+ /8 C )0 C )# @ @ @? GK+ .#
? GK
,+Q .r G jM Mb rn 1 q I #S& d# 71$!c G f .P&) G IL# .f# I Q .8 jhL H .9t v J n 1 ] E G .c G b Jr G K f .P ) G dA .P8 Jr f.u G ? GK . :dA .P9 k e ? Gh 3t G u Gh L r Gh Q S G iL f .t q , H G > / dm G&O d T c G s \8 / f .P ) G 7c 2[ fE = Dh q k D 0 G JL ^h ,A .Yl Jm GQ q V8h GQ U jqLS2 G Lul G J h q b LV9r H G ? G b f .P ) G T 9l8 f C J 1 L [ .O $ Gh ,e ? G b h C v l G b n q Oo q b =E1 rk GQ 1 ,L ul9 G J GhO $ .1 h C IOLq ? G c .1 72q GL G b J 9c b h Jm .b ? f .P ) G mS9t .k ) q 1Lc G H uP 9 G( H /L\O) .t A . P 7k \ LG OQh ,IJ Jb 7 q P R k g GL . 7 q . 7kLc b A .Yl G b dD .P9 G LV9r h :d U $ G 7 #P ML\ dOq 8 1 ,7 k .V G 7 q l V G . G A . O .c G GK 8C C ,e ? Gh 3t G u G gK :8 C C J .lP l G h C f . O $ G J .1 .>E JA .>h ? k T c jK G qOL G LR .2 LSb dO .9 G fLr G L_9 f C f .P ) G b f .th q fLr G GK . 9 GhQ . CJ1 v K r L [ s S1 q c G GLk <t ]28L8 7 GhL G Jc8 , LSc Gh jO .E G fLr G k Q . q $ G .Uk VGh ,7 q u l G J /! .1 ]28L8 1 ,U .HR $ .1 0
0
@-
1
+
$
%
)
#
-
1
.
.
%
(
/!
0
%
.
%!
.$
#
&
#
.
+
@
# /!
#
%
!
/
)#
1
)0
.
)#
.
0
0
"
1
+ )#
1
%!
2
&
@- 0
)0
$
$
)0
)#
1 &
/!
2$ !
2
"
5
1!
+
-1
!
1
0 %
.
&
.+
0
1 1
(
( 0
%
0
1
!
)#
0
.
$
%
1
(0
@
"
)
1
$
/! .
!
@ 1
-
@ 2
1+ #
1
1
2$! $
$
1
1
)1
&
0
.
2$
@
2
$
&
&
%!
$
$
.
)
!
@
1
!
0 0 )1
&
.
1
,
(
(#
#
$
.
%0
0
u J1 2q 7 .;
f.
G A
"
1&
U 8 . LG
6
.< M? . VVG v K 7 b . V c s; 7 b . c .9u K k . .9u LG k tK d> L c + . r d \ 9P JD $ .HR $ b Lt . . 9q . 9EU :2<9 R . k 7 7r L\1 . fU . eL b .Y F EU > 1 U .V9G / . > Q . 1 .9uk . H b v l b b Luk J :P K c . ? K 2E k .c .k cO . c Zc1 2r9P < Lr Zc1 2r9P u Jq J Lt b . 8 K q
"
.
#
Lc
B
2&
V
G
A
G
q
q
(
@ 1
(
G
@-1 E %!
q
q
.#
,
H
1$ !
G
KG
-
6
,1
"# C
n
U
)# @@@@%! A $!
G
)#
H
$ G
G
)
G
+
G
o
p
OQh
$ G / E O. 0 f C
G
n
2
q
#h
P
@ ,
Oh
,
Q
q
m
0
g (
q
,)11 ,
G
"
!
G
)# d
,
)
I
# " # AG
G q
+
G
q
k
G / E
$ G
fE
G
1
0h
q
1
k
(& C )# %
%!
#
)#
q
1F GhQ
/!
#
I Q.
q
.# .+ "
fC
J # .! m
2
B
Gh
A2
G
q
G.
G /!
.#
1
(
0h , % , Q "
@%+
1
@d 1
%,0
q
0C
,
1
)0
# b
B
# f.
P /!
0
G )#
G
G.
/ E q
?jQ
(1 C ) 0
.0 0
G
.1P( .+ .[ .k .S9t
f
J .t .+J2t
:# GO e.
M
d &h
Q.&
,
.
/!
Jr
9Y2q JRh s 0 L\
G
.
.
M
dkQ
d (0
.$ .[ .
c (+
K
j f
Q
Q
L?D
I
b
.P$
A
29u #
@-1
.ck
?e.
?(
1
P
)1
q .O
b
D L\ 0
j
K
G
q
)
3 @ 1 .
u
.
