Invention Journal of Research Technology in Engineering & Management (IJRTEM) ISSN: 2455-3689 www.ijrtem.com Volume 1 Issue 5 ǁ July. 2016 ǁ PP 11-23
Case Study, Cairo-Amman Bank-Jordan: Improving an Organization by the use of Smart Phones and IPads which are Considered the Basics of the Supply Chain Management (SCM) Yousef Ahmed Hussein AL Safadi (Business Management, / Girne American University, Turkish Republic of North Cyprus (TRNC))
Abstract : In this study, analysis and comparison between the most important enterprise systems Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP), Supply Chain Management (SCM), and Customer Relationship Management (CRM) are studied in accordance with the organization innovation performance as a special case Cairo Amman Bank in Jordan for process and as well the CRM while using smart phones and iPads as product innovations. Moreover, this study employed a database obtained from two computers aided, mobile surveys conducted since 2010 by the Cairo Amman Bank in Jordan. Both studies are focused along the dispersal and use of the information and communication technology (ICT) in Cairo Amman Bank and its ramifications. Each database contained information about 4000 customers with more than five employees, these databases representatively choose from the most important services in the bank. These databases are taken for the sample which is furnished from the credit rating employees or agents. This agency who provides the biggest database on organizations available in Jordan. Moreover, collects basic information about customers as addresses, sectors, organization’s sizes in the market, and sizes in all enterprises that applied to the bank for credits. These excerpts from the populations of Jordan organizations were stratified according to two size categories, as Jordan and Palestine (East/West) and to several branches in both states. As many organizations as needed have been asked until all classes were met. The interviewee was, in general, the principal executive officer of the organizations who could also resolve to legislate on queries to a corresponding employee like, e. g., The head of the ICT department. Besides detailed information on the use of several other ICT applications, the dataset provides the employment level of the three main enterprise software applications ERP, SCM and CRM. Additionally, to ICT application usage, size, industry branch and geographical region, the surveys also contain information about the organization’s workforce, like the share of highly skilled workers and other variables, e. g. Organizational practices. Using a two-part model, the results reveal that SCM systems foster the organization’s likelihood of turning a potential process innovator. In addition, ERP systems increase the number of process innovations a firm earns. These results do not only emerge for the short-run of two years or less, but remain also stable in the medium-run of two to four years. Concerning product innovation performance, only CRM systems increase the organization’s likelihood to acquire product innovations, despite the impact emerges for the short-run and vanishes if the medium-run perspective is taken into account. The actual interviewee had been, generally speaking, the particular chief of the bank branches which may also decide to spread questions to the corresponding employees like the head of the ICT department. Besides more information about using other ICT software, the database supplies the use degree of these principal business applications ERP, SCM and also CRM. In addition, in order to ICT software usage by smartphones and iPads, size, market branch as well as physical location, the actual research additionally consists of details about the actual organizations, workforce, just like the discuss with highly trained staff and other variables, and company practices. Keywords: Innovations, Enterprise System, Enterprise Resource Planning, Supply Chain Management, Customer Relationship Management, Smart Phones and iPads
I. Study Problem Nowadays, it is considered to say that all companies are seeking to improve their relationships between companies are their customers, there so many ways to increase and strongest this relationship. Increasing this relationship, helps companies or systems to amend and increase their level in the grocery stores. In this study, a case study on Cairo Amman Bank and its investments to increase the relationship between the bank and its customers by the usage of smart phones and iPads, as much as installing the needed software in these introductions. Moreover, increasing the enterprise systems and their innovations. Ultimately, keying out the purpose of the enterprise systems and their resources in order to amend the relationship management in the Bank. II. Background and aim of the study Enterprise organizations are these days widely spread amongst diverse industries all over the globe. Even though it is contended that business methods, improve company performance, their particular impact on innovation performance will be at the moment simply taught. Empirical data regarding any connection among enterprise methods and innovations overall performance remains lacking at
| Volume 1| Issue 5 | 11
www.ijrtem.com
| July 2016|
Case Study, Cairo-Amman Bank-Jordan‌ present. The present examines aims at completing this particular space through empirically studying the influence with the a few main enterprise techniques ERP, SCM and Customer Relationship Management on the innovational overall performance associated with agencies with regard to the method. Using a zero-inflated damaging binomial model comprising two parts, one outlining the decision to innovate and some other detailing the quantity of innovators for potential innovators, the results what is anticipated optimistic influences regarding enterprise program usage about the organizations innovational efficiency for both kinds of innovations. Lastly, to demonstrate the importance of smart phones and iPads in the system in general, and special case the Cairo Amman Bank in Jordan with most of its branches available in Jordan and in Palestine. The statistical significance of the study : It is well-known that the success of any system depends on the enterprise systems and the relationship of that establishment with the customers. Moreover, increasing this relationship depends on the strategic designs and the leaderships who are managing that system. It is hoped that this study will get the maximum number of advantages by using these enterprise systems. Also, this study analyzes the relationship between the most important three enterprise systems as enterprise resource planning (ERP), supply chain management (SCM) and the customer relationship management (CRM) of the organization.
