Reclaim Central
Wealth gap in society is reflected in urban built form...
Thesis Book (DESIGN) LAU Pui Yin Jim June, 2015 // Design Methodology and Practice // Professor Nelson CHEN
CONTENTS
SECTION 1. MASTER PLAN DEVELOPMENT STUDY 1.1 MASTER PLANNING
1.2 WATER FRONT CASE STUDY
1.3 MASTER PLAN DEVELOPMENT 1.4 MASTER PLAN MASSING STUDY
01 02 06 08 10 12 14 18 22 28
Point of Interest Master Plan Illustrations District Plan Analysis Toronto Central Waterfront Seattle Central Waterfront Marina Bay Waterfront Hong Kong Central Waterfront Master Plan Development Sketches Massing Models Digital Modeling
SECTION 2. DESIGN DRAWINGS
2.1 MASTER PLANNING 2.2 BUILDING DRAWINGS
2.3 EXTERIOR PERSPECTIVES 2.4 INTERIOR PERSPECTIVES
34 36 38 39 40 42 46
Master Plan Concourse Plan Exploded Isometric Court House Plan Sectional Perspectives Exterior Perspectives Interior Perspectives
SECTION 3. DESIGN MODELS
3.1 1:1500 CONTEXT MODEL 3.2 1:300 SECTIONAL MODEL
52 54
Context Model Photos Sectional Model Photos
SECTION 4. FINAL PANEL
4.1 FINAL PANEL
64
Final Panel
1
MASTER PLAN STUDY
1.1 MASTER PLANNING 1.2 WATER FRONT CASE STUDY 1.3 MASTER PLAN DEVELOPMENT 1.4 MASTER PLAN MASSING STUDY
1. Master Plan Development Study
1.1 Master Planning
Point of interest Point of interest plan illustration plan illustration
Picking up from the research stage of this thesis project, I realized this social issue of the Hong Kong Hegemony is not going to be addressed or answered by a single building. It must be tackled from an Urban Scale to have that significant impact to the society. Therefore, before designing the architecture, it is critical that Master Planing of Central is to be studied and developed, in order to integrate well with my design. Civic Concourse will be developed at the site of Statue Square and Star Ferry Car Park. With my research support, the concept of this project is to integrate more truly accessible public buildings and public spaces within the context of monopolistic urban developments. Currently with the nearly reclaimed land at the central water front, it is the largest public spaces in this area waiting to be integrated into part of Central. Within the 400 meters radius of the water front, it reaches much of the important landmarks but missing the connection. The connection between the city and the water front becomes the driving goal of this thesis, creating that new urban experience and highlighting the historic moments of this city.
50m
50m
civic concourse
civic concourse
1
central waterfrontcentral waterfront 50m
50m
100m
100m
200m
200m
government complex government complex
400m
400m
paths
paths
nodes
nodes
landmarks
landm
1.1 Master Plan
Master Plan Illustration Before any planning of the area, Master Plan illustrations of the Civic Concourse been stated out in written form, demonstrating the possibilities this project can achieve in this urban context. With the name of Civic Concourse, suggesting the building to be publicly accessible which provides a new urban experience, connecting the city and water front. Having the judicial system at this very prominent area, it will require it to being iconic and creating new landmark to the area. The application of judicial system with educational program will draw public to this civic center, creating contemporary Agora for exchange of ideas, becoming the center of athletic, artistic, spiritual and political life of the city. On the other hand, with the strong historic events and linear axis, it could easily become the path of the city (public connector). Stitching this monopolistic society back together with a sense of equality through the demonstration of publicness.
2
HSBC
TRAM LINE
PUBLIC ROUTE
OPEN LANDSCAPE LIGHT STRUCTURE
SQUARE
URBAN GARDEN
STATUE
VIEW CORRIDOR COURT OF FINAL APPEAL
TRANSFORMATION
CENOTAPH
HISTORIC LANDMARK
HOLY LAND
1 0 , 0 0 0 M E T E RS S Q UA R E FORMER STAR FERRY CAR PARK PUBLIC CONNECTOR, PLAZAS JUDICIAL SYSTEM
NEW URBAN EXPERIENCE L A ND M A R K, H A R B O U R V I E W
MEMORIAL
GARDEN
PERMEABILITY
SITE, CIVIC CONCOURSE
D
CONNAUGHT P L A Z A CONNECTIVITY
TOURIST ATTRACTION
CENTRAL AXIS
DEMONSTRATION CAR FREE
MASTERPLAN
T R A N S P O R TAT I O N
R EC R EAT I O N S Q UA R ES
MARKET
FESTIVAL CELEBRATION PEDESTRIAN ZONE
SEASONAL EVENTS
TA M A R PA R K GOVERNMENT HEADQUARTER POLITICAL GATHERING
CONNECT
URBA THEMN SPACE ATIC PARK
LUNG WO R OA
E DINB URGH PLAZA
MUSEUM
PUBLIC AMENITIES
LIBRARY
CITY HALL
CONNAUGHT ROAD
BRIDGE OVER
R EST, A R EA CONNECTIVITY COMMERCIAL
PEDESTRIANISED CHATER ROAD
MTR STATION
CHATER GARDEN
WEEKEND GATHER
DOMESTIC WORKERS
DES VOEUX ROAD
HEADQUARTER COVERED AREA
P T E S
DES
LAZAS R E E S X T R A P A C E
EDGE
WATETIRNATION FRONT EDGE
Written Master Plan
CENTRAL PIER
ED
JETTED OUT
GE
3
Function civic center
[connaught plaza]
C
A
4
civic center
[holy land]
[hsbc]
[chater garden]
pier
waterfront
city
[memorial garden] [edinburgh plaza]
B
commerce
Function
public connector
[chater road]
[connaught plaza] [lung wo road]
urban garden public functions
public connector
B
commerce
A [statue square]
[hsbc]
C
thematic park
[chater garden]
commerce
[holy land]
[cannaught road]
[memorial garden] [edinburgh plaza]
[waterfront masterplan]
[central pier]
5
1.1 Master Plan
District Plan Analysis Over the years, under the rapid development of Hong Kong, Central has become the core center of Hong Kong. With the profit driven developments, financial district grows in different places between city fabric. Separating the city into smaller districts, creating a scrambled situation. For that reason, the placement of the Civic Concourse in between different districts will serve an important role to this city, stitching the city fabric back together. Become the center for the public but also a connector between districts, echoing the existing Government Headquarter. As well as creating a new landmark and nodes to the area, its important to connect the existing landmarks. Linking the nodes in a sequence to create a new urban experience.
