a deep desire to give back to others in the same way. Knowledge and experience transfer is imperative to others as well as our own success.
Travis:
WAPA has been very supportive of people being involved in projects and initiatives that inspire individual employees. I think it’s important for organizations to realize the importance of participating in activities like technical committees, peer reviews, and groups like RMEL. Overall these activities contribute to greater organizational decision making and employee satisfaction.
Hoss: Ulteig has supported my development through numerous on-thejob experiences to drive breadth and depth – including cross-functional and rotational assignments. The company has also facilitated multiple mentoring relationships, along with investing in formal leadership development opportunities. While there are a number of different leadership/management development avenues out there, I’ve found the most value in those that provide introspective experiences. I think of experiences that help one understand and fully leverage strengths, while also identifying opportunities, which in turn, inform action and development plans. Programs that integrate feedback – whether objective (through independent assessments) or more subjective (through “360” assessments) – have also provided a great deal of value.
can management Q: What do to encourage more
people to engage in leadership positions? Tyson:
I feel it is important for leadership to support developmental programs and outwardly encourage participation. If employees are aware of opportunities and feel management is vested in their development, it fosters a culture of employee engagement.
Travis: I think it’s important for leaders at all levels to speak positively about our roles and positions as leaders. Leadership gives us the opportunity to inspire others, drive change and remove roadblocks to help others thrive. Prospective leaders need to understand there’s much more to leadership than personnel management,
and we as leaders need to do our part to communicate that message.
do you do for your Q: What own development?
Hoss:
Mary Ann: Listen to what is going on
This channels a leadership quote from Ralph Nader, but I couldn't agree more that one of the primary roles of leadership is growing more leaders. Beyond that, leaders also have an obligation to ensure that team members across an organization are set up to be successful, with role clarity, tools, and resources to do their jobs and do them effectively, and in roles that lend themselves to team members’ strengths and interests. As an industry, we are obligated to find creative ways to challenge, recognize, and reward the brightest technical minds.
Mary Ann:
Expose them to both the ups and downs. When people feel a sense of involvement and purpose, it often lends itself to them wanting to get involved to assist in driving change.
around me. Ask questions that may be outside my scope of work, but that help me understand more about the company and the industry.
Tyson:
Currently, my company doesn’t have any formal developmental programs so I rely heavily on outside sources such as RMEL. I find there are a lot of opportunities for development available if you seek them out.
Hoss:
I continue to participate in Ulteig’s mentoring program both as a mentee as well as a mentor. The mentoring work is aligned carefully with my Career Development Plan. I also try to maintain “feedback channels”, and tap into those trusted sources periodically for perspective on what I’m doing well, and how I can improve.
The Emerging Leader Awards Program began in 2014 as an RMEL Board directed initiative to recognize high potential employees who are making significant impacts throughout the industry. Beyond the Award itself, recipients have had unique opportunities for strategy sessions with RMEL keynote speakers like NBA star Mark Eaton and NCAA football legend Tom Osborne. These individuals also participate in RMEL events and publications to continue the important discussion of what it’s going to take to lead the way for the power industry future. The 2018 Emerging Leader Award Nomination deadline is 2/28/18. The nomination form is available now at www.RMEL.org.
W W W. R M EL .O R G
27
2018 EVENTS EVENTS FULL OF SOLUTIONS, BEST PRACTICES, CASE STUDIES AND COLLABORATIVE OPPORTUNITIES Plan Your Unique, Diverse and Trusted RMEL Community Experience
28
ELECTRIC ENERGY | WINTER 2017
By hosting 30 events every year, RMEL has consistently offered valuable and practical educational programming for the diverse electric energy professionals who make up its membership. The value of RMEL is its membership. The companies and people who are part of this association develop association resources, so content is by members for members. RMEL events are easily identifiable by sections that include Generation, Transmission, Distribution, Safety and Management. Each section features core events that repeat every year at the same time, so everyone can plan ahead. Event content is designed based on current, critical topics. Section elective events are created each year based on industry need. More information on each section along with preliminary details about 2018 events are listed below.
The Safety Section is a community of industry professionals dedicated to sharing, networking and solutions of all issues related to workplace safety at production, transmission and distribution, and management facilities in the utility industry. CORE EVENT
Safety and Technical Training Conference One of the most critical areas of focus for every utility is safety. Safety concerns impact every area of the business. This one-and-a-half-day conference will include broad safety and technical training initiatives and programs, and take that focus throughout the organization to include discussions about personal efforts to stay safe. In 2018, the event will take place April 18-19 at the Denver Marriott South at Park Meadows in Lone Tree, CO. CORE EVENT
Safety Roundtables — February, April, August and November Safety Roundtables are an opportunity to discuss corporate safety issues in the electric utility industry, issues for operations and craft safety, and other electric energy safety issues. Each participant can pose questions and share information. All attendees are encouraged to bring issues for discussion and materials for sharing. 2018 Safety Roundtables will take place February 23 at Tri-State Generation & Transmission Association in Westminster, CO; August 24, 2018 at Western Area Power Administration in Golden, CO; and November 2.
The Generation Section is a community of industry professionals dedicated to sharing, networking and solutions of all issues related to energy production and supply in the utility industry, including planning and development. Topics covered include renewable generation. CORE EVENT
Power Supply Planning and Projects Conference and Roundtable Evolving RTO markets, renewables, distributed resources, and calls for increased grid resiliency present power supply planners with significant challenges to ensure flexibility and reliability while remaining cost competitive. This conference will
W W W. R M EL .O R G
29
2018 RMEL EVENTS
explore current trends, relevant projects and market perspectives to gain insight to this changing industry. A roundtable discussion will provide an invaluable opportunity for open dialogue regarding challenges and best practices in meeting these challenges. The 2018 event is slated for March 7-8 in Lone Tree, CO. CORE EVENT
Plant Management Conference and Roundtable Topics at this event cover construction, operations, maintenance, emissions, water quality, plant personnel, fuels, planning, security, safety and technologies. Regulatory and policy issues, strategies and procedures that plant personnel can use to optimize operations and performance will also be covered. Attendees will learn about best practices to improve efficiencies, reduce costs and extend the life of their existing plants. The 2018 event will take place August 1-2.
