May 6, 2021

Page 1

May 6, 2021 | Indiana Daily Student | idsnews.com

IDS

Former members of Hope Presbyterian Church in Bloomington allege abuse, cover-up Content warning: This article includes descriptions of sexual harassment and abuse.

Editor's note To report this story, the IDS spent a month talking to three accusers, a church elder and one of the women involved in the initial investigation into Dan Herron. The IDS contacted every person against whom accusations were made. The allegations in the story were quoted and paraphrased from emails, church court documents, Monroe County court documents and interviews. If you or someone you know has experienced sexual harassment or abuse, help is available. Go to bit.ly/reportingresources for a list of onand-off campus resources. We're committed to bringing you stories that matter and holding people in power accountable. To give this story the space it deserves, we will not be running any other news stories on the first four pages of today's print edition. For regular coverage, please visit idsnews. com.

Words by Matt Cohen mdc1@iu.edu | @Matt_Cohen_

Photos by Mallorey Daunhauer mjdaunha@iu.edu | @mal_daun

The founding pastor of Hope Presbyterian Church was charming and charismatic, many agree on that much. Several former members of the Bloomington church said those traits enabled Dan Herron, their pastor, to abuse his power. Some say he sexually harassed them, while others allege exploitation and intimidation. Seeking justice within the church’s government, five accusers wrote a letter in 2019 to the Central Indiana Presbytery outlining allegations against Herron. None of the accusers brought the allegations to police, citing low conviction rates for sex crimes and fear of retraumatization. The Presbytery’s court system has the power to revoke Herron’s ordination and prevent him from working within the Presbyterian Church in America again, but it has no legal authority. An Indiana Daily Student reporter

reached out to Herron over the phone and offered to provide him with a list of allegations, which Herron declined. In a written statement to the Indiana Daily Student after the phone call, Herron said, “With regard to the specific accusations brought against me that I am aware of, I strongly and unequivocally deny any wrongdoing attributed to my actions, words, motivations, and character.” To report this story, the IDS spoke to three accusers — Abigail Harris, Kara Million and her husband Chris Baker — and reviewed documents including church court files and emails. Million said she has met or spoken to at least 10 other people with various accusations of abuse against Herron since sending the original letter. Those accusers, mostly couples, made their allegations anonymously to the church’s government. Million and Harris, who know their identities, said the anonymous accusers did not wish to be identified to the IDS to be contacted for comment. Nearly two years after the investigation into Herron’s alleged abuse began, the PCA’s

highest court called for the CIP to restart the investigation process. Herron’s accusers believe the initial investigation, which closed in February 2020 and found Herron had “no strong presumption of guilt,” was intentionally mishandled to protect him. A spokesperson for the CIP said he could not comment for this story because the new investigation, which began in February, is ongoing. Every person named in this story and each member of the original investigation commission was contacted several times for comment. Most of the 14 people contacted did not respond, and most of those who did said they could not comment because of the ongoing investigation. Bob O’Bannon, who was the chair of the initial investigation, responded to “emphatically deny that there was any coverup by the commission.” The Sunday after the IDS reached out for comment but before this story was published, a Hope member told the IDS there had been a congregation meeting earlier that day where Hope leaders made congregants

aware of this story. According to that member, the Hope leadership did not confirm nor refute any of the allegations in this story at the meeting. The next CIP meeting is on May 14, where there will be a vote on whether there is enough evidence against Herron to move to trial. If the committee does not find sufficient evidence against him, Herron will be exonerated in the church’s government for good. Because of his role as an elder in the CIP, Herron can vote on all investigations — even those into his actions. Women, however, are not allowed to be elders and thus cannot vote. Herron resigned from Hope in January 2020 but retains his role as an elder. He is still ordained as of early May. Herron began a yearlong, paid sabbatical after resigning. The accusers allege leaders within the CIP enabled Herron and protected him throughout the investigation. The same leaders who voted on the initial investigation will vote on the findings of the new one. SEE CHURCH, PAGE 2


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.
May 6, 2021 by Indiana Daily Student - idsnews - Issuu