STUDIO AIR 2014, SEMESTER 2, Tutorial No.1 - Phil Johnny Wang 637861
ABOUT ME
My name is Johnny, and i am currently in my second year at the university of Melbourne. I have always had a strong passion in the artistic and creative fields. I particularly enjoy the process of creating something from scratch, and watch it develop into a final product that i can claim as my own. I was born into a creative family with my grandfather being an artist, and my father being an architect and urban planner. Ever since i was young i have been a keen drawer, which later developed into my obsesson with design.
2
CONCEPTUALISATION
Aside from architecture, i spend most of my time writing music and playing sports. Basketball and music are my other two passions that i am currently pursuing while being at university. Through these other activities that i participate in, i have learnt the importance of teamwork and i’m always willing to learn from others.
CONCEPTUALISATION 3
PART A CONCEPTURALISATION 4
CONCEPTUALISATION
A. PRECEDENT STUDY
A1: DESIGN FUTURING LAGI COMPETITION REVIEW
Precedent 1.0 - City Trace Generator
Figure No.1 City Tracer Generator
Figure No.2 City Tracer Generator
Artist Team: Michal Gdak and Ewelina Gorczynska Artist Location: Wroclaw, Poland Energy Technologies: Solar Updraft Annual Capacity: 1000 MWh Designed for Site #2 in Abu Dhabi, between Saadiyat Island and Yas Island. The City Trace Generator design aspires to reflect the idea of city evolution in the form of an art installation piece. The design is inspired by the ever-repeating process that a city undertakes from the point of birth, to the dawn of collapse. Therefore, the Polish designers developed the City Trace Generator that creates footprints in the form of sand skyscrapers with its sculpted interior as it drifts between Saadiyat Island and Yas Island.1 The design is particularly clever in its metaphorical expressions. The circular form and movements as well as the
1
generator’s ability to be sustainable accurately captures the lives of cities as they rise and fall one after another, naturally and gracefully. The designers have also considered the natural environments of the deserts carefully and used it to their advantage. The element of sand is not only used as the material that forms the city traces, but is also adapted as the generator’s source of energy. During the day the generator is powered by solar energy, while at night, the ring uses the heat stored within the sand and powers the turbine until sunrise, before repeating the process over and over again. Therefore, with this “solar chimney system”1, the City Trace Generator is able to move across 1.5km of sand with the support of only sunlight and two strips of glass that lay next to the ring as heat storing instruments. This design is a perfect example of using the natural environemtns to the designers’ advantage.
Gdak & Gorczynska, City Trace Generator (2010) Figure No.3 City Tracer Generator
6
CONCEPTUALISATION
CONCEPTUALISATION 7
Precedent 2.0 - The Living Ribbon Artist Team: Brett MacIntyre and Adam Pelissero Artist Location: Halifax, Canada Energy Technologies: photovoltaic thin film and fog harvesting nets Annual Capacity: 1,500 MWh Designed for Site #2 in Abu Dhabi, between Saadiyat Island and Yas Island. The design of the Living Ribbon is also inspired by the natural environments of the Dhubi Desert. Native flora and fauna rely on the delicate balance of moisture and nutrients; however the water salinity of the area is often disrupted, causing native species to slowly disappear. Therefore, the design team proposed the idea of the Living Ribbon. A lightweight structure that stretch over 1.6km over the coastal boundary, harvesting electrical energy from sunlight as well as transporting fresh water collected from rain and heavy fogs back into the coastal habitat. 2 With this multi purpose ribbon structure, the salinity level of the coast may hopefully be restored along with the density of the native vegetation. The form of the ribbon is also visually fitting to its environments. The struture traces the curves of the coastal lines whilst the mesh surfaces on the ribbon rise and fall irregularly; causing the structure to seem almost organic as it appears to imitate the wind-driven movement of the sandy desert. However, the materiality of the structure allows it to standout from a distance in the desert. Furthermore, my favourite part of the design is that even though it appears alienated by the natural desert environment, it is still able to be viewed in harmony with its surroundings. The unique form that is used to create ths environemental friendly ribbon is particularly inspiring to me as i aspire to construct varies forms of my own in my future studies.
Figure No.4 The livng Ribbon
2.
