REVITALIZING TAMAN SETIAWANGSA THROUGH PLACEMAKING
PREPARED by Ku Noor Shabilla bl Ku Mohd Fauzi
2020412118
ANALYSIS
The Catalyst in Development
The nearest commercial area by the site : AEO AU2 gave a high competitive rivalry to the site
The Economic Interest Thus, most of activities and interest by the people centralize at Toman Setiawangsa compared to Bukit Setiawangsa
A very high potential on rapid growth of urban development (commercial)
Overall, Setiawangsa was catogarized as the residential district. By time, the high demand on the supply and need lead to the growth of economic sector Hence, the site is an area that put under high potential commercial area in the making.
Growth and Development
Start with residential area (the existence of users). Mahsuri apartment are among the earliest buiding structure for residential purpose.
center of the site . Categorized in the commercial area. Providing the needs anddemandfor the community who lives nearby.
2014 Kompleks Sukan Setiawangsa A center for recreational sports for the surrounding communityand athletes. Located in close promiximity to housing estated and a shopping center in the Wangsa Maju area.
SHADOW ANALYSIS
- WIND DIRECTION
GREEN SPACE - ROAD NETWORK
SITE CONTEXT
RESIDENTIAL AREA
1 Mahsuri Apartment COMMERCIAL AREA , Rosyam Mart , Setiawangsa Bussiness Center
, Setiawangsa Shoplots
• Street Hawker Area , Giant Mart ' KK Supermart Setiawangsa
FASILITIES SK Setiawangsa Klinik Kesihatan Dato' Keramat
3 Mahsuri Apartment Park
4 Parking lots Bussiness Park Stadium Mini Setiawangsa
1 Balai Polis Setiawangsa
�l Major Nodes
�) Minor Nodes
• Landmark
Major Landmarks
+ Setiawangsa Mini Stadium
+ Rosyam Mart
They are significant to the site, visible, and easy for way finding due to the high density of nodes.
Major Nodes
+ Food court
+ Public Medical Centre (KKM)
+ Food hawkers
+ Rosyam Mart
+ Politeknik Metro
+ Giant & McDonald's
All of the nodes are concentrated in the commercial & community district which act as magnet spaces that attract users.
Administrative Zone
Commercial Zone
Commercial Zone
The commercial area developed as to fullfil the basic needs of the community area. In the same time other main fasilities also been developed such and police station.
Next, the expansion of fasilities needs such sport complex health center and shop all over the site
Future Development
The site will develop into center of attraction if proper event and building structure were arranged. The main commercial area for the residential all around.
+9AM Covered by the high building structure on the right. Parking lots area protected from direct sunlight
RATING: 4/5
Exposed to direct sunlight and lack of vegetation for thermal comforts
RATING: 2/5 Building structure as shading and lot of vegetation planting
RATING: 4/5
+12AM Exposed to direct sunlight, lack of vegetation uncomfortable for the user RATING: 1/5
Exposed to direct sunlight and lack of vegetation for thermal comforts
RATING: 2/5 Building structure as shading and lot of vegetation planting
RATING: 4/5
+5 PM Exposed to sunlight ray but not to hot compared in the morning RATING: 3/5
Exposed to direct sunlight and lack of vegetation for thermal comforts
RATING: 2/5 Building structure as shading and lot of vegetation planting
RATING: 4/5
Overall, the zones that have proper shading structure either natural or manmade will fully utilise by the use especially on the commerial area The area that has vegetation planting give shade to the user and become the center of attarction,
STREET HAWKER AREA
Major nodes. People will gather to the area for food and beverage.
