January 31, 2024 by Ithaca Times

F R E E / J a n u a r y 3 1 , 2 0 2 4 / V o l u m e X L I I I , N u m b er 74 / O u r 5 2 n d Y e a r

Online @ ITH ACA .COM

The State of the County Chairman Klein Outlines 2024 Priorities PAGES 8-9

TCAT WINTER-SPRING SERVICE

MIKE SIGLER RUNS FOR STATE SENATE

PAGE 3

PAGE 4

ACTIVISTS RALLY IN ALBANY TO SHUTDOWN SENECA LANDFILL PAGE 5

JUST THE RIGHT NOTES

AMERICAN FICTION: PRINCIPLE VS. SUCCESS

PAGE 11

PAGE 12

PIZZA • WINGS • CALZONES • SIDES • PEPSI

Loaves & Fishes Extends Deep Appreciation to Our Sponsors, Potters, Restaurants and Wineries, Whose Support Made Empty Bowls a Resounding Success! Your Commitment to Helping Us Feed People in Need Makes a Diﬀerence Every Day.

Sponsors

Potters

Premier Gary Bercow Tompkins Community Bank Laura Burch Pottery Inn on Columbia Julia e Dean Triad Foundation The Clay School Leadership Betsy Graham Wegmans Cayuga Medical Center Judy Hoﬀman Partner Shawn Hull True Insurance Perri LoPinto Pottery Visions Federal Credit Terry Marcus Design Union Chemung Canal Trust Sharon Nelson Company Gary Rith Pottery Fingerlakes Wealth Front Porch Pottery Management by Tom Roach Advocate Guthrie Jenny Ross Cornell University Jaques Schickel Crown Construction Diane Sullivan Design Triphammer Laundromat Giotto Zampognia CFCU Federal Credit Union Friend Cayuga Landscape Co. The William Henry Miller Inn Dermatology Associates of Ithaca

CATERING & PARTY PACKS AVAILABLE

Food Beacon Events & Catering —Revelry Yards The Boatyard Grill Cayuga Medical Center Establishment Gola Osteria The Heights Restaurant Inn at Taughannock Falls Ithaca Bakery Loaves & Fishes Just Desserts Kiely’s Cooking Maxie’s Supper Club Moosewood Restaurant Taverna Ban� Taste of Thai Express Word of Mouth Catering Wide Awake Bakery

Wineries Damiani Wine Sellers Frontenac Point Vineyard Hosmer Winery Lakewood Vineyards Long Point Winery Montezuma Winery Shalestone Vineyards Six Mile Creek Winery Wagner Vineyards

THANK YOU! 2 The Ithaca Times / January 31 – February 6, 2024

SPECIAL

$29 49

1 LARGE CHEESE OR 1 TOPPING pizza, 8 count buffalo wings, bread stix & a 2 liter Pepsi. Valid thru 2/10/24

ITHACA 607 273-7272

BIG FLATS 607-358-6088

SYRACUSE 315-463-7272

REG

$41 76

JOHNSON CITY 607-777-9997

Newsline

VOL. XLIII / NO. 74 / January 31, 2024 Serving 47,125 readers week ly

ON THE COVER:

TCAT GM Discusses Winter-Spring Schedule Changes and Ongoing Driver Shortage

NEWSLINE ��3-5 LETTERS TO THE EDITOR �� 6 GUEST OPINION �� 7

By M at t D ough e rt y

service the YMCA and provide service to Cayuga Medical Park through Route 13. Additionally, route 65 is set to offer he winter-spring schedule for TCAT increased service to Hudson Street in both (Tompkins Consolidated Area Transit) began last week, and TCAT directions. However, Vanderpool expressed regret over the unfulfilled hope of reinstatgeneral manager Scott Vanderpool says ing routes 14s and 83 due to ongoing chalthe organization is still having trouble lenges in recruiting drivers. recruiting drivers and returning service to Efficiency in scheduling is a critical pre-pandemic levels. theme that Vanderpool has focused on to In a recent interview on WHCU news radio, Vanderpool explained that there would start the year. He emphasized the importance of data collection be some adjustments to in transit, mentioning improve route timing, automatic passenbut the unfortunate ger counts and other reality is that TCAT systems that track will not be able to bring ridership. This data service levels back to helps make informed pre-pandemic standards. decisions about routes Despite concerted efforts and services, focusing to recruit bus operators, on popular and wellVanderpool says the natraveled routes while tionwide transit issue of a optimizing efficiency. driver shortage remains — Scott Vanderpool When asked about a significant hurdle. the ongoing driver “We’re facing the same workforce shortage many others face, shortage, Vanderpool acknowledged the slow progress in recruiting new drivers. and it’s a nationwide transit issue caused by the Driver shortage,” Vanderpool stated. Currently, TCAT has around 60 full-time drivers, but to reach pre-pandemic service Highlighting specific changes in the levels from 2019, they would need about routes, Vanderpool mentioned the inte20 more. Vanderpool said service levels gration of routes 30 and 90 for enhanced will gradually return to normal as new efficiency. This integration aligns the two drivers join the team. routes, bringing more service to the busy “We can only do so much as the drivers north campus area of Cornell and slightly start to come in here. We’ve done a lot of reducing service to the mall. He also marketing, job fairs, poster campaigns, pointed out the extension of Route 30 to

Chairman of the Tompkins County Legislature Dan Klein.

“We’re facing the same workforce shortage many others face, and it’s a nationwide transit issue caused by the Driver shortage”

T a k e

SPORTS �� 10 TCAT is unable to return service to pre-pandemic levels as the organization continues to struggle amidst a national driver shortage. (Photo: Provided)

referral bonuses, and increased starting pay to $25.66. It’s a great starting rate, very competitive,” Vanderpool stated. The discussion delved into the challenges of balancing the need to provide services with the importance of not overcommitting and putting the existing drivers and the public schedule at risk. Vanderpool stressed the careful approach, taking one step at a time to bring back service levels. Reflecting on passenger feedback, Vanderpool highlighted the continued positivity from riders despite service reductions. He acknowledged the resilience of TCAT’s bus operators and their commitment to excellent customer service during the pandemic. A rider’s advisory group also provides valuable feedback, emphasizing the importance of maintaining a positive relationship with the community. Vanderpool concluded with a reflection on the changes in ridership since January 2021, with TACT currently at about 60% of pre-pandemic ridership levels. Vanderpool expressed optimism about gradually returning to previous ridership numbers as the transit agency navigates the ongoing challenges. Contin u ed on Page 15

N o t e

X Participate in 2024’s Point in Time Count to Help Track Homelessness Can you spare a few minutes this week to contribute to our community's annual Point in Time Count by offering this survey to people you encounter who are experiencing homelessness? The Point in Time Count is an annual HUD requirement that tasks communities with enumerating the number of people experiencing homelessness on a single night in the last ten days of January. It is considered local snapshot data and is collected and

submitted for analyses and becomes part of a report that Congress uses to help set funding levels and priorities for the homeless response system. While the Continuum of Care is aware that people's experiences of homelessness vary widely, for this snapshot data, they are seeking responses from people who were experiencing HUD definition of homelessness (sleeping in a place not meant for human habitation or in the emergency

shelter system) on the night of Thursday 1/25/2023. The service provider surveys are tools the CoC uses to reach and survey folks. The survey will be open from 1/25/2024-2/1/2024. Please consider participating by completing the survey with your participants if possible and by sharing the link with folks in your sphere. The survey asks people to describe their experience of homelessness on the night of Thursday, 1/25.

