Wednesday, April 12, 2017 | Indiana Daily Student | idsnews.com
IDS
Timeline of Murray’s talk, protests 5:20 p.m. Protesters gather outside Franklin Hall in Dunn Meadow and near Sample Gates. EMILY MILES | IDS
Protesters stand at the edge of a barricade blocking them from entering Franklin Hall while social scientist Charles Murray spoke inside. Many of the signs expressed themes of intolerance of white supremacy, betrayal and injustice.
SHATTERED SILENCE Charles Murray speaks at IU despite student protests By Lydia Gerike lgerike@umail.iu.edu | @lydi_yeah
Charles Murray’s exit from Presidents Hall happened just as quickly and quietly as the promotion of his talk days before. As he gave his speech Tuesday evening, the controversial social scientist’s voice carried over muted noises that, from inside the building, sounded like a broken metronome and people screaming on a roller coaster. Murray paused. “What I’m going to do is I’m just going to ignore them,” he said. Outside, the sounds were much clearer. Protesters filled the area between Franklin Hall and Sample Gates and screamed, “Fuck Charles Murray.” One man banged a pot with a tire iron near the windows of Presidents Hall by Indiana Avenue. A Twix bar hung casually from his mouth.
As he clanged the metal objects together, Tom Westgard, 46, said he wasn’t worried about the police or the barricades they had set up in front of Franklin Hall, especially because his new spot was not guarded by law enforcement. “I’m not sure there’s much they can do with me outside on a public sidewalk,” Westgard said. Although Westgard, a Bloomington resident, has protested in the past, he had never used this noisy method before. The pot was severely dented on the bottom from his banging, and he said his girlfriend’s pitbull, Birdie, probably wouldn’t be able to use it as a dish any longer. On the other side of Sample Gates, a young boy in a unicorn mask stood on the makeshift fence and raised his middle fingers to police. The yellow SEE PROTEST, PAGE 4
IU students, Bloomington residents protest Murray By Hannah Boufford hbouffor@umail.iu.edu @hannahboufford
Robert and Judy Woodley were the first people lined up at the ticket entry Tuesday night by Franklin Hall to see controversial social scientist and author Charles Murray speak. “I think Charles Murray is an important voice,” Robert said. “Whether you agree or not.” Robert said he had read Murray’s book “Coming Apart” and agreed with what Murray said about society dividing into two parts. However, Robert said he did not agree with Murray’s conclusions in his book “The Bell Curve.” In the book, there was a section that featured a discussion on racial differences affecting intelligence that caused controversy. From inside Presidents
Hall, Robert said he believed that the security outside the building seemed like overkill. While he said he believes protesting is a right to exercise, preventing someone from speaking was inexcusable. While the protests outside did not prohibit Murray from speaking about how the new upper class led to the election of President Trump, he did have to fight to ignore the commotion from outside the windows. The last question of the night asked Murray how he wanted to respond to the protesters. “I really wish you kept quiet while I was speaking,” he said. Throughout the speech, chants of “Charles Murray, go away” and “Fuck Charles Murray” were audible SEE REACTIONS, PAGE 4
Rabbi, Jewish students discuss growing anti-Semitic sentiments By Christine Fernando ctfernan@indiana.edu | @christinetfern
The first time IU freshman Jillian Osheroff ’s father traveled to the South, he was called out for being a Jew. “Where are your horns?” one man asked him. However, the issue of anti-Semitism isn’t limited to the South, Rabbi Sue Silberberg said. Silberberg has seen swastikas drawn on Jewish students’ dormitory room dry erase boards. She’s talked to countless students who have been the butt of jokes about their Jewish heritage. She’s even heard of a swastika etched onto the elevator walls at an IU residence hall. In the last year, Silberberg, executive director of the Helene G. Simon Hillel Center, said she has seen a rise in prejudice toward Jews on campus. “Every day, Jewish students have to face jokes and comments just for being who they are,” Silberberg said. She said these instances, paired with recent bomb threats against Jewish community centers, show that anti-Semitism is not just in the past but a growing problem today. Fifty-two percent of Americans are concerned about recent violence directed at Jews, according to a study published Thursday by the Anti-Defamation League. Almost half, 47 percent, of Americans said anti-Semitism has become a greater problem since the 2016 election than ever before in recent history. As anti-Semitism grows,
5:30 p.m. The protest officially begins with remarks from IU student Julian Epp from the Young Democratic Socialists of Bloomington. The “Rally Against Charles Murray” was organized by IU English Grad Solidarity Coalition. 6:00 p.m. Protesters move from the central area outside of the main Franklin Hall entrance to the side of the building on Indiana Avenue so their chants and music could be heard inside Presidents Hall where Murray is speaking. 6:30 p.m. Protesters spread out to the exits around Franklin Hall and continue their chants while waiting for Murray to leave. 7:57 p.m. Police take protester and IU senior Stella Shaffer into Franklin Hall with her hands tied behind her back in zip ties. Shaffer burned a ticket to the Murray speech Monday. 8:00 p.m. Protesters chant “Let Stella go” at officers in front of Franklin Hall. 8:05 p.m. Police block the entrance to Franklin Hall after barricades were taken down and prevent the protesters from accessing the building. 8:10 p.m. Shaffer is released from police custody and returns to the protest. 8:20 p.m. Protesters continue shouting at the police in front of Franklin Hall. 8:55 p.m. Police go inside Franklin Hall while protesters remain. 9:00 p.m. Protesters start leaving the Franklin Hall steps. Online View photo galleries, videos, social media updates, opinion pieces and more for additional coverage.