The Transmission Section is a community of industry professionals dedicated to sharing, networking and solutions of all issues related to planning, engineering, operating and maintaining transmission facilities in the utility industry, including substations.
2018 ELECTIVE
Physical and Cyber Security Conference The Physical and Cyber Security Conference is set for January 30-31 at in Tempe, AZ. Presentations will focus on current industry-critical topics like NERC compliance audit - WECC vs. ERCOT, substation intrusion detection systems, CIP proofing substations, sparing strategies for transformers, active shooter training and CIP topics. CORE EVENT
Transmission Planning and Operations Conference This conference addresses subjects related to planning, permitting, design, construction, technologies, renewable integration and substations. It will also cover regulatory and policy issues. In 2018, this event will take place March 14-15 at the Denver Marriott South at Park Meadows in Lone Tree, CO. CORE EVENT
Renewable Planning and Operations Conference The Renewable Planning and Operations Conference is focused on renewable issues related to generation and transmission renewable issues related to planning, integration, operations and new technologies. Presenters will discuss renewable technologies such as wind, solar, storage and biomass energy. The conference will also cover regulatory and policy issues.
B U I LT O N I N G E N U I T Y
INDUSTRIAL CONTRACTOR SINCE 1947
303-460-1274 | www.caseyind.com 30
ELECTRIC ENERGY | WINTER 2017
The Distribution Section is a community of industry professionals dedicated to sharing, networking and solutions of all issues related to planning, engineering, operating and maintaining distribution facilities in the utility industry, including distributed generation.
of the flow from the substation down to the customer. The course will begin with a substation & distribution overview and move into system protection/fuse coordination, reclosers, regulators capacitors, automatic throw overs (ATOs), transformers, cable & wire, additional products, modeling software and much more.
CORE EVENT
Distribution Overhead and Underground Operations and Maintenance Conference This conference focuses on overhead and underground distribution systems while incorporating new technologies. The electric utility industry is a rapidly changing industry both on the technology side and from a policy standpoint. To meet this need, the conference will drill down into the key aspects of distribution planning, regulation and environmental policy. In 2018, the event will take place March 21-22 at the Denver Marriott South at Park Meadows in Lone Tree, CO. 2018 ELECTIVE
The Vital Issues Section is a community of industry professionals dedicated to sharing, networking and solving all issues related to the management of assets, planning, operations and workforce of the utility industry, including corporatewide critical issues and topics that affect different management levels. Discussion may be technical but in general maintains perspective from a higher management level. This section includes demand-side management, energy efficiency and sustainability. This section also incorporates miscellaneous industry areas and fringe topics not covered in other sections. 2018 ELECTIVE
Distribution Engineers Workshop
Leadership Developing Future Leaders Workshop
Distribution engineers and designers will have a unique opportunity to hear from a wide range of organizations during the Distribution Engineers Workshop October 1011 in Lone Tree, CO. Instructors will provide an overview
At the Leaders Developing Future Leaders Workshop on August 15-16, you’ll hear from today’s leaders on how they identify those with leadership potential, gain their commitment and ensure their development.
Distance degrees for working professionals – anywhere, anytime Specifically tailored for people who want to advance their careers while still working full time Professional Science Master’s (PSM) in Electric Power Engineering
Master of Engineering & Technology Management (ETM)
Provides core and elective technical education in a variety of power system topics including power electronics, smart grid, renewables, and power systems economics. Supplement with professional core areas in quantitative methods, management, and legal/finance and you have a power MBA.
Master of Engineering & Technology Management (ETM) Program prepares engineering and business professionals to make strategic and operational decisions and become leaders in their fields. Courses provide practicing engineers with the knowledge, tools, and skills to manage projects, operations, organizations, and people.
For more information: esic.wsu.edu/PSM
For more information: etm.wsu.edu
W W W. R M EL .O R G
31
2018 RMEL EVENTS
2018 ELECTIVE
Introduction to the Electric Utility Workshop The Introduction to the Electric Utility Workshop is set for January 18, 2018, at the Denver Marriott South in Lone Tree, CO. This course is designed to acquaint nontechnical utility employees with the basics of their industry, from the generation to the distribution of electricity. The workshop will focus on five areas: an overview to electricity and electrical power systems, information about conventional production methods, alternative technologies, transmission and distribution systems, and customer service. The course places emphasis on understanding various words, terms and phrases unique to the electric power industry. Participants will gain a clear insight into how electricity works for the end-use customer. CORE EVENT
Spring Management, Engineering and Operations Conference The Spring Management, Engineering and Operations Conference has been a tradition since RMEL’s early beginnings. Known for providing outstanding continuing education and networking opportunities, this conference is a must-attend event for engineering, operations and management personnel in the electric energy industry. With 30 presentations, this conference covers issues in
generation, transmission, distribution, safety, customer service, human resources and other management topics. The timely topics and breakout structure of the conference allow attendees to customize their education experience to focus on presentations and resources that address their needs. The 2018 Spring Management, Engineering and Operations Conference is set for May 20-22 at the Keystone Resort & Conference Center in Keystone, CO. CORE EVENT
Fall Executive Convention
Leadership
and
Management
The RMEL Fall Executive Leadership and Management Convention started in October 1903. Since that first meeting, the Fall Convention has grown and evolved into one of the industry’s leading events for senior management. The Convention provides a relaxed forum for networking with your peers and colleagues to find and share solutions to the critical issues that keep you up at night. Utility executives offer their insight and thoughts on a variety of issues, trends, challenges and the direction they are leading their companies. Speakers are primarily CEOs, senior executives and other top leaders from inside the industry discussing the issues that matter most to you. The 2018 Fall Convention will take place September 16-18 at the Grand Hyatt San Antonio in San Antonio, TX.