8
Figure No.5 The living Ribbon
MacIntyre & Pelissero, The Living Ribbon (2010)
CONCEPTUALISATION
CONCEPTUALISATION 9
A.1 DESIGN FUTURING REFERENCES
TEXT
IMAGES
1.
Gdak & Gorczynska, City Trace Generator (2010), Land Art Generator initiative, http://landartgenerator.org/ LAGI2010/eim100/, accessed July 20th 2014
Gdak & Gorczynska, City Trace Generator (2010), Land Art Generator initiative, http://landartgenerator.org/ LAGI2010/eim100/, accessed July 20th 2014
2.
2.
MacIntyre & Pelissero, The Living Ribbon (2010), Land Art Generator Initiative, http://landartgenerator.org/ LAGI2010/apbr64/, accessed July 20th 2014
1.
MacIntyre & Pelissero, The Living Ribbon (2010), Land Art Generator Initiative, http://landartgenerator.org/ LAGI2010/apbr64/, accessed July 20th 2014
A.2 DESIGN COMPUTATION 10
CONCEPTUALISATION
CONCEPTUALISATION 11
A2: Design Computation “Design is a process we engage in when the current situation is different from some desired situation, and when the actions needed to transform the former into the latter are not immediately obvious.”1 The nature of a design process is not static. It is a process that is taken by one who creates something that resolute a problem or improves the convenience of the individual. Traditionally, buildings were not designed. They were built. The invention of ancient drafting tools allowed designers to describe form and structure without physically constructing the design as well as decreasing the consequences in the cases of errors.Similarly, the advancing digital technologies is increasing simulation capabilities. Programs like AutoCAD transformed pen and paper to the computer screen. Designers no longer need to worry about the percision of hand drawings and calculations as the program is able to do it all in the matter of a click. Furthermore, The development of computational tools are able to “create more responsive designs, allowing architects to explore new design options and to analyse architectural decisions during the design process.” 2 The nature of this new generation of drafting tools has revolutionized the way architects generate design ideas, giving them the freedom to experiment with a much larger range of aesthetic and structural opportunities.
12
CONCEPTUALISATION
Figure No.1 Modern Skyscraper Proposal
1. Rivka & Oxman (2014) 2. Peters & Bradley (2013) 3. Danny Karas (2014)
Forms that are previously impossible to draft have been made possible with digital scripting and advanced modeling tools. This has also introduced a whole new aspect to design and construction, as computerization tools have enabled designers the ability to virtually create complicated geometries beyond imaginations.
Precedent 3.0 - Modern Skyscraper The skyscraper proposal designed by SCI-Arc displays expressive forms that are impossible to be described with pre-computerisation methods. The highlight of the skyscraper design is no other than the distorted layer of outer skin that is created through 3D simulation of gravity. The twisting form is generated through digitally capturing the motion of twisting a piece of flexi-wood and transferring the gathered data into a modeling program. This project is “less about the result and more about the statement of digital production”. 3 It is a statement of the “speed and quality that digital design can create and how this revolution of speed can give architects a greater chance to impact that project outside of form making.” 3 Although the skyscraper proposal is not currently possible to be placed under construction, it displays the impact that computation can possibly have on the design industry.