SETIAWANGSA MINI STADIUM
Major nodes, and catogarized as landmark in Setiawangsa ST ROSYAM MART
Major nodes. New building in town.
the point of interest in the commercial area of Setiawangsa
+ INVENTORY & ANALYSIS 01 USD721 Urbanscape Design + Dr. Raziah Ahmad LAr. Rafiuddin Rosian Farah Adiba 2020243918 Nurhasnaa Idris 2020648908 Ku Noor Shabilla 2020412118 Master Of Science Urban Space Design (AP778)FSPU, UiTM Shah Alam KEY PLAN //� TOPIC OF STUDY LOCATION PLAN //� Site analysis is a preliminary phase of urban design processes dedicated to the study of the climatic, geographical, historical, legal, and infrastructural context of a specific site. The inventory and analysis were focussed on the selected area at Kuala Lumpur. By gathering all the data and site inventory, we capable to do some analysis and synthesis for the next phase of this assignment. Besides exposing students to the site issues and problems, the project theme related to "Public Spaces for urban wellbeing" are also important to be taken into consideration in setting up the project's aim. + SITE STUDY !The site location is situated at Setiawangsa. 11 covered the area of Toman Setiawangsa, Jalan Setiawangsa l, Jalan Toman Setiawangsa, Jalan Bukit Setiawangsa and Jalan Setiawangsa 13. Located at the eastern sideof Kuala Lumpur where within 4 km from the city center It caters to some Malaysia and expatriates.
Nukit Dinding The environment
peace
tranquility
tiawangsa
located
Setiawangsa
MORPHOLOGICAL STUDY 0 0 0fV') "-.if Early 90' develop as residential area 0 0 0 N As the community grows, the area started fully develop into commercial area N 0 N fz w Currently, there are massive development on fasilities and amenities as well as commercial sector [fl C>:'. CL SITE CONTEXT+ IMAGEABILITY 'Taran Be ia111angs!' m r Setiay,;mgsa 6 • Setiawangsa Mini Stadium I ... Jaran Setlawangsa 8 � I ,, ..."-POINT OF INTEREST COMMERCIAL AREA RESIDENTIAL AREA Community District Most of the community spaces are located in this area such as sports and recreational areas, community public hall, and other facilities for the community such as Public Medical Centre, school, food court, and police station. Edges Road as edges that separate the focus of each area and types of activities. The edges break the commercial area, administrative area, and community area into 3 districts. Commercial District Dominated by many business and commercial activities. This area is the most active on the site during day & night due to the existence of many shops and restaurants. Administrative District Dominated by many office buildings, this area is more passive at night compared to the commercial district due to the land use and activities. ... .· -:; · ,••· Terrain • <;'I · ,!! . · · .... MACRO PLAN f !KDE golf Bukit Setiawangsa & Puncak Setiawangsa positioned high up the hill of Bukit Dinding. + Setiawangsa on flat & undulating ground Residential Area Surrounded by a district that people live around Ex: Regime 515 Territorial Army Toman Hijau & Toman Keramat 1987 Mahsuri Apartment : among the oldest residential building. A low cost apartment located at the center location in the established township of Setiawangsa 2003 Giant Setiawangsa: Established at the
Both Puncak and Bukit Setiawangsa were positioned high up on the hiill of
is in
and
since it located the minutes away from the city center. Meanwhile, Se
in
on the flat and undulating ground.
focussed on the commercial & residential area and highland
Currently,
REVITALIZING TAMAN SETIAWANGSA THROUGH PLACEMAKING
Big trees were planted along the Persiaran Setiawangsa Provision of padestrian walkways along the network, leads to the vegetation planting. It gives shade for the user especially the student and teacher who live on the area nearby. Unfortunately, the vegetation was not continous and existed not shady enough! to give thermal comfort.
3/5
On the left, padestrian walkways (Mahsuri apartment). big shady trees were planted This plant grows best in the shade for padestrian walkways and sideroad parking. Since, every hours the path fully protected from direct sunlight. On right, the trees not big enough to give thermal comfort. Thus, the path unutilised especially for side road parking.
RATE: 4/5
Big shady tree grew in good condition and give thermal comfort for the padestrian and the user of side road parking. There also open space with green area on the side of Jalan Setiawangsa Unfortunately. it is not fully utilised by the community (not event/ function or provison of fasilities )
RATE: 4/5
Open space was provided for the people who come to the bussines park, and also for the workers to rest or walking around. Unfortunately, lack of vegetation planting and lack of fasilities such bench, cause area unutilised, The Bussines park views could be enhanced and attract more people attention.
RATE: 3/5
OPTICS Boring view, isolated parking lots dull colour of the building
PLACE: Insecure feeling ( the padestrian ), dry and no excitement element along the path
CONTENT: Shoplots and side road parking
RATING: 2/5
(view of street hawker)+ Insecure by the traffic
During peak hours- traffic congestion Street Stall and old building view
MAHSU RI APARTMENT
OPTICS : Green Scenery, Dull colour of building facade
PLACE: Boring feeling (padestrian to walk by), Insecure
CONTENT: Side road parking and Building Structure
RATING: 2/5
GIANT MART � .........
OPTICS Old Building view of the left, New Building structure on the right
PLACE: Awkward feeling (the different vibes between left and right view)
CONTENT: Old building shoplots and New Building Side road parking
RATING: 3/5
+ INVENTORY & ANALYSIS 02 USD721 Urbanscape Design + Dr. Raziah Ahmad LAr. Rafiuddin Rosian Farah Adiba 2020243918 Nurhasnaa Idris 2020648908 Ku Noor Shabilla 2020412118 Master Of Science Urban Space Design (AP778)FSPU, UiTM Shah Alam GREEN SPACE & OPEN SPACE s ,------------~-1 ---.... .... i h .._ .._ .._ .._ .._ .._ .._ .._ .._ Kebang � ' , I Seuawangsa ..., .._ l .... .... .... ,., .... .... , I '� I ·•-.. I I I I I ;; I 8' I ; I � Jl Ji I -'l I Food Coun Jalan Setiawangsa 13 3 I I I I 5 Setiawa"lgSc:i Mini Pernec Corporation JaranSetiawangsa 8 rt0tf r 1T!0tf I ..... .... .... Giant I I I I I Stadium � McDonald's I I I ... -- ------< Jalansei { --------- --- -Open space by the side of padestrian walkways. Vegetation were provided in order to enhance the view for the user. Unfortunately, the open space was not fully utilised as there is no function for the people to use (no fasilities ) RATE: 3/5 '• .. .. Along the road of Jalan Setiawangsa Old residential area Padestrian walkways+ Open Space Along the road of Jalan Setiawangsa Commercial area VISTA OPTICS Homey environment, serene scenery and green scenery PLACE: Padestrian will feel safe, comfortable and peace (the vegetation along the road) CONTENT: Continous pathway for padestrian and the residential facade not to stand out and balance in with surrounding RATING: 4/5 OPTICS Green Scenery Gathering area of community & Social Area PLACE : Feeling excited if walk along the roadway
CONTENT:
RATING:
OPTICS Green Scenery, Surrounded with full solid facade, not vibrant PLACE: Vegetation views made user feel peace, but the area is hot and unutilised CONTENT: Vegetation planting and hard building facade RATING: 3/5 Padestrian
STREE
i BUSSINES
.............. 3 Street Hawker area are fully utilised since the vegetation along the road network capable to give shade for the activities around. The open also fully utilised by the community and become the minor node on the site. RATING: 5/5 SHOPLOTS AREA Green area along the road of Persiaran Setiawangsa Transition place from commercial area to residential area Padestrian walkways Along the road of Persiaran Setiawangsa Transition place from old residential area to new urban residential area Padestrian walkways Along the road of Jalan Setiawangsa Transition place from old residential area to the commercial area Padestrian walkways+ Open Space +Side Road parking Along the road of Jalan Setiawangsa Commercial area Open Space PREPARED by Ku Noor Shabilla bl Ku Mohd Fauzi 2020412118
3/5
walkways+ Street Hawker area TAMANSETIAWANGSA �
HAWKER AREA
PARK
ANALYSIS
RATE:
i
tt
