8 minute read
Opinion No consensus on Russia
OPINION
VICTORIAHATTERSLEY |
No consensus on Russia
As the Ukraine conflict carries on, Western powers seem unable to reach an agreement on how to deal with Vladimir Putin’s expansionist ambitions.
The announcement that the British Museum has loaned part of the Parthenon marbles to a Russian museum has caused consternation in some quarters. The headless statue of Greek river-god Ilissos is now on display at the State Hermitage Museum in St Petersburg.
After all, relations between Russia and the West have been frosty to say the least in the wake of Russia’s invasion of eastern Ukraine earlier this year and the shooting down of Malaysia Airlines flight MH17 in July. Why then, argue some spoilsports, should the UK be seen in any way to endorse the Russian regime? Is the message that all of this is OK as long as we are sharing our headless artefacts? The British Museum’s rejoinder is that they “have always believed that such loans must continue between museums in spite of political disagreements between governments.”
One thing is clear, at any rate – the Greeks can’t have them back. And here is one of the ironies: The marbles are only in their present home because Lord Elgin, the British ambassador to the Ottoman Empire, swiped them from the Parthenon in Athens in the 19th Century. Understandably, the Greek government would prefer it if they were returned. Historically, Russia is by no means alone in its snatch and grab approach – whether the target is priceless statues or entire countries.
But then perhaps this is only fitting: the mixed messages inherent in this smaller issue seem merely to be a reflection of western Europe’s attitude towards the Russian problem in general. There appears to be no clear consensus on how to deal with president Vladimir Putin and his land-grabbing tendencies.
Differing approaches
For example, German chancellor Angela Merkel recently offered a blistering criticism of Putin, accusing him of interfering in the domestic affairs of Balkan states looking to form closer ties to the EU. He was, she said, “creating problems” in Moldova and Georgia.
When asked by Die Welt am Sonntag newspaper about the possibility of war between Russia and the West over the Baltic states – in recent weeks we have seen ‘unprecedented’ Russian naval and air force activity in the Baltic Sea region – her reply was: “The question of war in the Baltic States does not arise.” Although she went on to add: “Nevertheless, Article 5 of the Nato Treaty, that is the obligation of mutual support, applies to all allies.”
This no-nonsense attitude is in contrast to that of France, whose President Francois Hollande recently made an unannounced stop in Moscow for a two-hour meeting with Mr Putin to discuss the Ukraine crisis. (Curiously, Mr Hollande, as though to further emphasise the casual nature of the encounter, described it thusly: “I was just flying over Moscow when I decided to make a stop here.” As one does.)
It is unclear what lurks behind this lack of agreement on how to deal with Mr Putin. Perhaps France is sheepish about the two warships it has so far failed to deliver to Moscow, having been under pressure from its western allies to cancel the contract (although it has yet to do so). After the meeting Mr Putin indicated that the bear’s fur would not be unduly ruffled if France refused to hand over the ships, as long as the money already paid was returned.
And meanwhile the conflict in Ukraine rumbles on, where more than 4300 have died since last spring. There is also a question mark over how well its economy is likely to hold up. The International Monetary Fund has identified a $15bn shortfall in its bailout for the war-torn country and has warned western governments that the gap needs to be filled within weeks or it risks financial collapse.
Muddying the waters still further is the fact that Wolfgang Schäuble, the German finance minister, said recently he had called on his Russian counterpart, Anton Siluanov, to ask him to roll over a $3bn loan the Kremlin made to Kiev last year. UK finance minister George Osborne was probably not alone in expressing surprise at the EU asking for help from Russia whilst simultaneously sanctioning the Kremlin over the Ukraine. Look at this tangle of thorns, indeed.
Far-right links
Just as disturbing is Russia’s move towards cultivating links with the far right in Europe. For example, the founder of France’s Front National (FN), Jean-Marie Le Pen, borrowed €2m from a Cyprus-based company, Veronisa Holdings, owned by one Yuri Kudimov.
And who is Kudimov? A former KGB agent, now banker, with close links to the Kremlin – that’s who. More recently, the FN also confirmed it had taken a huge €9.4 million loan from the First Czech Russian bank in Moscow.
Elsewhere, Putin continues to pitch his woo in eastern Europe. Since as far back as 2009, Russia has been establishing ties with Slovakia’s far-right People’s party, Bulgaria’s nationalist, anti-EU Attack movement and Hungary’s radical nationalist Jobbik party.
It is perhaps convenient for Mr Putin that he is also able to take advantage of a rising wave of anti-immigration sentiment throughout western Europe. UK Prime Minister David Cameron’s talk of imposing ‘emergency brakes’ on the number of EU migrants moving to Britain and recent anti-Muslim protests across Germany may well have had the Russian premier rubbing his hands together with glee.