MEN’S BASKETBALL
Four Hoosiers declare for draft; Anunoby hires agent From IDS reports
ADELINA JUSUF | IDS
Rabbi Sue Silberberg, executive director of Helene G. Simon Hillel Center at IU, responded to recent threats against the Jewish community.
Silberberg said much of the responsibility in combating it should fall in the hands of the government. “The government really sets the tone for the rest of the country,” Silberberg said. “It’s their responsibility to make sure it’s one of acceptance instead of hatred.” Like Silberberg, 84 percent of Americans believe the government should play a role in curbing antiSemitism. Only 49 percent said President Trump should have done more to discourage anti-Semitism, according to the same study. However, Silberberg said Trump failed in discouraging anti-Semitism so far because he has created a culture in which prejudice toward
minorities is tolerated and even expected. Through his rhetoric, Trump validated anti-Semites and made them feel justified in voicing their hatred, Silberberg said. “Because of the political climate, hateful people really felt comfortable coming out of the woodwork to voice their hatred against Jews and any other minority in this country,” she said. Brian Dickstein, IU sophomore and Jew, said Trump has also failed in speaking out against those who voice such hatred. He said Trump’s silence has been disheartening for the entire Jewish community. SEE ANTI-SEMITISM, PAGE 4
LIVE UPDATES | MULTIMEDIA | + MORE
Junior guards Rob Johnson and James Blackmon Jr., along with sophomore forwards OG Anunoby and Thomas Bryant, declared for the 2017 NBA Draft, IU announced Tuesday. Johnson, Blackmon and Bryant will not hire agents, which allows them to come back to IU if they choose. “These four young men all have unique talents and we support them in their decisions,” IU Coach Archie Miller said in a release. “We congratulate O.G. and hope that James, Robert and Thomas can benefit from this and make the best decision that will have a lifelong impact.” Blackmon averaged 17 points per game last season and was named to the All-Big Ten Third Team. He currently ranks 33rd in school history with 1,235 career points. “My ultimate goal has always been to play professionally, and this is an opportunity I want to take advantage of,” Blackmon said in a release. “This is an important process, and I am excited to take part in it.” Johnson has made 87 starts for IU and averaged 12.8 points per game last season as a junior. “I’m excited to go through this
idsnews.com & @idsnews
process and use this as a learning experience,” Johnson said in a release. “Every player in college has the goal to compete at the highest level, and I’m looking forward to what the future may hold.” Bryant has started all 69 games that he has played in for IU and averaged 12.6 points per game this past season. “I’m going to put all my energy in getting the most out of this opportunity and see what the best decision will be for my future,” Bryant said in the release. “I love IU and my teammates, but having the opportunity to play basketball for a living has always been my dream.” Anunoby is the only one of the four to hire an agent. He suffered a season-ending knee injury at Penn State in January but averaged 11.1 points and 5.4 rebounds per game before getting hurt. “I have enjoyed my time at Indiana, and after thinking this over with my family, I believe this is the best decision for me personally,” Anunoby said in the release. “I will always be grateful to Coach Crean, his staff and especially my teammates for two of the best years of my life. I wish Coach Miller and the program the best of luck in the future.” Andrew Hussey