Table of Contents 1 Preface: What Gap Says Is Not What Old Navy Does...by Charles Kernaghan 5 Executive Summary 6 9 10 11 12 12 14 15 18 19 20 23 24 24 28 31 36 37 38 41 43 46 52 52 53 53 54 57 59 59 60
Next Collections, Where Grueling Forced Labor Is the Norm Gap Workers Are Trapped in Misery At Next Collections, the Minimum Shift Is 14 hours Grueling Hours – Even during Ramadan Women Denied Their Maternity Benefits, Trapped in Extreme Poverty I. Testimony of Zesmin Khatun Base Wages the Garment Workers Need to Survive II. Testimony of Morium Begum Total Disregard for a Woman’s Health Workers Cursed and Beaten at Next Collections Sweatshop III. Testimony of Taniya Begum Maternity Benefits and Wages Owed Police Force in Bangladesh Wracked with Corruption and Graft Statement by Mazharul Islam: Beaten with sticks and threatened with death A Brave Young Worker Blows the Whistle on Gross Overtime Violations Next Collections Scam Goes Right to the Top, Implicating Gap and the Ha-Meem Group Driven by Hunger and Long Hours, Workers Strike for Food and Win. Worker Leader Threatened and Fired Ha-Meem Group’s That’s It Sportswear: 29 Workers Killed, 100 Injured Corporate Responsibility in Gap/Old Navy’s Supply Chain What Must Be Done To End Gross Sweatshop Violations at Next Collections of the Ha-Meem Group Addenda A. Company Profiles B. Baby’s Jeans from Next Collections to Gap/Old Navy Distribution Center in Ohio C. Form of Resignation Letter D. Work Hour Regulation in Bangladesh E. Maternity Leave Law in Bangladesh F. Pay Grades in Bangladesh’s Garment Industry G. Zesmin Khatun’s Pregnancy Documentation H. Mazharul’s Medical Documents I. Complaint Filed by Taniya Begum at Ashulia Police Station J. Managers at the Next Collections Limited K. Illegal and Excessive Overtime
October 2013 Author Charles Kernaghan Research Barbara Briggs, Elana Szymkowiak, Brennan Kaye, Jennifer Martin We would like to thank Scott Prouty, who joined Charles Kernaghan, Barbara Briggs and the Institute’s South Asia team in Bangladesh, for generously lending his skills as a photographer, videographer and social media campaigner to help the Bangladeshi workers win justice. Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights (Formerly National Labor Committee) 5 Gateway Center, 6F, Pittsburgh, PA 15222 , U.S.A. +1-412-562-2406 | inbox@glhr.org | www.globallabourrights.org
1
1
Preface
What Gap Says Is Not What Old Navy Does By Charles Kernaghan Director, Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights In fact, Gap and Old Navy appear to have no idea what is going on at the Next Collections Limited factory — part of the massive Ha-Meem Group in Bangladesh — where their garments are being sewn. And this despite the fact that Gap and Old Navy appear to account for 70 percent of total production at the factory! If Gap/Old Navy have deployed “corporate monitors” to audit working conditions, hours and wages at the Next Collections factory, we urge Gap to release its audit reports. We can, however, inform Gap and Old Navy that the 3,750 workers at the Next Collections Limited factory in Ashulia are routinely forced to work over 100 hours a week, while being shortchanged of their legal wages — which are already well below subsistence levels. Gap is in violation of its own code of conduct and these abuses have been going on for more than two and a half years. The giant Ha-Meem Group, with its 26 factories, including Next Collections, and well over 30,000 garment workers, is in serious violation of Bangladesh’s labor laws and the International Labour Organization’s internationally recognized worker rights standards. Across the giant Ha-Meem Group of garment factories, workers are being routinely cheated of approximately
15 percent of their legal overtime wages. In this report, we provide documentation to confirm these serious violations. We hope that Mr. Stefan Larsson, Global President of Old Navy, will meet with the Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights, in Bangladesh, at his earliest convenience. Young women sewing Old Navy children’s clothing have been arbitrarily fired and denied their paid maternity leave, while also being shortchanged of their outstanding legal benefits. A young woman just 20 years of age recently lost her baby in her seventh month of pregnancy due to being forced to work over 100 hours a week. She was working on Old Navy jeans. It does not have to be this way. I believe that if we can work together in good faith, both Gap and the Bangladeshi workers will be better off. For over two decades, the powerful Ha-Meem Group of factories has actively blocked the garment workers’ right to organize an independent union. We hope that Gap/Old Navy agrees that Bangladeshi garment workers — among the hardest working yet poorest workers in the world — should have their legal rights respected.
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
2
Children’s jeans made in Bangladesh on display in an Old Navy store in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
3
3
Workers smuggled Old Navy skinny and bootcut jeans hangtags out of the Next Collections factory in July 2013. These jeans are sold for $19.50 in the United States. It is excellent that Old Navy hangtags are made of recycled material. It would be great if Gap showed a similar concern for the workers who toil under horrific conditions, making Gap and Old Navy clothing at the Next Collections sweatshop.
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
4
“Made in Bangladesh” Old Navy jeans sewn by young workers at the Next Collections factory.
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
5
5
Next Collections Limited factory in Ashulia, Bangladesh.
Executive Summary Next Collections Sweatshop, part of the Ha-Meem Group in Bangladesh • • • • • • •
• •
The 3,750-worker Next Collections factory in Ashulia, Bangladesh on the outskirts of Dhaka is part of the Ha-Meem Group, Bangladesh’s second largest garment exporter which owns 26 factories and employs over 30,000 workers. At the Next Collections sweatshop, approximately 70 percent of production is for Gap and Old Navy. Gap is the largest specialty apparel chain in the U.S. Next Collections workers are forced to toil 14- to 17-plus-hour shifts, seven days a week, routinely putting in workweeks of over 100 hours. Workers are visibly sick, exhausted and dazed from the grueling and excessive hours. Workers live in poverty, earning just 20 to 24 cents per hour. Physical punishment and illegal firings are the norm. Pregnant women are illegally terminated and denied their legal paid maternity leave. For the last two-and-a-half years, Gap has been complicit with Next Collections/Ha-Meem Group in a scam to defraud the workers of their legal wages and benefits. ─ Management hands out phony pay slips to pretend that Gap is in compliance with legal hours and wages. ─ Workers are paid in cash, off the books and cheated of 15 percent of their grueling overtime hours. Workers are being robbed of hundreds of thousands of dollars a year at Next Collections alone, and millions if one includes all the factories of the Ha-Meem Group. Workers live in miserable poverty in tiny primitive hovels. By the third week in a month, most have no money left for food. Bangladesh garment workers continue to be the hardest workers in the world and are also among the poorest.
* According to the BGMEA (Bangladesh Garment Manufacturers and Exporters Association) directory, Next Collection has 4,500 workers total. The workers estimate of 3,750 is for production workers. * Ha-Meem Group has an estimated 30,000 workers in its 26 woven apparel facilities. Workers estimate that Ha-Meem group has some 60,000 workers in total in its apparel and non-apparel businesses.
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
6
Next Collections Where Grueling Forced Labor Is the Norm Imagine Your Daughter Working Here Late one Saturday night in June, we met with a group of Next Collections workers in a safe location outside Dhaka. We were shocked to see the condition the workers were in. They were exhausted, skinny, dazed and with deep shadows under their bloodshot eyes. In nearly 30 years of interviewing workers across the developing world, we had never seen workers who looked so exhausted. The 3,750 workers at the Next Collections factory work seven days a week, including on Fridays, which is supposed to be their weekly day off. It is typical for the workers to toil from 8:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m., 11:00 p.m., 1:00 a.m., sometimes 3:00 a.m. or even later. Fifteen- to 17-hour shifts are routine in the finishing section. As of the third week in June, these workers had already toiled nine grueling 17-hour shifts, from 8:00 a.m. to 1:00 a.m., eleven 15-hour shifts, from 8:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m. and — on the last day of our visit — a 16-hour shift, from 8:00 a.m. to midnight.
In just 21 days in June, these workers were kept in the factory for a stunning 334 hours! And it is common for these workers to toil 14 ½ to 15 ½-hour shifts on their weekly holiday, Friday, from 8:00 a.m. to 10:30 or 11:30 p.m. We immediately sensed that Next Collections was a place of forced labor, where the normal rules regarding legal working hours, wages or factory conditions do not apply. When workers ask how long their shift will be, their managers always shout the same answer: “Keep working until it is done!” Workers told us that Gap and Old Navy clothing make up about 70 percent of total production at the Next Collections sweatshop. We met with workers again on Sunday, June 23. On that day, they were kept for a 21-hour shift — from 8:00 a.m. to 5:00 a.m.! On the following day, they worked a 19hour shift, from 8:00 a.m. to 3:00 a.m.
Despite the fact that she was pregnant, exhausted and sick, management at the Next Collections factory forced 20-year-old Morium Begum to work over 100 hours a week. She lost her baby in her seventh month of pregnancy. “I gave birth at 9:30 a.m., but the baby was immature and died…That was my first baby which I lost…For me, it is a loss I will never get over.”
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
7
Next Collections Ltd. 1323-1325, Beron, Ashulia Dhaka-1341 Bangladesh Head Office (Ha-Meem Group) 241, Tejgaon Industrial Area Dhaka, Bangladesh
Despite the mind-numbing mandatory overtime, if an exhausted worker arrives even a minute late to work, he or she will be docked their entire attendance bonus. If a worker punches his or her timecard out a minute early, he or she will be docked an entire hour’s wages. Physical punishment is the norm at Next Collections. No matter how many hours a worker has toiled, if she makes an error in production, she will be slapped, shoved or even punched. Anyone who dares challenge the gross human, women’s and workers’ rights violations will be immediately fired. When a young woman helper makes a mistake, management humiliates her in front of all her co-workers, forcing her to stand in front of her sewing line for oneand-a-half hours. Young women are routinely robbed of their legal, paid maternity leave. Once a woman is six months preg-
nant, management begins to harass and bully her to “get out.” These women are fired (or forced to resign) with nothing — denied their maternity benefits, paid vacation days they have earned, their severance pay and sick days. We will provide many concrete examples of how young women workers have been abused and robbed. On Saturday, June 22, 2013, buyers from Gap and Old Navy arrived at the Next Collections factory at around 10:30 a.m. Workers said the buyers looked like us: like “white foreigners.” As always happens before Gap auditors arrive, workers were alerted by management over a loud speaker that buyers were coming. Workers knew the routine and were ready to respond with lies, as instructed: “We work just two hours of overtime a day... We are always paid double time for these overtime hours... Factory conditions are very good... We are given face masks and caps... Yes, there are needle guards...”
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
8 Gap monitors do not spend much time on the plant floor, maybe just 15 or 20 minutes per floor. They take some pictures and then head to the office to meet with management. The bathrooms at Next Collections are normally filthy. But when the buyers come, management has them cleaned and uses air fresheners. The workers were 100 percent adamant that Ministry of Labor officials have never visited or investigated the Next Collections factory, or for that matter any other garment factories. The workers think that if the Ministry of Labor actually did anything, they might have a better life and more decent working conditions. No Bangladeshi worker — and especially those sewing Gap’s Old Navy clothing at the Next Collections factory — can afford to open a bank account. In fact, they told us that they run out of money every month, usually late in the third week of the monthly pay period. Then they have to rely on the cheapest food they can purchase on credit. No matter how long and hard they work, these workers are always behind and never able to catch up. A typical, primitive, one-room hovel that houses two or three workers can cost 2,000 taka [$25.94] a month. Workers have to limit their food costs to just 1,000 taka [$12.98] a month.
