Convenient Walk-in Care Made for You
From minor burns and UTIs to strains and sprains, Guthrie Ithaca City Harbor offers walk-in care for minor illnesses and injuries, with no appointment needed.
Walk-in care is available from 7 a.m. to 7 p.m. weekdays, and 7 a.m. to 1 p.m. weekends.
Guthrie Ithaca City Harbor Walk-in Care
720 Willow Avenue Ithaca, NY 14850
TCIDA Turns Down Developer’s Plan to Open Library Place to Younger Tenants
By Maddy Vogel
The Tompkins County Industrial Development Agency (TCIDA) has denied a proposal from local developer Frost Travis to remove the age restriction for prospective tenants at Library Place, a luxury senior housing development that has struggled to attract the level of interest initially anticipated. Library Place is a 55+ apartment complex at the site of the former Tompkins County Public Library at 105 W Court St. in downtown Ithaca. It has 66 luxury housing units, ranging from one to three bedrooms, but less than one-third of units are currently occupied by tenants.
Rent for a one-bedroom apartment in Library Place ranges from $2,545 to $3,122 per month, while two and three bedroom apartments top off at $5,935.
Original application documents show Library Place was intended to provide market-rate housing to Ithaca’s senior community. Fair Market Rent for a one bedroom apartment in Ithaca has increased by 12.4% from 2023 to 2024, from $1,276 to $1,434.
Frost Travis, president of Travis Hyde, told the TCIDA that rising costs during the project’s delayed construction and “enormous” increases in debt service payments, led to a rent hike. Travis added
that although they initially believed the restricted age community would increase demand, the restrictions unexpectedly led to a slow lease-up and has impacted the financial stability of the project.
Travis approached the TCIDA during their Wednesday, Nov. 13 meeting to request approval from the board to drop the age requirement for prospective tenants, but to still keep the project’s $5.32 million 10-year tax abatement.
Despite seemingly positive responses from the TCIDA at that meeting, the board did not have enough members present to vote and held a vote during their Wednesday, Dec. 11 meeting.
On Wednesday, multiple members of the public spoke during the public comment period against allowing Travis Hyde to retain their abatement if the board granted the developer’s request to drop the 55+ age restriction. The board also received multiple written comments regarding the proposal.
In response to the negative comments, Travis said he believed a lot of the individuals “don’t have the full context of the project.”
“It would be simple to lower the rents, but then I’d be defaulting on my debt service covenants; I’d be defaulting on a loan because I wouldn’t have the adequate coverage,” Travis said. “It’s not about maximizing profits by any stretch.”
T ake n ote
(Photo: Mark Syvertson)
Legislator and IDA Member Deborah Dawson criticized the high rents at Library Place, stating that both her and her husband, who are both elected officials, could not afford to live in Library Place.
“I don't have any real objection to removing the age restriction because personally, as an old person, I would much rather live in a multigenerational community than a warehouse for old people,” Dawson said. “My problem is that I really have not a lot of confidence that removing that age restriction is gonna save your building because your rents are so high.”
Dawson called on the IDA to pay more attention to the kinds of housing developments they grant incentives to. She also emphasized that subsidized housing that the IDA is granting incentives to is straining police resources, citing the Asteri building as a major concern.
“Market rate is not helping our community,” Dawson said. “What we need, IDA,
Continued on Page 14
X Ithaca Common Council Approves Parking Rate Increases for Cayuga Street Garage in 2025
ITHACA, N.Y. — The Ithaca Common Council has approved new parking rates for the Cayuga Street Garage, set to take effect Jan. 1, 2025. The resolution, passed during the council’s December meeting, increases monthly, hourly, and daily parking rates to bring the Cayuga Garage in line with other city-owned garages while funding necessary capital improvements. The decision follows a 2023 condition assessment of the 20-year-old structure, which found the garage to be in good condition but requiring significant investments to preserve its service life for another 30 years. Council members noted that current revenues are insufficient to support long-term maintenance and
improvement needs, necessitating the rate hikes.
Under the new rates, monthly permits will see notable increases. The cost for general parking, including long-term storage, will rise from $93 per month to $101.40, a 9% increase. Premium area rates will also increase by 9%, from $160 to $174.40 per month. The discounted Cornell contract rate will rise from $66.90 to $70.58, a 5.5% increase, while the TC3 contract rate will move to $89.21 per month, or 88% of the posted general rate.
Hourly parking at the Cayuga Garage will double from $1 to $2 per hour, and the maximum daily rate will increase from $10 to $12. Special event rates for downtown garages, including the Cayuga Garage, will remain at $5 for a weekend
day entrance fee with a 24-hour parking limit. Cayuga Garage management recommended aligning the facility’s rates with those of the Green and Seneca garages, which currently charge $105 per month for general permits. The council emphasized that the increase is critical to achieving a balanced budget for the garage while funding capital improvements.
The resolution also includes plans for a working group to be convened in 2025 by the city manager to develop updated parking rate recommendations across Ithaca’s parking facilities. The Cornell Office Parking Agreement, which impacts discounted parking rates for Cornell-affiliated individuals, will remain in effect until July 31, 2025.
THE WEB
F r EE lan CE rs : Barbara Adams, G. M Burns, Jane Dieckmann, Charley Githler, Ross Haarstad, Steve Lawrence, Marjorie Olds, Henry Stark, and Arthur Whitman
THE ENTIRE CONTENTS OF THE ITHACA TIMES ARE COPYRIGHT © 2024, BY NEWSKI INC.
All rights reserved. Events are listed free of charge in TimesTable. All copy must be received by Friday at noon. The Ithaca Times is available free of charge from various locations around Ithaca. Additional copies may be purchased from the Ithaca Times offices for $1. SUBSCRIPTIONS: $89 one year. Include check or money order and mail to the Ithaca Times, PO Box 27, Ithaca, NY 14851. ADVERTISING: Deadlines are Monday 5 p.m. for display, Tuesday at noon for classified. Advertisers should check their ad on publication. The Ithaca Times will not be liable for failure to publish an ad, for typographical error, or errors in publication except to the extent of the cost of the space in which the actual error appeared in the first insertion. The publisher reserves the right to refuse advertising for any reason and to alter advertising copy or graphics deemed unacceptable for publication. The Ithaca Times is published weekly Wednesday mornings. Offices are located at 109 N. Cayuga Street, Ithaca, NY 14850 607-277-7000, FAX 607277-1012,
Library Place, a luxury senior housing development in downtown Ithaca, faces challenges with low occupancy and high rents, prompting a denied proposal to remove its 55+ age restriction.
IN UIRING PHOTOGR PHER Q A
By Mark Syvertson
QUESTION OF THE WEEK:
“WHAT ’ S AT THE TOP OF YOUR HOLIDAY WISHLIST?”
Ithaca to Enforce Short Term Rental Law in 2025, Asks for Increase in State Aid
By Matt Dougherty
During a recent meeting the Ithaca Common Council received a detailed update on the implementation of the city’s short-term rental (STR) regulations, adopted in May 2024.
These rules aim to curb the growing trend of residential properties being converted into vacation rentals, a practice that has exacerbated the city’s housing shortage.
Deputy Director of Planning Megan Wilson reported that Ithaca currently has 314 short-term rental units, with approximately 82% consisting of entire homes rather than individual rooms. The majority of these properties are listed as singlefamily homes, highlighting the impact of STRs on the city’s housing stock.
“To address this, we’ve partnered with Host Compliance, a third-party monitoring company, to identify and track shortterm rentals operating in the city,” Wilson said. “As of today, we’ve identified over 98% of all STR units.”
The new regulations require STR operators to obtain a permit, with applications opening on January 1, 2025. In the weeks leading up to enforcement, city staff will focus on education and outreach. Property owners with identified STRs will receive two informational mailings explaining the policy and how to comply.
