ภภภThe Evolution of Management Theory
ภภEconomic Forces
Social Forces
MANAGEMENT THEORY
Technological Forces
Political Forces
ภภภ1.
2.
3.
ภภภ(Early Thought)( – 1880) ภภ(The Classical Theory) (1880 – 1930) ภภ! ภ(The Behavioral Theory)(1930 – 1950)
Management
Management
Management
ภภภ( ) 4.
ภŕ¸
(The
Management
Management Theory)(1940 5.
- 1990) ภภ&' (The Management Theory)(1950 - )
Science
Contemporary
ภภภ( -1880) 1. 2.
3.
John Kay ภ!" # $% & 1733 James Hargreaves ( ( ) * +! ,$-. /0 0* 1 23$! $ภ- 40) 5 - % & 1765 $ภภ7 0ภ*/$ ",$%. $.ภ7" # $8 0 0ภ9 )8 $ :/ ภ$ #* % * ภ; < 00$ < !< 00$ $0-./07 ( 0$ =>0 5,000 (
ภภภ( -1880) 4. ภ$ A B $)( C+ 0 ภ4,$ < ! James Watt ( ( 8>4 % & 1765 - /) C+ 0 $ภD.$ $ ภ$ )0 % ภ$ A B $ - >0 0%E ) *$=>0 11 & < ! & 1776 5. Adam Smith -* James Watt #: F>+0ภ/ %. )ภภ$ ) * +! - *0"$0 $.ภ7-* ภ$ ( $% )"G 0ภ9 < ! Adam Smith ภ/ %. )ภภ$ H ( $7( $ )G ภ/ James Watt ภ/ %. )ภภ$ H $ ภ$ %E A* 00$ 4,$
Adam Smith
% . 0 C The Wealth of Nations & 1776 Adam Smith E 4%. ).I /$ภ$ - /00$ ภ",$ (Division of Labor) ภ/ %. )ภ#* % $ /$0J (C ( $7)E +! E$D)KA$ "$0 (specialization) .! ) *$ $ภภ$ ) * +! 0$ !/ !0$ . >+0 :/0$ !/ ! ภ0$ . >+0 )A $ = $- /* ( ",$0$ % " ภ8 4 % * ภ; E/$02&7C -* E/ 08 0 ภ$ ) * +! 0$ !/ ! $ภ0$ . >+0 ภ0$ . >+0 ",$%. 0 :D) !) *$ $7$ = $0)( C+ 0 ภ.*$!E 7$E/ !) 7ภ$ #* !/$0 ภ8>4 -* ",$%. .! - 00$
Robert Owen (&, 1771-1858)
% & 1799 Owen ) 5 #: ภ$ -* . / < 00$ " # $ .*$!-./0" + New Lanark % Scotland % E/ 0 4)8$ )8 ! ภ$ ; /$ â&#x20AC;&#x153;8 $A) $) C+ A ภ. / ).*C )ภ" + ภ$ 7$)A !0)AC+ FC4 =:ภ8$!-A0 $E A !/$0 4",$%. ) C+ 7) !-* ",$*$!( $7 0$7-* ( $7 $7$ =)KA$ !/ $ 08 0( ) $ $ภภ$ ; !$ $ " +8 $A) $#/$ ภ$ ( $ $.ภ7-* A$; E!ภ7) 5 8 4 J 8 $A) $)EC+ < ! * /$ 7/7 ภ$ $0 !" + ภ/$L$!% " +).I -ภ/ !/$0 4 )E 0 â&#x20AC;?4
Robert Owen (&, 1771-1858)
Owen . / 0 ภ1 ภ2 New Lanark ภ3 1 4 3 ภ3 4 1/56 47 ! 2 ภ3 4 8ภ94 ภ1/ 2 1 ! ! 9 ภ: 1/ŕ¸
4 1/ & ภ; < ภ4 2 56 47 95< &= 6 4 47 / 4 Owen 9. &= !/ภ1 6 2 .& Owen ภ8>? &= ภ5 1ภ5 1/ 18 >7 ภ!