Bangladeshi garment sewers are among the hardest workers in the world, and also the poorest. For the last two-and-a-half years, Gap and Old Navy have been blissfully ignorant and totally detached from the actual conditions on the ground in the Next Collections factory, which is an illegal and violent sweatshop. Gap hides behind its phony code of conduct, which is never enforced. Yet Gap happily goes along with the pretense that the workers toil a regular shift of just 48 hours a week and never more than 12 hours of “voluntary” overtime, for a workweek that never exceeds 60 hours, with Fridays off. Gap also assures us that the workers have the right to organize, to form a union and bargain collectively. How easily Gap and Old Navy monitors have allowed themselves to be duped. A high school student would know better. All you need to do would be to drive past the Next Collections facility, where the lights are always on as workers toil well into the night. Parents and their high-school-aged teenagers could watch firsthand as exhausted and gaunt workers stumble out of the factory at midnight, 1:00 a.m., 3:00 a.m., or even 6:00 a.m. But shouldn’t Gap be effectively monitoring hours and conditions, and assuring that its supplier factory complies with the law? What we have here is a denial of truth, integrity and the rule of law. When will Gap come clean?
Working an all-night, 20-hour shift is often required at the Next Collections factory. On this particular day in July 2013, workers toiled a 22-hour shift, sewing jeans and shorts for Old Navy. They left the factory at 6:00 a.m.
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
9
9
Gap Workers Are Trapped in Misery Bangladeshi workers sewing Gap and Old Navy clothing put in mandatory 100-hour workweeks at the Next Collections factory in Ashulia, on the outskirts of Dhaka. When you look at the hip, feel-good Old Navy clothing, it is hard to believe that Gap workers live in some of the poorest hovels in the world. It is common for two, three, or even more Gap workers to share a small six-by-nine-foot room. In one home we visited, workers spread out a blanket to sleep on the concrete floor. They cannot even afford a makeshift wooden bed. Their primitive bamboo roof is torn. They have tried to repair it with cardboard, but the rain still pours in. Other Gap workers rent small one-room “homes� with walls and roofs of corrugated sheet metal. They heat up like ovens when the sun shines.
When our team of investigators met with the workers in their small rooms in June, we were soaked within 15 minutes, dripping in sweat in the humid, 100-degree heat. When we tried to write down the violations the workers were describing at the Next Collections factory, our notebooks became so soaked with sweat that the pages began to fall apart. Workers share one squat toilet with several neighboring families. There are just a couple of water spigots where several households can wash their pots and dishes. Tenants must line up and wait their turn. The American and Canadian people who buy Gap and Old Navy clothing made in Bangladesh have no idea how miserable and illegal conditions are for the 3,750 workers at the Next Collections factory.
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
10
At Next Collections The Minimum Shift Is 14 hours A Life of Exhaustion and Dirt-Poor Poverty
Finishing Section One thousand two hundred finishing section workers are routinely forced to toil over 100 hours a week, with mandatory 14- to 16-hour shifts, seven days a week. Finishing Section (Standard hours, seven days a week) 8:00 a.m. to 1:00 p.m. Work; 5 hours 1:00 p.m. to 2:00 p.m. Lunch; 1 hour 2:00 p.m. to 5:00 p.m. Work; 3 hours 5:00 p.m. to 10:00 or 11:00 p.m. Overtime; 5 to 6 hours Workers are at the factory 98 to 105 hours a week, while actually working 13 to 14 hours a day, seven days a week for a total of 91 to 98 work hours a week. The workers have just one hour off for lunch, and may receive a 15-minute snack break when they work to 10:00 p.m. It seems almost impossible to believe that 1,200 finishing section workers could have been kept at the Next Collections factory for nearly 500 hours in the month of June. When we met with several Next Collections workers in a safe location one evening in late June, we could immediately see that these young workers were sick, dazed and exhausted. There were deep shadows under their eyes, which were terribly bloodshot. Duties at the finishing section include: • Ironing, • Attaching buttons,
• • • •
Cleaning stains from garments, Folding, Inspection, and Packing garments in plastic.
Sewing Section • • • • •
2,000 Sewing Operators Major production for Gap’s Old Navy (May, June and July 2013) 14-hour shifts Seven-day workweeks All overtime is mandatory
Workers are routinely at the factory 93 to 95 hours a week, while working 86 to 88 hours. (Eighty percent of the sewing operators work these hours.) Saturday through Thursday (Six days a week) Work; 5 hours 8:00 a.m. to 1:00 p.m. 1:00 p.m. to 2:00 p.m. Lunch; 1 hour 2:00 p.m. to 5:00 p.m. Work; 3 hours 5:00 p.m. to 10:00 p.m. Mandatory overtime; 5 hours Friday (Mandatory overtime) 8:00 a.m. to 1:00 p.m. 1:00 p.m. to 2:00 p.m. 2:00 p.m. to 5:00 – 7:00 p.m.
Work; 5 hours Lunch; 1 hour Overtime; 3-5 hours
A few sewing operators — less than 20 percent — work only 8:00 a.m. to 7:00 p.m., seven days a week, for a 77hour workweek.
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
11
11
Grueling Hours – Even during Ramadan Next Collections workers were forced to work until 3:00 a.m. during the holy month of Ramadan in July 2013. During Ramadan, management allows the workers an hour and a half off, from 6:00 to 7:30 p.m., so they can return home to eat, to break their all-day fast. Management demands that they return to work until 11:00 p.m., midnight, 1:00, or even 3:00 a.m. From July 11 through August 7, 2013, Next Collections finishing section workers were forced to work 10 ½ to 16-hour shifts each day from 7:00 a.m. to 5:30, 6:00, 7:00, 10:00 p.m. or 1:00 a.m. This was during Ramadan, when most workers were fasting during the day. 7:00 a.m. to 1:00 p.m. Work; 6 hours 1:00 p.m. to 1:30 p.m. Prayer; half hour 1:30 p.m. to 3:30 p.m. Work; 2 hours 3:30 p.m. to 5:30 p.m. Overtime; 2 hours or to 6:00 p.m. 2 ½ hours or to 7:00 p.m. 3 ½ hours or to 10:00 p.m. 6 ½ hours or to 1:00 a.m. 9 ½ hours
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
12
Women Denied Their Maternity Benefits Trapped in Extreme Poverty The Truth about Sweatshop Conditions at Gap’s Next Collections Factory Next Collections has an unwritten rule. When a woman worker is about six months or more pregnant, management coerces her to resign in order to evade paying her legal maternity benefits. This scheme is so appalling that three brave young women decided to speak up and go on public record. (And we know of several other pregnant women who are being denied their maternity leave as this report goes to print.) • •
Zesmin Khatun was six months pregnant when management illegally terminated her, denying her maternity benefits, earned vacation and severance pay. Twenty-year-old Morium Begum lost her baby in her seventh month of pregnancy because she was forced to work grueling hours while being sick.
•
As they did with every pregnant worker, management attempted to force 24-year-old Taniya Begum to sign a resignation letter. After she refused to do so, her husband was jailed on false charges and beaten by management and the police.
For poor women garment workers in Bangladesh, being illegally cheated of their paid maternity leave can cause sickness and death of their infants. Next Collections management must immediately cease to deny women workers their legal right to paid maternity leave. Gap must put pressure on its supplier, the Next Collections factory. What follows are these women’s testimonies in their own words.
I. Testimony of Zesmin Khatun Zesmin Khatun was six months pregnant when management illegally terminated her, denying her maternity benefits, earned vacation leave and severance pay. Khatun routinely worked 100 hours a week. My name is Zesmin Khatun. I am 24 years old. I joined Next Collections, one of the factories of the HaMeem Group, on February 9, 2012 as a senior sewing operator. The company set my wage at 4,300 taka
13
[$55.77] a month. My husband also came to work at the same the factory on February 16, 2012 as a sewing machine operator. I had to work excessive hours from the very beginning. I started working at 8:00 a.m. and regularly worked until 10:00 p.m. On Fridays [the weekly holiday] the factory was also open. We had to work from 8:00 a.m. to 5:00 or 7:00 p.m. on Fridays. My colleagues in the finishing section worked extreme and excessive hours, from 8:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m., 1:00 a.m. and sometimes until 3:00 a.m. I worked on average 130 to 150 hours overtime a month, but the company routinely shortchanged our overtime pay. They tell the buyers that we do only two hours overtime a day, which is false. We also worked on public holidays, and when we were sick.
“
The buyers have known all about the excessive hours and whole night shifts, but they remain silent and blind.
In May 2013, when I was five months pregnant, I failed to keep up with the production goal because of complications relating to my pregnancy. This made my line chief and production manager angry and they tried to force me to quit the factory for health reasons, for being pregnant. The - Zesmin Khatun bosses had no sympathy for pregnant or sick workers. They wanted to see me working at a furious pace. The production manager, Mr. Rana, and the line chief, Mr. Mamun, demanded that I work on two machines simultaneously, doing two operations, which would have been extremely hard for any worker and impossible due to my pregnancy. I reported it to the director, Mr. Shahabuddin. The production manager and the line chief became angry with me because I had approached the director of the factory.
”
On June 10, 2013, Mr. Elias Khan, the Administrative Officer, tried to force me to sign a resignation letter, but I declined to sign the letter. Then Mr. Elias threatened me, “If you do not sign the resignation letter, your husband will also be fired.” Then I had no choice but to put my signature on the letter and I left the factory on June 10. They did not pay my earned leave [vacation] money, and they terminated me without paying my maternity leave and benefits.
There is no day care center at the Next Collections factory. For years management has always shortchanged us on our overtime pay. The buyers’ auditors would visit the factory and would have to know about the enormous violations. But they did not take any steps to improve factory Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
14
conditions. The buyers have known all about the excessive hours and whole night shifts, but they remain silent and blind. The Ministry of Labor and factory inspectors do nothing good for the workers. There is no labor union at the factory to voice our concerns — nobody helps us to resolve our problems. We do not see any ray of hope as factory conditions do not improve. The quality of our lives deteriorates as the cost of living keeps going up. It is impossible to live a decent life with the income that we are earning at the cost of our health and life. The landlord raises house rent two or three times a year, but our wages do not increase compared to house rent. We have to borrow money to support our lives. We buy groceries on credit. We can live just two or three weeks with the money we make. We have devoted our lives for the company, but they cheat and exploit us for every single taka. We could have a better life if the management paid us the legal double premium overtime and maternity leave and benefits. I think we would be able to live a decent life if garment workers got at least 8, 000 taka [50 cents an hour] as a base wage.
“
It is impossible to live a decent life with the income that we are earning at the cost of our health and life. - Zesmin Khatun
Base Wages the Garment Workers Need to Survive
”
All garment workers are demanding a minimum base wage of 8,000 taka ($104) per month for helpers, 10,000 taka ($130) for junior sewing operators and 12,000 taka ($156) for senior sewing operators. There is no garment company or factory in the world that could not afford to pay wages of 50 cents an hour! Helpers 8,000 taka per month* 50 cents an hour $3.99 a day (8-hour shift) $23.94 a week (48 hours) $103.76 a month $1,245.14 a year
Zesmin Khatun Card #8510, Senior Sewing Operator Next Collections July 20, 2013
Junior Sewing Operators 10,000 taka a month 62 cents an hour $4.99 a day (8-hour shift) $29.93 a week (48 hours) $129.70 a month $1,556.42 a year Senior Sewing Operators 12,000 taka a month 75 cents an hour $5.99 a day (8-hour shift) $35.92 a week (48 hours) $155.64 a month $1,867.70 a year *Exchange rate: $1.00 = 77.10 taka
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
15
15
II. Testimony of Morium Begum After reading Morium Begum’s testimony, many consumers in the United States and Canada may wonder if her infant’s death could have been avoided. This is also a question for Old Navy and Gap. Did Gap know that their workers were being forced to toil over 100 hours a week? Despite the fact that she was pregnant, exhausted and sick, management at the Next Collections factory forced Morium to continue working over 100 hours a week, which is why her baby died. Management wrote it off as
an unfortunate miscarriage. While her doctor ordered at least a full week’s bed rest, management was pressuring Morium to return to work just four days after her infant died.