ARTS & ENTERTAINMENT �� 11 CINEMA �� 12 SPECIAL EVENT �� 13 CLASSIFIED �� 16-17 TIMES TABLE �� 18-19

ON T HE WE B Visit our website at www.ithaca.com for more news, arts, sports and photos. Call us at 607-277-7000 M a t t D o u g h e r t y , M a n a g i n g E d i t o r , x 1217 E d i t o r @ I t h a c aTi m e s . c o m Ch r i s I b e r t, C a l en da r Ed i to r , A r t s @ I t h a c aTi m e s . c o m M a t t D o u g h e r t y , N e w s R e p o r t e r , x 1225 R e p o r t e r @ I t h a c aTi m e s . c o m Kenneth Waterhouse, Photographer Ste ve L awrence, Spo rts Co lumn ist St e v e S p o r t sD u d e @ g m a i l .co m J i m B i l i n s k i , P u b l i s h e r , x 1210 j b i l i n s k i @ I t h a c aTi m e s . c o m L a r r y H o c h b e r g e r , A s s o c i a t e P u b l i s h e r , x 1214 l a r r y@ I t h a c aTi m e s . c o m F r ee l a n ce r s : Barbara Adams, Stephen Burke, G. M Burns, Alyssa Denger, Jane Dieckmann, Charley Githler, Ross Haarstad, Steve Lawrence, Marjorie Olds, Henry Stark, and Arthur Whitman THE ENTIRE CONTENTS OF THE ITHACA TIMES ARE C O P Y R I G H T © 2 02 3, B Y N E W S K I I N C . All rights reserved. Events are listed free of charge in TimesTable. All copy must be received by Friday at noon. The Ithaca Times is available free of charge from various locations around Ithaca. Additional copies may be purchased from the Ithaca Times offices for $1. SUBSCRIPTIONS: $89 one year. Include check or money order and mail to the Ithaca Times, PO Box 27, Ithaca, NY 14851. ADVERTISING: Deadlines are Monday 5 p.m. for display, Tuesday at noon for classified. Advertisers should check their ad on publication. The Ithaca Times will not be liable for failure to publish an ad, for typographical error, or errors in publication except to the extent of the cost of the space in which the actual error appeared in the first insertion. The publisher reserves the right to refuse advertising for any reason and to alter advertising copy or graphics deemed unacceptable for publication. The Ithaca Times is published weekly Wednesday mornings. Offices are located at 109 N. Cayuga Street, Ithaca, NY 14850 607-277-7000, FAX 607277-1012, MAILING ADDRESS is PO Box 27, Ithaca, NY 14851. The Ithaca Times was preceded by the Ithaca New Times (1972–1978) and The Good Times Gazette (1973–1978), combined in 1978. Founder Good Times Gazette: Tom Newton

January 31 – February 6, 2024 / The Ithaca Times

INQUIRING Mike Sigler Launches State Senate Campaign Focused on Crime and Taxes PHOTOGRAPHER O N e w s l i n e

By Ke nne th Wate rhou se WHAT IS YOUR FAVORITE PAST OR PRESENT ITHACA RESTAURANT?

“Moosewood.” – Laura R.

“Manos Diner was the best.” – Ray A.

“Sammy’s pizzeria was my go-to.” – Phorrest T.

“Simeon’s Restaurant.” – Jenny C.

“Dolce, Best breakfast sandwich’s ever.” – Joann W.

By M at t D ough e rt y

n January 24, longtime Tompkins County Legislator Mike Sigler officially launched his campaign for the New York State Senate. Silgler is competing against Democratic incumbent Lea Webb for the 52nd District seat covering Broome, Cortland, and Tompkins Counties. Approximately 100 supporters gathered at the Sons of Italy in Endicott to rally behind Sigler, who has 14 years of experience on the county legislature. Sigler identifies as a moderate Republican and wasted no time in articulating his vision, emphasizing the need to address issues ranging from violent crime, drug-related fatalities, increasing taxes, and an exodus of jobs to other states. "New York isn’t the same place that it used to be. Violent crime is up. Fentanyl and other dangerous drugs are killing people daily. Taxes are skyrocketing. Jobs and young people are fleeing to other states," Sigler said, highlighting the urgency of addressing these critical concerns. Sigler has served as a Tompkins County Legislator for over a decade. His track record includes efforts to lower property taxes, boost funding for law enforcement and public safety, and expand programs benefiting seniors, students, and the broader community. He aims to extend this pragmatic approach to Albany as the next State Senator. “Despite it being clear that things are headed in the wrong direction, politicians in Albany like Lea Webb aren’t doing enough to fix it. They keep pushing extreme policies like Bail Reform, Sanctuary Cities, and Defunding The Police,” Sigler criticized New York’s Democratic leadership, positioning himself as a candidate focused on more moderate policies. Sigler outlined critical priorities for his campaign, including fighting inflation, reducing crime, making strategic investments for the energy future, managing the migrant crisis, and improving education. Sigler’s emphasis on combating inflation and enhancing public safety resonates with his local advocacy for lower taxes and increased law enforcement funding. Sigler pointed to rising costs of living, including high food and energy prices, as another top challenge facing the 52nd district. He said constituents regularly express concerns about being able to afford

4 The Ithaca Times / January 31 – February 6, 2024

basic expenses like groceries and dining out. In addition, Sigler argued that New York’s energy policies have emphasized electrification without increasing electricity generation and have contributed to higher utility bills. As a state senator, Silver says that he would aim to promote an "all of the above" energy strategy that brings more affordable options to the table. Sigler’s support for law enforcement has earned him an endorsement from the New York State Union of Police Associations (NYSUPA), a statewide organization dedicated to advocating for the rights and well-being of Tompkins County Legislator Mike Silgler is running as a Republican to represent the State Senate’s 52nd District against public safety officers. Democratic incumbent Lea Webb. (Photo: Provided) In the letter announcing the endorsement, NYSUPA his electoral success in Tompkins County, President Anthony Solfaro said, “[This] where Democrats significantly outnumber endorsement is a result of your support for Republicans. Despite the odds, he has been the law enforcement community and your elected four times as a moderate Republirecognition of those officers as dedicated and hard-working public employees who go can, which he says showcases his appeal to voters across party lines. out each and every day to serve the public In addition to his political career, at great personal risk and sacrifice.” Solfaro Sigler has worked for two decades at continued saying, “NYSUPA will be urging Park Outdoor Advertising in Ithaca. This its membership, their families, and friends professional experience has given him who reside in the 52nd District to support a firsthand look at the adverse effects of [Sigler’s] election.” Regarding the endorsement, Sigler said, economic policies on businesses, jobs, and families. Earlier in his career, Sigler “It’s an honor to earn this endorsement that represents the support of thousands of was a television reporter and producer for WENY and WETM in Elmira. uniformed law enforcement professionals Sigler acknowledged that as a Tompacross New York.” He added, “They’ve seen kins County resident, he would need to do what we’ve all seen; that New York isn’t more outreach in Broome County, where the same place that it used to be. Violent he is less well known. However, he noted crime is up. Fentanyl and other dangerous that Park Outdoor has a significant presdrugs are killing people on a daily basis. ence in both Broome and Cortland CounMeanwhile, out of touch politicians like ties, familiarizing him with economic Lea Webb are prioritizing the wrong poliissues across the district. Regardless, Sigler cies and just making things worse.” says that he has already spent time meetA main talking point of Sigler’s is that ing with community leaders in Broome violent crime is increasing, however data County over the past year and had pledged doesn’t seem to support that claim. According to data collected by police depart- to continue engaging voters there. According to Sigler, balancing the state ments and sheriff ’s offices in 57 counties senate campaign with his current role in across New York State, violent crime dethe Tompkins County Legislature will creased 6% in the first six months of 2023 require diligence, but he says his legislative compared to the first half of 2022. experience has prepared him well. While flipping a district that elected a On the county level, Sigler praised the Democrat in the last election cycle is an uphill battle, Sigler has said that his ability to secure bipartisan support is evident in Contin u ed on Page 15

N e w s l i n e

Environmental Advocates Rally at NY State Capitol Urging Governor Hochul to Close Seneca Meadows Landfill