Figure No.2 Modern Skyscraper Proposal
CONCEPTUALISATION 13
Figure No.3 - 3D printing
Precedent 4.0 - Production Furthermore, “innovative technologies have become a driving force in the formulation of theories as well as producing a new wave of tectonic and material creativity.”4
Figure No.4 - technique development
Virtual designs can now be brought to reality with the uses of laser cutting and 3D printing techniques. The Southern California Institude of Architecture uses computation to experiment with these structures’ formations as well as analysing material behaviours. The Anistropic Formation project is classified as a protoarchitectural project that experiments with robotics and vector based 3D printing. 5 This project is a great example of the current generation of architects’ medium of creating research-based design, as it largely revolves around the scripting of algorithms. 6
Figure No.6 - F2
The project on the right is designed and constructed by students of UTSA College of Architecture. The form, grid and calculations are all generated and calculated digintally.7 Without computation and computerisation, the project would not have been completed within the short period of 3 weeks. Figure No.5 - materialization
14
CONCEPTUALISATION
4. 6. Rivka & Oxman (2014) 5. Cortez, Lu, Tomara & Troufanov (2014) 7. Kudless & McClellan (2014)
Figure No.7 - F2
Figure No.8 - F2
CONCEPTUALISATION 15
Figure No.9 - City of Dreams hotel
Precedent 5.0 - City of Dreams Hotel Although digital technologies are often used in experimental and competition designs where the construction aspect of the design doesn’t neccessarily need to be highly considered, there are still many examples of successful comptemorary designs that incorporated computation technologies. This 40 floor hotel building designed by Zaha Hadid Architects displays an exposed exoskeleton frame that reinforces the dynamism of the design. This external frame “optimizes the interior layouts and envelops the building” 8. The division of the exterior steel grid as well as the creation of the interior panels were achieved through computation, contributing to both the aesthetics and the structural aspects of the tower. 9 Although the summary did not specifically mention the program used to achieve the designs, the panel and fold tools in rhino are able to calculate and produce forms of that nature. Overall, Computerisation has allowed designers to design quicker, and express their ideas easier; while computation opened up a new area of imagination. The development of digital technologies has definitely changed the ways architects approach designs and re-defined their design processes.
Figure No.10 - City of Dreams hotel
8. 9. Zaha Hadid Architects (2014) 16
CONCEPTUALISATION
CONCEPTUALISATION 17
A.2 DESIGN COMPUTATION REFERENCES
TEXT
IMAGES
1. Oxman, Rivka and Robert Oxman, eds (2014). Theories of the Digital in Architecture (London; New York: Routledge), pp. 1–10
1.http://www.suckerpunchdaily.com/2014/05/02/ sofi/#more-36337, accessed 18th August 2014
2. Kalay, Yehuda E. (2004). Architecture’s New Media: Principles, Theories, and Methods of Computer-Aided Design (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press), pp. 5-25 3. Peters, Brady. (2013) ‘Computation Works: The Building of Algorithmic Thought’, Architectural Design, 83, 2, pp. 08-15 4. Danny Karas (2014) ‘Skyscraper Proposal’, SuckerPunch Daily,http://www.suckerpunchdaily.com/2014/05/02/ sofi/#more-36337, accessed 18th August 2014
2.http://www.suckerpunchdaily.com/2014/03/24/ anisotropic-formations/#more-35611, accessed 18th August 2014 3.Http://www.suckerpunchdaily.com/2014/06/27/f²-2/, accessed 18th August 2014 4.http://www.suckerpunchdaily.com/2014/04/10/city-ofdreams-hotel-tower/#more-35932, accessed 18th August 2014
5. Cortez, Lu, Tomara, Troufanov, ‘Anisotropic Formation project’, SuckerPunch Daily, http://www.suckerpunchdaily. com/2014/03/24/anisotropic-formations/#more-35611, accessed 18th August 2014 6. Kudless & McClellan, ‘f2’, SuckerPunch Daily, www. suckerpunchdaily.com/2014/06/27/f²-2/, accessed 18th August 2014 7. Zaha Hadid Architects, “City of Dreams Hotel Tower”, SuckerPunch Daily, http://www. suckerpunchdaily.com/2014/04/10/city-of-dreams-hoteltower/#more-35932, accessed 18th August 2014
A.3 COMPOSITION TO GENERATION 18
CONCEPTUALISATION
CONCEPTUALISATION 19
A3: Composition to Generation
As digital technology rapidly develops, new mediums of design are introduced to the architecture industry. The generation of soft pencils and yellow trace paper is over, as the era of computational design begins. Algorithmic thinking and parametric designing are two of the main attributes many of the current generation architects commonly have. Ever since computers have been introduced to architects in the 1980s, it became a crucial elemtn in drafting precise plans as well as generating complicated structural systems.1 While computers continue to evolve, modern architecture appears to increase in its complexity. Many of the current experimental designs as well as existing architecture around the world are often created with the tool of parametric modelling. Parametric modelling is more than just a drafting tool. Unlike other types of digital modelling, parametric Parametric design software is able to detect how “changing any parameter of a structure will affect other physical aspects”. 2 Therefore it is not only able to depict a building and its relevant surroundings in 3-D, its scripted algorithms are able to revise a model instantly. It is used “not just to make buildings more visually compelling, but to precisely tune nearly every aspect of their performance, from acoustic to energy efficiency.” 3