Serving Electric Utilities Since 1955 Surveying Aerial Mapping
A MYR GROUP COMPANY
Corridor Siting Analysis GIS Staff Augmentation
YOUR BEST ELECTRICAL CONNECTION Since 1912, Sturgeon Electric has been one of the region’s top specialty contractors providing quality electric utility construction including overhead and underground distribution, transmission, substations, service and maintenance and emergency restoration. www.merrick.com Engineering | Architecture | Design-Build | Surveying | Planning | Geospatial Solutions
32
ELECTRIC ENERGY | WINTER 2017
Sturgeon Electric Company, Inc. | 303.286.8000 | sturgeonelectric.com MYR GROUP INC. AND ITS SUBSIDIARIES ARE EQUAL OPPORTUNITY EMPLOYERS. M/F/DISABLED/VETERAN ©2017 MYR GROUP INC.
Continue Discussing Issues in Your Section on Facebook, LinkedIn and Twitter RMEL’s trusted network is now accessible on Facebook, LinkedIn and Twitter. Join us by visiting www.RMEL.org and clicking the social network logos on the top right of the page.
CONNECTING
Join RMEL’s social networks to:
PEOPLE.
iscuss industry news and D trends with your peers. Connect with RMEL members with similar interests. Stay updated on the latest industry and RMEL news. Find news and pictures from recent RMEL events.
Take an In-Depth Look at Section Benefits RMEL has services and content focused on utilities’ top priorities that participants can attend year after year. The core events, electives, RMEL Course Catalog and roundtable events bring a fresh perspective to the RMEL educational experience in each section.
Roundtables
same time every year so you can plan ahead. At least one signature event has been established for each section, and section participants can quickly and easily identify with their events. Topics at core events evolve to stay relevant and ahead of electric energy industry trends.
Electives
EVENTS DEDICATED TO CRITICAL ISSUES OF THE DAY
Course Catalog
These forums allow you to meet in a setting that focuses on trust and peer-to-peer sharing. RMEL roundtables serve as a catalyst for future program development. By increasing your participation in discussion forums and enhancing roundtables, you can maximize the potential of the RMEL community and network with RMEL contacts throughout the year — whether you are at an RMEL event, your desk or in the field.
Bring an RMEL workshop to your location or region. Refer to the course catalog for your section to choose a course from a listing of successful RMEL events, which will be taught by an instructor RMEL has worked with in the past. These are not scheduled events and are specifically designed to custom-fit your needs and timetable.
RECURRING EVENTS LET YOU PLAN AHEAD
Core events in each section are scheduled for the
SINCE 1977. TRANSMISSION LINES DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS SUBSTATIONS/SWITCHYARDS
From year to year, RMEL will offer new events in each section to cover the latest technologies, evolving trends and critical issues that aren’t covered at core events. These events will zero in on your top priorities at any given time and may not repeat from year to year. Electives can take the form of an RMEL conference, workshop or roundtable.
DISCUSS YOUR PRIORITIES AND DRIVE RMEL CONTENT
Core Events
POWER TO
BRING RMEL COURSES TO YOU
Use this Education Edition of Electric Energy magazine to reintroduce yourself to RMEL education, and learn more about RMEL by visiting www.RMEL.org.
303.688.5816 gswc.us MYR Group Inc. is an Equal Opportunity Employer M/F/Disabled/Veteran. ©2017MYRGROUPINC.
W W W. R M EL .O R G
33
TRAINING NEEDS
RMEL MEMBER TRAINING NEEDS RMEL’s diverse membership includes electric utilities of all types and services and supplier companies. These are the collective responses from 2017 RMEL event attendees when asked about their biggest training needs. presentation at one of the RMEL A conferences (Renewables maybe) that addresses storage of energy for when the wind quits blowing and the sun stops shining dvanced design, large subs, large A commercial, line ext, dual feed, duel circuit
D istribution challenges
Consistency at the management level. (treating everyone the same)
D istribution Solar Integration
Craft specific training; Journeymen level training on annual basis, we just don’t have it!
D istribution standards
D istribution operations
D istribution staking design
D OL certifications
AMR/AMI training
Cross pollination, new manager training
sset Management – getting the A most out of our existing equipment
E ducating employees on helping to secure assets
Culture change Customer-side distributed energy resources (DER) and community solar gardens
E lectric system design training. Substation, grounding distribution & sub transmission line design, VG design, metering
Cyber Security
E lectricity 101
Asset management/health
Data clean-up
E ndpoint security
sset Risk presentation. EcoA nomic benefits of Preventative Maintenance vs run to failure
Deep dive into CIP 14
E nergy Trading Risk Management, Enterprise Risk Management.
sset management for determinA ing life cycle of existing plants and how the data is integrated into IRP analysis.
Basics of Power industry BESS hange management and doing C things differently ollaboration! Engineering and C construction collaboration Communication skills Compliance training Compliance/regulatory
34
onflict resolution & fielding C customer complaints
ELECTRIC ENERGY | WINTER 2017
Design classes Development of Leaders ifference between transmission D & distribution systems, design challenges, etc.