My name is Morium Begum. I am 20 years old. I was born in a village of Sariakandi, sub-district of Bogra District — North Bengal of Bangladesh. I came to Ashulia, Dhaka with my husband at the beginning of December 2011. I joined the Next Collections factory on December 8, 2011 as a helper. The company set my wage at 3,000 taka [$38.91] a month in 2011. Now my regular wage is 3, 200 taka [$41.50.] I have been working for the factory for about 19 months as a helper. The company would not promote me to a sewing operator position. There is always tremendous work pressure in the factory. Now it is Ramadan in Bangladesh, but still we have to work until 10:00 p.m. and sometimes until 11:00 p.m. or 1:00 a.m. Currently, we start operations at 7.00 a.m. During Ramadan, government offices limit working hours to six and a half hours, but in most cases the garment owners — especially at Next Collections and the Ha-Meem Group — extend working hours to 13 or 14 hours daily. The factory is open for seven days. It never stops. In the beginning of my work in 2011, I made mistakes because I was a new worker. My supervisor cursed and yelled at me. Shouting at workers is quite common. I work on the second floor as a helper. My job is to fold the garments or to mark where the buttons must be placed. In June, 2013 I had to mark the button locations on 200 Old Navy jeans each hour. Since the factory first opened, the majority of its production has been for Gap.
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
16
In April 2013, I worked 150 hours overtime. In May, I toiled 160 hours overtime. And in June 2013, I worked 210 hours overtime. You know that June 25 was a public religious holiday [Lailatul Barat] as Muslims believe that Allah decides the fate of every human being on the night of June 24. Muslims say prayers during the whole night of June 24 and then rest on June 25. You should know that I had to work from 8:00 a.m. on June 24 to 7:00 a.m. on June 25. That is a 23-hour work shift! We could not say our prayers. I worked a whole night shift on June 24. I was obligated to do that even being pregnant. If we ask our supervisor for leave, it seems that we are committing a crime, despite the fact that we are routinely forced to work extraordinary hours. They have no sympathy toward pregnant women workers at the factory.
“
That is a 23-hour work shift! ...I was obligated to do that even being pregnant.
�
I became pregnant in January 2013 but I had to work on average 140 to 160 hours overtime each month between February and May 2012. In June I had to - Morium Begum work 210 hours of overtime! This overtime is never reflected in the pay slip. The pay slip shows that I worked only 50 hours of overtime in June. Please have a look at my pay slip. The accountants use another sheet that shows that I worked 210 hours overtime in June. But they shortchanged our overtime on the pay slip. I made 8,250 taka in June with overtime, food allowance, attendance bonus and other benefits. The company deducted overtime pay from our hours. In fact, I worked all Fridays in June. In May 2013 I earned 7, 000 taka [$90.79] including everything as I worked 160 hours overtime. I had planned to go on maternity leave following the three-day Eid vacation in August. But all my hopes were destroyed. I lost my dream. I live in a village named Gorat that is two kilometers away from the Next Collections factory. I always walk to the factory. It takes me 20 to 22 minutes to get there, as the road I walk is muddy and full of potholes. On July 3, 2013 I had to work until 1:00 a.m. despite my pregnancy. In July and during the Ramadan, I worked in most cases until 10:00 or 11:00 p.m. This was strictly obligatory. During the last three weeks in July, I worked three or four days until 6:00 p.m. as I did not feel well. After work on Friday, July 19, I was really not feeling well. On July 20, my supervisor ordered us to work until 10:00 p.m. I urged him to let me go early at 6:00 p.m. He did not agree, but I did not return after the break at 6:00 p.m. On Sunday, July 21, I had to toil until 10:00 p.m. since the general manager, Mr. Liton, did not allow me to leave the factory early. On Monday I went to the factory at 7:00 a.m. but could not work. I was feeling extreme pain and
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
17
“
I gave birth at 9:30 a.m., but the baby was immature and died...For me, it is a loss I will never get over.
”
- Morium Begum
went to the doctor’s room at 9:00 a.m. I cannot express how painful it was. I gave birth at 9:30 a.m., but the baby was immature and died. The doctor at the factory referred me to the Centre for Woman and Child Health, a nearby hospital, and I was there for a full day on July 22. They released me in the evening of the 22nd and I went back home. That was my first baby, which I lost. The grueling hours, constant strain and pressure to reach excessive production goals all led to the death of my baby. For me, it is a loss I will never get over. After the delivery I have been shaken and physically sick. I lost my baby. The doctor at the Centre for Woman and Child Health advised me to take full bed rest for at least seven days. Attached is the doctor’s advice from the Centre for Woman and Child Health. Now I feel feeble and have developed the following complications: I can’t sleep at night; I feel weak; if I stand up I feel dizzy; sometimes I have a fever; I have low blood pressure; I feel constant nausea and can’t eat; I feel no hope. The company demanded that I return to the factory on July 26 to resume work. But how can I work just four days after the death of my baby? I am sick physically and emotionally. Management thinks we are machines — that we have no feelings, no sorrows, no hardship. Even after I lost my baby, I can’t mourn her. Management wants the workers to have no personal emotions, no feelings, no misery. Our bosses are happy if we behave like machines and accept this as our universal fate. Morium Begum Card #14410, Assistant Button Machine Operator Next Collections Gorat, Ashulia, Dhaka, Bangladesh July 25, 2013
Morium Begum and her husband live in the village of Gorat, two kilometers from the Next Collections factory. They pay 1,200 taka ($15.56) a month to rent a small 10-by-10-foot room with a tin roof, which heats up like an oven. They share an outhouse with their neighbors and use wood to cook their rice and lentils. Morium went to work at the Next Collections factory on December 8, 2011. She is a helper, assisting a button machine operator. Her regular wage is $41.50 a month, $9.58 a week — 20 cents an hour — including all benefits.
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
18
At the Next Collections Factory Total Disregard for a Woman’s Health Management tried everything possible to force Morium Begum to return to work just four days after her tragic miscarriage. Morium’s discharge certificate from the Centre for Woman and Child Health strongly advised: • • • •
Avoid all heavy work for three months. Take your medicine and eat nutritious food. Consult your doctor immediately if you have any health related complications. Take full bed rest for seven days.
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
19
Workers at the Next Collections mostly make Old Navy jeans and denim shorts.
Workers Cursed and Beaten At Next Collections Sweatshop At 9:00 a.m. on Wednesday, July 24, 2013, Saiful Islam, a supervisor on Line #4, violently slapped a young helper, supposedly for making a mistake. Later on that same day, Islam slapped another worker for not working fast enough. A quality inspector, Munir, attacked a young woman on July 24, cursing and screaming at her for falling behind on her production goal. According to the workers, supervisors like Islam and Munir are very aggressive and nasty, and do not hesitate to beat workers for the most trifling matters. Saiful Islam and Munir should be immediately terminated. (We will not disclose the identities of the abused workers until these two supervisors are out of the factory.)
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
20
III. Testimony of Taniya Begum A Young Woman Fights Against Corruption, Graft and Lies Threatened with Prison and Death at the Next Collections Factory My name is Taniya and I am 24 years old. I joined the Next Collections factory on November 10, 2012 as a sewing line supervisor. My ID card is number 205 and I work on line #183 where we sew children’s and adults’ denim jeans for Gap and Old Navy. My husband [Mazhar Islam] is also a supervisor and works in the same factory on Line #182. We were married on August 25, 2011. I was paid 11,000 taka [$146.67 USD] a month for working 13 to 15 hours a day. The company never gives us [supervisors] overtime pay, despite the fact that we work five to seven hours of overtime each day. Operators are entitled to overtime wages, but supervisors are not. As a result, many operators make more money than we do. Despite the fact that I am pregnant, I still have to regularly work until 10:00 or 11:00 p.m. I was also forced to work until 12:00 midnight on June 24, 2013, which is a special night for Muslims. [Management] does not spare us, and all overtime is mandatory, even for pregnant women. I was a supervisor in the sewing section until I told the welfare officer that I was pregnant. They transferred me to the finishing section, hoping to put so much physical and mental pressure on me that I would resign, being unable to cope with the work pace. The finishing section workers work five to seven hours of overtime every day. Finishers also have to work to 3:00 a.m. and even 5:00 a.m., and on every Friday as well. There are 20 lines in the sewing section, working on the 4th and 5th floors, with some
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
21
2,000 workers. In the finishing section, there are a total of 1,200 workers on 22 lines. There are other sections like cutting and the warehouse. The total number of workers at Next Collections is about 3,750. On June 27, I gave Ms. Shamima, the welfare officer, my ultra-sonogram regarding my pregnancy. I was 19 weeks and two days pregnant. I wanted to file my case in preparation for my maternity leave. On July 18, 2013, after management became aware that I was pregnant, they unilaterally transferred me to the finishing section against my will. They wanted me to quit so that I wouldn’t be able to receive my maternity leave and benefits. Management thought that I would not be able to keep up with the pace in the finishing section and that I would willingly submit my resignation. I worked as hard as I could and never thought of resigning. I was planning to go on maternity leave on September 20, 2013. I was mentally prepared to go forward. After the Eid vacation, we resumed work on Saturday, August 17, 2013. At 10:30 a.m. on the 17th, the welfare officer, Ms. Shamima, came to my floor and told me I had to resign. I asked her, “Why should I resign?” Ms. Shamima responded that, “A higher authority instructed me to inform you that you must submit your letter of resignation.” I explained again that I was expecting a baby in mid-November and I had every intention of taking my maternity leave on September 20, 2013. Why would you want me to resign just one month before my maternity leave? She said, “I have nothing to do with this. It’s up to management. The GM [general manager], PM [production manager], finishing manager and administrative officer all want you to leave the factory today.” I responded, “No. Never will I submit the resignation letter! I cannot give up my maternity leave. It is too important for my infant.” Ms. Shamima said that the factory owner is a very wealthy and powerful man and could cause a lot of trouble for me if I did not resign. But I was adamant and replied, “I won’t resign even if the owner threatens me. Maternity leave and benefits are my legal right. The Ha-Meem Group cannot deprive me of maternity leave and benefits.” The following day, on August 18, the welfare officer, Ms. Shamima, again came to my floor and asked me to resign. Ms. Shamima said, “Taniya, you must not appear at the factory starting tomorrow. The factory management does not want to see you at the factory again.” On August 19, I returned to work as usual at 8:00 a.m. The welfare officer again approached me. She said I had to leave the factory at once. Ms. Shamima said, “You do not have the power to fight against management. They can order the police to put you and your husband in jail on false charges.” I told Shamima I would not quit no matter what.
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
22 The big boss, Mr. Liton, the general manager, called me to his office and again ordered me to resign. If not, he said, “You and your husband will be arrested. False charges or not, you will be arrested by the police.” I responded, “Sir, I am planning to go on my maternity leave in September. How can you order me to resign and quit the factory without my legal right to maternity leave?” Mr. Liton said, “It is the decision of the company that you will have to resign and leave the factory forever. The factory will not approve your maternity leave.” On August 20, I took the risk and again went to the factory. The administrative officer, Mr. Elias Khan, immediately threatened that if I did not resign, someone would kill my husband and hide his body. A union advisor I know encouraged me to go to the local police station to explain how they were threatening my family.
did not return to the factory that afternoon.
After lunch on August 20, I left the factory and went to the Ashulia police station and filed a statement against the general manager, the administrative officer, production manager, and the welfare officer of the Next Collections factory for making death threats and threats of forcible disappearance against my family. I
When I went to the factory on August 21, the GM [general manager], Mr. Liton, called me to his office again and screamed at me, “Why didn’t you return to the factory after lunch on August 20?” He called me names, “bitch, bastard,” and shouted, “Do you think your father owns the factory? We will not keep you. You must resign and leave the factory immediately. I do not want to see you again.” Then he told me to get out of his office. The welfare officer took me to the medical center on the ground floor and left me near the doctor’s office. Shamima called the woman doctor and asked that I be declared “unfit for work.” The medical doctor was honest and responded over the phone, near where I was sitting, “I can’t give a false certificate.” The medical doctor is a good woman. She warned me that management could concoct a story that I had stolen garments. She advised me to leave the factory in order to avoid the police bringing false charges against me. She said it could affect my baby. On August 21, at 12:20 p.m., I left the Next Collections factory.