By M at t D ough e rt y

n January 24, activists and elected officials organized a rally at the New York State Capitol in Albany to call on Governor Kathy Hochul to shut down the Seneca Meadows Landfill — the largest landfill in New York State. The event was organized by Seneca Lake Guardian and drew support from key figures, including Senator Lea Webb and Assembly Member Anna Kelles. Seneca Meadows, located in Seneca Falls, NY, was initially slated to cease operations in 2025. However, its operator, Texas-based Waste Connections, has submitted a new permit application to extend operations until 2040. The proposed expansion would grow the landfill's footprint by 47 acres and increase the towering mountain of trash by an additional 70 feet, exacerbating environmental concerns. New York State released its Solid Waste Management Plan in July 2023, outlining a ten-year strategy prioritizing sustainable waste management practices in New York. The plan emphasizes reducing landfill waste and expanding recycling infrastructure, making the landfill expansion counter-

productive to the state’s environmental goals. Rally participants urged Governor Hochul to increase investments in recycling and composting programs, enforce producer responsibility, endorse reusable and refillable products, and adopt the Packaging Reduction and RecyState Senator Lea Webb and Assembly Member Anna Kelles rally with activists at the State Capitol in Albany to call on Governor Kathy Hochul cling Infrastructure to shut-down the Seneca Meadows Landfill. (Photo: Provided) Act. Yvonne Taylor, Co-Founder of Seneca Lake Guardian, emphasized the communi- emphasizing the need to commit to reducing waste, efficient resource use, and proty's firsthand experience with the landfill's moting recycling and reuse. Kelles stated, detrimental effects, stating, “As hosts to “It’s time for New York to commit to a NY’s largest landfill, we experience harmrobust transition to a circular economy.” ful air, water, and climate impacts every The environmental risks posed by day, and enough is enough.” landfills disproportionately affect marginSenator Lea Webb stressed the imporalized communities, including communitance of transitioning to a zero-waste, ties of color, indigenous communities, and circular economy, stating, “New York rural and low-wealth communities. Seneca State needs to move forward a zero-waste, Meadows contributes up to 200,000 galcircular economy and a greener, healthier lons of PFAS-laden wastewater daily, future. Expanding our landfilling capacity undermines these goals.” Assemblymember Anna Kelles echoed this sentiment, Contin u ed on Page 15

nstead of meeting once a month, the Ithaca City Common Council is considering making changes to its legislative structure that would see the Council meet in full at least three times a month. Mayor Robert Cantelmo proposed the change in structure as a way to improve communication among council members and the committees they sit on. The proposed schedule changes include a regular council meeting on the first Wednesday of the month, a Special Topics work session on the second Wednesday, and a study session on the third Wednesday. Currently, the Council meets in full once a month, with at least two additional standing committee meetings that don’t involve the full 11-member council. While discussing the proposed changes, Mayor Cantelmo said, “These changes

are designed to foster a more inclusive environment where all council members actively participate in shaping policies for our community.” Even though Cantelmo proposed the change as a step towards progress, some council members raised concerns about the scheduling impact on those with other commitments and proposed adjustments to meeting times. First Ward Alderperson Phoebe Brown said, “I have reservations about the frequency of these meetings [because] it could pose challenges for council members with other commitments.” Brown added, “We need to consider the practical impact on those who have full workdays before the meetings.” Despite the concerns, Mayor Cantelmo emphasized the efficiency of the new structure, anticipating shorter meetings and increased staff effectiveness. Accord-

Ups

Cornell Men’s Basketball defeated Princeton, the defending Ivy League champions 83-68. The Big Red improved to 15-3 overall and 4-0 in conference play to take top spot. Nazir Williams put up a game-high 20 points, and 3 other Big Red players got into double digits.

Downs

The Ithaca Police Department apprehended Zavierus D. King on January 26th, 2024, following an investigation initiated on January 12th, 2024. The arrest, made without incident in the 100 block of Cecil A. Malone Drive, resulted in charges related to the possession of an illegal handgun.

HEARD&SEEN Heard

On Tuesday, February 6, the Tompkins County Legislature will consider a resolution urging our federal government to call for a ceasefire in Gaza.

Seen

The iconic Chanticleer building at the corner of State and Cayuga Streets in Downtown Ithaca has been listed for sale.

IF YOU CARE TO RESPOND to something in this column, or suggest your own praise or blame, write news@ithacatimes. com, with a subject head “U&D.”

QUESTION

Council Considers Changing Schedule to Meet Three Times a Month By M at t D ough e rt y

UPS&DOWNS

OF THE WEEK

ing to Cantelmo, the idea behind the change is to encourage broader council participation in discussions and avoid policy being hammered out in specific committees without full council input. “The intention is to foster a more collaborative approach among council members,” Cantelmo said. He added, “This model ensures that all members are actively participating in shaping policies and prevents isolation within specific committees.” The proposed changes sparked discussions on handling urgent matters that require the council’s immediate attention. The unanimous consent mechanism was mentioned, which allows items to be added to the agenda at the last minute, but Cantelmo stressed that it should be used sparingly. Contin u ed on Page 7

Are you having trouble affording to pay utility bills? 38.7% Yes. 58.1% No. 3.2% I don’t know.

N ext Week ’s Q uestion :

Should Governor Hochul shut down the Seneca Meadows Landf ill? Visit ithaca.com to submit your response.

January 31 – February 6, 2024 / The Ithaca Times

The Talk at

LETTERS TO THE EDITOR Let’s Get Honest About Crime

“

Trump and the Republican Party constantly rail about rising crime rates. But that’s not real life in America today. They’re making it up. In 2023, murder rates plummeted faster than ever before, according to FBI statistics. Murder is down 12.7% with a decline registered in three-quarters of the more than 175 cities with available data. These are the largest percent declines ever recorded in overall violent crime, murder, rape, and aggravated assault, with nearrecord high declines in robbery, overall property crime, theft, and burglary. Yes, there is still a terrible level of gun violence in America, but we’re moving in the right direction in all areas except auto theft and, in some areas, shoplifting. In fact, the worst crime rates in the country occurred during the 1980s and very early 1990s when Republicans Ronald Reagan and George H.W. Bush sat in the Oval Office. Crime rates have been on

a downhill slide since then. We all heard Trump rage about “American carnage” in his 2017 inaugural address — he said there was a wave of violence sweeping our cities. He lied. Actual urban violence was near a generational low point at the time. But, bolstered by Fox and the right-wing media megaphone, his rhetoric resonated with many Americans. And as we know, Republicans only get concerned with crime when a Democrat is president. Even if they have to make it up. Of course, there was a brief surge in violent crime during the pandemic, for all kinds of reasons. But that is simply no longer the case as pointed out above. Violent crime rates are falling back to the low levels of the 2010s. So, if we’re going to be honest about crime, it’s time to tell your friends and family the truth: Republicans want us to believe that cities in blue states are hellscapes of crime. But the truth is just the opposite. Today, the murder rate in New York City, for instance, is about half that of Republican cities like Miami and Fort Worth. The good news is, Trump has been proven wrong again. The nation is heading back to our pre-pandemic, low levels of crime. The bad news is that the Republican noise machine still wants you to believe the worst, even though the facts prove otherwise.” — Sherwood Guernsey

6 The Ithaca Times / January 31 – February 6, 2024

Senator Gillibrand’s Finger Lakes Tourism Initiative

“

Something needs to be done with U.S. Senator Kirsten Gillibrand's Finger Lakes Tourism Initiative. Namely, U.S. Route 220, after traveling through several states in the Appalachians and linking several historical and tourist features. This route also leaves out our state, and its Finger Lakes region and the two cities of Auburn and Ithaca, ending in Waverly on the border with Pennsylvania, where New York State Route 34 continues from there to Lake Ontario, leaving this state and region out of several other states and similar cities in the Appalachians. This could be a heritage-tourism highway with the Appalachins and Finger Lakes and could connect Black history, film and entertainment history, motorsports, canal history, and railroad history. U.S. Route 220 begins in Martinsville, North Carolina, where there is an autoracing track on the NASCAR circuit and also NASCAR tracks nearby in Watkins Glen, Bristol, Tennessee, and Pocono, PA, the first of which has NASCAR's Research Library in our state and NY Route 34 goes by the Dirt Racing Hall of Fame and Museum in. The U.S. route also goes through Cumberland, Maryland, and the Pennsylvania cities of Altoona, Belfonte, Lock Haven, and Williamsport, all of which have historic 19th century canal history and the same with Sayre, Athens, and Waverly. NY Route 34 crosses the original Erie Canal path, NY Route 31 in Weedsport, near the more historic Erie Canal village of Port Byron, and crosses the modern Erie Canal/Seneca River just to the north. The combined route also features Black History with Harriet Tubman and her white landlord William Seward in Auburn and the fairly-new NYS Equality Museum there and also Greensboro, North Carolina, site of Civil Rights sit-ins and Ithaca being the home of “Roots” author Alex Haley. Much of the route and its parallel canal routes also combined with and intersected with the Underground Railroad. Elmira could also be included in such “Appalachian and Finger Lakes Heritage Route” via NY Route 13 and Interstate 86 in terms of literary, television, film, Black History with the Cayuga Museum in Auburn, where talking film was invented and the Fox company was co-founded, the aforementioned William Seward, Harriet Tubman, Alex Haley, “The Twilight Zone” creator Rod Sterling of Ithaca, and the Elmira historical figures of author Samuel Langhorne