In other words, architects are able to create formulas that acts as guidelines which calculate their alterations automatically. This attribute of parametric design not only revolutionizes the way architects approach a design, but also saves them the time in re-adjusting their trials and correcting their mistakes. Potentially, because making design alterations has never been easier before, architects are able to revise their designs more conviniently leading to a better design outcome. Furthermore, architect and vice president of Autodesk believes “parametric technology will help make new buildings more environmentally sustainable.” He also claims that it could reshape urban planning as programs will become powerful enough to model and alter the design of an entire neighbourhood with ease.4 Overall, computation has redefined architecture, opening doors of opportunities never previously explored by designers. Although technology is still at its growing stage, parametric designs done by the worlds most forward thinkers have displayed the potential advances that computation may provide us
1. 2. 4. MIT Technology Review (2013) 3. Rybczynski, Witold (2013)
20
CONCEPTUALISATION
CONCEPTUALISATION 21
Precedent 1.0 - Shang hai Tower
Gensler’s Shang hai tower, which will soon stand as the second tallest building in the world once construction completes is a prime example of how parametric technology has benefitted architecture. At 630 meters in height, every detail of the skyscraper needs to be considered, and every aspect of design needs to serve a purpose beyond aesthetics. Although the twisting curved form demonstrates a design expression, “by plugging geometry into a modeling tool known as Grasshopper, the desingers were able to tweak the shape to minimize the force of winds on the facade.” 5 Designer Ko explains that it would be tedious for architects to calculate the degrees of rotation manually. Therefore, they used rotation as one of the parameters which helped them run through various iterations to reach the final situation. 6 In Ko’s description of the design process, it is evident that computation served as a main catalyst in creating this piece of architecture. Parametric technology allowed architects to conviniently alter the software inputs, in the process of developing the raw initial concept of a twisting tower. The element of computation not only contributed aesthetically, but also structurally. From the algorithmic division of the tower’s facade grid to its self sustainable system, every aspect of the design involved the uses of digital technology. Therefore, there is no denying that computation and computerisation have reshaped the society’s perception of architecture.
5. 6. MIT Technology Review (2013)
Figure No.1 - Shang Hai Tower 22
CONCEPTUALISATION
Figure No.2 - Shang Hai Tower CONCEPTUALISATION 23
Figure No.3 - Shang Hai Tower 24
CONCEPTUALISATION
CONCEPTUALISATION 25
Figure No.4 - Bird Nest Stadium
Precedent 2.0 - Bird Nest Stadium While appearing to be visually contrasting the Shang hai tower, this phenomenal Chinese architecture also displays aspects of the generative architecture approach. The most unique element of the Bird Nest is its exterior shell that wraps around the core of the stadium. Polish architect Jaroslaw Ceborski stated that “It’s quite easy to distinguish something designed using parameters and algorithms from the rest.” 7 If so, the Bird Nest would definitely be one of the buildings that strikes to be designed parametrically. While the surface of the structure appears straight forward, the geometry is complex. Calculations were so numerous and complicated that they were impossible to be solved manually. 8 7. Rybczynski, Witold (2013) 8. 9. 10. Design Build Network (2014)
26
CONCEPTUALISATION
Therefore, “software was needed to make sure that the web of twisting steel sections fitted together, as they have to twist and bend to follow the surface accurately.” 8 Although the “nest” may appear somewhat random, it contains 36km of unwrapped steel that forms the structure which was designed to resemble yin yang “Chinese philosophy of balance and harmony.” 9 Furthermore, because China is highly vulnerable of earthquakes, the outter skeleton is seperated from the seating bowl to enhence earthquake resistance. All calculations done regarding this area were done digitally also.10 Overall, The Bird Nest further proves that the development of parametric technology is enabling architects with tools that allow them to be more expressive than they ever could before. Figure No.5 - Bird Nest Stadium
CONCEPTUALISATION 27
Parametricism & Disadvantages of computation Patrick Schumacher, a named partner at Zaha Hadid Architects(ZHA) promoted what he called “parametricism”.11 It introduces a new type of aesthetic. An aesthetic only archievable through algorithmic thinking and parametric technologies. Schumacher describes “parametricism” as a “deliberate response to an increasingly heterogeneous society.”12 Therefore, with the intention of creating “complex, polycentric urban fields”, Schumacher advices in the defining manifesto he wrote for the 2008 VAB, “Avoid repetition, avoid straight lines, avoid right angles, avoid corners, avoid simple repetition of elements...”13 This style has been developing ever since the the digital animation techniques in mid 1990s, and is now considered to “succeed modernism as a new long wave of systematic innovation.”14
Figure No.6 - Parametric Sketch
However, although parametric technologies are commonly recognised as the next step in architecture, Christopher Alexander, a well established architect, theorist, teacher and designer is concerned about the current generations’ obsession with computing. He claims that there has not yet been a problem that is so complex that we must use a computer. He feels that the use of computers in problem solving will “distort one’s view of the problem.”15 He believes that even though virtual technologies are able to solve problems, it only allows architects to consider the aspects of the problem that are able to be encoded, which in many cases are the least important.16 Overall, whether parametric technologies is revolutionary or a dead end, its potential to benefit the human society is undeniable.