6
-T ST
ong nT wu Hom K g ltra Hun Cen tral Cen
tra l
Planning Area
Ce n
New Waterfront Edge New Destination Existing Destination Landmarks View Points
VICTORIA HARBOUR
Connections Star Ferry Terminal
PIER DISTRICT
Market Hall Festival Pier IFC
FINANCIAL DISTRICT
WATERFRONT DISTRICT (OPEN PARK)
Market SquareWATERFRONT DISTRICT
(ENTERTAINMENT)
Sculpture Park
Hong Kong Flyer
CIVIC CONCOURSE
Edinburgh Place
CULTURAL DISTRICT
GOVERNMENT DISTRICT Government OямГce
The Cenotaph Statue Square
LegCo Chater Garden HSBC
HISTORIC DISTRICT
FINANCIAL DISTRICT Bank of China
FINANCIAL DISTRICT
7
1. Master Plan development study
1.2 Water Front Case Study Case 1 Toronto Waterfront - Publicly accessible Project: Toronto Central Waterfront Location: Toronto, Canada Construction Date: 2006 Architect: West 8
8
The Central Waterfront extends along 3.5 km along Lake Ontario and in direct proximity to the downtown business district. It is one of Toronto’s most valuable assets, yet, despite decades of planning and patchwork development projects, there was no coherent vision for linking the pieces into a greater whole – visually or physically. In this context, the fundamental objective of the project, was to address this deficiency by creating a consistent and legible image for the Central Waterfront, in both architectural and functional terms. Connectivity between the vitality of the city and the lake and a continuous, publicly accessible waterfront are West 8’s Master plan priorities. The plan expresses a vision for the Central Waterfront that brings a sustainable, ecologically productive ‘green foot’ to the rich culture of the metropolis. It suggests a new coherence and continuity along the waterfront, produced by four seemingly simple gestures that create a new ‘Multiple Waterfront’.
Waterfront Festival
Master plan by West 8
Floating deck
HTO landscape park
Timber wavedecks
CHINA TOWN
City Hall
FINANCIAL DISTRICT
FASHION DISTRICT
CITYPLACE
Toronto city-waterfront connection
Transportation Hub
Stadium CN Tower
Urban Park
HARBOUR FRONT
Museum
Urban Park
9
Garden
Park
Park
Beach
Water Sports Theatre/ Museum Centre Art Gallery
Ferry Terminal
Sugar Museum
Sugar Beach
paths paths
Inner Harbour
districts nodes landmarks
Ferry Terminal
Yacht Club
Museum
Train Station
Water Sports
Beach
Festival Events
Factory
Case 2 Seattle Waterfront - Waterfront for All Project: Seattle Central Waterfront Location: Seattle, United States Construction Date: 2013 Architect: James Corner Field Operations
10
Field Operations has been leading the design of a comprehensive framework plan and dynamic urban design for 1.5 miles of Seattle’s Central Waterfront. With the removal of the Alaskan Way Viaduct and the reconstruction of the Elliot Bay Seawall, the City of Seattle is poised to reclaim its Central Waterfront and reconnect to Elliott Bay. The Framework plan works at multiple scales to re-center the city and shape a new public realm. A robust Urban Framework utilizes character zones, nodes and linkages to acknowledge difference in adjacent neighborhoods and capitalize on unique waterfront conditions. The waterfront was organized by zones of programmatic focus. A number of urban design strategies were used to organize and accommodate all waterfront activities and uses, solidify the vision and anchor the design into the urban fabric and make one coherent place with its own distinct identity.