E ngineering E qui-potential grounding, cable pulling best practices E rgonomics, stretching, exposure (silica)
Different types of Design training in both Distribution & Network Design.
E verything covered is very familiar & similar to how we design.
Distribution Automation and Modeling (ETAP)
F inancial for IOUs
E xposure to various practices
TRAINING NEEDS
F ocusing on Building/Developing New/Younger employees G o in-depth on transformers and UG terminations (at switches, transformers…)
“We need training on training inside of our company and passing on useful information from seasoned personnel to newcomers.”
G ood basics, AE specific
New engineer protection training
S mart-grid info
H aven’t been there long enough yet
New engineer training
S oftware training
New technology
H ow to respond to the market and future demands.
New technology in distribution.
S treet light design & standards for LEP?
H uman Performance
New technology or new solutions
S uccession strategies S upervisor training on safety
In my dept., basic/introduction to distribution & design, for new hires.
ew utility standards may be N good to include or any updates on code that are important
I ndustry dynamics and the potential positive outcomes
ptions for generation as coal O goes away (PNM for example)
I nput studies for wind & solar facilities
Organizational development
echnical content and interdisciT plinary training
Organizational Development, Communication
T echnical training on the integration of renewables
Pad mount installation & overhead
T echnology advancement education – latest developments in the industry
I nspections and maintenance training by substation and transmission journeymen I nvolvement in being willing to speak up L eadership L ine tensioning on uneven terrain; specification oad forecasting and planning, L more on batteries, smart grid renewables L ow impact physical/cyber security initiatives M anaging change; Human Performance M arket diversity, developing technologies M entoring M entoring plan’s for succession M entoring program M icrogrids
Planning Pole staking & line extensions ole weight analyzing for selfP supporting ower/Distribution engineering P includes protection and design rimarily internal only on business P processes due to high number of new staff rocurement/Contracts/Inventory P Management roject Management and entry P level engineer training specific to the industry
S upervisory training S ystem knowledge since we have such a large footprint
The Art of Mentoring and Coaching T ime management T ime management and process creation/automation/streamlining T raining on distribution SCADA controls, voltage control, renewable energy impacts T rain-the-trainer, developing PowerPoint presentation T ransmission Design U nderstanding and importance of security
Renewable energy
U nderstanding markets
Renewable energy integration at the distribution level, system protection, training new engineers - distribution
U nderstanding of client project objectives nderstanding roles within organiU zation while still facilitating input
M inimum and mandatory skill sets for engineers and designers
Safety Safety leadership
U nderstanding utilities knowledge of the market and their concerns
M ore continuous professional training/seminars
Safety, new technologies
V alue
SCADA
W e need better IT resources; also utilizing GIS assets
ore education on primary M metering and certain metering applications oving younger employees into M management; capturing experience before people retire
SCADA/EMS overview Security Security & Compliance Security awareness that is engaging & interesting and not dry
W here is the generation future taking us? What to do with people from retiring plants W ire tension
N ERC CIP
W W W. R M EL .O R G
35
Awards Record 42 SCHOLARSHIPS FOR THE 2017-2018 ACADEMIC YEAR, THE RMEL Foundation has awarded scholarships to 42 deserving students pursuing careers in the electric energy industry. The RMEL Foundation Scholarship Selection Committee received 300 well-qualified applications in 2017. With students applying from across the United States and pursuing many worthwhile
degrees and careers in the electric energy industry, it was very difficult for the committee to select the recipients out of such a high caliber pool of applicants. At least two of this year’s scholarships recipients are interning at two RMEL member companies this summer. The RMEL Foundation is here to connect students to this industry.
NEW CRAFT SCHOLARSHIP RECIPIENTS
GRIFFIN BATES
Southeast Community College MAJOR: Energy Generation Operations
RETURNING CRAFT SCHOLARSHIP RECIPIENTS
DEVIN VANSPEREN
36
BO HOLTHUS
Western Nebraska Community College COMPLETING: Lineworker Program
JACOB NELSON
Southeast Community College STUDYING: Energy Generation Operations
FoRMEL SCHOLARSHIP
ZACH HEITKAMP
TY JONES
Southeast Community College
University of Nebraska, Lincoln
Southeast Community College
MAJOR: Electrical and Electromechanical Technology
MAJOR: Mechanical Engineering
MAJOR: Energy Generation Operations
ELECTRIC ENERGY | WINTER 2017
2017-2018 BACCALAUREATE SCHOLARSHIP RECIPIENTS