“Mark Twain” Clemons, Black football pioneer Ernie Davis, and television pioneer Hal Roach. As well are several art and other museums and higher educational institutions along U.S. Route 220 and NY Route 34. Just as the Interstate 86 designation needs to be completed over NY Route 17 to Interstates 84 and 87 in the lower Hudson Valley between the Catskills and the New Jersey border, so too does NY Route 34 need to be converted into an extension of U.S. Route 34 and made an “Appalachian and Finger Lakes Scenic and Historic Byway. Our state should not be left out of this U.S. Route.” — Kevin Yost

What a Difference a Year Makes

“

Marc Molinaro just marked one full year representing NY Congressional District 19. His campaign recently tweeted that “he is running for reelection to address upstate NY’s high cost of living, public safety concerns, and to make sure that all walks of life are included and have a seat at the table.” Yes, please! What has our Congressional Representative actually been doing during his first year in office? The 118th Congress passed the fewest bills in modern history while they were busy threatening to shut down the government and fighting over who would be Speaker of the House. But to make that dismal record even worse, it turns out that the vast majority were uncontroversial bills including multiple measures to rename Veterans Affairs clinics. In fairness, Veterans Affairs clinics do include “all walks of life” but what about “NY’s high cost of living” and “public safety”? Our Congressman wasn’t just sitting on his hands or securing the endorsement of Marjorie Taylor Green (which he got). He also voted to mint a coin commemorating the 250th anniversary of the Marine Corps. Rest assured, Marc Molinaro is on the job and working hard to, well, get reelected.” — John Bennett

RE: Cornell Free Speech Debate

“

So, crowded theatre and yelling fire. The students have not proven this is covered under free speech. It’s not and should not be. Calling for the death of people is not protected in this context and also the statement is seriously morally defunct. Leave it to the misguided to champion the dumbest thing they can. Contin u ed on Page 10

GUEST OPINION

COMMUNITY ANNOUNCEMENT

Keeping Guns Out of the Hands of Domestic The Spirit and Face of the Kheel Abusers Should Be Common Sense Center — Melissa Holland By Jo sh R i l ey

his year, the Supreme Court will decide a case that could have lifeor-death consequences for hundreds of thousands of women across the country. Women are five times more likely to be killed when their abuser is armed, and homicides of women by their partners typically occur after years of chronic abuse. That’s why the law says: if you’ve been convicted of domestic violence, you can’t have a gun. It’s common sense. But the gun lobby and the politicians they pay–like Congressman Marc Molinaro– are trying to tear those protections away. Molinaro’s voting record has been disastrous for survivors of domestic violence. Back when he was an Albany politician, Molinaro voted to allow domestic abusers to have guns. Just last year in Congress, he voted to cut funding for federal programs combating violence against women, and he voted to weaken the background check system that keeps guns out of the wrong hands. The gun lobby has rewarded Molinaro every step of the way, pumping thousands upon thousands of dollars into his campaigns. Now the same gun lobby that’s bankrolling Molinaro is trying to go even further. They want to get rid of the law that stops domestic abusers from getting guns, and they’ve taken their case all the COUNCIL CONSIDERS CHANGING SCHEDULE contin u ed from page 5

The third meeting of the month was highlighted as an opportunity to discuss various topics, including the possibility of creating new committees or addressing specific issues in a more focused manner. Mayor Cantelmo clarified that this meeting would provide a platform for members to initiate new conversations about policy ideas. Several council members supported the proposed changes, emphasizing the need for better engagement, education, and transparency in council proceedings. The

way to the U.S. Supreme Court. The gun lobby’s argument: there were no consequences for domestic violence in colonial America, so it’s unconstitutional to stop domestic abusers from owning guns today. They literally want to take us back to the 1700s! Protecting our most vulnerable citizens should not be partisan or controversial. That’s why I was honored to submit a bipartisan brief to the U.S. Supreme Court arguing that these common-sense protections for survivors of domestic violence must not be taken away. It’s the same kind of bipartisanship I saw firsthand when, as counsel on the U.S. Senate Judiciary Committee, I brought Democrats and Republicans together to pass a law to stop landlords from evicting survivors of domestic violence just because they called the police for help. At a time when our political parties can feel very divided, these laws show the progress we can make when we work together to find common ground and common sense. The Supreme Court should reject the gun lobby’s dangerous arguments and uphold the law protecting survivors of domestic violence. Josh Riley is an Ithaca resident and Broome County native. He served as counsel on the United States Senate Judiciary Committee, and he is a candidate for Congress in New York’s 19th District. idea of having more substantive conversations and involving the public meaningfully was well-received. In response to concerns about potential challenges for working council members, it was suggested that finding a balance between meeting duration and frequency is crucial. Mayor Cantelmo emphasized the value of the proposed changes, particularly in ensuring that all council members have a voice in the policymaking process. While there were differing opinions on meeting times and procedures, the focus remained on creating a more inclusive and collaborative environment within City Hall.

By M a rjor i e O l d s

rowing up Melissa’s Holland’s maternal Grandmother Annie Scott was the center of Melissa’s life in the Northside of Ithaca, a few blocks from Immaculate Conception, where Melissa would later enter elementary school. While she lived with her parents, mother Pat Scott Holland and Jerry Holland and sisters Terri (Lewis) and Sharon (Loucks), her grandparents lived right close by. “Our Grandmother was “The Sun” for us. We gave her phone number to our school administration for our emergency contact; and we used her mailing address for our most important mail. We went to her house after school until our parents got home from work, so we ate dinner there. As kids, we were at our grandparents’ home every day. As adults, we’d all stop by Grandma’s at least once a week. If we forgot anything at the grocery store, we’d still stop by Grandma’s house, grab something, and chat a while. Their home was our “bathroom stop/snack break” when we were out anywhere. And not just for me and my two sisters, but for my Mom, my aunts, the other grandkids, the great grand kids and Grandma’s nieces and nephews.” “Grandma Scott was our main babysitter. School holidays, after school and sick days. Between Grandma Scott, my maternal aunts, Alice Pernell Gould and Peggi Love, and my oldest sister, Terri watching

Melissa Holland and her family at grandmas kitchen. (Photo: Provided)

over me, I do not remember a babysitter from outside the family.” “I spent lots of my time watching TV or at the public library. While we were watching Captain Kangaroo and the Price is Right our Grandma Scott did our laundry, cleaned, and cooked. I also spent a lot of time sitting quietly with adults talking around me. Sometimes they’d notice and make me go in the other room…I played with my sister Sharon and my 2 cousins Kathy (Love) Turton and Jeff Love in Grandma’s side yard. We were not allowed outside the fence…” “Weekdays we had dinner at my Grandparents’ home. Well-balanced and portion-controlled by Grandma. So many family members came at different times, we each had an assigned seat.” Our “kid shift” was 3:30.” “When I was a kid, my Grandad, Ed Scott worked at the post office in the morning and at the airport in the afternoon. Grandad would take Grandma to the grocery store every Wednesday and Saturday. On Wednesdays, we always had hot dogs for dinner and the TV Guide arrived. We named it Hot Dog Day.” “Grandma Scott was a member of A.M.E. Zion Church. My mother, my sister Sharon and I were Catholic, so we attended Immaculate Conception Church. The rest of the family attended Calvary Baptist Church.” “After my parents broke up, Sharon and I lived with our Grandparents for three years. My Mom remarried in 1979 and we moved to Brooktondale with my stepfather, Ted Dean, just before I turned 10. When my father remarried he and my stepmother Vicki lived just outside of Syracuse.” “Mom worked as the bookkeeper at WHCU, until Cornell sold the station. Then she returned to working on Cornell’s campus, including in the History & Philosophy of Science, Technology, and Africana Studies. My Stepfather worked at Ithaca College.” Contin u ed on Page 15