overlook walk
Master plan by James Corner Field Operations
open plaza with water features
Floating pool barge
open plaza with water features
Seattle city-waterfront connection
Elliot Bay PIONEER SQUARE Festival Pier
WATERFRONT Beach
Skating Rink Barge Pool Ferry Terminal Seattle Wheel Aquarium Historic Piers Plaza Gallery
Cruise Terminal
Belltown Redevelopment 11
Overlook Walk Park
Stadium Occidental Park
MARKET DISTRICT
Pioneer Square
Market
Harbour Steps
paths
Museum
King St. Station
paths
Benaroya Hall
districts
FINANCIAL DISTRICT
nodes landmarks
Ferry Terminal
Yacht Club
Museum
Train Station
Aquarium
Market
Beach
Festival Events
Swimming
Ferris Wheel
Case 3 Singapore Waterfront - Garden City Project: Marina Bay Waterfront Location: Marina Bay,Singapore Construction Date: 2006 Architect: Grant Associates / Gustafson Porter
12
The Gardens aim to capture the essence of Singapore as the premier tropical Garden City with the perfect environment in which to live, work and play. It will complement and complete the necklace of attractions that have been planned for around the Marina Bay. At 101 hectares, Gardens by the Bay comprises three distinctive waterfront gardens. Bay East by Gustafson Porter is a 32ha linear garden that embroiders a stretch of the Marina Channel promenade, providing landscaped access to a strategic portion of Singapore’s waterfront. Providing visitors an intimate relationship with its shorelines and wonder views back to the skyline. South Bay by Grant Associates aims to blend nature, technology, environmental management and imagination to create a 21st century focus for tropical horticulture and a unique destination experience. Marina Bay Master plan
South Bay
Conservatories
Promenade facing Inner Harbour
Overlook South Bay
Singapore city-waterfront connection
Exhibition Centre Memorial
CULTURE DISTRICT WATERFRONT
GOVERNMENT DISTRICT
Formula One Pit
City Hall
Court House
WATERFRONT Theatres
Museum
Themes Garden
Museum
Parliament
Theatres
Concert Hall Museum
Performance Stage
Fullerton Hotel
Marina Channel
Museum
Merlion
Golf Course
Singapore Wheels
Water Sports
Marina Bay
13
FINANCIAL DISTRICT
Conservatories
One Raes Place
Entertainment complex
Integrated Resort
Pier Performance Stage
WATERFRONT paths paths
Garden Market
districts nodes landmarks
Museum
Concert Hall
Garden
Water Sports
Conservatories
Casino
Formula One
Ferris Wheel
Case 4 Hong Kong waterfront - Distinctive Identity Project: Hong Kong Central Location: Central,Hong Kong Construction Date: 2007 Architect: Aedas
14
A study on the Central Waterfront was completed by Aedas for few specific objectivities which are to project a distinctive identity for the Central Business District and the new harbourfront as well as create an attractive harbourfront with high quality public and private developments and open space in a luxuriant landscape setting. Introduce a mix of uses and diverse activities for public enjoyment to create a vibrant harbourfront. The existing pedestrian network in Central should be extended to the New harbourfront to enhance pedestrian links to the waterfront and to create a more sustainable and environmentally friendly harbourfront. A combination of at-grade walkways and crossings, subways, elevated walkways and landscaped decks is proposed in the Study. Central Waterfront master plan
Master plan by Aedas
Central Pier
Statue Square Corridor
Tamar Civic Corridor
Hong Kong city-waterfront connection
Central Pier Maritime Museum
VICTORIA HARBOUR IFC
Viewing Platform Bike Station
FINANCIAL DISTRICT
HKCEC
HARBOUR FRONT Waterfront Commerical Uses Clock Tower/ Gallery
Waterfront Commerical Uses
Boardwalk
Edinburgh Place City Hall
Hotel
GOVERNMENT DISTRICT
The Cenotaph
paths
Art Events Plaza
paths
Statue Square Court of Final Appeal
Government Complex
districts HKAPA
HSBC
HISTORIC DISTRICT
Art Centre
nodes landmarks
Bank of China
Ferry Pier
City Hall
Museum
Government Complex
Bike Station
Viewing Platform
Clock Tower
15
1. Master Plan Development study
1.4 Analysis at 3 Scale
Victoria Harbour is the center of Hong Kong, connecting the Hong Kong Peninsula and Mainland of Kowloon. With the waterfront at Central and Tsim Sha Tsui, it act as an anchor for both part of Hong Kong. It connects the city along the promenades and spared into the inner part of the city. By looking at the site with three different scale, from a City Level to a district level; realize the importance of connecting the city with the waterfront. 16
At the Urban Scale, the Central axis lying in middle of Sheung Wan and Wan Chai. By having an urban linkage between the two, it would revitalize the city with a more fluid connection as a whole at the Hong Kong Peninsula. By activating the central water front, a connection between itself and the city must be well connected in order to generate an effective circulation system. Therefore the central axis becomes the key to city connection.
KOWLOON
VICTORIA HARBOUR
HONG KONG ISLAND
1 km
City Scale
VICTORIA HARBOUR KOWLOON
17
VICTORIA HARBOUR
HONG KONG ISLAND
HONG KONG ISLAND
1 km
1 km
Urban Scale
Water Front Scale
1. Master Plan development study
1.3 Master Plan Development
From the context studies, there is a strong liner axis expressed from the Hong Kong Bank towards the Victor Harbour, due to the aerial ownership and historic events. However, the recent developments and land reclamations have disrupted this expression. That caused a segregation between the city and the water front.
18
Also, with recent development at Tamer Park Government Complex, it had the similar idea and approach to connect the city with the water front, allow the promenade to be more accessible for the public. However, it is not too successful with it’s expression of the architecture, and the final built form. It’s orientation of the building faces the Victoria Harbour where can only be perceive from the Kowloon side. With a single foot bridge system provided for the pedestrian to connect from the back of the building to the water front. Yet, that is the best and the only connection to the water front from the city. Therefore, this strong axis of connection became the focus of the Master Layout Plan. Directly connect the heart of Central with the Central Water Front with the liner axis, but also the surrounding public areas.
