Transcribing the Thermal Flows of the Jet Stream
An exploration of Atmospheric Circulation, Pressure Systems and Methods of Recording Meteorological Data
Contents Introduction Key Terms The Jet Stream & Climate Change Timeline of Events Climate Forecasting 01. Tropospheric Cartographies Meteorological Monitoring System Dynamic Weather Systems Stationary Weather Systems Historical UK Pressure Scenarios 02. Fluid Dynamics Set-Up Jet Stream Patterns Patterns of the Northern Hemisphere Cyclonic & Anti-cyclonic Behaviour 03. Jet Stream Transcripts The Drawing Machine Apparatus Functionality The Device in Action Measurable Data Transcripts 04. Site and Spatial Investigations Discerning a site Site Visit Local Customs and Vernacular Geological Investigations Site Analysis 05. Design Intent Masterplan Climate Beacon Stakeholders and Programme Timeline Form Generation 06. Design Realisation Overview Ground Floor Plan Section In Tune with the Wind Climate Compass Responsive Facade Climate Conference Upper Floor Plan Stone Etchings Physical Model 01 02 03 04 06 07 09 11 13 14 15 17 18 19 23 21 22 33 38
04. Site and Spatial Investigations
Discerning a site based on geographic
National and Local Scale Factors
The Outer Hebrides have historically experienced some of the most extreme recordings of atmospheric pressure in the UK. At the most North-Westerly location in the UK, the islands are closest to the threshold between the Polar Cell and Ferrel Cell, with a boundary that fluctuates between 50 and 60o. Moreover they are subject to the more frequent, Westerly fronts of strong Jet Stream Winds.
Zooming into the islands, the varied topography brings about stronger ground level winds, and the Isle of South Uist sees a rich landscape, popular hiking route and is dotted with communications systems and environmental monitoring equipment.
23
Beacons for COP26 Legend Record High Pressure Record Low Pressure Weather Stations Restricted Airspace Roads
On the Periphery Climate
World Coordinate Grid
Comparison of Two High-Altitude Zones of the Ferrel Cell
23
geographic thresholds and intersections
2 1 Hecla, South Uist 57.3 o N, 7.3 o W, 283 m elevation 6 km from coast, 3.8 km from roads. Close to hiking trail. Forest of Harris, Isle of Harris, 58o N, 7o W, 367m elevation 3.2 km from coast, 3.7 km from roads. Mountain peak in NW. 1 2 + 283 m + 12 m As the crow flies: 3.8km 1:21 sloped path: 6.2km
Northern
South Uist
Grasshopper simulation of 1:21 gradient path up to the
6km.
Harris - Westerly mountains block some of the strongest
Atlantic winds
- Easterly mountains exposes mainland to the strongest winds carried by the jet stream
site, over
Way of Life
24
Geology Local Construction
Crofting Land Divisions
Thatching
Crofting Land Divisions
Dry Stone Walling
Workshop with the Last Thatcher of Marram Grass
Site
Archaeology
24
Callanish Stone Circle
Dun Carloway Broch
Mount Hecla from the Roadside
Hike to Site Visit
Boggy Landscape of the South Uist Hills
Dimensions of Weather Attachment
25
Double-walled, Iron farmhouses. the galleries rooms retained form stones, to between. as
Iron Age Brochs
Double-walled, drystone towers from the Iron Age built as defensive structures and farmhouses. They provided protection from the stormy conditions of Atlantic Scotland; galleries within the walls shielded central rooms from the wet weather and voids retained the heat from the fire. A conical form was achieved by corbelling dry stones, and the cavities were wide enough to be occupied; even staircases would fit between. Those that remain climb as tall as 13m.
Neolithic Stone Circles Bothies Blackhouses
Prehistoric monuments consisting of standing stones in a circular arrangement. Their purpose is unknown, though they are speculated to have had religious, or social significance. Studies on their solar shading patterns imply their potential former use as an astronomical observatory. The Callanish Standing Stones on the Isle of Lewis range in dimensions of 0.5-5 metres x 0.2-1.8 metres. Their uniformity is a testament to the skilled craftsmen who erected them.
Relatively small, simple shelters built in remote areas, traditionally used by shepherds and forestry workers up in the mountains when they weren’t able to hike back to their settlements before darkness would fall. They are still used now by travellers and outdoor enthusiasts, they are free to use by anyone who needs.
Traditional Hebridean houses with thick stone or turf walls and thatch roofs, that were inhabited up until the early 20th Century. Typically they were built using dry-stone wall construction. The roofs supported by wooden rafters, with a layer of straw and then thatch from local marram or heather grass in the locality, secured in place by netting and stones.
25
Local Vernacular
Mount Hecla’s composition is of Lewisian gneiss on the western slopes and of gabbro to the east; both are unique forms of igneous rock with interesting appearances. Lewisian gneiss is distinctively banded in appearance due to the alignment of mineral grains during formation.
26 Geological Investigations
Section A - A
Section B - B
26 Investigations
Heather Growing Between the Rocks on Hecla Banded Grain Texture of Gneiss from a mountain on Lewis
View from the Hike to Hecla
Gneiss OS Grid Gabbro Peat LEGEND B B A A
Rock Samples Collected from Site
Topographic Analysis
Running a script to test the rate of increase in height over lateral distance
Digital Site Analysis Using Average Wind
Monthly Wind Averages and Vertical Profile
= Flat
= Steep
= Smooth rise
- ideal for site
- Avoid westward adjacency to a steep incline (due to turbulence)
Recursive subdivision of surface analysing height
Identifying zones with steep / shallow gradient
27
Topography
and
Topography
Average Annual Weather Data
Simulated Vorticity (Rotational Particle Behaviour)
27
SITE 1 7 10 4 Velocity (m/s)
CFD Simulation of Wind Velocity
A weather recording device at the intersection between world coordinate grid lines and the fluctuating boundary between two atmospheric air masses.
Emerging from the rich geology of the South Uist Hills in full exposure to Westerly winds, and sat just above the 1000mb pressure threshold, the building engages with the elements to amplify the tangible experience of the Jet Stream.
28 Masterplan
1 : 20 000 @ A2
28
A Climate Beacon at the Periphery of the Ferrel Cell
The Jet Stream as a Political Decision
The proposal seeks to tangibly communicate both long term patterns of climate, and the potential impact of impending global warming on the effects of more localised, short-term weather systems. Through various means of representation and kinetic response, the architecure engages with ground level aspects of weather and records patterns over time.
Patterns of the Jet Stream are directly affected by climate change, with the forecast of more frequent and intense1 extreme weather events caused by localised stationary pressure systems. This is of particular relevance to a remote, island location that on a higher level more subjective to extreme weather events and sea level rise. On the west coast and at the highest latitudes of the UK, the Outer Hebrides are exposed to the fronts of the polar jet stream, and have historically experienced some of the most extreme of national pressure recordings. 2 Moreover, the lifestyle of locals is so intrinsically governed by the weather, and the strong sense of community furthers the importance of implementing climate change adaptation strategies.
To achieve this, the architectural intervention will provide a facility for research, climate forecasting and political stratification. Rather than relying on a top-down approach to adaptation planning, the project will challenge the existing political hierarchy and respond to community initiatives, encouraging a collaborative approach to decision-making. Acting as a “Climate Beacon for the Western Isles” - engaging with local climate working groups and at a national scale when necessary - the scheme will lead the way into the development of effective climate adaptation strategies, and set a benchmark for other communities in the UK to emulate.
https://news.climate.columbia.edu/2022/07/05/more-frequent-european-heat-waves-linked-to-changes-in-jet-stream/
29
2 See map on page 11.
29
Closer Stakeholders:
MET Office
- UK National weather service and climate centre
UKESM
- National Earth Systems Model to support international efforts against climate change
Creative Carbon Scotland
- Provide training in carbon measurement and reduction, aid in policy making
Adaptation Scotland
- Raise awareness of impacts of climate change and identify means of adaptation
Community Energy Scotland
- Charity that aids communities in green energy development and decarbonisation
Outer Hebrides Community Planning Partnership
- Public agency partners collaborating for island wellbeing and development
Lan Thide
- The Outer Hebrides Climate Beacon (one of 7), to engage locals with climate change
Scale and Interaction
30
Stakeholders &
Engagement with Project Occupancy and Areas
30
& Programme
Project Timeline
31
Programme
Programme Matrixes
31
Form Generation
Developed from the Linework of the Drawing Device - South Uist 2020 Climate Plot
32
Laser Etching for Casting
32
Proposed Roof Plan
Hecla’s Jet Stream
Landscaped Wind Channels + Fins
Pressure Responsive Facade + Roof
Rainwater Tanks
Wind Tunnels + Acoustic Pipes
Material Storage
Totem Pole System
Stream
Archives Bothies Stone Archives Fabrication Area
Stone
Wind-Driven Form
Ground Floor Plan
https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1SMadjCjujvnRTTJD6tQqmFncWdWURnR-?usp=sharing https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1SMadjCjujvnRTTJD6tQqmFncWdWURnR-?usp=sharing
Datum +3m
Datum Level = MSL + 283m
All GL + FFL labels using this as 0.
Room Key:
01. Material Storage Zone
02. Rainwater Tanks
03. Wind Turbines
04. Renewables maintenance and storage
05. Climate Data Receiver Port at 57.3o, -7.3o
06. Small Data Management Office
07. Stone Archives Fabrication Zone
08. Community Amenities
34
01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 34
Grounding the Jet Stream
Section Of the Air: Wind Velocity
Of the Material
35
35 57.3 o N, 7.3 W
4 x internal turbines at 3kW each (in 25mph / 11m/s winds)
= 12kW capacity (based on precedents of similar scale)
36 In
Tune with
36 with the Wind
A Building as a Climate Compass
37
Lower Ground Floor Plan
Jet Stream Condition, S Wind, 2025
First Floor Plan
High Pressure, NE Wind, 2040
Long Section
Low Pressure, W Wind, 2050
Climate Beacon View
High Pressure, E Wind, 2055
37
Pressure - A Jet Stream
Pressure is used to forecast weather conditions, between 0.5 - 3 days in advance; and provides an indication of the jet stream latitude relative to a location. Low pressure corresponds to the jet stream trough, while high pressure signifies being in the peak, or an anticyclone. A responsive facade system acts like an aneroid barometer, as a small metal bellows of air expands and contracts with changing air pressure to induce helical motion; to architecturally express the jet stream’s current latitude.
https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1SMadjCjujvnRTTJD6tQqmFncWdWURnR-?usp=sharing https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1SMadjCjujvnRTTJD6tQqmFncWdWURnR-?usp=sharing
38 Triggering
a Kinetic Response
Stream Latitude Indicator
Response in the Facade
38
B B C C A A
Stormwater Management
39
Letting the Rain In
The Climate Conference Room
39
High Pressure / NE Wind Closed Facade Strategic Planning Mode Maximum Occupancy Low Pressure / SW wind Open Facade Water Harvesting Mode Minimum Occupancy 40 Weather Variable Occupancy Upper Floor Plan Datum +8m Room Key: 01. Climate Conference Room 02. Stone Archives 03. Maintenance Stair 04. Accommodation Bothies
01 02 04 03 40
Etched into Stone
The Jet Stream Archives are constructed over several decades to develop a physical, comprehensive archive of climate data; paying homage to the Hebridean neolithic stone circles.
41
2030-2040
2040-2050
2050-2060
2050-2060
41
Over time the stones in the archives are constructed according to pressure recordings. This would be a community-based craft enterprise whereby young people would stay in the accomodation temporarily for the short fabrication course, contributing to the rich stone heritage that is to come.
Left: Etched Jet Stream Pattern for Casting Below: Plaster casting against mould
42 The Archives Fabrication Reviving Stone
Casting against an etched pattern
Craftmanship
Fabrication Area
42
Stone
43 Of
Stone, Earth
Earth and Wicker
43