“
How many pregnant women workers will have to suffer to establish the rule of law at factories like Next Collections?
The general manager told my husband that I should send in my letter of resignation immediately. I am now at home, but I will not submit any resignation letter. I want to enjoy my legal maternity leave and benefits. The Next Collections factory has no right to violate the rights of - Taniya Begum poor pregnant women workers, who are vulnerable and victims. Many poor pregnant women have been compelled to quit the factory. We would like to see an end to the continuous violation of labor and women’s rights. How many pregnant women workers will have to suffer to establish the rule of law at factories like Next Collections? Is there no-one to monitor these fundamental violations of labor laws?
”
Taniya Begum Card #205, Supervisor Next Collections July 2013
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
23
23
Maternity Benefits and Wages Owed In Bangladesh, pregnant workers are entitled to 112 days of paid maternity leave. Their paid maternity leave is based on the average of their previous three months’ actual pay, including salary and bonuses. (See page 49 for Bangladeshi law on maternity leave and benefits.) As a line supervisor, Taniya Begum, earned a monthly salary of 11,000 taka, or $142.67 USD. Taniya was also often forced to work overtime on Fridays — which is the Muslim holiday — toiling seven days a week. Taniya Begum’s 112 days maternity leave starts on September 20, 2013 and continues through January 9, 2014. Her maternity leave totals $614.58. Based on her salary, Taniya’s regular maternity leave should be 40,370 taka, which is $523.61. Additionally, Taniya was also required to work overtime on several Fridays, which added an additional 7014 taka, or $90.97, to her maternity leave. Moreover, Taniya worked 20 days in August, for which she was not paid. She is owned 8,461 taka, or $109.74, which brings the total amount due Taniya to $724.32. This may not seem to be an enormous amount, but it will give Taniya and her infant a chance to have sufficient food and to grow healthy. We know many other women workers who were also pregnant and denied their maternity leave. This must end.
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
24
Police Force in Bangladesh Wracked with Corruption and Graft Almost everyone in Bangladesh is aware that — too often — police officers can be bought off with chump-change. However, it is a whole other level when the powerful Ha-Meem Group, and the Next Collections factory, is involved. Management has the power to use the police as a private army to attack the workers. For example, when Mazharul Islam supported his wife Taniya’s right to paid maternity leave, he was badly beaten with sticks by management and then turned over to the police. The administrative officer at Next Collections, Elias Khan, then fabricated a story that Mazharul “attempted” to steal 12 pairs of pants from the factory, and “admitted” to his crime. The fact that there was no proof
whatsoever did not stop the police, who immediately recommended that the court deny Mazhural’s bail. A police van was called and Mazhural was put in the back seat surrounded by three police officers. In the front seat of the van was the administrative officer, Elias Khan, who orchestrated the whole plot. It took three days and a lot of work by Bangladeshi worker rights organizations to temporarily free Mazhural, who will still have to report to the court every month for years. And there is the possibility that Mazhural could be imprisoned again, given the clout that Ha-Meen and Next Collections have.
Statement by Mazharul Islam Mazharul was beaten with sticks and threatened with death all because his wife, Taniya, was asking for her paid maternity leave. Mazharul Islam, a supervisor at the Next Collections factory, was attacked, cheated of his wages, beaten with sticks, and imprisoned under false charges in an effort to deny his wife, Taniya Begum, her legal right to paid maternity leave. Shahabuddin, Executive Director of the
Next Collections factory, along with General Manager, Liakat Hossain Liton, and Administrative Officer, Elias Khan, are implicated in numerous cases of harassment and intimidation to deny pregnant women their legal right to paid maternity leave.
September 5, 2013, Thursday Next Collections Limited workers and staff were paid their August wages on September 5. The general manager [Liakat Hossain Liton] and administrative officer [Elias Khan] refused to pay my month’s wages until I brought Taniya to the factory to meet with management. I reported this to the executive director. The executive director wanted to know who was holding my salary. The general manager went to the executive director’s office, explaining they wanted me to bring Taniya to the factory. The executive director said that if I brought Taniya to the factory, I would be paid. I left the factory at 10:00 p.m. September 6, Friday The factory was shut down on Friday. September 7, Saturday I did not bring Taniya to the factory. Management did not ask me about Taniya. But I still was not paid my salary for August. I left the factory at 8:00 p.m.
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
25 September 8, Sunday I started working at 8:00 a.m. I went home to take lunch from 1:30 to 2:30 p.m. After the lunch break, at around 3:30 p.m., the administrative officer, Elias Khan, came to my assembly line on the third floor. He ordered me to immediately meet with Belal Hossian, the managing director, on the 4th floor. When I entered the MD’s office, I saw that the welfare officer, Ms. Shamima, the two executive directors, the general manager, Liton, the managing director and others were meeting in Belal Hossian’s office. Elias Khan, the administrative officer, followed me into the managing director’s office. Other than me, there were seven top-level managers in the room. 3:40 p.m. It was around 3:40 p.m. when the general manager started interrogating me and asking why I used a cell phone to tape record management’s threats against me. When Taniya was asking for her maternity leave, they threatened that I would be in trouble, that I could be tortured by the police or even forcibly disappeared. I recorded the conversation using a cell phone that I borrowed from my colleague, Junaid, who was a quality inspector on the same floor and line as I was. 4:00 p.m. Junaid betrayed me. Only he knew that I taped management’s threats against my life using his cell phone. He gave the memory card to management. Then Elias told me to sign my letter of resignation. I replied, “What did I do wrong and why should I resign?”
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
26 Elias said that during the workers strike in May demanding a food subsidy for lunch, I had supported the strike and knocked down a sewing machine. He said, “We will file a lawsuit against you. We will not allow you to stay in the factory.” The general manager, administrative manager, the welfare officer and executive director told me to sign a resignation letter. I refused to sign the letter. Then the managing director called a security guard and told him to bring a cane stick to beat me. The managing director, general manager and administrative officer all threatened that if I failed to sign this letter, they would put me in jail for the rest of my life, that they would beat me to the point that I would never be able to walk again, and that if I did not sign my resignation letter, I could be killed.
“
Then the managing director kicked me hard on my back two or three times. He ordered a security guard to beat me with a cane stick...I felt like I would faint.
6:00 p.m.
”
- Mazharul Islam
I had no way out and I was forced to resign. Then I asked to get my salary for August. Then the managing director, general manager and administrative officer told me to come to the factory the following morning and I will get paid. 6:15 p.m. Two security guards accompanied me while I walked down from the 4th floor. I had just left the main gate at Next Collections and was starting to walk on the public road. All of the sudden the MD’s assistant and the chief security guard, Md. Ayub, called me back. They said management had decided to pay me now and I should go to the MD’s office. So I went up to the 4th floor where the managing director’s office is and saw that the welfare officer, Ms. Shamima, and the administrative officer, Mr. Elias, were there in the office. In a few minutes the general manager appeared. 6:30 p.m. The administrative officer gave me a blank sheet of white paper and ordered me to put my signature on it. I responded that I had already submitted my resignation, so why do you want me to sign a blank sheet of paper. The welfare officer told me that workers who resign must sign a blank sheet, and she left the office saying she would bring a file to show me an example. I told them again that I still have not gotten my salary for the month of August and neither did I get my overtime, so why should I sign my name on a blank piece of paper. A security guard was pressuring me to sign. I stood there quietly and said nothing. 6:45 p.m. Suddenly, the managing director stood up from his chair and started violently punching my ears. I felt stunned and extreme pain. Then the managing director kicked me hard on my back two or three times. He ordered a security guard to beat me with a cane stick. He immediately came at me, hitting me as hard as he could with the cane five or six times on my back, face and buttocks. The managing director’s assistant beat the soles of my feet with another cane stick. I felt like I would faint. In a few minutes a chief mechanic showed up, and he started slapping me across my face. This all happened on the 4th floor, in the managing director’s office. 7:15 p.m. I thought they would kill me. I was all alone. Six or seven people were violently beating me with sticks. I was forced to sign the blank sheet. I put down my signature, despite the fact that they did not pay my salary for August and other dues.
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
27
8:00 p.m. A sub-inspector of police, Mr. Arafat, entered into the managing director’s office. I was moved to another nearby office. This went on for 20 to 25 minutes. 8:20 p.m. A security guard brought me down to the ground floor, where he locked me in a medical room so that I could not escape. 8:30 p.m. The police officer, Mr. Arafat, came down to the ground floor. The security guard unlocked the medical room and told me to get into a police van. The administrative officer, Elias, also got into the police van, sitting in the front. I was in the back of the van with three other policemen. Elias came with the police to file a lawsuit against me. 9:30 p.m. The police van stopped at Ashulia Police Station where I was put in jail. They did not give me any food. There was no place to sleep. I sat on the concrete floor. I felt severe pain in all my body. Due to the beating, I had bruises on my body. My wife, Taniya, came to see me at 10:00 p.m. and she cried when she saw how I was beaten. The administrative officer Elias told Taniya this would not have happened if we had signed the resignation letters and stopped demanding maternity leave and benefits. Union leaders also came to the prison to help me. I saw them, but we were not allowed to speak. Late that night, I spent the night sitting on the concrete floor. I had pains all over my body from the beatings. September 9, Monday The Ashulia police put me in a prison van to take me to the Judicial Court in Dhaka City. The van started at 10:30 a.m. and reached the Dhaka Judicial Court at 2:30 p.m. They kept me in a temporary jail nearby the court. The judge held my hearing at 3:30 p.m. for half an hour and wanted to continue the hearing on the following morning. I was shifted to Dhaka Central Jail at 6:30 p.m. At 10:00 p.m. I was put in a big room with 70 other people. At 10:30 p.m. they gave me a plate of rice and lentils to share with four people. September 10, Tuesday I tried to sleep on top of a blanket on the concrete floor. There was no pillow, so I rested my head on my shoes. 4:00 a.m. The jail authorities woke us at 4:00 a.m. 10:00 a.m. For breakfast we ate roti and dal. We were waiting for the court hearing. 4:00 p.m. The Dhaka Central Jail authority informed me that I was being granted my bail. 7:00 p.m. Finally I got out of the Dhaka Central Jail. I saw my wife waiting to see me along with some leaders and rights activists who fought for my freedom.
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
28
A Brave Young Worker Blows the Whistle on Gross Overtime Violations Saydur Rahman is an experienced “ironing man” in the finishing section of Next Collections. Rahman was fired on September 1, 2013, when the head of the finishing section started questioning him: “You seem to be a labor leader. There is no space for a labor leader here, and we never keep workers who organize trade unions.” Suddenly the manager started shouting, “Get out of the factory at once, otherwise you will be in serious trouble. I will call the police and they will arrest you on the spot.” Saydur Rahman was fired without receiving the wages and benefits due him for the month of August. It is certain that Rahman was seen by company supervisors when he went to assist a young pregnant woman who had been forced out of Next Collections without her maternity leave and other benefits. The young woman was too terrified to confront management. He confirmed the following: • • • • •
Workers are kept at the factory a staggering 449 hours in the month of June. Mandatory 14- to 20-hour shifts are the norm. In June, Rahman was forced to work 200 regular and 213 overtime hours. Next Collections/Ha-Meem Group hand out phony pay stubs to mask the wildly excessive and mandatory overtime. Workers are paid in cash, off the books, while being routinely cheated of approximately 15 percent of their overtime pay.
Twenty-four-year-old Rahman worked at That’s It Sportswear and Next Collections for over six years, starting in February 2006. In June, he worked the following hours at Next Collections: Week #1: At the factory 95 hours. Saturday, June 1
8:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m.