MLP Concept Sketch
Master Plan Development Sketches
19
Development Sketch 1
Development Sketch2
Development Sketch 3
Development Sketch 4
1. Master Plan development study
Civic Concourse Sketches
20
21
Central Axis Sketches
1. Master Plan development study
1.3 Master Plan Development With a physical form of model, connection and massing of the MLP have been tested to see the relationship within the context continued from the initial sketches. A form of demonstrating the projects’ intention of connecting the surrounding urban spaces, city and the water front. Crafting techniques were used as a methodology to shape the form and overall mass to the building on the central axis. In this vertical city, a strong contrast is being established with the opposite approach. Spanning over 400 meters horizontally to connect the city with the water front. Therefore the overall height of the building kept as low as possible with pragmatic consideration along with the landscaper expression. 22
Bold massing is to be avoided, therefore building blocks have been crafted with stepping and modulations approach to break down the overall form. To create an seamless integration between the building and the urban context. Nevertheless, the connection from inland to be reached out to the waterfront. The lateral direction have not been neglected, breaking the liner form with horizontal elements jetted across the site, connecting the circulation with a multiple layer network.
MLP Connection
23
24
25
1. Master Plan development study
1.3 Master Plan Development
26
Initial Site Apporach
27
Massing Development Process
28
Massing Development Process
29
Massing Development Process
30
Finalized Massing Development
31
32
2
DESIGN DRAWINGS
2.1 MASTER PLANNING 2.2 BUILDING DRAWINGS 2.3 EXTERIOR PERSPECTIVES 2.4 INTERIOR PERSPECTIVES
2. Design Drawings
2.1 Master Planning Overall MLP has been laid out supported by the previous studies and testings. Equality can be found in this Master Plan regarding the reclaimed public realm in reposes to the thesis statement, with a vast amount of land designated to the public, a contrast of activities are demonstrated to strike a balance in this monopolistic urban situation. Establishing a real connection between the city and the water front, through a highly accessible building with civic purpose to the society. Creating important nodes along the Central Axis, stitching the segregated parts together, reclaiming Central with historic memories and contemporary additions. 34
Aedas Central Master Layout Plan, 2011
35
2. Design Drawings
2.2 Building Drawings
36
37
38
39
40
41
2. Design Drawings
2.3 Exterior Perspectives
42
Concourse Entrance
43
Central Axis City - Water Front Connection
44
Connaught Road Central
45
Central Water Front Park
2. Design Drawings
2.4 Interior Perspectives To deal with the pragmatic consideration of a court house, three different circulations are to be taken into account. First, for the staff and Judges, it is required to be separated from the public. This is to avoid any disturbance from the public. Second, the defendant are to be contained in a enclosed area under security at all time, this will happen in the basement with law enforcement up to the court rooms. Lastly, public circulation is to be considered with direct access horizontally pass through the building but also vertically to the court houses.
46
Court Rooms are designed to be separated into two floors, one designated to the authorized person who are related to the court cases, judges chambers, clerk offices and consulting rooms. The upper level is designed for the public only, with a access to the view gallery of each individual court room. Although the floors have been separated into two levels, visual connection are reminded between the two. Court Houses are promoted with a high transparency to the public, opening up to allow natural day night to enter from the East with visual commutation between the public who passes through the building at concourse level. Mega Court is to be introduced into the judiciary system to facilitate the high media attention cases. Allow large amount of public and media reporters to take part of the court cases. A viewing gallery locates at a upper level, which can facilitate 3 times more of audience than a standard court room. Civic Concourse becomes the new grade for the public, it serve as an express route of connecting from Statue Square to the Central Water Front Park. At the same time, it becomes the contemporary Agora for exchange of ideas, becoming the center of athletic, artistic, spiritual and political life of the city.
47
Civic Concourse
48
Court Room Interior
49
Mega Court Viewing Gallery
50
3
MODEL PHOTOS
3.1 1:1500 CONTEXT MODEL 3.2 1:300 SECTIONAL MODEL
3. Design Models
3.1 1:1500 Context Model
52
53
3. Design Models
3.2 1:300 Sectional Model
54
A sectional model can demonstrates the activity that happens in the central cores of the building, such as the court houses, mega court, viewing gallery and the civic concourse itself. Providing a clear spatial sequence from landscaping to built form. A device is installed to allow the model to be separated into two slices, showing the interior as well as the exterior with a complete form.
55
Sectional Model Opened
Operable System
56
City Entrance
Water Front Entrance
57
Statue Square Entrance
58
Central Water Front Entrance
59
Interlocking Blocks
60
Stepping Terrace
61
Long Section Cut
62
Landscape - Building Integration
63
4. Final Panel
4.1 Final Review Panel Urban Public Spaces Study
HONG KONG HEGEMONY - Reclaim Central
OCCUPY CENTRAL -
wealth gap in society is reflected in urban built form...
Popular Tourist Area Tsim Sha Tsui Promenade 1:10000
Public Event Space West Kowloon 1:10000
What social issues affect Hong Kong people and their urban environments?
• Hegemony is defined as authority, control or influence by one dominant group over another. • In Hong Kong, land supply is strictly controlled by Government; development is largely controlled by a handful of large developers. • Together, Government and developers dictate urban development to maximize their respective profits at the expense of people, places, neighborhoods. • The increasing gap between rich and poor is reflected in the increasing gap in urban places that are economically affordable by the majority of people.
Sports and Outdoor Concerts Hong Kong Stadium 1:10000
New Years Celebratation Times Square 1:10000
Political Demonstration Victoria Park 1:10000
CONTEXT
dark clouds - hovering over the towers suggest at society is currently in a ‘doomsday’ situation it is monopolized.
Reactivating Statue Square
Site History
Festival Marketplace The Peak 1:10000
MTR
Train MTR
44
hawk - symbolic meaning of power and vision, representing the ruling class of Hong Kong high in the sky over the poor.
60
MTR
buildings - densely built together in the monopolized urban area which neglects peoples’ need with only profit in mind. 32
80
60
40
LAU, Pui Yin Jim //Design Methodology and Practice// Thesis Advisor - Professor CHEN, Nelson
Stanely Market 1:10000
M
MTR
12 0
118
52
60 80
layman - at the very bottom of society, where people are lacking essential needs including public needs.