January 31 – February 6, 2024 / The Ithaca Times

The State of the County Chairman Klein Outlines 2024 Priorities By M att Dougherty

n his State of the County Address, recently appointed Chairman of the Tompkins County Legislature, Dan Klein, congratulated the legislature on their achievements from the previous year and outlined key initiatives the county plans to undertake in 2024. “The State of the County is excellent,” Klein said. “At the same time, plenty of areas need attention and help.” He added, “We have been doing a lot, and there is much more to do.” One of the challenges highlighted was the county’s need for additional office space to free up space inside the Tompkins County Courthouse for the expanding needs of the New York State Court system. As a result, the county has created the Downtown Facilities Committee to meet every month to prepare for the development of a new environmentally friendly center of government building. According to Klein, “The downtown Facilities Committee has been formed to deal with the multiple pieces of the multi-year project to solve our space needs.” He continued saying that he believes the county will be moving towards a solution by the end of the year, even though the project won’t be completed until 2028. Klein has said that the location of the center of government building will be on the 300 block of North Tioga Street, where the county purchased a pair of buildings in 2021 — the former Key Bank building andthe adjacent professional building. Klein stressed that this project would involve extensive engagement with legislators and the community throughout the rest of the year and beyond. Additionally, the county has been working on a strategic operations plan aimed at enhancing the delivery of services. According to Klein, the completion and adoption of this plan, scheduled for 2024, signifies a

Da n K l e i n h a s b e e n a p p o i n t e d a s t h e C h a i r m a n o f t h e To m p k i n s C o u n t y L e g i s l at u r e a f t e r r e p r e s e n t i n g t h e Tow n s o f Da n b y a n d C a r o l i n e f o r t h e l a s t d e c a d e . ( P h o t o : K e n n e t h Wat e r h o u s e)

County contract funded by OTDA, offering emergency housing and support to Temporary Assistance clients. Additional shelter beds provided by the County could benefit those in need as St. Johns has recently begun to enforce a “no animals” policy. Additionally, recent altercations between unhoused residents and staff members at the shelter have concerned the community, leading to questions regarding the operational standards of the shelter. While it remains uncertain whether or not a County-owned shelter would enforce a “no-pet” policy, a similar policy would likely be implemented in a County-owned shelter as long as the OTDA funds the project. Tompkins County Continuum of Care has estimated that around 60 individuals experience unsheltered homelessness from May through September. The existing shelter has a 26-bed capacity and is augmented with congregate shelter sites during periods of high demand — primarily in colder months when New York State Code Blue policy is enforced. County staff are currently evaluating the potential of a new shelter facility, including the option of a low-barrier shelter accessible to anyone experiencing homelessness, particularly during colder months. Factors under consideration include facility design,

commitment to improving overall efficien- York State Office of Temporary and Discy and effectiveness. ability Assistance (OTDA) guidelines and existing County services, including Temporary Assistance and Code Blue. ADDRESSING The initiative includes considerations HOMELESSNESS “Homelessness is a prominent issue for creating County-owned shelter beds here in Tompkins County, as it is in many and discusses potential funding mechaplaces around the Country,” Klein said. nisms and models of operation. CurrentHe added, “The county will be rethinking ly, St. John’s Community Services operates what we can do with our sheltering ser- the county’s only existing shelter through a vices to address this growing problem.” According to Klein, the county is focusing on initiatives to increase access to local homeless shelters to address the chal— Dan Klein lenging and unsafe aspects of people sleeping outside. Klein expressed confidence in developing effective strategies throughout the year to address this critical issue. Part of the plan to address the issue in Th r o u g h o u t 2 0 2 4 To m p k i n s C o u n t y w i l l b e r o l l i n g o u t t h e the coming year is creating an additional f irst y ea r of its R a pid EMS R esponse Progr a m i n a n effort homeless shelter operated by the County. t o r e d u c e r e s p o n s e t i m e s i n ru r a l a r e a s . ( P h o t o : F i l e) The initiative aims to align with the New

“The State of the County is excellent. At the same time, plenty of areas need attention and help. We have been doing a lot, and there is much more to do.”

8 The Ithaca Times / January 31 – February 6, 2024

Th e c r e at i o n o f t h e C r i s i s A lt e r n at i v e R e s p o n s e a n d E n g ag e m e n t Te a m m a r k s a s i g n i f i c a n t d e v e l o p m e n t i n t h e C o u n t y- C i t y R e i m ag i n i n g P u b l i c S a f e t y p r o c e s s t h at b e g a n t h r e e y e a r s ag o . ( P h o t o : To m p k i n s C o u n t y) the needs of the homeless population, ad- suffer from prolonged emergency response herence to state and federal regulations, and times, such as Newfield, Caroline, Lansing, and Dryden. potential funding sources. RAPID MEDICAL RESPONSE TEAM

In addition to addressing homelessness, the county is set to implement its rapid Medical Response project in 2024, aimed at enhancing emergency medical services and reducing response times. Klein highlighted the early success of the Rapid Response EMS Program, explaining that the county secured a grant exceeding their expectations, ensuring funding for its first year. Tompkins County successfully secured a grant of $630,000 for its EMS Rapid Response Program. The grant, obtained through New York State’s local government efficiency grants, surpassed initial expectations and brought a wave of joy to the county administration team. Klein said that the county had initially anticipated receiving around $69,000 but discovered that a typo in the application materials allowed them to secure up to 90% of the grant funds instead of 10%. The initiative involves setting up emergency response vehicle stations across the county. While the initial timeline aimed for implementation by March, Klein acknowledged the complexities of starting a new program and the need to hire staff, purchase equipment, and establish protocols. Reflecting on the challenges of launching a new initiative, Klein emphasized the difficulty of creating something entirely from scratch. He outlined the intricate details involved, from equipment and personnel to day-to-day operations, underscoring the responsibility of saving lives. Although specific placement details are yet to be finalized, Klein suggested a triangle placement around critical areas that

PUBLIC SAFETY AND CRIMINAL JUSTICE REFORM

Another significant aspect of the State of the County address was the county’s commitment to Reimagining Public Safety. The rollout of the Crisis Alternative Response and Engagement Team (CARE) marked a significant development in the reimagining public safety process, which began three years ago following the murder of George Floyd. The program pairs law enforcement with mental health professionals and aims to address specific types of calls where an armed police officer is not the only solution to the problem, demonstrating a commitment to innovative solutions in public safety. Klein clarified that while the unarmed police response idea primarily focuses on the City of Ithaca, it is not solely a city initiative and that the Sheriff ’s Department will be involved in implementing the initiatives on the County level. Additionally, Klein expressed the need to incorporate the initiative into the budget process starting in April. Highlighting the urgency imposed by the state mandate for a rapid plan submission, Klein acknowledged the county’s commitment to a thoughtful and thorough response compared to other regions. Describing reimagining public safety as an ongoing experiment, he emphasized the importance of evaluating data to determine the program’s success and areas for improvement. In addition, Klein said that efforts to plan for the county jail’s future, including a thorough task force examination led by Travis Brooks, are set to continue in 2024.

BROADBAND ACCESS AND ENVIRONMENTAL CONCERNS

ing to a more circular economy by diverting waste.

Recognizing the importance of internet access, Klein said that the county is aiming to make broadband available to every address, focusing on unserved addresses that remain in Tompkins County. Despite some challenges, Klein says that he is optimistic about using state and federal funds to make progress to achieving 100% broadband coverage in 202. Klein acknowledged Tompkins County’s impressive coverage rate of approximately 95%. However, he emphasized that over 1000 addresses in the county remain unserved for high-speed broadband internet. Klein outlined a goal to reach every unserved address, with a plan currently in progress. Despite receiving bids from internet service providers, specific details remain confidential. Klein expressed optimism about making decisions on the plan by March but highlighted a significant unknown factor — the availability of federal and state funding, expected to be released sometime in the next year or so. Additionally, environmental and climate change mitigation also took center stage in Klein’s address. Plans include protecting Cayuga Lake and transition-

COMMITTEE APPOINTMENTS AND ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

The address also acknowledged the pivotal role of county employees and the dedication of committee chairs and members. Committee appointments for 2024 were announced, covering various areas such as economic development, housing, health, and human services. The partnerships with the city of Ithaca and Cornell University were highlighted, emphasizing collaboration on various projects, including public safety initiatives and TCAT bus service. Klein expressed gratitude for the record number of legislators stepping up and volunteering for committee assignments. He under— Dan Klein scored the importance of clear communication between the county and the city of Ithaca, especially as both entities navigate new collaborations. “The county and the city have multiple projects we hope to collaborate on,” Klein said. Klein continued by saying that he and Ithaca Mayor Robert Cantelmo “both believe that we will have clear channels of communication between the city and the county and that communication is the key to a good relationship.”

“Homelessness is a prominent issue here in Tompkins County, as it is in many places around the Country. The county will be rethinking what we can do with our sheltering services to address this growing problem.”

C o u n t y o f f i c i a l s a r e d i s c u s s i n g t h e p o s s i b i l i t y o f c r e at i n g a C o u n t y- ow n e d h o m e l e s s s h e lt e r t o o f f e r a d d i t i o n a l r esou rces to u n housed r esidents. S t. J o h n s C o m m u n i t y S e rv i c e s i s c u r r e n t ly t h e o n ly s h e lt e r i n To m p k i n s C o u n t y. ( P h o t o : F i l e) January 31 – February 6, 2024 / The Ithaca Times

Sports

the Bears had a point subtracted for unsportsmanlike conduct. The weekend matches saw the return of Vito Arujau, the 2023 NCAA 133-pound champion (and threetime AllAmerican), after having A 7-2 win over Harvard last weekend out the Big Red (ranked #6) at been sidelined 17-5-1 on the season. They will take to the road this weekend to take on St. Lawrence and Clarkson. (Photo: Lexi Woodcock/Cornell Athletics) for a month. Vito won his Once again, the Swiss Army Knife- like match against the Crimson with a Major Chris Manon displayed his leadership, Decision, and his match against the playing a solid all-around game. The seBears with a Technical Fall, making him nior scored 16 points, grabbing 11 boards 4-0 on the season. If the wrestling fans wanted to see more and adding 2 blocks and 2 steals. Junior Nazir Williams was Red-hot from the Big Red supporters sporting big smiles, 3-point line, hitting all four of his treys on they needed only walk next door, where the way to a game high 20 points. Williams the Cornell men’s basketball team was also snared 8 rebounds. A.K. Okereke and putting on a veritable clinic in its dismantling of the highly touted Princeton Tigers. Sean Hansen put in 12 points apiece to Hoop fans were delighted to watch Cornell spread the wealth. The win brought Cornell’s Ivy-leading put a beat-down on Penn two weekends record to 4-0, and the team will travel to ago, but virtually everyone expected a Dartmouth on Friday for another key Ivy nail-biter when the Tigers — the 2023 Ivy League contest. champs and a Sweet 16 participant in the Finally the smiling fans from the Big Dance — came into Newman Arena. Friedman Wrestling Center and Newman Both teams were 3-0 in conference play, Arena could walk next door to watch the and a win would help to put the Ivy race Big Red women’s hockey team put a 7-2 in focus. thumping on arch-rival Harvard. The Few nails were bitten after the first home team came out on fire, putting 21 half, as the Big Red went on an absolute shots on goal in the first period alone. tear midway through the half, outscoring Princeton 30-5 over the torrid stretch, and Three of those shots — by Izzy Daniel, Avi Adam and Grace Dwyer — got past would adjust its game in the second half the Crimson goaltender, and the outcome to secure the 83-68 win. Princeton would was never really in question. The win make its predictable second half run to put the Big Red (ranked #6) at 17-5-1, close the gap from 22 points to 11, but and the women will take to the road this Cornell used its deep bench and homeweekend to take on St. Lawrence and court swagger to pour it on again and run Clarkson. the lead back up to 20 points.

No Place Like Home Cornell Scores Weekend Home Wins in Wrestling, Men’s Basketball, Women’s Hockey By Ste ve L aw re nc e

t is not uncommon to walk around Cornell’s campus in January — with the cold winds whipping high above Cayuga’s waters — and see some faces that look like they have not worn a smile in weeks. That was not the case over the weekend — especially around the athletic facilities — as Cornell’s teams put on an incredible collective display, establishing themselves as the cream of the Ivy League crop. First, the utter dominance of the Big Red wrestling team was on full display, as the wrestlers began their quest for their 43rd Ivy League title, and their 104th win in their last 105 Ivy dual match-ups. The matches themselves turned out to be spectacles that I am sure the grapplers

from Harvard and Brown hope to put out of their minds forever. After the two blowout wins, 14th ranked Cornell wrestlers hosted #2 Missouri on Sunday, and six Big Red athletes won their matches against ranked wrestlers en route to a thrilling 20-16 win. It was a historic day, as with the victory, Cornell tied its highest ranked win in program history and earned its highest-ranked victory in a home dual meet. In the match against the Crimson, Cornell won eight of ten bouts on the way to a 37-6 victory. When the Brown Bears took the mat, the result likely made the miserable 6-hour bus ride back to Providence seem even longer, as Cornell won by a score of — get ready to read this twice — 47 to —1. That’s right... negative one. Not only did the Big Red take all ten matches,

LETTERS TO THE EDITOR contin u ed from page 6

Cue the windmills. Old Don is putting on his armor.” — Ray Wheeler

“

FIRE is the most ridiculous organization. You would think Cornell would require their elite students to practice respect, integrity and morality in order to

10 T h e I t h a c a T i m e s / J a n u a r y 3 1 – F e b r u a r y 6 , 2 0 2 4

have a safe and enriched learning environment. A business would fire an employee with such words. When you have mentally unstable students lash out with violent disrespect, hatred, immorality and threatening murder…. this goes against campus safety standards and any integrity or morality. People (FIRE) who want to protect Contin u ed on Page 15

Cayuga Chamber Concert Strikes Just the Right Notes

By Peter Rothbart

alance in a musical ensemble is an exceedingly complex and elusive quality. Performers must balance volume, tone, and color within their own instruments as well as in combination with the other instruments in the ensemble. They must temper their performance according to the acoustics of the hall. They need to handily manage technical requirements with a sense of effortless musicality. They also need to select exciting, interesting, beautiful, provocative, emotionally rich, and technically inspiring pieces that will draw an audience. Happily, Sunday night’s Cayuga Chamber Orchestra Chamber Series concert successfully reflected so many of these balancing acts. Offered in the Unitarian Church, the CCO’s second sold-out chamber music concert this year reflects both the quality of the performances offered and the concert-going public’s interest in the more intimate classical music genre. The afternoon’s program was carefully balanced, allowing a conservatively paced Mozart Trio in Eb Major, K. 398 for Clarinet, Viola and Piano to progress to a livelier Trio for Oboe, Bassoon and Piano by Jean Françaix. The arc of the tempos quickened as the concert progressed, ending with the audience on its feet at the end of Robert Schumann’s Piano Trio No. 1 in D Minor, Op. 63. The conservative approach to tempo in the Mozart Trio was supported by relatively restrained dynamics appropriate for an intimate Mozart chamber work. Charis Dimaris’s piano playing was clear and assertive as is his style, yet never overplaying or overwhelming the secure and lyrical expression of clarinetist Sarah Chandler. If violist Kyle

Cayuga Chamber’s sold-out Sunday concert in the Unitarian Church showed a sense of “effortless musicality”. (Photo: Provided)

Armbrust was occasionally overshadowed, much of the fault lay in the hall’s acoustics which is brittle sounding and unkind to mid- and lower-range string instruments. But the Rondeaux-Allegretto movement allowed him the space to melodically soar over a fast and fitful piano run, then later couple with the clarinet in an artfully balanced series of thirds and sixths runs. Jean Françaix’s Trio for Oboe, Bassoon and Piano is quintessential Françaix, or as the composer himself described it, “Music to please.” And it does. A short, laconic introduction quickly yields to a decidedly light-hearted allegro moderato featuring a game of musical tag between the oboe and bassoon, replete with rollicking chromatic runs up and down, occasionally parodied by the piano. Veteran Central New York oboist John Lathwell and newcomer bassoonist Taylor Smith adeptly handled the playful exchanges, though occasional insecurities marred some of the musical handoffs. Tonal balance was a bit of a problem throughout the work with Andrew Zhou’s piano pedaling and powerful touch occasionally blurring the woodwind repartee. The Andante is a lyrical contrast to the first two movements. The bassoon leads with an introverted, angular melody rising clearly above the piano. Eventually coupling with the oboe, it eventually wanders into chromatic melancholia; the jocularity of the previous movements is gone.

Robert Schumann’s Piano Trio No. 1 in D Minor, Op. 63 is the most often programmed trio by the Romantic-era composer. Schumann wastes no time in overwhelming us with surging counterpoint and an expanded dynamic range that moves in wave-like patterns. It’s as if he drops us into the middle of the piece from the very first rush of notes. Rhythm is more fluid than the previous two works; the tempos vary by design. Yoon Lee evokes a plethora of colors from the piano, forceful but never overwhelming. Cellist Rosemary Elliott, lyrical and as direct as the hall’s acoustics allowed struggled to rise to meet the violin. When she did, the balance was exquisite, resulting in the best ensemble playing of the afternoon. The momentum of the first movement was relentless as if the previous two programmed pieces were designed to lead to this exact moment. Violinist Christina Bouey began the Langsam movement with a heartfelt soliloquy or perhaps lament accompanied by the piano. The minor melody is handed off to the cellist who responds in a major key, then joined again by Bouey in the most intimate of duets. Peter Rothbart is a Professor Emeritus of Music at the Ithaca College School of Music, Theatre and Dance where he taught electroacoustic and media music for 40 years. He remains active as a classical, jazz and pop musician.

Arts&Entertainment

FINDING BALANCE

January 31 – February 6, 2024 / The Ithaca Times

Cinema

Selling Soul American Fiction Examines Principle vs. Success By Mat t Minton

onk Ellison (Jeffrey Wright) is an undeniably talented writer who’s been routinely pushed to the sidelines within the larger literary conversation. He has a reliable agent and gets occasionally invited to literary conventions, but he hasn’t achieved the kind of name recognition in order to properly support himself or his family. Most of all, as a Black writer, Monk openly defies many of the harmful storytelling tropes that Black writers find themselves expected to write.

“American Fiction” Rated R Starring Jeffrey Wright, Tracee Ellis Ross, Issa Rae and Sterling K. Brown Currently playing at Cinemapolis

One day, the family life he’s conveniently pushed to the side for so long to pursue his writing career resurfaces after tragedy occurs and his mother, Agnes (Leslie Uggams), is diagnosed with Alzheimer’s disease. In order to help pay for his mother’s care facility, Monk goes against all of his principles as a writer by writing a manuscript that plays to all of the racial stereotypes he detests. Before long, Monk finds himself thrust into the world of literary fame while simultaneously struggling to reckon with how he’s pushed himself away from his family all his life. Based on the 2001 novel “Erasure” by Percival Everett, “American Fiction” has been a major player in the awards season conversation ever since winning the People’s Choice Award at the 2023 Toronto International Film Festival. Cord Jefferson, who previously found success as a story editor on acclaimed shows like “Watch-

men” and “Master of None,” makes the move to film with his bold, audacious and unbelievably hilarious directorial debut. With dark humor and wit up its sleeve, Jefferson’s screenplay refreshingly taps into the current conversation about what kinds of stories writers of marginalized communities are expected to tell. The satire that Jefferson uses to expose these flaws in the publishing industry is truly original. Jefferson also explores the kind of sacrifices that many writers and Erika Alexander and Jeffrey Wright in American Fiction. (Photo by Clair Folger, Orion Releasing LLC) creative people in the industry frequently have to make in order to Each member of this family is written financially sustain themselves. Beyond the with such care and the entire cast works film’s satirical elements, though, “American perfectly together to bring their flawed, Fiction” expertly pulls off a juggling act with imperfect and endearing dynamic to life. its emotional, heartfelt family melodrama. Wright is the obvious standout, with his sly These two halves, while in a few instances slightly uneven, ultimately comple- facial expressions providing some of the film’s biggest laughs. In a terrific supporting ment each other through Monk’s charturn, Brown effortlessly portrays Clifford acter journey. Monk falls in love with his neighbor, Coraline (Erika Alexander), and learning to embrace his identity as a queer man for the first time while knowing that finds necessary joy and levity in moments his late father will never get to know the with his drug-addicted brother, Clifford (Sterling K. Brown). Monk’s arc of learning true him. Monk’s relationship with Clifford is perhaps the most crucial in the whole to love his family for who they are allows film: it’s how Monk learns to realize the the audience to see another side to him. power of showing up as his full self. The film’s strongest elements are easily the acting and the writing. While it isn’t particularly exceptional on a technical level, Hilda Rasula’s strong editing choices help to heighten some of the film’s most hilarious moments. Take an early moment when Monk is visiting a bookstore with a disguise (in this case, just simply wearing sunglasses) only to find his novels in the “African-American Studies” section. After questioning an employee about what makes his books Black aside from his skin color, Rasula brilliantly cuts to Monk frantically running away with a giant stack of his books in hand. By the third act, Monk finds himself getting farther and farther down the rabbit hole: escalating his disguise as a convicted felon, dealing with Hollywood agents trying to turn his manuscript into an awardwinning film and continuously being in pure disbelief that his book actually sold. Through ensuing chaos, Monk confronts his values as a writer and what kind of sacrifices he himself is willing to make. The final scene between Monk and Sintara (Issa Rae), the successful Black female writer he’s scolded since the beginning of the film, is perfect. We track how Monk begins to truly understand Contin u ed on Page 15

12 T h e I t h a c a T i m e s / J a n u a r y 3 1 – F e b r u a r y 6 , 2 0 2 4

Special Event

Supporting Gayog hó:no˛´ Sovereignty By L a Bourge oi s

“

I want to see the children not get left behind,” said Wanda John, a member of the Gayogo̱hó:nǫʼ (Cayuga) Nation, who claims her only title is “Grandma, Mom, Great Grandma.” “The legal fees take away from our children’s and language programs. That gets costly, and a couple of weeks we have had to shut down the programs, so the kids lose out.” To pay legal fees related to an ongoing leadership dispute, the Gayogo̱hó:nǫʼ Legal Defense Fund was formed. On Sunday, February 4, the first fundraiser to support this fund will be held at the Foundation of Light here in Ithaca. This celebration of traditional Gayogo̱hó:nǫʼ culture will include dancing, storytelling, products and food. Sachem (Chief) Sam George and Dylan John Seneca, among others, will speak. Ithaca Times sat down with Dylan John Seneca and Wanda John to discover the highlights, how to help, and the definition of a good mind. What’s going to be a highlight of this fundraiser for you? DJS: The highlight for me for this whole event is going to be the children because I’m in there with them Monday through Thursday here in a community. We’ve been singing, we’ve been learning, we’ve been speaking a lot of the language. Singing, to our people, is a vibrational healing. To be able to see these kids sing, and share laughter, love, peace and good mind amongst one another, that’s the whole core of our program. It’s part of our curriculum to be proud of your identity and of who you are. What does “a good mind is our strongest medicine” mean to you? WJ: It’s an everyday thing. A good mind is always a good mind. Clear your head. Think before you do anything,

Support the Gayogºhó:no˛´Legal Defense Fund Fundraiser Sunday, Feb. 4, 2:30-5:30 p.m. Foundation of Light, 391 Turkey Hill Road, Ithaca, NY

before you move forward. Like I always tell my kids, there’s consequences for everything, good or bad. DJS: A good mind is a working mind. It’s tough to be good minded in this fight. A lot of people are dealing with trauma, stress, worry. They’re living in fear every single day. Good mind is one of the main principles and values within the Great Law of Peace. That’s our Constitution. That’s where it all started. It’s a strong medicine as long as we know how to work together. And it’s tough. I’m currently doing a lot of things for the community. I’m with the legal team, trying my best to help with them. I’m under the chiefs and clan mothers and trying my best to learn protocols and procedures. But not only that, I’m trying to encourage them to continue their responsibility. I’m also working a lot with the community. My job is to uplift everybody, and keep everybody moving forward with a good mind. To remove those layers of trauma, the best that I can. It’s tough, but good mind is our strongest medicine at this time. Because if you’re not using a good mind, you’ll start using emotion and emotion can get you into trouble. What’s your part in this fundraiser? WJ: I’m going to help sell food, like frybread and beans. Native foods. Always strawberry drink, which is just strawberries, mashed up with a little bit of water. Like lemonade, only using strawberries. DJS: I was approached by a few people, including Debbie George [Sachem Sam George’s wife], and they asked me if I could be the spokesperson on behalf of how it is to be in this fight while still teaching and learning and how we’re surviving to move forward with our cultural language. What is the heart of the fundraiser for you? DJS: The heart of this whole event is the children. They’re the next generation. We were also encouraged to get the kids to come. We want to be able to show anybody that wants to be involved how the children can hold laughter still. They can come together, hold a good mind, and celebrate with our cultural, song and dance. So when someone had mentioned to me, ‘Well, is it okay, we can bring the kids?’ And I’m like, ‘Yeah, we’ll see what we can

do.’ The kids said, ‘Let’s go and sing!’ It encouraged them to sing even more, because they know this event’s happening. I see the good medicine already happening. What are other ways that people can assist with this endeavor? DJS: A lot of trauma and physical altercations have been happening here within the community. And a lot of people outside of our community have been helping us throughout these years. I can encourage everyone else to continue to reach out and continue to check up on the people here within the community. Let’s continue to formulate more events down the road. Financial support keeps us moving forward, because financial support is the biggest struggle here within the community. We have entrepreneurs here within the community that help out a lot. But those of us that run these programs, we would like to get on our own feet. A lot of people outside of our community reached out and that goes a long way for us.

A fundraiser event in support of the Gayogo̱ hó:nǫʼ Legal Defense Fund will take place at the Foundation of Light located at 391 Turkey Hill Road on Feb. 4th, 2024. (Photo: Provided)

The whole core of this event is to get our voices heard on why we need support. So I appreciate all the help. And I’m thankful for all the support down the road. To learn more about the Gayogo̱ hó:nǫ’ efforts, visit Gayogohono.org.

YOUR BATHROOM. YOUR WAY. IN AS LITTLE AS

ONE DAY

CALL NOW 877.699.0860 SPECIAL OFFER

50% OFF Installation WITH

No Interest No Payments for 1 Year PLUS

FREE Safety Upgrade* If paid in full by end of 12 months.

*Add’l terms apply. Offer subject to change and vary by dealer. Expires 3/31/2024.

January 31 – February 6, 2024 / The Ithaca Times

14 T h e I t h a c a T i m e s / J a n u a r y 3 1 – F e b r u a r y 6 , 2 0 2 4

recently approved rapid response EMS program as long overdue. He also commended Sheriff Derek Osborne’s leadership in reimagining public safety initiatives. Sigler said that while change creates challenges, he felt the sheriff incorporated reforms proactively. Looking ahead, Sigler says that two

of his top 2023 county legislative priorities are bringing the planned detox center and mental health stabilization unit online to expand behavioral health services. Reflecting on his commitment to public service, Sigler, aged 54, resides in Lansing with his wife Sarah and their four daughters. With roots stretching back five generations in Upstate New York, he has actively volunteered for Rotary, the Cham-

ber of Commerce, and various community organizations. “When our youngest daughter was born last year, it was one of the best days of my life. But like so many others living here in Upstate New York, we’re apprehensive about what Hazel’s and her three sisters’ futures will look like in the years and decades to come,” shared Sigler, expressing concerns about the trajectory of the state’s future.

As the campaign unfolds, Sigler’s focus on crime and taxes positions him as a contender in the 52nd District State Senate race. The 2024 General Election is scheduled for Tuesday, November 5, with Early Voting from October 26 to November 3 and Absentee Ballot voting also available. Voters in Broome, Cortland, and Tompkins Counties will watch this race closely as it develops.

TCAT GM DISCUSSES CHANGES

ENVIRONMENTAL ADVOCATES RALLY

contin u ed from page 3

contin u ed from page 5

Vanderpool provided a comprehensive overview of the upcoming winter-spring schedule changes at TCAT, the challenges of the persistent driver shortage, and the cautious steps to address these issues. As the transit agency strives to optimize efficiency and gradually rebuild its service levels, maintaining positive customer relations remains a top priority.

polluting waterways and drinking sources in New York and New Jersey. Additionally, the landfill emits significant quantities of greenhouse gases, violating the Climate Leadership and Community Protection Act’s goal of achieving 100% net emissions reduction by 2050. Local impacts include lung cancer clusters identified by the State Department

of Health near the landfill, constant complaints of harmful odors from residents, and adverse effects on the region’s $3 billion tourism industry, supporting 60,000 jobs. The landfill’s truck traffic and the visual blight of the towering trash mountain contribute to these adverse effects. New Yorkers eagerly await the Final Scoping Document and a Draft Environmental Impact Statement from the Department of Environmental Conservation. These documents will play a crucial role in Governor Hochul’s decision

regarding the future of Seneca Meadows. Elected officials, environmental groups, and concerned citizens are joining forces to advocate for the permanent closure of Seneca Meadows, aligning with the state’s goals for sustainable waste management and environmental responsibility. Deciding the fate of the landfill will be a pivotal decision for Governor Hochul, who faces prioritizing the well-being of New Yorkers and the environment over the interests of a Texas-based corporation that owns New York’s largest landfill.

MELISSA HOLLAND

love. Ted taught me that someone could love me unconditionally. He also taught me that no matter what people say about you, YOU know who you are and just be that person… Don’t worry about or respond to gossip.” After Melissa graduated from Ithaca College, she worked for five years in Cornell’s groundbreaking Office of Minority Affairs, formerly known as Committee on Special Education Projects (COSEP) to promote equality and diversity. When her friend Marianne Graham

introduced her to the Catherwood Library however, Melissa envisioned moving to that quiet, orderly self-contained reference center, which would become the worldrenowned Kheel Center, shortly before she transitioned over. Providing superb administrative assistance in the Center since 1996. Her colleagues describe Melissa as the spirit and face of the Center. And those who have visited this incredible Center all mention “Melissa.”

When interviewed, Melissa describes answering reference questions over the phone, via emails and in person, ordering supplies, billing, interacting with the fiscal office, while handling the mail, assisting donors. All this, while monitoring the lovely, exquisitely organized, and comfortable Reading Room, where students, faculty, and the public are drawn to the extensive collection of both labor and management history, including a unique collection of rare original documentation.

Disappointed in Cornell Student Conduct at Basketball Game

is a well-known player and rising star of the Princeton team. I realize it is common to boo and make noise when the opposing team is making a free throw. Ok. But to single out a particular player for the entire game is rude and poor sportsmanship. As he was the only Asian

player on the team, at first I was seriously concerned this was overt racism, but after looking him up I think (hope) it was simply due to his fame and large following. Still, it was embarrassing and made Cornell look bad. Surely we can do better.” — Theresa Fulton

MIKE SIGLER contin u ed from page 4

contin u ed from page 7

“My parents taught me so many important things: To be truthful and to be myself… And they helped show me, along with my best friend Amy Baldwin Maloney, how to be a good friend. I had many loving, supportive, good people in my life. But my most important role models were my maternal grandmother and my stepfather.” My Grandma taught me the strength of family LETTERS TO THE EDITOR contin u ed from page 10

speech of hate, threats, racism, lies and violence only exist to make these things happen. Immoral speech has consequences and can be illegal such as slander, liable, defamation, etc. Look what Trumps “free speech” about E Jean Carroll did for him! And Rudy Giuliani! If a university protects people who threatened murder and create an unsafe environment, it means they have lost control of their campus and their honor.” — Rebecca Sydney SELLING SOUL contin u ed from page 12

the complicated reality of what it means to define success as a writer. While the ending is destined to be viewed as a bit abrupt for some viewers, it firmly lands the film’s social critique.

“

My husband and I just attended the Cornell men's basketball game against the Princeton Tigers. Cornell unexpectedly won, yay! But, I was very dismayed at the behavior of the attendees in the Cornell students section. First they booed every single Princeton starting team member. Then throughout the entire game, the entire section booed every time one particular player, Xaivian Lee (#1) had the ball. Apparently Xaivian

“American Fiction” is the rare kind of film that plays to two completely different genres with such confidence. From unexpected moments that lead us to erupt into laughter to family reconciliation that digs into past trauma, Jefferson has asserted himself as a filmmaker with something crucial to say. January 31 – February 6, 2024 / The Ithaca Times