14-hour shift
8 regular hours, 5 hours overtime
Sunday, June 2
8:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m.
15-hour shift
8 regular hours, 6 hours overtime
Monday, June 3
8:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m.
15-hour shift
8 regular hours, 6 hours overtime
Tuesday, June 4
8:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m.
15-hour shift
8 regular hours, 6 hours overtime
Wednesday, June 5
8:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m.
15-hour shift
8 regular hours, 6 hours overtime
8:00 a.m. to 5:00 a.m.
21-hour shift
8 regular hours, 11 hours overtime
Thursday, June 6 Friday, June 7
--- Friday Off --─ Working 48 regular hours and 40 hours of overtime. ─ Working a total of 88 hours a week.
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
29 Week #2: At the factory 116 hours. Saturday, June 8
8:00 a.m. to 4:00 a.m.
20-hour shift
8 regular hours, 10 hours overtime
Sunday, June 9
8:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m.
14-hour shift
8 regular hours, 5 hours overtime
Monday, June 10
8:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m.
15-hour shift
8 regular hours, 6 hours overtime
Tuesday, June 11
8:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m.
15-hour shift
8 regular hours, 6 hours overtime
Wednesday, June 12
8:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m.
15-hour shift
8 regular hours, 6 hours overtime
Thursday, June 13 8:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m. Friday, June 14
8:00 a.m. to 6:00 a.m.
15-hour shift
8 regular hours, 6 hours overtime
22-hour shift
20 hours overtime
─ Working 48 regular hours and 59 hours of overtime. ─ Working a total of 107 hours a week. Week #3: At the factory 108 hours. Saturday, June 15
8:00 a.m. to 7:00 p.m.
11-hour shift
8 regular hours, 2 hours overtime
Sunday, June 16
8:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m.
14-hour shift
8 regular hours, 5 hours overtime
Monday, June 17
8:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m.
15-hour shift
8 regular hours, 6 hours overtime
Tuesday, June 18
8:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m.
15-hour shift
8 regular hours, 6 hours overtime
Wednesday, June 19
8:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m.
14-hour shift
8 regular hours, 5 hours overtime
Thursday, June 20 8:00 a.m. to 1:00 a.m.
17-hour shift
8 regular hours, 7 hours overtime
Friday, June 21 8:00 a.m. to 6:00 a.m.
22-hour shift
20 hours overtime
─ Working 48 regular hours and 51 hours of overtime. ─ Working a total of 99 hours a week. Week #4: At the factory 96 hours. Saturday, June 22 8:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m.
14-hour shift
8 regular hours, 5 hours overtime
Sunday, June 23
8:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m.
15-hour shift
8 regular hours, 6 hours overtime
Monday, June 24
8:00 a.m. to 7:00 p.m.
11-hour shift
8 regular hours, 2 hours overtime
Tuesday, June 25
--- Muslim religious holiday --15-hour shift
8 regular hours, 6 hours overtime
Wednesday, June 26
8:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m.
Thursday, June 27
8:00 a.m. to 3:00 a.m.
19-hour shift
8 regular hours, 9 hours overtime
Friday, June 28
8:00 a.m. to 6:00 a.m.
22-hour shift
20 hours overtime
─ Working 40 regular hours and 48 hours of overtime. ─ Working a total of 88 hours a week. At the factory 34 hours in two days. Saturday, June 29 Sunday, June 30
8:00 a.m. to 4:00 a.m.
20-hour shift
8 regular hours, 10 hours overtime
8:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m.
14-hour shift
8 regular hours, 5 hours overtime
─ Working 16 regular hours and 15 hours of overtime. ─ Working a total of 31 hours during the last two days of June.
* Workers have a one-hour unpaid lunch break. * When workers are forced to work a 17-hour shift from 8:00 a.m. to 1:00 a.m., they receive an hours off for dinner. * Friday is supposedly the weekly holiday. See page 56 for more data on illegal work hours.
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
30
Grueling, mind-numbing overtime shifts in July In the month of July 2013, we tracked the work hours of three young women in the finishing section of Next Collections. We were shocked by the amount of overtime these workers were forced to work — toiling an average of 261 hours in just 15 days. Ms. L: Forced to work 15 all-night shifts in July • Twelve all-night, 17-hour shifts from 8:00 a.m. to 1:00 a.m. • Three all-night, 21-hour shifts from 8:00 a.m. to 5:00 a.m. Ms. A: Forced to work 14 all-night shifts in July • One all-night, 16-hour shift from 8:00 a.m. to midnight; • Nine all-night, 17-hour shifts from 8:00 a.m. to 1:00 a.m. • One all-night, 19-hour shifts from 8:00 a.m. to 3:00 a.m. • Three all-night, 21-hour shifts from 8:00 a.m. to 5:00 a.m. Ms. M: Forced to work 15 all-night shifts in July • Two all-night, 16-hour shifts from 8:00 a.m. to midnight • Eight all-night, 17-hour shifts from 8:00 a.m. to 1:00 a.m. • Two all-night, 19-hour shifts from 8:00 a.m. to 3:00 a.m. • Three all-night, 21-hour shifts from 8:00 a.m. to 5:00 a.m. When these workers were not forced to remain for the grueling and excessive overtime hours, they still had to work a routine shift of 14 hours from 8:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m., receiving only one or two days off in the month of July.
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
31
Next Collections Scam Goes Right to the Top Implicating Gap and the Ha-Meem Group Excessive hours authorized by top management. Workers paid off the books in cash, cheated of approximately 15 percent of their overtime wages. Everyone knows that the phony pay slips which are handed out to workers every month are a scam, meant to provide cover for Gap and Old Navy, Next Collections, and the Ha-Meem Group. Using phony pay stubs, the executive director of the Next Collections factory, Shahabuddin, along with other managers, is running an illegal scam to cover up — among other violations — the forced and grueling 14 to 20-hour shifts worked seven days a week by thousands of Next Collections workers. According to Gap, it would never condone more than a regular 48-hour workweek and certainly no more than 12 hours of overtime, for a six-day, 60-hour maximum workweek. Workers must receive one day off each week, [Translation] Serial: XXX Next Floor-1
Pay Slip, May 2013
Name:
XXXXXX
Date of Joining:
DD MM YYYY
Designation:
Finishing iron man
Worker Serial #:
NCL-XXXXXXXX
Grade:
4
Total Days:
Finishing #XX
Tk. 3,143.00
[$40.77]
Tk. 1,257.00
[$16.30]
Approved Leave:
Tk. 200.00
[$2.59]
Tk. 4,600.00
[$59.66]
00
Attendance:
22 days
Attendance Bonus:
Tk. 500
Other Allowance:
00
Absent Days:
00
Deduction for Absent:
00
Advance:
00
Actual Wage:
Tk. 5,100.00
Overtime Rate:
Tk. 30.22/hr
[$6.49]
[$66.15]
Overtime Hours:
32 hours Tk. 967.00
[$12.54]
Food Bill:
Tk. 225.00
[$2.92]
Tk. 10
[$0.13]
Tk. 6,282.00
[$81.48]
Deduction for Stamp: Net Pay:
It is standard for Next Collections workers to be forced to toil from 8:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m. or 1:00 a.m., for a 14- to 17-hour shift, seven days a week. Putting in a 100-plus hour workweek is the norm. We learned this from the dozens of workers we interviewed and the many more who wrote down their hours. While the workers are actually toiling 100-plus hours a week, often with no day off, the pay slips they receive each month adhere to the fiction: an eight-hour regular shift with two hours overtime, and every Friday off. Almost all workers throw away their phony pay stubs as soon as they receive them. And it appears that this same scam is being perpetuated throughout the Ha-Meem Group, affecting all of its 30,000 workers.
22 days
House Rent: Total:
Phony Pay Stubs as Cover-Ups
The pay stub below provides an example. This phony pay stub notes that Next Collections workers toiled just 22 days in May, but most of them actually worked 27
Basic Salary: Medical Allownace:
just as — Gap feels strongly — all workers producing their products have the right to freedom of association, the right to organize a union and to bargain collectively.
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
32
days, including over 150 hours of mandatory overtime (every day except for the May 1 public holiday and a work stoppage of three days, to be discussed.) Each week, this worker toiled 48 regular hours and an additional 46.2 hours of overtime, for an average workweek of over 94 hours, working an average of 6.6 hours of mandatory overtime each day, seven days a week. In May, this worker was cheated of $11.76 of his hard-earned overtime wages.
Management Signs off on Extreme and Illegal Overtime Hours Every Night In fact, it is the executive director of Next Collections, Shahabuddin, and the administrative officer, Elias Khan, who personally sign off on workers toiling extreme overtime hours every night! Moreover, Shahabuddin and Khan also sign off every night for food stipends to be supplied to workers who toil at least 14 to 17 overtime hour shifts or longer. Meticulous overtime hours and late night food subsidies are written down every night, as you can see in the handwritten lists on the next page. Workers required to toil until 10 p.m. receive a 20 taka (26 cent) food stipend. The groups of workers who must stay working until 1:00 a.m. or later receive a second food stipend of 30 taka (39 cents.) Workers who complete a mandatory shift of 17 hours or longer take home an extra 65 cents. Management asks workers to sign their names on a sheet of paper in order to keep a list of workers who toil overtime and receive this second food stipend for late hours. Then Next Collections’ executive director and administrative officer sign off on dozens of lists regarding these late night stipends. We know this because some brave workers smuggled many of the sign-off sheets for the late night stipend (“Night Bill”) out of the factory. This proves that thousands of Next Collections workers are routinely forced to work grueling 14- to 20-hour shifts at the orders of the factory’s top management.
Workers Shortchanged of 15 Percent of Overtime Wages This is how the scam operates. Every month the workers are paid in cash and off the books. Supervisors keep track of the actual monthly overtime worked by each person. These records are then turned over to the accounting department, which calculates each worker’s wages and overtime pay. On payday, usually on the seventh day of the following month, at about 10:30 a.m., the accountants set up several pay stations on each floor. Workers are called one by one to receive their pay in cash along with the fictitious pay slips. They receive no record of the actual amount of money they receive, but they are asked to sign a salary sheet, which is retained by the accountants and which, presumably, Gap and the other buyers never see. While management lies to the buyers about the long hours, they are also cheating the workers of their overtime wages. Based on extensive interviews and surveys of the wages as well as hours of Next Collections workers, we estimate that 90 percent of Next Collections workers are being shortchanged of up to 15 percent of their overtime wages, or approximately $10.97 a month, $131.50 a year. Given that some 3,375 workers in the Next Collections factory are being cheated this way, the workers are losing some $443,812 a year. If these same practices are applied to some 30,000 workers across all 26 factories of the Ha-Meem Group, the workers could be losing (and the company gaining) possibly millions of dollars a year in wages. This is a great deal of money that is being stolen from some of the poorest workers in the world. It is highly unlikely that Next Collections’ executive director and other factory management would have developed and implemented this system of phony pay stubs and off-the-official-books payments on their own, without the support and authorization of the Ha-Meem Group’s owner, A. K. Azad.
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
33
These scanned images of “Night Bill” records below show signatures of Next Collections’ executive director, Shahabuddin, and administrative officer, Elias Khan, on lists of workers to receive a food stipend for excessive, late night overtime work.