Figure No.7 - Parametric fabric study
11. 12. 13. 15. 16. Rybczynski, Witold (2013) 14. Schumacher (2008)
28
CONCEPTUALISATION
CONCEPTUALISATION 29
A.3 COMPOSITION TO GENERATION REFERENCES
TEXT
IMAGES
1. “Advanced Architecture Software Could Make Buildings More Energy-Efficient and Interesting | MIT Technology Review.” Technologyreview.com, July 31, 2013. http://www.technologyreview.com/ review/517596/new-forms-that-function-better/.
1 . h t t p s : / / w w w. f l i c k r. c o m / p h o t o s / quixoticguide/6881264310/, accessed 20th August 2014
2. Rybczynski, Witold. “Parametric Design: What’s Gotten Lost Amid the Algorithms - Architect Magazine.” Architectmagazine.com, July 11, 2013. http://www. architectmagazine.com/design/parametric-designlost-amid-the-algorithms.aspx 3. Designbuild Network, “Beijing National Stadium ‘The Bird Nest’, China”, http://www.designbuild-network. com/projects/national_stadium/, accessed 20th August 2014 4. Schumacher, Patrick, “Parametricism - A New Global Style for Architecture and Urban Design.”, Digital Cities, Vol 79, No.4, July/August 2009, http:// www.patrikschumacher.com/Texts/Parametricism%20 -% 2 0 A% 2 0 N e w % 2 0 G l o b a l % 2 0 S t y l e% 2 0 fo r % 2 0 A rc h i te c t u re%2 0 a n d %2 0 U r b a n%2 0 D e s i g n . h t m l , accessed 20th August 2014
2.http://travelinnate.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/06/ Beijing-National-Stadium-2.jpeg, accessed 20th August 2014 3.http://www.designbuild-network.com/projects/national_ stadium/, accessed 20th August 2014 4.http://www.ctbuh.org/News/GlobalTallNews/tabid/4810/ Article/648/language/en-US/view.aspx#!, accessed 20th August 2014 5 . h t t p : / / w w w. s k y s c r a p e r c i t y. c o m / s h o w t h r e a d . php?t=391698&page=314, accessed 20th August 2014 6 . h t t p : / / w w w. s k y s c r a p e r c i t y. c o m / s h o w t h r e a d . php?t=391698&page=296, accessed 20th August 2014 7 . h t t p : / / w w w . p a t r i k s c h u m a c h e r. c o m / Te x t s / Parametricism%20-%20A%20New%20Global%20 Style%20for%20Architecture%20and%20Urban%20 Design.html, accessed 20th August 2014 8.http://nwahart.blogspot.com.au/, accessed 20th August 2014
PART A - CONCLUSION 30
CONCEPTUALISATION
CONCEPTUALISATION 31
CONCLUSION
LEARNING OUTCOME
The advancement of digital technology has reshaped the architectural industry. While computerization has revolutionized the design process, the computation phenomenon has re-defined architects’ approaches in designing a building.