Council members expressed support for the phased approach, emphasizing the importance of voluntary compliance over punitive measures.
“Our goal is to help people meet the regulations and avoid issuing violations or fines whenever possible,” Wilson said. “We want to make sure hosts have the resources they need to comply with the new rules.”
However, violations will not be taken lightly. Beginning in June 2025, property owners found in violation of the regulations could face fines of up to $500 per day. Additionally, repeat offenders risk being barred from obtaining a permit for three years.
Council members also discussed changes in Ithaca’s STR landscape since the regulations were adopted.
While the number of STR units has decreased slightly, Wilson noted that the total number of listings, including duplicate postings across multiple platforms, remains higher.
“Some properties are listed multiple times, either on different platforms or for different rental terms,” she said. “That’s why the number of listings is often higher
than the number of unique STR units.”
The Council’s focus on STR regulations reflects broader concerns about Ithaca’s housing crisis. By limiting the proliferation of STRs, city officials hope to make more residential units available for long-term renters. The regulations are also designed to discourage speculative property purchases, where investors buy homes solely for use as short-term rentals.
During the meeting, Mayor Robert Cantelmo highlighted the historical significance of the legislation, noting its origins in community discussions years prior.
“This is one of our first actions to address the housing challenges in Ithaca,” Cantelmo said. “The goal is to ensure that homes in our city are being used to benefit the community, not just as vacation rentals.”
Ithaca Common Council Calls for Increased State Aid to Municipalities
The Ithaca Common Council recently advanced a resolution urging New York State to increase financial aid to local municipalities, emphasizing the need for consistent and equitable funding to support essential services.
The resolution aligns with statewide advocacy led by the New York Conference of Mayors (NYCOM), asking Gov. Kathy Hochul and the New York State Legislature to continue the additional $50 million in unrestricted aid provided to municipalities in 2024.
Additionally, it calls for the development of a long-term funding plan to ensure financial support keeps pace with inflation and accounts for unique local challenges, such as Ithaca’s high percentage of tax-exempt properties.
Mayor Robert Cantelmo introduced the resolution, noting the financial strain municipalities face as they try to balance budgets while maintaining essential services like public safety, infrastructure, and housing. He highlighted the role of NYCOM in advocating for increased Aid and Incentives for Municipalities (AIM) funding, which has remained stagnant for years despite rising costs.
“This resolution reflects the city’s support for a fair and sustainable approach to state aid,” Cantelmo said. “The current formula does not adequately account for the unique financial challenges of municipalities like Ithaca.”
Fourth Ward Alderperson David Shapiro pointed out that municipalities hosting large tax-exempt institutions, such as Cornell University, face additional financial burdens.
“The current formula overlooks the fact that a significant portion of our land is untaxable,” Shapiro said. “While we appreciate the additional $50 million, we need a system that considers these disparities.”
Shapiro also suggested incorporating metrics like the percentage of tax-exempt properties into the AIM funding formula, ensuring communities with limited taxable land receive equitable support.
The resolution underscores the importance of predictable state funding in maintaining essential municipal services. Ithaca, like many other cities in New York, relies on state aid to bridge gaps in its budget and address the needs of its residents.
Council members highlighted the impact of stagnant funding on the city’s ability to invest in infrastructure, public safety, and affordable housing.
Deputy Director of Planning, Megan Wilson, said that Ithaca’s short term rental laws will start to be enforced in the new year. Property owners with STRs will recieve two informational mailings explaning the law and how to comply. (Photo: Matt Dougherty)
Thid Ward Alderperson David Shapiro supported the resoultion to request an increase in AIM funding, adding that the state should consider the amount of tax-exempt property within a municipality when considering funding. (Photo: Mark Syvertson)
“A new hockey stick.”
Lincoln
“I want a tiny puppy.”
Jane
“A Minecraft Lego set.”
Geary
puppy
LETTERS TO THE EDITOR
RE: Shapiro Leadership
“Council NEEDS dissenting and challenging voices. David and Margaret are the only voices of sanity, imo. And the only ones not singing with the choir. For a community that claims to like “diversity” and “inclusion,” I’d say that you’re hypocrites. You only have people who hold exactly the same views on every question and who never challenge anything. Try listening to dissenting opinions instead.”
— Anita Graf
RE: Weapons & Narcotics at Asteri
“The Mayor and City Council need to get to the bottom of the stunning events happening at the Asteri building . Who is responsible for green lighting this building to be a homeless enclave?” — Jim Dennis
“Oh stop with the putdowns of The Asteri. Nice term, “Homeless Enclave.” I’d take living in an enclave like that compared to wherever some of your ‘Superior Enclaves’ are. Such snootiness. Just
as much b.s. goes on drug wise in places like Cayuga Heights but the focus isn’t on that area, or College town. I wonder why?
Sure The Asteri has some bad apples, but it also has a great community spirit you never hear about and 99% of the residents are super friendly. You hear a lot more ‘Good Mornings’! walking in The Asteri in the morning than you do when you hit The Commons.
I love Ithaca, and I’m proud to be an Ithacan, but some of you make me ashamed when I hear these better than them put downs of The Asteri and the homeless. None of us are squat in the grand scheme of things, and for all you huge numbers of well off drug users who buy from the same people you put down to sound socially correct, just stop. Judge not before you judge yourself.
That said, I hope you all have a great day, agree or disagree with me.” —
Milton James
RE: Cornell Basketball Beats Berkley
“According to Cornell’s “carbon net zero” program, the campus generates about 150,000 metric tons of carbon per year. Anyone with internet access can estimate that simply sending a basketball team all the way to California for one game generates about 3,000 metric tons of carbon. The degree of hypocrisy, gaslighting and lying with statistics involved in
such an endeavor is impressive.” — Steven Baginski
“Indeed! It is ridiculous for a team from California to be in the Atlantic Coast Conference. If they were removed, Cornell would not have to travel across the country to play a ridiculous game. Furthermore, Cornell teams should be prohibited from competing in anything other than the Finger Lakes Conference further reducing CO2 emissions for travel. This is the only way to save the planet, else the end of humanity will all fall on Cornell, and their selfishness in providing luxury jet travel to their mediocre basketball team. This is not fair for all the minorities who are more severely impacted by global warming than the privileged Ivy Leaguers at Cornell.” — Robert Young
RE: Co2 Fracking Bill Issues
“The fatally flawed Kelles/Webb fracking bill (A8866/S8357) was reportedly sent to the Governor on 12/12/2024.
Governor Hochul has 30 days from that date to make a decision to sign or veto the bill. If the Governor fails to act, the "pocket veto" has the same effect as a veto.
I write to request that all Fractivists take immediate, urgent action to make sure Governor Hochul does not sign the woefully inadequate Kelles/Webb legislation into law because it specifically excludes carbon dioxide used to frack Marcellus Shale from New York’s statutory definition of High-Volume Hydraulic Fracturing.
The Kelles/Webb bill also does not prohibit all forms of High-Volume Hydraulic Fracturing in New York even though the State Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC) determined that this policy is required to safeguard public health and the environment in New York.
It is absolutely imperative to require Governor Hochul to prohibit all forms of High-Volume Hydraulic Shale Fracturing in New York combined with horizontal drilling, including using any amounts of water, carbon dioxide, nitrogen, gelled propane and natural gas.
It would be irresponsible for the Governor, legislators or environmental groups to support anything less than a comprehensive prohibition of all forms of High-Volume Hydraulic Fracturing.
Fractivists must bring maximum pressure on the Governor. Her 30-day deadline for taking action nearly coincides with the inauguration of Donald Trump who has vowed to maximize USA oil and gas production.