PRESTON BARRETT
NOAH BELL
TRENTON CHRAMOSTA
University of Nebraska, Lincoln
Northern Arizona University
University of Nebraska, Kearney
MAJOR: Mechanical Engineering
MAJOR: Electrical Engineering
MAJOR: Computer Science and Information Technology
ZACHARY CHURCHWELL
AMBER COOK
University of Wyoming
CMIS at Peru State College
MAJOR: Electrical Engineering
MAJOR: Business Management
JACOB ECKSTROM
CALVIN HAENSEL
University of Nebraska, Omaha
Cal Poly San Luis Obispo
MAJOR: Electrical Engineering
MAJOR: Engineering
EMMA DAGERMAN
University of Nebraska, Lincoln MAJOR: Civil Engineering
ADAM HARRIS
Purdue University MAJOR: Engineering W W W. R M EL .O R G
37
2017-2018 BACCALAUREATE SCHOLARSHIP RECIPIENTS
BENJAMIN JOHNSON
HANNAH LIVINGSTON
University of Nebraska, Lincoln
University of Colorado, Boulder
MAJOR: Electrical Engineering
MAJOR: Civil Engineering
MAJOR: Electrical Engineering
ALEXANDER NELSON
DONALD OKOYE
Kansas State University
Texas A&M University
MAJOR: Mechanical & Nuclear Engineering
MAJOR: Electrical Engineering
PAUL QUINTANA
38
BLAKE LENNERS
University of Nebraska, Omaha
JULIA REDMOND
Colorado School of Mines
University of Colorado, Denver
MAJOR: Electrical Engineering
MAJOR: Electrical Engineering
ELECTRIC ENERGY | WINTER 2017
THUAN PHAM
University of Houston MAJOR: Electrical Engineering
MITCHELL ROBERTS
Engineering and Economics MAJOR: Washington Lee University
2017-2018 BACCALAUREATE SCHOLARSHIP RECIPIENTS
2017-2018 BACCALAUREATE SCHOLARSHIP RETURNING RECIPIENTS:
MITCHELL KHOURI
MIKAELA SALZETTI
Colorado School of Mines MAJOR: Mechanical Engineering
Arizona State University
MAJOR: Electrical Engineering
MAJOR: Chemical Engineering
JOSE GUERRERO
HOLLY TURMAN
Texas A&M University MAJOR: Mechanical Engineering
TESSA MURDOCK
Colorado School of Mines
TRISTIN STEINER
New Mexico State University
University of Wisconsin, Madison
MAJOR: Engineering
MAJOR: Electrical Engineering
2017 Steve Bridges RMEL Foundation Scholarship
CONNIE WENTWORTH Missouri University of Science & Technology
JACOB WOOD
CADE MCCOY
Arizona State University
Kansas State University
MAJOR: Electrical Engineering
MAJOR: Mechanical Engineering
MAJOR: Electrical Engineering
W W W. R M EL .O R G
39
2017-2018 BACCALAUREATE SCHOLARSHIP RECIPIENTS
2017 Black & Veatch Scholarship DEVIN KEEN
University of Missouri Science & Technology MAJOR: Electrical Engineering
2017 Platte River Power Authority Roy J. Rohla Memorial Scholarship BRETT JOHNSON
Colorado State University
JACKSON CUTSOR
University of Nebraska, Lincoln
2017 Kiewit Scholarship LAUREN RIPPY
Baylor University
MAJOR: Electrical Engineering
MAJOR: Mechanical Engineering
2017 South Dakota School of Mines Alumni Scholarship
2017 South Dakota School of Mines Alumni Scholarship
TYLER KLEINSASSER
DEREK BAIN
South Dakota School of Mines and Technology
South Dakota School of Mines and Technology.
MAJOR: Civil Engineering
MAJOR: Electrical Engineering
2017 SRP Scholarship
2017 Ulteig Engineers Inc Scholarship
2017 Zachry Group Scholarship
MATTHEW KOSEDNAR
GARRETT BEMBENEK
MAJOR: Environmental Engineering
Arizona State University MAJOR: Electrical Engineering
40
2017 Burns & McDonnell Scholarship
ELECTRIC ENERGY | WINTER 2017
Colorado School of Mines
MAJOR: Electrical Engineering
ADAM LONG
University of Minnesota, Twin Cities MAJOR: Mechanical Engineering
THANK YOU to Auction Item Donors and Bidders, Cash Donors and FoRMEL for Helping Us Raise $55,000 for Scholarships at the 2017 Fall Convention JOHN AHERNE Kiewit
BRUCE & TAMI AKIN Westar Energy
ANTHONY MONTOYA Western Area Power Administration
ARROWHEAD GOLF CLUB ELAINA BALL
THOMAS FALLON
Kansas City Power & Light
PAMELA FEUERSTEIN
Integrated Security Corporation
MATTHEW KAYE
RICHARD & BARBARA PENA
Retired- CPS Energy
JASON KELLY
RICK & SUSIE PUTNICKI
Intermountain Rural Electric Association
DAVID FULFORD
Asplundh Tree Expert Company
DIANE GIACOMOZZI
MasTec Power Corporation
PAUL BARHAM
GRAND HYATT SAN ANTONIO
KURT BATTEN
Lynn Elliott Co., K.C., Inc.
DAN BECKMANN
KEVIN NOBLET
Verve Industrial Protection
Austin Energy CPS Energy
RICK KAUN
Sea Glass Fine Art Photography
DON GRAY
Kansas City Board of Public Utilities
POWER Engineers, Inc.
MARK KELLY
RMEL
ANDY RAMIREZ
NASA
El Paso Electric Company
RODNEY KENAGY
SALT RIVER PROJECT
Graybar Electric
TOM KENT
Nebraska Public Power District
KEYSTONE RESORT & SPA
GAYE LYNN SCHAFFART Tensaska Marketing Ventures
KURT SCHNUBEL Osmose
Westwood Professional Services
GREAT SOUTHWESTERN CONSTRUCTION, INC.
MIKE KOTARA Zachry Group
Hubbell Power Systems
JERRY BENNETT
BOB AND EILEEN GRESHAM
LA POSADA DE SANTA FE
MIKE SOCHA
Irwin Industries, Inc.
BLACK & VEATCH CORP. BLACK HILLS CORPORATION JOEL BLADOW
Tri-State Generation & Transmission Assn.
GRETA BODENHAM
Exponential Engineering Company
TOM BOZEMAN AECOM
TIM BROSSART Xcel Energy
PAUL COMPTON Kiewit
SAMUEL DE LA ROSA UC Synergetic
DENVER MARRIOTT SOUTH AT PARK MEADOWS BILL ENGLAND
Emerson Process Management
Zachry Group
GRANT GROTHEN Burns & McDonnell
JON HANSEN Omaha Public Power District
KELLY AND TANJA HARRISON
BRIAN LARSON
Basin Electric Power Cooperative
DAVID LEBLANC
BRIAN SERATI
Volkert, Inc.