My experience so far in Studio Air has been eye opening. I feel like i have consumed a great deal of information in the the short few weeks time. The study parametric design is definitely one of my favourite parts of the course so far. I can see how learning programs such as Grasshopper and Rhino 3D could benefit me in the future. Through the few short exercises i have completed in tutorials and at home, i have learnt quite alot about the program, and i am excited to get into more practical side of this studio.
Parametric modelling not only allowed architects to generate and revise their design ideas with ease, but also guided them to realise geometric designs that are often far more complex than their imaginations. Overall, although computation opened doors of opportunities for architects to explore, the key to successful designs still remains as the architect.
However, even though i have kept up with the pace of the class, i still feel some what uncomfortable with the format of Grasshopper. The amount of information and its display format is quite overwhelming, but hopefully i can overcome the difficulties through more practice.
ALGORITHMIC SKETCHBOOK 32
CONCEPTUALISATION
CONCEPTUALISATION 33
I have really enjoyed the process of generating forms in grasshopper. The flexible nature of the program has allowed me to experiment freely within the program. I’m quite surprised by how diverse the outcomes could be when minor adjustments were made in Rhino. I have gained a basic understanding of the Grasshopper program through the first 3 weeks of practice. Although i am not fluent in designing in Grasshopper, what i have been able to create so far has really surprised me. With only a few plugins, algorithms of complicated forms were created and applied. In the 3rd week’s task of altering the patterned facade, i added a third line in Rhino as one of the initial line inputs, and the entire design changed. After making a few experiments, i have decided to place img.3 in the journal as i demonstrates the most fluidity. In conclusion, i believe with the right amount of practice, Grasshopper could really be a benefitial aspect for me in the future.
34
CONCEPTUALISATION
CONCEPTUALISATION 35
Heading 2
Heading 3 Cae estrem di co viviterum lartura? As cus At fici privivi denequo ac rehebenis? Fint. moditilnem temura? Nihil hos cordi, nos, inaris hilicta duc rem tabuspecrit. Ce nis vius oc, quit vivena teatquo nsulvivirmis es traet di casdam moreiss atilici aectur. Alicerum, ali estisserit aucon hos iam uteri patius esses inti, ubli poere mod ina, que fuem a niquam, tus nonduciam autem ius et in vit. Lis los hor actu viliconumus hostrun irissedi,Opiemoru sperfero etoris, telii pro verbis contico nsulestant. Vo, nonficultu quius orudeniconc opotis serfit. Itala noc tesultorum pubis patilla sessendam iaessenium. Ocavocturnit atiam oc facit. Puliam amenatr emnonsi manum, quis octorur inveroximus cae iae adhusse natante tus morum eniquam perfeco nterum atortum fue poerevis, deo, fac tus deatorum faut L. Odion hos, nis iae vic red num tebena, Catum etod ductore vivehem patus constro esciem pora, fate tebus, senductorei publint inici patuam arit ius bontiam te tus ca me teriptilius cludella rebuntiam Rommoris. Averus defacivit. Delut optius, nonvenes? Us forem hem, vid consusp ioruntela o postrac viveretiliu ma, deoraedem vium abus sa vestrit?Pices ne nonemente omnosul torarbit, critiam ia? Erenirit; Catum hocat inatia rente consulis. Opio Catum, ex maximul inatiae in dituius numeissed firi, con dius, pra, utum aude vivivius iam atquidem eo inationsu quondacesi intem. Ules perudem coentis coenatrum conlocc iendaci