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
34
Wage Scam Goes on in Broad Daylight Gap and Old Navy fall for it hook, line and sinker. Phony pay receipts used to mask illegal overtime and 100-plus hour workweeks. 30,000 workers cheated for years at Next Collections Limited and the Ha-Meem Group. Translation: June 2013 phony pay receipt Serial: #23 TSL Unit: IV
9BS
2BS
Pay Slip: June 2013 Name:
Ms. Morium
Date of Joining:
December 8, 2011
Designation:
Assistant Button Machine Operator, Grade 7
Worker Serial #:
TSL-BSA04014410
Grade:
7
Total Days:
25 days
Basic Salary:
Tk. 2,143.00
[$27.80]
House Rent:
Tk. 857.00
[$11.12]
Medical Allowance: Total: Approved Leave: Attendance Bonus:
Tk. 200.00
[$2.59]
Tk. 3,200.00
[$41.50]
00 Tk. 300
Other Allowance:
00
Absent Days:
00
Deduction for Absent:
00
Advance:
00
Actual Wage:
Tk. 3,500.00
Overtime Rate:
Tk. 20.60/hr
Overtime Hours: Food Bill: Deduction for Stamp: Net Pay:
[$3.89]
[$45.40]
50 hours; Tk. 1030.00
[$13.36]
Tk. 625.00
[$8.11]
Tk. 10
[$0.13]
Tk. 5,145.00
[$66.73]
Morium Begum, Assistant Button Machine Operator Forced to work over 100 hours a week, she lost her baby in the seventh month of her pregnancy.
The truth is that in June 2013, Morium Begum was forced to work an illegal 210 hours of overtime, which was almost certainly a factor leading to the loss of her baby. Far from working the 50 hours of overtime listed on her phony pay receipt, Morium was forced to work four times Bangladesh’s legal limit on overtime hours, which is no more than 52 hours a month. Every
month, Morium was routinely forced to work grueling and illegal overtime shifts. She was also cheated every single month of 15 percent of the overtime wages legally due her. In June, Morium was forced to work a grueling 96 ½ hours each week, for which she earned less than $25. Her base wage was just 13 cents an hour.
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
35
Translation: April 2013 phony pay receipt Serial: #31 Sewing Section
Pay Slip: April 2013 Line: 175
Name:
Ms. Zesmin
Designation:
Sewing Machine Operator
Worker Serial #:
NCL-SO0198510
Grade:
4
Total Days:
23 days
Basic Salary:
Tk. 3,196.43
[$41.46]
House Rent:
Tk. 1,278.57
[$16.58]
Tk. 200.00
[$2.59]
Tk. 4,675.00
[$60.64]
Medical Allowance: Total: Approved Leave: Attendance: Attendance Bonus:
00 23 days Tk. 500.00
Other Allowance:
00
Absent Days:
00
Deduction for Absent:
00
Advance:
00
Actual Wage:
Tk. 5,175.00
Overtime Rate:
Tk. 30.73/hr
Overtime Hours: Deduction for Stamp: Net Pay:
Zesmin Khatun, Sewing Operator Ilegally denied her maternity leave and fired.
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
[$6.49]
[$61.12]
32 hours; Tk. 983
[$12.75]
Tk. 10
[$0.13]
Tk. 6,148.00
[$79.74]
36
Driven by Hunger and Long Hours, Workers Strike for Food and Win. Worker Leader Threatened and Fired In May 2013, workers at both Next Collections and its sister factory, That’s It Sportswear, conducted a three-day work stoppage. Their demand was that management provide a lunch subsidy of 25 taka (32 cents USD) so that the workers could afford a more substantive meal. (As it is, Next Collections workers live from hand to mouth, and by the third week of the month many workers have no money left to purchase food.)
injured over 100, Shadin was transferred to work at Ha-Meem’s Next Collections factory, where he began work on January 1, 2011 as an “ironing man” in the finishing section.
On May 22, 2013, the workers won! Next Collections would pay 25 taka (32 cents) for the workers’ lunch. This shows up on the workers’ phony pay stubs starting in May.
On June 7, 2013, Shadin was fired for helping to lead the May strike. His supervisor, Masud, and the finishing department manager, Mamun, informed Shadin that he was terminated and would never again be hired to work in any of the Ha-Meem Group factories. Shadin was told by the manager, Mamun: “If you dare to try to enter the factory, I will call the police and will have you arrested for instigating a workers’ strike.”
Shadin was one of the strike leaders. He had started working at the That’s It Sportswear Limited factory, part of the Ha-Meem Group, on June 9, 2008. Following the December 2010 fire at That’s It Sportswear, which killed 29 people and seriously
He received his pay for May — which, like every other month, was short by 15 percent on the overtime pay he was due. In addition, when he was fired, Shadin was denied the paid vacation days and four months’ severance pay he had earned.
You can see Shadin’s phony pay stub for the month of May 2013. He receives a lunch subsidy of 225 taka ($2.92) for the nine days after the workers won their demand on May 22. The phony pay stub indicates that Shadin worked only 22 days in the month, including just 32 hours of “voluntary overtime.” In reality, Shadin worked 27 days in May.
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
37
Ha-Meem Group’s That’s It Sportswear 29 Workers Killed, 100 Injured On December 14, 2010, a fire broke out at the Ha-Meem Group’s That’s It Sportswear factory, killing 29 workers and injuring 100, 36 of them critically. Several workers jumped to their deaths so that their families could have their bodies to mourn. The majority of production in the factory was children’s clothing being made for Gap. Workers told us that when the fire broke out, security guards deliberately locked several exit gates to prevent the garments from being stolen, trapping many of those who died. Senior sewers at That’s It Sportswear earned just 28 cents an hour. In 1911 — over 100 years ago — workers at the Triangle Shirtwaist factory in New York City were paid 14 cents an hour. Adjusted for inflation, that 14-cent wage would come to $3.18 an hour in today’s dollars. One hundred years later, workers at That’s It Sportswear in Bangladesh are paid just 28 cents an hour, earning just one-tenth of the real wages earned by New York City garment workers in 1911. The garment industry is racing backward. In September 2008 — two years before the fire — Mr. A.K. Azad, the Ha-Meem Group’s powerful owner, ordered that a union organizing drive at That’s It Sportswear be crushed, firing 19 of the leading union activists and imprisoning the union president on false charges. Had the union survived and the workers had a voice with regard to health and safety matters in the plant, it is very possible that the 29 workers would not have died in the 2010 fire.
A. K. Azad Owner of the Ha-Meem Group Including Next Collections and That’s It Sportswear In addition to the Ha-Meem Group’s 26 woven apparel factories, Mr. Azad owns a sweater factory, a denim mill and a number of other companies, including a Bangladeshi television station, Channel 24, and a daily newspaper called Samakal, which gives him a powerful voice. Until recently, Azad held the post of President of Bangladesh’s top business organization, the Federation of Bangladesh Chambers of Commerce and Industry. He is reputed to be very close to Bangladesh’s Prime Minister, Sheikh Hasina.
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
38
An Old Navy store in Pennsylvania.
Corporate Responsibility in Gap/Old Navy’s Supply Chain GAP, Inc. Two Folsom Street San Francisco, CA 94105 Phone: (415) 427-0100 Glenn K. Murphy, Chairman and CEO Stefan Larsson, Global President, Old Navy In 2012, Gap Inc.’s net sales (including its fast-growing Old Navy division) grew to $15.7 billion, increasing $1.1 billion from the previous year, with over one billion in net income. As of February 2013, there are 1,010 Old Navy stores in North America.
“
We are pleased with our June sales results. Old Navy’s performance was particularly strong. - Glenn Murphy, chairman and chief executive officer of Gap Inc.
”
“Gap Inc. seeks to ensure that the people working at various points along the supply chain are treated with fairness, dignity and respect – an aspiration that is born out of the belief that each life is of equal value, whether the person is sitting behind a sewing machine at a factory that produces clothes for Gap Inc… “…people who work on behalf of our company help us to run a more successful business. People who work a reasonable number of hours in a safe and healthy environment not only have a better quality of life, but they also tend to be more productive and deliver higher quality product than those who work in poor conditions. “To achieve this aspiration, our Social and Environmental Responsibility department has a full-time staff of approximately 70 people dedicated to these issues, partnering with hundreds of factory owners and managers, NGOs, and industry associations worldwide that are experts in social and environmental issues.”
─ Gap Inc., Supply Chain Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
39
Gap Inc. Code of Vendor Conduct
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
40
“Made in Bangladesh� Old Navy toddler girls skinny jeans sewn by young workers at the Next Collections factory.
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
41
What Must Be Done To End Gross Sweatshop Violations At Next Collections of the Ha-Meem Group Phony pay stubs; make-believe 10-hour shifts; women cheated of maternity benefits; routine beatings; grueling forced 90 to 100-hour workweeks; workers cheated of 15 percent of their overtime wages....while Gap and Old Navy stand by doing nothing.
•
For at least two-and-a-half years, Next Collections and Ha-Meem management have routinely cheated at least 90 percent of the workers of approximately 15 percent of the legal overtime pay due them. As a conservative estimate, we believe that 3,375 of the 3,750 workers at the Next Collections factory have been shortchanged of some $444,000 a year in overtime wages, which would come to $1.2 million in the two and a half years the plant has been in operation. Each worker is due an average of $131.50 per year in back overtime pay.
A remediation plan is necessary to bring the Next Collections Limited factory into compliance with Bangladeshi labor laws and the International Labor Organization’s internationally recognized worker rights standards, which include: • Decent working conditions; • Freedom of association; • The right to organize an independent union; • The right to bargain collectively; • No child labor, and, • No forced labor.
We have reason to believe that it is routine practice to shortchange workers on their overtime pay throughout the giant HaMeem Group, where Next Collections is just one of 26 garment factories with a total of some 30,000 workers.
Critical improvements that could help move the Next Collections factory toward legal compliance: •
•
•
A respected independent human rights ombudsperson who the workers trust should be named to oversee labor, women’s and human rights compliance issues at the Next Collections factory for at least the next six months, or longer if necessary. Executives from Gap and Old Navy along with senior management of the Next Collections factory, the U.S.-based director of the Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights, and representatives of the progressive labor movement in Bangladesh should meet in Bangladesh to immediately launch a remediation and factory improvement plan. It is critical that Gap and Old Navy not pull their work from the Next Collections factory, which would only further harm the workers, who have already suffered enough. The Bangladeshi workers need these jobs, but they also need their legal rights ─ particularly the rights of the women who make up 70 percent of the workers at the Next Collections factory.
There must be an immediate end to the shortchanging of Next Collections workers of their legal pay for overtime hours.
•
Maternity Benefits: •
A. K. Azad, managing director of the Ha-Meem Group, and Shahabuddin, executive director of the Next Collections factory, must immediately cease to deny women workers their legal rights to paid maternity leave.
•
All the women workers of the Next Collections factory who have been denied the paid maternity leave due them under Bangladeshi law, including Zesmin Khatun and Taniya Begum, must be paid their maternity benefits, paid vacation days and severance pay. Given the hardship these women have suffered due to the denial of their legal maternity benefits, Next Collections factory management should make these women whole again by paying them triple the value of the benefits that were denied them.
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
42
•
Morium Begum, who was illegally forced to work 210 hours of mandatory overtime in June 2013, believes that her tragic seventh month miscarriage was directly related to the grueling hours she worked. She, and any other women workers who have suffered similar loss, should receive significant compensation.
•
Forced overtime must end. All overtime must be voluntary and paid at the proper 100 percent premium.
•
It is urgent that Gap and Old Navy compliance officers charged with monitoring facto-
ry and working conditions at the Next Collections factory undergo substantial remedial training, given that their monitoring efforts to date have been ineffective at best. •
Perhaps most important, management of the Next Collections factory must allot paid time for their workers on each floor to meet and enter into a dialogue with representatives of the Gap, Old Navy, the Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights, union leaders from the United States and Canada, and respected Bangladeshi union and women’s rights representatives. Such meetings will go a long way to build the workers’ trust and break their isolation.
In late July, the Bangladesh Garment and Industrial Workers’ Federation led a march to the collapsed Rana Plaza building — where 1,130 workers died and scores of others were maimed — demanding justice, union rights and a new minimum wage starting at 8,000 Taka, which amounts to 50 cents an hour and $24 a week.
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
43
Addenda A. Company Profiles
Gap
Tel: 201-558-2400 Fax: 201-558-2840 www.childrensplace.com info@childrensplace.com
Gap, Inc. Two Folsom Street San Francisco, CA 94105 Tel: 650-952-4400 www.gapinc.com Global_Integrity@gap.com
Jane T. Elfers, President & CEO Gregory Poole, Senior Vice President Global Sourcing
Glenn K. Murphy, Chairman and CEO Stefan Larsson, Global President, Old Navy Bobbi Silten, Senior Vice President, Global Responsibility & President, Gap Foundation, Gap Inc.