5
Charles Babbage
(&,
1792-1871) ) 5 G$ $ $ ! $ (; G$ " + Cambridge 8 0 0ภ9 % . 0 C " + Babbage )8 ! 8>4 ) C+ 0 On the Economy of Machinery and Manufactures % & 1832 4 Babbage ) " +ภN)ภ;O % ภ$ -ภD.$"$0ภ$ ภ$ < ! Babbage )EC+ / $ ภภ$ ( ", $ภ$ ) ( $ . 0$ < !(, $ > 0=> 0 L$A % -* /$0ภ$!8 0( 0$ -* ( 7 .7$!0$ %. ).7$ 7 ภ" ภ8 0( 0$ A 7ภ%. 8 - , $ / $ ( 0$ " + ", $ ภ$ 0 "P L$A( / - /0 $ภ#*ภ,$ Charles
Babbage
Henry Towne
(&,
1844 - 1924) ) 5 G ภ)( C+ 0ภ*E$ )7 ภ-* ) 5 P$ " Yale and Towne Manufacturing !:/=>0 48 & < ! Towne )EC+ /$)"( (ภ$ ภ$ ( ,$7$ ! ภ%E !/$0) 5 % < 00$ -* !C ! /$ภ$ ภ$ ) 5 "!$G$ 0 4 ( $7 : / $ 0J " + 77$ $ภ#: H 0 $ ( " + , $ 7$G> ภ$-* =/ $ !" %. -ภ/ภ-* ภHenry Towne
ภภ(1880-1930) % "9 N ภ$ ภ$ - ) 7 (Classical Management Theory) 7 ,$ ภ( " + ,$( D 2 ,$ ภ(C ภ$ ภ$ - "!$G$ (Scientific Management) "9 N 0( ภ$ - ) 7 (Classical Organization Theory)
ภภภภ: 5 D
Dŕ¸
____________ ____________
Classical Classical Organization Organization Theory Theory ____________ ____________
The Themanagement management Of Ofwork work
The Themanagement management Of OfOrganization Organization
Scientific Scientific Management Management
ภภ: 5 D
ภ$ ภ$ - "!$G$ (Scientific Management) ) G>ภ$ภ$ ",$0$ - "!$G$ )AC+ 0 "P L$Aภ$ ",$0$ 8 0( 0$ #: , $ ( $7( ภ$ ภ$ - " !$G$ - ภ/ Frederick W. Taylor, Lillian Gibreth , Henry Gantt -* Harrington Emerson
ภ$ ภ$ - "!$G$ (Scientific ) !ภâ&#x20AC;&#x153;Efficiency Engineeringâ&#x20AC;? â&#x20AC;&#x153;Taylorismâ&#x20AC;?
Management)
$0" $
â&#x20AC;&#x153;Rationalismâ&#x20AC;?