III. Introduction Addressing a wide variety regarding software program items, assisting day-to-day enterprise procedures as well as decision-making, company-wide packages of business software program, namely venture techniques in short, tend to be specialized in particular process integrated, throughout the benefit string. The three principal venture systems, Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP), Supply Chain Management (SCM) and also Customer Relationship Management (CRM), tend to be prevalent all through several market sectors in several locations around the globe (Bano, 2014). The objective of scalping systems is to speed up operations coming from supply management, inventory control, manufacturing scheduling, sales force automation and almost any other data-oriented management processes. Smart phones and iPads are considered the greatest International computer software merchant, estimates the whole operates in markets, technical engineers, and also personal computer info systems for primary venture applications, including ERP, SCM and also CRM (Baran et al., 2008). Generally speaking, nowadays all companies have enterprise systems and they are trying to connect it to, be spread out in all the company. While this software system has no ability to be connected and cannot be spread all over the company. Moreover, the improvements done on this software, gave the operational integration an idea that this is affecting the complete organization (Bibiano et al., 2014). According to this result, ERP and SCM proved that they have positively fostered in the innovation activities by decreasing the required idle time and saving the data by mining or even by identifying the bottlenecks and shortages, these systems are helpful for organizations with wide database for updating in the real time to be controlled and compared. Smart phones and iPads are also helpful by holding the CRM systems, this system is used as a database of the customers, as much as helpful as sources for product innovations (Cheng et al., 2006). Despite the fact that the usage of info and also connection technology (ICT) programs generally will be thought to enhance organization's innovation performance, the opportunity effect regarding business systems on innovational overall performance specifically is still not really looked into (Chopra et al., 2007). The actual materials in this field are actually scarce, supplying just a few research which analyzes the advantages of enterprise systems with regard to innovation activity. Empirical proof based on firm information covering this particular topic continues to be deficient Currently (Dezdar et al., 2010). Therefore, this research aims at providing the initial empirical evidence of the actual impact regarding taking on smart phones and iPads to put in the three principal venture systems about company’s innovation overall performance. To have useful outcomes, the existing research relies on a distinctive databases consisting of Cairo Amman Bank in Jordan being a special circumstance. Employing a two-step approach, the final results offer the first proof of innovations action fostered through enterprise method use (Hwang et al., 2014). The actual usage of smart phones included the particular ERP and also SCM techniques increases the propensity to appreciate procedure innovations. Furthermore, smartphones included the actual ERP program usage offers demonstrated a positive impact on the amount of obtained process innovations (AlQahtani, 2014). These effects are not only seen short-term centered; in fact, they will stay additionally steady inside the medium-run. Furthermore, use of smartphone's included CRM systems, alternatively, doesn't have an impact about process improvements, however absolutely effects the particular inclination to appreciate merchandise innovative developments, even though this impact just retains on the short-term schedule. Despite the fact that use of details and also communication technology (ICT) software generally speaking is assumed to boost company’s innovation overall performance, the potential influence of business techniques about innovation overall performance specifically remains not really researched (Barron et al., 2011). The actual literature within this area will be hard to find, supplying only a few research that analyzes some great benefits of enterprise systems for innovation exercise. Test evidence on the basis of firm-level data addressing this matter continues to be lacking Currently. As a result, this research is aimed at supplying the initial test evidence of the effect regarding adopting any of the three principal venture systems about organizations innovational efficiency
| Volume 1| Issue 5 |
www.ijrtem.com
| July 2016| 12
Case Study, Cairo-Amman Bank-Jordan‌ (Bugental et al., 2002). To have useful results, the current study relies on a special data source composed of Jordan organizations in the manufacturing market and also through program sectors. In this study, the performance of the ERP and also SCM is presented and enhanced with some difficulties. The rest of the study is organized as follows: in the next section presents the appropriate literature work covering the benefits of enterprise systems in general and their potential effects on innovation performance in particular. In section III the theoretical framework is presented and the estimation approach. Section IV represents the used research methodology. Section V represents the simulation results. Section VI concludes the work done in this study.
IV. Literature Review Fosser et al., (2008) outlined a framework summarizing prior research and suggest two researchable questions. In conclusion, presented some initial findings from two empirical case studies derived from part of the European food industry.Engelstatter, (2009) reviewed the relationship between the three primary enterprise techniques (Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP), Supply Chain Management (SCM), Customer Relationship Management (CRM)) and work productivity. Additionally, discussed it unveils the actual performance gains because of diverse combinations of These systems. Also, in addition, it tests with regard to complementarity among the business systems with regards to their particular communicating dynamics. AL-Ghamdi et al., (2013) reviewed a few critical achievement factors and issues which effect the actual setup associated with ERP system to lead inside helping the ERP execution rate of success. The most important concerns throughout ERP setup method is actually employees' potential to deal with acknowledge the newest program as well as dealing with it. As a result, mostly concentrated regarding how to make use of alter supervision methods and strategies to enhance the individual's' popularity fee which usually result in productive ERP execution. Khamees, (2013) focused on describing the role of ERP- CRM with respect to traditional business for overcoming the existing challenges. Moreover, discussed are the features of sap ERP/CRM, with the help of this new technology companies get business in market. Also, this tool used for increase the business scope, it increases the decision makings of companies and it helps to build the customers relations, and manage the high work or huge work with less efforts and manpower. On other hand, another management related tool is LMS (learning management system). As much as mentioned the benefits of ERP/CRM which helps to reduce the difficulties, problems which is exist in currents traditional business. Many industries have problems regarding the customer relationships, and for progress of industries need to implement the ERP/ERM tools in the organizations it increases the productivity of the company and the outcomes also helps to increase the growth of companies and it helps to maintain the relationships with the customers.Gelogo et al., (2014) explained the Enterprise resource planning (ERP) as a business process management software that allows an organization to use a system of integrated applications to manage the business and automate back office functions. Moreover, ERP software integrates all facets of an operation, including product planning, development, manufacturing processes, sales and marketing. ERP system is not a new concept. Also used in business industry a long time ago. However, in the fast growing technological advances, the mobile ERP System concept was introduced. As much as mentioned the contemplation of ERP to be mobilized is a challenging idea. Finally, introduced a mobile ERP system with the concept of SaaS cloud.
V. Theoretical Framework General Benefits of Enterprise Systems :Exchanging the complex systems with the standard cross functional transaction
system, ERP has the ability to use source data which integrates the enterprise functions as sales, distribution, managements, planning, financial accounting, control and management of human resources (Cohen et al., 2010). As mentioned earlier, ERP system provided by smart phones and iPads is assumed to reduce the order cycle times, which leads to the improvement, direct customer response time and the speed in delivery. This is due to the automatic financial transaction, cash to cash and the required time in order to minimize the patch financial data at the end of the year (Curado et al., 2006). This system ERP within the smart phones can collect all the enterprise data at the same time, stores them centrally, and then performs the update in the exact time according to the synchronization setting of the smart phone. This yields a greatly facilitation of the governance of the organization (David et al., 2012). IT-based SCM systems coordinate and incorporate the complete flow of knowledge, materials as well as financial situation and also enhance functional along with company preparing. The particular real-time organizing abilities of SCM techniques permit organizations to be able to behave swiftly in order to demand and supply adjustments, helping customers in a well-timed and extensive way (Ding et al., 2009). By reducing inventory ranges, having charges, spoilage and also guide times, SCM systems can immediately boost supply management and boost earnings by way of a reduction of expenses, steering clear of lost product sales and also improving customer satisfaction. Reduced coordination, sales, basic and admin charges, improved upon decision-making and projecting are additional advantages produced via SCM system utilization. According to its capacity of data revealing, collaborative organizing and also forecasting replenishment, the SCM method will also lead to advancements in selections upon buy amount,
| Volume 1| Issue 5 |
www.ijrtem.com
| July 2016| 13
Case Study, Cairo-Amman Bank-Jordan… lowered some time and expenses associated with order running or even elevated order wavelengths coupled with reduced lead period (Effeney et al., 2013). Providing the appropriate facilities, at the. Grams. permitting effective salesforce hands free operation, central client data warehousing and also data exploration associated with choice help and reporting tools, CRM systems help the development of medium-term relationships together with clients (Ehlers et al., 2000). The Customer Relationship Management system is furthermore expected to result in excellent client commitment, reduced cost of product sales as well as providers or perhaps enhanced bottom-line earnings. It cuts down on replication in information admittance as well as upkeep by any centralized firm-wide data source regarding customer info, capturing each of their wants and needs (Eisenhardt et al., 2000). Additionally, these databases replenish systems taken care of through individual sales people, institutionalizes customer relationships and also prevents the loss of organizational consumer knowledge, any time sales staff simply leaves the actual company. The particular database may additionally reduce costs by means of streamlining repeated transactions and purchaser’s processes (Gagnon et al., 2013). Effects of Enterprise Systems on Organization’s Innovational Performance :Enterprise techniques may well get a new organizations innovational efficiency by means of diverse channels. To start with, venture techniques create more improvements immediately based on the benefits they supply (Georgakakis, 2014). The particular firm-wide databases created as well as updated by the ERP method, for instance, provides every staff together with necessary info inside real-time, hence making data-mining out of date and also allowing the employees to be more revolutionary and versatile. ERP techniques may also be anticipated to provide ideal benefits as well as develop additional business improvements, for instance through permitting fresh marketplace techniques or accumulating new process chains (Goodman, 2011). Utilizing a SCM program all departments obtain with time information regarding the time necessary, therefore bottlenecks as well as idle period should be decreased low. Equally systems combined produce A Suitable plus more adaptable working environment and also, with merchandise lifecycles and useful resource usage demonstrated inside real-time, area with regard to procedure improvements and also innovative developments ought to be an easy task to identify (Grant et al., 2004). Additionally, using the company broad data source up to date in real time, the results from the improvements could be directly shown, controlled and also in contrast, offering much more area regarding enhancements. A Customer Relationship Management system, alternatively, could be particularly ideal for productive merchandise improvements because it is data offers a complete picture with the clients wants and requires. Generally, this knowledge of shoppers tastes is anticipated to form the particular company’s innovation good results. Consequently, organizations with CRM methods used need to expertise significant benefits inside item enhancement and style as they can follow a wealthy database of client details and adjust their own creation consequently (Griffiths, 2004). Besides direct effects, enterprise systems may additionally in a roundabout way increase innovational performance as the techniques might create the introduction of some organizational improvements which have shown to aid the era of more innovations (Janczak, 2008). Claims which business units are more progressive when they achieve a more central network position that enables them to entry new information generated through some other models faster. Venture systems match flawlessly into this kind of framework because, specifically, ERP enhances the intern system features from the companies by giving the central databases along with entry for every employee and enterprise device as well as attachment contacts together. As the conversation between the models is quicker by having an ERP program used, the particular innovational action from the organization may also boost. Companies create much more innovative developments together with established upstream, respectively downstream, connections to be able to vendors as well as customers. This argument as they highlight the truly amazing worth of backwards and also horizontal knowledge linkages with regard to method innovations (Juravich, 2012). Making use of their concentrate on connection together with vendors and customers, SCM and Customer Relationship Management methods are expected to keep up current as well as produce new upstream and also downstream contacts much easier, producing a lot more knowledge linkages along the way. For that reason, organizations along with SCM and also CRM techniques in use get access to a large swimming of data, which will, be useful to create much more innovative developments (Khezrlou, 2012).
VI. Research Methodology 4.1 Knowledge Production :In the current study, an innovation, respectively knowledge, and production function are used. Important and basic assumption is that the results of the several inputs which are linked research and ongoing knowledge are presented as the output of the innovation process (Kirsimarja et al., 2010). Augment this operate together with much more advices just like enterprise qualities, company sources and organizational abilities to consider different paths by which information may influence the actual organizations advancement routines into account. Additionally, venture techniques is included within the knowledge manufacturing function, supplying initial insights of the relationship in between venture program ownership as well as the organizations innovational action. In summary, the actual possibility that the company can create both item or even procedure innovations is offered through (Kohlbacher, 2009).
| Volume 1| Issue 5 |
www.ijrtem.com
| July 2016| 14
Case Study, Cairo-Amman Bank-Jordan‌ (1) th
Where, is the i organization’s product or innovation process, expected characteristics for innovations activities, control dummies in the industry, enterprise system used in the organization, and Standard error 4.2 Innovations : Equation (1) expresses the extent enterprise system for innovation tendency, in this section, in order to
detect the importance and impacts of enterprise systems multi innovations belong to the same organization. Intensity process can be written as in Equation (2). (2) Where, is the unhidden inherent variable for more than one organization’s processes, set of expected determinants that affects the number of innovations, the rest of variable are same as Equation (1), enterprise system, and standard error. 4.3 Estimation Process : Considering Equations (1) and (2) with maximum probabilities, rely information techniques must be employed for inference since the advancement depth will be measured through the amount of recognized improvements within this examine. Generally speaking, this kind of two-part model suffers from A range tendency as good info might be available for leaders just. In general, examine however, this choice does not happen because the questionnaire features the right development issue for each and every questioned firm at the end of the list of questions and possesses absolutely no distinctive questions with regard to innovators only (Mezghanni, 2010). This constellation leads to a so named nook remedy, featuring a potentially big proportion associated with zeros in the quantity of improvements. These 0's might occur for several reasons. Generally speaking, considering both hurdle and inflated models that clearly allowing for different treatments for the zeros and positive outputs. The stumbling block or the multi part model, the zeros are calculated by using the density function , so that and
(3)
In order to calculate the positive count which is obtained by the truncated density as (4) In order to ensure that the summation of the probabilities gives one, multiply Equation (4) by Quelling repressors in order to simplify, then the density of the stumbling block is expressed as
.
(5)
This stumbling block model is represented by the reflection of two stages of decision making process, each one as a model with its own decision. These two cases are independent on each other. Therefore, the actual difficulty model could be believed by way of maximum possibility simply by separately maximizing two conditions, one related to the 0's and also the additional one to the actual advantages. The beginning uses the full sample; the second part utilizes only the positive depend findings. Here appears that the zero inflated system is completely differs from the other model with , assuming that for all . Where, in the other system the zero inflated combines directly with , with density . in the case of zero value for the binary process and a probability of , then the result y is also zero. While, the case when binary process gets value of one with probability , then the result y takes value in ascending order starting from zero from the count density . This yields that the value zero takes place in both models, the density of the zero inflated model is represented as (6)
| Volume 1| Issue 5 |
www.ijrtem.com
| July 2016| 15
Case Study, Cairo-Amman Bank-Jordan‌ Since the zero-inflated design enables a couple of different types of 0's, it is expected to function as more sensible choice regarding inference in the present analysis. Nevertheless, any Voong analyze is used in the following to recognize whether or not the hurdle or perhaps the zero-inflated product is suitable in the given set up. represents the probability, this can be constant or can be parameterized inside the binomial model as logit or even probit. While considering the second part, which can be based on Poisson or even the negative part of binomial distribution. VII. The Data As mentioned earlier, this study employed a database obtained from two computer aided mobile surveys conducted since 2010 by the Cairo Amman Bank in Jordan. Both surveys are focused on the diffusion and use of the information and communication technology (ICT) in Cairo Amman Bank and its branches. Each database contained information about 4000 customers with more than five employees, these databases are representatively chosen from the most important services in the bank. These databases are chosen for the sample which is provided from the credit rating employees or agents. This agency who offers the biggest database on organizations available in Jordan. Moreover, collects basic information about customers as addresses, sectors, organization’s sizes in the market, and sizes in all enterprises that applied to the bank for credits. These selections from the populations of Jordan organizations were stratified according to two size classes, as Jordan and Palestine (East/West) and to several branches in both countries. As many organizations as needed have been asked until all categories were filled. All these are done beside all information on the usage of several ICT applications, beside this, the database provided the usage level of the most important enterprise software as ERP, SCM and CRM. In this study, a dummy variable varied with regard to the usage of each software program which takes the value a single in case a firm utilizes the application at least to some small level or even completely as well as zero otherwise. Additionally, the actual surveys contain information regarding the actual organizations workforce, such as the discuss regarding very skilled staff along with other parameters. According to the start point of the survey as a panel database, the usage of the software reported in the 2010 in order to construct the dummy variables. Nonetheless, the particular effects regarding business techniques about the organization innovational efficiency may to some degree be biased upward bein g a handful of companies may have their business methods reported this season not even set up once they will have generated their innovations. As the year 2010 study began in the month of January, this particular way to obtain internally prejudice should be instead little but despite the fact that, the outcomes ought to be construed cautiously. Inside the subsequent section, the potential size of this particular prejudice will be examined by means of reliable regressions. The actual estimation method making use of enterprise methods documented in 2010 is only able to capture short-term innovational results of a time area addressing two years or perhaps much less between the realized innovation and also the venture program usage. Consequently, the excess reliable regressions will also concentrate on revealing any innovational impacts regarding enterprise systems in the moderate operate. Struggling with cell fatality and a large amount of item-nonresponse, coordinating the info for that a couple of periods results almost 12,100 observations. After dropping the particular consumer banking sector, 11989 observations still left for the last databases. Desk a single displays the actual detailed statistics for your variables found in this study. To employ a well-defined temporary collection good noted enterprise program usage, other informative variables additionally make reference to The entire year 2010. The actual innovation measures, however, are extracted from laptop computer of 2013, taking the innovations inside the duration of the year 2010 to 2012. Furthermore, Table 1 also includes the detailed figures for that financial institution affiliations and also the place inside the eastern respectively western side a part of Jordan for the businesses within the last trial. Table 1: Statistical Summary Variable
Process Innovation acquired in 2010-2012 Amount of process innovations Product acquired innovation in 2010-2012 Amount of product innovations Process innovation in 2007-2009 Product innovations in 2007-2009 Employees (In Jordan) In (Employees) Share of computer workers Share of highly skilled employee Share of medium skilled employees International Organizational of Standardization (ISO) certificated
| Volume 1| Issue 5 |
www.ijrtem.com
Mean
0.6312 3.1026 0.5926 4.9999 0.7449 0.6447 417.00 3.9563 0.4687 0.2189 0.5569 0.4444
S. D.
Dummy Variabl e Yes
4.0556 Yes 9.5978 Yes Yes 635.4 2.1482 0.2298 0.2578 0.2568 Yes
| July 2016| 16
Case Study, Cairo-Amman Bank-Jordan‌ Jordan Tradition No enterprise system ERP SCM CRM All enterprise systems Whole sale as credits Retail trades Transport and postal services Electronic data transfer Technical services Other business
0.2669 0.2269 0.6298 0.4378 0.5239 0.2698 0.0469 0.0598 0.0598 0.0798 0.0962 0.0742
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes yes
Through 2010 to be able to 2012, close to sixty-four percent with the companies noted method innovative developments and also 60 % realized item innovations. The common quantity of process improvements a company has introduced within the mentioned moment area results in three, regarding item innovative developments this actually is a few. Since innovational overall performance is extremely influenced by past innovational expertise, the actual dataset includes two phony variables addressing regardless of whether a strong had been process or item innovator within the span of time associated with '07 to 2009. About 75 percent with the companies within the dataset are usually previous procedure innovators, 46 percent reported past product innovations. Regrettably, the quantity of innovations recognized from the organizations in the time period regarding 2007 in order to 2009 just isn't for sale in the particular databases. In 2010, the typical firm dimensions come down to 213 workers and the imply expense is J.D 22,495.900. The actual imply reveal associated with employees primarily utilizing a pc for work, like a proxy for the ICT power of the actual firm that is thought in order to positively impact any organizations innovational overall performance, comes from around 47 % in the utilized sample. Human money is actually measured through the share of highly skilled employees, which includes diplomas through university and specialized school, and the discuss associated with medium competent workers, such as finished apprenticeships, in-organization trainings or perhaps specialized diplomas. The actual imply discuss regarding very skilled employees comes from about 23 % inside the offered trial, regarding moderate experienced workers this results in concerning 56 percent. The actual certification from the ISO shows that a company can be applied an international standard technique within creating new services or even utilizing fresh procedures. Being ISO certified values the particular tasks from the certificated firm as well as, in general, means they are similar to jobs throughout the world. Inside the books, ISO certification will be argued to absolutely affect innovative developments to some degree, which makes it the feasible option being a control varied in today's research. Around 44 percent from the organizations within the dataset used are ISO licensed. Practically 27 percent with the companies are located inside Jordan. Business techniques are regularly found within the trial used, simply around a quarter with the organizations reviews absolutely no business methods whatsoever. Specifically, typical will be the use of ERP, about 64 % of the noticed organizations count on this technique. SCM techniques are used coming from close to 43 % with the companies contributing to one half with the companies make use of CRM methods. The three enterprise techniques mixed have employment with about 28 percent of the organizations. While Table 2 represents the descriptive of the group with some additional organization dummy control variables, these values were expected to be positive influence for the organizational performance. Mentioning that any organization’s activities are not the only ones to be influenced by the determining of the ICT as much as it is positively affected by certain factors in the organization that allow for more than the flexibility of the employees. Five practices including the control of the estimation procedures are included in order to capture the potential influence of these factors. According to the organizational variables confirming that if the organization includes variable for working hours, job positioning, quality and results in responsibilities or self-dependent working group. As mentioned, the percentage of these organizations that uses these variables are almost varies from 70% using working hours and 19% using job positioning processes. Table 2: Additional Control Variable Working hours Job positioning Quality Units with cost and result responsibilities Self-dependent workgroup
| Volume 1| Issue 5 |
www.ijrtem.com
Mean 0.6998 0.0998 0.4199 0.3788 0.6188
Dummy Variable Yes Yes Yes Yes yes
| July 2016| 17
Case Study, Cairo-Amman Bank-Jordan‌ Where, Table 3 presents the additional statistics of organizations applying enterprise system. While, there is no organization is not using these systems at all, or using them all. In order to compare the average performance of each group with all samples of means as reported in Table 1, for this reason, it is found that it is easy to detect an organization using enterprise software, while each innovation calculation exceeds the average mean. Moreover, the organizations who use the three systems together represents th e highest mean value. Opposite to these readings, the organizations who are not using any system are shown as the lowest values even less than the sample mean. This end result may be seen as a primary clue directed to the thought positive influence regarding business systems about innovational overall performance. Nonetheless, no provide virtually any illustrative data for very diverse influences regarding specific enterprise systems on a single thirteen form of innovative developments because asserted in area two. Customer Relationship Management users usually do not present increased suggest beliefs concerning merchandise improvements and the suggest beliefs associated with ERP or even SCM utilizing agencies are only slightly higher than the ones from CRM people in the case of process innovative developments. Table 3: Descriptive Analysis Variable Recent process innovator Number of process innovations mean Standard Error Recent product innovator Number of product innovations mean Standard Error
No sys. 0.4698 1.7798 2.7697
All Sys. 0.7789 4.0298 4.2478
ERP 0.7198 3.7578 4.3987
SCM 0.7578 3.9278 4.3897
CRM 0.7189 3.5878 4.2698
0.4007 2.1368 5.0389
0.7189 7.1569 10.7986
0.6589 6.0019 10.0089
0.6999 6.8489 10.8697
0.6786 6.1899 10.4489
VIII. Empirical Results Model Selection : Being a starting point with the evaluation procedure, an appropriate product for the given estimation create must be picked. Any bivariate product needs to be useful for procedure and also merchandise innovative developments nevertheless the hypothesis regarding self-reliance regarding each problem terms, because of the employed covariates, is not rejected in the current databases. As a result, a couple of individual designs will be useful for inference. Within the following estimations, both specs are used, some single parsimonious standards with no pointed out further company handle variables and another one capturing the effects of these handle variables too. For the evaluation from the binary process succumbed Equation (1), probit model is actually picked. Choosing the appropriate evaluation way for Equation (2), a probability percentage analyze evaluating the particular Poisson model while (distribution parameter alpha = 0) contrary to the damaging binomial dispersed choice because of the used covariates denies the theory regarding Poisson submission use in favor of the damaging binomial syndication significantly at the one per cent level regarding equally types of improvements. Testing the actual zero-inflated against the hurdle model the particular Vuong-Test lastly, implies that the actual zero-inflated product explains the info best for procedure along with product improvements. The test data tend to be tabulated within Table 4. Given these types of outcomes, piled towards the zero-inflated negative binomial design with regard to inference, that signifies there are a couple of different types of zero innovative developments noted from the organizations. The initial kind refers towards the non-innovators, who decide never to innovate almost all. The next kind of zeros, nonetheless, records potential leaders, who statement absolutely no innovative developments not simply because right now there will not innovate but Perhaps as a result of disappointment introducing the innovations within their organization. Consequently, the binary method that is believed in the probit the main zero-inflated product is created within the following method: The worth one records just about all non-innovators, people businesses that are not willing to innovate at all. The particular supporting function, indicated by the need for absolutely no within the binary method, contains all potential innovators, those organizations which have realized some innovative developments and those businesses willing to innovate but dealing with absolutely no innovative developments as a result of failure associated with realizing these. The second unfavorable binomial area of the product utilizes only possible leader s; therefore, its coefficients has to be translated having this symptom in thoughts. In addition to enabling these two different varieties of 0's, the actual zero-inflated design can be completely identified Set up exact same covariates operate in both parts of the design. Defining likelihood test using supremum function as shown in Equation (7) (7)
| Volume 1| Issue 5 |
www.ijrtem.com
| July 2016| 18
Case Study, Cairo-Amman Bank-Jordan‌ Table 4: Model Selection Process Variable Process Innovation Likelihood Test 449.1968 Voung Test 6.0049 Where,
6.2 Short Run Impacts of Enterprise Systems on Process :Visualizing the actual pointed out short-term relationship regarding a couple of years or less, Table 5 is the appraisal results of the particular zero-inflated negative binomial product regarding process innovative developments. Order a single as well as (3) of Table 5 exhibit equally requirements, the actual parsimonious a sin gle as well as a single including the company handle parameters, for that propensity of being a non-innovator. As a result, the event of being a potential head is actually captured inside the complementarity possibility. Line (two) as well as several regarding Stand 5, alternatively, statement the particular evaluation most current listings for both specs with the unfavorable binomial the main model. Because this study centers specifically on the impacts of venture methods about innovational overall performance. Needlessly to say, the parsimonious appraisal for method innovative developments implies that the actual ownership of a SCM method significantly diminishes the probability of being a non-innovator and accordingly increases the prospect of as a prospective chief. This particular outcome retains additionally When the specs effortlessly further control variables is applied, even though the coefficient associated with SCM reduces in size and degree of value. ERP and Customer Relationship Management method usage, however, displays absolutely no effect at all. Thinking about some other coefficients in Column (3), previous method leaders and organizations with established quality circles expertise a lower odds of non-innovation when compared with agencies without former procedure innovational action or simply no quality groups. An obtained ISO qualification furthermore generally seems to reduce the probability of getting absolutely no process innovations in any way, despite the fact that simply inside the parsimonious specs. The actual reveal regarding very skilled employees, on the other hand, displays any considerably optimistic impact on it is likely that as a non-innovator. This particular complicated impact appears to account for the truth which in contrast to merchandise improvements, process innovative developments may, in general, it be initiated through the highly trained workforce however simply by low to be able to method skilled employees operating immediately inside the manufacturing collection. Furthermore, an extremely percentage associated with highly trained workers may possibly mirror information intensive agencies, which, generally, don't have got big production processes together with much space regarding marketing. Conditional on as being a prospective process-innovator, the particular usage of the ERP method is firmly positive related to the quantity of procedure innovative developments within the short-run. This kind of holds for your parsimonious standards and for the particular specs such as extra organizational control factors, although the coefficient confronts a reduction in size inside the second standards. SCM methods, on the other hand, neglect to substantially improve the quantity of procedure innovations any progressive firm finds out. Use of the CRM method furthermore does not have an impact about the intensity of method improvements. Furthermore, being a previous procedure head and a purchased ISO accreditation present a very considerable, good influence on the amount of method innovations within 2010 to 2013, even though both coefficients reduction in dimension and value within the second specs with additional business variables integrated. Linking each product parts, Table 5 also contains the particular approximated unconditional marginal outcomes at suggest associated with enterprise system usage. Not surprisingly, the particular marginal results of ERP and SCM are usually optimistic and also substantial in the specs indicating a rise in the quantity of method improvements on average for businesses which usually follow either system, despite the fact that ERP looks slightly more effect because the minor result regarding ERP outmatches the effect associated with SCM in proportions. Not surprisingly, the result of CRM remains entirely unimportant. Table 5: Determinants of the Number of Process Innovations, Zero-Inflated Negative Binomial Estimates Variable In labor Robust Standard Error Share of computer employees Robust error Share of high skilled employees Robust error Share of medium skilled employees
| Volume 1| Issue 5 |
Specification 1 Probit Model N. Binomial -.0268 0.0298 0.0398 0.0298 -0.3489 0.1009 0.2649 0.1689 0.7475 -0.2569 0.4079 0.2709 0.3509
www.ijrtem.com
-0.0713
Specification 2 Probit Model N. Binomial 0.0087 0.0176 0.0487 0.0298 -0.3598 0.1059 0.2729 0.1738 0.7269 -0.2939 0.4229 0.2768 0.3126
-0.1187
| July 2016| 19
Case Study, Cairo-Amman Bank-Jordan‌ Robust error
0.3124
0.2136
0.3088
0.2176
ISO certificated Robust error
-0.2706
0.2306
-0.1369
0.0879
0.1423
0.0919
0.1489
0.0849
Organization had process last period Robust error
-0.3689
0.2619
-0.3009
0.2427
0.132
0.0986
0.1398
0.1056
ERP Error
-0.1409
0.2819
-0.1104
0.2789
0.1378
0.1049
0.1384
0.1054
SCM Error
-0.3182
0.0642
-0.2839
0.0589
0.1374
0.0768
0.1529
0.0963
CRM Error
-0.1812
-0.0679
-0.1979
-0.1029
0.1334
0.0939
0.1409
0.0949
Account for working hours Error
-0.1479
-0.0499
0.1379
0.0968
Job positioning Error
-0.0009
-0.0069
0.1839
0.1019
Quality Circles Error
-0.4849 0.1489
0.0759 0.0789
Units with own cost and responsibilities Errors
-0.1149
0.1059
0.1497
0.0897
Self-dependent workgroup Error
0.1249
0.0629
0.0149
0.0939
Constant Error
0.3298
1.1008
0.3119
1.1289
0.3748
0.2589
0.4029
0.2678
Alpha Error
0.4879
0.4889
0.1249
0.1323
Overall effect ERP Error
0.9698
0.9219
0.1249
0.132
Overall effect SCM Error
0.6239
0.5559
0.2919
0.2999
Overall effect CRM Error
0.0569
-0.0239
0.2879
0.2878
Number of observations
11989
Non-zero observations
6998
Zero observations
4991
6.3 Medium Run Impacts and Robustness Checks : Table 6 represents the values of the likelihood ratio tests by applying Equation (7) and vuong test for the robustness check in order to select a model. The results are obtained and tabulated in Table 6. Table 6: Robustness Check for Model Selection Variable Process Innovations Likelihood ratio test 175.8976 Vuong test 4.7896
| Volume 1| Issue 5 |
www.ijrtem.com
| July 2016| 20
Case Study, Cairo-Amman Bank-Jordan‌ In order to determine the determinants of the number of process innovations, zero inflated negative binomial estimation using enterprise system. The results are tabulated in Table 7. Table 7: Determinants of the Number of Process Innovations Variable
In labor Robust Standard Error
Specification 1 Probit N. Model Binomial -0.0178 0.0498 0.0697 0.0413
Specification 2 Probit N. Model Binomial 0.0598 0.0619 0.0897 0.0479
Share of computer employees Robust error
-0.0798 0.3409
0.2769 0.2149
-0.0362 0.3978
0.3829 0.2349
Share of high skilled employees Robust error
0.7329 0.5587
-0.4179 0.3808
0.8519 0.6819
-0.5198 0.3908
Share of medium employees Robust error ISO certificated Robust error
-0.1679 0.4669
-0.3189 0.334
-0.1839 0.5069
-0.4119 0.3449
-0.2849 0.1919
0.3059 0.1319
-0.2259 0.2264
0.1409 0.1409
-0.3552 0.2059
0.2468 0.1498
-0.2819 0.2239
0.2507 0.1649
-0.2189 0.2110
0.2222 0.1550
-0.1101 0.2965
0.3021 0.1987
SCM Error
0.0459 0.2349
0.1639 0.1349
0.0819 0.2619
0.1389 0.1389
CRM Error
-0.1919 0.2329
-0.0439 0.1289
-0.1958 0.2468
-0.0749 0.1198
Account for working hours Error
-0.1598 0.2698
-0.2489 0.1659
Job positioning Error
-0.2829 0.2679
0.0568 0.1339
Quality Circles Error
-0.5098 0.2269
0.1649 0.1289
-0.3569 0.2319
0.0468 0.1149
0.0398 0.2059
-0.0958 0.1229
0.4939 0.6569
1.5939 0.4449
Organization period Robust error ERP Error
skilled
had process last
Units with own cost responsibilities Errors Self-dependent workgroup Error Constant Error
and
0.6969 0.5729
1.5297 0.4039
Alpha Error
0.409 0.1949
0.4169 0.2058
Overall effect ERP Error
0.8559 0.3607
0.9128 0.3759
Overall effect SCM
0.4149
0.2709
| Volume 1| Issue 5 |
www.ijrtem.com
| July 2016| 21
Case Study, Cairo-Amman Bank-Jordan… Error
0.4567
0.4468
Overall effect CRM Error
0.1218 0.3906
0.0189 0.3827
Number of observations
8457
Non-zero observations
6284
Zero observations
2173
IX. Conclusion Regarding process innovative developments, the final results demonstrate that agencies together with proven SCM techniques encounter a lesser probability of being a non-innovator in comparison to agencies without SCM methods used. Furthermore, the actual ownership of your ERP system favorably impacts the amount of recognized process improvements. These kinds of good effects are not only found short-term dependent in a time horizon associated with two years however arise as well in case a medium-run viewpoint masking a couple of many years is actually taken into account. In the case of merchandise improvements, ERP and also SCM methods entirely fail to effect the organizations innovational efficiency. Businesses utilizing a Customer Relationship Management method, however, face some lesser odds of realizing simply no manufacturing improvements whatsoever when compared with agencies without having CRM systems operating. This optimistic influence is only short-term centered, although and fades away in case a medium-run viewpoint covering a couple of many years is actually taken into account. The results expose a new part of benefits via enterprise system use as, besides predicted productiveness and also effectiveness increases, enterprise techniques additionally create the actual organizations innovational overall performance for equally types of improvements. Rising for the brief and the medium-run, these results have got numerous sensible significance: First of all, managers should not just focus on charges and expected quick changing efficiency rewards whenever deciding to acquire or perhaps improve venture techniques, as the innovational efficiency increase due to business software program use needs time to work to build up. Particularly the improved method innovational overall performance via ERP as well as SCM adoption may, in the long run, actually reduce expenses for your firm in a bigger quantity total when compared to assets within venture systems. Alternatively, cool product innovative developments produced through Customer Relationship Management info may well directly increase businesses economic overall performance by means of checking new market segments or just raising revenue. Any short-coming from the examination, because the present study includes short- and medium-term points of views, is really a time concern. The present dataset provides no way to regulate regarding age of the particular business techniques used since the buy moment wasn't requested. In accordance with that, additionally there is simply no details regarding the agencies legacy system usage and possible implementation difficulties. Future availability of brand new data might provide evidence for these cases. To find out no suspicion, absolutely no example evidence nor a theoretical debate a complementarity relationship on the list of business systems, can foster the innovational effect of enterprise techniques, a result depending on prospective complementarity cannot be eliminated totally. Nevertheless, because the present examination varieties a beginning regarding the connection among innovational performance as well as enterprise methods, exposing any complementarity aspects wasn't any purpose of these studies and it is appropriately given to potential research.
References 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8.
AL-Ghamdi, A. A., Albeladi, K. S., and Alsolamy, A. A. (2013). Change Management for Human in Enterprise Resource Planning Syste m. International Journal of Computer Trends and Technology (IJCTT) – volume 6 number 2, pp. 99-103. Engelstätter, B. (2009). Enterprise Systems and Labor Productivity: Disentangling Combination Effects. Dis cus si on Paper No. 09-040. ftp://ftp.zew.de/pub/zew-docs/dp/dp09040.pdf. Fosser, E., Leister, O. H., and Moe, C. E. (2008). ERP Systems and Competitive Advantage: Some Initial Results. University of Agder, Kristiansand, Norway. Manchester Business School & Copenhagen Business School, pp. 1-13. Gelogo, Y. E., and Kim, H. K. (2014). Mobile Integrated Enterprise Resource Planning System Architecture. School of Information Technology, Catholic University of Daegu, Korea. International Journal of Control and Automation, Vol.7, No.3, pp.379-388. Khamees, R. A. (2013). Overcoming the Challenges of Implementing LMS, ERP and CRM in Traditional Business Environments: Survey. IRACST- International Journal of Research in Management & Technology (IJRMT), ISSN: 2249-9563, Vol. 3, No.1, pp. 5-12. Sarno, R., Djeni, A., Mukhlas, I., & Sunaryono, D. (2015). Developing a Workflow Management System for Enterprise Resource Planning, Journal of Theoretical and Applied Information Technology. 72(3), 412-421. Sheldon, H. (2005). Class A ERP Implementation: Integrating Lean and Six Sigma, Boca Raton, Florida: J. Ross Publishing, Inc. Simunovic, Katica., Simunovic, Goran., Havrlisan, Sara., Pezer, Danijela., & Svalina, Ilija. (2013). The Role of Erp System in Business Process and Education, Tehnicki vjesnik 20(4), 711-719.
| Volume 1| Issue 5 |
www.ijrtem.com
| July 2016| 22
Case Study, Cairo-Amman Bank-Jordan… 9. 10. 11. 12. 13.
Tsai, Bi-Huei & Chou, Shin. (2015). Application of Multiple Output Data Envelopment Analysis in Interpreting Efficiency Improvement of Enterprise Resource Planning Integrated Circuit Firms. The Journal of Developing Areas. 49(1), 285-304. Tsaia, W. H., Leea, K. C., Liub, J. Y., Lina, S. J., & Choua, Y.W. (2012). The influence of enterprise resource planning (ERP) systems performance on earnings management, Enterprise Information Systems, 6(4), 491–517. Veldhoven, R. H. M., & Roermund, A. H. M. (2011). System Quality Indicators. In M. Ismail & M. Sawan (Eds.), Robust Sigma Delta Converters (pp. 13-26). Netherlands: Springer. Vikkraman, P., & Duraikannan, A. (2015). Linkage between Customer Relationship Management and Its Consequences in Life Insurance Industry: A Customer Centric Analysis, International Journal of Applied Engineering 10(8), 20715-20724. Wittemann, Matthew., & Ables, Geoff. (2011). Microsoft Dynamics CRM 2011 Administration Bible, Indiana, Indiana polis: Wiley Publishing Inc.
| Volume 1| Issue 5 |
www.ijrtem.com
| July 2016| 23