Dam intero inam inulica urarios es erceris; C. Grae crum mendius terficae crebatatquon hossuam perceri mprat, tabemquam porteli ntres? Alaturbem quam nostabunum Palabena nos pra, Cupplic iendum sulatiam inuntribus caut ocae, quamque es popotabem a superum tatilicae ceris ad isquem Patius, mortum o ur ur. Vilicid cotiaci detiam virmis constra trunum num unicaedo, quemum es con videm di patus firi, nostabus locavehem pec fui ina, condiu inatius tripti, sulisse que condam meiAbem. Lesti, es de demusa none culut vit vius stre cut vo, vil ut fecrum opultum sen deo, quam ponsceres are nostrunius postrors vessoltorum di seret, Ti. Fuidem tus or inatil host inem ocaede menihiliqua restis. Cont. Ovis. Gula mus ere facciem et, etidemore nondies intem ius intiam pere, elus temorum dessenia vervil cerfir hos suam, se entere none non denator isserterfit opublium in Ita, utemuste, me comaxim incenam omnes ocus, terati in idet ventervis peropotia Serid cem, nossus. Cat. Ata, con trecre co viride cat. Sate adhuiu que nos moricae terum pecrit. Nos la quam cone quamque nosuam, qua te, et ner lari ia? O tui in seseniq uamdio vilicam pecepest gra det rebatid ienatil inimprit, cota consultortum puliam se, faceperit; haciend acitare condet at, sci suntem, que aut veressu menatiam sed sent.Natquer pl. Patur qui simus egiliquam et, Catisquam quam ta, cursus manum spiorta, C. Maesi inum is pride conficae pracit, pos omnicaedes consus deffre nem pubis peri spie mant grae dientervidi publibute pria? Maiorav esigna, vit; intereste pris, tandam a vivitescesi conloc tentrum tantra intus, opublicient. Im inum et videps, qui paturis, se cupecione teres con su contela buscer hos, Fig.1: (explain here & reference at the end of your document)
36
CONCEPTUALISATION
CONCEPTUALISATION 37
Fig.2
Ublicastin dii pesta, ublin videm ia nosum pubit; noc ret dit, nos eri sul haescrei in patiae popubli nihicul tortem aude intili ces omnium poportus, norum ad parit? quamdit. C. Ipicto et pora morum facie medi sultum videffrem condum seditarbis. Sente no. Oter quos fur. Abus, dium ut o es ad conem aucem dem ubliaetor prio vignonfit vemur, ses vendam tero avo, viu intis, ni es ad perit; iam. et publicaet patus, conficaedii pateride quem, vit. Uce conihil venimium intil vivid dit ficiem ompl. Duciendem, consum, senat, cont viri, nonicus, quam condam me hoca; et ina, firis. Fui post? Simurorbis. Ti. Quium oportem overum deti, niri, sest? Abuli con aperitius, convess esserae nostam te que pultodiere atque inte rentum senirimpos pre
38
CONCEPTUALISATION
Decte, cae confecu ternimi liurnum et ad aus, conihiliam in Etrem, egit dit? Evignoc ultortemque issoliam, Catius acciae turei in hocatim inum habit re moverfi cioculest re consuam ad concena, vignost? P. Es! Simis consultoreo, Cate, si patum spiem. But ad cepessi sena, quit intea omniquem et? Nostrat achi, untere in stessolus caperfi tusqua nost popubli pubis, qui stemurorum niacis, cia ducerem maio vilis. Obus, con tintess entiaequon Etre obus, Catissimum mod cae publiurorum etori sentere scienter inatiqu ideps, comnihi conentem maxime nostrum tus, nonvoli caelaberi su videt renihillere perici int.convernum me consumus se tanum mortendetrid consiti custabem pos, nes
Ublicastin dii pesta, ublin videm ia nosum pubit; noc ret dit, nos eri sul haescrei in patiae popubli nihicul tortem aude intili ces omnium poportus, norum ad parit? quamdit. C. Ipicto et pora morum facie medi sultum videffrem condum seditarbis. Sente no. Oter quos fur. Abus, dium ut o es ad conem aucem dem ubliaetor prio vignonfit vemur, ses vendam tero avo, viu intis, ni es ad perit; iam. et publicaet patus, conficaedii pateride quem, vit. Uce conihil venimium intil vivid dit ficiem ompl. Duciendem, consum, senat, cont viri, nonicus, quam condam me hoca; et ina, firis. Fui post? Simurorbis. Ti. Quium oportem overum deti, niri, sest? Abuli con aperitius, convess esserae nostam te que pultodiere atque inte rentum senirimpos pre
