Associate Justice Brion's concurring opinon

Page 1

G. R. No. 213181 - Francis H. Jardeleza, Petitioner, v. Chief Justice Maria Lourdes P. A. Sereno, the Judicial and Bar Council and Executive Secretary Paquito N. Ochoa, Jr., Respondents. Promulgated: A11g11st

19

2014(1/

SEPARATE CONCURRING OPINION BRION,J.: Prefatory Statement

I write this Separate Concurring Opinion to express my CONCURRENCE with the ponencia of my esteemed colleague - Justice Jose Catral Mendoza - and to reflect my own views on this case of first impression. This case is the first test, since the establishment in 1987 of the Judicial and Bar Council (the JBC), of its even-handedness and the extent of the discretion granted to it in determining the shortlist of nominees for a vi;icant position in the judiciary. These questions are posed in the context of allegations ofprocedural infirmities that violated an applicant's right to due process, as well as claims of partiality in the selection process. In resolving these questions, we must inevitably also look at the extent of the Court's supervisory authority over the JBC, as well as the Court's expanded jurisdiction under the Constitution to determine grave abuse of discretion on the part of the JBC, a governmental body. Notably, our decision in this case touches on matters of national interest, among them, the President's appointment power that must remain unfettered and to its fullest, to the extent allowed by the Constitution. Otherwise stated, to the extent that the JBC departs from the guidelines it has itself set and commits grave abuse of discretion in undertaking its selection, the President's exercise of his appointing authority is fettered and less than full. Any grave abuse of discretion by the JBC likewise affects the Supreme Court which then will not have the benefit of the best and the brightest that the President will choose. Additionally, any abuse of discretion is of great interest to the Court as its representative to that body is its Chief Justice whose actions in the JBC selection should be no less than sterling in keeping with the nature of her position and the trust that the nation places on the Chief Justice and the Court.

~


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.