J ul i e nNol i n MAr c hSe m.I I I
Se t e mpbe r2015J auar y2016
Manaus , Amaz onas , Br az i l
Ar c hi t e c t ur ea nd Ex t r e meEnv i r onme nt s
I ns t i t ut eofAr c hi t e c t ur e andTe c hnol ogy
RoyalDani s hAc ade my ofFi neAr t s
st ayi ng afloat . /devi ce
por t f ol i o. AnAr c hi t e c t ur a l De v i c ePor t f ol i o
Edi t e dwor kofade vi c ei nve s t i gat i onf oc us e dont he t heBr az i l i anc i t yofManausandi t ss ur r oundi ngs . Compl e t e dbe t we e nt hemont hsofSe pt e mbe rand De c e mbe rof2015.
INTRODUCTION
01 of 39
Map of Brazil Manaus Located
MANAUS
Amazon River
Rio Negro Rio Solimões
INTRODUCTION Located in the heart of the Amazon rain forest, is the city of Manaus. Located in Amazonas, Brazil’s fourth poorest State according to the World Bank1, a city that has seen itself rise to great riches in the end of the 20th century due to a large rubber boom, and fall to solemn depths after the boom’s eventual crash. In an attempt to revive the city in the heart of the Amazon jungle, Manaus was named a ‘Free Trade Zone’ in the late 1960’s, throwing it onto a course led by capitalist industrial pressures, leaving the urban fabric in disarray. Its proximity to the rivers leave it exposed to its fluctuating shifts and behaviors. In such an active environment, what role can architecture and technology play towards a sustainable future? The following portfolio covers four months of work focused on the city of Manaus and its surrounding areas. It is divided into three main phases: Phase 1: The Amazon, Data Collection; Phase 2: Device for Investigation; and Part 3: Expedition & Field Work. 1 “WB/Brazil: Improving Financial Resource Management in the State of Amazonas.” World Bank. N.p., n.d. Web. 09 Jan. 2016.
THE AMAZON: DATA COLLECTION
02 of 39
September 2015
PHASE 1: THE AMAZON: DATA COLLECTION The Gathering of Information Regarding the Brazilian city of Manaus and its Surroundings
The first phase of the semester focused on data collection regarding the location of our expedition and device testing: the city of Manaus, Brazil. The gathered information was grouped into various themes of interest, attempting to grasp as vast a understanding as possible of the location, with the goal of discovering what conditions or are specific to this precise area of the world. The research was to be explored through and clearly represented in infographic form. The goal was to visually map the information in a coherent and precise manner. Broad research was to done to get a vast database of information to be able to decipher and identify the key aspects of all fields and visually reconstruct them into clear graphically curated information. Information was grouped into various themes, from history, to traditional techniques, to technologies, to resources, to geology, geography, to rivers, to industry, to demography, to land exploitation, and international trade. The exercise was performed in order to get a clear idea of the various characteristics that make Manaus such a unique place. From this research, one could focus on an area of interest from which to develop a device, that could respond to the specific environment. Through exploring these various themes, several fields of interest stood out to me as possible areas of interest. Namely, two themes were of particular interest: “Rivers: Flows and Flooding” and “Climate”.
THE AMAZON: DATA COLLECTION
03 of 39
BRAZIL: MANAUS AND THE AMAZON
THE AMAZON BASIN
THE MEETING BETWEEN NEGRO, SOLIMOES & AMAZON RIVER
Rivers, Flow & Flooding
MANAUS
worlds largest and strongest river basin covers 40 % of South America
Amazon Solimoes
The Amazon River Basin is the largest and strongest in the world due to it’s incredible size and flow. Caused by deforestation, climate changes has taken a severe turn on the consequenses to the state of the ecosystem of Amazonas.
17 MAIN RIVERS LENGTH 6.400 KM
Flooding 2004
Early sailors could drink freshwater out of the ocean before sighting the South American continent
AREA OF WATER IN THE AMAZON BASIN
Average discharge 209,000 cubic m/s
49 %
Flooding 2009
average wet season
RIVER OCEAN E H T
Sediments from the Andes mountains gives the AMAZON RIVER it’s muddy colour
Rainy season discharge 300,000 cubic m/s
15 %
Amazon Solimoes
8233 cubic km fresh water
Known as the world’s second longest river after the Nile, but due to new discoveries in lenght, Amazon River might also take the prize as the world’s longest river
Negro
sediment swept into the ocean each day
USA plans to make a water connection to Brazil, since it contains the largest amount of ground water in the world
2.600.000 square km
MORE THAN 1100 TRIBUTARIES
MANAUS
3.001.585 cubic m
240 km into the Atlantic
7,050,000 square km
Negro
General Overview of Hydrology
POLITICAL DISCUSSION
The flow of the effluent into the Atlantic is so strong, that the waters of the Amazon River do not even begin to mix with the ocean water until the water has flowed
average wet season 1.200.000.000 x
Rainforest Water
per second
S ZONA AMA
s in the world by size River
Russia has half the amount of fresh water
2.5
but the country is times bigger than Brazil
The Amazon's daily freshwater discharge into the Atlantic is enough to supply New York City's freshwater needs for
M AN AU S
DROUGHT Long term climate change will modify river flows and lead to a reduction of recharge in aquifers in 2050 severe reduction in recharge of
9 years O NG CO
70%
20 %
Hundreds of
of the fresh water entering the world’s oceans
ISSIPI MISS
communities are stranding during drought - rivers are the most important way of transportation more than
10.000.000 fish are killed during the worst droughts
FLOODING ALL OTHE R R I V E R S IN T HE W ORL D
241
10-year cycles but rivers have overflowed significantly every year for the last three years Villages are vanishing Through flood periods the rivers expands their width and rises up to 9 m
INACTIVE OIL WELLS
151 PLANNED DAMS WILL CAUSE
Coast line
disruption in the connectivity of free-flowing rivers
Blend zone
TEMPERATURE MEASUREMENTS IN INACTIVE OIL WELLS, LED TO THE DISCOVERY OF UNDERGROUND RIO HAMZA
Hamza River
100 square km
Fresh water ecosystems
of flooded forest
Small rivers Amazonas main rivers
9
Rises up to m through flooding
Dams GEOGRAPHIC EXTENT OF THE AMAZON RIVER BASIN
DEPTH OF RIVERS
AMAZON RIVER 21.146,640 KM per year 0 KM
The Am on azon River Basin within Legal Amaz
per 1000 square KM Basin area Freshwater eco system area
0M
1400
-4 KM
1200
-20 M
HAMZA RIVER 0.001 KM per year
1000
CHANGE OF FLOW
800
-50 M
1.5 % WATER
600
400
RINGWOODITE MINERAL inside diamond
200
-100 M
Madeira
Amazonas mainstream
Negro
Araquaia - Tocantins
Xingu
Tapajós
Purus
Ucayali
Maranón
Juruá
Caquetá-Japurá
Miocene period 23 - 1 million years ago
Trombetas
Present
Napo
Cretaceous period 145 - 65 million years ago
Putumayo-Icá
0
Elevation 5.170 m
THE AMOUNT OF WATER INSIDE THE RARE MINERAL INDICATES A RESEVOIR OF WATER INSIDE THE EARTH’S TRASITION ZONE WITH A TOTAL OF ALL OCEANS PUT TOGETHER
HAMZA RIVER has in compare to Amazon River a width between -400 KM
200 -400 km
AVERAGE RIVER WIDTH 1,6 KM 10 KM
RIVER WIDTH WHEN FLOODED 40 KM
CREDIT: ASTRID BLICHFELDT
Due to it’s drain system The Amazon Basin is know as the deep plate ORIGIN - The Amazon Basin was a big lake 25.000 years ago
There are three types of flooded forests; Varzea forests which are fed by MUDDY RIVERS, Igapo forests located in BLACKWATER and CLEARWATER tributaries, and tidal forest located in the estuary.
THE AMAZON: DATA COLLECTION
04 of 39
BRAZIL: MANAUS AND THE AMAZON
Climate: The Amazon Basin Global Mechanisms and Anomalies - Local Effects
Horse Latitude 30°N Tropic of Cancer 23.5°N
d
s
de Tra
in W
Equator 0°
e ad Tr
Wind
ind W
Warm Current
s
Cold Current
Tropic of Capricorn 23.5°S Horse Latitude 30°S
s li e er st We
Hyper Arid Arid Semi Arid Dry Sub-Humid Humid
Trade Winds The trade winds are created by varm waters in the oceans close to the equator and blow consistently from east to west, picking up humidity on it´s way towards South America. This humidity provides the Amazone Basin with approximately 50% of it´s annual rainfall.
Provides the Amazon with:
50% of its
annual precipitation
Transpiration
Sahara Dust
The Amazon’s cover of rainforrest fuels its own precipitation through transpiration. Transpiration is the trees own ability to recycle water and release it back into the atmosphere through their biological processes.
Dust from the Shara provides the Amazon with vital neutrients. An annual estimat of 27.7 million tons is carried by the trade winds across the Atlantic to reach the Amazon. The dust contains an aproximated
The Amazon can receive as much
Provides the Amazon with:
Inter Tropical Convergence Zone
22.000
25% to 50% of its annual precipi-
ITCZ is a convection zone created by the converging trade winds, just north of the equator. It spans the intire atlantic ocean and mainland south america where it provides the Amazon Basin with precipitation through the distribution of humid sea air.
as tons of phosphorus annualy from the Sahara dessert
tation
22 000 tons of phosphorus, which plants need to build protein. The amount is almost enough to replenish the phosphorus that is lost through when decomposing material is washed away by the river.
40 30
El Nino and La Nina El Ninio and La Ninia, or the Southern Oscillatin are reoccuring events that cause anomolies in the South Pacific and South American climate. In the event of an “el Nino” the cold water current that provides the South American Pacific coast with fresh cold water from Antarctica is reduced or reversed resulting in warm temperatures and high surface pressure. In the event of a “la Nina” the same cold water current increases and will result in colder temperatures and low surface pressure. These events will last up to four years with varying intensity
20
Fluctuations in South Pacific Surface pressure corresponding to El Nino and La Nina (South Oscillation Index) 1880 to 2012
10 0 - 10
La Nina
- 20
El Nino
- 30 - 40
1880
1890
1900
1910
1920
1930
1940
1950
1960
1970
1980
2000
1990
The Amazon Basin
3000 mm
2700 mm
2400 mm
2100 mm
1800 mm
1500 mm
1200 mm
900
mm
300
mm
mm
10°N Eq 0°S 10°S 20°S 30°S
ITCZ Annual Drift Across The Basin, Corresponding with Precipitation Levels
CREDIT: ØYVIND ANDREAS LIMI
Total Annual Temperature Dec
Nov
Oct
Sep
Aug
Jul
Jun
Apr
May
Mar
(by Latitude) Feb
(by Latitude)
Average Monthly Temperature Jan
Dec
Nov
Oct
Sep
Aug
Jul
Jun
May
Apr
Mar
Feb
10°N
500mm 300mm 100mm
600
Toatal Annual Precipation
(by Latitude)
(by Latitude)
2269mm
33c°
24c°
1420mm
32c°
23c°
2307mm
31c°
23c°
2255mm
32c°
21c°
914mm
27c°
19c°
50c° 30c° 10c°
Avergage Monthly Precipitation Jan
Annual Total Precipation by Area
Night Day
2010
THE AMAZON: DATA COLLECTION
05 of 39
BRAZIL: MANAUS AND THE AMAZON
Climate: Manaus
Global Mechanisms and Anomalies - Local Effects
30m
25m
20m
15m
10m
7m
Flood Map Manaus
In Meters above sea level
30 -5
3m
Man aus ,B ra z
i
S 06 3° 0 l,
1W, Altitude : 2 6 0 °0 0
Contours every 2 meters
1997 Draught
2009 Flood
- El Ninio-related - Rioa Negro level at 16 m
- La Nina related - Cost 5.5 million usd in aid money - Rio Negro level at 29,6 m
2005 Draught - Rio Negro level at 15,5 m - Possible cause, low pressure anomalies in the tropical north Atlantic ocean causing reduced convection and percipitation
Manaus Flood Chart 1993 to 2010 In meters above sea level
2012 Flood
1997 Draught
- Possible cause, Cool South Atlantic, warm North Atlantic -Rio Negro level at 29,97
2010 Draught
2014 Flood
- El Nino-related - 62.000 families affected - Cost 13.5 billion usd in aid money - 8 billion tons of co2 released (China: 7,7 billion tons annualy)
- Possible cause, warm conditions in the western Pacific-Indian Ocean and with an exceptionally warm Subtropical South Atlantic. The South Atlantic SST gradient is a
25
2012 Flood Fluctuations in South Pacific surface pressure corresponding to
El Nino and La Nina
20
La Nina
main driver for moisture transport from the Atlantic toward south-western Amazon, and this became ex-
El Nino
ceptionally intense during summer of 2014.
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998 1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005 2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
Manaus
60 c° 55 c° 50c° 45c° 40c° 35c° 30c° 25c° 20c° 15c° 10c° 5c° 0c°
600mm 550mm 500mm 450mm 400mm 350mm 300mm 250mm 200mm 150mm 100mm 50mm 0mm Day
Night
Temperatures in Manaus are fairly stable throughout the year and seasons are based on wet and dry seasons. Being possitioned right under the equatorial belt means that Manaus receives a constant exposure of sunlight all year around at almost a 90 degree angle.
CREDIT: ØYVIND ANDREAS LIMI
Sep
(kmh) according to Beauforts scale
Oct Nov Dec
Jul Aug
May
Jun
Average Yearly Windspeed
Storm 100kmh
100% 90% 80% 70% 60% 50% 40% 30%
Light Breeze 12kmh
20% 10% Day
Seasons in Manaus are influensed by the amount of precipitation. June to November define the dry season and December to May make up the wet season with its peak in March.
Mar Apr
Jan Feb
Dec
Nov
Oct
Sep
Average Monthly Humidity Aug
Jul
Jun
May
Apr
Mar
Feb
Jan
Dec
Nov
Oct
Average Monthly Precipitation Sep
Aug
Jul
Jun
May
Apr
Mar
Feb
Jan
Average Monthly Temperature
Night
Humidity levels in Manaus are fairly constant during the night and vary more, according to the amount of precipitation and sunlight, during the day.
Winds Speeds are constant throughout the year and will mostly vary during the day when the the temperature fluctuations are higher than on an avergae yearly basis.
2012
DEVICE FOR INVESTIGATION
06 of 39
October 2015
PHASE 2-A: DEVICE FOR INVESTIGATION Device Explorations Through Various Media
Initial research of the city of Manaus revealed various hyper-specificities with their associated problematics. My focus was on the issue of flooding, or more broadly, on the extreme shifts in water level that affect the city, as well as on the condition of the city’s favelas, their sporadic access to electricity, and they’re relationship to the increasingly fluctuating waters. Manaus is located along the Rio Negro, where it famously meets the Rio Solimões to become the Amazon River, having impressive water level variations between seasons of up to 12 meters.4 The city’s intimate relationship to this phenomenon has been accentuated since being named a free trade zone, with a shift in the city’s focus towards port activity and industrial development along the water. With the spotlight on the market-driven economy, its inhabitants have been left in the shadows, a quarter of them living in extreme poverty.1 The specific river-edge conditions have resulted in a vernacular of construction on wooden pillars, known in Brazil as ‘palafittes’. With the tumultuous nature of current global environmental tendencies, the city has increasingly seen a pattern of floods followed by droughts. In such an active environment by the Rio Negro, static solutions have proven ineffective. Rising above the water in fear of its contact was a temporary solution that is failing to adapt to current conditions. Construction in these areas now have an opportunity to directly engage with the water, seen as an inhibitor and to shift water’s role into an allied one, as is being done in some few cases in floating villages along the river. These factors led me to the design of an architectural device addressing these specific issues, which was brought to Manaus to test its potential and feasibility of alleviating these issues.
1
“WB/Brazil: Improving Financial Resource Management in the State of Amazonas.” World Bank. N.p., n.d. Web. 09 Jan. 2016.
DEVICE FOR INVESTIGATION
07 of 39
September 2015
Three Potential Devices Based on the Data Collection Stage, Three Potential Devices Ideas Were Explored through Sketches
Kinetic Power Device The device utilizes kinetic energy through impact and stretching to generate power through a very well none symbol of Brazilian culture: the football. A center core would house the power generation system which would bet held by a deployable structure with Piezzo discs at each extremity where the ball skin is, also where the impact happens, thus creating a electrical current for every contact.
1 Navigation Device Aiding in The navigation of the highly fluctuating Amazon River, the device would act as a buoy integrated with a sensor being able to determine the depth of the river at that position, and emitting a different colored light based on the depth. A front fin would keep the device perpendicular to the current, in order to keep the current flowing through the miniature hydroelectric turbine. By multiplying the device, the conglomerate can serve as mapping system, to monitor rising river levels more accurately and point out danger areas. Together they could inform the safest path to take for ships, even different paths for different sized ships (some necessitating more or less water to navigate).
2 Floating + Power Device Three major problems that affect Favelas in Manaus. Flooding: Forces families to leave their homes during the flood period. Does serious damage to their home structures. Plastic Waste: With the emergence of new industries in Manaus due to the FTZ, plastic waste has been pilling up near slums. Access to Electricity: A large portion of the population has very limited access to electricity, especially during a flood. This device aims to alleviate these problems by providing floating attachments made of compacted plastic waste, also providing power through hydroelectricity.
3
DEVICE FOR INVESTIGATION
08 of 39
October 2015
Device Development Further Development of Device Idea 3: The Floating + Power Device
Common Favela House
‘Palafittes’
The typical house lays on a foundation or simply on the ground. The building materials used for the homes must meet three major criteria: be low cost, light enough to be carried on men’s backs, and small enough to pass through the narrow streets of the favela. As a result, all the houses are built with bricks; concrete pillars are used for the structure; floors are made from floor beams and slabs; and the roof is almost always corrugated iron.
In Manaus, like other flood-prone areas, many houses are raised on wooden pillars to rise above the potentially dangerous water levels. This type of housing solution is mostly found near bodies of water like the Amazon river and its tributaries.
3
Rising Water Levels
While in most cases of water level rising, the typical Manaus Favela home will be safe from water, floods have been recurring at an accelerated pace, putting many houses in harm’s way, forcing dwellers out of their homes, only returning when the flood has subsided, only to find a damaged home in need of repair. Flooding in urban areas where the streams are contaminated also brings not only economic damage but also social problems including disease. Experts say extreme flooding normally happens in 10-year cycles but rivers have overflowed significantly every year for the last three years.
4
Floating Above Floods
The most straightforward was to deal with a flood situation is to literally float above it. This system would attach to the legs of the house, and let it float above the water level. This would however require some type of moving joint where the house attaches to the pilotis, but in the end the cost and time to do so is lesser than having to rebuild the home after being damaged by the flood. The concept has been explored, as it is an obvious and viable way of dealing with floods, but has not been applied to its full potential, neither has it been created to generate power form the water.
Types of Turbines and Generators Through sketches, I cataloged the various types of turbines and electrical generators that used water as their driving force. While many different types and/ or combinations were appropriate, a variation of the ‘point absorber’ type of wave generated power seemed most appropriate. Ease of construction was also a deciding factor in the move toward this type of power generation.
DEVICE FOR INVESTIGATION
5
Detached House
In the event of a flood, where water levels reach the base of the house, the device will lift the house above the water, which will also lift the house from its pillars (assuming it has been detached). Thus a joint or connection must be designed to accommodate for this detachment. If not the house will inevitable drift away.
09 of 39
6
Power Generation at Varying Water Levels Having the device connected the house’s floor means its effective is entirely dependent on the water level having reached the house’s base. A device which follows the water level while still generating power would prove most more efficient. Power can be generated in a number of ways through the use of water power, yet the focus of this device has remained on power from the Amazon River’s current and from the waves of Manaus’ high traffic maritime ports.
7
8
One possibility for generating power from the river would be to use its current as the driver force of turbines attached to the buoys, which then connect to the house to either directly power a source or to store the electricity in a battery.
Another possibility for generating power is wave power. Due to the high frequency of freight and passenger ships that enter and leave manaus due to its high population and its industrial focus.
The downside to the method is the inconsistent current direction and forces at the edge of a river, where am ideal position is at the center of the river.
A high number of waves generated by these ships hit the shore, their energy wasted. Why not capitalize on this near-constant influx of waves to generate electricity for the numerous ‘palafittes’ situated along the river.
Power Generation from River Current
Power Generation from Waves
Potential Device Prototypes Various versions of the device were explored through sketches as well. They looked at various construction techniques and designs as well as using various types of turbines and generators.
DEVICE FOR INVESTIGATION
10 of 39
October 2015
Device Development 1 Sketches of Possible Prototype
Sketch Explorations Through the use of sketches, the device’s possible designs became increasingly attuned to the stability and transportability of the construct. The device generates power through electromagnetic induction and in order to do so, the magnets must move through the coils, independently from them. This version of the device attached itself to the bottom of the home the pillars held up. A floating ring would move around a coil surrounding the pillar. The downside to this design was the lack of adaptability to different water levels. In other words, it would only work when the water was at flood levels. A better design would allow the entire device to be free to move vertically with shifting water levels, and be loosely attached around the pillar. Finally the floaters, being very buoyant and thus sensitive to waves, and the inner core being less buoyant, would allow relative movement between the magnets and the coils, and thus create energy from electromagnetic induction.
DEVICE FOR INVESTIGATION
11 of 39
October 2015
Device Development 2 Sketches of Possible Prototype
Towards a Final Design The device acts as an attachment to the palafittes. Connecting around their wooden pillars, it could provide the necessary buoyancy to lift a home to safety in the event of a flood, additionally generating power from wave movement due to the high naval activity on the Rio Negro, transforming the traditional column into a power-generating pillar. Each yellow buoy acts independently, generating its own power based on its wave-affected movement. The buoys could then be attached to a battery, charging while the device is in the water connected to the house above. Unapologetically technocentric in aesthetics, material choice and functionality, the device was designed with the intention to separate itself visually from its host structure, to start a discussion about the functional elements of our built environment. Exposing these functions could promote engagement between its micro-workings and its macro surroundings, and holds the potential to form a new relationship of understanding and responsibility between its inhabitants and the functional forces that they utilize. Thus challenging ideas of building components and how active their role could be. Beyond that, it confronts our spatial understandings, how we perceive and interact with the surrounding ecology.
DEVICE DEVELOPMENT
12 of 39
October 2015
PHASE 2-B: DEVICE DEVELOPMENT The Development and Hand Assembly of Separate Physical Components
Ultimately, the device idea number 3 was chosen to be developed further. Multiple aspects of the design needed to be explored and tested physically, necessitating a better understanding of the technological aspect of the physics involved in generating power from wave movement. Through the dismantling and study of old DC motor and generators, I was able to design a first prototype through 3D modeling. This prototype was then made physical to test the functioning of the device as well as measure structural and material durability. From this study, the design saw multiple iterations modeled in 3D on the computer with additional functional elements added to the design. A final design for the prototype was worked out, leading to its main frame being laser cut out of 3mm aluminum plate, with all other components hand made or plastic, copper wire, and metal.
DEVICE DEVELOPMENT
13 of 39
September 2015
Process, Research and Development Various Tests and Experiments
Electromagnetic Generator
Learning from Generators Before starting any tests or experiments, I found some old AC motors that I could take apart to study their inner functioning and gain some insight on how electromagnetic induction works. As expected, they were composed of copper coils, magnets and many more complicated components. The level of engineering was considerably high and the motors assembly was more complex than expected and taking them apart piece by piece necessitated metal cutting saws and the like. My search also yielded many old coils that I could take apart and reassemble or simply use the wire in further experiments. The coils found in the motors were too tightly wound around their housings to properly use, and the magnets were also too tightly integrated into their casings or had unusable geometries for my intentions.
DC Electric Motor
Low-Value Inductors
Various Electronic Components for Study
Experiments with Electromagnetic Induction The experiment’s purpose was to explore the potentials of electromagnetic induction from a bobbing magnet moving through a copper coil, thus altering the magnetic field around the coil and generating electricity through Faraday’s Law. The experiment was somewhat of a failure since the magnets were not strong enough and the coil did not have nearly enough turns on itself, the two factors lowering the potential for a considerable voltage to be created. The voltage that was produced was a minuscule amount of nanovolts, disappearing too quickly to capture on camera. The next experiment of the sort will have to include stronger magnets and a coil with more turns on itself.
Sem 3. IBT: Architecture and Extreme Environments
Non-Predictive Adaptability Prototype 1 3D Design October 2015
On the Role of Objective Versus Subjective Strategies For a Sustainable Future By Julien Nolin
Outer frame attached to magnet and buoy movement
Wooden palafitte column
Interior frame moving individually from the outer frame
Spring wheels to adjust the device’s contact with the pillar as is rises with wave movement
Cylindrical housing for the magnets and coils.
Three foam ‘buoys’ for floating the device. Attached to outer frame and thus to magnet movement
Isometric View
Exploded Isometric View
DEVICE DEVELOPMENT
16 of 39
October 2015
Prototype 1 Assembly Assembly Process, Its Successes and Limitations
Necessary Device Design Adjustments The first prototype was constructed using 2mm HDF is the main material for its structure. The vertical moving joints were made from plastic plumbing tubes housing wooden pegs which attached to foam ‘floaters’ held to the structure with the use of electric tape. The prototype’s main HDF frame was laser cut for complexity and accuracy of the pieces. The spring wheels [center left image], were hand made from aluminum tubes, a wooden peg, a long screw, some washers and door stoppers for wheels. The dark opaque tubes [bottom left image] were cut from other plumbing tubes which represent the clear acrylic tubes that will be in their place in the final device construction. They will house the copper wire coils with a rod holding the magnets moving vertically though them.
DEVICE DEVELOPMENT
17 of 39
October 2015
Prototype 1 Fixes
Necessary Device Design Adjustments The main issue was stability. The wrong materials with the wrong thicknesses were used, resulting in a flimsy model. However, the intention was primarily visual, to get a greater understanding of the functioning of each joint and connection. The first prototype helped identify weakness in the construction and joinery. The HDF proved too thin and flexible, and wouldn’t be appropriate due to its water absorption capacity. Another major issue was the lack of vertical support, which led to a lack of stability. Overall, the design needed to be larger, spread out over more of a horizontal span, added buoyancy and better materials.
DEVICE DEVELOPMENT
18 of 39
October 2015
Component Testing The Engineering and Simulation of Key Components
The Test Board The board was devised as a 2.5D exercise to test two components in the device: The gripping unit and the rolling unit. The latter [left] is composed of a wheel pushed into the pole constantly with the use of a spring, adapting the contact between the device and the pillar. The board was also set up to help understand the double hinge system that needs to be integrated into the design. On the weaknesses of the first prototype was the relative movement of the core versus the outside more buoyant components, was understood as potentially not being enough. This experiment aims to address this problem by integrated a not component to the construction, a set of spikes or ‘teeth’ that grip to the central pillar. The basic premise of the double hinge system is the spikes or teeth are lifted when the device floats upwards but are pushed in when the floating components lower. Thus allowing the device to essentially ‘climb’ the pillar.
DEVICE DEVELOPMENT
19 of 39
Section: Rolling Component
Section: Gripping Component
DEVICE DEVELOPMENT
20 of 39
October 2015
Design Evolution
V02 Plan View
V03 Plan View
DEVICE DEVELOPMENT
21 of 39
October 2015
Final Plan Design
Final Plan View
CRITICAL THINKING
01 of 08
October 2015
Final Design
Isometric View
DEVICE DEVELOPMENT
23 of 39
Plan: Device Closing Around Pillar
Upward movement from wave moves magnet through the coil to generate electricity. Downward movement through the coil also generates electricity.
Electricity lights LED.
Section: Electromagnetic Induction from Wave Movement
Through the use of a spring, the component rolls along the pole, keeping the device steady around it. Through a double hinge system and springs, the component grips the pole to stabilize device core.
Section: Gripping and Rolling Components
DEVICE DEVELOPMENT
24 of 39
November 2015
Component Assembly Hand Assembly of Separate Physical Components Through Metal and Plastic Forming Techniques
Vertically Moving Arm: Primary
Vertically Moving Arm: Secondary
Jigs made for equal cuts to be made into the aluminum tubes, made to receiving the 3mm plate pieces.
Acrylic Tubes are fitted with acrylic rings that will hold the coils into place.
Tubes are marked and cut with a jigsaw. The resulting pieces are filled down to remove any sharp edges.
Openings cut into the acrylic tubes half way for receiving aluminum plates.
After being marked, the tubes are drilled into, making the holes that will receive the bolts necessary for attaching the springs to.
Aluminum tubes and drilled into, cut, and sanded down. They will make up the primary arm piece.
Tubes then marked and cut to accommodate interior moving parts. They will house the primary arm piece
Acrylic Generator Housing
The final pieces come together to form one of the main assemblages of the device.
The flexible protection for the acrylic tubes is cast with latex in vacuum formed plastic molds.
The coils are handwrapped around the acrylic tubes and set into place with a few drops of glue.
The final tubes are placed within their larger assemblages and held into place with special acrylic acidic glue.
DEVICE DEVELOPMENT
25 of 39
Gripping Component
Rolling Component
Buoys
A base piece is assembled out of laser cut HDF and a standard 5 liter white plastic bucket, which is then vacuum formed out of 2mm plastic.
Steel piece cut and ground down by hand, and are then welded together.
Aluminum tubes are cut and drilled into to house the steel pieces. The two are assembled to make up the final assemblages.
Aluminum tubes cut with a jigsaw, drilled into and filled with cork stoppers for the springs.
The secondary pieces and cut and ground down manually, which are then welded into place.
Laser-cut acrylic pieces are fitted onto the buoys, while foam structure is added to their interior.
Door stoppers are fitted onto the assemblages as wheels that will make up the final piece.
The buoys are designed to be composed of two halves, for ease of transport due to their stack-ability.
DEVICE DEVELOPMENT
26 of 39
November 2015
Design Assembly
DEVICE DEVELOPMENT
27 of 39
1
2
3
6
4
5
7
Assemblages Ready for Transportation 1. Yellow Buoys in halves
2. Rolling Component
5. Acrylic Attachments
6. Acrylic Housing for Coils
3. Vertical Support for Buoys and Structure
4. 3mm Aluminum Structure Halves
7. Spring Operated Vertical Movement Arms with Gripping Component
EXPEDITION & FIELD WORK
28 of 39
December 2015
PHASE 3: EXPEDITION & FIELD WORK The Device is Deployed in the Middle of the Amazon
In December of 2015, the device and its components were flown to Manaus, ready to be deployed in the field for testing. Expectations of a flowing river around the ‘palafittes’ were met with quite a quite different reality. The unexpected conditions I was met with forced me to adapt my device strategy, ultimately leading me to a floating village, expanding my understanding the issues I had been attempting to tackle. The following phase is divided in three locations which superseded each other as a result of each others circumstances: Location 1: Urban Manaus; Location 2: The Harbor; Location 3: Catalão.
EXPEDITION & FIELD WORK
29 of 39
Location 1: Urban Manaus
Location 2: The Harbor
Map of Manaus
Location 3: Catalão
December 2015
Location 1: Urban Manaus Drought and the City’s ‘Palafittes’
EXPEDITION & FIELD WORK
31 of 39
First Days in Manaus Though my research had prepared me for the design of the architectural device, it lacked one critical aspect: just how low the water level was in its fluctuation extremes. The expectation to find the palafittes standing in the flowing amazon river were met with a quite different reality. They stood perched upon hills, over 10 meters above water levels, without a single wooden column coming close to the river. Manaus and the regions surrounding the Amazon Region had been experiencing one of the worst droughts of the last century. The Rio Negro, which feeds into the Amazon River, has seen extremely low water levels leaving some boats stuck on the dry soil. Just a year ago, Manaus was experiencing a flood, which had also been preceded by drought, both part of a pattern of increasingly extreme water level fluctuations.
CREDIT: STINE BUNDGAARD
CREDIT: STINE BUNDGAARD
December 2015
Location 2: The Harbor An Abandoned Structure, A Possible Test Site
EXPEDITION & FIELD WORK
33 of 39
First Water Tests Failure to find a wooden pillar in the water led me to look elsewhere, which brought me to the harbor. Here lay one of the only structures with appropriately sized columns partly immersed in the water. Although it was no the right testing ground, it provided me the opportunity to attach the device to a structure and test it in the water. Subsequently, I shifted my attention to the broader issue, the palafittes design faced a somewhat similar problem to the device’s, a lack of adaptability limited their use in extreme conditions. Their staticity, the limiting factor in adapting to an unpredictable environmental set of factors, in this case, exemplified through their vulnerability to the potential of flood level water entering homes and damaging the structures. This highlighted the problem I had encountered due to my own research methods and design process, and the reasons that the device, not unlike other architecture projects, was lacking a considerable aspect of adaptability.
December 2015
Location 3: CatalĂŁo Forming a Different Relationship with the River
EXPEDITION & FIELD WORK
35 of 39
The Floating Village The issues associated with the ‘palafittes’ resonated in an especially strong way with me when I made the discovery of the floating village of Catalão. Bringing my device to Catalão and talking to the village’s inhabitants, brought up some interesting discussions about where the dependence of the Manaus’s inhabitants lies, whether it be on the city, the environment or technology, and where a potential shift towards more independence could be imagined. Here, just a few kilometers off the shore of Manaus, floating structures are the inhabitants’ adaptive solution to greatly shifting water levels. A small community of 58 families live together away from the bustling of the city, distancing themselves away from what is seen as a violent city center. Here, the houses float on the giant trunks of Assacú, one of the typical trees used for this purpose due to its high buoyancy. While they do not pay any property taxes, access to electricity is sporadic and access to clean water can be an issue, especially at low water levels, which causes a dirtier river. Yet, they seem relatively unaffected by the low water level.
EXPEDITION & FIELD WORK
36 of 39
December 2015
Projected Results Probable Results of More Accurate Testing
[COURTESY: HTTP://WWW.WIKIWAVES.ORG/OCEAN-WAVE_SPECTRA]
Power Output Potential Based on Wave Height and Wind Speed Based on the above graph relating wave height (m), wind speed (m/s) and period (s), some assumptions can be made on the waves generated by average ships and how they would affect individual generators (yellow buoys systems). The wave heights are taken up to 2.25 meters which resemble average waves created by a range of boats driving on the river. The voltages are based on the findings from the electromagnetic experiments (Technical Log p.40-41). The hypothetical voltage results show the voltage that could be fed to a battery charging.
Wind Speed [m/s]
Wave Height [m]
Voltage Output [ V: 1 Generator ]
Voltage Output [ V: 6 Generator ]
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
0.00 0.10 0.20 0.32 0.48 0.62 0.85 1.05 1.40 1.80 2.25
0.1 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.9 1.2 1.6 2.1 2.7 3.2 4.0
0.6 1.2 2.4 3.6 5.4 7.2 9.6 12.6 16.2 19.2 24.0
Findings From the above table, predicted results indicate at a wave height of 0.3 m, enough voltage is produced to light one LED, using all 6 buoy generators. To light an LED from one generator would require a wave of at least 1.7m. Though the goal of the device is not one shot voltage but the accumulative charging of one of multiple batteries.
EXPEDITION & FIELD WORK
37 of 39
December January 2016 2015
“Fleeting Device Water” Film In Search Stills Taken of a Testing from the Site
My search for ‘palafittes’ with their pillars laying in the river led me to multiple locations in and around the city, and forced my to rethink my device strategy. This search was exemplified in the short film entitled “Fleeting Water.” It tells the story of my time in Manaus, and the struggles I had trying to find the right site for the device, trying to make the environment work for me, rather than the other way around. It is telling of the shortcomings of my design process and the extents to which I tried to find success within my device experience. The film features many shots of the city and its surroundings, attempting to give the viewer a proper sense of the city of Manaus, and its environmental conditions, along with potential solutions to the issues it faces.
The search begins from a viewpoint, high above the ground on the roof of a nearby hotel. After making my way through the city center, getting odd looks from its inhabitants, I arrive at my envisioned testing site. Seeing that the river has dried up, my strategy shifts, and I hop on a boat looking for a potential site, one that is submerged in water.
The second site I arrive at is by the harbor, where I find a large steel structure in the water, the only pillar-like structure nearing the conditions I had hoped for. I try my best to test the device, yet the structure layout is impeding on any chance of proper testing.
Finally I take another boat ride towards the floating village of Catalão. Although it was not the setting envisioned for the device testing, it proved very interesting to place such a construct amongst these floating structures. The village along the grassy shores of the Rio Negro resonates with the themes present within the device.
EXPEDITION & FIELD TRIP
38 of 39
December 2015
Device Adjustments Device Performance Improvements
Added top weight Appropriate Testing Site
Stronger Materials
Less buoyancy
Necessary Fixes Without appropriate testing, not all of the device functions were able to be studied thoroughly, yet the harbor tests did prove useful inasmuch as test the physics of the device. Firstly, the buoys, were too large and thus too buoyant. They had been designed to withstand my weight so I may stand on them, yet another top plate piece would have had to be designed. The excessive buoyancy meant the vertical spring loaded arms were pulled towards the center of the device, stiffening the overall movement of these pieces, and causing the device to get stuck some of the time. Materials would also have to be rethought. The acrylic pieces were the weakest and a few broke off, finding themselves at the bottom of the harbor for the foreseeable future. Aluminum pieces would have been better suited for their intended function. Finally, for the device to be more efficient in terms of electricity, the coils and magnets could be multiplied for an added power output.
EXPEDITION & FIELD TRIP
39 of 39
CONCLUSION With the multiplicity of economic, ecological and urban forces at play, Manaus finds itself at the center of many of the questions raised in respect to the relationship between the built environment and ecology. As a major city located in the heart of the Amazon jungle, it has a deeply intimate relationship with the forces of nature that surround it. Two different ways of dealing with the increasingly extreme shifts in the global environment, specifically the dangerously fluctuating water levels of the Rio Negro, are prevalent. The palafittes lack of engagement with shifting waters is contradicted by the direct contact the floating village utilizes. A more introspective look at my experience in Manaus, contrasting it with the two typologies, revealed the issues surrounding a design process with scientific assumptions and predictability at its heart. Significant questions about the temporal aspect of a design were raised, requiring a critical look at the role of predictability and adaptability in the built environment, and the role of the architect and the built product during and after it is finished. As intrinsically alien to a natural site, architecture negotiates with an unpredictable environmental set of factors. An exclusive design supported by the objectivity of assumptions of scientific truths and expectations will most often fall short of the more inclusive one. Even with the received failures of my device experience, I deem my time in Manaus a great success, inasmuch as the discoveries made due to the necessity to adapt to the environmental factors present. Questions of adaptability, sustainability and independence were raised and remain somewhat unresolved in the city of Manaus, raising the question: what role can floating architecture have in the sustainable future of our cities?