L S
@ 1,
M
L\ 0 J D C
)
u0
%
l[
1
9
q g 1
. Ek
G
q
. Jr8
@ ,#
O
k
k
?(
71 .EO
c (+
f.
k
G
K+
G
.b
, 1
@1823
7 (P
G %
Yq
S$0h
:g
.9 /
q
L1D Jb
g ( # m q
O
u0 / C 3?0h
.D .2V# .,1k &P
/
2
.#z
.+
)#
dG
q
k
E& .,>.9#
.
O CQ L12 h C
G
.
.ub
G / E q
G
,e.
,O G.
2
q
,gR
k
K + LO
f.! G
.>P .O
vP
E
0Yb ]S(1 01!q
JDh A .$P
G 2& $
G
.
gQ ,&
b
O$G
,
91
-&E @- 1
.Pk .>
. $ G v!l
q
:q .
,
"
q
u P0
q
M .$t .# .$8
.b .,(#
E& 01!q .,D.q h
)
J
k
. .c$
@ &
k
.
.,1!b 3?0
fC
J 11
q
. 1
O.
g
71 GLq
G
G %
q jP.
.th
k
L\b L12 h C Ql(8
y!
-
L S
@ ,
T0L(1+ v!l 71E8
A GQh
@ ,
dh 0
G
G f
q
q
G
G
/!
,-
G -1 E O
O G.
k ]f0 L$r
q
. $G
&P
G
2
.E# G 32P1h
hC
.P$
,e #
Jb Jc1h
q
)
. Oh
Lq v K
L,2# 7m cR #1 d$!8
I m
G
A
m
q
.2O
. .VD .+L?0 71Lb :lq.8
q
\G
GPE
-F
:& .t
G
q
q
f &
lV
G dG
.t
k
. P
A $
q
Jm D Gh L9#.!1t Jc1
fC
,J G. m
k
2
.VD Mu h
k
J m
m
q ,2 1
2
G
@ (+ )#
, (+
,I
,-&
-
Llr$
7 k .U
.8L0 s1$b
v!8
E
, 1
Gh
1
q
b
?(
Heinrich Olbers L 2
mqhh
: c 1 . 8h
G
2
J
e.
M
7
] Oh
G
k
, !1! G
O GOR G
s0L\
, ,# # C
71Lc
k $ % 98
.
G
G
2
IQhO b +QE )# -1 m
?(
.
G
"
h
cS&
fE
.#
J20 Jq
L 2 h C T0L(1+ k
G 2
E&
)
.+
f.u G AJ1
"
2q 71& .;
10
)b J /D .P8 -Pl& /!b q 7r .b d GM8 / J .0 GJ2 G 7 .P# f C f.kLc0h ,iLG C IL1<t Q.# #1 q q q q ,70 GJ1 ., Q1 h 71 R C IO .$ G fE d.r8 29 G 71& .&.1 G 7lP!l G )11 q q q @eJc G )# IO .$ G L,^ C u G fE d.r0 jK G jJ1D.9 G f .$0) Gh q 2k -(+P / E O .b jK G d G&P G ML[ /!b L12 h C LU C ,v P d#h q q )u$90 f C fhO )# - J / .r# IJb 2k gLtPh ,v!8 m1V G 7!1 q k )# GQ .$Y# GK+ - G&P1 F99l0 -& C cQJ0 % h @-(b 71 .>E O .?0E )# k ,A .$!c G )11 Y GLU 72!D f.u1O GQ .$Y# ;mU. G b.l0 7kLc$ G q 70 GJ1 Lq O )b V.$f G )# L1<t mSt / E -?F .9& jO&9Oh m @f.u G )1 .
U Ch f.u G
@-!
7 q . G Jm .0 GhQ f.29u0 A .1O $ G CJ1 ,fLq d1Q Jc1
Jr q
fS# A .$!c G f .t
@ 1 1
8 .vVk vVvq f.v!v1q vHv9v0 GhQ .vVvk ,7v1q v$v!vcv G J .vk .vSv9vt / G
%v
Q 2
1 C
:WVr G gK+
9G ,
.
)1
1
q
q $! )#h @2
k
9vSv+O C
%v,v
b d .1G .,& #1 .rD / .,l1(V8
. <1 .c Dh , M 7 h ,3 .?c 01 k
k #.0 )1& $
%
G d.