Children’s Place The Children's Place Retail Stores, Inc. 500 Plaza Drive Secaucus, NJ 07094
Louis Raphael Bill S. Kim, President Kizan International, Inc. 100 West Hill Drive Brisbane, CA 94005 Tel: 415-468-7360 info@louisraphael.com www.louisraphael.com
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
44 Next Collections and Ha-Meem Group Next Collections Ltd. 1323-1325, Beron, Ashulia Dhaka-1341 Bangladesh Tel: 02-8811149, 02-8813011 Fax: 02-8826090 E-mail: hameem@citehco.net Ha-Meem Group 241, Tejgaon Industrial Area, Dhaka-1208, Bangladesh Tel: 880-2-8878630-31, 8878639, 8878647; 880-2-8878654, 8878655 Fax: 880-2-887-8646 www.hameemgroup.net delwar@hameemgroup.com A. K. Azad, Managing Director azad@hameemgroup.com
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
45
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
46
B. Baby’s Jeans from Next Collections to Gap/Old Navy Distribution Center in Ohio Clothing labels smuggled out from the Next Collections factory in Bangladesh belong to Old Navy jeans and denim shorts for children and toddlers. This pair of Old Navy toddler girls “Super Skinny PullOn Jeggings for Baby” is made in the Next Collections factory in Bangladesh and sold in the United States for $14.94.
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
47
U.S. Customs Bill of Lading for Old Navy’s style number 492171 “Pull-On Jeggings for Baby.” This shipment of 11 carton boxes with a declared customs value of $2,276.35 went to the Gap/Old Navy distribution center in Groveport, Ohio. Old Navy baby garments of this style were produced in the Next Collections factory in July 2013. According to workers, Next Collections orders are shipped out under “Refat Garments Limited,” which is also owned by the HaMeem Group. The Institute purchased a pair at an Old Navy store in Pittsburgh for $14.94. (See the next page.) Import Bill of Lading Details Shipper:
Refat Garments Limited 144, 147-148 East Narashingpur Ashulia, Dhaka-1341, Bangladesh
Notify Party:
Expeditors International 245 Roger Avenue Inwood, NY 11096, USA
Country of Origin:
Bangladesh
Arrival Date:
05/30/2013
Port of Departure:
Salalah
Estimated Value:
$2,276.35
Port of Arrival:
New York
Quantity:
11 CTN
Marks & Numbers: - OFC-0010 6001 GREEN POINT DRIVE SOUTH GROVEPORT, OH 43125 USA WEARING APPARELS: INFANT’S/T ODDLER’S GIRLS 100% COTTON WOVEN PANTS, OF BLUE DENIM, REACHES BELOW THE KNEE , WAS H AS PER APPROVED D PO.NO. PB0UP-AA STYLE NO. 492171-0 0-2 CAT NO. N/A . INVOICENO. RGLGAP03059313 . DT.10. 03.2013. EXP NO.2486- 03612 -2013 . DT.10.03.2013. MOU . NO. 20120046 DT.18.05.2012 . H.S.CODE . 6209.20.3000 & 6204.62.4041. FCR NO CHT 817101 RELAY VESSEL MAER SK CHICAGO 1310 CONTAINER SUMMARY MSKU8180 753 ML-BD0090889 40X9’6 11CTN 0.600CBM 176.510KGS B/ L TOTAL SUMMARY 11CT N 0.600CBM 176.510KGS FREIG HT AS ARRANGED
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
48
U.S. Customs Bill of Lading for Old Navy’s style number 52569 “Boys Straight-Leg Jeans.” This shipment of 624 carton boxes with a declared customs value of $196,475.32 went to the Gap/Old Navy distribution center in Groveport, Ohio. The Institute purchased a pair at an Old Navy store in Pittsburgh for $12.
Import Bill of Lading Details Shipper:
Refat Garments Limited 144, 147-148 East Narashingpur Ashulia, Dhaka-1341, Bangladesh
Notify Party:
Expeditors International 245 Roger Avenue Inwood, NY 11096, USA
Country of Origin:
Bangladesh
Arrival Date:
07/05/2013
Port of Departure:
Salalah
Estimated Value:
$196,475.32
Port of Arrival:
New York
Quantity:
624 CTN
Marks & Numbers: - OFC-0010 6001 GREEN POINT DRIVE SOUTH GROVEPORT, OH 43125 USA WEARING APPREL . BOY’S 100% COTTON WOVEN BLUE DENIM PANT S, REACHES BELOW THE KNEE,WA SH AS PER APPROVED . D PO.NO . PN0TN-AA STYLE NO. 52569 1-00-2 CAT NO. N/A . INVO ICE NO. RGLGAP03120013 DT.20.05.2013. EXP NO.2486- 07427 -2013. DT.20.05.2013. MOU . NO. 20130002 DT.08.02.2013 . H.S.CODE . 6203.42.4036. FCR#CHT-826692 RELAY VESSEL MAERSK PITTSBURGH 13 02 CONTAINER SUMMARY MSKU8972030 ML-BD0073106 40X9’6 624CTN 35.220CBM 74 88.000KGS B/L TOTAL SUMMARY 624CTN 35.220CBM 748 8.000KGS FREIGHT AS ARRANGE D
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
49
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
50
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
51
The U.S. customs records showed Old Navy garments from Next Collections being shipped to “6001 Green Pointe Drive, Groveport, Ohio,� which is the location of a distribution center of Gap and Old Navy.
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
52
C. Form of Resignation Letter Next Collections management has a vague and ready-made standard form letter used to illegally deny workers their legal rights under Bangladeshi law. When management wishes to evade paying a pregnant worker her maternity leave or wants to force out any worker seeking his or her rights, management pressures the worker to “resign” — thus forfeiting maternity leave, severance pay, earned vacation leave and any other benefits they are legally owed.
[Translation] To The Executive Director Next Collections Limited 1323-1325 Beron, Ashulia Savar, Dhaka-1341 Subject: Resignation Letter Dear Sir, I am __________, ID Card __________, Designation __________, Line/Section __________. I have been working for your company for many months. Due to health reasons/family problems, it is impossible for me to continue to work at the factory. Therefore, I am making the application to ask you to relieve me from my position from __________. I would urge you to accept my resignation and oblige me thereby, Date: Sincerely Yours, Signature
D. Work Hour Regulation in Bangladesh Bangladesh Labor Law 2006 Chapter IX: Working Hours and Leave Section 100 Daily Hours No adult worker shall ordinarily be required, or allowed, to work in an establishment for more than eight hours on any day. Provided that, subject to the provisions of Section 108, any such worker may work in an establishment not exceeding ten hours in any day. Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
53
E. Maternity Leave Law in Bangladesh Maternity Leave Law Section 46 Right to, and liability for, payment of maternity benefits: Every woman employed in an establishment shall be entitled to, and her employer shall be liable for, the payment of maternity benefit in respective of the period of eight weeks preceding the expected day of her delivery and eight weeks immediately following the day of her delivery. Provided that a woman shall not be entitled to such maternity benefit unless she has worked under the employer for a period of not less than six months immediately preceding the day of her delivery. Section 48 Amount of maternity benefit: (1) The maternity benefit which is payable under this Act shall be payable at the rate of daily, weekly, or monthly average wages, as the case may be, calculated in the manner laid down in sub-section (2) and such payment shall be made wholly in cash. (2) For the purpose of sub section (1), the daily, weekly, or monthly average wages, as the case may be, shall be calculated by dividing the total wage earned by the woman during the three months immediately preceding the date on which she gives notice under this Act by the number of days she actually worked during the period. Source: “Labour and Industrial Laws of Bangladesh—The Bangladesh Labour Act 2006 & Other Cognate Labour Laws,” June 2007, Nirmalendu Dhar, ReMiSi Publishers
F. Pay Grades in Bangladesh’s Garment Industry Bangladeshi labor regulations stipulate seven legal pay grades, Grade 1 being the highest skilled, best paid job categories to Grade 7, the least skilled and lowest paid garment factory workers. Grade
Job Titles
Monthly Base Wage
Grade One
Pattern Master, Chief Quality Controller, Chief Cutting Master
Tk. 9,300
$120.62
Grade Two
Mechanic, Electrician, Cutting Master
Tk. 7,200
$93.39
Grade Three
Senior Operator
Tk. 4,218
$54.71
Grade Four
Operator, Quality Control Inspector
Tk. 3,861
$50.08
Grade Five
Junior Operator
Tk. 3,553
$46.08
Grade Six
Ordinary Operator
Tk. 3,322
$43.09
Grade Seven
Helper
Tk. 3,000
$38.91
* Exchange rate: $1.00 U.S. = 77.10 Bangladeshi Taka
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
54
G. Zesmin Kahtun’s Pregnancy Documentation
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
55
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
56
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
57
H. Mazharul’s Medical Documents After being beaten by Next Collections management and jailed for two days, Mazharul Islam was examined and treated by Icon Diagnostic Centre on September 10, 2013. The doctor’s notes list swelling on right arm, right ear, back and spinal area, and pain throughout his body. The doctor prescribed medication for pain.
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
58
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
59
I. Complaint Filed by Taniya at Ashulia Police Station Translation of excerpt (August 20, 2013): My husband Mazhar and I work at one of the Ha-Meem Group factories named Next Collections Limited located in Beron, Jamgora. I have been working at Next Collections Ltd. (Line #183) as a supervisor for the last ten months. My ID # is 205. My husband is also a supervisor on Line #182. Currently I am seven months pregnant. I am supposed to go on maternity leave for four months starting next month [September.] [Management] took maternity related documents from me for the maternity leave file. But the company put me under tremendous pressure to leave the factory without maternity leave and benefits, and to give my resignation. I declined to resign from my position. They threatened that they would slander my character, harass me and file false charges against me. They also threatened to fire my husband if I refused to resign. They continued to treat me harshly, especially 1. Administrative Officer, Mr. Elias, 2. General Manager, Mr. Liton, 3. Production Manager, Mr. Firoz, and 4. Welfare Officer, Ms. Shamima. Today at 1:00 p.m. they again threatened me and forced me out of the factory. They forbade me to enter the factory starting tomorrow. They are also pressuring my husband...
J. Managers at the Next Collections Limited Managing Director/owner:
Mr. A.K. Azad The powerful owner of Next Collections and the Ha-Meem Group of 26 factories in Bangladesh, with some 60,000 workers.
Next Collections management Executive Director Unit 01: Executive Director: General Manager: Administrative Officer: Production Manager: Supervisors: Welfare Officer:
Major Khan Modasser Hossain Mr. Shahabuddin Mr. Liakat Hossain Liton Mr. Elias Khan Mr. Firoz, Mr. Rana Mr. Shaqar, Mr. Abdul Hanif, Mr. Saiful Islam, and others Ms. Shamima
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
60
K. Illegal and Excessive Overtime Worker A “Ironing Man” in Finishing Section At the factory 399 Hours in the Month of June 2013 173 Hours Mandatory Overtime Shortchanged of Overtime Wages Week #1: At the factory 96 hours. Saturday, June 1
8:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m.
14-hour shift
8 regular hours, 5 hours overtime
Sunday, June 2
8:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m.
15-hour shift
8 regular hours, 6 hours overtime
Monday, June 3
8:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m.
15-hour shift
8 regular hours, 6 hours overtime
Tuesday, June 4
8:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m.
15-hour shift
8 regular hours, 6 hours overtime
Wednesday, June 5
8:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m.
15-hour shift
8 regular hours, 6 hours overtime
8:00 a.m. to 6:00 a.m.
22-hour shift
8 regular hours, 12 hours overtime
Thursday, June 6 Friday, June 7
--- Friday Off --─ Working 48 regular hours and 41 hours of overtime. ─ Working a total of 89 hours a week.