10 8
48 60
What architectural and urban design issues are being addressed?
6
4
66
80
10 0
116
1900 - Monument with Promenade connected to Pier
120
MTR
88 100
12 0
1910 - Carpark and the Cenotaph Addition
1950 - Monument Removed
1955 - Public Carpark
1960 - Star Ferry Carpark Added
12 0
MTR
40
80
60
60
40 40
34
coins - the ultimate substance that everyone is effected by.
100
• High land prices and high density developments cause public space to be viewed as prohibitively expensive to provide and maintain. • Public space is generally neglected and, when provided, is often residual, leftover space.
100
pigs - it means the illusions over true nature of life, representing the layman’s worthless position
60
6
118
0
74
80
public space - provided in small, residual spaces and neglected in this urban context.
60
60
10 0
80
80 12 0
80
100
Objectives of thesis project:
100
114
118
100
116
12 0
MTR
EVENT
12 minutes 1km
2 km
? West Kowloon reclaimed land currently undergoing a leisure and cultural development. The space is often used as a major outdoor music festival, art exhibition and other rare festivals. It often has runners and cyclers at the promenades when it is not used for events.
NOTES
An urban park located between Tin Hau and Causeway Bay, with much of the sports recreation facilities. Every year it holds large events such as Lunar New Year Fair and some art and culture exhibitions. It often used as a gathering point for demonstrations, with weekly City Forum held in the park.
Tsim Sha Tsui Promenade is a major tourist hub in metropolitan Hong Kong, with many shops and restaurants that cater to tourists. Many of Hong Kong’s museums are located in the area. Victoria Harbor and the iconic Hong Kong Skyline at the HK Island are the main attraction for the promenade, often has big celebration events with fireworks at festivals.
A major shopping center and office tower complex with privately owned public space (POPS) at ground level. It has become one of the two main gathering point for new year celebration. Various activities take place which become an attraction to commerces for business. However the generous set back becomes an important breathing space in the dense urban condition.
Main sports venue of Hong Kong all take place at this stadium, it somehow represents Hong Kong’s sports with a symbolic meaning. The stadium was supposed to be a multi purpose entertainment and sports venue. However, its open-air nature has led to noise complaints from residents in tower blocks surrounding the stadium.
1940
1940
1940
0.4 km²
0.4 km²
0.4 km²
?
1940
0.4 km² 0.9 km²
1965 - Converted to Urban Square
Hong Kong has many street markets or shopping complex dotted around the city, yet there are no public activates happening apart from commercial activities. The two are always separated with very minimal relation as shown in Hong Kong; especially in the densely populated urban area.
1960
1960
1960
1960
1980
1980
1980
1980
Present
Present
Present
0.9 km²
0.9 km²
0.9 km²
2 km²
2 km²
2 km²
2 km²
6 km²
6 km²
6 km²
1980 - Urban Square Connected to Pier
1990 - Underground Connection Added
History Of Open Space and Land Reclamation
1940
2000s
• To design a project that demonstrates the essential need to integrate more truly public spaces within the context of monopolistic urban developments.
2010 - Further Land Reclamation
1960
Future - Central Waterfront Masterplan
1980
PRESENT
1990s
Political Demonstration “People’s Park” - N/A 1:10000
Festival Marketplace Nanjing Road East 1:10000
Sports and Outdoor Concerts Shanghai Stadium 1:10000
New Years Celebratation The Bund 1:10000
Popular Tourist Area Xiantiandi 1:10000
2000
196
s
0s
189
0s
2010s
Public Event Space Expo Park 1:10000
0s 195
Cen
196
der
Lung
Ped
0s 2
ught Road
Statu
e Squar
Metro
e
land use
Metro
fun
special
transit usage
64
historic
accessible
current society understanding
jury spaces
prvate parking/ entrance
STAFF library
Per capita area of public open space 5,000 10,000 (km²) population density
0
MTA MTA
0.4 km²
clerk’s office
0.9 km²
2 sq.m.
PRIVATE
Tokyo
2,200 km²
Lan Kwai Fong -
Accessibility
connected
12 1k
TFL
mi
m
nu
tes
observation deck
Coroner’s Court
plazas
retails
PUBLIC Public Realm
Efficient Operations
parking
200m
government complex
street market general infomation
=10,222m²
Program consolidation
events
bridge
cafes
Public Non-Accessable
PERMEABILITY
paths
An island with open green area is another main tourist attractions which contains ten statues of statesmen and other notable individuals. It is also the place where many demonstrations and protests have been held.
The promenade shows the iconic side of London, with the surrounding landmarks. For that reason, it easily becomes the detestation for festival celebration. Events include arts, music and community festivals happens annually to promote the cultural and tourism industry. New Years Celebration with fireworks happens at the river every year which becomes the spot for the festival.
Being the association football stadium, it hosts most of the major football matches and other sport matches. A sliding roof allows it to hold many other events, particularly major concerts but also private events like weddings and conferences.
Associated with the former fruit and vegetable market in the central square, now a popular shopping and tourist site, and the Royal Opera House. Attractions driven by the central square with its street performers, theaters and entertainment facilities, including the Theatre Royal, Drury Lane, and the London Transport Museum.
EDGE
NATION WATERF RONT
FESTIVAL CELEBRATION PEDESTRIAN ZONE
PLAZAS T R E E S E X T R A S P A C E
CENTRAL PIER
DESTI
JETTED OUT
EDGE
D
URBA N SPAC THEMAT E IC PAR K
WO ROA
MARKET
75% Public Accessable
400m
SEASONAL EVENTS
T R A N S P O R TAT I O N
R EC R EAT I O N SQUARES
CENTRAL AXIS
LUNG
GARDEN
CONNECT
MEMORIAL
MASTERPLAN
NEW URBAN EXPERIENCE L ANDMARK, HARB OUR VI EW
DEMONSTRATION CAR FREE
URBAN GARDEN
SITE, CIVIC CONCOURSE
1 0 , 0 0 0 M E T E RS S Q UA R E FORMER STAR FERRY CAR PARK PUBLIC CONNECTOR, PLAZAS JUDICIAL SYSTEM
LIBRARY
HOLY LAND
HISTORIC LANDMARK
CITY HALL
STATUE
PUBLIC ROUTE
TRAM LINE
SQUARE
OPEN LANDSCAPE LIGHT STRUCTURE
5 Retails 4 Restaurants
6 Plazas
courtcourt court public network
underground passage parking Parking connection parking service
CENOTAPH
CONNAUGHT P L A Z A CONNECTIVITY
TOURIST ATTRACTION
=150m²
privateroomroomroomLibraryarchive 24-hours roof garden market auditorium conference forum mediaspace event space
public squarecity center trade
VIEW CORRIDOR COURT OF FINAL APPEAL
TRANSFORMATION
100m
Public Accessable
BRIDGE OVER
central waterfront 50m
Offices Judicial Assisant Law Enforcement
REST, AREA CONNECTIVITY COMMERCIAL
HSBC
HEADQUARTER COVERED AREA
1 Underground Car park
3 Urban Landscapes/ Roof 2 Observation Deck
Judicial Members
Urban Landscapes Plazas
transport drop off area
Judicial Assistance
Court House
observation deck slowness foodwaiting
support chambers offices work enclosed space
permeability
waterfront
legal aid public service atrium exhibition space
Public Confidence
Orignal Program
Main Components
Public Facilities
Court Complex Total:
restaurants
legal space Retails
Judicial System
Concept Montage
x3
civic concourse
=1,000m²
Public - Private
500m² 200m² 50m² 500m² 200m² 50m² 400m² 1000m²
50m
TA M A R PA R K GOVERNMENT HEADQUARTER POLITICAL GATHERING
Judicial Program
Obscence ArticlesTribunal
Library/ Archive Bar Association Conference Area Auditorium Restaurants Cafe Observation Deck Underground Car park (50)
Program reshuffle
ED IN BU RGH PLAZA
public parking/ entrance
PUBLIC auditorium
This is the well known tourist attraction in the central London. Contemporary art installation has been hosted along with other commemorative statues and sculptures. The square is also used for political demonstrations and community gatherings, such as the celebration of New Year’s Eve.
retail restaurant cultural space
MUSEUM
Small Claims Tribunal
Being the largest park in London, it has held many major events in the past including the Great Exhibition of 1851. It has become a traditional location for mass demonstrations, with the Speaker’s Corner which holds political debates form time to time. It has also been the venue for some famous rock concerts and seasonal events for entertainment purposes.
Written Master Plan
plan illustration
bridge
cafes
CONNAUGHT ROAD
Eastern Kowloon City Kwun Tong Tsuen Wan Fanling Shatin Tuen Wan
PRIVATE
ancillary spaces
Point of interest
events
DES VOEUX ROAD
PUBLIC OFFICE
hearing room
market
general infomation
=192m² =60m² =800m² =400m²
PUBLIC AMENITIES
Simplification of operations and court structures Competent Operations confront problems before court
clerk’s office
observation space
archive
underground6m² x 32 connection 6m² x 10 Waiting Area 100m² x8 Chambers 25m² x 16 Clerk’s Office 200m² Jury Assembly 100m² Court Registry Office 500m² x2 Administrative Office 1,600m² Account Office Support Staff Office Human Recourse Office Judicial Program Public Realm Receipt and Dispatch Office Hong Kong Judiciary Office 300m² Bailiff Office 200m² Legal Aid Office 200m² Mediation Information Office 100m² SemiOffice Press and Public Relations 100m² public Private Public Resourse Center for Unrepresented Litigants 100m² Press Room 100m² Information Desk 50m²
DOMESTIC WORKERS
administrative office
courtroom legal aid
18 Observation space 17 Hearing room/courtroom 16 Jury space 15 Clerk’s office 14 Administrative office 13 Chambers 12 Legal spaces 11 Law enforcement spaces 10 Probation, health and welfare spaces 9 Legal Aid 8 Library/ Archive 7 Auditorium/ Conference Room
COURT FACILITIES
JUDEGE
Lands Tribunal Labour Tribunal
Landmark - eat
Statue Square -
lunch rest historic site
HSBC -
meeting point St. John’s Cathedral -
shop
worship social
tourist spot landmark
GE
ED
nodes
retail restaurant cultural space
landmarks
Program reshuffle
Public confidence Maintain its vitality Responsive to the needs of society Offer helps to those in need Everyone treated equally Assistance takes an educational form Simplification of operations and court structures Competent Operations confront problems before court
Planning Area
Function
New Waterfront Edge
Function
public connector
New Destination
civic center
n Tong - Kwu Hom ral Hung Cent ral Cent
Existing Destination Landmarks View Points
VICTORIA HARBOUR
Connections Star Ferry Terminal
[connaught plaza] [chater road]
[connaught plaza] [lung wo road]
C
pier Market Hall
thematic park
Festival Pier
public connector
B
commerce
A
PIER DISTRICT
waterfront
city urban garden public functions
C
A
commerce
civic center
B
commerce
IFC
FINANCIAL DISTRICT
WATERFRONT DISTRICT (OPEN PARK)
Market SquareWATERFRONT DISTRICT
(ENTERTAINMENT)
Sculpture Park
Hong Kong Flyer
[statue square]
[holy land]
[holy land]
CIVIC CONCOURSE
Edinburgh Place
CULTURAL DISTRICT
GOVERNMENT DISTRICT Government Office
The Cenotaph
[hsbc]
[chater garden]
[cannaught road]
[memorial garden] [edinburgh plaza]
[waterfront masterplan]
[central pier]
[hsbc]
[chater garden]
[memorial garden] [edinburgh plaza]
1
2
City Hall -
Bank of China -
Statue Square
LegCo Chater Garden HSBC
HISTORIC DISTRICT
FINANCIAL DISTRICT Bank of China
FINANCIAL DISTRICT
Lung Wo Road
Connaught Road
Des Voeux Road Central
Creating Destinations in the City
Linked and Connection between City and Waterfront
museum tourist spot
Former Legco Building -
Chater Road
Charter Garden
Connecting Surrounding Open Public Space
transport view
landmark food
4
Statue Square HSBC Covered Plaza
WEEKEND GATHER
library
ADMIN OFFICE
Court of appeal Court of First Instance
District Court
Magistrates’ Courts
x 10
passage parking parking service
Parking
hang out
gather hang out events
3
EVENT
NOTES
parking
Offer helps to those in need Everyone treated equally Assistance takes an educational form
District Courts
t r a n s p oConsultation rt Room drop off area Witness Room
chambers
Public confidence Maintain its vitality Responsive to the needs of society
courtcourt court public network
Hearing room/courtroom 120m² x 16 =1,920m² public square street city centertrade
legal aid public service High Courts atrium exhibition space x6
prvate parking/ entrance
Lyndhurst Terrace - shop
Connaught Plaza
privateroomroomroomLibraryarchive 24-hours roof garden market auditorium conference forum mediaspace event space
legal space
Court Complex permeability
waterfront
jury spaces
STAFF
Statue Square -
TFL
Program consolidation
offices Civic Concourse SOA work enclosed space
probation, health and welfare spaces
public
law enforcement spaces
shop social
Charter Garden -
TFL
building conditions
crime statistics
World Wide House -
lunch
Urban Strategy
Train
City Hall Memorial Garden
38 sq.m. London
1700 km²
observation deck slowness foodwaiting
support chambers
38 sq.m. legal spaces
London
1700 km²
High Court
Efficient Operations
supoort public service
medical
26 sq.m.
1,200 km²
700 km²
Judicial Assistance
Court of Final Appeal New York
Singapore
office
8 sq.m.
Judicial System
Public Confidence
1,200 km²
enviromental data
parking
courthouses
detention
walkable sittable
historic
accessible
New York
sanitation rating
attractive
convenient
pedestrain activity
PUBLIC Public Realm
meeting point lunch
Edinburgh Plaza
urban landscape
safe
MTR STATION
restaurants
PUBLIC FACILITIES
retails
retail sales
real
IFC -
eat shop hang out
Train
TFL
km
CHATER GARDEN
transit usage
plazas
TFL
TFL
social hang out
Peter Tourist Central Waterfront -
meet friends
Central Waterfornt
26 sq.m.
property values
special
Environment and Facilities
public
vital
Public Space
700 km²
walkable
observation welfare deck
Access For All - Hong Kong Judicial Complex
residential
fun
Public Utilization
Sociability
Singapore
TFL Train
0.5
6,300 km²
PEDESTRIANISED CHATER ROAD
volunteerism
Accessibility
active
8 sq.m.
stewardship
coperaative
neighborly welcoming
proximity
supoort public service
evening use
volunteerism
Judicial Program
probation
court
law enforcement
land use diverse
8 sq.m.
public parking/ entrance
6,300 km²
Roxanna Domestic Worker Central Waterfront -
chat hang out
Statue Square -
Public - Private
urban landscape
2,200 km²
office
Public Utilization
Environment & Facilities Shanghai
Tokyo
1,100 km²
courthouses
5 sq.m.
PUBLIC
Hong Kong
TFL
8 sq.m. Shanghai
Public
local business ownership
number of women, children and elderly
Sociability street life
2 sq.m.
governmental
auditorium commercial
work eat shop social
Statue Square -
TFL
TFL
legal
IFC -
Festival Marketplace Covent Garden 1:10000
Train
Main Components Private
ancillary spaces
It has a strong historic background, the original fish market has became a commercial area. With modern tourist malls featuring restaurants, shopping and nightlife, it attracts many tourists. Revitalization strategy of modern shopping areas has turned the museum int0 a greater tourist attraction.
Sports and Outdoor Concerts Wembley Stadium 1:10000
New Years Celebration River Thames 1:10000
Central Waterfront -
eat
TFL
6 km²
5 sq.m. Semi public
Hong Kong 1,100 km²
observation space
Home ballpark for the New York Yankees and the New York City Football Club. This has a strong symbolic meaning to the New Yorkers as a home for their team. A museum displays Yankees’ memorabilia along with wide choice of restaurants, it becomes a place to gather the fans from around the world. The capacity is large enough to allows music concerts to be held in this stadium.
TFL
TFL
Present
2 km²
hearing room
communication
archive
Political Demonstration Parliament Square 1:10000
Public Realm
1980
Metropolitan Environmental Quality Comparison courtroom
Commercial intersection that is one of the world’s most visited tourist attractions, brightly adorned with billboards and advertisements along with various events and street performances. Annual New Year’s Eve celebrations attracts millions of people gather for the count down as a year round attraction.
The park has historically been the start or the end point for many political demonstrations, now became primary public gathering point for mourners. Greenmarket is held regularly on weekdays by a number of regional farmers, serving more than 250,000 customers per week. This is a popular meeting place, given its central location in Manhattan and its many nearby subway routes with many bars and restaurants.
IFC / Exchange Square Popular Tourist Area Trafalgar Square 1:10000
Public Event Space Hyde Park 1:10000
Orignal Program Judicial Program
legal aid
A commercial complex but also a hot spot for tourist. It’s planning allows to draw people into the heart of the complex with seasonal events and other public elements. Being a National Historic Landmark helps to draw tourist to the area but also create a symbolic meaning to the people of the city.
Ada Student
chat smoke hang out
TFL
1960
Per capita area of public open space 5,000 10,000 (km²) population density
MTA
Jimmy Office Worker
Being the largest open space in New York City, it allows many recreation activates such as cycling, roller skate and seasonal activities. Music festivals are available to be held in the large open spaces on special dates while picnic / relaxation activities happens throughout the year on different seasons.
Public Transit
“Although this is a nice place, it is missing something ...”
MTA
Central Waterfront -
NOTES
tram line bus route mtr
car route
Vehicle Route
“ I enjoy coming here every Sunday meeting my friends.”
MTA
MTA
MTA
underground level MTR exits
Underground Pedestrian Connection
“ I am only meeting my friends here, Then, we go elsewhere.”
MTA
MTA
MTA
CONTEXT
chambers 1940
pedestrian route
Walking Route
“ I am quite surprised there are so few people around.”
MTA
MTA
1 km
JUDEGE administrative office
0
4 km 12 minutes
1 Underground Car park
health and welfare spaces
enforcement spaces
Road
Site Users
Festival Marketplace South Street Seaport 1:10000
Future - Unknown
3 Urban Landscapes/ Roof 2 Observation Deck
legal spaces
?
Underground Connection
Development of Public OpenlawSpace inprobation, Hong Kong
Lung Wo
MTA
MTA
enviromental data
5 Retails 4 Restaurants
Elevated Walkway
Centra
3
MTA
MTA
MTA
MTA
MTA
6 Plazas
Markets
l
Road 4
Associated with the former fruit and vegetable market in the central square, now a popular shopping and tourist site, and the Royal Opera House. Attractions driven by the central square with its street performers, theaters and entertainment facilities, including the Theatre Royal, Drury Lane, and the London Transport Museum.
Sports and Outdoor Concerts Yankee Stadium 1:10000
New Years Celebratation Times Square 1:10000
Political Demonstration Union Square 1:10000
crime statistics
18 Observation space 17 Hearing room/courtroom 16 Jury space 15 Clerk’s office 14 Administrative office 13 Chambers 12 Legal spaces 11 Law enforcement spaces 10 Probation, health and welfare spaces 9 Legal Aid 8 Library/ Archive 7 Auditorium/ Conference Room
Streets
Used as a multi purpose stadium where currently the Home ground for Shanghai East Asia football club. Being one of the largest football stadium in the world, it has held many sport events opening ceremony as well as other cultural events such as music concerts.
Overview Popular Tourist Area Fifth Avenue - Rockefeller Center 1:10000
Public Event Space Central Park 1:10000
building conditions
1940 1950 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010 parking
4
ught
attractive
convenient
pedestrain activity
r Road
Conna
sittable
walkable
Centr
1
sanitation rating Podium Garden
Environment and Facilities Covered Plazas walkable
Accessibility
volunteerism Urban Squares connected
Urban Parks
Road
Chate
This is one of the most famous tourist destinations as well as an iconic place for Shanghai. The promenade allows the capture the skyline of Shanghai with the former Shanghai International Settlement as backdrop. Light show and fire works gathers people around the world on New Years’ Eve for a festive celebration.
The park’s central location makes it the main spot for rallies and demonstrations in Shanghai where the Governments head quarters are located. With several major museums and Shanghai’s main shopping street nearby, it is also one of the top tourist destinations in the city.
- TST
Accessibility
Voeux
2
An affluent car free shopping, eating, entertainment district reconstituted traditional stone gate houses on narrow alleys. Tourist are attracted by the active nightlife on weekdays as well as weekends though romantic setting.
Cen tral
Evolution of Public Space in Hong Kong
Des
Although the park was built for the expo exhibition, the space is now became an area for tourists, and host events such as music festivals and exhibition. Visitors can walk along the riverside and enjoy the landscaping combines Western and Chinese gardening styles.
NOTES
safe
proximity
l
al
EVENT
retail sales
real Public Space
Centra
Site Circulation
Metro
property values
vital Public Utilization
Sociability
welcoming
0s
Metro
active
coperaative neighborly volunteerism
Environment & Facilities
188
Road Central
Street
diverse stewardship
r Road
Pedder
street life
Chate
Des Voeux
Queen
’s Road
evening use
ass
Conna Metro
Metro
Public Utilization
i Byp
Wo Road
1950s
-184
Pre
Metro
186
Metro
l - Wa
n Cha
Str
Metro
CONTEXT 12 minutes 1km
local business ownership
number of women, children and elderly
Sociability
tra
eet
0s
Sequence of Public Experience
historic value
tourist spot landmark
Present 6 km²
Concourse Entrance Sectional Perspective
Court House Sectional Perspective
Mega Court Sectional Perspective
65
Final Panel
67