)#
G
B
F
G O
2
f /B Q .tOE 2q F GhL G CLqh @%,9 .l[ 2k .(0LU .c# )# fhL1<t .+ CLq q k 7kO .V# :cqh 7m $0Jq 7m !?# 2k L12 h C d G&O Edgar Allan Poe .4 q r\(# -(q u h , .13!1q H8 .1k G.> - @P(k ,-0J0 )11 2k ,JD Gh fB 2k 2 m q ) 1( @ -8 .1D d .$b C %+ C .+L29b G ,y .u0Qh Cz .,$O G IJ1Vq m q f.u G f %k ,A GO.O 7$!_$ G A .$P G :& .t GPEz q 3 6 q f.& .q -1$P& .# fE @ GJ> J1c2 G 2X .$ G 2k 70 GJ1 - h ,OJE# q q 3 q q fm.t 2k ,70 GJ2 G K(# .0QP :1r C IO .$ G f $ O.>.# 711P .? G 5 5 r n o @ys!\#h jOLkh J0Lk ,U .G AjM> )# ,7D .P$ G OhJE# m m
L$b
-
Poe, Edgar, «Eureka», ed. Tristram, 2007.
)1(
11
f .1P( G .+ G.[ J .k .S9tE
q q d.r G GK+ f #1 e.1 G v!l G A .$!b Lr0 q k q "VD .$t .# .$8 ,s\($ G /!b .$&Eh ,71F .0M1l G 72q GL$ G /!b q q @H .9u G GK+ 2k .+ GL(O 29 G 7rD 0 G 71u!l G J .k .S9t / G "u J$9c0
q
%
-&E
q
@j.2&
q 71cX. G 7lP!l G Q .S9& G 32P2k q q q h C S G.E G :E8 dr0 .$1 /E )#&& / .&LU ,Q .29G / .1 /E )#&8 q q 2k 71u!l G J .k .S9t / G "t JQ .O )1D 2k @gQ .29G G )u$0 o n o q q J .v1vX .v0Lv .v1 h C sv\v(v$v .v1 mvSv9vuv8 7vrv1vrvEv G :Qvt .vcv$v G g .v?v8 / G k q q q f.(+L20 v!l G A .0M1k A .$!bh @ .+Jt&9k A .0M1l G 28 #8 %; , /h C q q 2F GhL G - .q .# f C /!b ,7(O )1P$Gh 7F .# )# L<t C Jc1 ,f! G /
29
G ,«Positive
philosophy»
3 @ .1$!b
2k
q J .1X .0Q
%
.b L,R C
Bernhard Riemann
)#
F1EU
k k GL12t .$bO
.+
.1
.1
f /B Q .tOE
f /B ILuk : .&h
-&E @LSb dO .9 G fLr G q )f(18.e 7c# .> 2k iL2u G 7b .r G :_9t G ,1854 7(P G 2lk q q q 70J1!r9 G 70L,S G ILX .E$ G .,&E @J .c# .? G IK8 .O Ch )1<D .2 .1 q q :v& .vt @H 0v\v Gh IKv8 .vO $ Gh )v1v<vD .v2v!v 7vcv# .v?v G .v,v$v_v(v8 2v9v G o k H .c19O / 71k .t 2+h ,LfU C 7m b .q 2k IO .b /r!8 J GLX .E$ G q q q IL$ G gK+ 2k LX .E$ G )u h @J GLX .E$ G Y .$P1 )1$9,$ G q q q a 2F .(<9O G WHR m .S9t G / E "U.8 -& C )b J .cF .R JLO Jqh , 8 k q q k q @%,cq.8 2k )121V# G.& .th , .l1<t GQ.YD f.$_($ G dq.9k ,e .+ n o q 7V($ 2q 2& .? G H .2 G F9p k ,7b .r G O.P0 @1?Y G f .t .$(11h
@
f .$0Q OQ .,&L1
q
3
.1r\(#
7# .r G "0.[ ,gL$b )# )0LSc Gh 7(# .< G 2k ">Q L,^h ,A .r ) G q 8 q k -&E @-1 f.1c G :r!c8h ,I #?k 7b .r G :$V G O .Pk @Jr G s1RQh 3 @ .1VHR
q .,1!b dXhh ,7V($ G
q L1,S G f .$0Q OQ .,&L1 J .1X .0L G
/!b
29
G 7 h .\ G
/
q E f .$0Q eJr8h
%
.b
u J1 2q 7 .;
f.
"
G A
1&
12
V1 LS J1 L R .2[ 7c\q KG 7 J ? 92 rD l 2P b . 8 / .c 39u J rc9 J JS 9 L_ k $ L Jr .t .q . ., R YE JD u .t k Tc K u b 7< JD 7 L_ I .9 uR k V .u 7 1 .? 791 .; . E E LG c 1 7Y 2 < .c1 7; 0; Wq . d\q ? J> H X @ u dkL k 7 ,O . .q LX .E 7 . Jc1 . L JD .b c 7 ,O $ . e #P J JD J> .Y .e .t . l J> .EX .t = JE J 3 .[ dk : V ._E Jc1 ., R JD l #O K L\ q m V J> . HX .? u .t :1 . ; @ ) .q ; Luk . : U u M d L f9 L\r mV #1 2r .u ? u uR k vuS / L f9 K J J> 7 L_ K1 K 1 ?1 r . J 7 L_ L Sc L r [ . c . 9 ]E u9O u J8 :q k . 7 L_ 4 / E8 L 2 .P8 L[ Jr . P . [ v K =E2 7c1 .9 1 JD J c9 k J> Lt .1 . . 9 L> . L c ; .E1 . c d1 .8 )0RQ
J. m
m
%, 0 %
2
@IQ.