JACK STEVENSON
Altec Industries, Inc.
HOSSEIN TABRIZI
AECOM
Ulteig Engineers, Inc.
MIKE MAGA
JENNIFER TIBBETTS
DMC Power
MARK MANSFIELD
Westar Energy
UNS Energy Corporation
HDR, INC.
RICHARD AND HELEN MATZKE
Power Equipment Specialists, Inc.
JILL TIETJEN
Technically Speaking, Inc.
JEFF WADSWORTH
GARY HELLARD
Texas New Mexico Power
Babcock & Wilcox
The Empire District Electric Company
RICK HELLEBUYCK
JIM MITCHELL
Babcock Power, Inc.
Babcock & Wilcox
Mitsubishi Hitachi Power Systems America
KARIN HOLLOHAN
TONY AND TRACY MONTOYA
WESTIN LA PALOMA RESORT & SPA
MIKE MORRIS
Associated Electric Cooperative, Inc.
Platte River Power Authority
TIM HUGHES
Hughes Brothers, Inc.
Western Area Power Administration
HUNGRY EYE MEDIA
Zachry Group
BARRY AND DENISE INGOLD
MYCOFF, FRY & PROUSE LLC
KELLEN WALTERS
KEN WILMOT
Tri-State Generation and Transmission Assn.
W W W. R M EL .O R G
41
CALENDAR OF EVENTS
2018 Calendar of Events OCTOBER
4
Planning Session: 2019 Spring Conference Lone Tree, CO
AUGUST
1-2
Plant Management, Engineering Operations Conference
JANUARY
18
Introduction to the Electric Utility Workshop Lone Tree, CO
30-31
Physical and Cyber Security Conference Tempe, AZ
21-22
Distribution Operations and Maintenance Conference Lone Tree, CO
APRIL
18-19
Safety Conference Lone Tree, CO
FEBRUARY
MAY
23
20-22
Safety Roundtable Westminster, CO
MARCH
7-8
Spring Management, Engineering and Operations Conference Keystone, CO
27
Lone Tree, CO
15-16
Developing Future Leaders
24
Safety Roundtable Golden, CO
SEPTEMBER
16-18
Fall Executive Leadership and Management Convention San Antonio, TX
17-18
Renewable Planning and Operations Conference Lone Tree, CO
NOVEMBER
2
Safety Roundtable TDB
14-15
Littleton, CO
2018 RMEL Foundation Golf Tournament
Transmission Planning and Underground Operations and Maintenance Conference Lone Tree, CO
42
Distribution Engineers Workshop
JUNE
Power Supply Planning and Projects Conference Lone Tree, CO
10-11
ELECTRIC ENERGY | WINTER 2017
CONTINUING EDUCATION CERTIFICATES Continuing education certificates awarding Professional Development Hours are provided to attendees at all RMEL education events. Check the event brochure for details on the number of hours offered at each event.
RMEL FOUNDATION
RMEL Foundation
YEAR
2000
$5,000
$500
2005
2010
$109,500
TOTAL SCHOLARSHIP MONEY AWARDED
$32,000
BY THE NUMBERS
Nearly 300 students applied for the RMEL Foundation Scholarship in 2017.
THE NAMED SCHOLARSHIP PROGRAM BEGAN IN 2007 WITH ONE SPONSORED SCHOLARSHIP, SPONSORED BY WÄRTSILÄ.
2017
*Live and silent auction donations
In 2017,
FALL CONVENTION FUNDRAISING NETTED
$55,000 IN 2017!
42 SCHOLARSHIPS were awarded.
FOR 2017, THERE WERE 9 NAMED SCHOLARSHIPS SPONSORS: Black & Veatch, Burns and McDonnell, Kiewit, Platte River River Power Authority, an anonymous South Dakota School of Mines & Technology Alumni, SRP, Ulteig, Zachry and Friends of RMEL (individuals who donated toward a named scholarship).
Over the past
17 YEARS
the Foundation has awarded
270 scholarships totaling
$667,000 ALL RMEL members can access a vetted list of applicants who gave their permission to be contacted about internship opportunities. Request the list by emailing info@rmel.org.
W W W. R M EL .O R G
43
MEMBER LISTINGS
Member Listings 1
ABB, Inc.
48 City of Fountain
94 Genscape, Inc.
2
ADA Carbon Solutions, LLC
49 City of Gallup Electric Department
95 Golder Associates, Inc.
3 Advanced Electrical & Motor Controls, Inc.
50 City of Garden City
96 Grand Island Utilities
51
97 Grand Valley Rural Power Lines, Inc.
4 AECOM
52 City of Glenwood Springs
98 Great Southwestern Construction, Inc.
5
Alexander Publications
53 City of Imperial
99 GSW Integrated Services
6
Altec Industries, Inc.
54 City of Yuma
7
American Coal Council
55 Classic Industrial Services, Inc.
100 Gunnison County Electric Association, Inc.
8
American Public Power Association
56 Co-Mo Electric Cooperative
101 Hamilton Associates, Inc.
9 Arizona Electric Power Cooperative, Inc.
57 Collaborative Learning, Inc./ Collaboration Unlimited
102 Harris Group, Inc.
10 Arizona Public Service
58 Colorado Highlands Wind LLC
103 Hartigan Power Equipment Company
11
Arkansas River Power Authority
59 Colorado Rural Electric Association
104 HDR
12
Asplundh Tree Expert Co.
60 Colorado Springs Utilities
105 High Energy Inc. (HEI)
13
Associated Electric Cooperative, Inc.