Is it the case that Mr Putin is in fact stealing a more insidious march on Europe whilst its major powers look the other way? Yes, the Russian economy isn’t looking healthy just now what with falling oil prices and the effect of European sanctions, but it is by no means beaten. Time will tell. Europe hasn’t lost its marbles over Russia yet, but it may want to be careful as to whom it lends them out. n
Editor Peter Mercer
Deputy Editor Victoria Hattersley
Profile Writers Abigail Saltmarsh Felicity Landon Piotr Sadowski Emma-Jane Batey Barbara Rossi Philip Yorke Edina Sin
Art Director Gareth Harrey
Art Editor Rob Czerwinski
Designers Leon Esterhuizen Paul Abbott Claire Bidle
Web Development Neil Robertson IT Support Jack Everson
Production Manager Kamila Kajtoch
Administration Anna Chamberlain Amber Dawson Kayleigh Harvey
Art Administration Tania Balderson
Advertising Manager Andrew Briggs
Sector Managers Matthew Howe Milada Preslova Massimo Ragazzo Helen Leisi Anthony McClintock Ben Snowing Anna Dudek Stephen Moore Martin Gisborne Victoria Pease
Industry Europe Alkmaar House, Alkmaar Way, Norwich, Norfolk, NR6 6BF, United Kingdom
© Industry Europe 2015 No part of this publication may be reproduced in any form for any purpose, other than short sections for the purpose of review, without prior consent of the publisher.
POSITIVE PUBLICATIONS
A Square Root Company
US Industry Today, Industry Europe’s sister publication, is published in the United States of America. For further information or to subscribe contact: Sue Poeton, 100 Morris Avenue, Suite 202, Springfield, NJ 07081. Tel: +1 973 218-0310 Fax: +1 973 218-0311. Email: corporate@USIToday.com. Web site: USIToday.com
CONTENTS
Pharmaceutical Industry p6
Comment
1 Opinion No consensus on Russia 4 Bill Jamieson Jean-Claude’s bulging billions
Pharmaceutical Industry
6 Uneven growth Global pharma industry held up by Europe’s slow recovery 9 Pharmaceutical news The latest from the industry 12 Working together to get medicines to market Roche looks at how to meet a transatlantic challenge
News
14 Winning business New orders and contracts 16 Linking up Combining strengths 18 Moving on Relocations and expansions 19 Industry people Appointments 20 Technology spotlight Advances in technology 21 Notice board New products and processes
Reports
22 Focus on Germany Allan Hall reports from Berlin 23 Focus on France Ian Sparks reports from Paris
Aerospace
24 At the leading edge Asco
Agriculture
33 Focus on fertile growth Yara International 38 Combining old and new Agrikon Kam
Automation & Tooling
42 Pioneering steel industry solutions Danieli Automation 46 Mission accomplished JEB 50 Power players SPARKY GROUP 54 The first choice for automation YASKAWA
Automotive
58 Advanced fastening systems Agrati 62 Quality components for the automotive industry Gedia Poland 68 Perfect fit Johnson Controls 72 Steering a course for growth Musashi 75 Top gear performer LuK Savaria Kuplunggyártó
VOL 25/1
Above: Procter & Gamble p100
Chemicals
78 In full colour Ampacet 82 Continued growth for chemical giant TVK
Above: Asco p24 Below: YASKAWA p54
Construction
84 Fresh thinking and design KÉSZ Group 88 With a true team spirit GranitiFiandre 92 Building a greener future Skanska
Consumer Goods
96 Out in front Gazelle 100 A sustainable future for P&G Procter & Gamble
Energy & Utilities
109 Heating Budapest city Főtáv 112 Step on the gas Hexagon 116 The power of commitment Končar Generators and Motors 120 Energy efficient power solutions Wärtsilä 131 End-to-end electrical solutions CG
Food & Drink
136 Quality cooking oil from Hungary Bunge 141 Tradition and innovation in Italian wines Fontanafredda
Forest Products
144 Renewable energy – it grows on trees Balcas
Above: Johnson Controls p68 Below: KESZ Group p84
Glass Products
148 Glass technology SCHOTT 152 Transparent success Sangalli Group
Metalworking
155 Sheer performance CIDAN Machinery 158 Completing the circle Corinth Pipeworks 162 Active even in critical times Makstil 166 Gearing up for new markets TTN Veneta
Also in this issue…
170 Environmentally chilled EPTA Group 174 Innovative communications GN Netcom 180 Pioneering smarter ventilation systems SALDA Above: Hexagon p112 Below: Bunge p136
Above: Balcas p144 Below: GN Netcom p174