/ h
0
M
q
h
G /!
1
,
,
I $! h
#
O
0 f
,e
q , 0
Ch
0h , 1
q
q
G
C
k
q
@-
$#
1
GPE :-1
G f
"
q g Q.
2
1 & j
&
((
fC
G f. q
$0
, 1
/( $
B
@)
1
" #( O
G
0E h
&
)
C
& ,
0Q
G
(#
j.
0
J 1( m
-
C
q
0
&
)#
G
0
m
,
q G - 0
Q.
G )
- 1
G
0
G I
k
f.
!
q
2
(
!1!+E
3
@G
0 %!
q
? !
q
3
% h
C
2( 0
IO
k
#
G
0
!1!+E f.
$ G
,I
G
0 ,&
k
r n
#E :)0 # C
fC
g
)# "+ :f $0Q d
C
%
Q
f
,
hC
$
G
!
H 1
G
3
k
, #., #h
@d
h
k
G
)# J
Gh
g
0
C
0
f
k
@-(#
h
m
1
1
G
%, 0
C
:d
3
+
G
k
& "+ , G
k
$
!1!+E f.
G
f
GPE
q
)
h
@)#
#
G
q
,I q
0
q
0
&
m
0
&
G
q
q
%
h f $ 0Q
$
h
$0
-
q
q
1
0
&
G
"
f
&
q
@2
-
!1!+
?
:d
h
!1!+E f.
G "
((
fC
q
fC 2
q
0
1
G
+
G
q
n IQ
G
+
- G.
/
-& C
C
f $ 0Q
cQ
0
%
#
f.
q
2+ h
,)0
G
f
G
d G.
A $!
G
e $ +G
q
@f.
m
h 2
,f 1
f $ 0Q
( G
q
0
+ G. k
@ # $ +G i
G O
$
o
&h . @
f
B "1! G
h
$
1 h C dD C
q
,
# G h 1 0 f C f h O )# % ,
M
0 %!
p
3
@G
C A $!
G
h
J .0.9E$ G SL,k + /8 C )0 C )# @@@? GK+ .#
? GK
5
............................................
9
......................................................
1 P(
f.
.+ G.[ J .k .S9tE
G
q 13
........................................................................
19
....................................
# J 0 Lk
f.
)0 .9S(0 C
-
#J0Lk
JX I GQ .2$ G LPH0
f.
....................................
27
....................................................
33
........................................
L91#.
$
ILX .E
.u
G
.......................................
45
................................................
)#
...........................................
55
..........................................
n dh $ G
0
d .f1h
71
.\1
59
..........................................
65
...................................
71
.....................................................
77
.................................................
q
G gQ
l
q
f.
uG
)u$0
fC
- >h
iL
........
91
.......
97
..............................................................
/
E f .c>L
0
G
& .1
g11z vv G
.l [
H .c C q
G
)11
.$ O
J
2q ; .E9P$
Y G LU
LQ
.>
G Y .cS G
PLANCK WMAP )# h
q
133
.u
f
q
71&.u G 71&hLu1$ G 7r1!H G Y .cRE h C
85
0
#
/ .# :"E G
$0) Gh %!c
q
s!H G 70 GJ1
71
e .E
)0 .9S(0 C
yg q
J .k .S9t Gh
.V90
k
-rF .qO 2k
-bL9G G %O G
gD GJb C q
"r c
Q$H G
3 .\ G
q
q
49
)0 .9S(0 C
LLG jK G
71X .0Q MhL1 LPH0 o
G
.&.1 C :LlV G 7b .O
G O .c1 C f .lS9u
f
39
.u
f
:IL1 .2? G Y GLU
q
23
o
$ 90
OJ
M G 7 B
71&.u G :1 G.< G Mf
. 9E$
J 0.
G S
L ,k
107 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
134
n ?gQ G
o
LO C gJ1b .?8
113 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A GO.
P
2
lH8
q G IO $ Gh
.
k I 1R
",
7$!_$
7q .\
G
g& .1 g11z v
G "
119 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . y
Jl
1 $ G
G
M
G
Mf
2q 71& .;
7 8 .H d> L Zc1
127 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 131 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I
)#
G
$
$ G
G