61
106 Highline Electric Assn.
Colorado State University
14 Atwell, LLC
62 Commonwealth Associates, Inc.
107 Holy Cross Energy
15
Austin Energy
63 ComRent
108 Hubbell Power Systems
16
AZCO INC.
64 CPS Energy
109 Hughes Brothers, Inc.
17
Babcock & Wilcox Company
65 Culture Change Consultants
110 IBEW, Local Union 111
18 Babcock Power, Inc.
66 D.C. Langley Energy Consulting, LLC
111 IEC Rocky Mountain
19
67 Day & Zimmermann
112 IMCORP
20 Basin Electric Power Cooperative
68 Delta Montrose Electric Assn.
21
69 DIS-TRAN Packaged Substations, LLC
113 Incorporated County of Los Alamos Department of Public Utilities
Barton Malow Company Beckwith Electric
22 Beta Engineering
70 DMC Power Inc.
23 Black & Veatch Corp.
71
24 Black Hills Corporation
72 E3 Consulting
25 Black Hills Electric Cooperative
73 El Paso Electric Company
26 Bohannan Huston, Inc.
74 Electrical Consultants, Inc.
27 Boilermakers Local #101
75 ElectroTech, Inc.
28 Boone Electric Cooperative
76 Emerson Process Management Power & Water Solutions
29 Border States Electric
E & T Equipment, LLC
114 Independence Power & Light 115 Innova Global, Inc. 116 Integrated Security Corporation 117 Intercounty Electric Coop Association 118 Intermountain Rural Electric Assn. 119 ION Consulting 120 Irby
77 The Empire District Electric Company
121 Irwin Power Services
32 Brooks Manufacturing Company
78 Empire Electric Association, Inc.
123 Kansas City Board of Public Utilities
33 Burns & McDonnell
79 Energy & Resource Consulting Group, LLC
124 Kansas City Power & Light
80 Energy Education Council
126 Kiewit
81 Energy Providers Coalition for Education (EPCE)
127 Kit Carson Electric Cooperative
82 Energy Reps
129 Klute Inc. Steel Fabrication
83 ESCÂ engineering
130 L. Keeley Construction
84 Evans, Lipka and Associates, Inc.
131 La Junta Municipal Utilities
85 Evapco - BLCT Dry Cooling, Inc.
132 La Plata Electric Association, Inc.
41 Central Nebraska Public Power and Irrigation District
86 Exponential Engineering Company
133 Lake Region Electric Coop Inc.
87 Fairbanks Morse Engine
134 Lamar Utilities Board
42 Chimney Rock Public Power District
88 Foothills Energy Services Inc.
135 Lampson International LLC
43 City Light & Power, Inc.
89 Fort Collins Utilities
136 Las Animas Municipal Light & Power
44 City of Alliance Electric Department
90 Fuel Tech, Inc.
137 Leidos
45 City of Aztec Electric Department
91
138 Lewis Associates, Inc.
46 City of Cody
92 Garkane Energy Cooperative Inc.
139 Lincoln Electric System
47 City of Farmington
93 GE Power
140 Llewellyn Consulting
30 Bowman Consulting Group 31
Brink Constructors, Inc.
34 Butler Public Power District 35 Carbon Power & Light, Inc. 36 Cargill Industrial Specialties 37 Casey Industrial, Inc. 38 CB&I 39 CDG Engineers, Inc. 40 Center Electric Light & Power System
44
City of Gillette
ELECTRIC ENERGY | WINTER 2017
Gamber-Johnson LLC
122 James Industries, Inc.
125 KD Johnson, Inc.
128 Kleinfelder
141 Longmont Power & Communications
191 Quanta Services
242 United Power, Inc.
142 Loup River Public Power District
192 REC Associates
243 Universal Field Services, Inc.
143 Loveland Water & Power
193 Reliability Management Group (RMG)
144 Magna IV Engineering Inc.
194 Reliable Power Consultants, Inc.
145 Marsulex Environmental Technologies
195 Safety One Training International, Inc.
244 University of Idaho Utility Executive Course College of Business and Economics
146 MasTec Power Corp.
196 San Isabel Electric Association, Inc.
147 Merrick & Company
197 San Marcos Electric Utility
148 Midwest Energy, Inc.
198 San Miguel Power Assn.
149 Missouri River Energy Services
199 Sangre De Cristo Electric Assn.
150 Mitsubishi Hitachi Power Systems Americas, Inc.
200 Sargent & Lundy
151 Morgan County Rural Electric Assn.
202 Schweitzer Engineering Laboratories
152 Morgan Schaffer Inc.
203 Sellon Forensics Inc.
153 Mountain Parks Electric, Inc.
204 Siemens Energy Inc.
154 Mountain States Utility Sales
205 Sierra Electric Cooperative, Inc.
155 Mountain View Electric Association, Inc.
206 Solomon Associates
156 Mycoff, Fry & Prouse LLC
208 Southeast Colorado Power Assn.
157 NAES Corp. 158 Navopache Electric Cooperative, Inc. 159 Nebraska Public Power District 160 NEI Electric Power Engineering, Inc. 161 New Mexico State University 162 Nooter/Eriksen, Inc. 163 Norris Public Power District 164 Northeast Community College 165 Northwest Rural Public Power District 166 Novinium 167 Olsson Associates 168 Omaha Public Power District 169 Osmose Utilities Services, Inc. 170 PacifiCorp 171 Panhandle Rural Electric Membership Assn. 172 PAR Electrical Contractors, Inc. 173 Peterson Company 174 Pioneer Electric Cooperative, Inc. 175 Pipefitters Local Union #208 176 Platte River Power Authority 177 PNM Resources 178 Poudre Valley Rural Electric Assn. 179 Powder River Energy Corp. 180 Power Contracting, LLC 181 POWER Engineers, Inc. 182 Power Equipment Specialists, Inc. 183 Power Pole Inspections
201 Savage
207 South Central PPD 209 Southeast Community College 210 Southern Pioneer Electric Company 211 Southwest Energy Systems LLC 212 Southwest Generation 213 Southwest Public Power District 214 Southwire Company 215 Springfield Municipal Light & Power 216 SPX Transformer Solutions, Inc. 217 SRP 218 St. George Energy Services Department 219 Stanley Consultants, Inc. 220 Sturgeon Electric Co., Inc. 221 Sulphur Springs Valley Electric Cooperative 222 Sundt Construction 223 Sunflower Electric Power Corporation 224 Surveying And Mapping, LLC 225 Switchgear Solutions, Inc. 226 System One
245 UNS Energy Corporation 246 Utility Telecom Consulting Group, Inc. 247 Valmont Utility, Valmont Industries, Inc. 248 Vertiv - Electrical Reliability Services 249 Verve Industrial Protection 250 Victaulic 251 Volkert, Inc. 252 Wärtsilä North America, Inc. 253 West Peak Energy, LLC 254 Westar Energy 255 Western Area Power Administration 256 Western Line Constructors Chapter, Inc. NECA 257 Westmark Partners LLC 258 Westwood Professional Services 259 Wheat Belt Public Power District 260 Wheatland Electric Cooperative 261 Wheatland Rural Electric Assn. 262 White River Electric Assn., Inc. 263 Wichita State University 264 Wilson & Company, Engineers & Architects 265 WSP/Parsons Brinckerhoff 266 WSU Energy Systems Innovation Center 267 Wyoming Municipal Power Agency 268 Xcel Energy 269 Y-W Electric Association, Inc. 270 Yampa Valley Electric Association, Inc. 271 Zachry Group TOTAL NUMBER OF MEMBERS: 271
227 T & R Electric Supply Co., Inc. 228 Technically Speaking, Inc. 229 Tenaska Marketing Ventures 230 TIC - The Industrial Company 231 Towill, Inc. 232 Trans American Power Products, Inc. 233 TRC Engineers, Inc. 234 Trees, Inc.
184 Power Product Services
235 Tri-State Generation and Transmission Assn.
185 PowerQuip Corporation
236 Trinidad Municipal Light & Power
186 PR Engineering
237 TurbinePROS
187 Preferred Sales Agency, Ltd
238 U.S. Water
188 Primary Energy
239 UC Synergetic
189 PSM (Power Systems Mfg., LLC)
240 Ulteig Engineers, Inc.
190 QuakeWrap, Inc.
241 Underground Consulting Solutions
W W W. R M EL .O R G
45
ADVERTISER’S INDEX
Black & Veatch Border States Electric
20
www.bv.com
(913) 458-2000
21
www.borderstates.com
(701) 293-5834
www.burnsmcd.com/RMEL17
(816) 333-9400
Burns McDonnell
Inside Front Cover
Casey Industrial
30
www.caseyind.com
(303) 460-1274
Great Southwestern Construction
33
www.gswc.us
(303) 688-5816
MasTec Power Corp
21
www.mastecpower.com
(888) 419-6432
Merrick & Company
32
www.merrick.com
(303) 751-0741
Mitsubishi Hitachi Power Systems
5
www.mhpowersystems.com
(908) 605-280
Nebraska Public Power District
18
www.nppd.com
(402) 564-8561
Northeast Community College
25
www.northeast.edu
(402) 371-2020
Pike Enterprises, LLC
9
www.pike.comC12
Inside Back Cover
www.siemens.com
Siemens
(336) 789-2171 (303) 696-8446
Six Was Nine
7
www.powerforward2018.org
TDGENERAL@IEEE.ORG
Southeast Community College
13
www.southeast.edu
Stanley Consulting
3
www.stanleyconsultants.com
(800) 878-6806
Sturgeon Electric Co.
32
www.sturgeonelectric.com
(303) 286-8000
T & R Electric Supply Co, Inc.
27
www.t-r.com
(800) 843-7994
TIC - The Industrial Company
Back Cover
www.ticus.com
(303) 325-0300
University of Idaho
17
www.uiuec.org
(208)885-6265
Trees Inc.
46
www.treesinc.com
(866) 865-9617
Washington State University
31
www.esic.wsu.edu
(509) 335-6456
(402) 761-8394
Send Your Message to RMEL Utility Members Providing vegetation management services to the power and energy industries. Line Clearance Storm and Emergency Response Right-of-way Management Herbicide Applications
Trees, Inc. 1-866-865-9617 info@treesinc.com
46
ELECTRIC ENERGY | WINTER 2017
RMEL Champions Program Reach more than 100 utilities through the RMEL Champions Program. This sponsorship program offers exclusive promotional opportunities that are not included in standard RMEL membership. Choose from four levels to customize your membership.
Become a Diamond Champion The Diamond level offers a custom elite sponsorship opportunity in addition to the benefits of the Platinum level. Participation is limited. Contact Ashleigh Iverson at ashleighiverson@rmel.org or (303) 865-5544 to sign up! RMEL | 6855 S. Havana St, Ste 430 Centennial, CO 80112 | (303) 865-5544 www.RMEL.org
W W W. R M EL .O R G
47
POWERED BY PEOPLE. Founded in 1974, TIC – The Industrial Company is a direct-hire general contractor serving a wide range of heavy industrial markets throughout North America. Through our network of local operating centers, access to vast resources and focus on self-performing work, we deliver safe and high-quality results on projects of virtually any size.
TICUS.COM A Kiewit Corporation Subsidiary 48
ELECTRIC ENERGY | WINTER 2017