Week #2: At the factory 93 hours. Saturday, June 8
8:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m.
15-hour shift
8 regular hours, 6 hours overtime
Sunday, June 9
8:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m.
14-hour shift
8 regular hours, 5 hours overtime
Monday, June 10
8:00 a.m. to 1:00 a.m.
17-hour shift
8 regular hours, 7 hours overtime
Tuesday, June 11
8:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m.
15-hour shift
8 regular hours, 6 hours overtime
Wednesday, June 12
8:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m.
15-hour shift
8 regular hours, 6 hours overtime
17-hour shift
8 regular hours, 7 hours overtime
Thursday, June 13 8:00 a.m. to 1:00 a.m. Friday, June 14
--- Friday Off --─ Working 48 regular hours and 37 hours of overtime. ─ Working a total of 85 hours a week.
Week #3: At the factory 104 hours. Saturday, June 15
8:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m.
15-hour shift
8 regular hours, 6 hours overtime
Sunday, June 16
8:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m.
15-hour shift
8 regular hours, 6 hours overtime
Monday, June 17
8:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m.
15-hour shift
8 regular hours, 6 hours overtime
Tuesday, June 18
8:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m.
15-hour shift
8 regular hours, 6 hours overtime
Wednesday, June 19
8:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m.
15-hour shift
8 regular hours, 6 hours overtime
Thursday, June 20 8:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m.
15-hour shift
8 regular hours, 6 hours overtime
Friday, June 21 8:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m.
14-hour shift
13 hours overtime
─ Working 48 regular hours and 49 hours of overtime. ─ Working a total of 97 hours a week.
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
61
Week #4: At the factory 77 hours. Saturday, June 22 8:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m. Sunday, June 23
8:00 a.m. to 1:00 a.m.
Monday, June 24
8:00 a.m. to 7:00 p.m.
Tuesday, June 25
15-hour shift
8 regular hours, 6 hours overtime
17-hour shift
8 regular hours, 7 hours overtime
11-hour shift
8 regular hours, 2 hours overtime
--- Muslim religious holiday ---
Wednesday, June 26
8:00 a.m. to 1:00 a.m.
17-hour shift
8 regular hours, 7 hours overtime
Thursday, June 27
8:00 a.m. to 1:00 a.m.
17-hour shift
8 regular hours, 7 hours overtime
Friday, June 28
--- Friday Off --─ Working 40 regular hours and 29 hours of overtime. ─ Working a total of 69 hours a week.
At the factory 29 hours in two days. Saturday, June 29
8:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m.
15-hour shift
8 regular hours, 6 hours overtime
Sunday, June 30
8:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m.
14-hour shift
8 regular hours, 5 hours overtime
─ Working 16 regular hours and 11 hours of overtime. ─ Working a total of 27 hours during the last two days of June.
• • • •
Finishing Section workers were at the factory 399 hours in the month of June, 2013. Workers toiled 200 regular hours and 167 hours of mandatory overtime. These workers had just three days off in June. They were shortchanged on their legal overtime wages.
Note: When workers are kept for 17-hour shifts, from 8:00 a.m. to 1:00 a.m., they receive two hours off, an hour for lunch and an hour for supper.
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
62
Worker B Folding Woman in Finishing Section Forced to Work a 26-Hour Shift At the factory 443 Hours in the Month of June 2013 Standing on her feet 15-17-26 hours a day A “folding woman” in the finishing department at the Next Collections factory was routinely forced to stand for 15-, 17- and even 26-hour shifts! She was at the factory 443 hours in June, while working 200 regular hours and 202 overtime hours. She was allowed just two days off a month. Week #1: At the factory 104 hours. Saturday, June 1
8:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m.
14-hour shift
8 regular hours, 5 hours overtime
Sunday, June 2
8:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m.
15-hour shift
8 regular hours, 6 hours overtime
Monday, June 3
8:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m.
15-hour shift
8 regular hours, 6 hours overtime
Tuesday, June 4
8:00 a.m. to 1:00 a.m.
17-hour shift
8 regular hours, 7 hours overtime
8:00 a.m. to 1:00 a.m.
17-hour shift
8 regular hours, 7 hours overtime
8:00 a.m. to 10:00 a.m.
26-hour shift
8 regular hours, 15 hours overtime
Wednesday, June 5 Thursday, June 6 Friday, June 7
--- Friday Off --─ Working 48 regular hours and 46 hours of overtime. ─ Working a total of 94 hours a week.
Week #2: At the factory 106 hours. Saturday, June 8
8:00 a.m. to 1:00 a.m.
17-hour shift
8 regular hours, 7 hours overtime
8:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m.
14-hour shift
8 regular hours, 5 hours overtime
Monday, June 10
8:00 a.m. to 1:00 a.m.
17-hour shift
8 regular hours, 7 hours overtime
Tuesday, June 11
8:00 a.m. to 1:00 a.m.
17-hour shift
8 regular hours, 7 hours overtime
8:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m.
15-hour shift
8 regular hours, 6 hours overtime
17-hour shift
8 regular hours, 7 hours overtime
Sunday, June 9
Wednesday, June 12
Thursday, June 13 8:00 a.m. to 1:00 a.m. Friday, June 14
8:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m.
9-hour shift
8 hours overtime
─ Working 48 regular hours and 47 hours of overtime. ─ Working a total of 95 hours a week. Week #3: At the factory 105 hours. Saturday, June 15
8:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m.
14-hour shift
8 regular hours, 5 hours overtime
Sunday, June 16
8:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m.
15-hour shift
8 regular hours, 6 hours overtime
Monday, June 17
8:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m.
15-hour shift
8 regular hours, 6 hours overtime
Tuesday, June 18
8:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m.
15-hour shift
8 regular hours, 6 hours overtime
Wednesday, June 19
8:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m.
15-hour shift
8 regular hours, 6 hours overtime
Thursday, June 20 8:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m.
15-hour shift
8 regular hours, 6 hours overtime
Friday, June 21 8:00 a.m. to 12:00 a.m.
16-hour shift
15 hours overtime
─ Working 48 regular hours and 50 hours of overtime. ─ Working a total of 98 hours a week.
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
63
Week #4: At the factory 97 hours. Saturday, June 22 8:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m.
15-hour shift
8 regular hours, 6 hours overtime
Sunday, June 23
8:00 a.m. to 1:00 a.m.
17-hour shift
8 regular hours, 7 hours overtime
Monday, June 24
8:00 a.m. to 7:00 p.m.
11-hour shift
8 regular hours, 2 hours overtime
Tuesday, June 25
--- Muslim religious holiday ---
Wednesday, June 26
8:00 a.m. to 1:00 a.m.
17-hour shift
8 regular hours, 7 hours overtime
Thursday, June 27
8:00 a.m. to 2:00 a.m.
18-hour shift
8 regular hours, 8 hours overtime
Friday, June 28
8:00 a.m. to 3:00 a.m.
19-hour shift
17 hours overtime
─ Working 40 regular hours and 47 hours of overtime. ─ Working a total of 87 hours a week. At the factory 31 hours in two days. Saturday, June 29 Sunday, June 30
8:00 a.m. to 1:00 a.m.
17-hour shift
8 regular hours, 7 hours overtime
8:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m.
14-hour shift
8 regular hours, 5 hours overtime
─ Working 16 regular hours and 12 hours of overtime. ─ Working a total of 28 hours during the last two days.
• • • •
Scores of workers at the Finishing Section were at the factory 443 hours in the month of June. They worked 200 regular hours and 202 hours of mandatory overtime. These workers had just two days off in June. Workers were shortchanged on their legal overtime wages.
Note: When workers are kept working from 8:00 a.m. to 1:00 a.m. or later, they receive two hours off, an hour for lunch and an hour for a late-night meal.
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
64
Worker C Sewing Infant, Toddler and Children’s Clothing for Gap and Old Navy Forced Overtime; Shortchanged on Wages At the factory 392 Hours in June 2013 In June 2013, a male senior sewing operator at the Next Collections factory producing Gap’s Old Navy label was routinely forced to work 14 to 15 hours a day, working shifts of as long as 21 hours, with just a single day off in the month. Along with 200 regular hours, he was required to toil 162 hours of mandatory overtime. Week #1: At the factory 107 hours. Saturday, June 1
8:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m.
15-hour shift
8 regular hours, 6 hours overtime
Sunday, June 2
8:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m.
15-hour shift
8 regular hours, 6 hours overtime
Monday, June 3
8:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m.
14-hour shift
8 regular hours, 5 hours overtime
Tuesday, June 4
8:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m.
14-hour shift
8 regular hours, 5 hours overtime
Wednesday, June 5
8:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m.
14-hour shift
8 regular hours, 5 hours overtime
8:00 a.m. to 5:00 a.m.
21-hour shift
8 regular hours, 11 hours overtime
8:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m.
14-hour shift
13 hours overtime
Thursday, June 6 Friday, June 7
─ Working 48 regular hours and 51 hours of overtime. ─ Working a total of 99 hours a week. Week #2: At the factory 91 hours. Saturday, June 8
8:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m.
14-hour shift
8 regular hours, 5 hours overtime
Sunday, June 9
8:00 a.m. to 9:00 p.m.
13-hour shift
8 regular hours, 4 hours overtime
Monday, June 10
8:00 a.m. to 9:00 p.m.
13-hour shift
8 regular hours, 4 hours overtime
Tuesday, June 11
8:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m.
14-hour shift
8 regular hours, 5 hours overtime
Wednesday, June 12
8:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m.
14-hour shift
8 regular hours, 5 hours overtime
Thursday, June 13 8:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m.
14-hour shift
8 regular hours, 5 hours overtime
Friday, June 14
8:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m.
9-hour shift
8 hours overtime
─ Working 48 regular hours and 36 hours of overtime. ─ Working a total of 84 hours a week. Week #3: At the factory 93 hours. Saturday, June 15
8:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m.
14-hour shift
8 regular hours, 5 hours overtime
Sunday, June 16
8:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m.
14-hour shift
8 regular hours, 5 hours overtime
Monday, June 17
8:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m.
14-hour shift
8 regular hours, 5 hours overtime
Tuesday, June 18
8:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m.
14-hour shift
8 regular hours, 5 hours overtime
Wednesday, June 19
8:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m.
14-hour shift
8 regular hours, 5 hours overtime
Thursday, June 20
8:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m.
14-hour shift
8 regular hours, 5 hours overtime
8:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m.
9-hour shift
Friday, June 21
8 hours overtime
─ Working 48 regular hours and 38 hours of overtime. ─ Working a total of 86 hours a week.
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights
65
Week #4: At the factory 78 hours. Saturday, June 22 8:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m.
14-hour shift
8 regular hours, 5 hours overtime
Sunday, June 23
8:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m.
14-hour shift
8 regular hours, 5 hours overtime
Monday, June 24
8:00 a.m. to 9:00 p.m.
13-hour shift
8 regular hours, 4 hours overtime
Tuesday, June 25 Wednesday, June 26 Thursday, June 27 Friday, June 28
--- Muslim religious holiday --8:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m.
14-hour shift
8 regular hours, 5 hours overtime
8:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m.
14-hour shift
8 regular hours, 5 hours overtime
8:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m.
9-hour shift
8 hours overtime
─ Working 40 regular hours and 32 hours of overtime. ─ Working a total of 72 hours a week. At the factory 23 hours in two days. Saturday, June 29 Sunday, June 30
8:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m.
14-hour shift
8:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m.
9-hour shift
8 regular hours, 5 hours overtime 8 regular hours
─ Working 16 regular hours and 5 hours of overtime. ─ Working a total of 21 hours during the last two days of June.
• • • •
These sewing operators were at the factory 392 hours in the month of June 2013. They worked 200 regular hours and 162 hours of mandatory overtime. These workers had just one day off in June. They were routinely shortchanged on their legal overtime wages.
Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights