Juris Magazine- September, 1967

The Duquesne LiW School NewsmaSizine

Juris

Duquesne Univenity, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvinia

"VohpDe "l. Number 1

"September, 1987

O,ienbtion Sptcill!

Juris

Library Seeks Cooperation

EOITOR-IN-CHIEF J. William McLaffe rty

ASSOCIATE EDITOR

81 EI.I'lABE1'H M. SClfEtB La.. LIInr\alI

BUSINESS MANAGER .June S. Schulberg

Geol"lte L. Zacharopoul08

ASSISTANT EDITORS fEATURE CO-EDrrORS AJ.1J ~n-.1 EDITOR Tboau J. cys,n Patrkt J . WcKLalt)'

Lo.1s P. Vim

NEWS EDITOR

ORA PI{I'C ARTS EDITOR

"'IWam A. Go)'lltte

Nkbolu

r . Loceuo

ADVERT IS I NG MANAGER Hint, Georre Satr FACULTY MODERATa\S: Patrick J. Basl&l

Ronald R. Dawop)rt Jolm J. SefqUo

In mlClY Ia.. scbool eI.!alocS aDd In roou 051lepl edutatloa, the 1:1.. library Is Ir ... qllliDUy mnr!'d 10 U u,., beil!1 of the Ia .. school. ...·1111 Ibis In mind. tilt LibrukD aDd staJJ utelld to dl DeW stv:leolS II bn.rtJ ...leomeudto a.U apper. el»$mta . . upress oar ~ lor eooIlmIed SIlCee53. for Ollt fit .. students, a brief vwd U to t.o.lIle librar y fWelkm$ Ill&J bil be4tul. Tbt b_ Iitnry Ii ClOt a Iflldlnl Ifbr.ry. All boob mllSt til! lISed La tbt Ubr1ry pI'OJlf:T. Most of OW' boldiJl&S lUI COIl'~tnUJ \oc:;rti'd on opell stacu adjaeeDt to tilt rea(\IDe rooms 00 til, tlgbtll aDd CIilItb flocn. 011 tilt t lcbth floor , ll$O adjaCetlt to tile readlni fOOIlI , Is. !tXl -took room. BooIIs tram this TOOIII mustbe slpld Dill for lISe In \be library Dilly aDd r«uroee by tilt borrovtf wbe Is rtspOnSlble lOT lIS ~e return. se rlPti~e 0(

II the IIbrarJ Is truly tile heart, It Is 1.«1\151 11 se r'tl<:e$ tbt WIIoif body of the I,w school, the stu~1I1S J.OO ttle beulty.

Lllce!he b~

Law School Neqmap.z.ine. Scboolof L,'II', 600 For besA¥I1I111t, Pittslllrcb. hllurtvanla, 15%lt.

to f'untt1on properly, lis arter ies 1'11\1$1. r UJll1II unol:ls:truo:: lOO. To usurt tht.s fUDcllonl..llc:. I I.... rule!! lui" beta ma~. They Uti 001 l.ctelldtol tG pelll\iw ; ther In 6es1pltd lor !he COIJlIDOO 1:llfTPSt llJ:I ellI'

Prtated at N.... COIDI', 1430 P_ Aw_. Pgb., Pl. 1m!

10 w1n( wt.ll make )'011 (og1)1UIIl oIl!lI! nuoIl !or lie

,JURIS . . . pubUeattoll of tilt DuquNDe tJlliw,",lt)' Scbooi 01 La.., Cor r tslJ)ll(knee maybe addrundloJURIS, DIIqoesge

b~l,

.n.l.IIC' . A momelli'J r etleeUoa 011 fle~ of tltt hl_

r ule.

JURIS

This ill the first IS9 ue of • new member of the Duquesne Law School family .

Wltb t his '"ue, JURIS becomes a relillty. With the next Iss ue and the once to follow.

J URIS will become an institution of the lAw School.

The policy of The Editorial Board Is to ~lIent an Informatlve magazine to ti e together all t he nrlous groups comprising the law 8cbool. Including day and evening students , raculty and t he alumnI. WhI le this goal of communJeation Is the purpose of our exifltence. we a lso present. forum ... lIable for the Uge of all . It Is wltbln tbe!8

• SUflICe masl be II\lIntalneod al all tim" III 1M Ubruy.

• SlIIotlDg, Pattnc llrl crilltlr.( Itt XoI pn'mUled In !be llbnry.

• Boots ClIII:I be r eplaced \l:Imf<b!J!oly IIItr

--

W, bo_ Wf ..1Il ret coope ratioo m.a a.!! of "'" liP aJId old 1tlIdent$ alln.

Wf doG't W1lII Itt La_ Ilbnry 10 I bfu1. attack!

:a.,

pages that a proper di alogue between studentand facu lty. student .nd a.lumnl •• nd faculty and .Iumnl should be encouraged.

Feature arti cles .re Important In the developmentoftbls news m.gazlne. A competent staff .nil begin work aoon to spotUght an ar e. of Interest to the legal community.

This series of .rtlclell will begin with the lIecond Issue . Letters to the EdItor are welcomed at any time and hopefully they may all be printed on thia page. Contributions are always welcome from an qu.rtera . and . In f.ct . w11l be act1vely solicited.

The Editor ial Board of this newsmag,zlne wishes to express Ita thllnke for the help .nd oonalde r. tlon ahowo to the staff during the first few awkward months of formation .

JURIS wtll .ttempt to repay these f.vora throughout the year.

FACULTY SPOTLIGHT It shall be the polley of the Edltorl.1 Board of thia newsm.gazlne to honor. member of the faculty from time to time by fe.hlnng tum In picture .nd print.

The ;l!tudenta of Duquesne Law School are fortunate to IlRve an excellent faculty, the faculty of tbla law school i8 aecond to none In giving 110 much of themaelves to the student .

Very often the .lumnl of the 1.w school . re una .... re of the blgh ellteem In wblcb certain f.culty mambere are held by the students. FACULTY SPOTLIGHT 8e"011 to tell m.ny people. who would not otberwl.lle be .ware, luat boTo' we feel .bout our f.culty.

We are not preaumptlOUll; It Is well wlttun our capacity .. atudenta to ett In Judgment of tboIIe who are .ppointed to gulde our careers. The best, aDd perhapa only.

Judge of the profee80r is the studeat". TIle student Is a~nily .;'. re of the quality of the educ.tlon he Is receiving. An - easy" prof may be great newll and seem popul.r to the student body. but the man we respect III the man who producea quaUty lnat ructlon .nd makes ua feel .nd ttunk as the nnlebed product we hope to become.

We ar e going to become attorneya . Thle Ie why'lile .re here: this Is 'IIIby we Intend to stay and see It through . It Is because we .re going to become professlon.l men of roesponelbiUty In our community that we leal proud to have a model of the hlgbest sort lead us to tbat goal. We sball, therefore. honor the te.cber as be deserves to be holIored .

We ehaIl bonor the te.eber a8 he hoo~re tue student!! .

STArF P OS ITI ONS T'bIrt are IJWllOIIIf ooeIIlDp OR tbt staft of roRts. Appllel.Dts sboIIld trJ to meet wtlll tbt Editor Ia Room 901 l.DyUm"

Orioallllion Sp••ilil

' ''' Th, ..

The Duquesne University Law Review LAW REVIEW A ....,""

• •

•

•

8, lUCIiAJlo S. IX»IrZAUl'I Editor_lII~

La.. Rmw

u _ . . n re....tlac I brief dtftIltloa c:I. ......

R,""" tbt u.o.. IIItcbt Mf'ft, partlellllrty. fte:r. &l1 tlIIJ 11 dIrind II II~ 'blacl &lid wb1te' 4et1dka. 8o'nftr, &ItIKJQp!tll lb)yt 1D17br1ef11~ LA. RI'rln, It doN DOl: dllI('q.. 1IM'& La.. JlIorin" IS.

111..

a-t ~ of lIIIonDatioII. ...... tIIeorJ. nvJWlc

QOIIIIeeIed wtltI 11M law tMt I eID tbd •• ,TbuI, tt CIA be _ IMt lAw R.,... _ U R _ tf_I,. Uapx1uit fllletloa tor. tile membln of tile a.p.I t:9tDllllalty.

STUD£MT OPPORTUIfITY

.1Ilb .. 1M atudIat '-lac -..u.d 10 11M ....u. tOT be1ar uapnparld for . claa. Bat It illlIl.to utz'taI,lr laIportIIII .on. &lid It earrleI yUh It • ,nit dt&l 01 r. , -fNJItJ• .,. ta1Nn to caleb uS correct tbt aec~ dtlltioa of 1M WOl'd ' lOt" IIItpM ~1Ite11 4IItrOr .. alOof'. "'..w a.l,.II . . . Korrkt eltatioD to l _ will renJt III &II _ea&rl ku 01 ~ tal. m 1M ailDntr wIlD o.u. to cbel:k 1M lllltlorltr eU.d.. 'hal, U tbII wort ls.lt doGe ..n, 1M btMftt dlrt...s b'OII l ...,.~ to L..., Rf11n WOUI tit I"lUr '" II~ U DOC obHt-

WIDELY USED

Fine, • La..- a.m..

I$: • IQ&jor ..reI at Itpl m.. ud Ideas. La ... a..t_arer.lIOloal, by ri:IcIeata (fa bet. 100 lew ...... botbtr to rtI4 1.....

RntnI) but by Ia~. ,.... ud proflllOl"S. N" to~

DOt

*' antbey"-ldbJ'_.benOlltbe ..... COIII.Do c:a_. ren.. lec"'"

Uty bat " " ar. tm:D• .u uUclt appear1arllla La..

Rm.. III&)' prof_to Ilia lDeGIod; II l1li.1 be III8d bJ III attorotJ m tbt ~_ HaD 011 brt,,; aDd it 111&1 be r lUld . . by. fudre

.......

wbtD u ~ ill r..st~ III lD ldGreu to tIM T.uteulI:I JrI,Uoca1 Collta-tlle. 01 Law RnfewI: 1M IOfIId )epl 1C1lo1ar, Prof~ WlWam 1.. ~ ltIIIId,. - (La...

C ITE D FOR REFERENC E S

n. ReOIICI _ _ oI'!U1k1pltk:la' " 1M IIIOA dlr.et ad 11 __ AHIf')1rac:to . . . . . . ptnOaIlr. 1\!I1.I tilt W11UaC "'*11 1M ___ 40M lot tile R ... ""' US WkII_rbe p ,bUsW IIUlu""', dt:rl ls QIe podDeC 01 dWc'IIl ~ lIId well l'fUODIld t!Io9t ullIIll,.ls, It II" IDOf't tlwllii"_lfilCIi bei.lty tOl" tIM 'WTiter 10 _ ~ lUI. lD. pr1Dl. It 'I1U be I 100110 be ulIu..d br oIIItr mtlllbenolltM ltpl COlD "

Rem..' an . . . . . . .IIoii&bI, 111.-

mUDlly. Eaeb lIU, 1II1dd:WocI 10 Ib rfCUlu lull-

R.new,.. .. won..

aCflptioas, tile ~ OtJqnfty La.. t.hu I _ber 01 reqtIeIU m C(IIII.M fit IJIa Rmn wtItrt it IIIIdt to I Jpkllk ~ Tbll:$, It till be _ Ibal staOul wort. .. IItWMd by

""ertae.

tile Itpl_lmitr u1llhDDI: IIIIJ_YeUle Al15fKUoG 01 tIIow'Iar tlIal lit II pIa1IDr I , ID&.D Btrr lIaponut role III ~

to tile dlftlolXDut of 1M

I...

SU: YEARS YOUNG

•

AI lor tilt ~ UDlYetsity 1..&.. Ran . ... It ls JOUIIC III La.. R.n.ws co. 1'1111 'I1U til '" 'iXIII r-r 01 pqb'.... UM 'llIlI wrlttr la IDmI\at.t 10 "'" tile -.or 01 Mn1Dc u E41tor-lA-ClIltf. II, 11 alai t~ 10 tit MntIc wt:I!I ue.Utat eo-.dJton: LouI5 l..ou&Vu. AJticIel EdUor; JoIIo Ktu1ct. ReDeellkcll EdItor; CbarJ. PuaUtum', Comma Ed1&or; Jonplil MCJ*;r, Boot RPSe .. £dUor ; Jo.epb MeG1D.kJ, BulDtu Mulpr. III additioa, Ole,.. are twtnty-m IWt IIImbers sa&'\1q 011 t.... R..ww.

BtcaIlM tilt Duqblnt L&.. R. . . . " )'Qq, tilt,.. is • _I 01 room for d".Iopmeat, EaelI 1\11:ceed!Dc ,ear 01 p;aWcatbl baa sboWII ~. .

111 !hi Rm.... D "1IopId IIIa1 we aII&D be atrIt 10 ecGtl_ WI ~lIIeal udto NIP 1Dltt~ UafftnllJ La.. Rm.w 1M type 01 peNlclligo I t....

Rm... II ad aIIoeld lit.

t_

cr-.t

F1RST ROW, 11ft to rfclI......tot. R. 1CtIIrIct. 1.ada Lo.&II"', RkMrd S. E4Itor-III-Cuet; Clar1M R. P....ft.... aDd JoIIII MeGtaley.

a.

noma-. a.

s.,.....,. 1961

--'---'"'---

0 ...111_

"1' Four

$,..1111

Student Bar Association presented mI eool1aue 10 prKIi!IIt lIIaDr ~.

YbIcb mol., arOllDd eoatrol of aeth1ttu, tlme IIld !)'pI! of aeth'itlH wh1cl! an a part of tile "Il001 ,.r.

These ~ltm. cu be s-etUed by Wl)rJdnC lor tile commOil (Ill! u1 DOt lD Jul;t seelD&: tIIlt OM Of Ibe otbn P"DIIP Is nttstled. Rep«stntaUnll w1ll bill eleeted. from eeeb elus milt Is iDcWDbeot14lOfl each class 10 ..ltd tIIosl st1Ideats wbo will bills!. til aIlIe to UDCSel':lltud &lid .oft tor tile best lIlteruts ot Ibe ubool u1 the ews.

Besides blllliIC reprfSepl('d by tbI' class tatlle, stv:Seots. IU ~ to dUIId.!be Studtot SIr meettll('s Illd ~h-e pH"sOllli eqlnSslOG to tllelr tHII.c.p 011 IlIbjects 01 partlelll&r ~rt$l to llIem.

f.__

1be StudtDt Bar bu &1....1$ bid .. oot ollIS prflDu, tuDet10Ds tile ~tgt 01 flealty-Studellt rtl&tloal. A mild flu bleked by 1M tmln scbool Is to • bttttr poslttoo wilen b'oolO'f<! ill lb. faculty-S'lldeot d1akICIIe. n.e faculty I I ~ I.s putkWarl, U\Unstecl ID ImproYUl( ~1: OWl! cOllrns aDd pro'l1d1Dr tile tIIICI 01 eour,eli IlIlt ...w be tbtIlIIOII beoeI'Iclal 10 !be ~L llof ilion ~ tbtI, recelWl from !be studeot bodr !be tetter !ber UtI alIle to e....hllle pn!RIlI UI(! Mw't Pf'OCI'1IU.

tbe social aide 01 Ilu &e:U'I1t1fS Is aJs.o III rof.' rftllllptac. N.... pidti1lles lor tilt IIIUlIbu &lid tn. of ~ wtll te Pfl"'eilted IIUs r-r. ~ aasal CIu1etmu oiate party wt1l blllllekllll Ibt m.lerll.ooc tb1f ,..,. aDd !be plCDk: II !be .:1 of naw ...w also be c:c-tlJW!'l HowI Yflt. U. fOtOrtty IIltstn .w. be jo1DtcI by date affa1rs I.IId IIlMe f1D:tI_...w te beld .1 t:I!Mi: wbleb WU\ IaIun mWJIHlDl ~

0n.e

~

foI" IIpl leu'UiD& ud pnetlee, e&IIDOt III! etteettft In 11011.· 11011 from 1M ~ IUId 1artibItiois ....111 wIIk. !be law llltenet.. Few 1tUd..... UlllII(I ODe wtIo bu pnettetd .aaId cboIe to stady III an _delllk YlCIIUIII, r«DOfed trom tilt llIterplay of kku aDd IXcbaDp of Tteft w:l1II whkh tile ll~ Is eooeetlK!d.·

law scbool, !!Ie pf'O'I'\nC

Ia....

1'1IiI -,ear wt1l be. r-r at trulltiIIrI tor Ibe studeat flu .t [)aqJesDe~1t 'fill ba"."", CODSt1tu11oD wlIie. wm attempt 110 ftt '" • pNIC""" ~by elCb. IMertst CJ'OIIP wt1l ..... ~te tbtI .e11'11Uec 10 wtIIcb U. stucIeat Blr wt1l ~. nue are mao, prob1elnl wtIkb eID til aolftd o.l, b1 lJIenued sI:IIdoeoI eooc,rg I.II! litton. TIl, La,

_,Ill

Sebool 11 dlYl(led beea\lSe

at

.-.

.. Jbe ~t Bar wlIl~!, •.~11Jlll1I lD .ell luul_ lD adttlUOD 10 !be podiq 011b, mlDldes 10 all r~

n. stIId.a1

Bar 011 bebalt 01 a.Il tbt stWtats eoII-

P'lruwe. Bm McLUfel"ty &lid hilIIlrtaffOllllle ueeUeut Job tbeJ 111ft !loot lD orpph\nc I.IId IlIIbllshlni !be

''''''.

mAlI)' fl.clon. Tbet. Is

Ibe o..,.&:bool - Nlallt Scbool dh1skm lAd tile War· ·rled-SlDcle ItiI:!ef.l cIlY1elOll. TheM cIl-.takai baWl 1'beH ~ of • J1IItict of !be S~me C~ rdleet !be rruoo fOf • IJtnlDC aDd &CU." stacIeut bar usocWioo, The SllIdefli Bar Asaoelalioa is tbe ODe orp.!ll.E&lion III tbe 1.1... Scliool to 'ftkb all atlIIleIIls be1oaa:.

Tberelore, It sbollld III tbt 1 = In lItlicb all stu· dents CID IU;IrIIS$ tbetr Idau aDd see tIIem CHTled 10 CODIl1let1011. AU l tadents are IDVlOOd to nbtlllt illIJ' Idet; 1I'hteb tbey teel woald be beueflcl&1 to ttl, acadtmle, senke or social deveklpment of the stu6elI1 aDd the scbooL The Stw:Ient Bu AsaoeIaUoo 1.1 0uQue$JIe Is a member of !be La. SdIooI Dlvisloo of the AmtrleLll Bar AssoebtiOli IDCI, u neh, fUtle!pa1es 011. Ill' Uoaal Ienl In propuIS Wblcb dtflCllP ~ as stwe.ts. Soma of !be Prorram&' IDclIlde wort1Dc ror • draft la_ 'I'hlcb 11111 be 'OIdtal>le tor aU 1&_ rnadents pushln( !or professltml statos III !be Atm~ Forces s1m1lU" to tlat aeeorotd to doeton IlIld 1ftenlly trylo( 10 ~ tile status of 1. 11... 5tucIeDl. Oar lIIem~hIp III tilt Amertcan Bar Anociatioo also Is IlII """" twit)' for 1Dtereste4 ~Ia to wort for DItsoaal amc. &lid tMnby fIa'tbIr p1I:I t1"oIIIlIIeir ~ .. 1IclIool e:qIerlellces.

,.., '

,

I

I

I

I

. ..

EDWARD

I

1"11CIitAS " .

SlptlmMr, 1961

•

' Oft fiwl

O,i..lltia11 5,.. 1011.

of PIlI. Alpba Otltl, __ to wwUly ~ III_ban of tilt tn.tlnlily"l IIIIdt anllabll III on5I r to .uta!

111 tile compilb ot 0111'1 IepJ. edIIcatloD.. PAD bJ lht ....r, " at 001, IIW fraItnIJt)' 1IIIkb 1IIat.. IJtII.dIIIIlDlM Ift.llable tIIlwP tbI .uo.lorpplptloa 'hi .. _t.nII:Ip 01 EplI CIII.pter of PIlI. AIPIa 0.", biellldlt!lllt 0lIl1 sCw' h t.t t.cuJly lII_berl g .ell maJortI;J of . . fII1l.1Uq _lilly of IbI

Phi Alpha Delta Law Fraternity

I

I

n.

Sclool of 1.&. lit,.. tittler aetn. FInltJ stat., ille~~ mtmban, orlM,U1Boaorarrmem,berl of !be orpDlatloa. . TIll omelll UId leU.. lDUlbtl". of PIlI AIIII& Otlt:a. __ of 'II'bo1D thtt Fln! Y-.r StudeQI:I IIIl1llt till 0r1tDIr.ti0R or at lilt U,te1 1100II: Sillt. till IIIOf1 ..::ti,.. III atta1n COtISaeIltd IAIM II'" sc~.

THy .... y til tco.IId 011 !be Matt of 1M .... Rnt.... !be sa.dtIt Bu tad lilt ....'"'ptlN. Uembenll!p ill PIli "ipIII Delta III 10 .., lrtrizipI 0lI !be ltlIO, tIJ:rlt of tbt ~t. m:I may ~ flet p .. him I BIOlI too.IDdtd uadlmJc uri. Phi . . 0.111 rllPl"UlQlall..... ma.r be to.d ~1Jl till ~I, ILDIi w1II t. mon IIwI wtUJ..oc to talt to IllJOD1 wbo ,tw III IatIIrwi III becmDlIIC' II)tlDber.

"'1DIOOi

--.,..11-,

PIlI AIpbl Deltl1s u.. ooe andOlllyLa .. Fr&lenlity III e:dstefIo::e al DuQ.uene UII\YeI'Slt)'. [pII e~er 1'9cel'f'fd Itl tWter hom the ,.&11&1 Ol'p!I.Il&t1oo In 1953, UId lILt bHa pvwiIIr st.adIly ..., IlJICe.lt Is opeD. tor m_btnhI,p to &II)' male atIIdeat III tile Sebool cI. L.w atIa" lit IiIU t:OIIIpleted lilt ftnt sem.stu cI. dlIdJ. (NatiClall nUes ~t r-le Ia. shdIIut!I troal jGfn!Dr 1M ~.)

PAD hu t'!' .cli" chaptel"5 III .u..rleu Bar AssoelaUOll ~rtdlled schools, COAI\dIenobiJ mort tIIaII IlIIJ oiber law trahrll.\ty. It s t r _ I proper bIG 01 proI'....1oDL.I and soelal PfOCtamlllill(, 1fIIk~ Is cU:~ to bt~ mold tile b.. ItudotDl cI. tod&y IMo tile ... " r-sed lIft'ecl1" IIwJef to tomorrow.

PIlI AIpIa Delta ott.n I OU'Itty ot saf'Yku fI(lI: o.IJ to UIe 1IId1'ridlal me-mbet, bill alao 10 tile 11;.$ebool as nlL Last rear Epa c llapter I p:IIISOr«I UIM'IIIi atbe.r iIIlDcs... speaRn: " rits, ftIclI ¢raY IIWI}' IIOted members 01 lilt lotal au to tile scbool to eooduct IKblrtl on ~wnat lepI problems. Tbe U5 dlmulid by a IlQbUe d&blt. III AptU, GO tbe aIloUUOD of eapUal pmlsbmtllt. TlIe pull \Delllded ..ell IIOtlblll as Jq. Sam...1 Stnasl, lalstalllt Dll:tnet Atton., D...ldO'H......

TlIomu Kerr, pr..kleet 01. u.. Pltbtlurcbellapttrcl.ttN!AlIIfrkUI CI'Ii! LlblrtlH UDIoD, and JobilLoftoft, Assoctat.

Editor cI. tile Ptttsmrp Post-Gu, u., I'IMttusto AI.

I.ut_

w..

I 4ebltt oanellllllabl,coatro...... la1.ubjletres.u.d III widespread Din eonf&ie. 'riUI tile Scbooi of La. l1li t llClpltJrt of a gn&t dMl of tUorabll publklty II;

!be IpouoI' of tH afta1r,

001 of tbe IIIOCt ~ txpud1 n, ~ of IUTkI 10 tM . tlIdIIII: ...... ban 01 tM mlll'll1ty.ls ~ oI.~~ iIUI. 'I'tIzwP tbe ElIIlcmDtlll r a j (Ill erlnllD&i II.... AI !be compwtloR 01 tb1s Octoba"•. 01:. RttaIto w:!Jl rect1ft all L.L.III. If.T,U. 1'1lta w1II briDe 10 ti... tile_bel" of ~ Dr. RafalIrio

!be fttld

DICTA

~ . III

'rom

•

Josqph A.

'1)1111 tIuI

GEORGE L lACHAROPOUlOS An,ti,'e Edittt:

WIIb tlw Id'teIrt ct 1M l,n·68 .cbool year, .., ill U. Scbpol ct La .. ani Dr_ted 'II11b • myriad of cIwJcM; !be tIrIt aDd ~I IInll'led1ately obvious ct 1IIIk~ II: ~ IIPSIJl.Ip ....... ttHlf. E,..uoae oocaeted ..till ~ eutt rprln belle. .

IlIaI ~ wk:oQltrJ UId npporUd brill. m:I that It wtU~. . iDlo a __ os.. ..., pari of!be ur. of stu·

It..w.

<aDtJ, flclllty, m:I alumlll.. W. !loPe 1ou.eampI1AUIll by prluaUDC ItelllS of InttttSl ODI oaly to u.- ollIS ill tbt Seboal 01 La.., but &Iso to !he Itpl COmJlulI>lty 11 Iarp.

ThIs p&I'1ieulu e<lilUIID orUI be prim.arlly direeted 10 lilt l tudtDt. aDd to wbat II: occurin&' UOODd hlm 01 ..1IkII III dIould be InrI. n IDlY &Iso IroJ;p tUIlt 10 ~t ~11Idt a lew' opIaiolll &lid eoGllIIUUi of tbt 'fl'itU. wIIklI DIQ 01" ID&1 !lOt til awree1aled.

!'be start of tilt _ UIdImJc ,.u aIR br1ap 10 tile Ia... sellool flelllty .on tacl. 1'1IiII ta ProtMSOr AUOll D. Twtntl. Prot. 1'Yersti received Ills B.A. dtifw In I~ from Beth Mor:trub EIJOD filmudlt: Rueareb IMUtutt and bl.s L.L.B. from l4arque1te Ul!l1"U$1ty 111196!I. Ht tbell lpellt a year ... Itb tile u.s.

Deputmllll. of Jllltlel as I trial lltOrlltJ', aDd hal /lISt compltltrJ • ,.u at BarYard Law Scbool u •

TIRdI1IIc Fillow....

..

•

•

Prot_r Wllttr A. RafaD:;o IIu SpllIi. Ibk lUI summer It N.Y.U., .ben be did r...areb III tbe neld of SoeioIociCll tlelOfl: IDfIIKIIICJ..oc tbe calpabtUty 01 I crimJ.naJ.. Or. RIfalto b primartl7 studJ1.IIc: IbI feasi· bilIty 01 de'tek¢oC • • soclolocicLllvt' loml'l'hal 011 !lie I1Da ct tilt ftrlouI5 ~yehiatrk '-til emp,.If:lywl m )Ui~

S.p'l",b.r. 1967

pUt

bas..,.

• •

• ".1, year day cll&l = er lJOrkIDc III WasIllD&'OlI, D.C. of Ibt tlIlrd

UIaf; wttb 300 othlllaW 1hIde1l1ll. JOI, along wltb I.,. ~"11 '(1 oIb4rs., wu 1ttac:Md to Ibt CrI.1DIl Dtmioo of IIIe tlIIpartaalll 01 JII5t1c•• H~ eluted tor Mr . Rkllard L. 8nua, Eaeutlft Aslldaal 10 Fred VIIIsoa. Am. "1kInIfJ GtlMrII. n. pI'~ of W\lJcb Jot 'IIU I part, .......

IJcDed 10 acqI&iIIl !be law stucIeDIs tram OQI5IOt wl$\IJICIoa 'II1tb tbe op,erati(lD. of !be OeJartmn! of J,.t\e •• Joe', .ork lDclllCltd ~rl1e~t1011ln arteDIIl.Di!hl rederal e..r Association' . SpeUers PfOi1"am, wb1eb bad I ~I coostattDc of JusUce Bp-oo R. IVh1tt of !be l1II1ted St&I.. Supt.lDl Court, AIto"" y C*MraI RUllu, Clark., aDd WlWam Btttmaa. .tIo bu p.1Md lame IS the ~Wlr of Jimmy HottI. aDd Bcbb)' BIker, ,\\so, 'Jot I~ tile Capitol Hill SptUtn PrOifllD, e1eIIlIId UIIODC ItIpreseot&tonStc:ntIrJ' of state, 0.0 R~ SnaIor Robert F. K.-c!y, ILDIi s..tor Tbruslo!l WorlOll.

Gritntltit. Specilll

Wishing

Your

The Appellate .

Moot Court Program Br ALFRED S. PELAEZ

ADIstaDt Protes.sot" 0:1 La. ~llm

Moot Com Woderltor

Splendid Appel1&te Moot COIU"t. .. III IIIe put, e~ ~ of 1M bw .:Il001', eW'rlo:alam.. All lee0IId JftI" <1ay I!Id WnI ,-r t?elI1Jlc stDlIb an comptlMd to partiell*e III l1li nm mal co~11«00. scbedldecl to btC1II III Oo:tober. The 'f'IDIlers III tile f\n'I roB ue tile. IIJ&tble to etlttr tile sec:ocacI I'OWII:I competlUoa to t. blid III tile !!prIDe Si!me:ster. '!'be III1rd &lid fOlU'lh J'OIIII6I, 1fI1II tile aJUIIIJ.te wtIIMn r . _ntlDg DuQveeae III tilt NaliollLl

to be •

Magazine

C~foUo.-.

Success

Tbe compet1i1011 1.1 m*~ after up_til beld ID !be Supreme COOIrU oIlbt UDlter:l stata tJId hnn.yl'lllll.L Tbe putkllUb aM patrt4 oIllato teams of two. OM tam npl'M" 1M ItJpeUub til all .dllll east! pl'e\'lous11 decided b7 eM Supreme COIII1 of PflBIISrl'rl.ll1t aDd lDOtbn' team represeol8 l1li ~ .,.11," , stlJ:Seol-p&rtlc~ Itl pftlliheteeot'd aDd b;uscrlpt at tile proet«tlap III u.. lower cout bat are not permttttd liCe,," to tile briefs GIl cOWISel or to tbe opWoa of !be covt. t'1Ie7 IIIIBt IIIHI prepilI'l br1efs I!Id prtIRDt IJI onI UJUlDe/ll. tbe pnc_ ltce, .~ ~lbl.. " to but tile attorDe)'3 no II"fI* IIIe ease betorl tIM Supreme COQr1 ,It as )ui:Ice8 to IIW tile querl .. !bey 110$6 to !be UtlpDtI eaJI. IiIII:II)n IDclllh... !be .-tnnel1I 01 !be rtm rOID1 'lOtIo proeeed. iDtD tlIfI tecoad romJd lA oot compelltCIlo write lJIlddItloaal brt4d, tIUI mar ImtI'f.d "" u.. brIetJ wrlttu by _ I 111 the SQpnme c ourt. At Ibl$ $lip, IbIJ oral arJIIIDlIII 11: at sole 1DIportuee. lbe AllIe litIII.lloa awlles III tbe Ib1rd ~ For IhI foarUl &lid ruw rDllDd. IbI J:UUcJtIIIU IIII1Sl mill e brief from 1M tnIIIerlpt to be 1111811 III tile fI'Ir1bcomlDC 1II.u.-J

n..

... from

your printer

NEWS COMP PITTSBURGII, PENNSYLVANIA, ISh. TELEPHONE 311-1'1S4

as IIlq teua brief III the 1Il\1ocllJ eompeUtioo.

Awella.lII urumeatl, moreeo IlwI :ugalDe 10) a 1111')', rept_ IIIe belgbt of adwoo:aey. COImMIIH bert IttemptIJII to 'II'\D • tattle 01. Wil$ apiDlrt ...

IIqIllU, .... U·traiDe(I oppDDent by c:oorm.:.lIlC 1 beDeb 01

Mpb SWled /IU1Sb. Hen, u1k.ulate and cOllV1DeJ.nc: marsballDg 01. rtlnaat tacl:l aDd tile awUealloa of legal prlDclplllll therein 1& !be _tial skill, and I Sl.II... !IWIIer ud de~ ftljc, will be Qf l.IWe Will U peoetnliDg ~ rroa. tile beDcll Irt DOl efrklll'llly fielded &lid dl5p1tebed. It Is Um. wouder, COIIHQIlenUy, lllat IIWIY Qf the for,,,,,,,,t AdYOCates of .... IIme-lDc ludiDC tbe two latest appollltee$ 10 !;be S\lprema Court 01. tile United States-tuDed tbelr lJ~ primari ly by ll"C'liDI appeUalll cues.

The Wr(IblI bfDeC1:I1H m&IIJ. StucIeIItIi wbo PIU'tlelplte 1/1 this eompetlHoa III earoest &lid tcqWrt a proflel-=J In appelWt amocac1 wtd.], $lIU In La• .school b .... dl5t1Det ~ Offr !lIe1.t colItql.leS trona KIIooLa tlJat 1lI.... IXI neb procnm. ~r wt.II haft IearDtd 11'11 "moot· I itwotlon, &lid DOl at 1M IQlfIllI of • plr\n& cHfIIL FarthenDOl'I, ttw1 wtlllla.. aeqWred alllSSIll'l olcoaMe.nc,IIIld4nQ _ 1l1li: • I&IIC of JOOps III (Ill" courL Fw:tbeflllOtt, Dv· quesne'. rtIILll.rts III tbe COIIIpetltjoo 1lI. ... atnrsbteo blghly SOIIIIIt bJ local fll'UIs. wbo rtoeOJlllzt tIM 1mportaoce 01 ~ ~ &lid 01 lilt beneftis !be puIk~ dllrh.. llIf,rffI'om.

So, iJDI ..., all ,.,.. w;toQeatu aad WI)QJd be I4Nell... Kftt 'S ,uar las! CbaDel 10 Up' beta" lilt SIIprtlu Coar! UDtiI after tbt 1965 tv IX1IIIlDlllo.a!

The Appellate Finalists 8, Bn.L GOYETTE

.

10&30 PENK AVEN UE

eompetltloa. " COIQJlO6lte oIlbeH briefs Is ~ IISI'(!

Wbe!t tILls ,-.r'e """,lilt.! Moot Court tIaallsts I pair 01. broCbenI-bl-law wtll be pitted aplDst eftb otIMr. Herb COIIIII!f IIId Jim Carl, wW <wOM Jay FIDe" C - ' , 1roIber-Ia-Il.., &DdFtlIIOaaitli.

ThHe toar .m-:ed tl'OIII ItIe HmI-ftDal ~ IM~ III J _ nen blylt'llMd Ibe ~01 ... MiWldrtW1D( mtu&lIelmUar 10 IIItI 01.1'1 ... Yon state. 8erpr •• If... Ten. deeJdedbylbe U.s. S\cItflIt Court ill .-clued !be If... Tort .... 1llle0ll-

meet,

.,_.J_, JlJ1S

S.".mbtr, 1961

II I j

J.y FIDeIl, 2', II; I .u.. 01 PltlIl;urfb aIld, ,.... C_ r , bot ..ttRded BeIlMI HIP Scbool. K, llIter.e! Rellsnw.r Pol)'tecbllk 1IIt1tUIe III TTo" N~w Yon, 00 I NIlI\OoI.l Merit Sc~blp lhJoup G...n l wotan wbert b. 1IIII!nrfod ID CbetakaI Ea·

"iiDHrlllc.

...ott. lIld !MIs \lie !DOlt stllD~ &lid 1IIIonIatI..

__ w . . . ..tu . . . . Ia....

.

III 'all ICIJh>nX'rt JMI" JIY ..... 1M kII;torr u.s rqTaplly 1P"'1a hl .. R.P.!.', CollIet Bowl~.

Hla ~ _ U. JaUIJD_ n.. , I 'i!I:I.. eootests &ad root t.d to sellool n.. '1 500 KiIolarsIIlp ptDU doattd b1 GeftenJ Electne. a . . NXess bdo" I II&doIaI ttoll<r\S1oD a\lditac., JI1 ",., ' ThlI; ..... ' " molt pcll:ll!c experlellet of IIlr w.. Enr yOOdy wu COOd 10 \IS aDdw. wtre "'III tilt roya.l trea\tD~1 10 New Y(lrk.

The WOO" n .. WHO were jUlt faBlU lk. '

OeIp!te • r1(ol"Ollll xadflllk tebedllie lie was

Ibl. 10 pla, botb buebeU &ad fOotbI.Il. &I: Il0l', DOl tuell' taDIISWtk .boII! ~ toottaIl CII"ftI".

Two

)'flirt

*CO R.P.L ...-:t a I tr. . 01 1..-,

. bE COIIIeevth'e plHS wiUlooll I "l"\eAotr, I.IId l.y wu IMn rlCbl 10 lilt .1dIt or all _ ~ ....1Ua;. "TheIr!lK!CtO was · Yo. cu't 10M ' _ all ' boll nut Jar was tllen tilty dld JUt tbll. 1"011 raLl, bad 10 10.,. roollllll to pla, al R..P..L III tb:IIt '-1$.

Ht It marrlt4 and U.... III CuU' SJ\am:loD. Hla

HERBERT 8. C(lrIm;R

Hub t:OIIDIIr, 25, IwI beeD. I Ylttsbutper lor A ~ 01 Belbe\ HJ&tI Scbool, IllsIorJ' ud m""'" .. P"!\oqlIIy al DIII_ III oddItjoD 10 bt\llc I broIMr 01 PU

,.&ni.

tile Ia&I teD lit ll\ajot'" IrI

---

r or 11M lui tIIntI ~'rI Her b _ bao;I a .erid 01 )om rt.,q 111m ~ .lIIp1o,.... eI· ptrinct.

Ia 111M be worked tor Alder . Wr1cbI ud BarroD 10 acquinl !eplGP'rt.::' btfon_ter!DC law tellOOL TIll folkrWiDC ..... lIIfr "" worked fGf 11M BIlu.on" OIIIo~ua ' pDCtJ~r.· ' I dro .. apIl_ all "y." Herb ta,., 'II1II Ie was r1IQ'ecI wort . !hI I It - 1M _ y was coocI ud tb8 peep\I . .rI ~.I, IDI1trutlDc·' LtJt Allllller 1M wortt4l11r tbr AUepn, COUDty DeputaI .... 01 EIIYiM'm"ta\ s.IIIIlMI*tIII(.Wim· 1II\11c pCIOli. Kill job was to IIIIbI e,rta.Ia Qoa1 !be ckioriM COI&eIlt 1Il1Uu.! "" 10 tIM mtt beaIU ~. !I~ wu lCIIIlltted (TIe 10 all till COId1 !MIblk pools, but dIdII'l II.... MJ tIa, 1o laM tap 01 lilt bcUlUu. For lilt Iut two ,..n Utd>. 1IM tItfII married 10 tM tor. . . _ _ rJDa. FIae!t·, .~r.s.u.b I \eaI:lIV II tilt Cui stnuas Etemtlll:U'J SeaooI ID st. CIW ToWlAip. H, rb , .... IIIIt lit lias pt...-uy beDtfllleo1 f'roIII Ills eolll~ III U. moot court prornlll. H• • 1ater,,1.e! III trial wwt attt.r &ftduaIlOfI lIld 1M btue,.. IlIIt III, upar~ be CAD ptIItr lkq 1M Q J wW be !IIOft~ . "!111M tilt cDlllpetitbe allllOSpben of U. moot tov1 PfOIJ'UI II • pKI 1hlIIc." lit sa1d, ' aDC! .. peclsUJ· 10 for 1II,.IDc, 1 1lopt to ..... lt IIIrc::an.-.'

wife 80001, was .. 5peteb C(ltreetlOll major al Wa.rqlltl\e and t eeeived lief lllUten cieCrflt from NorUrweslen..

Sbe teacllflll IptCLal tCIIca.lioa II hUlttDOtt Scbool for E'KtptIoNj CII.lldrMl 10 Seibel

"".

Jay . ._sed

I

doNltt

cn4UIU... ud ILls SUCCfIU

rw

trl.I.I wort antr

wm. eM IMP jl;ll:lpmeab

ud np6d r«all requIrIlcI lor COU~ Bowl Iadkale IlIat be IMlIoap 111 I cOCIfocND. He fetb" lhal tbt Tr1al Wool Court procram for tblJ ,..ar will p-uI b1DI III opportIIaIty 10 dttumllll wIleIlIer lit raU, .... Itl.at IftIrt.

-Jo""

..mu-

YfWlCES LOUlSE at.uTIS

.'~'. tammatt', rru <:IIodU . . . III lief ute III Pltllburp.. sa.. ...Ind ~r ~, edacl.tIca I' St. Xlner Ac:ade!n, IIlI111U"t:17 LaIrObt, h., IlIld trom IKnI abe C&lIM! 10 1JoQquIIII . tor IIIIdtt~1I st\Id1l11. The preuIIH 01 u.A.pptuatt Wool COIIft COlllpetltklO III DOt Weely to IItJ)c\Ir btr III 5be 11M bid p\ellly of spea.k\JIc upIIr lellu. III botb bIP tebool &lid coil'", alii .... IoCU... III IortIllX' &lid speat Ioar :ran 011 DIiq , , . . , ~ ttpl"dId dttJa&e tum. lier bome III North VttRI.Uts TDW1I!U4I III ruled wttb 10 IIIUJ ~ l1li1 &lie la .able to rtc.all _ I tn_iii" tiler rtplUlllL Fru compa.c.e! liar L'lrst rwo )Un 11 1M DI, ScbooI but tIIiI 1'&r me tnuIerT.e! to tbII ["f!Hdac Scbool 10 .aI* bar 10 WOZ"k. SlIt lias alIo bttII .. praetor \.D. 51:. .(l1li'. HI1I for till lui two ,.,., IJuI • wtlI til forc.cl to ullllpbb. tIIJ.a pooIl aDd t1Ad III ~eat..

Sbe t1DCII ~t won III Pllt's Rll.ltb t.w ClDltr \Ilt.trtlStb«. rtwU"d1lrc. and 1Jtfar1lllU.... SM 11 .11 1M

ttIaJ

Ir{IIIt s«Uoo of I OIIIII pDr I""KftI"Ck procnIII btl CI- Plu.bllrp _ of till -.!:kXI'. bUt

arc:,

eomptttl.Md .... '"'ttcl:!!.

Fru baa worttll1 • &n)ects for tile sw. 01 T_, tIM NIlkIoal 1Dsttt... 01 Welll&l HetltII, ud tilt Uu1tf1d StaIN Ait Force. A~eatI" ~ T _ lti1Jtatut . . pu.Md IIId ~edlawsilldlscrlllllll· IleI, III tile put aDd IIObDCIy 1IU taUr sure wbieb.

1.1.... n rt 011. lilt boOIu! ud wh\l:b n rt DOl. So tile ii_till Law Ctllhr ..... ~ to. cod1ty 1.11 u... laws . TIle Air rOl"ft bid _ r rtcordold all of IbI; eow1 IDII1lII r tpOrU &tid lllat IUt t.U to rru ud bet _111M IS did 1M eodItlctU.. 01.

JAW£$ 8. C.uu:T Jlm Cart, earIIId ILls IPOI In Ibe t\DI.ls by doIIIC I JICIIIIU' S job wIleII ILls puber. Lea Costa, wu lorct<! to drop out 01 the oompeUtIooo beea_ 01 111.

1ItP. Car.,. IIad 10 to 1.I!lee. and \lie l l&e 01 tbt lit was txt<! wUII CIII 0AI.f bt*"P"tcblecl bJ IIIoe otboer tIIret 1IDalJ5tr;; bec:I-. rlaUu lilt amo.a 01 work, tlmtandeatr"tbtJlallumba.,. pal kIwud bill tnJ*rt1i!lIl. Brli be . . . rewarded tor \lis .tlIr~ w\Ul1lls "Iec~ for tM tIDUI. lim sptoI I wee pr.rt of lID IU', ~. III KllIbII:ky, but IW; bUy IlION III "lt1Zbutp wbea lit was IJt IlIP «booL A1ttr ,",,'lllre from St. Enabetll Klib Scllool, be weD! 10 \lie UlLlnnlly 0' Pltbbluill wilen lit IIIl.jor«llll_le.I. 1'hlII SIIIIlmeJ" lit worUd lor \lie rtrm 0 1 c.c:&, CobttI, &ad O'Brl.. wtieb Ie IoeIMd IJt tile Law .. nll.DC' 1kIUdiDC. TIll I1nD • -.tal, ....,l"fed 11 Ia\:Dr taw ud trill ..... as p.Il1ItlfI"l r. h.

U.... ,... IdhUieoI 01. tbIII lira __ to tit rICIIt II willi Jim's OQ pnttreoc, tlr I IIptCtalty after be ,","1M Be. tlPKWJ, IDlIrtstotd III tr1I.l

w.

CGi, ..,.

JURIS

S."HlHr, 1961

alIlIIlIII::I.l MIlIIIIlWl Ibroopout tile OOUIItTy. Frill '.13 bet major problem aftoeor f\II.WLlIIt: law Kbooi will bI ,...1 pttIac I job.. ' 1' . Ioot\IIc

for -eUilir( willi I cr-I cIe&.I 01 HCVity ud ~ Ilk. wotl:iII.C lor a bdI! or I eon:nr.&D bt'C1UII' 01 lilt added benefits of iIIIIIr""IIP, peasioll piaDI, ud stable wol1!l.I.c &it rw met I eral deal of r-.l$taIICt 10 Wrln( I WOIIIUI la..,.er. TheJ_1II 10 IN I IbI.t Ilfttr tnlDlJC me lor Ihr... }'I:IrS or so ru rei IIWTIIId ud Ita.. lIMP.. wllb. go rltwo 011 twlr lanstmelll.

boW"..

' Bul tbeJ III1Itr .... lilY tiDd 01 ClllrIII&II IJI.ai w'beo u., Wre I I11III be'U star wUII tbem. few do IIIOIt awe Ia..,.en clIIIIp tbIIlr }GtIs an.- • COIIIIII GI PftJ"', too.'

.... 'IV,

11&"

hte Eight

Professor Louis L. Manderino HE'S A TlGER;II]. .IIbat'.wbatbe'mbell. ~1iDI b&lI wlUI llasaa. dIpeadt.cc OG "'-". ta11Di It. "'bat""' IIA b'. Qllec!. It'. _ pI!~ fl:ll<y allllleu: LoW L. lIudttmo. ~_ 01 La_. PrWe;uor 1laDcIer1,Qa, or . t..., lit "MaDdy". II tlllllltll!llll rear .. a Inembit 01 the f'Ia1l-ttml facility al lIN! SelIoo] of "'_ .

Sme. lie dartf4 III Its9 u a fIal]-ttm, Ulstruo::tot, OM ttU &ftft' tile 0., Dtrt:l\Oll -as ISU.bUlbid at DaQ_, - ' at the students -tIo b.a~ nlkedtMH hall$ . " beet) tlpOHd to 1I1III11_tl.m1 or LIIOlbllt.

Alter beiDc cndUIt..:I tromtlltIbnar1JU_Scboo]

al'. also a wa1tIDc.stereo let. or I

111 1954, ilr. WuderlDo IpI!aI two ,.,.. elt,,"- tor JIIdp AustiD L. StaJt, of !be 'T'IIlN Clmdl eOIll'! of Appeals. III eul, 1956. Loa ud l1li broCbtr Jim, a pt4aale 01 1M lIaift!n]ty of ilkbJpa ScbDoI 01

La_, btt:U prt"le pnclk, til 1IN!1r boGIl to.-rl of 101-. T1It reu ] \15, II .... lmpn1ut Cot tor LOll IUaStrlno UId ler [)rqqu.Hu VClhe . ,lty; tor II

... IIIR. uklsclerk:sltl:lwuelllliDc.lbatJudct Staler ~1Iie<I

b.LaI with tile posslttuty cf .eb!nr, OIl. put-Uml tub, a counIl III Eo1dmc. at OuqlH!$De. £Yt~.,. stroDe IlYorlte W1tb I.CI'/. d HarYll'd,prt· sellte(! It! entic:l.De cb:l.lleop. A$ It ullllllitel y wort~ out, Ill) position wu IIIeII open, and Lov, "forrettlD(' ..bout l.achlDc, turne(l hili tntllu$lum low'ar4 print!

prac tice.

Lou bu • bUy IactIf'OllDd of 1Jtud, IDd ~ work . H1I !atlltr, ADttIoIry f. WudtrlllO, CUDI to !til cl)llllif1 III 11m from Calabrll II -a.en KlKmI by Ills tnelldiS u • A.f.. " Loa'. !allier worUt IIucI u • IIbon!' In rm- aDd be . . . _ IiIDf IIuIkIIIIC bMdrW • .lfttr IabDrilI( lot _raJ ,e&f$, "A.r .· ~!IIe beDet1t:I of ~ c'-UIed sWIed Llb:lr. 1oI~ aaad .... tlAiiltatlcr,sk1Iled

llaJ,.

.._ &lid ~ IIWI, " A,r. · tq'tr tJ' applied OIIlJ' Ie be told lie 'QS IlOl: qvaUtled. TlIII IorellWl lIked Intbulastk. appikalll ~ 10 hlf'I b.LaI ucI tnlo. him III tile stills of ~. He mul'lIed 10 ltall III 1m lid stayed brlUly; aceompuylDc klm kef wu hI.s DeW bride. The l«aD6trino' ••etla.d IIIIo&celII$('IIlIId raised their lamUy tlIen, TIle ~I eliII<'..

Wary, locIIy If; !be fIIOther of IIebt prls IDd _ boT. L.ov b tilt neood dIUcI m:I be 11 tlIr" ,.., oIr. tlaII J1I!I • .lila MDierlDo .~ ID 1M Stall! t..c. bltlm-e UId b W foe" n-e1«UOG Dell :rear. ill tourtIII &lid MIl UudlerIDo eWllr. &f'I JoIapIIl:It. • a.-e..ue IDd !IIOtber of t.o, IIId Betty t.o.. .to;Il Ul'lIII ..1 IIoIIM alICl worttll&" al PUut.p I'I'~ Buk. ThiI. laby of the b Uy, Bob," r«tIIllJ' IW' rltd alICl U,.q 1.11 BAlo.

*

-coo'!"""

JUIlIS

Stpltl!l~tr, 1961

CD pICt

w.-

",1 Niu

.-.....u

~ rr- """ tI&M, • A.F.· - . p e l W. e~ 10 .a.tr by MWIIC 1.11 ~k. .".. LOll ~ IIiII IfUI&U bo.X ILIII Alber IIpeaI: boar'I 1.11 tilt ttttlIto ~ E.,u.tI WiG Ilk eb1II1NL DIlIctIt &Dd penlmllll wort willi !lit If'UIIII&r &Dd . 1*rby dktbary lit.. fWlllled I/) ID amo.t ......pW.. ..n.rtac ot tbt Ell(.

UIII . . . , . . !1UI. • fl1Dt1J "" 1:lIbII aceUll. 'n!Yi

bola,.

U ' ~~_for lDt..~ ... tn1ttd ill Ama1c:a at. Ole .,. at. 1'; owy t . .

taatcn* U, ~

of IIItt .,. ell! ~ tMt .EII iD

at. tIma.

SCHOOL YEARS

III lUI ...1, .:booI. ,..,.111 tile W_ _ Pablk SelIooII LoiI aeeUed" ICIIlmDc I!ICIWilc Ius tIw:I • hJl .tal. of · ... •• • • AI Scllool, Lou u .

"_'.!Up

IabUlMd • r«:Ol"d of ,.ul,. _ompl1sllmerlb. H. ... tlldlclto tile StIIdeaI CourIcU II . . . .

III lLI .I1rS'I rear, I.IId ..ned .. Pr.1OIot tor hto ,.UI. TN Utle CIII Pn.ktNt CIUII. tuUy to La.; III Iddltlol 10 !lie Staat C(ux:11. lit 91.1 I PrtJy of lilt Latla C IIIb, JIIIIkIt ClaM, Sam ClaN, U. Bud, DIbdt Cia lie ... t1to Yt&rboI;il Edltor.m..Qlef III Il1I ..Illor rev ...... rdl "I,. IlUlUltoas. H, l elll*"!! Ibt top soon III Ibt IIItloa III the Nal10aal For_Ie ~e and was el«:ted Pr~ Speaker 01 tM KouI. of R4tlTHtlllati\'tl III tilt P.aasylvaala JIIIIior l..tciILatvI. T1II ~ m.ui.l:lif\Llawa.rd ....

1M 'tOte 01 klI; leUo"lilISeDtII .. lilt _ W08t Lltely ~

_IItltI."

.......

AtlI.u., coJI.. . 0. a .:bolarllllp, Lou 91.1 ad. mltted 10 $I. VIDe_f. Coil.,. III Latrobe, PIGMy)'I'I1II&. Nun '1kkIIIc • bll, III Q\Ikt.l, ldded to IL1& prtor ldIlenm.... HI p&rlk4*ted III tile Wid-CeQ._ tvy Wll.tte H_CoaI'relleIOllCIllIdnI~&IId YOIItbI.lld .... Il&D'ltod to Who'. Wbc III Allllr leatllJaI"nIUu;&IIII CoUtp.1a I1IIMlior )W,r. N. ...l»Pir &lid reubook ..orb ..e" IImf-eoa.;lIIIIlIIC bY! Loll IItIoApd to elubl &lid of'P..lll*l P'~ 011 ~pu5 udofLHlYU I c\tleplt 10 tilt Na&.1 Faratloa 01 CalIIoIie Col. • 8tuOeci1l lor IUM """, MnIII( II lilt JrilGoalJ. Prwidelll ID Il1I I-.Jor reu. nat omc. called ~r tT..II abra&d u WlU II wtw. lilt Vatted~. Lou trl"ioed ~OOO IIIIfIlC "'lara 01. ome"a.::~ Irlpi 1De~ toalertlt. Ia BI'8da &Dd AlD5terdam II tbe Amllleu dtltpla 10 !lie Pu 1lotu..aI.1Iut. IIlUOaal Stutleat Coacr.... III. Io~k d:1UI _ aWB1i5 llr too lIIIIIel'OQi to alDUoD. St; Vl..:eat'.

awr.,

au..

I~

Loa

I

~I«

01 Artl dfCrH.

a...jarld

III ft!~, ud p-&dlllted e.m .... ill lilt IIIPPff . _ per CIIIl of ilia elua.

TBE BEGINN I MG OF' A LAW CAREER

H&nu4 tGtJo.otd eoUert. Lou Pieled Ilanan:I tor lay tWdIH almoIt U ~ lUll. tWe bedltk*llo III. COlI. . . ~,.~, _ ~UC&aDII tor .... -ellool

....1III1ltd. aad It ... W4r-...dto C&III.bI'1dce...... .

1C'mWtI. Be ... N:IdIlr ~td Ilut Yltbout a ~Lq.1Iad 10 work forkll tatUCa&Dd ~

ud Boud. A ...aa, wtC 0... TOCIkr fo\loQd" kII &n1ftl. III wUel • IcI&II ... ll'TUIpd. KI ... ~ &:Il a ClI) drtHr bill an.t two IIIdIa of trM 10 IbI kII ...., If'CMIII1, lit QIIll 10 ~ u ad III spotIecI 1.11 !be PIae..... BIII'IIII. fli ... CIIIf.rtd a r_ trtIII til. a..1IIDOIIt IamUy III rttun:I for I1&fII dutll• • loin. a..wnOllt W'Qntod tor tilt R.bUettl ~ &Dd Lou oftea I!e~ WlIb thlII KUvlly, IItbo\c11 De .... &lid stUl remliAl I Ulll ril [)emoel'lt. loI rs. a..u .

IIUIlit rl"OCll"td Lou'. IbWlr &lid abI arr UlCad for Lw to wwt.: at ller IluliblDd·. pluUe pluto Loa Ilad to hlk:II. II!lI:. 10 work lor lilt II to 7 &111ft IU lilt pilDt, CO 10 elau.. III Ibe CIIOnIlJic &lid [.tau 110m. tor lleep &lid lIhIdy. KI"u ..ttr promottd t.o tile J,ft'1'IIODII. t:IIlft.

Mttr tilt tint year. Prot. WudlrlDD _nebular. .hlp, so IIlat b.Lt tullioa 110 IoiIC'Ir wu a proble1D. HI did. bowever. eolllitIUt to W'Qn IQIbe summ.u, &lid IIoId down lb. plul1el pllllt pccltloD to mtelllla I I. At Harvard. IloIrc wllb !hi --.I aeth'ltl.. bot was • Rarvard VohlDlMr [)eft. r lor two ,.,...

Thls prop-am. wt.Iclo lItOlfId hlNdtprion &lid __ aebIIJ eourltOOla uperiaaee, prvred to beill1'l.lv&bII. TbII, &lid tilt oCtIItr trtn~WTkUar III!:th1Ut:I lit m. ppd III, obrioosl, II)(j: _ Uml .....,ttom IIlII Job. boa bJ thIs tlme ilia Iltber . . . .bIe III RllllIUlII IIIIIil UIlNIla of IIIOIIeJ fr'DII!I time 10 tim. 10 111-. oat.

Loa nturoed 10 WO'"' .... 10 HllIPlpttrate pne • tiCI. HI& boate tDWD trlellda "e" IJIUllrtsed to_ IIJIII r etlln! to tbIm after attead1Rc H&nvd. (HI ... tile IICODd boy tr'OIII W - . to IlteaO Kanud La ..

SdIooIJ TbII 91.1 ....., Loa wuU:I, &lid ften 1M! WUi&td 10 pnctlct •

pe_.

' FATE " AliD ... TE ... CHING C.lREER

n

1& 1M -..er ofl95t, Iftft' Loll bad ' 1Dr. lilt Idea of ttlcllll( .... aca!II CIIII. ~. He n«hld I IIUIr tna IIIlN EtaalIttII Slltlll, ut1Dc U bt ...." lUll ~td ill ttlclllDc. 11. rtplitd tbat lit m.I&\II III, &lid 1.11 1nrentn .... arrupd.

Udr; lItarrIn', Loa 91.1 ClllfIlnCl tlIIt job of LIpl R..m III IbI Iall of 1t56, &lid Ltc1J1&UcI IbI tolknrlllc 1tIriIc. At be bad bite 1.11.. t.fIItad DIll, III !Meht., E~. lit Aid lID, plettd ... iIlI lilt,. pat 011 kit . .t, &Ddlllarted oat !III door. a II III !til poIDt, III • ~ tbaI " Flte" toot 91.1

~. ~, tbaI

*t_

"'1

......

AI be ~ 4o'WII tlIIt IlI.ll &lid out tbt 000t, ot ~ lor 100II. lit a... a IDIII ~biQc Illm In

1M cort1dcr. ThlI_ ... J. Pall! flll'nU,. tor mlr proltIIM at DaQ_ wbo Will lit r ememberl(! by mur. 1.CId. "I"}' bl&b.1, rupecttd &lid sueeesmlat· tGnIty. Ht IDtrodaeed. hJ.aut1t 10 Lou, &lid ubi 'II'IIJ'

~I .... IDIIIt bIIIkI1IIC. Oa IIIlIIrtold!be d r tWlllllaDI:aI, Mr. FatTI U loot Loll by !be arm , &lid IIegIn to laU .111 boY woodemJ It .... 10 teach, ~ If It wuo't OM" lttOfltt nb)e:l. Be!ort LoiI ton wbat . . . bIp. pWDc. be bIIId IlIIIIIeIt bact In Wbs Sbdb's otrIet .. lib his . ., ott. liltealll( to "J. hul." The rVIIII 01 ilia! coa"rsatioo WIll tblt he Iccepted the )XI IS It .toad, &lid bepn to 1Me~ Ler;tl Researeb tbat faU. n ..u In Dec.mbar of 1956 tII1t Toomu f. QIIimI CIIII, 10 DuqueSDe U DeaD 01 u..,. L.a •• Sebool. Hf .tarled to recrull • t\I.U-tIm . faeulty for IbI! Oay 01 • 1&1o!II. 'II!ie~ wu Kbedulfd to , brt In thf WI ot IU 8. Lou was IWNlldled bt' Deau~UI prospee.

II.. IutruelOr. ud Loll wu iDteUliled, IIIlfIJ " .v Iold IIlat • t\I.U·Um, prOIusor eou.Id DOl c:arry 011 1.11 oullide Ia.. PfUtke. IoIr. WudlrlDO Ita.:! JUSI beeooQe r.U, 111101...:1 't'Itb trlll 'Io'Orl;. aDd ns 1IIl'lo1lliD.;: 10 ,I.. It ~ . . . . III tOIIOO !t .. \!I!joJ3bl~. So ooee &pin 1.111 UIo\IPIS of beeomlDi • tuU ·tIme I",Chet torrou~, &lid Lou eM111II1III III I part-lim. ill· . trllC!or. H. cODttlll..t, tbat w• .w oac:. ap.ID . tHe" 10 take a bud, ill 11M 'P11Di of 1958.

Lou laid naeu, cuUn his elluel tIIaI,... to 1..:lI EriIIIDoIlII UIt £lCbt1tboo1.AlIIU'!-U-prot_, U .... lSI: e.coa. u ....U u a.tol.tlllollIM'lU'!-

"I"

_*'

s.p, •• bt,.

1961

RECR VITIoIEI'IT PROGRAIoI f or . tim • • Loll IIIId 011 10 alIoat 60\ at his 01&. side Ia.. practlee. butbylMZ IIe .... 1IO Ioapr utually praclieillr. III IIIQ. &loDe wttIl c\ttOC1A( !WI t1mIlO Ills t_bl.q K btdule. lit \!IIICIerIooI{ lilt lob of r .. t nillillg lie" madeDiI 'or tIIt.:boo1. IIJ5 .I1rS'I ef1ot18 ..tn lICIt too luectu1l!1. IDr bJ tria tiIIIt LoI! COl aro.d 10 tile eollolpl. oCber nc:nIIl!t'$ IIad .... seMdlLled to IlItft Witt UIt IMIl'IIled 1\!Udtol:J, &Dd pk:~ .... r. slIlII. TN .at reu, Loll .....1Gdr. I _ lIIeti10d of rlCrll1meat. 1lIs\eatl 01 IIII1tl1:11: wilb ': CI'Oq) 01 ZO 10' 30 IIDoU II 0lIl tllIIl, II .... llII CODIIIKII rlCr-ailIDc Itc:ba.IQtIe. LoI! ~ttd IbI DeiDI • .&IId pte.1deatI: CIII tile eolleCU. ud IN."'* IlI& l\'IIlI.bUIty 10 IIIta II ttl _bIJ spubr, wtUcb.,.., uri .aI..mtratn,..tIM4I.Now. Loa had. 1.11 wtilDCt 01 UIadHdI lor ~ nl:tJe re:ndtIII(. ~ nnlItd .. I lOOS IauaM ill __ ron..!: at D 1 . . ill !lie S*'l1UM .-n. no.p

con.

-eM" ,

(II " " " _ _ _

Pot'

r..

Congratulations from

The Staff of the

Duquesne University law Review Richard S . Do nlz.un,

tJ;t..~

Egan Chapter

Hear~ily

Welcomes

~~Juris"

to the Law School

Phi Alpha Delta Law fraternity JURIS

Stp',mlttr, 1967

Editorial:

PROFESSIONALISM

You're In law school now.

You want to be an attorney. You'll go to school for three or four years. pick up a degree if you're lucky and go -Downtown, ' Is this all that law school means, or does It meSI) something more? Is a legal education all you should achieve at school ? When you get -Downtown," you will be expected to conduct youl'Self In the ssme manner as other uttorneys. You'll be expected to wear your white shirt. vest and striped tie, lunch fit the Colonnade. dine at the Le Mont. '..,jtb a large helping of law at each mea i,and join the lOCAl ooWltry club or Universlty Club . In short . along with being an att orney. you're a professionaL The Cfictionary defines wProfeasionnllsm" as : "The methods, manners, and

spirit of

profession ." ThJ sobvlolls\yencompassesacling 9S the established me mbe rs act, and recognizing the same set of s tandards and traditions.

No longer can you as an individual recogniz e and utilize your own values and mores when they come into confllct with those of the legal community lit large. You must now adhere to lind accept the same responsibiliti es as e veryone else in the legal fie ld it is he r e in the School of Law that you should begin to recognl.z e this respon sibility to the profession . It is here and now that you pick up some of the ~ methods , manners. and spjrit ~ that comprise the definition of professionalism . As there 'is obviously no course of study ava ila ble to help you In this endea vor. [t therefore becomes a PERSONA L responsibility to achieve this professional attitude on your II

of the pl"ofession

OW"

An easy way to acquire a professional all' about yourself is to copy: copy the wayan attomey dresses: copy the way he talks and acts: and try to copy the way he th inks.

Learning t o trunk as- an attorney is pe r haps the most importa nt. If you begi n to think like an attorney you wllt soon de \'elop a professional ai r aboul a1\ you do. This professional atm9sphere should be manifest e<l especially In your work at school.

You no longer have the undergraduate prerogatIve of doing as little as you can to get by.

You now have an obligation to perform 10 the utmost of your abili ty . This Is especially important In your SchOOl work, for If you att empt to sUde through school with a minImum of effort. it will show. [t will show not only here, but more i mportantly In your work after graduation.

Your work habits in law school w!ll carryover In your practice . If you do shoddy work now. 100 w!ll continue to do so later. Though this msy not be conSidered cheating In the traditional sense, that Is exactly what It amount s to. You w!ll be cheating your client out of your best efforts to whi ch he is entitled , and you wHl be cheating in your responsibility to the legal profession to conform to the hi ghes t possible pe.rsonal and worldng standards.

Professionalism may be considered in a sens e to be conforming to group standards, but it Is more . It actuall y is development of a personal mode of conduc t that Is patterned after a traditional mod e of performance. The unwritten rules of a profe ssion are really only a point of departure. Professionalism Is much more than following all the rules and guidelines of the field you enter . It Is a .way of life itself. which for you as a student In the School of La w should be followed.

MANDERINO

tOlltinu.d from pog' 9

be I:; no ~r acl1vely recrult1Dg students, tile results 0( his euUer eUorts U1I st1ll being &I>own III the UOwlDg DUmber of $~nts *W1)'1D( aDd com..lllC to !be ScbooJ of La ....

A FULL DAY AltholIrb be 110

~r

the otrld.al polkr at Duqtleslll! University that Its taeo.ltr sbo~ be ~o\ll"lgtod. to become IDrolved In commUDitr and cine &lfa1rs,- LooquictJyadded, "The <bys of I!\e 1Y0ry Tower coDCeptofeduc:ationU1l gooe.

A teacher ID IlIIIiverslty such as IhisCHIe sboold N!Cop:ti.u a duty aM respoosIbl.ut1 to serve hili COD1m lr nlty and be a nJlllble aDd be~l cltbeo. "

recruits, LOll .bu DOt slowed

dowl>. He Is married to !be former There.u. Zilka (vadaate of SetooHW w:ltha B.A. ID PoUtieal Scleoee),

A TEACHER ABOVE ALL

aDd II IbIl falbeJ" of. tIIre-e daue:bttrs, Susan, Laurie, aDd Amy, Carr)'lng a hili tAach!ag load, be aWl engages ID eOllSllttant wnrt: 00 bII<lretarr aDd lep.l matters Involl'\lli Fade,.1 aDd state loaDS aDd p:anl$ to munklr-l bodies. He Is a sebool dlreetor and eOUlleilmlD III WOIleSSeu aDd serYeS as Prasldent of the Holy Name Society of St. ~taD CItllrcb..1I.is club Dlembersbl]lls Ioollide ttu! E1t5 aDd I<Illghts of COJIUlllI:io.E, aDd be Is elWr!JWI of' I!\e MOll Valley Civic MlISk Assoclatloo. He slls 111 DUmerOIlli boards OJf dl.r0ctors aDd t100s time rot t.cb1..De • Bible class

The J!lI.pII.CJ of Lou Mal>derloo Is feU from tIJe first day of class by all studetlts.

He IoY1!S lea<:blAg. TfI&CbIDg, to Professor Man_ derlno, Is a creaUve e.tper:IeDCe wllere I!\e stodlmt Is tbe crell.ior.

'A lII"oressor sbould I'lllYe Iha stldeDi with aproblem aDd allow bIm 10 arrl,e alibi ilIIIiwer blmsalf '

at hU; ]lI.f!sb cburcb.

Receotly, Loo was

DOmiDlted as a delepte to the State CooslltlllklOl.l CooVIIIIUMI from ttJ.e tbIrty-seeOlld Senatotia.l Dl$trlet. Wbec asked If tII.J.s acl1vtty Is proper tw a professor of Ia_, Lou lIlSwoeM "It Is

be inaJntaJns. ' Prof.sor MaOOerIoo bas IDdeed comp.lledanama..zIng record of ~ic aDd ciYic accomplWlmellts, but, perhaps, tile mos1 signinclllt tribute a law professor CIIII ever attalD Is tIH! admirat/OQ of hili stu_ dellts. R&ymond F. Sekula, L '65, aDd !be bolder of. a L.L.M.. trom tile U.aJYet$Jty of Vlrgl.DJa wbere be later served 011 ttJ.e tacalty, $IIIllmarheci his fe-ellllgs ton.rd Lollls W~riDo,

JUIiIS

5'1'1111111..-, 1961

'To be

as a student, m&lllber of tile

$UN,

la!:u1ty, aDd an anorDer, I lIave llllver mown I more d)'lWllic, articulate, aDd Insptn.tIOIW teaeber. "

Lou has tile great abillty of provl(\in.g guld:ulc:i In dWerenl ways to d.ltferent llldhidual.s. For seven.l yeus, Mr. Manderloo spopsond tile Moot Trial Program aDd lectured at various ttm~s III 1M 1100 points of trial recb.nlque. His trial e:rperie~ and t.q~t belped m:l.llY students 10 i more pollsblKl trial practICe, One r eeent gTiduate, Lury GaUens, L ' 65, nOW assoc1atoo ... ltII tOO PQblic [)efeoo~r's Oltic~, pul it thIs-..y: 'Wr. Wanderioo's lecb.u"es ID tbe s trat~gy 0( trial proc edure provided Wi 'll'itll tbe most valuable tools tIlat I lI"qulred In taw scbooi. They

baW! sened me

e~treme ty

... ell

In mI' two years

bel\lre Ih<! be D<!h. ' F. Jef1ru:soo BragOOll., L '67, properly cbaracLou as "dytQtll le and dedleated" wile irwin

teriz~

B. Wedoor , L '65, otl;ervEld IIlat Loo

tile abHity

"ba,,;

to 00 a l\igI:tly SIlCCe$StuI practicing aitorDeY, tvt lo .~s

teaeblng. " Professor Leu runs a unlq\Ie TorlS clus. lils use 01 rldlcul<;lU$ esamples ... Ith a powt ue oot 10rirO\tllu.

H. Aroold Ge!sky, L '67, remembel"ll Lou's classes:

"Profe$S<Jr Ma.o:IeriDo has tile IIIliq!lOO abHity to bre.altle IUe into the s~bjOCt lie IS tea<:lI\.Qg . !lis Itnaglnatlve 2llproacb , hII; wtailiDI: energy wills deep loyalty to Duquesne Un\ve rslt)'make the course be teacbes Wliorgettable aperlenees In le.1.l1linii:. "

Professor Loo Mariderloo Is aooW! all, a te&cbe r ; Is a lell"ber that studellts respect aDd tb~re ls DO hlgber r eward ~ \balln hls pr<>fession,

be

PERSONAL FEELINGS Professor MaDderfDo credits ("0/0 men lor InnuellClng bls life. 10 coU~ wbare Lou was ma)Corlag lD Ph!Jo.sopby, Faiber Erie laUjtbI bIm ID a

Professor Loots L. MaOOerlDo ("Ma.odY- as be Is alfectlOlll\aly and respIlCItlJ.U)· rllferred to) Is \IIlQ\I&SI:ionablya 'Man BeblDd tbeScenes ' botll ID \be G(lQratioo. aDd UOfi!J · of tile La ...

School. As u eduulOr, be combiDes thefiDest of \be tbeoreti.calltoowllldge and. practical uperleoce so esseDtialIn Cl"aduii.1ing lbecall.ber OJf studellts \be professlou aDd Bar rigbttully e xpect froll) ~SPII. Que of Lou's Dl.I.Dy oolstaJldilla qualities Is !be dialogue be Is tble to ceoorare betw"eeo blmseU w:l Ills students wblcb manllests itself In a cOIIIitart sll"ftm <>f tra1tlc to bIs oftIce. He makes h!rw;;elf antJable at all OOIlC"S of tIJt . day aDd ILlgbt for !be beatf\t at bl.s sludentl!.• His ablllUes and c~blUties transceod tbose at leaeb1llg am reacb out IDto tile areas InditlooaJly admWsttatlve. The ItrideS made In developiDg ODe of tile top MootCwrt 1'l000000ms l"nI.IabIe bl 1liiy Law ScbooJ ue certal4ly , crOO1l to Loo's capable guklance aDd dlJ"ectloo.

His er.deIi"fOl1I ID tile Law ScbooJ Recruitment I'locram have mel With mIlCh success III \be

at eoot:IJllllDg ellJ"Ollment UOWlll.

Durhlg my term aseditorofIbeLa.wReI'Iew", I became IDcreas1lla:ly aware of tile capacity of Professor MaoderiAo. His lIIItltiog etforls In euId1netbe Law Re'llew w:llts members COlItrlbuted immellSllrably to the &lICCeBS of that

form

pubUcU1ort.

.

EDWARD G. O'CONNOR, L '65 E~. Swm''''' w:l COOlin

First in

I

Continuing Serin -

Neighborhood Legal Services Association: No Longer Mere Lip Service B,

"l'Iot/llili raotll$moRlDtHblllllubnrt tban. broodlDcsense of lD/usUef. nlnt$s . , eao pat lip with, bullDJusljct 1IIlke.s: us n1tt to pull thIngs dowa. • -RtpnaJd lIebtr Smith

TIle e~ts 01 th1s pas l SWlImer ttl" Cil'u added to the words or R.II. Smith, tIlo ltpllid plolI ... t. RHlIzil1c that local If1r.lI al:d soeletlu "'ere falliJlg to provide adequate help for the poor, lJ'Je Federal CO~t~.nt neated the LIp! Servlees braneh of th' Off1e' 01 E«IlIOmle Oppor tunity In. slCni!lcllll attempt to reach the goal 01 "Equal Justice UDde r law •• The Lepl 5ervl<:es group In J>!tI$bllrp Is thf Neighborhood LapJ Setrlees Assocl.allou(berflnlfter referred \0 lUI NLSA) and Is directed bJ R. OIin1d Roth.maD. Although primaril y fIIndl'd bJ tile Federal govetllllltnt Its polley Is set by • local blud 01 directo rs. S1Do:e ~LSA btpllQI)I'rat1otl 00 Ma, I, 19M II ~as haudled o~r 5000 nsl'S, stutlIDc eYkltllll:f 01 the poor 's lINd lor us1staDce. Orlg\llally "LSA btd IllDe olflees. all !oeattd III tile CIt~" Downtown, North Side, Soultl Side, Hili OIstrl<:t, llome ... ood·Brus~tol\, East Llber1r-Garfleld, llazelwood -Glenwood, La.reneeTIlle, and SouUI OU!;llJd. Receolly NLSA upanded 10 encompau all 01 AUtgheD)' CoUllty and IaJ arlded ofOce$ In McKeesport, Tarentum, and McKees Rocks. ~LSA has a !'\I1l-Urne 1tat1 0I14attoneys wbo are nol permilled to bav. an, prlnte pneUCf. For I"" $mnmer Nl..SA hires. s~ asslsblll 'or neb allOttlfy, _ I I fttIm DuqutSDe aod SeYl"II from Pttt.

G~ t inlel'1!Sl bat; ilMlI lbown III these Slmmfr IlOSl lloos ,nd the st"ft neeeasfa.l applkants for the fllJit sum/ftfr from o..peSDe Wfr~ Rlcha, ~ Dorf~n,

PATRIC K J. McKINLEY JClHJI' R. KOiRICK

.--.

THE MINOR JUD ICIARY

.~igbt

Thomas Godlewski, JoI:II! Kenrick, Lollis Lougttren , ~trlck McKinley, LouIs Vllt! IOncI SttVf Waror.lnsk\ (.all !tom !he clus of \9Gt). ill addItlOIIto reprue!lUng lrldlVidual cUen15NLSA IS contrJbuting 10 statutory n!form and 15 matiD( J.II elfort 10 iJ>crf!ue t ~ a lmocl non~isleot lep.! educaUon of the poor.

Most of tIw problems the IXIOr brllle 10 NLSA torney an! ill tile folio-in«: areu of iii., pI1!l1mlnarF hllr\JIgS on erlmlna! eharps be{or. tilt minor Jqdl d ary, ~ court. landlo rd IOncI telllllt, support, a~'IoD and eusWdy, c!l.allct of =f, lIlempioymelll compeusattoo, social seeu r lty, PQbUcassl~ e,COD­ tflcts of 111 ktnds aDd debtor'! rights. TIll> nelgbtwJf' hood otTlc\!S alro ~Hvt all the lrItaIo:e and relerral rule1e ' or dlyon~ .:l'!! "p'ratioo eases W/lk:h are lul.')dled by a voluntef"T ,.anei of laW}"l!r& from the AI-

.t-

lerhfny COIIIlty Bar A.1'S'''' llIlloD,. S!Dee l'LSA attorneys d.Il!I(lt represent a ~ UM I where tiler_ \$ a ;»$slblUty of a fet tnvolV@(!, Ille !l~!ihoorbood otrk:es also S£I"W as :lZ! nlellSion 01 t::f I! v A5Soelallon's \.twyer H~­ letral S.rVlef ln It>.at cUfiIts wlIo have I lee gt'OOn.l'Ili CUI! lIId do 001 t::ow 1II Itton'lty a n! releerl'd tileR. 8il1ee lhe ~on 01 !o'LSA Ibttt ha$ beo!I: a notieflbl. iDcrl'llSl' t: !be oomber 01 referrals.

NLSA attorneys represent tnd.ileots at prlUmill::l.ry be«rlngs on cr iminal chatteS before JusUces of Ibt Peace. Aldermetl aDd Maljil;trl1es. U the eUul Is beld for eou rt hili defease al trial Is lalctl! over by Ib~ Public Detendu's omce.

Becauu \I Is permissible to "sbop V()IUld" for tile alderlllJ.II of. yocu cboloee. NLSJ. attorneys have had tll awea.{ in maar far · nUll( ueu of ttle ~ounty. The hearing room maybe the IlIIc~ room of a grocery store, the aJdermlll'S tJasement, or a smaU room "'!th a desk IOncI a f~'" clWrs. UsuaU)· ttI. hearlngs are In tht UterllOOII a..rxI alllhHUU lrUehfdulfOd.for ttle same tlmt. " Is IlOt unusual fot the alderlllllll to eaU ~ eUe of tile NLSA attorney last. ne offlee Is cro",ded wltII S"'e:ott1 people, halt ol1l'lIom ue Uw!re for Im.lrlnp on ~urety of the peace or UUull aDd laner y t b.arfHI. These ru ottenses 5e!"Ve as IIDf 01 till:' p"~1 vellieles of oppressioa 01 the JIOOr, by till:' poor, In AUegheay COIIIlt,.

CIoet! a person llIP'ln belort the alderman and !lgtI$ a crim inal comp~t, IbfUSerman'Sco'lStablld run QIIt to the re$ldellCf of till! del&DdlIll tlld lalc e blm iIIto custody. The person Is bro~tbt to the Ik\o1rmu's olnef and asked lor bond motIIy. U the person caa alford bood and does I!i(It kIlO"" beadsman, tile friendly cOlIStable will ttDd a bonckllllD lOt h.Im.ODemlgtll ask U II Is mere ebanoe thaI the $.tIIIe boadsllWl appears at the same aldermu e.-err Hille. U tilt person doI$ not hue the 1IlOlII!, tor bolId the constable may let bIm I" to r a day to ftDd the money. TbfI (\e:fellCbJ:i.1 either f1Dds the IIIOIWY or Is jaUt<!. Altbougb NLSA. I11Ir be able to ifl a nominal bond (f~ boDd) lor the de!endaIlt, V<!ry Ie ... people ill powerl)' areas koo ..

• bout this and tllfreloTt poII l ttle bolld money b!lore even com ln!: to the nelghbotbood olflce. Furtber more. a nominal rood Is sutlle\ent WltU the dale 01 trial In ~ rlmloal cour t ",bereas Ihe boud plJd lor by the cUeol I.! ooly good up to the dale 01 Ilea r lDr, ... ben. if tbe delendaJlt Is held for court, J.IIOlIlfrtolldlsDfCessarr. for a person CD publlc assublle, t!It $12(J-$UO, rept t'SfDti1l¥ two bonds, (JI id 10 l he ~m.lO may be ball a mootbs !Deome.

AlnIQIII lIIvarlably Ihe defendanl Is Mid lor eoort: tile pRUmtoary b6a.rl.Dg siDe ~ all tllal Is neees,:;ary 1.0 IIoId this person lor court Is sligblly IJKlrc Ir-.n a !cinlil!a ot 'vidence. TM alderman only gels his costs II Ibe defe~nt Is held lor coorl or If !be case Is ~t

n tll e<!. Stoee In surety

JURIS

anda.s:R.~ !tcasu1btdelellClut

~'pI.mb ll , 1967

H. DAVID ROTHMAN Dirutor

Neighborhood legal Services usually brings • cOlllllernU befort "his" aldtl'llllD • the usual ruull Is thai both s mb ani settled siDee It Is eheaper to ply eost$ {aboolSZS) 1baD to pay bood. pay cO$I$, and sHU bage the IlOSslb111ty 0( being found tullty ill criminal cour l. lrI \be tDd resolt, the only dlffereoce betw... n DDt br ln,tnr 'lilt al all andsettllog cOWltersui15 \$ I!t:lt in I~t la tttr the partles pal' the alo;!e rm:l,ll mOlllly. lrI c!v:tl c~es, :my lawyer worth his salt knows L~lt I minor jOCkiary ~ase m~ns lOO~tII,I for tile ~laint1.ll. 11 Is Ihls faCI. that aldennen are ruonln~ a bus\Ms! illsleao or ~ syslem 01 f\lSUet, lhat allSE'd o~ attorarJ Ie l'LSA to comment: "Thtrt are fe_ Utas III our judlcJal system ttI:I.t an! .as mc rMlblf ; ac.~lnl In J"almess. !lI5tke, and <I!Ie proc'u as the 50 called minor /IIdIeiary. TbesysteJII per rotti ('RMru iDeom;>ttfuCf and al./nOSl rf(Juire6 bias. '

MANDERIHO

Faculty Interview

cOII'iRUt4! Iro. ,... 11

maJority of eourwI. Loa r _IllltJera 'UIlt f&!llei iric ' 0&**1 It! lin worlda of kIIo1ritdp to F~r H\!(G I tw.e!M-~ of hidorpt SJ. VIIIceaI·. dllfilla tilt tlme De . . . IIUlM from Fill Y..... umytn;itJ 10 Cb1DL. Loa tolt tIIal ratMr HUCO· ... till

1IltI.· .

w:u

Juris Welcomes Professor Twerski'

mod 1Ittw,tat mulfVOl' met.·

FUller Eric bu .mee pused I"Y &lid Fltller lIuro retunaed to FII Yeac University wtIeD It was lnIIIItetnd to Talwu.

ProfUlOr IIUlderlao 1& I r&rIIlly II'W ID. tile trIIo _ of !be WW'd. He rell!UD$ cion tu bill t~r. wbo 1& ..,... 7'1 but still ubib1bi !be vibrtDCe &lid l.qul,ltlveDM.S at.)'OOtb.

~

AutlD Twvski Joltallilt facility II DII.-

qlleSDe Law School tllIa ,.at. He tau be.- udplICI clusM ID Acm:J, Coarucl at La ... IIId III. l leelil'l!,

MmlJi1$trw.tift LI...

JURIS iIIlervlltrtd Prot,,~ 1'nrtld 1D lllaomce 011 ~ellb,!II tIcior 01 Rockwell Ka.Il. HI .... ....., aeeommodattac III IlttmpC1JlC< I!? llIIi . .r Ibtquu1u. pili tortb tu hlm.

AN ASSET

Q-Had 100 eYer IIear4 of DuquuOll baton be1a( 01-

feredl pooIltlOllIl...,

Profeuor IiaD:Ser1DO Is respeetod &lid l4mlnd by klI atDdent&. '" • fta&I word 011 II!U mu. ea11.111cler tbIIi state111_ b7 Cbarlts E. Ens, L 'I'l'.

MR. TWERSKI: YII. AI • matter 01 tact, I rteli11ha1 I bad researcbed III art1cit 1n the nUl lsN! of Ibi 0\IquefIIf La.. Re't1, .. while iwuroUlllllhrqvette (L.L.B. 85). II WU III rnscl. by WUllam

'!II lilY op1nion. Professor l4uII3er1DO Is • re&l bIue-chlp asset. prclealolllll, aOO perto tile Seboo l of Law.

Y..,.r pertl1A1ll& 10 prodUCllll.bllltr. '" I recall..

Y r. Yeqer bid written tlle artie!, tor lIle \.11_.

11 ... qultt &deq\Ilte, aDd I R&d it 1D conJUlletloD wtltl 1ll1 dud.. at WUqoMtte.

&0III1I,.

.w

IIllIId. IborovP kDcrwledp ot 1M &lid ltIiUt, tu dFnlmk:allJ' amoeate wttb l1liCUIIJ pernaSi_ maD IWD _ at till L1MIt lUI; ktc

Q-How nr, )'!lII1IWM ....n It IbI

tea.eI>en I 111." enr mit. J pu~uJ:ar IJ 1Ib1rl II1i c~ tIrst-dus prales.s'-1 IllUlller aOO eIn1abMt dJWty to comlllUlUeat. lID trtU III'Ith otbers. LoII's IdIft oca:en wtth tile a.dtGl body aOO wtUI aU rx.ta of Iep.I edacaUoa, u WIill IS Ids ueeDeol eIassroom Illlitrw:Ucill, plI.ee IWD hiP 011 tile Us! of wpor1allt r..'frii ilia P'OWUl &lid ncceu; at. UW; I4w,JdloCll"

t81.eh1n& pwlUOlll

II~?

YR. TVo"ERS!Q: I WU ftm 1nlen1end b)' Oeao Qu..lrm aDd Dr. Yllml.y. on-,lIad <lOme 10 Harvudto see me aDd d.lIcllUOd tile pooIUioD. IIIIWDe<I to ' " tIIeIIl apia at tile COIIYetII:Ioo at on- AmerlcaD La.. ScbccII AuoellJloa., aOO w. dlsclllAld It tur-

...,.

Prol_ 1.oIdI L. IiIlIdlrlIIO bu f'IIll!1ll.cI lilt at Ids IIl&fI ~l clau. He III.J suecwdled. III tile ~ _ _ of tile wor4.

w.

Q-.... did I'0Il nm He CW' beWtttu.I eampu&. aDd Ut !baA IIIJ ~ tIIal JOII Iefli tIIlt _ 'I11l 111." to _ ! u?

pPlClatIoM

WH. TWERSKI: .... n.1 tlnl Ykttedo.;,.;-thlsput Warell. OIl _ of PiUsbuflb'l typicall, bIaIItIfIIIl 1Pr1Dc days. lam DOtr~,~Sl,InIot IbI preble_ tIIal l 'I11l1ll.... lofaceillcbanclDi from Bar-

ftl'd 10 ~. I wtll", tllal ~ ..... I diftenllt procUar'l ot t..... bhIC tIIe~ ltu.a ts: ~ II lhnan1. YOI! see. II tIJ.n-ard II 1$ eommoa!bat tIrsl reu stlIdeta lrl lakeolbnNcb I IrlIllfOlll be&ina1Dc to !!lid. aOO tbeII tbfoaCIIlbe ~ TbtD thi II8rt IIIOQIlI tbIJ IN t&upt lAp! EIII1ei . Here It t:luquas:III tbe course Is IIIOrl Ia-

.""....

Q-WlaI prompted your oom.lDc;

te~?

MR. TWERSKl: I ClIDl to D\aq1MlSD' beeallSe I 1I'IIlled te Iaeb.1 reallJ tojoJ lilt stlmlllat10ll of tbeom1Di aDd Ibl:traetlllg I legal pollll to the IDftIl1te cIe(roe. TIlls 15' SOIDellWl&: tIIIl elIIIIOt be doIIt ill pn.ctlce becallff! ill practict )'011 ban to produce, ADoIbet TeaIiOII would be Illli tIIis 1s1lOt1." factery beu, \II 0W0fi1101l to soma otber scboolli. AI Iluquesoe I bopa IlllIIIIe studectlS .... lllll.nIH OIlp:lrtuDity te be able lo Iuhoulltlelep.l problems.

UId llIo Ill... sulf1c1eot time to meet .... th olber pror."IlI·S. students today 111." mon 01. social oatloot than ill tbe put. You CIII_ tbI& lD tbetr iDteresl III $Ucll jobIi u public dereD(len. Tb1I 1& .tlet1a1te clrup III tile tl'PI of. sWdeDt.

• • • •

JURIS w1sbe5 ProtUSOl' Twerskt a ~r $b.1 II DII.H, Is I 1I'I!Ieoto1 , "'"11011 to OW' facility.

quMIIe.

I

STUDENT

ASSOCIATION

Officers:

JURJS

TIiOMAS w. SMITII, Pre.slo1oot MICHAEL J. ARANSON, Vice Presll1el'll EDWARD J. ABtS. Treasurer

S.pt.IIIMr. 1961

'.1' f,,,tt •••

Alumni Interviews

!L I.

111 all lalmKs, II III.' be up'· !..... tbol Mr. DobI rty &lid lilt. Cuey .-eft Il0l110formlid u 10 1IIt.~ 01 u.. unr'l1t1l' beforHuo;L SlDea . Ia~t's illCC. . Is flllll.Sllnd by ~ 11I>00.III of prepl.rattOll, ~y Ife Iobus peel.lllyllwllfd lorthelt Improlnpl'a I.QI1rtri.

Q.-Wbal was 1M IlnSl. bl&:CW III )Wr IlU"Iy pnetle.,

fUI'l)I"l.$'

t

I

tl\lt JI'OII bad

A. -iolr. Cuty: How Uttle I lllllew aboQl. prXtk:lIJu., coateotll of pelWoa$, eoettllU of 1IIOUoas, ud so ... It _ really a probltln 10 m . aU lilt ..bIb ill tlIe bIct oI)011r mlDd. ~ pleuut $UfJJrls' was tile uIbt I rllC~l1'!d ftOIII oldt r aftOrlll}"S. Tbe help, ecoell1l, aoj s)'IDpllIIJ tba.! )'011 re-

Pfl1:ll.ps trw

s~e

<:el,. ls flmply amulDe. 1\ mUu }'OIl a1l'UI of what a DeO(JIIyte )'0\1 arl, bill JOII C&II' t help

belnC amued at lilt rtauLa. Interest lIIat etlre.

Q.-Wbat Wl'n till o",n::am.7 VUfC ENT M. CASEY, L-')4 WAJlCIOTfl &lid CASEY

blrcm

)'011

re_

005tIc1te: that )'OU bad 10

A._Job . Cauy: Ace. I found out l'SlIidJ1 tbat cllftta: lib 10 plaee tbdr coafIdence III &II older ma I

was

ttmpled

to

DOHiJIn

JOfUf A. L-'I$ LI'VUf(;.ST~, MD.LER, a.:IlUYWOOD

crow a lII015tKhe, &IIJ1blDI: 10

mah 1IIJ'H1f IDI* older .

....lIIner 01 !:be SIIalom 101001 Covi (ompet1lX1D, eompelN \II c:.o.tllJ' CI;IJI CompeUUoa... Law clnk 111 FedotnJOIIlrict Court CIt westen DIstrict 01 Pelllll... nt.rd CIIU.ll, ...:ItT \be HooonbM WIIlae. S. GoottMr.

Q.-How WOIJd JOII rate J'DIII' taw IC:bool echIcaUoa?

A.- Mr. Can,: £Ieellellt, I .-out nte It A cwnber OM. It Q,S u.. n-I practleal eo:t.c.llOCI that ClOt eoGJd rPelln. lIr. CUI, ...., klDd eDClUCb to rteet.. mt ill b~ ottIee durtnc one 01 Ids b\lsj dill'S and ..e ""ran OIIr Intent..... Tbe orne. Is located IrIIH Grant 11ui1d1Ps In dowfllOWII Pltt!ltllJ'ib.

Q.-1Po'hat Is !be alnc)e bIftesIl/IIsIUlg tlIIt I law ItudeGllIIlIIl mUf .... &nduItlo.1

•• -Wr . Cu.,: "-!wi to beemI, a realkt. No IIIO!"I lbIory. T"Horyls out. lIlibell)'Oll anomia .. .-:Il001 1becc"7 Is .. >1bl Jarl 01 )'0111' 1Itlr*!D(, ~o •• )'011 111111' become pnctical.

I reaU &/I 1neklenl: _ Hille wl'leB all attorney stood M or. I /lldce wbo ...., U IDem, of ills.

Tile

attorney bad a ease flaCU, III po\:ll 011 lid·

01 enoeoce, M 1Ila}lldp mIld apllllt 1M ,,\deotl&ry poUlt. The altortlfly then madt bl. mlstall:e. Mt s/IOuld bave ~1bM that tile ~ wu I!OI ",IDe to cba.ogt hl5 au.d, Instead, tilt a!SOt ..., tool Ihe toJt ~ to lilt beDc:h and u ptd with tN ~. T1Ie OWOSlllc anoINT . _ be_ IlIaI his adtwury was r!&bt. befthIa.IIJ, 11M attornt,. ~ Us book wtllllJlt '1u.:n-Ily II till JudIt and DUrowly lIIisHd IIl1a. nat was abollC tbe 0lIl, pnttlc:al t111Jrc 0..1 .. did. H, $boU:I t.. .. retra.ted ud trltd UOCIItr mLJ~\oII

-'.

Publlsbf<l, "lApI Ali~ts 01 Mtl1Ical Rf«ITd •• Worked. lor lwo years 1IIlbefirld,ofalltomAte<! ta_ seucllln8:.

We had Judge GlbSoII tet.cbtnr f"t6e1'1.l Pn.etk:e aDd (>I'(Icedu:re, aDd theN walD'1 a IIWI t.tt~r q1Q11f'Ied. JIIdp stew::l.rt tallClll T«ls. Wart Cn,Ij;

was YorklfIc at LaWyeT'S Tilt. Insurano:e COIII P1U11 and he bllCfJI Proptrt)'.

Tile courses were aU secoD:S IIIlurt 11'1 these pllliemell. Antr lilt COW"SI nde4 pOOl hid teulK'd tile S<Ib~t tboroaC!LIl, ud more ImportaDl, JOG di&!" forre! It ~alJP It qs pra.eUCaJud ~ ilia pncllal wa y.

O.-How _Id JOII nlll taw sellool fIlIdual. oIloda~' 1.'1 \'Omplred 10 the 11_ KIIooI cn.cm.IK '" Il\irty yean 110-:' A._ loI r. Casey: rm prejlldk:ed ptrtlall', bolt [ thlllk that todll thor ~ alll'lrMl)'ll, . reu IMrly years 110 thl'1 _en la...,..rs. By tIl\.s I "'tan.

IlIaI todi:fl &radlla' e practices !be ta_, lD 0pposition 10 lbe llIW)' t r _110 Uws tbllI_ .

or ewrse tbI ,..aduata todIr II mueh better qua.Ufled edaealiollllly, ud 1M, ITa Iar ~rIoI

t.tt11eetua1i.)'. n. octIr problem Willi loa!. r'1 Jf'8d-

,.1

U2t11is lllat he lIICb prlticaUlr. TMJ allsHm 10 be \II a burr,. TMr lui.. to IUe U. lim, '" ~r1tcl IbetT pnetie4: of tbt Ia_. ft' • • Iooc

--

-taGf!-' oa ~ Man-

JURIS

StjIt,mMr, 1961

MR . DQIIERT Y and 11I)e! tor IlIIICb allbe sual tim.

IS the bller't\,_. Mr. ~rtr was mosl eoqetllal and _ _ _ I"". Alter IuDCh lie aueed to ans wer n. loUa-tnc qouoestloDI; from widell "W staats 01 ioda, Ny bendll. TW law shdtal: more ItwI I ~ JtVs aro mlPt colilpar. tilt rtoea bere with llIe answers thaI tiler 1JIa1l\aYf rt- II gTaduallllII.

«

au"'I,

TUt I'JRSr Q'ItIItlon, asUd Mr. DolIef!, was. ' Wbat was !be I~lt ~I thlll~ IIIlII I 111._ Studlnt mWlt mu, a/'tIer lJ'I(lualloa1'"'

MR. DOHERTY: Tbe Silllrif

~

clwl(e, In III,

aplnlClG, \.s thlll JOIIIIOW must I:IakenaaJdeeIsJons.

YOII c.-:oC atforil tlIr hlnt1 of elldleq bypotbests as ...,. could Ia .. _ sc.bool. You mill! rtOl"pn!H )'OW'

I!liAktDc Ioto IlIOIe III a dolnC CIlIKltJ,

than • IbfIOr1-or\ente(S t'el&.

WHAT WAS )IOIlf staclt' biRest Hlpr" III JI)IIr nl'$l. 1"1' III ~tk .. ?

- .......' - ' from

CASEY

.-ee tovteeD-

~.,. "J

Tbe I1lOCkn dlKoY'l':'q lIIeCbod ts abused too mucll today. Som, UtotlleYi Ire lJSlDe 1\ lUuely 10 IIan6/i; and IJIIIOy I'llbel' tba.n to plead Ibo!Ir

.... _Mr. Cuey: An I eoald <10 Is ~raphrase, "til, L.a... Is I jet.JQ\IS mI.stnss." Theu Is DO tio;Je lor 1IIythlna; else U )'011 'ftIII III boll roocl'prac:.

Utioner. You must

c1e1'O~

".ery mlDute of )'Our time 10 tru! Ia... Especially, III the flnt yBlU'S of practic~.

"'l\OUler thing lor til attotr.ey 10 remlimOOr Is that be must always recophe til" dlgnIty oj tllecou.r:t, \XII tile IrId1rldual 'Ii'bo oce",te, 1M belICh, !Jut tilt beocb l!:seU. U I en,dllltiDg student ..en smarl lit 1fOIIld Ioo/r; 1.1110 11M! COWlra.meol lor zrome 1)lIt of postlloa.

There are owr 135 ~1J<: 1e$ aI>I1 a<1AI1I!blntlY'Ol boards Ill. Wasll~, D.C. , IU slatffd by at· torneys, ne .ork ,,1IIc~ tlley I re oolilC 1.1 00111 rewudillg &Del extremel)' IlItuesUDr. II "OIIkI prOOably tUe OIIe ytar IIQQe to di.!eoTtf fI'bal tile rules an or eatb or tile qtoelts. After flDdlIIg out !be nales ot eac:1I aceocf tile Ittoraey fI'OQ](\ IIIeG be ilbIe 10 $9fC1aU1e.

That's &IIOIb« polDl. Gndoatts sboorJd Itlernpt 10 spee1lllzol. TIlt daJ of lIIe ctotnl pncU~r Is jlllil abJut roae.

AootIIer ft rJ Inlpol1alll practleal pot,QllO UIII.... • ller ts thalltlol1lll)'S sboukllteep IMlr tw:dssepIl1IIe frolIl !be cUeol 's tImds.11 SHIIIlI that _ e UtoI1lll)'S nD.'t lUlderslllld IlIaI dleeJJeal' S _ J Is !lOt !belrs.

Q.-Wba.t adYke fI'OIIkI JIve to)

,1\ICIt~t

begtMln&;

1W:

.." scl:lool eati!tr?

.... - laIr. Case:r: The first thine thaI I wouW 00, biose<l (Ill my eIpllrl.aee, III iliaD tile PeIUlSy11'llll.a lJId Federal Constltutloos r"'luUeoJ rea~. I fJ.Dd that !ben are !be "eakes t points ID a lafl'Y'!r's mUO\lll. ThIs Is eV1delleed b)' tbe contusion In the r enslOD of the stale COOStltutiOD In Harris-

burr rlJbl ilOW. Too

many of

us t.odly cion'! reo

~

..

MR . DOHERTY: He sbOukl detl!rm1De fIlIa! IlI.s t:leld

I fI'OIIJd IIIInk !bat III tile Mure the rovemmelll Y1IJ play. ~r 1'011' In (be attorDe}" $lIfaclkt. w. w1ll ba VI! a captI re b&r. 1\ wm II.l be]lOfld SPKWlDtiOIl I.IId II 'flU be detrmetll:&l III the pra<:tIel 01 tile Jenera} bu'. II CIJI be fOTasE'en In the advent of \be Publlc Defellder, the Ne!gllborhood I..epJ Servtcas, the inODbpoly of IJ'nst comp:LOle.., and lIWlyother IndIutiOIli. Tht SOIII"Ces of bu51Des5 for a Ilrlvate pucU. tlooer are belllt remo'ffld. ""'htr.. the.e to be t\lt<!en or tweot)· atto' DeYs who lw.Idled tile hus\Qess lor "'!cOl, oow 001; fInD ~ It Ill. f'lrms tod:,tyare l1IttiDg larger , and more cODCeotrati'd OG the big husln" s. These art boIb cha.n(e$ today, and l preview of Ih.I.IIgs 10 eOllle.

SECOND, JlIl\f<I Colltley IDstI'I)Cts IDd advises his elerk,. IUs )"EIltS ot experJence IDd his lDsirbt are II'iU\:iOlltted to bts e!erlo:s; tberelo'r e,l bent· tilted ill a ulllQue fashion.

I would lite to I!lIteod my SlD<:ttf ttwW: to Mr. Casey 10. lib: e lllCldatln( """wpolnts IIId 1llISfl'eJ'f.

Q.'\'E MORE 1lIi.ac. T!w ~tlPg law s~ sbould DOt loot Ilr tile nluy. ratber, \be experteDCe. Of course, OIW w ... t be prac:tk'al, too.

'IS""

. .

. .

)'011 rale the .... sc/Iool (tadualts 01 today with UIIo&e of J:aSI JflUs ?

- eootitII.oed lrom

~

lovteu-

DOHERTY •• ,J,,,,·I lIiIR. DOHERTY: I would say tba.t the bll(tSt st.lllle s!IIllrise 1rU realiz1ni bow much ia" JOII really Itoow.

It fI'a$ pleulnl 10 be able 10 cHscllSS ItgaJ problem.l .-jill Ittor neys aod to /cIow ...nat )'011 were taI.Itl.De al.uut.

On the o(her band, I 1rU SW'lIfised at bo" mucb I had ~t to In.rll.

So mild 1rU I)etdt!od tor poUsh IUId finesse. To sum It ijp, It wollld probably be jU$1 I'iIttl.ll&: )'IIW'

Seeoadl1, I fI"OUkIadvbe hillllo .. ort iA COIIjImct10a wUII ollIe r stl.ldtlllS, am. U poss1bl~, u · 10""111 fI'IIo are DOl his COIIWmwT'lrles. Wort .till tIIo5e Qo are IlKlre erp.r1eoc~ !hall )'00, UcI. JOII elll't belp but to lfarll.

MR. DOHER'I'Y: 'lbat wonld be a cootinllltioll 01111)' wI &llSfl'er. 10 I woN. lIle JdeDtals. in ia" .scl:lool )'0\1 are prePll'ed for eonrt::OC)In fIOrt, lJId tauiIJt 10 Interpret tile ia". Aller aradlAl:Ion ..... OIIISI learD bo .. 10 ret Into court. how 10 ~t tbe proper for lllS , ud bo" 10 tile sucb tor ms.

I would say \bat I fUU tilD. day 5tWeQl wbo 'Ifotta for do'nIowIIstIoWd tIIl'elll ~ III ~1'WIII1IIc Itll:I" obItacle, _fllrIbeJess, II J.s

CODe.

rnmed.

""'y

WR . DOHERT\': I'm atrald tbU I couldn't bnoesll , t n.!ua.le I sltul.tIau 10 which I am so cJOSt. I eonl&t'1 be presump\1lOO$ enouctJ to that ClNc:k Seulata (L-61) n.s better P'WU'...:I b,l pne~ tbu (J. P.) Ir.icAt'cIIe oc (T .....) U'ftDptoa were wbeD graduated,

sa,

!be,

am, r~lath'ely speaklDg, a. lII~mber of !.be class 01 r ecent ara.clul.tes, I have IIOtbInr w1th wllk:b to compare tbtlll, sloot I doo't kIIow bow wtll Prec>ari'd oldEr attorDl)'!l were.

SINCE I

bearings.

Wt/AT WAS !be bl.i'iest oI;if;tlel,e \h:aJ )'W ~ to

A.-Mr. Casey. Well. II:H! IJIOCkn ol llle law pra<:tlce II to t:a.l<e IhlDp fot tor Hample, tocIt,)'QU plead an actioIIlII eKP"S5 COIIInct IJIal )"OIl sbonld hue placied III qllUltum mtl'lIlt. You expect 1M luc1rt to aIlDw!be error to be OV1Irlocted mel permit )'011 to recover. Tbis sbould DOl be cIDae. lt sbofl'$ Llet at pte$)ll'lHoo &Del sloppy pleadlni;. look alihi' result, I.IId IIOt tIM form. Ao alloroe, coukI CO IIIlJ1d plead anytl\lll( 1IoplD( durin( tbe II'IIJ 10 be able to ftIIIl somellilill: by aD abuse of the moOerD dlscoyery meltood or tact-ftDdIng.

For utmple, U hi is Inlerested lD Irlal .ork.

II.l Io IIle nnn "".r' be t l.ll cet tile most upni....::e lD tria l work before his deelsioo \.s macle tInal .

I wautid 10 be a trial IttorlllilY $0 the t..$1 Illlni; ilia! I cOllld do fI'U 10 pt a clerbhlp III the Fl(!etal C(lUl t Willi Judp Gollfiey . {Ieel that this was lilY beli t lIIove for two rea.'lOJ>S. f'IRST, btcause I was In \he court COllStanUy, I 'IoU able to see the best trial atlorneys ;Mlrform their tu.k$.

HOW WOULD

neet ..lat ..e u e Sl¢IP05ed 10 be protecllDi: III line willi our coostllutiOftal bellefs.

O.-Wbat ~ do JOII see ID tbe tutllre lor !be la", &Del orIW cbaages t\aq J'OII seell already?

of Inlertlt ts, ud eoaceotnle 00 perteeUDr this.

overcome?

,n.rm

an ~Ie. Someday perbaps there win be a brlt f _ I t or semlDlt ill Ia .. school cofl!l'iIIc

tb1a un..

HOlo' WOULD

)'011

nate

row

MR. DOIt£II:T'Y: £Ketijo:t.

law

sebool educ:at1oo?

Very sllEerely, I would

say tba.1 1I flU uetUeoI. 1.11 spite of some mlsslnr areas of IDstructSoo, I fI'nIIId sa7 tIIIl Dll;tueSDe olfetl l\'er )'tl1lnr tbII 1.11 Utorue1 aeedri: 10 1\'4nl III order 10 prulfce la .. sIJeus$fllUy.

WHAT ADVlC E would )"011 g:I~ his taw school ca.reer?

to a student

be;P.nnJ.ni

MR. DOHERTY: Read. Read. Reid.

Brie! !mIr, ca..se, and all castS tbaI )'Ou possIbly ~an. Don't take illY sbortcu\.s WIlD mucb IaU!r In )'OW' Ia" scbool car"t. Wbe!ber!be s tudtlnt Itoo'fl'S II or 001, be Iia!I !be time tn law scbool to do all the flOck. lie fI'OII'l baVi! !be Ullle III IIis la.. omc:e, 50 be bad better lISe tile thnt wttIle be's In scbool. tie bolll b.a" &1 .... )'11 IacIllle tim', 1..011, aDd ... alq,)'S &01 0I,It flOck 6oae. 'fIIen Is \XI reasoa wtly aU s~nlI; c:a.o'l do il.

HE SHOULD also ... tc:b tile Mool Coqrt Trials u otten as be eu to ,.1 lOlli' IDCIer stud1D( of fI'tlat lI'Ill Is Uk ••

..on

DO YOU see any cba.lliU ID ttle pnel1ce 01 Ll .. !bal

we IUJ I qlllCl III !be luaae1 MR. IXlHERTY: 'l'bat's a ftl")'lIroIod QUoes~ bot<evt:r, I "ould "' tbaI till _btt 01 Nportfd eases

iii arowtng 10 IIrre tballhere win be ID absolDte Me,"lt, for $(11111 decree oIlutomalloD to ,"1st In Je&rcblllg tbese eas... IIII1l1Y becom~ oects$l1'}' liter this slip Is lakaq. usumillc thai It Is laleta, to 111,. , I course III I.a.. scbool to teacb stlldelltll bow 10 s.uch by computer . Otber IIlaD ib is , I ooo'llhJ..u.k ibat l could predid lilY clla.oges "ltIl IIIJ (Iter_ ot &C<:o.&rraCy.

I sIIoWd 1I.t. 10 IbID.k Mr. Ooberly lor \be Ifme I.IId lDIt..-st tIIIl '- P'fe to ibis Interview. I ~ld &I.so 11);1 10 tIlaD/r; IIlm tor !be trw luDeh.

All alIImIIi an 1IIw1ted 10 elpres& tbetr seIIllmeal$ COIItfI'1llllc till ~ uted. &Del to 'f"'I1te tllelr on

I.IIIWlln to riot ed1tor 01 this colWIID UtbeJ 110 elK,",.

JU~IS

Sept'mlltr. 1967

' ov' SixtHI'!

We wookl Uh

IHebard J05epb., L

Recor

By LOUIS P. VI'I'I'I

Or! May Z, 1961, !he s lJ;leeotb _ I nllllll)a of DuqIlKDII La. alumni. wu held al tbt Hottl Wtb5t9r Hall In the Oakland ~tloa of Pllt.$tlaCfll. The IIDlUbtr of alumni 'I'bo atteDded refillCled the tremeDdous amollDl of VIOrk lhai.ml 11100 lbe plann1Drof the dinDer. Tbt alllIllni sll'eme<\ part1eularly happy to I:'ene.

past aeqIRlntances. Some of lhII more S(lUrtrt alter {trwe, were 1M Hooorabl. William F. CtreOM, aDd tbt HOIIOn.ble I.H. RIdge. No one .as IDOT<! .Um11 fllCelvtd than Thomas F. QIlInD, CierI:. of lbe Coort of Appeai!l of lIN! Tb.1rd Circuit, aDd lIN! past Deu of Duquesoe', Law School. It -.,uld $'eem lui !he alllll'lnl. stotlmtDts were well place<!, for II lias beell n1rle II>OIllhs IIlDce lie arJDOII!IC:ed his ru\il1atloa, aod II Ibe Ume of thLs wrltl!lr, thue !wi sllll been 1IO lwolntmeol of a I'IIn time d«a to f~laee Mr. 0u.Irm, Th\!l Ls, perhaps, a eompllmml !o Ibelt.

A eoektall bour prllCeded the dlnDer. GradllallDc law stude:ots were ab!t to take adva.lltage of the ~ven1ng 15 the guests 01 Mr. J,P. M ~Ardle, The bR!Iquet was a Wfl leome teUef to Ilw seniors who ~ }list completed e!use8 for the ,jay, and . ere lItarlJJ.g MIl"'lpletloa 0( their studies forever.

Upon completion ol!be cocktail bour mosl members ot !be t:ody rellred to dInJIt • • Some of tboISe preseot ..ere unable 10 remain, bowevu, because ot mon p~s~ duties.

One of these wu JoIIrl u.lella '66. PtacticlDg III tbt MallO. BuIlding WithC:wle7, Blrskl, aDd Clarke, aDd wrltlllC al ~ lame Ume lor Tile Plttsburrh Ltpl Jourtlll s bould kO!'ej) M• • Laldl& fairly busy,

TItt program's toastmaster, HOllOrable W!IIlaII"l r. Cet"roDt, did. aJI admlnble Job of IlanclJ.IIl& llIe nriollS Introduetloas aDd IIIgl11lg11t\Di: tilt program.

Judge Cen:OIW IoIIehed lClOIl !he lawyer' roli and ~IIOII II toda:r's society, aDd ho.. ~ law scllool pre....s ~ .u torDt1 for Ihls roM. Tbe Hoaon ble Her bert P. Sore thea IPlroduced thf I)OIa.bles to the dinDtr iUl'Sts. His tori'" taU: wu followe<:\ by !be introduction of !be Pres~ ot tile La ... School Alumni AssoelaUOn, lilt Hooorai.>le Joltfib 11. Ridge.

J\lClce Ridge lnfor me<1 all tht members o! the nct Uenl reviews Illat ~$lIf"S 14_5(, Il001 received trom the Atlantic [vaIuallDl! Comllllttw. Judge Ridge wall follo,....[ by a best of !pt.aker3. Among Itit mon notable .. ere Father lIeD;l" J J. MeAnull)", tile Presldenl of ~Sfle UoJl'erslty, aDd the HODOr_ able Austill L. Staller, Chief Jgdge 01 the Coo rt of Appnls tor !be Third Circuli.

• Arter !be dInIler we all nUred 10 drinks :aJJ:I dLseussiOll5. We ma.oared \(I se. Dr. Waltel" A. Rata1ko aDd R~mId McAnulty eolllluc:ttng a most Inl~resllng discussioo.

This Is a smal l WOJIOer , however, be<:ause all who were able 10 beDtfU by Ihelr IlIsIl"1ICting are a..-are of !belr rhetor ical skills.

George C. D!a.rnl/llopll\llos was reo:eiviDg coa rutuWlons 011 be~ admitted to the Pennsylvania Super ior Court. Mr .Olanlllltopollios also bad rllCe tved !l.ls promOlloo to Major In the U. S. Marine reserves.

H, maaagu to squeeze ill this {"e5er .....' time willIe pr:aetklDi Willi Samue l R. Sci ullo In the La.... lnO

FllwIce Bu1lcIlD&.

•

•

to utft!d

OW"

eoacratlllatloM

•

•

•

•

Mr . \'ktor K. LJllC b. L '58 ha5 been mat1Dc bet.dUnes -.,rtllli lor lilt " 'aler POUutloil COIItrol Assoc:laUOII of I'J.. He Is ewneUy adYoeat1JlC«rtalll directions for tbt ledtrll ...tlclpation 111 water quaUty managem enl. All 01 hls dirllCl1ft$ ilx:lucl, the S\lj)trvtsloo ot Ill"'" treatment ettorts bJ' local per.sll!lM'l. [woDdtr It lhtn lIe lIly adTocaw of ad<Uni GeldeD Tlllmbl. $coleb to the nUlr. Nuer beard of 11 ~ Th1s Ls th. bra!Id that ...as being sened al tbo aJ\IlIlIl blu!qutl.

.

·

Mr . &Djamln MeAIIlIY Is preserrtl, IUlOI h:\$ .... C'ltiDll from Waymlll, 1rl1D, Trusebel, Uld )l;e.o\ule" but 11', probable IlI&l he is 1101 £tttllI( mIlCh rest.

Hts wltf rllCeolly pve b1rUt 10 a taby rtrl. .. 11lII. 4 Ol., and Ib»:. three o'c1od: fl!fMilIlgs 11. IlOl condllc!vt to quiel nilf.!ls,

·

.

Any other information that may be relative to alumni Inltnst may be sent to this column and 1I"QUid be U_lly apprllClaled. ThallI< you.

J. P. McAr dle

•

Juris

lUll( U H U. So 1'05TAGf

PA I D l'Ilt.$bvJtl. Pa.

Duqu .... Uni•• roity School iiI UtW 600 Forb.. A......

Pittsburgh, Pennsylvenia 15219

horm!! No, 390

JURIS

•

S. I,mb, . 19 67

to

vpoe his recerrt appolntllltDl to tlIf "Public D(!findor' , ot1Ice. Kls t ft:lrts In moot eourl eompel1t1oA 15S1ftS lIS tblllll eUenls fortumt. toourh to baTt !II r. JOSfJ)h appolntt<'! 10 their ~U8 wt..D bl.YI! more Ihu eom peteol be~ftt of ~~eL .~,