Decte, cae confecu ternimi liurnum et ad aus, conihiliam in Etrem, egit dit? Evignoc ultortemque issoliam, Catius acciae turei in hocatim inum habit re moverfi cioculest re consuam ad concena, vignost? P. Es! Simis consultoreo, Cate, si patum spiem. But ad cepessi sena, quit intea omniquem et? Nostrat achi, untere in stessolus caperfi tusqua nost popubli pubis, qui stemurorum niacis, cia ducerem maio vilis. Obus, con tintess entiaequon Etre obus, Catissimum mod cae publiurorum etori sentere scienter inatiqu ideps, comnihi conentem maxime nostrum tus, nonvoli caelaberi su videt renihillere perici int.convernum me consumus se tanum mortendetrid consiti custabem pos, nes
CONCEPTUALISATION 39
Milium in terceris, quasdac vivis, C. Habefes! Tum audam aci siliamdictam patrae acepostre, Catus hena, noveri se praedenatus arbefecrei convoltus coero, ta noveravo, et patem teristrit? Nihi, caves nia mendern ihilinter publienter hos bonte, fue publiqu idessol torteat, C. Patilin clabis. Fulintem viridiem niqua re, conirit, quam cont? Eps, nic taribus, quonfer fectum orum, que nonsus M. Et dercesse viventimus addum patquis horum sci publiura inte in nos, morae, que re me culinatanum num, que quonsulis intra recorta stius, quemus. Sim co ex sentiliu simultorbis egerfic aecondius, nonequit? Quonsim ihilius; novenatque tantus, ublicavoli publius ponduc octod con virmacia nihi, igillabus vividien hali inum nium intempl. Ad medem reconsusul virio ex senita, cestat, idem publice rdinateres! Ilis seEdienteris fuemus aris ficae essimus caperi, que crei crem ade audem. Ebenam abut virica nihinertuam ussentem, tempribena, quam culeris iturni te meniquo nvercer esicivi demoeressat, Catuidi peredem hoc, oportum usultu virit; nos, pultui tum hostient. Locta num igit aturnum mis, vissuludam eor ad iam nonsit. Nihicior publius moludetiam tam. Cer huidet; etia di, cae etilinvensit ia? Et obse, omprorem ius publing ulegitiam. Tum et pes orbenam int? Pora nemus virmiu morei intero cae nes audemor ur que adhus elles! Ehebaturor uteriditilis et? quis caedem deo, cupplinis rem popubli npriocasdam. Axim consuam dio aur prat, us prit, con demus proximus habefes inguliacrus. Avocrib
40
CONCEPTUALISATION
CONCEPTUALISATION 41
42
CONCEPTUALISATION
CONCEPTUALISATION 43
Dit; in sentea cri in te, peraeliam inirtur. Vivis aurs si furemus forit. Ividelaris in vili pora, num atilis, ut diente intis, nemus hilisum paterfex sulto ime tum ent. Epeci imihilicae acchuctem medo, Catus fuit. Si siliae nocta, qua esiment ifecientem iu veric retorsulint nit vignaturitum Rompoteat re fecons C. La nercepost? Iferrioste, facepse es se essolud eressultuam dessi ia sa et venihicae ellarisus in Ita potanda ctoruntem strunt? Sedienemoves arium pulem inclute menatia equitiam nostruderum pliam mant quam terentil temei fortum in haliciemus ia? Abem, pra? Valarta ditus am imus nu que derevivere, Ti. Ubliae tus con dem is firmihina, verors apere ta, essena, furbes a tessesest? Cum iae publiis. Essilici estrist duciam ut const plibuntrum is audemus cre, consulv ivilnem P. con vere ate que etiur acri concupiortus hori proraec rentes clus, iam inpractumus, etius bon vilicaed clatiam tam. Bis, no. Quam res et aurem nuntilicae, nocum in ac te tem sen sente o culviris, qua remus oculica verrips, patifertes C. Fultodi ursulesimod mum paturis, numurnum omplicone confernihica nondem prit videt qui popublius escres constio nculium pulus escrit. Halaris opublicion Etrat. Maes vast niumed feridemque es? Nam quam inclus Ad pultus, demquem sen hoculinaris, oculto vit, egerten testam dis med confero niam Romnem vessena, elutur utem ordi silintea dienteme nem ducient fuidi, nos consum nium parissil huit nestis mere est vernicaesta ius la clarbit, consunt am, us, dum etortare
44
CONCEPTUALISATION
CONCEPTUALISATION 45