or
Frederrick W.Taylor
9 Scientific Management (&, 1856 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 1915) Taylor )EC+ /$ â&#x20AC;&#x153;= $ ,$ 8 0) *$-* ( $7A!$!$7" +( 0$ - /* ( %E % ภ$ # * # * # * . >+ 0 . / ! $ 7 $ = * * 0 < ! ภ$ ) A + 7 ( $ 7 E, $ $ D (specialization) -* ภ$ - /00$ ภ",$ (division of labor) -* Taylor A B $.* ภภ$ 4 ภภ$ #* 7 "P L$A7$ภ8>4 â&#x20AC;? ภ$ % ภ$ )A +7 "P L$A% " +",$0$ -ภ/ 1 ภ4/ 1 G>ภ$=>0 P ภ$ " +( 0$ H 0$ % L$ 0$ /$0J * 7 ( $7 : % 0$ " 40.7 " +( 0$ 7 !:/- / 7/ ,$7$%E !/$0) 5 "$0ภ$ -* " * 0 P ภ$ ภ$ /$0J )AC+ 0 P ภ$ H 0$ 1 ภ4/ 2 ภ$ 7 P ภ$ H 0$ %.7/< !)8 ! ) 5 ภN-* ) ! 8 4 " + ) 5 7$ $ % ภ$ H 0$
1 ก4/ 3 ( )*C ก( 0$ !/$0 ( )AC+ %. ( 0$ " + )8 $7$7 " ก -* ( $7 $7$ = 0ก ( $7 ,$) 5 8 0L$ 0$ -* 7 ( 0$ %. H L $ 0$ $7กN-* ) ! 8 4 " + ) 5 7$ $ % ก$ H 0$ 1 ก4/ 4 ก,$. 8 0#*0$ " +! P 7. C " +! 7 -* A B $ ก$ /$!)AC+ %. $0 *ก ( 0$ " +7 #*0$ ). C ก /$ " +! 7
The Gilbreths 9 Time â&#x20AC;&#x201C; and â&#x20AC;&#x201C; Motion Studies
- ( 8 0 Gilbreth ) ภ$ ภ, $ ( $7 4 ) *C 0 -* ( $7 7/7 "P L$A% ภ$ ",$0$ < !ภ$ .$ P ภ$ ",$0$ " + " + !/$0 . >+0 (the one best way to do work) < ! Gilbreth ",$ภ$ G>ภ$" + ,$( D(C * ภ; ภ$ )(*C+ . 8 0 /$0ภ$!% ภ$ ",$0$ (Motion Study) # 0ภภ$ ",$0$ (Work Flow Process Chart)
The Gilbreths 9 Time â&#x20AC;&#x201C; and â&#x20AC;&#x201C; Motion Studies $ภ#*ภ$ G> ภ$ 0 ภ*/ $ ", $ %. Gilbreth $7$ = 0 "P L$A% ภ$ ",$0$ " + 0%E ภ,$* 0ภ$!)(*C+ . -* * ( $7 ). C+ !* $ $ภภ$ ",$0$ 8 0( 0$ < !7 .* ภภ$ 0 4 1. ( .$-* ,$- ภPภ$ H 0$ " + " + 2. A!$!$7* ภN)ภ;O ภ$ ",$0$ %. !*0 3. ! ภภN)ภ;O % . ) 8 $ ภ7$ $ 8 0 P H 0 $ )AC+ )A + 7 #*#* -* * E + <70ภ$ ",$0$
Henry L.Gantt 9 Pay Incentives (&, 1861 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 1919) ) 5 #: ภ) ภ"$0 $ G $.ภ$ -* ภ$ ภ$ < !) 5 G ภ" + >ภ$ - ( 8 0 Gantt ) " +ภ$ %. +0 :0% (Incentives) %. ภ( 0$ " +",$0$ < !7 .* ภภ$ 0 4 1. /$!(/$ $0%. ภ( 0$ " 40.7 $7(/$- 08 4 AC4 $ " +ภ$, . 2. = $( 0$ ",$0$ ,$) I $7) *$" + ภ,$. Bonus A )G 3. = $ ( 0$ H 0 $ ภ). C $ภ" + ( $ . 0 $0 * (rewards) + (C %. ) 5 . . $0$ (supervisors) -* ) %. ",$. $" + ) 5 #: 2Qภ(coach) 7$ภภ/$%. ) 5 #: ( ( 70$ Gantt
Dก
Henri Fayol 9 Administrative Management (&, 1841 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 1925)
Fayol ! 1/ 18 6/ ภ9 56 / 1/ 53 Fภภภ0 ภ6 ภภ. / ภภภ(Technical activities) - ŕ¸
! 2 ! G, ? (Production) - ภ! 2 (Manufacturing) ภภภ/ (Commercial activities) - ภH? (Buying) - ภ4 (Selling) - ภภ& (Exchanging)
Henri Fayol 9 Administrative Management (&, 1841 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 1925)
ภภภ(Financial activities) - ภ$ .$)0 " -* )EC+ (Searching for capital & credit) - ภ$ %E )0 " !/$0).7$ 7 (Using them optimally) ภภ/ & < (Security activities) - ภ$ 3 0ภ((*-* " A! (Protecting property & persons)
Henri Fayol 9 Administrative Management (&, 1841 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 1925)
ภภF! (Accounting activities) - ภ$ ",$ S ( (Taking stock) - ภ$ ",$0 * (Keeping balance sheet) - ภ$ ">ภ" (Tracking costs) ภภภภ(Managerial activities) - ภ$ $0-# (Planning) - ภ$ 0( ภ$ (Organizing) - ภ$ +0ภ$ (Commanding) - ภ$ $ 0$ (Coordinating) - ภ$ ( ( 7 (Controlling)
ภN 14 8 8 0 Fayol
1. 2. 3. 4. 5.