Unless New Yorkers require the Governor
to fulfill the letter and spirit of the DEC’s proposed prohibition of all forms of shale fracking in its historic SGEIS, our state could get fracked. It is as simple as that.
DEC’s Final SGEIS determined that non-water HVHF methods associated with the “environmentally-friendly chemical approach,” including “Liquid CO2,” “Nitrogen-based foam” and “Liquefied Petroleum Gas (LPG),” “all fail to limit unavoidable adverse environmental impacts and fail to address the risks and uncertainties of high-volume hydraulic fracturing (emphasis added).”
DEC also declared, “Based on unavoidable adverse environmental impacts and uncertainty regarding the science surrounding high-volume hydraulic fracturing and its potential impacts to public health and the environment, the Department finds that the best course of action is to select the No Action alternative. Selection of the No Action alternative means that the Department will not establish a high-volume hydraulic fracturing permitting program; that no individual or site-specific permit applications for wells using high-volume hydraulic fracturing will be processed; and that high-volume hydraulic fracturing will be prohibited in New York State (emphasis added).”
DEC concluded, “In the end, there are no feasible or prudent alternatives that would adequately avoid or minimize adverse environmental impacts and that address the scientific uncertainties and risks to public health from this activity. The Department’s chosen alternative to prohibit high-volume hydraulic fracturing is the best alternative based on the balance between protection of the environment and public health and economic and social considerations.”
Our coalition letter requests that Governor Hochul adopt the following revised HVHF language pursuant to Section 1. Subdivision 3 of Section 23-0501 of the Environmental Conservation Law: 3. (a) No permits shall be issued authorizing an applicant to drill, deepen, plug back, or convert wells that use horizontal, directional or any other form of drilling combined with high-volume hydraulic fracturing to extract, complete or recomplete natural gas or oil resources. For purposes of this section, high-volume hydraulic fracturing shall be defined as the injection or stimulation of a well using any amount of water, carbon dioxide, propane, nitrogen, natural gas or any other substance as the base fluid for hydraulic fracturing for any individual stage or the combined total of all stages in a well completion, regardless of whether the well is vertical, or directional, including horizontal.” — Walter Hang
UPS DOWNS&
Ups
The City of Ithaca could soon be adopting an official City Flag.
Downs
An estimated 23.7% of New York residents can’t afford their utility bills. The average electricity bill is $193.40, a 20.2% increase from $160.96 in 2023. Additionally, 22.3% of residents kept their homes at temperatures that felt unsafe or unhealthy. Across the country, 23.4% have been unable to pay part or all of their energy bill during the same period. These figures are up slightly from a similar period in 2023, when 22% couldn’t pay their full energy bills.
HEARD SEEN&
Heard
The drinking water supply serving nearly 368,000 New Yorkers across the state is at risk from toxic pollutants due to a regulatory gap that has allowed landfills to release untreated wastewater into rivers. The report found that 89 million gallons of landfill leachate were discharged into the Mohawk River and Hudson River each year from 2019-2023.
Seen
The Downtown Ithaca Alliance is thrilled to host a ribbon cutting ceremony to celebrate the grand opening of Mushroom Spirits Distillery, a full-service bar and tasting room in Downtown Ithaca. The event took place on Wednesday, December 18, at 12:30 p.m.
IF YOU CARE TO RESPOND to something in this column, or suggest your own praise or blame, write editor@ithacatimes. com, with a subject head “U&D.”
QUESTION OF THE WEEK
Should New York State pass a bill to designate EMS as an essential service?
90 . 6 % Yes.
6.3% No.
3.1 % I don’t care.
N ext W eek ’s Q uestio N :
Should the Tompkins County Industrial Development Agency (IDA) expand to allow a member of the Ithaca School Board on the IDA?
Visit ithaca.com to submit your response.
Addressing Homelessness Means Treating Housing as Human Right
HBy Matt Dougherty
omelessness is not only a crisis but a failure to recognize housing as a basic human right, according to panelists at a discussion hosted Monday by the Tompkins County Office of Human Rights (OHR).
The event, titled “Housing as a Human Right: Local Perspectives and Solutions,” brought together public health, human services, and legal experts to address the systemic barriers contributing to homelessness and discuss actionable solutions for the Ithaca community.
Dr. Kenneth Clarke, OHR director, opened the discussion by posing a question that framed the evening’s dialogue.
“How might we imagine and work toward the idea that fair housing can be and should be a domestic human right? Can we envision what Ithaca, New York, and the United States would look like if the right to a dwelling was a protected human rights category?” Clarke asked.
Over 80 people attended the live discussion, which is now available for viewing on the Tompkins County YouTube channel. The panelists included representatives from local organizations and agencies, each bringing a unique perspective to the multifaceted issue of homelessness.
Liddy Bargar, Director of Housing Initiatives for the Human Services Coalition (HSC), provided a sobering overview of homelessness in the county. Bargar explained that HSC manages the local Continuum of Care (CoC), a network that oversees the community’s homeless response system. The CoC’s mission is to create a community where homelessness is “rare, brief, and one-time.”
Bargar described how the CoC uses a “Coordinated Entry” process to connect individuals and families experiencing homelessness to services such as rapid rehousing, transitional housing, and permanent supportive housing. She highlighted the effectiveness of evidence-based interventions like permanent supportive housing, which operates under the “Housing First” model. “Until people can meet that base level of Maslow’s hierarchy of basic physiological human needs—breathing, sleep, water, shelter, clothing—it’s almost impossible for them to reach that self-actualization piece where they thrive,” Bargar said.
She also noted that Tompkins County’s permanent supportive housing programs have a 90% success rate in helping individuals transition out of homelessness.
Danielle Harrington, Executive Director of Tompkins Community Action (TC Action), emphasized the dual challenges of housing affordability and availability. “Housing affordability and housing availability are the biggest barriers contributing to the rising numbers of our unhoused,” Harrington said.
Harrington shared how TC Action supports the county’s most vulnerable populations through programs like supportive housing, which offers stability to those experiencing chronic homelessness. She described the “Housing First” model as essential for addressing homelessness.
“When your whole day is focused on survival, it is hard to focus on your education or employment. That’s where supportive housing comes in,” she said.
Rick Alvord, Coordinator of Community Youth Services for the Tompkins County Youth Services Department, high-
lighted the challenges faced by unhoused youth, particularly those aging out of foster care, LGBTQ+ youth, and survivors of abuse or exploitation. Alvord praised local programs like Open Doors, The Learning Web, and the Advocacy Center for addressing the needs of at-risk youth.
“These programs provide critical services to help young people find stability,” Alvord said, adding that collaboration among organizations is essential for meeting the diverse needs of youth experiencing homelessness.
Dr. William Klepack, Medical Director for Tompkins County Whole Health, addressed the public health consequences of homelessness. “Homelessness often is a result of gaps that we have in our community that lead people to falling into being inadequately housed or homeless,” Klepack said.
He outlined the numerous health risks associated with housing instability, including poor sanitation, limited access to healthcare, malnutrition, and increased susceptibility to violence and mental health trauma. “Downstream, illnesses become harder and more expensive to care for,” Klepack explained. He shared an example of how an untreated minor infection can escalate into a lifethreatening condition, illustrating the costly consequences of failing to address homelessness.
Klepack also emphasized the importance of supportive housing programs in breaking the cycle of homelessness. “The more times that people come back into homelessness or being inadequately
Dr William Klepack, Medical Director for Tompkins County Whole Health, highlighted the public health consequences of homelessness, saying that it prolings housing instability, worsens health outcomes, and increases risk of mental health trauma.
(Photo: Tompkins County)
Liddy Bargar, Director of Housing Initiatives for the Human Services Coalition (HSC) emphasized the importance of “Housing First,” saying that it aims to meet basic needs that are essential for people to succede.
(Photo: File)
Dr. Kenneth Clarke, Director of the Tompkins County Office of Human Rights, asked the community to think about the concept of housing as a human right as the first step towards addressing homelessness.
(Photo: Tompkins County OHR)
The Stereoscope
By Charley Githler
We are blessed, in Ithaca, with a robust historical society in the form of the Tompkins County History Center. At the heart of the institution is the archives, containing thousands and thousands of documents, photos, books, artifacts, genealogy files, maps, vehicles, articles of clothing, toys, and, well, so many other things. There are lamps from the steamship Frontenac, and an actual made-in-Ithaca biplane. It’s all carefully stored, catalogued and managed by Donna Eschenbrenner, the History Center’s archivist extraordinaire. Donna has graciously agreed to select, once a month and her sole discretion, an item from the archives for me to write about.
This month’s selection isn’t so much an item as it is items: a stereoviewer (stereoscope) and boxes of stereoscopic photograph cards (stereographs).
For those not familiar with what these are, a stereograph consists of two nearly identical photographs taken with a camera that has two side-by-side lenses about the same distance apart as human eyes. The pictures are mounted next to each other on a card, and when viewed through a stereoscope, the lenses combine the two pictures into one and create the illusion of depth: a 3-D image. Simple and ingenious at the same time, and they were enormously popular for about 75 years, from about the Civil War until well into the 20th century. There are hundreds of stereographs in the History Center’s archives. Boxes of them. Of particular interest to me were the scores of stereo photos of Ithaca. Slot
the card in the holder, look through the viewer, and there’s the Clinton House in the 1880s, more alive than any two-dimensional photo could make it. It looks like it might be a sunny day, and Cayuga Street wasn’t paved yet, so likely a little dusty. It probably smelled like horses. The effect is actually a little alarming at first, as your mind makes its way into the depth of the picture. It’s a more complex experience than looking at a regular photo or, I would submit, a flat screen.
It's easy to understand the fascination with stereographs, which were a fixture in middle- and upper-class homes. Before television and newsreels, it was a way to see exotic foreign capitals, new inventions, the president, natural disasters, Native Americans in the West, and scenery, all in three dimensions and in your living room. Of course, there were humorous scenes available, and nudes, maybe not left on the parlor table.
Locally, there were at least a half dozen photo studios selling stereographs of scenes in and around Tompkins County. There are street scenes, fancy houses (including interiors), landscapes, pictures of Cornell in the early days. A winter scene of Cayuga Street at the intersection with State Street in the 1890s, taken from an upper story, pulled me in for a good fifteen minutes, with horse-drawn sleighs and pedestrians on the road stretching north toward Dewitt Park. Another fascinating image is the student body of the Ithaca Academy standing in front of the school on the corner of Buffalo and Cayuga Streets in 1884.
The ubiquity of stereographs over such a long time means that a lot of them survive, a century later. The archives has an excellent collection, of course, but you can also find boxes of them in antique stores. Pastimes in DeWitt Mall has a box with maybe a hundred of them, for $1.00 each, and if one were interested an antique stereoviewer might be found on eBay for around $100.
As always, it was an hour well spent at the History Center. The greatest thing about the archives is that they are available to everyone, either on a walk-in basis on Saturdays (10:00-3:00) or by reaching out to Donna at archives@thehistorycenter.net for an appointment.
AI Innovation Meets Public Worry: Privacy in the Spotlight
By Sasha Bykhovski, Cornell Student
Earlier this year, ChatGPT, an AI chatbot, had experienced a data leak that exposed personal data, including login credentials, payment details, and conversations with the chatbot. This breach was a direct violation of OpenAI’s privacy policies and is just one of many examples illustrating the risks associated with AIrelated data breaches. As AI continues to be integrated with our online interactions, these risks are continuing to increase. For example, when we visit any site, AI processes different data points like behavioral, contextual, and first-party data to predict consumer preferences. AI’s role in targeted advertising extends beyond data processing, allowing companies to deliver highlypersonalized ads tailored to our preferences. While it may be convenient, it raises serious ethical questions. Many companies are not transparent about the extent to which they are using AI to analyze personal data, leaving users in the dark about how their information is processed and stored. My survey question aimed to explore how concerned users are about these issues and whether these issues are influenced by demographic factors, like age.
A sample of Americans were told that companies use AI for targeted advertising, then asked to rate their level of concern about a possible data breach, from “Extremely Concerned” to “Not Concerned at all”. The survey results revealed a striking trend: the majority of respondents expressed significant concern about AI-related data breaches. Specifically, 30.5% of respondents were “Somewhat Concerned”, the largest group, followed by 26.4% were “Very Concerned”, and 26% were “Extremely Concerned”. Meanwhile, 12.5% were “Slightly Concerned”, and only 4.7% were “Not Concerned at All”. These results demonstrate that the vast majority of people are expressing some type of concern with over 82% of respondents expressing some type of concern and nearly 53% fall into “Extremely” or “Very Concerned” categories. It further underscores the public’s growing unease about the risks with AI and data breaches they may cause,
showing that the issue is more widely recognized. I further decided to explore whether there is a correlation with age and the concern of AI causing a data breach. The survey highlighted that the two oldest age groups, 50-64 and 65+, presented the highest levels of concern about AI exposing their data, with 59.2% and 58.6%, respectively, saying they were “Extremely” or “Very Concerned”. On the contrary, the two youngest age groups, 18-29 and 30-49, presented lower concern, with only 44.5% and 48.6% respectively for the same categories. The generational divide shows significant evidence for the differences in familiarity with AI and comfort with technology. Younger individuals who have grown up in a digital world may feel more comfortable and accustomed to sharing information online and trusting technology like AI. However, older adults feel overwhelmed by the rapid pace of technological advancements and are less familiar with AI and new technologies that they are more skeptical about sharing their personal information. For these individuals, the lack of transparency from companies heightened their fears.
These results are important because they highlight a critical need for companies to have stricter policies surrounding data privacy and improve transparency especially when engaging with older age groups. To help individuals trust AI more, companies must clearly disclose how AI is being used to process and store personal data, along with security measures in place to protect it. Businesses could invest in educational initiatives on AI, explaining the significance of its role and the various measures being taken to secure user data. With these efforts, concerns can be mitigated and trust can be built, especially among older demographics. With companies increasingly relying on AI for targeted advertising and user data processing, it’s vital that they enforce strict security measures and prioritize user trust. The public’s growing awareness and concern with these issues place a demand on companies to prioritize their users by showing them transparency and taking accountability. Only by addressing these concerns can businesses ensure that AI does not come at the expense of users losing their security and privacy.
A stereoscope from the Tompkins County History Center’s archives offers a 3D glimpse into Ithaca’s past.
(Photo: Tompkins County History Center)
AYear In Review: Ithaca 2024
nother year in Ithaca is coming to a close, and as tradition dictates, we at the Ithaca Times are reminiscing the year that just was by compiling a list of all the events that made 2024 a year for the record books.
From honoring the past to restarting beloved local services, witnessing astronomical milestones, passing historic legislation, supporting human rights and the labor movement, and voting in the 2024 Presidential Election, Ithacans have experienced an incredibly busy year. Now, let us sit back, relax, and welcome the new year with all the unexpected twists and turns it may bring.
WEST END DIORAMA REMEMBERS ITHACA’S PAST
We began the year in January with an homage to Ithaca’s past by looking at the one-of-a-kind diorama of the city’s West End before the construction of the flood control channel built by the Army Corps of Engineers in 1965. Former Freeville Mayor David Fogel spent eight years and thousands of dollars before he completed the diorama in 1986.
The diorama depicts an area of the city formerly known as ‘The Rhine,’ which was once home to hundreds of working-class families and small businesses. Fogel said that he created the diorama to memorialize a “marginalized” neighborhood that was “wiped out” by the flood control channel project.
According to Fogel, the construction of the flood control channel displaced the area's population while providing them with a meager amount of compensation in return. Community institutions like the West Side House, a meeting place for clubs, dances, and other kinds of recreation, and Beebe Chapel were not saved from the area's destruction. In total, the city and state acquired 185 parcels of land, and 31 houses were demolished in the neighborhood as part of the flood control project.
The diorama is now the only way to get a glimpse of the vibrant working-class community that the area once was before it was forever changed to help the city deal with an ongoing flooding problem.
While the diorama holds local historical significance, it has struggled to find a con-
By Matt Dougherty
ONCE IN A LIFETIME SOLAR ECLIPSE
Then came the total solar eclipse of April 8, 2024. Even though Ithaca only experienced 98.8% magnitude, it was the first solar eclipse to take place in the skies over Ithaca since 1925. Just as it did nearly one hundred years ago, it baffled locals and drew the attention of scientists atop the hill at Cornell.
Throughout New York State, schools canceled classes for students of all ages to experience the eclipse, and people gathered on rooftops and other outdoor locations to view the sky on that unusually clear day. Ithaca was no exception, as eight different viewing parties were scheduled around the city for the historic day.
The next solar eclipse to touch New York State will be in 2079 and 2144, making the 2024 eclipse a once-in-a-lifetime event.
sistent home and has bounced in and out of storage. It was most recently on display at the Chemung Canal Trust Station branch but is being moved into storage again as the branch has announced its closure.
ITHACA CARSHARE MADE A COMEBACK
Next, the City saw the return of Ithaca CarShare. This beloved local service was forced to shut down operations for nine months at the end of 2023 due to a New York State law that prevented nonprofit organizations from receiving insurance through Risk Retention Groups (RRGs).
Ithaca CarShare operated for over a decade before it was forced to close temporarily. In February, the service announced its 2024 relaunch with a fleet of 24 vehicles, including two electric and two plugin hybrid cars.
More than 1,500 Ithacans use the service, which provides a reliable source of transportation for individuals and families without personal vehicles who need alternative means of public transportation. The comeback was celebrated as a win for community-driven initiatives prioritizing accessibility and sustainability.
Now that CarShare is back up and running, it can qualify for $315,000 in grant funding from NYSERDA over the next
three years. NYSERDA has also invested $3 million in car-sharing services throughout the state to reduce emissions.
In response to the reopening of Ithaca CarShare Assemblymember Anna Kelles said, “As transportation is one of the greatest contributors of greenhouse gas emissions, continuing community carsharing and moving forward with the electrification of carshare fleets are important steps to combating transportation’s impact on climate change.”
PRO-PALESTINIAN PROTESTS HIT CORNELL
Later that same month, students at Cornell University organized with the Coalition of Mutual Liberation (CML) organized an encampment on the arts quad to bring attention to how universities like Cornell are complicit in the violence being committed by Israel in Gaza.
The encampment, dubbed the “Liberated Zone,” began on April 25th and lasted roughly two weeks as hundreds of students,
Ithaca CarShare celebrated its much-anticipated return this year, relauching with a fleet of 24 vehicles to expand alternative transportation options for the 1,500 residents who use the service. The comeback also marked a victory for environmentally friendly mobility solutions. (Photo: File)
The West End Diorama , unveiled in early 2024, offers a detailed tribute to a once-thriving Ithaca neighborhood displaced by mid-20th century urban renewal. The intricately crafted model preserves the memory of the community’s history, inviting residents to reflect on the city’s past and its evolution. (Photo: File)
Cornell University students established a “Liberated Zone” encampment on the arts quad in April 2024 to show solidarity with Gaza and call for the University to divest from companies linked to violence committed by the State of Israel in Gaza. The protests sparked national attention and resulted in the suspensions of several students. (Photo: Matt Dougherty)
faculty, and Ithaca community members participated. The encampment aimed to pressure Cornell into calling for a ceasefire in Gaza and divesting from weapons manufacturers complicit in acts of genocide.
The university responded to the protests by enforcing its Interim Expressive Activity Policy, which aimed to limit pro-Palestinian organizing on campus. The policy resulted in the suspension of six students for their involvement in the encampment.
In the days before the encampment, Cornell students voted overwhelmingly in favor of a resolution calling for the university to support a permanent ceasefire in Gaza and divest from major weapons manufacturers. A month earlier, the Ithaca Common Council also passed a ceasefire resolution of its own. However, when the resolution that Cornell students approved was sent to the office of former Cornell President Martha Pollack for final approval, she denied it.
While the encampment disbanded, protests organized by CML continued at the start of the Fall 2024 semester as a group of roughly 100 students disrupted a career fair at the Statler Hotel that hosted weapons manufacturers Boeing and L3Harris, which supply arms used by the Israeli military. Cornell suspended four students for their alleged involvement in this protest, including international graduate student Momodou Taal, which sparked national attention as it put him at risk of being deported.
ITHACA CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT PASSES REVISED BUDGET
Then, the Ithaca City School District (ICSD) successfully passed its revised 2024-25 budget in the June 18 revote, securing voter approval after the initial proposal was voted down in May.
The approved budget included a 2.79% tax levy increase, staying under the state tax cap and requiring only a simple majority to pass. This marked a significant reduction from the original budget’s proposed 12.14% levy increase, which drew sharp criticism from residents concerned about skyrocketing taxes. The district made substantial cuts to address voter concerns, reducing the tax levy by $5.9 million compared to the May proposal. Key adjustments included a 22% reduction in administrative labor costs, pausing staff hiring for vacant positions, and setting a minimum class size of 17 students.
Despite these reductions, Deputy Superintendent Lily Talcott emphasized that there will be an increase in teacher aide positions, and the budget avoids direct cuts to current staffing. Talcott acknowledged the potential challenges, including slower ad-
Despite opposition from local landlords the City of Ithaca Common Council voted 8-2 to adopt the Good Cause Eviction law in the summer of 2024, protecting the city’s majority tenant population from unjust evictions and rent hikes.
(Photo: Mark Syvertson)
ministrative response times, larger class sizes, and fewer behavioral support resources. Had the budget failed, ICSD would have been forced to adopt a contingency budget, which would have frozen the tax levy at last year’s level and imposed strict limitations on extracurricular activities, elective courses, and community use of school buildings. The Ithaca Teachers Association and board members described such a scenario as “devastating,” highlighting its longterm harm to students and the community.
GOOD CAUSE EVICTION: REFLECTING ON ITHACA’S LANDMARK TENANT PROTECTIONS
Ithaca’s adoption of Good Cause Eviction in July 2024 marked a turning point
Ithaca became a focal point for the labor movement in 2024, with workers demanding fair treatment and improved conditions. From the United Auto Workers (UAW) strike for improved wages at Cornell, to Teamsters Local 317 picketing BorgWarner over unsafe working conditions and contract disputes and GreenStar Co-op employees voting to unionize under Workers United, Ithaca saw what some would call a “Hot Labor Summer”. (Photo: File)
in the city’s housing landscape. Passed by an 8-2 vote after years of organizing by tenant advocates and elected officials, the law has provided critical protections for renters in one of the most expensive small cities in America. It guarantees tenants the right to lease renewal unless landlords can demonstrate “good cause” for eviction or non-renewal, such as non-payment of rent, illegal activity, or owner occupancy.
Mayor Robert Cantelmo, who cast the final vote, called it a “moderate regulation,” emphasizing its fairness, saying, “It gives people the right to stay in their homes if they uphold their end of the lease.”
The law also introduced rent increase caps, limiting annual hikes to the Consumer Price Index plus 5% or 10%, whichever is lower. While not a full rent control measure, it aims to slow the steep increases that saw rents rise 30% in Tompkins County between 2015 and 2023.
The law's passage was not without opposition. Landlords expressed concerns about compliance costs and feared it would hurt small property owners. Fifth Ward Alderperson Margaret Fabrizio and Third Ward Alderperson David Shapiro, the two dissenting votes, argued the law unfairly targeted small landlords while exempting larger developments and new construction.
Despite the contentious debate, advocates like the Ithaca Tenants Union (ITU) hailed the law as a major victory. “For decades, landlords had unchecked power over tenants,” said organizer Genevieve Rand. “This law changed that.”
Passing Good Cause Eviction remains a defining moment in Ithaca’s housing policy. It signals that tenant rights are a priority and sets a precedent for other cities grappling
YEAR IN REVIEW: ITHACA 2024
continued from page 9
with affordability crises. So far,12 cities have opted into Good Cause laws statewide.
A YEAR OF UNION ORGANIZING IN ITHACA
Ithaca also saw a surge in union activity in 2024, with significant organizing efforts and labor victories by UAW members at Cornell University, Teamsters Local 317 at BorgWarner, and workers at GreenStar Food Co-Op. These events underscored the growing momentum for workers’ rights across a range of industries in the region.
At Cornell University, UAW Local 2300 members went on strike on August 18 after failing to secure a contract that met their demands for fair wages and the elimination of a tiered pay system. The strike, which lasted 15 days and disrupted essential campus operations such as dining, custodial services, and maintenance, ended on September 2 when union members voted 77% in favor of a new $43 million, four-year contract.
The agreement brought 21%-25.4% wage increases, eliminated the tiered pay system, and ensured most workers would earn above $24 per hour by the contract’s third year. However, some members, particularly in lower job grades, voiced concerns about the deal’s inability to immediately deliver a living wage. Despite these criticisms, the strike was seen as a historic moment, with UAW leadership calling it a “monumental victory” for workers.
At BorgWarner, Teamsters Local 317 members ratified a new contract on September 18, ending a nearly two-week-long strike. After rejecting a previous proposal that failed to address concerns over health insurance and restrictive time-off policies, union members approved the revised deal by a 539-60 vote.
The contract included a 21% wage increase over four years, retroactive health insurance coverage, and additional vacation and personal days. It also eliminated healthcare surcharges for spouses and introduced a $5,500 ratification bonus. The strike had escalated after BorgWarner revoked health insurance for striking workers, prompting widespread criticism and further solidifying local union support.
Despite opposition from workers, BorgWarner still plans to outsource valvetrain production at its manufacturing plant on Warren Road to Mexico by 2026, resulting in a loss of approximately 300 jobs.
At GreenStar Food Co-Op, workers at the Cascadilla Street location voted 60-14 to unionize under Workers United on August 28. This marked a significant step for
Ithaca’s locally sourced grocery store, with workers citing the need for greater workplace democracy, communication, and accountability.
GreenStar’s General Manager, Jeff Bessemer, acknowledged the democratic process, and soon after, workers at its East Buffalo Street location voted in favor of plans to unionize.
These victories highlight the resilience of Ithaca’s labor movement in 2024, with workers across industries demanding fair wages, benefits, and improved working conditions through collective action.
DEMOCRATS HOLD GROUND IN NEW YORK AS TRUMP WINS PRESIDENCY
Despite strong Democratic performances in Tompkins County and across New York, former President Donald Trump defeated Vice President Kamala Harris in the 2024 presidential election.
Trump secured 312 electoral votes, winning key swing states like Wisconsin, Michigan, Pennsylvania, Georgia, Arizona, and Nevada. Harris garnered 226 electoral votes, with her nationwide vote total falling short of President Biden’s 2020 performance by roughly 7 million votes.
In local Congressional races, Democrat Josh Riley narrowly defeated Republican incumbent Marc Molinaro in New York’s 19th Congressional District. Riley earned 49% of the vote to Molinaro’s 48%, winning by a margin of only a few thousand votes. Riley’s campaign focused on protecting workers’ rights, defending Social Security, and addressing corporate consolidation and political corruption. Molinaro conceded a week after the election, congratulating Riley on his victory.
In the U.S. Senate race, Democratic incumbent Kirsten Gillibrand defeated Republican Michael Sapraicone with 55% of the vote. In the State Senate, Democratic incumbent Lea Webb retained her seat in District 52, defeating Republican Mike Sigler with 55% of the vote.
New York voters also approved Proposition One, enshrining reproductive rights and anti-discrimination protections in the state constitution. The measure passed with 56% support, marking a significant victory for progressive advocates.
From honoring history and embracing sustainability to advocating for justice and navigating political and economic challenges, Ithaca has once again demonstrated its commitment to equity, innovation, and solidarity. We look forward to what the new year brings, and that will start with our Readers Writes issue. Send in your submissions before it’s too late!
The 10th Annual Ithaca Chill Challenge Aims to Raise $50,000 for Community Recovery Programs
By Matt Dougherty
As the clock strikes noon on January 1, Cayuga Lake will once again play host to an annual tradition that blends courage, community, and commitment to a cause: the Ithaca Chill Challenge.
Now in its 10th year, this “dip-or-dodge” event, organized by Ithaca Community Recovery (ICR), raises funds to support vital recovery-related programming in Ithaca and beyond.
For a decade, the Chill Challenge has brought together participants from all walks of life to raise money by asking donors to decide whether they will take a plunge into the icy waters of Cayuga Lake or cheer from the safety of the shore. This year, ICR is aiming to raise $50,000 to support its mission of providing a safe, affordable, and welcoming space for individuals and families navigating addiction recovery.
Over the past 10 years, the event has helped sustain ICR’s operations at its home base on West Seneca Street, where the organization has provided meeting spaces for 12-step programs, recovery-themed yoga, and other community support services for over 24 years.
“This event helps ensure that if you or a loved one are trying to recover, there’s a place where you can find support and community,” said Veronica Johnson, Chair of the Chill Challenge. “Since the pandemic, substance abuse has touched more lives than ever. Events like this are not just about raising money; they’re about reminding people that they’re not alone.”
Johnson said that the Chill Challenge has grown in popularity each year, as more members of the community see the impact of ICR’s programs. “Each year, more and more members of our community see the importance of what we do and want to help.”
Participants collect donations from friends, family, and community members, who vote with their contributions to decide the participant’s fate: either take the icy plunge or stay dry. At noon on New Year’s Day, the donations are tallied, and the higher total for each participant determines the outcome.
“Whether you’re dipping or dodging, you’re helping to make a difference,” said Johnson. “And that’s what makes this event so special — it’s about coming together as a community to support something bigger than ourselves.”
Registration is open until December 31, 2024,
and donors can contribute at any time on the event’s website, www.ithacachillchallenge.org.
The funds raised by the Chill Challenge go directly toward maintaining ICR’s facilities and programs. This year’s goal of $50,000 will help fund capital improvements to the organization’s building on West Seneca Street and continue providing essential services for those in recovery.
“This event is our single biggest fundraiser of the year,” said Johnson. “It helps us keep our doors open 365 days a year and ensure that ICR remains a place of hope and healing for everyone who needs it.”
The importance of ICR’s work has not gone unnoticed by local leaders. Ithaca Mayor Robert Cantelmo praised the event as a reflection of the city’s values.
“The Ithaca Chill Challenge embodies the spirit of our city—coming together to support one another and make a positive impact,” Cantelmo said. “This event not only raises essential funds for recovery programs but also fosters a sense of unity and resilience within our community. I encourage everyone to participate and contribute to this important initiative. Together, we can continue to build a healthier, more inclusive Ithaca.”
This year’s event will feature a post-dip celebration at the Ithaca Yacht Club, complete with cake, prizes for the top fundraisers and best costumes, and appearances by local leaders, including Mayor Cantelmo.
“This year, our goal is to raise $50,000 for ICR,” said Stacey Dimas, Press Secretary for the
Chill Challenge. “With these funds, we’ll be able to commit to capital investment projects for our home on West Seneca Street and continue providing spaces for all kinds of meetings, from 12-step programs to recovery-themed yoga.”
Dimas emphasized that the event is as much about building community as it is about fundraising. “Community is both the star and the goal of this event,” she said.
For many participants and supporters, the Chill Challenge represents a fresh start — a way to ring in the new year with purpose and positivity.
As the Ithaca Chill Challenge marks its 10th anniversary, its organizers are optimistic about the future. The event has become a cornerstone of ICR’s efforts to support those affected by addiction and to build a stronger, more compassionate community.
“This is more than just a fundraiser,” said Johnson. “It’s a celebration of recovery, resilience, and the power of community.”
With registration open and fundraising already underway, ICR invites everyone to join the movement — whether by taking the plunge, cheering from the shore, or making a donation.
“We’re thrilled to see the level of interest already,” said Johnson. “It’s a testament to the strength and spirit of our community.”
To learn more, register, or donate, visit www.ithacachillchallenge.org. Then, bundle up and head to the Ithaca Yacht Club at 1 p.m. on January 1 to celebrate recovery and resilience in the most unforgettable way.
Arts & Entertainment
Participants in last years Chill Challenge brave the icy waters of Cayuga Lake on New Year’s Day to raise funds for Ithaca Community Recovery. (Photo: Provided)
Jazz Wednesday at the Argos Inn
By Austin Montgomery
Frank Zappa once said, “Jazz isn’t dead, it just smells funny.” Although the Argos Inn doesn’t smell funny by any means, Jazz is alive and thriving in both ear and mouth. Both musicians and bartenders bring a fresh perspective to music and cocktails that continually enchant me with unanticipated expressions that I can only describe as magic. Every Wednesday from 5:30 to 7:30 p.m. is a unique, multi-sensory experience that leaves me yearning for the next week the minute I walk out the door.
Although Jazz is a nebulous term, traditional Jazz shares a lot of similarities with craft beverages. In both disciplines, a piece is similar enough to be identified as
a “standard,” yet the artist adds their own unique twist that makes it their own. The fun part is seeing how the artist blends newness within the bounds of the familiar. For example, the typical format is for a band to play a few measures in which the melody is recognizable as a “standard,” then each person takes turns soloing, adding their own story to the song. Similarly, many of the cocktails are based on standard drinks, with unique twists that make the cocktails at Argos special.
My personal favorite to watch is Zack Knewstub on piano. While I believe he truly shines in his interpretation of slow, intimate ballads, he expertly weaves in and out of songs, keys, and ideas. Often, he starts with one song, seamlessly transitions to another so that I am transported
to another dimension, only to be brought back to the original song and reminded where he started. I’ve heard him play over 50 times by now, and still, he manages to bring newness to each performance. He’s my favorite artist that I have had the privilege of seeing live. (I will admit, my ear is biased towards piano.)
Owen Erickson or Greg Evans can be found on drums each week. Both selflessly keep the rhythm, occasionally change the tempo in a tasteful way, and dial up interest-
Christmas Services
Christmas Eve
Tuesday, December 24, 2024
4:00 PM Holy Communion with Carols and Organ; blessing of the crèche 10:00 PM Festive Choral Eucharist
Christmas Day
Wednesday December 25, 2024 10:00 AM Holy Eucharist with Hymns St. John’s Episcopal Church 210 N. Cayuga St. (Corner of N. Cayuga & W. Buffalo Streets) 607-273-6532 / stjohnsithaca.org
ing drum solos that are pleasantly surprising. The words that come to mind for both are “really cool”. You can catch Nicholas Walker, Michael Bates, or Tristen Jarvis on upright bass. Each of them communicates in their own unique way and does much more than just provide the bassline. They all produce some beautiful melodies during their time to solo, but they also are so much fun to watch. Clearly, they are one with their instrument, and love playing. It’s fun to watch them have fun up there.
I don’t want to compare the artists between each other, but I do want to give the artists recognition and show that they all bring their own “something” to each performance that I am so grateful for. This show is truly the best deal in town (I recommend a $10+ donation, although it is technically free). I’ve been to jazz clubs before that feel exclusive. Argos feels like the perfect combination of classy and casual. The musicians are professionals, but at the same time, they are just playing, and the audience happens to be in the same room. It’s a special vibe that mirrors the way the menu is laid out, as well. Just as the musicians add their own piece to each song, all the cocktails are
Craft cocktails like the Star-belly Sneetch and Argentina Sour, created by Argos Inn’s talented bartenders, pair perfectly with the enchanting live Jazz, offering guests a multi-sensory experience. (Photo taken by Josh Felton)
a team effort by the bartenders at Argos. Cocktails are conveniently rated on a scale of 1-3 in terms of uniqueness, so you can have some idea of what you are getting into before you commit to a whole drink. Most of these exist because the bartenders were just playing until they came up with something that works. And of course, if newness isn’t for you, they do all the standards as well. Some of my favorites on the current menu are as follows:
Star-Belly Sneetch is a fall themed-gin riff on a tiki cocktail. Barrel aged gin is the base, with a house made bay leaf infused old tom gin. Zerbenz is an herbal liquor that adds sweetness and complexity. Cinnamon and crème da violette add warmth and color, respectively. Fresh grapefruit and lime add a bright citrus zing and acidity. Its recognizable as a tiki cocktail, but more complex and warmer.
Argentina Sour is a creamy, yet aromatic riff on a whiskey sour. House made bitters add warm, spicy complexity. Fernet Branca adds a pleasant bitterness and herbal quality. Fresh lemon juice keeps it bright. Almond-hazelnut cream add a silky texture and body. Finally, freshly grated nutmeg adds an aromatic spice to top it all off. Everything is perfectly balanced and in tune with each other. It’s sort of like an herbal, complex creamscicle.
Grey Gardens is unlike any standard cocktail I’ve had. I would describe it as a marriage between strawberry fruit roll ups, brand new leather, and warm tobacco. It’s hard to describe it — I didn’t think that these flavors could go together before I tried it. This drink is made with Earl Grey
infused plum gin, Cardamaro, and Manzanilla sherry.
These are just a few of the cocktails that blew me away, but I will admit that they aren’t always in the “student” budget. When I’m feeling exceptionally poor, a $4 Genesee can is a great option. Even better, there is an option for “One for My Haters”, which is a Miller High Life and a shot of Four Roses bourbon for $6. There have been a few occasions when I have even had “Two for my haters” — the music sounds extra good after that.
Before I finish, I would be disappointed if I didn’t highlight one particular bartender who I find to be exceptional. I have never had a bad drink from anyone at Argos, and everyone on staff is exceptionally pleasant and friendly. However, Max Chang is truly special when it comes to making cocktails. Max has improvised unbelievably cool cocktails for me over the past year, and everything is always perfectly in balance. Just as the musicians can hear something in their head, and make their instrument “do that sound”, Max can do that with cocktails. He is an artist in every sense of the word.
Argos Inn on Wednesday at 5:30-7:30 p.m. is the place to be. Come by yourself. Bring a date. Spend $12. Spend $100 (although no matter what, please tip the band). It’s for anyone and any vibe. There is a good chance that you’ll see my friend, Josh, and me (we haven’t missed a week for about 6 months). In fact, I’m so confident that you’ll like it… if you come and don’t have a good time, find me at the bar. I’ll buy you “One for My Haters. ”
Nicholas Walker on upright bass adds depth and melody to the Argos Inn jazz night. (Photo taken by Josh Felton)
TCIDA TURNS DOWN
continued from page 3
is workforce housing. And we ain’t getting it because we ain’t supporting it.”
Legislator Anne Koreman said that the IDA isn’t seeing proposals for workforce housing being put forward because the state is not providing as many incentives as they are for subsidized housing developments.
“Looking forward to the IDA, I think we might consider that luxury housing is maxed out in this community,” Koreman said.
The city passed a measure in 2018 that required housing developments to have at least 20% of units be affordable to be granted a tax abatement. Despite having no affordable housing included in the plan, Library
SHORT TERM RENTAL LAW
continued from page 4
Fifth Ward Alderperson Margaret Fabrizio stressed the urgency of addressing the state’s outdated funding model, which disproportionately benefits larger cities while leaving smaller municipalities with limited resources.
“Many upstate communities are struggling to keep up with rising costs,” Fabrizio said. “Without additional support, we risk falling
ADDRESSING HOMELESSNESS
continued from page 6
housed, and the longer that they are in that situation, the worse their outcomes can be,” he said.
Dan Pesciotta, an attorney with Legal Assistance of Western New York (LawNY), focused on the legal dimensions of homelessness. Pesciotta highlighted new state legislation designed to protect tenants from income discrimination and improve housing conditions. He also explained how LawNY provides legal assistance to tenants facing eviction and refers cases of housing discrimination to CNY Fair Housing.
“Most of our clients come to us in crisis, facing eviction,” Pesciotta said. “We do what we can to help them keep a roof over their head.” He stressed that the theoretical right to housing must be paired with systems of support to address individual needs.
Panelists also addressed common misconceptions about homelessness. Harrington countered the belief that people move to Tompkins County to take advantage of its services. “Our data demonstrates that these are community members who have fallen through cracks and are a
Place’s abatement was approved because the city received the CIITAP application prior to Ithaca’s Common Council vote.
At the TCIDA meeting, IDA and Common Council Member Ducson Nguyen introduced an amendment that would grant Hyde’s request to drop the age restriction, but require him to transition 20% of the units into affordable housing or to contribute to the Community Housing Development Fund. Travis said that this requirement would likely lead to him defaulting on his debt service payments.
Both Nguyen’s amendment and the original proposal to drop the age restriction failed to pass. Legislator Koreman encouraged Travis to return in six months and see if the board would reconsider their decision.
behind on critical projects that directly impact the quality of life for our residents.”
The resolution is part of a broader effort by NYCOM to unite municipalities across New York in advocating for fair and sustainable funding. Cantelmi said that NYCOM has prioritized financial advocacy in its legislative agenda, including support for impact aid to municipalities hosting state institutions.
“This is about more than just securing additional funding,” Cantelmo said. “It’s about ensuring that municipalities like Ithaca have the resources they need to thrive.”
part of our community,” she said.
Responding to concerns that residents of supportive housing might engage in lawless behavior, Harrington explained that tenants are required to sign leases with clear rules and consequences. “Our staff work with clients to address root causes of any behavior issues, to help clients move forward,” she said. Throughout the discussion, panelists emphasized the need for systemic changes, additional resources, and stronger collaboration among organizations. Harrington highlighted the role of community systems in addressing housing instability, while Alvord called for continued advocacy at the state level.
Klepack pointed to the Cherry Street development as a promising model for integrating housing with comprehensive services. Meanwhile, Bargar called for a broader recognition of housing as a fundamental human right. “The fact that housing is not a human right is actually contributing to the scarcity of housing that is accessible to the people who need it,” she said.
For more information on emergency shelters during the winter months, visit Code Blue. To learn more about the Tompkins County Office of Human Rights, visit OHR Website.
2024
A Year of Columns on Championships, Closings and Medals
By Steve Lawrence
One of 2024’s earliest columns announced that the Cornell men’s and women’s ice hockey teams would both hang banners for the Ivy League championship. Those rafters are getting crowded with such banners.
Huge news followed when the Big Red’s Izzy Daniel was announced as the winner the the Patty Kazmaier Award, which could be accurately compared to — in terms of significance in that sport — college football’s Heisman Trophy.
The Cornell men’s basketball team had a strong season, and, as is often the case, a strong season opens the door for a coach to move on. When Brian Earl stepped out of that open door, there was one obvious choice as his replacement: Jon Jacques. Jacques was a key player on the iconic teams that won three Ivy titles from 20082010 (making the Sweet Sixteen in ’10), he paid his dues as a dedicated assistant for several years, and Cornell apparently saw the value in keeping him there, as he was named as Earl’s replacement soon thereafter.
Ithaca College diver Kailee Payne — a graduate of Ithaca High — won the 1-meter and 3-meter competitions at the
NCAA Division III championships. She is back for another year.
As the spring semester drew to a close, many students, staff and faculty at Wells College were stunned to hear that the college would shutter its doors at the end of the semester. Baseball coach Ryan Stevens — with deep Ithaca roots — was building a fine team, playing in a beautiful new facility, then came the proverbial curve ball. (Stevens ended up taking several players with him to SUNY Canton to build that program.)
I want to thank Carson Albanese for making my pledge to exercise more seem a bit more attainable. In the summer, Albanese completed a 200-mile trail run. (Yes... two-hundred miles.)
Wrestler Kyle Dake- who won four national championships in four weight classes while at Cornell from 2010-2013 — passed up an opportunity to throw his hat in the ring for some high-profile NCAA coaching opportunities to keep grinding it on the international stage, making another U.S. Olympic team at age 33. Dake won his second bronze medal in Paris (having also done so in Tokyo in 2021.)
The Cornell Athletic Hall of Fame inducted Terry Cullen (Sprint Football) and Bernie DePalma (Head Athletic Trainer), recognizing their combined century of service.
In August, C.U. Athletics mourned the passing of former Physical Education Director Al Gantert, who died riding his motorcycle across the U.S.A. (for about the 40th time). Al had just turned 80.
The Lynah Faithful are also the Lynah Grateful as Mike Schafer (who arrived at Cornell in 1983 as a player) enters his 30th and final season as the Big Red’s hockey coach. While Cornell football is, unfortunately, a rather low-profile sport, what with no conference tournament or bowl game opportunities, the program just said goodbye to a truly remarkable player. Jameson Wang was one of three finalists for the Asa S. Bushnell Cup, which recognizes the Ivy League’s top Offensive player. Wang (who was also in the running for the Walter Payton Award) had a prolific career, and in 2024, he lead all the the FCS in points re-
Kyle Drake — who won four national championships in four weight classes while at Cornell from 2010-2013 — won his second bronze medal in Paris (having also done so in Tokyo in 2021.
sponsible for (18.8 points per game.) Wang has 2,533 passing yards, 500 rushing yards and put up 31 touchdowns (24 passing and 7 rushing). His will be big cleats to fill.
So... another year has gone by, and I still
Ithaca College diver Kailee Payne — a graduate of Ithaca High School — won the 1-meter and 3-meter competitions at the NCAA Division III champtionships. She is back for another year.
love it when people stop me on the street, or send me an email and say. Have I got a story for you!” Keep ’em coming, my friends! Have a great holiday season. I know this first-time Grandpa definitely will!
Cornell women’s hockey’s Izzy Daniel was announced as the winner of the Patty Kazmaier Award, which could be accurately compared to — in terms of significnance in that sport — college football’s Heisman Trophy.
Wrestler