ภ$ภ4 Fayol ! 0 A B $8 " + E/ !%. #: ภ$ ภ$ 0( ภ$ !/$07 "P L$A7$ภ! +08>4 -ภ/ ภ$ - /00$ ภ",$ (Division of work) ,$ $ . $" +-* ( $7 # E (Authority & responsibility) ) ภL$Aภ$ +0ภ$ (Unity of command) $!8 0 ,$ $ . $" + (Line of authority) ภ$ ,$ $ ภ$ % (Centralization)
กN 14 8 8 0 Fayol 6. ) กL$A8 0" G"$0 (Unity of direction) 7. ( $7)"/$)" !7 (Equity) 8. *,$ (Order) 9. ( $7 ) +7 (Initiative) 10. ! (Discipline)
ภN 14 8 8 0 Fayol 11. ภ$ -" (*$ภ(Remuneration of personnel) 12. ( $77 + (0% ภ$ ",$0$ (Stability of tenure of personnel) 13. #* <!E 8 0#: % 0( DE$- /* ( 08>4 !:/ภ#* <!E 8 0 / 7 (Subordination of individual interests to the common interest)
14. ( $7 $7 ((
(Esprit de cords)
Max Weber 9 Bureaucracy (&, 1864 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 1920) Weber A B $"9 N $Eภ$ (bureaucracy) . C "9 N /$ ! ,$ $ . $" + (theory of authority) AC4 $ 8 0.* ภT ภ$ (C 1 ภ4/ I % $Eภ$ ,$ $ . $" +" +) 5 "$0ภ$ 8 0#: ภ$ 7$ $ภ,$-. /0" +)8$ ,$ 0 !:/% 0( ภ$ 1 ภ4/ J % $Eภ$ ( *$ภ( )8 $ ( ( 0 , $ -. / 0 )A $ #*0$ 7/%E/)A $ !C "$0 0(7. C DD$ / ((*
Max Weber 9 Bureaucracy (&, 1864 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 1920) 1 ภ4/ K 8 )8 8 0 ,$ $ . $" +" +) 5 "$0ภ$ % - /* ,$-. /0-* ( $7 # E % L$ 0$ -* ( $7 7 A P ภ, $ -. / 0 C+ J % 0( ภ$ ( ภ,$. %. - / E ) 1 ภ4/ L 0 4 ,$ $ . $" + $7$ ==:ภ,$ %E !/$07 "P #* % 0( ภ$ , $ -. / 0 / $ 0J ( =: ภ$7*, $ E 4 (hierarchy) 0 4 (*$ภ>0 : /$)8$ 0 $!0$ %( -* %( 0 $!0$ )8$ 1 ภ4/ M #: ภ$ 0 $0 8 0ภN (rules) 8 4 ภ$ H 0$ " +) 5 7$ $ (standard operating procedures : SOPs) -* " $ (norms) " +E )
Chester Barnard
9 Administrative Systems(&, 1886 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 1961)
% . 0 C The Functions of the Executive % & 1938 Barnard ).I /$#: .$ ( ,$) " $"" + ,$( D% 0( ภ$ )A $ ) 5 #: " + , $ ! <!E % ภ$ / C+ $ .$" A !$ภภ, $ . ) 3$.7$!-* :0% ( 0$ %. 7 / / 7% ) 3$.7$!-* ,$) ภ$ )AC+ %. ( $7 ,$) I ภ$ภ4 Barnard ! 0 ! 7 "9 N / $ ! , $ $ . $ " + 8 0 Weber - / ) EC+ / $ , $ $ . $ " + ( )ภ8>4 $ภภ$ ! 7 8 0( 0$ 7$ภภ/$ 8>4 !:/ภ,$-. /0
Lyndall Urwick & Luther Gulick 9 The Science of Administration % "( $7) C+ 0 Papers on the Science of Administration % & 1937 4 Gulick ) =>0( $7 # E 8 0 CEO % ภ$ ",$. $" + ภ$ ภ$ ( ) 5 $7 POSDCORB P O S D CO R B
-
Plannin Organizing Staffing Directing Coordinating Reporting Budgeting
ก ก ! ก 94 ก 5 0D (&, 1930-1950)
Mary Parker Follett (1868-1933) < - ! 0 / $ ( 0$ (C #: " + : " + )ก + ! ก 0$ 0 4 ( 0$ ( ",$ก$ )( $ . 0$ -* #: ก$ ( D$ %. ( 0$ )8 $7$7 / / 7% ก ก$ A B $0$ Follett % . ( $7 % ก " 7 ก$ ) 0 (self-managed teams) -* ก$ %. "P % (empowerment) Follett +0" + ) 0) !ก /$ “8 $7. $" +0$ ” (cross-functioning) Fayol 7 " G / ,$ $ -* ,$ $ . $" +% - Follett
The Hawthorne Study ภ$ G>ภ$E . >+0 ,$) 7$ 40- / & VWXY-VWZX " +)7C 0 Hawthorne 7* E ($<ภ8 0 " Western Electric F>+00$ ! 4) 5 " + : ภภ% $7 â&#x20AC;&#x153;Hawthorne Studyâ&#x20AC;? F>+0 ) +7% & 1924 < ! National Academy of Sciences
F.J.Roethlisberger William J. Dickson
Elton Mayo
1. 2.
3.
Room Studies (1924 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 1927) Interviewing Studies . C Relay Experiments (1927 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 1932) Observational Studies (1931 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 1932)
Assembly
Test
Abraham Maslow 9 The Hierarchy of Needs (&, 1908 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 1970)
Physiological needs Safety needs Social needs Esteem needs Self-actualization needs
Douglas McGregor 9 Theory X and Theory Y (1906 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 1964) Theory X : Theory Y : Some traditional assumptions about Some modern assumptions about people people 1. Most people dislike work, and they will avoid it when they can. 2. Most people must be coerced and threatened with punishment before they will work. They require close direction. 3. Most people prefer to be directed. They avoid responsibility and have little ambition. They are interested only in security.
1. Work is a natural activity, like play or rest. 2. People are capable of selfdirection and self-control if they are committed to objectives. 3. People will become committed to organizational objectives if they are rewarded for doing so. 4. The average person can learn to both accept and seek responsibility. 5. Many people in the general population have imagination, ingenuity, and creativity
ภภ(&, 1940-1990)
ภภ! & O (quantitative management) ภภภ(operations management) ภภO< 2 (total quality management) 9 5 5 : ? ภภ(management information system)
ก ก &' (&, 1950 >7 &' )
! 9 &' 3 4/ (Inputs)
" A!$ภ"$0ภ$!L$A (physical resources) " A!$ภ"$0ภ$ )0 (financial resources) " A!$ภ7 ! (human resources) " A!$ภ$ $ )"G (information resources)
! 9 ( ) ภ9 ภ& 5< (Transformation process)
. $" +ภ$ ภ$ (management functions) )"(< <*! ภ$ #* (technological operations) ภภ7ภ$ #* (production activities)
! 9 ( ) (Outputs)
( $-* ภ$ (goods & services) ภ,$ -* 8$ " (profits & losses) A9 ภ78 0 (*$ภ(employee behaviors)
4/ 6 / ภ(Feedback)
Inputs
Process
Outputs
Environmental feedback
5> ภOD (Contingency Theory)
UNIVERSALIST VS. SITUATIONALISTTHEORIES
Universalist Theories ‘One best way’ exists to perform management functions.
Situationalist Theories No ‘One best way’ Exists. Rather, First evaluate the situation & Then decide which Action to take.
Trial & Error Approach + Scientific Management + Behavioral Management + Management Science + System Theory
=
Contingency Theory
William G. Ouchi 9 Theory Z
&, 1981 ภO9ภภ4 ŕ¸
Short-term employment Individual decision making Individual responsibility Rapid evaluation and Promotion Explicit , formalized control Specialized career path Segmented concern
William G. Ouchi 9 Theory Z
&, 1981 ( ) ภO9ภภ4 F & P
Lifetime employment Consensual decision making Collective responsibility Slow evaluation and Promotion Implicit , informal control Nonspecialized career path Holistic concern
THEORY
Z
ORGANIZATIONS
Long-term employment Collective decision making Individual responsibility Slow evaluation & promotion Implicit, informal control with explicit, formalize measures Moderately specialized career paths Holistic concern, including family
Thomas J. Peters 9 Robert H. Waterman, Jr. In Search of Excellence (1982)
& 1977 " McKinsey #*ภ$ G>ภ$=>0 ( $7 7A P " + (* 0ภ8 0 - " + =C / $ ) 5 ภD - -./ 0 ( $7 ,$) I (keys success factors) . C " +) !ภ/$ McKinsey 7-S Framework
McKinsey 7-S Framework Systems
Structure
Style
Shared Value
Strategy
Skills
Staff
ภภ:7 ภภ. / >6 ภ3 D 1 5? !?
In Search of Excellence &, IRSJ 5 &. / Structure : - ) ! 0/$!P 7 $ A ภ0$ ,$ !ภ$ 7 ,$ภ(simple form & lean staff) Strategy 7 ( $7%ภ* E ภ*:ภ( $ (close to the customer) ",$P ภ" +7 ( $7)E +! E$D-* )ภ+! ) C+ 0 (stick to the knitting) Staff 7 % ภ$ ",$0$ -* ( $7 : >ภ) 5 ) $8 0 (autonomy & entrepreneurship) )A +7#* L$A< !A ภ0$ (productivity through people)
Style 7# ภ0$ !/$0%ภ* E (hands-on) Shared value ( $7)EC+ 7 + % (/$ !7) 5 - 0#* ภ(value driven) System 7 /0) " +ภ$ H Skill )8 70 -* #/ % ) *$ ) ! ภ(simultaneous loose-tight properties)
Michael Hammer 9 James Champy
&, 1993
Reengineering the corporation â&#x20AC;&#x153; ( $7( %.7/)ภ+! ภ.* ภภ$ AC4 $ -* ภ$ ภ- ภภ$ "$0 P ภ%.7/ !/$0= $ภ= <( )AC+ 0ภ$ ,$) 0$ !/$0K A* " 40% $ " ( ;L$A ภ$ -* ( $7 ) I â&#x20AC;? < !% . 0 C 0ภ*/$ %. ( $7 ,$( Dŕ¸
Fundamantal Radical Dramatic Process
Michael Hammer 9 James Champy
ภ? & 9 Rethink Redesign Retools Rehumaneering
&, 1993